journal cajle vol. 3 (2000) e*;+9l6-d rbat li€-#$r;a< do ... · 2. hie l e+;6o ,*tjh i oei,:...

17
E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do >o)lffittWffin +afiH E) 1-.Dt--)Iir+ Rdsum6: Dans la premidre partie, nous proposerons l'explication syst€- matique et globale des quatre formes grammaticales impoftantes du japonais: passif, causatif, intransitif et transitif. En effet, ces quatre formes peuvent €tre expliqu6es syst6matiquement, plutdt que sdpar6ment, en les positionnant c6te d cdte sur une ligne droite. On varra que cette ligne est constitu€e par un proc6ssus de <double-recyclage> des verbes <aru> et <suru>. Dans un deuxidme temps, nous comparerons les deux verbes: <aru> japonais et <do> anglais, lesquels jouent un r6le de premidre impoftance dans chacune des langues en question. Leur difference semble bien explicable sur le plan typologique, consolidant ainsi notre position pr6sent6edans Kanaya (1997,1998b) 1. ttDEt: E.+;g# TXW,AfZaW. Fg;rt. lftinJ. gH. lt.1p.6 rrrrJ' i.L b EF leXi*iF El fin\, . n 6 A rEffi #Ft' o,1,fi . t_t -C WZ#.EA T a .- Le+-#yaH-Ff TfE+T a . Z affitl c. E)tui1$ytFf'# L *aAz*cH,lFH (1)i4 r rl,) Etrf:*-;agteiJ t-f 6, t -F;a) ,\, . a&ffi*Ravffi;hfrtr.yz_-cu\ a r. LF-ffiffi-f 6" ffi < ffi**$-C liI o6JT++l: E) a l:itE L. E +;gl:$j{}6 ZDFYEI&t r1369 A A. &lf, Dld Dffiic4i#tlJ: r,\(*|fl Lt:{gt8,SD Arf,fgr;dDo L0) Lh#o L'ei+HRE! t:Atfi'f a " ffi-ES : EffifRrt.*a E g)Frd. Mtuiil. xH. ffi.Ip. 2. HiEL E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D. **X-e 6 A Q)-j t (D-eLZ n€nftr$ L r r, r 6 2.9, bna. +-#X.aFlX+, fr?r.ffi.<7 )V7 z,\y l-ojltE4i6X. e lr*X. fll{ X, clitrg{"eD6.L&zt<T. (1)-j iF'.EisaH[ElQ Ll:t (1)-e "A bear killed Taro" e)-j rjtB[nrF.E l.iq 3 fLl: : (2)-e "Taro was killed by a bear" Z A $)fit r, ra[] tI E +x L frx a *. q{ a; tR 4 6!/a i€ (z I tI /r i: tr ir Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000)

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do >o)lff ittWffin

+afiHE) 1-.Dt--)I i r+

Rdsum6:Dans la premidre partie, nous proposerons l'explication syst€-matique et globale des quatre formes grammaticales impoftantesdu japonais: passif, causatif, intransitif et transitif. En effet, cesquatre formes peuvent €tre expliqu6es syst6matiquement, plutdtque sdpar6ment, en les positionnant c6te d cdte sur une lignedroite. On varra que cette ligne est constitu€e par un proc6ssus de<double-recyclage> des verbes <aru> et <suru>.

Dans un deuxidme temps, nous comparerons les deux verbes: <aru>japonais et <do> anglais, lesquels jouent un r6le de premidreimpoftance dans chacune des langues en question. Leur differencesemble bien explicable sur le plan typologique, consolidant ainsinotre position pr6sent6e dans Kanaya (1997,1998b)

1. t tDEt:

E.+;g# TXW,AfZaW. Fg;rt. l f t inJ. gH. l t .1p.6 rrrrJ'i.L b EF leXi*iF El fin\, . n 6 A rEffi #Ft' o,1,fi . t_ t -C W Z#.EAT a .- Le+-#yaH-Ff TfE+T a . Z affitl c. E)tui1$ytFf'# L*aAz*cH, lFH (1) i4 r r l , ) Etr f :*- ;agteiJ t - f 6, t -F;a),\, . a&ffi*Ravffi;hfrtr.yz_-cu\ a r. LF-ffiffi-f 6" ffi < ffi**$-Cl i I o6JT++l: E) a l : i tE L. E +;gl :$ j { }6 ZDFYEI&t r1369A A. &lf, D ld Dffiic4i#tlJ: r,\(*|fl Lt:{gt8,S D Arf,fgr;dDo L0)Lh#o L'ei+HRE! t:Atfi'f a "

ffi-ES : EffifRrt.*a E g)Frd. Mtuiil. xH. ffi.Ip.

2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI, :

l t f thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgi lBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*eI*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j t (D-eLZ n€nftr$ L r r, r 6 2.9,bna. +-#X.aFlX+, f r?r . f f i .<7 )V7 z, \y l -o j l tE4i6X. elr*X. f l l { X, cl i trg{"e D6.L&zt<T.

(1)-j iF'.EisaH[ElQ Ll:t(1)-e "A bear killed Taro"

e)-j rjtB[nrF.E l.iq 3 fLl: :(2)-e "Taro was killed by a bear"

Z A $) fit r, ra [] tI E +x L frx a *. q{ a; tR 4 6! /a i€ (z I tI /r i: tr ir

Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000)

Page 2: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

R L-Ct /xL\" ico$L) -: i lO]_ a tf t#ff i t l ,-C^aff i fr 3 ,f i4411o'(LFu\ i \Bt '66.

. #4 F! /e a; t*699r XT 6 D . Z a ffiy1f.Avffi.Frll"& : { * 9nns'f€6na ". EAOH ri44Hf: lFJ D" (t;Snrf-;igah\&t-f&#f\a) 4nR aiEt,r1311a"U.

.

- o-,fi lt El t€;s L b ̂ rriE L{ ur a.

Ltr L. ?i1l iG L ( /eVi, f i& D e)A=2 A**xA* z7 > 7.71\i , le D i€ i . Znl t . E#;* l :* i i t 4*.qf i rZnEWD 8<, & D Eff iE&fr, a -*8T F> A o L. #i* a f i &*. q a H,4 I: FR 6 n A . L rrt E<trElLTU\4"

- iEi t . a+;i+ax.HaYt-e b5-(R)ARERUl.l*, Za{fr,I :z B

t: tsdl Ge+fi i?o+E;-f Etrt:) ' ,{ f f i , @ary*l iHo**A^\6nA) . FtE ( t - 1ts.->f :?arLr\ .B, t , \HEnA) t a S)af f i i t ,h\b 6 a L ir.H.l,\ ltj E tr16 . n-#. Z L].i_II^iiEOHr^i\6: T. Zn,\ r&6ff4n\, \P": a:7> l - 'E-JLAft& i - f :LL4-CIJEn6 ) TbA: Ll*Bf, i . fE'ff iEi 'L'CEI:" ( iT 1)

-: *. D . Lo (2)-j t JrH[i\Fk i3 +q E tt/: ] liH l: ( 1)-j r F'€r\ABf A +qI, f: t a lH,F.t A nf: b O -C lt /* < . F.E n\tBl\ E*. \' f:4* a {fi1: r Zol tn FTtHl l l f f f i r r j : / : t LL) i € ' r^ i r lpb: (L\6 aTb 6. -h . #X.o *.ryX lr. ffiWJX.L lEj D S€ A 4I:& rt.E A Za E o l: L r, ti,lf ffiir$fir,r"

? b ? 6 4;S o g q,X trff r^4fi E r\ L { b tr* r,r " E D Efi 8,(;6 o 7 t >Z;FTE L, *Hffi]XTa a iBEgr;d(:etre)+E*1);;lt lti*I'T?Ho trE 6 r l*/r |, \. 1'€b t'1 6 Fi ;d l: & : { l*{&, t: | ftA t o H4 6 b 6 "6lLr, l . r lYltf t l"f i : l f aoff iXnrHbtl(<l l est mort>Lfs6ir. arra -;g-;*AL-cI+Ena#x<* He is diedltfr 6 i \ t3lFxi*x'eF; a. qEftAv&lf.-:{<He has died>. b <-v\llYrE"=4X1. LT<He is dead>LEble< Tl*1,\f t fxL\"

XEAIY i Xtse, ff i i : fFff i E i1-{ v\ a 4/, aFJ^E'WtJlJ ( i l :2 ), +;Fi. *; t , r 1 lxqqtlf6EFjrxoHh a HiE I '-e b a . t rt \ &v\.: * D . g ryx t: li^fEz i1 t. ff ,s v a frcqrx. (nJ zt t t a Q) -el:It T6(1)-e) i\6 5. * l:. frc9hf-aE F!;*n\g9xrlf*;g Ltt6 ofifit6 ( a aTl*"Taro") ruaHEfuXIJfi!,9i;AXT/x ( {lIl* 6 /rt,r" rt1t:fi Lr. EAF*Tli r66{tw,i.*itJaftrl:ffiT.nlffit .z*.h. El'68 .s6& . E # 13 +tEo H 4/r o Et, 6 . ffightrtr{d gr idXT 6 a ftU *,! li4g-e F;a " Ag);1hegrf-.Lznt3itr$V a**X.aFta#tf t : "

(3)-j iHq+< XHIlis*l:r(3)-e "Jiro came early in the morning"

(4)-j fn+ < XBlli:* 6l1f::

Page 3: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

"o(4)-" "?????"

i I rj} E ?-^\ E /a O li(4)-j t. *i f t a F6 A a xf+ b A b A " -; *. D I i<Hlt t. tr + ( * B t-L{ E : l: I L v \ t w4 # a -uth I: a h e $ t I /: *4, TbD. .O,f i . Hl l$f EE:Trzta(3)* j& D * i1€+&€n\4<. Xt L:C rH A!l:gi\r -eba" *l : . E+i. l f .af l ' f4nlHE/rlt i l l ,EEtl

/ . , t t l f iJ-c. aOryAW tixe*: L l tEv: l : ( t ,r is. E + O,L' lgl, : l*,

+#ab : {4b i ilEifii 6 6 6 ofi.

r, \f n l. L T b . -

t1 B a $lrt\ 6 i E 4;g r) Pr. HXIJfrC4rX & +F.,R lIAb6irH4l t lE Dt t l i t (6E. i - l rL\ol*EE t>h;f i4 i " AH;Ea*. 9 I:WT AE t, t 2 t, E +;*#€ l:,tr E4 E t l:. 6 l, I v\ afi 4 a rt\.

& < +&nr'f f 6X[: t)t i t t f / 'ol€&W7**.1'f : t Lv\t t 4 )aXn\ 6 6. t t'Llf Xi*F! t: lf E L t,r 6 6; 6r. St A irh^\{ l,\ a fd [Jh d)-C r?fl ir C 5 Lt:a t LEt,r l : ( /e 6. L a Z i \ r *.HXltL /s E urttea L. +EH rf l ,d;Ei t ) r >t :HHi 'Lg Lt : : tAna a-eba ". i1, l*x;*o *.qx.a i atr *nill. t E 4;s t: Y ( lf, D l: fisR T b 6 i\,X t Lr li E 6 i. K < /l -: ( t, r 6 . T li C ) El, f: 6 L \ u \ o Fd z-, i i\"

toxl t r ( fJ, l i ) EAtt) i :H*t1*Ll : ) LTaLf:LFfti . rAa" :*D. El+;E-cl I f f i * rLTEaoltJ, t .Et r lxh( i f l , r T6Ai\6T. r .Et t - t tLt eElD Hf iLf i t r \ | , \L\ . E 6t .E^[ l 'tflt ltb i: 0 3 -: fza H/x O Tffi t, \ Z r\ L ) u \. a /"te{,J A+t l a t_.

E +AE a *. HX lrt€;6 o "

*t- & li i: /e 0'14.W e *rc L { u i a . L A + +,t . rEf i4Ett f Vr"

-CIHt.EUvtxt lF 6t .a, t - f > l - ' l t i# i \ t r :

( l /)**d-i\ l L t, \ i F21'e6 6.

3. t* t lHXt L i+D 66ura] oF€ig{. j f }

E Bt: , f f i f r#+.I : r f f iAn\E:{ tura:{ t#, : ae&A-f Aof i t )6.*HaNRt l ,T r ;6#rrgtuTt,r66iq, t :#Lfa

- L birRHlP"

r't )ir.EtwA.,tit +xtta.b 6 /Jt,\i\. +trtt rzo)fia,TfJ,t*Hfu t t,i a ) L t e E a A l-lf v r v r o rr. lF) nltlfr.tuf: Et?ktr,{\b Dt:, r > irb E"b JH & r r, ) 6 f# h )ltffi -e b a . Z . ltft .\ ffi 'ffi [: ++ l:E 3 a *. < B +X'f h T F> 4 ht r' . I i l, t o f: 1 t7 > 7 b &&.fr * 6 )t ) \ r&f f f ikTV\aA-e ba.

aatEAIt | ) t ,21:F_tW/. ' -e b 6: / : r (6a t , t t l lE, f i tA^-Ci) t i i t .EAW/"-c ( i .L/ : l ) L rSD bBvra; t l f .Z l i ' l , r t ' t . a

a. E #A/e 4T /- t tD Dt- : L\{ f i ( < 6 t4r \4;F+{ ;#6"660+4 l: li/e zi, /e ir E fR t: H r * f . Hdft H! t: +B L /J It n tf t ) LJ rr L \,fi l*,t rD r j8r*O*.* t I :&<pj{1, \6. t iSAaxrcLt Ll , ra=-*y)V&nLU-C r * .Ht L feD b 6 r , r ; tHtr j f i -C#.^6 t : . ,PHrARh;t iJ6.

* .HXt: f f iARZi" ' i {Et

i * t lHX: t : f f iL( f t*ELl :E* ( i t

Page 4: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

3 ) t€6F[3 b i , . '6#oft hz t X*fr-d.aff iXrrb 6 o"e ]e. LvtS 6'7:t / 2 l- t ffi l, r /: " Z afi tti^a(s)-e a; ffi /eX t # [l 6 i,Lt: "

(5)-e "l got my purse stolen"(5)-j 'ffifiAl#*il-t:

/ r6 [ I t (s)-el*-F.(S)- jO::r 7 > TAZa*.*f f i : {1, i6 L vt 5 6p4.t9IJA. Li ,L. lO*Xl: t t t iZA&+ff ihf f f f i1:J:urr l f f i#E!/rEi tSl* 0 ba LEbnaofa.

Z a 4 fr li . :. T Bj F, ;d H! i:1F b i'L { L ) a < get> o E 4 H! flEt# "e bb . a +aE a 9. H a E)fi =ra1l**li9r ;€ o ;6 ++ l. - (R)ARU' -; *. D gJ=6il aI bb t i \?FEEt 'L l :b a-ebA. zo I A' 6A ) r \4, ' f tE+;*Tl itBa.6tr4t t t : ryb2r:" .a ib6t l tx?iE9 TXlfra:r) l - '

E*)vawz-c. z. l : f r*q.* t l '< i f r ;4t J -Li \B*(u\64Ll t=i * f b l r t r . ( l ] '4) - f r . 4"=Fo<ge1>aItZ5vt27-p*

;dF!/eHntt*/e ( . {r t' 2ffifi=raa&.f:6 ba tt+4 ' +1.,^.i16I Tba" ZaiE#Lt . :o lED<get>ir . e<EDff iX"f . * .HLl iE,Eft a r ffi.1*. t T 6 Ebt'L 6 a a b 5. * l:

- o{tiF, lrs It D l&9r;4 a <

have>l3b r f f i?f t t L i f tu-e r* .9: f i \bA TLbIEA4EU$A" B+A*O ib6t f: r, lJi l f j tkvtf i \{Fit let,r

- LltEi HT6/rur.

(6)- j f* ;49€ff i : (*Et*L* i I(6)-e "l will get your dinner sent in"(1'f?t)

(7)-e "l had my hair cut"('|F?t)

(8)-e "l had my hat blown off"(**)

- nT 6 i \hf#t:, 4i#o<eet> Elf.o f:*.HXlt*l iF?qn\Xf'

a&ff i . I : / t ' ; {L\6.

8 19.t E z -c * I A\ tt#.4, l:'ftfr 8 t a t i* lI* !t B 4i6 l: b 6 : {t*F,1.re, t&nt:r oH4T i#. t f t , t t jd. t : : LE 5 z-Lr\6 A" .oLE

Ea tft , t t ]s.6: l iSf^X?iED]l t i+.T) iLTllht,r" r*f; ' r \ tErr: t t :$5U)-({ ' Ibff je/r ir: / : l L l .) i Oir*. 9-Ca-6rr. ?ni) 6#L { r fii\ b fL rr+4 I' f: a b lal tr ljl L l, \ i A4fR l. E 6 L lfj*.I: Frf 6

-RT 6 A " ALI 6 t'Ltr t,r:ltffi,A r n#.L I L l r i E* bE l,\ ff E n6 "

t,rjf,t t*nfirfr,/-fat LL) )#*lzlJA.b D l*/e(. t tTOP"lElI?a$*I:/t-f 6 ;6# l: & 6 f4fi,a;E u I -c b a "

Etrl aT(s)-j tWfrAW*W:: L(S)-e' l got my purse stolen"afr+ffi.ALh^\ 6 /e 6 . Ei6 t: *; t, I 1 p1 f f/" liffi , fi -; f:. t E I I l: lz t o)t.tf L r, tk#It7 n LE E *t a I fJ, t: H,f{ir6 6 I L t,, i #ffi irZ o*+i :&I :b: { tzr5 a-cba.

tr$. 7^ ,y 2 az, > A;ErcW.-a i--a\#affi, E :' E&qT A i #*aYVq ) f€xnr& aottJ.{LE f3{6?- a" Ellaitu;{ EIY->-:a{\4

Page 5: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

6B9!i4 <se faire> Hxnr?i.Lfj. /**;. fairel*4i6odoDbt:6&#.fr\tt{&tuif,-e ba.

(9)-f "Jean s'est fait voler de I'argent"(e)-j t)t ) is$#€KHi'Ll: t

F W r, ) O ltE D fXf\ lB *lB.a 7 t > Z af -e II)<W"a 66 r l{tprOH!FOF+l. l€.t>n5Lr,\ iS+-cbA" 7 t >7.-elty+ff io | (Fi lat :d>I:) . Et t6 l a-ebb.

(10)-f "Marie s'est fait faire un costume'(10)- j rYrJ ' - i r ( t rha) l :vTaGBtl : r

. o tt'i+ a f i.fzlEl -f X o f FE A {L llq 4W t, t it, E XfWa f.l*.

qE Bi \ -cba.

4. r*uf *t t- rffi&t Affi-ffitfa:Effiffi

*. * o ffi fi\ B F{q rr fr { E l: o T, E I: r *. * L ltlLtJE.ffi#, a ffi -ffi-e b Ar . L A H< L\ r i " . i 'L i r A+X#,t f$RW]l#.2 5Wa-2a7tr4 > F tB*rn6oll. +4t:L:-cS:i\t,\/J r?$.;rrf. {&9.tr4taKf l l t U OHff i f f i l . *6 Lt , r i t8 le / t ) y l - . i r66i \6Tb 4. - ;*.D. *.4 . t€l*.. Egr;A . ff i ,gr'tqlr,\ iff iDr€greusXi*qErr rff iEfrlts!z7A t L(t +4t:i lq8fi*6fit jH,t9fiff i Ll:r, i.

F;hx a #+# is L a | &frfi*fr. t r. 5,ff L ) /: o E. 4;ss{A aE a {F.t+.,/ *.q&fr,fi\ t9;4rr U +t 4, )V (Hfrtffi) Afif:B)fridt t1F: Tr,ra*.lrLtH-C. r H+;$Tl: Ea ta4 5 : t 4 i-r4l:oit6: ir l iTF> A " e 5 *-e b h ( i€;Erlt+9!;d'eb 6 <be,eet,have,make,iet>.{ ;6T 6lEt* [:49:o=d o<etre,faire,laisser>h EeAgJenJ LU-CtfrI?.,/*.H#fr,I.HfrtJffi L{ L,)A ofirr. .i't}f ir 4 v;E'pZ

^4 >""#' 4 t

t ) 7 i9tt E (fioEF Ek;ST b e < E +tT 6 a . E 4;E o fi fi, A^a yt W.f t.* l- TE (4-&i" (trH't. E#;El*fi+€Yt. NILiE-ctJ6ft.Ytt t* . t )

*.u* *MYt t€lk

E+;g A^\ B i'16 A^i6 A^{Et6

11r28 be eaten eat make eat

IAdE €tre mangd manger faire manger

J-Af<h\4

Page 6: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

69

(a) *{Ai6l: *i f} A 49"={(be,make/€tre,faire)ar)ffiifl""a t) t 4, )V (HfrIJffi)(b) r*UHt t rf f i I*. t i \^i*[: tVff iYt: i lDaff i 'Eff iaba't

o2,f i l f ,q6i\T66. (b) l I t*tt*t t rf f i l*: i t t#iEfl : &D

XEMtsYtff iA L(*j D. €HF!(marked)TD6. LEIA b&l'r"

(b) n\E4;* l : : I , ) {E.e aaE*EBH*fdnr. (a) t : :1, \ {b. Bn-i6o& a v*8 9a | 6 a ' 6t t6 t I*-(R)ARERU Lv\a -2AMff i#t34ntrf i*. ?a6Ytltr-(R)ARUlj ir6' Lt1lf, tHa 'E6t tt t t-b* i r t t6#Ea#tn1 | b A ) i r 6*aL\6. . tW, Mff i#Hl l :bH!*ff iH!t: bH 6i iE.

Iqffil.&?qo rta . ert6 t +>EY,'IJ-(S)ASU ttsD. I{+Affiffib4Fj : ; {o l t f t t l r ls i t l -HtPir6. t46b*l :#9! ;A t f r oEfr j f f iT66. r f l l t4,{ tE4;6/rr ' t - f a l / j . : *D (a) l : :u:rb . B ZS;FT b Z 0918 lis.lLi+ L E D rr o :f b 6 " t:fil' . HfrtJffi affr+r\+{A;g Lffi^\{#nil:#T I F,i-l:( ( I /r: {liL)a. zn}t.h il E # t a i4 l:tr Yt t & b a #ILAA L lX€ rz r . W E e9-c F> 6 B +;S "e

IiFJ! ;q r\;F++ l. 6 lti tu "e - {# t-tt -: { t, ) 6 i\ 6 c 6 a .

E 6 l. H E r, r ol lf, B:J g=ad t I' T | ) +J 4, JI' (Ef! ffi ) e *'t 6 & l' iE lft1/:Fl]="{ir. B+;stt€i EiFT?: < Dra'. Li,firi.

*.tt * fii 6 e l_lf . { ;F o Ei 9l ;4 6tre }*? a *' *'EE & ltr-f greq I b4 t -e bA. QD-faestlf€treo z )"trtF&Yt *l:4;6obeb4( lEt#.I:G#a*h"=4 L/e I ') a 4. Llf,Ei *Tb/*t,r"

(11)-f "Son l ivre EST ici"(11)-e "His book IS here"(1l) j t lEa+t*. .LbA )

l€.17.t:->v\-C b l-'l D L t hrA 16. { ;E t3*ift a tf'lp.o\)9,=4faireli#Fr;f lTt i t-f a) -cba.

\D-t "Marie FAIT ses devoirs"(rD-j tv rJ '-ltffiEau-cv\a )

E {. T lf, j€;6T l*1'Fl6( t T 4 t 0)H s* a ffi t gr a4Donrffi bnf flJaid,9r"=dMAKESIIAVE+GETirffibi'L A aT b 4 5 ht" i.nWW9JinJ tL{ ODOII. | {fr,Atr ffi7l\4f E{+nrE 6 /e t,II sffi ,rb 6 n\ 6 Tb 6 "?o+#+li. #=ff iXlh+aff i-H$t:*;urr ' B+;go | 6a ) LffnRF!I : f f i *A a. & i . L& i "

. .Tlfffi r,\( t Ei th;lA' lfifhililr t.66AiED&, " AffiXTfEFE?'aHff i#Rli r*IJH: t rf f i-1kt AZnAnfrff iL L{' Zaf1t: ' q

t iBr: iE< tEFjf iXt E. l€. I* . ] l f i .< r{dFi ;dxt tEtT4batra

Page 7: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

7o f i . Zaff i#&f . 9lJP t l f . lV-e I)t4 , )Ven-C tr l :Fjr,€ i bb t tr -d- (6) I i rSl tD iAfuid.{ f r ,9t i tJt a*<I . t€. t - ; i .L{ t , r6 i \BT

F>A.

E9l;At: l l t f i )a . {A*6 . rh*a .Tbat /eC, -ARUT#&b:Tr,, i6 bOi\tt , \ .

-nl iq 6h\t.gh;1aEui;g41"ut)afuenJ i b6 t

il\{.}r,rl: boTb a " (nJnltffi+Io I hh\ a : &{rJt. ti'Llx-, fri#a r 6

Ff i0r : ) l -n*)vdf f iz-c Eff t : ) htJ6t tS ( f* i l /e6) t tv\aa,r+E a t&frFfr* .6) Lt , \ iH4O i l?} i lAt Lt t : l :ba-e F;A.($5)

i F-f y;Fi \AirBlrurt Lvt io l i . ryD bh*;Ef i f r i , | t r : t - t{H4obA*S/t l l /r}f i \nA

- Lh<. -El* D Off iHDFra#aifr.trt-

LTff i .16. l t lzr i a L-e bA. r . OHqAflE L{ aZ i / i f i \A :i\<understand> L lt * 6 -C;F€ L l, -C a ft.ffiiri+, a L r\IEfi4 H * 6O T, <understand>zl\{&91;d Ttrf* E H!;F Ery A a fft U-C, hh\ A,tt444a*t*.Lrr6 b oAtr &E EIiHEF (NA)'eA < +ff i f f i ;F (Nr\)-f *bf E fh;iJfl.al|Z 0>aA6EttZt#JcE!;[#eT 6 a . tr9r;nJ r')h..6 :L t a O?f*ltffi EA Itit t,r v\ ) a l&9had | /iU A : l*.H*E! t3#i\ ?{ lzt6" (H 6 )

* l : , .a l , -c4aLqghi i lxa i F^-ry;6i \ah\a: t* .qxo r tH[i\+qei 'La (E;g'elt rf*E6t ) ; l f , .H*F!i:btrrff i f f iF!rrbt '*T* i r :TL)A

- L i \q6i \L/x.6" ' i l / lA_r b r#86, bJt t : tElr

i l " ]0)e6#+ bA ) -cbA L. H4b r f " :0D: > l - ' r :*)VAW^/: f i *si /xo"e66i\6. / :r j . EitrF!t: l f lED:cb. EF,;4r: lxqHa=z-7 >7-hrl^ffit:ffifr( L*: l:Lrzi j:1ftfitrt55"

_fi . ytatT,F?q t{ugraiJt .&<{u{t,\ .5" -

a-f t tg;d tT4.(frYtl* i f t ) E;E#|lfrH4 i1:.Hfr|Jff i (r)r4

' )V) L/:{*r i t

F,-c Lna" tE-t . 15Jf i4i i f . f*f : Eta{&#tiat l tEE 6it l :r ;F#+t ) -Cba. Ll,\ i & D lf , i f : T#(b 6gt;rJl,cl&9t=dAt#.2

A ,b. r\+ v\T b 4 a " ( l: lj L ? o U ltF -e lt /r (, ar a {Ugh-'6nr'crft -cr*b6ler,r. rf f i t ta . qla .-erj.6, rJc)

T l* a n 6 A * & D ( l.') & l, : J( gr*15 t: L r A' & 5 . * < a A 9'ri4.{fifhi4fi\^affi /e Effi *R-t L F> a t e n a .

(R)ARERU+ (R)ARU + SU + (S)ASERU*.* tr*had {&9rifl trtP

b: & b. EYt& li \i fx 6aa:EffifrF,lt |(R)ARU+SU+(S)ASUI [:qIH L ( L * i " * l: A RFS{t i: lt (R)ARU I: 5Efr L { (R)A\u L v t i yoi j6: l :" l :r j L zavtlt : E#, . Ftfr? . *.v q_ ri t t"e #6'1, oH

a a Y,,ffi# tit 1Y,6 fr\ I:f* o l: b O t.

Page 8: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

7l

E 6 i: , f{ l} Inle t-, toEff i*Ra1funnJt{&#t;aa7al. l f , . FfuHE*1l : r66t b - ' f (6) I 6Hl: l r t , : . L\b@ 4zr jv*2 ( f tH)o grF4flf

'\ b A. r- n B afreafiY.F-ffi#.L Ttfi E {E g pr a; l}. .- o,

)V * J tr:$R -: -C ItYt a j,fi' 6 E fi ;4 /a a h\ {fr9)=6A feo i) i^E H * /& L \ :t i?. ;F*?l:-Ui\: < 6orb rff i (6) < I /r 6 E9!;d/jn\ t5tJz trr 6{&,9i=adT6 6 " i6#I:-trRUi\' < b O:5lt tgln5l /r 6 E 9idfa'r\ i Ffl tJ 6 t ts 6 {frftJ;A-e F; 4 " .- a | ftlfii 6 lr E {dn\ Fl€ fr *re u I Is,l€ tt iEfr|J ffi E i'rl: 9r id [3 & a A fu,a< * 2 Eftt:ttV >t:b a 6 l' *L)E.r L t+< i lEEH*, +Errf f i€L&f t , r" Zn\afuirr#t+RT 6 tt6 lx, Effi*RliDJ,Tof*i: {6Et n4.

(R)ARERU+ (R)ARU + A + SL] + (S)ASERUE 9r;E A /{Utuet leeh--6iJ

-off i t- . Hff i*Rt. l*e*$r s ro4fri \ i f '5\. i t ' rY*t (trf f i)

a fu =dn) A H /- + t: E'fF{ l. lf r,A. F"l O : ) l- n * )V a*)fi' h l, I E tR O t4 l' \&trtf f ir Agre1 ibat a4fitJff i tr tT;r<l ' t tEgr;d t*.H et\trX' '+dft ' "JHE) i \6.3. f i{n|]Ll 'r9 5 ' .-E 6lf, r, \ f"1o/\7,6F!HtrF!/eft k t X &t>T MfueA L ffi & n\E]l ;E I T 6 : AFfii) ffi I' tzYtffi#-C tr I'{L)6 4 Li .Aa"

A+iSDWEAEtl ' -CaWff i f - . EfrJf f ia IbA) tT6t IJnaYtTttb tf,sgl,bhleL\ r LtrffiigLl:ii. r r.f,F:"soffi t:;st:i6ir ct 'Eh( :?u\( f f ( l Lba+&l i ,L ' t l ( l , r t4,ELl :" rEZEt tl I *38 tn4 ( l : i \ t r ) TF<.Lt fxot i \6. lof f iT l t*EL<+f i t :*r1Fi . t i \6ai f l€F: j r l :Ez 6i1a b acba.

ffi-*S : tbdr tDoolfFRH!#g

6. i b6: -V#LI ' -Ca E+;E

H--FBT-F.,1:&i l : . A+i#AghAi l tb6: IJ l )+14, )VZnT*<otrgren:ab-le 63', g-| ' i -q tfr l1L{trI68 ' *6t ' A#'a$)*haarctlF z -C v \ a " ffi -#tsT lI. . a fi e* a i€ft E!tr n\' D A W--afr 1' . . Ogheflir B + ;s t: t_ o -c gtf4I:F.ryiJ.1k#JE E : { rz I 6 n) a fFfiff f a . z n tl fFREtl f€;goDoAfdfJt. i lgl(1e77)a'8f-f a tbaFi#l B+;$ff rf6E;gt r€;go t 4 trn)-- (E;SFfttr4ift) Hllfd*A;Sfr I/

^)rT&;[ l'-C 7] 4d) irdE L) T 6 6.

E Bi+*( 1 9 7 1) t3 & n [d7 53+ i\ 6 1 33 1 + * T l: € i: i'L l: 1 4a E +Eft X Y'ff ft t: ltE^\ ftS & T *! 40 n ;g n\& *r i^1. t tu /a l: H l, \ fr E T fftrfLTb-;g t l ' -CWi-tz rRh Dff i l T1t23,880;F6' ; t : t u\ i . E 'C: o23,880;#ir 6 ffi 61FffifitroH t,rt'ff 10;E]'cxa+#.-cba " Ut'v: rttf,lHHtdfi)

f r , )AQ03a.) ' L t Q654) ' LrL(7364) ' -d-(6585) ' { ' \ L(6210) 'leL(5785) . r.Z(4930) . * ibJ-(4567) ' b-4@r0r) ' b0(4091)

Page 9: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

i2

f i tra;Hur, t , \ tr l06++;Fft l t7fsiE D fn;Fl l ' i r D rar\ ( i I 7 ), +-c6+ff iXTi lE LrUt 6 |bA (A) I l l -Kf ,St fAt, rL F'y JaB.t6Erur6"

L i\ L : t'L lsir D T ll/r r, r ot rj" 1 l{f tj{TT t fr ,tro H L \;* t3 ry 6 i\I : tF>6t AAA,r iboir66. {yr l i - t i '16. f fo rrr6 (pt .A) I(2113). 22{i i .a tZD (ft€^) ) QT07). ssirAa if i f , f (f f iE.) I(e34). 68{ta tbDt H (f i . f f i) t @2a)tsCr\F.r i \6. At F-e tr/e( t tsa) l i l l :b6t a i i * : l :bo/ j t , . f f i , ( 2= t zn€rLtd .bDt t t : ( . b0) -cba. .n64agaf inHTat. - t tat66r l l (9034)t \6 5 6lr(14612)Ll lht 'nrD. f f i - lAa i i L: a

*i & ? - ffi ,) fi t /e : r L * i " g L T+-ARU A a /"ri tr #tinJttw.4

< 6af i \B. t [ {4t . tba ) r r ;gf tomn:6 E4i6E]Ei lTq^{L)Air i t4f43t-L& i.

H;Ft l ,<ai4fua4lx '2f . ibA IJX. i t 'y*)V L L(f f iD(€wttv', f f i#-cbba" tEFi;dt o;F++t | *ttH.€6ft . trTFg. tr#,, aUghinJ-eb A a LltRl:" E 9r!"=rlcti#*? ({rI v-tt'rb* 5 . Afi *6 . i\i \a . i *H6j O-ARU) A(6-1)LL, t* tJH.H6t '469. E#, as)qj,il @JX- [i- r€^\ 6nA . ffF i'LA , a frv>Yt A^\ 6 6 . *.*.6 tO-(R)ARU) trc-z)t L{. . i1t:, f f i t t{r), Ft:f f i+#8f 6

- t-cz

aAgfuaff i < ̂ \E4ff i ' l tLtrr\ D Aff i f f iU-Cb't. i . .E.ur: < f j f tTt)(6-3)i\ 6 (6-10)*Tt|J+nr nI6ETb 5" t . t :d^\.6 0tl t*tr b OT.

-trLireTTli i*Lf /rr,r"

6-3 rbbt IJZidX.AGa

4,'f t B +;#o =*+Xa-)-e 6.5 A;-"lxf ir\ . .ntff , a I fa btbZt iw. i - rur6" t r j t l I : ta-Cb4, .+ -cba, =) iTDr

tFnD(*{{z\6i\ a-e F; a. J ntd.Z&errXc6frYt-C '-f iTl i6DFt l" t t iF- ,6t , r ' t -C<Aafa. * l : , 4*?Ft3l*-aE{F.ZoH* a | f iH-+F-eb D H9-- t rC& v\ tXh\4f f iEi ' t - / : " gEH

a.t l ta i*Tbler,r . L i rL tw^l-eba. LW iw*\Lr) i l t f f il :€ l , \T. (?aI : ) bb t L t \ i Oi \EiHlr0lr j i t B, A+;*oZi lxl*EitrE! I.t& | #Ex. I te.a-c b z.

&edX.LL{ l* tzr f i , / i ' t l : r i |1t-Z n-xt t \ , r t \b: l : i \ , .66l f , t t rR, i : . bD: o;**- : l :y t -c. +t ID '66_ n\_t6t : /J:(u)6. A;4Xl:* i ( , ) (A;Etr f f i<f#rrJ;dr\ r t : , i \6 --e

: t :A{f ,Uf.. &lX, taa&.or^T- 'E"t , rg j - ] tAt t J-4t \+i \ f i \MnlJ raAK.a+tr . .3"t , ig9-1 Ld' ; -C l , r l : I t t f r . t - Lrura. E4i* l :* ;t \ { "+{f af t ' f t r of&B/;4, t i , z in)x i :$t , ) -cI t . +*tEEia*Tti:r L tct irEtl f t -clf .bn-c3f:at*ff iETqF^ift | .)5*r- ' t ,

*+Or*Ffrtz.f i ( t trfel8Fnl) f f iFjrb:t: &|E€XO ' (#'r,rl:i$li) ffi F-e b? f:r i\[d DXt: le : T L * a a trtn- a:c"r \ T & a.( i i8)

Page 10: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

€;r lx i : [ t ld: rTf ] i -cbar Li t tur rTL& i l t f iz5 t 13

/r tb6D, ai16n\aT rb6t EiH-e 6aaIJea F:cblet , r .

6-4 ffi*,aWffinfla tf:t

r*l: itl:ir: I:t tffif:': l:t /e E t-ffi*Ytltfr,nA tl:l liruiHBf t: t*{rL4 tft7t / j i r . . t . t*I: ldff i t . tb6l Eff i f i . r ; ir ,W.zl : ! : l l rFt 'BB: l :0 ! t a tD) rr tE4l :6o-C6:f . E6t:Mhlx-ztoYt l t l i {6F:Ab0 ) TbA" .* 'L*/ : t i t '6R: l :LL\r{ t f f i t -* : t , r1 (?-t : ) bZt af+f ixT& 4. #=n4aBeaftAX, nll.rtJ.l have read a book.ltEitrFll:l have a book, read.ti rfi Et x t ( i ffi, /.tal tz r j :ltffi c+af*-: t ) ba L ff FRH!'e 6 6 "

t ; t(6-3) ofF LZitXa I f i : ? a b orr | rc-C b5 I Eitr/rot i i6, Jt t /c)&*Yt l"Lf . l : ' : l : l t : l i i&5; i r -EbEtaf [H,fL(r , )a-&t: /J6" FrJzr, t iF l i t : t : t L l , \ iXtX tNl . (60+Tb0 )Ltr i f#€T. | -nr t \ f f i&.LbAbD rNTbI)+TbD) h\6 tN/ j ' : f : t L*. t>:{E/: bO-ebA "

6-5 MEiaTX

,Rt:4r,1 6#;FXI*Y.6;dXT6 A. Z a TEYT6F-Xi* | 6 6 I i\/*r,,r 11'Ei11r vt. {F\z fJ' -= L t,ra*E-, & tr j {ft5 5 " ana6€yi : -q-6t3l t r -+L< /etzr*cfr L i t l ,< F'0*t tu. o:E0 aaf i \ .t \ r " i r - t :L(6 rF;6t El f .o{L)6. tk&a rbA*t /v: i : l * i64t f i \Za*HF.; t6 i \ . f fAO iTf : bEt i :6 ' r l : f f r t :4*t : i "e6DFf: l j i r6f j "

YtF; : l i :bt f t lof : i :Di6f f i t l t r< . F;O t -c. tHi 'e i l . l &ix H< ( :Hr. , rLr , r j l t f f iT) + (zata) b6) l : r t ) f t11\7t t>,Sj j€Tl \6" I Rf i t4 j i rHi :4af i \ . Hr,rgE, /e C L?TbEbi la bori"

6-0 ttst Y,,Eid

'+f f iXi*TFia L.z;a iYt#tui l , . E+;gXi*Tl t&< t tsY"E;Et L=bnbo+rtr i tr l f t F;4, f i" inF,tsEtrFE l"t lJtaff iatr lJ I n^fl.a E + E tur Tb -; -C I ft5. lJZad)X,OFfi(6-3)Ti8"rl:f*t. rt36 4t rtVR,trTbA. at.L*l: rnia"rc en7Ll,\ i l t f f iT)bA ) afart \E. t r t b Lo#fSl iFAXTD6"

6-7 -L,Tfl X

E4;E0r!€f : &< ax. f i \ i / , ,Tf t -efr(b6. Xf l f t t :A:{ l l toTT . ara. a-e f r ; l , *3- t /*df :b/r6. ( r tJhl tka- ' ;oxf lEt , r l t rfnlfiz; ) fi.r.

(13) fx4.fi\N.t 4,tr^.fft fi L { t ) * !-.

Page 11: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

74,14) 168 rt\7afr,E,rfdfr L f t,I 6 AJ-CT.

(1 3)T liH l: fe+.at-r h e+X L L {iE,\:C t. r 6 l: f E*tr L \ rr. (1,r) Tl*? t1 l: E4 b. r: * y )vg.*i\I[ i] .3 " . a +.- I )v*fr,awfrEa A4 <Wlt14)a i / . , ' t (b61,: l t r fO. l ) i \?OBtOXXU2<68{- iEoAeArcA.K(L* 5Hl:66. IHXH!i : l l (14) l lb l f ,& N-e3-, LA.b B tr r, I " i) < L { ( 1 3) O glr ;""1 x tl. +* y )v ruwE ffi l: (ia) T lia F=4xLtt6.

E ( . . TA ;dxlit' O6-3T-E l:ffi t: r F; A ) I.UW L. t:GEXf fr;6Lt tEl / rg79" Ih-eT) Xl l {FI&D*r t?A$tX. Af" lot :>fr j* )VAff i^-C. b i?.1.8[FIS* LI , -CGE. r ty lL{ t , ra. t?zr-d-a +Wte.afi. rfKlil,rv>A /-"-c'f ) lL tk+a | /"-fT t &ta-e b D *.q., * 'cMt'LH'. zafrdi l f i \GrExt:ba. LirE 6 r:&

< rEA4H*a ta4a " (& e )

6-8 +(+&fr,O tl:6 . /e 6 t

tB|+l+&tr , t :b t f t lg1f is$t f ; f g" r t rBt t r f :6 -Cb6.I X. /'fa 6 *. e tJ. " * 5 lr B €t{r /rt L I r i o li:6 E o & (,r',jlE*4ot

H;gfdrr. t*./"fa6t lX i f f i .a,-Cb 6fft irr; . rf tafrE t l i t*a lb Bl f r i r6-e , &Ika i6Btx-t I : tb6, i \F. .2[L\6. LaY',ht 6fXfi I lJt it#E t:b a-e F> 4 "

6-9 rFE ;f Lt -CA I b4 t

E +iF t: l**{A;F o & i /effi ="4 tf, €ffi ;d. .{.€E;d t b /e r.r 5 e n az]r . b LRb. i l t r iEl , )boAE€f a Li- t l l i ' , n_nl ,Jf f t7&in)t_LAa r f r>4t f i4a. e i*- fb/e(, :b494t LI t#fEya tn(rr) 66t aEIFYtdlF.ot :bOT. H4l l tZLLbAry: -eF;b"r f r , EbDtID. OkaI. tv\a.F;6t atrEtJIJ?t I2 ' l * :ED L

Tlzt /J i t : l : "

(15)-e A man was living in that village.(15)-j 6 anrtr?affi t:{+tu*cr,\f:"

6-10 rbbt frfF.at*ffierr

t* f f iF. i l t .b t66t l iFf f i f ,L{vr6. t / j f tB . f i i \ . Ai le . f i lJC: / rCl f ,Zn€i .L r-ct>5i \6 .Tbai \ . E r .nEb . 'e 6 AOnCbt t r6*( l )6 i \Bf j .

6-11 r,) < , i)o nH&q.

i [F] l : |64 t r rB+;FoEfrEaf.x-c L\ai \ . zaf t ,R af f i .o&I&a t Eb LL(8f f i4f f io&+*fr . rb0h.t t i t L rJ& i ts; , 1a+Lf e.2 " E+ir6a&$la, t7r t \6 r66t l iH{ < 4ara. ea*Tb/e( tFf#i I t r is?-e#(tdD -?)TF>4t tz i r :b6 t

Page 12: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

15. L i \*6Lt\Sff io l l jq. i : f f i# '1?. 6f l f i " I : ( , i \ iL a ) l .Abbol i * jETf:( . o i+ jDTLa) . :* j -?<: o t* :Fi t /*8La< w-fiLl: . Fl l :F€frt&fiaav\h"e ba" &f*o'tr i ;-" lr t#Lo i/ar r . i - taa al f rg L ( / r t , r " :E( : i r Ba+.( le l D*tA{bacF,a" ot l0)

iJ.k i ts6. afr I t t ;d(6-s)T-Et:* f f*e. t /a6l , i ' t AAi l Zof*/*6i i ' r Tb D t t r :F;6t i ' - ] o; f r* ' ; f : * :aTba. H*F!1.bf i&o&<{€aVtJnawa*4, tZi tTlXt r?fLD+l rDt i . {v-EFo Li \ t r { , i ' r tE 6[ j ' t / rc*Ti . 'HLt: i^ i f i "e 6:Lj l l l , rE+H!*q.fj. 4iFolGoa be with ye.ir6*l:Good-by. Z^-f )i9aAdioso4* l:ffi t* A ffi 6 H3-T 6 /a ( . fi> t E -: -C ILiE a Au revoir')Lfr.;Ea E-F,- F'^-{ y;#OAuf Wieder-sehen/-schauenP D4 9t ) 7 i* a Arrideverti. O+* t: Ea a ffiT A O T b le t, I " 5 6 D a ffi fr+AEoffr i :*D@({Hf i : t72=a2Y-- ' )Jtz3) L '7)=a2 ( :f t+) r /c\fr3-e b/rt)of i . ( iT I 1)

J T. .a t , -cH-( < 4 L. El4;gA'R&T 6+AEe--; f iLJ#]?l6/* r; Xb!' l : : F; 6 : zci*,sl^rg fa6 a . ' fui. \977)t i E+;gA iha; i ;5, t ts" : / : t \ . i t t6. Ej{6n\ : Iabat , \6 afr \+. i*-e baa-Lt+; i4 L. La - tWLItu-C{Jl '4\#i9t l : r f t>bEi#t tEot:tr\& D iEqrd.

7. 4;#l*44F! le iTbt EiE

E+;Si : f 66. r \ , #;evt IJZa*H. b6l) t f ,* t ry.L-C)<i f r fa' f aaLL xi t f f iT i - f A*\of f r t : , 4;Ft :6*t : rH9":1f .0

' a l 'B#A-F-ta9r;dr\6 a. n-nmE4;#o I b 6, t3f f iD69;4BETlt / r<, DO?*D tTA) -eba"

J:n]al*.tL#.q,t: f€i '6 E4;gth#otT. E+;gTlx f 61. \. t 'L;ST ttFAIREis&b it{ v\ 6 a E F,t:. L r 6 i\ft ;i#T ltr .

- T E ft F

ffi e i'L ( & l, \ Do is4, i',1/S t \. z o lE H ll. Do i\€F "c /r u r al T it/e (-C. L' l ' 4F*:tH)gt;A LUTlfr,a+#4 fr.f#Het#rir L *: ( l , \{ i f€?E * f + n\ Fl 6 /a t, \ l o n\*i'€ -e 6 6 h\ b -e b A " i- aHa+gr=FtlDo a 4+i,ftElE D4 > l: 3 *- n 'y /\i+ffiht-;l tv< >a#ffi.a F^ 4 v;6 L#^r6L 3 r, l:FF# t ts5. E 4;Fo r F;6 t W=,h t-E t)ffit:ffi+geTil^\-c 4 t i " le*;, . . TliBEg;d. rLA.BE#r1;i$)yla-"wgh=6f, a 4' &qvD L|JE.

EZs;*o'66r L#,t-CttJ+T 6qEotr l l+at) ,Tr i r \ . (7-1)r \BQ-4)I.+VJ A 4,f i t*f#xE!_F_r&i ' B4i4F!/r boT6 A. t i : i }-Fl Ll: l, r.

7-1 h€nlJ(

]i -/ 'y;ilTt* +.i{i t,fltt)aii-,Ei alEi:f 6 /jftTb€r"la1s€i 6 i'r6 r\,

Page 13: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

16 4;6ot[:t*Doi\F.6.

(16)-e Essen Sie rohen Fisch ?(16)-e DO you eat raw fish?

7-2 6Et

F* -f y ;F T li gi ;n l: 6 € ;d a nicht t l:I Lj a fd ll fi n\. i€i$ linot d; 4-"el tE6f. XL{bDoAff io:-* .6. ( iT 1 2)

(17)-e Er kannte nicht ihren Namen.(17)-e He DID not know her name.

7-3 lfi,a-fktu{4o{t*

E 6 l: (A a=d T lf ft A i1l: F; t: 6) {t9li€ bro-verb) t L { ODo" r..^4'y LII?_ nIzY lz 6 b a; lf, /e < . H l. lFl D 9l ;4 A ff* D )Ef fi ti /j"

(18)-e (Wer sah Peter?) * Maria sah ihm.(18)-e (Who saw Peter?) + Mary DID.

7-4 9ftffiX

F1&t.9AeEXi\b6" F4 y;E-e ll t#y t:: tEi & i /rEr.J"=d(naturlich, sicher, sewiss etdtffi:; {*;'F tgliilLl1JE'f 6ir. 6a t,rttEEaXa**9:"=4ti: t freff i4 > l-. j?r*!a2t:E( Lir/el,). +;g-e l f

- r. T t Doiif€tr i'r a .

(19)-e Nattirlich glaube ich das.(19)-e' Ich GI"AUBE das.(19)-e I DO believe it.

. n 6 A {nJh\ B i€46 t. *i r} a fuen)Do aK6E€& }t * E t3 ffi <,\ E b 0)L btalf'/e 6 /r t,I t L fr4f43 i1& i " E E(I991)/r ClX L oDoO Affi xH oi6ffi Ji D A 6 : { | n ffiUgr;f,W{fr,aAi* V F,y f: D ttvt. 4LL\ b aabb t L 6 rr€;glt- i '16 o).f i 'e *I:_ttt*tta;#-e 66" i^LT. f f iA;Fd)+T{t*ffre. H#AlhEigTlf,/xr,\ t L bi6^rrura" t 4 :f E jr* (ffsH4Fft) ah9la+p7a-etrFa130[t6&,5iE;s a ft Pi& ="t' L t: LT A r. O EH t. l* gfi r, r fi f$,f4 1t 5 6 .

i lUtot€;Ft t f6EiFt B4;gA rrab;- i9t de+iai-wtFl i fb6 I t Do L t, ) i - 9l tul a bb#-fi\ 6 b {tr tfi * A b a -c b 6 " l: /j n u* id d)f f i l : t /xal t l f tb6t aT|tuf : t r t -e b6.Lh\Bf l ,^ry-c b, +14l i t t LZ r b6Ei6t Lvt5SrtU t L l :1,r"

r t'r * T o 4 B me6 o ft K h +fi ew * z-c . a i+x.ly,Al by J n,- faFjf,44 r. L bEIFEri4 i . Li i L?i-LtI .atf iap+atE < ff i i .6 +)ar6a" ( i I13)

Page 14: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

tr ti€i6 L El 6;F liil, 14 h a 6 a it HR E! tb#n\ Si *+ f t, I I t IJ'! ts< L b E X- 4 fa 4 a " L ir L . trL li 6 < * T b ̂ n H* F! /a LLW.t I' kr* E-e F;A. f l+'RAMnld"iE: /: i$l,r l i [St[J{b*& i L. tn{tr€;Et.7=: XAH!ra*4, i t* / j l : I l : {L)5Ob+*f i ( i } . 1 4) . +f f i#,+#l l E +;6l l f rn\ B a*a&iH< BE{ u\ a al . f f L{ . # i4Df il*{&oFPE(;Stff^r{E naiHt: r bbaa1.t i t6 tf6E;61 ^.LA#,E6t l t :a/ jLt , r iEF+H!A*EUt:- L i r66" ( i t 1 5) LirL*tF* F! /e thff T lt, E;E.f h E t-L/r Lii'Lf < lE D lt#,T b a Lb fqb 6 3"'+;g L E +;Sn\M E r if HR F!' F.F.II aA A# 4L& T: a a $4*-e b a "4+F!r. E+;gl i r#-s'Xt ax,ff i ' tT aal:f t L{4;Fl i rf fFxlt-tt 4 {il1-e E> 4 . z a t. t:Fr) a=2 rat r +LI:C *j 3 l: t, r.

(20)-j iF+zu:i\66.1Qj)-e I have time.

Qr)- j r f@;$ftJ)fr61(21)-e I understand Chinese.

(22)-j tt{.al<fisilnZt(22)-e I see a cherry tree.

. n B a Flt: H 6 i: te ffi tl, 4 ( lE D liiE T-e E +;F ll E 9r,-"1 a fF l, \.bf : f i ib rFf t t [ :?- lc) f inr \ f f* ' f Atn<L&fr- l -a. r

^ f r , { \4;4r l:&6 ur6t96 r*;Fr oEE^ltE+;gTlrx LU-:T.EIXTltrxr,\ i) 6 . zat'x t u-c LTEot-th'ft l idfi < +T6 H E i 'L/r t,t. ( ig1 6) l : t i - r tLt ZaArrL{b t i t ta l l fB[ l : rH+ff i '+tr ;S'&/)/s: i r6DrL*:{ lz16. t iEtr f :a l t r l : f&t TDD. r fJ^ l l i t *'ffr "e li/r< {rL 4 tZa:lfltl.n\fir€f atBffit L L:CE;F'fhEnaaTbA" HAbi\ l : rn6OyaT. Al f , r fLr r l f /e1. ^€f#,*ha rn+f"1 .+tr ;€ '&o^r / j . (20)- ja tba) t3b(21)- j thf i 'a l i .b rb6r r \F.^TL)a ol t { - } L 45ff i t } .a-eL>a. .n6 Oxlr#f f i L L(lr[R D te < GEffi t6f::\h&{ffint) G#.y].inv\orii\ 5 ' lfi$a*t8,. t tra Itfi&t lf,Ht'L/et,r.

i€;*Tlrfr& a+.(+:ca"b rfLt nr*;gL L{fr. 6q,i.t' "i'Llrf6xF!t:€86fi*/xl,)g*Tb D. r*ie ' +tr;g 'tra+: l:fFlir: -C tFfr

HV a ' WAW-tr A ' F,4 t Ti&tt ),.AL LTHE &t>-:-CTsa a-e ba " zncba ld.z. .nBa9);alf,{&9r;4-c6 D . monev t'lttfi&a{t*,.Lts.a tr+* E ffi;STb 6 "

=5 *Tb/r l , \ . Lf j i \ . La 3{t l } t+^l ' 'Cln*f f iT l l /s l , \ . r l *Lt , r r Ef€re1*. t94t a i l ,* , r*Tt ' f f ivr l 44' t t ' *6t aFjFgt4,. | . . Lt:--l i \b A ) o#ffiXret+AHtffiXrrtr<+;F' El 6;grffHRH!/eHE-F.tJ a a-e b a.

t#iE{i*r a&ab L tl. m;FF"1[:&f:it 4.nb o tEnffi 'altF,RF! hE r, r I tt tr 6 tr^ o 4 < aqfifr,An\ E A fttt( l, \ 6 {ql6l liffi A/j.ftrffi l.=^ lf,^. +;* b El H!;go b /ev:. ?tlt l,\{ J ( E *h#ffia | *T

Page 15: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

1B '5T-fr al\ t-t O L i tL,J.F;kl: ir i l3-Cf Lrt ' : ; f :X&lt- ' ;"C' tfuEl#';T<l love you.>L8i '*5f*/e{qf ' . ln\66Ofj" .&< bK< L:T;*0D'lStf, W t,t ft I if! [f, *iS E l* : T t) H f - b rf{ tt & tsf:& E I' -C[)* f , *aEaXb. / \ tRt, \ ' i \ Xi fA! ] -e l i65. L i :L. , ZnDlxEft/rEi#ffiffi.a b eTftf axTll/eur. La+\k lr;grs L-t'-cfr-;{ f \4. i EAiFl t )d; '#o4T4+X Lt ' rnLiT 6, t ;d 'E6fdl tT'#W+rA.MbP6lst , tgg. t4 l*Tf- t r \<( l ) love (you)>i :Yl :6. t- & - l--s'o r +;Eft H -r.ft , (1 e60) 1t.10+f < *r Et i: Bf, i: tdF L T r, )6 a fa. +;#tr E g! ;gnr#6x i: 44T 6 4 t& ;;, .\ tfi it€ ;4 ti.Z aGAI4H &*.-; {. H/s6,\f6;r l Lft ' :-cl '*.a a-e trt6. 4l-ETf ,OHF^i\ l love you./4Oi\You love him.l lOi\We love it . /Joir.b a v t tdu a lfr a H.!fr h o i\ it, t a t9 6; 1 >, + 7 l- i\** E iur ix- t, t t, rfat b. a -e t, A . l4 b e( & E t, r,5. j- 6 n\E'S'f hT lf, /r t t. 114 4 = *r: v / \ is i\{ffi z { r, r a n I+. kl+.&"=-'l o i€ r., : s - A.flr' I\z ;nJ a xn L e t. &aAf i iE{;St i* : [ i \ 6ALtre l tht l \ i \ " ?&Xi* i :4Xi*A FgtI t: Ll:l;*a;d'D{t\ 61ooffirEE"l:. f +;9. t*EniA E +o jEit'fLO,Ht r =LJ Tba

E+;gxi* (t D brt+ttxi*) 1r96sntl i :&iF_e?'1. qt. E+;#d)#:rSi : RE"Lt:Xi* ;dfEtL6 t l t i *a f i7: i i \ . . : l (1960)Zaka

| 7) 441J,b6. FIWiJ'. -of i f tXT?o-ff i&Rf:ff i t : ,

fnig :6

5 : t* t,r * /ji6t 6 /r urtrgw < D; < fR a El .6;* i: dF D K B L ( |,) .6 i\ Bf i " E4;St i t< t f+#lr ' [ tb.af f iAqh\. # i ' t ra. ? L{E+;goA6FfiI : tbZt FR?. {\k E4;gxi*6ff ' f t ,Xa 2 1Ef'd, i .* jrta&fd' l itih\>ffi481:rr'E ftffifla -c#r4 a "

*' i- . plx-lr; .g10974a:r429-r430)ir tna . ah,. otfrtrt-e b4 t4. i '4t

t:ru\to# L < EtsidL(i/ \6" /(ryi l?o#iFL L.Cff,€t-<\,\ 4 i$ff i i \H,*tttk4t aR.wawea t+ (b) 6: l i46B!1.+kk04^i:)[ lr fr. {r]b 146r t: [R6AElf,te(. t66: ioe^tuti f f i iF tb4: &f 's8l jz: i"ib4t l : lJ rb6&)tr : t tza. : ;* .D l teat t t )* .h4t oHqbAtu

TL\ar) , r fa" Et. t4\ '6*t t4frr f r .OlJL0 1 a i t t4, l f i :66r oH4A&<tSL(i1\6. F+{tFl-c*jElr l*4r) r* j&ft* j t l t>D v, ! r b*/: l f f i latT&6"

2 . f a a ;( + -- (1 965) o l, ) *r @ 6 H#ISAft nriEE A t *'' i"i l: rE H O -' fl.fr €*rE 46il xL t *9hx.aa.MffiHtJ, iri6H,H * tu t t E6 ht b 4

- L-e b

6" Many people speak a fet' languages. t-t t)ffiF)X&AKtffi.HtJI:httJ t Ygl]i- A few languages are spoken b1' manl' people. hr&,'nai \H4r\Jt8 1A.t t=TL*4.

s . h ty n+;saHffiF+(c.AJr-tr)1ee6+Hft$84<#6fi^i: l--. t >l-. u 2--rrt+Ta-rt.. ' ' E 4;F&i€.{ *=={'a9!}q&tn }bPi, (1996.,1.20)

4 . RiEr ^

i/ x l- dr IFi[ < -e : -f i ((, I' f:E I6hr*F- 3 tt- l:4tr o HLL'*Y rrt-.1 *- o ff fr itffiffi J i.r 6 " 1923+ l. t ttt! +fr o-.tffi[A A E L ( * rr^i L' zl-. 1! l:#tsHti6 ctir I & Fqliri 'r.(. 1frlj r?: t: Llit& 4h\ a (Becausethe mountain is there )LExt: . mountain l : igJC; ' l i \ t t \ ( I ' \6r) fJn-#rd l,,Z ]-LLO

- &*C,

^Eiof : l- t]* lf.tt:&?,,*: b4 cltl-FffilLt

Page 16: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

'79

- - t: & ( rEtt-c v r a " ?5+ b otr 3 l(.bt: o \ & 3 L-# D #r$n(te/:o

It. HLlt & r,\ i r'.fd o)€'f; 'ft A tfi < HCI: : > 7 + 7 l' O + T O : oXirH*t)v\ f . -&l :& 4bDfi4a.

5 . b: & b-q-ARurr-F, i (b. zoff iD*I1z.ht?#-: l j l j l . t : -c L*i & i /xF,t;",] (#Ja . flJa' *5t^c) li E 9ri-,1 r lf,[E'? let,t" : i'L 6 l**eftwAR-. KAR-. SAR*A--#++ & ?.^\3 b oT b 6.

6 . Et t.&;s &lf.-:t: iwffi-l. 4r TL*{0Etl;E }h6rr. .aI*#EIv.Fx-r 4i IS, & t f f i : IJ=-: &b tAl j6 l H4oH+-eb6a&f. i lELl : r , ' " *

l : . iFg) aAlf f i .a l f t - 'LtrD (-S+glD) r TD6"7 . &ffi*4RaAfil ' l ltgIB(1974b)t.# L !)"s.

-o$t fJ, t< t ) f t i ; - " l r r ibt t t= '$ idfr ' +8,"1 '48tu '& '* i t : ( l

ra t orf* l: 4 Fl ELR-raF-l:ft L T l, \ 6 a L t aA'] r\ t: B€ tr L -a l, \ 6 " E +"=6oErlAiFFtJ[:S.i-i 'LfJ i#F1E; &Db ttr6l t i€tl [:itEf6'ftFfF-Jnrifi r, r. tiJF{E: l:i} H f 6 46F &homocentric A-# t.ff'\-c E #iEltloco-centric & E: ( tzr lz r /: ' 4 a "

- a Ra€RA r'v L* t L f #A(1998b) l:

$rzt / : - thrbA"9. I a-ebat xoi#6gt:H-ra€trJetJ/ \>7.1'v D)<#aff i f f i t r f fEl3#

b6E[i \J<* i , : lc"0. ttrWa ) &rt )v F )j )v=#DobligadotriF&f 4 alJ+<ffirur)Ar,\RF"1'-#iFd,rd. ffiffi Dfrffi e i z

- LEEL ir l: L r r & v t 5 aq o**#wh I:rR

5 t* iL*: E*r Lv\ahAE bqn(u\4. -oA*LftrJt lz lFHit ' 'Et&ffi;X*-ctr[Jn-c*/:F€Fna |ffi; E tJ:ffiftl Lr*tufjoirb t tAa"

?offirr#<R#{!!,finr iffiR'l -e b4.7. b5l , \ l f4E+af iL(EAir*6ia6 t72=a2Y*' i - t1t ( f t .

Tb+nfi+;SllitE 3t'16"2. ZeAX.tMAi-" lX&t r iEtu r l i66nr. E+;+T r+&Tl:& D *t tu-rR < 6 D *. t A, : L t b 7-> t -eoftXe lF 4 D L€*"EgJefl]dr) d€ODolf,

* E L < ttHHB! & AX_ A fa 4 t . * t:. F.rl;,"] J(T tr iBf E A,st: D + b D * tfufit t tt t" L i b 4 t {'f{.of:Ettthht&;a "3 . t a Lt:it ba -ffi[*SA(r996)T#,*.1't:"4 . &FI(1 994) l*? o Htf 'l+ a ? l/ \ r. l D tr llF*w l, \iff iFT 6 : /:"5. Kanaya (1983)6 . . i L l: E #-rFJ(i* [. *8 4[ * i'11: 7 -- : x"A'lt [: : r. t :C lJKanaya(1997),d A(1 998a) le tT# L ( id'sl: "7 .

^W os73) + *A (1 9 7 8) I: k 4 = L a+;+* H ffi t: *'tt' 6 #t+lj nr*fi T b

6 -

L L]Kanaya (1997)*'#6(1997)Tz< Ll:.

>+xffifu L#8Q97 7) | -tr 4 t E 6 aA-#+r E f l A#( 1977.9-1978.8)

x.Mffiaffi+treHf, (1s80) r+{A{toiE{Laft I FAffi #,(Bf g(1e74a) rEiEEiS#&r Hi.EEIS,(Etg(1974b) r E 4"'64 Ei\otI6r H&tr#/tEig(l ee3) | 1* D #ELnaffi#.t Et&#tE

A6fi#(iee6) rE #;S& E + oEttffi : h ti ES=##HffiF+Newsletter(vol. 12)

Page 17: Journal CAJLE Vol. 3 (2000) E*;+9l6-d rbAt Li€-#$r;A< Do ... · 2. HiE L E+;6O ,*TJH I OEI,: ltf thM)L{nJX.Q)Q)i,6 tgilBXt t4 zT\&,a " (1)-j L(1)*e I*€E9!XT 6 D . **X-e 6 A Q)-j

BC6afi#(1997) r+ffiXi* 6 0 trat),E t JOURNAL CAJLE(vol.1)#Airt#(1ee8a) t E +=-#+;++4ft : 9 4 $a )* &ElBt-#fi&Xi*'rcr

A4t JOURNAL CAJLE(vo1.2)+4f i#(1998b) r ! !A &iK: -Cr,EtUJ. i 'Lt ,r E"*(1998+11E E)Jttr{Xffi(le8l) iE+;+ : X.rE2I iE4-#oEFr FRAffittAsI €(1e73) f E+Xl*{frfrl Xl4ffi#tr*'dh 8 os78) | E +;soatfr t *{trffi#rEffi1<+*(J975) tffi E"3t-Ll:=;*' E A"=*oEJFt trffi EgA Et{f (199r) itrrFo)E"=F & E AEF] < Z L$jfrfiF+illffi i l^. ffiEfifi!,ffi(1ee4) t7::XA Effi{rr ffie#&{t9fFl .(1e78) |

- & {,J & 4F'1t Ri&Js+trffiA

+{gIFI -(1ee4) i E +;5 &4;61* C i {Ur l, \ a i,t h, I E +i*#€ ffi&e;#iF(19s4.12.4)

=tH(r960) t4ll#itFt,rt ( Z LJtrlHffi-t#(r975) r=tF;ftJCFt ( Z LJ:rHffiEB)g*(re7 1) rEft lf HR-# R't.. t tr?it#E ( tStB(1 9 7a: 1 1 9) l. I i H )

Comrie, B.( 1981) I-anguage Universals and Linguistic I>'pologyOxford, Basil Blackwell

Chomsky, N. (1965) Aspects of the T'heory of Syntax , Ir{lT PressKanaya, T. ( 1 983 ) Sur Ia v'aleur fonctionnelle de Ia voix moyenne

indo-europdenne , Master thesis, Universit6 l.avalKanaya, '1.(1997) I-a notion du sujet en japonais", Ph.D.

dissertation, Universitd de Nlontr6alMeillet, A. ( 192 1) Iinguistique historique et linguistique

gendrale, Champion, Paris