janata bank job analysis & description
TRANSCRIPT
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
INTRODUCTION
i) ORIGIN OF THE REPORT:
This report is prepared with the respect to three-month course of Job Analysis and
Performance Appraisal. I am assigned to prepare a term paper by our reverent Dr. Nargis
Akhter, Associate Professor. My task is to do job analysis and job evaluation.
ii) OBJECTIVES OF THE TERM PAPER:
Broad Objective: To broadly learn and know about the method of preparing job
analysis and job evaluation.
Specific Objective: To know how organizations of Bangladesh prepare job analysis
for their own organizations and evaluate respective job and hence fix total
compensation.
iii) METHODS:
a) Sources of data collection:
Data are mostly collected from two organizations: Janata Bank and Grameenphone primary
sources are mostly used and also a few secondary sources for preparing the report:
o P rimary sources: Primary sources are the individuals of the organizations who are
aware of the human resource practices for that organization and helped to collect the
information by answering the questions and filling up the questionnaire given to them.
o S econdary sources : Secondary information was collected from the internet about
comprehensive information about job analysis and job evaluation system.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
b) Scope of the study:
The information given by Janata Bank, Grameenphone and some general real life
assumptions.
iv) LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY:
Some difficulties were faced while preparing this report such as-
Access to the internal information to various organizations.
Time constraint
Text constraint
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
PART 1
JOB ANALYSIS
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
CHAPTER-1
CONCEPT REVIEW
i) MEANING OF JOB ANALYSIS:
Job Analysis is a process to establish and document the 'job relatedness' of employment
procedures such as training, selection, compensation, and performance appraisal.
Detailed examination of the following factors is analyzed:
1. Tasks (performance elements) that make up a job (employee role),
2. Conditions under which they are performed,
3. What the job requires in terms of aptitudes (potential for achievement), attitudes
(behavior characteristics), knowledge, skills, and the physical condition of the
employee.
ii) OBJECTIVES OF JOB ANALYSIS INCLUDE:
1. Determination of the most efficient methods of doing a job,
2. Enhancement of the employee's job satisfaction,
3. Improvement in training methods,
4. Development of performance measurement systems, and
5. Matching of job-specifications with the person-specifications in employee selection.
Comprehensive job analysis begins with the study of the organization itself: its purpose,
design and structure, inputs and outputs, internal and external environments, and resource
constraints. It is the first step in a thorough understanding of the job and forms the basis of
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
job description that leads to job specification. It is also known as human resource audit, job
study, or occupational analysis.
iii) METHODS OF JOB ANALYSIS:
Interview
Observation
Questionnaire
On-Line Forms
iv) JOB DESCRIPTION:
A job description is a list of the general tasks, or functions, and responsibilities of a position.
Typically, it also includes to whom the position reports, specifications such as the
qualifications needed by the person in the job, salary range for the position, etc. A job
description is usually developed by conducting a job analysis, which includes examining the
tasks and sequences of tasks necessary to perform the job. The analysis looks at the areas of
knowledge and skills needed by the job. Note that a role is the set of responsibilities or
expected results associated with a job. A job usually includes several roles.
iv) PURPOSE OF JOB DESCRIPTION:
The objective of a job description is to have a clear outline of duties and responsibilities to
make the screening process as direct and focused as possible.
Job descriptions may have the following elements:
improvement cooperation by giving all members of the organization insight in
existing responsibilities/roles
enabling career moves within the organization
determination of amount of pay per function
increase of results by specification of responsibilities and key performance indicators
development of job owner by specification of competences
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
may include the phrase "perform other duties as assigned"
iv) JOB SPECIFICATION:
It denotes the personnel requirements of a particular job. A job specification sets forth the
skills, education, and experience required for a particular position.
CHAPTER-2
JANATA BANK
i) AN OVERVIEW:
Janata Bank is a nationalized commercial bank that was established under the BANGLADESH
BANKs Nationalization Order 1972. It was created by taking over the branches of two
abandoned Pakistani banks-the United Bank and Union Bank, which functioned in East
Pakistan. With its head office at Dhaka, the bank started its operations with an initial
authorized capital of Tk 50 million and paid up capital of Tk 10.5 million. The authorized
capital was raised to Tk 30 million in 1973. Since then the authorized and paid up capital
remained unchanged till December 1983. Later, both were increased from time to time and
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
their amounts stood at Tk 8 billion and Tk 2.594 billion respectively on 31 December 2000.
The reserve funds of the bank on that date were Tk 367 million.
In addition to traditional deposit taking in various accounts and providing loans to almost all
sectors of the economy, the bank offers different types of other services and conducts 'off-
balance sheet (OBS)' activities. The value of assets created by the OBS activities of the bank
was Tk 26.07 billion in 1998 and Tk 25.46 billion in 2000. The agency services of the bank
include making payments to different public sector corporations and acting as paymaster in
the government's food procurement scheme. The bank provides loans and advances to not
only the clients of selected groups like the traders and industrialists but also to people of all
classes and professions. Side by side with industry and commerce, agriculture and other
priority sectors also receive funding and advisory services support from the bank. Janata
Bank disburses government grants to the teachers of private and public educational
institutions.
Janata Bank has a large participation in foreign exchange business including overseas
remittance services. The total volume of foreign exchange business handled by the bank in
servicing imports and exports and remittances during 1999-2000 amounted to Tk 40.312
billion. In 2000, the bank had correspondent relationships with 1,180 foreign banks/bank
offices.
In 1972, Janata Bank started its banking operations with a total initial deposit of Tk 1.57
billion; ever since the bank has been making continuous and sustained efforts to mobilize
deposits from untapped resources in both urban and rural areas. A special deposit
mobilization program introduced by the bank in 1976 resulted in remarkable increases in the
volume of its deposits, which grew at a rate of approximately 63% and 42% during 1972-74
and 1978-80. The deposits growth rate in 2000 was 8.2%. The volume of loans and advances
of the bank was Tk 1.13 billion in 1972 and it increased to Tk 5.28 billion in 1984. Major
areas that received financing from the bank were jute trade, jute industries, tanneries, sugar
industries, textile trade and industries, transport, iron and steel, tea plantation and trade,
livelihood trades/income generating activities and housing.
The credit portfolio of the bank expanded manifold after the 1980s and covered almost all
sectors of the economy. The bank was a major participant and a provider of funds in the Tk
10 billion Special Agricultural Credit Program (SACP) launched by the government in 1977.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
The total amount of its loans and advances stood at Tk 80.95 billion in 2000. Loans and
advances provided by the bank to the broad economic areas up to 30 June 2000 were:
agriculture and fisheries - Tk 4.362 billion, industry (small and cottage, and large and
medium) - Tk 32.352 billion, retail/wholesale trade and hotels and restaurants - Tk 5.215
billion, transport & communication and storage - Tk 331 million, special credit program
including poverty alleviation - Tk 1.698 billion and others - Tk 18.862 billion.
During 1999, Janata Bank disbursed Tk 16.383 billion in loans and advances and the
recovery during the year was Tk 4.541 billion. In 2000, the recovery rate was 20% of total
outstanding loans. The amount of overdue loans and advances on 30 June 2000 was Tk 27.34
billion and on 30 June 2000, the ratio of total overdue to total outstanding loans was 37.12%.
Poor loan recovery and the increase in the amount of overdue loans caused a fall in the
quality of its lending assets. The bank's total classified loan amounted to Tk 23.63 billion on
31 December 2000.
Up to December 2000 the bank's loans to the public sector were Tk 15.9 billion, of which Tk
2.15 billion was classified. 19.6% of the bank's total loans and advances went as borrowings
to the public sector enterprises. Up to the same date, the bank disbursed Tk 5.603 billion as
rural credit including Micro credit. On the other hand, the bank borrowed Tk 2.16 billion in
1998 and Tk 2.08 billion in 2000 from the inter-bank market. The credit-deposit ratio of the
bank was 77.95% in 2000. On 31 December 2000, the liquid assets of the bank were valued
at Tk 36.22 billion.
In 1999, the interest rate offered by the bank on savings deposits in both rural and urban areas
was 7.5%, while the rates charged by it on loans in different sectors averaged 12.65%. On 31
December 2000, the total and net incomes of the bank were Tk 9.25 billion and Tk 829.2
million respectively. However, an increase in the volume of classified loans weakened the
quality of the bank's assets. An increase in operating and interest expenses of the bank slowed
down the rate of growth of its total incomes in 1999-2000.
Janata Bank monitors its work through a performance budget. It has a marketing intelligence
unit and conducts a program of human resources development through training and
motivation. It introduced the Lending Risk Analysis suggested by the Financial Sector
Reform Program. Business policies of the bank in the 1990s included fulfilling capital
adequacy requirement, mobilizing deposits in large amounts, and making investments in
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
more profitable ways. The bank diversified its activities in off-balance sheet items to expand
its area of operations and increase non-interest based incomes.
The management of the bank is vested in a 7-member board of directors appointed by the
government. The managing director is the chief executive and he is assisted by a deputy
managing director, six general managers and other senior executives. The general managers
are in charge of the bank's branches in six administrative divisions of the country namely,
Dhaka, Chittagong, Rajshahi, Khulna, Sylhet and Barisal. At the head office, the bank has 27
departments including a training institute. On 30 June 2000, the bank had a total of 17,138
employees. Up to 31 December 2000, the bank had 894 domestic and 4 overseas branches (in
the Middle-East). Among the domestic branches, 348 were in the urban areas and 546 in the
rural areas.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
ii) THE REASONS BEHIND CHOOSING THE POSTS IN THREE
DIFFERENT LEVELS:
A. Why Officer?
Among all entry-level posts, officer rank is the most dimensional one. The officers of Janata
Bank get various opportunities to learn different tasks through job rotation. An officer
generally experiences different tasks getting involved in different sections such as HRD,
HRDD, JBTI, WD etc.
B. Why Senior Principal Officer?
Senior Principal Officer takes part in decision making process and planning the strategies for
the Bank. They are ultimately responsible to execute the final decisions taken by the top
management and prepare the employees for following the taken decisions. They also monitor
and control the whole process and provide timely feedback depending on the employees,
performance. The Senior Principal Officer actually makes a bridge of communication
between the top level and entry level employees which is necessary for implementing the
strategies. They also find out the lacking areas where there is a need for recruitment or
training.
C. Why First Assistant General Manager?
First Assistant General Manager is a newly introduced top level post in Janata Bank. As the
top management (AGM & GM) was previously facing problems in policy and decision
making, this post is introduced to be a representative for the top management who will work
with the Senior Principal Officer in the field. They possess the authority to take decisions on
behalf of the top management. It has significantly reduced the possibility of biasness by the
Senior Principal Officer. They also suggest solutions to the AGM and GM according to the
lacking areas found by the Senior Principal Officers.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
CHAPTER-3
FINDINGS OF THE STUDY
i) THE SUGGESTED JOB ANALYSIS:
ENTRY LEVEL POSITION:
Job Title: Officer
Department: Human Resource Department
Position Code: 01-06
Activities to be performed:
Maintains employment résumé, application forms, and applicant flow logs in line with
company policy.
Retains records in line with company record retention requirements
Maintains employee personnel files in line with company policies and government
regulations.
Job Duties:
Daily
Duties performed at irregular interval
Monitory Responsibility:
Line managers and the other executives.
Delegation of Authority:
Monitors and controls the line managers’ activities
Take decisions about rewarding or punishing them
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Has the authority to take any step to manage conflicts.
Reporting Relationship:
Report to the senior officer.
Knowledge, Skill and Ability:
Computer literacy
Proficiency in English
Communication skill
Hard working capability
Integrity
Loyalty
Accountability etc.
Educational Requirements and Experience:
Title of the job
Age Qualification For Promotion
Officer 21-30
Required grade is second class or
CGPA equivalent to second class
for B.com, B.com Honors, (Post
Graduates will get preferences)
from reputed institutions. First
division for SSC and HSC.
Three years in the existing
job.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
MID LEVEL POSITION:
Job Title: Senior Manager
Department: Human Resource Department
Position Code: 01-03
Activities should be performed:
Developing policy and Procedure for Recruitment and selection.
Implementing taken strategies.
Guiding officers and managers.
Evaluating the subordinates’ performance by observing them.
Report to the direct supervisors such as to AGM or GM.
Job Duties:
Daily
Duties performed at irregular interval
Monitory Responsibility:
All the entry level employees.
Delegation of Authority:
Monitors and controls the subordinates’ activities and
Take decisions about rewarding or punishing subordinates
Evaluates subordinates performance
Reporting Relationship:
Report to the Assistant General Manager.
Knowledge, Skill and Ability:
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Computer literacy
Proficiency in English
Communication skill
Monitoring and controlling power
Decision making ability
Leadership qualities
Integrity
Loyalty
Influencing capacity
Ability to make bias free judgment etc.
Educational Requirements and Experience:
Title of the job Age Qualification For Promotion
Senior Manager 45-50
Required grade is second class or
CGPA equivalent to second class for
B.com, B.com Honors, (Post
Graduates will get preferences) in
Finance, Banking, Economics or
Accounting from reputed
institutions. First division for SSC
and HSC.
Three years in the
existing job.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
MID LEVEL POSITION:
Job Title: Assistant General Manager
Department: Human Resource Department
Position Code: 01-02
Activities should be performed:
Guiding and supervising all mid level employees.
Taking care of the whole strategy implementation process.
Allocating and controlling budget.
Monitoring and evaluating employees’ performance and designing compensation
package accordingly.
Maintaining a friendly working environment through managing conflicts and
counseling.
Ensure the co-ordination of this department with all other department.
Job Duties:
Daily
Duties performed at irregular interval
Monitory Responsibility:
All the mid level employees.
Delegation of Authority:
Participates in taking decisions about the major HR activities like recruitment,
compensation, promotion, designing training, performance appraisal.
Reporting Relationship:
Report to the General Manager.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Knowledge, Skill and Ability:
Computer literacy, proficiency in English
Communication skill
Monitoring and controlling power
Decision making ability
leadership qualities
Integrity
Foresightness
Ability to make bias free judgment etc.
Educational Requirements and Experience:
Title of the job Age Qualification
Assistant General Manager 50-55
Post Graduation (CA/FCA /MBA)
from reputed institutions in Finance,
Banking, Economics or Accounting. .
Total experience of 20 years in
relevant field with 1 year in the post of
Deputy Managing Director.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
ii) JOB DESCRIPTION FOLLOWED IN JANATA BANK:
A. Job Description for Entry Level Position
Job Title: Officer
Department: Human Resource Department
Essential functions of the job: Keep the logs of the employees’ résumés, applications,
performance appraisals of previous years, and incentive records. They also maintain records
of all the information regarding training need assessment, training programs conducted
previously and individual employee’s improvement level in those training. The records of
increments and festival bonuses allocated to the employees are also maintained by them.
Job context: Officer must follow the instructions given by the senior officers, Service Area
managers and cooperate with the line managers and employees.
Reporting relation and other activities: The officers have to report to the departmental
Manager. They have to frequently contact with Manager, Heads of Service Areas, line
managers and other staff.
Specific matters/cases should be discussed directly with the Principal Officer and
Senior Principal Officer.
Developing the practice of collaboration, communication and counseling amongst
other HR colleagues.
Challenges of this job:
The rank holder face challenges to identify and promote opportunities and solutions of
various problems in a changing environment.
To work with the HR Team in relation to equal opportunities and employee welfare
often in a cross functional working groups whose inspirations have a substantial
impact on HR practices.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Other requirements of the position (mental and physical factor): The candidates
have to be mentally and physically fit for the job because they have to do some field works
and sometimes they may stay in the office for longer hours.
Knowledge and experience required:
A high level of interpersonal skill, communication skill and Trainability is needed. Work
related knowledge and proficiency in English is compulsory.
Title of the job Age Qualification
Officer 21-30
Candidates are expected to take their educational degrees
from reputed institutions. Required grade is second class
or CGPA equivalent to second class for B.com, B.com
Honors, (Post Graduates will get preferences), First
division for SSC and HSC.
B. Job Description for Mid Level Position
Job Title: Senior Principal Officer
Department: Human Resource Department
Essential function of the job: As Human Resources (HR) Managers they must have a
clear concept about their organization’s business objectives and be able to implement policies
and follow appropriate methods which will help to select and retain the right person at the
right position to meet those objectives.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Policy making and interpretation: Developing coordination with other departments,
assisting line managers to understand and implement policies and procedures.
Job context:
Maintain, review and update proper filing of HR handbook, performance appraisal
forms and training schedules of the organization.
Planning and preparing annual report and updating the replacement chart.
Take part in preparing compensation package for designated employees.
Maintains agreement/contract of employees.
Designs yearly manpower planning and expansion
Assist in drafting out Annual Letters and Promotion Letters.
Manages and evaluates subordinates' performance and the need of their career
development.
Planning and developing training program:
Conducting Training Need Assessment.
Make plan and Conduct training program for the existing and new employee of the
organization according to the TNA result.
Identify Training Need both individually and department as a whole.
Coordinates with external and internal trainers.
Evaluates employee performance in the training programs and give them timely
feedback.
Reporting relation: Directly report to the First Assistant General Manager or in some
cases to the General Manager.
Challenges of this job:
The post holder is challenged to take part in decision making, developing policy and
strategy which will help the organization to compete with other leading ones and
sustain in the long run. Generates innovative ideas for the welfare of the organization.
Other requirements of the position (mental and physical factor): Decision
making ability, integrity, monitoring power, conscientiousness, flexibility etc.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Knowledge and experience required:
Title of the job Age Qualification
Senior Principal Officer Max 52
Candidates are expected to take their educational
degrees from reputed institutions. Required
grade is second class or CGPA equivalent to
second class for B.com, B.com Honors, Post
Graduate, and First Division for SSC and HSC.
Area of Education: Finance, Banking,
Economics or Accounting.
C. Job Description for Top Level Position
Job Title: First Assistant General Manager
Department: Human Resource Department
Essential function of the job: Provide administrative and technical human resource
assistance to Principal and Senior Principal Officers in the local department.
Policy making and interpretation: Developing Policy and Procedure. Ensure that the
Principal and Senior Principal Officers have a clear understanding about the objective and
strategy of the organization. Allocate all the necessary resources to carry out the tasks.
Job context:
Forecast the required manpower and budget for the training program.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Preparing performance appraisal and preparing compensation package for all
employee.
Instruct and supervise other managers to execute the operation.
Monitor the gradual improvement in every level of the departments.
Managing conflict and ensuring healthy working environment.
Reporting relation: The First Assistant General Manager have to report to the General
Manager and the Assistant General Manager. Specific matters discussed direct with the
General Manager and Head of the department. Communicate with all other departmental
head.
Challenges of This Job:
Developing Strategy according to the need of the changing technology and
economical environment.
Participating in policy and decision making in supervision of the AGM and GM and
implementing that timely.
Creating a friendly and supportive environment for the employees.
Handling critical situation and come up with instant solution.
Other requirements of the position (mental and physical factor): The candidates
have to be mentally and physically fit for the job because they may have to visit other
branches for inspection.
Knowledge and experience required:
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Title of the job Age Qualification
First Assistant
General managerMax 55
Candidates are expected to take their
educational degrees from reputed
institutions.
Area of Education: Finance, Banking,
Economics or Accounting(CA/FCA/A
CMA/FCMA/MBA/BIBM).
Total experience of 22 years in relevant
field with 1 year in the post of
Additional Managing Director or
Deputy Managing Director.
CHAPTER-4
RECOMMENDATION & CONCLUSION
The job analysis data collected from Janata Bank is organized and full of information. Janata
Bank has explained all the job duties and responsibilities and necessary requirements for
performing those duties in detailed manner. The tentative job analysis done by me is prepared
in a highly structured format which clarify the job description and specification. Hence, it
becomes so easy to understand that anyone can have a clear idea about the job just at a
glance. Whilst, the Job Analysis of Janata Bank is prepared in a descriptive way which may
take more time to be understood.
In my job analysis I have suggested the delegation of authority from which an employee can
easily understand ones autonomy and limitations in the job. Besides, I have also suggested
the position number which illustrates the chain of command inside the department; and the
required years of experience which provides a clear direction of an employee’s career
development.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Conclusion:
In conclusion, after visiting Janata Bank and collecting their Job Analysis report I have
realized that HR prospects in Bangladesh are gradually increasing and developing as well.
According to my observation, the HR activities of Janata Bank are more structured than I
have expected. But my suggested Job Analysis is organized and easily understandable. Some
significant differences between the real scenario and my suggestion might be recognized as I
have followed the theoretical direction based on my prediction. However, I think and hope I
have successfully assumed the factors accurately in preparing this Job Analysis.
Reference & Bibliography:
Performance Appraisal and sample appraisal templates and 360 degrees appraisals,
http://www.businessballs.com/performanceappraisals.htm
Introduction to Performance Appraisal,
http://www.performance-appraisal.com/intro.htm
Performance Appraisal – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Performance_appraisal
Job Analysis - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job_analysis
Job Analysis – Definition of Job analysis
http://humanresources.about.com/od/jobdescriptions/g/job_analysis.htm
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
PART 2
JOB EVALUATION
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
CHAPTER-1
CONCEPT REVIEW
i) MEANING OF JOB EVALUATION:
Job evaluation is the process of systematically determining a relative internal value of a job in
an organization. In all cases the idea is to evaluate the job, not the person doing it. Job
evaluation is the process of determining the worth of one job in relation to that of the other
jobs in a company so that a fair and equitable wage and salary system can be established. Job
evaluation is a practical technique, designed to enable trained and experienced staff to judge
the size of one job relative to others. It does not directly determine pay levels, but will
establish the basis for an internal ranking of jobs.
ii) PRINCIPLES OF JOB EVALUATION:
1. Clearly defined and identifiable jobs must exist. These jobs will be accurately
described in an agreed job description.
2. All jobs in an organization will be evaluated using an agreed job evaluation scheme.
3. Job evaluators will need to gain a thorough understanding of the job
4. Job evaluation is concerned with jobs, not people. It is not the person that is being
evaluated.
5. The job is assessed as if it were being carried out in a fully competent and acceptable
manner.
6. Job evaluation is based on judgment and is not scientific. However if applied correctly
it can enable objective judgments to be made.
7. It is possible to make a judgment about a job's contribution relative to other jobs in an
organization.
8. The real test of the evaluation results is their acceptability to all participants.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
9. Job evaluation can aid organizational problem solving as it highlights duplication of
tasks and gaps between jobs and functions.
iii) OBJECTIVES OF JOB EVALUATION INCLUDE:
The main objectives of job-evaluation are as follows:
1. Job evaluation is used to determine the relative worth of every job. Relative wages
may be fixed on the basis of an objective evaluation and comparison.
2. It establishes the general wage level, which could be comparable with factories
nearby.
3. It provides a basis for ranking different jobs.
4. The relative worth and wage-structure of a new job may be easily established in
comparison with the established jobs.
5. It helps in establishing line of authority, responsibility and accountability.
6. It provides a sound basis for wage negotiation. It reduces grievances of workers due
to improper wages. It eliminates wage inequality within the organization.
7. Job evaluation is useful in the selection and recruitment process, as skill match with
job profile may be achieved.
8. It is helpful in achieving cordial relations between management and union.
9. It provides a base for on-job training and orientation programs.
iv) METHODS OF JOB EVALUATION:
Ranking
Classification
Point Method
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Factor Comparison
Market Comparison
v) FACTORS IN JOB EVALUATION:
Job evaluators often assess jobs based on these factors:
1. Training level or qualifications requirements
2. Knowledge and skills requirements
3. Complexity of tasks
4. Interaction with various levels of the organization
5. Problem-solving and independent judgment
6. Accountability and responsibility
7. Decision-making authority
8. Degree of supervision required
9. Cross-training requirements
10. Working conditions
11. Degree of difficulty in filling job
vi) JOB EVALUATION METHODS IN ELABORATION:
A. RANKING
Ranking jobs is the easiest, fastest, and least expensive approach to job evaluation. It is also
most effective in smaller organizations with few job classifications. To rank positions, order
jobs from highest to lowest based on their relative value to your organization.
The process of job ranking typically assigns more value to jobs that require managerial or
technical competencies. More value is also assigned to jobs that supervise, exercise decision-
making authority, or rely on independent judgment. For example, a job-ranking system might
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
rank the job of CEO as the most valued job within the organization and the job of product
assembler as the least valued.
Advantages: Simplicity is the main advantage in using a ranking system. It is also
easy to communicate the results to employees, and it is easy to understand.
Disadvantages Ranking jobs is subjective. Jobs are evaluated, and their value and
complexity are often assessed on the basis of opinion. Also, when creating a new job,
existing jobs must be reranked to accommodate the new position.
B. CLASSIFICATION
The general purpose of job classification is to create and maintain pay grades for comparable
work across your organization.
To conduct a job classification: First, write descriptions for a category of jobs; next, develop
standards for each job category by describing the key characteristics of those jobs in the
category; finally, match all jobs to the categories based on the similarity of tasks, the
decision-making exercised, and the job's contribution to the organization's overall goals.
Universities, government employers and agencies, and other large organizations with limited
resources typically use job classification systems. These types of organizations have many
types of jobs at diverse locations and must maintain equitable and fair standards across all
work settings.
Advantage Job classification is simple once you establish your categories. You can
assign new jobs and jobs with changing responsibilities within the existing system.
Disadvantages Job classification is subjective, so jobs mightfall into several
categories. Decisions rely on the judgment of the job evaluator. Job evaluators must
evaluate jobs carefully because similar titles might describe different jobs from
different work sites.
C. POINT EVALUATION
Point evaluation is the most widely used job evaluation method. In a point evaluation system,
you express the value of a particular job in monetary terms. You first identify compensable
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
factors that a group of jobs possess. Based on these factors, you assign points that
numerically represent the description and range of the job.
Examples of compensable factors are skills required, level of decision-making authority,
number of reporting staff members, and working conditions.
Advantage This method is often viewed as less biased than other methods because
the job evaluator assigns each job's total points before the compensable factors
become part of the equation.
Disadvantages Subjective decisions about compensable factors and the associated
points assigned might be dominate. The job evaluator must be aware of biases and
ensure that they are not represented in points assigned to jobs that are traditionally
held by minority and female employees.
D. FACTOR COMPARISON
Job evaluators rank jobs that have similar responsibilities and tasks according to points
assigned to compensable factors. The evaluators then analyze jobs in the external labor
market to establish the market rate for such factors. Jobs across the organization are then
compared to the benchmark jobs according to the market rate of each job's compensable
factors to determine job salaries.
Advantage This method results in customized job-ranking.
Disadvantage Compensable factor comparison is a time-consuming and subjective
process.
E. MARKET COMPARISON
Job evaluators compare compensation for your organization's jobs to the market rate for
similar jobs. This method requires accurate market-pricing surveys.
It is to be mentioned that this is the most widely used method in today’s time in Bangladesh.
CHAPTER-2
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
GRAMEENPHONE LTD.
Grameenphone is now the leading telecommunications service provider in the country with
more than 23 million subscribers as of December 2009.Presently, there are about 50 million
telephone users in the country, of which, a little over one million are fixed-phone users and
the rest mobile phone subscribers. Starting its operations on March 26, 1997, the
Independence Day of Bangladesh, Grameenphone has come a long way. It is a joint venture
enterprise between Telenor (55.8%), the largest telecommunications service provider in
Norway with mobile phone operations in 12 other countries, and Grameen Telecom
Corporation (34.2% ), a non-profit sister concern of the internationally acclaimed micro-
credit pioneer Grameen Bank. The other 10% shares belong to 10% to general retail and
institutional investors.
Over the years, Grameenphone has always been a pioneer in introducing new products and
services in the local market. GP was the first company to introduce GSM technology in
Bangladesh when it launched its services in March 1997.The technological know-how and
managerial expertise of Telenor has been instrumental in setting up such an international
standard mobile phone operation in Bangladesh. Being one of the pioneers in developing the
GSM service in Europe, Telenor has also helped to transfer this knowledge to the local
employees over the years.
CHAPTER-3
FINDINGS OF THE STUDY
i) GRAMEENPHONE’S GENERAL POLICY:
Compensation is what an employee receives in exchange for his/her physical and mental
works, and contribution to the company. Compensation does not represent only salary but a
wide range of benefits and service are part of the total compensation package. Grameenphone
wishes to pay rewarding and competitive salaries to attract, retain and motivate competent
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
and skilled employees at all levels of the Company. By rewarding and competitive salaries it
means that each employee should be rewarded in accordance with:
1. What the post requires,
2. How skilled the employee is and
3. What the market pays for work of the same type.
Grameenphone wishes to design a compensation system that has strong positive impact on
employees and ultimately on the Company's performance. Keeping Company's strategic
objectives and unique characteristics and environment in mind, Grameenphone determines a
number of criteria for designing a compensation system. The criteria are:
i. Internal and external Equity: Internal equity means that there should have fairness of
the pay structure within the Company i.e. similar jobs get similar pays. External
equity assures that jobs are fairly compensated in comparison with similar jobs in the
job market. To achieve internal equity, periodic job evaluation that assesses the
relative worth of jobs throughout the Company should be conducted. On the other
hand, to achieve external equity, periodic market survey and cost of living adjustment
should be taken into account.
ii. Competitiveness: There are obvious affect of market forces on compensation.
Compensation must respond to the supply of and demand for employees in the market
since employers compete for work force.
iii. Cash and non cash benefits: Cash payment motivates employees through monetary
rewards such as salary and allowances. The Company pays cash benefits according to
ability to pay. Non cash benefits such as job security and making the job interesting is
also taken into account.
iv. Performance based pay: Employee productivity, skills and performance are also
important determinants of the compensation system of the Company.
v. Consistency: All-out efforts are made to ensure that compensation system is
consistent with HR policies and it is uniform and stable.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Grameenphone wants a salary system which rewards qualification, good practice and
performance. During fixation of employee's salary, Grameenphone looks at the following
criteria:
Company's affordability to proposed salary level
Competitive pay in the market for similar job
Growth of the Company
Individual's economic welfare
Fairness and equity
There are number of ways Grameenphone fixes employees salary. They are:
1) During appointment through salary negotiation. The salary for the new hires will be
fixed based on the position level, the applicant’s qualification, skills, experiences and
the budgetary provision,
2) Year end inflation adjustment with the basic salary,
3) Salary adjustment during confirmation, based on performance,
4) Due to revision of salary structure, an employee’s salary will be adjusted in such a
way that the new salary shall not be less than his/her current salary.
5) For a promotion to higher Grade, employee will occupy the step of the upper grade in
such a way that one receives an increased salary not less than his/her one step
increment at the current grade.
Hence, according to the information provided above we can come to a conclusion that
Grameenphone uses market comparison method to evaluate job.
Regardless of what workplace studies reveal, working is about compensation. Working can
be about much more, too, but the bottom line for people is that their work must pay their
bills. Employees desire reasonable, viable, and market-responsive salaries. Compensation is
the visible demonstration that an employee's work is valued. Consequently, effective
compensation is one of an employer's most important and powerful communication tools.
ii) JOB EVALUATION METHOD FOLLOWED IN GRAMEENPHONE:
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Employees desire reasonable, viable, and market-responsive salaries. Compensation is the
visible demonstration that an employee's work is valued. Consequently, effective
compensation is one of an employer's most important and powerful communication tools.
Grameenphone uses market comparison method. It studies salary surveys and other market
data to determine pay ranges. Because a key factor in employee retention is satisfaction with
pay, this figure should serve as a signal to employers that they need to conduct market pay
studies and communicate the results to their employees. Market pay is the compensation paid
for a specific job, including information about bonuses and benefits that is determined by a
continual analysis of the competitive job market. Increasingly, with data so readily available,
potential candidates and internal employees are negotiating their salaries armed with
knowledge of market pay data. As an employer, Grameenphone is prepared to respond.
Market pay data is a part of their organization's overall strategy to determine equitable
compensation. Otherwise an organization might not remain competitive.
Effective market pay studies also help Grameenphone in several studies:
1. Carry out your compensation philosophy (above market, below market, and at
market).
2. Attract talented employees.
3. Negotiate fair compensation with candidates.
4. Control compensation costs.
5. Communicate the rationale for salary grades and ranges.
6. Improve employee satisfaction through fair compensation practices.
7. Improve interaction with and trust in management.
To accomplish these results, Grameenphone creates and maintains an effective market pay
measurement system, and is knowledgeable about how to integrate salary surveys into its
company's compensation philosophy and practices. Market pay studies are critical for
establishing equitable and fair compensation within an organization. Attracting and retaining
superior employees for ones jobs is critical to ones success as a business, particularly as
demographic changes (such as population aging) create a more competitive job market
because there are fewer candidates. Organization cannot afford to let the market pass it by.
An effective market pay study is the answer which Grameenphone follows.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Therefore, the value that is assign to jobs in organization's compensation system should be
driven by the most up-to-date information about market pay. Practical market pay data can be
obtained which includes information about salary, benefits, and bonuses, from a continual
analysis of the competitive job market.
Grameenphone incorporated strategic work valuation in structuring pay. Strategic work
valuation emphasizes both the market pay rate for the job and the value of the job to the
organization in which the valuation factors are specific to its organization. These valuation
factors measure the impact of each job in its organization's success.
By considering all these factors Grameenphone prepares its pay structure. In addition to using
market comparison method of job evaluation it also has its internal classification of job.
iii) TOTAL COMPENSATION IN GRAMEENPHONE:
The features of Grameenphone’s Pay structure are stated below:
1. Grameenphone maintains a degree of fairness between the pay allocated to jobs
having different level of skill, responsibility and experience.
2. Each step salary (other than step 1 salary) in any grade is calculated by adding a
certain fixed amount with the previous step salary. The fixed amount may vary
between grades.
3. Employees move upward in the steps will reflect the good performance, increased
skills, work related knowledge and/or years of work with Grameenphone.
4. The salary structure will be reviewed after every three years in September.
For a complete month, one month basic salary applies but for fractional period, pro-rata basic
is calculated by dividing basic into 30 days as set standard.
In a number of situations, Grameenphone deducts basic salary of the employee. They are:
1. Deduction due to absence without proper authorization
2. Deductions for damage to or loss of property/goods expressly entrusted to the
employee for custody; or loss of money for which he/she is required to account,
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
where such damage or loss of money is directly attributable to his/her neglect or
default.
3. Deductions for adjustment of advances or overpayment, if any
4. Deduction of income tax payable by the employee and
5. Employee's provident fund.
For better convenience, the total compensation of Grameenphone is divided into three
categories and they are as follows:
1) Basic pay
2) Fringe benefit
3) Incentives
iv) BASIC PAY:
Basic salary is an important part of employee's salary. It is paid monthly with other
admissible allowances such as house rent, medical allowance, and transportation allowances
in applicable cases. Grameenphone provides salaries to its regular and contract staff
according to Grade and Salary Matrix of the Company. The Grade and Salary Matrix of
Grameenphone is composed of 13 classified grades and under each grade there are 10 salary
steps. The Pay Structure for Grameenphone employees represents the salary level of the
company. Each grade has salary ranges and the fixation of basic salary during appointment,
confirmation or annual appraisal completely depends on the discretion of management. The
salary structure is kept strictly confidential and not shared with employees or outside except
authorized officials.
v) FRINGE BENEFIT:
Fringe benefits are compensations made to an employee beyond the regular benefit of being
paid for their work. It is not related to performance. Following are the fringe benefits
provided by Grameenphone:
PROVIDENT FUND
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
The permanent employees of the Company are eligible to become members of the Provident
Fund. Employee contributes 10% of their basic to the provident fund and the Company
makes equal contribution to the fund. The Company's contribution starts once the employee
has become permanent employee of the Company.
A Provident Fund Trustee, with separate rules, is formed for managing the provident fund.
The PF maturity period is three years. Employee has to serve minimum three years for being
eligible for both employee and company contribution.
GRATUITY
Gratuity is paid to an employee for providing a life time service to the Company. The
eligibility is minimum five- year service with the Company.
Gratuity amounts are linked with the respective employee's length of service which are as
follows:
Gratuity Years of Service
@ 1 month's basic/for each year 5 years
@ 1.5 month's basic/for each year 5 Years to 10 Years
@ 2 month's basic/for each year More than 10 years
Gratuity is equivalent to one (or more as the case may be) month's basic based on the last
drawn basic salary for every completed year of service or for any part thereof in excess of six
months.
HOUSE RENT
House rent is another component of pay structure. The amount of housing allowance is
expected to allow employees to rent a reasonable but standard house. To the extent possible,
a fair level of consistency between house rent and the respective employee's living standard is
ensured. The company expects that employees rent a standard house.
The housing allowance is calculated at a certain percentage of respective employee's basic
salary. The percentage is equal irrespective of employee's place of posting. If an employee
joins or leaves the Company on a day other than the beginning of a calendar month, then
his/her housing for that month will be calculated fractionally by dividing house rent by 30
days as set standard.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
MEDICAL ALLOWANCE
Medical allowance is paid to the employee at a fixed amount and the monthly payment is
made according to their position entitlement. This medical allowance is in addition to
hospitalization or on duty accident benefits, if any.
EMPLOYEE TRANSPORTATION BENEFIT
Grameenphone provides transport benefits to all employees as per the following guidelines &
procedures. For administration purposes of this employee benefit, the Transport Section and
the Transport Policy will be applicable.
It is essential that all employees use the transport benefits as specified in this policy as per
rules and guidelines described herein. For local travel outside office on official purpose, the
employee will be reimbursed actual travel costs. In this regard, employees should claim
reasonable transportation costs.
For all employees in the Manager & below level, a lump-sum amount of Tk. 100 can be
claimed as transportation allowance for each way travel to office in a weekly holiday or other
holiday in case transport could not be provided even after request is made. Such request
should be made by 30 minutes prior to end time of normal office hours of the last day of the
week. It is essential that by no means divisional vehicle be used for employee pick & drop.
The allowance for travel to office in a weekend or holiday will be claimed by using
prescribed allowances format duly endorsed by immediate supervisor and approved by
Department/Divisional Head.
TRANSPORT BENEFIT FOR EMPLOYEES OF DM LEVEL AND BELOW
If opted for, employees in DM and below level will get pick-up and drop services to and from
convenient places near to their respective residence for arriving and departing from office.
However, on exceptional cases, operational employees might be given pick up and drop to
and from home and technical sites by on-call divisional vehicles as per the policy guidelines
for such vehicles. Such pick up and drop services will be arranged by Grameenphone vehicle
or hired vehicle.
Route for pick & drop services shall be determined as per the actual need of the employees
and in accordance to road condition by the Transport Section. Employees are discouraged to
frequently change the route plan. Employees on board such vehicle are not authorized to
change the pre-determined route or to influence drivers or fellow employees to do the same.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Employees shall be given the option of choosing between Transport Allowance and Pick &
Drop service by filling a prescribed format.
In case of new employees, the declaration of his/her choice for availing the transport service
or claiming allowance will be taken at joining. Based on option, new employees will be paid
transportation allowance effective from the date as mentioned in the prescribed format. This
will also be applicable for transferred/promoted employees.
Once the option has been given, employees will not be able to change their choice within the
next three months, unless employee has been transferred or has medical reasons supported by
documentation from registered physician. Employees opting for Pick & Drop service shall be
issued with a Transport Pass, which needs to be returned should the employee intend to
switch the option after the specified three months or at the time of separation from
employment. The option will be effective from the first day of a month. Therefore, the
employee will communicate their choice of option at least 10 days before the beginning of
the month.
Transport Section will monitor the use of transport facility being used by the employee in a
particular route. Partial Allowance and One-way pick & drop service is not allowable.
Employees with transport pass who require working beyond normal office hours will be
given staff drop by company pool vehicle at specified time on pre-determined routes. All late
hour drops after dusk will be provided up to the nearest point of the employees’ home.
Employees with transport pass who requires to work beyond normal office hours need to
inform Transport Section in timely manner through their supervisor enabling transport
section to organize necessary number of vehicles for such drop. Part-time and contractual
employees will be allowed to use drop facilities as per the Transport Administration
Guideline.
CAR SCHEME OPTION FOR DGM LEVEL EMPLOYEES
Under this scheme, company will finance to support all confirmed employees in the DGM
level to have their own transport for personal convenience and safer mode of transport.
Types of Car: Employees can purchase new or unregistered reconditioned cars as specified in
Appendix-Car Scheme.
Value Ceiling: The maximum car value will be as per specifications laid down in Appendix-
Car Scheme.
Employee’s contribution: Individual employees availing the car scheme will have to bear 1/3
(one third) of the total cost of the car.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Insurance and Registration Costs: The Insurance and registration costs of the car will be
borne by the company.
Inspection of Reconditioned cars: Reconditioned cars may be purchased within the value
ceiling specified in Appendix-Car Scheme. Purchase of Reconditioned cars will be subject to
inspection procedures and engine analysis as per company specifications in a reputed
workshop designated by the Company. The Company’s decision as to whether a
reconditioned car meets the inspection standards will be final.
Fuel and Maintenance Allowance: All fuel, maintenance, repair, servicing, and replacement
of parts and/or similar costs will be provided as per Appendix-Car Scheme.
Alternative: If an employee does not avail the scheme, he will be entitled to an allowance of
Tk. 23,000/month instead of Tk. 11,500 to maintain his personal transport or have self
arrangement.
Applicable Conditions: To avail this scheme, an employee will have to sign a surety bond to
serve the company for 5 (five) years. In case the company has made full payment of the
company part for the purchase of the car, and the employee leaves the company before
completion of 5 years, pro-rata deduction based on the company provided amount will be
made from the employee’s final settlement amount and the individual will take the car. All
costs relating to the transfer of ownership of the car shall be borne by the individual.
After completion of the 5 years, the ownership of the vehicle will be transferred to the
employee and he/she will be eligible to apply for the Car Scheme again.
On Promotion: If the employee gets promoted to AGM during/before the expiry of the
scheme; the company will pay the remaining balance of the total amount and take ownership
of the vehicle. The employee will continue using the car with full support and at the end of
the remaining period of the five years term he/she will own the car.
LATE WORKING HOURS AND REPRESENTATION ALLOWANCE
Manager (including DM) and above level of employees are permitted to claim entertainment
allowance of Tk. 200 per day for working three or more hours of work in excess of their
normal working hours.
TRANSPORT BENEFIT FOR AGM AND ABOVE
For employees in the AGM and above level, Grameenphone will provide company vehicles
as per the following entitlement table, guidelines and regulations –
`
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Designatio
n
Engine Volume(CC) Vehicle
Maintenanc
e and other
expense
Maximu
m Fuel
Allowanc
e (litre)
Max OT
Allowanc
e for
Drivers
Driver
Allowanc
e
New Recondition
AGM1300 1500 By GP 250 100 Hrs
Actual as
per
Company
Policy
GM 1500 Up to 1800 By GP 250 100 Hrs
Actual as
per
Company
Policy
DD
2500
Nissa
n X-
Trail
Not
Applicable
By GP 300 100 Hrs
Actual as
per
Company
Policy
Director 3500 Not
Applicable
By GP Actual Actual
Actual as
per
Company
Policy
If the vehicle plies outside the respective city area for official purpose, the fuel consumed
extra will be allotted based on that vehicle’s average fuel consumption rate. If the vehicle
runs on CNG limit of CNG will be equivalent value of the fuel cost. Grameenphone will
arrange the drivers for these vehicles with the consent of the concerned employee. No spare
driver is possible to be provided for these drivers going on leave.
On resignation of an employee entitled for personal vehicle, the particular assigned vehicle
will be under the custody of Administration department. Management will decide as to the
use of the vehicle thereafter.
Car specified according to each designation can be rented by GP for employee’s use until the
car is purchased and allotted to the particular employee. Car purchased/issued shall be
replaced after five years. The car shall be retained by the user (for AGM & GM level) if it has
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
been used by them for a period of five years. If the employee leaves the company before the
time period, the used vehicle shall be sent back to Transport Pool for Transport Section to
dispose of the vehicle as per the Asset Disposal Guideline of Grameenphone.
If an AGM is promoted to GM, he/she will continue using the same car for five years from
the date of first issue/purchase. If a GM/DD is promoted to a higher tier of the organization,
he/she will continue using the car till authorized car as per his/her new hierarchy is provided
to him/her. Upon receiving the authorized vehicle according to his/her new designation, the
old car shall be retained by Transport Pool to be reissued/disposed off.
TRANSPORT BENEFIT FOR MANAGERS AND DGMS
Managers/DGM level employees are provided with door-to-door pick-up and drop services
with Company vehicle. However, they too can claim for transport allowance instead of
pickup & drop as per their entitlement. Employees in Manager/DGM level will get pick up &
drop by the common pool vehicles designated for them. Should the road condition of the
residence of Manager / DGM deters vehicles to provide door-to-door service, such service
shall be rendered to the nearest point of the residence of the Manager/DGM.
Divisional/Department transport cannot be used for pick up drop when common pick up drop
service is available. However on exceptional cases in emergency operational requirement an
employee in Manager/DGM level can be picked up from his/her residence to the site and
dropped back to his residence by the department’s vehicle. This practice cannot be made on a
regular basis.
Transport section, in accordance with the user shall determine the route for Managerial pick
& drop. Managers/DGMs who fail to avail their regular drop service at the end of the work
require taking common late-drop. For such arrangement, concerned Manager/DGM needs to
inform Transport Section for their arrangement. If anyone wants to leave early due to
personal reasons, s/he will not get the drop facility except emergency.
OVERTIME
Overtime is defined as “hours worked beyond normal working hours” that has prior approval
from department / section head.
Statement of principle: Company expects that employees shall have proper work plan.
Disorganized or unplanned work habit that necessitates extra hours to work is discouraged. In
case of emergency, employees may require working beyond normal working hours for a short
duration as approved by department /section heads.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Overtime Policy: Employees in officer level or below are eligible for claiming overtime
allowances. Normally overtime is calculated at the double of basic salary on standard
working hours (208 hours a month). The hourly overtime rate is calculated as under:
Hourly rate = (Monthly basic X 2) /176
However, for working from 10 PM to 6 AM, 3 times basic salary will be applicable.
Normally overtime will not exceed 30 hours in a month. In exceptional cases, second level
supervisor of an employee can approve overtime beyond the limit of 30 hours.
As a standard, overtime will be claimed by using a prescribed format wherein the date, time
must be mentioned. The overtime claim must be endorsed by immediate supervisor and
approved by Department/Divisional Head before submission. Overtime shall not apply in
case of outstation travel or attending any training program.
For contractual employees, a monthly overtime allowances will be applicable according to
following slabs:
Extra hours Amount
10 - 19 hours Tk. 1000
20 - 29 hours Tk. 2000
30 - 39 hours Tk. 3000
40 - 49 hours Tk. 4000
50 - 59 hours Tk. 5000
60 hours and above Tk. 6000
SHIFT ALLOWANCE
Shift allowance is paid to managers and below level employees who work in a shift other
than normal working hours of 8 AM to 5 PM.
The shift allowance is paid by hourly rate. There are different rates for different established
shift jobs. Respective department can define shift hours according to own convenience but
payment will be made as per the following table:
Shifts Duration Rate per hour
General Shift 8 a.m.-5 p.m. ---
Evening Shift 4 p.m.-12 a.m. 30
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Night Shift 12 a.m.-8 a.m. 45
Holiday Shift Any time 40
Shift allowance is also applicable for contract employees at the above rate. Shift allowance
will not be more than Tk. 4500 in a month. In case someone’s shift duty falls in 2 defined
shifts then pro rata allowances will apply. For example, for working in shifts from 2 PM to 11
PM, shift allowance will be calculated according to the following principle:
2 PM to 5 PM : No shift allowance
5 PM to 11 PM : 6 hours shift allowance @ 30 per hour
When shift time ends, and employee has to work further, he/she will be compensated for the
additional hours served by either overtime (for officers and below) or extra hour allowance
(for DM/DSE, Managers/SE or equivalent positions) as the case may be. But during the
defined shift hours, no overtime or extra hour allowance will apply.
Each employee is required to submit a monthly statement to Finance in prescribed allowances
format. The statement must be endorsed by immediate supervisor and approved by the
Department/Divisional Head. In case of roaster duty pre-approvals have to be made by the
divisional heads mentioning actual hours with no major deviations. The statement is prepared
within the end of the month and the deadline for submitting the statement to Finance is 15 th of
the following month.
O N CALL ALLOWANCE
On Call Allowance will be applicable for all regular or contract employees in manager grade
and below who may remain standby (on call duty) for emergency services to be provided for
the interest of the Company. This is Company's policy to compensate those employees for
their extra hardship. The On Call Allowance rate is Tk.250 per day. Such allowance is
approved in addition to overtime allowance paid to the employee.
On Call Allowance cannot be more than 15 days in a month. At the end of each month, an On
Call Allowance statement of each employee has to be submitted to Finance upon
endorsement of immediate supervisor and approval of Department/Divisional Head.
BONUS
All employees are eligible for two bonuses in a calendar year which is an amount equivalent
to their two months basic salary.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
One bonus is paid during Eid-ul-Fitr at a flat rate to all employees irrespective of the religion.
Another bonus is paid as per the following festival of different religious affiliation:
Muslim : Eid-ul-Azha
Hindu : Durga Puja
Buddhist : Buddha Purnima
Christian : Merry Christmas
Two month's basic as bonus is paid in full for a calendar year or a pro-rata amount for
incomplete calendar year, whichever may be the case. The bonus will be paid according to
the basic that is due on the festival day, not the basic on the payment day.
An example: An employee who joins on April 1 and if there are two festival in that calendar
year, then the employee will get fractional festival bonus according to the following formula:
Bonus = (2 months basic x days with the Company) / 365
HR will prepare the bonus list prior to three weeks time of Eid-ul-Fitr and the respective
festival day and Accounts, based on the list, will arrange to transfer bonus amount two weeks
ahead to employee's account.
An employee who joins after festival date will be paid bonus after the end of the year. If an
employee leaves the Company on any day preceding to the festival bonus payment date for
whatsoever reasons other than retirement, his/her festival bonus will not be paid.
EDUCATIONAL GRANT
An employee can avail Educational grant for pursuing higher studies in a discipline related to
current responsibilities or in an area where he has future career aspirations. This will enable
him/her to have personal development and better contribute to the business.
Eligibility: Employees at any level having two year or more service length with
Grameenphone will be eligible for the Educational grant.
Details of the Grant: Grameenphone will bear up to 75% of the total course fee, not
exceeding Tk. 350,000. The total number of grants will not exceed 40 per year.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
The grant will be disbursed as reimbursement of the course fee per period/semester.
Course Criteria: Employees will be allowed to pursue higher studies beyond working hours
that is related to his particular profession. Educational grant will not be applicable for any
certificate course. The grant will apply for in-country courses. An employee will be allowed
to receive the grant for only one course at a time. After the completion of the course, he/she
may apply for another grant. However, first time applicants will be given preference.
Conditions: To sustain eligibility for the Educational grant, an employee must maintain at
least an average standard in each semester/period throughout his course. In case his
CGPA/class falls below the above mentioned standard, he/she will not be reimbursed for that
particular semester/period. An employee availing the Education Grant will sign an agreement
to serve the company for 2 years from the date of completion of the course. The employee
will submit a formal letter from the Educational Institute clearly mentioning the date of
completion of the course. In case of separation from the company before the 2 years term,
proportionate cost considering the 2 year period will be deducted from his final settlement
amount. In case the employee discontinues the course, or is separated from the company
during the course, full amount will be deducted from the final payment.
CHILDREN EDUCATION ALLOWANCE
Children education assistance is an allowance to share employees’ children’s educational
expenses. All confirmed employees will be eligible to avail children educational benefit
according to the following entitlement structure –
Level Entitlement (maximum per child per month)
Assistant - Officer Tk 1000
DM - Manager Tk 2000
DGM - AGM Tk 3000
GM - Deputy Director Tk 4000
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
To avail the children education assistance, an employee must declare and record his/her
child’s information and submit an attested/certified copy of the birth certificate of the child to
HR. The amount will be paid out with the monthly salary of the employee. An employee can
avail this benefit for all of his/her school going children below 18 years of age. For both the
parents working in Grameenphone, only one claim will be allowed. The children education
benefit will be effective from March 2006.
LONG SERVICE AWARD
An employee on completion of 5 years as of March 26 each year will be acknowledged for
his/her contribution to the company. The employee will receive a gift within an amount of
Tk. 30,000 for completing 5 years at the Long Service Award giving Ceremony organized by
HR. Those completing the 5 year tenure after March in any particular year will be entitled
for the award in the subsequent year.
HARD FURNISHING
Hard Furnishing is an incentive given to employees to assist improvement in their lives by
buying durable household goods such as A/C, Freezer, TV, Home Theater Systems, Stereo
Systems, Washing Machine, Kitchen Appliances, and Furniture etc. All confirmed employees
in Manager and above level will be eligible to avail Hard Furnishing according to the
following entitlement structure –
Level Entitlement
Manager Tk 200,000/-
DGM Tk 250,000/-
AGM Tk 300,000/-
GM Tk 350,000/-
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Deputy Director Tk 400,000/-
Payout of Hard Furnishing will be made on a reimbursement basis upon submission of the
payment vouchers of the goods purchased by the employee. An employee will be eligible to
avail Hard Furnishing once in every 3 years. Payout of the amount desired by the employee
availing the benefit will be done by one go. If an employee avails an amount lower than his
maximum entitlement, he/she will not be able to avail his/her remaining balance.
Once availed, the employee has to serve the company for 3 years from the date of
disbursement of the amount. This 3 years period will be effective for any employee even if
he/she avails lower than his maximum entitlement amount. If he/she is separated from the
company before completing the 3 years period, pro-rata deduction on the basis of his/her
amount availed will be made from his/her final settlement amount.
EMPLOYEE MOBILE PHONE
Grameenphone provides mobile phone to all employees that facilitates our work and
establishes communication between employees and family. In regard to the use of mobile
phone, there are a number of guidelines that every employee has to follow strictly.
Type of set: Employees will get company decided handset along with connection as part of
their package. In case different handset is required for technical use or special features are to
be incorporated in handset, it will be against divisional budget and respective Directors will
approve of such handsets.
1. For r egular employee : Company approved handsets will be provided to all regular
employees for a 2 year term. After 2 years new handsets will be issued.
2. For Contract employees : The handsets will be given to those contractual
employees (based on requirement) whose agreement is for at least 1 year and the cost
would be deducted from respective divisional budget. However, in case of business
requirements, lesser duration may be considered. For resignation cases, same policy
applies as of regular employee.
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
3. For Consultant (local & foreign) : The respective department/division will provide
handset to consultants, based on requirement, from divisional budget. If any
consultant wishes a handset for their family members they would buy the handset in
their own.
4. For driver & support staff : The handsets would be issued by the third party through
agreement. GP will pay bill up to certain limit.
5. For BR employee : Respective division will handle new issue, loss and theft cases of
BR employees according to their divisional budget/policies.
Employees should be more responsible for the safeguarding of handsets provided by the
company.
Tariff Rate: Employee Mobile Phone Tariff Rate under GP Account will be as under (except
BR employee):
1 second pulse,
GP employee to GP employee: FREE,
GP employee to any other GP number: Tk. 2/min (both peak & off peak),
GP employee to other operators: Existing rate applies.
Mobile usage limit: Company will bear phone bill up to certain limit for different level of
employees. The limits are:
Level Limit
Director Tk.10,000
DD/GM//AGM/DGM/Manager or equivalent
positions
Tk. 5,000
DM/Officer/Assistant or equivalent positions Tk. 3,000
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Support staff, Drivers Tk. 1,500
Respective Division will decide mobile usages limit for contract employees/ consultants in
line with the above usages limit policy.
ACCIDENT BENEFIT
In the event, an employee regular or contract, meets an accident while in working hours, in
the workplace, and during carrying out work, the employee will be reimbursed 100% of all
legitimate expenses in respect to such accident. “On duty” means that the employee has been
in the course of discharging official assignment which is attributable to the pursuit of work
objectives. If an accident occurs at a time when the employee travels from residence to office
but has not yet reached duty station or on his/her way to residence from the office, accident
benefits will not apply.
The reimbursement in respect to accident benefits is contingent upon submission of the
following: A requesting memo from the concerned department stating the nature of injury
(internal or external) resulting from accident on duty. Doctor’s prescription and all supporting
vouchers in original form Discharge certificate from the hospital/clinic, if admitted.
The expenses include:
1. Doctor’s consultation fee in respect to accident
2. All medicine costs supported by Doctor’s prescriptions
3. All pathological tests fees in respect to accident
4. Hospital rents during hospitalization, if any
5. Operation charges, if any
6. Any other expenses relating to accident
The concerned Departmental Head will recommend such expenses and will forward medical
bill to HR for approval.
ACCIDENTAL DISABLEMENT
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
When an employee becomes disable resulting from accident Grameenphone, depending
on the nature of disability, will make every endeavor to provide alternative suitable
employment for the employee. In such case, Grameenphone will extend possible support
to the employee in the form of monetary assistance. This payment depends on the
duration of the disability and the benefit provisions are covered under insurance policy of
Grameenphone.
DEATH BENEFIT
If a confirmed employee dies under normal circumstances, the Company will pay twenty four
month’s gross salary to the legal heirs of the deceased. If an employee dies by accident while
on duty, the legal heirs will be paid 24 month’s gross salary by Insurance Company.
Death benefits will not apply if death is caused by suicide, during taking part in political
activities or by criminal prosecution.
vi) INCENTIVES:
Grameenphone adjusts employee's salary in a number of situations. This is one type of
benefit being offered to the deserving employees with a view to recognizing their best
services rendered to the Company and thus keep their morale high. Regarding approval of
Increment, Company's discretion is vital. Obviously, the basis is performance and any other
relevant factors that the company deems fit to be given due consideration.
PERFORMANCE INCREMENT
An employee will receive salary increment in case he/she demonstrates excellent
performance throughout the performance year and is recommended for increment by
immediate supervisor according to Performance Appraisal Process of the Company.
INCREMENT DURING CONFIRMATION
At the time of confirmation, salary increment may be approved by HR Director based on the
recommendation of Director/ Divisional Head. The concerned Head/Director proposes for
increment with proper justification and HR Director, upon review of the justification, finally
approves increment during confirmation. This type of increment may be considered for
excellent performance during probationary period.
EXTRA HOUR ALLOWANCE
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
Extra Hour Allowance will be applicable for the following managers in case they work extra
30 hours or more in a month:
DM/DSE or equivalent positions: Tk. 6000
Manager/SE or equivalent positions: Tk. 8000
The Extra Hour Allowance will be claimed upon submitting prescribed allowances form duly
endorsed by immediate supervisor and approved by Department/Divisional.
CHAPTER-4
CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATION
Job evaluation is a powerful tool in the compensation and benefits specialist's repertoire.
Effective job evaluation helps to gather information to develop job descriptions that meet the
changing needs of an organization. By implementing a successful job evaluation, an
organization can develop an equitable compensation plan and attract and retain high-
performing and talented employees.
Compensation is what an employee receives in exchange for his/her physical and mental
works, and contribution to the company. Compensation does not represent only salary but a
wide range of benefits and service are part of the total compensation package. Grameenphone
wishes to pay rewarding and competitive salaries to attract, retain and motivate competent
and skilled employees at all levels of the Company. By rewarding and competitive salaries
we mean that each employee should be rewarded in accordance with:
What the post requires,
How skilled the employee is and
What the market pays for work of the same type.
Grameenphone believes that regardless of what workplace studies reveal, working is about
compensation. Working can be about much more, too, but the bottom line for people is that
22
Job Analysis & Job Evaluation August 3, 2010
their work must pay their bills. Employees desire reasonable, viable, and market-responsive
salaries. Compensation is the visible demonstration that an employee's work is valued.
Consequently, effective compensation is one of an employer's most important and powerful
communication tools that Grameenphone demonstrates very well by paying the most
competitive and highest remuneration to the employees as compared to the other telecom
operators. However, the only recommendation for Grameenphone is to reduce the call rate as
it also disturbs the employees.