is it wrong to design a baby?. gattaca in gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility...

32
Is it wrong to design a baby? Is it wrong to design a baby?

Upload: godwin-bond

Post on 18-Dec-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

Is it wrong to design a Is it wrong to design a baby?baby?

Page 2: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

GATTACAGATTACA

In In GattacaGattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility ’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's [heroic] struggle to realize his dream strikes a blow [heroic] struggle to realize his dream strikes a blow against the status quo on behalf of the human spirit – against the status quo on behalf of the human spirit – for which, as is observed in the film, there is no gene.”for which, as is observed in the film, there is no gene.”

John A. WoodcockJohn A. Woodcock,

NYU School of Medical Humanities DatabaseNYU School of Medical Humanities Database http://endeavor.med.nyu.edu/lit-med/lit-med-db/webdocs/webfilms/gattaca96-film-.html

Page 3: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

The most unremarkable of events.The most unremarkable of events.

Page 4: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

The most unremarkable of events.The most unremarkable of events.

Page 5: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

The most unremarkable of events.The most unremarkable of events.

V O:O: This highly prestigious This highly prestigious assignment assignment was guaranteed was guaranteed Jerome at birth. Jerome at birth. He has all the He has all the gifts required. A gifts required. A genetic genetic quotient second to none. quotient second to none. There’s There’s nothing remarkable about nothing remarkable about the the progress of Jerome Morrow.progress of Jerome Morrow.• What is the irony of this VO introduction? • How does it establish the film’s central

theme of the human spirit’s victory over genetic determinism?

The The most unremarkablemost unremarkable of events. of events.

Page 6: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

IntertextualityIntertextuality

• Several of GATTACA’s Sci Fi and film noir elements are borrowed from earlier films.

Page 7: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

IntertextualityIntertextuality

• Several of GATTACA’s Sci Fi and film noir elements are borrowed from earlier films: 2001 – A Space Oddyssey

Page 8: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

IntertextualityIntertextuality

• Several of GATTACA’s Sci Fi and film noir elements are borrowed from earlier films: Blade Runner

Page 9: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

INTRICATE VISUAL INTRICATE VISUAL SYMBOLISMSYMBOLISM

Page 10: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 11: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 12: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 13: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 14: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 15: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 16: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 17: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 18: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 19: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 20: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

Film NoirFilm Noir• Film noir is a movie genre

marked by cynical characters and a mood of menace and fatalism.

• The term [black film] was applied by French critics to describe American thriller or detective movies in the 1940’s, which used B&W film stock (because it was cheaper than colour) and whose themes reflected a social pessimism, largely as a result of WW2.

• What are its double meanings?

Page 21: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

GATTACA NoirGATTACA Noir

• What features does GATTACA borrow from the genre of film noir ?

Page 22: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

IntertextualityIntertextuality

• What does Niccol’s reference to Alfred Hitchcock’s 1951 Noir classic Strangers on a Train lend to his film?

Page 23: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

IntertextualityIntertextuality

• What does Niccol’s reference to Alfred Hitchcock’s 1951 Noir classic Strangers on a Train lend to his film?

Page 24: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

CHAPTER 11CHAPTER 11

• LOVE IN PARALLEL:– WHAT DO EUGENE AND IRENE HAVE IN

COMMON?

Page 25: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

CHAPTER 11CHAPTER 11

• LOVE IN PARALLEL:– WHAT DO EUGENE AND IRENE HAVE IN COMMON?– (APART FROM ‘HOMOSOCIAL DESIRE’)

Page 26: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's
Page 27: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

““MIND FORG’D MANACLES”MIND FORG’D MANACLES”

Page 28: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

CHAPTER 20CHAPTER 20

Page 29: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

DOPPLEGANGERS & SIBLING RIVALRYDOPPLEGANGERS & SIBLING RIVALRY

“I got the better end of the deal. I only lent you my body; you lent me your dream”

Page 30: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

DOPPLEGANGERS & SIBLING RIVALRYDOPPLEGANGERS & SIBLING RIVALRY

Page 31: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

DOPPLEGANGERS & SIBLING RIVALRYDOPPLEGANGERS & SIBLING RIVALRY

Page 32: Is it wrong to design a baby?. GATTACA In Gattaca’s dystopian society, “physical perfectibility has, ironically, led to an obsession with flaws. Vincent's

DOPPLEGANGERS & SIBLING RIVALRYDOPPLEGANGERS & SIBLING RIVALRY