interim results & outlook - gjetc€¦ · • marcus schürmann (ahk japan) • tobias...

Interim Results & OutlookJune 2017

2German Japanese Energy Transition Council

Kick-off 28th September 2016, Tokyo

1st Council Meeting28th/29th September 2016, Tokyo


Review 1st Council meeting


Stakeholder dialogue with the industry29th September 2016

Participants

Germany Japan• Christian Arnold (EWE)• Masahiro Ito (BayWa R.E.)• Albert Kirchmann (Daimler)• Jörn Kristensen (Enercon)• Marcus Schürmann (AHK Japan)• Tobias Schweinfurter (TÜV Rheinland)

• Katsuhiko Hirose (Toyota)• Hiroshi Hosoi (JX Nippon Oil & Energy)• Takashi Mishina (Daikin)• Motoshi Muraoka (NTT Data)• Hiroshi Nambo (Global CCS)• Hiroshi Okamoto (Tepco)• Takahiko Onozuka (Sumitomo)• Minoru Saito (Euras Energy)• Masahito Yoshimura (Hitachi)



Stakeholder dialogue with delegates of theMinistry of Environment Japan, 1st October 2016

Participants

MoEJ & IGES GJETC• Dr. Kotaro Kawamata (Jap. Embassy)• Satori Morishita• Sei Kato • Dr. Akio Takemoto• Yuzo Sugimoto• Dr. Yuji Mizuno• Prof. Hironori Hamanaka (IGES)• Dr. Junichi Fujino (IGES)• Akihisa Kuriyama (IGES)

• Prof. Peter Hennicke• Dr. Stefan Thomas• Franzjosef Schafhausen• Manfred Rauschen• Johanna Schilling



Stakeholder dialogue with the German-Japanese Parliamentary Group, 02. October 2016

Participants

Parliamentarians GJETC• Sylvia Kotting-Uhl (Grüne)• Dr. Matthias Bartke (SPD)• Sabine Zimmermann (Die Linke)• Oliver Grundmann (CDU/CSU)• Rudolf Henke (CDU/CSU)• Andreas Rimkus (SPD)• Annett Ullrich, Verw. Bundestag

• Prof. Masakazu Toyoda• Prof. Jun Arima• Prof. Peter Hennicke• Dr. Stefan Thomas• Dr. Felix Matthes• Prof. Miranda Schreurs• Manfred Rauschen• Franzjosef Schafhausen

Results 1st Council meeting


Ø Discussion & Agreement• Rules of Procedures• Common Bidding Procedures• Terms of References (ToRs) • Financial framework of the studies• Shortlist research institutes

Ø Dialogue & networking with stakeholders• GER & JP industry representatives• GER Parliamentary Group• Reception at German Embassy

2nd Council meeting23rd/24th Jan. 2017, Berlin


Stakeholder dialogue withdecentralized actors of energy transition


Review 2nd Council meeting


Stakeholder dialogue with decentralized actors24. January 2017

Germany Japan

• Olivier Feix (50Hertz)• Frank Baumann (EnergieAgentur.NRW)• Nicolai Ferchl (Heidelberger EG)• Harald Halfpaap (proKlima)• Brick Medak (LichtBlick)• Dr. Peter Moser (IdE Kassel)• Bene Müller (Solarcomplex)• Martin Rühl (SW-Union Nordhessen)• Ursula Sladek (EWS)

• Akihiro Hara (Ohisama Shinpo)• Tatsushi Isobe (Miyama SE)• Motoshi Muraoka (NTT Data IMC)• Yauemon Sato (Aizu Electric Power)• Jun Yamada (Aizu Electric Power)

Results 2nd Council meeting


Ø Discussion & Approval of inception reports for ST 1-4 Ø Discussion and Agreement on

• Review process by council members for each study• Preparation of input papers by council members• Topics for fact sheets & topical papers• Increasing the outreach through additional public event

after the upcoming council meeting

Ø Dialogue & networking• Stakeholder Dialogue with GER & JP representatives of

decentralized energy supply• Reception at Japanese Embassy

German-Japanese Energy Dialogueon the occasion of the mission of the German Foreign AffairsOffice (STS Steinlein) to Japan, 15th November 2016, IEEJ


Quotes

Rita Schwarzelühr-SutterState SecretaryBMUB

„There will be no ideal solution for the transformation of our energy systems. […] Therefore it is also about learning from the good

examples in our both countries and to avoid mistakes regarding the implementation of the energy transition. Against this background, the

German-Japanese Energy Transition Council can develop important recommendations for the energy transition.“


Quotes

Stefan Steinlein, State SecretaryFederal Foreign Office

„The German-Japanese Cooperation Council is a sort of experimental ground for an innovative form of international cooperation. It candemonstrate how synergy effects to governmental contacts can be

tapped effectively by research and civil society initiatives.“


Quotes

Miguel Berger Head of Department,Economy & Sustainable Development Federal Foreign Office

“…tonight the best example for our mutual cooperation is the Council itself, and we strongly support its work. It enables an

exchange of experiences in energy management and joint research by bringing together experts from industry, politics and

science”


Quotes

Prof. Masakazu Toyoda,CEO & ChairmanInstitute of Energy Economics Japan

„Japan and Germany both have highly efficient societiescompared to other countries. We can expect to discover aspects

that Japan has not yet perceived and vice versa.“


Quotes

Noriaki OzawaDirector-GeneralEnergy & Environmental PolicyANRE (METI)

“I think this council will provide a platform on which we can communicate openly and honestly and consider how future

challenges can be met. […] This council will take over an important role for strenghtening the cooperation in the area of

energy.”


Study programTopic Applicants Reviewer

ST 1 „Energy transition as a central building block of a future industrial policy-Comparision and analysis oflong-term energy transitionscenarios“

1. Wuppertal Institut, DIW Econ, IEEJ*

• Felix C. Matthes • Eicke Weber • Claudia Kemfert

• Koji Nomura• Jun Arima

ST 2 „Strategic framework andsocio-cultural aspects of theenergy transition

1. IZES, Arepo Consult, IGES, Nagoya University*

2. Wuppertal Institut,IEEJ

• Miranda Schreurs • Yasumasa Fujii• Tomihiro Taniguchi

ST 3 „New allocation of rolesand business segments ofestablished and newparticipants in the energysectors currently and within a future electricity marketdesign“

1. IZES, JEPIC* • Felix C. Matthes • Junichi Ogasawara• Hiroshi Okamoto• Shinichi Sasayama

ST 4 „Energy end-use efficiencypotentials and policies and thedevelopment of energy servicemarkets“

1. Ecofys, IAE*2. Wuppertal Institut,

IEEJ

• Stefan Thomas• Manfred Rauschen

• Toshiharu Ikaga• Mami Ito

22German Japanese Energy Transition Council *Accepted proposal

Study program: Schedule 2017


Inception reports:Due date: 16. Jan

01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 1211

Discussion at 2. CM:23./24. Jan.

Interim reports:Due date: 31. Mai

Feedback byreviewer:

until 16. Juni

Draft final reports:Due date: 01. Aug.

Final report:Due date: 15. Oct.

Discussion on 3. CM:

04./05. Sep.

Feedback byreviewer &

council:Until 16. Sep.

Input Papers


Goal:Intensify the scientific exchange among GJETC experts and with thegeneral public

Format• Short (10-12 pages) scientific paper• Topics of general interest regarding the energy transition in both

countries• Each GJETC member should write one article• Clearing: Each article should contain a review (max. 2 pages) of an

author from the „other side“

Input Paper 1(Submission: July)

Input-Papers


Expected Input PapersGerman Council members


Uwe Leprich/UBA The coupling of energy sectors - a promising strategy to a decarbonized world?

Stefan Thomas, Peter Hennicke The governance of energy efficiency policies

Claudia Kemfert Decarbonizing in the energy systems in Europe without nuclear power and CCS (including costs)

Eicke Weber/FhG ISE Comparison of potentials and costs of renewable electricity in Germany and Japan

Felix C. Matthes, Patrick Graichen, Uwe Leprich

Costs of the system integration of fluctuating renewable energies/role of conventional energy generation, particularly base load plant“

Felix C. Matthes, Eicke WeberNecessity of further development of the infrastructure / How will the system integration succeed technically with high shares of fluctuating renewable energies

Manfred Rauschen Potentials and cost-benefits-analysis energy efficiency in buildings

Franzjosef Schafhausen Comparison of long-term Climate protection targets/NDCs of Germany and Japan


Jun Arima Japan‘s Intended Nationally Determined Contribution(INDC)

Toshiharu Ikaga Energy efficiency of buildings

Tomihiro Taniguchi The impact of energy transition on energy security

Koji Nomura Improvement of energy productivity in Germand and the UK

Yasumasa Fujii Renewable electricity and grid stability

Expected Input PapersJapanese Council members

1. Macroeconomic aspects

2. Energy supply & demand

3. Energy Security

4. Political & market aspects

5. Geographical & country-specific conditions

Collection of comparative statistical datafor Germany & Japan

Topics to be covered:


Entwurfsfassung++Factsheet+

on+energy+supply+and+energy+demand++in+Japan+and+Germany+

+

!++

+Authors++

+Imprin t+

Pub lisher

Con tact++

German +Japanese+Energy+Transi?o n+Council+

Entwurfsfassung++Factsheet+

on+energy+supply+and+energy+demand++in+Japan+and+Germany+

+

!++

+Authors++

+Imprin t+

Pub lisher

Con tact++

German +Japanese+Energy+Transi?o n+Council+

Macroeconomic+aspects+

a)+GDP+1990+–+2015++

German+Japanese+Energy+Transi? on+Council+

Year+Germany++ Japan+

Numeric+value+in+current+US$+


b)+GDP+per+capita+1990+–+2015++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++


Year+Germany++ Japan++

Numeric+value+in+current+US§+


a)+GDP+1990+–+2015++


Year+Germany++ Japan+

Numeric+value+in+current+US$+


b)+GDP+per+capita+1990+–+2015++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++


Year+Germany++ Japan++

Numeric+value+in+current+US§+

Fact SheetsEnergy supply & demand in Germany and Japan


+Germany:+Popula?on+by+age+groups+(in+thousands)++

German+Japanese+Energy+Transi?on+Council+

In+th

ousa

nds+

+Japan:+Popula?on+by+age+groups+(in+thousands)++


in+th

ousa

nds+


+Germany:+Popula?on+by+age+groups+(in+thousands)++


In+th

ousa

nds+

+Japan:+Popula?on+by+age+groups+(in+thousands)++


in+th

ousa

nds+

Topical Papers


1. The G20 states – selected official energy and climate targets: Renewable Energy, Energy Efficiency, CO2/GHG emissions (June 2017)

2. Supporting and hindering framework conditions for decentralized actors – Overview on status and perspectives in Japan and Germany (Summer 2017)

… summarize the current knowledgeregarding a specific topic, includingForward-looking statements and possiblydiffering evaluations

Homepage (English)

Ø Basic information on• Purpose• Members• Sponsors

Ø Publications• Studies• Input Paper• Fact Sheets• Topical Papers• Press

Ø Internal Communication

Homepage: www.gjetc.org


http://www.gjetc.org

Press conferences


Media response


Award Nominations

• Japan Prize 2018(by Ernst von Weizsäcker)

• NRW Innovation Prize(by Manfred Fischedick)


Synergies & relevance of thecouncil work


Ø Remarkable media response

Ø Expansion of German-Japanese networks, personal contacts, as well asdelegation visits initiated by GJECT and its members

Ø Extraordinary interest of invited Japanese and German participantsregarding stakeholder dialogues and their willingness to answer thequestionnaires in detail

Ø Unreserved positive support of GJETC activities by high-ranking Japanese and German council members

Ø Constructive and trustful climate of discussion within the council, despite differences regarding e.g. nuclear energy



Ø Good cooperation between the secretariats and between both Co-Chairs

Ø Very encouraging support through the German and Japanese Embassy

Ø Appreciation of the council through …• State Secretaries Baake and Machnig (BMWi), Schwarzelühr-Sutter

(BMUB) and Steinlein (Foreign Affairs Office) on the German side• Director-General Ozawa (METI) and several high-ranking members

of METI and MoEJ on Japanese sideØ Positive feedback regarding the GJETC from representatives of industry,

decentral actors and NGOs in Japan and Germany

Ø Nomination of the GJETC for the Japan Award and NRW Innovation Award; positive laudations by Prof. von Weizsäcker, Prof. Weber und Prof. Leprich

Ø Improved mutual understanding of the council members towards manytopics, for example:

• Positive estimations of many industry representatives regardingenergy transition

• Role of decentralized actors

• Meaning and configuration of the liberalization

• Possibilities of net integration of fluctuation renewable energies



Outlook – Upcoming Events


3. Council meeting, 4th/5th September 2017, TokyoØ Agenda

• Presentation of study results• Review by council members• Presentation and discussion of selected input papers

Stakeholder-Dialogue, 5th September 2017, Tokyo„How much energy can be conserved and how“ –The role of suppliers of advanced energy efficiency technologies and of Energy Service Companies”

Ø Participants: • Representatives of construction and real estate businesses with

experience in energy management• Manufacturers of energy efficiency technologies• Representatives of energy sergice companies (ESCOs)


Outreach-Event, 6th September 2017, Tokyo“Perspectives of energy transition in Japan and Germany and the role of international cooperations – first interim results of the German-Japanese Energy Transition Council (GJETC)”

Ø Public event (application necessary)

Ø Venue: Institute of Energy Economics Japan (IEEJ)

4th Council meeting, 14th/15th February 2018, BerlinØ Agenda

• Finale Studienergebnisse

• Presentation and discussion of selected input papers

• Policy recommendations

Outlook – Upcoming Events

interim results & outlook - gjetc€¦ · • marcus schürmann (ahk japan) • tobias...

Documents