human-like ai quest drives general ai development …...human-like ai quest drives general ai...
TRANSCRIPT
Page 1 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
In this e-guide:
While AI technologies can do things humans can't, they're
currently limited to specific and straightforward tasks -- a state
known as narrow AI. A big goal -- or holy grail -- for developers
is to create human-like AI tools that think the way people do.
Estimates of how long it will take to make so-called general AI a
reality range from a few years to more than a century. Much
work lies ahead. "We will not get there using the techniques we
have today," Raj Minhas, head of the AI research lab at Xerox's
Palo Alto Research Center, told TechTarget contributor Maria
Korolov.
This guide compiles stories on the push toward human-like AI
and the challenges that AI vendors and users must overcome.
Page 2 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Common sense AI approaches point to more general applications
Maria Korolov, Technology Journalist
Artificial general intelligence is the holy grail of AI research; this form of an AI
system can think for itself, has common sense, has a similar intelligence level to
humans and could even pass for a human in conversation.
AGI raises big questions about ethics and human employment, but the most
fundamental questions about AGI and how close we are to it have yet to be
answered.
In late 2018, in a book titled Architects of Intelligence, futurist Martin Ford
interviewed AI professionals who said that, on average, there was a 50%
chance that common sense AI would be completed by 2099. Google's Ray
Kurzweil put it at 2029. Rodney Brooks, co-founder of iRobot, was at the end of
the spectrum, predicting the year 2200.
Samir Hans, AI expert at Deloitte Risk and Financial Advisory, predicted that
we're going to see tangible results in two to three years. AI can already learn
from its mistakes, which means there's a feedback loop that improves the AI
over time.
Page 3 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
So, why the spectrum of possible application dates? Part of the problem is the
very definition of AGI and how we measure it.
What is intelligence?
There was a time when technology's ability to do mathematics or make logical
inferences was a sign of intelligence. As soon as calculators were invented, the
goal posts were moved. Where is the goal for AGI? Maybe it's the ability to play
chess. To parse human speech. To extract meaning from text. To translate from
one language to another. To play Jeopardy. To pass a Turing test. As AI hits
each of those milestones, it becomes clear that we still aren't seeing true AI in
its final form.
"My definition of general AI is where a machine is fully autonomous, performing
human tasks, without human involvement," said Josh Elliot, director of AI at
Booz Allen Hamilton Inc. "And you need the ability to perceive, and learn, and
act and the emotional side of what humans actually bring to the table."
Today, AI is primarily special-purpose machine learning systems and algorithms
that can do one thing well, Elliot said. This is narrow AI, and while it's getting
really good, AGI requires the ability to do tasks across multiple silos.
"We can get very good results in specific domains, but there is a huge gap,"
said Raj Minhas, head of the AI research lab at the Palo Alto Research Center.
Page 4 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Minhas said that he wouldn't even hazard a guess about whether technology
would ever achieve AGI.
"We will not get there using the techniques we have today," he added. "The
techniques we have are the ladders that allow us to climb skyscrapers, but they
won't get us to the moon."
Page 5 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Page 6 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
With each new advance in AI, the definition of AGI gets more nebulous. As
computers advance calculation, analysis and predictive abilities, the criteria for
real intelligence becomes more amorphous and includes feelings, self-
awareness, empathy and ethics.
"You can have a machine that's very adept at learning, but does it have the
ability to be sentient?" said Matt Jackson, VP of digital innovation services at
Insight, a consulting and system integration firm.
With the increase in available computational power, the emergence of quantum
computers and the improvements in AI algorithms, the progression to eventual
common sense AI is there.
"It will happen in a reasonable lifetime, 20 to 50 years, probably on the latter
end," Jackson added.
But a machine that can be useful and capable enough to pass a Turing test is a
lot closer, he said.
"If you take Siri or Alexa and think about how it can expand on the abilities [we]
have today, then you're effectively simulating general AI with multiple types of
narrow AI," he said. "I think we will have that in a decade or two."
Or maybe even sooner, according to some experts.
Page 7 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
"When I studied AI at university, I was taught that we would have completed AI
if it could beat a human being -- a grandmaster -- at the ancient Chinese game
of Go," said Rob Clyde, chair of the ISACA board of directors.
"Software could not brute-force it, like it can [in] tic-tac-toe, checkers or chess.
Two years ago, Google bought an AI that beat a grandmaster. The holy grail
has been reached. Since then, they have built self-learning AIs that learn by
playing themselves," he continued.
According to Clyde, with platforms like AlphaGo and Watson, the same AIs can
do many different things -- achieving some experts' definitions of AGI.
"I would argue that the tipping point has been reached. We've reached the point
where the growth is exponential. The pace is going to be incredible over the
next few years," Clyde added.
Progress measurement
Along with no clear definition of common sense AI, the AI industry also lacks
clear metrics for progress.
One common approach is to measure the success of AI algorithms at particular
tasks, such as image recognition or natural language processing. Here, AI
systems are quickly approaching -- or already exceeding -- human levels of
performance, and the rate of progress is accelerating.
Page 8 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
In 2017, AI programs matched or exceeded human performance at identifying
skin cancer, recognizing speech, and playing poker and arcade games. In 2018,
AI matched humans at tasks including translating Chinese to English and
grading prostate cancer. AI systems keep getting better at communicating with
humans. Last May, a new language benchmark test, General Language
Understanding Evaluation, was released. AIs scored at under 70% -- compared
to around 90% for humans. By October, AIs had already improved, with scores
crossing the 80% mark.
If AI can continuously improve, how do we measure progress vs. achievement?
Maybe AGI depends on common sense -- being able to explain what's going on
in a situation. Say, for example, looking at a picture and answering questions
about what's going on and why. But who sets the limit, the goal, and when is it
achieved?
What comes after common sense?
AGI will enable companies to move on from AI technology that currently exists
as narrow, special-purpose machine learning systems that are difficult to train
and calibrate.
Banks, for example, will be able to gauge customer emotions, identify special
needs cases, make more accurate predictions and better detect fraud, said
Raghav Nyapati, digital automation product strategist at Bank of America.
Page 9 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
"In order for the machines to reach that state of general artificial intelligence, it
might take another 10 years. We are already seeing some of this, where
systems are able to discern a person's emotional state based on their voice or
facial recognition," Nyapati said.
With common sense AI, the Anderson Center for Autism could get answers to
questions it didn't know it needed to ask, said CIO Gregg Paulk. His center
currently uses HR tools from Ultimate Software to predict which of its most
valuable employees are most likely to leave the company early enough for the
organisation to take steps to improve their job satisfaction.
"If [AI] had common sense, it could identify areas where we can improve, such
as with tasks that we're doing on a daily basis," he said. "I think that would have
a huge reward. A lot of times, you don't know what you don't know."
Page 10 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Artificial intelligence creativity tools mimic human ability
Ronald Schmelzer, Principal analyst
While conversation about artificial intelligence is centered on augmenting the
enterprise or adding value to daily lives, there is also unique interest and effort
in applying AI to creative human pursuits. While artificial intelligence creativity
might not seem relevant to enterprises, the use of machine learning to generate
images and video, craft text for ad copy, marketing materials, press releases
and speeches has definite impact in the business sector.
AI turns to text
AI systems that create and generate text of all forms have been used with
surprisingly good results. Early experiments in natural language generation
(NLG) were focused on converting numerical and quantitative data into a more
natural narrative form. In the past, this would have required human analysts to
spend hours poring over data to generate reports. However, AI-based systems
can now easily complete content summarization and report generation with very
similar levels of quality in just minutes.
Page 11 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
News organisations and media outlets -- ranging from Bloomberg, The
Washington Post, The New York Times and Forbes -- have been using NLG
systems to generate content for general consumption. Other companies in the
financial, insurance, legal and healthcare industries are adopting AI-based NLG
systems to generate content that can be consumed by nontechnical users. The
user-friendly content produced includes financial reports in human-readable text
form, synopses of healthcare records and data, and analysis of legal cases and
intellectual property research for legal workers.
Recently, OpenAI released a deep learning neural network model that can
generate entire paragraphs of coherent text from just a small block of
introductory words, phrases and facts. OpenAI's artificial intelligence creativity
platform focuses on maintaining coherence and accuracy at a large scale --
from 500 to thousands of words. Even in its limited released form, these
pretrained neural network models are proving to be very helpful in generating
longer-form content that would otherwise be the job of marketing, analysts or
communications teams in an organisation.
Generating audio, speech and music
Computer-generated speech has been around for decades -- however most of
that generated speech comes from a list of preprogrammed output responses,
or by combining words together from a preselected list. It's only recently that
speech and audio are being generated without manual interference by systems
Page 12 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
that use AI and machine learning to generate good quality audio that mimics
human speech.
In May 2018, Google demonstrated this at their Google I/O event with a demo of
their Google Duplex intelligent assistant. The assistant was able to make phone
reservations for a haircut and book restaurant reservations with the human on
the other end of the call unaware they were speaking with a robot. The assistant
generated conversations, responded to questions, and elaborated on
information while using frequent human pauses, interjections and fillers.
In 2016, Adobe's VoCo preview showed ability to modify existing audio to say
things speakers didn't actually say; using existing clips to change intent. These
demos, still unfinished, show the power of AI-enabled voice and speech
generation that could be used for a wide range of practical purposes.
In addition to human speech, AI is enabling a high-quality generation of music
and other audio output. In 2018, YouTube personality Taryn Southern released
a record produced and composed entirely by AI. While Southern provided inputs
that controlled the feel of the music, the AI system was able to generate new
music by synthesizing existing tracks. The immediate application of this
technology is to produce original, royalty-free music for video background music
or other applications.
Page 13 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Does this photo exist?
Some of the most powerful examples of artificial intelligence creativity tools are
in the creation of images and video. Machine learning systems using deep
learning approaches are able to create lifelike images of people that don't
actually exist using GANS image compilation. Other AI-based systems can
create original advertising copy and images, generate original film trailers for
movies, and create new paintings mimicking and adhering to the style of notable
artists.
The applications of artificial intelligence creative technology in the enterprise
range from marketing departments generating original hyper-personalized
advertisements to healthcare organisations generating helpful videos tailored to
the specific needs of their patients. Whatever the intent, the use of machine
learning to create images and video is on a path from fringe use to mainstream
application.
The bigger question surrounding creative AI is, are these systems exhibiting
real creativity or simply mimicking the creative ability of humans? Where does
the line of adaptation and imitation end and creativity begin? While we seek the
metaphysical answers, AI-based systems remixing human creative output to
generate new results are proving to be extremely valuable for organisations in
generating text, images and audio they need without requiring the human labor
for creativity.
Page 14 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
More curiosity could help narrow AI tools handle broader uses
Torsten Volk, Managing Research Director
Artificial intelligence has made significant strides in recent years, but it still has a
major constraint: narrowness.
The inherent limitation of AI today is its specificity. You can get a narrow AI
application to take orders at the McDonald's drive-thru or beat the world's best
chess and Go players. You can build AI software that drives cars with fewer
accidents than humans. You can also use AI for quality control in product
assembly, diagnosing cancer or prequalifying mortgage applicants. However,
the moment you change up the task even slightly, the AI tool is at a loss as to
how to respond.
To understand the specificity issue of AI, it is key to look at the underlying core
principle of how AI works today. The issue is rooted in the conceptual approach
of approximating human decision-making by combining sets of algorithms into a
model that is then rewarded for good responses to environmental stimuli and
punished for bad ones.
Page 15 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
AI equation: Algorithms plus compute power
The narrow AI of today is based on sophisticated algorithms and incredible
amounts of brute force compute power. We define AI as an accumulation of
better and better algorithms relying on better and better hardware to calculate
their way out of narrowly defined challenges.
For example, when looking for a tumor on a CT image, an AI application sees
combinations of individual pictures that have no meaning by themselves.
However, different combinations of pixels in an image can be correlated with
different probabilities of cancer being present.
This is a fundamentally different approach from how a human doctor looks for
cancer. Instead of using abstract processing power, the doctor leverages her
experience, skill and intuition to look for indications of cancer where they are
most likely to occur. Ultimately, this can lead her to identify a few corner cases
of cancer and, hopefully, save some lives by doing so.
On the other hand, the AI application is relentless in examining all of the
available data, potentially yielding more thorough results than a human doctor.
But the same AI program that can identify the rarest corner cases of lung cancer
will not be able to diagnose bone cancer or even a broken leg because its set of
training images were strictly focused on lung cancer.
Page 16 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Igniting the spark of curiosity in AI
Expert Go players are able to use sophisticated strategies and diversions when
playing the board game, but they can't think through every obscure set of moves
that is likely to lead to a game-winning trap much later down the road. An AI
program can.
In its 2016 match against human champion Lee Sedol, Google subsidiary
DeepMind Technologies Ltd.'s AlphaGo algorithm deployed a long-range game
plan that didn't produce any immediate measurable gains on the board.
However, DeepMind managed to incentivize the algorithm to explore
unconventional strategies that increased the probability of it gaining significant
advantages later in the game.
Of course, once AlphaGo used this spark of curiosity to abstractly calculate
large sets of permutations that would play out over many turns, it knew how to
win games by exploiting the limitations of the human brain. It is exactly this
combination of the ability to tap into a full repository of what has worked in past
games, explore strategies that are a bit out there, and then mercilessly
implement the ones best suited to the situation on the board that makes AI
algorithms unbeatable in most games.
DeepMind trained AlphaGo in a similar manner to how Amazon Web Services
trains its SageMaker machine learning platform to automatically apply the
optimal set of hyper-parameters for a specific model and use case.
Page 17 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
First, the AI software takes a series of different guesses and observes the
predictive accuracy of each guess as the model training begins. It then
combines successful configurations from different models into one winning set
of hyper-parameters that can be expected to yield the best result for the specific
human-defined task.
The path from narrow AI to general uses
This type of algorithmic curiosity is similar to our oncologist knowing where to
start looking when evaluating a CT image for cancer. However, the auto-tuning
of hyper-parameters or AlphaGo's auto-detection of human weaknesses still
can't shake the brute force, iterative character of AI.
The AlphaGo developers made the correct assumption based on evolution
theory that some degree of variation is needed to come up with spectacular
wins. However, these guesses are initially random, without the human intuition -
- or bias -- accumulated through experience and training.
The cheaper that compute power becomes, the more this variation can be
introduced without too much cost impact, which could push AI past its lack of
intuition. But can all of this lead to general artificial intelligence?
Conceptually, if we assume unlimited compute power and humans preparing a
sufficiently large training set of text and multimedia data, a narrow AI application
could jump from playing chess to playing Go, and from there to taking orders at
Page 18 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
your local burger joint. However, the dependent variable is still missing for a lot
of potential AI use cases. And, in many cases, it has to be provided manually by
humans as part of the training process.
It doesn't even end there. How does a human train a self-driving car on whether
it's OK to run over an animal in a certain situation, or if it's better to apply the
emergency brake when doing so could mean getting rear-ended by an 18-
wheeler? The racist chatbot that Microsoft inadvertently deployed in 2016 is
only one of many examples where humans can provide a problematic frame of
reference for an AI tool.
These questions that extend beyond the purely technical aspects of AI will
continue to challenge the technology as it looks to extend beyond current
applications that are narrow in scope.
Page 19 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
New deep learning techniques take center stage
Maria Korolov, Technology Journalist
Generative adversarial networks, reinforcement learning and transfer learning
are approaches that have been explored by theoreticians and researchers for
years. Today, with recent improvements in technology, these deep learning
techniques are finally becoming practical for enterprise use.
"They are not really new concepts," said Hermann Ney, professor of computer
science at Germany's RWTH Aachen University and director of science at
speech recognition company AppTek. "But now, in the era of deep learning,
they have a better chance to be helpful."
GANs blur line between real and artificial
Last year, researchers from chipmaker Nvidia, based in Santa Clara, Calif.,
released a video showing computer-generated faces, cars and furniture suites
that were amazingly realistic.
The secret? Generative adversarial networks (GANs), in which two different AI
systems battle it out. One system tries to create realistic-looking images; the
other system tries to tell which ones are fake and which ones are real.
Page 20 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
As the two duke it out, both get better and better, and the results can be
exceptionally lifelike -- and a little disturbing, said Vivek Katyal, global analytics
leader for risk and financial advisory at Deloitte.
"It's a pretty scary thing" how realistic these artificially created images can be,
he said.
But while GANs are of clear benefit to, say, film and video game companies
looking to fill out crowd scenes, there are other uses as well.
For example, companies can use it to take photographs and create 3D
renderings or even generate models for 3D printing.
"This is now being looked at in very advanced manufacturing," Katyal said.
There are also potential uses in other areas, he added, such as medical
imagery and generating the massive sets of training data that drive deep
learning. "The key application is generating image sets for learning data."
However, Katyal warned that companies need to be wary of inadvertently
introducing bias and errors into their systems. If an enterprise implements GANs
without first ensuring their data is clean, representative and unbiased, the deep
learning technique could magnify these problems.
"I don't see it inhibiting adoption," Katyal said. "But that's because I don't think
people today look at risk first. They look at what they can get out of it."
Page 21 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Reinforcement learning creates new strategies
Last month, Google published the results of its experience with AlphaZero, a
system that learned to play Go and chess all by itself, without studying human
games or getting any feedback from people.
The secret was its use of reinforcement learning, one of the most cutting-edge
new deep learning techniques. The program played the games over and over in
an attempt to beat its own previous versions. It quickly evolved into a system
that could beat all existing competitors.
David Silver, who leads the reinforcement learning group for Google's
DeepMind, wrote in a recent blog post that this approach can lead to a more
creative kind of algorithmic game playing.
Reinforcement learning can be used by an AI system to teach itself how to do
almost anything, as long as there's a way to keep score.
Practical applications include navigation software that can enable robots to find
their way around new places that they don't have much data on yet or
manufacturing robots that learn how to interact with objects, said Jacob Perkins,
CTO at San Francisco security analytics company Insight Engines and author of
several books about machine learning software development.
"I don't know if Roomba uses reinforcement learning, but it would be a good
application of it," he said.
Page 22 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
In fact, any process that can be optimized could be a target for reinforcement
learning, said Christian Shelton, professor of computer science at University of
California, Riverside.
Optimization challenges, such as supply chain management, data center energy
use and cloud workload schedules, are currently being handled by other
approaches, such as traditional statistical methods that don't require
reinforcement learning. However, as these challenges get more complex
because, say, companies look at more contributing factors, reinforcement
learning will start coming into its own, Shelton said.
Transfer learning could lead to more natural AI
Transfer learning is something that comes naturally to humans. Once we learn
how to do one thing, we have an easier time learning a second related thing,
instead of having to learn each element of the second task from scratch.
This doesn't come naturally to computer programs, but AI programmers are
using various methods to give new systems a head start.
With the recent advancements of new deep learning techniques, the
possibilities of transferring knowledge have gotten better.
AppTek, for example, is a Virginia-based company that uses AI systems to
understand and translate spoken language.
Page 23 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Transfer learning enables it to train its systems on large, publicly available data
sets, such as broadcast and entertainment videos and audio. Then, the learning
can be applied to other situations, such as user-generated videos or telephone
calls, where the sound quality is different, said AppTek CEO Mudar Yaghi.
"The results in all cases are more accurate predictions -- such as chatbots that
now recognize regional dialects or spellings," said Ken Sanford, analytics
architect and sales engineering lead at New York data platform company
Dataiku and professor at Boston College.
Sanford has worked with many companies on AI projects, including Walmart, in
his work for AI vendors and as an independent expert.
Walmart and other retailers are using transfer learning to help better categorize
products, he said. "They have too many new products, and the classification
system is too complex to do it manually." Transfer learning, in combination with
image recognition, can identify subtle differences among products.
Cloud providers that offer AI model-building services, including Google,
Microsoft and Amazon, are also using transfer learning.
"You upload a training set, they reference the history of all models they have
that appear close to it and they use the labeled training set to further hone the
model," Sanford said.
Page 24 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
New deep learning techniques may lead to more natural AI
Over the past decades, AI technology has improved dramatically, moving from
basic rules-based systems to statistical approaches. More recently, it's come to
be powered by the machine learning algorithms widely in use today, Deloitte's
Katyal said.
Now, GANs, reinforcement learning and transfer learning are helping take us
beyond machine learning and into narrow AI, he said. That's the next step on
the road to general AI.
"General AI is when it almost automates human intelligence," Katyal said.
Page 25 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Researchers race for quantum AI as quantum computing advances
George Lawton, Contributor
Researchers have been exploring algorithms that would allow computers to
process data at the quantum level on a theoretical basis for many years, but
only now are the physical capabilities of quantum computers starting to catch up
to this theory. This could create opportunities for quantum AI that could allow for
the development of machine learning algorithms with less data.
It's still early, as existing quantum computers face several technical limitations
related to encoding quantum data, error-correction and the length of time that
calculations take. But researchers looking to create a more human-like type of
artificial intelligence may have to overcome these challenges. Some evidence
suggests that there is a quantum basis for human intelligence that complements
neural networks.
Targets of today's research
In the meantime, AI researchers will need to learn new approaches to building
quantum AI.
Page 26 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
"Regardless of task, the algorithms that run on quantum computers are
significantly different from those designed to run on classical computers," said
Bob Sutor, vice-president of quantum computing at IBM Research.
Sutor acknowledges there is still considerable work to be done in terms of
developing algorithms for AI within the constraints of today's approximate
quantum computing systems. But there has been some early research into
artificial neural networks run on the 5-qubit IBM Q Experience device published
by a team at the University of Pavia in Italy.
In the short run, quantum algorithm research could also inspire better AI on
classical computers.
"There have been examples of scientists discovering more-efficient ways to
solve problems in machine learning on classical computers due to what's been
learned about quantum algorithms," Sutor said.
For example, University of Washington doctoral student Ewin Tang developed a
better recommendation system following his research into quantum AI.
Early work on existing quantum computers also identified AI algorithms that
seem to work better than classical computers. For example, IBM worked with
Raytheon BBN in 2017 to perform certain black box machine learning tasks
more efficiently.
Page 27 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Quantum computing-inspired machine learning algorithms could also enable
developers to train models with less data or better understand the structures
and categories hidden within the data. Canadian quantum computing company
D-Wave has launched a machine learning business unit to help with this called
Quadrant.ai.
There are many directions for improving quantum AI algorithms, said Michael
Hartmann, associate professor at the Institute of Photonics and Quantum
Sciences School of Engineering and Physical Sciences at Heriot-Watt
University in Scotland. One line of research is looking at how to make the
individual calculation steps of machine learning algorithms faster. Another line
of research is exploring how quantum machine algorithms could operate on a
lower level of abstraction that is directly linked to the physical operations of the
quantum processor.
Dealing with errors
There are a variety of approaches being explored for building quantum
computers using different physical phenomena. But they share many common
challenges.
"In all efforts to build quantum information processing devices, keeping error
rates sufficiently low is the biggest challenge," said Hartmann.
Page 28 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Information stored in a quantum device is much more fragile than information in
classical computers.
Existing quantum computers work at very low temperatures so that the
materials used in the circuits restrict energy flow and prevent the basic units of
information -- qubits -- from changing state. The electrical circuits used in
classical computers at room temperature would destroy all quantum information.
Quantum computing depends on maintaining coherence across the qubit
computing elements in a quantum system. Qubits are the quantum equivalent of
a bit, but it can be used to encode significantly more information than a bit. They
are also more prone to errors. Today's quantum computers are considered
approximate systems. They have errors and short coherence times within which
to run algorithms.
"There are physical device limitations we still need to overcome before we have
fault-tolerant universal quantum computers that operate with the stability we
expect from classical computers," IBM's Sutor said.
As it turns out, some quantum AI algorithms are less impacted by errors.
Hartmann said the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm is a strong
candidate to run on near-future quantum computers, as it does not require
quantum error correction, which have a large resource overhead.
Page 29 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Another big challenge lies in encoding the data into quantum memory systems
in a way that maintains its quantum state. However, loading classical data into a
quantum memory is demanding.
"If you want to exploit the ability of a quantum computer to handle much more
data than a classical one, you still need to convert the classical data into
quantum data at the beginning," Hartmann said.
This can be the dominant effort when building a practical algorithm. And this
process must be repeated for each new machine learning application because
researchers have not found a way to store quantum state data for very long.
Hope for human-like AI
A popular idea suggests that we are on the verge of creating classical
computers with more processing power than humans possess, which could lead
to sentient machines, or the singularity.
But researchers like Roger Penrose and Stuart Hameroff think this is off base.
In the mid-90s, they postulated that there may be a quantum basis to human
intelligence with their Orchestrated Objective Reduction theory. The implication
of the theory is that AI will have to move beyond classical computing models if it
is going to replicate human-like intelligence.
Late last year, Pavlo Mikheenko, associate professor of condensed matter
physics at the University of Oslo, found some physical evidence that quantum
Page 30 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
strings exist in human brains. He noted that this work is still early, and he is
waiting for others to confirm his findings.
"My research directly suggests that there is a quantum aspect to biological
intelligence," he said. "The brain seems to be both superconducting and
quantum."
The one big challenge in replicating the quantum information processing of the
brain in quantum computers is that information processing structures in the
brain appear to be highly dynamic and seem to break down after a few minutes
only to be recreated within the cells. In contrast, existing approaches to building
quantum computers are designed to work with stable quantum structures.
"It would be helpful if the relevant quantum computing technology was the same
as the memory storage rather than having to search and introduce memory,
Hameroff said. "Quantum processing relevant to consciousness runs on the
same structures encoding memory."
Getting some practice
It may be a while before quantum hardware catches up with the theory. But in
the meantime, developers can learn some of the basic principles by tinkering
with quantum computing cloud services like IBM's Qiskit and D-Wave' Leap
Quantum Application Environment.
Page 31 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
"AI is for many developers, on the top of the agenda for the first applications of
quantum computers that are currently being developed," said Hartmann.
Existing quantum computers only demonstrate a proof of principle, but Hartman
sees many companies pushing hard to achieve the first demonstration of
quantum computing power that exceeds the capabilities of classical AI.
"I expect the demand for it to be huge once it is there," Hartmann said.
Page 32 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Augmented intelligence: The clearest path to focused AI?
David Petersson, Freelance Writer
Companies are competing in a billion dollar arms race to implement artificial
intelligence, but experts are beginning to see cracks in the relentless pursuit.
This is primarily because, so far, big AI promises have produced little concrete
innovation. Most AI technology still struggles to complete tasks that a four-year-
old child accomplishes effortlessly.
The current "intelligent" systems are shortcuts that detect patterns based on
statistical methods but still have no understanding of what they have detected.
This understanding and the ability to mimic human task completion -- what
developers refer to as artificial general intelligence -- is a long way from full
development.
Rather than focus on a general goal to improve artificial intelligence, CIOs and
businesses should start paying attention to -- and investing in -- augmented
intelligence technology. Augmented intelligence technology is a form of artificial
intelligence that does not seek to replace humans, but instead seeks to assist
humans with their work. This makes augmented intelligence a concrete and
ROI-accessible alternative to AI.
Page 33 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
No replacement for humans
The automotive industry is a great example of the potential of AI, but also
serves as a great example of AI's flaws. Mercedes, Toyota and Nissan were
among the companies that touted their self-driving car concepts, but the biggest
question to come from the 2018 Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas was,
"Where are the autonomous vehicles?"
We need to find the correct balance and, for now, it seems the best way would be to
combine AI with human intelligence and form augmented intelligence technology.
Tesla's Autopilot is not a full replacement for self-driving, and Uber's vision was
crushed after a fatal accident involving one of its self-driving cars. Tesla's
Autopilot, on the other hand, recently crashed into a stopped firetruck because
the AI is trained to ignore them. Trying to lean toward the side of safety,
Waymo's cars try to abide every single traffic rule but create inferior systems
that would fail basic driving tasks.
Augmented intelligence overrides the critical problem of AI adoption: that the
systems are reactive, not proactive. A human driver has the ability to make
educated guesses about what will happen on the road 10 seconds in the future,
whereas the current AI systems have no way to make such predictions. It's here
that augmented intelligence could make a difference. The trick is to train the
system so that it accurately recognizes the subjects it is trained on, as well as
offer reasonable performance when it comes to unforeseen road hazards.
Page 34 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
An extra 'Eye'
Discoperi Inc.'s System 'Eye' is reflective of augmented technology as a step to
complete AI adoption. The Eye is a camera placed on a vehicle that combines
the data from several cars that allows the system to form a grid to assist all
nearby drivers. This augmented intelligence doesn't operate the vehicle, but
instead assists the primary, human operator by detecting objects and behavior
patterns to recognize when a driver is breaking from normal patterns and driving
dangerously -- hoping to reduce fatal accidents.
The Eye demonstrated great accuracy when detecting objects on the road, but
the AI's primary task is to build behavior patterns. Of course, there are several
parameters involved, such as where an event happens, under what conditions
and whether there are pedestrians on the road. The system checks what's
normal under these circumstances to what is currently happening, and if it is
beyond a certain threshold, it will send an alert to all cars within that proximity.
While access to information about every car on the road sounds like a privacy
nightmare, Discoperi has already taken steps to ensure privacy as well as give
users full control over their data by storing the data on a blockchain.
Privacy might seem more like a problem for augmented intelligence because it
involves human input, while artificial intelligence is theoretically fully
autonomous. But due to the real shortcomings in AI, many companies have
Page 35 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
already used humans behind the scenes to complete AI's job where it failed,
raising privacy concerns in AI.
Universal implementation
Augmented intelligence capabilities will benefit industries -- perhaps even more
than traditional AI would. In healthcare, an AI algorithm can analyze a patient's
symptoms and vital signs, compare it with the history of the patient, their family
and millions of other patients, and provide possible diagnoses a for a doctor to
analyze. In education, AI can track the progress of the students and help
teachers understand what topics and which students need more attention.
Augmented intelligence can contribute to streamlining business processes and
aid human workers in a concrete, helpful and cost-effective manner.
AI has undergone two winters by now, and the next one is looming. But this
time, AI has made far too much progress to be forgotten again. CIOs can't
continue investing in stalled technology, and they should also resist giving up
the benefits of AI technology. We need to find the correct balance and, for now,
it seems the best way would be to combine AI with human intelligence and form
augmented intelligence technology.
Page 36 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Limits of AI today push general-purpose tools to the horizon
Torsten Volk, Managing Research Director
When we watched Star Trek and 2001: A Space Odyssey, we developed a very
specific idea of artificial intelligence as a humanlike, or even superhuman, entity
that can live in starships or computers and answer any question in real time
based on humanity's collective knowledge.
Today, AI is the most talked-about topic in enterprise IT, with all major
enterprise software vendors aggressively promoting their stories. However, the
limits of AI today make the technology very different from what the movies
taught us to expect. This does not mean that AI today cannot provide ROI. But
we need to continue pushing toward the next frontier of a more general AI
approach that develops universal problem-solving capabilities with minimal
supervision and significantly reduced training requirements.
What AI should be
If AI and machine learning are everywhere, why do employees still get bogged
down with so many tedious, manual tasks? Why can't an application on my
laptop look at my calendar invites and book flights, hotels and rental cars based
Page 37 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
on my schedule? Why can't it remind me of conferences that are relevant to my
field? Of course, it should also monitor my credit card bill, Uber account and
airline and hotel charges to automatically create my expense report. And when I
write a paper or prepare for a presentation, it should automatically surface
relevant contextual info based on the audience, my personal preferences and
current industry trends and events.
The difference between the AI scenario described above and today's reality is
rooted in the fact that neural networks and reinforcement learning models
require too much manual architectural training and deployment effort. Neural
networks are best at solving problems through reliance on massive number-
crunching without much contextual awareness.
AI tools that perform a broad range of tasks, like object and facial recognition,
speech-to-text transcription and optimization of logical unit numbers on a
storage array, all have one thing in common: They use a large amount of
processing power to analyze hundreds of thousands of training data points to
identify subtle correlations between many features. However, each one of these
AI models needs to be trained, configured and architected to be used for a
single task, which is one of the major limits of AI today.
When asked whether a given photo was taken on Mercury or on Earth, for
example, a human will most likely know that there is no camera located on
Mercury, so he or she can infer that the photo can only have been made on
Earth. An untrained neural network will simply find no matches of Earth or
Page 38 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Mercury landscapes and not return a result. It cannot generalize common
principles and concepts but exclusively relies on the patterns it has identified
within each training set. While an untrained human can figure out how to solve
many advanced tasks and challenges without any specific training, the limits of
AI mean it does not have this ability.
Delayed rewards as the key to unlock a strategic AI
Google's AlphaGo managed to beat the world's best Go players only after the
AlphaGo project team created an algorithm that goes beyond simply optimizing
its next move. AlphaGo learned to play sophisticated strategies that led to
reliable wins over human opponents by gradually identifying human players'
weaknesses and by playing thousands of simulated games against itself. The
reinforcement algorithm encouraged AlphaGo to make unexplored moves.
When these moves led to a loss, AlphaGo would explore different moves,
always rewarding game wins and avoiding moves that were similar to the losing
ones.
AlphaGo's reward algorithm could be seen as a starting point. But instead of
merely rewarding positive behaviors and penalizing negative ones, future, more
general AI applications need to explore a much more constructive approach for
complex problem-solving. This approach could be called "strategic curiosity,"
and it is inspired by the concept of the Memory, Attention and Composition
(MAC) network -- pioneered by Stanford researchers Christopher Manning and
Drew Hudson. The term strategic curiosity refers to the idea of training an AI to
Page 39 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
make educated guesses based on what it knows about the environmental
context that is relevant to its specific task.
The core idea of Manning's MAC network is to provide the learning network with
a knowledge base that it can use when working on answering a specific user
question, such as: Which planet is second closest to the sun and has a ring
around it?
The network trains on a few thousand natural language questions and answers,
such as: Which planets are blue? Is Venus further from Earth than Jupiter?
What is the third largest planet? Traditional neural networks, by comparison,
require hundreds of thousands, or even millions, of examples in training data
sets, one of the major limits of AI today.
Based on this training and a knowledge base -- in this case, the planet map
below -- the MAC network can respond to our natural language question with a
much higher accuracy than traditional neural networks.
Here are the stages of the model's decision process:
1. The model looks at the first part of the question -- second closest to the sun -- and focuses its attention on Venus.
2. The model looks at the second part of the question -- planets with rings -- and sees that Uranus comes after Saturn among planets with rings.
Page 40 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Why is this simple example so interesting? Because the MAC network model is
able to answer each part of a question by memorizing relevant content
knowledge it gained from understanding the individual components of that
question. In our example, the MAC network keeps the fact that it knows that we
are looking for something that is the second closest to the sun in memory. Then,
when the next MAC cell responds to the second part of the question -- "has a
ring around it" -- it adjusts its answer based on contextual knowledge it
previously learned.
Bringing back the excitement to AI
Manning's MAC network, while still in its adolescence, shows the potential of
bringing AI to the next level by modeling the ability of our brain to learn from
context. When asked questions, like "Which color are this tree's leaves?" the
human brain will instantly make our eyes look up into the tree, instead of
scanning our entire field of view. Even more, our brain would already know from
context that it is summer and all the trees on our street have green leaves. Of
course, the MAC network is still far away from this type of reasoning, but it is
significant, as this type of breakthrough keeps the AI excitement going strong.
Page 41 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Humans and AI tools go hand in hand in analytics applications
Craig Stedman, Editor at Large
AI tools may be intelligent, but they aren't all-knowing -- and they can learn a
thing or two from people.
That's the view of analytics and engineering managers whose teams apply a
human touch to the work of machine learning algorithms and other forms of AI.
Pairing up humans and AI software provides information that the technology
can't deliver on its own -- and it prevents organisations from blindly following
algorithms down the wrong business paths.
Referred to by proponents as human in the loop, the idea is to tap
knowledgeable data analysts or business users to give feedback on the findings
of AI tools, particularly in cases where there's uncertainty about the validity of
what they find. The resulting feedback loop supports so-called active learning
approaches designed to eliminate errors or fill in missing info, and can then train
algorithms to produce better results in the future.
For example, O'Reilly Media Inc. uses a combination of humans and AI to label
and categorize the content of the videos recorded at the technology
Page 42 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
conferences it runs. Data analysts can't handle that task themselves, according
to Paco Nathan, director of the company's online learning unit. In a presentation
at this month's Strata Data Conference in San Jose, Calif., Nathan noted that
O'Reilly was recording about 200 hours of video there -- and the event was just
one of the 20 or so conferences it puts on each year.
Word games lead to AI uncertainty
However, the natural language processing (NLP) algorithms that the
Sebastopol, Calif., company uses to parse the video content often get confused
by words with multiple meanings or ambiguous contexts, Nathan said. When
such cases are identified, a person from his team must step in to figure out the
correct meaning and to label the content accurately.
The output of the NLP-driven machine learning models is stored as a log file in
a Jupyter Notebook, which the analysts can review and update. "It's really a
two-way street, and you end up with documents that are collaborative, partly
done by machines and partly done by people," Nathan said.
He added that O'Reilly, which jointly organizes the Strata conference with big
data vendor Cloudera, is seeing more than 90% accuracy with content labeling
due to the combined AI and human efforts.
Pinterest Inc. uses a group of machine learning applications to drive the
operations of its image search and bookmarking website, including the search
Page 43 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
process and things like ad placement and content labeling. But the San
Francisco-based company relies on human evaluators to check what the
algorithms produce for relevance and accuracy.
They also take part in A/B testing of algorithm-generated user interface designs,
rating the different options based on personal preference, said Veronica Mapes,
a technical program manager at Pinterest who is in charge of the human
evaluation effort.
After initially doing all of the evaluation work on third-party crowdsourcing
platforms, Pinterest built its own human evaluation system in 2016, and it used
that to significantly expand the rating efforts last year, according to Mapes. The
company still uses outside platforms, too, but it now has full-time employees
and internal contractors involved in the process, a step designed to both reduce
costs and improve the quality of the evaluations, Mapes said in a Strata
session.
The intermingling of humans and AI applications is part of a broader effort
pushed by Pinterest executives to ensure that the website provides useful info
to visitors, said Garner Chung, engineering manager for the Pinterest human
evaluation team. The human input acts as a counterbalance to standard
engagement metrics that track what users click on and how much time they
spend on pages, he said.
Page 44 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Engagement is the signal that the machine learning algorithms are based on,
"but that's not always the best metric to use," Chung said after the session. "We
really don't just want to be serving up clickbait and turning our users into
zombies."
Chung cited the example of links to content on lowering body fat showing up in
the results of a search for chicken recipes. That might seem like a logical
connection to an algorithm, but it's one that a human evaluator should flag as
not directly relevant to the search, he said.
AI's limits leave humans in the loop
In general, AI software isn't close to being ready to fully take over the work that
people do, said Michael Chui, a partner at the McKinsey Global Institute who
leads research on how technology innovation affects businesses and society.
"There are real limitations to AI now," Chui said at the Strata conference. "Don't
think these technologies can do everything."
Ebates Inc., which runs a shopping rewards program for consumers, is in the
early stages of AI adoption. The San Francisco-based company uses semi-
autonomous machine learning models to rank member preferences to better
target cash-back offers and to help detect odd buying behavior or other
potentially fraudulent activities, said Mark Stange-Treager, its vice president of
analytics. In the next 12 to 18 months, he expects to start running full-fledged AI
Page 45 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
algorithms against the company's Hadoop data lake, which has AtScale's data
management platform layered on top.
Even then, though, Ebates will likely continue to combine the work of humans
and AI in analytics applications, Stange-Treager said in a post-Strata interview.
For example, he said he sees a continuing need for manual reviews by workers
at the company to determine whether member behavior flagged as anomalous
by an algorithm is problematic.
"I envision a scenario where we're using algorithms to do a lot of the work, but
not just letting them go off and do their own thing," Stange-Treager said. "I'm not
saying we won't get there in the future, but I think that's well off in the future
from our point of view."
Page 46 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Panel: What we call AI today doesn't live up to hype
Ed Burns, Executive Editor
Not everyone believes that the technology we call artificial intelligence today
lives up to the hype it's generated in the last year, and the gap between reality
and hype could influence how the technology is ultimately used by enterprises.
"We still don't have real AI because we still don't know how the brain and mind
work," MIT professor Josh Tenenbaum said in a panel discussion at MIT's
Sloan CIO Symposium.
The panel discussed the differences between the type of applications we're
calling AI today and true AI, programs that can think and learn for themselves.
In general, the participants saw a wide gulf between the current state of the art
and the ideal of true AI.
"The one caution I'd bring forward is to set expectations correctly," said Ryan
Gariepy, co-founder and CTO at Clearpath Robotics Inc. "When you're working
in your organisation and exploring this technology, we've seen examples in the
past where these expectations get so high and people starting buying the
technology and then nothing happens."
Page 47 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
AI has promise, but keep it in perspective
Gariepy said there is no doubt that the systems we call AI today are a vast
improvement on the AI technology of just a few years ago. Clearpath makes
autonomous vehicles for industrial applications like mining and warehousing.
These drones couldn't function without the kind of machine learning and
computer vision that today are lumped into the general AI category, according to
Gariepy.
But despite this kind of progress, we're still a long way from truly autonomous
robots that can think and function on their own without any kind of human
supervision, Gariepy said.
"That's something we need to be careful about," he said. "There's a tremendous
amount of potential in AI, but let's not say it's going to solve every problem
without human intervention."
The point here is not just about defining terms. Whether the AI we see today is
true intelligence or something short of that plays into how applications are used.
After all, the existence of truly autonomous, intelligent systems could pave the
way toward full job automation of everything from rote, routine tasks to higher-
level knowledge work.
The notion that AI could automate all of our jobs has sparked debate about far-
ranging topics such as political stability and the possible need for universal
Page 48 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
incomes. But panelists said people are ahead of themselves when they get into
these topics because today's AI technology is not ready to put that many people
out of work.
AI won't automate all jobs
Today's technology is far more likely to augment workers rather than automate
their jobs.
"Since the very beginning of AI there's always been the debate about
augmentation versus automation and that's very much still happening today,"
MIT professor Joi Ito said. "I don't think automation is an optimal answer."
Instead, he and other panelists said they believe AI will fill in for workers on the
most routine tasks that demand simple pattern recognition and other basic
skills. In their view, this will remove a lot of the drudge work from jobs and allow
human workers to focus on the more creative and interesting aspects of their
jobs.
But it's still early to even talk about this. The platforms we call AI today are
finding the most success in fairly simple applications, like call centers and other
customer service venues. Thinking about AI-assisted workflows for other types
of jobs in areas like law, healthcare and journalism are hard because the
technology is still so new and functionality is relatively limited, panelists said.
Page 49 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
"The challenge any organisation faces today is, how do you get there?" said
Seth Earley, CEO at consulting group Earley Information Science Inc. "There's
this vision of the future where everything is going to change. How do you get
from here to there? You have to look for processes to automate but still keep
people engaged."
Page 50 of 50
In this e-guide
Common sense AI
approaches point to more
general applications
Artificial intelligence creativity
tools mimic human ability
More curiosity could help
narrow AI tools handle
broader uses
New deep learning
techniques take center stage
Researchers race for
quantum AI as quantum
computing advances
Augmented intelligence: The
clearest path to focused AI?
Human-like AI quest drives general AI
development efforts
Getting more CW+ exclusive content
As a CW+ member, you have access to TechTarget’s entire portfolio of 140+
websites. CW+ access directs you to previously unavailable “platinum members-
only resources” that are guaranteed to save you the time and effort of having to
track such premium content down on your own, ultimately helping you to solve
your toughest IT challenges more effectively—and faster—than ever before.
Take full advantage of your membership by visiting www.computerweekly.com/eproducts
Images; stock.adobe.com
© 2020 TechTarget. No part of this publication may be transmitted or reproduced in any form or by any means without
written permission from the publisher.