international mkt pri
DESCRIPTION
international market prioritizationTRANSCRIPT
-
International Market Analysis:Market Prioritization
March 2013Discussion Document
CONFIDENTIAL AND PROPRIETARYAny use of this material without specific permission of McKinsey & Company is strictly prohibited
-
McKinsey & Company | 1
To develop a prioritization of international market opportunities, we leveraged a diverse set of experts, data sources, and statistics
Conduct deep dives to finalize prioritization and identify ~4 priority Cessna markets
Refine full list to countries that matter and develop initial clustering
Collect initial fleet size data and projections on all markets
12 3
Sources used
McK aviation experts 3 Asia experts 2 Latin America expert 1 Middle East expert 2 Europe expert
Global aviation experts Bus Dev Leader, global OEM
(China, India, Brazil, EU) Sales Lead, global OEM
(Africa, Australia, Middle East, Brazil)
OEM market advisor (Brazil, China, India, Russia)
Jet purchase advisor for corps HNW (EU, Brazil, India, Russia)
Experts Fleet size Historical fleet growth (%) GDP growth Corporate profits HNWI projections Airport infrastructure Credit rating Fleet penetration rates Competitor market share Jet class segmentation Market environment index
Statistics ACAS global fleet data World Economic Forum International Monetary
Fund Credit Suisse Wealth
Report S&P credit ratings OneSource corporation
data Bombardier market
forecasts JetNet market forecast Embraer market forecast IHS Global Insight Teal database
Databases
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 2
Our approach started with the 163 countries with general aviation and focused on 9 market clusters of interest
SOURCE: ACAS; McKinsey analysis
Approach Outputs
4 Evaluated each clusters economics and general aviation environment to prioritize, e.g., GDP, HNWI population, # of corporations Current fleet size, expected growth Competitive position Aviation infrastructure, political / regulatory
support
Prioritized clusters of interest High opportunity: Brazil, C. Europe Growth options: China/HK, India,
Turkey, E. Europe, Russia/CIS, Indonesia, Saudi/UAE
Aggregated neighboring countries selected in step 2 to create market clusters (added small neighboring countries with similar economic characteristics to develop core market clusters)
3 Created 19 clusters (anchored around the 27 countries selected in the prior step, and adding in select small neighboring countries (e.g., Switzerland added to C. Europe group)
Excluded countries with 2012 low fleet size (< than 50)
2 27 countries selected, 137 markets excluded, (examples of excluded countries: Guatemala [24 business jets], Iran [19 business jets])
Start with all the countries listed in ACAS database
1 163 total countries
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 3
19 international clusters represent >85% of near-term international sales opportunity
In the Americas, growth is expected to be dominated by Brazil
Middle East opportunity is concentrated in a few countries
Asia expected to sustain growth momentum in a few key countries
Europes growth is driven primarily by Central Europe
Other ME 36
Lebanon &Jordan 55
Saudi Arabia &UAE 122
Other Asia 227
Indonesia 120
India 194
Australia 203
China 226
Other Amer. 207
Mexico 189
Venez., Argent., Colom. 258
Canada 317
Brazil 593
Other E. Eur. 79
N. Europe 86
Turkey 109
Russia/CIS 148
S. Europe 152
CR, Pol.,& Slovak. 183
UK 218
C. Europe 652
Africa is fragmented and has limited prospectsNigeria, Kenya, & Tanz.
115
South Africa
Other Africa
94
102
77%
83%63%
95%
87%
Figures represent average annual addressable market opportunity1 in $, million
1 Proxy forecast. method: For business jets, allocated 3 regional growth forecasts to 2012 addressable base (business jets < 15 seats and light turboprops) to determine growth through 2017. Then distributed expected regional growth across countries according to each countrys absolute fleet growth as % of region total. For turboprops, took historical 5 year CAGR by country and projected forward as growth. Adjusted from expert interviews.
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 4
Cessna may benefit from new sales approaches targeted at select high-value and high-growth markets with unique challenges
Nigeria,Kenya,Tanzania
N. Europe
Mexico
1
0
Expected market opportunity2$ millions, per annum
700650600550500450400350300
Indonesia
India
Czech Rep., Poland, & Slovakia
China & Hong Kong
Canada
C. Europe
Brazil
Australia
Environmental supportCategorization
5
250200150100
4
0
Jordan & Lebanon
S. Arabia & UAE
Venez., Arg., Colom.
UK
50
South Africa
3
2
S. Europe
Russia & CIS
Turkey
Unstable political conditions or market environment
1 =
Limited infrastructure and / or high corrup-tion, stable market
2 =
Supportive infra-structure and political support, but concerns
3 =
Good infrastructure and govt support; select inefficiencies
4 =
Environmental support
Robust infrastructure, very supportive government (e.g., US)
5 =
Bubble Size represents fleet value estimate in 20121
1 Estimated market value of existing addressable fleet per country. Addressable fleet Includes bizjets
-
McKinsey & Company | 5
We propose prioritizing the high value and growth option market clusters
Environmental support
543210
Expected market opportunity8006004002000
C. Europe
Brazil
Environmental support
543210
Expected market opportunity8006004002000
S. Arabia/UAETurkey
Russia Indonesia
India
Czech Rep
China
Expected market opportunity800
3210
6004002000
UK
S. Europe
Mexico
CanadaAustralia
Environmental support
54
Environmental support
32
5
10
4
Expected market opportunity8006004002000
Jordan, Lebanon
Venez., Argent., Colombia
Nigeria, Kenya, Tanz.
High opportunity prioritized High growth markets prioritized
Highest market opportunity ($600-650M / year)
Immense fleet base (1200+) Highly developed
infrastructure with supportive governments
Serve as anchor to other markets with lower value (e.g., N. Europe, Mexico)
Stable markets de-prioritized
Mid-sized market opportunities ($125-250M) with very high annual growth (10-20%)
Small-medium fleet base (typically 100-200)
New customers, opportunities to become established player in large future market
Very low penetration relative to US (e.g., China and India have 2-15% US corp penetration); potentially great upside
Political and infrastructure development may create opportunities for immense growth if well positioned
Mid-sized opportunities ($150-300M) with low growth (3-4%)
Large existing fleet (400-1000) All mature markets with
established competition Cessna already has leading
position in all of these markets for jets, often 35%+ share
Most markets (exception Mexico) likely similar segmentation to US
High risk markets de-prioritized
Typically small markets (
-
McKinsey & Company | 6
Even within groups, markets significantly differ on fleet size, market potential, Cessna position, and environment
222
Venez., Arg., Colomb. 930N. Europe 266South Africa 423S. Europe 525Mexico 916
Australia 488
United Kingdom 443Canada 1,008Turkey
Nigeria, Kenya, Tanz.
Indonesia 104
Saudi Arabia & UAE 113Russia & CIS 107Czech, Pol., & Slovak. 107India 199China & Hong Kong 136Brazil 1,391
C. Europe 1,368
Jordan & Lebanon 32
91
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P
14
21
43
32
34
38
21
39
30
37
31
21
9
8
61
23
13
44
44
23
9
5
4
4
3
3
8
6
4
11
21
17
20
19
10
19
7
5
Environ. Support(1-5)
Addressable fleet size(# jets, props)
Cessna Share(jets %)
Forecast fleet growth (%)
78
78
17
13
25
8
17
34
15
23
25
72
29
37
8
11
60
20
13
Cessna Share (prop %)
Variation in growth scenarios
Penetration per 1,000Corps.
65
44
11
92
11
74
860
188
260
120
n/a270
n/a
534
n/an/a
1.565
133
521
Medium
Low
HighMedium
Medium
Medium
Medium
Medium
Medium
Low
Low
Low
Low
Medium
Low
Medium
Medium
Medium
Medium
4
4
2
3
2
2
3
2
3
5
4
5
4
4
4
4
1
1
1
Highest opportun.
Stable
Growth option
Low value
High risk
1 Proxy forecast. method: Allocated Bombardier, JetNet IQ, and Embraer regional growth CAGR to 2012 base to determine growth through 2017. Then distributed expected regional growth across countries according to each countrys absolute fleet growth as % of regional total. Averaged across 3 forecasts. Assumed average cost of business jet at $9.5M and average cost of turbo-prop at $3M.
2 Business jet projected fleet discounted to account for portion of jets that are large, defined as >15 seats.
55
148
183
194
226
593
652
102
258
86
94
152
189
203
218
317
109
120
122
Forecast annual growth($ mil)2
Light / Mid-size bizjets Light TPs
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 7
C. Europe, Brazil, China, and India present large opportunities for CessnaInitial insights on priority markets
High value markets
Group Country
High growth markets
C. Europe
Brazil
Central Europe has immense fleet (~1,300), with nearly 80% in Germany, Austria, and France
Corporate and HWNI penetration only 10-20% of US, presenting growth opportunities; likely not reach US levels (competitive infra., regulatory issues)
Growth from light and mid-sized business jet purchases, to access emerging markets (e.g., Asia, Eastern Europe)
Brazil has highest penetration of HNWI and corporations due to cultural norms, lack of competitive infrastructure, and supportive reg. environment, which should support further penetration as customers increase (2x HNWI by 2017)
Business jet growth driven by companies pursuing regional expansion, and HNW families living abroad
High turboprop growth driven by HNWI ranchers, who commute to urban centers from remote ranches with private runways
China
India
Chinas relatively small fleet (140) has seen 30% growth in recent years, driven by strong economics (9% GDP, doubling of HNWI and corp profits)
Chinas regulatory environment constrain growth (corporate penetration at 2% of US): airspace restrictions, flight planning delays, and infra. limitations
Explosive growth could occur in mid- to long-term with reforms to regulatory environment and continued investment in infrastructure
Mid-sized fleet (200) has relatively high penetration (20% of US corp), due to broad geography, lack of competing infrastructure, and govt support
Globalizing companies and geographically dispersed HNWI expected to drive continued demand for business jets (12% p.a.)
While select bureaucracy may inhibit efficiency, continued government reforms (FDI openness in Sept 2012) and investment should enable growth
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, Expert interviews
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 8
These priority markets have significantly different demographics and customer base from US, and may require a different sales approach
India
1,241
China
1,344
Brazil
197
C. Europe
156
US
312
Country Population# millions
GDP Growth% CAGR (2013-17)
HNWI# (000s), income > $1M
Large Corps.# (000s), rev. > $100M
8%9%4%2%3%
IndiaChinaBrazilC. EuropeUS
India
158
China
1,056
Brazil
227
C. Europe
3,747
US
11,023
India
2
China
13
Brazil
3
C. Europe
14
US
35
SOURCE: World Bank, Credit Suisse, OneSource
China and India have nearly 4x US population
Brazil, China, and India have higher 1.5-3x expected GDP growth than US, from lower base
India, China, and Brazil have only 2-10% of the HNWI of the US; due to lower income (India, China) and inequal wealth distribution (Brazil)
China has similar number of corporations as US and Europe (though many state-owned enterprises)
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 9
In addition, fleet size and penetration is generally lower than the US, which could drive market growth
1991361,3911,068
18,487
IndiaChinaBrazilC. EuropeUS
1.30.1
6.1
0.31.7
IndiaChinaBrazilC. EuropeUS
92.310.8
533.6
73.8
523.4
US C. Europe IndiaBrazil China
SOURCE: World Bank, Credit Suisse, OneSource
US leads world in fleet size; Brazil is second with only 7% of US fleet
C. Europe penetration of HNWI and corps only 10-20% of US
Brazil has highest fleet penetration of HNWI in world; corp. penetration in line with US
India HNWI penetration is ~60% of US, though corporate penetration is only ~20%; both HNWI and corps expected to double in 5 years
Chinas penetration of HNWI and corporations is lower than any peers (only 2-5% of US)
Total Fleet Size (2012)#
Fleet Penetration of HNWI# per 1,000 HNWI
Fleet Penetration of Large Corps.# per 1,000 Large Corps
-
McKinsey & Company | 10
Central Europe offers growth from increasing customer base and focus on emerging markets, limited by cultural and political issues
Central Europe has immense fleet base (~1,300), with nearly 80% in Germany, Austria, and France
Corporate and HWNI penetration only 10-20% of US market, presenting further growth opportunities
Growth from light and mid-sized business jet purchases, to access emerging markets (e.g., Asia, Eastern Europe)
Additional growth in customer base: corporate profits (up 30% by 2017) and HNWI (up 60% by 2017)
Likely will not reach US penetration levels due to cultural and regulatory issues (e.g., 22% tax, high fees, airspace inefficiencies)
1
-
McKinsey & Company | 11
Central Europe expected to see stable growth from large base, though select regulatory constraints remain
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P
1 Based on 1-7 airport infrastructure score from World Economic Forum's Travel and Tourism Report. Factors include: overall quality of air infrastructure, airport density in the country, number of departures, and number of operating airlines
Deep dive to followPositive indicator
Negative indicatorNeutral indicator
Criteria Country assessment
Market opportunity
Supportive environment
Demand drivers
Current and forecast fleet
Govt/ Regulatory
Infra-structure
Addressable fleet size Light/med bizjets Light TP Piston engine
Forecast fleet growth Light/med bizjets Light TP
GDP growth forecast Corporate profits 5 year
growth HNWIs 5 year growth
Airport infra. rating1 Regional airport infra. MRO/FBO availability
Government stability and credit score
Airspace regulation
Tax incentives and fees
Financing availability
Large addressable fleet regional fleet nearly equivalent to Brazil
Moderate growth on large base Jet and turbo-prop growths are above GDP
Moderate GDP growth similar to developed world average Stable but increasing profits
High and growing number of HNWI
Robust airport infrastructure, but certain ATCinefficiencies and very high airport fees
High availability, but expensive higher fees than in US due to expensive land, labor, fuel, and high tax rates
Stable government
Supportive reg. within countries; inefficient handoff between country ATCs (e.g., multi-hour wait times)
High taxes and fees; no accelerated depreciation; high airspace-usage fees
Financing available
A
B
C
D
~750
Value
~500TBD
6% p.a.3% p.a.2% p.a.
30%
60%
4.5-5.5
AA- to AAA
15-25% VATTBD
HighGood
Select inefficiencies
1
-
McKinsey & Company | 12
Central Europe demand remains high, while Euro-crisis solvency has depressed demand in Northern and Southern Europe
Comparative view of European regions
SwitzerlandOther
BelgiumFranceAustria
Germany
N. Europe
86
S. Europe
152
UK
218
C. Europe
652
Year 1 market opportunity$, million
Credit Rating(S&P)
AA- to AAA AAA
BBB- to AAA
CCC+ to AAA
Recovering economies and significant base create opportunity
Weaker economy and Euro solven-cy concerns limit potential opportunity
Overall market drivers Pent-up demand since
financial crisis Lower corporate adoption
so far than US and lower penetration per capita provide room for growth
Robust airport infrastructure
Business jets drivers Access to Eastern
Europe, Russia/CIS, and select Asian countries will drive growth for mid-size models
Turbo-prop drivers May be used to fly to
countries with poor infrastructure (e.g., Eastern Europe)Corporations(rev. > $100M) ~15k ~10k ~4k~7k
Corp. Profits($) 2.4T ~975bn ~500bn~1.7T
SOURCE: S&P, OneSource, IHS Global Insight
1A
-
McKinsey & Company | 13
Select inefficiencies in the Western European aviation environment may keep it from reaching US levels of penetration
SOURCE: Expert interviews conducted by McKinsey team
Overview of BarrierBarrier
Competitive infrastructure
Most business hubs in EU are linked by direct commercial routes High speed trains (e.g., TGV) link key cities in UK, France, and Germany These alternatives reduce demand for small / mid-size jets
Cultural norms
Much lower cultural acceptance than US Jets are often portrayed as corporate misuse of funds Government actively discouraging jets to relieve congestion of airports
Higher cost / fees
Netjets estimates a 1.5-2.5x cost multiple over US flying cost Significant costs for airspace (fees >$100 / hour), airport fees, FBO
services, fuel, parking, labor (due to social taxes), etc.
Taxation / depreciation
VAT ranges from 15-25%, charged for flying within a country as well as maintenance, fuel, etc.
Typically amortize assets over 20 years, versus 5 years in the US
Inefficient ATCbetween countries
Handoffs between fragmented ATC centers cause multi-hour delays Limited access to major airports due to lower value proposition for airport Fees for flying across different airspaces based on aircrafts seats,
weight, distance traveled, countries in question, etc.
1D
-
McKinsey & Company | 14
Europe will likely continue along its recovery, but Euro crisis could reduce growth by ~3% per annum
Scenario
Base Scenario: Steady EU Recovery
Alt Scenario: EU Debt Crisis Occurs
Likelihood1
85-90%
10-15%
EU member countries recover as expected (1-2% GDP growth p.a. 2013-17)
Select interventions may be needed by stable EU countries (Germany) to support smaller ones (Spain, Portugal, Italy, Greece), but overall market grows
Over the next five years, corporate profits gradually increase (33%) as do HNWI (67%), enabling continued demand
5% fleet CAGR 2013-17
Description
EU debt crisis occurs, reducing government stability, financing, consumer confidence, and economic growth (-5-2% GDP growth p.a. 2013-2017)
Sovereign debt levels remain high relative to GDP and various EU countries are downgraded, affecting financing
Jet and turboprop demand falls to a similar growth rate as 2008-12 global financial crisis (1-2%)
2% fleet CAGR 2013-17182 190 199194186
4140393837
219
2017
239
2016
234
2015
229
2014
224
2013
Forecast annual growth ($ mil)2
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P, IH Global Insight, Credit Suisse
1 Based on varied analyst projections on Euro collapse scenario.2 Business jet projected fleet discounted to account for portion of jets that are large, defined as >15 seats.
519 553 589 628 669
61159
2013
57557
2017
73465
2016
69163
2015
65061
2014
Light / Mid-size bizjetsLight TPs1
-
McKinsey & Company | 15
Brazil offers a political and cultural environment supportive of private aviation, and the market is enhanced by strong economic growth
Brazil has second largest fleet in the world and highest penetration of HNWI and corporations due to cultural norms, lack of competitive infrastructure, and supportive environment
Customer base increasing immensely, with HWNI and corporate profits expected to double by 2017
High turboprop growth driven by HNWI ranchers, who commute to urban centers from remote ranches with private runways
Business jet growth driven by companies pursuing regional expansion, and HNW families living abroad
Developed airport infrastructure will be maintained by continued government investment (recent $7 billion in airport infra. project)
2
-
McKinsey & Company | 16
Brazil is a large market opportunity for Cessna with relatively low environmental risks for doing business
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P
Criteria Country assessment
Market opportunity
Supportive environment
Demand drivers
Current and forecast fleet
Govt/ Regulatory
Infra-structure
Addressable fleet size Light/med bizjets Light TP Piston engine
Forecast fleet growth Light/med bizjets Light TP
GDP growth forecast Corporate profits 5 year
growth HNWIs 5 year growth
Government stability and credit score
Airspace regulation
Tax incentives and fees
Financing availability
Very large fleet Brazil has the second largest fleet of business jets and turbo props in the world
High fleet growth - Across both business jets and turbo-props
Strong GDP Growth - double the US / EU GDP growth Very high corporate profits expected to double
Very high 800,000 millionaires expected in 2017
Developed regional airport infrastructure robust network of regional airports; HNWI have private runways
Good MRO availability - large regional airports have MROservices; select remote regions (e.g., Amazonias) do not
High political stability high government stability (BBB rating)
Efficient regulation open airspace, easy to register aircraft
Tax incentives / fees - TBD Financing availability - TBD
A
B
C
D
~700
Value
~700TBD
5% p.a.10% p.a.4% p.a.
~100%
~100%
3.91
BBB
TBD
TBD
Deep dive to followPositive indicator
Negative indicatorNeutral indicator
Good
Airport infra. rating1 Regional airport infra. MRO/FBO availability
Good
1 Based on 1-7 airport infrastructure score from World Economic Forum's Travel and Tourism Report. Factors include: overall quality of air infrastructure, airport density in the country, number of departures, and number of operating airlines
Supportive
2
-
McKinsey & Company | 17
As expected, the vast majority of aircraft are located in Sao Paulo and key business centers
000s
5713
75
Others
0
JetsTurboprops
Helicopters
Piston
% fleet by aircraft type
% fleet by aircraft primary use
6911
12 62
Instruction
Air TaxiPrivate Business Aviation
OthersAgriculture
SOURCE: ABAG Second Report of Brazilian Aviation (2012), EBACE (2011), team analysis
Number of aircraft registered by state (2011) 2011 fleet composition
2011 fleet composition
2A
-
McKinsey & Company | 18
Brazils business jet and turboprop markets have unique demand drivers that may create three specific segments
Brazilian turboprop growth from HNWIRegional trade drive business jets
SOURCE: Expert interviews, Credit Suisse Wealth Report (2012)
+17%
2017F
497
2012
227
2015142013
2
1
0201716
0.80.7 1.00.9 0.9
Light to medium jets demand by companies pursuing regional and intl expansion Jets use driven by regionally (e.g., Sao
Paulo, Rio) and international expanding (e.g., Argentina, Miami) companies
Light jets used for travel between major developed hubs (e.g., Sao Paulo and Rio)
Mid-sized jets for LatAm, US expansion Jets additionally used by HNWI commuting
to international homes Bifurcated society of extremely wealthy
families commuting for safety reasons; want discretion
Turboprops are significant focus for wealthy agriculture or ranch owners Agriculture in Brazil is a $100 billion / year
industry, and covers 400,000 sq mi, driving immense wealth in the country
Increasing turboprop demand from large ranchers and farmholders in remote areas of Brazil (e.g., Amazonias)
Ranchers often have makeshift runways to fly from their land to major cities (to meet with politicians, have social life)
Turboprops, unlike business jets, have ability to handle rougher infrastructure
Corporate profits$ million
High Net Worth Individualsthousands of millionaires
2B
-
McKinsey & Company | 19
Brazils government continues to support aviation and promote public and private infrastructure investments ($50-100B per year)
SOURCE: BMI, ABDIB; Team Analysis
32 43 4955 66 62
2426 34
3236 42
88
08
83
07
69
2006
56
+13% p.a.
2011
104
10
92
09
PublicPrivate
219
191
163
137
111
+18% p.a.
2016F15F14F13F2012F1
Brazil continues to increase investment in its infrastructureBrazils supportive aviation environment Developed infrastructure in cities and
relatively well developed support mechanisms Some congestion in Sao Paulo, but
not a restriction on growth Variation in degree of FBO / MRO
support at smaller regional airports; key markets supported
Supportive government promoting continued growth Relatively open airspace with
minimal restrictions on airspace Very easy to get planes certified
through Brazils regulatory body (Infraero)
Immense investments planned over next 5-10 years with increasing private partnerships
December 2012: Dilma Roussefannounced $7 bn investment to Brazilian regional airportinfrastructure and support
1 BMI industry definition of infrastructure (graph on the right) is more comprehensive than ABDIB (graph on the left)
2C
-
McKinsey & Company | 20
Chinas immense customer potential is artificially constrainedin short-term by government policies and infrastructure
Chinas relatively small fleet (140) has seen 30% growth in recent years, driven by strong economics
Driven continued economic growth (GDP 9%+), market drivers of HNWI and Corporate profits expected to double by 2017
Chinas political and regulatory environment constrains penetration in corporations (2% of US) and HNWI (5% of US)
Airspace restrictions, flight planning delays, and infrastructure inefficiencies may limit penetration in short-term
Explosive growth could occur in mid- to long-term with reformsto regulatory environment and investment in infrastructure
3
-
McKinsey & Company | 21
Chinas political environment and infrastructure are expected to continue to curtail growth of an otherwise robust economy
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P
Deep dive to followPositive indicator
Negative indicatorNeutral indicator
1 Based on 1-7 airport infrastructure score from World Economic Forum's Travel and Tourism Report. Factors include: overall quality of air infrastructure, airport density in the country, number of departures, and number of operating airlines
Criteria Country assessment
Market opportunity
Supportive environment
Value
Demand drivers
B Highest long-term GDP growth in world Very high and growing corporate profits
Very high 2M millionaires expected by 2017
9% p.a.
~75%
~100%
GDP growth forecast Corporate profits 5 year
growth HNWIs 5 year growth
Infra-structure
C Business jet infrastructure under developed regional airports inadequate; governmental investment expected
Limited FBO/MRO limited support at regional airports, and lack of aviation training among Chinese population
4.24
Govt/ Regulatory
D AA-
22%
Stable, military driven government stable government with strong fiscal position, but little transparency
Highly restrictive air regulation Immense airspace restriction, excessive delays on flight planning (1-6 days; no flexibility)
Very high taxes and restrictive ownership military restricts ownership and operation
Financing availability - TBD
TBD
Government stability and credit score
Airspace regulation
Tax incentivesand fees
Financing availability
Current and forecast fleet
A Small/medium fleet size China has only recently begun
developing its fleet, in part due to restrictive policies
Very high growth Chinas fleet should grow significantly from low base
~100~50TBD
15% p.a.
Addressable fleet size Light/med bizjets Light TP Piston engine
Forecast fleet growth Light/med bizjets Light TP 25% p.a.
Poor
Airport infra. rating1 Regional airport infra. MRO/FBO availability
Limited
Restrictive
3
-
McKinsey & Company | 22
Regulatory and infrastructure constraints detract from theattractiveness of owning business jets in China
Regulatory landscape
Infra-structure availability
US China
Unrestricted ownership Restricted private ownership of aircraft
Approval requires 30 min Flight plan approval requires 1-6 days on average (can be 1 month) minimal flexibility to change
Deregulated airspace Airspace is highly regulated by military; aviation body (CAAC1) controlled by military
Negligible tax only High tariffs (5% import tax + 17% VAT on AC)
No restrictions Domestic flight require Chinese aviators (shortage of trained pilots who fly internationally)
Wide network of both commercial and GA airports
Business jet infrastructure under developed; commercial more robust
Lack of robust MRO services; government investment to develop
Full MRO services
Current regulatory regime will likely prevent explosive growth
Significant pent up demand from HNWI, corporations, and politicians
Some a/c based and registered outside China (especially Hong Kong, Singapore)
SOURCE: Interviews; BCA; Press; team analysis
1 General Administration of Civil Aviation of China, charged with regulating China's airspace, overseeing civil aviation operators, and commercial airline flights
3C 3D
-
McKinsey & Company | 23
Foreign OEMs often required to leverage local JVs, while sharing IP to establish strong position in market
SOURCE: Interviews; Press releases
Overview
Benefits
Bombardier COMAC Deal Audi A6
Deal between Bombardier and COMAC re: C-series jet, signed in 2012 that enables Bombardier to gain deeper access to China
Goal to achieve gains in product development and cost efficiencies across C-Series and C919
Joint venture between FAW Group and Volkswagen, which began in 1988
Audi locally produced a Chinese version of the A6, which enabled it to rapidly penetrate Chinas premium car market
Bombardier co-developed designs with COMAC, sharing practices and technology regarding their C-Series model to increase commonalities
Audi sold ~400,000 Audi A6s in China in 2012 (a record high), 1/4 of Audis global sales, and 1/3 of Chinese premium car market
One fifth of Audi A6 sales were to governments
Challenges
Bombardier President Hachey cited the sharing of IP in this partnership as a major issue Bombardier had to consider
Concerns remain that local companies may use the IP to compete against Bombardier later
In early 2012, government announced preference for domestic cars to clamp down on waste
Demand shifted to BYD, Guangzhou, and others chosen by local government authorities
Domestic manufacturers may be using Audis IP, discovered from its local production
23 77Bombardier share 100 33 67
Audi marketshare 100
3D
-
McKinsey & Company | 24
Loosening of Chinas strict regulation aviation could increase demand by up to 20% per annum
Scenario
Base Scenario: Current aviation regulations
Alt Scenario: Loosening of aviation regulations
Likelihood1
90-95%
5-10%
Current government regulation uncertainty limits corporate jet purchases
Assumes tempered market growth, closely tied to GDP
Market underpenetrated due to regulatory restrictions
Similar to 2008-2012 overall fleet CAGR of 23% 19% fleet CAGR 2013-17
Description
Government opens airspace above 20,000 feet, loosens regulations, and makes allowance for corporations to purchase airplanes
SOEs follow US corporations purchasing behavior for jets (same number of jets per unit of revenue)
Market heavily penetrated with jets due to government endorsement, open airspace, and lower flight lead-times
40% fleet CAGR 2013-17 (double 2008-12)
Forecast annual growth ($ mil)2
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P, IH Global Insight, Credit Suisse
1 Based on interviews with experts regarding Chinas regulatory landscape.2 Business jet projected fleet discounted to account for portion of jets that are large, defined as >15 seats.3 Illustrative trajectory assuming loosening of restrictions at 2012 fleet size.
179156137120 101
80634939
2017
306204
2016
259
2015
219
2014
186
2013
158
Light / Mid-size bizjetsLight TPs
332 463 64890657
2017
1,485
1,266
219
2016
1,062157
2015
760112
2014
54480
20133
389
3D
-
McKinsey & Company | 25
Indias economic growth and strong environmental support should further drive demand for private aviation
Indias mid-sized fleet (200) has relatively high penetration (60% of US HNWI and 20% of US corp), due to broad geography, lack of competing infrastructure
Geographically dispersed HNW families, and globalizing companies driving demand for business jets (12% p.a.); both expected to increase 40-60% over next 5 years
Environmental drivers include government support (open skies) and developed regional airport infrastructure (built during WW2)
While select bureaucracy may inhibit efficiency, continued government reforms and investment should enable further growth
4
-
McKinsey & Company | 26
India has significant demand drivers expected to push growth, as well as supportive infrastructure and regulation
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P
Criteria Country assessment
Market opportunity
Supportive environment
Value
Second highest long-term GDP growth in world Very high and increasing corporate profits
Very high 240,000 millionaires expected by 2017
GDP growth forecast Corporate profits 5 year
growth HNWIs 5 year growth
8% p.a.
~60%
~100%
Demand drivers
B
Well-developed infrastructure regional airports developed during WW2; government is investing $5 billion during next few years on modernizing
MRO/FBO availability variable - remote airports have little support services, though India overall has many trained pilots and engineers
4.11
Infra-structure
C
Highly stable democratic country Stable international relations and economic growth; government subsidies increasing debt
Relatively de-regulated open sky Indian government poses little restrictions, though
High taxes, but reasonable fees India taxes aircraft 26%, but airport use fees are not excessive
Financing availability - TBD
Government stability and credit score
Airspace regulation
Tax incentives and fees
Financing availability
BBB-
26%TBD
Govt/ Regulatory
D
Mid-size fleet strong growth (17%) over last five years
Very high jet growth Indias fleet should grow significantly from low base, with strong (12% p.a.) jet growth; limited turboprop (~3%) growth
Addressable fleet size Light/med bizjets Light TP Piston engine
Forecast fleet growth Light/med bizjets Light TP
~100~100
TBD
12% p.a. 3% p.a.
Current and forecast fleet
A
Deep dive to followPositive indicator
Negative indicatorNeutral indicator
Variable
Airport infra. rating1 Regional airport infra. MRO/FBO availability
Good
1 Based on 1-7 airport infrastructure score from World Economic Forum's Travel and Tourism Report. Factors include: overall quality of air infrastructure, airport density in the country, number of departures, and number of operating airlines
Supportive
4
-
McKinsey & Company | 27
India has five key factors driving demand for private aviation
Robust economic growth increasing individual and corporate wealth: GDP growth ~8% on average throughout past decade (second to China, making it 10th largest economy); number of millionaires expected to double by 2016
1
Rail and road infrastructure fail to link Indias immense geography: India is the 7th largest country in the world (1.2 million sqmi), but no high speed rail systems linking cities, road infrastructure density is one of lowest in world
2
Well-developed regional airports and supportive government: During WWII, the British colonials build thousands of smaller airports across India for military purposes; government investing USD billions in modernization, and relative open sky policy
3
Indian corporations shift to regional and international expansion: India corporate profits expected to double in next 5 years; global corporations (looking to expand across India and beyond; expected to drive demand for small- to mid-range aircraft
4
Geographic dispersion of HNW families expected to drive private aircraft use: Indian familiar are often geographically dispersed across the country and abroad; HNW families increasingly Owner-Users with small/mid aircraft to maintain family ties
5
4B
SOURCE: Interviews; BCA; Press; team analysis
-
McKinsey & Company | 28
India has an overall supportive regulatory and infrastructure environment, with select constraints due to bureaucracy
SOURCE: Interviews; BCA; Press; team analysis
Chennai & Kolkata Airport upgrades (2006-13)
$1.2B
Delhi & Mumbai airport modernization (2006-13)
$5.0B
35 additional airport modernizations (2006-13)
$1.6B
Various airport Investments in single year (2008)
$1.5B
Flight plan approval for intl flights requires 1 business day
More flexible for flight plan changes than China
Airspace generally deregulated; government supportive of growth in private aviation
26% tax on imported ACIndia
Variable MRO services in India, though significant pilots and trained engineers
Paved airport infrastructure allows connectivity to main hubs only
GA face same delays as commercial airlines; have to go through same processes
Regulatory landscape
Infra-structure availability
Indian government continues to invest heavily in airport infrastructure:
Also, in September 2012, Indian government announced reforms opening aviation to private investment and privatization
4C 4D
-
McKinsey & Company | 29
Appendix: Additional Detail on Prioritized Markets
-
McKinsey & Company | 30
C. Europe Market View of Business Jet and Light Turboprop Markets
Avg age: 12
173259273
354
481
3117
+7% p.a.
+6% p.a.
2017F
1,142
5 89 3282 96
168
2012
831
1 3380
127
2007
633
0 20 333 3570 102 32 535
215 209 203133 186
26024
+3% p.a.+3% p.a.
2017F
632
0 00 519 3033 82
2012
537
1 0272864
2007
467
0 00 219 2450
3190
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; Embraer; JetNet
San Marino
Gibraltar
Monaco
Liechtenstein
Netherlands
Belgium
Switzerland
France
Austria
Germany
Business Jets
Light TurbopropsGermany
San Marino
Monaco
Gibraltar
Liechtenstein
Austria
Netherlands
Belgium
France
Switzerland
Avg age: 15
26
74
Heavy
Light/Medium
Business Jet Class (% of jets)
Business Jet Competitors (% of jets)
Light Turboprop Competitors (% of turbo-props)
6235813
4419
Other
Gulfstream AerospaceLearjetBombardier
Raytheon AircraftEmbraer
Dassault AviationCessna Top Model:
Citationjet
1158812
1331
13
OtherHawker BeechcraftPiperPilatusEmbraerSocataCessnaBeech Aircraft Corporation Top Model:
King Air B200
Historical and forecast growth Market characteristics
1
-
McKinsey & Company | 31
C. Europe Market View of Macroeconomic Growth and Drivers
0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
00
1
0
0
0
4
6
12
15
SwitzerlandFrance
Germany
Belgium
San MarinoMonaco
GibraltarLiechtenstein
Austria N/A
Netherlands
SOURCE: IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P; Credit Suisse;
1 WEF Ranking Factors include: overall quality of air infrastructure, airport density in the country, number of departures, and number of operating airlines
Infrastructure Index Score1World Economic Forum Index (1-7)
Training centers# of training centers, 2012
Market GDP Growth Forecasts % growth over prior year
Credit RatingS&P rating by country
Corporate Profit Forecasts$ billions
+10% p.a.
2017
5,979
2012
3,747
HNW individuals#, thousands
Corporations#, revenues > $100M
14,478
Germany AAAFrance AA+Switzerland AAABelgium AANetherlands AAAAustria AA+Liechtenstein AAAGibraltar N/AMonaco N/ASan Marino N/A
Germany 5.48France 5.5Switzerland 5.08Belgium 4.3Netherlands 4.99Austria 4.37Liechtenstein N/AGibraltar N/AMonaco N/ASan Marino N/A
Country Macroeconomic Environment
Country Macroeconomic Environment
Airport infrastructure
1
-
McKinsey & Company | 32
C. Europe Business jet market share by manufacturer and modelCompetitive Variance
SOURCE: ACAS
26%
9%
19%
19%
21%
8%
5%
9%
OtherEmbraerGulfstreamDassault
Bombardier
Cessna
C. Europe
3%
44%
US
2%
35%
Top-selling models
Top model: Citationjet
Top model: CL604
Top model: Falcon 50Top model: G550
Top model: Phenom 100
1.6%Dassault - Falcon 2000EX 1.8%Bombardier - Learjet 35A 1.8%Dassault - Falcon 7X 1.8%Cessna - Citation Sovere 1.8%Bombardier - Challenger 300 2.1%Cessna - Citation Bravo 2.2%Cessna - Citation II 2.2%Dassault - Falcon 2000 2.3%Cessna - Citation Excel 2.3%Cessna - CJ2+ 2.4%Cessna - Citation Mustang 2.4%Bombardier - Learjet 60 2.4%Dassault - Falcon 900EX 2.6%Dassault - Falcon 50 2.7%Cessna - Citation XLS 2.7%Bombardier - CL604
Gulfstream - G550
2.8%Cessna - CJ3 3.0%Cessna - CJ1 3.1%Cessna - CJ2 3.5%Cessna - Citationjet 5.5%
30Heavy1Light/Medium
70
Business jet segment (% of market)
1 Defined as >15 seats
53%Covered:
1
-
McKinsey & Company | 33
Competitive Variance
SOURCE: ACAS
11% 11%
8%
10%
12%
7%
13%
50%
36%
6%
8%
Other
Piper
Embraer
Pilatus
Cessna
Socata
Beech
C. Europe
13%
US
0%
16%
Top-selling models
Top model: King Air B200
Top model: TBM700A
Top model: CE208B
Top model: PC-12XII/45
Top model: EMB-121AA
2.8%Socata - TBM850 2.8%Reims - F406 3.4%Pilatus - PC-12 47E/NG 3.5%Socata - TBM700A 3.9%Beech - King Air C90 4.0%Beech - King Air 350 4.5%Beech - King Air C90B 4.5%Piper - PA-46-500TP Mer 5.1%Beech - King Air 200 5.5%Pilatus - PC-12XII/45 5.9%Cessna - CE208B 7.0%Beech - King Air B200 9.6%
Piaggio - P.180 1.6%Beech - King Air E90 1.7%Beech - King Air F90 1.7%Pilatus - PC-12XII/47 1.7%Cessna - CE208 2.1%
Beech - King Air C90A
2.1%Gulfstream - TurboCommander 2.1%Cessna - Conquest I
Embraer - EMB-121AA
Piaggio - P.180 Avanti 2 2.3%Socata - TBM700B 2.3%
2.2%
Top model: PA-46-500TP Mer
82%Covered:
C. Europe Business jet market share by manufacturer and model1
-
McKinsey & Company | 34
C. Europe Business Jets by Geography
Geneva
ParisVienna
Salzburg
Stuttgart
Zurich
>256-253-52
FranceLiechtensteinSwitzerland
Luxembourg
Belgium
Germany
Austria
1
SOURCE: AMSTAT
-
McKinsey & Company | 35
FranceLiechtensteinSwitzerland
Luxembourg
Belgium
Germany
Austria
Villacoublay
C. Europe Turbo-props by Geography
>256-253-52
1
SOURCE: AMSTAT
-
McKinsey & Company | 36
Brazil Market View of Business Jet and Light Turboprop Markets
7
93
Heavy
Light/Medium861680
299
+5% p.a.+18% p.a.
2017F20122007
1,126
711449
+10% p.a.
+10% p.a.
2017F20122007
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; Embraer; JetNet
Avg age:12
Avg age:18
Business Jets
Light Turboprops
Business Jet Class (% of jets)
Business Jet Competitors (% of jets)
Light Turboprop Competitors (% of turbo-props)8
2356
1517
44
OtherBombardierRaytheon AircraftDassault AviationBeech Aircraft CorporationEmbraerLearjetCessna Top Model:
Phenom 100
52337
1420
44
OtherRockwellPilatusMitsubishi Heavy IndustriesEmbraerHawker BeechcraftCessnaBeech Aircraft Corporation Top Model:
CE208B
Historical and forecast growth Market characteristics
2
-
McKinsey & Company | 37
Brazil Market View of Macroeconomic Growth and Drivers
SOURCE: IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P; Credit Suisse;
1 WEF Ranking Factors include: overall quality of air infrastructure, airport density in the country, number of departures, and number of operating airlines
Brazil: BBB Brazil 3.91
Infrastructure Index Score1World Economic Forum Index (1-7)
Training centers# of training centers, 2012
Market GDP Growth Forecasts % growth over prior year
Credit RatingS&P rating by country
012345
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
2012 2014 2016 2018
1,500
1,000
500
0
1BrazilCorporate Profit Forecasts$ billions
+17% p.a.
2017
497
2012
227
HNW individuals#, thousands
Corporations#, revenues > $100M
2,607
Country Macroeconomic Environment
Country Macroeconomic Environment
Airport infrastructure
2
-
McKinsey & Company | 38
Brazil Business jet market share by manufacturer and modelCompetitive Variance
SOURCE: ACAS
29%13%
9%
5%6%
19%17%
6%
15%
OtherDassaultBeechEmbraer
Bombardier
Cessna
Brazil
44%
US
2%
35%
Top-selling models
Top model: Citation Mustang
Top model: Learjet 35A
Top model: Phenom 100Top model: Beechjet 400A
Top model: Falcon 2000
2.7%
Cessna - Citation I 3.1%Embraer - Phenom 300 3.2%Cessna - Citationjet 3.3%Cessna - Citation II 3.6%Cessna - Citation Mustang 3.9%Bombardier - Learjet 35A 4.6%Embraer - Phenom 100 8.6%
Bombardier - Learjet 31ACessna - Citation Excel
2.4%Cessna - CJ2 2.5%
Cessna - Citation XCessna - CJ1 2.4%
2.4%
Cessna - CJ3
2.6%
Cessna - CJ2+ 1.7%Cessna - Citation Bravo 1.7%Cessna - Citation VII 1.8%
2.8%Beech - Beechjet 400A
Raytheon - 125-800XP 2.0%Beech - Hawker 400XP 2.0%Cessna - Citation XLS 2.1%BAe - 125-800B 2.2%Cessna - Citation Sovere 2.3%
7Heavy1
93 Light/Medium
Business jet segment (% of market)
1 Defined as >15 seats
64%Covered:
2
-
McKinsey & Company | 39
Brazil Turbo-prop market share by manufacturer and modelCompetitive Variance
SOURCE: ACAS
31%
11%
3%
50%59%
3%
7%
Brazil
20%
US
0%
16%
Other
MitsubishiEmbraer
Cessna
Beech
Top-selling models
Top model: King Air C90B
Top model: CE208B
Top model: EMB-121ATop model: MU-2 Marquise
1.7%
Beech - King Air 200 1.9%
Beech - King Air B200GT 2.2%
Embraer - EMB-121A1 2.9%
Gulfstream - TurboCommander 3.1%
Beech - King Air C90A 3.2%
Beech - King Air C90GT 3.8%
Beech - King Air C90GTi 4.2%
Mitsubishi - MU-2 Marquise
4.3%
Beech - King Air 350 4.7%
Beech - King Air F90 4.8%
Cessna - CE208 5.0%
Beech - King Air B200 6.0%
Beech - King Air C90 6.5%
Beech - King Air C90B 8.6%
Cessna - CE208B 18.5%
Embraer - EMB-121A
81%Covered:
2
-
McKinsey & Company | 40
Rio Grande do Sul
Rondnia
Amazonas
Roraima
Par
Amap
Tocantins
Maranho
Piau
Cear
Bahia
So Paulo
Paran
Mato Grosso do Sul
Mato Grosso
Gois
Rio Grande do Norte
Paraba
Pernambuco
Alagoas
Sergipe
Distrito FederalMinasGerais
Esprito Santo
Rio de Janeiro
Acre
Santa CatarinaOsascoSao Paulo
Belo Horizonte
Brasilia
Rio de Janeiro
>256-253-52
Brazil Business jets by geography2
SOURCE: AMSTAT
-
McKinsey & Company | 41
Rio Grande do Sul
Rondnia
Amazonas
Roraima
Par
Amap
Tocantins
Maranho
Piau
Cear
Bahia
So Paulo
Paran
Mato Grosso do Sul
Mato Grosso
Gois
Rio Grande do Norte
Paraba
Pernambuco
Alagoas
Sergipe
Distrito FederalMinasGerais
Esprito Santo
Rio de Janeiro
Acre
Santa Catarina
Belo Horizonte
Goiania Brasilia
OsascoSao Paulo
Brazil Turbo-props by geography
>256-253-52
2
SOURCE: AMSTAT
-
McKinsey & Company | 42
China & Hong Kong Market View of Business Jet and Light Turboprop Markets
Avg age: 671
13788
16
2012
+14% p.a.
+31% p.a.
2017F
171
34
2007
232 20
158104714
+27% p.a.
+28% p.a.
2017F
0
158
2012
48
2007
14
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; Embraer; JetNet
China, Hong Kong
China
Business Jets
Light Turboprops
Business Jet Class (% of jets)
China, Hong Kong
China
Avg age: 6
Heavy 66
Light/Medium
34
Business Jet Competitors (% of jets)
Light Turboprop Competitors (% of turbo-props)34488
OtherLearjetHawker BeechcraftDassault AviationIsrael Aircraft IndustriesCessna 13Bombardier 23Gulfstream Aerospace 35 Top Model:
G550
06
1760Cessna
Beech Aircraft Corporation17
PiaggioHawker Beechcraft
Other
Top Model:CE208B
Historical and forecast growth Market characteristics
3
-
McKinsey & Company | 43
China & Hong Kong Market View of Macroeconomic Growth and Drivers
China AA-China, Hong Kong AAA
China 4.24China, Hong Kong 5.1
02468
10
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
8,000
2,000
020172016201520142013
6,000
4,000
0
4
China, Hong Kong
China
SOURCE: IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P; Credit Suisse;
1 WEF Ranking Factors include: overall quality of air infrastructure, airport density in the country, number of departures, and number of operating airlines
Infrastructure Index Score1World Economic Forum Index (1-7)
Training centers# of training centers, 2012
Market GDP Growth Forecasts % growth over prior year
Credit RatingS&P rating by country
Corporate Profit Forecasts$ billions
1,056
+15% p.a.
2017
2,081
2012
HNW individuals#, thousands
Corporations#, revenues > $100M
12,572
Country Macroeconomic Environment
Country Macroeconomic Environment
Airport infrastructure
3
-
McKinsey & Company | 44
China Business jet market share by manufacturer and modelCompetitive Variance
SOURCE: ACAS
23%13%
9%8%
19%
23%
9%
35%
8%
Other
Israel AircraftDassault
Cessna
Bombardier
Gulfstream
China
13%
US
5%
35%
Top-selling models
Top model: G550
Top model: CL605
Top model: CJ1
Top model: Falcon 7XTop model: G200
Bombardier - Global Express 1.6%Beech - Hawker 900XP 1.6%Cessna - Citation XLS 1.6%Cessna - Citation II 1.9%Beech - Hawker 4000 1.9%Bombardier - Challenger 300 2.5%Bombardier - CL604 2.5%Gulfstream - Gulfstream V 2.5%Bombardier - Global XRS 2.5%Cessna - Citation Sovere 2.9%Dassault - Falcon 7X 3.2%Gulfstream - Gulfstream IV 3.2%Cessna - CJ1 3.8%Bombardier - Global 5000 3.8%Raytheon Aircraft - 125-800XP 3.8%Bombardier - CL605 6.7%Gulfstream - G450 9.5%Israel Aircraft - G200 11.1%Gulfstream - G550 16.2%
62Heavy1
Light/Medium38
Business jet segment (% of market)
1 Defined as >15 seats
Covered: 83%
3
-
McKinsey & Company | 45
China Turbo-prop market share by manufacturer and modelCompetitive Variance
SOURCE: ACAS
50%
33%
32%
6% OtherPiaggio
Beech
Cessna
China0%
60%
US
2%
16%
Top-selling models
Top model: CE208B
Top model: King Air C90GTx
Top model: P.180 Avanti 2Beech - King Air 350i 1.2%
Piaggio - P.180 1.2%
Beech - King Air 350ER 2.5%
Piaggio - P.180 Avanti 2 2.5%
Beech - King Air B200 3.7%
Beech - King Air 350 3.7%
Beech - King Air C90GTi 4.9%
Beech - King Air C90GTx 8.6%
Cessna - CE208 23.5%
Cessna - CE208B 48.1%
100%Covered:
3
-
McKinsey & Company | 46
>256-253-52
China Business jets by geography
Sichuan
Heilongjiang
Jilin
Liaoning
Hebei
Shandong
Fujian
Jiangxi
Anhui
Hubei
Hunan
GuangdongGuangxi
Shanghai
Henan
Shanxi
Hainan
InnerMongolia
Shaanxi
Ningxia
Gansu
Qinghai
Guizhou
Yunnan
Tibet
Xinjiang
Jiangsu
Zhejiang
Tianjin
Beijing
Chongqing
Beijing
3
SOURCE: AMSTAT
-
McKinsey & Company | 47
>256-253-52
ShanghaiSichuan
Heilongjiang
Jilin
Liaoning
Hebei
Shandong
Fujian
Jiangxi
Anhui
Hubei
Hunan
GuangdongGuangxi
Shanghai
Henan
Shanxi
Hainan
InnerMongolia
Shaanxi
Ningxia
Gansu
Qinghai
Guizhou
Yunnan
Tibet
Xinjiang
Jiangsu
Zhejiang
Tianjin
Beijing
Chongqing
China Turbo-props by geography3
SOURCE: AMSTAT
-
McKinsey & Company | 48
India Market View of Business Jet and Light Turboprop Markets
Heavy25
Light/Medium75
185
105
49
+12% p.a.
+17% p.a.
2017F20122007
1109480
+3% p.a.+3% p.a.
2017F20122007
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; Embraer; JetNet
Avg age:10
Avg age:12
Business Jets
Light Turboprops
Business Jet Class (% of jets)
Business Jet Competitors (% of jets)
Light Turboprop Competitors (% of turbo-props)
568
Other 14Israel Aircraft IndustriesLearjetRaytheon AircraftDassault Aviation 14Bombardier 14Hawker Beechcraft 16Cessna 23 Top Model:
Falcon 2000
0015911
OtherReimsNALPiaggioHawker BeechcraftCessnaPilatus 12Beech Aircraft Corporation 63Top Model:
King Air B200
Historical and forecast growth Market characteristics
4
-
McKinsey & Company | 49
India Market View of Macroeconomic Growth and Drivers
SOURCE: IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P; Credit Suisse;
1 WEF Ranking Factors include: overall quality of air infrastructure, airport density in the country, number of departures, and number of operating airlines
India: BBB- India: 4.11
Infrastructure Index Score1World Economic Forum Index (1-7)
Training centers# of training centers, 2012
Market GDP Growth Forecasts % growth over prior year
Credit RatingS&P rating by country
02468
10
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
20172016201520142013
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
0
5IndiaCorporate Profit Forecasts$ billions
242158
+9% p.a.
20172012
HNW individuals#, thousands
Corporations#, revenues > $100M
2,157
Country Macroeconomic Environment
Country Macroeconomic Environment
Airport infrastructure
4
-
McKinsey & Company | 50
India Business jet market share by manufacturer and modelCompetitive Variance
SOURCE: ACAS
27%19%
9% 14%
6%16%
19%
21%
8%
Other
Raytheon
Dassault
Beech
Bombardier
Cessna
India
23%
US
4%
35%
Top-selling models
Top model: CJ2
Top model: CL604
Top model: Hawker 850XP
Top model: Falcon 2000
Top model: 125-800XP
1.9%Gulfstream - Gulfstream III 1.9%Dassault - Falcon 2000LX 1.9%Bombardier - Global XRS 1.9%BAe - 125-700B 2.3%Beech - Hawker 400XP 2.3%Cessna - Citation XLS 2.3%Beech - Beechjet 400 2.3%Gulfstream - Gulfstream IV-S 2.3%Cessna - CJ2+ 2.3%Cessna - Citation II 2.8%Bombardier - Challenger 300 2.8%Cessna - Citation Excel 2.8%Israel Aircraft - G200 2.8%Raytheon - Premier IA 3.3%Bombardier - CL604 3.3%Embraer - Phenom 100 3.3%
Dassault - Falcon 900EX
4.2%Raytheon - 125-800XP 4.2%Beech - Hawker 900XP
Cessna - CJ2
Beech - Hawker 850XP 6.6%Dassault - Falcon 2000 7.5%
4.2%
Heavy1 25
Light/Medium75
Business jet segment (% of market)
1 Defined as >15 seats
Covered: 70%
4
-
McKinsey & Company | 51
India Turbo-prop market share by manufacturer and modelCompetitive Variance
SOURCE: ACAS
24%
10%
12%
50%
71%
6% Other
Cessna
Pilatus
Beech
India
11%
US
16%
Top-selling models
Top model: King Air B200
Top model: PC-12XII/45
Beech - King Air C90GT 0.6%Cessna - CE208 0.6%Reims - F406 0.6%Beech - King Air 250 0.6%Beech - King Air 300LW 0.6%Beech - King Air C90GTi 0.6%Pilatus - PC-12 47E/NG 0.6%Beech - King Air C90GTx 1.2%NAL - Saras 1.9%Beech - King Air B200GT 1.9%Pilatus - PC-12XII/47 1.9%Beech - King Air 200C 2.5%Piaggio - P.180 Avanti 2 3.1%Beech - King Air 350 5.0%Beech - King Air C90 6.2%Cessna - CE208B 6.2%Pilatus - PC-12XII/45 6.8%Beech - King Air C90A 8.1%Beech - King Air C90B 16.1%Beech - King Air B200 34.8%
Top model: CE208B
100%Covered:
4
-
McKinsey & Company | 52
Andaman & Nicobar Islands
Jammu andKashmir
HimachalPradesh
PunjabChandigarh
Uttarakhand
Haryana
DelhiRajasthan
Uttar Pradesh Bihar
Sikkim
Arunachal Pradesh
NagalandManipur
MizoramTripura
Meghalaya
Assam
West Bengal
Jharkhand
Orissa
Chhattisgarh
Madhya PradeshGujarat
Maharashtra
Andhra Pradesh
Karnataka
Lakshadweep
Kerala PuducherryTamil Nadu
Goa
New Delhi
Mumbai
>256-253-52
India Business jets by geography4
SOURCE: AMSTAT
-
McKinsey & Company | 53
India Turbo-props by geography
New Delhi
Andaman & Nicobar Islands
Jammu andKashmir
HimachalPradesh
PunjabChandigarh
Uttarakhand
Haryana
DelhiRajasthan
Uttar Pradesh Bihar
Sikkim
Arunachal Pradesh
NagalandManipur
MizoramTripura
Meghalaya
Assam
West Bengal
Jharkhand
Orissa
Chhattisgarh
Madhya PradeshGujarat
Maharashtra
Andhra Pradesh
Karnataka
Lakshadweep
Kerala PuducherryTamil Nadu
Goa
>256-253-52
4
SOURCE: AMSTAT
-
McKinsey & Company | 54
Appendix: Additional industry context and select data on pistons
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 55
Questions to be answered by worldwide segmentation
1 What are the priority international markets for Cessna to target? Which countries should Cessna target? What drivers and constraints (e.g., demographic, economic,
regulatory) can unlock or limit the market opportunity?
2 What are important customer needs within priority markets? Are foreign customers buying criteria and decision processes
significantly different than those in the US ? How can we segment customers (and size segments) to focus efforts? What is the market size and breakdown of key segments?
3 Which marketing and sales initiatives should Cessna focus on in global markets? Which initiatives will generate near-term sales opportunities? What local partners, relationships should Cessna consider in focusing
on underserved high value markets? How should Cessna prioritize and implement these new initiatives?
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 56
CAGR(2012-17)
7%
10%
4%
7%
3%
Global installed base of business jets by geography
Strong growth in international markets will make them increasingly important to Cessnas future
79%68% 66% 62%
11%15% 15% 16%
11% 11%9%
4%3%3%
4%4% 4%
2008
4%
2003
6%4%
2012
APACME & Africa
2017F
Europe
NAM
LATAM
SOURCE: JP Morgan; ACAS aircraft database, Bombadier, JetNetIQ, Embraer
Rest of world
NAM
Forecast
Business jet market continues to shift away from NAM. Similar trend occurring in turboprops.
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 57
In fact, Asia and Latin American regions constituted nearly 50% of the growth from 2008-12, driven by a few markets
100% = 2,317 jets2
New growth markets
Middle East & Africa
154(7%)Europe 262
(11%)
Asia 339(15%)
Latin America
741(32%)
North America
801(35%)
1 From Sept 2008 to Sept 2012 2 Pie excludes 20 jets with unknown regional origin
Business jet fleet growth by region (2008-12)1
631532
64
85
Other S. Amer.ColombiaBritish Virgin Is.ArgentinaVenezuelaMexico 138Brazil 344
48
14
14
43
48
All other Asia
Thailand
Indonesia
Australia
India
China 159
Latin America
Asia
Bus. Jet Fleet Growth# jets (2008-12)Country
Key countries driving high growth markets
SOURCE: McKinsey analysis, JP Morgan; ACAS
-
La
st M
odified 3/8/2013
1:28
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
eP
rinted 3/8/2013
1:29
PM E
aste
rn Sta
nda
rd Tim
e
McKinsey & Company | 58
Some growth option clusters in particular have very low penetration and potential for dramatic economic growth, signaling upside for Cessna
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P
16
30
102
111
116
116
124
168
174
284
317
345
439
570
574
648
788
789
Indonesia
S. Europe
United Kingdom
C. Europe
Czech R., Pol., & Slovak.Australia
N. Europe
Jordan & Lebanon
Canada
Brazil
Nigeria, Kenya, Tanzania
China & Hong Kong
Russia & CIS
India
Saudi Arabia & UAE
Turkey
1,181
1,083
United States
Mexico
Venez., Arg., Colomb.
South Africa
Fleet as a function of GDP# of planes per $1 Trillion of GDP
11
11
92
270
120
65
44
74
188
133
260
534
860
521
523
1,565
Fleet per 1,000 HNWI# planes
Fleet per 1,000 corporationsCorporations revenues >100M USD
0.1
0.6
1.3
1.3
1.1
1.0
0.3
0.3
2.3
6.1
6.5
1.7
20.2
-
McKinsey & Company | 59
Macroeconomic indicators are helpful to drive projections, but alone are not sufficient to understand fleet growth
01,0002,0003,0004,0005,0006,0007,0008,0009,000
0 200 400 600 800
Country GDP$ billions, 2012
Fleet Size# business jets, 2012
Russia
Japan
Austria
UKFrance Germany
Canada Mexico
China
Brazil
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Historical GDP GrowthPercent CAGR (2008-12)
Historical Fleet GrowthPercent CAGR (2008-12)
Saudi Arabia
Nigeria
Luxembourg
India
Turkey Hong Kong
China
Brazil
SOURCE: ACAS; Bombardier; IMF country database; World Economic Forum, S&P
Country level insights should additionally include : Small airport
infrastructure Supportive
government policies
Political stability
Corporate profits
HNWindividuals
-
McKinsey & Company | 60
North American share of global piston engine deliveries is decreasing, with Europe, Asia, and LATAM taking increasing share
SOURCE: GAMA (2011), McKinsey analysis
67 68 59 53 58 50
16 1521
19 12 20
9 8 1014 16 16
9 10 1077
2012
4
2011
5
2010
6
2009
3
2008
2
2007
5 3
Piston engine deliveries by region(% of total deliveries)
Rest of worldNAM
-
McKinsey & Company | 61
General aviation aircraft are used for a wide array of applications
Business transpor-tation
Corporate/ executive transpor-tation
Air taxi
Aerial application in agriculture
Aerial observation
Personal/ recreational use
Individual or group use for business transportation without a paid flight crew
Individual or group business transportation with a paid flight crew
Includes fractional ownership
On-demand passenger and all cargo operations (excl. air tours, medical, scheduled service)
Refers mainly to agriculture and forestry, e.g., crop and timber production, fertilizer and pesticide application
Aerial mapping/ photo-graphy, patrol, SAR, hunting, traffic, ranching, surveillance, oil and mineral exploration, etc.
Flying for personal reasons Excludes business
transportation
Other aerial applications
External load and other work applications
Air medical services
Sightseeing and air tours
Instructional
Military/ government users
Public health sprayings, cloud seeding, firefighting including forest fires, etc.
Helicopters with external load (e.g., hauling logs)
Other work includes construction, parachuting, aerial advertising
Air ambulance services, rescue, human organ transportation, emergency medical services
Commercial sightseeing
Flying under the supervision of a flight instructor, including student pilot solo flights
Variety of missions, e.g., police observation, military pilot training, personnel transport
SOURCE: GAMA (2011); FAA GAATA survey; company Web sites; McKinsey
-
McKinsey & Company | 62
Within US, most GA piston aircraft usage is driven by personal, corporate, and instructive uses, whereas turboprops are used more broadly
SOURCE: GAMA (2011), McKinsey analysis
Usage typeUS FAA categories1
GA turboprop aircraft% of active aircraft
GA piston aircraft% of active aircraft
20
132
00
201
614
121
1819
Aerial observationAgri applicationsInstructiveCorporateBusinessPersonal
On-demand air medicalAir toursAir taxiOtherAero medicalSightseeingOther work3External loadAerial other2
00110000021
81
1173
Total fleet: 9,369 aircraft in use
Total fleet: 155,418 aircraft
-
McKinsey & Company | 63
Cessna is one of four players that dominate the piston engine market, comprising 75% of global deliveries since 1998
Global PE aircraft deliveries, 1998 - 2011Number of aircraft
4 players comprise 75%+ of globaldeliveries
SOURCE: GAMA (2011), McKinsey analysis
132152
311
486
487
636
731
892
1,394
2,651
3,0555,071
9,273
Liberty Aerospace
GippsAero
Daher Socata
Aviat Aircraft
Maule Air
Columbia Aircraft
Mooney
American Champion
Hawker Beechcraft
Diamond
Piper
Cirrus
Cessna
-
McKinsey & Company | 64
The top 10 manufacturers by performance have seen 50%+ dropoff in sales since the 2007 peak
SOURCE: GAMA 2011 Statistical Databook and Industry Outlook
050
100150200250300350400450500550600650700750800850900950
12111009080706050403020120001999
Columbia Aircraft (prev. Lancair)
Columbia Aircraft
American Champion
Hawker Beechcraft
Diamond Aircraft
Piper Aircraft
Cirrus Design Corp.
Cessna
-
McKinsey & Company | 65
From a global perspective, aggregate single engineand multi-engine aircraft are expected to see along-term decline
SOURCE: GAMA 2011 Statistical Databook and Industry Outlook
26252423222120191817161514131211100908070605040302012000
160,000
155,000
150,000
145,000
140,000
135,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
020323130292827
Forecast Multi engine
Historical Multi engine
Forecast Single engine
Historical Single engine
Average annual growth, %
-0.1
-0.5
-
McKinsey & Company | 66SOURCE: Factiva, CAAC, Lit research, Press clippings, Mckinsey anslysis
Chinas general aviation market is similarly limited by regulation,though expected to become significant force in the future
Infra-structure
By end of 2011, China had 70 GA airports and 216 temporary landing points More than 20 provinces and cities in the country had constructed aviation industrial parks Many private enterprises are exploring investment opportunities in general aviation More capital is expected to be introduced into the whole value chain construction
Regulation
Opening of low-altitude air space will proceed in three pilot phases, scheduled to complete by 2015 Jun 2012, General aviation airport construction specification released by CAAC1 , is expected to
guide and stimulate the investment of infrastructures of GA Dec 2012, CAAC and Ministry of Finance released temporary measures to regulate the specific fund
for Chinas general aviation development, which is expected to stimulate the GA and training market
China has large HNWI population with interest in flying constrained by airspace limitations according to PR of China General Aviation Association
Forecast of growth
China regulatory constrains remains a barrier to significant market growth As of 2011 China had 1,124 GA planes including 314 training tails Recreation and training market will be the key lever for GA piston markets Agriculture, aerial work and cabin transportation are three main markets for turbprops Broad GA market in China expected to reach a market value of $1 trillion at peak and become major
force in domestic economy
1. Civil Aviation Administration of China
-
McKinsey & Company | 67
Cessna 172 and the Chinese Yun-5 aircraft jointly dominates thepiston fleet in market, with ~60% of share
SOURCE: CAAC
11235566121313
2327333743
HaiyanCirrus SR20Piper Seminole PA 44DA-42tb200DA-40Yun-5 148Cessna 172 150
PL-12Cessna 182TCessna 152Cessna T206HCirrus SR22DA-20tb20GA-200Nong-5ALE500
Current piston engine fleet# of aircrafts
Cessna currently the dominant player (30% share), with Yun-5 capturing similar share
The proliferation of flight training schools in China presents an opportunity for the Cessna 172 or 152 due to their size
Yun-5 is a very large Chinese-made single-engine piston aircraft, that would not be used for flight training
-
McKinsey & Company | 68SOURCE: Airports Authority of India (AAI); press search; Chamber of Commerce India (2010); SP Aviation(Feburary 2013)
Infra-structure
Lack of aviation infrastructure for GA still most inhibiting factor - India requires 200 airports by 2020 for general aviation purposes
Indias Airports Authority has started ~$5 billion+ modernization efforts of non-metro airports in 2011 for 60 locations, out of which 35 have been started
Main infra. issues: safety concerns, lack of skilled labor (e.g., maintenance and ground services), lack of airfield information about small airports, lack of navigation aids, and limited hangar parking space
General aviation in India - trends
Regulation
Due to a nascent GA sector, regulations are airline centric current regulatory environment has many disincentives for general aviation and their operational and infrastructural needs are often ignored
Process of importing aircraft perceived to be bureaucratic, complex Financial burden on small operators due to regulatory requirements These issues are starting to receive attention in the media, and many Indian conglomerates in the
sector (e.g., Tata and Mahindra) pushing government to change regulation
Applications
The presence of global businesses as well as mining, oil, tourism applications are main drivers of increased activity in general aviation
Increasing demand for helicopter service, especially due to the oil and gas industry
Forecast of growth
In India, general aviation is still a nascent market compared to the countrys size By 2020, the Indian general aviation fleet is expected to reach 2,000, from 680 today Untapped potential - aircraft movement for general aviation comprised only 15% (including business
jets, helicopters, small a/c) of total movements as of Oct-2011
-
McKinsey & Company | 69
Cessna dominates the piston fleet in India, with 53% of pistonengine aircrafts, primarily the Cessna 152
SOURCE: Airports Authority of India (AAI)
3333334444556681010121517
2231
5059
113
PIPER SUPER CUB PA-1ZENITH CH 2000CESSNA 172PZENAIR STOL CH 701TRINIDAD TB20CESSNA SKYHAWK 172 SPP68CSWATI TRAINER LT-2MHANSA-3DIAMOND DA-40 CS AIRCRAFTCESSNA 172PUSHPAK MK-1CESSNA 172RCESSNA 152
ZLIN143LZENAIR STOL CH601THORP T 211DIAMOND DA42L360DIAMOND DA 40DCESSNA 172R GA AIRCRAFTSWATI TRAINER LT-1MPIPER CUB SPECIAL J3DIAMOND DA 40CESSNA 206HZLIN Z 242 L
Cessna currently the dominant player (53% share), driven primarily by the 152 and 172 small piston engines
Current piston engine fleet# of aircrafts
-
McKinsey & Company | 70SOURCE: Factiva (Brazil's booming general aviation sector, Aug 2012), http://www.aroundtherings.com , Brazil Gov portal
General aviation is expansive in Brazil, and infrastructure and regulatory improvements will allow further growth
Infrastructure
General aviation serves 3,500 destinations In December 2012 Brazils president announced Logistics Investment Program -- Airports, a program to
improve the infrastructure and quality of airport services and to increase access to air transportation for the Brazilian population, strengthening and expanding regional aviation through investments and incentives
Over R$ 7.3 billion in investments is planned for the expansion of regional aviation services
Regulation
Regulation to authorize public civil airports and airfields dedicated exclusively to general aviation was published on December 21, 2012, which aims to increase the supply of airport infrastructure dedicated to general aviation: Regulatory improvement for slots (times of arrivals and departures) in airports which already
operate at full capacity Authorization for airports dedicated to general aviation
Applications (medical, transport, HNWI etc.)
The economy is booming, the companies, the number of rich people and this means higher sales of aircraft - Dorieldo Luis dos Prazeres, Brazilian Civil Aviation Agency
Perception changes These aircrafts are no longer viewed as luxury in Brazil, but as a tool which makes it possible to generate more business in less time"
Forecast of growth
Brazil has the world's second largest general aviation fleet behind the United States As of 2011 it had 13,094 GA planes, Of those, 25 percent are based in Sao Paulo The sector grew 6.4 percent from 2010 to 2011 and is forecasted to grow 4.5 to 5 percent
-
McKinsey & Company | 71
Brazils piston-engine fleet is concentrated in Sao Paolo and comprised mostly of single-engine piston aircrafts
SOURCE: ABAG
Pistons by engine type (L1P single, L2P double)Number of piston engine aircrafts
Usage of piston aircrafts by engine typeNumber of piston engine aircrafts
Number of piston engines registered by state (2011)
Double engine
2,032 2,147
Single engine
7,6537,306
2584001,0511,074
4,870
117449471,534
Private Air Service
Intruction Agricultural Aircraft
Air Taxi Other
2011
2010
Double engine
Single engine
5% 6%