ieta report: mrv considerations for offset projects

8/8/2019 IETA Report: MRV Considerations for Offset Projects

1/16


2/16

!

!!"#$%&%'()*+,%-(.)/01%23.)%43.%05/%/+6*.3+-/+0%

100 King Street West, Suite5700, Toronto, OntarioM5X 1C7, Canada

Tel. +1 (416) 913 0135

Boite 27Rue de la Loi 235Brussels, 1040, BelgiumTel: +32 (0)22 30 11 60Reg. 0889.072.702

24, Rue Merle dAubignGeneva, 1207, SwitzerlandTel: +41 (22) 737 0500

1730 Rhode Island Ave., NW,Suite 802, Washington, DC20036 USATel: +1 (202) 629-5980

!!!

!!

"#$!%&'$&'!()!'#%*!+,+$-!%*!'(!)(./*!(&!'#$!012!'$.#&%.,3%'%$*!%$-$&'!%&!'#$!*$''%&4!/+!,&5!.,--6%&4!(/'!()!())*$'!+-(7$.'*!5$*%4&$5!'(!())$-!.(*'8$))$.'%9$!$:%**%(&!-$5/.'%(&!,&5!-$:(9,3!$,&.$:$&'!(++(-'/&%'%$* ; !)(-!#$&!5%))$-$&'!())*$'!*6*'$:*!,-$!3%&D$5!8!"#!$%&''$(!!)#$!*+*'$%!,$-!",.$!')!/0(12"*$!$%&**&)#!($301'&)#!

1$('&4&1"'$*!-$#$("'$3!!"#)'2$(!*+*'$%5!!62)()0-2!/($.&%"(+!7)(8!7"*!1"((&$3!)0'!/(&)(!')!'2&*!3"'$9!.03-!"!:)'!$44)(' ; !')!1)%/&.$!"!'",.$!'2"'!"''$%/'$3!')!1)%/"($!$"12!$.$%$#'!)4!'2$!3&44$($#'!)44*$'!*+*'$%*!0*-!'2$!+*'$%!4)(!-($$#2)0*$!-"*$*!?/()/)*$3!!NOOR!

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


3/16

! ! ! !!

"#3!NOO[@!"#3!)#$!"1'&B$!*+*'$%F!M.,$('"Q*!E44*$'!>+*'$%!4)(!-($$#2)0*$!-"*$*5!\(&'&*2!=).0%,&"Q*!E44*$'!>+*'$%!4)(!-($$#2)0*$!-"*$*!?*'&..!0#3$(!3$B$.)/%$#'9!3("4'!($-0."'&)#*!:0*'!/0,.&*2$3!)#!E1'),$(!NN9!NOPO@!7"*!&'&"..+!.03$3!!)0(!*'03+!,0'!"*!&'!7&..!,$!1)#*&*'$#'!7&'2!L=J9!&'!7"*!1)#*&3$($3!($30#3"#'!')!.03$!&'!*$/"("'$.+!4()%!)'2$(!L=J!:0(&*3&1'&)#*!!'2$!1)%/"(&*)#!3$*1(&,$3!!'2&*!/"/$(5!!

! M!B).0#'"(+!VWV!($301'&)#!/()-("%F!'2$!=.&%"'$!M1'&)#!Z$*$(B$!?=MZ@!! 67)!B).0#'"(+!VWV!"11)0#'-!/()')1).*F!J>E!PCO]CDN!?J>E@!"#3!'2$!L\=>GXLZJ!

VWV!^()')1).!4)(!^():$1'!M11)0#'-!?VWV!^()')1).@!! 62$!E!"11)0#'-!/(&/.$*5!


4/16

! ! ! !!

6("#*/"($#1+! `! `! `! `! `! `! `! `! `!=)#*$(B"'&B$#$**! `! ! `! `! `! `! `! `! `!=)#4&3$#'&".&'+! `! `! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

M//()/(&"'$#$**!?1)#*&3$(!.)1".!1)#3&'&)#*@!

! ! `! ! ! ! ! ! !

^("1'&1".&'+! ! ! ! ! ! `! ! ! !!

!;5 62$!THU!!HZ

! F5$&'%)6!,33!-$3$9,&'!! G$3$.'!'#$!! J$'$-:%&$ !72&12!)4!'2$*$!>>Z*!%0*'!,$!($-0."(.+! :(&%'(-$5 !"#3!72&12!

)#$*!1"#!:0*'!,$! $*'%:,'$5 !D!M!7(&''$#!:0*'&4&1"'&)#!4)(!#)'!*$.$1'-!"!($.$B"#'!VWV!>>Z!4)(!($-0."(!%)#&')(-!&*!0*0"..+!,0'!#)'!".7"+*!($Y0&($35!

! K/,&'%)6 !VWV!$%&**&)#*!"#3X)(!($%)B".*!4)(!$"12!>>Z!($.$B"#'!')!'2$!/():$1'9!"#3!*$/"("'$.+!4)(!$"12!>>Z!!'2$!,"*$.$!*1$#"(&)5!

! K/,&'%)6 !(9$-,33 !VWV!$%&**&)#!($301'&)#*!"#3X)(!($%)B".!$#2"#1$%$#'*!"*!'2$!3&44$($#1$!,$'7$$#!'2$!VWV!$%&**&)#*!"#3X)(!($%)B".*!($."'&B$!')!'2$!/():$1'!"#3!'2)*$!!'2$!,"*$.$!*1$#"(&)5!

! 0,&,4$!5,',!I/,3%'6!L! 0#1$('"'+!"**$**%$#'!0*0"..+!($Y0&($35!L2$#!0#1$('"'+!.$B$.*!"($!'))!2&-29!1$('"!/()-("%*!($Y0&($!'2"'!"!1)#*$(B"'&B$!Y0"#'&4&1"'&)#!%$'2)3!,$!"//.&$3!!)(3$(!')!$#*0($!'2"'!$%&**&)#!($301'&)#*!"#3X)(!($%)B".!$#2"#1$%$#'*!"($!#)'!)B$($*'&%"'$35!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!7 This paper does not cover the determination of baseline scenarios.8 Controlled by, related to or affected by the offset project


5/16

! ! ! !!

C5 62$!TZU!!HZ

62$($!"($!*$B$(".!/():$1'!3)10%$#'*!'2"'!"($!&%/)('"#'!4)(!'2$!'$-(&'+!"#3!'("#*/"($#1+!)4!"#!)44*$'!*+*'$%!"#3!"($!8$+!')!'2$!B".&3"'&)#!"#3!B$(&4&1"'&)#!*'"-$*F!

! 62$!/():$1'!3$*&-#!3)10%$#'!)(!/():$1'!/."#!

! 62$!%)#&')(-!($/)('*!

! 62$!/():$1'!($/)('*!

!C5P5 ^():$1'!G$*&-#!G)10%$#'9!^():$1'!G$*1(&/'&)#!)(!^():$1'!^."#!

62$!^():$1'!G$*&-#!G)10%$#'9!^():$1'!G$*1(&/'&)#!)(!^():$1'!^."#!&*!"!8$+!3)10%$#'!

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a0"#'&4&1"'&)#9!H)#&')(-!"#3!aMXa=!^."#*!&*!".($"3+!)0'.$3!!'2$!/():$1'!*/$1&4&1!/()')1).5!J#!*)%$!/()-("%*!?=MZ!4)(!$S"%/.$@!'2$!^():$1'!G$*&-#!G)10%$#'!)(!^():$1'!G$*1(&/'&)#!&*!($/."1$3!,+!"!^():$1'!>0,%&''".!A)(%!1)#'"-!'2$!)(%"'&)#!#$$3$3!')!"**$**!'2$!/():$1'Q*!$.&-&,&.&'+5!!

!L2$#!"!%)($!1)%/.$'$!^():$1'!G$*&-#!G)10%$#'!&*!#$$3$3!?4)(!$S"%/.$!!'2$!=GH!)(!0#3$(!M.,$('"Q*!($-0."'&)#@9!&'!0*0"..+!1)B$(*!'2$!4)..)7-!"($"*F!!

J5 ^():$1'!&3$#'&4&1"'&)#!

! ^():$1'!'&'.$9!/0(/)*$*!"#3!),:$1'&B$*!! ^():$1'!.)1"'&)#!

!JJ5 ^():$1'!1)#'"1'!)(%"'&)#!!

! ^():$1'!/()/)#$#'!! 6$12#&1".!1)#*0.'"#'*!! E'2$(!/"('&$*!7&'2!"!%"'$(&".!'$($*'!! ^$)/.$!72)!1"#!/()B&3$!)(%"'&)#!)#!"#+!-)B$(#%$#'!/()-("%*!/()B&3-!

4"#1&".!)(!)'2$(!"**&*'"#1$!4)(!'2$!1"((+-!)0'!)4!'2$!/():$1'!! Z).$*!"#3!($*/)#*&,&.&'&$*!


6/16

! ! ! !!

!JJJ5 ():$1'!3$*1(&/'&)#!

! =)#3&'&)#*!/(&)(!')!/():$1'!&'&"'&)#!! ^():$1'!3$*&-#!')!"12&$B$!VWV!$%&**&)#!($301'&)#*!"#3X)(!($%)B".!

$#2"#1$%$#'*!! ^():$1'!'$12#).)-&$*9!/()301'*9!*$(B&1$*!"#3!'2$!$S/$1'$3!.$B$.!)4!"1'&B&'+!

!J'"8$2).3$(!1)#*0.'"'&)#!3)10%$#'*!!

C5N5 H)#&')(-!Z$/)('*!

0(&%'(-%&4!-$+(-'* !"($!($Y0&($3!,+!%)*'!)44*$'!/()-("%*5!62$+!"($!3$*&-#$3!')!/()B&3$!)(%"'&)#!"#3!3"'"!)#!%$"*0($3!"#3!$*'&%"'$3!VWV!$%&**&)#*!($."'$3!')!'2$!/():$1'!"*!7$..!"*!"..!'2$!*0//)('-!3"'"!?1".10."'&)#!d!$*'&%"'&)#!%$'2)3*9!1)#B$(*&)#!4"1')(*!d!)'2$(!*'"#3"(3!4"1')(*9!1".&,("'&)#!)4!%)#&')(-!$Y0&/%$#'9!3"'"!"#3!)(%"'&)#!%"#"-$%$#'!*+*'$%*!"#3!1)#'().*@!!"11)(3"#1$!7&'2!'2$!%)#&')(-!/."#5!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!![ !e#3$(!M.,$('"Q*!($-0."'&)#9! /():$1'!*1)/$ !$S/."*!'2$!40#1'&)#!)4!'2$!/():$1'!"#3!"..!)4!'2$!($.$B"#'!1)%/)#$#'*!"#3!1.$"(.+!&3$#'&4&$*!72&12!"1'&B&'&$*!"($!.03$3X$S1.03$3!4)(!'2$!/0(/)*$*!)4!Y0"#'&4&1"'&)#!)4!VWV!($301'&)#*5!J#!)'2$(!/()-("%*9!/():$1'!*1)/$!1)(($*/)#3*!')!/():$1'!'+/$5!PO!e#3$(!M.,$('"Q*!($-0."'&)#9! /():$1'!,)0#3"(+ !3$*1(&,$*!'2$!,)0#3"(&$*!4)(!'2$!)44*$'!/():$1'5!62$!/():$1'!,)0#3"(+!%"+!$S'$#3!,$+)#3!'2$!/2+*&1".!)(!-$)-("/2&1".!,)0#3"(&$*!)4!'2$!/():$1'Q*!("*'(01'0($9!)(!%"+!,$!"!*%"..$(!/)('&)#!)4!"!."(-$(!/2+*&1".!*&'$!,)0#3"(+5


7/16

! ! ! !!

H)*'!/()-("%*!*/$1&4+!'2$!#$$3!4)(!/():$1'!/()/)#$#'*!')!/($/"($!*$/"("'$!%)#&')(-!($/)('*!?9!VWV!^()')1).9!=GH9!IJ9! !"#"$" @5!J#!)'2$(!/()-("%*9!/():$1'!/()/)#$#'*!"($!#)'!($Y0&($3!')!/($/"($!"!%)#&')(-!($/)('!/$(!*$!,0'!')!*$'!0/!"!($1)(3D8$$/-!/."#!?=MZ9!J>E!PCO]CDN@5!!J#!'2$!=GH9!"!'$%/."'$!4)(!%)#&')(-!($/)('*!&*!#)7!"B"&.",.$!"#3!($Y0&($3!')!,$!0*$35!H)#&')(-!($/)('*!0#3$(!'2$!=GH!($1)(3!"%)#-!)'2$(!'2-*9!'2$!1$('&4&$3!$%&**&)#!($301'&)#*!?=cZ*@!-$#$("'$3!"#3!'20*!*$(B$!'2$!/0(/)*$!)4!"!/($.&%"(+!/():$1'!($/)('9!/(&)(!')!GEc!B$(&4&1"'&)#5!!62$!VWV!^()')1).!($Y0&($*!'2$!%)#&')(-!($/)('!')!,$!/()301$3!1)#1)%&'"#'.+!7&'2!'2$!"##0".!Y0"#'&4&1"'&)#!($/)('!!)(3$(!')!1)#4&(%!'2"'!'2$!VWV!/():$1'!2"*!,$$#!&%/.$%$#'$3!"*!/."##$35!!

E44*$'!%)#&')(-!($/)('*!1"#!,$!3&($1'$3!')!($-0."')(+!,)3&$*9!"*!&*!'2$!1"*$!!M.,$('"!"#3!L=J!:0(&*3&1'&)#*!72$($!'2$!1($3&'*!/()301$3!"($9!)(!"($!/()/)*$3!')!,$9!0*$3!4)(!1)%/.&"#1$!/0(/)*$*5!

!

C5;5 ^():$1'!Z$/)('*!

M!+-(7$.'!-$+(-' !&*!"!1)%/&."'&)#!)4!)(%"'&)#!)#!"#!)44*$'!/():$1'5!G$/$#3-!)#!'2$!)44*$'!/()-("%9!'2$*$!($/)('*!"($!1)%/&.$3!$&'2$(!/(&)(!')!/():$1'!B$(&4&1"'&)#!?VWV!^()')1).9!=MZ9!="#"3"9!=GH@!"#3!*$(B$!"*!"!,"*&*!4)(!/():$1'!B$(&4&1"'&)#!"1'&B&'&$*9!)(!"4'$(!/():$1'!B$(&4&1"'&)#5!!J#!'2$!4)(%$(!1"*$!"#3!4)(!*)%$!/()-("%*9!/():$1'!($/)('*!"($!#)'!*/$..$3!)0'!"*!*012!,0'!1)#*&*'!)4!"!1)%,"'&)#!)4!*$B$(".!)'2$(!/():$1'!3)10%$#'*F!4)(!$S"%/.$!'2$!%)#&')(-!($/)('*!"#3!'2$!VWV!M**$('&)#PP5!J#!'2$!."''$(!1"*$9!/():$1'!($/)('*!"($!"&%$3!"'!)(%-!'2$!/0,.&1!",)0'!'2$!/():$1'!"#3!"($!#)'!($Y0&($3!')!1)#'"!"#+!1)#4&3$#'&".!)(%"'&)#!?J>E!PCO]CDN@5!J#!)'2$(!7)(3*9!'2$!*&-#&4&1"#1$!)4!/():$1'!($/)('-!3&44$(*!$#'&($.+!4()%!$#B&()#%$#'".!/$(4)(%"#1$!($/)('-!4()%!)(-"#&_"'&)#*5!A)(!/():$1'*9!($/)('-!&*!0*0"..+!*+#)#+%)0*!7&'2!'$(#".!($1)(3!8$$/-!)4!VWV!$%&**&)#!($301'&)#*!"#3X)(!($%)B".!$#2"#1$%$#'*!1".10."'&)#*!3)#$!,"*$3!)#!'2$!/()1$30($*!)4!'2$!/():$1'Q*!%)#&')(-!/."#5!62$*$!($1)(3*9!)4'$#!1)%/&.$3!!"!%)#&')(-!($/)('9!"($!'2$#!($B&$7$3!,+!B$(&4&$(*5!


8/16

! ! ! !!

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


9/16

! ! ! !!

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e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

B".&3"')(XB$(&4&$(!"11($3&'"'&)#!($Y0&($%$#'*9!'2$!.$B$.*!)4!"**0("#1$!($Y0$*'$3!"-"*'!"!B".&3"'&)#XB$(&4&1"'&)#!*'"'$%$#'!"#3!."*'.+!'2$!1)#'$#'*!)4!'2$!B$(&4&1"'&)#!*'"'$%$#'*!"1()**!'2$!3&44$($#'!/()-("%*5!!

K5P5


10/16

! ! ! !!

N,:$!()!+-(4-,:!

2,3%5,'%(&! 2$-%)%.,'%(&!G.(+$! OH7$.'%9$*! G.(+$!! OH7$.'%9$*!G)10%$#'!

^0,.&1!1)%%$#'*!

^)**&,.$!*&'$!B&*&'*!"#3!1)#*0.'"'&)#*!7&'2!'2$!.)1".!*'"8$2).3$(*!

/():$1'!&*!"!B".&3!=GH!

/():$1'!,+!($4$($#1$!')!"#!"//()B$3!%$'2)3).)-+X/()')1).!

($1)(3*!)4!'2$!

=cZ*!-$#$("'$3!

1$('&4&1"'&)#!

($/)('!,"*$3!)#!'2$!B$(&4&1"'&)#!"**$**%$#'!

IJ! ^():$1'!G$*&-#!G)10%$#'!

^0,.&1!1)%%$#'*!

A".!3$'$(%"'&)#!($/)('!,+!($4$($#1$!')!($Y0$*'*!)4!2)*'!-)B$(#%$#'!"#3!/)'$#'&"..+!'2$!IJ!)B$(*&-2'!,)3+Q*!"//()B$3!/()')1).*!

H)#&')(-!($/)('*!7&'2!/)**&,.$!*&'$!B&*&'*!


11/16

! ! ! !!

N,:$!()!+-(4-,:!

2,3%5,'%(&! 2$-%)%.,'%(&!G.(+$! OH7$.'%9$*! G.(+$!! OH7$.'%9$*!

($301'&)#!

1".10."'&)#*!"*!/$(!'2$!($Y0&($%$#'*!)4!J>E!PCO]CD;!

J>E!PCO]CDN! G)10%$#'*!"#3!)(%"'&)#!*)0(1$*!"*!3$4$3!!J>E!PCO]CD;P] !

E!PCO]CD;Pb!

'"#3"(35!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"


12/16

! ! ! !!

!IJF!J#3$/$#3$#'!c#'&'+!'2"'!&*!"11($3&'$3!,+!'2$!IJ!>0/$(B&*)(+!=)%%&''$$!?IJ>=@!4)(!'2$!($.$B"#'!*1)/$!"11)(3-!')!'2$!IJ!"11($3&'"'&)#!*'"#3"(35!!="#"3"F!62&(3D/"('+!B$(&4&$(!"11($3&'$3!,+!'2$!>'"#3"(3*!=)0#1&.!)4!="#"3"!!"11)(3"#1$!7&'2!J>E!PCO]K5!E!PCO]K!($Y0&($%$#'*5!!L=JF!E!PCO]KFNOOb!7&'2!"#!"11($3&'"'&)#!*1)/$!*/$1&4&1"..+!4)(!'2$!!^()-("%5!


13/16

! ! ! !!

($"*)#",.$!.$B$.!)4!"**0("#1$!1)#1$(#-!'2$&(!B".&3"'&)#XB$(&4&1"'&)#!*'"'$%$#'*i!M.,$('"!($Y0&($*!"!.&%&'$3!.$B$.!)4!"**0("#1$i!J>E!PCO]CD;!*'"'$*!'2"'!'2$!.$B$.!)4!"**0("#1$!%0*'!,$!"-($$3!0/)#!7&'2!'2$!1.&$#'5!!!

K5C5 =)#'$#'!)4!'2$!B$(&4&1"'&)#!*'"'$%$#'*!!

e#3$(!'2$!9!'2$!B$(&4&1"'&)#!*'"'$%$#'!*2"..!*'"'$!'2$!"1'0".!"%)0#'!)4!E!PCO]CD;!($Y0&($%$#'*!"*!4"(!"*!B$(&4&1"'&)#!"1'&B&'&$*!"($!1)#1$(#$35!!J#!'2$!=MZ!/()-("%9!'2$!B$(&4&1"'&)#!*'"'$%$#'!&*!"1'0"..+!1)%/)*$3!)4!'2($$!3)10%$#'*F!'2$!'"#3"(3!0*$3!')!B$(&4+!VWV!$%&**&)#*!($301'&)#*!)(!($%)B".*! ! `! `! !G$'"&.*!)4!'2$!B$(&4&1"'&)#!'$"%! ! ! ! `!E,:$1'&B$*!)4!B".&3"'&)#XB$(&4&1"'&)#! `! ! `! !>1)/$!)4!B".&3"'&)#XB$(&4&1"'&)#! `! `! `! `!G$*1(&/'&)#!)4!'2$!$.&-&,&.&'+!"**$**%$#'9!($-0."')(+!'$*'! ! `! ! !


14/16

! ! ! !!

=(&'$(&"!)4!B".&3"'&)#XB$(&4&1"'&)#! `! `! `! !G$*1(&/'&)#!)4!'2$!B$(&4&1"'&)#!"1'&B&'&$*X/()1$**! ! `! ! `!g&*'!)4!($.$B"#'!$%&**&)#!*)0(1$*!&3$#'&4&$3!"#3!("#8$3!,+!

%"-#&'03$!

! `! ! !

G$*1(&/'&)#!)4!'2$!*"%/.-!'$12#&Y0$*9!/."#!"#3!(&*8!"**$**%$#'!%$'2)3).)-&$*!$%/.)+$3!4)(!$"12!*)0(1$!

! `! ! !

cB".0"'&)#!)4!72$'2$(!'2$!/():$1'!&*!!1)%/.&"#1$!7&'2!'2$!"//.&1",.$!/():$1'!/()')1).!

! `! ! !

cB".0"'&)#!)4!72$'2$(!'2$!/():$1'!&*!!1)%/.&"#1$!7&'2!'2$!^():$1'!G$*&-#!G)10%$#'9!'2$!%)#&')(-!/."#!!1)%/.&"#1$!7&'2!'2$!%)#&')(-!%$'2)3).)-+9!%)#&')(-!!1)%/.&"#1$!7&'2!'2$!%)#&')(-!/."#!!

! ! ! `!

M!.&*'!)4!$"12!/"("%$'$(!*/$1&4&$3!,+!'2$!%)#&')(-!/."#!"#3!"!1.$"(!*'"'$%$#'!)#!2)7!'2$!B".0$*!!'2$!%)#&')(-!($/)('!2"B$!,$$#!B$(&4&$3!

! ! ! `!

=)%/"(&*)#!)4!'2$!/():$1'Q*!)B$("..!VWV!($%)B".*!)(!($301'&)#*!7&'2!'2$!B$(&4&$(Q*!1".10."'&)#!)4!VWV!($%)B".*!)(!($301'&)#*!

! `! ! `!

G$*1(&/'&)#!)4!72$'2$(!'2$!3"'"!"#3!)(%"'&)#!*0//)('-!'2$!VWV!"**$('&)#!7$($!2+/)'2$'&1".9!/():$1'$3!"#3X)(!2&*')(&1".!!#"'0($!

`! ! ! !

g&*'!)4!4-*!)4!'2$!3$*8!($B&$7!"#3!*&'$!B&*&'*! ! ! ! `!M**$**%$#'!)4!($%"-!&**0$*!4()%!'2$!/($B&)0*!B$(&4&1"'&)#!/$(&)39!&4!"//()/(&"'$!

! ! ! `!

Z$*/)#*&,.$!/"('+Q*!VWV!"**$('&)#! `! ! `! !=)#1.0*&)#!)#!'2$!VWV!"**$('&)#9!.03-!"#+!Y0".&4&1"'&)#*!)(!.&%&'"'&)#*!?)(!)#!'2$!B$(&4&$3!"%)0#'!)4!$%&**&)#!($301'&)#*!"12&$B$3@!

`! `! `! `!

!

O9$-,33!.(&.3/*%(&*!,&5!&$V'!*'$+*!!62$($!"($!'7)!*&-#&4&1"#'!3&44$($#1$*!!'2$!7"+!'2"'!'2$!/()-("%*!1)B$($3!,+!'2&*!*'03+!7$($!)(!"($!,$-!,0&.'!'2"'!2"B$!"#!&%/"1'!)#!'2$!HZ


15/16

! ! ! !!

"33&'&)#".&'+!'$*'-!"#3!,"*$.$!3$'$(%"'&)#!2"B$!,$$#!1)#301'$3!0/!4()#'!30(-!'2$!1($"'&)#!/2"*$!)4!"!/()')1).9!'20*!%"8-!$%&**&)#!($301'&)#!1".10."'&)#*!4)(!/():$1'!/()/)#$#'*!%)($!*'("&-2'4)(7"(3!"#3!B$(&4&1"'&)#!"1'&B&'&$*!.$**!3$/$#3"#'!)#!/():$1'!*/$1&4&1!*&'0"'&)#*!'2"'!%"+!1($"'$!,&"*!"#3!($"*$!0#1$('"'+5!!!M#)'2$(!%":)(!3&44$($#1$!($*&3$*!!'2$!"11($3&'"'&)#!($Y0&($%$#'*!4)(!B$(&4&$(*!?J>E!PCO]K9!G$*&-#"'$3!E/$("'&)#".!c#'&'+9!=MZ\!"11($3&'$3!B$(&4&$(*9!12"('$($3!"11)0#'"#'*!)(!/()4$**&)#".!$#-$$(*@5!h$B$('2$.$**!'2$($!*$$%*!')!,$!"!1)#B$(-$#1$!')7"(3*!J>E!PCO]K!7&'2!4)(!$S"%/.$!=MZ!($Y0&(-!"11($3&'"'&)#!"-"*'!'2&*!'$(#"'&)#".!*'"#3"(3!4)(!&'*!B$(&4&1"'&)#!,)3&$*!"*!)4!I"#0"(+!NOPP!"#3!M.,$('"!2$"3-!'2$($!Y0&18.+!"*!7$..5!!M/"('!4()%!'2$*$!'7)!%":)(!3&44$($#1$*9!'2$($!*$$%*!')!,$!"!($."'&B$.+!1)#*&*'$#'!

HZ

!!!!!!!!1$)$-$&.$*!!c#B&()#%$#'!="#"3"!

!"#"$"*)(+,,)&-(./)-&0(,1'(2'&)&(2")&)(5(+6&'67&8 !?3("4'!4)(!/0,.&1!1)%%$#'9!I0#$!NOO[@!!"#"$"*)(+,,)&-(./)-&0(,1'(2'&)&(2")&)(5(247$&(,1'(9'1-1:1;(4;&)(,1'(@&'7,7:"-71#("#$(247$"#:&(,1'(@&'7,7:"-71#(A1$7&)(?3("4'!4)(!/0,.&1!1)%%$#'9!I0#$!NOO[@!

!M.,$('"!c#B&()#%$#'D!>/$1&4&$3!V"*!c%&''$(*!Z$-0."'&)#!

+,,)&-(!'&$7-(9'1?&:-(247$"#:&(


16/16

! ! ! !!

B&:3#7:";(247$"#:&(,1'(+,,)&-(9'1?&:-(&:100$"-71#)(9"%&' !?M/(&.!NOPO@!!=.&%"'$!M1'&)#!Z$*$(B$!

! 9'1='"0(G"#4"; !?H"(12!P]9!NOPO@!! @&'7,7:"-71#(9'1='"0(G"#4"; !?I0#$!Pb9!NOO[@!

!ehA===!

H/1-1(9'1-1:1;(-1(-3&(I#7-&$(J"-71#)(K'"0&81'L(!1#6-71#(1#(!;70"-&(!3"#=& !?P[[b@!H/1-1(9'1-1:1;(A":L='14#$M(N17#-(D0%;&0-"-71#(H/1-1(9'1-1:1;(G&:3"#7)0)M(N17#-(D0%;&0-"-71#(247$&;7#&)(,1'(-3&(4)&')(1,(-3&(?17#-(70%;&0-"-71#(%'1?&:-($&)7=#($1:40-(,1'0!

?E!PCO]CDN!.%&:7,7:"-71#(87-3(=47$"#:&("-(-3&(%'1?&:-(;&6&;(,1'(O4"#-7,7:"-71#P(01#7-1'7#=("#$('&%1'-7#=(1,(='&)&(=")(&07))71#('&$4:-71#)(1'('&016";("#:&0-) !

J>E!PCO]CD;!.%&:7,7:"-71#(87-3(=47$"#:&(,1'(-3&(6";7$"-71#("#$(6&'7,7:"-71#(1,(

='&)&(=")("))&'-71#)(J>E!PCO]K!!10%&-:&('&O47'&0-)(,1'(='&)&(=")(6";7$"-71#("#$(6&'7,7:"-71#(

-&"0)(87-3(=47$"#:&(,1'(&6";4"-71# !L\=>GXLZJ!VWV!^()')1).!4)(!^():$1'!M11)0#'-!?2''/FXX7775-2-/()')1).5)(-X4&.$*X-2-j/():$1'j/()')1).5/34@!!

ieta report: mrv considerations for offset projects

Documents