lirot tov katan 1. - kabbalah mediafiles.kabbalahmedia.info/files/heb_o_bb-sefer-lirot-tov... ·...
TRANSCRIPT
TZKMF:D’[EPGQ
TKPGEPPGI[C:E’DGNEKQ
PFEGZFZB[GRF,2006
REVSCK[ZBN,\[S"G
2006#MNFHMGKG\[PGZG\NPKMBNNKKJPQ
PS\"C:ISBN: 965-7065-30-5
www.kabbalah.infowww.kab1.comwww.kab.tv
Copyright # 2006 by Laitman Kabbalah Publishers127 Ramblewood Lane
Thornhill ONT. L4J 6R3, CanadaAll Rights Reserved
\GMQFTRKKRKO
FYEPF. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5
NPKP\BKONNPGEYCNF. . . . . . . . . . .9
NKPGEFYCNFGPJZ\G. . . . . . . . . . . . .17
I[KCG\F\V[JG\FYCNF. . . . . . . . . .31
FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF. . . . . . . . . .41
SVZFHGFZFYEG[. . . . . . . . . . . . . .59
FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO. . . . . . . . . . . . . .90
BIEG\. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .116
[PIFG\TRGD. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .129
HPQG\RGTF. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .138
PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\. . . . . . . . .144
FRS\ZGFRDNF. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .158
FCRFG[VF. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .167
F[\GG\FXGZFGECYG\. . . . . . . . . . . .179
BPGRFGKZB\[PKO. . . . . . . . . . . . . .187
SDGNFG\KYGQ. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .192
\VKNF. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .210
F[DFZGIRK\. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .213
K[ZBNGFTPKO. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .236
YCNFTM[KG. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .255
\VKNFYGEOF\VKNF. . . . . . . . . . . . .265
FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ. . . . . . . . . . .269
IGYZKOGFGDKETG\TNFYCNF. . . . . . . .293
FYEPF
PTCZNIG[KOGN\IG[G\[NRGYKKOTGNOZGIRK
RVNB[MGNGJGC.MNBIEPBK\RGKMGNNF\ICZBNKG
GNIG[BG\GCBGVQPP[KBOZYKZXFCML.BCNBKL
BV[ZNZXG\P[FG[TGENBI[KO?N[OMLBRIRG
HYGYKONFRIKFPPK[PXGKCBG\GTGNO,[KMGN
NSVZNRGTNKG.BOFGBKSVZNRGMPFJGC[O,RZXF
NFDKTNPYGOCGFGBPXGK.
FPYGCNKOFOBNG[ZGBKOJGTPKOGIGGKOB\
FTGNOFTNKGQ,ECZKFORSVDKOC\GMRG,FOBGPZKO
NRGPFFGBJTOFIKKO,GPK[[GPTBG\OMCZZW
NMKGGQ[BNKGFOPGCKNKO.FF[\GYYG\BNBG\G
TGNOP\IKNFPF\VTNG\ZB[GRK\,PML[BGPZKO
NRGTNP[FG[FGBJGC,GB\FF\VTNG\FHGBRIRG
KMGNKONFDEKN.
NM\CKFPYGCNKOK[\MGRFPKGIE\FYZGKF
"FPBGZFPIHKZNPGJC".FPBGZFHFPKGIENSVZK
FYGE[,[M\CGPYGCNKODEGNKOCTNKF[DFZGIRK\.
FGBVGTNTNFR[PF[NRGGPTRKYNF"IQEYEG[F".
FMGIFHFP[RFCRGB\FKGXZG\,GPV\ICRGIG[
IE[[PBV[ZNRGNF\MNNCBP\TOPF[RPXB
CTGNOFFGB.FBGZ[PDKTPFTGNOFZGIRK,EZL
M\CKFPYGCNKO,CGZBGTG[FCRGIG[RGSU,IG[
ZGIRK.BKQNRG[GOBV[ZG\NCRG\B\FIG[FHF
CEZLBIZ\.CTGNOCGBRIRGIKKORK\QNF\Z[O
PBR[KOBIZKO[\GV[KOGI[KOB\FTGNOMPGRG.
FOJGTPKONP[NP[FGJGCGBGPZKONRG[MEBK
NJTGOBG\G,BCNBKLBV[ZNKXGZCRGF\Z[PG\PQ
FTGNOFTNKGQVZJNM\CKOPSGDHF,BG\OM\CGBNG
[JTPGGZBGBG\G?
"NZBG\JGC"FGBSVZFP\BZC[V\O[N
DEGNKFPYGCNKOB\PF[FOZGBKO,GBKLBV[Z
NFDKTNPYGPOGNZBG\JGCB\FPG[DKOFTGPEKO
CZGPG[NTGNO.PG[DKOBNGPRG\YKOPBK\RG,GNMQ
BRGHYGYKONFRIKFPRYGE\PCJO[NFPYGCNKO,
BNG[PSGDNKONZBG\BG\OJGCPRYGE\PCJG[N
FCGZB.FSVZPSCKZNRG,GPTPKECVRKRGTZMKO[DO
BRIRGXZKMKONZBG\BG\OJGC,PG[DKO[DOBRIRG
RZBFBG\OJGC,BOR\YQB\TXPRGMEKNZBG\
BG\OJGC.M[R[KDBG\OMPXKBG\BHR\TNFCBP\
NZP\IKKOBIZ\.
FFPI[FGFF\VTNG\[RYCNPFM\CKO[CSVZ,
P\GL\KBGZO[NFPYGCNKOB\FBZWFFKB,B\
F[PKKOFFO,B\FTGNOFFGB,KDZPGNRGNF\VTN
GNZXG\B\PF[FOP\VTNKOPPRG.FOMCZRPXBKO
[O,FOPZDK[KOGPYCNKOB\FIKKOFBNG,B\
FTGNOFFGB,CBGVQPP[K.BORXNKINSVGDB\
FF\VTNG\[NFO,GNYCNB\F[VT\ON\GMRG,HF
K[P[NRGMMGINTNKF.
"NZBG\JGC"BKRRGBGSU[NBPZG\KVG\,BNB
SVZ[PSKKTNMNBIEGBIE[ZGXFNFDKTNVSD\
FYKGOFBRG[K.PK[ZGXFNFDKTNF[D\FTGNO
FZGIRKXZKLF\VTNG\,FMZ\DENG\FCGZBMBGGKZ
NR[KPF,P[KMFYEKPF.
FSVZFHF,P[P[MTXFGSKGTNPK[ZGXFNZBG\
JGCB\PJZ\FCZKBF,B\DPZF\KYGQ,B\PF
[FMKQTCGZRGCGZB.FF\VTNG\PECZKFPYGCNKO
6NZBG\JGC
DGZP\NIKHGYDENG\FPJZFFZGIRK\.BORZBFB\
PJZ\FCZKBFMDEGNFGI[GCFRGMNNF\DCZTNY[KK
FTGNOFHFGDONF[KDB\FTGNOFFGB.
FMN\NGKCKMGN\NZBG\JGC,HB\BGPZ\TE
MPF[HFJGCCTKRKRG.
7 FYEPF
NPKP\BKONNPGEYCNF
BEORGXZMEKNFZKOB\F[PKO.
�łÆØ������ª����
PXGFNDNG\HB\FIMPF.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ�
PK[PZDK[CTXPG,BIZKMPFGMPFRSKGRG\,[RV[G
CYZCGP\KK[C\CPRGI\FZYCTSYZHK\GZF,KET
RBPRFMKNMLRGXZ.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’, "�Y "Ł
F\GZFRK\RFNNPGEGNNPECMEK[MGNOKGETKO
PYJRKOTEDEGNKO,ET\F’,GDOPXKRGCFZCFSVZK
PYGCNKO[PHFKZKOTNNKPGEIMPFHG[MNBEO
IKKCNNPGEBG\F.
ł’Ø��Æ�ÆØ�øº��Ø,Ł�łœ��ªø,��"�
MKFYGZBCP[RFGC\NPGERYZBTCEFP[P[B\
ZCGTNPR\NYCNVZS,PF[BKQMQCIMP\FBP\MK
FGBP\YQMCKMGNGRG\QMINPTNFNPTNFGHFGRYZB
TGSYC\GZFN[PFCNKSVYGNBTGEBNB[NBRCZB
FBEOBNBMEKNNPGEIMP\FYCNF.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"���ø�ł���ª�œª�Æ’
BNKCFNGFGMNPRKTG\[CTGNO,D[PKG\GDOZGIRKG\,
PNFKG\ZWBNPYGZIKKGG[NPG\GFBPK\K\,GM[KHI
PYGZGGKRGENENG\B\PKPKGPCBZG\BIZG\,[BKRQ
[KKMG\NGCTXO,KRGEPKOTEKOGPRFZTEBVSK
BZWGPRGIFNBKPXB,MKMXVGZRGEE\PYRFMQBK[
RGEEPPYGPG.TNMQ\PKEK\BPWNCGCF’GKKINNBN
IKKG,KGXZR[P\GCYZCG,CZGIPKGIEGRJKFYEG[F
PKGIE\,[EGYBTNKEFKPXBB\B[ZKCY[.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’, "�Y "Ł
GBNKBPZFSZKSFQBRKTWKC[GPKBRMKND[\BN
FYGE[VRKPFCSVZKYCNF.MKMCZFSMKPGMN
FXEKYKOMKHFGPTX\FKXZG[YZCKPKRGGBU[BKRG
PCKQFMN.PMNPYGON[GQFHGFZFYEG[PSGDN
NR[PFGFGBECZF[GFNMNRV[K[ZBN,YJQGDEGN
[OFGB,MNBIENVKFCR\GG[GZ[R[P\G.
łÆØÆØ�ØłøÆ�Ø��Æ�łÆØı,����œØøłœ,�œ�’
BVKNGBORPXBBR[KODEGNKOC\GZF,CKZBF
GCIMPF,[BKQFTRKRKO[NS\ZK\GZFRGDTKONFO,
PVRKDENPTN\O,PVRK[K[CFOZMG[ZCNFTSKYCG
B\ZGIRKG\OCPMPRKF\GZFGFIMPFFDNGKKO,BN
KVGNCHFNKCG[NBEO,[FGBPZDK[CYZCGIG[VRKPK,
GNIW[NTZKDFR[P\K\BNBGZIG\FZHKO.MKBVKNG
BORINKJ[\[GYFHGCBFNGPVRKPKTGJM[ZGRG
NTRKRKOFDNGKKO,PFCML,SGUSGUHB\FKBP\\
ICNG,GZBGKNGN[PICINYG,MKYZGCF’NMNYGZBKG
CBP\GC\PKO,GNBRKMZNVRKG[GTPVRKEN.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł�, ł�Ø’,æ�Ø�ª’
PKK\QGFKF[K\IKNGNNPGETOFXBQYEG[KO
M[FOTEKKQCYJRG\OCQJ’GK’[RKOSVZFHGFZ
10NZBG\JGC
FYEG[...GFKGCGEBKFDBGNFCYZGCCNK[GOICNK
P[KI.GMCZM\CFZCZCK[OJGCCSVZFBPGRG\MK
ZYTNVKIMP\FYCNF\G[TKFGEFGK[ZBN\[GTG\
TGNPKOMKZYFGBIMP\BNYK\FPSGZFNIMPK
K[ZBNPKPKYEOG[RKOYEPGRKG\GTNKEFKDNF
MCGEBNYKOGMCGE\GZ\GFYEG[F.
łÆØøÆœØÆ�Ø��ÆØ���Ø øØı,æ��œØøł��,��łºœ�’�œ�’
BKBV[ZBNBCNKPGEFIMPFFRS\ZFGFF\PEF
CMGGRFFZBGKFCPT[FFPXGGFGF\GZFGF\VKNF,
GBHGGEBKK\KIEYGC"FG[MKR\KF,GK[NKOTCGE\G...
GBOMQBKQZBGKNF\Z[N[GOBIEPK[ZBNPF[D\
PXGGFHGTNP\MGR\F,MNBIEGBIEMVKMGIG,GFRF
\IKN\FKEKTFCMNNFPXKBGKG\FBNF,GBIZMLMVK
DGENFET\GFKEKTF,MQKDEKNYKGOPXGGFHG.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,�ł��łÆ
B[ZTNMQMNK[ZBNPIGKKCKONNPGECSVZF\GZF
FHF[NZ[C"K,BIEDBGQ,BIEZCDEGN,BIEIMO,
BIEFPGQ,BIEYJQ[FDKTNIKRGL,CTK\KOPHGPRKO
GPGM[ZKOB[ZFPFPSGEZKOECZKGOCKGPGPZB[
IGE[BNGNTEPRI\KGOFMKVGZKORI\OT\TYKE\
KXIYNYZCFDBGNFGKFKGRKXGNKOPMNVDTKOZTKO.
łÆØø���ÆłØ��Ø,łøÆ"Ø,œØ��Ø���ł,��ª�œ���Æł,º���Øł�
PK[PZDK[CYZCGI[YG\[GYFNNPGEFECZKO
FVRKPKKO,GNF[MKNCBPK\\GK\CZL,FZKFGBCMNN
11 NPKP\BKONNPGEYCNF
"NTGNOKNPEBEO\GZFCPYGO[NKCGIVW",MKGGQ
[PFS\OCGEBKK[NGNHFM[ZGQPKGIE,GPHFTXPG
PGMI[HFGZXGRG[NFYC"F,[FGBKTSGYCKEKT\
[PGK\CZL.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł�, ł�Ł’,Ø"Æ
MNFTRKRKOFBNFFRGDTKONKEKT\[PGK\CZLFO
YGCTKOCGB\FKZBFGPCNTEO\ISZNG,BXNGGEBK
FOTXPOFC[ZGFNIOFPF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł�, ł�Ł’,Ø"Æ
PK[PZDK[[MNGGRJK\GCBP\NET\B\F’,KFKF
IHYPBECEZMGGKETMKK[MKNGKXNKI...GTKYZNKPGEG
CTGPY[PI\NCGYCKTG\KFKFCPF[RV[GIG[Y\
NECYFCKEKT\[PGK\’,GKET[NGMLKB\F.GBOKZBF
[ZGCFNGPEKOBKQFRFD\OML,KET[CBP\NFO
ZBGK[NBKFZSGBNFYGE[TE[KNMGMVKFFEZDF.
GBKQ[KKLCHFNF\ZGPPG\GF\VBZG\,ZYCIKRG\
PIGNYG\CBXKNG\FRV[K\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł�, ł�Ł’,Ø"Æ
CPTPYKFR[PFFBRG[K\YGNF’YGZBCNBFZU.
PFGP\FIKKOKMGNFZYNFPOB\FRV[,TE[NB
\[PTCZGCT\G\IKKFB\FYGNFYGZBFHF.BCN
C[GOBGVQNB\GMNNTYGZB\FKSGE,B\F[GZ[
GFTKYZ[NFYGNFHF,[FGBCBP\MNTXOFIKKO
FBRG[KKO...GDOCBNF[FOP\BPXKONCZGIPVRKG
GNF[\KYBG\G,BKQFCZKIFGFF[\YFFHB\,BNB
PDNFCKG\ZB\YK[GZFFVRKPK[NFRV[BNBG\G
12NZBG\JGC
FYGNFBEKZ,[BKRGVGSYPRFGODOCNCCOGPZXG\
DOCFOTXPO.BMQN[GBDOMNPBPXKFCZKIF
PPRGGMNF\ICGNG\NF[\Y\G.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�,113
CP\YZCKOZBKRGD’M\G\:PFOJGTG\,PFO
IGJBG\,PFOZXGKG\,GFM\FZXGKFFOBG\O
FBGIHKONFOEZLFK[Z[K[NFOINYCPYZBGINY
CDPZBGFGZBG\KF[FOBXNRGMP[RFGINYCIMPF
HGGNGPEKOBG\FN[PFNFMRSCSGEG\KFNET\
B\YGRONF[KDFPTNFFRVNB\CF[DFFBPK\K\
CKEKT\F\GZFGNF\VNNNVRKYGRONKIECPXG\KG
FYC"FG[MKR\KFGFKBFTCGEFFZXGKFNVRKCGZB
MN.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,��"Y��"�
CFMR\TXPGNFKG\ZBGKNKMRSBNFFKMNFHFFQ
BP\BKQZBGKNMNFCBNPNBB\KEGNNCG[B\CDEK
F[ZEN[Z\CYE[KCBGKNC[ISG[NGO,BNBZBGK
ZB[GRFNFV[KJPTNKGYNKV\FDBGFFDSFFPGRT\
BG\GPNF[KDFBP\GKMGKQNCGN[PKOMEK[NBKM[N
GNBKPRFINYGPFM\FIGJB\.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,��"�
NNPGEYCNFKET\KMKB\FCTXPLNB\ZXFNNPGE,
CNTEKBKHFDEGNPPL.GNB\PXBHF.ZY\NPGESVZ
FHGFZ.BCNNVRKMNNKPGE\KK[CB\TXPL[NB
KFKFPXG\BR[KOPNGPEF,ZYNPTQF[OK\CZL.
13 NPKP\BKONNPGEYCNF
GNBMNFT\KO[GG\:VTPKO[\GMNNNPGECI[Y
DEGNNPTQF[OK\CZL,BO\HMFNF\VNNCPI[CF
HMF.GNVTPKOCPI[CFYJRF.BCNFMNCPI[CF
NPTQF[OK\CZL.
�łÆ�ø�� ØØÆø,ØøłªÆłØ��œ,��’º"�
FF[DIF,MCZBPZRG[FKBPF[CKQFCGZBNCZGBKG,
GFZKPYGPFFGBFTKGQCBNGYG\GRT[FFKY[T\F:
FYC"FPXGGFBG\RG[RETF[DI\G,GFZKBRGZGXKO
NNPGEPF[KGEKTRGF[DIFHB\.GPF[KGEKTRGF[DIF
HB\BKRGBNBIMP\FBP\,[FKBFTKGQCBNGYG\G
K\CZL[PG.BOMQFZKBRGZGBKOCNBSVYIGCF
NNPGEIMP\FBP\.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,ø�łØł��"�,���ł�غ�,��’ ’
BIKC[CKNHF[B\FJZGECTSYKOFQCTG[ZGFQ
CENKENG\ISG[NGONB\VJGZPTSYIMPFHGIS
G[NGO,MKTNPFGNPFB\FIK,GNPFR\DNFNRGHB\,
GNPF[NIF’NRGNF\DNG\CEGZKRGPF[NBDKNFHGN\
CEGZG[NZCKTYKCBGZCK[PTGQCQKGIBKGICZKG,FGB
TSYIMP\FBZKH"N.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,æł�ł�º"Ł
BKQB\FVJGZPVRKPKG\F\GZFMKPCNTEFFBEO
MCFPF[GZBGMNT[CMR"NC[OF\KYGRKOPVSGY
"MNFC[ZIXKZ".
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,æł�ł�º"Ł
14NZBG\JGC
CFDT\FHPQ,BKQSVY[BKQZBGKNBEONKMRS
CIMPFHGBONBR[BB[FGKJFZPI[C\G,GBN
K[KCRKPMPF[NPEGYGEONHPQHFMKNBMNFETG\
[GG\.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�"æ
GBGPZBRKFNGBK[NBFKGPYKNKQDEGNKFEGZ
CNKPGEFIMPFFYEG[FGFNGBKFKGPNPEKQEZL
N\NPKEKFONTSGYCIMPFFNHGBHKCGEBKNBFKF
[GOFZP\ZB[NIMP\FIKXGRKG\GFKGMNFIMPG\
REIKOPVRKFMPG[REIFFIG[LPVRKFBGZBL
[TGRG\KGDZPG[DOMPFGMPFPXEKYKFEGZSDZGB\
EN\KFIMPFCVRKVZIKFMFGRFGBPZG[NBKNPEG
TE[KFKGCTNKPEZKDFGZGIFYGE[GFRFTCGZHF
R[BZRGTZGPKOPQFIMPFFYEG[FGR\DCZCTGRG\KRG
FZCKOI[KMG\FIMPG\FIKXGRKG\FMSKNCIG[L
FGNLGCPFZFCKPKRG"GKBPZBNYKOKFKBGZ"GKBZ
NRG.
ł’ÆØ��Ø��Œø Øł��ªØ�Æ,��ł"�,��Ø���Ø�, ł��’�œ�’
PK[NBNPEF\GZFTNVKSGE,BUTNVK[F[NKO
TCGE\GC\MNK\F[NPG\,FGBZYCCIKR\TCE,
CCIKR\"MKNKCRKK[ZBNTCEKO",TCEKFO,[R[P\O
PTGNOFCZKBF[[OFMSBGFIKG\GBGVRKO[FO
RYZBKOTCEGBPF,BCNPK[NGPEGTGCEF[OK\CZL
CVRKPKG\FIMPFCRS\ZG\F\GZFGTG[FKIGEKO
FGBCCIKR\CQGMCQP[P[NBCKGGNBPGTCGEF
15 NPKP\BKONNPGEYCNF
[NKPF,MKR[P\GPTGNOFBXKNG\,GTNKGRBPZ"FCQ
KYKZNKBVZKO".
�łÆ�Øæ�øت�Æ,��ª�œ��ł�"ø� ł�"ø
FRFCNKKEKT\IMP\FYCNFFGBMCFPF,BIZ
[TG[FFPXGFCNKJTOZYPXG\BR[KOPNGPEF,
GEGPFNCFPG\FBGMNG\IXKZ,[BKQCGJTOBMKN\
BEO.GBVKNGFGBCTNTSYKODEGNCP[BGP\QGJZGE
FZCFNBKVJGZPTSYIMPFHB\.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,æł�ł��ø�ŁÆ
GTGEBPZGIMPKFBP\,[MNRV[XZKMFN\KYGRF
NTSGYCVZE"SMVKPF[FKBKMGNFNF[KDGNKET,GMN
PK[KMGNNF[KDGNKETFZCFGR\TXNGNBF[KDGKET
BNBPTJXZKLNCBCDNDGNTE[K[KDGKETMNPF
[BV[ZNR[P\GNF[KDPKEKT\F\GZF,FQCV[JK
FFNMG\FQCZPHKOGEZ[G\GSGEG\,MKMNPF
[R[P\GKMGNFNF[KDGNKETPKEKT\F\GZFHFG\KYGQ
[NKPG\F,GBKBV[ZNFNF\\YQGNF[\NOCXZGZ
FIKKOB\F’CPYGZFB[ZIGXCFP[OCN\KKEKTF
HG,GNMQBPZGIMPKOB[ZKPK[CBNMBQG\NPGEG
CKEGMEK[NBKXJZLNCBCDNDGNNTGNOFHF.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,ø"��łÆ,��ºœœ"œ ł��’
16NZBG\JGC
NKPGEFYCNFGPJZ\G
GB\F[NPFCRKETB\BNYKBCKLGTCEFGCNC[NO.
ªÆłØ�Ø�Ø��’º"�Ł’
BRKF’BNYKLPNPELNFGTKNPEZKMLCEZL\NL.
Øø�Ø��"�Ø"�
GFKGTKRKLZGBG\B\PGZKL.
Øø�Ø��’º’
B[ZKBEO[[OTXPGM[GZNTGNGMIPGZNP[BGK[C
GKFDFCECZK\GZFCMNKGO\PKEPKEZGIFYGE[
[GZFTNKG.
��Ø�łÆ�, łø�Æ’
BKQSVY[PMNEZG[KFTGNOBKQI[GCPEZK[\S\ZK
\GZFPVRK[FORGDTKOCBNFG\,MKPXKBG\MNPF
[R\Q\GZFNK[ZBNFMGGRFNET\FBNGFGNTGCEG.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�’
PK[NBNPEIMP\FYCNF[NSGEG\GZHKQEBGZKK\B,
NBHMFNVRKPKG\FYC"F.
æ’ÆłØœ����ª�Æ’
BKRRGPIE[KOECZ.TCGE\RGFKBZYNFBKZTNPF
[ICGKC\GMG[NBEO.
�łÆØ������ª����
FBNPE\[MNPK[BKRRGNGPEYCNFBKRGCTN\GZF
[NKO.
�łÆø��Æ��ø�Æ���,��ªø��Œ���ł ’�ø ŁØ�ø�
G\BPKQNKBIKPK[BKRGNGPEHB\FIMPFFGBMPG
FEZCIGWNBZWGEGPFMPK[BKQNGBNGYKBIZ
[F\BGG\DGCZGFKXZPSK\GPCKBSVYBPGRFBCN
FP[KORV[GCMVGGTGSYCIMP\FYCNFNBK[BZNG
[GOSVYCEZMKF’FPVNKBVNBG\.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,æł�ł�,æ"Ł
GNVKMLP\IKKCFNGPECJZOFNKPGENF\IHY
CBPGR\F[OK\CZLGCF[DI\GC[MZGTGR[,MPG
[BPZGIH"N"RBPQCTNPNBM\L[K[NONL[MZ
VTGN\L".GKMGGQB\FKDKTF[NG,[KFKFN[OPXG\
F\GZF.GCEZLFHFKHMFNKFRG\PFPBGZ[CF,[DO
BPGR\G\\IHYG\\DENCSDGN\FPBGZFHF,MPG
[M\GC"ZVBG\\FKN[ZLG[YGKNTXPG\KL")P[NK
D’,I’(.
GBHKFKFRMGQNCGCJGI,MKP\GL[NBN[PFKCB
N[PF.CBGVQ,BVKNGPK[KGETCTXPG,[TEKKQNBHMF
NBPGRF,K[NG\YGFDOMQTNKEKTSYF\GZF.MKBO
K[KONCGGET\GNHMG\TNKEFNBPGR\F[OK\CZL,
MCZBKQNLPXGFDEGNFPHG,MPG[BPZGIH"N
"CBICYGYGFTPKEQTNBI\:XEKYCBPGR\GKIKF"
)PMG\M"E(.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���œ��ª�øłæ Øłœ,�œØ"�
18NZBG\JGC
BPROK[CHFECZDEGN,GZBGKNVZSPG,MKK[SDGNF
RVNBFNBKQTZGL,NTGSYKOCIMP\FYCNF,[BUTN
VK[BKROPCKRKOPF[NGPEKO,BNBP\GLFI[Y
GFZXGQFIHY,NFCKQPF[NGPEKO,PTGZZKOTNKFO
B\FBGZG\FPYKVKOB\R[P\O.VKZG[,MKMNBEO
PK[ZBNPGCJICSGVG,[K[KDMNFF[DG\FRVNBG\,
B[ZI[CF[OK\CZLCPI[C\FCZKBFNFRG\NMN
RCZB.BNBPK[NBHMFCDNDGNHF,KHMFCDNDGNC’GMG’
TE[KHMFNF[NKOPI[C\FCGZB[I[CTNKG.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���œ��ª�øłæ Øłœ,�œ��"�
MKIMPFHGFKBNBVIG\GNBKG\ZBNBSEZ[N
[GZ[KOFP[\N[NKOTNEZLYGEOGRP[LCIGYKO
YCGTKOGPGINJKOFP\ICZKOGYGNTKONPJZFBI\
PBERTNF,FRYGCFC[O"DKNGKBNYG\GK\CZL
NRCZBKGCTGNOFHF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł��œ�ø��º�œ��Æ��
GMQF[N"FFYEG[BPZNCRKG[MNPK[NBJTO
IMP\FYCNFNBJTOJTOKZB\IJBPKPKGGBPZ
[DEGNGI[GCFKGO[R\DNFCGYCN\ZCKRGFBZ"K
HMZGRGNCZMFMKGO[RK\Q\GZ\P[FNK[ZBN.
��ª��º��Øœ����Ø�
IMP\FBP\PNPE\BG\RGB\FBIEG\FTGNPK\,
B\FXE[NF[KGGK[K[NPXGBCFGKFMGNFTE
19 NKPGEFYCNFGPJZ\G
NPTNFNPTNF,NEKPGKFXGZFNKGXZF,GBKLNNM\
CEZLBGZFHGCNKPM[GN.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,ª�ø"�
GBOBEOJGZINET\CHFFTGNONPGEKOBUTNVK
[BKQNGNCT\FKFKFNGNCCK[KCF[CZYKT.
łÆØØ�ª���æت,æ ł��æتØ�,œœøæ"ª
MNNFTGNF[IKKCBEONKET[PGK\CZL,GPK[NB
ZBFIMPFHGNBZBFBGZG\PKPKG,GFMSKNCIG[L
FGNL.GPK[NBZGXFCIMPFFGB[\\DNFMIMPF
HB\[CHMG\FKCGBP[KIXEYRGCPFZFCKPKRG
BPQ.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,�łœ�ØØ�ª�Ø"�
TGEETMKFBEOPIGKKCNTSGYCE’PEZDG\VZE"S
GFOV[JZPHEZG[GSGE,GXZKL[K\DNDNTE[K[NKO
BG\O.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,ø�ł�����Ø�
TKYZNKPGECVRKPKG\F\GZFKFKF[\[KDFBZF
GIKG\BNGYK\CRV[LCT\NKPGELGCMNFKGO,GNB
[\FKFPYGCNBGIGYZGMG’.GNVTPKOFBEOFGB
CYJRG\F[MN,NBKVJGZB\TXPGPMNGOMKHFPKRG\
GMG’GBHTYKP\[V\KGFGFPT[FGPMNB[MKCTN
BCRKOGBG\KG\MPG[FQ.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�ª�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº�,ªÆłØ�ª�ł"�
20NZBG\JGC
BOKNPGECBP\GCKZB\IJB,[KNPGEKG\Z,KGMRT
KG\Z,GKZBFB\TXPGZIGYPQFBP\,GCGEBKKCGB
NKZB\IJB.BCNM[KNPGEMEKNFKG\NPEQGPVGNVN
GCYKCEKRKONEGQGNFGZG\,MNPF[KGSKUET\BKHF
VNVGNGSCZB,KGSKUPMBGCGK\DENFNCKG\Z.GCBP\
PIP\HFFMSKNCIG[LFGNLCMNPKRK\BGG\
G[YZKO,GKCNG[RG\KGCISZNC.
�łÆ�ø�� ØØÆø,ØøłªÆłØ��œ,��’�"Ł
FETG\FCBG\TNKEKFPIYZKOFIE[KO,[FO
CZGCOSG\ZKOB\V[JKECZK\GZF,ET\KCHFFKB
[MNPK[ETG\KGK[ZG\,ZBGKNGNET\,[BU[BKQMN
BP\PGMZI\CMNBG\QFIE[G\,PMNPYGOBKQ
BRIRGIKKCKOMNNNFMIK[QCCZGZGNTPGERDEQ,PVRK
[BKQHFMNNTKYZ[N\GZFNSVZNRGTGCEG\V[GJG\
GPT[KO[FKG.FTKYZFGBF\GL,FFSCZFFVRKPK\
[CFTRKRKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�æ"�
FRFPRKFTCGEF\\INYN[N[FINYKO,FBIE
FTGCES\O[BKRGRG\QNCNET\,BKRG[GPZMNPXG\
F\GZFGPXGF,GBKRGKGET[GOCIKRFCBNFG\BNB
PMKZ[K[BNGFR\Q\GZFNK[ZBNGXGF[KTCEGFG,
GPMNNBNGM[ZKTOFTGCEKON\GPO.
GF[RK\FOFVKNGSGVKO[I[CGTPEGTNTKYZ
FBNFG\GF[KDGFGGFD[KPGFGGMKGXB,GBNGFPINKVKO
FOYZGCKONTCGEHGN\G,BNB[NCORMGQNBP\
GPT[KFOZXGKKOGMGR\OCN\KZXGKF.
21 NKPGEFYCNFGPJZ\G
GF[NK[K\FOBG\O[TPEGTNSGEF’GFTPKYG
CECZKZCK[PTGQGS\ZKSGEG\KG,GFMKZGGKETGB\
BNFKBCKFOCKEKTFGNBFINKVGNHGN\G,GNBTCEG
MBG\OFS\GPKOTKRKF[MN.
GFRFBNGF[NK[KOFOFPGCIZKOTE[BNGFO
[MGGRGNFXEKYPT[KFOTNMGGR\CZKB\O[NBRCZB
BEOBNBN[RKTRKKRKOBNG,FB’NTCGEFC’NFMKZ,
GBNGFKGETKOTPEGTN[RKFOTCEGGFMKZG,GTN
[RKFOBPZEGEFPNLGFHFKZ"ETB\BNFKBCKL
GTCEFG",FKGETTGCEC[NKPG\GFCN\KKGETTGCEBCN
NBC[NKPG\NMLFYEKOGBPZET.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�’
FICGZFHFNBKTEZGNBKTNOBNBK\ICZGKM\C
GKSGEZ,MKBKQI[[CM\KC\GP[GOENBKPRTFCB
NTSGYCGFGBXEKYBGZ[T,BOFGBXEKYBEZCF
FICGZFHFFGBMPG\KC\RI[BGSUG[GBCBG\G
BNKGC[TZNF’[BGSUFXEKYKOBN\GLFFKMN
VRKPF.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,Ø"�
MLSDGN\FICGZFHF,[PK[TGSYCI[YGBFC\F’
K[BCRGM[BKC\FBCQF[GBC\B\FCZHN,GKMRS
BNKGNFXN\RV[GGZGIGGR[P\GG\KYGRGGBKQZBGK
NPRGTJGCPCTNKG,GBOKFKFZ[TBKQI[[BOKMRS
PVRK[BKQMRKS\GMRKSFBNBKFKFNGBI\P[N[,
BGKIHKZRGC\[GCFGKFKFXEKYGKMRSCG,BGKEIRG
EIKFDPGZFGKVZG[TXPG,MN[MQMKZGCFVTPKONB
K\YZCNG,MTKQ\KC\RI[FKFEGIFFZ[TKOGBG\O
22NZBG\JGC
[IJBGPQFIKFGPQFCFPF,GBOKZBFCTKRKBEO
[FOP\YZCKOBNKGGBKQNFOPT[KOFDGRKO,FGB
SG\OTXPGCVRKGGBKQVG\ING[TZKGGFGBCTRKKRG
PCIGWGEBK.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,Ø"�
GFNGPEC\GZFNET\MPK[NGPECSVZFHMZGRG\HF
GEBKNBKGTKNCNKPGEGNBKDKTFGPPRG\GTN\GFNGBK
[NBKVSKE,BCNMB[ZKCBFBEONNPGEC\GZF
XZKL[KFKFMGGR\G[FGBNGPEFTRKQFFGBCPF[FO
ECZKOBNFKKO[RTNOPPRGTGXOVRKPKG\OGCECZ
FHFKKJCFCNF\GZFFKGXBPVKGNVRKFYC"F.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�"Ł
GBUBOK\TSYCV[GJKFECZKOCIMPFFHB\,NB
K[KDFPEZDFFHB\,BNBMB[ZKVNVNGKKJKCTKGRG,
GBONBK[KDCVTOBI\G[RKFIMF,MKCF\PE\
FTKGQK[KD,BHRYZBPIMFGK[KDFPEZDFFHB\,[BH
P[\P[CIMPFGCKRF,MKFIMPFFOZB[KVZYKO
[RPSZGNRGGRPXBGCSVZKZCK[PTGQCZKGIBK,GCKRF
FGBNFCKQECZP\GLECZGNF\VNVNGNEYEYFZCF
CIMPFGBHKXBNGSGE,GFZKFGBPIE[IKEG[C\GZF
[PTN\GDEGNF.
�ł��º�����ł,Æø��ł�"�
FNMFBKFKYCNF.FJTONPFFYCNFRYZB\FNMF,
TNMKFKBNCEFFGNM\TOFBEONCK\TGNPG.GHF
ZPGHCPF[M\GC:BN\YZBFNKMG\BNBFNMG\,
GNPFNBRM\CFNMG\TGNONG,NNPELEEGYBFYCNF
23 NKPGEFYCNFGPJZ\G
FRYZB\FNMG\FOFGNMKOTOFBEONCK\TGNPG,
GCMNPYGO[FGNLCK\GTPGNXGG\BGNMCGEGN\VBZ\,
MKFPNBLFRCZBPNKPGEFYCNFNTGNOBKRGRVZE
PFBEORGSUTNP\Q[MZG.
ºæ���Œ���ª�œ�œØ��Ø���łª�Ø"ª
BOR[KONCRGNF[KCZYTN[BNFBI\PVGZSP\
PBGE,CJGIBRMK[MNF[BNG\GFSVKYG\FNNG
K\TNPGPQFBGVYG\CKJBNPYGPOGBKRO.GFKKRG
F[BNFFHTGPFFR[BN\PMNCRKKZE,[FKB:PFG
FJTOCIKKRG.
MNGPZ,PSVZ[RG\IKKRGFNNG,FTGNKONRGCKGYZ
MNML,EFKKRGPZCK\FKSGZKOGFPMBGCKO[BRG
SGCNKOCTEO,CMEKNF[NKPOTNBIZK\O,FRFPK
FGBFRFRFPFO.BGCK\ZEKGY,NPKBRKPFRF.GFQ
BP\[MCZRNBGIGYZKFEGZG\NFZFZCHF,GBKQXZKL
NGPZCEGZRGHF,[NBKZXFPK[FGBBVKNGNFTNG\F
TNFET\.TOMNHFTXOF[BNFCTKRFTGPE\CMN
\GYVFGPZKZG\F,[FZKNT\KOFKBVGD[\BG\RG
CN\KYZGB,GPRYZ\B\PGIKRG,GP[VKN\RGTETVZ,
CJZO[RXNKINPXGBF\ICGNFFKEGTF,EFKKRG,
NFSIUCNKET\CHZPKFIKKO,MEB\PGN.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���œ��ª�øł�æ Øłœ,�œÆ’
FTGSYKOZYCNCG[KF\GZFFKROJGTKOCHFPBE,
F’KZIOTNKFOGKSNINFOCDGENISEG.GMB[ZEZK[\
F’RTHC\GFPGQIMPKF\GZFBKRRGKGETCZGCGDOB\
XZMF,GIMP\F\GZFN\MNK\FRI[C\BXNOZY
24NZBG\JGC
FGSV\BKHFVNVGNKOCFGGKG\[NFNMF,[FOBPRO
YEG[KOGKYZKO,BCNNBFOKBKZGB\R[PG\KRG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,��"�
BPROFXTKZKONKPKO,BGB[ZKPXBGCTXPOMCEG\
GPKTGJI[YNPBGZFVRKPK,TNKFOFIGCFPGJN\
NVIG\,[NBNDZGTIGY,ECZKGOCKGPG,N[KTGZKO
[TFG[\KKOCMNKGONIMP\FBP\GBHCFP[LFHPQ
\FKFET\OP\ZIC\,G[VTFXNIFKIGNTNFDKGRO
DOCDGVK\GZF,GMIVNVGNOK[DBGKDENCZTKGQHL
GFZIC\FET\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’, "Æ
BPROBRKZDKN\PKENFTKZB\DEGNKTPRG,[NB
NFS\VYZYCPYXGTBIE,DOCINYFZGIRK[C\GZF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœª’,æ"�
NB[PTRGNYGNRCKBKFBP\NYGNPTGNKIMPKEGZG\
TGNPKO,NYGNFXEKYKOGFISKEKO,IMPKFPGSZ
GIMPKFTKGQGFZHKO,[XGIGGFMZKHGCYGNKYGNG\MK
SGUFRFZ[NF\NPGEFPT[KNCEGNFKG\KC[GIZC,
BONBRP[GLN\GMG\PKEPKOPRKKO,PKPB
EIGMP\BGYCNF,PKOET\FBNFKO,PKOJGFZ
FBPGRFFJFGZFFRGCT\PR[P\RGVRKPFP[Z[F
PPYGZFIKKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,�"�
CECZKGTN"FJZYNKQFZGIRK[C\GZF"P\KISFZC
YGYBNBG\GFIGD[NFPGZDNKOCBPGRFC\GZF
25 NKPGEFYCNFGPJZ\G
GPXGG\,BNF,[PFOFKGZBGKKOGRBKONFKG\MCRK
CK\CJZYNKQFHF,FKGETKOFONFKRG\GNFRG\PHKG
[NFJZYNKQ?PCKJKOFOCBKPFK\ZF=NBMCQ
VNJKQFKGETB\TZMG,BNBMCQ[GPZFIXZ[RFRF
PIKXGRKG\G[NFJZYNKQ,GZTKGQNBKTNFTNNCCG,
[NGRBFGKBFEGYBNFMRSVRKPF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�,�"�12
ZKCGKFNKPGEPY[ZB\FYEG[FFTNKGRFCZGIG[N
BEO.BUTNVK[BKRGKGZENTGPYO[NECZKO
GNVTPKOVGTNTNKGNJGCFTNKGRF,DOM[BKRGKGET
B\FV[JCPF[NPE,BCNFGBXPBNECZF’NNPGE
FZCF,GP[CKZB\XPBGRGC\NPGEPZGCF,GFR[PF
P\TNF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł�, ł�’,Ł"�
CNKPGEZHKF\GZF,BUTNVK[BKRGPCKQB\FTRKRKO
NVZJKG\O,GREPFNGMBKNGFGBTGSYCXKGZKO
[PTRKOB\RV[GGB\IG[GFZGIRK,F[GYYNECZKO
PGCRKO,PMNPYGOBIZFNKPGE,FBGZFPGVKTF
TNKG,GFGBCMNNMNFTGSYC\GZFCNKNF[FYC"F
PG[LTNKGIGJ[NISECKGO,[RBPZ"KGPOKXGFF’
ISEGGCNKNF[KZFTPK".
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł�, ł�’,Ł"�
PK[PGM[ZNTSGYCTKGQIMP\BGYCNF...TKYZ
NKPGEGXZKL[KFKFNFMKZB\YGRG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"�Y�"Æ
26NZBG\JGC
GFTRKQMKPK[NBNPEEZLFSGEMNNGKG[NO
CTCGEF\MNK\F[NKPG\KHMFBNPEZD\TCE[NO
GNTGNONBKGMNNHMG\BNPEZD\CQ,GFJTO[FGB
NGPETNPR\NYCNVZS.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,��"Ł
MKNBTNIROMVKZXGROVSYGJPBJFGZBSGZ
GFK\ZM[ZGVSGNBNBP\GLVRKPKG\F\GZFMRGET
NKGETKIQ.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,�’
CMIFNKPGEFYEG[FHFRXBPQFDNG\NBCHGN\HF
FNKPGE...GDEGN[MZNKPGEFHFKG\ZP[BZMN
F\GZFGMNFPXG\...GBOTSYCIMPFHGNBIZ
KXKB\R[P\GPDGVGVGJZKQBG\GPMNEKRKO...GFTGSY
CIMP\FYCNFNET\ZHKF\GZFGJTPKFPXG\TNVK
SGERYZBCQNFYEG[CZGLFGBGYGE[BCZKLFGB
P\VBZCGCZYKT.
ł’ ��æ��Ø�Æ���Øł,æ ł�ÆłØœ,���Æ’���łØ"Æ ł��’
FIMPFFBPK\K\,ISG[NGO[\GZK[[GOBPGRF
ZTFBGET\RVSE,BCNCFVL[\RIKNFBP\GFXEY
G\[ZK[BPGRG\GETG\BP\KG\CNCNGPEKF,GBU
BOKYEKPGFNNPGEF\GZFMKFKBFPGXKBFNBGZ
\TNGPG\F\GZFGTYZKFGPIHY\G\GPM\[Z[KF.
łÆØø���Æ��ªłœ,łøÆ"�,�ƪœ��ªø,����œº�Øœ ł�Ø"�
27 NKPGEFYCNFGPJZ\G
NBKTNFCNCCMO[GOVIENNPGEMKTNKEKNKPGEO
K\YE[GGKJFZGZP"IBCZKOG[S"FDKEKOG\GMNG
NYE[GNJFZMNBCZGBCZNFKG\PZMCFN[MKRF
GNYZCYWFDBGNF.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�ª�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº�,Æł�øØœª��"Æ
FTGSYCIMP\FBP\C[CGTG\ZGBFSKPQKVF
CNKPGEG.��ª�º��ØæØ���’�œØ"Æ
PK[FGB[NODOCS\ZK\GZFRYZBP[MKN.PK
[K[CKEKGPYZBPBG\F’BIZGRF[C[OR[NING
PNBLN[PZG,GBOK[CKEGP[RFG\NPGETOFPYZB
RHYYKQNGC’BG\KG\BIZGRG\G"FP[OFGK"FN[NGI
NGC’PNBMKON[PZG,GBOK[CKEGPYZB,P[RF,
\NPGE,BDEF,GS\ZK\GZFGSVZKXKZF,GBKRG[NO
CIMP\FYCNF,RYZBIMOGRCGQ,GBKRGRYZBP[MKN.
GMNF[OFPKGIEZGCGMMGNGHYGYN[GPZG,GPK
[FGB[NOCMNFECZKOFRHFZKO,MNBG\KG\FGK"F
HGMKON[PZGNTGNO.�æª��Æł��,�Ø���ł���łØ"�
TKYZDEGNNF\DCZPBECMINNPGEEGYBCT\
FHB\,[BKRGPZDK[CTXPG[GOI[YNNPGEZY
FIGPZPYZZGCTXNG\GCMCEG\GMG’,BVKNG[PGIG
GNCGBJGPKOGNBKMGNNMGKQMNNPF[NGPE,BUTNVK
MQK\DCZCMINGPZBHCVKGB\ECZKFDPZBP[RKG\
PEZ[GHGFZ.���œ�’�’Ø�œº"�
28NZBG\JGC
GHF[BPZGIH"NCBCG\EZCKR\Q)S"VM"JGM"F
D"M(CCZMG\:MNPK[K[CKEGPEZ[GBKQCKEGFNMG\
NBJTOJTO[NIMPF,MNPK[K[CKEGFNMG\GBKQ
CKEGPEZ[NBTOJTO[NKZB\IJB,VKZG[[FNMG\
RYZBG\JTO[NIMPFNVK[CFQGTNKEQPG[DPFG\
IMP\GK\CZL[R\NC[FCFNMFHG.
PF[BOMQCNKPGEFVRKPKG\FRYZBPEZ[BKQ
PG[DFPFG\PP[,GNMQRYZB[NBJTOJTO[N
IMPF,VKZG[FPFG\PP[.GTOMNHFPK[K[CKEG
FNMG\GBKQCKEGPEZ[NBJTOJTO[NKZB\IJB,
MKBU[CNKPGEFPEZ[BKQPG[DZYFBZF,PMN
PYGOHGFFBZFPCKBFNKEKKZB\IJB.GTGE,MKBU
[HFGZYFBZF,FRFFKBFBZFPCIKR\FVRKPKG\,
MKBGZKK\BS\KOGDNKB.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,��ŁØœł��Æ���œ�Ø�Łłª’
FGBSGENKPGEIMP\FYCNFB[ZPIMKP\V\KGPK
[NBZBFBGZFIMPFHGNBZBFPBGZG\PKPKGMKBH
KCKQGK[MKNSGEBIEG\GCZGLFGBGSGEF[DI\G...GMN
FVGZ[PPRFVGZ[PFIKKOFRXIKKOFZGIRKKO.
łÆØØø�Ø�Æ��Æł����Ø�łÆØı,�ø�"���ªø,���łł�ø�ª��’
PXKEFKHMFFTGSYCFNIKKFTGNOFCBBVKNG
[K[DFCF,GZBGK[NBK\Z[NPPRF,BUTNVK[KCGBG
TNKG\GMI\PGSZMKPF\GIN\RGCTGNOFHFBNB
NYRG\IKKFTGNOFCB.
łÆØØø�Ø�Æ��Æł����Ø�łÆØı,�ø�"���ªø,���łł�ø�
29 NKPGEFYCNFGPJZ\G
\GTNG\KFKEGTG\,MKPNCEFKG\FBEOPXKEFKGET
B\YGRGGKGETS\ZK\GZFGJTPKFPXGG\FP\GYKO
PEC[GRGV\XGVKOB[ZPXKEOFKBP[KC\RV[,MK
FRV[PHEMM\CFOGP\CGEE\TOYGRG,DOMQKP[L
PPRFT[KK\FPXGG\M\KYGRQGCBFCFZCF,GFKB
FPNFC\BG\GNT[G\C[NKPG\,GTNHFBPZFIMO
"PKOZCKONBKGMNGNMCG\B\FBFCF".GTGEKDKT
PPRF\GTN\RPZWCTRKKQF\VKNF.
łÆØØø�Ø�Æ��Æł����Ø�łÆØı,�ø�"���ªø,���łł�ø�
GTOFYEPFHGVKZ[ZCB[MRHKMGGR\FM\GC"GKFK
EGENMNEZMKGP[MKNGF’TPG",[PK[FGB[NO
CPYZBCP[RFCBDEFGS\ZK\GZFGSVZKXKZFCTGPY
RYZBP[MKN,GMNBG\KG\F[OFPKGIEMCKMGNHYGYKQ
N[PZG.
��ª�œ���ت"�,��łºœœ’�œØ"ª
GFF[MNFFBRG[K\,M[\CGBNPZGOIGV[\F,\MKZ
B\FTZLFDEGN[K[NFZXGQ[NFBEO,CFKG\G
P\TNFBNFI[YFBNGFK,GCFKG\GEGZLCBNF
FEZMKO[PCKBKOBG\GNZGOPJZ\G.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł Ø�ØŁ�ł
30NZBG\JGC
I[KCG\F\V[JG\FYCNF
ZBFR\\KNVRKLFKGOB\FIKKOGB\FJGCGB\
FPG\GB\FZT...GCIZ\CIKKO.
ªÆłØ��’Ł"
BLGZYCF\V[JG\IMP\FYCNFCZGCTO,RHMF
NDBGNFF[NPF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł �Ø���Øłœ�æÆØłœ,�œ�’
FQFKIKEGFQFBGPF,NBK[NKPGFMGRF,[TNKF
RCZBG,HGN\CF[D\VRKPKG\F\GZFGSGEG\KF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł �Ø���Øłœ�æÆØłœ,�œ�’
NF\V[JG\DEGN[NIMP\FBP\CYZCFTOBRG
XZKMKQPYGEO,CBGVQ[RFKFZBGKONYCNF\GTN\
PP[KIXEYKRG,GNVKML\NGKOFPFF\V[JG\FIMPF
GCKB\P[KIXEYRGHFCHF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł �Ø���Øłœ�æÆØłœ,�œ�’
FZKBRGPIGKCKONYCGTPEZ[G\GNICZSVZKO,MEK
NPFZ\VGX\FIMPFCPZICKFBGPF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł �Ø���Øłœ�æÆØłœ,�œ�’
FRFRGETPVKSGVZKOGVKSVZKOB[ZNKPGEIMP\
FYCNFFGBPIGKCCFINJNMNBEOPK[ZBN,GNG
NPEBEOMNF\GZFMGNF,GCYKC["SGVGSYKOCTN
VF,DOPPGNBCPKEG\GCPT[KOJGCKOKG\ZPMNCRK
EGZGGNBNPEIMP\FYCNF,FGBPIGKCNF\DNDN
GNCBTGEVTOCTGNOFHFMEKNNPGEZHK\GZF
GIMP\FBP\,[HFGPGCBCMPFPYGPG\CPEZ[K
IH"N.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł Ø�º�
GFGBIKGCDPGZCFINJTNMNBEOPK[ZBN,NNPGE
GNFCKQZHKQEBGZKK\BGMNEZMKF[VTG\KGK\’
N\I\GRKO,[FOTKYZIMP\FBP\G[MZFR[PG\
NT\KENCB.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł Ø�º�
BKQIMPKFDGKKO,[MGNOBKROKGETKOCKXKZFPF
[KGETYJQ[CK[ZBN.G\GTN\[BZFIMPG\NFKG\
SGNONIMP\KEKT\FCGZB.
łÆØ��ø�Æ�����,�ł�Æ"�,ºœÆØł�Æ"�,���łœłœ�’œ�Ø��,��’��"�
TNBI\MPFGMPF[K[NRGNZEGUCMNNCGCMNRV[
GCMNPBEBIZIMP\FBPGRF,FGBIMP\EZL
FYCNF,[FGBEZLFBP\.
ł’Øøł��Æ��ø�ŁÆ,�Æ�ø"Ł,��Øłœ�Ø�Ø�, łøœł��
32NZBG\JGC
NZDNKFPRKTFFMNNK\[NFNPGEFZGIRKCTRKRKO
FBNFKKO,FGNLPG[DFBNGFG\GRI[L,PBKQTCGEF
[MNK\GFZD[K\PJGFZF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,�º"
FVIEFIKXGRKGFBPGRFFJCTK\GF[TCGE[N
FFMRTFR[BZKOCNCCG\ZCKOC\GZF[VT\KZG[F
PBG\QF\YGVG\,[FETFGFFZD[FFBNGFK\FK\F
PBKZFCFQCTHF,TE[FK\FZBGKFPXEDENFN[TCE
BNKFB\MNFRV[G\.GMKGQ[RYGE\F\GL[NFFMZF
FBNFK\TPGPFFKB,FZKFPFG\FBNFK\MNGNF
CFPGQ,GDOCKIKEKO[FOZBGKKONFKG\NPBKZKEZL
NFO,ZYC\GZMI\YKU[BKQNFPNJPPRGGFMZI
FGBNF[\TCEBNKG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,�º"
M[CBKONF[\TCENTCGE\BNFKOTNVRKFPXC
FZKYQFHF,[NFXKGZFBVNFPNB\FGGCFG[P\FGF
CZTKGQM[IG[CKOTNECZBNFKOCNBF[MNFGCNB
\GZF,KZBF\\BFFR\GYFPPYGZF,[FKBKZBF
TKNBF,FBEOFGNLGPBCEB\HFZTGNPGTNKEKPF
[FGBPY[ZB\TXPGNYJRG\=FPGIKQ.
BKQDBG\BNFKOP\DNFBHC\GLFRV[,MKBO
[VNG\EPKGRG\VZGTKO,FPXKKZKO\MGRF[NBKHG
PXKBG\CEGKFPJG[J[\,PEGNEN\GYXGVF,[PCFN\
B\MNPBPKQCFGPEMB\B\ZGIG,PJPJP\B\
FNCGPGRT\B\TEKRG\FRV[[NFBEOPNF\DCZ,
GTGYZ\B\FHKGFBNFK[CR[P\G.
33 I[KCG\F\V[JG\FYCNF
GBUBOKBPZMNFKGOMGNG[BPGRFHGFKBCF’
BIE,FKBPKNFZKYF[BKQFR[PFKGET\PPRFMNGO,
GMNTEKQZGIPGMZIFGBNFSKIET\GPPRF,GHB\
FKBFMVKZF[CTKYCBEP[KIBM[BHNGPKOPRKKO
FET\FBNFK\CMRS\K[ZBN=GCTGNOMGNG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,�º"
NB\GMNNTEF\GZFNFKG\PXGPXP\ZYCIYZ
FNMFFPT[K\NCEG.FINYFZGIRK[C\GZFNMN
ZGICG,TGPYGGFKYVGPGMZIDOFGBNPXGBPYGO
CK[KCF...XEIKEG[HFFGBPGMZICEGZRGFEGZ[
ZVGBFZGIRK\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,� "�Y� "Ł
EZMKOIE[KOFRRGIKKCKONSNGN,[FOFKRO
CBP\FEZMKOFKG\ZK[RKO,[CFOFNMGZCG\KRG
FZB[GRKO...GRGMNNFKG\CJGIKO[NFPSKKTCHF
KFKFPFYZGBKOFZB[GRKONYGNFT\KENVGXWCZB[K
FFZKO:"MNPK[KVTNTOBNKCGBGKJGN[MZG"
)KZG[NPK[C\,V"GF"J(.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,� "�Y� "Ł
MNBG\OFSVZKOFRVNBKOPNBKFTRKQ,[MNML
F\TPYGCFODEGNKFEGZG\CIKCGZOGFVX\O,FO
PGRIKOCYZQHGK\,BGRI[CKONSVZKJKGN,[PTKKRKO
CFOCEZLBZTK,GTKGQMHFBKRRGPCKBMNNB\\GTN\
FPCGY[FMNNKNF\MRSG\FPI[CG\,NY[GZQ,
F\KNEG\QGCRKRQ.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ªł�Ø�ł,Ł"
34NZBG\JGC
MNHB\CB\RGPVRKFKZBFFRVZHFPMNTKGQGPI[CF
CINYKF\GZFFRGDTKONNCFPZDK[GNPIFIG[C,
[XGGTNKFDEGNKFEGZG\,CKIGEFPYGCNKO.FKZBF
[CBF,FKBTXPFPPKTGJFNKPGEGFKEKTFCBKMG\F
[NPKE\FKZBFCMNN,GCF\DENFVZBCNC,FKB
P\FVM\NVNXG\GCT\FFZIGYF,GKZB\ZGPPG\
FEZMCGETNKGQ,FP\IN\PFFMZFFCZGZFTEMPF
FNKPGEKOFBNFKKOVGTNKONJGCFTNF\ZCG\
FMNNK\TEKTE,GTEMPFFOPCKBKOBGZF[N[NGF
GXEYNTGNOPPYGZ[OBNFKK[ZBN.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ªł�Ø�ł,Ł"
GBOCIMPG\IKXGRKG\FYK[KG\PGV\KG\TKGRKG\
[MNKG\JCTKG\ZVGBKG\FDKGRG\NPGEKG\FQMN,
ZB\FTKRKDZDKZBGB[MGN,VNDPNBBGJVF,NBMGN
F\GLGNHZGYFYNKVF,NFKG\BPGR\KCBNGPXG\KG
PKGVF,CRV\FBP\PSGCKF[YZPRGVF,GBOKET\K
CBP\,GTNNCKHB\FIG\P\,MKFIMPFFVRKPK\,
B[ZBKQCF\ZPK\,GPTN\FTN[BZFIMPG\
DEGNF,FKBIMP\FBP\IMP\FYCNF,FKBIMP\
RCKBKRG,GCFP\R[BKOR[KBKRG.
FKBFKBIMP\F\GZFB[ZPMNSKDJFGZF.
CFK\YZCGNBNCRKBEO,FKBHKGOFKBFEZOFKB
FGEO,FKB\BKZCPT[FCZB[K\R\KCF,FKB\DNF
IEZKPZMCO,\GEKTSGEI[PN,GMNTKGQCGCHGN\F
TPN,GCVKZG[F[PG\\DNFNRG\TNGPG\,GVNKBG\
GCXKZGUFBG\KG\RGJZKYGRG\GDPJZKBG\,B[ZPK
B[ZBNKFHMF,GN\\TNKGFKGOCZMF.
35 I[KCG\F\V[JG\FYCNF
G[BZFIMPG\BKROZY[KIG\,GBNKFFPF
V\KIG\,GBOFKBDCZ\FPF[VIG\,GEKNFOCHF
PTNF,GBIZB[ZTEFPGV\B[ZBKBV[ZNFMIK[G
PIYZFTNF,FBPRORFDRGCTXPRGCNPGEOFK\Z,
MEKNF[KCB\BVKYGZGSTG[F\GZ\KRGVNS\Z,MK
F\GZFNFGEKTRG\TNGPG\ZPG\CNKPGV\\IK[,BL
FPGV\NB\MIK[,GFBP\FCZGZ.
MKFTGHCEZMKFTGRGXZGZ,GVRKFP\ZVKO
CPXG\KFYCXGVBZGZ,NBKGTKNGFIMPG\ZYNNJG[
FPI[CFFOSCF,BLFKBCPXG\KFFKBFPCKBF
NIKKFTGNOFCB,GCHFTNMNQHGN\FPE\FPZGCF,
MFECZKFP\BCYCTVZZDNKFP[MKNKOCICF,
PT\KZNBNTKNGO,KVZG[TNKFOSGM\[NGO,MPKQCK\
PTGCF.
łÆØø���Æł��ªł��,łøÆ"ı,æ łœøÆ"ı,���Æ’æØ���"Æ
BPRONTGNONBRGMNNF\TNOPF\ZGVFFMNNK\
FMGNN\B\FMNG[THKC\FFKB[DZPFNRGB\
RVKN\RGGFGBFECZ,PF[BRKCTGRKKGCPZRV[K
ZDKNNYZGB,N[RG\GN[N[PBG\GBNVKOVTPKO,
THCRGB\R[P\F\GZFGHB\FKBFXTYFFDEGNF,
FPYV\CTGHFEGZG\ZCKO,PKPKFRCKBKO,FSGVZKO
GFIMPKO,DEGNKFEGZG\FZB[GRKOGFBIZGRKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�º"�Y�º"�
DEGNKFM[ZGQ[CRGVRGNFOCTKYZBNFXEFPT[K
[C\GZF,GDO[OZYCPYXGTG\PKGIEKO,TCEGFG
GFZDKNGFGCIKRGL,GFXEFZD[K,GKG\ZPHFFXE
36NZBG\JGC
FTKGRK,GPF[NPTNFPPRGGCBBIZKGPPKNB,FYE[K
FFGVTK,[CGFDBGNFGFK[GTFDRGHF,BG\GTHCG
NDPZK,GNDSZGIGP[GDTKI[CDOPK[CBG\GCTB\
FTNCGQFDEGNFHF,PZGTKFBGPF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�º"�Y�º"�
FYGNFDEGN[NIGYZKRGFBNFKKO,[NISKEKRG
FTNKGRKO,[NFPYGCNKOFJFGZKOCBKSGEF’,
YEG[KFPCJGBEKZKFZXGQ,IGMKK[GTFGXGVKDBGNF,
FKFNYGNYGZBCPECZ.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�º"�Y�º"�
EGYBCT\P[CZDEGNGSMRFTXGPF,XZKMKONYI\
B\FPTGNF[C\ZGVG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�º"�Y�º"�
MNF\GZF,CVKZG[KFFZGIRKKOMGNO,XZKMFFKB
NF\TNG\BXNRG.MNPK[K[BGPWCNCCG,MICTJG
GZGIF’CR[P\G,YZGBFGBNXB\BNFPTZMFGNXTGY
FCGBGZ.PIHFBIZ,NDPZKBIZ,FKKRGZGBKOCEGZRG,
BNPNKR\RECGINYZ[GOPCTNKFM[ZGQ,FPPGNBKO
C\GZFGC[MNJGC,NTCGEB\MZOF’C\GMGVRKPF,
NTSGYCJFZ\O[NPG[DKFBPGRFGFTCGEF,CCKZGZQ
[NFEKTG\CTRKRKFBNFG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�º"�Y�º"�
BRIRGFKKRGP\IKNKOCPNBM\[PKOFDEGNF[N
CKTGZZGIFJGPBFPQFBZWG[NF\IN\FGVT\\KYGQ
TGNOCPNMG\BNTGNO.GTNHFBRGR\CTKOGNHFRGXZRG.
37 I[KCG\F\V[JG\FYCNF
GCMNHPQ[BRGRGEEKO,R[IJKOGRJCIKO,MXCBG\
GMBKNKO,TNB[ZBKQBRGPMKZKOB\\VYKERG,CBKO
BR[KOYJRKOGPXGPXPKOGPZVBKOBG\RGCZVGBG\
YZG\PMNFPKRKO,GB\SOFIKKOFTKYZK,BG\G,
PRKIKOCYZQHGK\.BNFP\GLJPJGOFNCGYJRG\
BPGRF,GBNFP\GLDBGFGISZGQKEKTF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�º"�Y�º"�
MB[ZKPTJFF[MNFPCRKK[ZBNCFP[LFDNG\,
GFFYEPG\FBNFKG\K\TNPGGK[\MIGPFOKVNG
FZCFCPFPGZG\FD[PG\,GFT[G\OBNGFCTN
PYZKOG\GBZKO,GHFPVRK[S\ZK\GZFK\TNPG
PFOGNBZCKOKIMPGGNBKETGFSGEBNBB’PTKZ,
GRPXBGZCKOC[GI\FJTG\,NHFCJNGMIGGF\VNNG
TNKGMEKNFINK[Z[\G.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,��"ŁY�"�
GKETS\ZK\GZFGJTPKFPXG\...MKFRV[P\IHY\
CFOGP\CGEE\TOYGRF...GPNCEFJGCFDRGHFTGNO
FCBNP[\ENGP\IMOCFDOCTGNOFHFJGTOJTO
TGNOFCB...GCHMG\FTGSYKOKCBP[KIMKBH
\PNBFBZWETFCSC\GB[ZHF\FKFSCFYZGCF
NCKB\G.
łÆØØø�Ø�Æ��Æł����Ø�łÆØı,�ø�"���ªø,���łł�ø�,ª��’
[PTCYGNKBKTXLGKFKBNYKOTPLBN\PRTC[CKN
FVIENMRGSCTSYFIMPFMKPFRV[IKG\LB[Z
38NZBG\JGC
B\FCTGNOBOISG[NGOBKQCLIMPFGPETBKQ
IKKLIKKOGFM\GCBGPZZBFR\\KNVRKLB\FIKKO
GCIZ\CIKKOGFDTTXPLBOBK[KTPKETNKLNPGRTL
PIKKOISG[NGO\TPGETPGNPNIPF...
GNFKVLGMNB[ZNBK[K\QCTERV[GGKYNGCTKRKG
MNFVTGNG\GBKXJEYBG\[CTGNONTCGZCKOGNTNG\
N[PKOTE[KMRKTB\FTGPEMRDEGGZGXFNPRTGPQ
FIKKOGYNGIGPZPFRBPZCIKKOFRXIKKOFRYZBKO
IKKO.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,æł�ł�,�’
IKEG[NKTNFTKZVZBD[FKBPYGONGPEKO,G\GZF
CKQCTKERBETSKYCFGCKQCTKERBENBTSKYCF
PDRBGPXNB)\ZDGO:G\GZFPDKRFGPXKNFCKQCHPQ
[FBEOTGSYCFGCKQCHPQ[FBEOBKRGTGSYCF(,
GBKLKGZE\[OFKFEG\PKGONKGOBIGZRK\.
BMQFTRKQFGBEPYGEOFKFEKC\GZFFRDNK\,
BCNT\FCTYC\BEP[KIB,XZKLNFKG\DO\GZ\
FRS\Z,MPG[BRGZGBKORZEGNY,GYGEO[MCFFGB
P\IHYCKG\ZG[NFC\GTGNFKG\Z,MPGMQPYGEO
NBFKFFKXZFZTP\DCZMNML,GFKFEKC\GZF
CRDNFN\CNKQNRDEG,BCNT\FYGEOFDBGNFFKXZ
FZTP\DCZKG\ZGXZKMKONF\IHYDOCRS\Z.
łÆØø���Æ�Ø�� øØæ��,œłœø�����’�"�
IKKCKONET\BG\F,MKPXGGFFKBTNKRG:"GKET\
FKGOGF[CG\BNNCCL,MKF’FGBFBNGYKO".FZK
39 I[KCG\F\V[JG\FYCNF
[IKKCKOBRIRGNKETCKEKTFGNBCBPGRFCNCE,BNB
CECZKOFP\KK[CKOTNFNC.
�łÆ�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,æ ł����œ�ø�,º��Ø�,��’ø�"Ł
MNIMP\FYCNFFKBZYNET\FRFD\G[NFZXGQ
FTNKGQ,TNPFCZBMNFCZKG\FBNF?GPFFGBZGXF
CFO?GPFKFKFSGUMNSKCGCKFTGNO?GBKLP\VZ[KO
MNFDNDGNKOFBNFB[ZNTGNO,[FOMNMLHZKO,MK
MCZ[KTZFZXGQFTNKGQCTXPGSKCGCFRFDFHB\
FDGPZ\C[NPG\DPGZ.GBNFF[KTGZKOFOPF[BRG
PVZ[KOCSGEFSVKZG\GFTGNPG\.
�łÆ�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,ª�œœÆ�œ��’21
40NZBG\JGC
FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
[\KOZTG\T[FTPK,B\KTHCGPYGZPKOIKKO
NIXCNFOCBZ\R[CZKOB[ZNBKMNGFPKO.
Øł�Ø�Æ’Ø"�
ZBK\KTCEKOTNSGSKO,G[ZKOFGNMKOMTCEKOTN
FBZW.
���œØ’�’
MNDEGNKFYCNFVFBIEXGTYKO,MMZGMKF,[MN
HPQ[PSNYKOPBGZKK\BB\ZHKFGBKROTGSYKO
CSGEG\KF,PIZKCKOB\FTGNO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,ł�"�
ZBGK[RETBOFPMIK[TRKQPXKBG\FSVKZG\KYZB
MGVZBONBG.GRBPZMKJTG\FBEOCTRKQHFKFKF
CBIEP[RKVRKO,FVQFBIEPK[NBKETCFOMNN
NBPXE[BOK\DNGNG\TNGPG\IMPFKMIK[OIS
G[NGOBNBPXE[NBFGZDNCFOGNBR\DNGNG[TZK
BGZF,FBK[FHFGEBK[NBKYZBMGVZGNBPMIK[.
BCNFPMKZB\CGZBG[RDNGNG[TZKFFYEPG\
CSKNGYFD[PG\GBKRGPGEFCBP\GPTKHVRKGGBGPZ
[FBNGFFGBD[O,HFGEBKKYZBPKQ.
FVQF[RKFOBG\OB[ZRDNGBNKFOTRKQ
FSVKZG\GPXKBG\O,GKMIK[GOPVRKZGT\MGR\OMK
FGZDNGCIMPG\IKXGRKG\GCKNEKRMZKOKSVKYG,GBNG
BONBKYZBGMGVZKOBGPKRKOPVB\MKFOPBPKRKO
CMNTRKRKFBNFG\,TOMNHFKYZBGMGVZKOPVRK
[FOPMIK[KO\GZF[CTNVF.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�Ł"Y�Ł"�
TNHFFEZLKGMZI[FBGPZ[BKQNGTSYCYCNF
GBKRGZGXFNMGKQC\VKN\GBNBNCTNFBGZG\MB[Z
I[CGZCKOGEBK[KYZBJGTF.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�Ł"�
ZCKOI[CGMKBKQZBGKNFIHKYCSGEKG\ZPEBK
PVRK[\[\MI\GZ\FPT[FEFKKRGFBSGZGFPG\Z
FVSGNGFM[ZPK[ZBN,GISG[NGO\GZFHGPF\FB
TNKFBOFKKRGMGNRGPKKIEKOCSGEG\F\GZF...
BPROFPGBSKOCFBKROCMNNTCEKF’.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,��"Æ
ZBKRGFP\ZIYKOPIMPFHGP\INYKON[NG[F
INYKO,FINYFBIEFOBG\O[K\ZIYGPPRF
NBPZOMKBKQFMZINFBPKQCRTNOF\GZFNSCG\
ZCG\.BONI[COFECZKOCV[GJQ,GCRTNOBKQ
NFOIVWMKPKKMZKIONFBPKQCT[ZSVKZG\,
G[BZINYKOB[ZNIMPFHG,GBKQZXGRONFBPKQ
BNBCBIEG\FRVNB,GM[BLKDKTOYX\PIMPFHG
GPFDOC[PTOBKQSGUGXGZ\F\GZF,KVTZGVKFO
NCNKIYNEGVKFP[MKNKO,GMPTJKFKGCTKRKFO
MMGVZKO...
GK[M\[RK\,[K\ZIYGPQFIMPFFHB\
GK[\\VGNFOJTRG\ZCG\,GMGNOPSMKPKOCDGEN
42NZBG\JGC
PTN\FIMPF,K[[BPZ[FKBIMPFR[DCF,GBKQ
FMNZBGKONFMRSBNKFTE[KEPFCET\GNFTRK[
NRG[BKOGNRG\RKOCF,CBPZG[FGBPYRBYRB\F’
XCBG\,GYRB\\GZ\G,CZBG\GMK[NIGKEOCPYGO
DCGF,NTSGYCBNFG\...
GK[M\[NK[K\[K\ZIYGPQFIMPFFHB\
NBPZOMKYZGCBEONJTG\CECZKOBNF,GBV[Z
NCBNKEKIJBGNKVGNCBIEPQFJTGKG\FRGDTKO
CPYGODCGF,GFRFFM\FHB\MGR\OZXGKFGPT[KFO
BKROZXGKKO...DOBONBKPXBFBEOPK[KNPENG
MZBGK,[NBPVRKHFKPRTTXPGPTSYF\GZF,[SGU
SGU[MZNKPGECKEG,GCHFKHMFBNFBP\.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�Ø"�Y��"Æ
NBKIVWMSKNC\CGRFMKBOCF\DNG\NCG,[RP[L
BIZK[MZGQFTGNOF[VN.GPPTJCF[MN\F\GZF,
PNF\TSYCSGEG\KFFRTNPKO,PVRK[XZKLNHF
"\CGRF"NFCKQECZP\GLECZ.GFMSKNBKRGIVW
NTPGNCMEKNFCKQ,BNB"CF\DNG\NCG"MNGPZ:
ECZKOFRDNKONTKRKMN,[BKRGXZKLNTPGNCMEK
NF[KDO.GNVKET\GFYXZFIG[CFGBMKFGBKCKRO,
GBUMKBNKCBEBP\DOHFFGBNBP[KD.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,�ł��łÆ, "�
FBZM\KCHFNFGXKBPNCFJGTKOFBGPZKO[BKQ
NVNVNCIMPFFHB\GNBNIE[CFECZ,GR\NGCHF
[PXBGCHGFZVZ[\CZB[K\TGR[FPIE[CIMPF
FHB\PF[NBYKCN.
43 FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
GJTGCFCR\FECZ,BPRONVNVNCZB[KVZYKO
GNIE[P\GMOFYEPFPGZMC\TNZB[KVZYKO
FKEGTKO,FQFQFECZKOFI[GCKONVRKFCGZB.[BO
NB\BPZMQ,BOMQPF[MZFTGSYCFBGC[BZ
F\GZFGPFTRKKQBGPZOBVKNGPF[\NPKEG\KY
T\KENIE[CFBONBR\QZ[G\NF\TSYBNBCPF
[NPE.�ł��º�����ł,Æø��ł�"�
TKYZFDBGNFFGBPZHKEBGZKK\B,MKBG"ZCDKPJZKF
Z"H,GHFRYZBM"QCDKPJZKFSG"EPKSG"E.GHF
[M\GCCPEZ[,BRKBPZ\KKFKMQ,GFZ[TKOBGPZKO
NBMQ,[FOBGPZKO[BKQC\GZFBNBFV[J,TN
M"QNBYKKPG.GTKYZFKBIMP\F\GZFGZHKF[K\DNF
NRG.�łØøł����œØ��Ø���łœØ���"Yª��"�
TNFEGZ[NRGRBPZP[GETRKKODGVKKFGQT\FBYGO,
CHMG\BPZG\F’FPHGYYG\[CT\KKO,BLF’K[PZRG
PFZ[TKOB[ZSCKCK\FNMGQGBKROZGXKOCZHK
GCSGEG\F\GZF,[FOMZGOHNG\,ECZKOFTGPEKO
CZGPG[NTGNOGFYC"FKZGPO.
�łØøł����œØ��Ø���łœØ���"Yª��"�
KEGTGPVGZSOFGBDGENFIKGCFPGJNTNFBEO
NNPGEIMP\FBP\[FKBIMP\FYCNFGS\ZK
F\GZFMPCGBZCSVZKOYEPGRKO...G\PF\KTNBR[K
EGZRG[FXRGTKO[CFOPG[MKQKEKFOPNNPGEIMP\
FBP\.ł’ÆłŒÆ��Æł����æÆ,��ª��ƪ�,ª��’
44NZBG\JGC
ZBK\KCSVZKPYGCNKOZCKOFZCFDGENFTGR[
FTXGOGFPZTNPK[PRTB\TXPGPNNPGEIMP\
FYCNFGTGXOF[MZGFTGRDCTGNOFCBNPK[NGPEF.
ł’ÆłŒÆ��Æł����æÆ,��ª��ƪ�
GBRK\PF\KTNCTNKFC\KOFM[ZKONPFK[RGMN
FNKNFGKCNGKPKFOCFCNNPFNBKTPEGCB[PGZ\
NGPZ\FKNKOCIXG\MVKMIO,GBIZMLKNMGNF\VNN
PNFCPNFCMGGR\FNCMNIEMVGO[KTGZEKNKF,GBO
FGBCZFMKNNPGETNMNVRKOP[RKG\NPFKPRTTXPG
PHFGNGPZBKHFEVKQPQFHGFZFYEG[MKMNEKCGZKO
BNGFOYK[GJKFRV[IKKONRV[G.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,æ ł�Ø�ª�Æ��ª��,ªÆłØ�ª��"
GPMBQ\CKQB\FKC[G\GFI[MG\[PXBRGCEGZRG
HF,[NBR[PTMPGFQCMNFEGZG\[YEPGNRG,[FGB
P[GO[BVKNGTGCEKF’[PJGKEKFOPFTSYCSGEG\
F\GZF.�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł���ł,�œ�"�
BCNBOISG[NGONFKVL,[FBEOPK[ZBN,P[VKN
PTN\VRKPKG\F\GZFGSGEG\KF,FERFCEZMK
R[PG\KRGGPEZDG\KFQ,GMQCINYF[MNGJTPKPXGF,
MNVKPTN\IKXGRKG\F\GZFFERFCINYFPT[F
CNCE.GBVKNGBOTGSYVTOCVRKPKG\F\GZF,FZK
FGBPYXKCNF[TFPGTJ\PHPRG,C[TF[NBKGO
GNBNKNF,MPG[FK\FISG[NGO,ECZ[BKQXGZLCG,
FGBRPXBDGZOCHF,NF[VKNGNFGZKEPJFPJF
45 FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
B\VRKPKG\FTGNO,[FOCRKK[ZBN,GNFDCKZB\
IKXGRKG\FTGNOTNKFO,[FOBGPG\FTGNO,GK[VKNG
GKCHGB\CRKK[ZBNMPG[FKGECZPKG\ZCTGNO,GBKQ
NTGNOIVWCFOISG[NGO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł���ł,�œæ"Ł
FOTG[KOMNFIGZCRG\GF[IKJG\FBKGPKO,[CRK
EGZKRGFKGTEKZBKFNFO,F[OK[PZRGPMBQ
GBKNL...GMNKZKE\O[NCRKK[ZBN,FOPIP\[THCG
B\VRKPKG\F\GZF,GF[VKNGPTN\FPJFPJF,
GT[GBG\FMPGFK\FISG[NGOECZ[BKQXGZLCG
MNN.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł���ł,�œæ"Ł
BGKNFONBG\OBR[KOFDGZPKO,[ZGIG[NP[KI
KS\NYGKNLNGPQFTGNO,GNBKGMNN[GCNTGNO,
[FPFFOFTG[KOB\F\GZFNKC[F,MNGPZCNK
P[FGNINGIK\[N[MNGET\,MKPXJPXPKOZY
CINYFPT[K[NF\GZF,GBKROZGXKONF[\EN
NFCKQCIMP\FYCNF,NKETGNF[MKNCSGEG\F\GZF
GJTPKPXGF.BGKNFO,[FODGZPKOCPT[KFOFNNG,
[KFKGTRKG\GIZCGIPSGCKHFGFZKDG\GF[PEG\
CTGNO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł���ł,�œ�’
GIH"NBPZG,[F\GZFFYEG[FPYGRR\NVRKFYC"F:
"T[BGRKCRKL[KZCC\KP[YBG\".GFPFBVKNGEPG\
[KZBKROTG[KOPF\GZF,ZYEKCGZKOPCFKNKONMN
46NZBG\JGC
[GPTGMEKCHKGQGYXU.GTGEPCY[KO[MZMVRIS
CBPZO,[CBPGRF[NKPFFPFTG[KO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł Ø�º�
GTNKFOFM\GCBGPZ:"KTQRD[FTOFHFCVKG
GC[V\KGMCEGRKGNCGZIYFKPRK"[HGFKSC\FIGZCQ
ECK\ZB[GQ.GTEKKQF[JQPZYECKRRGEGYBCTYC\B
EP[KIB,[FGBHPQ\MNFEZHKQEBGZKK\B.GYRB\
F’XCBG\CBFMB[CTXPKNB\MCF.B[ZPSC\F
R\FG\FCYZCKF\TGZZG\NDNG\B\F[PNFC[KTGZ
MHF,B[ZKETG[K[IMPFCK[ZBN.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł Ø�º�
FRFTOCRKK[ZBNRINYKOND’M\G\:
=M\B’PFO,FOTOFBZWFPGQFTO.
=M\C’,FOF\NPKEKIMPKOFTGSYKOCV[JK
F\GZF.
=M\D’,GFKBCTNKIMP\FBP\.
GFRFMRDEM\B’BPZ:MKBGKNTPK,BG\KNB
KETG.FOFPGQFTO,FRYZBKOTOS\O.
GMRDEM\FD’,FOFTGSYKOCZHKF\GZFGSGEG\KF,
FRYZBKOCRKO...
GMRDEM\IMPKFV[J,BG\OB[ZFOPGBSKO
NTSGYCIMP\FBP\,GBGPZKO[BKQC\GZFBNB
FV[JCNCEISG[NGO,TNKFOBPZG,IMPKOFPF
47 FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
NFZT,GNFKJKCNBKETG,G\YNG\ZCG\KGXBG\P\I\
KEKFO.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,Ł’YØ’
MRDEM\FB’BPZ,ZBK\KB\FBZWGFRF\FG...
GPIHKZKOFTGNON\FGGCFG,B[ZNSKCFHGYZBO
NPTNFBGKNKO,CBGPZGMKBGKNTPK,MKBKQNLBKGN\
DEGNFPHGNYKKOB\DGVOGNFIZKCB\R[P\O...
GMRDEM\FC’FOF\NPKEKIMPKO,FTGSYKO
C\GZ\F’...BKQNFOBGZC\GZ\O,MPG[M\GC
NPTNFC[OIH"N,TNFVSGY"CPI[MKOFG[KCRK",
HF\NPGECCNK.
GIMP\SVZFHFZFKBFPBKZFBG\O,GPCBZ\
FECZKOFRBPZKOC\NPGE.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,Ł’YØ’
GCNKSVYMKFTGSYKOC\NPGECCNKCNCE,PD[[KO
MTGZKOYKZ,CNCG[KF\GZF,GBKQNFOTKRKOZGBG\
CZHKF\GZFFRS\ZKOCG.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,Ł’YØ’
BGKNFONCZKG\PTNCGRF[N\GZF.MKCNKSVY
CFKG\OTGSYKOCV[JKFGCSKVGZKFNCEO,FKB
NGC[\CDEKBNPRG\F,G[YFG[\MSG\F,GMN
FBGPG\KBPZGNK[ZBN,PFEGELPEGE,PF\GZ\MO
P\GZ\KRG,FNBDO\GZ\MOSKVGZKOCFCNKFTGNO,
48NZBG\JGC
BKQTNCGQ\GZFDEGNPHF.GNMQBGKNFONCZKG\
PTNCGRF[N\GZF.GBKROTGSYKOCIMP\FYCNF,
[FKBRG\R\MCGEN\GZF,MKFOPBZKMKOFDNG\,GMN
FZTG\FP\ZD[G\NCBCTGNO.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,Ø"�YØ"Æ
GPFKT[GFV\BKOFK\G[KOB[ZCHPRKRGHF,
CFKG\OIMPKO[PIKOCINYOG[[KOCTCGE\O,
GBKROKGETKOMKPKZB\ONKMRSCFFORPRTKO
PNF\TSYCFMRHMZ,GTNMQDCTG\BNGR\YNYNG,
GNKCO[GZ[VGZFZB[GNTRF,GTN\FCFOINGE\
JKJGZV[,NMVGZCIMP\FBP\,GBGPZKO[BKQ
C\GZFBNBV[JKFGNCG[KFCNCE,GBKQSVYMKNB
KFKFNFOINYCTGNOFCB,GTNKFORBPZ"FRFTCEK
KBMNGGB\O\ZTCG".
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,Ø"�YØ"Æ
CFKG\GTGSYCIMP\FP[RFGF\NPGECCNKGNBK\Q
INYDOBNSGEG\F\GZFGS\ZKFMKFZKHFEGPF
NDGUFKG[CCIG[LCN\KR[P\BEORZFGK"FFPBKZF
C\GMF,CBGVQ[FDGUKC[CN\K[GBUPPYGZIKKO
B[ZHFGTRKQBGPZGCPYGOBIZFFGBFRHMZNTKN
GHFN[GRG:EBNKQBKRGQETCETNBGZKK\BKC[FGNB
CTBQNB[\ENBCIMP\FYCNF.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"���ø�ł���ª�œª�Æ’
49 FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
F\NPKEKIMPKOFTGSYKOC\GZFN[PFGNBN[PG
NT[G\NG[O,XZKL[KTSGYC\IKNFCIMP\FPYZB
GFP[RFGF\NPGEMVKPF[KGMN[MNGNSCGN,GBIZMN
KTSGYNET\B\YGRGCIMP\FBP\GMPG[XGFEGE
FPNLTNKGF[NGOB\[NPFCRG"ETB\BNY"KBCKL
GTCEFG",GBOFBK[FHFKFKFMCEGY[FCTRKQFTKGQ
C\NPGEPGJCNG[KRKIB\KEGPPRGBIZ[CIQPHNG
CIMPFHB\GKTSGYCIMP\FBP\,GHFG[BPZG:MN
\NPKEIMO[BKRGZGBFSKPQKVFC\NPGECIP[\
[RKO[GCBKRGZGBF.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"���ø�ł���ª�œª�Æ’
GBUDOHB\CEGZFHFFBIZGQNBPBSRGGNBDTNRG
NFVZCZK\GB\RGISG[NGO,GMPG[BPZGC\YGRKO:
ECEZBC\ZBFCSGUKGPKBK\VZRSGQPFBKICGZB
GCDKRKFGYZB\OEZGZCBZWGDGPZMR"NDOCSVZ
FHGFZVZ[\GKZB)EUYK"I(GHFN[GRGGMEKFBYZKC
NKGPKP[KIBBVKNGFRKZCKKETNPBHPKRKQNB[MIB
ZHKQJPKZKQEIMP\BGMG’.
FZKPCGBZMKTET\FFKGECZKIMP\FHGFZ
RTNP\GCEZBC\ZBF\\DNFG\\VZSOIMPFFHB\
GKCKRGGK[MKNGCZHKF\GZF[NBF[KDGFYGEPKOBNKRG
GCHFRS\NYFF[D\FV\BKOFPY[KOGBGPZKO
BKM[GZEZKBOEGZG\[NVRKRGNBFK[KDGFBKLRETRF
BRIRG,GCHFKSMZVKFO.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"���ø�ł���ª�œª��"ª
50NZBG\JGC
FRFR\CBZMPFPTNG\JGCG\NBEOF[NOTNMN
FRPXBKOMNO.GK\CBZPHFFFVLFBIZ,MKCFKG\
FBEOIGJB,MCZFIJKBFMGGRFCCZKB\G,GNBEK
[NBKYZB[NO,BCNFGBVIG\PMNFRCZBKO,GBVKNG
PFCFPG\GFIKG\FJGZVG\,GMPG[M\CFZPC"O
H"N,MKMNPK[NBFDKTBNF[NP\FXGZFFBRG[K\
NBKYZBBK[.
BCNCFPFTNXGZ\BK[,MKK[NGKMGN\TNPKRK
FFKHYGIKEG[FZTG\,PF[BKQN[BZCTNKIKKO,MK
F[MNGFPI[CFB[ZFKGPGMRKONF[D\F[NKPG\,
K[\P[CFONMNPKRKF\ICGNG\NFGNKEFRHYKO,
GBOMQBKVGBFGBVIG\PFCFPF.
�łÆø���Æ��ÆØ�,ºœ� �,�ª�œº�Øœº�œ�ÆłØ��
GPMBQ\[GCFNSMNKOFP\IMPKO,GIMP\PFNFO,
FVGTZKOVKFORDEFTGSYKOCIMP\FYCNF,
FBGPZKOTNKFO,MKYGNECZKOFO[GPTKO,G\PGRF
BKROZGBKO,BGKNFOGNZGTPHNOTNSMNG\O
GFGNNG\O,MKNBKZGKIGPHF,ZY[FOPRKBKOB\
TOF’PTNG\NFZYGE[G,[FZKDOPNBMKPTNFKDTKO
GBKROP[KDKOTXOFMCGE,GPZGC\[GY\OP\BPXKO
NTNG\NVRKOPPIKX\O,GFRO[GBDKOTNEZLBGPZG,
CBFC\F\[DF\PKEGNBN[DDFKI[CNFO.
BU[GMRKC\KIGPZ,B[ZCTVZKSGEO,NBKI[C
NFO\[GY\ON[DDF,ZYN[CIGDEGNFGMCGE,MK
F\GTFCEZL,GMGGR\GNCY[B\CK\FPNL,GFGBPIHZ
INKNF,NET\BKHFFEZLK[MGQ,NXEYF\I[CNG,
51 FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
GVZSPB\FPNLKYCNTNJZIG.GHFGFBP\,GPF
[BKQCGSVY.
�łÆø���Æ��ÆØ�,ºœ� �,ŁÆł���º��Æ�ª�
GFEGCZKOT\YTNFTGSYKOCSVZKFYCNFCDBGF
GCGH,T\KEKQNK\QB\FEKQ,MK\BNPRF[V\KFOCHF
GCCB,MKKSMZVKEGCZK[YZFP\FNNKOCBNKNKO
PT[FKEKBEO,CPGV\KOFPGZD[KO,MVKFRDNF
NSRGKZKTKRKFO,GB\VGTNF’FZGIRKNBKCKJG,MKFGB
R[PFNPGZD[,GEKNFOSMNG\ONTGR[RV[O.
�łÆø���Æ��ÆØ�,ºœ� �,ŁÆł���º��Æ�ª�
RHZF\GZFFKBIMP\FYCNFB[ZZGCFTGNO
VGZ[KOPPRFCBPZOCPF[FGZ[K\F\CGRQGBKQNL
TSYCRS\ZG\B\F[NIRBKELGBIGHCHFBOB\F
PSGDNN\GZFFHB\GPRFNB\HGTMKPK[NBJTO
JTOIMPFHGNBZBFPBGZG\PKPKGGFGNLCIG[L
GBGKNFONCZKG\PTNCGRF[NF\GZFFHB\.
ł’ ��æ��Ø�Æ���Øł,æ ł�ÆłØœ,���Æ’���łØÆ’ ł��’
GNCBZDGENFTGQ[NBG\QFBR[KOFDGZPKOPRKTF
NBG\OFZGXKONNPGEIMP\FYCNFCSCZG\
JTRG\KFQFPHGKKVKO...GFPM[NFFHB\BKRRF\I\
KEFFPGQCNCEBLKEFSDRKOGFIMPKOP\IMPKO
CET\OCPZEGCPTNFHB\GNBHGCNCE[PGBSKO
CKEKT\FBNFG"\BNBBUHGF\IKNGNCHG\GNDRG\
FIMPFFHGCIG[LKNMGGCIG[L[POKMGSFTN
52NZBG\JGC
[VTZGVKFOGBPZG:KERGZPFCRDNFPFNRGNIMPF
FHB\EKNRGCV[GJKF\GZF.
ł’ ��æ��Ø�Æ���Øł,æ ł�ÆłØœ,���Æ’���łØ"Æ ł��’
GPK[NBTSYCIMP\FBP\GNBZXFNNPGEBG\F
C[TF[R[P\GZGXFNTNG\CDQTEQEGIKQBG\FP[O
CCHKGQ.
ł’ ��æ��Ø�Æ���Øł,æ ł�ÆłØœ,���Æ’���łØ"Æ ł��’
GBN\VQNYI\ZBKFPDEGNKF\GZFCTNKFRDNG\
[NBZGXKONTSGYCIMPFHGMKECZKIMPKRGHMZGRO
NCZMFCPEZ[GCHGFZRBPRKOKG\ZPDEGNKFEGZ
FHF.
ł’ ��æ��Ø�Æ���Øł,æ ł�ÆłØœ,���Æ’���łØ"Æ ł��’
MNFPGRTGIG[LTXPGPNKPGEFYCNFFGBREIF
PPIKX\XEKYKOGPVSKETGNPGGBKRGHGMFNZBG\
CBGZVRKPNLIKKOK\CZL.
�łÆØæ���Ø��łł�� �ª,�œØ�Øł,æØ��ł"Ø
FKBF\ZGVFFMGNN\B\FMN,G[THKC\FFKB
[DZPFB\RVKN\RGGFKBFECZB[ZBRKCTGRKKGCPZ
RV[KZDKNN[RG\N[N[PBG\GBNVKOVTPKO.THCRG
B\VRKPKG\F\GZF...
53 FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
CBKOBR[KOYJRKOGPXGPXPKOGPZVBKOBG\RG
CZVGBG\YZG\PMNFPKRKOGB\SOFIKKOFTKYZK
PRKIKOCYZQHGK\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��"łœ "�
NBRCFNMNNPFPVIKEKOBG\RGP\TGV\FPI[CF,
FBGPZKO[BRGP\BPZKONTNG\PZGPK[IYKOCBKQ
SGNO.NBMQ,K[NRGSGNOPGXCBZXFGZB[GPDKT
F[PKPF:FPBGZ[CR[P\RG,CR[P\FMNNGCR[P\
FVZJ,B[ZK\TGZZKVFTNKEKBGZDRHK\GZF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,æ’Yæ"�
FPFFOFTG[KOF\GZFKC[F,[BKROIVXKO
NF[\ENCIMP\FYCNF,BGKNFO[DGZPKOCHF
TRKG\GIZCGCKHFGFZDGBGCEQNTGNO.
łÆØø���ÆłØ��Ø,œØ��Ø���ł,œØ���’
MNBIEPF[PNPEKQBG\GCCJQBPGMQK[KMGN\
CKEGNF[KD.GPK[FKFKMGNNF[KDSGEG\F\GZFGFGB
NBK[\ENNF[KDQ=RKEGQCEKRKQY[KQ.
����ł’��Ø��Ø���,��ł"�,�Æ�ø������º"ª
TNBG\OISKEKO[K[CFOFZCFZT[RG\BLNB
TPYG\GZD[,FKFBGPZ[FOBZGCG\CNKC\KO:PTNK
T[QNNBB[.
�łÆØ������ª����
CBKQPJZFNIKKO=FPGG\PGMZINFKG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,ø "�
54NZBG\JGC
F[KYGTCBVZFIGPZKG\ZYPDEKNB\FPGG\,PBIZ
[FBEO[YGTMGNGCECZKO[FPGG\[GNJCFO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,ø "Æ
GMNHPQ[FBGZ\GEGYSKFBGPZ\,CTY[RG\EGYB,
NB,ZYDPZFGVGSYKONCEO,NBBDEFGNBPGSZ,
NBYCNFGNBPIYZ,FZKPENEN\B\TXPFGMN
FBPXTKO[FKBNGYI\CKEF,NFDQTNTXPF,
PCNKNYI\B\SO=FIKKOFBPK\K,BGZF\GZF
CVRKPKG\F,FONFNBNTHZGNBNFGTKNGFKB
P\PNBFCYXU...IGWPFECZFDNGKGPGI[,FRDNF
[C\GZFGPXGG\NCE,[BKRGKMGNC[GOBGVQNCGB
GNFCKBNPJZ\G,CMNFEGZG\GCKG\ZCEGZRG,MK
BOCKIETOF\ZICG\O[N[GZ[KGFPZGCKO
FZGIRKKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,ł�"ÆYł�"�
GBPROCF[BZFIMPFMLTZGPF,ECZKOS\GPKO
CNKFCRF,RGNEPHFZTFBIZ\=[IMPKODEGNKO
THCGFCYZQHGGK\,MKPJCTFIMPKONCY[FCRF
PKG[C\,GNET\FECZKOCTPYO,GNBNF\ZXG\
CPKNKQCTNPB.GCZBG\O[BKQCECZKOFBNFPF
[KPNB\BGG\O,BPZGNPFRCNFHPRRGCPF[BK
BV[ZNRGNF[KD.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,ø�łØł��"�,��ª������ł�غ�,��’�"�
GBIZKOFZTGKG\Z,MKNBEK[PBSGCF,BNB[ECZG
TNKFSZF,CI[GCBG\FMV\KG\[YCNGTNKFOCRK
55 FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
BEONF\YTCECZKODSKOGCN\KP\YCNKO.GTGEFDKTG
NMVGZCTKYZKF,GN[NGNFKG\FHFZFYEG[PIGCZ
PZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKH"NGICZKG.GMNHFPFKG\ECZK
FIMPKOHZKOCTKRKFO,TE[BKQZBGKNFONF\KISBN
BK\RKOPGSEKBZW=F\RBKOH"N.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,ø�łØł��"�,��ª������ł�غ�,��’�"�
HFGFJTO[ZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKXGGIMNMLTNHF,
GYGZBNTGSYKOCV[JF\GZF,[FOK[RKOC\ZEPF,
MKBKROVGYIKOTKRKFOMNNNZBG\CBFCF[FYC"F
BGFCBG\O,MBKNGFOISG[NGOMVGKKJGCFBNKG.
GTGE,[BKROZGBKOGBKROKGETKOEZLFYEG[FMNN,
GB\FECYG\CGK\CZL.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,���ł�غ�,��’"�
GFRFHFVZKFDNG\CTGGRG\KRGFZCKO,[[MIGK[ZBN
B\FEZLFHF,GR[BZGK[RKO,P[GYTKOC\ZEP\O,
GBKQ[PKONCCNHB\.BCN\GZFIGDZ\[YTNXZ\F.
GFRFBRIRGCPI[MKOMP\KTGNO,MTGZKOPP[
FPD[[KOYKZ.NK[ZKONBRBGFNNM\CEZLFHF,
BNBBEZCBNVYGITKRKKOTKGGZG\,GNZBG\BFC\F’,
GNET\FYEG[FGEZMKF,NF\YE[CFPP[.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,���ł�غ�,��’"�
BCNK[I[LBIE[PI[KLTKRKCRKBEO,N[YT
BG\OCECZKFJCT.GBHBKROPMKZKOTGE[FYC"F
FGBFPRFKDFTNKGQ,FPSCCB\FMN,BNBFMNRG\RKO
NPHN.GSGEHF)K[TKFSF,KB(FTGZMKONDE[NIQ.TO
56NZBG\JGC
MNHFCGRKOMNPI[CG\KFOGMNP[VJKFO,FMNTN
VKFJCT.GDOMPFIMPG\IKXGRKG\RPXBG,MNOCSGE
FJCTFHF,GMGNOP[YTKOCRKFTGNOCSCZG\BNF.
GCHFR\ZIYGPKEKT\FFRFDFFVRKPK\.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’œ�"Ł
GNHFFDKTGFECZKOCEGZG\FBIZGRKO,[R[\MIF
F\GZFPK[ZBN,GBKQPCKQTGEFFRFDFTNKG[ZF,
BNBFGNMKOFMNBIZFCXT.GBVKNG[NBKIJBG
IJBKOPP[,BLTRKKROMCFPG\C[EFFRG[BKO
P[BO.GMNNMNHFFGBFI[L[BKRGPRKINZBG\
[Z[FFRFDFFKMQFGB.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’œ�"Ł
YCNRGPZCRGFDEGNFDZ"BH"N,[INKNFNGPZ[FSGE
FBPK\KKS\GZFEKQFPGSMONFNMFVSGYF,ZY
[FBIZGRKONBKZEGNTGPYFIMPFFHB\.
��ØØœ��Ø�����ł"�
BYGF[[GOBEONBKI[ERKCPKTGJBFCF,INKNF,
N\GZFFPT[K\,NF\PE\NKPGEFGNFZIC\FCVNVGN
GSCZB,CIZKVG\GCYKBG\.BCNCT\[FECZCBTE
NKEKFVZ\\GZ\BP\,\GZFENTKNB,TENMEKFETM\
R[P\FR[PF,TEMEKFIN[\MIFPI[CF,GTEMEK
FCB\PTPEFIKKOFZGIRKKO[NRGG[NMNFTGNO
MGNG,F\NGKCRG,NPXC[NVZVGZGTKNGURGZB...
GBOKCGBBIEGKBPZ,[K[GT\RGPGRI\FKB
CR[P\F[N\GZF,CFDEN\FGFBEZ\FFTNKGRF
GFBPK\K\,KCGBGMNFJGTRKOPTCZKOGKPJKZGTNKL
57 FP\RDEKONNKPGEFYCNF
PCGN[NF[DG\:PFB\FIVWCYCNF,CPGSZ,
CIYKZF,CVKNGSGVKF,CEZ[RG\,CSVZG\,C[KZF?
FNBMNBNFV[JGB\FZDNGNBR\RGNRGB\PF
[FCJKIGCT\[F\IKNF\SKS\O,GJTRG\MBNF
PSVKYG\MCZNFIRKYB\YGNF’,FYGZBCRGPYZC
PTPYKR[P\RGGPPNBFTGNPKOMGNO:"EZ[GRK
GIKG",CT\MHB\BRGIKKCKONFVDKQTNFDEGN
[CISZGRG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�º"�Y�º"�
GKKXZF’BNYKOPQFBEPFMNIK\F[EFGMNTGU
F[PKO,GGKNTNPBEBKRGQBJKPKNCBGS\KPKENB
PS\MNKQCZHKEBGZKK\BGNBKETKQEGGEBKIK\F[EF
GTGUF[PKOBKRGQTPKFBZWGBVKNGCBNKQEBKRGQ
RV[IKFNBB[\MITHZCFGQN[MKR\BCDNG\BGNB
NP[FEBKRGTPF.TEMBQN[GQFHGFZ.
BKRQTPKFBZWCSVZBGZK[ZBNVKZ[EFMK
YBPZGBKQTNKFO\ZTGP\[NBNPEGFSGE.EBKRGQ
RV[IKF,FOF\NPKEKIMPKOFNGPEKOFV[J
GPRKIKOFSGETNKFOFKBF\ZTGP\NVKENBB[\MI
THZCFGQCDNG\BN[MKR\BNVK[TNKEKSGEG\F\GZF
[YGZBFBEOTG[F\KYGQDEGNN[MKR\BCDNG\B.
�łÆø��Æ��ø�Æ���,��ªø��Œ�"�º"�
58NZBG\JGC
SVZFHGFZFYEG[
B[ZKRGPFJGCINYKRG[HMKRGNBGZGNKNLGNFDG\
CBPZKRGTOPHKGHGFZTNKGQBGZFYEG[,IMG
PP\YKOGMGNGPIPEKO,PKO[BKQNFOSGUGYW
NFCKQGNF[MKNCPT[FCZB[K\GCPT[FFPZMCF,
GBKLNFKG\PZMCFNF\KKIEGNF[KCRV[BNFPYGZ
PIXCFG[Z[F.GHB\RINJGR[Z[CRV[KB[ZPK
[NBZBFBGZSVZFHFZNBZBFBGZPKPKG.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,�ŁłœÆØ, ’Æ���œŒ
CHMG\NKPGEFHGFZFYEG[KCGBFDGBN.
łÆØ��Ø�Æ�æ�Ø�����Ø,ºæ���Ø�,ø�łª’
DOETMKK[RGFDKONNPGEHGFZFYEG[MGNGCMN
F[RF[PINYKOFEVKOMVKFKPKO[NMNF[RF
GB[ZKFOGB[ZKINYO.
łÆØ��Ø�Æ�æ�Ø�����Ø,ºæ���Ø�ø�łª’
MCZKEGTNMCGEOPTN\NKPGEFHGFZFYEG[B[Z
FGBPCJNMNPKRKVGZTRKG\GDHKZG\Y[G\GZTG\.
łÆ�ØØłø�Ø�,ø�œœł "�
GCDNN[T\KEKOK[ZBNNJTGOPBKNQFIKKO[FGB
SVZFHGFZFYEG[,KXBGTNKEGPQFDNG\.
ł’ø���ÆłØ��Ø,���ł,�ø��œ’
MT\FHPQFPIKCNFZCG\YRKQC\GZFFVRKPK\.
SVZFHGFZFVGZWR\KCG\IE[G\,P[KOCPECZEZL
PSKNFCTZCF,FGBGMN\CGB\GPGMQFGBNV\GI
V\IKDBGNF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,�"�
FCTN[OJGCXGFNBR[KG[YGEOMN\VNFKNPEG
PBPZKHGFZ.
ł’Ø��ÆłØø�Ø��ŁØ�,ªłøŁÆ,��Ø���ł
KHFZNNPGECMNNKNFYGEOF[KRFBGCBDEFBG
CHGFZFYEG[.
ł’Ø�Ø���غ����ŁøÆ,����œł’�غ����ŁøÆ,�œº"�
GNTGNOBKQMICRGNFV[KJF\GZFPPNCG[KFBO
NBFZ[C"KT"FGICZKGCYX\PYGPG\.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,Ł"�
GPK[NBHMFNFCKQFHGFZ,BUTNVKMQKNPGE,MK
FN[GQ[NFHGFZPHMLFR[PF.
�ł"� � łØø,�łªØ�Ø�,æØ���’æ�Ø�Ł"�
BPZFZCKPYBCZKQH"N:BPKZ\FHGFZFYEG[CMN
KGOBUMKNBKETPFFGBBGPZTOMNHFBPKZ\
FHGFZFYEG[PHMLFR[PF.
�ł�ØøłØ�
60NZBG\JGC
NKPGEF\KYGRKHGFZFYEG[PJFZFDGUGFR[PF
GSDGN\GNYZCFDBGNFCPFZFCKPKRG.
ł’� łØ�Æ��Æł���łªŁ,�Ł�� łØ�,����Ł�,æ�Ø��Ł�º"�
PM\CPGZRGFCTN[OJGCNFZCZ’EGEPPKYBNBKGC
TXF[NBNKZBC[KRFNNPGEPBPZBIEP\KYGRK
HGFZYGEOF[KRF.
ł’Øøł��Æ��ø�ŁÆ,�Æ�ø"Ł,ºœłø�ŁÆ
N[GQFHGFZFYGE[FGBPSGDNNR[PFBU[BKRG
PCKQMNNPF[BGPZMP[NFRMRSNIRG\[NCG[O,
BUTNVK[NBNYIMNGOPMNPYGOZKIJGCYNJ
TPG.
ł’�ø��ØØ�� łØ��æªØ��Æ,ª������� łØ�,�Ø�ŁØ�
NKPGEFHGFZFGB[NKPG\DEGNBNFRV[,GBUTNVK
[BKRGPCKQ,FN[GQ[NFHGFZNCEPSGDNPBE.
łÆØ��Œ��ØŒ���æ�,æªł��Ø�ª,�œÆ’
F\KCG\GFEKCGZ[NHGFZFYEG[TXPQPY[ZKQB\
FBEONBKQSGUK\CZL.
�łÆ�ø�Øøł��Æł��Ø�,ø�łØœØøł��,ø�ł��œ�øłœ,ø�ł�’ªłø�’���łÆ’
61 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
KEGT[NKPGEFHGFZPSGDNPBEPBE,GET[TNKEK
NKPGEFHGFZRT[FI[Y,GFN[GQFYEG[[NFHGFZ
PTGZZPBENTCGE\F[OK\CZL.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,øØ�œ�ł"�,�"�
KTSGYCSVZFHGFZBUTNDCENBKETGNBPCKQPBK
YBPZ,PMNPYGOFN[GQ[NFHGFZPSGDNN[MKR\B
GNR[P\BNYZGBCGKG\ZPMNTSYF\GZF.
œØ���Ø��ø"ł
BOHMFKNPGEHGFZCB[PGZ\,MKCHMG\GKXBGK[ZBN
PFDNG\[EGPFNNKNF.
�ł"� � łØø,�łªØ�Ø�,æØ���’æ�Ø�Ł"
KNPGECSVZYCNFGBUBOBKRGPCKQCFOKBPZECZK
FHGFZG\KYGRKOMKFOPSGDNKONJFZFR[PF.
łÆØØ��Æ�� Ø�,æتł��Ø��Æ,Ææªłº�œ��Ø�ª
CKGO[C\YGE[KFKFNMO[KTGZYCGTNNPGE
CHGFZFYEG[PSEZF[CGT,GHFKFKFNMOIGYGNB
KTCGZ.
�º��ªłÆ��œ�’
GNNPGESVZFHGFZCI[YDEGN.
����œ�ł’����Łøł�ÆØ���"�
62NZBG\JGC
PK[FGBCTNTSYDEGNKFKFZGCNKPGEGCHFZBU
[BKRGPCKQ,MKPFBKMV\NKF[BKRGPCKQBVKNGFMK
FGBSDGNF.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,���łØ��ª�"ł������łØ�ª�œ��"�
KNPGECMNKGOHFZPTJGC[C\MNFKGOHFZ.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,���łØ�ª�"ł�������œł� łøœœ�ª�œœ�"�
PK[NBHMFNFCKQ,BVKNGFMK,KYZBFN[GQPVRKMK
FN[GQPSGDN\NHMLFR[PFGNFBKZFCHGFZRVNB.
łÆØ�ØØ��º��,����œŁÆœ,�œ�"�
M[NGPEHGFZKTKKQCMNPNFGPNF.MKMNBG\FGB
IKEG[CVRKTXPG.GECZKOFRZBKOMV[JBKROBNB
SGE.MKFHGFZMGNGBGZF.
łÆØ�ØØ��º��,����œŁÆœ,�œ�"
BP\[PYGCNCKEKRG[DOPK[NBKETMNGOBUTN
VKMQN[GQFHGFZPSGDNNHMLFRV[.
ł’ÆØ��Ø��Œø Øł��ªØ�Æ,��ł"�,�æ œ��ł"�,�œŁ’
K\IE[NGCMNZDTBGZIE[PP[TE[RT[FPP[
CZKFIE[FTNKEKFHGFZGPZ"QFBZ"K.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�ª�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº�ªÆłØ�ª�Ø"�
63 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
MNBG\GBG\[NSVZFHGFZGM\CKPZ"Q[NFZI"G...
FO\KYGRKODEGNKONR[PFN\YQMNFDNDGNKO.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�ł�æª, ł�ª’�ø��º’
TKKQ[ODGENFIKGCNTSGYCSVZFHFZGC\KYGRKO,
GFOR[P\F\GZF,GCHFKHMFCR[P\BNR[P\B
ECZKOT\KYKOGMG’.
�ªłœ��Œ���ł ’Æ���œø�,ª�ł�"�
KHFZNTSGYC\GZFSPGLN[MKCFBKHF[KTGZDKZSB
CP[RKG\BGCSVZHGFZFYEG[B[ZYEG[\F\GZF
B[ZNPEC[MNG\RXGZBG\G.
ł�ø�Øł�œ�Ł"
GNHFFSVZKYZBSVZFHGFZPVRKF[VT\FBGZ
FFGBPFHGFZFTNKGQ,GEZLBGZGP[VKTKOCF[DIF
BNFK\MNFP\TSYKOCG,[FKFBGZG[VTTNKGQ
PFET\PG[VTCZHK\GZFEFKKRGZHKGS\ZK\GZFGMG’
MKGQ[R[VTP[OB\YZKFIKCGZFHFSVZFHGFZ,
MNGPZ[R[VTPFHGFZFFGB.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,Æ’
GNGTPK[GPTNKCEGZFHF[FPKRG\DGCZFKGNGPEKQ
TO\KRGYCQ\[TF[RKOSVZFHGFZGF\KYGRKONFDG\
CFOGFKFKZB\IJBGYGEP\NIMP\GGK\YKKO.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�ł�æª, ł�ª’�ø��º’
64NZBG\JGC
PHPQB[ZFXKWGHZIBGZKYZG\[N[RKPBGZG\
FDEGNKOSVZF\KYGRKOGSVZFHGFZYKKPGGYCNG
FKFGEKOYFNTE\K[ZBNNFIHKYCNKPGEFYEG[[N
F\KYGRKOGFHGFZKIKEGZCKOPRTZGTEHYQ,GFDOEBKQ
NBNKEONF[KDGNFCKQSGEBPZG\JFGZG\[CSVZKO
FYEG[KOFBNFBUTNVKMQ[G\KOCXPBB\
ECZKFOGP\NFCKQCYZKB\QPBEPBE.
łÆ�Øæ��ØØ�,�Æ��Øø�Ø,Æ��ª�œ�œØ��Ø�Æ�Ø�
SVZFHGFZCGECGYRV[KTEB[ZC[MCKGCYGPK
CGRY[Z\K,NBRIGNB[YJNCK,MKCBP\FSVZ
FNHFKEGTGPVGZSOSDGN\TSYGCG,GFGBPYGZ
NMNSVZKKZBKOGPPRGRGCTKOMNFPGSZKOGBFC\
F’F\PKPFGMG’.
�œŒ�ºœÆÆ���ŁłœÆØ�łÆ�ł�Ø"��� Ł���"�
M\GCCSVZFYRFG[C\OGZBK\OCKQXEKYGDG’CKQ
TGCEBNYKONB[ZNBTCEG,TGCEBNYKOFKKRGFTGSY
C\NPGEGCHFZ,NBTCEG,FTGSYC\NPGENCEGBKRG
TGSYCHGFZ.
ł’ÆØ��Ø��Œø Øł��ªØ�Æ,��ł"�,��Ø���Ø� ł��’
YGEOF\VKNFNPTJCEKCGZMNPFEBV[Z,GNPGE
BKHFTRKKQCHGFZFYEG[BGC\KYGRKOBGCHGFZ
IE[.
æªł�Ø����łœ��ªøÆæ’ÆØœ��ł�
65 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
NPGESVZFHGFZR[DCPBGENJFZGNYE[FRV[
GBVKNGBKNBKETPBKYBPZG[GDFCG[DKBG\FZCF
FGBI[GCNVRKFYEG[CZGLFGBMEM\KCGEDNGTNK
BFCFVKZ[GZCG\KRGH"NGENGDGTNKBFCF.
FBNPFFECZEGPFN\KRGYYJQ[BKRGKGETECZ
GPECZIXKKQ[N\KCG\CNTDK[VFGBCKGGBPGKXIYG
NGK[PIGNYGNGMLKG[CC[PKOK[IYGK[PIM[FBK[
FK[ZBNKK[NGIKCFC\GZFGZGXFNNPGEBLBKQET\G
P[D\BGBKQNGPK[KNPERGGNGPEM[KGETCGEBKTG[F
RI\ZGINKGXZGGCBC[MZGFRFMKMQBKQPYGOVJGZ
NPK[BKRGKGETNNPGEBKQJTRFHGVGJZ\GNKGOFEKQ
MKKMGNNNPGEMPG[KGET.
ł’��Ø��łÆłØ�� , ��Ø�ı,�łŒ��ł
FZCFISKEKOGBR[KPT[FP\IKNKONNPGESEZ
\KYGRKHFZFYEG[PIP[\T[ZCBCTEKGOFMKVGZKO.
MKPTN\BPKZ\\KYGRKHFZCIGE[BNGNPCGBZ
CFYEP\MSBPNL[PJFZFDGUGFR[PF.GSDGN\G
NYZCYWFDBGNF,GMQM\GCCBGZXEKYKOSKPQN"G
SKPQC’B[ZKPK[K[NKOSVZF\KYGRKOCKPKOBNG
GKYKZKKZG[NKOP\IKNKOCBPKZ\F\KYGRKOPJ"G
CBC,GMQRFDFBEPG"ZPSYGGZBH"N.
�Ł�Ø�ÆłØ��ÆØ���łØ� ł��"ŁæØ��Ø"�
GPKNRGDEGNPFSVZFYEG[FHFSVZFHGFZKVZ[
FEZMKOKSYNFPSNFKMRKSBFCFGKZBFCNCG[N
BEOKNPERGKEZKMRGCPTDNKXEYNFCKBBG\RGBN
FPRGIFGBNFRINF.
��ª�œ��"���łª æ��ŁÆ�
66NZBG\JGC
GPKKGMN[KIDGENYEG[\SVZFHFZG\GTN\GB[Z
ECZKGXVGRKOGRS\ZKOMNVKEKOCGTZKOPBKZKO
GPHFKZKO.V\ITKRKOPYGZFIKKO.IKKFRV[G\
\GMGZXGUBFCFECZKGPNFKCKOB\FNCCG\NBFCF
GNKZBFB\F’FRMCEGFRGZB.GBUPK[BKRGPCKQ
\GMKG\VRKPKG\ECZKGMNIKLFJGTPGGNGPEN[GRG
ECZKGFPFPSGDNKONR[PFNFBKZFGNHMMFMRGET.
��ª�œÆØœªØ���æŁłª��ª æ���łœ�æ"ª
GKZDKNNNPGECYCNF[YZKB\FYCNFFKB\KYGQNTGQ
HFGNMQRYZBGFPYGCNKOPIXEKINBTN[O[MGZ\KO
MNFYNKVG\.GNKPGESVZFHGFZFGBCMNN\KYGQHF.
)KSGEKGSU(GCVZJNKPGE\KYGQP"IPF\KYGRKO[FGB
JGCNBPZGCKGO[ZBFYZK,FRFDG\KG[Z[NFZC
SZGYH"N.GRZBFNK[DOCKPKF[GCCKOJGCNYZG\G
PEKKGOCKGOIGYGNBKTCGZ.
�ł�œªØ��œ�"�
FCFRYGFMKCBGVQMHFMNBIKRGCK\K[ZBNKYCTG
NKPGECSVZFHGFZFYEG[KIET[KZGBCKGQYJGQ
GDEGN[OFGB.GPFJGCGPFRTKOBOK[\ENGNYCGT
ICZG\NNKPGEFHFZGCVZJNT\MHB\B[ZRKXGXK
FDBGNFFINGNVZGITNKRGNF[\ENCNKPGEFYEG[
FHFFPSGDNNCKB\P[KIXEYKRGMB[ZECZCYE[G
BNKFGFRCKBHMGZNJGCNZTKBPFKPRBECFBKSVZ
FHGFZK\VZYGQPQDNG\BGCKFKVYGQPGDNG\B.GF’
KIK[DBGN\KRGCCKB\P[KIXEYRGCTDNFGCHPQYZC
CPFZFCKPKRGBPQ.
��ª�œ�łÆ�Ø����łª æ�’łÆ�
67 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
GKZCFCKPKOBNG]KPKBNGN[CXEYFGCNKPGEHFZ
G\KYGRKOP[RKG\G\FKNKO.
ł’�ØØ�ªªØæ�����Ø,��ت"�,�ł�Æ�Æ�æØ’�’�Ł�ł�"�
GKHFZNYCGTNPGEGCNKNFCP[RKG\BGCHFZ,BG
[RKFOMBIEJGCKO.
ł’�ØØ�ªªØæ�����Ø,��ت"�,�ł�Æ�Æ��œ�’
NKPGESVZFHGFZPZGPOTNMNNKPGE,C[DONBKET
PBKYBPZ,GBU[KJTFCYZKB\G.GFGB\KYGQDEGN
NR[PF,NVK[FDOEMNF\GZF[PG\KG[NFYC"F,
PMNPYGOR\NC[FCMPFSKVGZKO,GBEOFYGZB
GPCKQFSKVGZKORG\QET\GTNV[JFV[GJ.BCNSVZ
FHGFZFQFSGEG\TXPQCDNGK,GFYGZBKGET[FO
SGEG\GS\ZK\GZF,BNB[BKRGPGCQPYGXZFP[KD
GTGPYFPG[D.
ł’�ØØ�ªªØæ�����Ø,��ت"�,�ł�Æ�Æ�,�œ�"ª
GMQBPZFDBGQFXEKYZCK[NPFCNGLH"NP[O
ZCGFIVWIKKOH"N[TNNKPGESVZFHGFZBKQ[GO
FDCNFMKZGCGPEZ[GFKFFIVWIKKOPTGZZNMGNO
[KNPEGMN[C\B\FHGFZ[NBG\FVZ[FGBVKNG
NCIGZKO.
ł’Øæ�Æ�ø���� �’Ø�,�æ œÆ�Ø�Øæ�
MNSVZFHGFZPKGSETNPGSZKODEGNKOTEBKQ
[KTGZ,GCVZJNFKG\PZMCFNKIGEFYC"FGF[MKRF,
GPTKZTKRKK[RKOP\ZEP\O,GPSKZNCFBCQ,BOBCQ
68NZBG\JGC
FGBRKPGI,GDOFGBSDGNFNFKRXNPPKOFHKEGRKO
PKOFPZKOFPBZZKOIMP\FIKXGRKG\,GMNFJGTO
PPRGKJTGOCTXPGB[ZBKQIMPFCTGNOMIMP\
TPYKS\ZKJTPK\GZF,GMNFIMPG\PCNTEFNBVS
G\GFGRI[CG.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,��ł"�,æł�ł��ø�ŁÆ
FVNKDPBGEMPFVTPKOC[CIDENG\YEG[\
F\KYGRKHGFZ.GFKFZDKNNTSGYCGCKG\ZDOCMN
F[RFBVKNG[NBCKPKBNGN.GBPZ,[CSVZF\KYGRKO
MNGNKOMNFIMPG\[CTGNO.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,øØ�œ�ł"��º"�
CNKPGEFHGFZFKFCGMFFZCFTE[KHMFNFCKQ.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,øØ�œ�ł"�,�’
VTOBPZMP\PKF,BXNFTGNOFMN[GKQSVZFHGFZ
GF\KYGRKO.GFPGCQPECZKGFKF,[CBP\K[IKNGY
DEGNGTXGOCKQSVZFHFZFYEG[GCKQSVZF\KYGRKO,
BUTNVK[SVZFHGFZFGBYEG[GRGZBPBGE,BKQNG
[GOTZLRDEYEG[\GSGEG\[NSVZF\KYGRKO.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,øØ�œ�ł"�,�’
GCT\TKYCBEP[KIBF\DCZG\FZTGFTHG\GFPEG\
ZTG\CFRFDG\ZB[KTZCZCR\DNFFBGZFDRGHPQ
F[PKOSVZFHGFZGF\KYGRKOGBIZKFOM\CKPGZRG
FBZ"KGCHFFNKPGEPCTZFYGXKOGFZT[CRV[G
GKHMFNECYTXPGCBGZTNKGQGKHMFNMNPKEG\JGCG\
69 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
[CTGNO,GNHFR\DNFFBGZFHF,GTKYZNPGEL
CVRKPKG\F\GZFKFKF[\[KDFBZFGIKG\BNGYK"\
CRV[LCT\NPGELGCMNFKGO...BPZPGZRGFBZ"K
[CHPQFHFRS\ZG\RT[GRDNG\G[PIFNVRKFPYGO
NNPGECZHKF\GZFGNDNG\ZHKQNMNCZK[ZBN.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�ª�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº�,ªÆłØ�ł"�
MKFBP\FGB,[BKQFHFZPECZCPYZKOD[PKKO
MNN,BNBCTGNPG\TNKGRKO,[BKQ[OSEZHPRKOMPG
CD[PKG\,GHPRKOFZGIRKKOP\CBZKOC[KRGKXGZG\
GPEZDG\FONPTNFPPYGOGHPQ.
ł’ø���ÆłØ��Ø,���ł,Ø�, Øłø�æ��ª’æ"Æ,���łªØ���Ø�ªØ�œ�œ�
VTOBI\FHFKZNGPZFZCF\FNKOGNNPGEHGFZ
FZCF.
�łÆł" ��łØı�ªłø ��æ,Ø"�,�œÆ’
FNGPEFHGFZVRKGPHFKZKO,GHFGFJTONPFRYZB
SVZFHFZ,GBEGRKBCKH"NCZB[VZ[\CZB[K\M\C:
EYZBGSVZFHFZZPHNPNKQTNBKQMK\KC\HF"Z
DKPJZKBFBK"QSG"UCZGLFGB.
��ª�œ��"���ł�Øł�
FNGPEFHGFZ[FKBIMP\FYCNFRT[FCQNFYEG[
CZGLFGB...BVKNG[BKRGPCKQBVKNGFMKRT[FCQ
NFYEG[CZGLFGBGFGBRMGQ[VKZ[.
��ª�œ��"���ł�Øł�
70NZBG\JGC
FNGPEFHGFZPYZCFDBGNFGMLM\CFZCBP\
NKTYCH"NCFYEP\SVZGP[OFHGFZGF\KYGRKO
GFIZKEFZCFFZCTNPK[NGPE\GZF[CM\CG\GZF
[CTNVFTGR[GDEGNBONBKNPGECSVZFHGFZ
GIMP\FYCNF.
��ª�œ��"���ł�Øł�
TGEBPZ,[CKY[PZCG[KRXNPQFDKBG\GFVXKZNG
PBGETNHF,GBPZNG[KNPGEHFZ,GBPZNGBRKNGPE
HFZ,F[KCNGZCG:[KNPGEFZCFHFZ.
�łÆł" ��łØı�ªłø ��æ,�",�œ�"�
TGEBPZNBEOBIE[KBPZHFZCMNKGOGKGOGKFKF
NGVZRSF.
�ªłø ��æª��",�œ�"�
YGEOF\VNFKYCTTXPGNNPGEP[RKG\DPZB
HFZ.GNBK\VNNTE[KNPGECHGFZFYEG[FQZCFQ
PTJ.
ø����Ł�łæØ��"��œÆ’
GET[MNSVZFHGFZGIKGCNKPGEGGMG’,FMNPXGG\
T[FNECYFCGGNKET[K[BNGYKPXGKCKEKTFYEG[F
CVZJGCKIGEKOGBFCFGKZBFGBIEG\.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�œØÆ�œØŒ,øÆØ��Ø�ª,øÆØ�Æ’�œ�’
71 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
SEZFNKPGENNPGECMNKGODPZBGP[RKG\GHGFZ
NF[CKTRV[GC[CT[PIG\B\VRKL.
ł’Ø����Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ�łØ��ł� ,�œØÆ���œØŒ,Æ �ª ,øÆØ� œ�ł �’��œ�"Æ
BCNFTKYZ\ETBIK[TKYZNKPGEHF[R\DNFCHPQ
FHFCMNMLCFKZG\GBGZGF\V[JG\FGBPIP\
[FZTDGCZPBGEGMRS\K[ZBNRGVN\GCNKPGEHF
RHEMLFRV[GCBP\CT\NKPGEFSGEG\GCVZJSVZ
FHGFZGF\KYGRKOPBKZFRV[.
ł’Ø����Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ�łØ��ł� ,�œØÆ���œØŒ,Æ �ª ,øÆØ� Ø��ª�’��œª’
CVZJCT\NKPGESVZFHGFZ[PP[F[MKRF[GZF
TNKLGFYEG[CZGLFGBPBKZTNKLBGZGIKG\GCNCE
[\FKFNLFMRTFCBP\,GTGE[\HMFTNKEKNKPGEHF
NFKG\TVZGBVZNSCGNKSGZKOGIZGVKQ,GEZK[G\TYC
[\FKFCTKRKLMBSYGVFF\I\GRF[FMNE[KQTNKL,
GF[OK\CZLKTHGZNLCFZICG\FPGIKQ[NFYEG[F
GCRGTOHKGF[MKRF[NB\ZDK[PMNBNF[GOFZD[
MNNGMNNBNBFZICG\FET\GFPGIKQP[PI\RGTO
HKGBGZ[MKR\G[K[ZFTNKL.
ł’Ø����Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ�łØ��ł� ,�œØÆ���œØŒ,Æ �ª ,øÆØ� Ø��ª�’��œª’
BKQ[KTGZGTZLNPTN\FFGDFCECZKBNYKOIKKO,
CSVZFHGFZGMNFRNGKOBNKG,GCECZKIMPKBP\
GCKG\ZCM\CKFBZKH"NFCZGZKO...MKTNKEKFTSY
72NZBG\JGC
F\PKEKKDNG[TZKBGZFGV\IKIMPFNMNFFGNL
C\GOCEZLF’,B[ZIPEFRV[GNYZCFBNFKMNPNL
FMCGEIKFTGNPKOCZGLFGB,GTNMQKFKGCZGMKOMN
FP\RECKONTSGYCMPFBVKNG[TFBG[\KOCKGO
PEKKGOCKGPG...
GPI[CFJGCFFYC"FPXZVFNPT[F,GKI[C
MBKNGTGPEFGBMNFKGO\PKECIXZG\F’GP[MRG\KG
CZHKQEBGZKK\B.
łÆł�Ø" ���,�� ÆØøł��Æ�ª�ø ,232
KETMCGEG,[MNTKYZMGGR\KCIGCZG\K,GCMNPF
[BRKMG\C,FGBZYNTGZZNCC\NPKEKIMPKO,HYRKO
GXTKZKO,NTSGYCTKGQCVRKPKG\F\GZF...GNNPGEB\
MNFSVZKOTOECZKHGFZFYEG[GSVZBEXRKTG\B,
SVZFCFKZGSVZKXKZF,GMNPEZ[KIH"N,CTKGQ
GCCYKBG\,XZKLTNHFF\PEFDEGNF,PP[MF\PE\
F["SGVGSYKO.
łÆł�Ø" ���,��ł�œ�’,"�Y"Æ
\YRG\ZB[GRG\NYCGTNKPGE\PKEKB[ZNBKVSKY
FNKPGEFYEG[FHFCSVZFHFZFYEG[G\KYGRKO,
NNPGEMNBK[PFOINYGHFBIZHFPBIZ\VKN\
FCGYZGTET\\VKN\PRIFTZCMNFKPKO\PKEIGW
P[C\GKGOJGC,GTGEFGSKVGCNKPGEF\PKEK[N
FHFZFYEG[NNPGEMNFKGOMGNGGTGE[[[TG\
CNKNFIGWPQFNKNG\PPGXBKKGOMKVGZ.
ØłØ�ø ,��ØØ�Ø�����Ø�łÆØ��ø �ØØ�����Ł�,œ���œł�ø���œ
73 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
GC[R\\X"B)1731(FKGDHKZG\RGZBG\NCTZSVZK
F\NPGE[NCRKK[ZBN,GFDBGQZCKCBSBQ[BNNZCKRG
ZPI"NNCBZNGSGEFTRKQ,GZCKRGF[KCNGCCKBGZSGE
MNFTRKQ,MKFGBZBFHB\PYGEOGFYEKOZVGBF
NPMFG\KYQCK[KCF[NG[KNPEGHFZG\KYGRKOGHFZ
IE[CNKFVSYPTNG\F[IZTEXB\FMGMCKO.
ØłØ��ø�,��ØØ�Ø�� ��Ø��łÆØ��ø��ØØ���Ł
M[TGSYCIKCGZHFPTGZZKOMIFR[PG\GMI
FXEKYKOFFOTOMIP[FZCKRGTNKGF[NGO...MK
CFKG\OP\TSYKOCGFOPIE[KOFBGZFPIGE[
[R\IE[CT\ICGZG,GPHFKZFF[MKRFGPBKZFPBG\G
FBGZM\IN\IEG[FBH,GMNFTGSYKOCFIGHZKO
GPTGZZKOBG\GF\GTN\GBG\GFBGZFYGEO[DNFZCK
[PTGQCZKGIBKGICZKGC[T\ICGZG.
�łÆ�ø��ØØ�Æ�Ø��Æ�łªÆØł,�ł�"�,�łØ�ł,ø�ł�’æØ���’
GPGZKH"NFKFBGPZ,PK[FGBIZKUGCYKCTKGQ
PBGECPFKZG\,JGC[KTKKQ[TFBI\BGC’CTKGQ
GNBKG\ZGMG’,BCNPK[BKRGPFKZMNMLGFGBY[F
FTKGQ,KG\ZJGCNG[KTKKQCVRKPKG\FECZ[FGBCVZK
PPF[KTKKQCYNKVG\,GFGB[KTKKQGKTSGYCPEZ[KO
GCVZJCHGFZGCSVZKYCNF.
łØ�ı�ØØ�����œ��Ø�ª
[K\IHYMNCZK[ZBNNNPGECHGFZFYEG[BU
[KTCGZTNKGMPFRSKGRG\NFVZKEBG\GINKNF
PNNPGECHGFZFYEG[GMQBOTCZTNKGMPFRSKGRG\
74NZBG\JGC
PCRKBEOFPDG[PKOCIGPZ[NFO[FONKXRK
FEGZZIPRBNKXNQGFGBKG[CCKRKFOM[G[RFCKQ
FIGIKO...
[K\IHYCTNRV[PK[ZBNFZGXFNECYCECKYG\
FCGZBCZGLFGB...BUTNVK[RZBFNGCPYX\BKHF
VTPKO[FGBM[G[RFCKQFIGIKOBNK[DKITNHF
IHYGR\IHYCMIFBKQSGUCZGLFGBGCZGL[PG.
�łÆ��Ø��łÆłø�ŁÆ ,ª�ø���Ø��ł,Æ��ª��ªłŒ��ªø�œØ"Æ
EUHFZFYEG[...GF[PZVQK[KBLNCCLNIEGNPHF.
łÆØ�ø��łØ��ª��æŁ,����œłÆØ�ø��łØ��ª��æŁ,�œº"�
G[C\OGZBK\OCKQXEKYGMG’CKQTGCEBNYKONB[Z
NBTCEG,TGCEBNYKO,FKKRGFTGSYC\NPGEGCHGFZ.
NBTCEG,FTGSYC\NPGENCEGBKRGTGSYCHGFZ.
ł’ÆØ��Ø��Œø Øł��ªØ�Æ,��ł"�,��Ø���Ø�, ł��’�œÆ’
[PTGRKBIKKGZTKFICZKOFP[\GYYKOGPCY[K
BP\BPK\\TCGE\FNCNIHG\CRGTOF’GNCYZ
CFKMNGRV[K\[\GIIG\ECYCSVZFHGFZMB[Z
KEGTPVKYEPGRKRGSDGN\TSYSVZFYEG[.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,æł�ł�,ª�ª’
BPZYGEOCKB\FP[KI\\DCZPKRG\GBVKYGZSG\
ZIPRBNKXNQCTGNOFTXFNHFNKHFZC[NG[FECZKO
75 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
FNNG,FBIENBPZCMNKGOHGFZBUTNVK[BKRGPCKQ
PF[BGPZMKBPKZ\HGFZPSGDN\NJFZ\FNC.
�łØøłØ�,�Øł�ªºØ�
NKPGEFHGFZCDKZSBCTNPBCGRFTGNPG\GMN[MQ
BOKHMFNNPGEGNFCKQVKZG[PBPZKT[FCG\KYGQ
NPTNFC[TFBI\PF[NBKT[FCNKPGEFV[J[RF
\PKPF.
�łÆø��Æ��ø�Æ���,ºæ���Œ,œØ���"��œæ’
GMCZKEGTPTN\NKPGESVZFHGFZMPG[BPZFBZ"K
H"N[NKPGEKGOBIEPSVZFHGFZGSGEG\F\GZFFGB
MRDENKPGE[RF\PKPFPV[J.GCHMG\HFFYC"F
KBZKLKPKFOCJGCG[RG\KROCRTKPKOFTG[ZGFMCGE
KIEKGKFKG\PKOCCRKOGCRKCRKOGC\KOPMNJGC
PNBKOCCZM\F’GCZM\BNKFG.
��ª����łª æ�Øł�œł�"Æ
MKIKCGZHF[RYZBSVZFHGFZFGBMPG\KC\RI
[CGFKGPKRKOFZCFGNBFKFYKGONBG\QFPKRKO
GFP[VIG\MGNOBNBTNKEKMRKS\ONF\KCFMQ
FGBPP[...
MQKMRSGFXEKYKOBNSGEBGZIKCGZFHF
NF\YKKOGMLSDGN\FIKCGZ[PKE[TGSYCI[YG
BFC\F’K[BCRGM[BKC\FBCQF[GBC\B\FCZHN
GKMRSBNKGNFXN\RV[GGZGIGGR[P\GG\KYGRG,GBVKNG
BOKFKFZ[TBKQI[[BOKMRS.
�łØ�ł,ø�ł�’æØ���’
76NZBG\JGC
NBK[KDBGZIG\IKKOBNBTNKEKNKPGEFHGFZ...
GCEGZFHFBKBV[ZNFP[KL[MKR\BTNKGRFBNB
TNKEKFHGFZGM\CKFBZ"KGFZCIKOGKJBNCNCE
[RBPZGCZGIFYGE[GCEGZFHFPKFBK[FIVWIKKO
BGFCKPKOPCNKNCNG\KGOCN\KYEG[FNZBG\JGC
TGNOFCBCTGNOFHFKECYRV[GCSVZFHGFZGCM\CK
FBZKGFZCIKOGKJBNCNCE.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�ª�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº�,ªÆłØ��"�
FRFCKGOFHFB[ZRM\CFSVZFYEG[FHGFZ[FGB
PFBZ\FBGZMKJGCFDRGH...GHFPBKZNRGCDNG\TE
K\DNFCHMG\HFP[KIXEYRGKFKBGZHFBGZG[N
PNLFP[KI.ł’ÆØ��Ø��Œø Øł��ªØ�Æ,��ł"�,Æ�ØØøøºł,���łØ�ªø�ØØł���ł�’�œª’
FZKNTKRKL,[DBGN\K[ZBNGMNPTN\K[ZBN\NGK
CNKPGEFHGFZGCVRKPKG\F\GZF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł���ł,�œæ"Ł
[PT\KPPGZKH"N[SVZFHGFZK[NGCMNKGOVKZG[
BIZ.ł’�ø��ØØ�� łØ��æªØ��Æ,ª������� łØ�, ’Æ�,��’ "ª
SVZFHGFZPNBPGSZ,GMNBG\[NGFO\KYGRKO
DEGNKONR[PFN\YQMNFDNDGNKO.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�ł�æª, ł�ª’�ø��º’
77 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
BIZF\VKNFCMNKGOGMG’KBPZPBPZPFHGFZ
FYEG[BGP\KYGRKO.
æªł�Ø����łœøºœÆ�ł�"��łÆł’��ł����ł�Ø�,æ łÆØœ��ł�
NKPGEFHGFZFYEG[CHPQFHFRXZLNRGPBENFDQ
GNFXKNBG\RGRDEMNZT,MKDKNGKFIMPFHB\T\F
CEGZG\DZGTG\FGB.MEK[KFKFNRGPDQT\FNBIGH
CNCC[NONBCKRG[C[PKO.MKBG\QEGZG\YGEPKO
FKGBR[KPT[FGISKEKOGFPT[KOJGCKOFKGPXKNKQ
BG\QPVRKFPYJZDKO.T\FZIGYKOBRGP[Z[
FTNKGQMPGF[PZKOC\GLFICKG\.PKKDQTNKRGBO
NBYZKBG\RGCIMPFFHB\.
�łÆØ��Æ��,Æ��ª�œ��ı��ØØ�
GMQK[FZCF[GJKO[CGZIKOPNNPGEZHKQ[N
PGZRGFBZ"KGSVZFHGFZB[ZFOIKKRGGNGTPK
[GPTNKCTYCG\P[KIBB[ZFZTGFPKRG\DGCZFKG
[GYEKQMNKPKFONNPGESVZFHGFZGF\YGRKOM\CK
PZQGFKGPCJNKQMNDHKZG\ZTG\GFKGPP[KMKO[VT
GBGZ.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�ł�æª, ł�ª’�ø��º’
IKG\BEOFK[ZBNK\NGKCSVZFHGFZGCM\CKPZQ
NNPGECYEG[FGC[PIFGCRGTOGCKZBFGBFCFMN
BIENVKF[D\GGYEG[\GGMNK[ZBNYEG[KO.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�ł�æª, ł�ª’�ø��º’
78NZBG\JGC
F\GZFFKBBPXTKCNCE.GFTSGYCFXZKLNFKG\
P\GL[BKVFGZXGQTPGYNECKYG\CF’.G[GOMGGRF
BIZ\BSGZFCFKMNF’.CZGZ,[BONGPEKF\GZFFKG
TGSYKOCFP\GLBFC\F’FKGYE\CNKCO,GFZXGQ
NFKECYCGFGBHF[FKFPPNBB\MNK[G\O,NBFKF
RGXZ[GOGKMGICY[ZNVRKPKG\F\GZF,GMGNOFKG
RGFZKONFKMNFPNLNTSGYCIMP\FYCNFGFHGFZ
FYEG[CINYRMCECKG\ZCSEZKGPO,GBUZGC[TG\
KPKFO.
øÆØ�� łªæ,ºłŒØ"�, łøœØø��œø�"�,��Ø�3/515
VTOBI\[BNGNCTN[OJGCH"NBIEPFECZKO,
GBHKV\ISVZFHGFZ[FKFPGRITNF[GNIQGFS\MN
CGGBPZNFOMNFPBGZT,GBIZMLRPXBFBP\B\G
[MKGGQCECZKG.G[BNGVKGFYEG[,GMKC[CKN[V\I
B\SVZFHGFZGFS\MNG\PTJCHGFZK\MQNET\
GNZBG\PZIGY.
GBHF[KC,FNBPXKRGBGZ[CZBCGFYC"FB\
TGNPGFKFPBKZPZB[FTGNOGTESGVGGDOFBEO
KMGNNZBG\PZB[FTGNOGTESGVGTOBGZFCFKZ
GPBKZNBZWGNEZKOTNKF,GMKGGQ[ZBFFYC"F[BKQ
FTGNOMEBKNF[\P[TOHFFBGZ,DRHGNXEKYKO,
GBVGBFPYGOFPMKNB\FBGZGFKMQDRHG\DRHB\
FBGZC\GZF,[\GZFBGXZGFJGC[NFYC"F,GM[BEO
NGPE\GZFN[PFPS\MNCFCTKQ[MNG,FPBGZFDRGH
PBKZNGR\KCNF[MKNGNZBG\PZB[FTGNO,MB[Z
PBHYGEO[RDRHFBGZ.
�ł���Øł)�ØŁ��Øł( ’ �ªØ,ª�º"�Łł�’
79 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
GM\CFZCH"N,CIGNBGPZKOFZKTGNF’MNFBZW,
ZB[K\KCG\FNMF,GC[C\BGPZKOF[\IGGNF’
CFEZ\YGE[ZB[K\KCG\YCNF,MKFYCNF\[\CI
CKGO[C\,MKYKEG[FKBCSGEBXKNG\ENK\\PQ
YNKVKQMNN,GNKPGEPBPZKFHFZGYZKB\GHGFKB
FKNGNGBUMKDKZSBCTNPB.
łÆØ�ø��ºœ�,ł�"�,��"�
BKRGEGPFIKG\G\TRGDNKPGEFRDNFMNKPGEFHGFZ
GF\KYGRKO.GBPZTNTXPG[FGBBKQNGIKG\G\TRGD
BVKNGCNKPGEFDPZBMPGPQFHFZG\KYGRKO.
�ªłø ��æ,��ł�"�ł" ��łØı,�"Æ,�œ�’
CTRKKQNNPGEYCNFGM\CKFBZ"KH"N,KET\KMK
B\FCTXPLNB\ZXFNPGECNTEKBKHFGDEGNPPL
GNB\PXBHF,ZY\NPGESVZ[TZKBGZFGDKR\BDGH,
GFTKYZSVZFHFZGF\KYGRKO.
ØøłªÆłØ��œæØ���"Ł
GCMNNHFDOMQ\HFZGCRKKPBGENNPGE,BGTNMN
VRKONGPZCMNKGOCCGYZF[MOBNKCBZKYRB[KTGZ
HGFZFYEG[,GECZHFPGTKNPBGENJFZ\FRV[GDGZZ
\BG\FNKPGEMRHMZCSVZTCGE\FYGE[,B[ZKMO
CRKKFKYZKOBO\[PTGCYGNK.
ł��Ø��ÆæØ���’
FRFPCGBZ,[MNFTGSYCSVZHFPYZCFDBGNF
GTG[FRI\ZGIDEGNNKGXZG,MPG[M\GCMBKNGVEBRK
BRKGCQPQFDNG\MG’.MKMLDHZFCGZB[NBK\DNF
80NZBG\JGC
GKFKFDRGHTESGUKGPKBECDKRKFKCGBEZGZ,MKSDGNF
HGCGGNBCHGN\G.
�łÆø��Æ��ø�Æ���,��ªø��Œ�œØ��Ø���ł
GCBKHFEZLK[MGQFBGZNCGBNF[DFHB\,NHF\KYRG
IH"N[KYZBBEOYZKB\[PT[N[IZK\GTZCK\
[PTK[ZBNF’BNYKRGF’BIETNMGRFHG[KPNKL
NFYC"FNPTNFGPJFGE’ZGIG\FTGNO.
GM[KBPZVSGYHFCCGYZCMGRFHGGCF[\GYYG\
DEGNTEMNG\FRV[BNKGGMG’.BLPK[TEKKQNB\KYQ
FPEG\MZBGKGNB[CZ\BGG\FD[PKG\NBKMGNNYZGB
VSGYHFGNGPZBIETNMGGRFHGGMG’,GTXFFKTGXF
NHF[KMGNNGPZBIE[NBKCNCNBG\GFPI[CG\
HZG\,FGB[KNPGEFZCFYGEOF\VKNFP[RKG\DPZB
GHFZFYEG[TNMGGRFHG[TNKEKNKPGEKMGNNGPZ
[PTK[ZBNF’BNYKRGF’BIEME\,GRMGQ.
��łø�øÆł�øØœ,ª"�Ø��ł���Ø�Ø�Øł�Ø�
PF[BRGZGBKO[K[CRKBEO[BKQET\ORP[M\
BIZSVZKOYEG[KOGRGZBKOPBGEMDGQSVZKFHGFZ
GSVZKFBZKH"NGMKGXB,BUTNVK[K[CFOIKEG[KO
RGZBKOPBGEPBGEFPBKZKOTKRKOGP\GYKOMEC[,
GFORP[MKOEKKYBBITRKKRKOBIZKOMDGQIYKZG\,
ETMKHFGPIP\PHDO,MK[BKROKMGNKONSCGNB\
FECZFYEG[CBP\,GCBP\CGEBKK[NGCIKZFGK[
NGMIN[CZB\PHDGFZT,BCNPBIZ[RGNECPHDZT
MHF,FGBXZKLNSCGNPZKZG\DEGNN[CZB\PHDG
GJCTGFZT.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,øØ�œ�ł"�,�’
81 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
VTOBI\[BNFZCFYEG[FIGHFPNGCNKQH"N
N\NPKEGFZCFYEG[ZCKPBKZPBVJB:FBOB\F
NGPECSVZFYEG[PBGZTKRKO,GF[KCNG,B[ZBKRG
NGPECG.BPZNGFZCFYEG[PNGCNKQ:BRKBGPZNL,
[NBPXB\KC[GOSVZECZKORVNBKOMPG[PXB\K
CD’SVZKOBNG,FKKRGSVZFHGFZ,GSVZBGZFIKKO
FYEG[,GSVZPBGZTKRKO.
�ł�"�ł’Ø���æ�Øł��Ø"�,ºł�Øøł��)ł�Ø�(ª�º"
GBO\BPZCEGZG\BNG[BRGTGSYKOCHFZPBK
BKMBNPKPZ,GK[NFCKQ,[FGBZCK[PTGQCZKGIBK
FTKEC\KYGRKO[CSVZTXPGKFKFRS\ZTEEGZ
FBIZGQEGZFP[KI,MKXGZLDEGNFGBTSYFIMPF
FHB\NKKIEYGC"FG[MKR\KFNSPLBNHFCDNG\,
GNMQR\DNFFSVZFHFZCEGZFHFFBIZGQNZBG\BO
KTSYGCGCBPK\G\NT[G\SPLGSTEN[MKRF.
�ł�������"�ª��"�,Æø��ł�"�
GBRK\PF\KTNCTNKFC\KOFM[ZKONPFK[RGMN
FNKNFGKCNGKPKFOCFCN,NPFNBKTPEGCB[PGZ\
GMG’,BOFGBCZFMKNNPGETNMNVRKOP[RKG\NPF
KPRTTXPGPHFGNGPZBKHFEVKOPQFHGFZFYEG[,
MKMNEKCGZKOBNGFOY[GJKFRV[IKKONRV[G.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�ª�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº�,ªÆłØ� æ�Ø’
TNMQCRKGBIKK\ZDKNGTXPMONNPGECECZKFHGFZ
GF\KYGRKOC[YKEF,GPK[NBZBFBGZFHGFZP\GYKO
82NZBG\JGC
PEC[,NBZBFPBGZG\PKPKGGNBJTOJTOF\GZF,
GTGE[FGBPJFZFRV[GPHMMF,BVKNGBPKZFCTNPB
PQF[V\KKOSDGNFG\KYGQFRV[PBGE,GCVZJSVZ
F\KYGRKO[FO\KYGRKFRV[PP[PMNVDOGSKD
GIGNB\.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�ª�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,��ª�œæ ł�Ø�ª�
G\MNK\FECZKO,M[\ECYRV[LCSVZKKZBKO,
[\ZBFCMNT\IKGCLNCGZBMNTNPKQ,GCVZJCSVZ
FHGFZTKYZBEMGNB,GFGBKNFCNCLC[NFGCBEB[B,
SVZFHGFZFGBFPV\IGFGBFSGDZ.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,æł�ł��ø�ŁÆ
KTSGYCSVZF\KYGRKONZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKH"N
[FGBVKRFNFCKQTNKEGCSVZFHGFZ,GSVZFHGFZ
TXPGKTSGYCGPEK[C\C[C\GGIGE[CIGE[GGFMN
NVKPF[FGBBEOBNB[FXT\KFECZKONVRKG
GFP[MKNKCKQGKCIZ.
æªł�Ø�,æªł��Ø�ªØ�Æ��ªØ�’
BPZFCTN[OJGCH"N,CD’ECZKOFMNNFKVLPPF
[BPZGBIEFPZCFGBIEMG’GCNCE[KZCF,BPKZ\
FHGFZPSGDNNR[PF,[YKE\PYGGBG\PJFZFDGU,
R\KR\XEYF,BPZGIH"N"FRG\QSNTNXEYFC[CKN
[KIKFCRKFZKHFXEKYDPGZ",ETNMNVRKOPIKF
B\FTRK.
ł’���� �łØŁø,æ ł�œØÆłø"Ø
83 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
FPYGCNKOM\CG,MKIP[EVKQPHGFZFYEG[CMNKGO
FGB\GTN\DEGNG\KYGQDEGNNRV[NFBKZFGNHMMF
GN\YRF,GFGBPZVBG\KYGQNIJBKOGNV[TKO[N
FRV[.
ł’� łØ�Æ��Æł���łªŁ,�Ł�� łØ�æØ��œ�Ł"æØ���’
GBR[KPT[FRFDGNNPGEBGNGPZCMNKGOPBG\Q
BZCTKOKGO[PZB[IGE[TEKGOFMKVGZKOBKHF
EVKQPSVZFYEG[\YGRKFHFZGP\MGGRKONDPGZMN
FSVZTEKGOFMVGZKOGRZ[OCF\YGRKHGFZNMNKGO
GKGOGTKKQCSGUFYEP\SVZMSBPNLGTGECSVZKO
[FNFKCGPBGETNFNKPGEC\KYGRKHFZCBZCTKOKGO
BNGGBUPK[BKRGPCKQPMNPYGOFN[GQ[NFHGFZ
FYEG[GF\KYGRKOPSGDNPBGENR[PFMPCGBZMN
HFCSVZKOFYEG[KOCBGZL.
ł’� łØ�Æ��Æł���łªŁ,�Ł�� łØ�æØ��œ� "�æ�Ø��Ł�Ø"�
GNMQBIKJTPGGZBGBGZFDRGHGP\KYG\[K[CHGFZ
FYEG[FPBKZNRV[,TE[PZGCBGZ\YCNTNTXPL
MNFZTG\GFXZG\GFKSGZKQ,GNBK\IN[ET\LGNB
\KVGNPPEZD\L,G\\TNFNPTNFTEZGOFPTNG\,
IHYIHYIHYGBPW,NB\KZBGNB\VIE.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�œØÆ�œØŒ,�œØÆ�œł�,øÆØ��’�œ�’
BOHMFNIMP\BP\PSGDN\FFXNIFCT\KOFNNG
MKBHRBPZSGEF’NKZKBKGGBKQFB[FPDNFS\ZF
84NZBG\JGC
BNBNCTNFGCNKNFKNPGEHGFZCB[PGZG\MKCHMG\G
KXBGK[ZBNPFDNG\GFDNG\RP[NNNKNFGPK[NB
HMFNFCKQCHGFZBUTNVKMQKYZBMKFN[GQPSGDN
NHMLFR[PFGNFBKZFHGFZRVNBGCSVZF\KYGRKO
TNFKG\ZJGCGM[NGPEHGFZKTKKQNIMP\BP\CMN
PNFGPNFMKMNBG\IKEG[CVRKTXPGGFECZKO
FRZBKOV[GJKOBKROZYSGE.
æتłł’øÆœØł�ø�Æ�łæªł��Ø�ªª�Ø"�
BOHMFKNPGECHGFZFYEG[CB[PGZG\MKCHMG\G
KXBGK[ZBNPFDNG\[EGPFNNKNFGBU[NBHMF
NFCKRGBUTNVKMQKNPGEFN[GQMKFGBPHMLFR[PF
GFYC"FCZGCZIPKGKPNBNP[BNG\NCGCVZJ
CHMG\NPGEN[GQFHGFZMKFGBRKKIBYPKFBUTNVK
[FGBPDPDOCNK[RKFGEBKPBQI[GCPBQSVGQ
GPBQZYKTCHMG\HFFYC"FKPFZGKIK[GKENDGCB
NXKGQDGBNBPQMQKFKZXGQ.
æتłø�ł�ø�Ø�,Ææªł��Ø�ªøºœÆ��ª��Ø�
\[GCFF[C\KNP[MKNBIE[[BNTNB[ZM\CG
DGZKFBZ"KHMZGRGNCZMF,[NKPGEFHGFZFGB\KYGQ
DEGNNFBKZFRV[GNYE[F,GFZCHMZGRGNCZMFR\Q
\KYGQNCTN\[GCFNNPGEIP[\EVKOHFZCMNKGO
BUTNDCENBKETPBKYBPZ,EYZKB\FHGFKB
NFBKZFRV[GN\YRF,GRZBFMKEGGYBNKPGEFHGFZ
K[CGSDGNFHGKG\ZTNNKPGEP[RFG\NPGEGPYZB,
85 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
GFGBVNBCPFMGIGDEGNPMNF\GZFBONPYZB
GBONP[RFGMG’,BNGECZKG.
ł’�ØØ�ªªØæ�����Ø,��ت"�,��ª�Ø����ت"���łºœæ łØ��œÆ’
GBRKBPZ\KNG,EKMKBKQSVYMKMNNKPGEC\GZF
FYEG[FR[BGZOFGBPZGPO,GCVZJBOKFKF
N[PFCBPK\KG\GEBKCGRFC[PKOPTNKG\KGGP\YQ
FTGNPG\GPKKIEFEGEKO,BPROB[ZDEGNNKPGE
FHGFZ,FKKRG[FPYZBGP[RFGF\NPGEFOPNGC[KO
PBGEGBKRGRKMZCFOFSGEMNN,NBMQFHGFZ[PECZ
CSGEKF\GZFCVKZG[GBKQV\KFYGZB[NBKCKQMK
ECZKGCTGPYKZHKF\GZF.GNMQNFKG\S\ZK\GZF
DNGKKOCNKNCG[FQPHFKZKQGPBKZKOFRV[.
ł’�ØØ�ªªØæ�����Ø,��ت"�,��ª�Ø����ت"���łºœæ łØ��œÆ’
GZBGKNYCGTTXPGNNPGEIP[EVKQCHGFZCMNKGO
GFGB\GTN\DEGNG\KYGQDEGNNRV[NFBKZFGNHMMF
GN\YRFGNMNG\YGXKOPEG\ZTG\G\BGG\ZTG\
NHMG\CRGTOF[OGFGBPZVBG\KYGQNIJBKO
GV[TKO[NFRV[GMQR\QPZQFBZ"K\KYGQNCTN
\[GCF[KBPZIP[FEVKQHGFZBG\KYGRKOCMNKGO
GMQRFDPGZKGZCKEGEKFYEG[ZCKXCK.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�œØÆ�œØŒ,Æ��ª��,øÆØ��œł��’�œ�"�
BPZPGZK]FBZ"K[HMZGRGNCZMFNZCBCZFOFNGK
TXFJGCFNTRKKQF[DF,[KNPGECHGFZEZLCYKBG\
86NZBG\JGC
CNCECNK[KTPKYCTKGQBZCTKOBGIPK[KOTNKQ
CMNKGOG[KYZBCSVZFHGFZVTPKOZCG\.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,ø�łł���ªø
GK\RFDCEZLHG[KZBFNSKKOHGFZK[QGHGFZIE[
GF\KYGRKOCMN[RF.BLBOKNPGESEZFVZ[KG\[N
FHGFZFYEG[TNSEZF[CGTG\,NBKSVKYNVTPKO
[RKOG[N[F[CGTG\CVZ[FBI\,EFKKRGCVZ[G\
DEGNG\.
NMQZBGK[KYCT[KTGZFNKPGEPFHGFZ
FYEG[G\KYGRKOD’EVKQCMNKGO,[KGMNNF[NKO
MNFHGFZK[QGIE[G\KYGRKOCMN[RF,GBIZ
NKPGED’EVKQKYCTNKPGEGC[BZSVZKFPYGCNKO,
GKNPGESVZKFPYGCNKOTNSEZ[KMGNTE[KSKKO
MNSVZKFPYGCNKOFRPXBKOGMG’,BLFHGFZFYEG[
GF\KYGRKOKHFZNSKKPOCMN[RFMR"N,GMHFK\RFD
MNKPKIKKG.
Øæªøłø��ƪ�,ø�łØ�øØøØ,ø�ł��Øı
M\CGFPVZ[KOGHFN[GRO:FNGPECHGFZFYEG[
P\YQTGNPG\FTNKGRKO,GFNGPEC\KYGRKOPCZKI
FYNKVG\GP\YQTGNOFT[KKF.GPHFFJTOKSEZCK
[PTGQCZKGIBKFHGFZFYEG[CI[CGQDEGNGSVZ
F\KYGRKOCI[CGQYJQ.GHF[M\GC"GKCZBBNGYKO
B\[RKFPBGZG\FDEGNKO",ZPHNSVZFHGFZFYEG[
GSVZF\KYGRKO,JGCKOF[RKOGMG’,BLFIKNGYCKQ
HFNHF,HFCI[CGQDEGNGHFCI[CGQYJQ.
NMQBPZFPBGZFDEGNFGBFHGFZFYEG[,
NP[N\FKGOGMG’,GB\FPBGZFYJQ,NPP[N\FNKNF,
87 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
ZPHNTGNOFT[KKF.FZK[NKPGECFOFGBECZDEGN
N\YQTGNPG\C[PKOGCBZW.
�ØØ��łØ,æ ł�æª��œ
TNMQZBGKNNPGECHGFZFYEG[GCSVZ\KYGRKO,
B[ZFOPNBKOHKGGPVKYKORGDFCS\ZK\GZF,DO
ENBKETPFYBPZ.GTNKEKNKPGEFRS\ZCGZB[PKKO
IE[KO,GTNKEKNKPGEFV[JCGZBBZXG\IE[G\,MPG
[RBPZMKMB[ZF[PKOFIE[KO.
�ØØ��łØ,æ ł�æª��œ
MPG[[PTRGCVKZG[PVKBEPG"ZFHYQCNKBHRK,[K[
CIKR\JPJGOFPGIGMG’,GNHFPGTKNYZKB\ECZK
FHGFZFYEG[BUENBKETPBKYBPZ.
����łØ��,��łØ"����Ø�,ø�œ��’æ"ª
GFKFBGPZPGZKH"N[SDGNFNKPGEKF’CSVZFHGFZ
\GTN\TXGOC[C\BUBONBKET[MNGNIE[CGECZ
GMG’BCNNNGPEKOCSGEF’CHGFZGC\YGRKOB[Z
PFGNN\[CIG\PPGNIJFGZYE[CSGEFBXKNG\
YZKB\GHGFKBFNNGNFYEK[GNFTZKWFR[PF
FJFGZFGN\\IKNGTGHCVPNKB[NPTNFPF[NB
KT[FCBNUBNVKEZG[KOCZCCG\V[JKOGMN[MQBO
F[DK[KDNF[YKUGNIHG\CRGTOF’CPM\CFYE[
FBZ"KHMZGRGNCZMFNF[MKNCFOPBPZKFHGFZB[Z
BKQNLPEFJGCFFKPRF.
�łÆø��Æ��ø�Æ���,��ª�œ��ªø��Œ
88NZBG\JGC
GFP[MKNKOKCKRGBKRGQPBZKYCNFEB\PZCFGQ
GFP[MKNKOKHFKZGMHFZFZYKT,BKNKQBKRGQEYB
P[\ENKQCHFZEBEB\YZKSVZFHFZEBKRGM\KC\
RIEP\MR[KQCF[RKOPTKZG[CTPPNMG\BECFGQ
K\YKKOMNFCQFKNGEFKBGZF\[NKMGFGGEBBGZF
ESVZBEB.
��łÆ���œŒ��"�
GECYRV[L\PKENVKF[D\LCSVZFHGFZGCM\CK
PZQFBZ"KGECYRV[LPBGECKZBFGBFCFGFMRTF
[NB\FKFMGGR\LINKNFNFKG\ZCGZCKMKHFG
TCGEFHZFPP[GMG’GNMQBIKKGCRKKRV[G\KYZG\
DCGFKOGZPKO\ECYGRV[MOCSVZFHGFZ\YGRKO
HGFZIE[GMG’.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�ł�æª, ł�ª’�ø���’
89 SVZFHGFZFYEG[
FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
ZKCGRG[NTGNO,CRKL[PGVRKFOTNK[BRKMCQCK\
NVRKL,BKRKHHPMBQTE[\ZIOTNCRKL.
�ø��,�溜œ��Øœ, ł��’
ZGIF’ECZCKGPN\GTNN[GRK.
ø���Æ’,º"�Æ’
[MKRFPECZ\P\GLDZGRG.
��ł�æ�� ��æ�œø�"Æ
ZGPPG\B=NCDZGRO.
œ��Ø���"Ł’
NVK[MNGKFNNBK[.
�ø�ØØ"Æ�’
[NGIG[NBEOMPG\G.
Æłºœ�"ª
ZYCKPKZ[C"K,BIZKK"D[RFB[ZFKFCPTZF,
RV\IG[TZKFIMPFTNKG,NFBKZNMNK[ZBNTEYW
FKPKO.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’Ø"�
FRFZ[C"KIKCZSVZFHFZ,NVKFFBZFB[ZFDKT
BNKGCF\YRGCPTZF,GTRKRGIKCGZTNF\GZFPCBZ
SGEG\DEGNKONVKSEZKF\GZFTXPF.G[BZFSVZKO
B[ZRT[GPQFBIZKO,MDGQSVZKXKZFGVZYK
FKMNG\GMKGXB.GMNFSVZKOB[ZNZB[GRKO,MDGQ
SVZZHKBNSVZBEIRGLGMKGXB,BKROTNF\GZFGNVK
SEZK\GZF.
BLHFGIKCGZDEGNGRGZBFPDNFTGPYFSGEG\
CCKZGZZCTNF\GZFTXPF,GHFGRYZBDKNGKF\GZF
CVRKPKG\F,MPG[T\KEFYC"FNDNG\F\GZFTXPF
CK\ZVRKPKG\TPGYFDOMQNT\KENCGB.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’º"ª
GFKFZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKPDNFSGEG\F\GZF,
GICZKOPY[KCKONYGNG,GP\ICZKOTPGNFKG\
CIKCGZHF,MNBIETGRFINYG.MPG[RT[K\FP[RF
TNKEKF\RBKO,GZCRGFYEG[IKCZSCZ\MGNOGT[F
PFOSVZFP[RF.
MLZXFZCK[PTGQCZKGIBK[KIGCZSVZMNGN
PPBPZKMNCRKK[KC\G,GKFKFFSVZPIGCZTN
F\GZF.MKFIKCGZKOPECZKOTNTRKKRKOVZJKO,BL
FHFZFRT[FTNF\GZFHFRYZBFV\IFDEGN[N
MNNG\F\GZF.GFRFZCK[PTGQCBKGIBKXGGFNZCK
BCBNFKG\MG\CGPSEZB\MNFECZKOB[ZKECZG
FIMPKOCRKFK[KCF,CMNHPQGHPQGCMNPYGO[FO,
B\FMNKSEZNVKSEZF\GZF.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’º"ª
XGZFTGNPKO,NBFKF[OPMKZGGNBKGETGBNB
KIKEKOCTGNO,MDGQIRGLGP\G[NIGRIG[OGTCZ.GTN
EZLHGFKFFTGNOP\DNDNGFGNLTE[RGNETPGEG[N
TGNO,GFGBBCZFOBCKRGTNKGF[NGO.MKGQ[RDPN
91 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
BK\QHFF\IKNN[GJJCET\G,GFGBYJQ,NI[GC
CKGOGCNKNF.GFKF\PF:FKBLBV[Z[KFKFFDNDN
FHFRGFD\PKE,GNBKFKFNGPRFKD?GPKKSCCBG\G?
MKBV[Z[KSCCB\TXPG?
GNBFKFNGPNPEGNBPGEKTECZ,BNBPG[YT
CBGZM[EKOCKQTGCEKTCGEFHZFFJV[KO,GBCKG
GBPGGMNFTOTGCEKTCGEFHZF,GFGBFKFTGCETPFO.
GNCGP[GJJGPCKQ,TE[F[KDEZLFBP\,GFCKQYG
FXEYPET\GFRMGRF,GKET[K[[OBNGFBIE,GFGB
PRFKDFDNDN,GFGBCZBFMN,GBKQCMNFRPXBBNGF
IGWPPRG.
ł’�ø�Æ��Ø��,�ł�Æ"�,��ºœ�"�, ł��’
GFRFPICZSVZFKXKZF,CZBG\GCET\GF[NPF,
[FEZLFPYGCN\TNVKFBG\KG\FKBFEZLFPCKBF
NKEKFF[DFF[NPF,GFTEG\FKB,[MNBEONB
K\MQ[K\IMOCPKQIMP\FF[DFF[MNK\,BONB
KZCFCNKPGEFSVZKOFPGZKOTRKRF.NVKMLFZBF
NRGCKBGZFEZLFPG[MN\,BKLR[KDRFCYZGCKG\Z
P[BZEZMKO,GFKDKENRG[\IKN\FF[DFFKB
FYCNFCPSKZ\FBG\KG\,TOF[PG\[NFOGTO
FPSVZKO.
łÆØ�Æł���Æ�� Ø�, Øłøæ ł�ØØł�
GNVKTZLIMP\[NPFFPNLT"FFKFRXZLND’BNVKO
P[NKO[KGZKETGPY\TNGP\IMP\GCZCGKFGZEG\HG
BIZHGPP[NNP[N,TEMKCP[NGEGDPBFBIZGRF
FKFBV[ZNCRKBEONF[KDOCPGIOG\CGR\O.
ªłŒ�œØŒ�œ,œ���œ�ł�,�"�,Æ’
92NZBG\JGC
FXEKYKOFDEGNKOMGNNKOCR[P\OFMN:K[NFO
MNFJGCGFZT[NFMN,GSGCNKOKKSGZKOCTEFMN,
GPYCNKOTGRDPFMN,CFGVMOB\FZT[NFMN=NJGC.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’,��"�
MNNFECZKOMKDOCV[JKONBRPXBKEKRGGZDNKRG
CN\KSTEFPYGCNKO,GBNKFORMZTBVKOGKV\INRG
CMNBNFFTKRKKO.
æ ł��Ø�Œ ’œł��
GFZDKNCSVZFHGFZGF\KYGRKOGSVZKFPYGCNKO
CTKRKGKZBFGNCCGKCKQDGENPTN\IMPFHGGKPSGZ
RV[GTNKFGNVGOXTZBBDZBBPROBUPK[BKQNG
KECIMPFHGNBKPRTP[GJCSVZKFPYGCNKO
FPVZ[KOMGR\F\VKNG\GCZMG\GPXG\.
MKBHC[T\PT[FK\NFCNCGCHKMZGMKFO
ECZKOFTGPEKOCZGPG[NTGNOTPGYTPGYGDCGF
PTNDCGTB[ZKKNGEB[FFCGRFC[PKOTNKG\KG
GNBKFBTGCEC\VKN\GNYCNVZSZYKMGKQN\YQ
FECZKO[[GZ[QNET\YEG[KOB[ZCBZWFPF
GBEKZKMNIVXKCOGNCGNPGBCKXTY[PT[FKEKRG
KMGRQTNKRG.
�ØØ�ø����łºœ�ª�Ø��łŒæª
ZCKRGCIKK\NPKEFZPC"QMG\CTNBNG[NBHMG
NFKMRSBNIXZFYGE[FVRKPK\,[NBFCKRGVRKPKG\G
[NTRKKQ,GNBNYIGPRFGZYRDNFG,GM\C[OTN
FZPC"Q,[FGBFGZFNRGB\FEZLB[ZRTNF
CF,GCEZLBP\FRIRG,FGBB[ZFXEKYRG,GHKMRG
93 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
G[FIKKRG,PB[ZNYIGBHRK[PWPRFGGFXKXGZTKGRK,
VTOBCBZVTOBZPGHGKXBMCZYPNVRK,MKPPIXC
FTNKGRFRIXC,NVRKI[GMKOCNK\KKXC,NVRKPNMKO
K\KKXC,FPFIMPKF\GZFB[ZCBGNVRKGNVRKO,
ZHKTNKGRKOXVGRO,GF[KDGCIEZKFM\GCSGEG\
R[DCKO.
łÆØÆ�ØØÆ��øł,�ØÆ�����,łÆØ�Æ�ØØ
ETMKNMNECZK[\MNK\,GN\MNK\K[TGE\MNK\
BIZ,DCGF.NP[N\MNK\CRKQFCK\,MEK[KFBNBEO
PYGONRGI.G\MNK\FPRGIF,MEK[KGMNCMIFHF
NTCGEB\F’.G\MNK\FTCGEF,GMG’.G\MNK\[NMN
ECZFGBPIGCZNFPI[CFGF[MN,KG\ZPFECZ[HF
F\MNK\CBPPRG.
GYZGCF\MNK\NFPI[CFCYZGCKG\ZPFECZ.MK
SGUPT[FCPI[CF\IKNF,RPXB[FSGUGF\MNK\
FGB\IKNFCPI[CFGYZGCNF,GPF\MNK\R[\N[N
FPT[F.NP[N,M[TGNFCPI[CFNCRG\CK\,CGGEBK
FCK\BKRGRCRFCC\BI\,BNBXZKLNFMKQTXKO,
GNSJJGNCRG\MNTWGTWNVKXZMG,GBIZMLRCRF
GR[NOFCK\,[FKB\MNK\FCRKQ,GSGVGFKFCPI[CF
\IKNF.RPXB[F\MNK\FGBYZGCNPI[CFCKG\Z
PF\IN\FPT[F.
GET[F\MNK\[NFCZKBFFGB[T[GTTGNO
FCB.GBKBV[ZNYZCHB\F\MNK\NPI[CG\CRK
FBEO,MKHB\F\MNK\,TNKGRBPZ)K[TKFGS"E("TKQ
NBZB\F".BCNFXEKYKOCBP\,FOKMGNKON\VGS
CPI[C\O\MNK\FTGNOFCB.GMNBIEGBIE
94NZBG\JGC
PK[ZBNNVK[GZ[G[K[NGC\GLR[P\FXEKY,MQ
PYCNPPRGDOMQHB\F\MNK\.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,�Ø�ŁØ��ł"�,œł�Ø"�
FKFP\PKECNKPGEGPBGE["SGVGSYKOG\R"LGTKQ
KTYCGSVZKFHFZG\KYGRKOGMG’,GYX\FKFCNK[KTGZ,
GCVZJCSVZK\R"LGTKQKTYCGMNM\CKFBZ"KGSVZK
FHGFZG\KYGRKO.
øÆ�Ø�ł"��’
GB[ZKFBEO[KNPGEF\KYGRKOCBNGFKPKOMN
\KYGQ[OBG\GFKGOECZKGOCKGPGGNBKTCGZMKNMN
ECZK[NG[GZ[GJTOGMGGRFNMQJGC[NBKYEKOGNB
KBIZGMQFKFPRFDGFJGC[NTJZ\ZB[KRGPGZKRGFZC
FPGVNBISKQYEG[PZ[BZKRGFVZE"SH"NGBVKNG
CHPQ[FKFNGTGNFXKCGZFKFVGRFPMNFTRKRKO
GNKPEIGC\FKGO,DOJGCNCTN\[GCF[KNPGE
IP[\EVKOCMNKGOPFHGFZFYEG[MPG[M\CCSVZ
[OFDEGNKOINYC’PTZMFC’BG\C’.
��ª�º��ØæØ��Ø"�,�œØ"Æ
BEO[VDOGRVSYFICN[FGBY[GZMPBPZKTYC
ICNRIN\G,GNCGPJGPJOGBKRGKMGNNECZEKCGZKO
HMKO,BHXZKLNF\CGRQPDENG\FCGZBK\CZLBKL
[PPNBMNTNPKQGSGCCMNTNPKQGNK\B\ZVRGK
PKRKF.
GHFGKZB\F’ZB[K\ET\,ET\FKBN[GQ
F\CGRRG\GCKRFNKCB,HFGIMPFCNC.GTKYZFGBTN
95 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
KEKF\GZF,MPG[M\GCC[OFCTN[OJGC[XGGF
NBR[KG[YGEOMN\VNFKNPEGPBPZHFZG\KYGRKO.
ł’Ø��ÆłØø�Ø��ŁØ�,ªłøŁÆ,��Ø���ł
PF[M\C[OCHFZ)I"DEUZV"BT"B(\VKNFNP[F
FZTKBPFKPRB,[YOGB[\JIYPKYGC"FGCMFGBPZ
KFBZTGBMG’,GHFEZMGNF\VNNTNK[ZBN[K\ZXG
PT[KONKKIEF[MKRFNFYNDHKZ\FDNG\FY[F
GFDHKZG\FP\IE[G\BHNK[ZBN,GHFFKFMGGR\ZCK
[PTGQCZKGIBKTNKGF[NGOCIKCGZHFXGZLDCGF
NCJNFEKRKQ,GMNEGZGEGZ[IMPFHGP\DEN\GRGSV\
CFO,HGMKONKKIE[MKRFGNCJNFEKRKOGFDHKZG\,GHG
FKK\F\VKN\P[FZCKRGTNKGF[NGO.
�ł�������"�ª�ł "��"�,Æø��ł�"�
GHFGTXPGFKK\FTKYZMGGR\ZCK[PTGQCZKGIBK
CIKCGZSVZFHFZ,NFKG\F[MKRFCDNG\CBVS[VT
CBKQ\GLGBKQTGHZ,GZXFNKKIEFTOF\"\KIGEPGTJ
TNKEKIKCGZHFCPF[FKFFGBTOICZKGTGSYKO
CSGE,[HFDGZONKKIEYGC"FG[MKR\KFTNKEKFSGE
[FGBZ"HEFKKRGBG"Z.
GDOTNKEKIKCGZHFFGBCKJGNFYNKVG\PFDNG\
GF[C\\YJZGDO[FONGIPG\CMNT\GCMN[TFRDE
F’GRDE[MKR\GGRDECRKF[FOK[ZBNFR\GRKOCDNG\
CKQFBGPG\FRYZBG\IKGQ,IKGQCK[KQGEGCKQEBMNKQ
TRB[FOK[ZBN,GTSYF\GZFRYZBFYNTGFIZC
GFZGPI,GFOCIKR\FSGEG\NFXKNOPZT\OCIKCGZ
HFMG’,GFSVZFHFT\KENF\VZSOCKPKPNMB
P[KIB.GFRFNBG\O[KHMGBNKGKHMGNDBGNFCTHZ\
96NZBG\JGC
F’,GCF’CJIRG[RFKFCMNNFHGMKO,BPQMQKFK
ZXGQ.
��ª���ø�Ø��æ ł�ł��º��
TNSVZF\KYGRKONCENBKSVKYGBNVKOSVZKO
NCBZTGXOZKCGKFSGEG\[K[[O,B[ZNBKMKNO
FZTKGQ,MKEGTNMNDENG\YEG[\F\KYGRKOFYEG[,
B[ZMNTGZG\BKNKRCKG\NBKSVKYGNCBZSGEG\KG
GZPKHG\KG.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,øØ�œ�ł"�,ł "�
ZCKRGFYEG[PGZRGPHKEKJ[GCH"N,BVKNGCT\
[FKFIGNFGXZKLNZVGBFDEGNF\CZDHKHBECZEB
GKZEGJCNCRFZFYVGB\I\FYZIFRGZBGNPE[O
MNFNKNFFHGFZFYEG[G\KYGRKFHFZG\FKNKOC\GL
FPKOFYVGB.
�œŒ��ª���æ łÆØ�ªØ�
KTGKKQCSGUFYEP\CTNMSBPNLGTGECMPFSVZKO
YEG[KO[FNFKCGPBENNPGEF\KYGRKFHFZCBZCTKO
KGO[PZB[IGE[BNGNTEKGOFMVGZKO)GBGNKK[
NFSPKLHFPPF[M\CC\KYGQG’"GKV\IRIB\INGQ
F\KCFB[ZT[F"GEBKGOFMVGZKOE\KC\RIFKB
BKPBTKNBFINGQEKNKFFKBTPGEBEBPXTG\B
ECKFBGZK\KZFBGZGM\CCCKBGZFDZ"B[CKGO
FMVGZKOINGRG\F\KCFGFGB\[GCFBKPBTKNBF
V\GIKOGHFG[M\GCPYWBZCTKOKGO[FOBZCTKO
KGOFKEGTKOPZB[IGE[BNGNGBK\BTNF\KYGRK
HFZEBKFKMDGGRBE\KC\RIGMG’MKEGT.
��ª�œ��"�œØ��Ø��ł���ł"�
97 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
GZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKGCRG[PIGNYZB\MOCYZG\MO
HGFZTNPTZ\OGCMVZFSPGLNFOGMG’GCMQ\ETMK
FO[PIKOPBECYZG\MOHGFZTNPTZ\OBGCMVZ
FSPGLNFOGBO\\PKEGNYZG\MQKDNGNMOZHKQ
TNBKQGMNFGZPKHKQCHGFZ.
��ت�ØøłØ� łøœ��ł
N"DNTGPZCMN\VGXG\K[ZBNTG[KOFNGNBZCF
TNFYEG[F\RBFBNYKZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKH"N
GFKZBNRV[GKFKFCPGZBGKZBFGVIEMNFNKNFMEK
[\FBHMG\ZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKGICZKGIGVUTNKG
MNFKGO.
GHMGZNJGCNFDCKZPSDRKNGKFET[FFYE[
GF\YKQNEGZG\NNPGEFHGFZFYEG[[NOCCK\GCKGO
FHFCMRGVKBMNF\NPKEKIMPKO[CTKZF’TNKFO
KIKGBPQ.BKQSVY[YRF[OJGCYRFNTXPGYRFNG
IKKFTGNOFCB.B[ZK[KBIHCSVZ[CIKZCK[PTGQ
CZKGIBKBGCSVZFNGNBZCF.NFDG\NKNGGKGPG
GXEKYKCIQF\NFCG\DEGNCRV[GCYZKB\G.GPFJGC
BOKGSKUNYZG\CPBPZKOB[ZBSUGYKCWCSVZ
YPISGN\MB[ZKTGKQ[O.
��ª�º��ØæØ���’�œ�’
[ZBK\KCSVZM\KC\KEK[QEIMOBIEFKFNGSVZ
FHGFZGPMZG.GCNKNFFKFPXTZKQBG\GGYGZKQBG\G
CFPFGCKGOSKVZFINGOGBPZNG\NPKEIMOBIE
MKFGMKIBG\G[PMZFHGFZGHFGCFP"FZB[K
98NZBG\JGC
\KCG\C’TZ\F’YE[P’QF’CK\,GM[PTGFNLGFIHKZ
FHGFZ,TNMLM\GCCSVZ.
ªÆø� Ø��łºœÆ’Yª’
FKIKEKOFTRYKO,BR[KFYGE[,FGNMKOGP\PTJKO,
BLFMNNFGNLGP\V\I.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�,30
FTGSYKOCZPHGSGEBKQKXZFZTKMGNNF\DCZ
CFO.
����ł’��Ø��Ø���, Øłø��ł"����ø�Ø�’Ø"�
VRKPKG\F\GZFFOIKKONVRKPKG\FDGU[FGBFRV[,
GFIKXGRKG\NIKXGRKG\FDGU,GFTGSYKOCZPHGSGEBKQ
KXZFZTKMGNNF\DZG\CFO.
����ł’��Ø��Ø���,��ł"�,�Æ�ø���, ł��’�œº"�
BXNRGCYGXYFKGRGFDKONGPZ,FPGV\KOP\DNDNKO
P\I\N[GNIRG\,GBKQBK[JGZINFZKPO.
�łÆØ������ª����
SKVZGNZCKPRENTNXEKYBIECTNPGV\KO[DKNF
CZGIFYGE[[NGFKMQFS\KZGDRCKOTDN[NBIE
PISKEKG.RBRIZCKPRENGBPZ:BEODEGNMPGFGMF
K[VKNTXPG.
�łÆØ������ª����
99 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
FZKNTKRKL,[CTRKRKOZGIRKKO,P\FVLHMG\
FZCKO=NIGC\O.GKGXBFIGY:BIZKFKIKENFJG\.
MNGPZFKIKEFPVG\I.MKECZDNGKFGBNMNBEO,
B[ZFPVG\IKOGFP[MKNKO,FO\PKEPKTGJYJQ
PBEC\GLMNFICZF.GRPXBMNFXNI\FICZF
GBG[ZFFZGIRK=XZGZFGI\GPFCKEKFPKTGJ.GFCQ
HFFKJC.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł��Øłœ
GP\GLHF,P\IKKCKOFZCKOCHFKZG\K\ZF,N[PGZ
CTKRKKOVYGIG\TNMNFETG\[NFKIKEKO,[NB
K\CJNGPFTGNO,MKTNKFONET\CCJIF,CGGEBG\
PGINJ\,B[ZFETG\FKG\ZPVG\IG\GFKG\Z
BPK\KG\=BKRORPXBKONTGNOCZ[G\FZCKO
F[GNJKO=BNBEGGYBCZ[G\FIN[KOCKG\Z,
EFKKRG,EGGYBCPKTGJ[BKRGRKMZNTKRKKO.
MKMNIMPFGMNKYZ=EZMFNCGBNTGNOCMPG\
PGTJF.NVKMLRT[KRGPGHFZKON[PGZTNFETG\[N
MNFKIKEKO,P[GOIGN[\FKMGN\[NFZGCF[GNJ,
NCZZCKRKFO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł��Øłœ
CT\VJKZ\GR\QXGGBFNZCIKKOGKJBNH"N,[NB
KNPEB\FIMPFNBIZKO,GNGF\KZNTSGYCFCVRK
TXPGCNIK[F.BPRON[BZFICZKOBSGZNF\TSY
CFOMNN,MKBPZ,[NBFCKRGFIMPFMZBGK.GFKB
FSKCF,B[ZFZCIKKOGKJBNH"NNBSKEZMNNB\
FM\CKO,GFRKIOCNKSEZKO,GPMN[MQ[NBCKBZ
FY[ZKOPTRKQNTRKQ,MEK[NBKFKFCHFMPGPNPE
100NZBG\JGC
NBIZKO.GNMQBRGPGXBKOFKPRGHFKZG\K\KZFCHF
MRGETNFCYKBKOCM\CKFBZ"KH"N.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł �Ø���Øłœ�æÆØłœ,�œ�’
GHMKRGNZGIBVKRGFCTN[OJGCH"N,B[ZVZ[\
YEG[\GGTGXOYEG[\G,NPTNFPMNFDFGPMNPNF,
NBF\CGRRGGNBK\CGRRGCG,HGN\BG\OFHMBKO
[[P[GNBGZG,GDOFON[KTGZKQ...GFQBP\,[BGZ
\GZ\GGIMP\GFYEG[FRCRKOTNBERKFYGE[
PFBZ"KH"NCKIGE,BPROBKQTRKROEGPFHFNHF
MNN.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł �Ø���Øłœ�æÆØłœ,�œŁ’
GFBZM\KCHFNFGXKBPNCFJGTKOFBGPZKO[BKQ
NVNVNCIMPFFHB\GNBNIE[CFECZ,GR\NGCHF
[PXBGCHGFZVZ[\CZB[K\TGR[FPIE[CIMPF
FHB\PF[NBYKCN.GJTGCFCR\FECZ,EFKKRG
EGGYBFPIE[ISG[NGOFYEPFCTRKKRKOFDEGNKO
[NBYCN,BPRONVNVNCZB[KVZYKOGNIE[P\GMO
FYEPFPGZMC\TNZB[KVZYKOFKEGTKO,FQFQ
FECZKOFI[GCKONVRKFCGZB.
[BONB\BPZMQ,BOMQPF[MZFTGSYCFBG
C[BZF\GZFGPFTRKKQBGPZOBVKNGPF[\NPKE
G\KYT\KENIE[CFBONBR\QZ[G\NF\TSYBNB
CPF[NPE.
�ł��º�����ł,Æø��ł�"����"�
101 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
CMNEGZGEGZP\ZCFGP\DZFPINGY\TNFXEKYO,
GTNVKZGCTKYZFPINGY\TNBNGFXEKYKOFTGSYKO
NYZCRV[G\FZIGYKOCKG\ZNF[OK\CZL,PIP\
[PKE\FEKQP\DZFPBECSGNGFRV[K\FR"N.TNMQ
RMRSJKRFCNCFTGNOGNVTPKORMRSDOCNCDEGNK
FXEKYKONINGYTNFXEKYKOFR"N,FPYZCKOBG\O,
TE[PEPFNFO[BKROP\RFDKOMZBGK.GHFRP[L
GP[\N[NPCIKR\FPINGY\[INYGF[CJKOTN
KGSUFXEKY.�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,
�Ø�ŁØ�ªœ��ø�ø,�����œª�,Ł"�
P[FZCRGM\CF\GZFMGNFPVKG[NFYC"F.FGEKTG
\IKNFTRKKQCZKB\F[PKOGFBZWGMNXCBO,GDOMQ
MNFRBPZCRCGBFPPT[FPZMCFGPT[FCZB[K\,
GFMNRM\CC\GZFCVKZG[BGCZPH,GMNFRPSZNP[F
ZCRGC[TZKFCKRF,FMNRM\CC\GZFCVKZG[BG
CZPKHFC\KCG\BGCDKPJZKBG\BGCXGZ\FBG\KG\,
BGCYGXKFBG\KG\GCM\ZKFQ,MKFZPHKOFBNGNB
K\CGRRGBNBPVFBNVFTEP[FPSKRK,GPRKQKCGB
KIHYBNGKDNFNFOS\ZKFPZMC,MNGPZ[FMNRNPE
PF\GZF.łÆØ��ø�Æ�����,�ł�Æ"�,Æ��ª�œ� Øłø���œł�
TGEK[CKEKRGYCNF[NBP\,MNF\GZF[PG\KG[N
FYC"F,GPVRKHFSVZ\GZF[JTFCGCBG\BI\
CPNBBGCISZ,VSGN.łÆØ��ø�Æ�����,
�ł�Æ"�,Æ��ª�œ� Øłø���œł�
102NZBG\JGC
GBRKFRRKPCKBCCZK\RBPR\,NMNFPS\MNCSVZ
FHF,NCNKSCGZSCZFGBNKI[GCPI[CG\CECZPMN
FZPHKOB[ZBRKMG\CCS\ZKF\GZF,MKBRKPGEKTG
RBPRF,[NBKG[DGECZKGNBKGETGMNNC[GO[MN
GCKRF,HGN\KPVKPYGCNIMO,NBGHQPYCNPCKQ...BN
KFZSGBNF’NZBG\,MKF’BNYKRGB[BGMNFFGB,BN
YRBG\,GFGBKZBFB\ZXGKKGP\GZ\GRVNBG\.
łÆØ��ø�Æ�����,�ł�Æ"�,Æ��ª�œ� Øłø���œł�
BKQ[GOECZPFXTG\GFPI[CG\[NK[BKQNGPYGZ
CM\CKFBZ"KH"N.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ø�ø�Æ���œł"�,�Ł��’
FRRKCHB\NDNG\B\ET\KFTRKF,TNECZF[BNF
BGEG\YEG[\SVZFHGFZGSVZKFPYGCNKO,PCBZKG
G[G\KPKPKG,[MCZFNMFZGGI\CK[ZBN,PDBGRK
FEGZG\ZB[GRKOMPNBMKOGDEGNKGYEG[KFBIZGRKO
TEEGZBIZGQ,[ECZKFHGFZFYEG[FOYGE[YGE[KO
GPYGZOPYGZPKOIKKO,[NZHKBPGR\K[ZBN
FYEG[FGFJFGZF.
BNB[TNVKZGCFECZKOFOS\GPKOGI\GPKO,
PVRK[BKBV[ZNECZCECZKOR[DCKOMBNF,MKBO
TNVKP[NGIKEF,KCKRGPFOFZBGKKONHFMNBIE
GBIENVKEZDKF.GDEGNKFPYGCNKOH"NCKBZGMPF
TRKRKOPZHKYGE[FNNGGFSCKZGOYX\,GDOECZKFO
GYEG[KFOCZGIF’B[ZTNKFO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��ÆØøł��Æ�ªø�,�"�232
103 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
NFKG\[[RKVTPKOC[RFIGYGNBKTCGZFGNMKOMN
IMPKSDGNFFCYKBKOCIMP\FBP\KG\ZPMN
FIMPKONPKZGQ,G[OVGZSKOBGFNBIEPQYCZG[N
ZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKTEYCZG[NZCKBNTHZGKG[CKO
[OCKQZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKGZCKBNTHZT[ZFKPKO
GT[ZFNKNG\ZXGVKOGTGSYKOCSVZKFHGFZ,GHF
FSEZFOTG[KOT[ZFKPKOYGEO[CGTG\GT[ZF
KPKOYGEOZB[F[RF\PKE.
ł’Øæ�ø���ł �ªØ��ªØ�,Øøł���ªØ��,æ ł�ł���º��,Ł��Ø�����Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø���ªłøÆ"Ø
æ�Ø�Ø’,�ºœÆ�ª��ł’ø���ø�Ø��
HFKG\ZPPBF[RFYKKP\ICGZFMHB\,PIMPK
FSVZEKOC[O"CK\=BN",[RGFDKQNNPGEIMP\
FYCNF,CKIGEM\CKFBZ"KH"NCMKRGVKBGNF\VNN
TNVKSEZKFMGGRG\,[SEZFPYGCNPGFZZ"[[ZTCK
H"N.DOMCZFKFNTGNPKO[F\KZGVZG[KONNPGE
IMP\FYCNFCZCKO,GFZP"TPVBRGH"NPTKETNTXPG
CSVZKG,[NPECK[KCFB\SVZ"FVZES"NFZP"Y
H"NNVRKFVZY[FDKTGNKEGM\CKFBZ"KH"N,GRZBF
[BIZMLYCTNKPGECFO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,æ"�Yæ"Ł
BNGFSGEG\NBB\PSZGNMNCZR[BNBFP[MKNKO
IECEZBBG\ZKCEZB,GCEGZZCK[PTGQNBRPXBG
BNB[CTFFICZKO.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�"Æ
104NZBG\JGC
GFRFBKQCMNEGZGEGZ,[NBRPXBGCGBR[KOKIKEK
SDGNF,[[Z\FTNKFOZGIFYGE[,GFKFBNKFG
FRCKBH"NRDNFTNKFO,GPNPEBG\OS\ZKF\GZF
FHB\.
GDOCEGZKRGHF,BNFKFZB[GRKOGFBIZGRKONB
F[CK\DGBNPK[ZBN,GKYRBNBZXG,GKIPGNTNTPG,
GK[NINRGTKZGYEK[PQ[PKKBRIK\,FZCFDEGN
FBNFKFISKEPGZKGZCKKXIYNGZKBB[MRHKH"N,
PNB\GZFMZKPGQ,GMNHFF[KD[NBTNKEK[PG[
YCN\PT[KG\ISG[NGO,MKBKSGZDEGNK[C[KPG[O,
BNKFGFRCKB[FKFRDNFBNKG\PKE,GPECZTPGVFBN
VF,GNPEGHB\FIMPF.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,Ø"�
FRFFIMPFFHB\,FK\FRDNK\CB\DNKKB,TEVJKZ\
ZCK[PTGQCZKGIBK.GPBHGBKNLRS\OIHGQ...GMN
BIEPFIMPKOFKGETKOFIMPFFHB\,PBHGBKNL,
FKGTGSYKOCFCFS\ZDEGNGNBCB\DNKKB.GNBFKF
PDNFBG\F,BNBN\NPKEGFKIKECEGZG.GBUHF
CZB[KVZYKO,PVFBNVF,PDNFJVIGPMSFBNU
JVIKO.GFK\FFIMPFFHB\P\PGJJ\GP\PTJ\
GFGNM\PEGZNEGZ,TEFZPC"QH"N,BIZGQFPYGCNKO
FBPK\KKO...
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,Ø"ŁYº’
GFRFMNSVZKFPYGCNKOFBIZGRKO,[FKGBIZ
FZPC"QH"N,BN\YZCBNKFO,MKPQFZPC"QGBKNL
105 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
RS\ZFEZLFIMPFFHB\PTKRKMNFIMPKO,GNB
R[BZCFOMKBOYX\TRVKFYEPG\,CN\K[Z[KFO,
GTNKFOCRGFPYGCNKOFBIZGRKOH"NECZKFOC[MN
BRG[KGPTXPL\GMNNET\NTPGETNFPCIQ...
GBR[KNCC[PTGNK,BNKFZSGBNF’NZBG\
CSVZKFBIZGRKO,FCRGKOTNVKF[MNFBRG[K,G[GPT
NKK[MGQCJIG[BRQPVIEZTF.GNMQBRKFMG\C
FXTKZIKKOGKJBN,ZXK\KNHMG\B\FZCKOCFTNO
RPZW,GFP[MKNKOKCKRG.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,ºœÆØ��ł"Ø,�ı�ØØ��"�,��ª�œ��ł�"�Ø�"�,Ø"ŁYº’
BPZNKZCKRGFBZ"KH"N,MKNSKCF[FKK\KCDNDGN
BIEPQFYGEPKOCN\KPBPKQCIMP\SVZFHGFZ,
[XZKLT\F[BTSGY\PKECMNKMGN\KCIMP\SVZ
FHGFZ,G[HFFGBFTKYZFDEGN[BRKXZKLNT[G\T\F
CDNDGNHF.DOBPZNK,MKNSKCFFRHMZ\NTKNXZKL
BRK[NBBY[FYG[KG\ZCG\CHFZTEB[ZBNPE
TPG[PQKEGTBXNG,GBIZMLKFKFNKZ[G\NFY[G\
GN[BGNMNPF[BRKZGXFNIYGZGNKETCSVZK
FHGFZ.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,Æø�ł�����Ø�ª��"Ł
CEGZFHFFBIZGQ,PK[BKRGTGSYCSVZFHGFZ
G\KYGRKOGM\CKPZQFBZ"K[FOIKKOPP[NRV[,
CNGNFCPYZBGCP[RFGC\NPGEGVGSYKO,KETRBPRF
[MN\GZ\G[TGSYFGBP[VFGNIGW,MEGBD,GBKQNG
TSYCIKKOGFBZFNRV[,GFGBMGNGJTG\GZPBG\,
GBKRGTGSYC\GZFBNBNFKG\PBR[K[O,NFKG\ZC
106NZBG\JGC
GZB[DEGNFEGZGNF[\ZZTNFCZKG\,GBKQNGIKKO
GNBINYCIKKO...
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº� ’��Æ�’,Ø"Ł
GCEGZFHFFBIZGQBKBV[ZNFP[KL[MKR\BTNKGRF
BNBTNKEKFHGFZGM\CKPZQFZCIKKOGKJBNCNCE
[RBPZGCZGIFYGE[,GCEGZFHFPKFBK[FIVW
IKKOBGFCKPKOPCNKNCNG\KGOCN\KYEG[FNZBG\
JGCTGNOFCBCTGNOFHFKECYCSVZFHGFZGCM\CK
PZQFZCIKKOGKJBNCNCE[RBPZGCZGIFYGE[.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº� ’��Æ�’,Ø"Ł
GRBPRF\ETBIKMKNBMEGZG\FYEPGRKOGFKPKO
FZB[GRKO[FKGCBNUFIPK[KEGZG\FNNGGFKPKO
FBNFMKCBG\QKPKOFKG[TZKIMPFHGSDGZKO
GPSGDZKONMQNBFKGBHPYGCNKOBNBPTJKO.
NBMQCBNUF[K[KFHF[RV\IG[TZKBGZF
[TZKZIPKOMKFGBYZGCNT\YWFKPKQG[PIF[N
PXGFGRI\ZGIDEGNMT\CTKRKF’NF\VZSOMCGE[O
PNMG\GNTGNOGTECVZJMT\[REVSGMNM\CKM\CK
FYGE[NFBZ"KNGZKBH"NB[ZV\INRG[TZKBGZF
[FKGS\GPKOGI\KPKQCBNUTHYKQPKPG\TGNOGMN
ECZKGECZKBNYKOIKKOTNVKBNKFFRCKBHMGZNJGC
GCZ[G\GDNFPF[DNFGBKQNRGPM[GNGNB[GOSMRF
MT\MPGCRDNG\PP[.
ł’ ��æ��Ø�Æ���Øł,æ ł�ÆłØœ���Æ’,���łØ"Æ ł��’
107 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
[PT\KPVKFYEG[CT\[EKCZTPRGPDGENFTRKQ
[NSVGZKPT[KG\PXEKYKO...GBPZBH[FGBCTXPG
H"N,TKYZF\TGZZG\GNTCGE\F’K\CZLCBP\FKF
TNKEKSKVGZKPT[KG\PXEKYKO.GSKVZ[CCK\BCKG
GBPGFXEKYKOHMZGRONCZMF,FKG[MKIKO[OMN
FXEKYKO.MKMNFXEKYKOFKGPXGKKOCYFKN\
PTH’CGH’PIP\[FGBPYGOFCTN[OJGCH"N.
GZGCOMMGNOF\BMSRGCCK\BCKGH"N,G[PTFZCF
PT[KG\PXEKYKOGTNKEKHFFKFTKYZF\TGZZG\G
NF[OK\CZL,TE[HMFNPF[HMF.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,øØ�œ�ł"�,��"�
NBZYCNKPGECRDNF[OZCKRGTKGRGBHCKPKOFNNG,
BNBDOCIMP\FRS\ZFTGPE\CZGPG[NTGNO.CKPK
NKPGEGCVZT[CGZDCK[KC\ZCGFM\CSGVZFING
BKHF\NPKEKONVZGWDEZGTSYGCI[BKCIMPG\
IKXGRKG\.CFGGETFECZNZB[KFK[KCFF\IKNG
NIYGZGNEZG[TNHFGRXKDKOPKGIEKOIHZGTN
FBMSRKG\[NFCIGZKONZBG\GNFS\MNBOC\GZ\
F’\GIN\OBGCKNEKRMZKOK[VKYG.
ZCKKFGEFDZKRGGBNE[FKFBHCIGZXTKZNKPKO
RPRFTNCIKZKF\NPKEKO[FNMGNCYZCBMSKRBG\
[NFCIGZKO,MB[ZFDKTGNFBMSRKB[NZCKRGNZBG\
PFJKCGPXBGBG\GKG[CGPTKKQCTKGQDEGNCBKHF
SVZTE[NBFZDK[MKCBGBR[KONIEZG.
FOFNMGPBIGZKGGFRFZBGMQ\PFGMKCKEG
SVZFHGFZGFGBPTKKQCGGVNDKPKOKGZEKOPTKRG,
MB[ZCBGMQFNMGGFGBNBKETCCGBOGCXB\OZCK
KFGEFDZKRGGBNEP\ZD[PBGEPDGENKZB\GGJFZ\G
108NZBG\JGC
[DOCSVZMHF[OCGTKGRGGVRFBKVGBNZCGCCY[F
[FGBZGXFNNPGECXGG\BTOZCKRGN[BN\ZCGPF
HFGTNPFHFFRGP[\GYYNMLSKVZB\B[ZTKRKG
ZBGGNBHZ,ZCGFSMKOTNKEGGFGSKUNICCGCK\Z
[B\TNKZB\GFYGEP\NIMP\G.
łÆØ�ø��łØ��ª��æŁ,œ�ªœ�ł�œ�Æø�ª��"Ł
GEGEFPNLFYEG[XGFNCRGETB\BNYKBCKL
GTCEFGGTKYZKKEKTG\BPK\KG\KIGEFYEG[FGBTN
KEKFIMPFFYEG[FFNHG.
ł’ÆØ��Ø��Œø Øł��ªØ�Æ,��ł"�,�æ œ��ł"�,�œØ"�
BKNHB\CB\KNEZG[[NGOICZKKBR[KOMDKNK
NFKG\IZEKOTNECZF’NYCGTNFOT\KONTKKQCSVZ
FHGFZNKETPYGZFBGZP\GYFGBNTKRKKO.
ł’ÆØ�Øłø�Øغ�øŁØØ���ØªØŁøÆ,æł�ł�ª�ª:
CTNKFRS\Z,FOPZDK[KOPKQZKTCGQRGZBGXKPBGQ
BEKZNXKGZKOMPGSKOGRTNPKO,GF[BNG\ZPG\
FTZL,FTGNG\CZGOF\TNGPF,BKRQRG\RG\NFO
PRGIF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł Ø�ØŁ�ł
FPGM[ZNFS\MNG\FRS\ZIKFGBCBPGR\FRS\Z.
GFDNGKBXNGFGBZYFHEZIG\MFFPFRS\Z,FPBKZ
CCZYF[MN\GFDEGNF.GFF[MNFFRS\Z\FKB
PKGIE\CMNBEOCXGZFPKGIE\NG.FKBPBGDE\TO
109 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
FTXPKG\,[BKRFRMVN\,C[GOBGVQ,GBKRFRPSZ\
C[GOFDFGFSCZF.KFKGNLNCEL.GXEKYCBPGR\G,
[NGEGYB,KIKF.GP\GLFBPGRF,FPBKZF,[NG,
FPMKRFNGTEQCVRKTXPG,KGXBFGBNJKKNCIXZG\
F’,[Z[G\FZCKOPTGZC[O,GRT[K\ET\GPTGZC\
TOFCZKG\.KVXGPTKR\KLIGXF,CZICG\VNDKPKO.
GFVNDKOFNNGP\ZICKOMRFZG\P\GLFKOFDEGN
[NFBPGRFFDEGNF,FDRGHFCPTPYKFNC,GPPYGO
[FRINKOCBKO[OFO[CKONNM\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ºœÆØ�łÆ��
TPYKFSGEG\FBNFKKOV[GJFGB[BKQNFCKRO
CCKZGZOC[MNFBRG[K,BNBTNVKFYCNF,
PBR[KOPGVNBKO,[FBGZFBNFKIEZN\GLR[P\O.
GM[NGPEKOB\ECZKFO,CFMRFFZBGKF,CBF
FF[TZFFVRKPK\,GPK[C\B\FTRKRKOTNFNC,TE
[FOEGPKONPG[DKOC[MNFJCTKFV[GJ.GNTGNO
XZKMKONXZUBNFPETFHFB\MIFBP\[NFYCNF,
GBHRT[KOFECZKOPBKZKOG[PIKOMR\KR\OPSKRK,
NMNIEGIENVGOEZDKF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ºœÆØ�łÆ��
HFHPQZCB[ZPGSZMNKG\KKZEVRKKGOKGO,NXB\
PDEZKGNICZBKHFIKCGZKSGEKCECZR[P\FKFEG\
GFE\GCKEKT\PYGZKG\IMP\FYCNFGNFVKXGCYZC
FTO,CBGVQ[K[KDGP\GMGFMZG\GFCRFCMNN
FECZKOFTGPEKOCZGPG[NTGNOMZBGK,CBGVKO
GXCKGROFBPK\K.
110NZBG\JGC
GNVRKOCK[ZBN,CJZO[R\DN\FCTGNOPNBM\
FEVGS,NBFKGCYZCRGSVZKOPHGKVKOCTKRKRKO
FRGDTKONR[P\FKFEG\GMG’,P[GO[MPTJNBFKF
CYZCRGPICZCN\KBIZBKTNECZKG,GHB\PJTO
V[GJ,MKFRFBEOCN\KBIZBKTNVKZGCBKRRG
PFPVGZSPKO,NVKMLBOCPYZFKXBBIEGFTKHVRKG
NICZIKCGZMHF,FZKNBFKFMEBKN[GOPT\KY
NFT\KYB\SVZG,MKNBK[NPGNG[MZJZI\GB[Z
TNFMZDKNSMGOI[GC,GRPXB[FKFP[VJGIZGW
PBNKGNFBCEP\GLFYFN.
GCT\FFKBDOKGETKECZNBFKFNFO[GOTRKQ
G\CKTFNICZSVZKOPFSGDFR"NP[GO[FKEKTG\
FNNGBKRQRIGXG\NFPGQFTO,BNBNFKVLFKF
NFOTRKQNFS\KZFECZCIEZKIEZKO,PJTO"MCGE
BNYKOFS\ZECZ",MKRXJGKRGNFS\KZB\R[P\
F\GZFGFTCGEFPBG\O[BKROXZKMKONFBGBKRO
MEBKONF,GNBNHNHNCFGNFXKDFCINGRG\ZBGF
NTGP\\BG\O[NFPS\MNKOCBZGCG\BGCTNK
F\VBZG\,MKMQMCGEBNGYKOPIKKCBG\RG.
BGNOPT\[PNBM\FEVGSR\V[JFCTGNOGBKQ
FPICZKOXZKMKOKG\ZNPT\KYKOECZKFOGR\PTJ
FPIKZFDCGF[NFSVZ,FRFTOHFFGMQFEZLDO
NPICZKOCN\KBIZBKONPT[KFONT[G\SVZKO
MMNBG\RV[ONVZRSFGNMCGEGMEGPF,GB\TXO
PT[FKEKFOBKROPCKBKOCI[CGQGNVGTNKEKFONB
KCKJGMNN.
GPFT\FFKBF\IKNGNF\ZCG\FSVZKODOPQ
FSGDFBPGZNTKN,B[ZCNK[GONKPGEGYCNFVFBN
VFPZCPGSPLNMLGBVKNGCISZGQKEKTFCMNBG\O
111 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
FSVZKOFYEPGRKO[K[NFO[KKMG\NSGDFHF,
FGNMKOPICZKFOGPGXKBKOSCZG\PEPOGC[Z\
TXPOGPMNCGYKSZKYK,G\GNKQFECZKOCZGPG[N
TGNONXKKZCHFR[P\FBGPFGMNBGXZFFMCKZ.
GMMSKNKONBKETGNFHFZDOBKQNFOEZLNKETHB\,
B[ZPCKBKONEGZG\ETG\P[GC[G\,GC\PGZ\
\BGG\KFOFYJRJRG\IGJBKOGPIJKBKOB\FZCKO
NEGZG\.
GNBIZGRFFTNGXIROPTNFPTNF,MKDO\YTG
B\XVZRKFOCIMP\FYCNF,PCNKN[KONCB[Z
IMPFHB\RPXB\SDGZFGPSGDZ\CBNUTHYBG\
TEFKGOFHF,TEB[ZBKQKGXBGCBC\GMFNFCKQ
BUPNFBI\CP[PTG\FFZBGKFGBKQXZKLNGPZ
BKHFY[ZCKQPNFBI\NICZ\F,MKCMNFSVZKO
FBPK\KKO[R\ICZGTOFKGOBKQCFOHGN\ZPHKO
EYKO,B[ZCEGIYDEGNFPFPSVKYKOZYC[CKN
\NPKEPCKQPET\GNYCNVKZG[OPVKIMOPYGCN
GPGSPLNML.
GFRFDO"[PFYRRFYVGHG\PNJGCYTFGEDZF
CXNF"GR\ZCGCKPKRGBNFIGCZKICZB[ZTG[KO
[OPJTPKOMBNF[FPFNDGTNRV[NMNFPS\MNKO
CFO.GK[PFO[KVNKDGTGENTNG\TNZB[FVSDF
GNGYIKONFOPYGOFZBGKNZB[KFEGZG\,[TG[KO
TXPOMKGETKONCZZCKQSVZKFYEPGRKOGFZB[GRKO
H"NNFGZG\NXKCGZBKHFSVZZBGKNFDG\CGGBKHF
SVZ[BKRGMEBKNJVNCGP[GO[PNBECZKFHKF
ISG[NGO,GMEKCHKGQGYXU.
MKTET\FFK\FPNBM\FCKZGZFHB\PKGIS\
GPGDCN\ZYNBIEPT[ZFZB[KEGZG\,GT\F
112NZBG\JGC
RCTZKOK\TNNGCF.GNVKMLR[\C[FPBEET\FXCGZ
C\VKS\FTRKRKOFBNF,GTGERGSUMKRGXZFBGKZF
[NYNG\ET\GMNBIEIG[CNTXPGB[ZEKNG
CSZKYFBI\C[T\FVRBKNF\CGRQGNCYZCECZKO
R[DCKOBNG,GTGCZKOCKTUTNMNTGNOFIMPF
FDCGFGPYGZKG\R[P\FKFEG\CJKSFBI\MPG
FPNBLFRGET,GPGXKBKOPSYRG\MNBIENVKFNL
ZGIG.
GBNFFQFSKCG\[FGXKBGBG\KPIGWNDEZK,
GFINJ\KMKT\NT[G\NF’GNFXKNPF[BV[Z
TGENFXKN.GYCN\KTNTXPKNDNG\[KTGZPSGKKO
PFPYGZKG\FRGDT\NSGDFBPGZGNFVKXGCYZC
FTO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł�œ��øœ
FRFECZHFPCGBZCSVZ[TZPBPZKZ[C"KNFBZ"K
H"N,CVZ[\P[VJKOHGFZ,EUY’.GHFN[GRG:ET,MK
R[PG\FXEKYKOK[PFOPCIKR\BGZFPYKU.GK[
PFO[FOPCIKR\BGZVRKPK.GMNBG\O[FOPXE
BGZPYKU,K[CFOMINECZCRS\ZG\GSGEG\F\GZF
EZLMKSGKGFTNODEGN,MEK[NBKGCRGBNBNPK[ZBGK
NFCKRO.
GFRFZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKTNKGF[NGO,FK\F
R[P\GPXEBGZFPYKU.GNMQFKFCGMINFNCK[
FECZKOGNEGZ[O,CBGVQ[BUBOKEZ[ONZCKO,NB
KCKROBNBPK[ZBGKNFCKRO.GNMQRK\QNG"Z[G\"
NM\GCSVZFHGFZ.GNBRK\Q"Z[G\"NZCG\KGBG
NZB[GRKOB[ZYEPGNG,NM\GCSVZCIMPFFHB\,
TOFKG\[GEBKFKGKGETKOCIMPFFHB\KG\ZPPRG.
113 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
BCNFJTOFGB[NBFKFCFOMINFNCK[FECZKO
MPGFG.
GHFGPF[M\GCCZKFEKGIBKKETNBS\PZB
BZIGK)CRG[NKGIBKKETN[PGZEZMKG(.GCHF\CKQ
DGENFTNOSVZFHGFZ,B[ZM\CZ[C"K,[BKQMN
PGIGPGIKMGNNFCKQECZKG.
\PXK\ECZKG:B[ZTRKQCKBGZKECZKOCIMP\
FBP\BKRG\NGKMNNCDENG\GGYJRG\G[NFIMO
FPYGCN,BNBFGBTRKQFBZ\FR[PFFPKGIE\NECZ
HF,B[ZFBZ\R[PFHB\FKBCIKR\R\KR\"Z[G\"
PF[PKONDNG\IMPFFTNKGRF.GRPXKRGNPEKO,B[Z
PK[NBHMFNZ[G\FHB\,BSGZNGNCBZCKBGZKO
CIMPFHG,P[GO[BKRGKMGNNFNCK[FECZKOFEYKO
FFOCPNKOFP\BKPKONECZ,CBGVQ[NBKM[NG
FPTKKRKOCF.
[P[GOHFNBPXKRG[GOSVZPSGEZCIMP\
FBP\PNVRKSVZFHGFZ[NZ[C"K.MKMNFSVZKO
[YEPGFGCBG\FFIMPF,BKROPGDEZKOC[OCKBGZKO
CIMPF,BNBZYZPHKOCTNPB,GDOCNKSEZ[NYGEO
GRP[L,MRGETNPGXBKET\.TEMBQFCR\ECZKGH"N.
GK[NFGSKUMVKPF[YKCN\KPVKSGVZKOGPVK
SVZKO,B[ZPHPQZ[C"KG\NPKEKGCTNKFHGFZTE
HPRG[NFBZ"KH"N,NBFKFBUBIEPFPICZKO[KCKQ
ECZKFHGFZGF\KYGRKOMPGFBZ"KH"N.GMNFIKCGZKO
FBNG[YEPGFG,BKROBNBCCIKR\CTNKZPHCIMPF
HG.GDOSVZKFIMOFZP"YH"NCMNNO.
GDOTNFBZ"KH"NTXPGZBGKNGPZBG\O
FECZKO[BPZTNZCK[PTGQCZKGIBK.EFKKRGB[Z
NYGEPKG[NFBZ"KH"NNBRK\RFZ[G\PF[PKO
114NZBG\JGC
NDNG\CKBGZKFIMPF,GNFBZ"KH"NRK\RFFZ[G\
FHB\.CBGVQ[BKQNFCIKQMBQP[GODENG\GYJRG\
MNN,MKKMGNNFKG\[PTN\FYGEPKONGFK\FNBKQ
TZGLDEGNFPPTN\FBZ"KH"N.BPRONFONBRK\RF
FZ[G\NECZHF.GNVKMLR[PZGPNM\GCFCKBGZKO,
F[KKMKONTXOFIMPF,BNBFS\VYGCZPHKO
YXZKO,[BKRORY[ZKOHFCHFMNN.
GPJTOHF,PT\[R\DNGSVZKFBZ"KH"NCTGNO,
MNFTGSYKOCIMP\FYCNFFRKIGKEKFOPMNSVZK
FZP"YH"N,GPMNFZB[GRKOGFDBGRKO[YEPG
NFBZ"KH"N,MPVGZSOCKQFTGSYKOCIMPFHG.GMN
IKKZGIOFECKYGZYCM\CKFBZ"KH"NCNCE.CBGVQ
B[ZTKYZKFIKCGZKOFRI[CKOCCIKR\CKBGZKO
CIMPFHGMZBGKNFKG\,BKROBNBSVZKFHGFZ
GF\KYGRKOGBIZKFOSVZKFBZ"KH"N.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,�Ø�ØŁ �ºØæØŁ �ØØ�
115 FPYGCNKOGM\CKFO
BIEG\
BKQTGEPNCEG.
ªÆłØ�ª’�"�
BRKZB[GQGBRKBIZGQGPCNTEKBKQBNYKO.
Øø�Ø��"ª’
BRKZB[GQGB\BIZGRKOBRKFGB.
Øø�Ø��"�ª’
B\F[PKOGB\FBZWBRKPNB.
Øł�Ø�º"�º"ª
CMNEZMKLETFG.
�ø�Ø�’’
F’PNLNTGNOGTE.
œ��Ø�Ø’Ł"�
GR[DCF’NCEGCKGOFFGB.
Øø�Ø�Æ’Ø"�
MKPNBFFBZWETFB\F’.
Øø�Ø�Ø"�Ł’
MKPPLFMNGPKELR\RGNL.
ªÆłØ�Ø�Ø��’º"ŁØ"ª
NTGNOBN\KMRTNZD[G\CEKEG\.CMNPYGOCGB\F
RPXB,BNGFKOYZGCBNKL.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
HMGZ\IG[\FZKIGYPBNGFKOHGFKZY\IG[\L
FBK[K\,BKQHGPXKBG\.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
MNPF[BEOP\DEN,P\DENFTGNOMGNGTPG.
CEBDG\FIKKOFKGO=KGPKKO,CRMNKFVGNKJKYF,
CIMP\FIMPKOGC[DTGRG\FP[\DTKO=CMNPGVKTF
GPG[N\ZGIF’.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,º"Ł
NBTHGCFGBFJCTCPFNMG,NBBNPRFFFKSJGZKF
CFS\CMG\F.C\GMFIKDGBNIHY,BEGQMNFPT[KO,
XEKYCMNFEGZG\.FPFNMKOYCGTKOGPSGEZKO,GFMN
FGNLGBGZ.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,º"�
BKQRYGEFK\KZF:FMNRXZL,GFMNP[P[N\VYKEG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,øæ"�
PXG\KIGEF[ONFBPKQGNKET[F[OK\CZLFGB
BEGQFMNCGZBMNBIEKIKEGPKGIE.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,æ ł�Ø�ª�Æ��ª��,ªÆłØ�ª��"�
117 BIEG\
PXG\T[FNFBPKQGNKETCKEKTFGEBK\[F[O
K\CZL[FGBFVGTNNFPXKBG\,PRBXNFZB[GQTE
[KN[GNYJQ[CKO,FGBBEGQFMNCGZBMNBIEKIKE
GPKGIE,CNK[GO[K\GUINKNFGINKNFKIKEGPKGIE
[RBPZ"[PTK[ZBNFGK"FBNF"KRGFGK"FBIE"
BIEPV[JKFPXGFG[Z[KF,FMNBIE[XZKLNKET
[K[[OPXGKZB[GQENK\B\ZVRGKPRKFGFGBBIE
KIKEGPKGIENK\PI[CF\VKSBCKFMNN.
GBKQ[ONBXKGZGNB\PGRFGNBDGUGNB[GO
\VKSFCDGENBGZGGYGE[\GGIMP\GGCKR\GGET\G
G[MNGFTPGYFTEBKQSGU,GBKQNG[RKNGINKNF,
"BRKZB[GQGBIZGQGPCNTEKBKQBNY"KO"NBYEPG
GNBBIZG[GOECZ[FGBZB[GQGFGBBIZGQGFGB
RPXB\PKEFKFFGFGKFKFP[DKITNMNPT[FCRK
BEOGBNGVG[NTGNO,FGBCMN\RGTFG\RGTFGXZKL
NYCNTNTXPGNPSGZRV[GTNBPGRFHB\.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,æ ł�Ø�ª�Æ��ª��,ªÆłØ�ª��"�
BGPROBP\[F[OK\CZLFGBBIECZGLFGBGCZGL
[PG[GZ[PXGFHB\MNSVZFHGFZGF\KYGRKO
GSVZKPZQGMNSVZKFPYGCNKOR\KSEGTNSGEPXGGF
HB\.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,æ ł�Ø�ª�Æ��ª��,ªÆłØ�ª��"�
GKJTB[NCCBZ[CTGKYZBC[OF’BNTGNO.
BN\YZK"GKYZB"BNB"GKYZKB".PNPE[FYZKB
BCZFOBCKRGN[PG[NFYEG[CZGLFGBCVFMNTGCZ
118NZBG\JGC
G[C.MKXE?NBIZ[BMNGG[\G,TPEGNCZMG.BPZ
NFO:GMKP[NKBMN\O?P[NBNFKTGNOBMN\O.
FGEGG[CIGGCZMGNPK[BPZGFKFFTGNO.
æŁ�,Ø’,�’
BOMNCRKFBEOFKGP[KDKOPG[MNG\[GG\GRJKG\
[GG\,CNK[GOFCENMNNGMNN,BHFKGCBP\MN
FRV[G\[NCRKFTGNO,NRV[BI\\I[C.GTZMF
FKF,MPGBGZF[P[[P\NC[FBGZCMNCRKFTGNO,
GPMNPYGONBRCIKQMNN[K[XGZG\RCENG\CBGZ
F[P[,MPGMQFK\FRV[P[MN\BI\P\NC[\
CFZCFDGVKO,MKFPYGPG\BKROPCEKNKOMNNCMN
ECZZGIRKBONBK[C\MGR\OXGZG\RCENG\.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł Ø�º�
CCZKBFBKQ[GOMGIBIZIGWPFCGZBTXPG,
[\FKFNGKMGN\NVTGNGNT[G\P[FG.NTK\KOFBEO
ZGBF,[K[ROECZKOGMGIG\CTGNO,[PMIK[KO
CTKRKGB\KIGEKG\GG[NKJ\G[NFCGZB.FSKCFNML
FKB,[MLZGXFGTG[FFCGZBCTXPG,MEKN\YQB\
FBEO.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łÆ’,��Ø�øºØ�œ�Æ��œ�
NPZG\FFVZTG\BEOIKKCNF[\ENNFKG\\PKE
ECGYCCGZB,[MNPI[CG\KG\FKKRF\NGKG\\PKE
CCGZB.GBUTNVK[RPXBCPXCFMKDZGT,CKZKEF
FMK\NGNF=DOBH[NBKXBPZ[G\FCGZB,MNGPZ
[NBKI[GC[K[RFZ[G\BIZ\IGWPFCGZB,BG
[K[RGBKH[FGMGIBIZ,MGIJGPBF,[NBRG\QNG
119 BIEG\
NFMRSNZGIRKG\,FKKRG[BGNKP[FGBIZKMGNNFJKC
NGBGNFZTNG.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łÆ’,��Ø�øºØ�œ�Æ��œ�
MPGMQM[PZDK[[RPXBCTNKF,FKKRGPZDK[JTO
CZGIRKG\,\[GYFGF\ZGPPG\ZGIRK\=BNKBPZ
[TM[KGFGBPCKQ[MEBKNTHGCFMNNPTQNFDKT
NZGIRKG\.BNBXZKLNET\,[TM[KGFGBPXBIQCTKRK
FCGZB,GNMQFCGZBPYZCG,GNMQFGBPZDK[TM[KG
JTOCZGIRKG\.GKHFZ[[GCNBKI[GC[K[VGTNCTGNO
IGWPFCGZB.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łÆ’,��Ø�øºØ�œ�Æ��œ�
PJZ\FCGZBCCZKB\BEOFKB,NFCKBB\FBEO
N[NPG\GRKXIKG\,[CMLFBEOK[\GGFNCGZB.GMEK
NF[KD[NPG\HG,FBEOXZKLN[NGNB\FBDGBKHO
[CG,ML,[KuPIBLGZYPHF[K[RI\ZGINCGZB,
CHFPJZ\GCCZKBFNFJKCNRCZBKGP\YKKP\.GCML
P\ICZKOFCGZBGFBEOC[NPG\NRKXIKG\.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łÆ’,��Ø�øºØ�œ�Æ��œ�
ETMKMNF\GZFMGNFFKBMPGVKZG[N[OF’
K\CZL,GHFSGE"\GZ\F’"CGEBK...MNF\GZFMGNF
RBDZ\TNFMKRGKKO,TNF[PG\,GF[PG\FYEG[KO
120NZBG\JGC
MGNO\NGKKOTN[OF’GMGNOP\BIEKOCG.RPXB\
MNF\GZFMGNFRBDZ\TN[OF’.
ł’Øæ�Æ��Æł���’Ø�ŁØ��,ø�łØ�ł�
KGETKOBRIRG,[FKXZFZTGFKXZFJGCKXKZFBI\
FKBPKEKBNTGNO...FMNIJKCFBI\FKBGFMN
TGNFCPTNG\FYGE[GP[GTCENZXGQDCGF,FMNFGB
"BPZ\KGRT[FZXGRK".
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,º"ª
PK[NBPYG[ZTOMNNK[ZBN,[GNJBXNGF[YZ,
FKVGMG[NFY[Z.
�łÆØ������ª����
FFGKFFPT[FFCIKZK[NFBEOGZXGRGFYCGT,FRO
[N[N\BI\DEGNF,[PTGNOBKROR\YKOBIE
PICZG.IVWFBEOY[GZCPT[KG.DOFPT[KO[N
FTCZBKROR\YKOPPFG\FIKKOGFIVWCPYGZG,
MKGGQ[BKQECZP\R\YNDPZK,K[CKEFIVWNFJCKT
XCKGQPKGIEDOTNFPT[KO[TCZG.GHFGSGEF\[GCF,
[CZBBG\FFYC"FYGEO[CZBB\FTGNO,MNGPZ:
FZIKCB\MIFKXKZFFRV[K\FZGIRK\CKIGSFBN
FPT[KOGFFGKF,TE[F\FKF\GVS\CZ[G\FDO
B\FTCZ.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł�’,æ�Ø��’
TGPEFBEOG\GFF,BKHFXGZLK[CMNFPGQ
FPT[KOGFCZGBKOFP[GRKOGFZCKO,GBKRRGPCKQ
BKLFMNFGBIJKCFDEGNFBI\...BKQRYGEFYJRF
121 BIEG\
K\ZF,FMNRXZLGFMNP[P[N\VYKEG.B\FCMNPF
[NPJFPPL,GFRLY[GZGTGNFTOMNPF[R[DC
PPLGTGNFTNKL.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,øæ"�
DOMNF[PG\GFMKRGKKO,CKQFTCZKKOGCKQFNGTHKKO,
BKRORG\RKOMKBORKXGWYJQGMFFPBGZFXVGQ,
[FR[PF[GYY\NGGBGPZ\NG:"BNGFKO".MN
FDEZFCBNGFG\PCKBFNKEKMVKZF,FFDEZFFKB
BNKNKG\ZGIRK\.BVKNGFDEZ\F[MNGFZXGQGBVKNG
FBNGFG\TXPFG[OBNFKOFDEZFFKB,GPCNTEK
FKEKTFFTNKGRF,[MNBNFBKROMKBOFHZIG\
RKXGXKG\PPF[NPTNFPFDEZF,FKGDOFOPCKBKO
NKEKMVKZF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,�º"ªY�º"�
[\KRJKG\P\ZGXXG\FRRGVGD[KOCRV[FBEO,
N[\KPDPG\PIGNVG\.RJKFNPNBB\MN[BKV\
FZT,B\MNF\BGG\FKG\Z[VNG\,CKQPXEFIGPZ
CKQPXEFZGI,[FQTGEP\ZICG\GPSCMG\CTGHQ
B\FBEO,MYRBFG[RBFGMKGXBCFQ.
GNTGP\FNBRGMNNF\TNOPNZBG\B\[BKV\
FJGC,FP\DNFNVTPKOCZGIG[NBEO[MNFTGNO
MGNGMEBKFGBNF,NF[MKNGGNFKJKCG,GNPNBG\
BG\GISEBFCFGBGZF.BCNMNRJKFIVXFNF\DEZ
CNCEFGNFKG\FKBF[NJ\CYZCFNCGPNBFB\
MNZGIGRV[.GFRKDGEFHFFGBPZTK[B\FNC
GPPNBB\FIKKOINING\,GFBEOP\BPW\PKE
122NZBG\JGC
BKLNF[NKOCYZCGF[NPFVRKPK\GCNCE[KIENG
PPRGPXGYG\RV[G.
GF[NGOP\GMRQTNKEKMCK[\BIEPQFXEEKO
CEZLMRKTFNXEF[RK,BGPF[FGBNPTNFPHF,CEZL
MZK\G\CZK\GF\BIEG\DPGZF,CBGVQ[FXEFPRDE
P\FVLMGNG,TOMNMGIG\KG,NFXE[MRDEGNIO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,��"Ł
FGDNPFCK[ZBNF[BKVFBNF[NGOFTNKGQ,F[NGO
FBPK\K[FGBCJGICRXIGRG,BUTNVK[EZMGZIGYF
GFKBTGPE\CY[ZPNIPFRDEF[BKVFFFVGMF,B[Z
SGVFNKVGNGNFGMKIB\BVSG\FNTKQMNGBHKFKFF’
BIEG[PGBIE.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,��"ŁY�"�
FRV[ZGIFBEOCTZLNDGVG,[FORG[BKOMNML
ZIGYKOHFPHF,B[ZZYCVNKBG\TGNOFOY[GZKO
HFCHF,KSGEY[GZOFGBNBPXETZMOCPFG\O,MK
FTZLFPCEKNCKQZGIGIGPZFKFXZKLNFZIKYO
GNVHZOHFPHF,BCNICGZOGBIGEOCBPMIFVNB
FTNKGQ,[FMNPBGIECBIEG\G...GBKQFCENGFVZ[
PXKEGGNBZKIGYTZLCKQZGINIGPZ.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��œł�Ø"��’,�’
NMNFFCENKOFBGVKRKKO,MNFPZIYKOFPCEKNKO,
K[TZLGKISZYMNVKFKXGZKOGTZMO,BCNMNVKKGXZ
MN=FMNCBIE,FMNKGMN,GMNNOKIE.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���ł�Ø��’,�’
123 BIEG\
FCRFV[GJFGK[ZF[MNPF[BRGZGBKO,[GPTKO
GPZDK[KO,PMNFTRKRKOGYNGIGPZPTRKRKOFPGSZKKO
GF[MNKKO,GCKG\ZPTRKRKOFBNYKKO,FMNFPFC\GZ
PNCG[KO,[PG\,[\I\ORPXB\GLTXPK,NKG\ZYKKO
GKG\ZIKGBIEG\K,[CHFFMNP\BIE.
MNFF[MNG\[NRGFRQXEEKOBIEKOPFXGZF
FVRKPK\FP\DNFTNKEKFXKGZKOFVRKPKKOCINYKO
KEGTKO,MF\DNG\INYBIEPQFKONTGPECXKEG,
GEGYBTNKEKIKCGZBGVYKOZCKOP\YZC\FFMZF
NKEKFMN,BUTNVK[FOGEBKRZBKOMSG\ZKOHF
B\HF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"Ł
FRRGP\ZGPPKOPBG\FF[VNG\FPINY\CKQFZGI
F="[PK"GF="BZK".B\MNFBEOCZBF’CXNPG.
BPROFTRVKOFGNMKOHFNKPKQGHFN[PBN,BCN
FMNTGNFNPYGOBIE.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
FRFFGFKEGTNMNMK\MNK\CZKB\FTGNOFGB
C[CKNF\DNG\PNMG\GK\CZL,EBKQPNLCNBTO.TO
PN[GQTGPPG\,[FOECZKORVZEKOGHZKOGZIGYKO
PPTN\FPNL.MKBKNGBVKNGFKGNGCRKOZCKOPBGE
NB[KKL[OPNGMFTNKFO,GMQBVKNGTN[ZKONCEO.
ZYCZGCTOEGGYBFEZ\PNL.G[OFPGZFTN
PE\PNMG\GK\CZLFGB[OBERG\,MKFGBBEGQMN
FBZW.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,œ�Ø�,ø�ł�Ø�ª�����, ł��’
124NZBG\JGC
TRKQF[DIFVZJK\FGB,ENBHGCNCEEMNVZJK
\RGTG\FRCZBKONPKRKFOFOCF[DIFVZJK\,GFKB
FKBIKG\FRCZBGYKGPG,BNBTGEHB\E\RGTFVZJK\
[NRCZBK[NFKISMNNKNMNNG\MGGR\FCZKBF.
ECXKZGUGBKIGEMNFVTGNG\FVZJKG\R[NPFMGGRF
FTNKGRFCSGEFCZKBFMGNF.
GK\CGRQFBEO:GPFBO\RGT\T[CCBF
CF[DIFVZJK\GRGDT\NF[NP\MGGR\FCZKBF,PKQ
FPECZCMNNGK[ZBNTOYZGCGCVZJTNBI\MPF
GMPF.
���Ø�Ø�,º"��ø�
MKXZKMKOPBGEN[PGZB\FHMZGQ,[NBKVGN
N[MIF,CIKR\PK\\FNC.GTKYZFHMZGQFGBNHMGZ
\PKECTNPBEB\K)FTGNOFCB(,[NBKFKFCET\G,
ISG[NGO,[BKQTGNOBNBBIE.GTNKEKPF[PECY
PI[C\GCTNPBEB\K,TNKEKHFRT[FKIGEF’BNYK.
GCIKRFHG,NHMGZ\PKECTGNOFCB,EFKKRGNB\ECYB
PI[C\KFCTNPBEB\K,FGBCMNNKG\GVZJKG\.
CMNNKG\MLZBGKNFKG\PRFDKZBKF[O,\MUCCGYZ
CFYKXG,YGEO[K\IKN[GOECZ,KHMGZPKECTNPB
EB\K.
łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,��ŁØ��ł"��"ª
GFTRKQMKTKYZPI[C\FTNKGQZB[GRFFGBNFKG\G
PJKCNHGN\GKPNGLTNKFO,GKYCNGBG\OFHGN\FO
MNFRPXBKOPZGOFM\ZGTECZKBFYNF[CCZKG\
[FOCKXKMKRKOPNMG\GTNKFO,GTKRKFOBNKGK[CZGQ,
125 BIEG\
GKMKZGGKETG[FGBFPJKCNFO,GKPNKMGFGTNKFO
KYCNGJGCGG[VTG.
�łÆ�ø���łª�ÆØł�,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�"
MK\MNK\FR[PFCCBFNDGU,[\HMFCTGEF
PNGC[\CDGUN[GCN[Z[FGNFECYCGK\CZL,MPG
[M\GC:"NBFCFB\F’BNGYKMOGNNM\CMNEZMKG
GN[PGZPXG\KGGNECYFCG".FRLZGBF[DPZFTRKQ
FGB"GNECYFCG".EFKKRG,MPG[FK\FJZO
F\NC[G\FCDGU.
BCNXZKMKQFMRFEZCF,=[FGBNNM\CMNEZMKG,
GPKKGETEZMKF[K"\?BPROH"S"BGZKK\B[K[CF
\ZK"DBGZIKQ",[FFGNLTNKFOSGVG[KHEML,TE
[DGVGNBKFGGFPIKXF[NCZHNCKRGNCKQYGRG.MPG
[M\GC:"GFSKZG\KB\NCFBCQPC[ZMO",GBH,
K\ECYCYGRG,PP[MPG[FKFECGYJZOF\NC[G\
R[PFCDGU.
RPXB[K[NL[NG[CIKRG\:
B.K[ZBN,FGBFPKKDTB\TXPGN[GCN[GZ[G.
C.FYEG[CZGLFGB,[FGBF[GZ[[BNKGP[\GYY.
D.FGBCIKR\\ZK"DBGZIKQEBGZKK\B,B[ZTNKFO
PHMLRV[GGDGVG,[FGBSGEF\CNKQ,MPG[M\GC
"CZB\KKXZFZT,CZB\KNG\GZF\CNKQ".
BLCBP\FRK[N[FBIEFOPP[,[MQCSGVG[N
ECZMNTGCEF’,P[KDBG\OCCIKRFBI\KIKEF
GPKGIE\.GPF[RZBF[PIGNYKON[N[F,FGBCTZL
FCN\K[NOCTCGE\F’K\CZL.
�łÆØ��ª��ø�,�łœª�æ"ª
126NZBG\JGC
GCZB[GRFXZKMKONFCKQB\FCGZBK\CZL,B[ZFGB
"FJGCFPGINJ".MNGPZ[BKBV[ZC[GOVRKO
[CTGNO,[KDZGONPK[FGBXTZMN[FG,[HFGPGCQNRG
MPGPG[MNZB[GQ.CB[ZF[MNFCZKBPZBRGCTNKN
B\FCSKSNMNTG[KZTG\,[FGBPGDEZBLGZY
"CZXGQNYCN".VKZG[,[P\GL[NFGJBIZKYCN\
JGCFNF[NP\GTXPG,FRFP[GOHFKGXBNFZT
NHGN\GP\GL"FZXGQNYCN"B\F[NP\GTXPG.CBGVQ
[BOFCZKFNBFK\FPGXB\[GOYGZ\ZGICTE
TXPF,NBFK\F[GOCZKFCTGNO[\ZTNHGN\F.
GBONVTPKOBRGPGXBKOBKHGCZKFFPHKYF
NHGN\FCNK[GO"ZXGQNYCN"FRBFNTXPF,BKRF
TG[FHB\ZYP\GLFZDNYEGO,[FDKTNFP\GLFZXGQ
NYCN,B[ZFFZDNVGJZBG\FT\FPMNSCFIE[F,
MRGET.GP\GL[FCGZBK\CZLPGCQNRG[FGB[NO
PTXPG,GBKRGRXZLNPK[FGB[KTHGZNGNF[NP\G,
NFKG\GYEPGQNMNECZ,BOMQCZGZFGB,[BKQNG[GO
"ZXGQNYCN".GMKGQ[BKQNG[GOCIKRF[N"ZXGQ
NYCN",PPKNBBKQNG[GOCSKSNFZTNPK[FGB.
GHFGV[GJC\MNK\FV[JG\.
GNBTGE,BNB[PYGCNGP\KK[CTNNCRGC\MNK\
FV[JG\CPG[MNZB[GQ,[K[NG"ZXGQNF[VKT"JGC
BNHGN\G,EFKKRGNRCZBKG.[HFPGMINRGPMNFCZKBF
FDEGNF[CZBGTZLNTKRKRG.MKCFMZI,[K[MBQ
CTGNPRGCZKG\[PZDK[G\BGFZD[FJGCFBGFZD[F
ZTF.GBKHGFZD[F[FQPZDK[G\,CFMZIFGB,
[RDZP\NFOPFCGZBK\CZL.
GBIZ[KEGTCCKZGZDPGZ,[BKQCIGYFCGZB
K\CZLNFZT,MPG[R\CBZ,BOMQCFMZI[MNFCZKG\
127 BIEG\
PYCNKOFKPRGK\CZLJGCG\CNCE.FZK[CZBB\
FCZKG\ZYMEKNFJKCNFO.RPXBRGNPEKO,[K[NG
K\CZL"ZXGQNF[VKT"JGCCNCE.GC[GOBGVQ[CTGNO
NBKXGKKZCIGYGDZO[NFKHYGXTZ,[KFKFRP[L
FKPRGK\CZL.
GTNMQDEZRGBG\GK\CZLC[O"FJGCFPGINJ".
GBIZK[KETRGB\HF,RZEGRS\MNCPXKBG\FPP[K\
FP\RFN\GPG[DI\TNKEGK\CZL,BKLFGBK\CZL
P[VKTNFOZYJGCCNCE.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��œ�ªœ�Łłœ�
128NZBG\JGC
[PIFG\TRGD
BH\\TRDTNF’.
Øø�Ø��"�Ø"ª
MKC[PIF\XBGGC[NGO\GCNGQ.
Øø�Ø��"�Ø"Æ
XEKYKOKG[CKOGTJZG\KFOCZB[KFOGRFRKOPHKG
[MKRF.
ÆłºœØ"�
GMNFXEKYKOKG[CKOTNMSBG\QGBGMNKQG[G\KQ.
æªłłÆ��ł����,�ªØøø�Ø�ت
BLJGCGISEKZEVGRKMNKPKIKK.
œ��Ø�º"�’
B[ZKMNKZBF’FFGNLCEZMKG.
œ��Ø��º"��’
GTNMNV[TKO\MSFBFCF.
�ø�ØØ’Ø"Æ
MKCZGCFVTPKOPCY[KF’FROPEG[RKTGRDGPRGIF
VRKPK\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’, "�Y "Ł
FRV[FBGFC\FKBNTGNOKG\ZDEGNFGBZGMF
PFRV[FBFGCF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøª’,œ"
M[PS\MNKOCBP\CXEFJGC[NMNBIE,P\BFC
FBEOTNFCZKG\CIKCFVRKPK\,GBKRGHYGYN[GO
BCY[NIRGVF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’,øº"ª
M[P[\NFC\FBFCFNBNGYKO,BKQNFKCFNP[GO
I[CGQ:
PXGGFNF\TRDTNF’CPNGBZGICFNC,GNVXGI
C[KZKHPZF,N[BGCPKO=IKKOPPTKKRKFK[GTF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøª’,ø"
NFNFKCNCCG\K[ZBNN\GZFGNTCGEFCIMPF
FVRKPKG\P\GYFPEC[GRGV\XGUPBKZG\TKRKO
GP[KCG\RV[IPGEFDRGHFP\GYFBGZNTKRKOGJGC
NRV[NHMMFGNFBKZFCPEG\JGCG\K[ZG\NJTGO
JTOBGZFDRGHNTGNOFCBCTGNOFHFTNKEKIMP\
FHGFZ.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�œØÆ�œØŒ,Æ��ª��
GNVKHFKGXB,PK[FGBZGBF,[BKQNG[PIF,MPG
[K[NBR[KOBIZKO,FSKCFNHFFKB,[FGBTGPE
CPEZDFKG\ZDCGF.NMQFGBXZKLNET\,[F’PSCCNG
130NZBG\JGC
FFHEPRG\,[K\IKNNTSGYC\GZFGTCGEF.GHFKCKBNG
F[PIFBPK\K\,[RYZB\[PIF[NPXGGF.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ��Æ’,���łœ�Ł",��ø���
\GMQFIGNBKRGMKBOPSGFFPS\KZ,FVGTN\TNGPF
TNMNHFZKFBGZF[NFIKKOFRIPEKOGFICKCKO,
[PRGTOF’FPFPVMKOGFGNMKOCPNGBTGNPKO,
CPNGBR[PG\GCPNGBIKKRGVRKPF.FYGE[CBCPGTEG,
GPSKZB\FXTKU,PDNFB\VRKFNGJ,GFBGZFFYEG[F
CMNIPEG\KF,FRFRZBF,GPNCC\FKBBG\RGCRTKPG\
[KIKF,PZGFBG\RGRI\P[GE\TRGDKF,GFRRGP\TRDKO
TNF’GTNJGCG,GNCCRGP\PNBZGOGTEQ,CZKGGK
\TRGDKO,BH\\TRDTNF’.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"�
GTNEZLF\[GYFGF[PIFGFPRKTFCF[DFCBNFG\,
XZKLNFSCKZML:MNHPQ[REPFNRG[BRGTGPEKO
CPXCPFG\KPKGIE,RVZEPFTRKQFBNFK,BKQFBNFG\
PG[D\NRG,GP\GLMLBRGP[\GYYKONF[D\FF[NPF,
FPTGZZ\CRG\[GYF[NECYG\VRKPK\,FP\DNF
C[MN,CZD[,GCPT[F,CECGZGC\RGTF,GCEPKGQ.
GP\GLF\[GYFF\PKEK\BRGPGSKVKO\PKE
FMRFNTNKFFTNKGRF,[FRRGCBP\IKKOCBNFKOIKKO
GMNVZJ[NPI[CF,FPCZZNRGB\PRKT\FF[DF
FBNFK\[CPXCRG,PGMKINRGB\FTGZGQ[NRG,GFRRG
FGNMKOGP\VYIKOGFBGZFGNLGP\DNFHFGKSGE
FVGTNB\F[PIF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�"�
131 [PIFG\TRGD
FBEONBRCZBBNBNF\TRDTNF’=\TRGDHF...FGB
F\GMQFJFGZ[CBKEKBNKG\FKG\ZJFGZF,[BKBV[Z
NCJBFC[GOFDFBRG[K.PGZD[\FKBFZD[FPGTJ\
C[BKV\FNCFJFGZCF\TNG\GPTNMNFPXZKO
FPXPXPKOBG\G.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�æł��ªø,�æ"�
PF[BRKPZDK[TGRDGRI\CTSYFRS\ZG\FBNGFKG\
CFZICFGIGV[,HB\FKBTKYZPJZ\K.MNF\VYKEKO
[NK\ZFM[ZGRG\,FPT[KKOGF[MNKKO,BKROMKBO
JVNKONPFG\K.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł Ø�ØŁ�ł,�"�
PXKB\[PIFBPK\K\FKBFY[F[CP[KPG\
FZGIRKG\.BOFEZLFKIKEFN[PIB\TXPLFKB
CT[KK\PT[F[JG\K[BKRGVGDTCHGN\,T[FHB\.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
MPG[FBEOP[DKINVTPKOCSVZFHGFZG\KYGRKO
GBHK[NG\TRGDPBGEGF\TRGD[NFKIGEFRHMZNTKN
FGBKG\ZZGIRKCPTNF.
� œ Ø���"�
FYCNFFPT[K\ZGBFB\FMNCPXKBG\.K[CF
FZCF[PIF,PXEFDGENFKGVKFJGCGF\VBZ\.BPRO
K[CFDOMQFZCFTXCG\,GRJKG\SKDGVKG\,PXEFZT,
FHGFPBGFJGPBF,[FBEOPNGVUCF,CTGRG\KG,
GTGRG\BCG\KG,TGRG\FTGNO,GIJBKFTGNPG\,CRJK\
ZXGROFPGDCN.FXKGZNF\R[BGNCJNB\MNFZT
132NZBG\JGC
GFISZGQNBKGMNN[RG\B\FPXKBG\.TNMQFKB
PNBFMGCEZB[.FYCNFFTKGRK\,FKBFBKEKBNK\,
[CKG\ZR\CBZFCISKEG\FIE[F,[NFEGZG\
FSPGMKO,FKBPCBZ\FMNCBGVQXKGZK.FJGCFGB
FPGINJ,FTGPE,GFZTBKRGMKBOEPKGRK.BOMQK[
CCKZGZFET\,GFDCZ\FZGI,NFVLFMNNJGC,GBKQ
PYGONTXCGRG\,ZY[PIF,GZGPPG\R[PF,XZKL
NPNBB\FMN.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ºœÆØ�łÆ��
MKFTGSYCIMPFFHB\GPPNBVKG[IGYCGPPNB
NCGKZB\[PKOGKZB\IJBGKGSKUBGPWCTCGEF...
KZBFBNFBEO[PIFCRV[CKZB\F’MBNGTGSY
TOFXEKYKOCDQTEQ...MKBKQSVY[HFTKYZTSY
F\GZFCDQTEQCKQFXEKYKO.
�ø�Æ�Ø��Æ�łªÆØł,�ł�"�,�ł��łÆ,�����ØøØ ł�Æ’
XZKLNTCGEB\F[OK\CZLC[PIFGCECKYG\
CFZIC\FET\,NF[KDPPNMG\TEIMPF,FPIKF
B\MGNO,NF[KDPGIKQYEG[KOGIEGG\BE[PT\B,
MNBIENVKPT[KGJGTOPBGZF\GZF,MKMLEU
DPZBGVZYP[RKG\PIKFPP[FRV[,GCVZJSVZ
FHGFZTNMGNO,GNT[G\FPXGG\C[PIFGPZGCMN,
MKFOPP[IKKRGGIKG\RV[RG,IKG\G\TRGDPP[K,
PZGCMN.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº� ’�ø ŁØ�ª��"Ł
133 [PIFG\TRGD
FVTGNFFZTFFGNM\GP\DNDN\,PSCC\MTGZGZT,
FVSEGMNKGQ,MNHPQ[NBFJCKTFZXGQTNKFXCKGQ
IE[.FJCKTTNKFFZXGQXCKGQ[NJGC,PDNDN\FKB
TXPFJGCGRGTO,IEG\F’GBGZG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł�’,æ�Ø��’
FFXNIFGFBG[ZFBPK\KKOB[ZFOVZKMN
FCZKBFGMNIVWGMNK[TFOKEKT\FKKIGE[M\CRG
MKFGBFET\B\F’,GMNPF[KGSUFPKIEKEKTF
GF[DFCKKIGEFRFPGSKUET\GF\GZFGPXGG\KF
SGCCG\TNHFGFOFEZLNKEKTFHG[FGBFKKIGE
GHGN\OBKQ[OKKIGEGNBET\F’GBKBV[ZNF[KDHF
FET\MKBOCTSYF\GZFGPXGG\KFGPFOR[MKN
BGVQFT[KF[FGB\YGQFMCGEGFGBFKKIGE.
łÆØø���Æ��ªłœ,łøÆ"�,�ƪœ��ªø,����œº�Øœ ł��’
BKBV[Z[KTNFKEKT\HFF\YGQGBGVQT[KK\GBO
NBKFKFFP\GYQPPGNBCR[P\F\GZFFKBIMP\
FYCNFFTGSY\CFK[Z\FET\B\F’[FGBKKIGEG
MKEGT. ...MKPNCEFKG\FTGSYCFGP[KDFKGETB\
F[OGP[KDS\ZKF\GZFGJTPKFPXG\FP\GYKO
PEC[GRGV\XGVKOB[ZPXEOFKBP[KC\RV[GHF
MKFRV[P\IHY\CFOGRECY\TOYGRFTGEKP[L
PPRFT[KK\FPXG\M\YGROCBFCFZCFMKFKB
FPNFC\B\NCKGETKFNT[G\OC[NPG\O.
łÆØø���Æ��ªłœ,łøÆ"�,�ƪœ��ªø,����œº�Øœ ł��’
134NZBG\JGC
GPK[IRRGFBNGKDTGPXBGF[\ENGHMFNF[KDINY
FIMPFFPG[DCTGNOFHF,HMFNJTGOCTGNOFHF
YX\P\TRGDFTGNOFCB,GTGE[TNKEKF[D\HFFINY
K\TGZZGBNKGFZCFSVKYG\G[BNG\[BKBV[Z
NF[KDOBNBCTGNOFR[PG\.GMVK[KTGZF[BNG\
[PGNKMFFR[PFPFTGNOFHFNTGNOFR[PG\MQFGB
[KTGZF[PIF[P[KDCTGNOFR[PG\,GM[K\GZXGNG
FSVKYG\[KFKGNGGTGEK\TGZZGNGSVKYG\BIZG\
FZCFPBGE[BKBV[ZNKK[COBNBCF[D\FR[PG\
BIZF\IKF.
�Æł��Æ��łªºØ����Ø,��ª�œæ ł�ł������’ "�
GCT\[B\FTG[FFPXGGFB\FPMGKQCFMRTF
GCKZBF,NTGZZNPTNFFPYKVKQGFPGIKQ,BUTNVK
[BKQB\FKGET[GOPFG\,NBFPYKVKQGFPGIKQGNB
C[GOECZ...
BUTNVKMQCKEKT\LB\FPTGZZB\PXKBG\O,
BL[BKRLKGETPFG\ORP[LBNKLBGZDEGNGB\F
TGCEB\F’C[PIFGCJGCNCCPP[PZGCMNFDGEN
BGZFPBKZTNKL.
GCVZJCT\NKPGESVZFHGFZ,[PP[F[MKRF
[GZFTNKLGFYC"FPBKZTNKLBGZGIKG\,GCNCE
[\FKFNLFMRT\BP\.GTGE[\HMFTNKEKNKPGEHF
NFKG\TVZGBVZGNSCGNKKSGZKOGIKZGVKOGEK[G\
TYC,[\FKFCTKRKLMBSYGVFF\I\GRF[FMNE[KQ
TNKL,GF[OK\CZLKTHGZNLCFZIC\FPGIKQ[N
FYEG[FGCRGTOHKGF[MKRF,[NB\ZDK[PMNBNF
135 [PIFG\TRGD
[GOFZD[MNNGMNN,BNBFZIC\FET\GFPGIKQ
P[PI\RGTOHKGBGZ[MKR\G[K[ZFTNKL.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�œØÆ�œØŒ,�œØÆ�Ø�ª,øÆØ��’�œÆ’
S\ZK\GZFP\BIEKOC[PIF.FBEOPGXBNGB\
MNZGICNCCG,B\MNBKEKBNKG,P\PNBKOTNKEK
IMP\FBP\FTNKGRF,[BKRFP[GTCE\NBG\GFPXZ
FEIGY[NFDKGQNCFBEO,TNVKFY[KGFPXGPXPKO.
TNMQKPNB[PIFGDKN\XEKYKO,MN[KGSKUNFKG\
IKCBPGR\G.FPETFBRG[KFPXGPXOFGBMNKFDGQ
NTYZTNKEGBG\OF[Z[KOFHZKO[NFEPKGRG\
FMGHCKO,[FOXZKMKONFTYZ,FOFOMNFEPKGRG\,
[KSGERJK\OFGBCTZG\FBEOGRJK\FZ[T[CG.
BCNF[PIFFDEGNF,FPPNBFB\FNCIEG\YGE[,
PVRK[P[BNG\KGFTNKGRG\P\PNBG\,HGBKRRFCBF
MKBOTNKEKZHK\GZF,[PXKDKONVRKFBEOB\
FBSVYNZKBFPBKZF[NR[P\G,FIKF,FTNKGRF,
MPG[FKB.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ºœÆØ�łÆ��
CHPQ[TGSYC\GZFBHKXZKLNFP[KLPBGZGBHKFGB
FHPQN[NKPG\,MKPGMZIKONFBPKQMPG[BPZGIH"N
PP\RFRINKBN,[F\GZFRYZB\CIK’P\RF,FKKRGMK
B\HFRG\RKONFBEONNPGEGNF\VNNGNT[G\PXGG\
BVKNGZDTBI\CKGODOHFP\RFPB\F[K"\,MK
K[MPFPNKBZEKOCTGNO[F[K"\NBR\QNFOB\
FFHEPRG\[KFBNFOFBV[ZG\NI[GCPF[K"\
BVKNGZDTBI\C[RFNMQCHPQFF\TSYG\C\GZF
136NZBG\JGC
XZKMKONFKG\C[PIF,MKZYTNKEK[PIFHGMKQ
NFP[KLPBGZF\GZF.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,��łœº"ª
MNTCGE\RGNDNG\BFCFCYZCRGCMNKGOGKGOPP[
[GFC[GFMPGC[T\FYCNF,EFKKRGNFZCG\GNFVZG\
F[MNC\GSVG\PZGCG\TNFTKYZ,TE[F\GSVG\
CZMFEF[\BKFKFRGDTCIG[KO[NRGMPGP\RF
FTKYZK\CVTOFZB[GRF,GNHFXZKMKO\ICGNG\
DEGNG\GTZGMG\NT\FXGZL.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª��"�
NBISZNLKG\Z,BNBNF\IHYCTGNF\GZF,[BKQ
KXZFZT[GZFBNBCNCVRGKPIMPF,GNF[PZPBE
PTXNG\,MKCTXN\KOKPLFPYZF,GFKBFYNKVF
FKG\ZY[FCTGNO,GFMNNVKZCFPT[F,GSKPQ
NTXNKOFKBFTXCG\,GSKPQNHZKHKOFGBF[PIF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª� ’
137 [PIFG\TRGD
HPQG\RGTF
NMNHPQGT\NMNIVW.
���œ�’�’
MKBNU[RKOCTKRKLMKGOB\PGNMKKTCZ.
œ��Ø�’ª’
BMQ\ET,[F\RGTFFZGIRK\BKRRFM\RGTFFPGI[K\
PPYGONPYGO,BNBFMGRFFKBTNF\IE[G\FXGZF,
[MNIKEG[XGZFBRGPMRKOC[O\RGTF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,œ��ª�øł�æ Øłœ,����’,�机�œ �Ø�Øœ, ł�Ł’,�œ�"�
GECZFHPQCFDEZ\GFZGIRK,\CKQ,MKMNTKYZPG[D
FHPQBXNRG,BKRGBNBFZD[[N\RGTG\.MKPGI
FPEPF[CBEO,PXKKZGPZYOPSVZPSGKKO[N
\RGTG\,[FZDK[CFQCHGBIZHG,GPT\KYOCEPKGQ
"HPQ"PSGKO.CBGVQ,[BOFKFFBEOTOSCKC\G
CPXC[NPRGIFPGINJ\,NBFKFKGETBHPPG[DFHPQ
GNBMNGO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,œ��ª�øł�æ Øłœ,����’,�机�œ �Ø�Øœ, ł�Ł’,�œ�"ª
GMNHFCMGIG\GSDGNG\[NF\ZGTG\,MKFMZK\GMN
PZKTGNBK[GCNMSNGTGE.GBHHGMFNFMZFF[NPF,
CHGGDBENBVSKY,CSGE"FET\",GZGBF[MNFYG[K
[FDKTBNKGCZKCGKFHPRKO,BKRGBNB"NET\",GFGB
SGE"CBG\GFHPQ",MNGPZ,"FKEGTNKGET\TNGPG\",
[FHPRKOT[GCGFSDGNFFR"N,[KTPGECXEY\G
NRXIKG\.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª��’
MN\GMQ[NHPQ,BVKNGFPG[D[NTCZGT\KECMNN,
FGBZYBIEPEZMKF\CGRFFBRG[K\GMNVKDCGFBKQ
MNHF[KKL,TNMQBKQPXKBG\N[GOECZ[NMI,FISZ
VGTN,PXEFPXKBG\FPGINJ\FTNKGRF.[FZKMN
PF[CMIKGXBFGBBNFVGTNCFP[LFHPQ.GFP[L
FHPQBKQ[KLMNVKPTNF.PPKNBBRGKMGNKONGPZ:
PF[KFKFFGBMCZFGF.
GPK[PYZCB\IVXGGPTPYKIKKGBNPZGO
FECYG\FBNFK\FTNKGRF,FTGPE\CZGOTGNONPTNF
PSEZHPRKO.NVKBG\FFPKEF[NTKNGKKGRT[KO
FFCENKO[CKQMINVGTN,GPPKNBCKQT\KENFGGF,
YNG[KOTE[BKROIGXXKOMNN.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�"�
BKQTCZFGGFGT\KEPIGNYKOCBPK\\FK[,PF[FKF
FGB[KFKFGPF[RT[FFGB[KT[F,GPF[RT[FPMCZ
GPF[KT[FNT\KEFGNLFGBGRT[FCFGGF,\PKE
G\MGU.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,ø�"�
FYGE[ICGKFGBCMNHPQ,BNB[FIGNPSGFFPS\KZ
BG\G.CPGTECBFYGE[GPSKZB\FXTKU,PDNFB\VRK
FNGJ,GFBGZFFYEG[FPNCC\GPZGGF="BH\\TRDTN
F’".
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�ł�Ø��’,�"�
139 HPQG\RGTF
YEG[\F[C\,PNCEYEG[\TXPF,FKBPP[KMFB\
MGIFDON\GLKPKFIGN,[K\ZGPPGDOFOPVRKHMZGQ
F[C\,GRPXBFNCRTGW\PKECYEG[F.
�łÆł�Ø"���,����ł�Ø�Æ’,�"�
NPF\\BGRQTNPSMGQFF\YEPG\GT[KK\VZK
C\NPGEL,NBMQCRK,NBCEZLPGZD[P\ZBFVZK
TPNL.FRRKPNGPEPRSKGQ,MKVTPKOZCG\KTCZG
HPQ=HPRKOJGCBGBKQFNCPZDK[PF[VTNGMPF
FGSKUNYI,M[O[BKQFKNEPZDK[[FGBFGNLGDEN.
BCNPVZYNVZYCBIHKGQIE[,IE[NDPZK,FKEKTG\
P\NYJG\NBJNBJGPXJZVG\NI[CGQDEGN,
FNKPGEKOFRZEPKOPBGEIGHZKOGRKTGZKOGFFCRF
P\ZIC\...
HPZCMNKGOGBIZMLSGUFMCGENCGB,FGSU
RBNTKKQDOMQNVZYKOCSVZKO[NDEGNKFBIZGRKO,
FZCFDODZDKZBIEK[ZGRMGQFKGXBPQTJDBGQ,
GCFP[LFHPQP[\NCG\FKEKTG\GFCZMFP\RTZ\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���Øł�Ø"�,�œ�œł�ª�25
ETG\CRKFBEOCYEPG\FTGNOBGIKEG[GBXNMN
PBPKQMKK[BNGFRPXB=[NG[ETG\.FET\FZB[GQ,
GFGBET\MNPBPKQC\GZ\P[FFGBMKFTGNO
CMNNG,ZXGRKNGPZ:MNFPXKBG\,PCNTEKFBNK\CZL,
FPXKBFGFCGZBBIZKBVKSFPGINJ\,GMKFBN
K\CZLFKF[OHGN\GNBPNBLGNBDNDNGNBPF[K[
C\GLFDNDN.
BIZMQFPXKBMNBNFFRPXBKOTNPF[FO
TNKG,CIVXGGCZXGRG,GNBPECZ,GMKFHPQCTXPGFGB
140NZBG\JGC
PMNNFRCZBKO,MKFHPQFGBECYC\RGTF,GF\RGTF
FKBPYZFCP\RGTT,GHFFP\RGTTCTXPGB[ZFHPQ
ECYN\RGT\GFGBPIGE[GRCZBGFKFBIZK[NB
FKF.
GHFG[KBPZGMKFBNFKFYGEOCZKB\FTGNO,
MKPN\"FKF"\GZFTNHPQ,GMQMNPF[RP[L
CZTKGQPBKMG\PXKBG\GYEOCZKB\FTGNO=BKMG\
[BKQNG\MNK\,GFMNC[KTGZHPQBGXKGZHPQ=NB
BPK\\HPQ,MKFHPQFGBPYZFCNKSVY,GFGB
BXNRGPMNNFPYZKOFCZGBKO,MPGF[IZGFNCQ,
GBOBKRGPPKQFBKMG\,BLTNEZLMNNFGBPYZF
ECYC\RGTF.
łÆØ�ø�Æ��Ø��,�ł�Æ"�,�ł��ƺØ�,æ łø�Ø, ł�Ø"ª
BN\[\NCLCBNFFPYGPG\NECZKMNPECZ,MK
MCZFGET\KL,MKTYZMNF\GZF=[FCGZBFPXKB
FTGNONBPECZGCNKF\INFHPRK\=BNBFHPQRCZB,
MKFGBECYTO\RGT\FDNDN,GFDNDNFGBRCZB.
łÆØ�ø�Æ��Ø��,�ł�Æ"�,�ł��ƺØ�,æ łø�Ø, ł��"�
FTGNOIE[,MKFGBDGU,GFDGUBKRGRPNJP\RGTF
GPRGIF,G[RKFOPYZKOP\IE[KOTNKG,CBKOHF
CTYCHF,GFCBTNKGIE[PCNKSVYCTCGZCGBG,
GFIGNUIE[,MKBOFKFYEPGQNBFKFRTEZ,
G[RKFOIE[KO,GPF[BKRRGRPNJPQFIKEG[KOFGB
IE[,MKNBYEONIKEG[KO,GFIKEG[KOIE[KO,BO
MQFGBIE[.
141 HPQG\RGTF
FBNYKOYKKOYEPGQNBKINGU,MKBOFKF
IE[FKFXZKLBNPIE[,GHFP[\N[NBNPF[BKQ
NG\MNK\,GNBKGCQ,TE[KDKTBNPIE[YEPGQ,FGB
FZB[GQGFGBB[ZBRIRGPCY[KO.FBNYKORXIK
NBKINGU,MK[F\YKONGFYEPG\F\ZIYPPRG
FFTEZ.
łÆØØ�ª���Ø,æ ł�º�łØ
GEBKMKCMNKGORYNBNFBEONNPGEBPROFHPRKO
FKG\ZPGMRKONF[MKNCTGPYFQCNKNG\BZGMG\
PIXG\GBKNLBGCKGPBE[C\BEKGPBDZKOGMQ
CTZC[C\PIXG\GBKNLGCKPKOJGCKOGPFDO
CTXZ\GHFRKSK\KVTPKOZCG\GPXB\KKGOFXNIF
EZLVNBGCKGPKSGMG\CSMFMK[OK[FXNIF
DEGNFG[TG\BNFFRHMZG\FQPRGSG\BXNKGEZL
RSKGQBRKPECZ.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�æ"�
[YZKB\FDCZEFKKRG\ZRDGNPNBLDCZKBNFGB
CIXG\,GBHHPQBHFZ\O[KYGPGNF[\ENCSGEG\
F\GZF[FGBHPQTSYF\GZF.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�æ"�
GK[NET\[TRKKRKOZGIRKKOBKROMTKRKKRKOD[PKKO
[CFOFR\KRFGFYCNFCBKOMBIE.MKCZGIRKG\HPQ
R\KRFNIGEGHPQYCNFNIGE.MK\IKNFRK\QFECZ
PF[OK\CZLNPYCN,GCR\KRFHGRG\QNGZYFHEPRG\
NYCN,BCNTGENBYKCNMNGO.TE[K\YE[GKJFZ
142NZBG\JGC
MZBGK,BHHGMFNYCNFECZ,CBGVQ[PHPQFR\KRFTE
HPQFYCNFKMGNNF\TMCHPQPZGCF.
GNVKHFPF[M\GC[FEGZFHFMCZFDKTNFM\GC
GPNBFFBZWETFB\F’GMG’,FRFHFBPGZPCIKR\
R\KRFCNCE,BCNNCIKR\YCNFGEBKNBFDTRGTGE,
TE[RJFZGR\YE[GRNPEGR\KDTC[KTGZFZXGKKDKT
HPQFYCNFGKYGKKOCRGFM\GCGPNBFFBZWETF
B\F’.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł�æØ����ł
143 HPQG\RGTF
PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\
PT[KLKYZCGLGPT[KLKZIYGL.
�ø��,�溜�ª�Ø�œ�ł��’�ø��’
MNB[Z\PXBKELNT[G\CMILT[F.
��œŁ’Ø’
GFMNNVKZGCFPT[F.
�ø��,�溜�Æ�œ�ł��’�ø��Ł"�
FMSKNICYB\KEKGGBMNB\C[ZG.
��œª’�’
GMNB[ZNBK[K\QCTERV[G.
�Ø�ÆÆ’ª’
MKYZGCBNKLFECZPBECVKLGCNCCLNT[\G.
ªÆłØ ’Ø"ª
TCGE\F’[K[CFXEBK[K,EGPFNTCGE\BNKNKO.
PFFFCENBOTGCEBEONVSNBGBOTGCEFGB
NTXPG?
�łÆØ��� ��ª�����
BKQTCKZFPMCFPXGFGBKQPXGFPMCFTCKZF.FRF
EZLFTCGEFFGB[XZKMKONNM\CEZLFJGC,BCNFZT
[CBEOBKRGRG\QNGNNM\CEZLFJGC,BCNXZKMKO
NET\[BKQFBEOXZKLNTYGZB\FZT,MKECZHF
FGBCN\KBV[ZKBNB[XZKMKOZYN[RGBFZT,
MPG[M\GCBGFCKF’[RBGZT.[ZYF[RBFXZKMKO,
[PEZLF[RBF[PVZKECKQFECGYKO.
�łÆÆł�Œø� �ø�,ø��œØ,���ł�"Æ,�Ø��ÆØł��ºÆ������
EZLFBP\FGBYGEYPBE,[TNKGVGSTKOGFGNMKO,
TE[CBKONFKMNBEPNMB.GMNPK[P\IKNNNM\
C\IKN\FYGXZKL[PKZFPTGNF,[NBKJFNKPKQ
FYGBGN[PBNG,BVKNGMIGJF[TZF,MKBOC\IKNF
FRJKFFKBMIGJF[TZF,BVKNGBIZMLFGNLK[Z
CBP\,BCNMCZNBKCGBC[GOBGVQ,NFKMNBEPNMB,
P[GO[BKRGEGZLTNFYGFBPK\K.
�łÆØ��ª��ø�,��łœª�æ"�
GCFKG\FBEOPK[ZBNPDCKZGPMCEB\CIKR\
VRKPKG\G,[FKBCIKR\K[ZBN[CG,TNIKXGRKG\G,
[FKBCIKR\BGPG\FTGNO[CG,EFKKRG[RG\QZGC
JZI\GGKDKT\GNFDEKNGNFTNG\CIKR\VRKPKG\[CG
N\GTN\RV[G,GJZIFPGTJ\C[KTGZFPGMZIFGB
RG\QNYKGOCIKR\BGPG\FTGNO[CG,EFKKRGNXZMK
FDGU=FRFBHDGZOCPT[KG,DOCVRKPKG\GIKXGRKG\
EMNNG\FTGNO,[CRKK[ZBNTGNKOC[NPG\OPTNF
PTNF,GBGPG\FTGNO,[FOFIKXGRKG\[CMNNG\,
KMKZGGKI[KCGB\TZLCRKK[ZBN.
�łÆØ��ª��ø�,��ª��æ�ł��ł,��œæ"
GBN\\PFTNHF,[BEOVZJKKDZGOCPT[KGPTNF
BGKZKEFNMNFTGNO.MKHFGIGYGNBKTCGZ,B[Z
145 PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\
FMNNGFVZJ[GKOM[\KJVG\PKO,GMN[RGFDCMNN
MGNGRGFDDOCVZJ.GBEZCF,FVZJKOTG[KOMNPF
[CMNNMGNG.MKNBK\DNFFMNNBNBNBIZDKNGK
FVZJKO[CG,GNVKPE\OGBKMG\O[NFVZJKO.GGEBK
[PT[FFVZJNVKTZMGPGZKEBGPTNFB\FMNN
MGNG.
GCHFK\CBZFM\GCCHGFZ,[P\GLFTSYCSVZ
FHGFZGCIMP\FBP\KHMGNXB\P\GLFDNG\
NDBGNF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł���ł,�œæ"�
GCFPCGBZPGCQFKJC,MKDOF\GZFK[CFVRKPKG\
GIKXGRKG\,MPGMNNG\FTGNOMGNG.GNVKMLDOFTGSY
C\GZF,K[NGBNG[\KFPEZDG\.GCFKG\GPDCKZ
JZI\GCVRKPKG\F\GZFGSGEG\KF,RPXBDGZOC[KTGZ
FHF[PTN\VRKPKG\FTGNO,[FOK[ZBN,\TNFPTNF
PTNFTNIKXGRKG\FTGNO,[FOBGPG\FTGNO,GMN
FBGPG\KGEGGKMKZGC[CIO[NK[ZBNTNKFO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł���ł,�œæ"Ł
XZKLFBEO[KMGGQMNPT[KGMGNONKETB\F’CZGL
FGBCNCE,GKFKF[C\GGYGPGGECGZG,FMNNTGP\
FECZ...GMQM[KBMNGK[\FGKCTGN,NBK[KOTNNKCG
NT[G\ECZKOFNNGMEKNKFRG\CNCE,TE[RPXB[BKRG
BGMNG[G\FBNBFP\GYNIKLGKCTGNMEKNKFRG\,
BNBK[KOTNNKCGM[KBMNGK[\F,MEKNFCZG\DGVG
GBKCZKGCNCE.
RPXBFPFNLCEZLHGMNKPKGMGNQ,TGCEB\F’
\PKE,GBVKNGC[TF[FGBK[Q,BOK[QNET\MEK
146NZBG\JGC
[\RGIET\GTNKG,GKRGIDGVGMEK[NBKINF,GNBKGMN
NTCGEB\F’GFGBIGNF,RPXB\[KRF[NGTCGEF
NPYGOCZGLFGB.GTNTRKKQHFXGGIMPKOGBPZG:
"MNPT[KLKFKGN[O[PKO",GFGB[BPZ[NPF
CIMP\G:"CMNEZMKLETFG".
łÆØ�ø�Æ��Ø��,�ł�Æ"�,��ºœª�œ, ł��’
ZB[K\F[NF\TGZZG\ZGIRK\FKBCF[ZBFFCBF
PFCGZB.ZYBH,[MCZTNK\TNFEZL,P\IKNF
FTCGEFFBPK\K\.F\PECEZML,GBH\RCTFF[ZBF
PVRKPKG\L.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
C[NCKOFZB[GRKO[NPSTLFZGIRK,KEPFNLBGNK,
[FBNEGIFBG\LGPGBSCPBPXKL.F\PECEZML,
BN\\KKB[.CCGBFKGO,\GSZRFMNFPIKXG\.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
NFCKQNPFCZBF’K\CZLHF[KVGNXEKYPPEZD\G,
FNBNMBGZFFGBKG\ZJGC[KTPGEXEKY\PKETN
TPEGNTCGEF[K"\C[MNDEGNGNBFGCBG\GBFCF
[NKPF.
ECZHFBPZFCT["JH"NGPGZKFXEKYEGCCTZ
HX"N[PHF[RGVNFXEKYPPEZD\GGP\IHYNIHGZ
GN[GCNBK\RG,PHFRCZBGR[PG\.GFGBMPGPK
[ZGXFNFTNG\B\ICKZGPJKJGZV[,[XZKLDO
FGBNKZESPGLNFJKJGZV[NFTNG\BG\G.MPGMQ
PHFRCZBGR[P\DZKOPPF[FXEKYRGVNPPEZD\G
147 PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\
GP\IHYB\TXPGNTCGEF[OK\CZLGNIHGZGN[GC
BNPYGPG.GFGBRZPHDOMQCM\CKFBZ"KH"N.
ł’�ØØ���ÆłªØŁøÆ,�ªøœ�Ø,ł��ØøØł�øØłØ�
PTKEBRKTNK[PKKOGBZWCKQK[ZBNCKQDGK,CKQBK[
CKQBK[F,CKQTCECKQ[VIF,FMNNVKPT[F[TG[F,
MLZGIFYGE[[GZFTNKG.
œØ��Ø���ł
K[B[ZKM[NGFIKKOCPFNMOGNBKTXZGMINNM\TO
FXKGZKOFZGIRKKO,GKKTUBHFZGIF[GBUNFD[KPO
CPT[F.BH\GNEPCGMFGFETG\P\VNDG\.
BPKXKFZGIKBPZG:FIKKOFOTNGNKPINF,
BCNDOTNGNKON[GCBNFCZKBG\F[NPF.GMNB[Z
KIGCZBNFIKKOK[CJIGQ.
FBKEKBNKOFKYZKO,FDRGHKOCICKGRKFPT[KO,
PIGKCKOFONXB\B\FBGZEGYBTNKEKF\DNPG\O
CPT[KO.FOXZKMKONFBKZB\MNI[M\FIKKO,
GFI[LTERFDEGNFGBGZCPBE,NBRGMNNBPZTNKFO
[MCZDPZGB\PNBM\O,RDPZGGCBGN\TGE\O.NBRTHGC
B\FEDN,R[BGRSCNCBFCF,RDNOCVGTNCPT[KOB\
FPI[CFFDEGNF[NFR[PFFK[ZBNK\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,æ’Yæ"�
M[VGDPKOB\FZTKGQ,M[P\ZIYKOTNKEKF[YGT
CYJRG\FIKKOFZDKNKO,PZGPPG\FPI[CG\
FTNKGRG\[FQPIGNNG\B\FPT[KOFDEGNKO,G[FQ
DRGHG\C\GMOCDRKHFBNFK\TXGPF,PPKNBFGNMKO
FPT[KOGRVDPKO...GM[FPT[KORVDPKO,NTGP\HF
148NZBG\JGC
FGNLFZTKGQGP\ZIY,TE[FGBRFVLNPKQPI[CF
YNG[F,FPTGZZ\DOFKBCGHPMNBK[=PT[FPXE
PZIYFPQFIKKOGPXEZVKGQMIFNVTGNTNKFO.
MEKNPXGB\ZGVFNTGP\PXCBKGOHF,NTGP\
PINFMHB\,FBGMN\B\[\KFYXGG\B[ZNIKKO
GPPKNBRIZ\GMO,BRGXZKMKONF\BPWCMNFKMGN
C[PKZ\FPT[KO,NICCOGNBPXO,BCNNBNTPGE
TN\IGOHFCNCEG.
PBGPFNBR[BCTPNRG,BONBRXZUBNZGPPG\
FPT[KOB\FF[CFBN\TGV\FZTKGQFBXGZGDRGH
CFO.BOK[BZGFPT[KOPXG\BR[KOPNGPEF,NB
NCE[NBKGTKNGBNBDOK[VKNGTGEB\FZTKGQ,GSGU
[VNG\FZTKGQNFDPZCCJGNFPT[KO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,æ’Yæ"�
FPT[KOPECZKOFOC\GLFR[PF.MNVTGNF,[FKB
P[\N[N\BIZKF[\N[NGKG\ZCG\PFJGCPFYGE[,
M[O[FKBRGCT\PPYGZFYGE[,[FPXKBG\[N
FYGE[DZPFNFB\FGK\F,B\F\DNG\FBNFVGTN
GBKQYWNSKCG\B[ZF\DNDNGPZGCICKGQTEB[Z
CBFVTGNFJGCFHGBNFDNGKFPT[K,MMFCFKG\F
MCZKGXBFBNFVGTNFKBP[KCFB\FBGZN[GZ[F,
FKBPMFB\FDNKONBIGZGPZIC\FKBB\VTGN\
FYGE[GPDEN\FPPJFNPTNF.
GFGBFEKQNFVL,MNVTGNF[PYGZFP[I\,
M[O[FPYGZFJPBFGBPIGNNF,MLFKBPDNFB\
INB\FC\GMKG\FZGIFTG[FBG\F,TEB[ZKTYZF
PPYGZFFBK[F[NKJTNPT[KGGTNZXGRGCMIFDEGN
[N\[GCF,[BHCF\TNG\FCKIGENPKE\FBFCF,
149 PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\
\YCTB\PEGZFCTGPYFJGCG\MFB\FDNKOPPJF
NPTNF,MFNMG\FVTGNG\FJGCG\NJGCF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł�’,æ�Ø�’
FBEO[R[P\GPBKZFCYZCG,PGMZIFGBNF\CGEE
FZCF.FICZF,F\EKZG\[NBR[KOBIZKO,FPDG[PKO
TNVKZGCRDEGDOCZGIRKG\O,PTPP\B\BGZF
FCFKZ[NR[P\GFTNKGRF.
GP\GLMLMNVTGN\GFI[GCFP\PTJ\GCPYGO
FFJCF[FKFKMGNNFKJKCNICZFTNKEKF\CGEEG\G,
GFZIY\GPPRFCZGCFHPRKO,[DOBHK[[FKIS
FZGIRKNBKKVSY,GRDEVRKGKFKFMNFEGZMGNG,
NF\VNNCTEOGNXKKZB\TKNGKKO,B\FBGXZFJGC
[CFO,KDZGONFRVKNFTNKEKRVKN\GPVRKFBVKNF,
[FKBPBVKNFB\ZGIRKG\GCYZC\OFPJZE\.GXZKL
\NPKEIMO[KT[FB\TXPGMTRYHFNXGBZ,[RZBF
GBKRGRZBF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�æł��ªø
Y[FPBENSCGNB\FICZF,B\FVDK[F[NBR[KO
[ZGKKOCMNPFG\OCTGNOBIZNDPZK,[FBK[KG\
F[YGTFCPFNMKOZGIRKKOBXKNKKO,C[BKVG\
PGSZKG\DCGFG\,BKQNFPDT[PF.GPMNPYGOSCN
HFEGYBFGBPXIXIB\FBEOGPTNFG.F[VT\G
FZGIRK\[NFBEOFRTNFTNFSCKCF,[CBFEGYB
TOFVDK[FF\EKZG\PJFZ\B\FSCKCF,PTNFIQ
[NYGE[TNMNPK[CBCPDTG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�æł��ªø
150NZBG\JGC
SEZFTCGEFPCTNFSGNO:
B.NFBPKQ[K[P[DKITNFTGNO.
C.NET\[FBPGRFFGBCIKR\NPJFCI[KCG\,
GFGBCGIZNNM\CEZLHF.
D.[FBPGRF[NGKFKFCEZLF[VTF,GNBCTNPR\
NYCN.
E.GM[PKISKOB\FTCGEFNF’,NFBPKQ[F’PYCN
B\TCGE\KRG,GNBI[GCCBKHFXGZFRZBF
FTCGEF.
F.CBPGRFNPTNFPFET\,K[NFCIKQC’FCIRG\:
=[FGBFGNLNPTNFPFET\PJTO[BKQNG
CZKZF.
=FGB,BVKNGK\RGNGET\,GMCZBKQFGBXZKL
NFBPKQGNNM\NPTNFPFET\,PMNPYGO
FGBCGIZNNM\CEZL[NNPTNFPFET\.
G.[FBEOXZKLNET\,M[FTCGEF[NGFKBCBFCF
TXPK\,BIZKMNFFXNIG\[FBEOPXKKZNTXPG
[FGBKMGNNF[KD,KFKFCKEGNFJKCZYCIKR\
VZJKG\GTXPG,P[B"MCBFC\F’FGBPJKC
NMNN.KGETN[PGZTNFTHZF[PYCNPNPTNF,
[NBKBCEB\HF.
H.XZKMKON\\[CIGFGEKFTNFTCZ,MKCHF\NGK
FT\KE,MNGPZ,C[KTGZ[RG\RKO\GEF,C[KTGZ
HFFBEOPI[KCMNPF[PYCNPNPTNF.
I.TKYZFTCGEFFGBNNM\CYGKPKQ,FKKRG[NKPG\,
MNGPZ,TEMPF[K[NGYX\BIKHFCZGIRKG\,
FGBXZKLNFKG\[PI,CHF[HMF[F’R\QNG
PI[CFGZXGQNT[G\P[FGCZGIRKG\.
151 PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\
J.GDONNM\CYG[PBN,GHFPSVKYIXK[TFCKGO,
FKKRG[KT[FI[CGQNTXPG,MPFFGBPTEKU
BFC\F’TNBFCFTXPK\,GC[KTGZ[KZBFB\
FISZGRG\,K\QTNHF\VKNF[F’KYZCBG\G
CBP\,[EGYBTNC’YGKOFBEOKMGNNF\YEO.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���ł�"�,æªł�ƪ��Æ���æ���"�
CSEZFTCGEFK[NFCIKQD’CIKRG\:
B.NF[\GYYNF[NKOR[P\G,NF[KCFN[GZ[F,
[HFRYZBCIKR\K[ZBN.
C.NFCKQEZMKF[K"\,GZHKQEBGZKK\B,EPBQNB
KETXKGGKBEPBZKBKLKTCKENKF,[HFGCIKR\
BGZKK\B.
D.NF[\GYYNF[D\YGC"F,MNGPZ,NFECYCGCFMZF
[NKPF,[HFGCIKR\YGC"F.GPGJC[K[\GYY
NCIKR\XKGGKBEPBZK[HFGYGFBPXTK.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���ł�"�,æªł�ƪ��Æ���æ���"�
BRKZGBF[TKYZPRKT\FFXNIFCMNPF[TG[KO
NIHYB\FKFEG\GPTPEO[NK[ZBNCMN,FGBPVRK
[RHRIFBGZFBNYK,RHRINDPZKPQFNCGFPGI.FMN
VGRKOTM[KGZYN\YQB\F"VZBSJTVZGPYKKJ"
)FIZEKG\FV[GJF(,MBKNGKFKFBV[ZNFIKG\B\
FTGNOCDGUCNBR[PF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"æY�æ"�
152NZBG\JGC
BPROMGR\KRGBNKGGNBNPKEG\KG,GNHFXZKL[KFKF
YEKP\BPGRFCNCFP[MKNMKMNPF[RKKIEFSVKZG\
BGRP[KLPFOBKQCMNKOPP[G\VTGNFBNBPMIG
FP\V[JBNKFOPVRK[FOMNKONF\V[JG\BGZG.
GBOI"GKTNFCET\SKNGYF[DI\GGTXPG\G
FP\V[JBNKFOK[BZGMNKO[CGZKODGUCNBR[PF,
BPRONIKG\GBNKFONBKS\NYPFOMNNBNBPXE
[FVTGNG\K\ZIYGPPRGGFSVKZG\KPRTGBGZGPQ
F\I\GRKO,NB[FGBKPRTFJGCNTGNOBNBPT[KRG
GPTNNKRGDZPGKPRTFJGCPPRG,GHFBRGYGZKO
GPKISKOBG\GC[OVDO.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,��"
PVRK[HFGMGR\GK\’)GFKKRGSGE(,NFKJKCGNDNG\
BNGFG\GBNF\I\GRKOGPK[PGRTHF,FGBPFVL
MGGR\GK\’GFKKRG,SGEBGPZG,G\VZTGMNTX\KF,GFKKRG
TSYF\ZFBNKRG.GNHFMNFPZCFNFMKQFSVKZG\
FBNGGNMGRROGN\YRO,FKBFKBFTCGEFFZXGKF,
[K\YQFXKRGZG\,[EZLCOKTCGZJGCGBNKRGGNBKPRT
BG\GFJGCFPG[VTPPRGTNHGN\G[GOSKCF
PFSKCG\FPGRTG\FJGCFFGB.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ø�ł���,��œ�øºØ��,ª��"
KEGTMKPTN\FXEKYTNFZ[TBKRFBNBCFMRT\
FRV[FCFPK\GF\DCZG\FRV[F[MNK\,GTKYZ
F\GZFMNFGKSGEFFGB,[K[CZB\\BG\KGGKMRKTO
GK[KCOTEEMB,TE[KCKBOC[TCGEFRV[F[MNK\,
153 PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\
GFTG[FHB\GPDCKZ[MNGTN\BGG\KGGP[CZGPMRKT
FRV[FCFPK\[NGFGBRYZBXEKY.
łÆØÆ�ØØÆ��øł,�ØÆ�����,ºª����,�ªł�œ�ªØ�
MKCFMR\F\I\GRKOG\[GY\OBNFTNKGRKO,K[VKTG
TNKFOFTNKGRKOJGCFGCZMF,MKF\I\GRKOFOMSB
BN[NPTNFPFO.GBONB\PXBFFMRFNPJF
C\I\GRKOTNPFKRGIF[VT?TNFTXKOBGTN
FBCRKO.GKBPZMKPJTOHFXZKLNFMKQNPJFBKHF
ECZ,TNPF[KIGNFCZMFTNKG.
�łÆø���Æ��ÆØ�,ºœ� �,œØ���øºØ����تØ��ø��œ�œ�Ø�
GBNKBPZCNKCG[FGBDEGNPICKZG,[FGBTGCE
CECYG\KG\Z.[FGB,M[BZFRCZBKO[RCZBGNXGZL
TCGE\GK\CZL,GF[K"\NBR\QNICKZG[MNMPG[R\Q
NG[MN.GCPFFGBI[GCKG\ZPF\GNT\=TGCENF’
K\CZLCMN[MNGGMGIG.
GFBEODOMQZPFG\GNTF,MPG[M\GC"GBRMK
\GNT\GNBBK[",GBONBR\QNGF’K\CZL[MNNBFKF
KMGNNTCEGZYMPGF\GNT\.GBOMQ,BVKNGP\GNT\
BKRGI[GCCPTNF,MN[MQPCRKBEO.
GKI[GC[FGB\GNT\G[BZCZKG\YJRG\FO
I[GCKOMPGICKZKOCTGNO=[MGNORCZBKOGBKQNFO
KMGN\ZYPF[R\QNFOFCGZBK\CZL,GECZHFKFKF
\PKECPI[C\G.
ł’Øøł��Æ��ø�ŁÆ,�Æ�ø"Ł,�œłØÆ"ø,Ø"Æ
154NZBG\JGC
GBPZGIH"N,BKHFGIMOFPMKZB\PYGPG,FKKRG
PEZD\G,GZXGRGNGPZEPK[BKRGIMOKGMNFKXZ
NZPG\GGNGPZ[FGBRMCEGPYKKOB\F\GZF,MVK
[FTGNOPIHKYKOBG\GNNPEQGKZB[PKO,[PYKO
B\F\GZFCPXGG\KF.
BCNBOFGBCTXPGBOBK[RCGQFGB,KPXBMPF
PXGG\[TGCZTNKFQCMNKGOGBKRGP[KONCTNKFQMNN
NYKKO,GMQCTRKRKFNBGKQ[TGCZTNKFQGBKRGP[KO
MNNN\YRO,GF\GTN\PHFDEGNPBGE,[BOKMKZB\
TXPGFMZFBPK\K\KSGZFDBGFPPRGGK\ZXFCPF
[RG\QNGFYC"FFQCF[VTFGFQCTRKRKFMCGE,GMN
TRKRKGKMKZ[FYC"FP\RFDTPGCPKE\FISE.
łÆØØøł����Øł�º��,�� ı�ØØ�,��Łłæ��ÆœØøł��
FKGETKOCSGEF’YCNGTNTXPOGM\CG)CVZKTW
IKKO(PK[KJCGNPT\FCNKMGGRFFGBMMGVZI"G,
GFGBMEK[KEIYGTXPQ\PKENMGKQCT\JCKNFNT[G\
RI\ZGINVRKGK\CZL[PG,GPHFKYIZBKFPKCBCSGE
F’NMGGQMEYBKBG\,GBG\Q[NBCBGCSGEF’JCKN\
PJFZ\Q,GEKNFOFMGGRFNMCGEGK\CZL[PGN[O
JFZFNT[G\RI\ZGINVRKGK\"[,GTNET\MGGR\Z’
[PTGQCZKGIBKGFBZKH"N.
ł’�ø�ŁØØŁ�ÆØ�����,Øø���ø�Æ�Ø�ŁØ�
PYGEOXZKLNNPGEFNMG\GNYKKOBG\O[FOMNIO
NCCBRG[KSTE,GBIZMLKTSGYCNKPGEFSGEG\
[RP[NGNKKQG[PQ.
����ł’��Ø��Ø���,��ł"�,�Æ�ø������º"Æ.
155 PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\
BKBV[ZNFDCKFB\TXPGPPTNNFTKDGN[NG.NMQ
FBEOPGMZINKRGYPK\GLFSCKCF[NGGBKQNG[GO
TXF,NBEZL\GZFGKDKTFZCF.NMQBOFBEOCGIZ
NTXPGSCKCFJGCFBHKFGBPZGGKIHPQGKDKTF.KTQ
[FGBRP[LNVKFSCKCF[NG.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łłº"�
BEOPK[ZBNFP\CGRQDOCTRKKRKFTGNOFHFGDO
CTRKKRKTGNOFZGIRKFTNKGQ,BKRRGRG\QN[RKFOBG\G
FTZL.BOPEGCZCPK[MGNIG[KG[YGTKOCTRKKRKG
FKGOFKGPKKO,PI[CG\KGGEBDG\KGFOCTRKKRKF[TF,
GMQMNIGDPMZKGICZKGFO[KKMKONTRKKRKFTGNOFHF,
GGEBKMK[OKPXBMNMGCEP[YNTKGRKG,CTRKKRKOBNG
FGBPHEFFCFMZFIHYFKG\Z.
BCNNBMQBEO[FGBMGNMGNG’R[PF’,[FGBI[
IGGKFTPGYFCTRKKRKOFRV[KKO,[PI[CG\KG\VGSG\
CTRKKRKFRXI,BXNGTRKKRKFTGNOFHFRI[CGNJVNKO.
FGBMPGBGZI[CBPPZIYKO,GPS\MNTNMN
FPFGPFCPCJ[FGBPPTN.TKYZP[TR\GFGB
CTRKKRKFZGI,GZYCPYX\FGBPTGZFCTGNOFHF,NVK
F[VT\BG\OFECZKOTNVK\GZFGPXGG\KF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ÆØ�łØ��øØŁœØ,Ø’,��’152
PF[DEGNKFF[DFP[\GYYKONTKGRKOZGIRKKO,
GJGTPKOCFOB\JTOTERO,GCGINKONVTPKO
CNKPGEKOPT[KKO,FGBPVRK[BKQFTGNOFPGI[K,
GFHPRKCMNN,\GVSPYGOBXNO...GFRXIKG\,HGFK
FVZGCNKPFFYCGTF[NXEKYKTGNO,FKBPYV\
B\R[P\OGPPNBFB\MNFGGKK\O...GPPKNBFKRO
156NZBG\JGC
\PKETGZDKONNKPGEKOMBNF[FXCKGQFRXIKTGPE
CFOCDKNGKPGZD[,GFOFPI[CG\FPGV[JG\GXKGZK
FFGE...[FOFOMNNKZHK\GZFGS\ZKIMPFCRGTO
F’.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ÆØ�łØ��øØŁœØ,�’,��’142
TNFNPTNFTNF,MKMGITHNL,GK[NLMRVKZGI,MRVK
R[ZKOBCKZKO.BN\MI[CO,VQKMI[GNL,EZG[
BG\O,GKPXBGNLPKE.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø,ª� "�
TNKRGNF\IHYCEZLGCCJIGQTH[MNKGOKFKFNRG
MIE[,[XZKMKONIE[CMNT\B\FKSGEG\,GRXTE
YEKPF.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��
157 PT[KOGTCGEFCEZLFBP\
FRS\ZGFRDNF
BMQB\FB=NPS\\Z.
œ��Ø�º"�Ł"
BPZNGTGNOFVGLZBK\K,TNKGRKONPJF...,BPZNG
CRK,TGNOCZGZZBK\.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø�溜 æ�Ø��’,ÆÆ�Æœł�Ø’
BS\ZPQF\GZFPRKQ.GBRMKFS\ZBS\KZ.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø�溜��Ø���"Ł
FRS\ZG\NF’BNYKRGGFRDNG\NRGGNCRKRGTETGNO
NT[G\B\MNECZKF\GZFFHB\.
ªÆłØ�º"Łº"�
NBKFKFCLBNHZ.FBNNBKFKFCL,C\GML,CCIKR\
HZ.
�łÆØ������ª����
ZCKNGKBPZ:M\KC,"PFDENGPT[KLF’PBGETPYG
PI[CG\KL".PFDENGPT[KLF’,HFPT[FCZB[K\,
[FOPT[KG[NFYEG[CZGLFGB.PBGETPYG
PI[CG\KL,BNGS\ZK\GZF.
ł’�ø�Æ��Ø��,�ł�Æ"�,�ł��ƺØ�
TNEZLFZPHK[NET\TRKQRDNFRYZBCIKR\PT[F,
GRS\ZRYZBFMGGRF.FMGGRF[FKBFSKCFFPIKKC\
BG\GNT[G\B\FPT[F,HFRS\ZPBR[KO,[BKQ
BEOKGETPF[CNKCG[NICKZG.GBVKNGBEOBXN
TXPGDOMQKMGNNZPBG\B\TXPGCTRKQMGGRF,[FGB
IG[C[FSKCFFPIKKC\BG\GNT[G\B\FPT[F,
FKBCIKR\N[O[PKO.GKMGNNFKG\[CBP\\GTN\
TXPGFKBHB\[PIKKC\BG\GNT[G\B\FPT[F.
NMQRS\ZPZPHTNFMGRF.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ��Æ’,���łœ" ,�æœłœ��’���Ø�
FXEKYFBPK\K,ET\G[VNFTNKGNBKQ[TGZ,PVRK
[FGBPMKZB\DGENFMKTGZ[NFZTFPGCNTCG...
GPMNPYGOBKRGPZBFB\[VNG\GCDNGK.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’,ł�"Ł
PF[M\GC[BKRGZGBFCHPQFHFPK[FGBPYGCN,
B\PFB,BKLBV[ZNK[CCSCKCFPGDCN\GNZBG\
CMNFTGNO,GPMN[MQZBKFMHGPK[FGBCTN
PYGCN,GFQBP\[DOBRMKNBZBK\KPYGCNBPK\K
CHPRKHF,BCNBRKPCKQ[NBBNPQK[ZBNGBKQNL
EGZ[BKQCGMBCZFOKXIYGKTYC=GCMNNNBZBKRG
BKRGZBKF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª��"�
FZXKGRNKG\P\V\I\,ZYPVRK[PTCZNSU=FFMZF
[NF,TG[FFRS\ZB\VTGN\GFPETK\GFPGSZK\.
PHGKKV\FKBFFRIFFFPGRK\,[FRS\ZPTMZB\
FPETFCFKZGB\FCYGZ\FPEGKY\.EGYBTNKEK
FRS\Z,GCTHGH[KZ\GGTGPYFDKGRG,KGSETNKSGE
BK\QFPTPE[NFPETFFGNLGP\IE[GFCYGZ\
159 FRS\ZGFRDNF
FPEGKYFFPR\I\GIGEZ\.PXZGVO[N[RKBNF
F[VTKOCT[ZOFDEGN,FRS\ZGFCYGZ\,KCRFKSGE
FBK\QB[ZNBGZFBNFKFTNKGQ,FTGPENPTNFPMN
FDFGFMZF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,"Æ
SGEG\F\GZFFOP\NC[KOCP[NKOGIKEG\C\GZF,
PJTOF\V[JG\F\GZFGKZKE\OPZGOFPTNG\TE
FTGNOFD[PKFHF,GFRFSGEF\GZFFP\DNFFGB
[F[MNEGNFPKOTPGYKOPNPTNFNPTNF,GVTPKO
KBPZFP[MKNSGE,GK[NSGEGRS\Z,GFGBBGPZCNK
FKG\GPTPKYCSGEG,GHFPVRK[FGBPVZ[F\GZF
CCIKR\HTKZBRVKQ,GK[NGS\ZCBZKLBRVKQ,GZ’
[PTGQFGFEGNFPTPYKFPI[CFFTNKGRFCMNSGEG
PVRK[FKF[GBCFSGEPFM\Z.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,Ø"ª
CFCEN[CKQZGIRKG\GD[PKG\,XZKLNFTKZ,[MNTKYZ
FCENHFFGBZYCTZLNF[D\RGF[MNK\GFIG[K\
GCTXPKG\=GYNGIGPZCKISNFXTFFTNKGRF=BKQ
PYGON[GOFCENCHF.
GM[BRGZGXKONFSCKZNRGB\FTRKRKOBRG
BGPZKO,[CZGIRKG\BRGPMKZKOINYKG\ZDNGK[N
FGVTF,GCD[PKG\=INYKG\ZS\GZGPIGCB.GCPYGZ
FBNFKFMNFGBCPXKBG\PNB,PYJQGTEDEGN,
GP\DNFFPXKBG\NVKFMR\FPYCNKO.
BCNMNPF[P\DNFFGBK[PP[,BNB[P\DNF
RKXGWYJQPQFMNGTNMQBRGP[KDKOCGF\MGRF
160NZBG\JGC
FISZF,[BRGZDKNKONCJBFC[O"D[PKG\"PF
[BKQHFNVKFBP\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�"Ł
GFP[NCHFMBEOFNCG[NCG[TNDGVG,GB\FZGXF
NTPGETNEPG\DGVGP\GLNCG[GCCNKJ\HZGTG\KG
G[GYKG,P[OKMRSBNRS\ZG,MLP\GLNCG[F\GZF
B\FRMRSBNVRKPKG\G,GBKQNLECZCRDNF[C\GZF
[NBDZOFRS\Z,GFGBMIG\OFRI\OC[TGF[BKQ
\GSV\GBKQPDZT\CIG\O[BKQCPI\KOGNMQ
M[K\Y[FNL[GOTRKQCRS\ZFIHZKE[MNLTN
V[GJGGZBFEZ[\ZH"N,GFMRSP\GLV[GJGBN
RS\ZGCEPG\GGXNPGBNSGEVRKPKG\G.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,æ"�
FKKRGPN\P[MKNKO[KGETKONTPGETNSGEIMPF
TNKGRF,NBP\GLCYKBG\FECZKOFRCZBKO[HF
PT[FFIXGRKO[CY[GNTPGETN\GMQFTRKKRKO
FRVNBKOP\GLFRDNKO.GBKQHFINYK[ZBNBNB
TGPEKOTNFRDNFP\GLFRS\ZKO,GEGZ[KOVSGYK
F\GZF,GP[OFOKGETKOSGES\ZKFIMPFNB
PFIYKZFFJCTK\.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,"�
MKC\GZFK[RDNFGRS\Z,FRS\ZRYZB\GZ\F’
GFRDNFRYZB\GZ\FBEO.
GFRFFRS\ZNBGMNBIEHGMFNF[KD,BCN
PMNPYGOZBGK[KI[GYGKIVGWNF[KDF,GHF[BPZ
FM\GC,MKBOC\GZ\F’[FGBFRS\ZIVXG,BU
161 FRS\ZGFRDNF
[BKRGP[KDF,PMNPYGOIVXGCF,GC\GZ\GFGB
FRDNF,[FGB\GZ\FBEO,KFDFKGPOGNKNF.
�łÆ�ø�Æ��ØØ���øØŒ,���øØŒ��ªø,�Æœ�’, ł�ø�ØøØ
GFRFFRDNFRYZBMNKIPEF,PVRK[FRS\ZFGBDRGH
GJPGQC\GMG,GFRS\ZRYZBIPEFDRGHF.GTRKQFRS\Z
FGBCIKR\BGZG\TNKGRKOZGIRKKO,[CFORCZB
FTGNO.GHF[BPZGIH"N[TNKEKF\GZFRCZBFTGNO,
FMGGRFTNKEKVRKPKG\F\GZF,[FOFSGEG\GFO
FRYZBKOIPEF,MKZBGKNIPGEBG\O.GHF[BPZ
F\RB:ICKCKQK[ZBN[RK\QNFOMNKIPEF[CFRCZB
FTGNOGBKRGYBKTNFMNK,ZYTNFIPEFFDRGHFC\GL
FMNK[CGRCZBFTGNO.
GCBP\FIPEFFRS\Z\NBRK\QNFOCP\RF,
MKBOFMNK[NBG\FFIPEF[CFRCZBFTGNO,RK\Q
NFOCP\RF.IKCFK\KZFRGET\NFO[RBPZMKNYI
JGC,[FGBFRDNF,FNYI,FCK\KE[NFRS\Z:R\\K
NMOCP\RFG\GZ\KFGBFRS\Z,BUTNVK[BKRMO
KMGNKONF[KDF,PMNPYGOBN\THGCG,ZY\PKE
\IPEGBG\F.
�łÆ�ø�Æ��ØØ���øØŒ,���øØŒ��ªø,�Æœ�’, ł�ø�ØøØ
FJTO[M\CGH"NMKNKPGEFHGFZFYEG[RGZB
GR[DCPBE...CMNF\GZFK[VZE"SGCMNNKPGEBKRG
RKMZFSGEMNNGBEZCFFYGZBG[GRFET\GTNFV[J
NCECBKQPCKQBOK[SGEC\GZFMNN,PF[BKQMQ
CSVZFHGFZFYEG[EFSGEG\FOCDNGKGFNGPEKGET
162NZBG\JGC
MKKECZRVNBG\GZHK\GZFGFGBNBKET,GNHFPGTKN
PBEN\YQFRV[.
ł’�ØØ�Æ�Ø�����’Ø�,� ø��ØØ�,��łºœ�’
CZB[K\FXTEKO[N\NPGEZHK\GZF,M[ZGBKOBKL
FVZJKOP\Y[ZKOHFCHF,GPMNPYGOBKQPCKRKO
B\F\GMQFKSGEK[CFO,XZKMKONXKKZKVF,BKL[MN
BNFFETG\GFXKGZKOCBGP\GLFGVTFZGIRK\,DEGNF
GPVGBZF,[NZGIFYGE[,TNKEKF[ZKEKOB[ZF’
YGZB.GF[N[N\FGNM\FKBGRP[M\CYEG[F,TE
[P\BIE\CFNMFNP[FPSKRK.GBHHGZI,TNKEKMI
BPGRFYEG[FHGGF[TZ\F,BGZDEGNNK[ZKO,GFCKRF
FVRKPK\FGNM\FKBGP\ZIC\.MKF’K\QIMPFPVKG
ET\G\CGRF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ºœÆØ�łÆ��
TNBR[KRRGGFPSVZFRCKB,MKC[T\FP[CZ
"GKYZBGBNF’CIGHYF".HGFKTCGE\O[NBKMZKO
PDG[PKO.NF’NBYGZBKOCIGHYFBNBCI[BK,P\GL
FNCGPVRKPKG\G.BKQBEOCIGWXZKLNET\PFYGZB
FNCVRKPF.
�łÆØ������ª����
NKPGENVKFV[JRYZBTCE,GNVKFSGERYZBCQ.
[MB[ZFBEOBKRGKGETGPMKZB\YGRGBNBNVKFV[J
EZLMNNRYZBTCE,GMB[ZFGBCQ[KGETCS\ZK\GZF
[FOCBXKNG\MCQFPIV[CDRHKBCKGRYZBCQ.
�łÆ��Ø�Æł�ø�ªØتø,ł�øØœ�º��ø’��ªø� ł��’
163 FRS\ZGFRDNF
GFRFPMNHFKGCQC\GSV\CKBGZTRKKQ"GNB\[CK\
PNI"MG’,[NKPGEFVRKPKG\RYZBC[OPNI,[FPNI
PP\Y\FC[ZBU[BKQCGJTOCTXPGMPGFC[Z,
GMLFRDNF[C\GZFRP[NNNIO,MPG[M\GC)P[NK
J,F("NMGNIPGCNIPK",GDONC[Z,MPG[M\GCTN
FVSGY"HB\FVTOTXOPTXPKGC[ZPC[ZK",EYBK
TN\GZF[CTNVF,GMQCDPZB)C"CM"C(BPZG"BMNG
CK[ZB[PKRBCKZCB".
GFKKRGMPGFNIOGFC[ZK[CFQJTO,GPP[ML
CNKPGEFRDNF[C\GZFK[CFF[D\FPFG\PP[,
PF[BKQMQCNKPGEFVRKPKG\[BKQCHFZYKEKT\
FPXKBG\GNBF[D\FPFG\,GFPFG\RS\ZGRTNO
GBKRGPG[DMNNNFKG\CIKR\JTOPP[MPGFRDNF,
TENT\KENCGB[K\DNFVRKPKG\F\GZF.GNMQRP[N
NPNI,NGPZ[TOFKG\[BKQCGJTO,TOMNHFFGB
EKKYBFRG\QJTOFC[Z.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,��ŁØœł��Æ���œ�Ø� łøœØ�ł�ª��"ª
IMPKRGH"NIKNYGNRGB\FIMPFN[RKTRKKRKO:
RDNF,GRS\Z.
INYFRDNFMGNN,MNPF[BRGPCKRKOP\GL
FMZ\RGFV[GJF,GB\FTKGRKOFRCRKOTNCSKSPT[K,
CNK[GOTHZGSKGT[NTKGQ,TNEZL[BPZGIMPKRG
H"N:"BKQNGNEKKQBNBPF[TKRKGZGBG\".
GINYFRS\ZMGNN,MNBG\OFKEKTG\[[PTRG
PVKBR[KORBPRKO,BG[K[NRGCTXPRGCIKR\FMZF,
G\VKSFMNNK\CFO.BNBBKBV[ZNRGNF\YZCBNKF
CPKEFPSVY\NCKYGZ\F[MNFCZKB,PCIKR\FMZF
164NZBG\JGC
V[GJF.GHFG[RYZBC[ORS\Z,[KKTXGNRGNYCN
FECZKOPCIKR\"BPGRFV[GJF".GBSZGTNKRGCMN
FRGDTNE\,CBKSGZIPGZ,BVKNGNFS\MNCECZKO
FDGZPKONF\TGZZG\FTRKKQGFIYKZFCFO.
BGNO,F[PG\FNNG:RDNF,RS\Z,BKRO[PG\
YCGTKO,FINKOTNSGDKO[NKEKTG\PSGKKPG\,MVK
[FFPGQIG[C,BNBFOINKOZYTNF\GETF[N
FBEO,MNGPZ,MNFKEKTG\[MCZFSVKYNDNG\O
GNFMKZO,P\GLF\RSG\PP[K\,PMGRKOBXNFBEO
C[O"RDNF".GMNFKEKTG\[TEKKQNBFDKTNCIKR\
FMZFHG,PMGRKOBXNGC[O"RS\Z".
CBGVQ[BKQNLBEOCMNFEGZG\GFHPRKO,[NB
KFKFNG[RKFIKNGYKOFNNG,M[CINYFRDNF[NGPG\Z
NGNTKKQGNIYGZ,P\GL[K[NGCSKSPP[K.GCINY
FRS\ZNG,BSGZFTNKGBVKNGBKHG[PW[NIYKZF,
P\GL[BKQNG[OCSKSPP[K.
�łÆØ��ª��ø��,���ł����ø
C[R\\ZV"D)1923(CTZLCKYZFVZGVSGZBKKR[JKKQ,
CBZWK[ZBNGSGEZFVDK[FCKRGGCKQZCRGFZBK"F
YGY,CMNHB\RDTPZQCMNNG\FYV\[KJ\GFKISK\
[NFVZGVSGZ,GFTKEBG\G[HFGIHGQRVZWMPF
VTPKOCBGXZG\FKFEG\FT\KYKO,[BKHFF\DNG\
PVNKBFB\FBRG[G\MGNF,PGXBKOBG\FCBKHF
VKRFRS\Z\[NSVZG\RGFYEGPFGCTKYZFPS\GZK\,
FPZYKTFCPTGUCZYKFCZGOFTGNOFPI[C\K,
GP\R[B\NPTNFPMNEZDB[NF\V\IG\FKSJGZK\
CTGNOFPI[CF.
165 FRS\ZGFRDNF
G[MQBKZTDOMQNF\DNG\FRVNBFFPZTK[FB\
FNCCG\[NMNFGDFETG\CMNFTGNOMGNG,P\GL
[KJ\GFKISK\FIE[F,[DOPYGZFMCZRPXBCSVZK
FPS\GZKQGFYCNFGFPVZ[KO[R\ICZGTNKFO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,œ�ªœ�łÆ,º’.��’87
NBPYZFFGB,MKBOTXPG\JCTRV[K,PF[BRK
PZDK[TGRDGRI\ZGICTSYFRS\ZG\FBNGFKG\
CFZICFGIGV[,HB\FKBTKYZPJZ\K.MNF\VYKEKO
[NK\ZFMK[ZGRG\,FPT[KKOGF[MNKKO,BKROMKBO
JVNKONPFG\K.BRKXZKLNPXGBB\BG[ZKCYZCK
VRKPF,NBCFSMP\FCZKG\,GNBC[GOYZKKZF,BKHG
[\FKF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,œ�ªœ�łÆ,º"�,��’95
166NZBG\JGC
FCRFG[VF
FR[PFP\V[J\CINYKFDGUGRMNN\CMNNBIE
CNCCSGEFFCRF,[HFG"FNCPCKQ")CZMG\S"B(.MK
FFCRF[NFNCFKBPP[ZBKF,MKMPG[FTKRKKO
ZGBKO,MLFGBFCR\FR[PF[FKBZYFS\MNG\.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’ł�"ª
GBVKNGPF[BKRGKMGNNFCKQTNCGZKGBUTNVKMQ
FNKPGECTXPGFKB\GTN\[BIZVJKZ\G[KHEML
IGPZBHKHMFNFCKQGMG’NMLKNPGEBEOBUTNVK
[BKRGKGET.
ł’�������ŁÆłæ�Ø�’ł�ÆØ�,��ł�Ø�Ø�,�تøØ�øÆœ
TNMNECZ[BKRGPCKQK\GEFGKCMFPBGEGK\QECZ
NXEYFGBHKBGZGTKRKGFBZFRVNBF.PRFNFYEPGRKO
FKFM[FKGNGPEKOHGFZBGYCNFNK[CTNDCKYZYT.
NFGZG\FMRTFNVRKGK\CZL.
łÆØ�ØØ��º��,����œŁÆœ,�œ�"�
N[GQFPYGCNKO:FKB[VFPP[CPNGBPGCQFPKNF,
EKKYRK\PBE,FQCTRKKQ[GZ[GTRU,GFQCTRKKQYGEO
GRP[L,GNFFPTNFFPKGIE\,[BV[ZNECZC[VFHG
CVZJKOGVZJKVZJKO,CNKFDCNF.DOBV[ZTNKEF
ND[\K[ZNTRKKQFVZJ[ZGXKO,CNKFXGZLNY[ZF
TOFYGEONF,FPBGIZNF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���łœłœ��Æ����œ�
ZB[K\MNXZKMKONET\,[CPYGO[K[NRGTSYTO
TRKRKOZGIRKKO,FPGV[JKOPHPQ,PYGOG\RGTF,GBKQ
XZKLNGPZTOBNGYG\,FZKBKQNRGB\FPNG\NFDG\
GNF\CJBTNKEKFQ,[FZKMNBGXZFPNG\[NRG
FGBNYGIPFZD[KFIG[KOFPEGPKO,GBKLBV[Z
NFS\KKTCFOCPYGO[IG[GEPKGQBKRO[GNJKO
[O,MKNP[N,BVKNGBO\YIB\FPNFFKG\ZEYF
MDGQ"BGZG\",FZKFKBDOMQPEGPFGPG[BN\PQ
BGZF[P[BGBGZPGZD[[NRI\ZGIGMEGPF,BO
MQBKLK\MQNF\CJBTPFQCTRKKRKBNGYG\,B[Z
GEBKNBKXKTGNPTKKQ[GOECZBP\.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,œ��ª�øłæ Øłœ,����’
NVKMLPXBGNFOFIMPKO[VFPGMRFCNKJGZI,
[KGMNGNPSGZTNKEKFBK[NZTFGB\F[D\O,CTN
VFGCM\CPEGZNEGZ,MKNYIGNFOB\[PG\FTRVKO
[CTGNOFHF,B[ZMN[OPCBZB\TXPG,MPGZF
CBXCTTN[Z[GFTNKGQ,B[ZCPTZM\FTGNPG\
FTNKGRKO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,œ��ª�øłæ Øłœ,����’
GHFG[JZI\KCCKBGZKHF,NFSCKZB\T[ZFSVKZG\,
MVK[FGZFNRGFIMOFBNGYKFBZ"KH"N,TNVKJFZ\Q
FZGIRK\,FPGV[JG\PMNPG[DKOPGI[KKO,CBGVQ,
[KGMNMNP\IKNND[\BNFIMPFCNKNFM[NC[GO
FD[PFGJTG\,B[ZTOFCR\T[ZFSVKZG\FBNG,
KV\IFV\IDONFS\MNGNET\,BKLNFCKQCK\Z
FTRKRKOCIMPFFHB\.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,œ��ª�øłæ Øłœ,����’
168NZBG\JGC
GNJTR\M\F[NK[KFDO[BKQHGJTRFC[CKN[BKRG
PCKQNMLNBKFBZGXFNFCKQFNBNBTNKLNDPGZ
M\KCGFDK\CGKGPOGNKNFGNBM\KCGFCR\CGKGPO
GNKNFBO\CKQ\CKQGBONBG[MZFNKPGECKELGFB
ZBKFPSVZFHGFZ[BUTNVK[BKRGPCKQFN[GQ
PSGDNNR[PF.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,��"� œ�Ø�º��Æ��ª��
PK[BGFCIMP\FBP\GBKRGPGXBPK[KNPEFG
KYZBCFPTXPGBUTNVK[FGB[GDFCFMKPMNPNF
GPNFRT[KOBKNRG\DCGFKO.
�Æł��Æ��łªºØ����Ø,�ł����,Æ��ª��
BGZDEGNNKFGEKO.GMNGPIPEKO.PNBISEKO.\GZ\G
[NZCKRG.PBGZTKRKRG.TNTPY[GF.CKQKGETCKQ[BKRG
KGET.GPECZLRBGF.BPROBUTNVK[BKRGPCKQPF
[YGZB.PMNPYGOFFGBKYZB.
��ª�����łª æ�Øł�œł�"Æ
GMNPBQEB[\ENGMG’,BVKNGCYZKBFNCEGCDPDGO
FZKFGBMFGDFGPVZ[B\F[O[K[MGICGNT[G\
RSKOBVKNGCNBKEKTF,GMPG[M\GCCDPZB[K[MGI
CVSGYKONFDQ.GMNHFKFKFR[PZPMNZTPKXZFZT
GPPYZKOZTKOGCTGNOFHFFIGPZKOGDOCTGNO
FCBFZGIRKMKDO[FGBNBKETSGEFZGIRKG\FNB
K\TGZZNFSLTNKG.
łÆØ�ø��ºœ�,ł�"�,ª����:
169 FCRFG[VF
GDOMKS\GPKOGI\GPKOFECZKO,BNRB\PRT
PYZKB\O,MKCZK\MZG\FN[V\KKOFRGJVG\PZ
CBKPBGZTG\BENCBCFRKMC[KEZIPRB[BKRO
IGHZG\ZKYO,PTGZZB\FBFCFTE[\IVWCNDNGD
GDPDGO,BK[FGDFG[GDFCBFC\FMG’.
łÆØ�ø��ºœ�,�ł�"�Æ���œØ�æ’�º�œ
TKYZDEGNNF\DCZPBECMINNPGEEKKYBCT\FHB\
[BKRGPZDK[CTXPG[GOI[YNNPGEZYFIGPZ
PYZZGCTXNG\GCMCEG\GMG’BVKNG[PGIGGNCG
BJGPKOGNBKMGNNMGGQMNNPF[NGPEBUTNVKMQ
K\DCZCMINGPZBHCVKFGB\ECZKFDPZBP[RKG\
PEZ[GHGFZ.
���œ��Ø�œº"�
FPET[NHPRKRG,MCZCBNKEKF\V\IG\NFCKQFECZ
FHF,TN[KTGZGFBPK\K,GFINKJG,[BKQGEBKPGINJ
CPXKBG\.
BGNOIMPKRGH"NFCKRGB\FECZ,GCBGNFMZF
HG,CMPFBNVK[RFNVRKFO.NVKMLCRGDTNTRKKRKO
FE\KKO,FEZKMGGBSZGTNKRG,NBNCE[NBNYCGT
BKHFPSYRFTNCSKSTKGRK,BNB[BSZGTNKRGDO
NFS\KKTCTKGRKOMDGQBNF,GBVKNGCEZL[NP[B
GP\QCNCE.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł��� ø
JTG\DEGNFFKBNI[GC,[N[GQFYCNFP[P[\
C[PG\PGV[JKO,BNBBEZCFFKBBKRFRGDT\BNB
ZYCPP[KG\.
170NZBG\JGC
BMQK[ECZKOCTGNO[FOPP[KKO,BUTN
VK[BKQNRG\VKSFCFO,MDGQ:FPDRJ,FI[PN
GEGPKFO,TOMNHF,PKV\KB[ZKBPZ[F[PG\FNNG
FPF[PG\PGV[JKO?FZKBRGPMKZKOFKJCB\
VTGNG\KFO,GPFBKMV\NRG[NBKEGTNRG[OTXPG\G,
SGUSGU,BRGPMRKOBG\G,NCIKR\RG[BGEBK,BN
FVTGNG\FP\KISG\BNKG,GFGB[OPP[K.GBVKNG
\KRGYFP\IKNNECZ,KMGNNMRG\OC[O,BOZY
FZDK[B\PT[KFOCBVSPF,GHFIGYKRG,MNPF
[NBR[KDNBRDEKZFGC[O.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł��łœ
BKQ[GOS\KZFN[GOECZPQF\GZFPMNETF
PIYZK\[CTGNOMNN,BNB[BKQBRGXZKMKONYCN
F[TZG\NGEBKG\,BVKNGKFKGPGSPMG\FZCF,MKFQ
MXKWRGCN,[TGEPTJK\V\IGKG\ZMNK=FEZK[F,
G\FKKRFMNFF[TZG\FIE[G\NNTDGNYNS,GMN
FIMPG\FRTNG\[CKPKRGNYJRG\FPGI,GECZBNGYKRG
KYGONTGNO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"
F[MNFZXKGRNK[NRGBKRGMKBO\NPKEYJQFPSCKZ
YX\B\MNBGZFIKKO[K[CBGXZEPKGRRG,FT[KZ
GFYEG[,FIKCIKKPXKBG\TNKGRF,FPMZT\B\
FPXKBG\FZKBNK\,CBK\RKG\TXPKG\FGK\F.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’,łº"�
GBONBG\O[FOPEYEYKOZYCVZJK=ECZKO,RT[KO
MPFECZKOY[KO,PGHZKOGSG\ZKO,PFNRGGNFO?GMK
171 FCRFG[VF
ECZDNGKGV[GJFGBPFNLFRCGBFGZGIFYGE[?GMK
KGETKOBRIRGB\MNXVGRG\KFO,BGBVKNGBKHFINY
PFOCCZGZFZBGKNTZLF[DGC[NFO?BGBOKMGNKO
BRGNFDCKNB\TPYKPJZG\KFO?BRIRGTPNKO
NK[CTEMPF[[MNRGPDKT,BCNPF[R[BZS\GO
CVRKRG,FKGMNPYGOPBVNHF,[KSGEGCTKRKRGFMFG\,
NFI[KLB\BGZF[P[CDCGZ\FFMNNK\,[PMNNG\F
EGYBBRIRGNGYIKOIKKOGTH?
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�Ø"Ł
FBGPWFDGVRKGFIPZKGCZKBG\FRV[FJCTK\,
[FGYJRFGFGIN[FFZCFKG\ZPMNBXN\NPKEK
IMPKO.GHFCBDOMQPSKCG\[NXKGZKOPGJTKOCMN
FPZIC[NFETFFVRKPK\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"�
GFIKEG[KOFKG\ZJGCKOCBKOM[BKQPMGGRKO
NIKEG[GNVNVN,MKBONFBKZGNCZZB\FV[J
GFMNNG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’
KZBF[N[JG\FKBPF[P\KKZBKOPFP[NKO
FD[PKKO[CZHK\GZF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł Ø�ØŁ�ł,�"�
F[BNG\FZGIRKG\FDEGNG\[FKGRV\ZG\ZY
NDEGNKOGPXGKRKO,PIGKKCG\FQNFKV\ZTM[KG
CFEZDG\[GRG\NMNNFTO;GNFGZKEECZKORG[BKO
GR[DCKOPPZGOTGHOTETGPYFEKGJBFZDKNF
172NZBG\JGC
FFPGRK\.XZKLNHFTG[ZZGIDEGNGBEKZGTSYRG\
YCGTFGPGZDN\,[ZYBH\\ZICFETFG\CZZF[VF,
TEMEKNFCKTFECZKOFKG\ZTPGYKOCSDRGQYN
GVGVGNZK,NF[KCRV[G\XPBG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��ÆØ���,�"ª
GFRRKNTGZZB\MCGEGGB\MNFXTKZKOFIVXKO
NF\TGEENIKKOZGIRKKO,PMGCEKOGP\GYRKOCBP\
CTHZ\F’,TNEZLFFS\DNG\FSVZG\K\.FRRGIKKCKO
NYRG\NRGB\FM[ZGQFSVZG\K,B\FSDRGQFIKNMN
XCTKG,B\FVZGHKGB\FPNKXK.GBOK[CRGPK[PZDK[
B\ZGIGCRJKFN[KZFGVKGJ,BNRBKTHGCM[ZGRG.
KT[GPSG\,CIKRG\,NNPEB\CRKKFGEFY[\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,łº"
CTZLBEOYEPGQ,RCFN\KNZBG\,BKLXKKZGXGZF
D[PK\NPG[DBEOYEPGQ[NFYCNF,[FGBZYPG[D
PJVKHKTNEZLF[MNFBNFK,MVKPF[FGBPG[D
NPI[CFFMNNK\.GINKNFNFZ[G\NTXPRGNFD[KO
PG[DKOYEG[KOMBNF,BVKNGCEZLNKPGE.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�æ"Æ
BI\PFRVNBG\[N\NPGEZHKF\GZFFKB,[CHPQ
[BEONGPEB\FTRKRKOFR[BKOFNNGP\GLBFCF
GZD[VRKPK,BUTNVK[BKRGKMGNN\VG[B\FTRKRKO
CFCRF[MNK\CFKZF,PMNPYGOFOPZGPPKOB\
MNPFG\G,GBOMQPCFKYKOFTRKRKOTNKGB\BGZO,
TE[RINKRFZKIMPFP\V[JKOTNKG,GFGBPGSKUTN
173 FCRFG[VF
KEKF\TNGPFFVRKPK\,FCN\KCZGZF,[MNCFKZ
GPI[CFCZGZFCEZLFGVTFCIGDF[MN\G.
�łÆł�Ø"����,��ł�œ�œ�ł�,�ł�Ø’æ�Ø�Ø’
GBONVTPKOKZBFNG,[PKEFFP\TGZZ\TNKEK
FYZKBFCSVZKOPTRKRKFPGSZGFKZBFBKRFNVK
PKE\G,K\CGRQGKIYGZTNPKE\GPFFKB,GK\IHY
GK\BPWCKIGECPKE\GFTXPK\;GDOPHFBNKRIKEG,
PPF[P\TGZZTNKEKFSVZKO,GBUTNVK[YJQPBE
FGBXEF\VKSF[NGCTRKRKO[BKROMNML[KKMKONG,
PMNPYGOMNPEZDG\FJGCGFYGE[XZKMG\NFKG\
PYG[ZG\HGTOHG,GKIEMGNQKT[GIJKCFBI\NFBKZ
TNKGBGZF’G\GZ\GFTNKGRFCRTOF’GJGCG.
�łÆł�Ø"����,��ł�œ�œø�Æ�,�ł�Ø"ª,æ�Ø�Ł"�
FPI[CFFY[GZFCFXKGZFBNGFK,FKBFPI[CF
FKG\ZPTGERF,KG\ZTHKHF,DCGFFGISKRF[CTGNO.GBH
\GYVFRG\QFGBIGSQGTGHNMNFPVTNKO,F\RGTG\,
FFGKG\GFIKKO.MNFNKPGEKOGFIKRGMKO[CTGNOBKRO
MKBOMNKOPM[KZKOB\FMIFPI[C\K,[KFKFKGXB
BNFVGTN\EKZCPTPEGFKG\ZTNKGQ,EFKKRGFXKGZ
FBNGFK.�łÆł�Ø"����,
ØŁŁ�œø�łÆ�������æØ øƺœÆت
MNSKCGMKFETG\[CCRKBEOGMNFS\KZG\FVRKPKG\,
[MNKIKESGCNCETG\KG,CBKOZYPVRKFTZVKNKO
FPXGKKOCPI[CFTNECZFPG[DFBNGFK.
�łÆł�Ø"����,��ł�œ,�º"ª
174NZBG\JGC
GKET\K[KY[FTNFPTKKQMKMNFECZKOFBNFBKRO
F[D\PXKBG\FKEKTFCTXPF,BCNFOF[D\PXKBG\
[K[KEKTFCTGNO,GFBP\[MLFGB,BCNRCIZCKEKTF
FPGTJ\CECZKOFRS\ZKOPFKEKTFFPZGCFCECZKO
V[GJKO.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ, "Æ
GBUTNDCECXEPFECZKGS\GPKOGI\GPKOPBGE,
EFKKRGNFCKQS\ZTNKGQCTXOGNKET\GMQFECZKO
TNCGZKKQGTNP\MGR\QEGEBKXZKMBZC,GNBKCKRG
FECZKOMKBOPVKIMODEGNNBGHQPYCN,CZO
FMNNG\RKMZFKG\QZHKQTKNBKQGFECZKOTG[KOZG[O
C[GZ[KFOTNKGRKONPTNF.
ł’�ØØ�ªªØæ�����Ø,��ت"�,��ª�Ø����ت"���łºœæ łØ��œÆ’
GNMQSGSGZGMCGCKOFRFM\KC"MK\ZMCTNSGSKL
PZMCG\KLK[GTF"GCKBGZFECZEFRFFBG\KG\
RYZBKOSGSKOMPG[SGSCJNNDCKZGMCGGFZGMC
PRFKDGMLFRFBG\KG\ECGZGFOCJNKONDCKF[MN
GF[MNPRFKDGNMNB[ZKIVGWKJRG,BLPMNPYGOK[
K\ZGQPTNFCSGS[KMGNNFGNKLB\FZGMCNPYGO
[BKQFZGMCKMGNNKNL[O.
GMLK[K\ZGQGPTNFCBG\KG\FECGZ[KMGNKO
NFDCKFB\F[MNNPEZDFPBGERTNFPF[BKQ
CKMGN\F[MNNF[KDPXETXOF[MN\GMPG[RZBF
CIG[,[TNKEKFECGZK\GSUF[VT\[MNC[MNG.
GMLFGBFTRKQCRV[FBEOFPECZ\F\VNFFDO
[FECGZFGBZYPNCG[KFRV[GBKQNGTZLMNNNDCK
175 FCRFG[VF
PFG\FRV[TXPF[FBZFPPRFCNCEFKBP\V[J\
NFKG\[MNGPEG\MG’PMNPYGOPCIKR\FECGZRT[F
BGZPYKUNFR[PF[PYKVFPZB[FGTEZDNKFNFKG\
XZGZFCXZGZFIKKOB\F’PP[GMG’.
MPG[R\CBZNKYGJKBPZKOPF[NBFKFMI
CR[PFPXETXPFGFRFM\KC"NBCDCGZ\FSGSKIVW
GNBC[GYKFBK[KZXFZGXFF’B\KZBKG"MG’,MLMN
XKZGVKBG\KG\F\GZFK[CFOK\ZGQGPTNFHG
[CECKYG\RV[FBEOCXKZGVKBG\KG\BU[BKRGKGET
GPCKQFTRKQCTKQF[MNZY[FGDFGPECZCFO)NBVGYK
FZFGZENBGMECGZEPK(FZKFOPTNKOB\FRV[
NPYGO[NBFK\FFRV[PDT\[OPXE[Z[FMK[Z[
BG\KG\F\GZFFKBFDCFNPTNFP[Z[FRV[EBCB
KSECZ\BBNB[FBEOXZKLNFKG\CIKR\ZGMC
NFBG\KG\.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,œł��ł, łøœÆø��
GT\FETB\BNFKBCKLGTCEFGCNC[NOGCRV[
IVXF,CMNEZMKLETFG,GK\YKKOCLPYZB[M\GC:
"B[DCFGMKKET[PK".GKGCQPBPZIH"N)[GIZJGC
X"B(:"PVRKPFK[ZBNP\VNNKQGBKRORTRKQ,P[GO
[BKRQKGETKONF\VNNC[O".
GXZKLNFCKQECZKFOFTPGYKO,PBCKZKNC
ZIGYKO.MKNMBGZFKVNBFECZPFTRKQKEKTFHGGPF
JKCF?FNBBVKNG\KRGYG\[NRGKGETKQNF\VNNC[O,
GBONFHMKZGCM\CG?FNBECZHFRBSZCDCGNKQ,
GFFGDFBG\GCBG\KG\KGBKQNGINYNTGNOFCB,BCN
176NZBG\JGC
FKBFKEKTFTRKQICGZGY[GZ,GKIGE[KFBF[O[NO
GMSB[NO,[FGB[NPG\FTGNO.
�łÆØ��Æ��ªØ�,Ø�Æ"ı,æ��ÆØœ��,ª’ت,łŒª�œ�ø�
BVKNGCYZKBFNCEGDPDGOFZKFGBMFGDFGPVZ[
B\F[O[K[CMIGNT[G\RKSKOBVKNGCNBKEKTF...
GMQHFKFKFR[PZPMNZTPKXZFZTGPPYZKOZTKO
CTGNOFHFFTGNOFIGPZKGDOCTGNOFCBFZGIRK
MKDO[FGBNBKETSGEFZGIRKG\FNBK\TGZZ
NFSLTNKG.
łÆØ�ø��ºœ�,ł�"�,���ł�"��"���"
GMCZBPZGECKBNKFG[BVKNGYZBMNFKGOVSGY
GBIG\NGJQ\PRTFGBCQTGNOFCB.GFJTOMK
BG\KG\G\KCG\FFOKTGZZGZGIRKG\OGDOKFKF
\GTN\TXGOCFZMC\OBMNVTOKGNKEBGZIE[NVK
PXCFTGNPG\GXKZGUF[OFPKGIEB[Z[GNJCZDT
FFGBCBGVQMKFYGZBC\GZFCMNPYGOBU[NB
KCKQPMNPYGOFBG\KG\GF\KCG\TXPQFQFQ
FPZMCFFZMC\XGZG\FYEG[KOGZGIRKG\O.
�ØØ�ø����łºœ�ª�Ø�Ø’ø�"�
BVKNGBKRGPCKQPMNPYGOPKKDTTXPGC\GZF
[ICKCCTKRKGNFDG\CPBPZGK\CZLBVKNG[BKRG
HGMFNF[KDFJTOMKF\GZFRTNPFPTKRKMNIK
GFBEOXZKLNTSGYC\GZFBIZFKEKTF[BKBV[Z
NF[KDBIEPRKBNU[CFGBHK[NGINYC[GZ[
177 FCRFG[VF
F\GZF.NMQM\CFPFZ"N[PCZMKQNTSGYCECZK
\GZF,FDO[BKQKMGNNF[KDPMNPYGOTGSYFGB
C\GZF.
ł’Ø��ÆØøł����ł��Øı,���ت��ł�Ø�ı,ø œ��œÆ��œØ,œł�"Ł
178NZBG\JGC
F[\GG\FXGZFGECYG\
GNECYFCG.
ªÆłØ�Ø"�º"Æ
GPC[ZKBIHFBNG=F.
�ØÆØ"Łº"
DOFIMOPIGKCNYKOFECYCPEG\KG.
ø"œ�����Œø���,���Ø"ª,æØ��ł�"�
FECYG\CF’FGBF\[GYFFKG\ZJCTK\NBEO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,��"�
ZGIRKG\RYZBPF[NBK\CJNNTGNO.NMQ,FZXGQ
NYCNCXGZF[FGBRPXB,[FGBTNPR\NYCN,RYZB
D[PKG\,P[GO[FGBK\CJNPXGZFHGGKYCNXGZF
CTNPR\NF[VKT.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���ł"�,ł��Øœ��ł���ø��ØœÆŁ�����
TRKQTCGEF[NNF[VKTHFGMNFTCGEF[K[NRG
NT[G\,PSKC\[HFGRDEFJCT[RJCTCRG,FRYZB
ZXGQNYCN.GBRIRGXZKMKONT[G\B\FFKVL,[RI[GY
ZYNF[VKT,GNBNYCNNTXPRG.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���łł"Ł,���ÆłØ��œØ���ÆłØ��
MNFMGTSMBKNGTGCETCGEFHZF,MKCMNFTCKZG\
K[SLFMNTCKZFBI\,FKKRG\BGF.BCNBKQCFQ
DBGF,MKBKQBEOP\DBFCHF[NBKMGNNF\DCZTN
F\BGF.
P[BOMQMTS:PNCEHF[RFRFPF\BGF[N
MTS,FGBTGEP\DBFCHF[MGTS,[FGBKGET[FXEY
TPG,BIZ\BKLFGBKMGNNF\DBG\.RPXB[K[MBQC’
TCKZG\:B’\BGFPHF[RFRF,GC’PHF[P\DBF.
GMNFP\DBFBKQBRKGFGBKMGNKONEGZCPEGZ
BIE,GR[P\GPS\NY\.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���łæ"Æ,º��º�æº�Ø��ƪ�ƪ��ł�
BCNXZKLNFMKZCRV[G,B[ZF[OK\CZL,ZGEU
BIZKG,PP[CBG\GF[KTGZ,[FGBZGEUBIZF[O
K\CZL.GBSGZNGN[MGIISG[NGOB\HF,DOCT\
FDTDGTKOFKG\ZDEGNKO,GCHMZG[F[OK\CZL,P\DTDT
GZGEUNF\ECYCGC[KTGZTXGOMPE\TXPG,RPXB
\PKEFGNLCMKSGVKOGDTDGTKO,PIKNBNIKN,CHGGDB
ENBVSKY,[FGB\MNK\[NKPG\MIFRV[,TE[HGMF
N\[GCFPBFCF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª��’
TGEFOPECZKOGBRKB[PT.MNGPZ,[[KTGZF[PKTF
[NFYC"F,\NGKPP[C[KTGZFDTDGTKOFP\DNKO
CEKCGZKF\VKNF,GCFZDK[FBEODTDGTKOK\ZKO,KET
C[T\PT[F,[F[OK\CZL[GPTBNKGCKG\Z.
180NZBG\JGC
GPGCQPTXPG,[CKGETB\HF,RPXBP\IHYCKG\Z
C[VKM\NCG,MKBKQNLHMG\DEGNFPHG,B[ZPNMG[N
TGNOPJFBGHQY[C\BNKG.
GEGPFCTZL,NPF[BPZGIH"N:"FYC"FP\BGF
N\VN\Q[NXEKYKO".MKC\BG\G[NF[OK\CZL
NFBEO[K\YZCBXNG,R\TGZZMGIGDTDGTKODEGNKO
CFBEON\BGCNF[OK\CZL,MK"MPKOFVRKONVRKO
MQNCFBEONBEO".GRPXBPP[[EKCGZKF\VKNF
G[PKT\F\VKNF,TGNKOGCBKOCYRFBIE,TE
[K\YCXGN[KTGZF[NOGYGRFFMNGMG’,GHFTRKQ,
"ZGIBP[KLGBKK\KZGI"GMG’.G[KONCLCECZKOFBNG
[FOKSGEG\FZB[GRKOCEZMKF[OK\CZL.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª���"�
KMGNKOBRGNFP[KLR[PG\DEGNG\CTGNO,[KFKF
NFQZXGQBEKZGMIDEGNNFCKBDBGNFNTGNO,NFSKZ
B\MNFBVNGNKG\[CIKKO...GFMN\NGKCZXGQ[NRG...
CF\EPG\NBNFKOTNKEKFNKMFCEZMKG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł Ø�ØŁ�ł,�"�
\GG\ZTNMN\[GYG\GPBGGKFIGPZCT\PSTL
FZGIRKG\KYZBYKXGRK.
BL,FECYG\CBNBKRFYKXGRK\.FF\PSZG\
NPKNGKGSKVGYF\[GYG\HGFKYKXGRKG\.BLBVKNGPF
[PMGRFCVKFCZKG\YKXGRKG\,BKQCGXGZL.BV[Z
NF\YZCNCGZBBUPCNKNGG\ZTNFMN.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
181 F[\GG\FXGZFGECYG\
PFFGBRYZBIRGQ,BUB\FFKFIRGQ.PFFGBRYZB
ZIGO,BUB\FFKFZIGO.PFFGBRYZBYEG[,BU
B\FFKFYEG[.
GTNEZLHGYZBGFRCKBKONBNCMNBG\QFMRGKKQ:
BZLBVKOGZCISE,XEKYGK[Z,\PKO,DKCGZGIHY,
GMKGXBCFQ,NFGEKT[FQEZMKOJGCKOGK[ZKO,GIKC
BEONFRFKDTXPGCFQGNFEPG\BNKGMVKMGIG.
ł’�ø�Æ��Ø��,�ł�Æ"�,��ºœª�œ�ł�Æ"�, ł��’
M[O[FBEOXZKLNF\ZDNBNFJCTFIGPZK
GMGIG\KG,KNPEB\EZMKGGPT[KGT"VBG\OFIGYKO
F[GNJKOCTGNO,[FGBCTXPGDOMQINYPFO.
GFO[GNJKOC\GMGMPG[FO[GNJKOPIGWNG,MMF
KG\ZPHFXZKLGPGMZIFGBNFS\DNNIGYKFJCT
FZGIRK,[FOKG\Z[GNJKOCPXKBG\MGNF,[FGB
INYPPRF.
GZB[K\GBIZK\[NSKDGNHFFKBFRYGEFFTNKGRF
[NFECYG\FBNFK\CMNEZMKGGCMNPT[KG,CMN
ZD[G\KGGPI[CG\KG.FSKDGNBNFPXKBG\FZGIRK\,
FMGNN\MN,PPRFFGBRGCTGBNKFFGB[C.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ØŁŁœ�ªÆłØ�łÆ��,�� ��æØ�øƺœÆØ�ت,�łœ�ł�Ø"�
CTXOFFGKF[NRV[FBEOJCGTFKSGE[NFFMZI
FR[P\KGFBPGRFCBNGYKOKGXZFTGNOGP[DKITNMN,
KZB\FZGPPG\GFBFCFG[BKV\FECKYG\FBNGYK\
182NZBG\JGC
FTNKGRF.GBPGRFHB\FKB\GMQFIKKOGVGTN\TN
FBEOCMNKPKIKKGGCVTGNG\KG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�
F\MGRFFK[ZBNK\FBPK\K\...TXOFIKKOFK[ZBNKKO,
FOMNGNKOZYCRYGE\BFC\F[OK\CZL...HB\
FKBF\MGRFFTKYZK\[NRG...GBUTNVK[NVTPKO
FKBP\TNP\,FKBTGPE\EGYBC[CKNHFNIHGZ
GNFDNG\CMIKG\ZDEGN,MIGYMIMCKZGBEKZ[SCN
HPQZCPMITGXZGPGRT,[M[P\DCZTNKGFGBCZTO
GMIBPKW,CRVWGHZO.HB\F\MGRFNBF[\R\FGNB
\[\RF.
\FNGMG\FIKKOGXGZ\OFIKXGRFFQPYCNG\
NVTPKOBKHF[KRGK,BCNNBF\GMQFVRKPK...HB\
FKBF\MGRF[NRGFYCGTFGFYKKP\...,GMNPF[BRG
PZIKCKOGP[MNNKOB\FETFGFFMZFBKRFMKBO
MEKNK\QPYGOGPZICNF\MGRFFBNFK\FTXPK\
FHB\,[\\V[JG\\DNFCKG\Z.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"�
M[O[FBEOXZKLNF\ZDNBNFJCTFIGPZK
GMGIG\KG,KNPEB\EZMKGGPT[KGTNVKBG\O
FIGYKOF[GNJKOCTGNO,[FGBCTXPGDOMQINY
PFO,GFO[GNJKOC\GMGMPG[FO[GNJKOPIGW
NG,MMFKG\ZPHFXZKLGPGMZIFGBNFS\DNNIGYK
FJCTFZGIRK,[FOKG\Z[GNJKOCPXKBG\MGNF,
[FGBINYPPRF.GZB[K\GBIZK\[NSKDGNHFFKB
FRYGEFFTNKGRF[NFECYG\FBNFK\CMNEZMKG
GCMNPT[KG,CMNZD[G\KGGPI[CG\KG,FSKDGNBN
183 F[\GG\FXGZFGECYG\
FPXKBG\FZGIRK\FMGNN\MN,PPRFFGBRGCTGBNKF
FGB[C.�łÆł�Ø"���,ØŁŁœ�ªÆłØ�łÆ��,�� ��æØ�øƺœÆØ�ت,�łœ�ł�Ø"�
MNFTCGEF,MNF\GZF,MNFIMPF,MNFPGSZ,
MGRRKG\FTGNOMGNO,FKROFMRG\NFTNG\B\FTGNO
MGNGGB\FBEOCMNNGNPTN\FECYG\FBNGFK\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ØŁŁœ�ªÆłØ�łÆ��,�� ��æØ�øƺœÆØ�ت,�łœ�ł�Ø"�
\CKTF[N[YZFKBNCY[PFR[PFECYG\BNGYK\
BPK\K\CNB[KRGK[NNKPGECPTPYKZHKF\GZF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ØŁŁœ�ªÆłØ�łÆ��,�� ��æØ�øƺœÆØ�ت,�łœ�ł�Ø"�
FIMPF[FBEOXZKLNET\BG\F.BI\FKB,NET\
GNFS\MNCSGEBEGRG,GBI\FKB,NET\B\TXPG,
[KETPKFGB,GBKLRCZB,GPBKQFGBCB,GNBQFGBKNL,
G\KYGQFDGUBKLP\\YQ,GBKLFGBT\KENCBCEKQNVRK
PNLFMN.łÆØø���ÆłØ��Ø,���ł,
øØł�øØłØ��� Øłø�æ��ª’��"�,���ł�º�œ�ª�ŁłØŒ�Ø��Æł�ø
GFZKF\GZFPXGFGBGPZ"GCG\ECY")ECZKOK’,M’(.
GBUTNVK[VKZ[GTNFP\ECYC\NPKEIMO,BCNSGU
SGUBKQPYZBKGXBPKEKV[GJG.GFBP\,[XZKMKO
K[ZBNNKECYCGPP[CECKYG\DPGZ,NET\EZMKG
FPKGIEKOTNVKYEG[\G,GNNM\CFO.GFRFTNMQ
184NZBG\JGC
BPZG:"[KZF[KZKO=YE[YE[KO")[KZ
F[KZKOZCF,SGUFV\KIF(.MKFGBPKGSEPP[
TNHFFTRKKQ,GPVZ[FBFCFFHB\,GMNFF[\ENG\
[P[\ENFYC"FNF\ECYCYEG[\GTOK[ZBN,
[K[ZBNXZKMKONFYCKNMRDEHF\[GYFBNKG
K\CZL,NF\ECYECKYG\PP[.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,���ł�غ�,��’"�
GRGET[FMN\NGKCB\TZG\BEN\\B,M[BRGP\TGZZKO
NECGYCCGZBK\’PNPJFTNKEKHFBRGPTGZZKO,
MCKMGN,\[GYFCCGZBRGK\’NF[VKTNRGMNJGC,
GBRIRGTOFCGZBK\’ECZBIE[NO,M[BRGECKYKO
CGK\’.GHFCNBHFMCKMGN,BKQRYZB[NOMPBPZ:
BKQF[O[NOGBKQFMSB[NO,[BRIRGRYZBKO
MSBNFCGZB.
ZYMB[ZBRIRGPTGZZKO\IKNFPKQRGYCKQ,
EFKKRG\[GY\KRGPNPJFNECYCGK\’,TNKEKHFBRG
PTGZZKO\[GY\GK\’PNPTNFNPJF,GBHM[F[RK
\[GYG\CBKOMBIE,BHFGBECZBIE[NO,GHFG
[RBPZ:\PKO\FKFTOF’BNYKL,ZGXFNGPZ,B\F
TOF[OK\’RYZBECZBIE[NO.
ł’�������ŁÆłæ�Ø�’ł�ÆØ�,��ł�Ø�Ø�
PK[K\TSYCHB\FIMPFCBP\BHK\\Y[ZRV[G
NF[OK\CZLGMNT\PGSZRV[GCMICBP\NF[O
K\CZLCBFCFTHFTE[BKRGXZKLNPSKZG\RV[
CVGTN.ł’ÆØ��Ø��Œø Øł��ªØ�Æ,
��ł"�,�æ œ��ł"�,�œ�’
185 F[\GG\FXGZFGECYG\
BCNPF[FOYGZBKORS\ZIMP\FYCNF,FBKL
FGBRS\Z,FNBMNPK[ZGXFNNPGEFSVZNVRKG,
GBOBKRGPCKQFGBTOFBZW....BNBTRKQFRS\ZG\
[CMNFHGFZGM\CKFBZKH"NFMNCRGKOTNVKECKYG\
FCGZB,NPK[HGMFNFECYGNFKG\XGVFCPZMCF
TNKGRF.
�łÆ�ø�� ØØÆø,ØøłªÆłØ��œ
XZKLFBEOM[PTKKQCBKHFSVZG\GNF\YGG\GCG
K\CZLGFNKPGE[NGXZKLNFKG\TNKSGEFBPGRF
[FGBPBPKQCF[DIF[F’KBKZTKRKG,BHFGBRT[F
HYGYNF’GK[NGBHPDTTOF’GTNKEKHFFGBKMGN
NHMG\NECKYG\CGK\CZL.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���ł�’
PTKQD[PKNBKGNKEBNBD[PKG\,GCMNPYGO[RG\Q
TKRKG,RPXBZYPD[O.GPTKQZGIRKPGXKBZY\PGRG\
ZGIRKG\,GCMNPYGO[RG\QTKRKGP\CZL.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª��"�
186NZBG\JGC
BPGRFGKZB\[PKO
FMNCKEK[PKOIGWPKZB\[PKO.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�æºœÆłºœª��"�
MNFCFKZG\CBFP\GLBPGRF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�تœ�ł�Ø�,����
NPBPKQFBPK\KBPGRFFKBZBKF.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
MNECZKMGNN[P[MBPXTKNTCGE\FCGZB.BLMMN
[VGI\\FBPGRF,MLVGRKOFBR[KONEZMKOSCGMG\
GY[G\KG\ZCMEKNTCEG.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
F\ZIYP\IMGOGPF\IMPGKG\,FONBKTHZGNL
NF\YZCNBN.EZG[KONLZYV[JG\,KG[ZNC,
GBPGRF.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
FMNCKEK[PKOIGWPKZB\[PKO.BO\CY[ECZ
PFCTRKKRKIGPZGD[PKG\[NFTGNOFHF,SVYBO
\KTRF.BCNBO\CY[KZB\[PKO,PGCJINLMK
\KTRF.
�łÆØ������ª����
CHPQ[CBNBEOCIKR\KZBFFGBXZKLNKET[BKQ
TGEPNCEG,M\GC,GBVKNGPT[KM[VKOGBOFGBZGBF
[FKZBFP\DCZTNKGBHKFGBXZKLNET\[BKQIS
G[NGOPYZFBNBR\QNGF[OK\CZLFHEPRG\
P[PKOGFGBXZKLNTKGQGNPGENBKHFPJZF[NIGNG
B\FKZBFFHG,PS\PBFGBCMEK[KGMNNF\DCZ
GNGPZBKQTGEPNCEG.
GBVKNGBIZKMNBNFTEKKQFKZBFGFVIENBFNL
PPRGBHKFGBXZKLNYCNPHFEGDPBGNGPZ,CBG\G
[KTGZFKZBFXZKLNFKG\CTCEG\F[OK\CZLFKKRG
[FKZB\[PKO[FGBNHMG\XZKLNFKG\CHFFBGVQ
[NKZBF[K[NGTM[KGFKKRG[FDGUP\VTNPFKZBF
FHGFIKXGRKG\MQPP[CBG\FFXGZF[NF\VTNG\
FDGUXZKLNFKG\KZB\[PKO.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���ł��"�,��Ø�Øł�� �ªøÆ�� ��Ø����ª�
[PKTFRYZB\BPGRF[XZKMKONFBPKQPF[FGB
[GPTPF[BGPZKONG[FGBBP\.ZBKFRYZB\
KEKTF,[BKRGXZKLNFBPKQ,BOFGBZGBFCTXPG.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���łøº"�,ł�Ø�ø�Ø��
FBPGRFBKRFNB[MNGNBZD[,BNBDKNGKTXPK
FKG\ZKSGEK[NPFG\FR[PF,[XZKLNFEZKLBG\F
C\MGR\F.GM[BKQP[IK\KOB\EZMFFJCTKNF,
BKRRFXZKMFN[GO\GMQBIZNSTEF,BNBFKBPGXB\
CTXPFB\FMN.CT\FIN[,BGZFBHCBF[MNGFZD[
NVRG\NVRKFEZL.GDOBHFKBXZKMFNET\B\TZMF,
[NBP[Z\KF=F[MNGFZD[=FOFROTXPG\F...
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�,70
188NZBG\JGC
XZKLNET\[BKBV[ZNVRG\BNF[OK\CZLC[GO
[MNGC[GOZD[,GYNGIGPZC[GOIG[,MKBOCBPGRF
NCE,G\VKNFFKBBPGRF,GKZBFGBFCFFRODOMQ
DKNGKKO[NFBPGRF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�,70
CTXOFFGKF[NRV[FBEOJCGTFKSGE[NFFMZI
FR[P\K,GFBPGRFCBNGYKOKGXZFTGNOGP[DKITN
MN,KZB\FZGPPG\GFBFCFG[BKV\FECYG\
FBNGYK\FTNKGRF.GBPGRFHB\FKB\GMQFIKKO,
GVGTN\TNFBEOCMNKPKIKKGGCVTGNG\KG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�,244
FBEOFK[ZXZKLNFBPKQCIKKG,MNGPZ[KBPKQCIKK
TXPGGFZD[G\KGFFGNMG\CEZLK[KZFPKSGERV[G,
[FOJGCKOGK[ZKOG[FOPGNKMKOCEZLK[ZF.
F\GZFXZKMF[\FKFRZNZDNG,[TNKEFKZBFB\
FPYGO[[OFJTG\TNGNF,[NVTPKO\\TFRV[C\FG
NBEZL.BCNFPTPEF\PKEKXZKLNFKG\FCJIGQ
FRV[K.FBK[FK[ZBNKPIGKKCNFBPKQ[R[PFBNFK\
[ZGKFCYZCG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł�, ł�Ø"�,æ�Ø�Æ’
PF[FGBNPTNFPQFET\,BKQ"IGV[ETG\"RGVN
TNKG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł Ø�ØŁ�ł,Ø"�
GFNBMNFVSKPKG\RGCT\FKBZYPHFF\GMQFKIKEK
[NFSVYRG\[PBFIKKOFIGPZKKOFOMNFK[,MN
189 BPGRFGKZB\[PKO
FIKKO.GTEMPFKGMNKSGEZTGTMHF,[BKQNGMN
SPKMFPETK\CZGZF,MKBOBPGRFTY[RK\,NTZTZ
KSGEIKKOPNBKET\GBPGRFTNKGRF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�
GK[TGE[RKPXG\NZCKRGKGRFF\NGKG\CMNNG\F[O
FYEG[PXG\T[FNF\CGRQCDENG\F[OK\CZL
[RBPZGKET\FKGOGF[CG\BNNCCLMKFGK"FFGB
FBNYKOC[PKOPPTNGTNFBZWP\I\BKQTGE
GRBPZ[BGPZGOTKRKMOGZBGPKCZBBNFEFKKRG
NF\CGRQCDENG\KGXZCZB[K\...GTKYZPXGFHGNIYGZ
GNNPGECECZKPZ"QBNYKGCECZKFHGFZGKCKQPTPE
GPXCMNFTGNPG\.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�ł��ØØ�ø�œª��"�
IMP\FBP\,[FKBCBFPF\DNG\ZGIFYGE[,
PCBZ\B\MNFFBZG\,FTGNPKOMGNO,PXEJGFZ
F[MNK,[FEPKGQK[NGYX\BIKHFCFQ.GP\GLML
FIGN[FFDGVRK\TNGNFFKBNCGBBIZKF[\YTG\
DEGNFCFFGVTG\FTNKGRG\,GBKQNHF\YRF,MKBO
NR[BB\MNFTGNOFEPKGRKBNFZGPPG\F[MNK\.
GHFCBPXETCGEFYEG[F[NKZBFVRKPK\,[FKB
PYGZFIMPF,FPTNFIMPF\\BFNZGPF[NIMPF
TKNBF.
GBHNBEK[IGN[FDGVRK\BKRFCBFTNKEK
FF\DCZG\F[MNK\,BNB[HZPKDCGZF,DEGNKO
GPNBKO,P\DCZKOGTGNKOTNKEKF\DCGZ\FDEGNF
190NZBG\JGC
[NFF[\YTG\F[MNK\FJFGZF,[FKBPGVKTF
CBGZ[NZGIFYGE[.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ºœÆØ�łÆ��
191 BPGRFGKZB\[PKO
SDGNFG\KYGQ
ZXFFCGZBNCZGBTGNOISZMEK[CRKFBEOCTNK
FCIKZFK\YRGB\FISZGQFHFCTCGE\FCGZB[NFO
"N\YQTGNOCPNMG\[EK".
ł’�ø�Æ��Ø��,�ł�Æ"�,�ł��ƺØ�
RPXB[FTGNORCZBC[CKNK,XZKLBRKNZBG\GNTKKQ
CMNT\C\KYGQFTGNO,GNPNBG\ISZGQFTGNO,
GNF\VNNCTCGZO.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ,�Ø�ŁØ��ł"�,œł��’,�’
FRFC[TF[FBEOTGSYCIMPFFHB\,GPHMKZB\
F[PG\[NFBGZG\GFMNKO,[K[NFOPCIKR\R[P\G
[KKMG\BNKG,FRFFO\KMUPBKZKOTNKG,C[KTGZ
PSGKKO,BNB[FOPBKZKONGCNKF\NC[G\CVRKPKG\
R[P\G,PJTO[ISZKOFMNKOFPGM[ZKONYCN\O,
MBPGZ.BPROFFBZF[PYCNVTOBIZVTO,CT\
FTSY,PG[MKOTNKGIQPPZGPKO,GP[VKTKOCG[VT
[NYEG[FGJFZF,[FPFPYZCKOB\FBEOPBE,
[KDKTN[NKPG\G.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���œ��ª�øł�æ Øłœ,�œ��"�
RPXBNVKHF,[MNFEIKG\FYGEPG\[FKGNG=MGNQ
FKGPFCGZBTXPG.GMGNQFKGMEKNEIGUBG\G
NF\V\IG\ZGIRK\,MEK[NBKS\VYCPXCG.GNB
[FEIKG\FBNFFKGMTGR[TNPT[KONBJGCKO,
[BG\OT[FPVRK[NBFKFKMGNNF\DCZTNFFVZTG\.
BNBZYPK[FCGZBZGXFNYZCG,FCGZBCTXPG
[GNINGTHZFPNPTNFTNKEKEIKG\BNF.GTHZF
MHB\R[NI\BLGZYNPK[K[NGZXGQBPK\KNF\TNG\
PFTGNOFHF=BEOMHFPYCNTHZFPNPTNF,CHF
[PZBKONG\PKE,BKL[FGBNBCSEZ,[FGBNB
P\YEONZGIRKG\,G[GNIKONGPI[CG\GEKTG\RDE
KIGEKG\PTuKFCGZB.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łÆ’,��Ø�øºØ�œ�Æ��œ�
FBEOXZKLNET\,[BUVTOFGBNBKCGBNET\B\
F[KTGZFBPK\K[NI[KCG\FY[ZCKQBEONCGZB,
MKBKQCKEFBEONFTZKLB\PKE\TZMFFBPK\K.
BNBMVK[KTGZ[FBEOPTZKLBG\F,C[KTGZHF
FGBP[KDB\PTN\FGI[KCG\F.GK[CHFSDGNF,
[TNKEKHFFGBKMGNNHMG\,[FBZFHG\[BZBXNG
CYCKTG\.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łª’,æØÆœ�ºÆªœÆ�ƪ�
TRKKQFKDKTG\[FBEOP\KKDTFGBZYFMRFNCGB
NPSKZG\RV[.NMQXZKLFBEONF\ZDNNPSKZG\RV[
\PKE,PVRK[NBKMGNNCGBN[GOPEZDFCNKPSKZG\
RV[,[ZYHFFMNKFPM[KZNHMG\NMNFPEZDG\.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łł"�,��Ø��Ø�Ø��
KEGT[PJZ\FCZKBFFKBNFJKCNRCZBKG,FKKRG
[F’ZGXFNF[VKTN\I\GRKOMNJGC.GMNHF[FBEO
TEKKQNBYKCNB\[NKPG\F\TRGDKOGTEKKQPZDK[
193 SDGNFG\KYGQ
BKHFIKSZGQ,HFGSKPQ[TEKKQNBFDKTN[NKPG\
FPJZF.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���łł"Ł,���ÆłØ��œØ���ÆłØ��
MNNZB[GQ,PF[RGETNRGPMGGR\FPBXKNC"FCHF,
FGB,MKCZXG\GNFKJKCZXFNFPXKBRPXBKO[KYCNG
B\JGCG.GMEK[KFKFFJGC[NO,XZKL[KYCNGFG
CHMG\GNBCXEYF,[NBKFBFCG[\VGDPG,MBGMNB\
[BKRG[NG.
GMEK[KGMNGNHMG\,FPXKBPXKBG\BIE[KFKF
BNKFONF\YQ,PF[BKRGXZKLFGB,GC\YRO
BG\G=KHMG.GFGBPXKBG\FSVKZG\,MKFOPXKBG\
BIEMPGPICZ\XKRGZG\,[CTPEFTN\KYGRFMZBGK,
PP[KMKOF[VTPQFPBXKNBNFP\YRF.GHFG
HMG\G=[FYKOIVWFPBXKNC"F,[IVW[KYCNG
RPXBKGB\JGCG.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,º��Ø œ�Ø�º��ª�œ
MNXKZGVKBG\KG\F\GZFK[CFOK\ZGQGPTNF
K\KZFHG,[CECYG\RV[FBEOCXKZGVKBG\KG\BU
[BKRGKGETGPCKQFTRKKQCTKQF[MNZY[FGDFGPECZ
CFO)NBVGYKFZFGZENBGMEKCGZEPK(FZKFO
PTNKOB\FRV[NPYGO[NBFKK\FFRV[PDT\[O
PXE[Z[F,MK[GZ[BG\KG\F\GZFFKBFDCF
NPTNFP[Z[FRV[.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,œł��ł, ’Æø��ª"��øØł���’
194NZBG\JGC
K[[N[FECZKOFONFSKZMNFPGRTKOC\VNF
GMG’,GFD’FGBTSYGNKPGEECZKPGSZFRPXBKO
PN[GQFBZF[FBKZCPYGOFIG[L[FGBIMP\
BP\.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,��ŁØœł��Æ���œ�Ø�, łøœøØł�øØłØ�,ª��"�
GDOETFNKPGEFHGFZTNMGNFPGTKNNF[DMKECZKG
FZPKONCEPBKZKOVRKFBEOGRG\RKOMIGIKN
NR[P\FBEOFTGSYGCFKVGLINKNFFQPBQEP\VZ[
PKRKFMBNGVGZ[PMGNBMKMQEZ[GTNKGCKPKGPBQ
EP\VZ[PZCK[PTGQMBNGP\VZ[PMGNBGF[\BBU
TNVK[FGBBKRGMBQMCGEGK[MBQGECZKGFYEG[KO
XZKMKOBRGNNPGEGTNKEOBGNKKHMFNF[KDECZPF
MKBONBKGTKNMGNGKGTKNPYX\GMKFYNKVFBKBV[Z
NFSKZCVTOBI\MKPTJPTJBDZ[RG.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,��ŁØœł��Æ���œ�Ø�, łøœøØł�øØłØ�,ª���"
GHFTXFRVNBFCMNPKRKXTZI"GGKZKEFGYJRG\
FPGIKQGJPJGOFNCNPGECECZKOYNKOMPGTKQ
KTYCPEZ[BGNGPZHFZG\YGRKOGDONNPGEDPZB
V[GJDOMKNBPGCQBXNGMNGOGHFTXFDEGNF
GRVNBFNF\TNG\PMNPKRKKZKEFGYJRG\GNBMET\
F[GJKO[BGPZKO[BKQNNPGEC[TF[NCGCNTPG
GKEGTMPFPT[KG\PBR[KOV[GJKO[HMGTNKEKHF
NTRKKRKODCGFKO.
�����ÆÆœ,���ł�Ø�ª�œł�
195 SDGNFG\KYGQ
TGEPXB\KPZDNK\JGCFGFKBKYZ\FTZLGPGTKNF
FZCFN\KYGQTGQ,GZBGKNMNPK[YZFNGISG[NGO
NGPZBG\F,GK[CFMINYCWGNNYJFRKXGXG\[RVNG
CYNKVF,MB[ZFTKEFBGZFPGVNBPZQFBZ"KH"N
GFZCIKKOGKJBNGCVZJNPK[ZBFYZKCBG\GFKGO
GFGB[KNPGECMNKGOBIZF\VKNF\KYGQP"I
PF\KYGRKOMKFGBPSGDNNFGXKBKYZPHGNNGN\YQ
VDOFYZKGPFJGCGRTKOBOKNPGEBG\GCKPK
F[GCCKO.
æ��ª�ØØ�"Æ�œ ’
GCBP\CT\NKPGEFSGEG\,GCVZJSVZFHGFZ
GF\KYGRKOPBKZFRV[,GTNKEKNKPGEGKEKT\MGGR\
FPXGG\PTGZZC[GZ[KOTNKGRKO...GKBKZGNPJF
CTKNGKZCBGZDEGN...
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�œØÆ�œØŒ,�œØÆ�Ø�ª,øÆØ��’�œÆ’
TKYZF\DNG\FIMPFFHB\CEGZKRGNBFKFBNB
NFBKZTNFRV[NHMMFC\[GYFGECKYG\BFCF
GKZBFCYEG[FJFZFGTRGF...MKF\DNG\FBGZFXVGQ
FHFCKPKRGFKFNFBKZTNKRGGTNRV[KRGNFSKZPB\RG
MNFHGFP\G\BG\FZTG\NJTGOPBGZTNKGQBGZXI
PP[JTOTGNOFCBGNFSKZFYGXKOPEG\ZTG\
GDBGFGF[\ZZG\TNZTFGGK\ZPKEG\ZTG\B[ZFO
N[KMKOCTKRKRGYRBFG[RBFGBFC\ZTG\.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�œØÆ�œØŒ,Æ��ª��
196NZBG\JGC
GBO\BPZBOMQPF\GTN\K[C\KYGRKOFBNG.ET
MK\GTN\DEGNK[.ZB[GRF,[MCZBKRORBCEKOBNB
[FOR[PZKONSGUFKPKO.[RK\,MKCFKT[G\MN
FVTGNG\FDEGNG\FBNFCVRKO,BUTNVK[BKQ
FVTGNG\TXPQKGXBKONIGW,BLSGUSGUFBZFKGXB
P[ONT[G\\KYGRKODEGNKOCMNNG\FDBGNF.BNB
[NFGXKBBG\FFBZFYJRF,XZKMFMNFVTGNG\
FFOFDEGNG\,PVRKFKG\OSDGZKONVRKO.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,ª�Ø�
GFRFNZVBG\IGNBKOFVRKPKOEFKKRKNFTNG\
FRV[PCIKR\FYJRG\FGBNF\TGZZ\PKEC[PIF
K[PIK[ZBNCTG[KGBCNNHFXZKLDOMQSKKT\B
E[PKB.
GFRFFTXFFKTGXFNHFNFZCG\CBPKZ\\YGRK
HFZFYEG[GEKKYBNGPZ\KYGRKO[TNHFR\KKSE
F\KYGRKON\YQCIKR\PGIKQEYJRG\MPGCBCSVZ
MSBFPNLCFYEP\GGNGPZBPKZFV[GJFCNK[GO
VKZG[MNNCIKG\BNYG"\GCF\TGZZG\,GCBO\ZDKN
TXPLCHF\ZBFVNBG\.
GMBQR\\KNFICZKO\YGRKFRV[NDPGZCMN
IGE[SVZF\KYGRKOGYGEO\DPGZF\KYGRKOC[N[
VTPKKOEFKKRGNGPZCVTOZB[GQ[NK[\KYGRKOCVTO
BIEGMMF[RKG[NK[K\GBIZML\DPGZCMNIGE[CNK
K[GRFGHFKGTKNNLKG\ZPMNNPGEKSVZKPGSZ.
��łœø�łØ���Ø�,��łœ��
MNPXGG\FM\GCG\C\GZFBGFPYGCNG\[\YRG
FBCG\,BUTNVK[ZGCOFOCPT[FBGCVF,FMNFO
197 SDGNFG\KYGQ
N\YQFNC,MKMNNCCG\EGZ[F’,GMNKXZPI[CG\
PCKQ.
łÆØ�Æł���ØÆ���ł�,ł�Æ"�,Øæª�ł�,ª��’�"Æ
PF[BKQCKEKFBEON\YQ,BNK\TSYCG\EKZ,
GKYKKO"EBDFCNCBK[KSKIRF"=KSKIRFPET\G.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�تœ�ł�Ø�,œØ��
FPBPKQCF[DIFVZJK\KGETMKPF’PXTEKDCZ
MGRRG,B[ZR[PFHGXZKMFNCZZGN\YQBKHFCKZGZ
G\KYGQCPYGOVNGRK.GPBG\C[RKO,BGDOP[T\
CZKB\FTGNO=FRFFECZ[XZKLNF\CZZBGNF\\YQ
PIMFNBG\FFR[PF[\CGBNCZZGGN\YRG.GDO
R[PFFNHGFRFPBHRBXNFGRCZBFFKBPIMFNHPQ
KZKE\FNCZZGN\YQB\B[ZFGJNTNKF.
���Ø�Ø�,º"ŁæØ�
NYCNB\[NKPG\FCZKBFPGMZINFKG\CIKR\
\KYGQ,[HFCIKR\\KYGQFCZKBF,[HFPGJNTN
FRCZBKONT[G\,[HGFKCIKR\B[ZCZBBNGYKO
NT[G\.G\KYGQHFFGBCIKR\FZXGQNF[VKT,MPCGBZ
CSVZKFBBPG"ZH"N,[PJZO[FBEO\KYQB\
MGGR\G,[MNPT[KGKFKGN[O[PKO,BKBV[ZNYCN
F\TRGDKOFTNKGRKO,[CIKRFHGRYZB\PYCNTNPR\
NF[VKT.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���łł"Ł,���ÆłØ��œØ���ÆłØ��
198NZBG\JGC
BKQXZKLNSKDGVKOGBKQXZKLN\YQB\FIKXGRKG\.
GNB\\YQMNNB\FIKXGRKG\[NL,BNBZYB\
FVRKPKG\[NL.MKZYFVRKPKG\[NLTGPE\NYCN
\KYGQ.GTKYZPF[FVRKPKG\P\YNYN\PIP\FK[G\
GFDBG\.GBOB\FZGXFNPZYFIJBKOPPL,K[NL
NTSGYCCKJGNFK[G\CPYGOFSKDGVKO,[\ZDK[
CTXPL[B\FF[VNGFDZGTCKG\ZPMNCBKFTGNO.
BMQXZKLNFKHFZ,[NBK[VKNTXPGBNBPBR[KO
M[ZKO,NVRKFICZF[NRG,GNBNVRKHZKO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª��"�
FRFTX\KHG,RYKFGYNFFKB,GBVKNGBK[IN[KGMN
NYKKOBG\FCMN\GYU.MKBKRFPJ[\MGIG\FDGU,
GFKBFJFZFF[NPF.GFDO[NBECZ\KTKPLPHF,
FGB,PVRK[NBFKK\XZKLNFMNML.MKCFKG\L
ECGYTKPKCPYGOBIE,NBJNBJFKK\PMKZPPKNB
C[KVNG\[NL,CNK[GONKPGEKOGPT[KO,PF[BKQ
MQTM[KG,[BKRLTKPKCPYGPK,BHKB\FPGMZI
NTSGYCCKJGNFK[G\EZLFRHMZNTKN.
GFTKYZNFZCG\C\VKNFGNIHYFCKJIGQ[KXNKI
F[OK\CZLBG\LNHMG\N\[GCF[NPF.GNET\BKL
NF\ECYCGK\CZLCY[ZBIENRKXIKG\.MKHFG
FTKYZ,GCHFRKMZCKQTGCEF’NNBTCEG.G"BNEPK
NL,GBN\\QEPKNG".TE[KSNINMNIJB\KLGV[TL,
GKYZCLBNKGNTENRXIRXIKO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª��"�
\GZ\FF\V\IG\,FGNM\GMGC[\B\FTGNOMT\,
FKBP\BP\NZHKTGNO[NFYCNF,KG\ZPMNF\GZG\
199 SDGNFG\KYGQ
FVKNGSGVKG\FBIZG\.FF\V\IG\FFGNM\CPSNGN
[NF\TNG\,FKBRG\R\B\FKSGEFBGVJKPKCTGNO,
MKBKLBV[ZNF\KB[C[TF[ZGBKO[FMNP\V\I
GP\TNF...FFGKFMGNFP\V\I\GTGNF,M[O[FECZ
RKMZCINYKOPPRFGTNK\FFKBMNNK\MPGVZJK\,
TGNFFKBTEPZGOFVKSDF[NFJGCFPGINJ...
GTGPE\FFGKFNCGBNKEKPKEFHG,[MGNF\SVGD
B\MNFJGC[NMGNFCMNVZJKF,GHB\FKBTNKK\F
FMNNK\,[[GOVZJNBK[BZIGXF,[GORKXGWNB
KBCEPFBDGEF,FMNP\GYQNSTGEF.NPJZFHGXZKMKO
[MNGNZGIN\[GYFFBNFK\FTNKGRF,[RGXZFTNKEK
TCGEFBPGRG\CF’.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,œ��"�
FPG\FGBIHKGQ[GB,JGPB\GFKB[YZG,PF[CRK
BEOYGZBKOPG\FZKFGBZY\DCGZ\FIKKO
G\TXGP\O.GP\GLF[YKTFF\FGPK\CYJRG\,B[Z
KXZNCFBEOF[YKTBG\GCF,FZKFGBPXKKZB\
\DCGZ\FIKKOFHB\CXGZFPEBKCFGI[GMF,[FGB
YGZBFPG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,ø"
FPG\PGOFGBCKXKZF,K[ZBNRGTENFTCKZG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,ø "
FXTZFVRKPKTNISZGQFF[NPF[NFR[PF
CPT[KO,CKEKTG\GCETG\,CKIGECYRKQF\GZF,FO
FOKSGZKFDKFRGOFP\DCZKO,[FOCBKOPFVKM\
FVRKO[NFYC"FPNFBKZTNFR[PFCFGVTF\EKZK\,
200NZBG\JGC
NVKBG\FFPKEF[FISKZFB\YRKRFFZGIRK,[MN
PYGZFIKKOCG\NGK,FGBYRKQF\GZF.
IGSZF\GZFFGBFDKFRGOCTXPG.G[JUFZXGQ
FIKXGRK,[RDEFZXGQFVRKPK,FGBPXZKDKFRGO
FP\DCZKONVKBG\GFTZL[NPRKT\BGZF\GZF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł� ł��’,æ�Ø��’Y’
MNPF[FTGNOP\CSSKG\ZGZGIFBEOP\V\I
CYZCG,P\TGZZ\KG\ZF\CKTFNIKG\TNVKFZGI
FJCTK[CYZCG,CYGNKG\ZIHY.\CKTFHGK[CF
FZCFPQFBP\GFXEY,G[NPKFET\XZKMKONHMMF
GNFTPKEFTNPMGRF.FBEOFGNLGPGXBB\BNFKO
CYZCG,CRJKG\KGFRMGRG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,æ"Ææ�Ø��’
GZCKOPFECZKOFTKGRKKOBKBV[ZNFCKQTN
CGZKKO,BONBKFKFFZD[DOMQPGM[ZMZBGK,GTN
MQRYZB\F\GZFDOMQ[KZF,MPG[RYZB\PXGF.
TNMQXZKLNFS\KKTTOFMIFPKGIENFZDK[ECZK
BNYKOIKKO,[BKROP\CZZKOMKBONNCJFGZ.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,"ª
SDGNFK[NBGXZG\MBNF,[CNBETFDOMQFO
[GVMKOTNFR[PFBKHGFVTNF...ZD[KFBPGRF,
[FKROFSKPRKOFKG\ZPGCFYKONR[PFCZKBF,
P\DCZKO,GRJKK\BXKNG\P\IHY\,GFCIKNFCDSG\
FIKKOP\BEZ\,DOTNKEKSDGN\FENEGNFPCJBK
[NBGXZG\IQFNNG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��ÆØøł��Æ�ªø�,234
201 SDGNFG\KYGQ
F\GZFEGYBFKBFKB\CNKQNKXZFZT.GNB[GO
F[DFCTGNO,GNB[GOFZD[G\TNKGRG\,EGYBF\GZF.
"CZB\KKXZZT,CZB\KNG\GZF\CNKQ".BPROF\GZF
XZKMFNF\V[JCMNCIKRG\KF,GBHBGZFPBKZCMN
FF[DG\GCIKRG\GPKEG\ZGF"YGDKNGKKOGMKGXBCHF,
GM[FOPBKZKOCBGZF\GZF,P\CZM\FKBF\GZF
PBE,GFKXZFZTCTXPGFGNLGP\TNF,P\YE[GRFVL
NJGCF,GYJKDGZTXPGRT[FSRKDGZ,GCECZ[NGYKQCG
P\ZVBKQ.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œł�, ł�Ø"�,æ�Ø��’
TNKEKFZFGZK\[GCF,[GPTFBEOYGNF’FYGZB
BNKGP\GLF\GZF,GP\GLMNZD[KFNC,P\GLFTGNO
GPNGBGGMNB[ZCO,GI[YFJGCFGNLGP\DCZ
CYZCG,GFC[ZCTXPGFDGZOB\FIJBFGNLGP\TEQ,
TE[BGZF\[GCFIGEZCG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł��’,æ�Ø��’
B\FDGUBKQBRIRGTGHCKO...MKBOBRIRGPRXIKO
BG\G.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,ª�º"ª
TX\F’FTNKGRFFKBNSGZPPGY[KZT,GNFTNG\B\
FBEOGB\FTGNOPPTPYKFZTBNPZGPKFJGC.
GNHFRGTEFTGNOGFBEO,GNHFRGTEDOFZTTXPG,
[C\GZPFG\PXGKTXPK,CVRKPKG\G,K\TNFDOFGB
GK\FVLNJGC,TNKEKPF[KMKZB\[BKV\FZT[CG
PMGGR\BNF[MNGNFMNNK[NFJGC.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøÆ’,ª�œ�"�
202NZBG\JGC
NVTPKOP\DNFFRV[CMNPTZGPKMKTGZFNBEO,
GFGBP\CFNPFPZBF.ZYCHFPZDKTFGBB\ZGIG,
MKNVKDGENFMI[NXEFMKTGZ[NFRV[GJGPB\F,
MFKDENFXEFKVF[CFGJFZ\F,GMKB\HFNTGP\
HFTG[FFBNFKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’,ª�ł�"�
GPI[C\Q[NK[ZBN...KGET\FKBB\FZTTEMEK
[RBFTPGYF,FPTPY\B\BFC\FJGC.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªø�’,ª��Ø"�Y�Ø"�
FPNIPFFYEG[FFHB\BKRRFPNIPFPMGGR\
EGYBRDEBK[KOBIZKO.DO=GCKIGE=RDETXPG
RNIOFBEO,RDEFZT[CG,RDEMKTGZG...FMNTG[F
FGBC[CKNR[P\GFPMFDNKOCYZCGGBGPZ\NG:
DEN!
�łÆł�Ø"���,���łØ�ł�Ø"�,508
F\[GCFFKB\PKE[ZGKFCNC,BVKNGCT\FIJB
TXPGF\[GCFDRGHFFKBCR[PF,GFKB[GNI\B\
YGKF,[FOP\DNKOBIZMLCT\[CBFRGIOFYGZB
N\[GCF.
CTGPYFFGKF[NFIKKOFPXKBG\KKOPGRI\
F\[GCF,PVRK[FKBYEPFNTGNO,GJZO[CBFIJB
MCZPGMR\F\[GCFPPRG.TNMQBKQECZCJGICTGNO
MPGF\[GCFGSGUFMNN[GCN\KYGQ.GYNGIGPZ
[K[ZBNPGCJIKOGTGPEKONT[G\\[GCF,NF\YZC
BNFZXGQFPYGZK[NFO,NFD[KOCIKKOB\JCT
203 SDGNFG\KYGQ
R[P\O,NPZG\MNYKZG\FCZHNFTGXZKO,FIGXXKO
CTEF\DNG\G[NJCTBK\QHF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł�’,æ�Ø�Æ’
TNKEKFZFGZKF\[GCF[GPTFBEOYGNF’FYGZB
BNKGP\GLF\GZFGP\GLMNZD[KFNC,P\GLFTGNO
GPNGBGGMNB[ZCO.GI[YFJGCFGNLGP\DCZ
CYZCGGFC[ZCTXPG,FDGZOB\FIJBFGNLGP\TEQ,
TE[BGZF\[GCFIGEZCG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł��’,æ�Ø��’
MNVTGNF[PYGZFP[I\,M[O[FPYGZFJPBFGB
PIGNNF,MLFKBPDNFB\INB\FC\GMKG\FZGI
FTG[FBG\F,TEB[ZKTYZFPPYGZFFBK[F[NKJ
TNPT[KGGTNZXGRGCMIFDEGN[N\[GCF,[BH,
CF\TNG\FCKIGENPKE\FBFCF,\YCTB\PEGZF
CTGPYFJGCG\MFB\FDNKOPPJFNPTNF,MFNMG\
FVTGNG\FJGCG\NJGCF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł�’,æ�Ø�’
FPMBGC[PZDK[KOCZTKGQF\[GCFCZB[K\HZKI\G,
FGBCBPVRKFRK\GYKO,[INYKFRV[FZTKO,[BKQ
NFO\YRFMNHPQ[FOPIGCZKOCIJKCFBI\
CBGZDRKG\FRV[K\,PYNYNKOB\MNFRV[GVGDPKO
BG\F,GTNKEKF\[GCFFOFGNMKOGRK\YKOGRTYZKO
PTXPKG\FRV[FKSGEK\CTYZF.
GMNRK\GYPCKBMBC,MMBC[NTYKZ\BCZKO
FPYGNYNKOGMZK\\OPJTOFZVGBF.GBNGFO
FKSGZKOFKG\ZVRKPKKO,[TNKEOGCFOFBEOKGXB
204NZBG\JGC
NIZG\PFTCEG\FI[GMF[NIJBKGGRJKG\KGF[VNG\
G\GXBG\KFOFPZG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł��’,æ�Ø��’
FPMBGCKOFDEGNKOF\GYVKOB\FRV[TNKEKZTKGQ
F\[GCF,BUTNVK[NVTPKORZBKOFOMBKNGFO
CBKOPXEKZB\FTGR[,BKQF\GMQFVRKPK[NFOMK
BOKSGZKOTXPKKO,[FR[PFRMGK\CFOPVRK[FIJB
PMBKCBG\F,[FGBRDEMN\RBKIKKFGBNFFKSGZKO
CTXPO,FOPPZYKOBG\F.
GFBEOFPMKZCFMZFVRKPK\B\FBGXZFJGC
FPGRIC\GMKG\O[NKSGZKOBNG,FGBPYCNBG\O
CBFCFDPGZFGET\GP\K[C\CFO,GCHFTGNFFGB
CPTNG\ZCG\,G\NPGEGP\YKKOCKEG,GBVKGFVRKPK
P[\NO,GFZ[PKO[T[GTNKGTGGRG\KGRPIYKO,
GFOP\FVMKONSKPRKOJGCKO,[FGER[P\KCGNJ
PFO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�œøÆ�, ł��’,æ�Ø�Æ’
M[TGNFTNNKCG[NBEON[GCC\[GCF[NPF,GN\YQ
B\MNPT[KGGZD[G\KG,BVKNGCPI[CFNCE,NBKVGN
NKCGCYZCGPPF[FGBRIZEPVRKZGCFTGGRG\,[RT[G
BXNGKG\ZPGZD[KO.MKMLFGBJCTFECZ,[MNHPQ
[FBEOFGBRZEUPVRKHTUFJCTFDSGI[M\FPKEG\
FZTG\FSGCCG\BG\G,BKRRGPZDK[MNMLCIJBKG,
GNVTPKO[BKRGPZDK[MNGO,GFZKFGBXEKYCTKRKG.
BCNMKGQ[MGIGFPGSZKP\TGZZ,PKERDNFBGZ
FR[PF.
205 SDGNFG\KYGQ
GTNKEKFBGZRCEY\FKBRV[GMGNGBXNG,GZGBF
FGBB\MNM\PKF,GNCGEGBDCYZCGCIZEFDEGNFTN
PKTGJ[NPG\GGTGPYRVKN\G.BCNEGYBBHK[KOBN
NKCG,[ZBKFHGGFEBDFFCBFTPFFRFFQFSKPRKO
FKG\ZJGCKO,FPC[ZKONGK[GT\TGNPKOC\KYGQ
FRV[GK\IHYPBECHFCF’BNFKG.
�łÆł�Ø"����,��ł�œ�œø�Æ�,�ł��’,æ�ØŁ"
FF\V\IG\[NZGIFBEOPM[Z\B\[MNGFTXPK
GB\IVXGFVRKPKNFKG\[GBUBNFJGCFDPGZ,[FGB
FJGCFBNGFK,[FGBFKSGE[NFPDPFNMNF\DNG\
BNFG\,GF[VT\F\GZFGFRCGBFCTGNO.
CKPKOFZB[GRKOFKFF[MNFMNNK[NFBRG[KG\
VIG\PVG\I,GIVXGFKFDOMQKG\ZCZCZK.BHFKF
FIHGQFBNFKMGNGRGTENEIG\B\F[MNFSGZZ,
FP[GTCEZYNFIVXKOFCFPKKOCMNNG\FICZF
FBRG[K\,GNEIGY\PKEB\FIVWFJCTK,[FK\F
F\TGZZG\GKG\ZPMGGR\NYZB\FMKTGZGFIJB.
F\CSPG\FTGNOTNKEKMNFP[LFEGZG\,TN
KEKCKSGOFKG\ZTNKGQ[NDKNGKKF[MKRFCK[ZBN,
GTNKEKRSKGRG\FHPRKO,F\DENG\FKISFICZG\K,
GF\ZICG\FPETKO,HKYYFFZCFB\ZGIFBEO,TE
[BUTNVK[NBRDPZFTEKKQJFZ\G,PMNPYGOINY
DEGNPFDKGRG\KGG[BKV\ZXGRGFJCTKFROPMGGRKO
PXETXPOBNFJGCFBNFK.
�łÆł�Ø"����,��ł�œ���ªøÆ’
206NZBG\JGC
FPNG\NCECYZKBF...NPFHFEGPFNIGNF[[G\F
P[YFZVGBF[FGBPGTKNGCSDGN\GBUMKNBKET
IMP\FZVGBF.
łÆØ�ø��ºœ�,ł�"�,���ł�"�����’ª���"�
FTGSYKOCZPHGSGEBKQKXZFZTKMGNNF\DCZ
CFO.
����ł’��Ø��Ø���, Øłø��ł"����ø�Ø�’ª�Ø"�
VRKPKG\F\GZFFOIKKONVRKPKG\FDGU[FGBFRV[
GFIKXGRKG\NIKXGRKG\FDGUGFTGSYKOCZPHGSGEBKQ
KXZFZTKMGNNF\DZG\CFO.
����ł’��Ø��Ø���,��ł"�,�Æ�ø���, ł��’,�œº"�
[PT\KPPGZKFZCFNGKKVF[BPZC[OBEGRRG
PGZRGFHYQ"SDGNFNPI[CG\HZG\CT\F\VKNFFGB
D’EZMKO"GMG’,GMQSVZFHGFZFN[GQPSGDNNR[PF
BUTNVKENBKETPBKYBPZ,GNMQMKGQ[D’ECZKO
BNGBKROXZKMKOMGGRF,NMQPGTKNKONJFZFPI[CF
PPI[CG\HZG\.
æ ł��ª���,���łØª�"���ª�ł"Ø�Æ"ª,ª�œº"
MKBKQNGNFYC"FYGZ\ZGICTGNPGBNBMB[Z
TGSYKOCIMPFHG,GNBTGEBNB[NBRCZBFBEO
BNBMEK[KNPGEIMP\FYCNF,BNB[XZKLDGU
RYKC\IKNFTNKEKFPXGG\FPT[KG\,[MN\MNK\Q
NECZHF.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,�Æ��ø�ł���ª�œ
207 SDGNFG\KYGQ
GPF[BRGEGZ[KOC[CIF[NMRS\K[ZBNFGBTN
DCZFSDGNFFBNGFK\FRPXB\CR[P\FBGPFCMNNF,
GPPKNBFKBP\DNFDOMQCMNKIKECBKHGXGZF
PKGIE\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ÆØ�łØ��øØŁœØ,Ø"�,��’169
GBHKYCNGFXEKYKO[MZO,GNBYGEONMQ...[NB
KGTKNNFOXEY\ONFXKNOPKSGZKFTGNOFHF.GHF
NBPJTOF[MZGFTGR[GGEBK,BNBMEK[K\GYQTN
KEOF\KYGQF[NO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ÆØ�łØ��øØŁœØ,Ø"ª,æ�Ø��’,173
[MNPK[FGBPGM[ZNTSGYCVRKPKG\ZHK\GZF,FGB
P\PNBKG\ZPBGZFISE[N\GZ\ISE,GTNKGFIGCF
NTSGYC\KYGQRVGNKOGCYKZGCZIGYKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�Øœ,º"�,��’267
MRS\K[ZBNZGXF\KYGQTGNOPQYNYGNG,GNBEK
CSNKI\BKHFTGGQM[NTXPG,BNB\KYGQMNFPTZM\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,œ�ØłØ��æ łØ,�.œ�Øł"�łœ",��’260
MNPF[NGPEKOBGPF[P\VNNKOBGPF[TGSYKO
CKK[GCG[NTGNO,FMGNPXJZUN\KYGQFMNNK,
GFPJZFFBKEKBNK\FPCGY[\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,œ�ØłØ��æ łØ,�."�łœ��ªø",��’344
208NZBG\JGC
SPGLNTYCBEP[KIBP\ZCFSDGN\FBIEG\
CBGPF,GFPT[KOFJGCKO,GFETG\,GFBGZFBNGFK
[RPXBCXEKYKO,VGTNKOTNMNYEG[\FMNNKG\Z
PC[BZFHPRKO.GFSDGNFFFKBJPGRFFKBCPJPGQ
[NYJKDGZKBGPZKCG\,BCN\GMGZXGUBFCFGBIEG\
RVNBF,[PTGZZ\FZD[FMNNK\NXVG\N\[GT\FDGK
MGNG.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł �ØŁ�ł,��ª�"�
ZYM[RFKFPF[BRGXZKMKONFKG\,\[GCNFBRG[KG\
FSDGNFFTNKGRF,[F\PXK\[NF\FKFPSGDNFNBGZ
FZGIRKFDRGHC\MGR\F,GPPKNB\\ZGPOMGNF,GCDBGQ
\MKZB\FBG[Z[NF,CPF[HM\F[FINYFKG\Z
PGM[Z[CFKFKFPPGNBCBGZFBNFKFHL,GTNKEK
F[VT\Q\ETCMNNG\FBKLNF\ZGPONVKPE\F.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœØøł��,Øøł����œ����
209 SDGNFG\KYGQ
\VKNF
JZOKYZBGGBRKBTRFTGEFOPECZKOGBRKB[PT.
Øø�Ø�æ"�º"ª
PS\MNBRKTNRYGEFYJRFFRYZB\BFC\FHGN\.
GBRKIG[CTNKFPFBRKKMGNNT[G\CMEKNFRG\B\
FMNN.FKG\[BRKPS\MNTNFMNNMGNG,BRKZGBF
KSGZKFVZJ,PING\GPMBGCKO,GKSGZKFVZJPFMNN
MGNG,FKKRGPNIPG\CKQFTPKO.GPNCE\VKNFBKQPF
N\\,GHFRYZBPXJTZCXZ\FMNNCKRGRK.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���ł�æ"�,��Æœ���œ
TRKKQBPGRFRYZBNPTNFPFET\,FKKRGNPTNF
PFJCT,MKMNPF[FGBC\GLFET\RYZBC\GLJCT
GFET\.MKPF[FBEOPCKQFGBKMGNNT[G\,BOBKQ
NGPKE\FTXNG\.PF[BKQMQNPTNFPFET\,BKQ
CKMGN\GNT[G\.
NMQECZ[FGBNPTNFPFJCTRYZBCIKR\
RS.GMNFRKSKORYZBKOTN[PG[NFYC"F,FKKRG
[HFGRCIQNCIKR\B\TZG\BENTKNB,GNBB\TZG\B
EN\\B,MKF\I\GQBKQCKMGN\GNT[G\ECZ[FGB
NPTNFPFJCT,BCNCMEK[KT[GNGRS,FBEOXZKL
NF\VNN,[KT[GNGRS.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ��Æ’,���łœł�",Øłø��ª�
NMQFTCGEFPXEF\I\GQ,FKKRG[KT[FCIKZF,RBPZ
HFZYTNCIKR\\VKNF.GBHFYC"FFGB[GPT\VKNF.
NMQRG\RKONGP[BNG\KG.GHFMNN[\VKNF[KKLEGGYB
TNPYGOIKSZGQ.NMQFBEOXZKLNVTGNCTXPGCIKR\
XGZLGIKSZGQTNFBPGRF,MKZYCHPQ[FBEOZGBF
GPZDK[,[ISZNGBPGRF,GC[KTGZ[RIGWNGB\HF,MK
ZGBF[FGBPXETXPGBKBV[ZNYCNB\FR"N,
BHFGBKMGNNT[G\\VKNFBPK\K\,[F’KTHGZNG,BH
FYC"FTG[FNGRS,GRG\QNGB\FBGZFBPGRF.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ��Æ’,���łœł�",Øłø��ª�
GBOFGBZGXFNET\,GFGBPCY[PF’NFCKQB\
FY[Z,HFRYZB\VKNF.GHFECZDEGNGI[GCPBGE,
FKG\[K[NGY[ZTOF’,[ZGXFPPRGP[FG.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ��Æ’,���łœ��",œ Ø��
F\VKNFRYZB\TCGEF[CNC,MKFNCFGBPNMG\,MK
FNCFPRFDMNFBCZKO.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’ł�"ª
BCNF\VKNFFKBKG\ZVZJK\BNFNC.GFKBPDT\
BNKGZB[GRFNFMKRGNFCKQB\FBCZKOMZBGK.GMN
MGIF\KYGQFGB,[FNCCMNCIKRG\KGKFKFP\ECY
C[OFGK"F,EFKKRGFH"B,GRMNNCG.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’ł�"Æ
211 \VKNF
NTGNOBN\\KKB[PNHTGY,PNF\VNNGPNF\IRQ
BNFBN.F\PECMLTE[\XNKI,TE[\DKTNYZC\
BNGFKO=PG[BMPKF\L.
�łÆØ�����Æłæ�Æ
PP[MPG[TWYJQPENKYB\FDEGN,MLXTYFYJRF
PCKBFMCZNKEKF\TGZZG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ�ł�Ø��’,º"ª
M[P\VNNKOP\V[JMIFZXGQ,CPKNGKFZXGQBN
F’,BHMNMGIG\FRV[P\DENKOPTNMNDCGN,GFZXGQ
FJGCGFPTGNF,CF\V[JG\GCKG\Z,VGTNFGBB\
JGCG,GF\VKNFFKBVTGNF[NPP[.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł Ø�ØŁ�ł,�"Ł
BKHFCIKR\PXC[FBEORPXB,BOFGBPCY[
NFIKG\B\RV[GPCIKR\BPGRFR\YCNB\\VKN\G.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���ł�Ø"�
FKDKTFGFTPNFP\DNFCNCFBEOC[T\\VN\G,
FKBFKG\ZRBPRFGKG\ZPXNI\GPDKTFNPJZ\FPMN
FTRKRKO[CPXKBG\.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��łœª���"Æ
ZGPPG\F’VKZG[G[FGBXZKLNCY[PF’[K\QNG
FMINNM\NPTNFPFET\.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łØ"ª
212NZBG\JGC
F[DFZGIRK\
GNBKMRUTGEPGZKL,GFKGTKRKLZGBG\B\PGZKL.
Øø�Ø��’º’
GNBKNPEG...MKMGNOKETGBG\KNPYJROGTEDEGNO.
Øł�Ø��"��"�
GKET\FKGOGF[CG\BNNCCLMKF’FGBFBNGYKO
C[PKOPPTNGTNFBZWP\I\BKQTGE.
ªÆłØ�ª’,�"Ł
B\OZBK\OMKPQF[PKOECZ\KTPMO.
ø�œº’Ø"Ł
BRKCXEYBIHFVRKLB[CTFCFYKW\PGR\L.
œ��Ø�Ø"�Ł"
BHZBFGKSVZFFMKRFGDOIYZF.
�Øƺ"Łº"
GZBK\OB\GGHMZ\O.
Æ�ªÆłŁ"�"Ł
BKQNGNEKKQBNBPF[TKRKGZGBG\.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜ÆÆ�Æœł���"�,æ��ªłØ�’
F[PZNLG[PZRV[LPBEVQ\[MIB\FECZKO
B[ZZBGTKRKL.
ªÆłØ�ª’Ł’
P[F...HMFN\PGR\F’KCKJ.
œ��Ø�Ø"�Ł"
GFRFF’RXCTNKG.
Æł�øØœº"�Ø"�
C[GCF’B\[KC\XKGQFKKRGMIGNPKO.
œ��Ø��º"�’
BGHQ[PTFG\B[ZRK.
�Øƺ"ŁØ"�
BERKBNYKOR\QNKN[GQNPGEKONET\NTG\B\KTU
ECZKTKZCCYZCCYZ,KTKZNKBHQN[PTMNPGEKO.
Øø�Ø��’ª’
GF[PKTRKB\YGNL.
øØł�øØłØ�Æ’Ø"ª
GILBMNKJTO.
�ØÆØ"ÆØ"�
MNBIEP[KDF[DFVZJK\NVKPEZD\GGNVKFHPQ.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’ł�"Ł
214NZBG\JGC
FBP\FGB,[PK[PDKTNKEKTFBPK\K\,KGMNNZBG\
[N[FECZKO:FFRFDFFBPK\K\FRTNP\,FPZBF
FIKXGQ[NFFRFDF[BKRGBP\,PFKMQKGXBFPZBF
FHF,GBKLP\Y[ZTOFFRFDFFBPK\K\.
ł’�ø��ØØ���Ł,�ł��"�,�ªØłÆ�ł�,��’œ�"Ł
BRKPNBBFCFNBNGYKO:BRKKGET[PF[BRKPCY[,
BKRRGRYZBC[GO[O.BKLKKYZBPF[FGBKG\ZPQ
FMN,KG\ZPQFJGC,KG\ZPQFPFG\?GBRKBGFCGBRK
BGPZ,BRKBGFCB\FBNGYKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ��ªøª’,œ’
BRIRGBKQBRIRGPMKZKOB\F’PQFTGNOGTNKEK
FTGNO,MKBOP\GLRV[RGVRKPF,P\GL\MGR\G
FBNGFK\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"�
PMBQP[PT,[TRKKQPXKB\IQCTKRKFCGZBBG
NFKVL,BKRG\NGKCBEOTXPG,BNBFMN\NGKCCGZB.
GPEGTEGGYBBEOPSGKOGEGGYBTM[KGPXBIQCTKRK
FCGZB,GNMQFCGZBPYZCGGBIZMLTGHCG=HFBK
BV[ZNFCKQNPK[TGENBZM[uMNZGIRK,MKZY
NBIZMRKS\GNZGIRKG\,HGMFFBEONFCKQHB\.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���łÆ’,��Ø�øºØ�œ�Æ��œ�
PXKBG\PYGOCZGIRKG\RYZBPYGOFPXKBG\
PJTO,[MNPK[CBN[O,FKKRGNPYGOFFGBZGBF
BG\FXGZFMPGF[RK.PF[BOMQECZEPKGRKBKRG
215 F[DFZGIRK\
RYZBPYGOPXKBG\K,P[GO[FGBEPKGRK,BHMN
BIEPEPFNTXPGCBGVQBIZ.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ø��œØ,���ł"�,ł��Øœ��ł���ø��ØœÆŁ�����
GYZB\KFCKBGZC[O"FSGNO",NFGZG\[\VYKE
CKBGZKFGBC\VYKEMNSGNO,[BOK[NLTNKFPNBF
MNJGC,BKRLISZBNB"SGNO"NTNG\CG.GBHMNJGC
FTGNOCKEKL.BPROBKQ"FSGNO"PJZFMNVKTXPG.
MKBO\RGICPEZDG\FSGNOGNB\MRSBNFTNKF,BH
NB\G[NOMGR\L.
MQFECZCCKBGZ[NKTNFHGFZ.MKNCBZ
ECZKFOFTPGYKOPMNTPGYTESGVO,TGENBRCZB
FCKJGKNHF.BNBT[K\KTNMNVRKOCCKBGZKHFEZL
GPCGBNMNCQBEO,[KGMNTNKEGNTNG\GNFTPKY
GNFS\MNCSVZFHGFZDGVG,MKZYBH\G[NOMGR\K
CCKBGZKHF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł���ł,�œ�"�
CTNFSGNOVTN[BEOV[GJ[BOFGNLCEZMGKMGN
NHMG\NECYG\F’MPG\NPKEIMOPGCFY,P[BOMQ
NVRKGFKGXZKMKONFKG\\NPKEKIMPKODEGNKOCMEK
NHMG\NECYG\F’.GNVRKFCTN[OJGCFKGXZKMKO
NFKG\DEGNKTGNO,BIZ\NBFKGKMGNKONHMG\NF[D\
BNGYG\.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,ªł�œ�æ���’,���ł�"�, �Ø�œ�ª�Ø����
216NZBG\JGC
BOKPXBBIECTKZG[RKOPP[VIFFNGPES\ZK
\GZF,FBK[FHFFGBCTKYZCET\F[NOCNK
ISZGQ.
æ ł�����ª�ª��"�
PK[HKMFGF’CIMP\FBP\KGETPTN\V[JKF\GZF
G[MNECZKF["SCRGKTNSGEG\F\GZF,MKEGTNKGETK
IQ.
ø"œªÆłØ�ØØ��"ÆØ"ªæØ���"�
G[PT\KSKVGZPT[FCBK[BIE[NBFCKQVKZG[
FDPZBGFKFEZMGNGPZFDPZBCNBVKZG[GTNKEK
HFHMFNPEZKD\DKNGKBNKFG.
ªłŒªØ�Ø�
MKNPEQP[VFGNIGWNBKJTGONTGNOBGZF\GZF
GNBK\IE[NG[GOBGZGMNFIKEG[KQ[SGCZ[PIE[
CSCZG\HZG\GMZSKG\CFCNFCNKOFOFKVLFNMF
BPK\K\GNJFZB\FJPBNFM[KNCRKK[ZBNNBMGN
[ZWTGUJPBGECZKPZQFBZ"KGFHGFZ[FOPBKZG\
TKRKKOP\GYKONRV[K[ZBNKFP[MN\[K\IE[NG
CMNZDTBGZIE[PP[TE[RT[FPP[TE[RT[F
PP[CZKFIE[FTNKEKFHGFZGPZQFBZ"K.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº�ªÆłØ�ª�Ø"�
GFPNBMKOBKROKGETKOSGEG\F\GZFGBKROP[KDKO
PCGZBOMF[D\FR[PG\[FOEGZ[KOF\GZF
GP[KDKOP\GMFF[D\FCGZBDEGN\FKGXZGP\TNKO,
217 F[DFZGIRK\
[MNF\GZFBKRFBNBPDE\PXKBG\FKGXZGPTN\G
CSVKZG\KGGVTGN\GCFO,GMNFPZCFNEZG[CSGEG\KF
FZKHFP[GCIPVRK[PDKEPTN\GGPVNKBNT[G\
CSVKZG\,GNHFNBRPSZTRKQHFBNBNXEKYKO
GFPNBMKO[PIKON[PGT\GZ\O.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,�’
FBEOFGNLGPGXBB\BNFKOCYZCG,CRJKG\KG
FRMGRG\,GBVKNGCBG\QFRZBG\CZB[[FQP[DG\PQ
FEZLFJGCFFPGSMP\PXEFF[YVFFZDKNF,KGMN
FGBNTNG\NPKEFTNKGRFMHB\TE[KETNMGRQB\
FMNN\MRK\FTHGFBG[Z.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�łœ,æ"ÆYæ"�,æ�Ø��’
FBEOBV[ZNGNCGBNKEKPKEFMHG,[KDNFCYZCG
B\FPZMHKG\[NMNFFGKF[CYZCG.GBHKZDK[CZGIG
B\MNFP\ZD[,MNFT[GK...GMNFP\RGTTCMNPNGB
FK[NMNVZJKEZDG\KG.MKNBKT[FF’BNGYKOECZ,MK
BODKNFSGEGBNTCEKGFRCKBKO.FF\DNG\FVRKPK\
FHB\[NFZKMGH[CR[P\FBEOFKBFGXBFPQFMI
BNFVGTNPF[DRGHCFCBP\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�æł��ªø,ø�"�
MPG[PTN\FBEO[K[NGET\,MLBNGFR[PG\K[
NFOET\DEGNCBNGFG\.GVKZG[ET\,BKQZGXFNGPZ
FKEKTFNCE,BNBCIKR\FZD[FPP[.M[FF[MNF
RY[Z\GRYCTFCRV[GMBNGPZDK[,MKET\PN[GQ
"GFBEOKETB\IGFB[\G",N[GQF\Y[ZG\
218NZBG\JGC
GF\ICZG\.GTNEZLHFRBPZ"GPC[ZKBIHFBNGF",
BIHFPP[MBKNGZGBF.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,œł��ł
VRKPKG\F\GZFFGBCIKR\P[YFFP[MZ\,MPGKKQ
NBIZ[RMRSCPTKGKXBPFTNPGGP\DNFGBHP[MZ
GPCNCNFET\GFF[DFPVRK[FKFCGMGI[NPTNF
PQF[MNCFTNOGT\FKXBGR\DNF.
MPGMQCZHKQEBGZKK\B[FGBPF[NBR\NC[F
CPXGGFBNBFQSKVGZDEGN\BGZBKQSGUCZGLFGB
NPTNFTEBKQYWGNPJFTEBKQ\MNK\GMG’NF[MKN
GNF[KDSEZMNFF[\N[NG\GNSVZC[KTGZYGP\
TXPG\FPBXKNGFRBXNKO,MPGMNPBPZKFBKEZB
ZCBGBKEZBHGJB[FGBCIKR\BFCFZCF[NPTNF
PQFET\GMG’GZHKQEBGZKK\B[NPTNFPQFF[DF
CFTNODEGN,GM[JGTPKOGP[KDKOK\CNNET\G,MNGPZ
[RGNENGPIP\FF\CGRRG\CFOBFCFRVNBF
[NPTNFPQFET\GFF[DF.
łÆØø�Ø�ł�������ªØ,æ ł���łØ�ª�"ł����,œ�æ"��"Æ
MNHPQ[REPFNRG[BRGTGPEKOCPXCPFG\KPKGIE,
RVZEPFTRKQFBNFK,BKQFBNFG\PG[D\NRG,GP\GL
MLBRGP[\GYYKONF[D\FF[NPF,FPTGZZ\CRG
\[GYF[NECYG\VRKPK\,FP\DNFC[MN,CZD[,
GCPT[F,CEKCGZGC\RGTF,GCEPKGQ.GP\GLF\[GYF
F\PKEK\BRGPGSKVKO\PKEFMRFNTNKFFTNKGRF,
[FRRGCBP\IKKOCBNFKOIKKO,GMNVZJ[NPI[CF,
219 F[DFZGIRK\
FPCZZNRGB\PRKT\FF[DFFBNFK\[CPXCRG,
PGMKINRGB\FTGGZGQ[NRG,GFRRGFGNMKOGP\VYIKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,�"�
TKYZF\NG\F[D\F\GZFGFBNFG\[FGBTKYZ
FBEOGYKGOPXG\KF[FGBTPGEFTCGEFNBN\NGK
CF[D\FIMPFFHB\MKEGT.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ, ’
VRKPKG\F\GZFFOIKKONVRKPKG\FDGU[FGBFRV[,
GFIKXGRKG\NIKXGRKG\FDGU,GFTGSYKOCZPHGSGEBKQ
KXZFZTKMGNNF\DZG\CFO.
����ł’��Ø��Ø���,��ł"�,�Æ�ø������º"�
PV\IG\FIMPFGPFDOIMP\FSGEBKRFRPSZ\
CKEBEOBIE,[MNBIEGBIEK[NGINYC\GZF,GPF
[VG\IHFBKRGVG\IHF,[BKBV[ZNKDTCINY[N
ICKZG...GFJTOP[GO[BKQFMGGRFBNBNET\B\
FCGZBGBKBV[Z[K[KDBEOBIEB\MNFIMPF,
GBONBMNCBKTGNO,BPRORGETC[TZKOCTNF
C[KTGZKOMNBIEGBIEK[NG[KTGZC\GZFNET\B\
YGRG.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,"�
GFRFK[PK[KS\MNCV[JKF\GZFGV[JKFTRKRKO
NCE,GBNGCCG[\NTGNOFCBPVRK[BKQ[OTKYZ
V[GJKFTRKKRKOBNBSGEG\KFO...
MEK[KGMNN[B\GN\\CKQ[BZFXEKYKOEGZ[K
S\ZK\GZFB[Z[O,GBONBGKEIFPFONIGWBN
220NZBG\JGC
PYGOCTNKFV[J,GBNGFPTPKYKOCSGEK[NFO
INYCCKRF,MEK[P[OKBKZGGKHFKZGPSGEVRKPKG\
F\GZFGPEKE\[KTGZYGPF,EFKKRGMHGFZFZYKT...
BKQ[MZM[MZNGPEK\GZFGKEKT\SGEG\KFNMCGE
CGZBF.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,��"�
CZB[F[RF[R\\Y"H)1747(T[K\KF[CT\TNKK\
FR[PFMKEGTNL,GZBK\KECZKORVNBKOCPZBF,PF
[NBZBK\KTEFRFPKGOTPEKTNET\KGB[ZZBK\K
GNPE\KCTNG\KN[OCN\KBV[ZKNSVZGNECZBVKNG
VRKOBNVRKO.TE[RMRS\KNFKMNP[KI,[[ONGPE
P[KITOMNF\RBKOGFXEKYKOGDOTO[CTF
ZGTKO.
G[OZBK\K[PIFDEGNFTEPBGE,GBKRKKGET
N[PIFPFHGTG[F,GFKK\KSGCZ[F[PIFFHGIS
G[NGOTNVJKZ\KPFTGNOFHF,GFGEKTGNKBIZML
[BKRKRVJZTEKKQMKFRBFNFONPTNFM[BRKPKKIE
KIGEKONPJFTNKEK\GZ\OFYEG[F.BCNPFG\
F[PIFBKRKKGETTEFKGOFHF.
G[BN\KB\VKP[KIBKP\B\KPZ?GF[KC,
CHB\\ETCT\[K\VZSONPGELGK\DNFCTGNOGKVGXG
PTKKRG\KLIGXFPF[NPE\KBG\LGF[D\,GKGMNGDO
FPFNT[G\KIGEKOGTNKG\MPGLGBHKMNGMNFYNKVG\
GKFKFT\ZXGQGK[GTF.
ł’Øøł��Æ��ø�ŁÆ,�Æ�ø"Ł,ºœłø�ŁÆ,��łœ�ªøøø����Øæ,ł’�Æł���łø���ØŁÆ
221 F[DFZGIRK\
PDP\F[NIMP\FZHKO,NMNPFNMF,FKBV\GIMI
FR[PF,TEMEKTPKEFTNMIFFVRKPK,N[BGC
PPYGZF,CNK[GOFXJZMG\[NF\NPEG\BPXTK\.
GFGVTFHGPCKBFB\MNFFGKFMGNFNFMKZB\
TXPF.GP\GLFFMZFFTXPK\FVRKPK\RP[L[VT
FIKKO,CBKIGEF[MNGFZXGQ,CBKQFVSYF[NDCGNKO
G[NVZJKO.
�łÆł�Ø"���,ºœÆØ�łÆ��
GBIZ[FR[PG\FOPFBNGFINYBNGFPPTN,ZBGK
CNKSVY[K[KDGCIMPFTNKGRFF[D\PF,GFRF
FFXTFFHB\PGZMC\PD’ECZKO.
FECZFB’MKFECYG\SKC\FF[DF,GECZ
HFCZGZ,MKFD[PKKOFDGVRKKOMCFPG\GCRKBEO
FP\RFDKOMCFPFBIZFPBMNGF[KRFGF\[PK[NB
K[KDGFGMNN,K[PFO[BVKNGPXKBG\G,BNBBGMNKO
PFPHGPQCNKNF[MKN[K[SKCFTNKFO.
FECZFC’FGBMKFR[PG\INYBNGFPPTNGTRKQ
HFPGSMOCKQFPYGCNKO,GFOECYG\PP[C[GZ[O...
BOMQGEBKK[KDFF[DFFZBGKFBNKGCFECYGPEZDF
BIZPEZDFMVKMIFF[DF,GK[KDPPRGNBTXPG\G
GPFG\G,BPROK[KDPFIMPFF[DFMVKMIGNFS\MN
CFYEPG\F\GZF[FKBIMP\G.
FECZFD’MKFR[PG\FOCTXPG\GCCIKRFBI\
GFOIGWPPRGCCIKRFBIZ\,GMPG[TXOFBNGF
K[KDTXPG,MQFR[PFINYPPRFK[KDFGGINYPPRF
K[KDF[DFFPTGJFFRHMZ\.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,��"ªY��"�
222NZBG\JGC
GBKQINYC\GZF[KDZGOKKIGEMNMLMS\ZK\GZF,
GNMLFKGFOMPTJCMNTSYODGZPKQKKIGE,MVKCIKR\
TSYF\GZFPP[FKFRT[FYK[GJN[MKRF,G[MKRF
TNZB[O\PKENF\YE[CPS\ZK\GZ\ONF\KKIE
NPTNF.
�łÆ�ø��łªÆØł,�ł�"�,ª��œ���Ø�ÆØŒ,ł"�
B[ZKFOMNBNGFTGSYKOC\GZF,NET\IMP\
BEGROGFOKGETKOGPS\MNKOCSGEG\TNKGRKO.MK
M[FBEOKGXBPFTGNOFHFGFGBT[F\[GCF,GNB
R[BZGNGBNBFTCKZG\[ZYFPK\FPMVZ\TNKFQ,TN
KEKHF,EFKKRGFPK\F,PS\NYKOPPRGMNFEKRKO
[CTGNOGNBTGEBNB,[VG\IKONGK"D[TZKOPSGEG\
FBVZSPGQFJFGZ,[IMPFTNKGRF\NGKFCFO.
łÆØø���ÆłØ��Ø,���ł,øØł�øØłØ��� Øłø�æ��ª�’��"�
CGBGZBFPFM\GC,BONB\ETKNLFKVFCR[KO,
FYC"FP[KCNR[PF,BOB\CB\,GNBFS\MN\
CIMPFPJZO[CB\NMBQ,GBKRLKGET\B\FTGNO
FTNKGQ,XBKNL,BKQB\ZBGKFNMRGSNMBQCNKKEKTF,
XBKNLCTYCKFXBQ,FKKRG[\\DNDNKVTO[RKFNTGNO
G\FKKKGET\CTYCKFXBQFBNG,[FOCRKBEO,
[FBR[KOE[KOBG\OCTYC,EFKKRG[PIHKYKO
BG\ON[VNKOGFOKGETKOFSGEG\FTNKGRKO[N
223 F[DFZGIRK\
BEGRO,GCFO\ETKNFS\MNGNET\.MNGPZ,[PFO
\NPEK.
łÆØø���ÆłØ��Ø,���ł,øØł�øØłØ��� Øłø�æ��ª���"�
GMCGBKVFTOFCZKG\ZBGZBK\KCTGRKTPK,TRKG\
FET\G[IGYFMSKNKOTNFTNKMYGNFSKZKO\I\
FTKZN[YWGNZP[TNR[P\CK\PBGKRG.
PECZKOSZFTNF’GTN\GZ\GGTNTPGYGNDEGN,
[CIMP\FYCNFMGNFBKQMBQCKRFGET\GSCZFMNN
GMNN,BNBFPFYKCGW[NPNG\G[PG\,NBP[NGNB
RP[N,ZYECZKOMM\CO.GHMG\FGBNVJVJVJGPK
PNKOCECZKOMM\COCBPGRF[NKPF,[FOECZKO
YEG[KO,[CHF\G[NOTNKRGMGR\FCZKBF.GM[K\ZCG
FTGSYKOCFECZKOMM\CQCBPGRF[NKPF,PKEKK\K
PNMBP[KIB)KCGBPNLFP[KI(,MKKG[NOCHFMN
F\KYGQG\GNBPKEK.
TE[VD[\KB\FPVGZSPKO[CFO.FPFBR[KO
[MCZMKNG[RG\KFOTNFNKPGECM\CKFBZ"KGHGFZ.
GFXNKIG[MNSVZKFBZ"K[DGZKOCVKFOTENFVNKB.
G[ONFOMYEG[KO[FKGCBZW.
G[BN\KO,BONPEGBXNZC,[FK\FNGF[DF
CVRKPKG\FECZKO.GTRGNK:"ISPNFHMKZ!BKQMBQ
[GOVRKPKG\,HGN\ECZKOMM\COPSGZKONRGG\GNB
PKEKISG[NGO!"G[BN\KO:"BOFZI"GH"NF[KD
VRKPKG\FECZKO?"GTRGNK:"GEBKNBF[KDKG\Z
PPF[BRGP[KDKO".G[BN\KOTNFBZ"KH"NTXPG.
GTRGNK:"GEBKNBKETVRKPKG\KG\ZFKPRGMNGO.GMN
224NZBG\JGC
PF[KET,PSZN\NPKEGFZI"GH"N,GMQFDKTG
BXNKRG".
GXIY\KPBETNKFO:"[BOMQBKLR\ICZG
FTRKRKOCNCFBZ"KH"NCNK[GOFCRFGET\?"GTRG
NK:"B[ZIKCGZFTRKRKOYKCNPVKBNKFGH"N.GFGB
KETFVRKPKG\CB[Z[FGBPNBL".GMBQ[VM\KIP\K
TNKFO,MKBVSCKMIFSCNRG\NTPGEBXNO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł Ø�º�
FS\ZC’:FRYZBCSVZKO"FS\Z\GLFS\Z".
VZG[G[BKRGZGBFBVKNGB\FBIGZKO[NF[K"\.
BNBBGPZ,[F[K"\THCBG\GGBKRGP[DKITNKG.GMN
FKSGZKO[PYCN,\GNF[YKCNPIP\KEKFDGZN
FTKGGZGFJCT,MKEZMKFF[DIFRT[KONGPSGCMKO
CKG\Z,TE[PCKBKONKEKML[P\VYZI"G.
XKGZ:P\VNNGTG[FXEYFTNXZG\KG=GBKRG
RTRFMNN.GEGGYBC[TF[VGSYPNF\VNNTNXZ\G=BH
RTRF.CMN[TF[P\DCZNFBPKQCF[DIFGPJKC
PT[KG=VGRFNGFFXNIFTGZUGKGZEBIGZRK\
CBMHZKG\DEGNF.GC[TF[P\VYZI"GGP\IKNNFZKT
PT[KG=BHP\IKNNFXNKICKG\ZGNR[GONZGGIF.NB
PHEPR\NGVZRSFCEZLM[ZG\,BNBEGGYFCEZL
FGRBFNCZKG\,BGTNKEKIKNGN[C\,GMEGPF.
BG[MNFPMKZKO[NG,[FOCTNK\GZFGPXGGF,
SGCNKOTRKG\,GPING\PZGCG\,GPCGHKOPBECTKRK
FCZKG\.GCTNKPXGGFFBNGREPFNG[FPFISZKEZL
BZWGJV[KOPNKEF,GXCGTKODEGNKO,TE[PBGSNG
NK[CCICZ\OBVKNGZDT.GMNFPMKZKOFZ[TKO,
FP\NGXXKOTNBPGR\G,FRFFPFFPXNKIKOCKG\Z,
225 F[DFZGIRK\
CZKBKOG[NKPKO,NBKETGPINF,VYIKO,CTNKPEG\
JGCG\,GSKPVJKKOCMNEZMKFO,KG[CKOCNKEBDG\,
GCCJIGQ,GC[NGFZCFRPXBKOMNFKGO.
M[F[DIFPS\EZ\NBEOCBGVQMHF,RYZB
"FS\Z\GLFS\Z".MKBHISG[NGOZGCW\I\P[BG,
NBKGMNTGENFP[KLCF\IHYG\NFBPKQ[KSGZKG
CBKONGPF[K"\,PBKHFJTOMPGS.TE[RM[N
GP\VYZNGPZI"G,[F[K"\BKRGP[DKIMNNTN
CZKG\KG,GMNPF[CBNGISG[NGO,CBNGPKEKFDGZN
GFJCT=[HFRYZB[BKRGZGBFBVKNGB\FBIGZKO.
GCPXCHFCFZD[\FBEOYCN\KSGZKO,MDGQ:
B.PISGZCVZRSFBGPISGZCCZKG\,CHKGRG\
GBKFXNIFNDPGZB\\MRKG\KG,GBKSKVGYRV[K.
NP[N,[[GPZB\TXPG[NBNTRG\ICZG.
C.P\VNNGBKRGRTRF.C[TF[PKJKCPT[KGRPXB
IZEBIGZRK\,GC[TF[PZKTB\PT[KGRPXB
PXNKICKG\Z.BKQPHEPQNGVZRSFCEZLM[ZG\.
HGN\CEZLFGRBFGDRCF,BGCIKNGN[C\.
D.MNPMKZKGFFGNMKOCEZLK[Z,SGCNKOTRKG\
GPING\,GMNPKRKCHKGRG\.GPMKZKOFZ[TKO
P\NGXXKOKGOKGO,PXNKIKOGTGNKOCT[KZG\
GCCZKBG\GKG[CKOC[NGFCNKEBDG\.
E.MNPMKZKGFXEKYKO,PYKKPK\GZFGPXGG\,EGPF
NG[FPFBMHZKOGBDGBKSJKOP[GRKOBGJV[KO
PNKEFGISZNFOEZLBZW,GXCGTKODEGNKO,TE
[PBGSNGNK[CTKPFOCDQTEQ,TE[BKRGKMGN
NFKG\CICZ\OBUZDT.
226NZBG\JGC
FS\ZB’:[BKQVRKGK\’PDGNKO,EFKKRG[BKQF[K"\
P\RFDTPGCF\BON[PGK\’"FJGCGFPJKC",BNB
I"GNFKVLPHF.
GFRFCBGVQHFBKQFBEOZGBFB\VRKGFJGCKO
[NF[K"\,BCNFGBPBPKQ[TNMNVRKOF[K"\SKCC
NGFECZKOFNNG,BGPIP\TGR[[NFTCZG\[T[F,
BGMEKNFKJKCCBIZK\G,MPG[M\GC"B\B[ZKBFC
F’KGMKI",GMQB[ZFXEKYKO\IKN\OKSGZKO,PIP\
[F[K"\ZGXFNK\QNFOCSGVO[NGFZCF.
GBKRGRM[NNGPZ,[MNHFFDKTNGPDGZNFTKGGZ,
GFJCTI"G,GCNKI[CGQGET\,BNBP\IHYNFBPKQ
[F[K"\SGCCNGCF[DI\GB\BNF=RCIQ[ZGBF
TNMNVRKOB\FBIGZKO[NF[K"\,MKFGBPYCN
PPRGK\’KSGZKO.
XKGZ:BG[FGBPIGSZVZRSF,GK[NGCTNKIGCG\
PZGCKO,FPPZZKONGB\IKKGGFGBPNBJZEG\
GEBDG\MNFKGO.BG[SGCNI"GPPING\.BG[BKRG
PMGCETNFCZKG\.MN\MRK\[P\IKN,BKRFTGNFCKEG
NDGPZFGFGNLMNFKGOCNKSKVGYRV[K.
DKNGK:FCKYG[[NFBEONFK\IHYCBPGR\F[DI\G
K\’TNFTGNOCHPQFFS\ZF,PCKBFGNFDG\CSVZKO,
C\GZFNKYIP[OFBZFGFCRF,BKLNF\IHYCBPGR\
F[DI\GK\’.GFRFFFBZG\GFF\CGRRG\FNNG,[PYCN
TNKEKF\GZF,PMGRG\C[O"\GZF\CNKQ",TE[K\YCW
N[TGZPSGKOGFYC"FPZIOTNKG"GKTZFBNKGZGI
PPZGO",HB\BGPZ\[VTTNKGRF.
BCNHFBIZ[DKNFC[NPG\B\"F\CNKQ",EFKKRG
FBGZ\GZF,[FBEO[GBUNDGVGPIP\F\IHYG\G
227 F[DFZGIRK\
CBPGR\F[K"\,MKBHRT[FPGM[ZNF[DIFCDKNGK
VRKGK\’,[VKZG[G[F[K"\P\RFDTPGCF\BOM[PG
"FJGCGPJKC"K\’RKPXB.
[PGK\’PZBFNRG[FGBJGCGPJKCNMNCZKG\KG,
EFKKRGCMNEZMKFJCT,FPSVKYNMNPKRKFPYCNKO
CMNK[ZBN,[CGGEBKBKQ\TRGDGJGC[NBIEEGPF
N\TRGDGJGC[NICZG.NP[N,FTGSYCIMPF,NB
K\TRDPMCGEGTG[Z.G[BKRGTG[YCIMPF,NBK\TRD
PF[DG\GFPXBG\DEGNG\[CIMPF.BNBGGEBK[NHF
RG\QF[K"\TG[ZGMCGEGNHFRG\QF[DG\RVNBG\
CIMPF.
XKGZ:[PYCNPF[K"\ZGCJGC,G[NGFZCF,
GPXGK\PKECSKVGYRV[K,MKP[KDVZRS\GCYNG\
DEGNFGCPNGBF.NBKETJZEG\GEGIYNTGNO,NB
KETP[GOPINF,PMGCEPBECTKRKFCZKG\,DGPZ
CYNG\MNPKRK\GMRKG\[TGNFTNET\G,GCMNB[Z
KVRFKXNKI.
M[ISZNGECZPF,FGBP\VNNGRTRF\KMUTN
PYGPG,MKTGRFNG\PKECMNPF[KEZG[PPRGK\’,BU
\VKNFBI\NB[CFZKYF.GC[TF[P\DCZCPT[KO
JGCKO,FXNI\GTGNFCPKEFPZGCF.GM[P\Z[N,
RPXF[CPEFHGKGZE\FXNI\G.
MNFPMKZKO[NGFGNMKOCEZLFK[Z=FPFCTNK
VZRSF,NBKETGPINF,GFOFPMGCEKOCKG\ZCTKRK
FCZKG\,GBKQNFO[GOJZEG\.G[YJG[NGFZCFNFO
MNFKGOG\PKE,GFPFVYIKO,BR[KBP\,CTNKXGZF,
TE[P\CZLGP\TRDCKG\ZNK[CCICZ\O.
GMNFPMKZKO[NG,[BKROFGNMKONEZL
F\GZF=FPFPIGSZKFVZRSF,PGJZEKOCIGCG\
228NZBG\JGC
PZGCKO,NBKPXBNFOBUZDTBI\NR[GONZGGIF,
SGCNKOPING\PNBKPMBGCKO,GPCGHKOCKG\ZCTKRK
FCZKG\,GFPFRZBKONGISZKET\GISZKEZLBZW,
ZTKOGBMHZKOTOFCZKG\,IRVRKOPNBK[YZKO,TE
[PBGSNK[CCSPGLNICZ\O.GCPXCHFCFZD[\
FBEOYCN\JGCMDGQ:
B.YCN\JGCFGZGC[NGF,F[D\VZRS\GCYNG\
DEGNFGCPNGBF.NBKZDK[EGIYNTGNO,NBKET
PING\MNN,K[KDMCGECMNB[ZKV\IGMN
\MRKG\KG,[TGNFTNET\G,DGPZCYNG\GCFXNIF
ZCF.
C.P\VNNGRTRF\KMUTNFPYGO.C[TF[PKJKC
PT[KG=PXNKICKG\Z,GC[TF[PZKTB\
PT[KG=PBCEB\FXNI\G.
D.MNPMKZKG,FFGNMKOCEZLFK[Z,FPFCTNKVZRSF
GT[Z,CZKBKO,NBKETG[GOPINF,FPMGCEKO
CKG\ZCTKRKFTGNO,KG[CKOCF[YJG[NGF
ZCF.GPMKZK,[BKQFOFGNMKOCEZLFK[Z,FPF
PIGSZKVZRSF,PNBKJZEG\GXTZ,SGCNKO
PING\GPCGHKOCKG\ZCTKRKFCZKG\.
E.MNFPMKZKOFXEKYKO,ZGBFBG\OVYIKO,
CTNKI[CGQ,CTNKEZLBZWTOFCZKG\,BR[K
BP\,CTNKXGZF=TE[P\TRDPBGENFKG\
CICZ\O.
�łÆØ��ª��ø��,���ł�æœł��Ø��Ø
GKFKC\GL[RKFPNIPFCKPKFJCIFBKGO,GBRK
\VNF,GBCLCMKZCMNFNKNF.GKFKMTNG\FCGYZ
229 F[DFZGIRK\
GFRFBR[KFTGNOMGNGMPGPYGCXKOCYKCGWBIE
NVRKEPKGRK,GBK[BIEPZIUCKRKFOCZB[IZCGTN
ZB[KFO,PXNKUMNVKZB[KFO,GFZB[KOVGZIKO
NPZGOGDGKG\KFORGVNKONCYTFDEGNFPBGEGKFKG
NKO[NTXPG\.
GFRFYGNBNK:BRKBN[EKFPRFKDNMNFTGNO
MGNGCZIPKOPZGCKO,[NIKELGBIGHCFIZCMKT\F
R\\KNLTXPFGDCGZF.G\NCK[KRKZGIF’GBIH\K
CFIZC,G\KMURTNOBG\GFBK[GFCJ\KFKJCTN
PYGPGGBKRRG,GFIZCCZ[G\KNYRKRKFVZJK.
GKBPZF’BNK:[BZDNLGNLNLPPGNE\LBN
BZWFIPEFBZWFBCG\FYEG[KO,GBT[L[ONIMO
DEGNGTXGOGRCZMGCLMNDBGRKFBZW,MKBG\LCIZ\K
NXEKYGIMOCMNFEGZFHFNPTQ\ZVBB\[CZ
FBRG[KCK[GTF[NYKKPB,GB\FIZCFHF\KYI
CKELG\[PGZTNKFCMNRV[LGPBGEL,MKFKBFBG\
CKRKGCKRKLB[ZMNFECZKOFJGCKOFBNGK\YKPGTN
KEKL,MKTET\FTGENBFKFNKBK[RBPQMPG\L
NPSGZNGFIZCFHB\GTNMQT[GFIGCNKOPF[T[G,
GPT\FMNPICNB[ZKZBFB\IZCKCKEKL\KMU
K\TNOGK\CTZPFBZW.
GBS\KZVRKMKKZB\KPNFCKJNTGP\FEGCZCK,
GFIZC[FK\FNPZBFTKRKEPKGRKMPGIZCV[GJF
[NCZHNCEPG\P[IK\RGZB,FRFR\FVMFCZ[G\K
NBG\KG\RGXXG\F[OFYEG[BN[EKB[ZCZY
HKGGOPNBFBGZGRI\GF[YJGCJIB\MNFTGNO
MGNG.
230NZBG\JGC
GBGPZ)F(BNNCK:PKK\QGBYRFNMNEGZKFTGNO
PJKV\JFZF[NFIZCFHB\MKBHKETG[K[RGTO
F’CBZW.
GB[BTKRKGFRFF’RKXCTNKGKBPZBNK:BRKBN
BNYKBCG\KL,[BRBTKRKLPFPYGOB[ZB\FTGPE
NVRKG\ZBFMNFPXKBG\B[ZFPXB\KK[PBKQ,
TNKGRKOG\I\GRKOKIEPZB[P\IKN\KXKB\ONDKNGK
FPXKBG\GTEMNFP[LHPQCSEZKF\V\IG\OTE
KCGBGTNDPZPNBM\OMZBGKNPT[FKEKNF\VBZ.
GBZBFGB[PIPBGETNFCZKBFFRFEZFGMN
PNGBF,GFTGRDGFJGCB[ZMNCBKFBZWP\TRDKO
TNKF,GBGEFNF’.
BHBPZ\KNF’:NVRKLRTCGECKZBFGVIEGRGEF
N[PL\PKEMKPB\LNB\XBFZTG\GFJGC,BMQ
[N[N\[NRGTOTZGMFNVRKRGPZB[TESGU,GB[ZK
FEGZMKOTNTGNPLB[ZFMKRG\NFONRGTOGTEQGMN
JGC,BKQ[GORV\NGTY[CMNPT[KKEKLFTNKGRKO
G\I\GRKOKIE.GRPNB\KIMPFRFEZFGTNMGNOIMP\
F[DI\GFVZJK\C\MNK\.MQFNM\KGFGSV\KIMPF
KGOKGOKPKOZCKO[PGRKOGPBG\KGO.
CKPKOFBNFTNFTNNCKNTZGL\VNFNF’
NBPGZ:FQRPNB\KIMPFKG\ZPMNFYEPGRKOGBKQ
ECZCTGNOB[ZKVNBPPRK,BGNOB\ECZKFRCKBKO
GIMPKF’BKRKPCKQMNGO,DOF[PG\FYEG[KOCZGCO
NBFCR\K,GFZFZ\K:FRFF’FCJKINKIMPFGET\
TENFKG\NPGV\CKQIMPKOGFRCZBKOGBRKTEKKQB\
[KI\OBKRKPCKQ.
GCJZOBYZBGFRFF’[GZFTNKGKBPZ:FQ
\ZBFIMP\LGF[D\LNPTNFNPTNFTNMNFIMPKO
231 F[DFZGIRK\
B[ZFKGCBZWTEFRF,GPF[BN\)K(PPRKGNB
R\\KNL?GNPF\EBKCB\ZGILCFCR\ECZKFRCGBF
[BKRLPSGVY[ECZKFORBPZKOP\GLYJRG\
PF[D\L,FBO\ZXF[BGZKELPPEZD\LGBH\GMN
NFCKQB\MNECZKFOMPG\O?GFIZ[\KG[PI\K
CF\VBZG\ZICFGNBTRK\KECZ.
BIZKHF[BN\KB\F’:FNBTEFRFNB[PT\K
ECZTNYKGODGK\KGMNFJGCG\GFKTGEKOFDKTGNK
P\GLZGIRKG\CNCEGBNKFFMNPKGTE,GBOMQPF
KFKF[CDNNBKHFPINFBGVDTKFDGUK\CNCN[MNK
GBIJBNVRKL,FBO\[NKMRKPNVRKLG\BCEB\MN
FJGCFFHB\BG\TRK[RK?
GK[CTNKF’)FQMCZCB\TN\MNK\LGNMNV[TKL
SNI\KGFISEFHF(C[PGFDEGNGFRGZBGCMSBG
FRXIKMKNBKZVFISEGPPRKCRXIKG\,GBOBIJB
GBONBBIJBISEGGYEG[\GNBKSGZFKPRKNRXI
G[PT\KG[PI\KPBGE.
GCPNB\FKPKOFBNFFY[C\KY[CZCNMN
FKTGEKOGFFCJIG\[RGTE\KPB\F’,GNBPXB\K
CFOSKVGYGN[GQBKLNECZBNCRKFTGNOGNFCKBO
NIVWF’B[ZFGEKT)K(RK,GNBKMGN\KNF\BVYNJKKN
CKQCRKBEOFZKYKOPMNGEGCZKOSZFTNF’GTN
CZKB\G,GBRK[C)G(TGFNNFGNLG[PIGMPGPXJIY
TNFBGPNNKOFBNF,GRDTGBNKFECZKOTEFNC.
BHFGSMOCNCK=KFKFPF[KFKFGBVKNGBZE
PPEZD\KFZPF,FRRKPGMZIN[VGL\VKNFIPF
NF’,NK\QNKF[DFGET\CECZKRCGBFGIMPFGN[GQ
NFGTKNB\CRKFTGNOFBGPNNKONFTNG\ONEZD\
FIMPFGFRGTOMPG\K.GFDO[KET\KPBH[BSGZNK
232NZBG\JGC
NFEBKCZGIKTOMNHFNBF\BVY\KG[VM\K[KI
G\VKNFIPFPBGE.
GKFKCCGYZGB[BTKRKGZBK\KKG[CC[PKOK[IY
TNKGTNECZKGKBPZNK:PFB\FZGBF?GBGPZBRK
ZGBFC’BR[KOP\BCYKOKIE,BIEIMOG[NOCMN
TGH,GF[RKYJQGJV[MPGYJQ[RGNE,GF[RKFISZ
JTOFYJQGFIN[PVKNB\FDCGZGF[NO.
GKBPZNKF’:HFFYJQDEGNKFKF.GKV\IFYJQB\
VKGGBPZNKBKHFVSGYKOCN\KPGCRKONKMNXZMO,
BGPROFZD[\KCFOMNBGXZG\FIMPFGFRCGBF
FRFGDFCKQMNRCKBKBP\,TE[KET\KMKTRFNKF’GR\Q
NKPFNMKOCKQMNFRCKBKOGIMPKF’.
GKBPZNKF’:YGOTNZDNLGFCJNZGIPHZIK\
YEPF,GR[B\KTKRKGZBK\KB[ZFYJQFNHCZDTBI\
R\ZGPOGF[GFB\TXPGGYGP\GNYGP\FDEGN,GTEKKQ
FKFISZJTOG[MNMPYEOGRVNB\KPBGE.
BIZHFFKFECZF’BNKCPIHFNBPGZ:[MC
TNXELFKPRK\.GB[MCTNFBZW,GKBPZNK:PFB\F
ZGBF?GBGPZ:BRKZGBFDGKKOGNBGPKOZCKOPBE
P\R[BKOGRBCEKOGPZBKFOP[I\PBEO.
GKBPZNKF’:BO\GMNNK\QXGZFNMNFDGKKO
FBNFGNFVKICFOZGIIKKOBHBCKBLBNFBZW
B[ZR[CT\KNBCG\KLN\\NLGMNKTGEKK\YKKPGTN
KEL.
�łÆØ��ª��ø��,�œ���œ�Æ��Øœ
TKYZTCGE\FBEO[K\CGRQCDENG\F’,FKKRG[FGB
XZKLNFS\MNCSVZKOFPECZKOPDENG\F’GCHPQ
[NGPEKOXZKMKONXKKZNTXPG,CBKHF[TGZFKGIH"N
233 F[DFZGIRK\
PZDK[KOB\DENG\G[NFYC"F,GK\VNNNF’[KBKZ
NFZDK[B\ZGPPG\GK\CZL,CMEK[KGMNNFMRKTNCCG
GNFCJNNVRKFYC"F.
�łÆÆłŒø���ø��,��łœº"Ł
ET,MKJZO[RBXNGFRBXNKOGRCZBGFRCZBKO,
FKFBGZTNKGQV[GJPPNBB\MNFPXKBG\.
GNBFKF[GOPYGOVRGKCCIKR\BGKZZKYRKGINN,
BNBFMNFKFPNBBGZFBKQSGUFV[GJFFGB.
GNBFKFNGNBCIKR\ZB[GNBCIKR\SGU,
BNBFMNFKFBGZBIEV[GJ[GGFCF[GGBFBI\,
GFGBFRYZB"BGZBKQSGU".
GMB[ZTNFCZXGRGFV[GJNCZGBB\FTGNPG\
GNFBXKNB\FRBXNKO,
NFGXKBNBGZ[NKPG\VTGNG\KG,[PG\KGGMKRGKKG,
[FK\FHB\SKC\CZKB\FTGNPG\.
FRFBHXPXOB\TXPGBKQSGUCRYGEFFBPXTK\,
B[ZCGCBPXTPP[,
GXPXOB\FBGZFFGB,
GF\ZIYBNSCKCG\XEEKFRYGEFFBPXTK\.
GBHR[BZPYGOVRGK,BGKZGINNZKYRK
PFRYGEFFBPXTK\PP[.
GFRFFXPXGOFHFFKFCF[GGBFBI\
CSCKCG\FRYGEFFBPXTK\FZKYRK\FFKB.
CBGVQ[PYGOFINNFFGB
FKFTDGNPMNSCKCG\KGCF[GGBFDPGZF.
234NZBG\JGC
GFRFBIZFXPXGO,
B[ZBHR[BZPYGOFINNGFBGKZVRGKGZKYRK
CBPXTBGZFBKQSGUPP[,
FRFMCZFKFPYGO,
[KGMNG[ONFKG\FRBXNKO,
GFRCZBKO,GFKXGZKO,GFRT[KO.
GBHFP[KLPQBGZBKQSGUYGBIE[NG,
PNPTNFNPJF,
P[\N[NGKGZE\GLFINNFFGB.
GEZLFYGFFGBFBXKN,GCZB,GKXZ,GT[F
MNFTGNPG\MGNO.
YGEOBZCTFFTGNPG\FNNG
FKFBKQSGUBIEG[PGBIECBIEG\RVNBGRTNO,
[BKQMGIBVKNGCPNBMKOFYZGCKOBNKG
GBKQNFOF[DFCBKQSGU,
MKBKQ[GOuMNRCZB[KGMNNF[KDG,
FKG\MKBKQNGPYGO,GNBDCGN,GNB[O.
�łÆØ���łØ�,��ł"Ø,æ ł�ı�ØØ�,����’,ø�ł�’
235 F[DFZGIRK\
K[ZBNGFTPKO
GFRLZGBFIKGCFPGINJ,FPGJNTNMNK[ZBN,KFKF
PK[KFKF,NTSGYCVRKPKG\F\GZFGCSGEG\KF,[NB
\G[NOCBEOMGGR\FCZKBFHGN\F.GNSCFHGBRG
P\DNDNKO,EGZKGXBGEGZCB,TEEGZKRGHF[FGB
F[BZK\[NFR[PG\,[TEKKQNBR[NPFTNKFQMGGR\
FCZKBF,PVRK[NBHMGNF[KDCEGZG\[TCZGTNKFQ
B\SGEG\F\GZF.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł Ø�º�
GBK\BCPEZ[KIH"NGCHGFZG\KYGRKO,B[ZMN
FTGNPG\FTNKGRKOGMNFSVKZG\FYEG[G\EF’
TGNPG\B"YGBCK"TCMPG\OGBKMG\O,MNHFFGMQ
PMNPZB[ZYNF[NPG\CRKK[ZBN.MKR[P\BK[
FK[ZBNKFKBINYBNGYKPPTN.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł Ø�º�
BPROMQMCZFGZGNRGIH"NCFZCFPYGPG\,[MN
FTGNPG\MGNONBRCZBGBNBC[CKNK[ZBN.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,œ��ª�øł�æ Øłœ,����’,�机�œ �Ø�Øœ,�œ’
K[ZBNDEZNTGNO.
ø�œłÆ� łø�Æ’
K[ZBNFQSDGN\G[NFYC"F,[RBPZNFKG\NGNTO
SDGNF.
�ªłøœ��Ø��ªÆłØ�, ł�Ø"ª
K[ZBNPCKBKQBGZFNTGNO.
øØł�øØłØ�łÆ� łø�ª’
K[ZBNPBKZKONPK[PBKZNMN.
ø�œłÆ� łø��"
BGPFRMRS\GBGPFKGXB\,GFBZWNTGNOTGPE\:
BNGK[ZBN.
�ªłøœ��Ø�,���ł�"
BGPF[MNJGCF[FKBCBFNTGNOBKRFCBFBNB
CHMG\F.
Æł�øØœłÆ�, łø�æ"
BGPF[[NGOFTGNPKOEZC\GMF.
Æł�øØœłÆ�, łø�æ"
K[ZBNIGJBKOGNGYKQGIGHZKQGIGJBKOGNGYKQ.
�غ�łÆ�, łø��’
PFFDVQFHFFTNKO[NFPMSKQTNFB[MGNG\,ML
FOK[ZBN,TPKFBZW[CFO,PMSKQTN\NPKEK
IMPKO.
Ø�ł�łÆ�, łø��"
K[ZBNM[FKSGZKQCBKQTNKFO,FQRMRTKQGP\VNNKO,
BCNBGPG\FTGNOPCTJKQCFQGBKROPMKZKQ[PG[N
FYC"F.
�ªłøœ����, łøœ�ØÆØ�,æØ���’
237 K[ZBNGFTPKO
M[K[ZBNBGMNKOG[G\KOFOTGSYKOCPYZB,
CP[RF,BCNBGPG\FTGNOM[FOBGMNKOG[G\KO
BKQP\IKNKQBNBCECZK\KVNG\.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜��Ø��,��’Ø"Æ
K[ZBNNKPG\FP[KIPMNKQMNFBGPG\.
Æ�ªÆłłÆ�, łø�Æ’
PFKGRFHGPMVZ\TNFTGNKO,MLK[ZBNPMVZKQTN
FBGPG\.
øØł�øØłØ�łÆ�, łø�ª’
K[ZBNRP[NGMXGZKO,GBGPG\FTGNOMIZS.
Ø��Łø���Ø,�æœł
K[ZBNRZEVKQPVRKFBGPG\,GCIZFYC"FCK[ZBN.
Ø�ł�łÆ�, łø�º"�
K[ZBNR\GRKQCEKQCBG\F[TF,BONFKRXNBO
NFKBCETOPXZKO.
łø"Ø,ø�œ, ł�Ø"ª
K[ZBNT[GKKOEKK[NMNCBKTGNO.
æØ�œ�łÆœØ łø�Ø"�
K[ZBN[CIGWNBZWTGCEKOTCGE\BNKNKOCJFZF.
�溜œ�Ł�œ,�溜�ÆœªłÆØ�œ�, ł�º’
238NZBG\JGC
K[ZBN[CPXZKOFYEKPGBPGRFN[PKTF.
øØł�øØłØ�łÆ�, łø�Æ’
K[ZBNNT\KENCGBBKQMNBGPFGN[GQKMGNFN[NGJ
CFO.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜��Ø��,ª�Ø"�
M[O[BKBV[ZNTGNOCNKBZCTZGIG\,MLBKBV[Z
NGNTGNOCNBK[ZBN.
łª"��ºłØ�, ł�Æ’
ZBGKFKF[FYEG[F\FKFTNMNFBEO,[FZKY[Z
FBEOTOF’FGBNPTNFPMNTO.BGNOFYNYGNKO
[CBEOF[MKIGB\FYEG[F,GKXKZFIE[FRT[\F
CK[ZBN,[EGGYBPPYGZFMNYGE[KKP[L.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
CMNTO,FVRKPKG\[NIKKFYCGXFFKBCXGZIKK
FMNMNFGFD[PKG\.BGNOK[ZBN,JCTR[P\OFGB
FXKPBGQNFZDK[CMNPZICKFIKKOB\FBNGYKO.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
GCBG\GFHPQNBKFKF[ONBZTCGNBPNIPF,GNB
YRBFG\IZG\,[FJGCF\FKFPG[VT\FZCF,GMN
FPTERKOKFKGPXGKKQMTVZ,GNBKFKFTSYMNFTGNO
BNBNET\B\F’CNCE,GNVKMLKFKGK[ZBNIMPKO
DEGNKOGKGETKOECZKOFS\GPKOGK[KDGET\CGZBO
239 K[ZBNGFTPKO
MVKMIFBEO,[RBPZ"MKPNBFFBZWETFB\F’,
MPKONKOPMSKO".
�ø��œł���ł�Æ"�,��ºœ��ºØ�����œ, ł�Ø"Æ
MNMLPIGCZZGIK[ZBNCZGIBNGYKO,TE[BVKNG
PK[BGPZ[BKRGHYGYNBNGYKO,MKGGQ[FGBIVWCZGI
K[ZBN,FZGIFBNGYK[GZFCGDOCTNMGZIG.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
MLV\IZ’\RIGPBCZBCB:"DVQPPXZKO\SKT,
\DZ[DGKOG\JTF"NPFRP[NGK[ZBNNDVQ?BNB
PFFDVQ,M[CTNKFPCY[KO[\[CKI,PFFOTG[KO?
TGYZKOBG\FPPYGPF,G[G\NKOBG\FCPYGOBIZ,
GFKBP[CI\:ML,MKGGQ[CKY[FYC"FNVZSO
NK[ZBNCTGNO,PFT[F?TYZOPPXZKOGFCKBO
NPECZ,GF\IKNGPXNKIKO[O,GBGPZKO:"MNB[Z
EKCZF’,RT[FGR[PT"GKXBNFO[OCTGNO,[RBPZ:
"GKXBNL[OCDGKKOCKGVKKL".
ø�œłÆ�, łø��"ª
K[ZBN\PXK\FFGGKFMGNF,BKQNL\RGTFCMNFTPKO
MGNO,[NB\PXBEGDP\FCK[ZBN.BPGR\G=FKB
FPYGZFP[VKTB\FJGCNBGPRG\MGNQ.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
BEOPK[ZBN[ZGXFNHMG\NBGZIKKOCBP\,XZKL
FGBNFSMKON[\GNB\TXPGCMRS\K[ZBN:NI[GC
240NZBG\JGC
K[ZBNKG\NFZDK[K[ZBNKG\NYRG\B\FKEKTG\
FPKGIEG\NK[ZBNGNZBG\C[PI\K[ZBN.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
F\IKKF[NFBGPFFKBFKSGENCRKKQ[NF\[GCF
FDEGNF=\[GC\K[ZBNG\[GC\FTGNO,[\CGB
BIZKF.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
K[ZBNFBGPF[FBGRKCZSNKG\FDPGZFJPGRFCTGPY
R[P\F.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
BNDKR\BDGHKZE\K.NPFRP[NGK[ZBNMBDGH?
PFFBDGHFHFP[IYN\KRGYG\TRGDNPNMKO,ML
K[ZBN,M[FOHGMKO="GFKGPNMKOBGPRKKL"GM[FO
IGJBKO="FKK\K[IGYNMNFTPKO".
æØ�œ�łÆœØ, łø�Ø"�
K[ZBNCHPQ[TG[KQZXGRG[NPYGOBKQMNBGPF
GN[GQ[GNJ\CFO,GCHPQ[BKQTG[KOZXGRG[NPYGO,
PGSZQCKEBGPF[VNF.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜ºœÆœ,ª�æ"
PFZBFFYC"FNECZTOP[FP\GLFSRF?BPZZ’
PBKZ:PFFSRFTG[KQBG\GDEZNDKRF,MLK[ZBNDEZ
NTGNO.
ø�œłÆ�, łø�Æ’
241 K[ZBNGFTPKO
GKZOYZQNTPG,GNPFRP[NGK[ZBNNYZQ?PFFYZQ
CZB[FKBR\GRF,MLFOK[ZBNZB[NMNFBGPG\,
[RBPZ"GR\RLF’NZB[".
�ªłøœ��Ø�,���ł��"�
BPZZCKBNTHZCZBCKRB:BKQVGZTRG\CBFNTGNO,
BNBC[CKNK[ZBN.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜ØÆ�œ,ª�æ"�
GBCEKNB\MOPQFTPKOBPZZCKNGK:MNPT[KFO
[NK[ZBNP[GRKOPBGPG\FTGNO:CIZK[\Q,CHZKT\Q,
CRJKT\Q,CYXKZ\Q,CTKPGZQ,CEK[Q,CDGZKRFQ,CDDG\KFQ,
CCMGZG\KFQ,C\DNI\,CPRKKRQ.
Æ�ªÆłłÆ�, łø�Ø’
CJRLTZP\IJKOZCKKGSKCQIRRKFBGPZ:PFIKJF
HGSGVD\)\GVI\(,MLK[ZBNSGVDKQRMSKFO[NBGPG\
FTGNO.HFG[RBPZ:"GBMN\B\MNFTPKO".
øØł�øØłØ�łÆ�, łø��’
XEYFT[FFYC"FCK[ZBN,[VKHZQNCKQFBGPG\.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜 æ�Ø�,ª� "�
CMNFTGNOK[ROISKEKO,VKNGSGVKO,BR[KYGE[
GBR[KBNGYKO,BCNBKQCTGNOBGPF[NPF,[TXPKG\F
FKBFBKEBFFBNGYK\=MKBOTOK[ZBN.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
242NZBG\JGC
BVKNGFBVKYGZSG\FK[ZBNK\PNBFBPGRF,FZCF
KG\ZPBPGRG\FDGKKOMGNO.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
FPCEKNCKQK[ZBNNTPKOFGBBGZFISE,FTGNO
KGETZYB\TXPG,B\FRB\GFDSF,GBVKNGFFRBG\
FZGIRKG\FQZYMP[Z\G\NG.K[ZBNPJCTR[P\G,
IVWCJGCFBNGYK,NFKG\JGC=NMGN.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
R[P\K[ZBNFKBR[PFKGXZ\,R[P\MNFTPKOFKB
ZYPXKKZ\,PSEZ\.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
MNFDGKKOR\GRKO\I\P[JZFJCT.MN[BKV\OFKB
NPNBZXGRQFTKGGZ,[FGBIKZG\[JIK\C\GLTGPY
[NF[\TCEG\VRKPK\.BCNK[ZBN=KXBPPXZKO.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
KXKB\K[ZBNPPXZKO\K[BZNTEFBCKC[NMN
FTGNO.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
CJGIBRK,[EGGYBHFFEGZFRZBFMNMLZKYGVGZY
TGN,EGGYBFGBTNV\IK\[GCFTGPE,FGBFPGM[Z
CKG\ZNBGZ\[GC\BP\.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
243 K[ZBNGFTPKO
PYGCNKOBRG[\FKFPZKEFZGIRK\CBZW.F[NGGF
FD[PK\[\CGB\YJKQB\FR[PF,GKCGBGKPKO
[\BPZBKQNKIVWCFO.F[BKVFNBKEKBNKO\IEN.
TEKCGBSTZGPFVMF,GKKZBFCTNKNMKIGSQK[ZBN
FGBCBGZF’NCEG.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
CEGZRGFRRGRGNEKOPIE[MKPKYEO.MNFZGIRKG\[N
FTCZFGNM\GRCNT\CPYGZF,BGNOFKBKGXB\CVRKO
ZTRRG\,YJRG\CMPG\,BLTNGNKONXPKIFDEGNF.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
P[KICQKGSUPDNFB\I[KCG\K[ZBNNCEO,BL
\MNK\K[ZBNFKBNBIEB\FTGNOMGNGNP[VIF
BI\NYZGBC[OF’,TNMQ"T\KEP[KICQKGSU
NKFZD"GKPNGLP[KICQEGE.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
FPNIPG\PTPKYG\B\FTZLFPKGIE[NMNTO,
TE[P\CNJ\FXGZF[NG,GKGXB\BNFVGTNCXGZF
PDPZ\.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
BZW[FK\FJGCFGMNPNMKTGNOR\BGGNF.
�ªłøœ����, łøœ�ø ŁØ�,æØ��Ø’
BZWK[ZBNDCGFFPMNBZXG\.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜�Æ�Ø�,ª��"ª
244NZBG\JGC
BZWK[ZBNFKB\CNG[NTGNO.
��Ø�łÆ�, łø�Æ’
BZWK[ZBNKG[C\CBPXTK\G[NTGNO,GKZG[NKO
CBPXTK\F[NBZWK[ZBN.
�ªłøœ����, łøœ�ªøØ�,æØ��Ø’
BZWK[ZBNPNBFEDQ\KZG[GKXFZ,GMNFBZXG\
CBG\NPNBG\BG\FMSUGHFC.
Æł�øØœ�"�,Ø"ª
BZWK[ZBNP[YFBG\FFYC"FCTXPG,GMNFTGNO
MGNGP[YFGTNKEK[NKI.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜œ��Øœ,ª�Ø’
BZWK[ZBNPYGE[\PMNFBZXG\.
Æ�ªÆłłÆ�, łø��’
BZWK[ZBNRCZB\\IKNFGMNFTGNOMGNGRCZB
NCSGU.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜œ��Øœ,ª�Ø’
BZWK[ZBN[G\FPKD[PKOGMNFTGNOMGNG
P\PXK\,BZWK[ZBN[G\F\INFGMNFTGNOMGNG
NCSGU.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜œ��Øœ,ª�Ø’
BZWK[ZBNYNFPMNFBZXG\NC[NB\VKZG\KF.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜ºœÆœ,ª��Ø"Æ
245 K[ZBNGFTPKO
BZWK[ZBN\FBPCGZM\CVKZG\,GMNFBZXG\
P\VZRSG\FKPRFGPP[KMG\NFMSVOGHFCO.
łø"Ø,ªÆłØ�,�"�
BOKBPZGBGPG\FTGNONK[ZBN:BGPF[N[GEEKO
B\O,[MC[\OBZXG\[CTFDGKKO,FOBGPZKO
NFO:MNFBZW[NFYC"F:FGBCZBFGR\RFNB[Z
K[ZCTKRKG,CZXGRGR\RFNMO,GCZXGRGRJNFPMO
GR\RFNRG.
łø"Ø,Æł�øØœ ł��’
T[ZFINYKO[NDCGZFCTGNO:\[TFCKFGEF,GBIE
CMNFTGNO.
�溜�ÆœªłÆØ�œ�,�æ��Æ’, ł��"�
T[ZFYCKQIMPFKZEGNTGNO:\[TFRJNFBZW
K[ZBN,GBIEMNFTGNOMGNG.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜�تøØ�,ª��"Ł
T[ZFINYKO[NKGVKCTGNO:\[TFCKZG[NKO,GBIE
CMNFTGNO.
�æœłłÆ�, łø��’
T[ZFINYKO[NIMPFCTGNO:\[TFCBZWK[ZBN,
GBIECMNFTGNO.
�æœłłÆ�, łø��’
246NZBG\JGC
T[ZFINYKO[NIMPFCTGNO:\[TFCKZG[NKO,
GBIECMNFTGNO.
�溜�ÆœªłÆØ�œ�,�æ��Æ’, ł��"�
T[Z\INYKO[NIRGVFCTGNO:\[TFCKZG[NKO,
GBIECMNFTGNO.[RBPZ:"MKPB\RCKBKKZG[NKO
KXBFIRGVFNMNFBZW".
�æœłłÆ�, łø��’
T[ZFYCKQKGVKKZEGNTGNO:\[TFRJNFKZG[NKO,
GBIEMNFTGNOMGNG.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜�تøØ�,ª��"Ł
T[ZFINYKO[N\GZFCTGNO:\[TFCKZG[NKO,
GBIECMNFTGNO.
�æœłłÆ�, łø��’
[RGZCG\KRG:NTGNOKEGZBEOCBZWK[ZBN,BVKNG
CTKZ[ZGCFTMG"O,GBNKEGZCIGWNBZW,GBVKNGCTKZ
[ZGCFK[ZBN.[MNFKGXBNIGXFNBZW,MBKNGTGCE
TCGEFHZF.
łÆØ�ø�Æ��Ø��,�ł�Æ"�,��ºœ��ºØ�, ł��’
GK[C\ONCJICBZXMO,CBZXMOB\OKG[CKO
NCJI,GBKB\OKG[CKONCJIIGXFNF.
æ ł�Æ��œØ, łø��’
M[O[FJCGZFHFR\GQCBPXTFBK[,MLBZW
K[ZBN=JCGZF[NTGNO,[RBPZ:"KG[CTNJCGZ
247 K[ZBNGFTPKO
FBZW".BZWK[ZBNKG[C\CBPXTK\G[NTGNO
GKZG[NKOCBPXTBZWK[ZBN,GCK\FPYE[CBPXT
KZG[NKO,GFFKMNCBPXTCK\FPYE[,GFBZGQCBPXT
FFKMN,GBCQF[\KFNVRKFFKMN,[PPRFFG[\\
FTGNO.
�ªłøœ����, łøœ�ªøØ�,æØ��Ø’
M\GC"GFKFPEKIGE[CIGE[GGPEK[C\C[C\G
KCGBMNC[ZGDG’GBKLBV[Z[KCGBMNC[ZNKZG[NKO
CMN[C\GCMNIGE[?BPZZCKNGK:T\KEFKZG[NKO
NFKG\MB"K,GB"KMMNFTGNOMGNG.GBKLCBKO
CZB[IGE[GC[C\PSGUFTGNO?BNBFTCKOCBKO
GJGTRKOBG\O)MPGTNPZCE[NYSPKO(GPCKBKO
BG\ONKZG[NKO.
Ø��Łø���Ø,Øø�Ø�ł��œ�"�
CIGWNBZWP\DNFFTZL[NFPT[F,CBZWK[ZBN,
TZLFEKCGZ,GCCK\FPYE[,FTZL[NFPI[CF.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
R[PFMNNK\BKRF[GZFCBK[VZJK,BNBCBZW
K[ZBN.\MU[CBBEONBZW,P\CJN\R[P\G
FVZJK\,PVRKFBGZFDEGN[NR[P\K[ZBNFRMRS\
C\GMG,GVGTN\B\VTGN\F.
���łœ�łÆ�ł�Ø"���,œ��ø�Øæª��Ø�
248NZBG\JGC
BZWK[ZBN[G\FPKD[PKO,GMNFTGNOP\PXK\
)[G\FPF[BZKG\(..BZWK[ZBN[G\F\IKNF,GMN
FTGNOMGNGCSGU.
œ��ªÆÆ�Ø,�溜œ��Øœ,ª�Ø’
TGCEKMGMCKOGPHNG\KCG[GGK[ZBNK[PIG.
łø"Ø,�溜ÆÆ��Ø��,ª��"�
BGPG\FTGNOBGPZKO:BRGTKYZGC[CKNRGRCZB
FTGNO,BPZGNFOK[ZBN:FP\KRGTE[KDKTFKGOGBRG
KGETKOC[CKNPKRCZB.
Æł�øØœłÆ�, łø� "�
GFKFFTGNOBGPZKONK[ZBN:RNMFTPMO,[RBPZ
"BRFFNLEGEL",GK[ZBNBGPZKONTGCEKBNKNKO:BKQ
NMOINYCG,[RBPZ:"BRKNEGEKGEGEKNK".
Ø��Łø���Ø,øØł�øØłØ�,ł��œœ� "�
BGPG\FTGNOBGPZKQNK[ZBNFZKBNGFG\RGBRG
ZGBKOBG\O,B\OFGBBNGFKMO?GFQP[KCKQ:
BNGFMOPT[FKEMO,B\OZGBKQBG\OGFOBKRO
ZGBKOB\MO,GBNGFKRGC[PKO,GBRIRGPT[FKEKG=
FGBZGBFGBKRGRZBF.
�ł��ªłøØ�,��’�º"
BGPG\FTGNOBGPZKQNK[ZBN:TEP\KB\OP\KOTN
BNGFKMO?=GFGBDGPNNMOZTG\,[GCGNMOBXNRG.
æØ�œ�łÆœØ, łø�º"�
249 K[ZBNGFTPKO
BGPG\FTGNOBKQNFOJGCF,BCNJGC\Q[NK[ZBN
JGCF[NPF.
�æœłłÆ�, łø��’
BGPG\FTGNOBKQNFOK[KCF.
�æœłłÆ�, łø��’
BGPG\FTGNOBKRQDGNKO,BUTNVK[DGNKOBKQDNG\O
DNG\=BCNK[ZBN[BKQBGMNKOPV\OGBKQ[G\KO
PKKRO,DNG\ODNG\.
�غ�łÆ�, łø��’
BGPG\FTGNO=BUTNVK[IGJBKQBKQMNGO,BCN
K[ZBNIJBGGNYG.
�غ�łÆ�, łø��’
BGPG\FTGNONBFKGGNBT\KEKQNFKG\=BCNK[ZBN
FKGGDOT\KEKQNFKG\.
�ªłøœ����, łøœ��,æØ��Ø"Ł
BGPG\FTGNONBPGRKQ[C\BNKPKFIGN,BCNK[ZBN
PGRKQB\F[C\:IEC[C\B.
æØ�œ�łÆœØ, łø�º"�
BGPG\FTGNOPGRKQNIPFGK[ZBNNNCRF.
æØ�œ�łÆœØ, łø�Ł"
250NZBG\JGC
BGPG\FTGNOP\KZBKQNVRKFYC"FGYZGCKON\[GCF
GK[ZBNY[KTGZU.
�ªłøœ����, łøœø�Ø�Ø,æØ��Ł’
BGPG\FTGNORCGB\QS\GPF,BCNK[ZBNRCGB\Q
PVGZ[\.
�æœłłÆ�, łø��’
BGPG\FTGNORP[NGMYGXKO.
�ªłøœ����, łøœÆ�ªÆł
BGPG\FTGNORP[NGNVZKOGBKNKOG[TKZKOGK[ZBN
NCRKKGRF.
łø"Ø,Æł�øØœ, ł�Ł"
BGPG\FTGNOT[GPV\QBIEGK[ZBNT[GMPF
PV\RG\.
œ��ªØłø��Ø,�溜�ƪ��ł�, ł��’
BGPG\FTGNO[FQPFNMKQCBSYVJKG\BKQDNG\O
DNG\,BCNK[ZBN[FQPFNMKQKIVKQ,DNG\ODNG\.
�غ�łÆ�, łø��’
BGPG\FTGNO[FORG\RKQTKRKFOCMKSO[NK[ZBN
GRGJNKQMNB[ZNFO=GIG[CKQ[MNPF[TG[KQNFO
PQFKG[Z.
Æ�ªÆłłÆ�, łø�Ø’
251 K[ZBNGFTPKO
GRGET[FDBGNFG[NKPG\FF[DFMZGMKOHFCHF,
GFPGV\FGB[MNPK[K[NGFP[MFNSGEG\F\GZF
K[NGFP[MFNBZWK[ZBN,GNVKMLNBFGCJINRG
GPNBFFBZWETFB\F’GDG’BNBCBIZK\FKPKO,
EFKKRGCHPQFDBGNF.
GNVKMLMPG[C[NKPG\FF[DFNBHMKRGTGENHPQ
YCNFBNBNHPQR\KRFCNCE,[CMGIFRK\R\FHEPRG\
NCGBN[NKPG\FF[DF,MQFGBCTRKKQFDBGNF[NB
HMKRGNF,BNBCCIKR\R\KRFCNCE.MKFTGCEFFKB
[FYC"FFGXKBBZXRGFYEG[FPZ[G\FRMZKO
GFIHKZFNRG,GCMNHB\TEKKQNBYCNRGFBZWNZ[G\RG
PVRK[TGENBFDKTHPQFYCNF,MPG[CKBZRGCTRKKQ
[NKPG\FF[DF,CBGVQ[R\QGBRIRGTGENBYCNRG.
[FZKBKQNRGTXPBG\MNMNK\,GBKQTXPBG\PEKRK\
CNKTXPBG\MNMNK\.
GTGEFZCFKG\ZPHF,MKBKQDBGN\FDGU
CNKDBGN\FRV[,GMNTGE[ZGCCRKFBZW[CGKKO
C\ZCGKG\FHZG\[NFBGPG\,GBKROPSGDNKOMNN
NE\K[ZBNG\ZCG\K[ZBN,FZKDOFDGVG\[CGKKO
\I\FMGIG\FRMZKO.GPCIKRFHGRPXB\TGEFBZW
CKEKFRMZKO.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł�æØ����ł
GFPGV\FGB[BKQ[GOBEOP\ZD[MNNPQFDBGNF
MPG[FKFXZKLNFKG\CHPQFDBGNFBIZKBNVKKO
[RF.GNBCNCE[BKQCRKFDGNFP\VTNKONCGBBNKRG
GNFRG\PQFDBGNF,BNBINYDEGNPBG\O[RDBNG
GMCZKG[CKOC\GMRG,PXVKOCMNKGQTKRKKONFVJZ
PDBGNFHGGN[GCNBZXG\VHGZKFO.
252NZBG\JGC
FZK[BUTNVK[FYC"FFGXKBFBZWPZ[G\
FBGPG\GR\RFNRG,TOMNHFBRGTGENBYKCNRGF,
GBKQBRGRFRKOPHF.BNB[CR\KRFHGR\QNRGFYC"F
B\FFHEPRG\NDBGNF,EFKKRGNFJFZGNF\YE[
GNYCNTNKRGTCGE\F’,C\GZFGPXGG\N[PF,GBHKCRF
CK\FPYE[GRYCNFBZWNZ[G\RG,GBHRIG[GRZDK[
C[PI\FDBGNF.BCNMNTGE[NBCBRGNHF,[GOECZ
NBR[\RF,GBKQ[GOFVZ[CKQRKPGSKFBZWT\F,
PMVK[FK\FTEKKQ\I\HZKO,FQCP[VJ,FQCMNMNF
GFQCTCGE\F’.GBKQNRGBNBFHEPRG\NDBGNF.
FKGXBPECZKRG,[EGZKRGHFFGBFEGZ[NKPG\
FP[KI.GNVKMLHMKRGNDBGN\BZXRGFYEG[FPKEK
FRMZKO.DOHMKRGNF\DNG\SVZFHGFZ[FGB\IKN\
YKGOFM\GCGPNBFFBZWETFB\F’.GNBKNPEGTGE
GDG’.MKMGNOKETGBG\KNPYJROGTEDEGNO.
BCNC[\KBNFHMKRGZYCCIKR\R\KRFPFYC"F,
BCNBRGNKEKRGTGENBYKCNRGMNGO,BNB[RK\RFNRG
FHEPRG\CHFNF\IKNCTCGE\F[OK\CZL,NTSGY
C\GZFGCPXGG\N[PF,[BHRHMFNFXNIFDEGNFMMN
FPGCJINEGZG[NP[KI,PF[NBKETGMNFEGZG\
[NVRKRG,GBHRHMFNHPQFYCNF[N[\KBNF:
"[NKPG\FF[DF"G"FDBGNFF[NKPF".
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł�æØ����ł
MPGMQPGJNTNFBGPFFK[ZBNK\TNKEKFTSY
C\GZFGCPXGG\N[PFNFM[KZB\TXPOGB\CRK
FTGNOMGNGTE[K\V\IGNYCNTNKFOB\FTCGEF
253 K[ZBNGFTPKO
FDCGFFFHG[NBFC\FHGN\[FGBFSGNON\MNK\
FCZKBF,[FKBECKYG\GK\CZLMPCGBZ.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���ł��łÆœ
254NZBG\JGC
YCNFTM[KG
PF[RDHZNPTNF[NBK\TSYGCIMP\FBP\CDNGK
FKFNHPQYXGC,TE[\[NKO[R\FZ"Q)1490(.GP[O
GBKNLKYZBEGZBIZGQ,GFG\ZFFDHKZF,GFZ[G\
R\GRFNF\TSYCSVZFHGFZ.GP[R\F"[)1540(
NKXKZFPXGFPQFPGCIZ[K\TSYGCZCKO,DEGNKO
GYJRKO,MPG[PGCBCZTKBPFKPRB.GBIZ[CHMG\
HFT\KENCGBPNLFP[KIGNBCHMG\BIZBKQZBGK
NF\Z[N.
�Æł��Æ��łªºØ����Ø,��ª�œæ ł�ł������’ "�
\IKN\[R\\M"B)1661(=PPRFP\IKNFF\DNG\
P[KIK\CSGEIMPFTNKGRFGKIEBK\FIMPF\I\K\
FCBFCB\TZG\BEN\\BKIETOF\V\IG\IMP\
FPETFCBFCEZLFJCTNVKFPGCBCHGFZFYEG[
VZ[\GKZB)EUYKH("GKC[G\PBF[RKQN[\K\BF
K\V\IGQ\ZTKEIMP\BENTKNBGPCGTKEIMP\B
N\\B".GP[RFHGGBNLP\IKNYGNF\GZCBGZG[N
ZCRGFDZ"B)FDBGQZCKBNKFG(FFGNLGBGZTERMGQ
FKGO.
œ�Øœ�œŒ�’ ł�Ø����ø�ØÆ�ł’����ø��Æ�łÆ��ł"�
\VYKEFP[KIFZB[GQ,P[KICQKGSU,YKCGWDNGKG\
[KCKBNYZGCFDBGNFTNKEKPT[KK[ZBNCT\TZG\B
EN\\BCEZLJCTK\B[ZPTGZZ\NTGP\FFRFDF
BNGYK\RKSG\RS\Z\FPSKKT\NFXNI\MNFVTGNF
B[ZPDP\FFIHZ\F[MKRFNXKGQ\YGVFHGFINF
C[R\\"YNBNUF[K[K)1740(.BIZMLKCGB"BGZ
FKGO"=[FKBFDBGNFTNKEKP[KICGEGE.
œ�Øœ�œŒ�’ ł�Ø����ø�ØÆ�ł’����ø��Æ�łÆ��ł"�
ETMKDHZFIMP\GK\CZL[IKCGZSVZFHGFZNB
K\VZSOGNBK\DNFBNBCEGZG[NZCK[PTGQCZKGIBK
TNKGF[NGOGTNKEG,GRDHZFDHKZFCVPNKB[NPTNF
[NBIZEGZG[NZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKGZCKBNTHZCRG
NBK\TSYGCHB\FIMPFCVZSGOTEFEGZFBIZGQ
EGZG[NP[KICQEGE.GFMKBK\BC\KYGRKQCFZCF
PYGPG\,[BNGFSGEG\NBK\DNGTEEZBEKK\KPNMB
P[KIB,ZGXFNGPZCEGZFBIZGQC[CKNFP\TSYKO
CIKCGZFHGFZK\DNKPNMBP[KIB.
�Æł��Æ��łªºØ����Ø,��ª�œæ ł�ł����
NBR\DNFFHGFZFYEG[NEGZG\FZB[GRKOZY
CEGZG\FDZGTKOPFO,TKKQCSVZGKYFNP[F,
GPSKKO[O[FGBCMEKNFDQTNFEGZG\FBIZGRKO.
GXZKLN[PGTCYGNF’,MKMQZXGRGNJGCNRGNFDQ
TNKRGPXZKRGGNFIK[DBGN\RG[\FKFCPFZFCKPKRG
BPQ.
ł’�ØØ�ªªØæ�����Ø,��ت"�,æ ł œ��Ø�ØØ����ت"�
���æ’æ��ªłØ�ª�"�
K[NIYGZPEGTSVZFHFZFYEG[NBR\DNFCEGZG\
FZB[GRKO,GBKLR\DNFBIZMQCEGZG\FDZGTKOPFO,
256NZBG\JGC
BCNBIZ[TCZBNU[RKOPFIGZCQ[R[NPG[R\E’
BNVKO\\M"I)1068(BHFKFKMGNNCGB,GCTGRG\KRG
FZCKOB[\FK,GHFIJBRGSUNMNNGCVZJTNMN
IJBKOGIKNGN[PGK\CZLG\GZ\GGR\DCZFKXZFZT
PBGEKTQMCZR\CZZFZCF.
GT\FFCZKZFCZDNKO,GMPG[M\GC"CTYCG\
P[KIBIGXVFKSDB"[FGBF\BGF[P\DCZ\
CZBG\FMKMN\FBNKFZTF,GMPG[CKBZCBGZL
ZCKRGFBZ"KH"NGP\DCZ\NFIJKB,BCNM[NMGIF
CTRKKQFZTG\G\GYUFXZG\MKMCZFGCZZFZCF
MBPGZPVKMCGEFBZ"KH"N,GNMQSPGLNEGZG\[BIZ
FBNU[RFPFIGZCQR\DNFBGZFHFZNFDQTNFEGZG\
GBORHMFNTSGYCS\ZK\GZFME\PFNT[G\,CHMG\
HF\VZ[K[TK[GT\K[ZBN.
ł’�ØØ�ªªØæ�����Ø,��ت"�,��łºœ�ª�Ø��’łØ"Ł
PFZ[C"KGBKNLF\IKNNF\RGXW[RKBNVKKPG\
FP[KI,GPFCTN[OJGCGBKNLF\IKNNF\RGXW
F\DNG\FP[KI.
�łÆ�ø�Øøł��Æł��Ø�,ø�łØœØøł��,ø�ł��œ�øłœ,ª�Ø"ÆŁłª’
GHFGEZ[EZ[P[F,FKKRGM[K\DNFMKCMNEGZGEGZ
K[CIKR\P[F,GBK\BEZCK[PTGQCZKGIBKFKF
CIKR\P[F,GKEZG[PF[EZ[MCZP[F,FKKRGZCK
[PTGQCZKGIBK,SVZFHGFZ,BHGFRF[GZU,FKKRG
[K\CJNGMNFYNKVG\GPPKNB\KFKFFDBGNF.
ł’�ø��ØØ�� łØ��æªØ��Æ,ª������� łØ�, ’ø�Ø�Ø
257 YCNFTM[KG
TNKEKTSYK[ZBNCSGEG\F\GZFKCGBP[KIXEYRG
CPFZFCKPKRGBPQ,MPCGBZCHGFZFYEG[.GSKPQ
NECZSG"ECPKNGKSP"LG"GEN"\DKPJZKF"P[KICQ
KGSU"CPMGGQ,[BUP[KICQKGSUKIKFGK\YKKOTN
KEKHMG\NKPGEZHKQEBGZKK\B.
æ ł���œØ��Æ�Æ������ł�Ø��łŒæª
GCRKK[ZBNKGXBKOCKEZPF,G\ZDGPGGCRKK[ZBN
RVYKQCZK[DNK,TNEZLEBK\BCHGFZFYEG[CSVZB
EBKVYGQPQDNG\B,GTKKQ[O[PCGBZTGEKG\Z
M[K\DNFFSVZFHGFZCEBKVYGQPQDNG\B.GHFG
[PZGPHCVSGYGCRKK[ZBNKGXBKO,FKKRGPQFDNG\,
CKEZPF,G\ZDGPGCZK[DNK,CZK"[ZB[K\KCG\"Z’CK
[’PTGQC’QK’GIBK",DNK,M[K\DNFSVZGFYEG[SVZ
FHGFZ,BHCEBKVYGQPQDNG\B,GFCQ.
ł’�ø��ØØ�� łØ��æªØ��Æ,ª������� łØ�, ’Æø��
YGPKBGZKMKCBBGZL,"BGZ"CDKPJZKF"BKQSGU",
"BEGQTGNO"GCDKPJZKF"ZH",[FGBSGEG\F\GZF
B[ZFGBBG"ZNRG.GHFGYGPKBGZ"K,[K\DNFMCGE
PNMG\BEG"QTGN"O,MKCBBGZ"L,MKMCZR\DNFNFO
IMP\SGEG\F\GZF[FGBZ"H,BGZF\GZF,GTNKEK
HF\FKFDBGNFNF\DNG\CSGEPNMG\GMRGET.
��ł�ªº��� Łłœ ’œÆ�
CEGZG\FZB[GRKOFKGKMGNKQNF[KD[NKPG\RV[O,
NF\NFCCHKMGLZCGCYEG[FNFP[KLTNTXPO
RGTOHKGBGZF[MKRFCBGZTNKGQGXICECKYG\GKZBF
258NZBG\JGC
GBFCF,GFMNTNKEKV[JG\F\GZF,\GZF[CTNVF
RDNF.
BCNCEGZFHFTYCG\EP[KIB,[FZTDGCZ
GP\R[BGIGXVFKSDK,PKKDQTNKRGPQFYNKVG\
FZTG\FPI[KMKOFBGZGF[MN.GTNKEKRDN\F\GZF
BKBV[ZCEGZMHFCBKQVRKONFNFKCMNMLRV[
FP[MN\CECKYFGI[KYF,[FZTGFPYJZDKOFZGIRKKO
P\DCZKQ,GNBTGEBNB[FOP\NC[KOCD[PKG\CTZC
ZC[FOFZCKO,GPG[NGDGCZGBVKYGZSG\GPKRG\
G[RB\IKROGN[GQFZT,GMNPK[FGBIXGUCKG\Z
DGCZCKG\Z.
GNGNBP\KYG\TZKCG\RGTOHKGQN[GQFHGFZ
GF\KYGRKOGM\CKPZQ,FPBKZKQNRV[FP[MN\
GPKK[CKQFET\P[PI\NCGPBKZ\TKRKKO,NBFKF
CBV[ZG\NFBKZPZGCFXZG\GINK[G\ET\PZ[TKO
FPKRKOGBVKYGZSKO.
GNMQBIKJTPGGZBGBGZFDRGHGP\KYG\[K[
CHGFZFYEG[FPBKZNRV[,TE[PZGCBGZ\YCNTN
TXPLMNFZTG\GFXZG\GFKSGZKQ,GNBK\IN[ET\L
GNB\KVGNPPEZD\L,G\\TNFNPTNFTEZGOFPTNG\,
IHYIHYIHYGBPW,NB\KZBGNB\VIE.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�œØÆ�œØŒ,�œØÆ�œł�,øÆØ��’�œ�’
NFVRG\B\FNCCG\GNFTSKYB\FPGIG\CPI[CG\
RBXNG\,[PYGZQCZHK\GZF,RT[FCEGZBIZGQFMZI
DPGZNYKOFKFEG\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ł Ø�ØŁ�ł,æ"�
259 YCNFTM[KG
K\IHYRBKEKERV[NFBKZB\BGZIMP\FRS\Z
CTGNO.T\FYZCGFKPKO,[FMNKMKZGGKETG[K[GT\
K[ZBNGK[GT\FTGNOMGNG\NGKFZYCFGVT\IMP\
BGZFDRGH[NVRKPKG\ZHK\GZFC[VFCZGZF.FRS\Z
KTPKETNZDNKGDOB\FRDNF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,"Æ
GMCZEKCZ\KMPFVTPKO,[EGYBHFFEGZFRZBF
MNMLZKYGVGZYTGN,FGBFKG\ZPGM[ZNBGZ\[GC\
BP\.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœ�’,�"ª
SGUMNSGUBUTNVK[BRKPNPENTXPKGNBIZKO,
[\FKFPE\F[NGFGFISEDCZ\F\MGRG\CRV[G\KRG
GCSDRGRKRG,PMNPYGOIPG[KOBRGXZKMKONFKG\
NPNIP\F’CTPNYFVRKPKGFIKXGRK,GFRRGIKKCKO
NFMKQNRGB\FR[YFHPRK=FTJ.BRGXZKMKON\ZDO
TNVKFSDRGQFHPRKB\MNFBGXZFYEG[[NRG,BGXZ
FETG\GFZD[G\[NMNF\GZFMGNFMPTJ,NYZCO
NCRKEGZRG,EGDP\G[NTHZB,[R[\RFFM\CTNKEG,
[BIEFJTPKOFGBDONYZCTNKEKHFB\EGZG
NFCR\F\GZFGNKPGEF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,��łœÆ’,łº"
GHFGCGEBKSKPQNDBGNF[P\IKNNF\RGXWBGZVRK
PNLIKKOTGNOF\KYGQTGNOFVZXGVKQPF[FKF
YGEOCFS\ZVRKO[RBPZGBRMKFS\ZBS\KZVRK
PFOBZBFPFBIZK\O.
260NZBG\JGC
GCTGRG\KRGFZCKOFIJBFKFDZO[NBHKMLG\KYQ
FBZ"KHMZGRGNCZMFB\R[PG\KRGTEFYXFFBIZGQ
NDBGNBG\RGGISEKFGK"FMKNB\PRGMKNBMNGZIPKG
GBKQNRGNBHMG\BIZNF[TQNK\QNRGKEG[ONFDQ
TNKRGHGN\F\TSYG\CIMPFFHB\FMGZ\\GPYXX\
B\PSLFTRQPKFJPBPCEKNPTCGZF\VKNF
NFZBG\VRKPNLIKKONFZBGKKOBNKGNYCN\GZ\KRG
G\VKNG\KRGGNDNG\TNKRGBGZ[CT\FKPKO.
Ø����ø�ª�ª’
DKNGKIMPFHB\T\FCEGZG\DZGTG\FGBMEK[KFKF
NRGPDQT\FNBIGHCNCC[NOCBCKRG[C[PKO,MK
CBG\QFEGZG\FYGEPKOFKGBR[KPT[FGISKEKO,
GFPT[KOJGCKOFKGPXKNKQBG\QPVKFPYJZKDKO.
T\FZIGYKOBRGP[Z[FTNKGQMPGF[PZKO
C\GLFICKG\,PKKDQTNKRGBONBYZKB\KRGCIMPF
FHB\FRVNBFGFTPGYF.GCVZJTNEZL[M\CFZC
H"N[FRS\ZG\RT[GT\FMPGRDNG\,MKCEGZFHF
PG[NFHRG\GPN[KRG\GN[GQFZTG[RBF[CNC,
GR\V[JGFYNKVG\CBGVQ[P\CKK[FBEONRFGDECZK
ISKEG\,GF[OKDQTNKRGGKPIGNNTGRKRG,BPQMQKFK
ZXGQ.
��ł"łØ��Æ��,Ææ���ª�œ��ı�ØØ�
PIP\[F\DCZG\FYNKVG\GFPKRG\GFTHG\GTZC
ZCCEGZFHFTNMQRK\QZ[G\PQF[PKONDNG\BGZ
FIMPFFHB\NY[ZRV[GCIKG\BGZBNYG\NECYF
261 YCNFTM[KG
CGPP[...MKNBR\DNFIMPFHB\CEGZFHFBNB
NYE[GNJFZGNFSKZFPEG\FZTG\.
ł’Ø���Ø�Ø�Ø�ª�Ø�Ø��æ łØ����ł��,�غ��Æłº�ªÆłØ�ª�º"�
GMB[ZR[GCC\[GCFNTSGYPBFCFCIMPFFHB\
KDBNGK[ZBN,CPFZFCKPKRGBPQ.
�łÆ�ØØ�ØŁ��,�Æ��ø�ł���ª�œ
FXZG\T[GB\EGZRGY[FGTH,FGBNBKGMNNFKG\
MVGU,NBK[BTGN[NBKPXBCGBGZIKKO.DOBOKZXF
NBKGMNN[GCPKZBF,BNBPBFCF.
�łÆł�Ø"���,�ªł�Ø�ł��ÆØ���,�Ø"�
FDBGNFFHB\NB\FKFZYTNKEKNKPGEF\GZF.
GTKYZFDBGNF\NKBCNKPGEFYCNF.
����ł’��Ø��Ø���,��ł"�,�Æ�ø������Ø"��’
MNBG\Q[KHMGBNKGKHMGNDBGNFMKFTCGEFFHG
FPGTJ\CHPQFHFFGBI[GCKG\ZPMNBKNKRCKG\
[FKFCHPQ[FKFCK\FPYE[YKKO.
ł’�Æł��ºı����Øæ�,�æª��Æł����Ø�ł�ø�º"ª
TNKEKTSYK[ZBNCSGEG\F\GZFKCBP[KIXEYRG
CPFZFCKPKRGBPQ.
�łÆØ��ÆÆØØ��Øø,���œØ��Æ,�łŒæª
[PIBRK[RCZB\KCEGZMHF,[MCZPG\ZNVZSOB\
IMP\FBP\.
262NZBG\JGC
GBO\[BNGRKPBKQBRKKGET[PG\ZFGB?B[KC
NMO,P[GO[RK\QNKZ[G\NDNG\,MNGPZ,[TET\F
NBRDNGN[GOIMO,BG\OFEZMKO[BV[ZNTSGY
TPFOCVZFSKBCVRKMNTOGTEF,GNFSCKZMNPNF
GPNFTNBGVRF,MKDOBRMKR[CT\KNZCK,[NBNDNG\,
MPGMNF\NPKEKO[YEPGRK.BCN[CGTFHG,GBKSGZ
HF,BKROINKOHGN\TNBG\OFEZMKOFRPSZKOCTN
VF,PEGZEGZ,TEFRCKBKOGPTNF,MKFEZMKOFBNG,
BOFKGP\DNKONFPGQFTO,FKGPCKBKOFVSEZC,
PJTPKOFMPGSKONRG.
BPROBG\GFEZL,B[ZBRKTGSYCSVZKFGBEZL
FPG\Z,GBEZCFRXJGK\KPVKZCKNFZIKCGMPF
[BV[ZNK,GPMGRFBXNKRGEZLF\NC[G\FECZKO.
GTKKQCPBPZKZ[C"K,[NEZLFHFPMRFR\KR\Z[G\.
GHFG[FTRKYNKF’CPEF[NPF,B[ZPYGCN
BXNKRG,[HFBKRG\NGKCDBGRKG\[NFIMOTXPG,BNB
CPXCFEGZ,TNEZL[BPZGH"N"ZBGKFKF[PGBN
FYJQGMG’BNB[BKQEGZGHMBKNML",GTNMQBPZ\K
[MNHMKK\KCEZLDKNGKFIMPF,FGBPSC\FEGZ[NK.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,���łœłœ��Æ����œ�
GMKGQ[MQFZKBRGPIGKCKONYCGTPEZ[G\GNICZ
SVZKO,MEKNPFZ\VGX\FIMPFCPZICKFBGPF,GNB
FKFMQCHPQFYGEOPVRKFKZBFP\TZGC\\NPKEKO
[BKROPFGDRKO,MPG[FBZMRGNTKN,GPPKNBFKFHF
NTKYZFSKCF[NBZKM\FDNG\CTGRG\KRGFZCKOTE
FKGOFHF.
GFKKRG[BPZGIH"NBKQP[KICQEGECBBNB
CEGZ[MGNGHMBK,FKKRG[MGNOKFKGVZG[KOPZEKVF
263 YCNFTM[KG
BIZF\BGFGFMCGE,[BHKFKFBV[ZNYCGTPEZ[G\
CZCKO,NFMKRONCKB\P[KICQEGEMR"N:
BGCEGZ[MGNGIKKCEFKKRGCEGZMHF,[VRKFEGZ
FGBMVRKFMNC,GKZBKIJBKPBSG,GIMP\SGVZKO
\SZICFOGMG’,B[ZBHNBKELDKSB,KFKFBV[Z
NFSKZF[PKZFFK\KZF,GMNFR[BZCCK\KTYCGNCG
EGVYNF[D\FIMPFGF\MNK\,YEG[KBPZNGGKCGB
GKNPGEMKBKQTGEI[EGVIE,VQGBGNKNBK[BZTGPE
TNPEG\KGGKXBGKSIGZBG\FC[GY,MKMCZBVSYGRF
PFFPGQMGNG,GMCZFIMPFPBGSFCTKRKFOCBGVQ
[BKQNF[KD\PGZ\F,NB\BGFGNBMCGE,GNVKMLMN
FZGXFNMRGSKCGBGKMRGS.
GK[GJJGZCKOGK\ZCFFET\CMNBG\OFMEBKO
NF,GCHFRHMFCYZGCNCKB\P[KIXEYKRGGVEG\
RV[KRGCPFZFCKPKRGBPQ.
�łÆØ�ª��ø��,��ª���æ ł �Ø���Øłœ�æÆØłœ,�œ�’
264NZBG\JGC
\VKNFYGEOF\VKNF
KFKZXGQPNVRKLF’BNFKRGGBNFKBCG\KRG,[GPTYGN,
[GT\T\KZG\,GPBHKQNYGN\VKN\TPGK[ZBNCZIPKO,
[\MKQNCRG,G\MGRQPI[CG\RG,G\[DZ\VN\RGCVKRG.
G\Y[KCBHRL,N[PGTCYGN\VKN\TCEKL,FP\IRRKO
BNKLCYGN[GTFGZGIR[CZF.
GB\F,BNZIGO,CZIPKLFZCKOGCISEKLFDEGNKO,
\PIGNG\SNIG\MVZNRGGNMNTPLCK\K[ZBN,B\
MNPF[IJBRGGFTGKRGGFZ[TRGGV[TRGNVRKL.
MKDNGKGKEGTNVRKL,MKNBCPZEGCPTNINKNFGINKNF
PZKRGB\VKLGECZK\GZ\LGPXG\L,MKBOPZGC
FKXZFCGTZCYZCRG\PKE,NBKRGIGNBK[YGJ,TE
B[ZPCKBRGBN\BG\FTGNOF[VNFHFGBNFCNKG,
GPCNCNB\PI[CG\RG\PKE,BVKNGC[TF[BRIRG
TGPEKONF\VNNNVRKLGNCY[TNRV[RG,FGBPCNCN
B\PI[CG\KRG\PKEC\ICGNG\KG.GBKQBRGKMGNKO
NTPGERDEG,MKRIN[[MNRGGPGIRGTEPBE,GM[NMI
FSCNPZCFXZG\GF\NBG\GJZE\FHPQ.
NMQB\F,BNZIGOGIRGQ,T[FTPRGMPG[FCJI\RG
TNKEKRBPQCK\L,GIRG\KB\B[ZBIGQGZIP\KB\
B[ZBZIO.GBPZGIH"N,BUTNVK[BKRGFDGQGBKRG
MEBK,MKMQEZMLNFKJKCNZTKOGNJGCKO.MKDNGKGKEGT
NVRKLBRY\KRGGXTZKRGG[KIRGTNB[ZBKQBRGKMGNKO
NYZCTXPRGNTCGE\LGNECYNKCRGCLCBP\GC\PKO,
BFFTNRV[RG,BGKTNKRGPBGE.
BCKRG[C[PKO,GT\F\TGZZRBZIPKLGISEKL
FDEGNKOGFPZGCKOTNKRG,NDZ[GNCTZB\KXZRG
FZTPYZCKRG,G\DTZCG[KSGZGKNLPBK\RG,GBNKSK\
BG\RGNFEKIRGPTCGE\KLINKNF.GBNKTNFCNKCRG
[GOPI[CFZTF,FQCFYKWGFQCINGOFNKNF,CVZJ
CT\[BRIRGTGPEKOC\VKNFNVRKL,BGC[TF[BRIRG
NGPEKO\GZ\LG[TF[BRIRGTGSYKOCPXGG\KL,\FB
PI[CG\KRGHMF,XNGNFGCZGZFGIHYFCBP\GNCC
[NOMZXGRLFJGCTKPRG.
G\TGZZNCCRGGNCCMNK[ZBNTPLNKIELCBP\
GCBFCFNTCELTCGEFFK[ZF,FPYGCN\NVRKMSB
MCGEL.G\YCTBPGR\LCNKCRG\PKECNKFVSY,G\FB
BPGR\LY[GZFCNKCRGMK\E[NB\PGJ.G\TCKZ
PTNKRGMNFPSMKO,FPCEKNKOCKRKRGNCKRL.
BCKRG[C[PKO,\XKNRGPMNFPM[GNG\GJTG\,BN
\THCRGGBN\J[RGGBN\MNKPRG.G\FBTOVKRGCT\
FJKVRG,GTOKEKRGCT\PTCEKRG,GTONKCRGCT\
PI[CG\KRG.G\HMRG,BCKRG[C[PKO,BNPNBZIPKO,
[RKIEB\NCCRGGPI[CG\KRGGEKCGZKRGGPT[KRGGMN
\RGTG\KRGGFZD[G\KRG,FKEGTG\NRGG[BKRQKEGTG\NRG,
FRDNG\GFRS\ZG\,[KFBFMNCKIGEBNKLCBP\
GC\PKO,CNK[GOPI[C\VKSGNINKNF.
GJFZNKCRGGYE[RG,GHZGYTNKRGPKOJFGZKO,GJFZRG
CBFC\LGCIPN\L,G\JTBFC\LGKZB\LCNKCRG\PKE
CNKFVSYCMNT\GCMNHPQGCMNPYGOCNM\RGC[MCRG
GCYGPRG,\CTZ\PKEZGIYE[LCYZCRG.GR[TRKO\PKE
CLGCDEGN\LGCBFC\LGCKZB\LGC\GZ\L,[CM\C
266NZBG\JGC
[CTNVF,FRDNFGFRS\Z,GCPXGG\KL,NKIE[PLFDKCGZ
GFRGZB.
G\[PZKRGPQFVRKG\GFDKBG\,GPQFMTSGFYVERG\
GFTXCG\GFZMKNG\G[BZPKEG\FZTG\,GPMNECZ
FPVSKETCGE\LFYEG[FGFJFGZFFICKCFTNKRG.
G\[VKTZGIYE[LTNKRG,[RFKFECYKOCLG[R[\GYY
\PKEBNKLKG\ZGKG\Z.GPPEZDFNPEZDF\TNRG,[RHMF
NCGBNPTN\BCG\KRGFYEG[KO,BCZFOKXIYGKTYC.
GHMG\OKTPGENRG,[\[PTCYGN\VKN\RG,[RFKF\PKE
RTRKOCT\[R\VNNBNKLTNKRGBGTN[GOBIEPTPL
K[ZBNTNKIKEBGTNZCKO.
G\[PIG\\VBZCRG,GRT[FVZKNPTNFG[GZ[NPJF,
GBN\HMZNRGIJB\KRGGCVZJIJGB\RTGZKRG,MPBPZ
EGEFPNLT"F,IJGB\RTGZKGV[TKBN\HMGZ.G\FVGL
TGGRG\KRGGV[TKRGNHMG\,G\[VKTTNKRGPTGNOF\[GCF
\PKEFZFGZN[GCBNKLCNC[NO,GN\YQB\B[Z
VDPRGC[PG\KLFYEG[KOGFJFGZKO.
G\XKNRGPYRB\BK[PZTFG,GNBKTNFYRB\BEOTN
NKCRG,GNBYRB\RGTNBIZKO.BEZCF,\QCNKCRG
[RZBFMNBIEPTNG\ICZKRGGNBISZGRO,G[RECZ
MNBIEB\ICKZGCEZLFK[ZGFZXGKNVRKL,GBNKTNF
[GO[RBFPBIETNICZGINKNF.
G\IHYF\Y[ZG\RGCBFCFBNKL,MB[ZDNGKGKEGT
NVRKL,[KFBFMNRI\ZGIBNKL.GHFTYZMGR\KRG.
GBOBKQNRG[MNNMGGQB\NCCRGBNKL,B\F\NPEKRG,
B[ZRETCBP\MGGR\ZXGRLFJGC.
267 \VKNFYGEOF\VKNF
GTNMNHB\P\IRRKOBRIRGNVRKL,BNPNBZIPKO,
[\YCNB\\VKN\RGCZIPKOGCZXGQ,BPQMQKFK
ZXGQ.
łÆØ��Ø��Œ��Ø�’��æ�,œ Ø���ª�œ Ø��
268NZBG\JGC
FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
Z’BCZFOBCGNTVKF)1240{1295(
Z’BCZFOBCGNTVKF,PYGCNRGETPIMPKSVZE.RI[C
CSKXKNKFNRCKB.IKCZT[ZKOG[RKOM\CKYCNF,
GNKPE\NPKEKOZCKO.FKFCQEGZG[NZ’[NPFCQ
BEZ\,FZ[C"B.
Z’BCZFOBKCQTHZB,ZBC"T)...{1164(
Z’BCZFOBKCQTHZB,ZBC"T,PDEGNKIMPKSVZE,IK
MNIKKGCREGEKO.IKCZT[ZG\PBPZKOCRG[BKO
[GRKO:[KZF,EYEGY,VZ[RG\,BSJZGNGDKFGTGE.CKQ
SVZKG:"KSGEPGZB","FPSVZ","FTKCGZ","[VF
CZGZF","FJTPKO","ZB[K\IMPF".
Z’BCZFOCQPZEMKBHGNBK)1570{1644(
Z’BCZFOCQPZEMKBHGNBK,ZCPYGCNPPZGYG,
RGNECVS.P[VI\GDGZ[FPSVZEC[R\.1492TNF
NBZWC[R\1615GRVJZCICZGQ.Z’IKKOEGEKGSU
BHGNBK,FIKE"B,[FKFPXBXBKGM\CTNKGECZK[CI.
Z’BCZFOBHGNBKIKCZPSVZSVZKYCNFGCKRFO:
"BGZFIPF","ISENBCZFO","HFZKIPF"=YKXGZ
VKZG[FHFZ[NZ’BCZFODNBRJK,"CTNKCZK\
BCZFO".
Z’BCZFOKXIYFMFQYGY,
FZBK"FYGY)1865{1935(
Z’BCZFOKXIYFMFQYGYFKFPDEGNKK[ZBNCPBF
F[RKOFBIZGRG\.TCGZZCKOSKPNFEPG\G[NZ’YGY
B\FPTCZPQFDNG\NBZWK[ZBN.FGBTXPGFKF
ZCFFZB[K[NK[KC\CGKSY,C[R\1904TCZ
PK[KC\GGNGH’KQNKZG[NKOG[KP[MZCFB[MRHK
FZB[GQ[NBZWK[ZBN.
FGBF[VKTZCG\TNBGVQFIKRGLFKFGEKCBZW
M[RKSFNBIEB\FHZPKOF[GRKO[PXB,GNIE[
B\FDK[FNIYZGNKPGEFKFEG\.Z’YGY\PLCNKPGE
IMP\FRS\ZGFKFPKEKEKG[NZ’KFGEFB[ND.
TEFKGOP[P[KOM\CKGMTPGEF\GGLNIKRGL
FE\KFNBGPK,P[R\GPVGZJ\CFZICFCSVZKO
ZCKOGCKRFO:"BGZG\FYGE["B’C’D’,"BDZG\"B’
C’D’,"PBPZKFZBK"F","BGZG\","BGZG\F\GZF",
"BGZG\F\[GCF","BEZFKYZGTYCKFXBQ","ZB[
ECZ","TZVKNKJGFZ","DRHKZBK"F","TGN\ZBK"F",
"PKEG\FZBK"F","BGFCK[ZBNCYEG[F","PGSZ
FYGE[",XKJJG\PECZKZ’YGY,PFVRYSKO[CM\CK
FKE,"BGXZG\FZBK"F".
Z’BCZFOMWPYBNKSY)...{1810(
Z’BCZFOMWPYBNKSY,PICZ"ISENBCZFO",
P\NPKEKFDZ"BPGKNRB,FXJZUNIXZG[NFPDKE
PPHZKW.TNFNBZWK[ZBNC[R\\YN"HKIETOZ’
PRIOPREKNPGKJCSY.NBIZVJKZ\G[NZ’PRIO
PREKNTPECZB[FTEFFISKEK\CBZWK[ZBN.
FDBGQZ’BNKFG,FDZ"B,
FDBGQPGKNRF)1720{1797(
FDBGQPGKNRF,FDZ"B,RGNECGKNRFGIKCFTEKGO
VJKZ\G.FGBFKFPDEGNKIMPKF\GZFGCTNKEKTG\
TXGPG\DOCF[MNFFMNNK\GCPETKO.FDBGQPGKNRB
IKCZNPTNFP[CTKOSVZKVZ[RG\NPYZB.VKZG[KG
270NZBG\JGC
NPYZBFXJKKRGCV[JG\OGCFKZG\O.FDZ"BF\VZSO
MDEGNFP\RDEKONISKEG\.FGBCKY[NTNG\NBZW
K[ZBNGBUFINB\FPSTBNKF,BLC[NY[KK
FEZLIHZNGKNRF.YCGX\\NPKEKGK[PFB\FGZB\G
GFYKPFCKZG[NKOGCXV\B\TE\FVZG[KO.
Z’BNKFGCZP[FEKGGKE[
Z’BNKFGCZP[FEKGGKE[,PYGCNPXV\,FKF
P\NPKEKG[NZ’P[FYGZEGCKZG,FZP"Y,G[NFBZ"K
FYEG[.C[R\1575SKKOB\IKCGZSVZGFRGET
"ZB[K\IMPF".SVZYCNFRGSU[IKCZRYZB
"MGGRG\F[O".
Z’BNKFGCQSGNKPQPBRK)1818{1899(
Z’BNKFGCQSGNKPQPBRKRGNECCDEEGTNFNBZW
K[ZBNC[R\.1856C[R\1858F\K[CCICZGQGFYKO
CFK[KCF.C[R\1865R\PRFNZCFTKZ.VZSOPSVZ
SVZKO:"MSBBNKFG","CZM\BNKFG","PTKNBNKFG",
"HMZGRG\BNKFG","YZRG\XEKY","PHMKZ[NGO",
"[KIKXIY".
Z’BNKPNLPNKH’BRSY)1717{1787(
Z’BNKPNLPNKH’BRSYRGNECVGNKQGF\YZCKIETO
BIKG,Z’HGSKF,NIXZG[NFPDKE,Z’EGCCZPPHZKJ[.
[RKFOREEGCZICKVGNKQGVZSPGB\\GZ\FISKEG\
CZCKO.NBIZPG\FPDKEF\K[CZ’BNKPNLCTKZF
NKH’BRSYGIKCFTEKGOPG\G.SVZG"RTOBNKPNL"
FGBPSVZKFKSGE[NFISKEG\,GFGBTGSYCI[KCG\
FY[Z[CKQFXEKYNCKQFISKEKO.CSVZHFRPXB\
271 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
F"\VKNFNVRKF\VKNF"FKEGTFCYFKNG\K[ZBN.CKQ
\NPKEKGFKFDOFIGHFPNGCNKQ.
Z’BNKTHZCZKXIYVVG)1786{1824(
Z’BNKTHZCZKXIYVVG,FKFPIMPKJGZYKFGTCZ
NSNKSJNKF[CZGPRKF.RGETMPYGCN.SVZGFPVGZSO
"VNBKGTW"FEQC\GMI\PGSZF[MNF\YCNGRNPE
CYFKNG\ZCG\.
Z’BNKTHZCZ[OJGCVVG)...{1898(
Z’BNKTHZCZ[OJGCVVG,PIMPKBZWK[ZBN.IKCZ
B\FSVZKO"EP[YBNKTHZ","BVKHGJZK","ISE
GBP\","P[YCK\K","\VKNG\TNIGNKO","SEZN"D
CTGPZ".
Z’BVZKOCQBCZFOBZEGJ
Z’BVZKOCQBCZFOBZEGJ,FKFPYGCNGMKFQMZC
CBKHPKZ[CJGZYKF.
SVZG"PJFBVZKO"[FGEVSC[R\1796EQ
CIKEG[KOTNFZPC"O.
Z’CIKKCQB[Z,BKCQINBGF
Z’CIKKCQB[Z,BKCQINBGF,PYGCNSVZEKP\NPKEKG
FPGCIZKO[NZ’[NPFCQBEZ\,Z[C"B,GPP[KL
EZMG[NZ’B[ZCQKIKBN,ZB"[.IKCZB\FSVZ
"[GNIQ[NBZCT",GVKZG[ZICN\GZFCEZLFYCNF
FYZGK"MEFYPI".
Z’CZGLCQBCZFOPYGSGC)...{1782(
Z’CZGLCQBCZFOPYGSGC,PYGCNPIMPKVGNKQ,
PFEGZFZB[GQ[NFISKEG\,\NPKEO[NZ’PRIO
272NZBG\JGC
PRENPGKJCSYG[NFPDKEPPHZKW.IKCZ[RKSVZK
YCNF:"TPGEFTCGEF",G"KSGEFBPGRF"=EZG[KO
TNF\GZF.
Z’CZGL[NGOB[ND,FZC"[)1907{1991(
Z’CZGL[NGOB[ND,FZC"[,FGBCRGCMGZGGPP[KLEZMG
[NCTNFSGNO.MCZCDKN\[TF\IKNNNPGEBXNBCKG
GFXJZUBNKGCRSKTG\KGNZ’PVGZSGCGNZ’PCTNH.
C[R\1921TNFNBZWKIETOBCKGGCFKG\GCQ
T[ZKOFGSPLNZCRG\TNKEKFCE"X[NFTEFFIZEK\
GTNKEKFZCFZB[K[NKZG[NKOZ’IKKOHGRRVNE,Z’KTYC
P[FIZN"V,GFZB"KFYGY.MLYKCNTNVKEZK[\BCKG,
FSPMFPQFHZOFIZEKGFXKGRKDOKIE.
FZC"[NPEYCNFBXNBCKGCP[L[RKOZCG\,
GFINNNPETNVKCY[\BCKG.NBIZVJKZ\G[NCTN
FSGNOFVLNPRFKDFTEFTNVKCY[\F\NPKEKO.
FZC"[FYEK[B\IKKGNFVX\EZMGFKIGEK\[NCTN
FSGNOGNFZIC\FVKZG[GFFSCZ[N[KJ\G.
NYZB\VJKZ\GR\QFZC"[N\NPKEGGPP[KL
EZMG,Z’PKMBNNKKJPQ,PICZ\CFZ[OB\ECZK
BCKGMVK[[PTBG\O.FM\CKOVGZSPGCSVZC[O
"[PT\K".MPGMQVGZSPGM\CKG[NFZC"[CSVZ
"EZDG\FSGNO",GPM\CKGN\NPKEKGTNEZLFTCGEF
CSVZ"[NCKFSGNO".YCGX\"CRKCZGL",[FGYPFTN
KEKZ’PKMBNNKKJPQ,N[OFP[LFVX\EZMG,YZGKF
TN[PG[NZ’CZGL[NGOB[ND.
Z’IKKOCQKXIYPGGNGH’KQ)1749{1821(
Z’IKKOCQKXIYPGGNGH’KQFKFPDEGNKFPYGCNKO
\NPKEKFDZ"B.KKSEB\K[KC\GGNGH’KQFDEGNF
273 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
CFGZB\FDZ"B.SVZKG:"RV[FIKKO"EQCPGSZ
F[MN,"ZGIIKKO"VKZG[TNVZYKBCG\.
Z’IKKOEGEKGSUBHGNBK,FIKE"B)1724{1806(
Z’IKKOEGEKGSUBHGNBK,FIKE"B,RGNECKZG[NKO
GRVJZCNKGGZRG.FGBFKFVGSYFNMFGPYGCN
FKSJGZKGQGCKCNKGDZU.FIKE"BTZLZGCKPKGPSTG\,
GFKFPZB[GRKFCKCNKGDZVKOFTCZKKO.
FIKE"B[KP[CP[LIP[[RKOMZCCPXZKO,
GCKYZCKQFK\ZCJGZYKF,KGGQ,BKJNKF,XZV\,BRDNKF
GDZPRKF.CMNPYGOCGCKYZIYZGIKV[M\CKKE
T\KYKOPFOFT\KYVZJKOI[GCKO,BG\OZ[OKGPQ
C[O"PTDNJGC".FIKE"BIKCZT[ZG\SVZKO
GCKRFO:"PIHKYCZMF","CZMKKGSU","IKKO[BN",
"PGZFCBXCT","[KGZKCZMF","KGSUBGPW".
Z’IKKOFMFQ
Z’IKKOFMFQ,PIMPKB[MRH,TNFNBZWK[ZBNCHPRG
[NZ’CXNBNB[MRHK,CTN"[KJFPYGCX\".
Z’IKKOGKJBN,PGFZI"G)1543{1620(
Z’IKKOGKJBN,PDEGNKFPYGCNKOCXV\,FKF\NPKEG
FBK[KGPP[KLEZMGFKIKE[NZ’KXIYNGZKB,FBZ"K
FYEG[.
Z’IKKOGKJBNRGNECXV\GRVJZCEP[Y.FKF
\NPKEO[NZ’P[FBN[KLG[NZ’P[FYGZEGCKZG,
FZP"Y.C[R\1570,TOFDT\G[NFBZ"KFYEG[
NXV\FMKZZ’IKKOGKJBNCDENG\GGCKIGE[KJ\G
GFVLN\NPKEGFBK[K.CP[L[RFGIXKZ[OCYVKEF
B\ECZKGPRFDKFBZ"K.
274NZBG\JGC
JZOVJKZ\G,C[R\1572,FGZFFBZ"KFYEG[
NMN\NPKEKG[K[MIGB\PF[NKPEBG\OVZJNZ’
IKKOGKJBN.FGBXKKQCVKZG[[ZYNZ’IKKOGKJBN
PG\ZNFP[KLGNNPEB\[KJ\GFPKGIE\.C[R\
1594TCZNEP[YGIK[OTEKGPGFBIZGQ.M\CKGRDRHG
GRYCZGNKEGTNVKFGZB\G,BGNOFGXBGPQFYCZ
PBGIZKG\ZGVGZSPGTNKEKCRKP[VI\G.
SVZGFPVGZSO"TWIKKO"P\BZB\[KJ\G
[NFBZ"KFYEG[.CKQK\ZM\CKGKXBGNBGZ"[PGRF
[TZKONFBZ"KFYEG[",GCKRFO"[TZFDNDGNKO",
"[TZFMGGRG\","[TZFFYEPG\".CRGSUNFOVGZSPG
M\CKG:"SVZBGXZG\IKKO","BZCTPBG\[YNMSU",
"SVZFIHKGRG\".
Z’IRGLFRKLPBNSY)...{1884(
Z’IRGLFRKLPBNSY,PDEGNKFPYGCNKOCDNKXKF
CEGZFZCKTK[NFISKEG\.FKFZCFYFKNFCBNSY
GCSJKRGCGIKRLBNVKISKEKO.IKCZSKEGZ\VKNF
C[O"NC[PI",GVKZG[N\GZFFRG[BB\BG\G[O
"NC[PI".
Z’KFGEFB[ND,CTNFSGNO)1885{1954(
Z’KFGEFB[ND,PMGRF"CTNFSGNO"TN[OFVKZG[
FREKZGFPYKU[NGNSVZFHGFZFYEG[FYZGK
"VKZG[FSGNO".FGBYZBNVKZG[GC[OHFMKGGQ
[FGBP[P[MSGNOTNKGPJVSKONTNKFFPNBFMN
JGC.CTNFSGNORGNECVGNKQGF\IRLBXNFBEPG"Z
PYNG[KQGBXNFZCKPVGZSGC.FGB[KP[MEKKQZB[K
CGBZB[FGTNFNBZWC[R\.1921[KP[MZCFZB[K
275 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
[NDCT\[BGNGTSYMNKPKGCNKPGE,VKZG[,IKEG[
GFVXF[NIMP\FYCNF.
CTNFSGNOVK\I[KJFIE[FNNKPGEFYCNF
FPBV[Z\NMNPK[PTGRKQNFDKTNF[DFZGIRK\
NF[\P[CF.CRGSUNIKCGZVKZG["FSGNO"NHGFZ,
V\ICTNFSGNOGVKZ[B\M\CKFBZ"KFYEG[
CSVZG"\NPGET[ZFSVKZG\".
C[R\1933FGXKBNBGZB\FSVZ"P\Q\GZF"
CGYKCWPBPZKOCRG[BFYCNF[VZSOCTK\GQ.CTN
FSGNOIKCZSEZF[NFYEPG\FPMKRG\B\F\NPKE
NNKPGERMGQ[NM\CKFYCNFGPCBZG\B\EZL
FNKPGE.CKQSVZKG:"PCGBNSVZFHGFZ","FYEPF
NSVZFHGFZ","FYEPFN\NPGET[ZFSVKZG\",
"VRKOPBKZG\GPSCKZG\","BGZFCFKZ","CK\[TZ
FMGGRG\","VZKIMO=BDZG\YGE[","VZKIMO=
PBPZKO".
Z’KFGEFFISKE)...{1217(
Z’KFGEFFISKE,PDEGNKFPYGCNKOCEGZG[NZ’KXIY
CQBCZFO,FZKXC"B,PCTNKF\GSVG\,FKF\NPKEG
[NZ’KTYCCQBNKTHZ.CKQ\NPKEKGFKEGTKOFKG:
Z’BNKTHZCTNF"ZYI",GZ’KXIY"FBGZHZGT".VZSO
PSVZSVZKOGIKCGZKOGCKRFO:"SGEFKIGE","SVZ
FDKPJZKBG\","SVZFJTPKO",GSVZGFKEGT"SVZ
FISKEKO".
Z’KFGEFFNGK)1075{1141(
Z’KFGEFFNGK,P[GZZGFGDFETG\,RGNECJGNEF
[CSVZEGR[NINBNKSBRFNNPGE\GZFPVKZ’KXIY
BNVSK,FZK"U.C[R\1140KXBNBZWK[ZBNGRVJZ
276NZBG\JGC
CEZMGBNKFC[R\1141CPXZKKO.FGBIKCZB\SVZ
"FMGHZK"FKEGTDOC[O"SVZFFGMIFGFZBKKF
NFDR\FE\FPG[VN\".
Z’KGSUBNKTHZZGHRVNE)...{1915(
Z’KGSUBNKTHZZGHRVNE,PIMPKVGNKQ,PGRFNZC
CVZKK[JJNC[R\.1890IKCZB\FSVZKO"IGG\
KBKZ"G"TJZ\XCK".
Z’KGSUCQBCZFOD’KYJKNF
Z’KGSUCQBCZFOD’KYJKNF,PYGCNDEGNPSVZE
PSGUFPBFF=.13CQEGZG[NZ’[NPFCQBEZ\,
FZ[C"B,G\NPKEG[NZ’BCZFOCQ[NPFBCGNTVKF.
SVZKGFPVGZSPKOFO"[TZKBGZF","DKR\BDGH".
Z’KGSUIKKO,FCQBK[IK)1835{1909(
Z’KGSUIKKO,FCQBK[IK,IKCCDEE,IKCGZKG:"CQBK[
IK","CRKFG","CQKFGKET","ZCVTNKO")[G"\(.
Z’KGSUYBZG)1488{1575(
Z’KGSUCQBVZKOYBZGRGNECSVZE,M[FKFCQ4
TCZFP[VI\GNJGZYKFTYCDKZG[SVZEG[OFGBIK
40[RF.C[R\1536FGBTNFNBZWK[ZBNGIKCXV\,
[ONPEYCNFPVKFBZ"KFYEG[.SVZG"[GNIQ
TZGL"FTGSYCEKRKOGFNMG\,REVSNZB[GRFC[R\
1565GF\YCNCMNYFKNG\FKFGEKOCTGNO.
Z’KGSUYBZGIKCZCRGSUN"[GNIQTZGL"TGE
SVZKO:"CK\KGSU","MSUP[RF","BCY\ZGMN",
"CEYFCK\","BGZXEKYKO","MNNKF\NPGE","KCKQ
[PGTF","PDKEP[ZKO","IKEG[KCK\KGSU".
277 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
Z’KIKBNPKMNPHNGJ[GC)1726{1786(
Z’KIKBNPKMNPHNGJ[GC,PYGCN,PZB[KFISKEG\,
CRG[NZ’KXIYPEZGFGCKW,G\NPKEG[NZ’K[ZBN
CTN[OJGC,FCT["J.NBIZVJKZ\FCT["JNPE
BXNFPDKEPPHZKW.NKPECCZGEK,YBNY,HNGJ[GC
GKBPVGNK.Z’KIKBNPKMNNBIKCZSVZKOBGNO
\NPKEKGPZCKONXJJPECZKGCSVZKFO.
Z’KTYCK[ZBNPYZPRKW,
FPDKEPYZPKRW)...{1800(
Z’KTYCK[ZBNPYZPRKW,FPDKEPYZPKRW,PIMPK
VGNKQ,PICZFSVZKO:"[V\BP\","[CJPK[ZBN",
"BDE\BHGC".
Z’KTYCTPEKQ,KTC"W)1698{1776(
Z’KTYCTPEKQ,KTC"W,CRG[NFIMOXCK,RGNE
CBNJGRF,GF\VZSOCPKGIEMNGIORDEF[C\BG\.
NBIZMFGR\GMZCCTKZTPEKQIHZNBNJGRFGV\ICF
CK\EVGS.SDRGRGFIZKUGFIECBNKEKCKJGKCSVZKG
FZCKO:"PGZGYXKTF"=VKZG[N[GNIQTZGL,"NIO
[PKO"=VKZG[NP[RF,"SGNOCK\BN","PJVI\
SVZKO"=FSCZKOTNFHGFZFYEG[,"BGZIIKKO",
"[BKN\KTC"W"=[G"\.
Z’KTYCXCKKBNK[)...{1825(
Z’KTYCXCKKBNK[,PYGCNDEGN,P\NPKEKFZ’KTYC
KXIY,FIGHFPNGCNKQ.FKFBCCK\EKQCEKRGCGDNGDGC.
PICZFSVZKO:"PNGBFZGTKO","YFNG\KTYC",
"VZ[\EZMKOHGJB","IKRGLCK\KFGEF",GTGESVZK
YCNFZCKO[RG\ZGCM\CFKE.
278NZBG\JGC
Z’KTYCXPI
Z’KTYCXPI,PYGCN,\NPKEG[NZ’[PGBNGKJBN,CRG
[NFZ’IKKOGKJBN.Z’KTYCXPIRGNECNKSCGQGTNF
NKZG[NKOEZLEP[Y.IKCZPSVZSVZKOGCKRFO:
VKZG[PVGZSONM\CKFBZ"KFYEG["YGNCZPF",
YKXGZTNMGGR\FBZ"KC[O"RDKEGPXGF","TGN\
F\PKE"TNMGGR\Z’IKKOGKJBN,"XPIXEKY".
Z’KTYCYBVKN)...{1769(
Z’KTYCYBVKN,PIMPKVGNKQ,PYGCNDEGN,PICZ
SKEGZ"YGNKTYC".
Z’KXIYBKHKYKIKBNSVZKQPYGPZRF)1806{1874(
Z’KXIYBKHKYKIKBNSVZKQPYGPZRF,F\VZSOMCTN
KEKTG\ZCG\C\GZ\FRS\ZGFRDNF.IGRLCIXZG\
FIGHFPNGCNKQ,Z’RV\NKPZGV[KW,GZ’BCZFOPZEMK
PVKRJ[GC.FGBIKCZSVZKOZCKOGCKRFO:"PT[F
BZD"G"TXKTEQ"TNFP[RKG\,"VRKHYQ"TNPSM\
[YNKO,"BGXZFIKKOGFKMNFCZMF","RGXZISE",
"HGFZIK",G"R\KCPXGG\KL".
Z’KXIYCQXCKB[MRHK)...{1806(
Z’KXIYCQXCKB[MRHK,FKFBCCK\EKQCIGEGZGC
CVGNKQ,GPBGIZKG\ZEKKQCNCGC.SVZGFPVGZSO
"JFZ\FYGE["FEQCPSM\HCIKO,FGMKITNTPYG\G
CFNMFGCYCNF.FGBIKCZDOSVZRGSUC[O"BGZ
FRZ"TNBDEG\.
Z’KXIYCZK[TKFTJKF)...{1823(
Z’KXIYCZK[TKFTJKF,PIMPKSGZKF,ZCCIBNC,
PICZFSVZ"EGZ[JGC".
279 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
Z’KXIYNGZKBB[MRHK,
FBZ"KFYEG[)1534{1572(
FBZ"KFYEG[VK\IGDKNF[KJFIE[FNNKPGE
FYCNFFPMGRF"[KJ\FBZ"K".
FGBRGNECKZG[NKOGR\K\OPBCKGCDKNXTKZ.
BPGRSTFTOCRFFXTKZNBIKF,Z’PZEMKVZRSKS,
[IKCPXZKO.FBZ"KFYEG[NPE\GZFGYCNFBXN
Z’EGEBCQHPZB,FZEC"H,GBXNZ’CXNBNB[MRHK.
CP[L[CT[RKOF\CGEEGIYZB\SVZFHGFZ.
C[R\1570TNFFBZ"KNTKZFPYGCNKOXV\.
DEGNKFPYGCNKO,HYRKOGXTKZKO,[FCIKRGCDENG\G
GCKIGEF[N[KJ\GCKY[GNNPGEBXNG,GNINYOFGB
SKZC.CP[L[RFGIXKNKPEB\\NPKEKGB\TKYZK
[KJ\G,BGNOCJZOVJKZ\GFGZFNFO[NBNTSGY
CF.ZYN\NPKEGZ’IKKOGKJBNFZ[FFBZ"KNNPETN
VK[KJ\G,MKGGQ[ZYFGBFCKQBG\FNB[GZF.
FBZ"KFYEG[NKPEB\\NPKEKGCTNVFGNB
FG\KZBIZKGZ[KPG\,BGNOZ’IKKOGKJBN[Z[OB\
ECZKGCYVKEFIKCZTNVKFOB\SVZ"TWFIKKO"
GB\"[PGR\F[TZKONFBZ"KFYEG[".M\CKFKE[N
FZCIKKOGKJBNRDRHGGRYCZGNKEGBGNOCRKP[VI\G
FGXKBGBG\OPBGIZKG\ZGVZSPGB\SVZKG.FBZ"K
FYEG[IKCZPSVZVKGJKOFPXGKKOCSKEGZGCKRFO:
"BHPZC[CIKQ","CRKFKMNB","BSEZNSTGE\B".
Z’K[TKFCQBCZFOFNGKFGZGCKW,
F[N"FFYEG[)1560{1630(
Z’K[TKFCQBCZFOFNGKFGZGCKW,F[N"FFYEG[,
PYGCN,FKF\NPKEG[NZ’KFG[GTVNBYCTN
280NZBG\JGC
"SVZPBKZG\TKRKO".FGBNPECK[KCG\VZBD,
NGCNKQGYZBYB,GFKFZCZB[KCEGCRB,BGSJZKF,
VZRYVGZJ,EPKKQGVZBD.
C[R\1622FINKJF[N"FFYEG[NTNG\NBZW
K[ZBNMEKNYZCB\FDBGNF.FGBF\K[CNHPQYXZ
CXV\,NBIZPMQCKZG[NKO,GRVJZCJCZKF.YCZG
RPXBCJCZKFNKEYCZFZPC"O.F[N"FIKV[GIYZ
CP[L[RKOZCG\B\M\CKFBZ"KFYEG[.SVZKO
[M\C:"[RKNGIG\FCZK\","PXGG\\VKNKQ","[TZ
[PKO","[PG\DKJKQ".
Z’K[ZBNCTN[OJGC,FCTN[OJGC,
FCT["J)1698{1760(
FCTN[OJGC,Z’K[ZBNCQBNKTHZCTN[OJGC,
PKKSE\RGT\FISKEG\,RGNECVGNKQGF\K\OPFGZKG
CDKNXTKZ.CXTKZG\GRFDNF\CGEECFZKOGNNPGE
YCNF.FGBFS\GCCCZICKVGNKQGBSUBNKGKFGEKO
[HKFFBXNO[BKVFPKGIE\NFMZ\\MNK\IKKFO.
NBIZ[NKPEBG\OBKLNFDKTNF[DFZGIRK\FYKO
GFRFKDCTHZ\OB\\RGT\FISKEG\.
FCTN[OJGCCNJCBK[KG\GFPKGIE\GFSGIV\.
FGBTKXCEPG\IE[F[NPRFKDCKFEG\,EPG\G[N
FXEKY,FZCK.FCTN[OJGCDOTKXCEDO[NICGZF
FP\NME\SCKCBK[KG\G[NPRFKDMZKHP\KFPTRKY
FEZMFBK[K\NMNBIEP\NPKEKG.
FISKEG\FEDK[FB\MGGR\FNCGF\NFCG\
KG\ZPQFNPERG\GF[KRGQ.FKB[PFED[TNF[D\G
[NFBEOB\FBNGYG\CTXPGBGCTHZ\FXEKYBNKG
281 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
FGBRXPE.ECZKGXGJJGCSVZKOZCKOGCKRFO"M\Z
[OJGC","PBKZG\TKRKO","XGGB\ZKC"[".
ZCKK[ZBNPBKZFMFQ,
FIVWIKKO)1838{1933(
Z’K[ZBNPBKZFMFQMGRFC[O"FIVWIKKO"P[GO
[[OFSVZFZB[GQ[M\CFKF"FIVWIKKO".FSVZ
VGZSOC[R\1873GTSYCEKRKOFRGDTKONN[GQFZT
GNZMKNG\.FIVWIKKORGNECTKKZFFSPGMFNGKNRF,
CZGSKFFNCRF,GRI[CNBIEPI[GCKFVGSYKOCNKJB
GPDEGNKF\GZFCEGZG\FBIZGRKO.FKFPPKKSEK
BDGE\K[ZBN.
FSVZKO[M\CF[VKTGTPGYG\TNF\V\IG\
FPI[CFFE\K\CK[ZBNCEGZG\FBIZGRKO.SVZKG
FRGSVKOFO:"P[RFCZGZF","CKBGZFNMF","[TZ
XKGQ","BFC\ISE","[PKZ\FN[GQ","JFZ\K[ZBN",
"NKYGJKFNMG\".
Z’NGKKXIYPCZEKJ[GC)1740{1810(
Z’NGKKXIYRGNECTKZGSBYGCCDNKXKF.C[TF[RGNE
Z’NGKKXIYPCZEKJ[GC[PIPBGEFCT["JGBPZ
N\NPKEKG[C[TFHGRGNEFR[PFDCGFFPBGE.BCKG
Z’PBKZFKFPYGCNNKPEB\CRG\NPGEGYCNF.
NBIZ[F\I\QNPEBXNFPDKEPPHZKJ[,GNBIZ
PMQ[KP[MZCCTKZVKRSY.NBGZFIZO[NFDZ"B
TNFISKEG\THCB\VKRSYGTCZNCZEKJ[GC.SVZKG:
"YEG[\NGK","ZPHK[KZF[KZKO".
282NZBG\JGC
Z’PRIOPRENPYGXY)1787{1859(
Z’PRIOPRENPYGXY,RGNECTKZFDGZBK[CVNL
NGCNKQ.DENCCK\P\RDEKOBGNOMCZCDKNXTKZ
RP[LNISKEG\GNPEBXNZ’[PIFCGRKOPV[KSIB,
FZ’KTYCKXIY,FKFGEKFYEG[PV[KSIB,GFIGHF
PNGCNKQ.
FKFIZKUGPYGZKPBGECDK[\GGF\VZSO
CBPKZG\KGFPEGKYG\GFIEG\MSMKQ.P\NPKEKGEZ[
KISBPK\KGZXKRKNTCGEFFZGIRK\,\GLF[YT\PKZC
FPBPXKOCPJZ\IKKFO.CKQ\NPKEKGFKEGTKOFKG
FZ’KXIYPBKZPDGZ,CTN"IKEG[KFZK"O",FZ’IRGL
FRKLPBNMSREZ,FZ’HBCGGNUPSJZKYGC,FZ’KIKBN
PBKZPDGSJRKQ.
\NPKEKGFZCKOFP[KMGB\EZMGFKIGEK\
CISKEGKG\[FYKPGCZICKPHZIBKZGVF.C[R\1840
F\CGEEFZ’PYGXYGSKZCNCGBCPDTBVKNGTO
\NPKEKG.SVZKOZCKORM\CGTNKGGTNIEG\N[GRG
GFCIRG\KG,GCKRKFO:"BKQ[NOPNC[CGZ","SRF
CGTZCYGXY".
Z’PRIORIGOJCZSYKPX’ZRGCKN
)1730{1798(
Z’PRIORIGOJCZSYKPX’ZRGCKNIGRLCK[KC\NKJB
GFG[VTP\GZ\FBZ"K.FKFP\NPKEKFCT["JGNBIZ
VJKZ\GNPEBXNFPDKEPPHZKW.FKFBEPG"ZPQ
FEGZFZB[GQ[NFISKEG\.FYKOGKKSEB\[G[N\
ISKEG\X’ZRGCKN.SVZKG:"PBGZTKRKO"TNF\GZF,
"K[PINC"V[JKOCDPZBTNEZLFSGE.
283 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
Z’P[FCQIKKOBN[KL,
FBN[KLFYEG[)1508{1600(
Z’P[FCZIKKOBN[KL,FBN[KLFYEG[,PYGCN
GVGSYKEGT,RGNECJGZYKF,IKZGCKPKGCXV\GRVJZ
CEP[Y.NPEBXNZ’KGSUYBZGGZ’KGSUJBKJBXY.
FBZ"KFYEG[SKZCNNPEBG\GYCNFM[VRFBNKG
GJTQ[FGBNBCBNTGNOBNBCCIKR\EZG[.
C[R\1587THCB\XV\NEP[YTYCPDKVF,
G[OFEVKSB\SVZG"\GZ\P[F"FKEGTKG\ZC[PG
"FBN[KLFYEG[".SVZKORGSVKO[VZSOFO:"ZC
VRKRKO","ECZKORIGPKO","P[B\P[F","ZGPPG\
BN","ICXN\F[ZGQ","INY\PIGYY".
Z’P[FCQPKPGQ,FZPC"O)1138{1204(
FZPC"OFKFPDEGNKFVGSYKOGPI[GCKFKFEG\CKPK
CKRKKO,PRFKDGZGVB.FGBRGNECYGZEGCF[CSVZE,
GTCZNXVGQBVZKYF.NBIZ[IKCZB\FIGCZ\
"YKEG[F[O"CKQFBRGSKORBNWNCZGIGFDKTNBZW
K[ZBN.TYC\RBKFIKKOFY[KOCBZWF[\YT
CPXZKOG[KP[MZGVBGGKGTXG[NBIEPI[GCK
F[NKJKO.PTPEGBKV[ZNGN[P[MRDKE[NKFGEK
PXZKO.
CKQIKCGZKG:"FNMG\ETG\","FNMG\T"H","PGZF
RCGMKO","VKZG[FP[RKG\","P[RF\GZF","SVZ
FPXGG\","\[GCG\CFNMF","BDZG\FZPC"O","VBZ
FEGZ")[G"\(.
Z’P[FCQRIPQ,FZPC"Q)...{1270(
Z’P[FCQRIPQ,FZPC"Q,PYGCN,VGSYGZGVB,RGNE
CSVZEGTNFNBZWK[ZBN.FKF\NPKEO[NZ’R\Q
284NZBG\JGC
PJZRYJKNK[,Z’KFGEFCZKYZ,Z’THZBPDKZGRBGZ’
THZKBN.CKQ\NPKEKGRPRGZ’[NPFCQBEZ\,Z[C"B,
GZ’BFZGQFNGK,FZB"F.FZPC"QIKCZSVZKFNMF,
VKZG[N\GZFGN\NPGE,GSVZKOZCKORGSVKO.
Z’P[FDZKRGGNEPIGSJ)1853{1911(
Z’P[FDZKRGGNEPIGSJ,PZCRKFFPVGZSPKO[N
FGRDZKF,FKF\NPKEO[NZ’BCZFO[PGBNSGVZCTN
F"M\CSGVZ",G[NZ’PRIOM"WVZGSJKWPXNKO.
C[R\1882FKFNZCCFGPRB,GC=1887CYNKKRGZEKKQ.
C[R\1893R\PRFNZCCIGSJ.FKFVTKNCXKCGZ,
GFYKOK[KCFDEGNF.IKCZPSVZSVZKO:"TZGDG\
FCG[O"TNF[GNIQTZGL,"FNNRZXF"TNFFDEF[N
VSI,"PYGFJFZF","FMRFEZCF".
Z’P[FHMG\B,ZP"H)1625{1698(
Z’P[FHMG\B,ZP"H,PDEGNKFPYGCNKOCBKJNKF,
RGNECBPSJZEOGRGETCMKRGKG"ZB[FP[GZZKO
FPYGCNFBNGYK".NPECVGNKQGCZGSKFG[KP[MZC
CGRXKFGCPRJGCF.KKSEK[KCFDEGNFNPYGCNKO
CGRXKF.INYPFVKGJKOGF[KZKO[IKCZRMRSG
NSKEGZTEG\FPHZI.SVZKG:"YGNFZP"H","[GEB
EEKKRK","BDZ\FZP"H".
Z’P[FIKKOBVZKOPSEKNYGC)1748{1800(
Z’P[FIKKOBVZKO,PICZFSVZ"EDNPIRF
BVZKO",FKFRMEG[NFCTN[OJGCGF\VZSO
MZCKPSEKNYGC.FGBRGNECTKZPKHCGH’GNPEPSCG
FCT["J.NBIZVJKZ\FCT["JNPEBXNFPDKE
PPHZKJ[GZ’KTYCKGSUPVGNRB.NBIZPMQF\K[C
285 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
CSEKNYGC.SVZG"EDNPIRFBVZKO",FGBPSVZK
FKSGE[NFISKEG\GFGBP\BZCEKYRG\B\\GZ\
FCT["J.
Z’P[FIKKONGXBJG,FZPI"N)1707{1747(
Z’P[FIKKONGXBJG,FZPI"N,PYGCNDEGNGKEGT
PBKJNKF.RGNECVBEGCFGCNJCPKGIEMCZCKNEG\G
MCTNHKMZGQREKZGKMGN\NKPGEPTPKYF.
MCZCDKNBZCTT[ZFKETCTNVFB\MNM\CK
FBZ"K.CDKN[CTT[ZFM\CB\SVZGFZB[GQGHMF
NF\RDEG\RPZX\PFZ’P[FIBDKH.C[R\1740
VZSOB\SVZGFKEGT"PSKN\K[ZKO".C[R\1743
TNFNBZWK[ZBNGRVJZCTMGTOMNCRKCK\GTYC
PDVF.IKCZMBZCTKOSVZKOGCKRFO:"MNNKV\IK
IMPFGET\","[TZKZPI"N",G"BEKZCPZGO".
Z’P[FJKKJNCGKOPBGFN,)1759{1841(
Z’P[FJKKJNCGKORGNECDNKXKF,FKF\NPKEO[N
Z’KGSUPYGNCSGCGZ’KFGEFBZKFFNGK.RGETC\IKN\
EZMGMP\RDEGNMQMGRF"CTNZB[FCZHN",BGNO
NBIZVDK[\GTOFIGHFPNGCNKQFVLNBIEPZB[K
FISKEG\.FRFKDB\ISKEG\BGFN[CFGRDZKFGTYC
KMGN\GFPKGIE\NRBGOGNFNFKCB\FYFNP[LBNKG
BNVKBGFEKOMGNNDGKKO.PSVZKG:"F[KCP[F",
"K[PIP[F","\VKNFNP[F"TN\FKNKO.
Z’P[FK[ZBNCZBNKFG)...{1782(
Z’P[FK[ZBNCZBNKFG,FKFZCCZGEGS,IKCZB\
FSVZKO:"[BZK\K[ZBN"G"P[FKECZ".
286NZBG\JGC
Z’P[FYGZEGCKZG,FZP"Y)1522{1570(
Z’P[FIKKOCQKTYCYGZEGCKZG,FZP"Y,PIMPK
BZWK[ZBN.
IKZGCKPKGCXV\GFKFP\NPKEKG[NZ’KGSU
YBZG,G[NFZCFPYGCN[NPFBNYCW,PICZFVKGJ
"NMFEGEK".
MCZCDKNT[ZKOG[[IKCZB\SVZGFZB[GQ
"VZESZKPGRKO"FEQCIMP\FYCNF.TEFDKTG[N
FBZ"KFYEG[NXV\RI[CFZP"YNDEGNFPYGCNKO
CXV\.CKQ\NPKEKGRPRGBNKFGEKGGKEB[,CTN"ZB[K\
IMPF"GFZ’BCZFODNBRJK,CTN"YGNCGMKO".
FZP"YVZSOTGEPSVZSVZKOBGNOFKEGT[CFO
FGB"BGZKYZ"=VKZG[ZICGPTPKYNSVZFHGFZ
FYEG[.INYPQFVKZG[FZICFHFFGXBNBGZ\I\
F[O"[TGZYGPF"=PCGBNVKZG[FBKEZG\[CHGFZ.
PSVZKGFRGSVKO:"BGZRTZC","SVZFDKZG[KQ","SVZ
BKNKPFZC\K","\VNFNP[F","ETB\BNYKBCKL".
Z’P[GNOVKKCG[PHCZKHB)...{1795(
Z’P[GNOVKKCG[,PYGCNPZB[KFISKEG\,\NPKEO
[NZ’KIKBNPKMNPHNGJ[GC,FPDKEPPHZKWGZ’PRIO
PRENPVZPK[NQ,FKFICZGFJGC[NZ’IKKOPX’ZRGCKW
FPXJJBG\GCSVZKG.EZ[G\KGZGMHGCSVZ"NKYGJKO
KYZKO",GZTKGRG\KGTNFISKEG\GEZMFPGSCZKO
C\KPXG\CYGRJZS"EZLBP\".YGRJZSHFRPXB
SVZFYCNFFKEGT[IKCZ"KG[ZECZKBP\".
Z’RIPQPCZSNC)1772{1810(
Z’RIPQPCZSNCFKFRMEG[NFCTN[OJGC.C[R\
1798TNFNBZWK[ZBNBGNOC[NPNIPG\RVGNKBGQ
287 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
IHZNBGYZBKRF,F\K[CCTKZFBGPQ,GNKPEB\
\NPKEKGISKEG\TNKEKBDEG\GSKVGZKO.CKQ
IKCGZKG:"[KIG\FZ"Q","NKYGJKPGFZ"Q",
"NKYGJKTEG\FP[GN[".
Z’VRISBNKFGCQPBKZ)...{1802(
Z’VRISBNKFGCQPBKZ,FKFPYGCN[IKCZCTKNGO
[OB\"SVZFCZK\".
CRGSUIKCZDOB\"PXGG\JGCKO"FEQCJTPK
FPXGG\,"CK\KGXZ"[FGBVKZG[NSVZFKXKZF,
"PJPGRKPS\ZKO"TNXKZGVKBG\KG\,GVKZG[N"P[R\
ISKEKO",SVZG[NFZ’TPRGBNIKZKYK.
Z’XCKBNKPNL[VKZBPEKRGC,
PFZX"B)...{1841(
Z’XCKBNKPNL[VKZBPEKRGC,PFZX"B,PGHMZ
CFTZMFZCFCSVZKFO[NCRKEGZG.FZ’BNKPNL
PNKH’BRSYRKCBTNKGDEGNG\TGECKNEG\G.FKF
\NPKEO[NFIGHFPNGCNKQG[NZ’PRIOPREKN.
SVZKGFZCKOPTKEKOTNTGPYF[D\GCIMP\
FYCNF:"CRKK[[MZ","EZLVYGEKL","BDZBEMNB",
"BDZBEVZYB","ECZKORIPEKO","MNKFZGBKO",
"ZDNK[ZF","PTKQDRKO","GFKFCZMF","CZMF
P[GN[\","ZKIEGEBKO","PDKE\TPGNF","FGSVG\
PFZX"B","NKYGJKPFZX"B","FDFG\PFZX"B".
Z’XCKFKZ[BKKMR[JKKQPHKEKJ[GC)...{1831(
Z’XCKFKZ[BKKMR[JKKQPHKEKJ[GC,CRG[NFZC
KXIYBKKHKYPSVZKQ[CFGRDZKF,FKF\NPKEG[N
FIGHFPNGCNKQ,GRI[CNBIEPKGZ[KG.CKQFK\ZNPE
288NZBG\JGC
DOBXNFPDKEPYGHRKW,Z’BNKPNLPNKH’BRSY,Z’P[F
NKKCPSBSGC,Z’KFG[TF[KNPBVJB,GZ’CZGL
PPHCGH’.FKFPVGZSOC\GZ\FRDNFGFRS\Z.GIKCZ
B\FSVZKO"TJZ\XCK"VKZG[DEGNTNFHGFZ,"SGZ
PZTGT[FJGC","CK\K[ZBN",G"VZKYGE[FNGNKO".
Z’XCKFKZ[CQKTYCFGZGCKW)...{1873(
Z’XCKFKZ[CQKTYCFGZGCKW,PIMPKVGNKQ,\NPKEG
[NFZ’YNGDZPCZGE,PICZFSVZKO:"NKYGJKXCK",
"[BZK\XCK","PYRFGYRKQ","TJZ\XCK","IPE\
XCK","FRFDG\K[ZG\","MZO[NPFGDKEGNKXCK".
Z’[C\KCQKTYCKXIYNKV[KW
Z’[C\KCQKTYCKXIYNKV[KW,PIMPKVGNKQ.
P[R\1865FKFPGZFCKGNRKXB,GP[R\1907ZBC"E
CBGZ[KGGT.PICZFSVZ"SDGN\K[ZBN".
Z’[NGOCQP[FCGHDNG)...{1780(
Z’[NGOCQP[FCGHDNG,PYGCNPVGZSOPPZY[
[CPZGYG,P\NPKEKG[NZ’BCZFOCQPZEMKBHGNBK.
IKCZPSVZSVZKYCNF:"MSBPNL"=VKZG[TN
\KYGRKFHGFZ,"FEZ\PNL"=VKZG[TNFHGFZFPIGNY
N[RKVZYKO="FGEPNL"TNSVZBEXRKTG\B,"PYE[
PNL",G"MSBPNL"TNF\KYGRKO.
Z’[NPFCQBEZ\,Z[C"B)...{1310(
Z’[NPFCQBEZ\,Z[C"B,PDEGNKIMPKSVZE,FKF
\NPKEO[NFZPC"QG[NZ’KGRFDKZGREK.CKQ\NPKEKG
FKEGTKOFKG:Z’CIKK,Z’BCZFOCQBKSPTKN,Z’[O
JGCDBGQ,GZ’KGOJGCCQBCZFOBNB[CKNK,FZKJC"B.
FZ[C"BM\CSVZKOZCKOGCKRFO:"TCGE\FYGE[",
289 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
"[TZFPKO","\GZ\FCK\","VSYKINF","P[PZ\
FCK\".
Z’[PIFCGRKOPV[KSIB)1767{1827(
Z’[PIFCGRKOPV[KSIB,CRG[NZ’KXIYFPDKE,RGNE
CGBEKSNCNPECXTKZG\GBXNZ’PZEMKCRJ.F\GET
NISKEG\GFVLNBIEPZB[KFEGZF[RK[NFISKEG\.
FKF\NPKEO[NFIGHFPNGCNKQ=Z’KTYCKXIY,G[N
FKFGEKFYEG[=Z’KTYCKXIYPV[KSIB.
FGBFP[KLB\EZMG[NFKFGEKFYEG[,FTPKY
GFZIKCB\EZMF[NFISKEG\.\NPKEKGFKEGTKO
FKG:FZ’PRIOPRENPYGXY,Z’KXIYPGGZYB,IKEG[K
FZK"O=FZCKPDGZ,Z’KIHYBNPYGHPKZ,Z’IRGL
FBRKLPBNMSREZ,Z’BCZFOPJ[MRGCGTGE.
ECZKGVGZSPGCSVZK\NPKEKG:"IEGG\[PIF",
"\GZ\[PIF","ZP\KOXGVKO","YGN[PIF".
Z’[PTGQCQNCKB)1488{1588(
Z’[PTGQCQNCKB,PYGCN[RGNECSVZEGDGZ[TO
P[VI\GC[R\.1492REENVGZJGDNGC[R\1497TCZ
NVS[CPZGYG.C[R\1549TCZNJZKVGNKGFKF[OZC
FYFKNF.Z’[PTGQCQNCKBIKCZVKGJKOTNFZ[C"K
G[RKSVZKO:"M\OVH"G"KERBPQ".
Z’[PTGQCZKGIBK,Z[C"K
Z’[PTGQCZKGIBK,Z[C"K,PI[GCKF\NPKEKO[N
Z’TYKCB,PGHMZC["SVTPKOZCG\M"ZCK[PTGQ",
GPVGZSOC\GZ\FRDNFGFRS\Z.
DENCKCRFGFGSPLTNKEKZ’TYKCBGZ’KFGEFCQ
CCBNNPEB\IMP\FYCNFNEGZG\FCBKO.NBIZ
290NZBG\JGC
[RMNBZ’TYKCB,GFN[KRGTNKG[FGBPECZMRDE
F[NJGQ,FS\\ZKIETOZ’BNTHZCRGCPTZFCVYKTKQ
CP[L[NG[T[ZF[RKO.
Z’[PTGQIKCZB\SVZFHGFZFYEG[CFKG\G
CPTZFBGNOFGZFN\NPKEGZ’BCBNM\GCBG\GMKGGQ
[KETMKZYFGBKGMNNFS\KZB\PF[XZKLGNDNG\
B\PF[PG\Z.M[IKCZB\SVZFHGFZFYEG[KET
[FGBRGTETCGZFEGZG\FCBKOGNMQDRHBG\G.
SVZFHGFZRM\CC[VFPKGIE\,[V\FPEZ[
CBZPK\.CHGFZTXPGPSGVZ[FBZPK\FKBFBIGZKO
[NFTCZK\.FHGFZFYEG[RI[CNKSGEIMP\
FYCNF,FGBP\BZ[KJFCZGZFGPDGC[\NF[D\
ZGIRKG\,GRNPETNKEKMNNYFKNG\K[ZBN.VKZG[G
FPTPKY[NZ’KFGEFB[ND,VKZG[FSGNO,PBV[Z
NNPGEBG\GDOC\YGV\RG.
Z’[PTGQCZXPIEGZBQ,Z[C"W)...{1444(
Z’[PTGQCZXPIEGZBQ,Z[C"W,FKFZGVB,VKKJQ
GPYGCN.NPEBXNZ’RKSKOCQZBGCQ,FZ"Q,GBXN
Z’KXIYCZ[[\,FZKC"[.IKCSVZEBGNOCHPQ
FZEKVG\CSVZEC[R\1391TCZNBND’KZ.IKCZ
SVZKOZCKOGF\CNJCPKGIEC[BNG\G\[GCG\
[F\VZSPGC[NG[\MZMKF"\[C"W".CKQSVZKG
FRGSVKO:"PDQBCG\","BGZIKKO","NGK\IQ","KCKQ
[PGTF","HGFZFZYKT".
Z’[RKBGZHNPQPNBEK,
FBEPG"ZFHYQ)1745{1813(
Z’[RKBGZHNPQPNBEK,BEPG"ZFHYQ,KKSEB\
ISKEG\IC"E,NPZG\F\RDEG\G[NFDZ"B.Z’[RKBGZ
291 FZCRKOFPGHMZKOCSVZ
HNPQPNBEKNPEYCNFGISKEG\BXNFPDKE
PPHZKJ[,GFYKOB\[KJ\GCISKEG\RYZB\IC"E
)IMPFCKRFET\(NBIZVJKZ\G[NFPDKE.
CPNIP\ZGSKFXZV\C[R\1812[MRTB\
\NPKEKGN\PGLCZGSKFGRBNWNBIZPMQNCZGI
PRYP\FXZV\KO.FGBIKCZB\FSVZKO:"[GNIQ
TZGLFZC"SVZFNMG\PTGEMQTCGZISKEKIC"E
FP[P[BG\OTEFKGO,"SKEGZ\VKNF","NKYGJK
\GZF",GB\"F\RKB"FP\BZB\KSGEG\[KJ\G.
292NZBG\JGC
IGYZKOGFGDKETG\TNFYCNF
KGFRSZGKMNKQ)1455{1522(
FGPRKSJGVKNGNGD)CN[Q(DZPRK.[KP[MKGTXGFBK[K
[NYKSZDZPRKFGFKFPYGZCNZB[KFBYEPKF
FBVNJGRK\)D’GCRKVKYGENFPKZREGNFGBIZKO(.
ZGKMNKQFKFPDEGNKFPGPIKON[VG\T\KYG\
)NJKRK\,TCZK\GKGGRK\(GIYZB\\ZCG\Q.
PGZK,VK\DGZS,BCKFVKNGSGVKF,MRZBFYKCNB\
\GZ\GPFKFGEKOGNBPFKGGRKO,GFGBFZB[GQ[\KZDO
B\FPKNF"YCNF",[NBFKK\FKEGTFNCRKKPKG,
NPKNFFKGGRK\"VKNGSGVKF".
Ø��æłØº�Ø�,������œ��Æ�ØœReuchlin, De arte cabbalistica
FVKNGSGVKF[NVK\DGZSRCTFPQFKOFBKQ=SGVK[N
FYCNF.Ø��æłØº�Ø�,������œ��Æ�ØœReuchlin, De arte cabbalistica
YCNFBKRFP[BKZFBG\RGNFTCKZB\IKKRGCTVZ,
BNBPTNFB\[MNRGNVSD\FKEKTF.
Ø��æłØº�Ø�,������œ��Æ�ØœReuchlin, De arte cabbalistica
D’GCRKVKYGENFPKZREGNF)1463{1494(
PETQBKJNYKPVGZSOC\YGV\FZRSRS.ETG\KG
FVKNGSGVKG\P[NCG\RBG=BVNJGRKHOG\GZ\FYCNF.
VKYGENFPKZREGNFNPECBGRKCZSKJBG\[NCGNGRKF,
[NVZZFG[NVEGCFG[NJCTCZK\GCTZCK\.CKQF[BZ
IYZB\M\CKFYCNF,F\R"LGFYGZBQ,NBIZ[NPE
BG\OC[VG\FPYGZKG\[CFQRM\CG.
BG\GVKZG[BPK\K[NFIGYB[ZRDNFNP[FCF\DNG\
FBNGYK\,PMGRFC[O"YCNF"(dicta estCabala),P[PT
BXNFKFGEKO"NYCN"(receptio).
�’Æ�Ø Ø�ª���Øł�ª��,�æ��œPico dela Mirandola, Conclusiones
CTXOYKKPKO[RKPETKO:~...|FBIERYZB
YGPCKRJGZKYF(ars combinandi),GFGBFRG[KTGZ
FF\YEPG\CPETKO~...|F[RKPECZTNFMGIG\[N
FECZKOFTNKGRKO~...|G[RKFORYZBKOBXNFKFGEKO
C[O"YCNF".
�’Æ�Ø Ø�ª���Øł�ª��,�æ��œPico dela Mirandola, Conclusiones
VBGNGZKXKGS)~1470{1541(
EGYJGZNZVGBFGVZGVSGZNVKNGSGVKFCBGRKCZSKJ\
VCKF.[KP[MZGVBGGKGTXGFBK[K[NFYKSZ
PYSKPKNKBQFZB[GQGMQMPIRMGFBK[K[NKGZ[
FTXZ,VZEKRREFZB[GQ.
FEZLNF[D\[NMNFSGEG\FBNGYKKOGFBRG[KKO
P\GZ\P[FPMGRFC[O"YCNF".
��łØØæRicius, Introductoria theoremata cabalae
294NZBG\JGC
FVKZG[FPKNGNK,FV[JG\[NF\R"L,[KKLN\RBK
FHPQGFPYGO.FP[PTG\FBNDGZK\GFYCNK\[KKMG\
NRXIKG\,PTNN\RBKFHPQGFPYGO.
��łØØæRicius, Introductoria theoremata cabalae
\BGVZSJGSVZXNSGS)1493{1541(
ZGVBGIGYZJCT[GGKXZK.VZXNSGSFKFPKGHPK
F[KPG[C\ZGVG\FMKPKG\C\IGOFZVGBFGRI[C
NBIEPPKKSEKFPETFPGEZRK.
NPEYCNF(artem cabbalisticam)!FKB\V\ICTCGZL
FMGN!
œ� łæŁæ ł�ææParacelsus, Das Buch Paragranum
YGZJ[VZRDN)1766{1833(
ZGVBGCGJRKYBKDZPRK.FYEK[HPQZCNPIYZ
FFKSJGZKFFZVGBK\GFCGJRKYF,GF\VZSOCKKIGE
CHMG\\ZGP\GNPETFPGEZRKCTKZGZGTKEGEFPIYZ
FPKYZGSYGVK[NZYPG\FXPIKOFPVG\IKO.
BEOFZB[GQFMKZFKJCB\FYCNF.FGBKETB\
IG\PO[NMNFECZKOGNMQR\QNCTNKFIKKOB\
[PG\KFOFP\BKPKO,FPGZKOPTXPOTNJCTO
FBPK\K.
�łŁø ł���Kurt Sprengel, Versuch einer pragmatischen
Geschichte der Arzneikunde
295 IGYZKOGFGDKETG\TNFYCNF
NGNGSZKKPGREGS)1235{1315(
VKNGSGUGSGVZ.RI[CNIGYZFPGCKNC\IGOFYCNF
GFBSNBOC\YGV\G.VSNB\[KJ\FBNMKPKFGTSY
CRK\GI[N\GZ\FNGDKYFGCVK\GIF.PIYZHFFGCKN
BG\GNFPXB\FPMGRFFNGDK\FZB[GRF.
FFGGKFBGF[VF,[\KFQCTNG\BG\GP[YNCIMP\
FYCNF.PBIZ[FFGGKFBGF[VFFQ[GZ[FZDGNXKF
[NFMGN,CZGZMKIMP\F[GNJ\CMNK\ZFPETKO
CPKEFPKGIE\GPMGGR\BG\O.
��æłØØ��ªæRaymundi Lullii Opera
PETKOMPG\BGNGDKF,VKNGSGVKFGP\PJKYFPYCNKO
B\TYZGRG\KFOGB\[GZ[KFOPPRF.NMQPETKO
(scientiae)BNFRIG\KONTGP\IMPF(sapientia)HG,
GNMQTYZGRG\KFOGIGYKFO~[NFPETKO|RIG\KO
PTYZGRG\KFGPIGYKF~[NFYCNF|.GP[GOHB\EZMK
FJKTGQ[NFOISZKOFOCNTEKF.
��æłØØ��ªæRaymundi Lullii Opera
D’GZERGCZGRG)1548{1600(
PETQ,VKNGSGU,VKKJQGBSJZGRGOBKJNYK.RBNW
NCZGIPBKJNKFNXZV\MKGGQ[RZEUTNKEKFMRSKKF
FY\GNK\C[NETG\KG.TOIHZ\GNBKJNKFFGB[O
CMVKZFGFGTNFTNFPGYEC[R\.1600
CZGRGFXKT[GZF[N\BGZKG\C\IGOFYGSPGNGDKF
)\GZ\PCRFFKYGO(B[ZFYEKPGB\HPRQ:\BGZKF
CECZYKGPO[NMGMCKNM\[BG\ONBFMKZG
296NZBG\JGC
BSJZGRGPKOBIZKOCHPRG,\BGZKFCECZ\RGT\F
FSKCGCK\[NF[P[G\BGZKFCECZYKGPO[N
BKQ=SVGZDGVKOCKYGOFEGPKON[P[[NRG.MPGMQ
FVZKLCZGRGB\F\BGZKFF[DGKF[NKPKFCKRKKO
CECZFS\KZF[CKQMEGZFBZWN[PKO.
FYCNFPVZ[\B\FTKYZGQFTNKGQM[OFPVGZ[,
GPPRGFKBPBXKNF,C[NCF[RK,BZCTFTYZGRG\,
GMNBIEPFOC\GZGRINYN[RKO=T[ZGMNBIEPFO
RINYN[CTKOG[RKKOGMQFNBF,TEBKQ=SGUTRVKO.
MVK[YKKPKOCTGNPRGBKQ=SGUPKRKOG\\K=PKRKO,ML
RK\QNMNTXO[PGFPKGIE:NBNGYG\,NPNBMKO,
N[MNFRTNOGNF[DIFF[GNJ\CMNPKQ.
KGXBPMBQMKRK\QNKKIEB\FPTZM\FBNGYK\
MGNFNPYGZBIEGKIKE,MEGDP\FBGZFV[GJFPBKZ
CBGVQBIKENMNNFPZBG\.BNFPVXNG\BG\GN[NN
FXGZG\,GP\GLXGZG\BNFRK\QN[IHZB\FTKYZGQ
FBIEFCSKSK.
�’łª�Æł�Giordano Bruno, Le opere italiane
DGJVZKEGKNFNOVGQNKKCRKW)1646{1716(
VKNGSGU,PETQ,P\PJKYBK,BRXKYNGVEKSJ,EKVNGPJ
GTGZL=EKQDZPRKPVGZSO.NKKCRKWFPXKBB\FPG[D
"VGRYXKF",VK\IB\FI[CGQFBKRVKRKJKSKPNK,GCKKIGE
B\PG[DFBKRJDZN.FGBFPXKBB\[KJ\FSVKZF
FCKRBZK\)BVSGBIE(B[ZTNKFP\CSSMN\IGO
FBNYJZGRKYFGFPI[CKOCKPKRG.
297 IGYZKOGFGDKETG\TNFYCNF
MKGGQ[RTEZPFBRG[G\FPV\IFRMGQBNFSGE,
F\[GYFNKETFRTNOF\CHCHFN[JGKG\GNBPGRG\
JVNG\.MLF\FGG\FSGD[NYCNFTPPK\FZIGYF
CKG\ZPFYCNFFBPK\K\.G\I\[O[YZ=PBDKF
RGXZGEPKGRG\[GRKOFPPNBKOSVZKOZCKO.
�Ł łØªØ���� ��ØØÆ�ØıLeibnitz, Hauptschriften zur Grundlegung der Philosophie
VZKEZKL[NDN)1772{1829(
SGVZDZPRK,PCYZ\ZCG\,VKNGSGUGFGDFETG\.
PPKKSEKPETFSRSYZKJGNGDKF)IYZFSRSYZKJ
FT\KYF(GFCN[RG\FF[GGB\K\.
FKGVKFBPK\KFGBZYFYCNF. łØªłØŒø���Schlegel, 1802
KGFQGGNVDRDD\F)1749{1832(
PPKKXDKF\ZCG\FDEGNKO[NFFKSJGZKFFTGNPK\,
SGVZ,P[GZZ,PIHBK,FGDFETG\,FGPRKSJ,PEKRBK
GPETQ.D\FRI[CNBIEFSGVZKOFEGPKRRJKKOCSVZG\
FDZPRK\CKQFPBG\F=18GF=.19FGB\ZO\DNKG\
ZCG\C\IGPKFCKGNGDKF,FBGVJKYF,FBYGSJKYF,
FDBGNGDKF,FPJBGZGNGDKF,\GZ\FXCTKO,FVSKMGNDKF
GFVKHKGNGDKF[NFZBKKF.
FDK[FFYCNK\N\R"LFKBFVKZG[FKIKEFRPXB
CF\BPFPNBFNTG[ZFBKQ=SGVKFPXGKCSVZ.FQ
CPYGZKG\,CTXPBG\GCTG[ZFJGJBNK[NG.�œ�
Goethe, Materialien zur Geschichte der Farbenlehre
298NZBG\JGC
aR+KCZGL
www.kabbalah.info
"CRKCZGL"FKBYCGX\PYGCNKOFNGPE\GPKK[P\CVGTNB\
EZMO[NFZCKFGEFB[ND,"CTNFSGNO",G[NCRGFZCCZGL
B[ND.CRKCZGLFGYPFC[R\1991TNKEKFZCE"ZPKMBNNKKJPQ
NBIZVJKZ\PGZGFZCCZGLB[ND.CPFNLF[RKOFVMF"CRK
CZGL"N\RGTFCKQ=NBGPK\TRVF,FMGNN\BNVK\NPKEKOCZICK
FTGNO.ICZKF\RGTFTGSYKOCPIYZ,CNKPGEGCFVX\IMP\
FYCNF."CRKCZGL"PVTKNFB\ZKBKRJZRJNYFNFZICC=22
[VG\,GCFOBZMKGQPEKFPYKU.BNFFOPBDZKFPKETFDEGNKO
CZ[\NM\CKYCNF,NSVZKO,NPBPZKO,NSZJKNKPGE,N[KTGZKO
GNFZXBG\.MNFIGPZPGD[NYFNFZICEZLFBKRJZRJGRK\Q
NFGZEFCNB\[NGO.C[RKOFBIZGRG\FYKPF"CRKCZGL"B\
ICZ\FSZJKOARI Films,FPVKYFSZJKO\KTGEKKOGIKRGMKKO,
GMQ\MRKG\NKPGEKG\FP[GEZG\CTZGXKFMCNKOGFJNGGKHKF
CK[ZBNGCTGNO.
PHMKZG\CRKCZGL:
ZI’H’CGJKRSYK112V\I\YGGF,
JN’:9226723=03,VYS:9226741=03