infrastructure for testing and qualifying robust radial...

27
Institute for Clean Energy Technology Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial Flow HEPA Filters Ronald Unz, John Wilson, Jay McCown , Charles Waggoner Institute for Clean Energy Technology Mississippi State University 205 Research Blvd Starkville, MS 39702

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jun-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Infrastructure for Testing and

Qualifying Robust Radial Flow

HEPA Filters

Ronald Unz, John Wilson, Jay McCown, Charles Waggoner

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Mississippi State University

205 Research Blvd

Starkville, MS 39702

Page 2: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Background

Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant

Need Robust Radial Flow HEPA Filter

Current AG-1 Filter Designs Do Not Meet

WTP Performance Requirements

Filter Qualification Based on WTP

Performance Requirements for Filtration

Systems

2

Page 3: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Performance Requirements

Performance Requirements

– 225 in w.c.

– Loaded to 4 in w.c., the Filter Needs to

Withstand 170° F and 90% RH for One Hour

– Under Operational Conditions, Be Able To

Load to 225 in w.c.

3

Page 4: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Test Criteria

4

Test Criteria

Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Initial filter efficiency Filter efficiency measurement using DOP at rated flow

(2000 cfm)

Resistance to liquid

pressure performance

Maintain 25 in w.c. to 225 in w.c. for one Hour

Rinse water capabilities Heated water (95° F or 35º C) at 30 gpm (1.9 L/s) for 60

minutes, total 2000 gallons (7570 L)

Drying Performance Maintain heated air supply at 100° F (38° C) over 100 to

400 cfm

Post resistance to liquid

pressure filter efficiency

Filter efficiency measurement using DOP at 5 and 20 %

rated flow (100 cfm and 400 cfm)

Rough Handling ¾ inch (1.9 cm) amplitude, 200 cycles per minute, for a

total of 15 minutes

Post rough handling filter

efficiency

Filter efficiency measurement using DOP at 5 and 20 %

rated flow (100 cfm and 400 cfm)

Page 5: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Conceptual Drawing

5

Page 6: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Bench Scale Testing

6

Page 7: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Bench Scale Testing

7

Page 8: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Test Fluid

Dow Chemical CarbowaxTM Polyethylene

Glycol (PEG) 8000

50:50 Aqueous solution

8

Page 9: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Final Drawing

9

Page 10: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

RLPTS – Air

10

Page 11: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

RLPTS - Liquid

11

Page 12: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Filter Tubesheets

12

Page 13: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Rinse Water System

13

Page 14: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Aerosol Instrumentation

14

Instrument

#/cc

(min)

#/cc

(max)

Particle Size

Distribution

(µm)

Scanning Mobility Particle Sizer (SMPS)

TSI Model 3080 Electrostatic

Classifier

37.4 inch (95 cm) Custom

Differential Mobility Analyzer

(DMA)

TSI Model 3775 Condensation

Particle Counter (CPC)

2 1x108 0.008 - 1

TSI Model 3321 APS

(with TSI Model 3302A Diluter) 1

1x103

(1x105)0.3 – 20

TSI Model 3340 LAS <0.02 1.8x103 0.09 – 7.5

Page 15: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Testing Sequence

Seal Leak Test

Resistance to Airflow

Initial Filter Efficiency

Resistance to Liquid Pressure with PEG

Rinsing Filter

Drying Filter

Pre-Rough Handling Filter Efficiency

Rough Handling

Final Filter Efficiency

15

Page 16: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Seal Leak Test

Use Bladder to Blind Filter Pack

Seal Top Section of Housing

Pressurize Housing to 240 in w.c.

Observe Pressure Drop Over 1 Hour

16

Page 17: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Resistance to Air Flow

Air Flow is Ramped

From 0 cfm to 2,000

cfm

250 cfm Increments

One Minute Intervals

at Each Interval

17

Page 18: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Initial Filter Efficiency

ASME AG-1 Section FK Article FK-5120

2,000 cfm

DOP (TDA-6C)

5 Sets of Data (75 sec each)

18

Page 19: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

RLPTS Control System

19

Page 20: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Resistance to Liquid Pressure Test

Ramp from 0 to 225 in w.c.

10 Inch Increments

Maintain 225 in w.c. for 60 minutes

20

Page 21: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Washing

Washing

– 100°F Water

– 30 gallons/min

– 60 min total or 2000

gallons

21

Page 22: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

DryingDrying

– 100 cfm to 400 cfm depending on dP

– 400 cfm is maintained once capable

– Flow maintained until dP reaches minimum

Filter Efficiency at 20% rated flow

22

Page 23: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Rough Handling

23

Page 24: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Data Analysis

24

Page 25: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Heated Air Test Stand

Capable of Performing Resistance to

Heated Air at 700°F in Accordance with

ASME AG-1 Section FK article FK-5150

25

Page 26: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Phase 2 Testing

Phase I Testing

Filter Loading Test

Elevated Temperature and Humidity Test

26

Page 27: Infrastructure for Testing and Qualifying Robust Radial ...isnatt.org/Conferences/33/Tuesday/Infrastructure...Test Criteria 4 Test Criteria Initial resistance to air 100 to 2000 cfm

Institute for Clean Energy Technology

Conclusion

Developed Unique Test Stand for

Evaluation of ASME AG-1 Section FK

Radial Flow Filters

RLPTS Designed and Built for Performing

High Differential Pressure Testing

Test sequence for filter evaluations

27