learning outcomes: support for learning?
DESCRIPTION
Presentation at Thompson Rivers University, KamloopsTRANSCRIPT
Thompson Rivers University
Learning Outcomes: designed to support learning?
Alan TaitProfessor of Distance Education and Development
Thompson Rivers University
What is a learning outcome?
The specific intentions of a programme or module, written in specific terms. They describe what a student should know, understand or be able to do at the end of a programme or module.
University of Central England, Staff Development Unit
Thompson Rivers University
Learning outcome levelsMicro
Meso
Macro Programme specification: ‘a precise description of the
intended learning outcomes of a higher education programme, and the means by which the outcomes are achieved and demonstrated.’
QAA 2007 Outcomes from institutional audit, the adoption and use of learning outcomes
Thompson Rivers University
Module level
Identify aims of moduleWrite learning outcomesDesign assessment taskDefine assessment criteriaDevelop learning and teaching strategyReview and improve
Thompson Rivers University
Module outcome format
‘on successful completion of this module students will be able to…’
Thompson Rivers University
At Programme level
Knowledge and understandingIntellectual skills (being able to able to make use of knowledge
and understandingPractical skillsKey/transferable skills (communication; problem solving; self-
evaluation)
Thompson Rivers University
Programme outcome format
‘A successful student from this Programme will be able to..’
Thompson Rivers University
The role of the Quality Assurance Agency
Assuring Quality and standards in UK Higher Education
Through audit
Peer review
Thompson Rivers University
QAA Quality Code for HE
Indicators of sound practice (since about 10 years)
Indicator 2
Learning and teaching activities and associated resources provide every student with an equal and effective opportunity to achieve the intended learning outcomes.
QAA UK Quality code for HE
Thompson Rivers University
QAA link of LO’s to assessment
Once determined, the learning outcomes for the programme of study map directly to the summative assessment, with the assessment methods being appropriate to offer every student an equal opportunity to demonstrate their achievement of the intended learning outcomes irrespective of how and where the student has studied (see Chapter B6: Assessment of students of the Quality Code).17
Thompson Rivers University
Frank Furedi’s critique
Yet learning outcomes are not just another banal instrument deployed to monitor and quantify the achievements of students. The very purpose of this organisational instrument is to accomplish a shift in emphasis from learning to outcomes. This is a technique through which a utilitarian ethos to academic life serves to diminish what would otherwise be an open-ended experience for student and teacher alike.
Times Higher 29 November 2012
Thompson Rivers University
Furedi’s four arguments
1 LO’s Disrupts relationship between teacher and student
2 Diminish or exclude unexpected in learning
3 Diminish judgement and professionalism of teaching
4 Create cynicism
Thompson Rivers University
What about the student?
Assists understanding of what will be learned
And capacity to explain that to employers
Thompson Rivers University
And the teacher?
Assists in making clear what is to be taught
And how learning is to be organised
Thompson Rivers University
And the employer?
Who should have a clearer idea of what the organisation can assume the student knows or can do
Thompson Rivers University
And Quality?
Assists both internal and external quality assurance of organisation of teaching, by making organisation of learning and teaching explicit, and therefore open to review
Thompson Rivers University
Evidence?
Very little on any score!
Thompson Rivers University
Discussion
1 Clarification
2 Present situation at TRU
3 Pro’s and Con’s