heterosis: defined and research experience heterosis: defined and research experience scott p....
TRANSCRIPT
Heterosis: Defined and Heterosis: Defined and
Research ExperienceResearch Experience
Scott P. Greiner, Ph.D.
Extension Animal Scientist, Beef
Department of Animal & Poultry Sciences
Virginia Tech
Can We Have It All???Can We Have It All???
Reproductively efficient cow herd Cows that are low-cost, adaptable to feed
and environmental resources Superior growth/feed efficiency End product merit
Crossbreeding FundamentalsCrossbreeding Fundamentals
Heterosis (Hybrid Vigor)– Individual heterosis– Maternal heterosis– Paternal heterosis
Breed complementarity
Heterosis DefinedHeterosis Defined--Superiority of crossbred animal relative to average Superiority of crossbred animal relative to average of its straightbred parentsof its straightbred parentsBreed A Weaning Wt. = 530 lb.Breed B Weaning Wt. = 470 lb.A x B Crossbred Calf
– Expected performance 500 lb. (average of A and B)
– Actual performance = 520 lb. – 20 lb. (4%) increase = heterosis
Genetic Basis of HeterosisGenetic Basis of Heterosis Additive vs. non-additive gene effectsAdditive: favorable effect on performance
results from increase in homozygosity (heterozygote intermediate to homozygotes)
Non-additive: favorable effects realized through increase in heterozygosity– Dominance and epistasis
DominanceDominance
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
No dominance(additive)
Partial dominance Complete dominance
AA Aa aa
Economically Important TraitsEconomically Important Traits
Reproductive efficiency Calving ease Calf survival Weaning Wt. Post-weaning growth Feed efficiency Mature size Red meat yield Palatability
Individual HeterosisIndividual HeterosisAdvantage of the Crossbred CalfAdvantage of the Crossbred Calf
Trait Units %Calving rate, % 3.2 4.4Survival to weaning, % 1.4 1.9Birth weight, lb. 1.7 2.4Weaning weight, lb. 16.3 3.9ADG, lb./d .08 2.6Yearling Wt. 29.1 3.8
Cundiff and Gregory, 1999Cundiff and Gregory, 1999
Carcass TraitsCarcass Traits
Trait heterosis Dressing percent 0 REA 3% Fat thickness 5% Quality grade 1% Cutability 1%
Long, 1980Long, 1980
Maternal HeterosisMaternal HeterosisTrait Units % Calving rate, % 3.5 3.7 Survival to weaning, % .8 1.5 Birth weight, lb. 1.6 1.8 Weaning weight, lb. 18.0 3.9 Longevity, yr. 1.36 16.2 Lifetime Production No. Calves .97 17.0 Cumulative Wean. Wt. 600 25.3 Cundiff and Gregory, 1999Cundiff and Gregory, 1999
Impact of HeterosisImpact of Heterosis
Reproduction
Growth
Carcass Merit
Heritability
Low
Moderate
High
Heterosis
High
High
Low
Maternal HeterosisMaternal HeterosisAdvantage of the Crossbred CowAdvantage of the Crossbred Cow
Advantage of crossbred cow vs. straightbred– Reproductive efficiency– Maternal ability– Longevity
Increased lifetime productivity Maternal heterosis accounts for
largest portion of total heterosis advantage (60%)
Estimating HeterosisEstimating Heterosis
Expected Performance =General purebred mean
+ ½ sire breed direct value
+ ½ dam breed direct value
+ dam breed maternal value
+ individual heterosis
+ maternal heterosis
Weaning Weight ExampleWeaning Weight Example
Direct Value lb.
Maternal Value lb.
Breed A +20 +10 Breed B -10 +30 Breed C +40 -50
General mean = 600 Individual heterosis = 4.0% Maternal heterosis = 4.0%
Calculated performance with direct and maternal breed values600 + 0.5(40)+ 0.25(20) + 0.25(-10) + 0.5(10) + 0.5(30) = 642.5
Add individual heterosis642.5 + 0.04(642.5) = 668.2
Add maternal heterosis668.2 + 0.04(668.2) = 694.9
Sire C x crossbred A-B damSire C x crossbred A-B dam
Paternal HeterosisPaternal HeterosisAdvantage of the Crossbred SireAdvantage of the Crossbred Sire
Advantage in reproductive traits
Realized primarily when single sires mated to high numbers of cows (> 40)
Difficult to measure due to large influence of female in total herd reproductive efficiency
Breed DifferencesBreed DifferencesSire breedof calf
Gestationlength,
d
Unassistedcalvings,
%
Birthweight,
lb.
Survivalto wean.,
%
200-dwean. wt.,
lb.
Hereford 284 95.6 90.4 96.2 524
Angus 282 99.6 84.0 96.7 533
Red Angus 282 99.1 84.5 96.7 526
Simmental 285 97.7 92.2 96.7 553
Gelbvieh 284 97.8 88.7 97.1 534
Limousin 286 97.6 89.5 96.9 519
Charolais 283 92.8 93.7 97.1 540
source: Cundiff et al., 2001, Germplasm Evaluation Program Progress Report No. 21
Effect of breed typeEffect of breed type on level of heterosis on level of heterosis
Bos taurus x Bos taurus
Bos indicus x Bos taurus
Individual heterosis Birth weight 2.4 11.1 Weaning weight 3.9 12.6 ADG 2.6 16.2 Maternal heterosis Calving rate 3.7 13.4 Calf survival 1.5 5.1 Birth weight 1.8 5.8 Weaning weight 3.9 16.0
Cundiff and Gregory, 1999Cundiff and Gregory, 1999
Heterosis: Bottom LineHeterosis: Bottom Line
Heterosis offers best genetic solution for improvement of lowly heritable reproductive traits
Majority of heterosis advantages realized through crossbred dams
ConsiderationsConsiderations
Breed contributions Optimizing heterosis Heterosis retention Interaction with environment Economics of crossbreeding Sustainable systems to capture
heterosis
Heterosis: Defined and Heterosis: Defined and
Research ExperienceResearch Experience
Scott P. Greiner, Ph.D.
Extension Animal Scientist, Beef
Department of Animal & Poultry Sciences
Virginia Tech