in the bahamas court of appeal criminal and ...226/2018 devaughn hall 10:00 a.m. vs. regina...

1

1

IN THE BAHAMAS COURT OF APPEAL

CRIMINAL AND CIVIL APPEALS

CAUSE LIST FOR THE MONTH OF SEPTEMBER 2020

(All dates and time subject to change) CORAM AMENDED LIST

CAIS No. As of September 18, 2020

TUESDAY, 1ST SEPTEMBER, 2020

MAGISTRATE COURT CRIMINAL APPEALS

165/2018 ELVARDO FARRINGTON

10:00 A.M. Vs.

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

(Continuation of Substantive Hearing

Stealing by Reason of Employment, Adj. from 2/7/2020

Davis & Co. and Director of Public Prosecutions)

SUPREME COURT CIVIL APPEALS

64/2020 In the Matter of all those pieces parcels or lots 12:00 NOON. of lands situated at “Signal Point” also known as “Summer Point” on the Island of Rum Cay one of the Islands of the

Common wealth of The Bahamas and designated Lots 2,3,5,9 and 10. AND IN THE MATTER of the Quieting Titles Act 1959. IN THE MATTER OF the Petition of Scott E. Findeisen and

Brandon S. Findeisen (as Trustees of the Stephen A. Orlando

Revocable Trust).

WAHOO RESORT FOUNDATION

AND

SCOTT E. FINDEISEN AND BRANDON S. FINDEISEN (As Trustees of he Stephen A. Orlando Revocable Trust)

(Application for Leave to Appeal

Pyfrom Farrington and McKinney Bancroft & Hughes Chambers)

Continued on the next page …./2

2

2

SUPREME COURT CRIMINAL APPEALS

194/2016 THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

2:00 P.M. Vs.

SHAWN KNOWLES

AND (Substantive Hearing, Manslaughter and Possession of Unlicensed Firearm and Ammunition, Adj. from 22/7/2020

Director of Public Prosecutions and Public Defender’s Office

221/2016 SHAWN DION KNOWLES

2:00 P.M. Vs.

REGINA

(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Manslaughter and Possession of

Unlicensed Firearm (2) and Ammunition, Adj. from 22/7/2020

CG Chambers and Director of Public Prosecutions)

WEDNESDAY, 2nd SEPTEMBER, 2020


37/2017 ERVIN L. BROWN

10:00 A.M. Vs.

REGINA

(Substantive Hearing, Murder Adj. from 8/6/2020)

Roberto Reckley & Co. and Director of Public Prosecutions)

Continued on the next page …/3

3

3

MAGISTRATE’S COURT CRIMINAL APPEALS

272/2018 LAVARDO FORBES

12:00 NOON Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Possession of Firearm with Intent to

Endanger Life

Pro Se and Director of Public Prosecutions)

73/2019 SHIRVON A. STUBBS

12:00 NOON Vs.


(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Possession of Firearm with Intent to

Endanger Life



152/2018 ANTOIN MEADOWS

2:00 P.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Substantive Hearing on Retrial, Adj. from 30/7/2020

Public Defender’s Office and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

4

4

THURSDAY, 3RD SEPTEMBER, 2020



10:00 A.M. Vs.

JOSEPH FOULKES

(Substantive Hearing, Unlawful Sexual Intercourse

Adj. from 9/7/2020

Pro Se and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

110/2019 RODRIGUEZ JEAN PIERRE

2:00 P.M. Vs.

REGINA

(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Murder, Adj. from 16/7/2020

Public Defender’s Office and Director of Public Prosecutions)

FRIDAY, 4TH SEPTEMBER, 2020

Reserved/ Reading Day

5

5

MONDAY, 7TH SEPTEMBER, 2020


195/2018 EMMANUEL ROLLE

10:00 A.M. Vs.

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Manslaughter and Attempted Murder

Adj. from 6/7/2020



244/201 7 TARANO DEVEAUX

12:00 NOON Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Appeal of Sentence and

Violation of Bail Conditions



283/2018 RAHEEM GIBSON

2:00 P.M. Vs.


(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Manslaughter


6

6

TUESDAY, 8TH SEPTEMBER, 2020


214/2018 KIKO HANNA

10:00 A.M. Vs.

REGINA

(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Robbery, Adj. from 13/7/2020


273/2018 TROY JOHNSON

10:15 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Attempted Murder, Assault with a

Deadly Weapon


14/2020 CHARLTON PIERRE

2:00 P.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Manslaughter, Adj. from 13/7/2020


7

7

WEDNESDAY, 9TH SEPTEMBER, 2020


191/2019 BENJAMIN COUPLAND SIMMONS

10:00 A.M. BR-ILAND RESPONSIBLE DEVELOPMENT LTD (BIRD)

AND

TOWN PLANNING COMMITTEE

4M HARBOUR ISLAND LTD

(Substantive Hearing, Costs, Judicial Review Proceedings

Adj. from 16/7/2020

Gail Lockhart Charles & Co. and Graham Thompson)


164/2017 EDNOL CASH

2:00 P.M. AND

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Conditional Leave to the Privy Council

Pro Se and Office of the Attorney General)

8

8

THURSDAY, 10TH SEPTEMBER, 2020


86/2019 KENNETH KNOWLES

10:00 A.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Murder, Adj. from 27/7/2020



122/2019 DIEUSON TOMAS

12:00 NOON Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Possession of Unlicensed Firearm

and Ammunition

Lord Ellor & Co. and the Director of Public Prosecutions)


90/2017 ANTONE CAREY

2:00 P.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Substantive Hearing, Importation of Dangerous Drugs


9

9





63/2018 JOSEPH DICKERSON

10:00 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Substantive Hearing, Attempted Murder

Raymond A. Rolle & Co. and the Director of Public Prosecutions)


25/2020 TERVALLIS TINKER

12:00 NOON Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Resisting Arrest and Housebreaking Aksum Law Chambers and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

7/2018 PAULINE PHILLIPS

2:00 P.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Possession of Dangerous Drugs with

with Intent to Supply and taking preparatory steps to export

dangerous drugs

Lord Ellor & Co. and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

10

10



133/2019 JEVON ALEXANDER ROLLE

10:00 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Substantive Hearing, Armed Robbery

Lord Ellor & Rolle & Co. and the Director of Public Prosecutions)


251/2018 DEVROY COLEBROOKE

2:00 P.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Possession of an Unlicensed Firearm,

Possession of Ammunition and Possession of Dangerous Drugs

with Intent to Supply


WEDNESDAY, 16TH SEPTEMBER, 2020


151/2019 FRANKIE PIERRE

10:00 A.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Constitutional Redress, Proceeds of

Crime and Forfeiture

Murrio Ducille & Co. and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

Continued on the next page …..11

11

11


254/2018 TENIRO MINNS

12:00 NOON Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Possession of Unlicensed Firearm and

Possession of Ammunition


183/2017 SIMONE FERGUSON

2:00 P.M. Vs.

REGINA

(Call Over, Possession of Dangerous Drugs with Intent to Supply




60/2020 MALIK WRIGHT

10:00 A.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Fraud by False Pretenses, Causing

Damages, Unauthorized access to a computer

Martin, Martin & Co. and the Director of Public Prosecutions)


12

12


161/2019 LEONARD DAVID SYMONETTE

12:00 NOON Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Possession of Firearm and

Ammunition


183/2019 DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

2:00 P.M. Vs.

ANDRE PEDRO VALDES

(Application for Leave to Appeal, Manslaughter by Negligence

Director of Public Prosecutions and Lennox Coleby)

13

13



95/2020 AMBER LOUISE MURPHY

10:00 A.M. AND

HOT PANCAKES LIMITED

CS&PSA

ANSBACHER (BAHAMAS) LTD.

(Urgent Application, Variation of Ex-parte Injunction

McKinney Bancroft & Hughes and Lennox Paton)

97/2020 GARET O. FINLAYSON

10:00 A.M. AND

MARK A. G. FINLAYSON

CATERPILLAR FINANCIAL SERVICES CORP.

(Urgent Application, Stay of Proceedings

Common Law Center and Attorney General’s Office)

14

14

MONDAY, 21ST SEPTEMBER, 2020


141/2019 SHAQUILLE CULMER

10:00 A.M. Vs.


(EOT Hearing, Refusal of Bail

CML Chambers and Director of Public Prosecutions)


257/2018 ANTONIO WRIGHT

12:00 NOON Vs.


(Call Over, Shopbreaking and Stealing


45/2020 WADE MACKEY

2:00 P.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Shop Breaking and Stealing Ian Cargill & Co. and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

15

15

TUESDAY, 22ND SEPTEMBER, 2020


57/2020 CHARLES WILLIAMS

10:00 A.M. Vs.


(EOT Hearing, Possession of Dangerous Drugs with Intent to Supply

Possession of Dangerous Drugs

Geoffrey W. Farquharson & Co. and Director of Public Prosecutions)

40/2020 SAMUEL JOSEPH

2:00 P.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Housebreaking, Stealing and Receiving Munroe & Associates and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

WEDNESDAY, 23RD SEPTEMBER, 2020


211/2017 PAUL BELLIZAR

10:00 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Substantive Hearing, Murder and Armed Robbery, Adj. from 3/6/2020

Geoffrey Farquharson & Co and the Director of Public Prosecutions)


16

16


226/2018 DEVAUGHN HALL

10:00 A.M. Vs.

REGINA

(Substantive Hearing, Murder and Armed Robbery,

Adj. from 3/6/2020




10:00 A.M. Vs.

JOSEPH FOULKES

(For Mention, Unlawful Sexual Intercourse

Adj. from 3/9/2020



87/2020 ANISHKA A. MISSICK a.k.a ANISHKA HANCHELL

10:30 A.M. AND

LARELL RENARDO LIVINGSTON HANCHELL

(Urgent Application, Ex-parte Custody Order

Pro Se and Cedric L. Parker & Co.)


17

17


95/2020 AMBER LOUISE MURPHY

1:00 P.M. AND

HOT PANCAKES LIMITED

CS&PSA

ANSBACHER (BAHAMAS) LTD.

(Variation of Ex-parte Injunction Application Continuation

Adj. from 18/9/2020

McKinney Bancroft & Hughes and Lennox Paton)



211/2017 PAUL BELLIZAR

10:00 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Substantive Hearing, Murder and Armed Robbery

Adj. from 23/9/2020

Geoffrey Farquharson & Co and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

226/2018 DEVAUGHN HALL

10:00 A.M. Vs.

REGINA

(Substantive Hearing, Murder and Armed Robbery

Adj. from 23/9/2020



18

18


41/2018 LEVARDO MESIDOR

10:00 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Bail Application

Mangra & Co. and Director of Public Prosecutions)

200/2018 CHARLVIN LARAMORE

10:45 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Bail Application, Murder

Pro Se and the Director of Public Prosecutions

277/2018 TERRANCE OMAR PICKSTOCK

11:30 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(Bail Application, Attempted Murder, Possession of Firearm with

Intent to Endanger Life

Pro Se and the Director of Public Prosecutions

93/2020 MARCELLO McKENZIE

12:15 P.M. Vs.

REGINA



96/2020 DENNIS MATHER JR.

2:00 P.M. Vs.



White’s Legal Services and Director of Public Prosecutions)

19

19





29/2019 DENISE BARNES

10:00 A.M. AND

PEARL MOXEY

CHARLES MOXEY JR.

(Final Leave to the Privy Council, Adj. from 27/2/2020

Sharon Wilson & Co. and Bostwick & Bostwick)



12:00 NOON Vs.

REGINA

(Appeal against the Decision, Possession of Dangerous Drugs with Intent to Supply, Adj. 16/9/2020




12:00 NOON Vs.

REGINA

(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Possession of Dangerous Drugs with Intent to Supply, Adj. from 16/9/2020


Continued on the next page …../20

20

20


180/2019 MICHAEL COX

2:00 P.M. Vs.


(Application for Leave to Appeal against conviction Engaging in Gainful Occupation

CG Chambers and the Director of Public Prosecutions)

181/2019 MAURICE COX

2:00 P.M. Vs.


(Application for Leave to Appeal against conviction Engaging in Gainful Occupation

CG Chambers and the Director of Public Prosecutions)



63/2018 JOSEPH DICKERSON

10:00 A.M. Vs.

ATTORNEY GENERAL

(For Mention, Attempted Murder, Adj. from 14/9/2020



21

21


121/2019 BARTHOLOMEW PINDER

10:00 A.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Possession of Dangerous Drugs and Conspiracy to Possess Dangerous Drugs with

intent to supply and Assault with a Deadly Weapon

Geoffrey W. Farquharson Chambers and Director of Public

Prosecutions)

94/2020 BARTHOLOMEW PINDER

10:00 A.M. Vs.

REGINA

(Bail Application, Possession of Dangerous Drugs and Conspiracy

to Possess Dangerous Drugs and Assault with a Deadly Weapon

Geoffrey W. Farquharson & Co. and Director of Public Prosecutions)

124/2019 BILLYDEE ROBINSON JR.

10:00 A.M. Vs.


(Substantive Hearing, Possession of Dangerous Drugs and Conspiracy to Possess Dangerous Drugs with

intent to supply and Assault with a deadly instrument

Geoffrey W. Farquharson Chambers and Director of Public

Prosecutions)


22

22



2:00 P.M. Vs.

SHANNON WILSON aka RAMON WILSON

(Application to Appeal against a Verdict of Acquittal

Director of Public Prosecutions and David Cash)

WEDNESDAY, 30TH SEPTEMBER, 2020 Hon. Sir Michael Barnett, P. Kt.

The Hon. Mr. Justice Jon Isaacs, JA

The Hon. Madam Justice Carolita Bethell, JA.


161/2017 JEAN RIGAUD DERIVAL

10:00 A.M. Vs.


(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Conspiracy to Possess Dangerous Drugs and with Intent to Supply, Conspiracy to Import Dangerous Drugs,

Possession of Dangerous Drugs with Intent to Supply and

Importation of Dangerous Drugs


163/2017 JACQUELY PETIT-HOMME

11:00 A.M. Vs.


(EOT/Substantive Hearing, Conspiracy to Possess Dangerous Drugs

and with Intent to Supply, Conspiracy to Import Dangerous Drugs,

Possession of Dangerous Drugs with Intent to Supply and

Importation of Dangerous Drugs



23

23



12:00 NOON AND

JONATHAN REID

DAVID VALDEZ-LOPEZ

RUDOLPH KERMIT KING

(Certificate of Urgency

Office of the Attorney General and Monique Gomez & Co.)



2:00 P.M. Vs.

CHRISTOPHER JOSEPH

(Application to Appeal Against the withdrawal of the offence

of Manslaughter by Provocation and Manslaughter without intent

from the Jury

Director of Public Prosecutions and David Cash)

RESERVED JUDGEMENTS AND DECISIONS

DATED THIS 30TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2020

Dellarese B. Lightbourn

(for) Registrar Court of Appeal Commonwealth of The Bahamas

24

24

in the bahamas court of appeal criminal and ...226/2018 devaughn hall 10:00 a.m. vs. regina...

Documents