lomas_the early contact period in northern ni
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
1/22
The merican Society for Ethnohistory
The Early Contact Period in Northern New Ireland (Papua New Guinea): From Wild Frontierto Plantation EconomyAuthor(s): Peter LomasSource: Ethnohistory, Vol. 28, No. 1 (Winter, 1981), pp. 1-21Published by: Duke University PressStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/481575.
Accessed: 21/01/2015 08:58
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at.http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
.
Duke University Pressand The American Society for Ethnohistoryare collaborating with JSTOR to digitize,
preserve and extend access toEthnohistory.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=dukehttp://www.jstor.org/stable/481575?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/481575?origin=JSTOR-pdfhttp://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=duke -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
2/22
THE
EARLY CONTACT
PERIOD
IN
NORTHERN NEW IRELAND
(PAPUA
NEW
GUINEA):
FROM WILD FRONTIER
TO PLANTATION ECONOMY
Peter
Lomas
Simon Fraser
University
ABSTRACT
Tnis
paper
examines the
period during
which
Europeans
established
themselves in
northernmostNew
Ireland
Papua
New
Guinea)
using
accountsof
early
visitors to
the
area. In the
late 19th
century
he
region
was notorious or the
ferocity
of the
indigenous
population
and
yet
northernNew Irelanders
were
soon
in
high
demandas laborand
after
1900
the
area was
rapidly
incorporated
nto the
plantation conomy
of
GermanNew
Guinea.
Cryptic
references o
indigenous
social
structure
n
early
visitors' accounts
are
considered in the
light
of current ocial
organization.
The
exploration
and
colonizationof the Pacific
islands
by Europeans
as
long
been
and remains
a
subject
of interest
to
scholars
of
many disciplines.
Melanesia,
the last
frontier n
the
area,
has been
examined
rom
a
historical
point
of view
by anthropologists
and
others
(e.g.,
Belshaw
1954;
Whittaker
1968)
and
in
more recent
years
the
early
contact
period
in
former German
New
Guinea has received attention
rom
English
speaking
writers
(Rowley
1958;
Biskup
1968;
Sack
1968;
Moses
1968;
Moses
and
Kennedy
1977).
It
is
understandable
hat
the
Blanche
Bay
area of New Britain
(Neupommem),
the
center
of
European
mission,
commercial,
andadministrative
ctivity
in
the
early
years
of contact n the
Bismarck
Archipelago,
hould
have inviteda detailed
examination of the relationsbetweenexpatriates ndindigenes n one limited ocation,
using
both
documentary
and oral
history
sources
(Salisbury
1962a,
1970).
This
area,
from
Kokopo
to
Matupi,
was
the home
base for
the handfulof
commercial
nterprises
responsible
for
opening up
much of the rest
of the
archipelago
o
commercial
activity
between
the
late 1870s and
the turn
of the
century.
It
was a
jumping
off
point
for
the
adventurers,
missionaries
and later
administrators
esponsible
or the
establishment
f
the
plantation
economy
of
the
former
German
colony
(cf.,
Reed
1943).
One
area in
which
traders
sought
to find
a
foothold
was
northernNew Ireland
Neumecklenburg),
where,
for
some two
decades
prior
to
the
establishmentof
German
administrative
control,
outstationsof
the
Blanche
Bay
firms of
Forsaythe
and
Hernsheim
managed
o
generateand control a lively trade n nativeproduced opra
(Blum
1900:61).
Although
accounts of
the
area in the
writings
of visitors
to
or residents n
northernNew Ireland
between
1880 and
1910 are
frequentlycryptic,
it is
possible
to
summarize these
impressions
and
offer a
tentative
picture
of
general
conditions
prevailing
here
during
hat
ETHNOHISTORY
28/1
(Winter 1981)
1
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
3/22
2
PETER
LOMAS
period,
as
this
paper
attempts
to
do.
Until the
end of the
19th
century
northern
New
Ireland
enjoyed
a
reputation
of
being
the home of
a hostile and
ferocious
population
practicingcannibalismand frequentlyslaughteringhe isolated traderswho were bold
enough
to seek
to establish
posts
amongst
hem.
Yet
long
before 1910 slanders rom
his
area
were
amongst
the
most
sought
after aborers
n
the
plantations
hroughout
German
New
Guinea,
and the
region
was
shortly
hereafter
major
plantation
enter tself.
The
transition
rom
wild
frontier o
a
thriving
opra
producing
conomy
n
which ocal
people
were
very
much
involved
occurred n a
matter
of
some two
anda half
decades.
Undoubtedly
the
most
widely
known
anthropological
ccount of a New
Ireland
society
is
Powdermaker's
Life
in
Lesu
(
1933
reprinted
1971).
In
her
preface
she
notes
that
in this
part
of the
world it
is
difficultto
apply
an
historical
point
of
view,
because
there is
so
very
little
real
historical
nformation
1971:21).
Although
he follows this
remarkwith a reference to
German
writerson
New
Ireland he
discusses neither
heir
ethnographic
materialnor
their
references o
the
larger
ocioeconomic
ramework
within
which
very
marked
changes
had
occurred
during
the
lifetime of her
older
informants.
Other
ethnographic
writings
in
English
at that
time do
take
some
account of the
encapsulation
of
the
indigenous
population
n
the
European
dominated
conomy
of
the
islands in the
inter-war
period,
and
although
hey
recognize
hat he
old customs
hadbeen
irreversibly
undermined
hrough
contact,
they
do
not
spell
out the
natureof
the
impact
(Groves
1933a,
1933b,
1934,
1936;
Chinnery
1929).
More
recent ield
workers
n
New
Ireland focus
on
certain
imited
aspects
of
indigenous
culture,
as
they
survived nto
the
post-PacificWarperiod,anddo notconcern hemselveswithconditions hatprevailedat
the
time of
contact
(Lewis
1969;
Billings
1971).
Of
these
contributors
nly
Lewis
appears
o
have
consulted
he
German
material.
There
are,
in
fact,
no
complete
ethnographic
ccountsof
northern
New
Irelandat
the
time of
contact
or
shortly
hereafter,
lthough
ieldwork
was
undertaken
n
north-central
New
Irelandand
on
Tabar
Island
by
Walden
in
1907/9
as
a
memberof
the
German
Marine
Expedition
headed
by
Kraemer
cf.,
Kraemer
1925).
Although
Walden's
work
was
primarily
in
the
Fissoa-Medina
area,
he
also
visited
the
northernmost
art
of
the
island
and
makes a
few
references to
differences in
custom
between the
two
regions.
Regrettably,
however,
he
never
published
his
material
as he
died
in
the war of
1914/18
and, apartfroma brieftalkgiven in Cologne in 1910(Walden1911), he neveroffered
any
analysis
of
his
field
data. This
was
undertaken
much
later
by
Nevermann,
but
the
report
is
incomplete
(Walden
and
Nevermann
1940).
The
richest
sourceof
information
on
aboriginal
ife
and
culture s
Parkinson's
Dreissig
Jahre
nder
Suedsee
(1907),
which
offers
observations
by
a
man
long
familiarwith
the
area
during
he first
two
and
a half
decades of
contact. One
drawback
with
Parkinson'swork
s
thathe
tends o
make
general
observations
and it
is
frequently
not clear
to
which
part
of
the
northern
ne-third f
the
island
he
is
referring.
However,
since
most
European
activity
was
concentratedn
the
northernmost
rea,
where
the bulkof
the
trading
posts
were
maintained
rior
o
1900,
it is
possible
to
make the
assumption
hathis
observations
would
have
been
made
primarily
n
this
region.
The
question
also
arises
as to
which
period
Parkinson
s
referring.
Some
comments,
notably
those
dealing
with
cannibalism,
evidently
refer to
the
two
decades
before
Boluminski,
he
German
administrator,
acified
he
area,
whereas ther
references
appear
to
be to
the
post
contact
period.
Parkinson
died,
however,
only
six
years
after
pacification
was
commenced
and
although
most
recent
observations
may
have
been
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
4/22
The
Early
Contact
Period
in
NorthernNewIreland
3
important
in
determining
the comments he
made,
his earlier
experiences
must have
contributed
significantly
to his
assessment
of the
local
people. Apart
rom
Boluminski
(1904) few other writers make explicit ethnographic bservations.The othersources
used
here refer
primarily
to
expatriate
activities and
to the
interactionbetween
the
handful
of
Europeans
and the
indigenous
population.
The
major
radingpost
in
the
area,
on
Nusa
Island,
off
the northern nd of New
Ireland,
was a
stopping-off
place
for a
few
visitors
during
the
twenty years
that
it was in
operation
and
some
of
these
left
brief
references
to
trade and
local conditions.After
1900,
when Boluminski
establishedhis
headquarters
on
the main
island and
pacification rapidly
transformed
onditions
in
northernmostNew
Ireland,
the number
of
visitors
increased,
as
do
the
reports
on
the
area.
This
paper
focusses on
northernmostNew
Ireland,
some reference
being
made
to
adjacent
areas.
Fieldwork n the area
n
the late 1960s
did not
produce
irst
hand
accounts
of
either
the
pre-contact
or
early
Boluminski
periods, althoughmany
older
men
could
recall
employment
histories
on
German
ships, plantations
and
in
households.
Early
attemptsby
the
Weslyan
(laterMethodist)
missionaries o establish
a foothold
n
the area
were
also often
recalled
by
articulate
older
villagers,
but the decades
prior
to the
establishmentof Pax
Germanica
were
regarded
with
some ambivalence.For some
they
were
classified as the 'darkera'
(taim
bilong
tudak),
a
timeof
insecurity,
annibalism
nd
powerful
leaders.
For others
they
were
thought
of as a time when life
was
better
and
richer,
the eraof
the ancestors
taim
bilong
ol
tumbuna),
and a few
outstanding
eaders
were on occasionrecalled, ncluding ome whosuccessfully esistedGermanpacification
for
a
brief
period.
As
access to andcontrol
over landwas
very
much
an
important
ssue
in
the late
1960s
many
stories
were
circulating
bout
he
way
in
which andwas
acquired y
the first
Europeans
n
the
area,
at
Nusa,
on
the
main
sland
opposite
where
Kavieng
now
stands
and
at
Kapleman,
where a
trading
post
was
maintained,
n and
off,
for
many
years
before 1900.
In
public
memory
hese
early
transactions
were classified
as
trickery,
but
n
general
people living
in
the late
1960swho
recalled
he
German ra
werenotbitter
n their
assessment of conditions
then. This
may
be
contrasted
with what seems to have been a
prevailing
attitude
amongst
expatriate
ettlers
on
New
Irelandafter 1914 who
appear
o
have
believed thatthe German
period
wasoneof
harshness nd
regimentation.Although
northernNew Irelandwas
very
rapidlypacified,
some
groups
of
villagers
in the south
resisted
longer
and as
late as
1913
therewas
an
attackon anAdministration
atrol
with
loss
of
life
(Kraemer-Bannow
916:viii).
The
reputation
hatNew
Irelanders ad
amongst
Whites
for
ferocity
and
treachery
during
the last
decades of the
19th
century
evidently
stemmed
from
the
bad relations
between
islandersand
Europeans enerated
by early
contacts
n
connectionwiththe
labor
trade.
Hahl,
sometime Governorof
the
German
colony,
claims
thateven beforevessels
seeking
workers
for
plantations
n
other
parts
of
the
South
Pacific
arrived,
here was
general
dislike and
suspicion
of
Whitesas a result
of contacts with
whalers
to South
America, and possibly sandalwoodtraders,often roughandviolent towards he local
population,
who
had also
put
ashoreon
occasion from
the
1850s on
for
food and water
(Hahl
1937:47;
Schnee
1904:55;
Finsch
1914:290).2
The demand or
labor
on
plantations
in
Queensland,
Fiji
and
Samoa
gave
rise
to
the
notorious
blackbirding
ctivities
of
recruiters
hroughout
Melanesia,
and
by
the
late
1870s
and
early
1880s vessels
seeking
new
sources
of
manpower
were
active in
the
New
Ireland rea.The
labor rade
peaked
n
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
5/22
4 PETERLOMAS
this
area
in
the
early
1880s,
according
o one observer
Schnee 1904:56),
and
Romilly
(1886)
claims that
by
this time the recruiters ad taken
away
2000
of
the
best men.
One
Germany company, the Deutsche Handels und PlantagenGesellschaftder Suedsee,
concentrated
on
recruitment
n
the Bismarck
Archipelago
for
plantations
n
Samoa,
employing
two vessels for this
trade.
According
to
Blum
(1900:6),
in
1883 some
700
islandersfrom
New BritainandNew Ireland
were
taken
o Samoa. In
the
same
year
over
double
thatnumber
were
recruited or work n
Fiji
and
Queensland,
t
is
claimed.
In
1884
the German Administration
prohibited
urtherrecruitment
or these latter
points,
but
illegal
and
sometimes forcible abduction
continued,
from the
New Irelandarea
and
elsewhere
(cf.,
Paul
1907:31).Wawn,
who
acted
as
a
sometime
Queensland
Government
agent
on
recruiting
vessels
sailing
out of
Brisbane,
admitted hat
kidnapping
id
occur
(1893:13).
In
Queensland
two sailors
were
imprisoned
or
the forcible recruitment
f
villagers
from
Tabar
Island,
off the north coast
of
New
Ireland
(Schnee
1904:59).
Rannie,
in
the area in
the
mid-1880s,
notes that there was
considerable
ecruitment
n
offshore
islands,
although
he claims that
few
Queensland
essels visitedthe main sland
(1912:261).
He notes
that
herewere few
New
Irelanders
n
plantations
n
Australia,
but
he describes an
incident
nvolving
the
repatriation
f a
Nusa
woman
(1921:271).
Wawn
(1893:283, 295)
makes
reference
to
recruitment
n
New Ireland
or
the
Queensland
plantations,
but
he
appears
o be
referring
o the
southern
part
of the island. The
early
impact
of
this
recruitment s
hard
o
assess. Paul
(1907)
notes thatwhenhe came ashore
on New
Ireland
villagers
fled before
him,
and
he ascribed his to a fearof
recruiters,
whereasRannieclaims thatpotential ecruitshad o beturned wayafter1884,when hey
were
placed
underGerman
protection
1912:263).
Schnee
reports
hat here
were
some
attacks
on
recruiters
n
New
Irelandand on
Tabar,
with resultantoss of
life
(1904:124).
Writing
of
the offshoreislands
(e.g.,
Tabar)
Rannie
notes
that
alreadyby
the
mid
1880s
recruitment
had made its
mark
on
local cultures.
In
1891
Queensland
legislated against
the
labor tradeand recruitment or that
destination
ceased,
but
as
plantations
penedup
in
the 1880s
in
the Blanche
Bay
area
of
New
Britain
and,
somewhat
ater,
on
the north oast
of
New
Guinea,
ncreasing
umbers
of recruits
were
sought.
Islanders
were also still
being
taken o
Samoa.
In the
labor orces
employed
by
the
plantation
owners men from
New
Ireland,
Buka
and
Bougainville
featuredprominently Sapper1910:115).IntheBlancheBay areaNew Irelanderswere
employed
on
the
new
plantations
eing
established
by
the Christianmissionsas well as
in
various other
capacities
(Schnee 1904:132).
Men from
northernNew Irelandwere
especially sought
as labor
because
they
were
allegedly quick
to
learn
skills
(Parkinson
1907:262),
and
because of their
cheerful,
carefree and more industrious
manner
(Reichs
Marine
Amt
1912:117).
Blum
(1900:134)
notes that
between 1887
and
1898
over
3,500
laborerswere
shipped
o the
northcoast of
New Guinea rom the
Bismarck
Archipelago,
many
of
whom
musthave come from
northernNew Ireland.
After
1900,
as
plantations
were
establishedaround
Kavieng,
local laborwas
highly
valuedas
a
willing
workforce
by expatriate mployers(Paul
1907:35;
Kraemer-Bannow
916:260).
The
heavy
recruitment
nvolved
a
large
percentage
of
village
populations
and
Boluminski wrote in
1904 that
he
associationof northernNew
Irelanderswith
expatriate
plantations
for
almost
fifteen
years
had
left
its
mark
n the form
of
diseases
introduced
and
sickness
and
death
on
the
labor ine
leading
o
population
ecline
(
1904:134).
Schnee
notes that
venereal disease was
widespread
n
northern
New
Ireland
by
the
turnof the
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
6/22
The
Early
Contact Period
in Northern
New Ireland
5
century
and
he associated
this with the
recruitment
f local
people
for workelsewhere
(1904:45, 133).
Sapper
(1910:97)
also makes reference
to diseases
introduced
as a
consequence of recruitmentand claims that venereal diseases were not presentin
southern
New
Ireland,
with the
implication
hat
heavier
nvolvement
f
northerners ith
the
expatriate
economy
was a direct
cause
of
the disease.
He also
mentions
dysentery,
and Pfeil
(1899:71)
notes that
an
epidemic
of
this
disease in 1881 was
responsible
or
many
deaths.
Hahl
(1937:47)
thinks that the diseases
in
northernNew
Ireland hat
contributed
o
the
obvious
population
decline were
introduced
here
hrough
he
earliest
contacts
with
Whites,
that s thewhalers.
New Irelanders
were also taken
into the
police
force
established
by
the
Germans,
and
Lemusmus,
on the
west
coast,
was
for
a time
a
favorite
area
or
recruitment
Schnee
1904:129;
Reed
1943:141),
as
was
Djaul
Island
off
the
coast
(Hahl
1937:41,
64).
One
former
policeman
from
north-central
New
Ireland
absconded
from the
headquarters
barracksnear
Kokopo
with several firearms
n
a
stolen cutterand
set
himself
up
as a
mercenary
in
his home area
in
the 1890s.
He
eluded
a
punitive
expedition
mounted
against
him
and was
finally captured
by
Boluminski
many years
later
(Hahl
1937:38;
Boluminski
1904:132-133).
This
heavy
involvement
of
northern
New Irelanders
n
the
larger
socioeconomic
system being
established
by
the
expatriates
ven
prior
o
pacification
of
their
homeland
evidently
contributed
o the
ease
with
which Boluminski's
iny
police
troop eight
men)
succeeded
in
bringing
intervillage
hostilities to an end
in
the
Nusa-Kapsu
area
in
1900-01. Hahl(1937:158)notesthat herewasscarcelyavillage n whichyoungmenhad
not
seen
service with
Europeans,
and
this,
he
feels,
made
them inclinedto
accept
the
imposed
peace.
In
addition
o
introduced
diseases and trade
goods,
this
early period
of
contact also
brought
about
the
establishment
of
pidgin
English
(now
termed
Neo-
Melanesian)
as
the
lingua ranca throughout
he area
(cf.,
Boluminski
1904:130).
One
visitor noted that
by
1897 this
language
was
extensively
used
(around
he
trading
posts)
and dated from
pre-Germanexperience
of the
islanders on
plantations
n
Fiji
and
Queensland
(Cayley-Webster
1898:290).
If
opportunities
for
employment
outside their home area
allowed the more
adventurousor the more
gullible
of the inhabitants
f northernNew Ireland
o
experience
the
ways
of the Whiteintruders,twasthe
tradingposts
whichchannelled
mported
tems
in
a
steady
flow into the
village
economies.
Starting
n
1880
resident
expatriate
raders
provided
a
range
of
commodities,
including
metal
tools,
calico
cloth,
tobacco
and
mnatches,
n
exchange
for local
produce,primarily
oconutsor
village
sun-dried
opra,
but
including
also beche-de-mer
trepang
r sea
cucumber,
a
delicacy
nthe
Orient)
and
trochas shell.
They
also
quickly
came to makeuse of local shell 'monies'for
purchases
f
copra,
and
by
the
1890s
were
importing
uch shell
money
from northern
New Hanover
for
use
in
the
Nusa-Kapsu
area
(Finsch
1914:41).
As shell
money
was
and s an essential
ingredient
n
any
major nter-group
ransactionn the
villages,
andas
wealth n termsof
suppliesof tapsoka(as it is generally ermed n theliterature)wasa sinequanon of Big
Man
status,
this flow
evidently
had an
impact
on local
village politics,
as
is discussed
below.
In
addition o these items traders
lso introduced ed
glass
beads,
accepted
at first
but later
rejected
as
payment
for
copra
(Finsch
1914:279,
292),
and
possibly
some
firearms.
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
7/22
6
PETER
LOMAS
The first
trading
post
was
established
at
Nusa
in 1880 and t was maintained
lmost
continuously
until Boluminski founded
Kavieng
in
1900,
at
which time the centerof
commercialactivityshiftedto the main slandandcommunications, itherto xclusively
by
water,
began
to
rely
heavily
also
on
the network
of
roads
being
built
by
the
German
Administration
n the northof New Ireland.
Nusa served
as
a
centerof
trading ctivity
or
the whole
New
Hanover/northern
ew Ireland
area
and was a
regular
port
of call for
vessels. Nusa Island shelters a natural
deepwater
harbor n an
areawhere hidden
coral
reefs
present
a
major
hazard
to
shipping
and
it
was
evidently
more
easily
defended
against
attack han other sites selected
on
the main slandfor
trading
posts.
Unlike most
of
the
other
stations
n the
region
t was
plundered
nd
temporarily
bandoned
nly
once,
in
1883 or
1884,
the traders
escaping
by
boat
to
Kapsu
(Finsch
1891:123;
Schnee
1904:80).
The island
was
owned
by
the
Hernsheim
Company,
based
n the Blanche
Bay
area,
and
this fir-mdominated rade
n
northernNew
Ireland,
maintaining
numberof
posts along
the coast or on
atolls
between
the
main
sland
and
New Hanover.
By
1881 there were some ten such stations and
the
number
luctuatedover
the
succeeding
two decades. The
majority
were
owned
by
Hernsheim,
but some were
operated
by
the other
major
company
based n
the Blanche
Bay
area,
Forsaythe's,
and
he
rest
were
run
by independent
adventurers
Blum 1900:152).
One of
the
posts
was
operatedby
a
survivorof the
Marquis
de
Rays expedition
and
settlement
n
southernNew
Ireland. Two small
coconut
plantations
were startedbefore the end of the
century
on
islands
controlled
by
traders,
one
on
Kung,
off the northwest oastof New
Hanover,
he
other on tiny Nusaum Islandin the Nusa Channel Blum 1900;Schnee 1904:70).The
remaining
posts
were at
Kapsu,Kapleman
nd
Putput
n
the
north
oast,
at Kabienon the
west
coast
andon
Kaboteron sland
n
the NusaChannel
Schnee 1904:80).
By
the end of
the
century
herewere additional
posts
elsewhere.
They
were staffed
by
adventurersrom
Europe
and
elsewhere,
including,
at
various
times, Germans,
Englishmen,
Australians
or
Americans,
Japanese,
Chinese,
Malays,
a Frenchman
nd a
Mexican,
supported
y
workers recruited rom the
Solomon Islands
primarily
Bukaand
Bougainville)
Schnee
1904;
Cayley-Webster
1898:279, 281;
Rannie
1912:274).
These
traders,
eeking
wealth
or
oblivion in the
south
seas,
were the
regular
victims of attacks
by
the
local
populace,
and
over
a
period
of
some fourteen
years
from 1881
eleven
Whites,
at
least two Asians
and an unknown numberof Solomon Islanderswere killedduringassaultson trading
posts
or
coastal vessels
(Schnee 1904).
Coconuts
or
sundried
opra
could
be
acquiredby
the traders
y bartering ny
of the
trade
goods
they
offered.
In
the
early
years
a
piece
of
tobaccowouldfetch
forty
nutsanda
strip
of
iron,
probably
of the
type
still
imported
n
the
1960s
o makemachetes or
garden
work,
would
bring
100 nuts at new
stations at
Nusa,
Putput
or Kaboteron
Finsch
1914:292-293).
In 1885
Finsch
observed the
exchange
of
small
quantities
of
copra,
estimated
at
fifteen to
twenty-five
pounds,
for a
thimble full of
glass
beads
-
but
a
decade
later these beads had
become worthless
1914:279, 292).
By
that ime a
stick of
tobacco fetched
only
fifteen
coconutsand a small
(five inch)
knife 100.Shell
money
was
evidently
in
demandanda
variety
of
types
were
accepted
at Nusa
during
he
early
years
of
trading
here,
but laterseveralof
these
disappeared
rom
circulation
Finsch
1914:38
f).
Finsch
speculates
on
where
these
were
in
use,
noting
hat
one
type
seemedto
come from
the east-central
areaof New
Ireland,
whilst
another
apparently
ad a
west
coast
point
of
origin.
The
most
widely
used
variety
was
the
reddish-white
apsoka,
which,
as mentioned
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
8/22
The
Early
Contact
Period
in
Northern
New Ireland
7
above,
was
imported
o Nusa
probably
rom
Kung
off New Hanover or use
by
the
trader
in the
early
1890s.
A 650 mm
length
of
tapsoka
would
purchase
120
pounds
of
copra.
Such a stringof tapsokahadan equivalentvalueof threemarks n German urrencyat
thattime.
By
the late 1890sGerman
urrency
was
being
ncreasingly
sed
throughout
he
Bismarck
Archipelago,
and
in
1902 the
Administration
rohibited
he continued
use of
shell monies in transactions etween
Whites
and
natives.
It
is
not
possible
to estimate the
volume
of
copra
traded
by indigenes
n the
area
during
the
period
under
consideration.
By
all accounts coconut
palms
flourished n
northern
New
Ireland
at
this time
as
they
do
today.
Rannie,
in
the area
in
the
1880s,
claims
that
from
Kapleman
o Nusa the coastwas lined
with
palms
(1912:274).
Parkinson
( 1907:255)
describesthe areaas well
populated
nd
with
heavy
stands
of
coconut
palms,
the
harvest
of which was
sold
to
traders.
Theremusthave
been
enoughcopra
available o
make it worthwhile for the
companies
to maintain
posts
in the area. The
only
non-
indigenous
copra
would have come fromthe two small
plantations
mentioned
bove,
and
it is uncertainwhen the
palms
there
started
o
bear,
as seven to nine
years
are
required
or
maturationbefore nuts
can
be
harvested.
Blum
reports
hatthe
total
copraexports
rom
the
entire German
erritory nly
reached
2,500
tons towards he end of the
1890s,
and
he
notes that a decline in
volume
by
some
seventy
tons
from 1896
to
1897 was
largely
ascribable to
internalconflict
in northern
New
Ireland
1900:156).
Hahl
(1937:29)
and
Boluminski
both refer to warfareat this
time,
and
in
1896
it
involvedthe
people
of the
Mangai
area.
After
a
trading
post
had
been attacked ome
White residentscalled
for
a
punitiveexpedition romtheGermanheadquarterstKokopo odestroynativeplantations
and shoot a few
villagers.
The
expedition
was
mounted
but
failed
to make contact
with
those involved in
the
attack. A
year
earlierKabien
andthen
Kapleman
ad
been
the sites
of attackson
tradersand
a
subsequentpunitive
expedition
Hahl 1937:69-70).
Neither
of
these sets of
incidents
would
have
totallydisrupted
rade
n
the
area,
although hey might
have cut
off
supplies
of
copra
from the
areasaffectedon west andeast coasts for a time.
Even if
Blum's
figures
are
accepted Salisbury
1970:113,
ootnote laims
he is
inaccurate),
the
seventy
tons
clearly
representsonly
part
of the Nusa area's total
production.3
t
is
possible
that northernNew Ireland's
share of the
copra
tradedeclined
in
the 1890s
as
expatriate
operatedplantations
stablished
n the
Blanche
Bay
area
were then
starting
o
bear.
How
the
supply
of
imported
tems affected
village
life can
only
be
speculatedupon.
For
some
twenty years prior
o the establishment f GermanAdministrativeontrol
here
must have
been a
steady
trickleof
metal
goods,
cloth and
other
tems into
the
hands
of
villagers.
Steel and iron
implements rapidly replaced
stone and
shell,
but Finsch
observed
a
man
using
a shell axe to constructa canoe in 1885 on Nusalik
Island,
immediately
adjacent
o the
tradingpost
at
Nusa,
despite
the
readyavailability
f steel
axes
(Finsch
1914:125).
Parkinson
notes that shell
and
pigs'
tusks
were
still
used for
carving
at
this
time. Both Parkinson
1907:287)
andFinsch
(1914:245,
note)
report
hat
stone axes hadalreadydisappearedromnorthernNew Ireland ythe 1880s,although n
ornamental
one,
thought
to have
been
a
ceremonial
object,
was
found
at
Kapsu
by
a
European.
Matches and
tobacco were
probably
egarded
s consumer uxuriesand
here
is
little evidence
that cloth was
greatly
used
before
the
end
of
the
century.
Early
visitors
indicate
thatthe traditional irtual
otal
absence
of
apparel
ontinued or some time after
the
traders
stablished hemselves
Cayley-Webster
898:290).
Later,
after
1900,
western
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
9/22
8
PETER
LOMAS
clothing
was
adopted
by
some
villagers,
occasionally
n
excessive
fashion
c.f.,
Parkinson
1907:271).
By
the end
of the
19th
century
t
appears
hat he
steady
rickle
of
trade
goods
had become a flood. Boluminskireports hatvillagerswerebeingswamped n imported
items
as
competition
between
expatriate
raders or
copra
drovethe
price up
300
percent
in
a
matterof
five or six
years
(1904:134).
He
refersto
goods
receivedon credit rom
a
certain
Australian raderand
notes that
slanders
ould obtainall
they
needed rom
copra
sales and
were thus
disinclinedto allow
themselves
to
be
recruited or workelsewhere.
This
observationdoes not concur
with
the
evidence that northern
New Irelanders
were
being
recruited n
recordnumbersa
few
years
after
pacification.
Firearms
are mentioned in
several
accounts
(e.g.,
Blum
1900:26;
Boluminski
1904:13
1).
It is
possible
that
hese
items
may
have
been
originally
uppliedby
recruiters,
as
Blum
suggests
that
English
traders
offered them
to the New
Ireland
natives,
already
renowned for
their
savagery
(1900).
Romilly
too makes
reference o muskets
received from
recruiters
1886:39).
It
would
seem
unlikely
hat
rading
posts
wouldoffer
firearms or
copra
as
the factors
were
only
too
well
awareof the
ferocity
of
their
rading
partners
and could
easily
obtain
the local
produce
for
tobacco
and metal
implements.
Parkinson
tatesthat
severalof
the
early
attackson
Whites,
for
whichNew
Ireland
arned
an unenviable
reputation
mongst
raders,
were
undertakenn
order o
acquire
irearms,
which could
be
used
against
less
well
equipped
neighboring
populations
r in defence
against
punitive
expeditions
(1907:283).
Hahl
describes the havoc
wrought
n
central
New
Ireland
by
the
runaway
policeman-turned-mercenary
ith
the arms
he took with
him (1937:36-37). Not only didhe terrorizehis fellow villagers,slaughteringhosewith
whom he
quarrelled,
but
he also
threatened
Europeans
and
succeeded
in
interrupting
local
commercial
activity
at a
post
in
Fissoa in
the
mid or late
1890s
(Hahl 1937;
Boluminski
1904:132).
This
he
managed
o do
with
only
five
stolen
weapons
and an
ample
supply
of
ammunition.
His
training
n
the
police
force
undoubtedly
quipped
him
with the
skill
necessary
to
protect
his
weapons
from
rust
and
general
deterioration.
Romilly
(1886)
claimed
that firearms
oon
became
useless in
the wet
tropical
limate
n
the
hands
of those who
did not
know how
to look
after
hem and
he thus
discounted heir
importance
or
the
local
people.
In
a
major
battlehe
witnessed n
the
early
1880s there
were
apparently
no
firearms
employed.
Their
use
evidently
becamemore
common
ater
and Boluminski made a point of collecting firearmsand ammunitionas
part
of his
pacification
campaign
after
1900
(1904:131).
It
seems
possible
that
the
introduction f
valued
exotic
commodities
obtained rom
traders or
recruiters
nto the
exchanges
between
villagers
may
have,
initially
at
least,
affected
the
position
of
local
leaders.
Recruiters
egularly
dealt
with ocal
Big
Men
when
seeking
plantation
aborers
and
it
appears
hatsuch
leadersalso
actedas
brokers
between
fellow
villagers
and the
trading
posts
(Wawn
1893;
Romilly
1886:41;
Finsch
1914:40,
citing
Romilly).
Furthermore
he
flow
of shell
money
from
copra
saleswould
enhance
the
influence of
the
major
recipients.
Finsch
notes that
wealthand
'chieftainship'
were
closely linkedand thepowerof one leaderatKapsuvisitedbyRomilly ntheearly1880s
was
evidently
bolstered
by
his role
as broker
betweenhis
village,
and
several
others,
and
the
White
traders.If
local
leaders
were
ableto
monopolize
he
inflow
of
trade
goods
they
may
have
enhanced
theircontrol
over
fellow
villagers
during
he
earlyyears
of
contact,
as
is
suggested
in
the
account of
the
Kapsu
leader and
also of
the
musket
wielding
mercenary
of
Medina a
decade
and a half
later.
Boluminski
(1904:127)
does
note,
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
10/22
The
Early
ContactPeriod
in
Northern
New Ireland
9
however,
that
by
the end
of
the
century
eaders had but little
power,
possibly
because
access to
trade
goods
other than firearms
was then much easier
and
they
were more
widely distributed mongst hepopulation.
Writing
of
New
Irelanders,
a man with
many years
of
experience
of Melanesians
notes in the
1890s that
they
are
a
fine,
warlike and treacherous
ace
and
inveterate
cannibals
(Wawn 1893:283).
Whether
heir
capacity
or warfarewas
greatly
ncreased
by
the
provision
of
firearms
or
other
imported
weaponry,
such as steel
axes,
as
it
apparently
was elsewhere
in
Melanesia
(e.g.,
Salisbury
1962b)
s
questionable.
nter-
community
warfare
appears
to have
been endemic
in
the northern
part
of the island
throughout
he
early
contact
period,
and
in
the
1890s,
when
assaultson Whites led to
punitive
expeditions
from
Kokopo,
the
regular
intervention
by gunboats
and
police
troops
did
little to eliminate hese conflicts
Schnee 1904:119;
Blum
1900:28;
Boluminski
1904:127;
Hahl
1937:29, 37, 69, 104;
Kraemer-Bannow
916:vii).
Boluminski
notes,
however,
that there was
no
larger
unified
group
which
could
pose
a
major
threat o
Europeans.
Romilly, visiting
he Hernsheim
ost
at
Kapsu
n
1883,
witnessed
major
onfronta-
tion between two
large
groups
of
warriors,
stimated
by
him
to have numbered
1000and
1500
respectively
(1886:46-47).
He observed
that
the
Big
Man
of
Kapsu,
a
certain
Nanati,
normally
had a
following
on
hand
of
some 500
men,
but
on this occasion
drew
n
an additional
housand,
ncluding
allies,
to
participate
n a
meeting
at the
request
of the
Europeans.
The
size
of
this force
must
surely
be
exaggered,
for,
even
with the denser
populationsallegedly residentin northernNew Irelandat thattime, such numbersof
males of warrior
age
would
imply village
populations
f considerable
magnitude,many
times those
usual
during
this
century.4
Furthermore,
iven
the tactics available
o
Big
Men
to
control their
followers,
Nanati would
likely
have encountered
difficulty
in
maintaining
a hold
over such a force
(cf.,
Sahlins
1963).
Even
allowing
or
inaccuracy
n
the
part
of the
observer,
the
size of the
groups
arrayed gainst
each othermusthave
been
impressive.
If
Nanati
did,
as
Romilly
claims,
control
villages
along
a fifteen-mile tretch
of
coast,
then his stature
must have been
exceptional
n thearea.Theobserverdoes
not
give
the
names
of
the
villages
included n his
domain,
but t is
likely
that
hey
wouldhave
been
communities to
the
southeast,
as
the
Kapsu-Avelus
area is in the transition one
from
Tigak speakers
(to the
north)
o those
speaking
a
slightly
differentdialect
(Kara).
Romilly's
mentionof
Nanati's
'tribe',
which the leadercould order o attend he
meeting
with the
Englishman,
probably
refers to allied
communitieswithin the dialect
group.
Some
eighteen
years
later
Boluminski
reports
on conflict
between a
village
in this area
(Avelus)
and
one to
the northwest n the
Tigak speaking
region
(Putput),
and it
may
be
inferred
that there was
some
longstanding
hostility
between these areas.
Furthermore,
Romilly
describes the
enemy
force as
coming
round he
point, possiblyreferring
o
Kapsu
Point
to the
north
of the
Avelus-Kapsu
area,
and
if this
is
so
it
is
likely
that
the
invaders
were
Tigak speakers
either
from
the
north
(Kapleman-Putput)
r the islands
beyond Nusa. Nanati's force succeededin drivingoff the invadersandin the process
captured
the
corpses
of six
fallen
enemies,
which
were
consumed
n a cannibal
east.
How
much
Nanati's
allegedly lively
participation
n
trade
with the Whites contributed
towards
his
considerable tature n
the
area s
unknowable,
but
it seems
highly probable
that
his
dealings
in
shell
money
were an
important
actor.
His
force made
no use
of
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
11/22
10
PETERLOMAS
firearms,
relying primarily
on
spears,
indicating
that
imported
weaponry
was not a
significant
factor.
Support or the contention hat Nanati's situationwas unusualandpossiblydueto
the
position
the
man
held
in
the trade
with
Whites
comes from
Boluminski
who
notes
that
in
general larger
alliances between
indigenes
for the
purpose
of
warfarewere
not
established
(1904:128).
He
goes
on to
suggest
that numbersof
fellow
clansmen
were
the
usual
socio-politicalgrouping.
As the matrilineal
lans
were,
thenas
now,
dispersed,
this
would
imply
a
local clan
segment
or
hamlet
group,
evidently
boosted
by
affines
and
nonconsanguinealcognates;
such a unit
would,
even
with
the
larger
populations
n
the
area
eighty
years
ago,
rarely
exceed
a few
score.
The
favored tactic
in
warfarewas ambushor assault
by
small
numbers ather han
major
confrontations f the
type
described
by Romilly
(Boluminski1904).
Small
groups
of
fighting
men
raided
their
neighbors,
either
by
land
or sea.
Romilly
and Parkinson
mention
that
villages
were
usually
located
slightly
inland
from the
beach,
in
orderto
minimize the
danger
of anunheralded
ttack,
despite
he
fact
that
he littoralwas and
s a
favored
location for house construction
ecause
of the cool
breezes
off the
water.
As
indicated,
the
European rading
posts
and some vessels were also
regularly
attacked
by
indigenes
during
he
19th
century.
The
factors,
solated
along
with a handful
of
Solomon Islanders n
their
outstations,
were
frequently
killed andthe northern
art
of
New Irelandwas
notorious or the
danger
hat
raders
an,
the area
beingregarded
s
one
of
the
most
hostile
in
Melanesia
in the
late
19th
century e.g.,
Rannie
1912:261).
The
recordindicatesthatbetween 1881and 1895therewere thirteenmajorassaultson posts
with
heavy
loss to
the
occupants
(Schnee 1904:80).
Kapsu
post
was
destroyed
wice
during
the
1880s,
with the loss of life of
thetraders.
Putput
tationwas
also
attacked
t
least
twice,
with the
loss
of
life of the factor each time. Other
attacks occurredat
Kaboteron
sland,
at
Kabien
and
at Nusa
itself,
which
was
briefly
abandoned
n
the
early
1880s as
the
factor
fled
to
Kapsu.
Attackson coastalvessels
occurred
rom
time to time
and
islanders rom
Selapiu
were notorious or their
piracy
n
the
waters
betweennorthern
New Ireland
and New
Hanover.
Using
sail-equipped
anoes
they
raided
villages
and
attacked
trading
vessels,
retreating
nto
their
island
stronghold,protectedby
reefs
and
mangroves
when
pursued
Hahl 1937:39-41).
The peopleof Kabienalsoenjoyedareputationorattacksonvessels, andwhenthe
Whites in
northern
New Ireland
complained
o
GovernorHahlthat
hey
were
disrupting
trade,
he led a
punitive
expedition against
them,
only
to discover
that
they
had
slipped
away
to
Kapleman
on the east coast
(where,
incidentally,
another
Asian]
traderwas
murderedabout the same
time)
(Hahl
1937:69-70).
This
recordof violence not with-
standing,
Schnee
(1904:119)
claimed that
by
the late
1890s therewere a dozen or
more
White
traders n
northern
New Irelandand
adjacent
sles,
enjoyinggood relationships
with
the
native
people,
and
it is
clear
from
Romilly's
account
of his visit to
Kapsu
a
decade
and a
half
earlier,
that
traders
periodically
had
the
respect
of
some local leaders.
Cannibalism was
allegedly rampant
n
New Ireland and
adjacent
areas in
the
precontact
period.
Even
though
heearliest
Europeans
n the Blanche
Bay
areaencountered
this
custom
there and
some Pacific
Islanders n the
employ
of
the
Weslyan
mission fell
victim
to
local
villagers,
New Ireland
was notorious
amongst
Whites
n
the islands or its
widespread
cannibalism
e.g.,
Brown
1908:160;
Powell
1883:247).
Romilly's
account
of his
visit
to
Kapsu
n
1883offers a
graphicdescription
f the
preparations
or a cannibal
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
12/22
The
Early
Contact Period
in
NorthernNew Ireland 11
feast he
witnessed,
featuring
the fallen
of the defeated invaders
(1886:53-58
cf.,
Parkinson
1907:263-264).
Parkinsondescribes
how,
off
the
coast
of
New
Hanover,
he
encountereda returning aidingpartyand,on headingoff one of thecanoes,discovered
in the vessel
abandoned
by
the
crew,
the
corpses
of
three
young
people
allegedlybeing
taken
to
provide
fora cannibal east
(1907).
Boluminski
eports
hat
one of his first
asks
as
Administrator
on New
Ireland
was to undertakea
punitive expeditionagainst
the
people
of
Putput,
where
nine
people
from Avelus
had
recently
been eaten
(1904:131).
It
appears
that
although
he administration
eplored
acts of
cannibalism,
t
may
also
have
contributedto
them. Hahl
(1937:37-39)
reports
that
when
he
attacked
the
Medina
mercenariesandtheir followers in the
1890s,
he
landed
at Lemusmus
on
the
west
coast
and crossed over to
move down
the
east
coast,
assisted
by
spear
bearing
ocal
villagers,
possibly
from
the Lemusmus
area,
where some of the
police
he used
evidently
had
their
home. After the rout of Medina
villagers
in
which the
mercenary
eader
escaped,
Boluminski
withdrew,
but he claims that his erstwhile allies
slipped
back to take
the
corpses
of
the fallen for a cannibalfeast. Both Boluminski
1904:127)
and Parkinson
(1907)
refer to
the
custom
of
invitees
to cannibalfeasts
making
countergifts
of
shell
money
to
the
host(s),
and
it
is
noted that
a
warrior ould
in
this
way
increasehis wealth
and
standing.
Parkinson
adds
that
although
an
already
established
Big
Mancould
claim
the
choicest
parts
of
the
victims,
the
countergift
was
mandatory.
Procedure
ssociated
with such
feasts was
evidently
similar to that usual
in
other ceremonies
when
pigs
were/are
consumed,
namely
thatvalued
parts
of the animal
e.g.,
the
head)
are
given
to
men of standing,but all invitees areexpectedto makecountergiftsn shellmoneyto the
sponsors
of
the feast.
AlthoughEuropeans
illed
were sometimesdismembered
nd
parts
of
theirbodies
kept by
islanders,
hey
were,
according
o
Parkinson,
oteaten
1907:266).
Parkinson
also
implies
that,
in some areasat
least,
consumption
f
victims
was associated
with
the belief
that the consumersdrew some
strength
rom the deceased. He notes
that
informantsadvisedhim
thatWhitesdid not taste
good,
but hatone
local
leader
not
from
the New
Ireland
area,
however)
feared
he
spirits
of slain
andeaten
Whites.
Villagers
n
northernNew
Ireland
n
the 1960s made referenceto the
precontact
period
in
various
ways,
as
indicated
above,
and several
myths
made
explicit
reference o
cannibalism.
There are
clearly
anomalies
n
the
reputation
f northernNew
Ireland
amongst
he
Whites who madetheirhome inthe BismarckArchipelagonthese lateyearsof the 19th
century.
On
the one
hand
the
indigenes
are
depicted
as
violent, treacherous,
given
to
cannibalism and to
unprovoked
attack.
On the
other,
observers
omment hat
hey
were
much
sought
after
as
plantation
abor
and
even
policemen,
becauseof theease
with
which
they
mastered
required
skills.
Increasingly
arge
numbers
of
islanders,
both men
and
women,
were
being
recruited
or work
outside
New Irelandas the
century
came to an
end,
and
their
contribution o
building up
the
expatriate
ontrolledcoconut
plantation
economy
of
German
New Guinea was
obviously
not
inconsiderable.
Possibly
hundreds
of
Tungak, Tigak,
Kara.
and Nalik
speakers
from the
villages
of New
Hanover
and
northernNew
Ireland,
saw
service in
places
as
far afield as
Samoa,Fiji, Queensland,
Bougainville,
and the Blanche
Bay
areaand the northcoast of New Guinea.
They
were
taken
from
a
total
population
of
probably
ess than
20,000
during
hose
decades.5On
their return
hey brought
with them
not
only
more rade
goods already
eadily
available
n
the
area,
but
also
knowledge
of other
lifestyles
and a
linguafranca,
increasingly
understood
throughout
he
islands
and
later
also
on the mainlandof New
Guinea.
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
13/22
12
PETER OMAS
Villagers
in
the
area
were
already heavily
involved
in trade
by
the
1890s, and,
as
observers of the time
note,
were
among
the native
populations
most
strongly
nfluenced
by foreignways (Walden1911:29).
After the turnof the
century
hesituation
n
northern
New
Ireland
hangedabruptly.
Boluminski,
in
the New Guinea
region
since
1899,
foundeda
police post
on
the
site
of
Kavieng
in
1900
and
within four
years
had
succeeded n
pacifying
not
only
the
northern
part
of
the island
but much
of the
south
o
beyond
Namatanai
s well
(Boluminski
1904;
Hahl
1937:105, 158-159,
172;
Kraemer-Bannow
916:vi-viii).
Hahlattributes
is success
in
part
to
the
lengthy
association between local
villagers
and the
expatriate
nclaves,
suggesting
that the natives
welcomed the
imposition
of
Pax Germanica.
Although
he
various accounts of
northern
New
Irelanders
uggest
that
they
were
receptive
to
new
ideas and
lifestyles,
they
are
also
characterized
as
clinging
to
old
customs
(e.g.,
Parkinson
1907:269).
Boluminski's initial acts included
convincing
local
populations
that
henceforth
he,
as
representative
f the German
Crown,
was the
lawgiver
n the
area.
He also
very quickly persuaded
or
forced,
depending
on
the
interpretationlaced
on his
tactics,
local
villagers
to
construct,
underhis
direction,
he Kaiser
Wilhelm
Strasse,
the
main
east coast
road,
which was
laid out with
great
alacrity
cf.,
Gibson
1961:82,
who
suggests
he
was
harsh and that
natives died
working
on
the
road).
He also established
plantations,
a
botanical
garden
and a
wharf,
encouragingexpatriates
o settle
in the
region
around he new administration
enter. GovernorHahl
clearly thoughthighly
of
him,
and his role in
changing
northernNew
Ireland
was
unequalled.
He
died
in
Kavieng
in 1913 and his gravestonestill stands near the waterfronthe developed(cf., Hilder
1950:36).
Following
Boluminski
came,
in
1905,
the
Weslyan
(Methodist)
mission,
staffed
primarilyby
Fijians,
but headed
by
an
(Australian?)
xpatriate
and with some
Tolai converts
providing
assistance
(Paul
1907:36,
216).
The Methodists elected
Omo
village,
about a
mile from
Kavieng,
as their
first
headquarters,
nd it
was here that
a
number
of
Tigak
speakers
were
trained n the
Tolai
language
or
service
as
preachers.
Informants
n
the
area
in
the 1960s recalledthe
experiences
of kin in the service of the
mission,
which
rapidly
sought
to
expand
to
Djaul
Island
and New
Hanover,
as well
as
down
the
east coast road. The Omo stationwas not the first
footholdof the Methodist
n
New
Ireland,
as
George
Brown,
working
out of
Makada
on the Duke of York Islands
(Neu Lauenberg)had established one on the west coast as early as 1875. After the
Methodists came
the
Roman
Catholics,
also fromtheir
headquarters
n the Blanche
Bay
area,
but,
apparently y agreement,
hey
did
not seek
converts nthe northwestern
art
of
the
island where
theMethodistswere
already
stablished. nstruction
ffered
by
the local
missionary
included some
limited
teaching
of
reading
and
writing
skills,
using
the
scriptures,
and also some arithmetic
Gibson 1961:85).
At
this time therewas little
intereston the
part
of
the
German
Administration
n
providing
ducation o the
indigenes,
and the
mission
was
paid
500
marks
a
year
to
offer
some German
Gibson
1961:87).
Walden
(1911:29)
suggests
that
mission
activity
was
not
pronounced
n
northernNew
Irelandduring he first decade of thiscentury,an observationwhich echoes thatof Paul
on
the
situation
n
1906
(1911:223).
Parkinson
1907:269)
notes that he
Christianity
f
converted
indigenes
consisted
mostly
in
superficial
observances.Gibsonasserts hat he
Methodist
missionaries
olerated
raditional
mortuary
eremonies,
whilstRoman
Catholics
did not
(1961:83).
Traditional estivities
were
evidently
still
being organized
n
northern
New
Ireland
during
the
first
decade of this
century.
Kraemer-Bannow
1916:259)
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
14/22
The
Early
Contact Period
in Northern
New
Ireland
13
mentions
masks and
dance
practices
in
the
north
in a
community
she terms
Solangit
(Kulangit?)
and in
a
neighboring village, possibly
Omo, which,
despite
the
early
association with the Methodistmission(orperhapsbecauseof it, if Gibson s correct),
appears
o have
preserved
raditional
rts.
In
the
1960sdance eams romOmo
performed
widely
in
northernNew
Ireland
cf.,
Billings
1971:353,
who witnessed hemat
Mangai),
and
this
community
was
locally
renowned
amongstvillagers
or its traditionalism.
Other
visitors
after
1905
also observed festivities connected
with
traditional
rituals,
and
northernNew
Irelanderswere
characterizedas
being
much
given
to
song
and dance
(Kraemer
1925:72;
Walden and Neverman
1940;
Parkinson
1907).
Boluminski
notes
that
singsing
(festivities)
are the
nightmare
of
every
European
employer,
whether
planter,
recruiter r
trader
1904:130)
and
villagers
used
every
opportunity
s an
excuse
for such
activities.
Major
events,
the
mortuary
ceremonies,
then as
now,
required
months of
preparation.
By
the
end of the
period
of German
ontrol
October
1914),
however,
he
cumulative
impact
of
recruiters,administrators,
he
planters
and the
missionaries
haderodedmuch
of
the traditional culture. Recruitmentcontinued
during
the first
decade,
despite
Boluminski's
lament that local
villagers, swampedby
trade
goods
on
credit,
could
no
longer
be
tempted by
would-be
employers
(1904:134).
However
plantations
were
expandingvery
rapidly
n the
Kavieng
area
cf.,
Firth
1977:15-16).
Reynolds
1972:850)
gives
a
figure
of
3,725
acres
already
under
palmsby
1905,
while over
11,000
moreacres
had
been
acquired by expatriates
and
were
awaiting clearing
and
planting.
These
plantations mployed, it is claimed,551 laborers,of whomthemajoritywouldhave been
local
men.
Kraemer-Bannow
1916:256)
notes that he road rom
Kapsu
o
Kavieng
was
largely
lined with
plantations
by
1908/9,
and
although
not all the
palms
she
saw would
have been on
expatriate-owned
and,
the observationnevertheless
ndicates
he
speed
with which
the
copra
ndustry
was
expanding.
Nusa Island
tself
was
by
this
time covered
in
palms
(Kramer-Bannow
1916:258),
and
it remainedan
expatriate
wned
plantation
until
the
1970s,
first
in the handsof the
original
owners,
the Hemsheim
Company,
and
then
Bums
Philp (except
for a
few
years
during
he Pacific
War).
In the
mid 1970s the
island was
returned o the
original
landowners.
Rowley,
drawing
on official German
reports,
notes that
New Hanover and New
Ireland
seem to
have
remained he most
heavily
recruitedof all
areas,
providing,
in
1912/13, 2,446
new
recruits,
or
almost
thirty percent
of
all recruits or
the
year.
Shortly
after his
the
areawas
closed to
seekers
after labor
by
the
Australian
Military
Administration
Rowley
1958:110-111,
120).
An
official
report
notes
that n
1911 one-third
of
all
males oversixteenwere
employedaway
from their
villages
(Hoffman
1913).
Population
declinehad
been remarked
pon by
several
observersbeforethe end of
the first
decade
(Parkinson 907:268;
Sapper
1910:97; f.,
Scragg
1954).
Some
observers
ascribedthis
to introduced
iseases,
as indicated
bove,
whilstothersblamed ecruitment
or
marriage
restrictions
mposed
by
custom
(Parkinson1907;
Sapper
1910:99).
In the
1960s villagers also claimed thatin formertimes populationshad been muchgreater.
There
was,
moreover,
a marked ex
imbalance.Parkinson
uggests
hat herewere
only
half as
many
females
as
males,
whilst
Sapper
1910:101)
offers
figures
which
suggest
that this
impressionistic
assessment s
probably
not far
from
correct.The
demographic
factors, together
with
heavy
absenteeism rom
villages,
speeded
up
what
was
probably
inevitable
by
1905.
Twenty-four years
later
Chinnery
noted
that even
the
mortuary
This content downloaded from 128.176.254.22 on Wed, 21 Jan 2015 08:58:58 AMAll use subject toJSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp -
7/25/2019 Lomas_The Early Contact Period in Northern NI
15/22
14 PETER
LOMAS
ceremonies,
one of
the last
remaining ragments
f
aboriginal
ulture,
were
on
the brink
of
following
most
other features nto oblivion
(1929:6).
He
was,
in
fact,
mistaken
cf.,
Lomas n.d.).
Some
informationon the
aboriginal
culture of northernNew Irelanders
may
be
gleaned
from the
various
sourcescited in this
paper.
As
indicated arlier
residents
of
the
villages
in
the late 1960s
appearedrelatively
uninterested
n
the
pre-contact
or
early
contact
periods,
and
although
t
is
possible
o
extract ome data
rom
anecdotes
especially
those
connectedwith
land
controlwhich s
often
legitimatedby
reference o
sequences
of
earlier
controllers),
the overall
picture
obtained
s
very incomplete.Possibly
additional
fieldwork
may
retrieve
more facts.
The
literature,
on which this
paper
relies,
refers
primarily
to conditions as observed
after the
European
presence
had
alreadybegun
to
distort raditional
ctivities.
Early
references,
uch
as
that
of
Romilly,
were
o sociocultural
systems
which
had
already
begun
to
adjust
o the
demand
or
labor
and
copra,
and
to
the
supply
of
trade
goods.
Later
descriptions,
such
as
those of Parkinson
nd
Walden,
are
sometimes
ambiguous
as to which
period
is
being
discussed. Materialculture eatures
prominently
n
the detailed
reporting
f some of
the Germanobservers
e.g.,
Parkinson
1907:641-652;
Finsch
1914),
possibly