lcw public presentation workshop #5

Public Involvement Workshop Public Involvement Workshop April 18April 18thth, 2013, 2013

• Workshop Goal: – Present 3 conceptual restoration designs

• Workshop Objectives: – Update on Conceptual Restoration Plan’s progress– Share 3 conceptual restoration designs– Discuss NEXT STEPS– Perform workshop activity to generate feedback on

restoration design alternatives

• Workshop Ground Rules

Public Involvement Workshop #5Theme: Fire

Mascot: Coulter’s GoldfieldColor: Red

Public Involvement Workshop #5

Workshop Outline1. Conceptual Restoration Plan Progress Update

- Overview of Conceptual Restoration Plan progress & scope2. Summary of Previous Workshops

3. Present 3 conceptual restoration alternatives

- Evolution of each alternative- Analytical process

4. Next Steps

- Alternatives Analysis

Conceptual Restoration Plan Progress Update

Planning Process1. Collect data on existing conditions

2. Compile and analyze opportunities and constraints to restoration

3. Meet with the Public to brainstorm potential restoration alternatives

4. Determine preliminary restoration alternatives

5. Meet with Technical Advisory Committee and Public to identify final alternatives

6. Analyze each of the final restoration alternatives7. Finalize report that presents the restoration alternative

analysis and summarizes the project findings

Land Ownership of Entire LCW Complex

Studebaker LLC

In February of 2006, a joint powers agreement was adopted among the:

Rivers & Mountains Conservancy, State Coastal Conservancy, & Cities of Long Beach & Seal Beach

=

These agencies comprise the project’s Steering Committee

Los Cerritos Wetlands Authority

Project Organization Chart

Consulting Team

Community Stakeholders

Public Involvement

Plan

Technical Advisory Committee

Staff from Applicable Public

Agencies

Steering Committee:RMC, Coastal Conservancy,

Cities of Seal and Long Beach

Los Cerritos Wetlands Authority:Project Manager

Project Scope• Develop conceptual restoration plan for Los Cerritos Wetlands• 2 year long project• Regular meetings with the Technical Advisory Committee• 5 Public involvement workshops through Spring 2013

April 18th, 2013

Aquarium of the Pacific

Goal: Initiate development of Concepts

Goal: Review Conceptual Restoration Alternatives

Goal: Review Final 3 Alternatives

Summary of Public Involvement Workshop #1 Theme: Spirit

Mascot: Wandering Skipper butterflyColor: Yellow

• Workshop Goal was: Introduce the project to the community and receive initial feedback on public interests and concerns

• Workshop Objectives were: – Discuss Los Cerritos Wetlands’ natural history– Introduce the LCWA and consulting team members – Introduced preliminary project goals and objectives– Exhibit a road-map for Public Involvement Plan – Perform activity to collect feedback on community values and vision– Introduce stakeholder email database and project website

• Workshop Activity Results were…

Workshop #1 Activity Results

• 61% had visited LCW through the LCWA’s stewardship program

• 51% enjoy hiking or walking around the wetlands • 52% value the natural and open space of the wetlands• 35% would like to see increased tidal influence to the site• 88% have visited Bolsa Chica Wetlands

• 40/75 attendees completed the workshop questionnaire

• 51% live 1-5 miles away• 38% of participants live less than 1 mile away

VALUE EXERCISE

• Workshop Goal was: Review the Los Cerritos Wetlands baseline data collected

• Workshop Objectives were: – Present findings from Hydrology Report, Watersheds Report, and

Habitat Assessment Report– Discuss the urban setting of Los Cerritos Wetlands and the

Opportunities and Constraints to Restoration and Public Access– Launch LCW Conceptual Restoration Plan Website– Perform activity to collect community feedback on baseline data

• Workshop Feedback Activity results were…

Summary of Public Involvement Workshop #2 Theme: Earth

Mascot: Southern TarplantColor: Green

Intoloscerritoswetlands.orgIntoloscerritoswetlands.org

Workshop #2 Activity Results

General Ranking Raw Numbers Raw numbers/TotalWow! This station’s information is

comprehensive and it is exciting to see this data finally compiled. My comments reflect

what I liked most about this station.70 82%

Interesting! This station’s information is excellent, but there are a couple shortcomings that could be investigated further. My comments express the data gaps that I observed.

13 15%

Unimpressed! The information displayed at this station is not complete and there remain noticeable opportunities for growth. In my comments I have described the areas that could be improved upon.

2 2%

Overall Responses to Feedback Activity for Workshop #2

• Workshop Goal was: Initiate development of Conceptual Restoration Alternative Designs

• Workshop Objectives were: – Update Conceptual Restoration Plan’s progress– Introduce Conceptual Restoration Alternative design

process– Perform workshop activity to initiate discussion of

potential restoration alternatives


Summary of Public Involvement Workshop #3 Theme: Water

Mascot: Pacific Green Sea Turtle Color: Blue

Workshop #3 ActivityNow we want to work on developing preliminary concepts for

restoration alternatives with you

We encourage you to use the maps in front of you and:

1. Use the Green Marker to outline areas you think need Lots of Restoration AttentionLots of Restoration Attention

2. Use the Blue Marker to outline areas you think need Less Restoration AttentionLess Restoration Attention

3.Use the Red Marker to outline areas you think need Little Restoration Attention Little Restoration Attention

Use the pens on the table to explain the “bubbles” you have created and describe

what your vision is.

Workshop #3Activity Results

Incorporation of Workshop #3 Activity Results

WETLANDS!!WETLANDS!!

• Workshop Goal: – Discuss conceptual restoration design alternatives

• Workshop Objectives: – Update on Conceptual Restoration Plan’s progress– Describe initial restoration design alternatives– Perform workshop activity to generate feedback on

restoration design alternatives


Public Involvement Workshop #4 Theme: Air

Mascot: Belding’s Savannah SparrowColor: White

Workshop #4 Feedback ActivityProvide feedback on the 6 conceptual restoration alternatives

that have been developed

We invite you to visit the rendering of each screening alternative that are set up inside the Watershed Classroom

1.1. Sea Level Rise Adaptation Min TouchSea Level Rise Adaptation Min Touch2.2. Sea Level Rise Adaptation Max TouchSea Level Rise Adaptation Max Touch3.3. Habitat Connectivity Min TouchHabitat Connectivity Min Touch4.4. Habitat Connectivity Max TouchHabitat Connectivity Max Touch5.5. Habitat Diversity Min TouchHabitat Diversity Min Touch6.6. Habitat Diversity Max TouchHabitat Diversity Max Touch

Each station offers an interactive way to provide feedback on the alternatives. A member of the consulting team will be at each station

to answer questions and collect feedback.

Watershed Exhibit

Screening AlternativesThings to Keep in mind:

1) There are three themes

2) Each theme has a Minimum vs. Maximum touch3) These are screening alternatives from which 3 preferred alternatives will be created

4) Your feedback on the creative ideas being presented will help drive this process

Sea Level RiseHabitat

ConnectivityHabitat Diversity

MinTouch

MaxTouch

Workshop Activity Feedback Directions



Min

Tou

chM

ax T

ouch

SA1

SA6

SA5

SA4

SA3

SA2

Results from Screening Alternative ExerciseResults from Screening Alternative Exercise

• No/minor changes to existing oil infrastructure

• Utilize/improve existing tidal connections

• Minor grading • Transitional and upland habitat

along perimeters• Potential interpretative sites on OTD

and/or State Lands parcels

*Note: trail locations are in draft form

*

Conceptu

al/Draft

or elevated 2nd Street



Min

Tou

chM

ax T

ouch

SA1

SA6

SA5

SA4

SA3

SA2


• Consolidation of oil infrastructure• New tidal connections to SGR and

Haynes• Steamshovel Slough expansion• Moderate grading • Transitional and upland habitat

along perimeters• Potential interpretative sites on OTD

and/or State Lands parcels

*

Conceptu

al/Draft





Min

Tou

chM

ax T

ouch

SA1

SA6

SA5

SA4

SA3

SA2


• Consolidation of oil infrastructure

• New tidal connections to SGR, Haynes, and Los Cerritos Channel

• Fill and grading of OC Retention Basin

• Significant grading to remove fill material and create contiguous tidal channels

• Maximum salt marsh habitat

• Potential interpretative sites on OTD and/or State Lands parcels

*

Conceptu

al/Draft



Alternative AnalysisEach alternative will be analyzed by the following criteria:• Habitat• Public access• Hydrology• Construction requirements• Maintenance regime• Cost estimates• Consistency with project goals and objectives• Public support

Our team will also describe:• Infrastructure changes• Phasing options• Preliminary engineering designs

Next Steps

• Perform analysis for 3 conceptual restoration design alternatives

• Finalize report that presents the restoration alternative analysis and summarizes the project findings

• Prepare project for Environmental Review

Closing / Leave BehindQuestions?Questions?

Visit: intoloscerritoswetlands.org

or

Contact:[email protected]

lcw public presentation workshop #5

Documents

public interests

workshop questionnaire51

stepsperform workshop

preliminary project

activity results61

state coastal conservancy

cities of seal

initial feedback