how to engage in broadband policy & regulatory...

Upload: dinhcong

Post on 01-May-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents

4 download

Report

Download

Embed Size (px):

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

What is this Network Neutrality thing

everyone keeps talking about...?!

Anindya CHAUDHURI

Global Development Network

How to Engage in Broadband Policy

& Regulatory Processes

Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi

New Delhi, India. 17 December 2016

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 2: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

Once upon a time in a land far far away...

1 Ostensibly, Comcast vs. subscribers....

2 ...but nicely summarizes the big picture...

1 Carriers2 Consumers3 Content/application developers4 Engineers5 Civil liberty groups6 Policymakers7 ...China?!!

3 But why was everyone so agitated?

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 3: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

But how did sandvine do it?

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 4: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

How is this related to NN?

�End to end principle� - �...universal and reciprocal accessamong users...�

Reliable communication with unreliable hardwareNetworks application neutralDumb networks, smart terminals

ARPANET - redundancy of hardware

Packet switching (vs. circuit switching)

�Best e�ort� communicationAny packet can go anywhereNo �xed pathPackets can be lost, delayedData �reconstituted� at end

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 5: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

Understanding NN through the OSI/Hourglass Model

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 6: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

Simplifying...

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 7: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

Has the Internet always/ever been neutral?

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 8: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

Neutrality (contd.)

Other examples

Peering connectionsCDNQoS/ThrottlingFCC: �reasonable network management�

Packet shaping reasonable?

Can we now de�ne NN?

Di�erent de�nitions

technicalservice-orientednormative

Quiz: Does Android (or ad-blocking) violate NN?

Shine (getshine.com)

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 9: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

What is at stake? (says both sides)

1 Money

1 Market power2 Need for investments

2 Technical

1 NGN2 Convergence

3 Innovation

4 Internet Governance

5 Social liberty (including privacy/security)

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Page 10: How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processesbroadbandasia.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/IITD.20161217.pdf · How to Engage in Broadband Policy & Regulatory Processes

Quiz: Can you guess who's for/against?

1 ISPs

2 Activists

3 Content providers/e-commerce companies

4 Policymakers

Anindya CHAUDHURI Bharti School & LIRNEasia

Revisiting the Regulatory Status of Broadband Internet

TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA · 2017-12-16 · Broadband (≥ 256 Kbps download) Total Broadband subscriber base has increased from 15.19million at the end of June 2013 to

Regulatory Framework of Mobile Broadband to Boost ... - JOAMS

BROADBAND TO WHERE? A New Definition and Regulatory Framework for the NBN Holly Raiche

International Bureau - Federal Communications …...2005 – BROADBAND Engage Leaders Global Outreach – European Regulator’s Group (ERG) – World Summit on the Information Society

National Broadband Network: Regulatory Reform for 21st Century … Regulatory... · National Broadband Network: Regulatory Reform for 21st Century Broadband Discussion Paper iv It

Introducing broadband: Investment conditions, regulatory challenges and quality issues

Regulatory Tools to Achieve Universal Broadband

Www.lirneasia.net Introducing broadband: Investment conditions, regulatory challenges and quality issues Rohan Samarajiva Telecoms World South Asia Dhaka,

Broadband Technologies – Trends in mobile broadband equipment for end users 12th Conference Regulatory Activity in Electronic Communications Sector, Budva,

EVOLVING REGULATORY FRAMEWORK FOR RURAL DRINKING … · Evolving Regulatory Framework for Rural Drinking Water 153 kind of activities that panchayats can engage in, such as constructing,

Engage good practices high speed broadband

G.Pūras Development of Broadband markets Communications Regulatory authority of Lithuania Electronic communications department Disclaimer: The

Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission - IN.gov1).pdfBPL Broadband over Power Lines ... IURC Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission ... MVPD Multichannel Video Programming Distributor

Assessing the Telecom Regulatory & Policy Environment in ...€¦ · – Mobile – Broadband • List of “significant regulatory and policy events” in relevant period sent to

A report by the broAdbAnd Commission september …...2.2 Growth in Broadband 18 2.3 Regulatory Frameworks for an Internet of Everything 24 3. Evaluating Global Growth in Broadband:

Telecommunications Regulatory Affairs Advisory …...Telecommunications Regulatory Affairs Advisory Committee Development of Broadband Infrastructure Introduction This paper provides

Broadband over Powerlines: Regulatory and Policy Issues · Broadband over Powerlines: Regulatory and Policy Issues Updated January 29, 2008 ... howev er, like any technology, has

A report by the broAdbAnd Commission...Chapter 1. Introduction 8 2. Realizing our Future Built on Broadband 12 2.1 Defining Broadband 16 2.2 Growth in Broadband 18 2.3 Regulatory Frameworks

Ensuring low-cost and high speed broadband to rural areas · PDF fileBangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission Ensuring low-cost and high speed broadband to rural areas [email protected]

AFFORDABLE broadband of ADEQUATE quality THROUGHOUT Sri Lanka Buddika Wijetunga Isura Silva Mahesh de Andrado How to engage in broadband policy and regulatory

Regulatory Tools to Achieve Universal Broadband Sofie Maddens Head, Regulatory and Market Environment Division Telecommunication Development Bureau (BDT)

Broadband over Power Lines - W4CLJw4clj.com/ncs-bpl.pdf · Including Broadband Over Power Line Systems.vii” This ruling placed the United States under the most liberal BPL regulatory

1 9 March 2004 Broadband for All Concertation Meeting The Broadband For All Cluster Business & Economics Technology & Applications Policy & Regulatory/Legal

TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA New Delhi, rd 23 ... · Top five broadband service providers constitute 82.92% market share of total broadband subscribers. They are BSNL (16.37

Regulatory Framework and Technical Aspects of Broadband Access

Regulatory Implications of Broadband Workshop

Sean Stokes Casey Lide Key Legal and Regulatory Issues Affecting Community Broadband Projects Broadband Communities Summit April 13, 2015

Regulatory initiatives to promote universal access to Broadband

LirneasiaWorkshop Broadband Policy and Regulatory …lirneasia.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/S8_Indian-BB-Environment.pdf · LirneasiaWorkshop Broadband Policy and Regulatory Process

RADIO FREQUENCY ASSIGNMENTS FOR WIRELESS BROADBAND Augutis Čėsna Deputy Director of Radio Communication Department Communications Regulatory Authority

FCC Satellite Forum March 21, 2005 Mobile Broadband Solutions Robert Hanson Vice President - Regulatory Affairs

The Regulatory Threat to Broadband

Bolivia: Universal Broadband Access: Advances and challenges · Bolivia: Universal Broadband Access: Advances and challenges, Association for Progressive 6 SITTEL, as the regulatory

Broadband policy and regulatory issues in emerging marketslirneasia.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/Samarajiva_broadband... · Broadband policy and regulatory issues in emerging markets