heavy quarkonium melting with holographic potential defu hou (ccnu,wuhan) sqm2008, beijing, oct....

36
Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potent ial Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008 , Beijing , Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008.

Upload: shannon-eaton

Post on 05-Jan-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential

Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan)

SQM2008 , Beijing , Oct. 6-10, 2008

With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008.  

Page 2: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

• Motivations

• Potential from AdS/CFT

• Heavy quarkonium melting T

• Summary

OUTLINES

Page 3: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Many interesting phenomena in QCD lie in the strongly-coupled region.

Non-perturbative methods for analysis

Lattice: problematic with finite chemical potentioal, time-

dependent problems

AdS/CFT: Notable success in RHIC physics

Viscosity, Jet quenching, …

Motivation

Page 4: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

QCD Diagramm

Page 5: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

AdS/CFT now being applied to RHIC physics

• Viscosity, /s.• EOS

• Jet quenching

• “Sound” waves

• Photon production

• Friction …

• Heavy quarkonium

• Hardron spectrum (ADS/QCD)

Page 6: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Heavy meson melting

• At T<Tc, confined ,potenial linearing rises• At T>Tc, deconfined, short range attraction

range: screening length Lsc

As T , ↗ Lsc , ↘ there exists a Td : the potential no

longer binding for T>Td ( Melting Temperature)

Heavy quakonium melting is an important signal of QGP

See the talk by H. Satz on Oct.7

Page 7: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Nonperturbative calculation of Td

• Potential model

Lattice F. Karsch , Brambilla…

AdS/CFT Maldacena, Rey, Liu , Avramis

• Spectral function

Lattice Karch

AdS/CFT Hoyos, Kim et al

Page 8: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Q Qr

1/Tt

Extracting V(r) from Wilson loop

Page 9: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

• F(r,t) is the free energy excess of a static pair of qq

The internal energy reads

Page 10: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

• F-ansatz

V(r) =F(r,T)

• U –ansatz

V(r)=U(r, T)=F+T S

Page 11: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Poential From Lattice • Quarkonium probes non-perturbative information about medium. How?

W (C) 1

NTr P exp i A

C

W (C)Texp iLtime E(L) E ren

• Wilson loop is static time-like and in fundamental representation:

• Wilson loop is calculable in lattice QCD

Bielefeld Group, hep-lat/0509001time

distance

L

Ltime

Matsui, Satz 1986

Page 12: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

AdS/CFT at finite temperature

Classical Supergravity on AdS-BH×S5

4dim. Large-Nc strongly coupledSU(Nc) N=4 SYM at finite temperature(in the deconfinement phase).

conjecture

=

Witten ‘98

Page 13: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Potential from AdS/CFT

• According to the holographic principle, the thermal average of a WL operator in 4D N=4 SYM at large N_c and large 't Hooft coupling corresponds to the minimum area of the string world sheet in the 5D AdS metric with a Euclidean signature.

Page 14: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008
Page 15: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

WL at Zero T (Maldacena 98)

Page 16: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

• Euler Lagrangian EQ Solution,

Page 17: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008
Page 18: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008
Page 19: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

bounded by the loop C, when y goes to infinity, y->1 BH

Wilson-loop at finite temperature

Page 20: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Minimizing the world sheet area (the Nambu-Goto action)

Page 21: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

qq r qq r

BH

+_

y

Page 22: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Free energy

Page 23: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Result of pentential

Page 24: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

F(r,T)

r

r0

Page 25: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008
Page 26: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Bound state & Schrődinger equation

Page 27: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Numerical Results

• Value of ‘t Hooft coupling.

• Upper limit : QCD value of coupling at RHIC

• Lower limit: heavy quark potential , (Gubser)

• Mc=1.65Gev, Mb=4.85Gev, Tc=186MeV

Page 28: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Dissociation Temperature

Hou, Ren JHEP01 (08)

Page 29: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Holographic potential model with an IR cutoff

Hard Wall : Erlich, Katz, Son, Stephanov

Page 30: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

• In the hadronic phase

• In the plasma phase

Page 31: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

• Soft-wall model 1 : Karch, Katz, Son, Stephanov

A dilaton is introduced, Metrics are the same.

• Soft-wall model 2 : Andreev,Zakharov;Kajantie

modify string frame metric by a conformal factor

Page 32: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

• Free energy

Page 33: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008
Page 34: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Td with deformed metric

Page 35: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

AdS/CFT and Lattice

Page 36: Heavy Quarkonium melting with Holographic Potential Defu Hou (CCNU,Wuhan) SQM2008, Beijing, Oct. 6-10, 2008 With Hai-cang Ren, JHEP 0801:029,2008

Summary

We calculated dissociation temperatures Td of heavy quarkonium states from holographic potential

The computed Td have remarkable features compariable with that from Lattice

ButN=4 SYM is not real QCD with less stronger screening