march 09 planning commission
DESCRIPTION
March 09 Oak Harbor Planning Commission presentation for the Subdivision Code Update ProjectTRANSCRIPT
SUBDIVISION CODE UPDATE
PURPOSE
•A) Present code changes for street widths and discuss review process
•B) Obtain Planning Commission input on policy issues, especially provision of on-street parking.
EXISTING PROCESS
•1. Design streets to meet standards
•2. Apply for a “waiver” or use PRD, both reviewed by PC.
EXISTING STREET SECTION
PROBLEMS
• Currently, with narrower lots, less parking is being provided than one would expect; even with wide street sections
• Significant staff, applicant and PC process time.
• Waiver process for non-PRD applications - there is no other way to vary from street standard
NEW “RULES”
•New rules need to:• Introduce design flexibility for
the applicant
• Simpler review process for alternative street designs.
•1st tier - Standard Designs
•2nd tier – Administrative Variance (NEW PROCESS)
•3rd tier – Waiver (PC)
NEW “RULES” – CONT.
1ST TIER TWO STANDARD
DESIGNS•a). “narrow” section:
•5-foot sidewalks on both sides
•5-foot planter strip on both sides
•6-inch curb on both sides
•28 feet of pavement
•Parking on one side.
•Total right-of-way width is 50 feet.
“NARROW” SECTION
1ST TIERTWO STANDARD
DESIGNS•b). “wide” section
•5-foot sidewalks on both sides
•5-foot planter strip on both sides
•6-inch curb on both sides
•36-feet of pavement.
•Parking on both sides
•Total right-of-way width is 60 feet.
“Wide Section”
2ND TIER ADMINISTRATIVE
VARIANCE
• Demonstrate - cannot provide standard sections
• Unusual site or design reasons• Staff review Administrative
Variance dimensions only – essential elements required
2ND TIERADMINISTRATIVE
VARIANCE•Essential Elements?
• Sidewalks - both sides OR ped connects• Landscape strip OR landscaping
somewhere• Parking one side OR parking
somewhere• Curbs on both sides • Two minimum 10-foot travel lanes
ALTERNATIVE PARKING
Mid-block off street parking & walkways through long blocks & parking one side of street
Off-street parking & traffic calming
3RD TIER WAIVER
• Demonstrate cannot provide one of the essential elements
• Waiver review by PC – i.e. bike path
POLICY ISSUES PARKING
•Benefits of reduced street widths include:• less costly to construct• less costly to maintain (non-LID)• less stormwater (LID)• smaller stormwater systems• improved visual quality• traffic calming effect• shorter crossing distances for
pedestrians
POLICY ISSUES PARKING
•Costs of reduced street widths include:• less on-street parking
POLICY ISSUES REVIEW PROCESS
•Three-tiered review process?
• Proposed to eliminate staff, applicant and PC time.
• There would no longer be a need to for PC review of minor deviations.
• Are we meeting the goal?
POLICY ISSUES LANDSCAPE STRIP
•How wide should the landscape strips be?• Propose a 5-foot landscape strip
• Smaller = cracking
POLICY ISSUES TRAFFIC CALMING
•Narrow streets do not inhibit traffic calming, they promote it.
FURTHER DISCUSSION
“NARROW” STREET SECTION
“WIDE” STREET SECTION