integrated volt/var control
TRANSCRIPT
Integrated Volt/VAR Control
Mike Prevallet, Sales Engineer
Tom Johnson, Regional Director-Energy Automation Solutions
EAS – Smart Grid Solution Leader
CPS Controls
Building one team focused on software, controls, and communications with
250+ engineers focused on intelligent grid solutions
3
Agenda
How does Volt-Var Management benefit utilities?
What is Volt-Var Management?
Power Factor and Voltage Optimization Requirements
Volt-Var input values from capacitor controls, voltage regulator controls and LTC; algorithm decisions
Questions
Volt/Var Fundamentals
Switching capacitors on will reduce the electric
current (I) on the line, which will:
Reduces the electrical losses (I2R)
Reduces the amount of energy (kilowatt-hours) required to
supply the existing load and reduces the peak demand on the
system
Indirect control of feeder voltage through Capacitor
Switching which raises the feeder voltage to:
Increases the real and reactive load (depending on the kind of
device)
However, this increases losses in distribution transformers
4
5
Change in voltage leads to a corresponding
change in power consumption:
a 1% change in voltage causes a change in kW
usually ranging from 0.2% to 1.5%
Effect of change of voltage on reactive power is
even more significant :
1% change in voltage causes a change in kvar
usually ranging from 2% to 6%
Volt/Var Fundamentals
The change in load will decay over time, but not to the value before the
change in voltage. The amount and time constant of decay depend on the
characteristics of the circuit. **KEMA PES Conference June 2005/IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, Vol. 10, No. 2, May 1995; pp. 709-715
6
VAR Optimization - Power Factor CorrectionDistribution feeder capacitor bank control provide energy loss
reduction by coordinating capacitor banks control.
Conservation Voltage Reduction (CVR)Coordinating voltage regulator and LTC controls to reduce feeder
voltage levels provide load reduction on substations and feeders.
Integrated Volt/VAR Control (IVVC)Coordinated Control of substation load tap changers, feeder
voltage regulators and capacitor banks ensure VAR and voltage
profiles to optimize these benefits.
Why Now?Utility Investment in communications and Smart Grid investment
links all facets from End-Customer to Generation, Transmission
and Distribution
Volt-Var Optimization Strategies
7
How does IVVC benefit Utilities?
88
Integrated Volt/VAR Management
Business DriversRegulation imposes new requirements with the overall goal
of reducing energy consumption and demand - (Reduction
in peak load MW) x ($/MW to add capacity or demand
charges)
Stimulus bill driven energy efficiency projects such as
Decoupling Rates/Green initiatives - Capacity release
(MW) due to reduced losses (typically a very sizable $
benefit)
Business Case
Energy purchase savings – Reduction in Energy (MWh) to
serve losses (can be a very sizable $ benefit)
Conservation Voltage Reduction - (Reduction in Losses
MWh) x ($/MWh to generate or purchase energy)
9
Business Drivers
Pennsylvania PUC Act 129 Information: Seven major Electric Distribution Companies (EDCs) in
Pennsylvania need to implement a plan to reduce energy demand and consumption.
The Act requires a 1% reduction in consumption by May 31, 2011, a total of 3% reduction in consumption and a 4.5% reduction in peak demand by May 31, 2013.
Ohio PUC Senate Bill 221 Information: Commission proposed electric distribution utilities will
implement a cost-effective energy efficiency and peak demand reduction –
Bill 221 benchmarks nominal requirements for more cost effective decisions to provide energy conservation than to provide power, electric distribution utilities must offer energy savings to lower generation purchases.
10
Business Drivers
Snohomish CVR 2006: Robert Fletcher of Snohomish PUD said conservation
voltage reduction drops the utility's voltage by 2.5 percent, to 117V.
"That buys the average customer about 350-400 kWh per year savings," Fletcher said. "So the net savings for our customers is about $3.5 million a year.“
Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance Distribution Efficiency Initiative: 13 Northwest utilities consolidating research efforts validate
value of conservation voltage reduction
Results from “The NEEA Phase 1 DEI Final Report” shows that "operating a utility distribution system in the lower half of the acceptable voltage range (120-114 volts) saves energy, reduces demand, and reduces reactive power requirements without negatively impacting the customer.
Validated energy savings results of 1 to 3 percent total energy reduction, 2 to 4 percent reduction in kW demand, and a 4 to 10 percent reduction in kvar demand.”
11
What is Integrated Volt-Var Management?
System Approach to Savings
Local Control:
Power Factor
Load Current
Voltage
Var-Flow
Temperature
Time of Day /
Season
Centralized Automation:
System Overview of
Assets
Conditioned Based
Optimization for -
Voltage
Var – power factor
Maintenance
12
Integrating the LTC’s and Regs provides Real-time Voltage & PF data to
operate the correct capacitor or regulator and optimize system efficiency
13
What is Integrated Volt/VAR
A Flat Feeder Voltage Profile. (improved voltage profile)
Unity Power Factor (minimize losses)
The ability change the voltage on demand
– Demand Response - conservation voltage reduction
The ability to define roles where Voltage or Power Factor are the primary metric based on advance algorithms, real-time data, power flow, constraints and system dynamic needs.
1414
Case 1: No Voltage Regulation
Voltage drops off with distance from the substation
– On-load Tap Changer on substation transformer, or substation regulators step up voltage so that voltage at end of feeder stays within required range
VAR injected at substation (for inductive loads)
– Either via generator or substation capacitor bank
Can be very difficult to manage Volt/VAR within target range on a long feeder with numerous loads of varying types
Severe penalties for not maintaining power factor
Substation LTC or
Voltage Regulators
1ph
XFMR
End
Customer
Line Voltage
Regulator
Cap
Bank
Distribution ConsumptionGeneration & Transmission
Vo
ltag
e
Distance from Substation
Target
1515
Case 2: Distributed Voltage Regulation
Optimized planning for placement of Regulators – Cyme
Standalone Voltage Regulators added along the way keeps Voltage in a tighter range
Benefits– Minimize/avoid voltage violations
– Improve efficiency by reducing “average voltage”
Substation LTC or
Voltage Regulators
1ph
XFMR
End
Customer
Line Voltage
Regulator
Line Voltage
Regulator
Distribution ConsumptionGeneration & Transmission
Vo
ltag
e
Distance from Substation
Target
1616
Case 3: Traditional Volt/VAR Management
Optimized planning for placement of Regulators and Capacitor Banks – Cyme
Adding capacitor banks to the system further flattens the voltage profile
Benefits
– Minimize/avoid voltage violations
– Improve efficiency by reducing “average voltage”
– Improves power factor
– Frees up generating capacity by injecting VARs; reduced generation
Substation LTC or
Voltage Regulators
1ph
XFMR
End
Customer
Line Voltage
Regulator
Cap
Bank
Line Voltage
Regulator
Distribution ConsumptionGeneration & Transmission
Vo
ltag
e
Distance from Substation
Target
1717
Case 4: Integrated Volt/VAR
Optimized planning for placement of Regulators and Capacitor Banks – Cyme
With Integrated Volt/Var (IVVC), regulators, load tap changes and capacitors are continuously monitored & controlled to manage power factor and voltage
Additional Benefits
– Volt/VAR is optimized in real time for power quality and system efficiency
– Utilities can perform Conservation Voltage Reduction to shed load - 1% reduction in voltage = 0.5-0.7% reduction in load
Substation LTC or
Voltage Regulators
1ph
XFMR
End
Customer
Line Voltage
RegulatorsCap
Bank
Line Voltage
Regulators
Distribution ConsumptionGeneration & Transmission
Vo
ltag
e
Distance from Substation
Target
18
Power Factor and Voltage
Optimization Requirements
19
Functional Requirements
Control Set Points System evaluates optimization pattern to control LTC and regulator
set points and tap positions
System optimizes capacitor bank statuses to flatten voltage in the distribution to the specified target.
Targeted Power Factor The Volt-VAR Management application evaluates how to change
capacitor bank statuses to manage feeder and substation VAR flows as close to a specified target power factor.
Loss of Communications Failover / Recovery support System communications support a failover and recovery scheme to
insure voltage quality is maintained when communications from the application to the controls fails.
Communications Band-Width Management Measurement Communications by exception to reduce the message
traffic in the communications network.
20
Functional Requirements
Feeder Reconfiguration Integration switch status change and data processing
Results in dynamic coordination of feeder capacitor banks, feeder measurement points, and substation LTCs, and regulators.
Voltage targets Support for normal and emergency voltage targets to allow
for emergency CVR operation
Control Center Operations Support disabling/enabling Volt/VAR Management automatic
control from the control center/operations desk.
System Integration SCADA/DMS/OMS integration to support capacitor bank,
LTC, and regulator supervisory control actions from the control center operations desk.
21
Volt-Var System Input Values
22
Field Hardware
Communication Enabled – Hardware
for voltage, Var, and substation current/watts (bias)
Substation Regulators
Substation Capacitor Banks Controls
Down-line (Feeder) Regulators
Feeder Capacitor Bank Controls
Medium Voltage Sensors
Customer Meters
23
Volt/Var Management Algorithm
IVVC Algorithm is triggered by:
Value limit violation
Periodic interval
IVVC Algorithm Sequence of Events:
Scan and Correlate Measurement Data Set
Evaluate Feeder Voltage Profile and Power Factor
Evaluate if Device control actions could improve:
Feeder Voltage Profile
Substation and Feeder Power Factor
Calculate costs for current operating state, proposed operating
states.
Optimization resolves conflicts between Voltage and Power
Factor targets and minimizes the number of control actions.
24
IVVC Optimization Table
Algorithm Resolves Constraints
Cost for voltage and Var used to determine
operation. Capacitor vs Regulator/LTC
Decision criteria to resolves voltage or VAR
violation
The utility defines/selects resolution costs and
metrics through solution weighting
25
Volt/Var Management Implementation
Data Requirements: Data is provided in a formatted flat
file and imported to the Volt/Var Management application
via a standard data import script
Static Device Attributes examples are Capacitor Bank size, LTC and
Regulator static attributes: Primary and Secondary voltages, Number of
taps, max/min voltages, bandwidth
Regulation Settings examples are Cap Bank Regulation type (Volt,
Var, Time, Temp), regulation target, regulated phase are integrated in the
model
Nominal feeder topology: examples include Cap Bank/Regulator to
feeder section, Cap Bank/Regulator to Sectionalizing Switches (SCADA
Switch, Sectionalizers, Reclosers), Cap Bank/Regulator to feeder, Cap
Bank/Regulator to substation bus, Device to control zone
26
Volt/Var Management Requirements
Integration Requirements:
Real Time Measurement Data: Volts, Amps, Watts and
Vars at each control device and each meter location
Typically Utilities integrate with: SCADA , OMS, DMS
EMS and database systems to support operational objectives for
application status and control positions
Sectionalizing Switch Positions: Support automated
recoordination of feeder cap banks and regulators to the
appropriate feeder and substation bus after feeder switching
Example Architecture- IVVC
27
PI Database
AMI
Meter
YUKON
IVVC
SERVER
Regulator/LTC
Cap Controller
Recloser
Field
Commands
Fie
ld
Co
mm
and
s
2828
Summary
Business Drivers Business Objectives
Functional Objectives Technical Requirements
Monitor and control substation regulators
or LTCs (Regulator Controls)
Monitor and control substation and feeder
capacitor banks (Cap Bank Controls)
Monitor end of line voltages to avoid
violations (Smart Meters, Sensors, etc.)
Manage Feeder Voltage down to a settable
target
Manage Feeder VARs to a settable target
Flat voltage profile
Regulation imposes new requirements
with the overall goal of reducing energy
consumption and demand
Energy purchase savings
Increased KWh sales on improved voltage
profile
Stimulus bill driven energy efficiency
projects
Unity Power Factor minimizes losses and
minimizes purchased KW
Reduced voltage profile minimizes
purchased KW:
1% reduction in voltage results in 0.5
to 0.8% reduction in KW
IVVC Solutions Improve Grid Efficiency