jeremy j. burdon,editors, ,cambridge studies in ecology (1987) cambridge university press pp. 208....

1
Reviews cycles have often become secondarily reduced and apparently single'. Reynolds' chapter is a whole catalogue of challenges to the accepted ways of thinking and interpreting pleomorphism and associated matters. It is the gems like these that finally entice the reader to think somewhat more differently about the implications of the pleomorphic lifestyle. At a price oscillating about the £70.00 mark it will not be a realistic purchase for most individuals. B. C. SUTTON ProcessDevelopment in Antibiotic Fermentations. By C. T. CALAM. (Cambridge Studies in Biotechnology 4. Cambridge University Press, 1987.) Pp.217. Price £3°. 00 . For the mycologist this is a frustrating book because the author gets off to a bad start in trying to establish the confidence of the reader. Section 2.5 on the identification of the micro-organisms comments that' Fungi are usually identified as far as genus, the identification of species being more difficult. Streptomycetes are usually identified as far as species, of which there are very many'. The author amply demonstrates how difficult he finds the fungi by confusing the diploid state with the heterokaryotic and dikaryotic states and confusing the nature of the perfect and imperfect stages of moulds. The author comments that the identification of fungi is a special subject in itself. This may be the case, but the author would not have made the mistake of suggesting that Penicillium chrysogenum was' a partner in the diploid Eurotium' ifhe had consulted an undergraduate text book on mycology. This is a pity because the subject matter of the book is undoubtedly important and it contains valuable infor- mation and useful ideas based on the author's personal experience. The text is divided into three parts: (1) Background; (2) Process development in the laboratory; (3) Industrial fermentation plants and pilot plants. It is completed with a brief postscript highlighting the difficulty of access to information about the high yielding strains, developed by . industry, a bibliography of further reading and references used in the text. Process Development in Antibiotic Fermentations is written with enthusiasm for fermenters and the careful reader will find some useful material. This reviewer's concern is that students using the text may be misled by errors and lack of precision in those topics outside the author's expertise. M. O. MOSS Diseases and Plant Population Biology. By JEREMY J. BURDON. (Cambridge Studies in Ecology. Cambridge University Press, 1987.) Pp, 208. Price £12.50. Hard covers £27.50. This book is about the role plant pathogens play in the ecology of their hosts, with emphasis, for a change, on non-agricultural plant populations and communities. With the help of chapters on how disease develops in plant populations, the genetic basis of disease resistance and the effects of the environment on host-pathogen interactions, the author creates within the first three- quarters of the book a picture of how pathogens may affect individual plants and the size, density and genetic structure of plant populations. The remainder of the book contains a chapter on the reciprocal relationship of how the host might affect the genetic structure of the pathogen, a short, but useful, chapter on further study, a glossary of plant pathological terms, over 20 pages of references and an index. In addition to the well-written text there is a reasonable number of mostly helpful tables and figures. All is well-presented and there are remarkably few errors. In this book the author deliberately breaks down the traditional boundaries between disciplines and champions a neglected area of study. Many readers may find that this demands more than the usual effort. Students and research workers in plant pathology are included in the target readership on the back cover, but the preface reveals that the book was written specifically for popu- lation biologists (ecologists and geneticists). This ac- counts for a glossary to assist population biologists with their plant pathology and the absence of anything the other way round. Most plant pathology students, how- ever, will find the first part of the book easy to follow and a useful revision of many aspects of plant disease. I, a root pathologist, sailed through the first five chapters, not too pressed to find things to carp at, but thereafter I had to work hard. After such effort, it was somewhat of an anticlimax to find the apparent raison d'etre of the book. i.e. how pathogens affect wild plants, long on speculation and short on facts and figures. Nearly every aspect had to be introduced as being fragmentary, having yawning gaps or lacking in information. After a while this ceased to be challenging and became tedious. The author was well aware of the perils of breaking new ground like this and on the whole his attempt is commendable and highlights the increasing need for scientists who can rise above the traditional demarcations. For those more discipline-orientated readers, who are willing to persevere beyond the easy bits of their subjects, whole new vistas will be revealed and, for such a modest price, that surely is reward enough? DAVID HORNBY Food and Beverage Mycology. Ed. L. R. BEUCHAT. (Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, znd edn, 1987.) Pp. xiii + 661. Price £58.45. Since the first edition of Food and Beverage Mycology in 1978, several text books have been published establishing food mycology as an important component of food studies. Nevertheless, this book remains an authoritative collection of essays on the many facets of food mycology. The book opens with a general account of the classification and characterization of the moulds and yeasts encountered during food studies. Although there is no escaping the need for specialist texts dealing with individual groups of fungi, the liberal use of simple keys based on a presumed understanding of fundamental mycology makes this chapter a useful springboard to identifying food associated fungi. I was surprised to see no reference to the excellent monographs on the demati- aceous hyphomycetes by Ellis, the coelomycetes by

Upload: david-hornby

Post on 13-Sep-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Reviews

cycles have often become secondarily reduced andapparently single'. Reynolds' chapter is a whole catalogueof challenges to the accepted ways of thinking andinterpreting pleomorphism and associated matters. It isthe gems like these that finally entice the reader to thinksomewhat more differently about the implications of thepleomorphic lifestyle. At a price oscillating about the£70.00 mark it will not be a realistic purchase for mostindividuals.

B. C. SUTTON

Process Development in Antibiotic Fermentations. By C. T.CALAM. (Cambridge Studies in Biotechnology 4.Cambridge University Press, 1987.) Pp.217. Price£3°.00.

For the mycologist this is a frustrating book because theauthor gets off to a bad start in trying to establish theconfidence of the reader. Section 2.5 on the identificationof the micro-organisms comments that' Fungi are usuallyidentified as far as genus, the identification of speciesbeing more difficult. Streptomycetes are usually identifiedas far as species, of which there are very many'.

The author amply demonstrates how difficult he findsthe fungi by confusing the diploid state with theheterokaryotic and dikaryotic states and confusing thenature of the perfect and imperfect stages of moulds. Theauthor comments that the identification of fungi is aspecial subject in itself. This may be the case, but theauthor would not have made the mistake of suggestingthat Penicillium chrysogenum was' a partner in the diploidEurotium' ifhe had consulted an undergraduate text bookon mycology.

This is a pity because the subject matter of the book isundoubtedly important and it contains valuable infor-mation and useful ideas based on the author's personalexperience.

The text is divided into three parts: (1) Background;(2) Process development in the laboratory; (3) Industrialfermentation plants and pilot plants. It is completed witha brief postscript highlighting the difficulty of access to

information about the high yielding strains, developed by .industry, a bibliography of further reading and referencesused in the text.

Process Development in Antibiotic Fermentations iswritten with enthusiasm for fermenters and the carefulreader will find some useful material. This reviewer'sconcern is that students using the text may be misled byerrors and lack of precision in those topics outside theauthor's expertise.

M. O. MOSS

Diseases and Plant Population Biology. By JEREMY J.BURDON. (Cambridge Studies in Ecology. CambridgeUniversity Press, 1987.) Pp, 208. Price £12.50. Hardcovers £27.50.

This book is about the role plant pathogens play in theecology of their hosts, with emphasis, for a change, onnon-agricultural plant populations and communities.With the help of chapters on how disease develops inplant populations, the genetic basis of disease resistanceand the effects of the environment on host-pathogeninteractions, the author creates within the first three-

quarters of the book a picture of how pathogens mayaffect individual plants and the size, density and geneticstructure of plant populations. The remainder of thebook contains a chapter on the reciprocal relationship ofhow the host might affect the genetic structure of thepathogen, a short, but useful, chapter on further study, aglossary of plant pathological terms, over 20 pages ofreferences and an index. In addition to the well-writtentext there is a reasonable number of mostly helpful tablesand figures. All is well-presented and there are remarkablyfew errors.

In this book the author deliberately breaks down thetraditional boundaries between disciplines and championsa neglected area of study. Many readers may find that thisdemands more than the usual effort. Students andresearch workers in plant pathology are included in thetarget readership on the back cover, but the prefacereveals that the book was written specifically for popu-lation biologists (ecologists and geneticists). This ac-counts for a glossary to assist population biologists withtheir plant pathology and the absence of anything theother way round. Most plant pathology students, how-ever, will find the first part of the book easy to follow anda useful revision of many aspects of plant disease. I, a rootpathologist, sailed through the first five chapters, not toopressed to find things to carp at, but thereafter I had towork hard.

After such effort, it was somewhat of an anticlimax tofind the apparent raison d'etre of the book. i.e. howpathogens affect wild plants, long on speculation andshort on facts and figures. Nearly every aspect had to beintroduced as being fragmentary, having yawning gaps orlacking in information. After a while this ceased to bechallenging and became tedious.

The author was well aware of the perils of breakingnew ground like this and on the whole his attempt iscommendable and highlights the increasing need forscientists who can rise above the traditional demarcations.For those more discipline-orientated readers, who arewilling to persevere beyond the easy bits of their subjects,whole new vistas will be revealed and, for such a modestprice, that surely is reward enough?

DAVID HORNBY

Food and Beverage Mycology. Ed. L. R. BEUCHAT. (VanNostrand Reinhold, New York, znd edn, 1987.)Pp. xiii +661. Price £58.45.

Since the first edition of Food and Beverage Mycology in1978, several text books have been published establishingfood mycology as an important component of foodstudies. Nevertheless, this book remains an authoritativecollection of essays on the many facets of food mycology.

The book opens with a general account of theclassification and characterization of the moulds andyeasts encountered during food studies. Although there isno escaping the need for specialist texts dealing withindividual groups of fungi, the liberal use of simple keysbased on a presumed understanding of fundamentalmycology makes this chapter a useful springboard toidentifying food associated fungi. I was surprised to seeno reference to the excellent monographs on the demati-aceous hyphomycetes by Ellis, the coelomycetes by