hasc dems dissent

8/3/2019 HASC Dems dissent

1/8

6

BMWW@ERMEH QM@XW CA OMECTMR] O@OD@TW

Rj` Cq`twmhjr feb Meq`wrmhfrmcew Wpdgcoomrr`` mw gjfth`b xmrj cq`twmhjr ca rj` Bàèw`

B`|ftroèr feb t`nfr`b fhègm`w rc èwpt` Fo`tmgfw efrmcefn w`gptmr} X` rfi` rjmw

t`w|cewmdmnmr} w`tmcpwn} feb d`nm`q` rjfr fe fww`trmq`. dm|ftrmwfe f||tcfgj mw rj` d`wr o`few rc

fgjm`qmeh rjmw cdk`grmq` B`rfme`` mwwp`w tòfme foceh rj` ocwr gjfnnèhmeh x` afg` fw f efrmcefeb x` ft` gcoomrr`b rc wp||ctrmeh f gftàpn feb gco|t`jèwmq` f||tcfgj rjfr |tcocr`w rj`

efrmcefn w`gptmr} ca rj` Pemr`b Wrfr`w X` f||t`gmfr` rj` fwwmwrfeg` ca fnn oòd`tw ca rj`wpdgcoomrr`` me xctimeh rcxftbw rjmw gcooce hcfn Jcx`q`t. x` d`nm`q` rj` t`|ctr mw

megco|n`r` feb x` bmwfht`` xmrj w`q`tfn ca rj` i`} amebmehw feb t`gcooèbfrmcew Act rjfr

t`fwce x` xmnn ecr wmhe rj` t`|ctr

Rj` efrmcefn w`gptmr} ca rjmw gcpert} tòfmew rj` epod`t ce` |tmctmr} ca rjmw

wpdgcoomrr`` feb ca rj` apnn gcoomrr`` X` d`nm`q` dcrj rj` Fbomemwrtfrmce feb fnn ca rjòòd`tw ca rjmw wpdgcoomrr`` ft` pemr`b me rj` fht`òèr rjfr mr mw ecr me rj` d`wr mer`t`wr ca rj`

Pemr`b Wrfr`w rc t`n`fw` ct rtfewa`t fe}ce` atco HROC xjc xcpnb èbfeh`t cpt efrmcefn

w`gptmr}

Rj` t`|ctr wrfr`w rjfr rj` wpdgcoomrr`` xfw bmt`gr`b d} rj` Gjfmtofe feb Tfeimeh

Omectmr} Oòd`t ca rj` apnn gcoomrr`` rc gcebpgr f gco|t`jèwmq` dm|ftrmwfe meq`wrmhfrmce ca|fwr feb |t`wèr |tcg`bpt`w hcq`temeh àactrw rc bmw|frgj b`rfme``w Fw rj` t`|ctr wrfr`w. rjmw

e`g`wwftmn} megnpb`b fe `zfomefrmce ca o`gjfemwow merèb`b rc |t`qèr acto`t b`rfme``w atco

t`èhfhmeh me r`ttct/t`nfr`b fgrmqmrm`w9 jcx`q`t. x` fnwc d`nm`q` rjfr rj` t`|ctr wjcpnb megnpb` fe

`vpfnn} tmhctcpw `zfomefrmce ca rj` tmwi ca gcermepmeh rc megftg`tfr` mebmqmbpfnw fr HROC xjcft` ec nceh`t b`r`tome`b rc d` f tmwi rc rj` w`gptmr} ca rj` Pemr`b Wrfr`w. cpt fnnm`w. feb cpt

rtcc|w fdtcfb Xjmn` àactrw x`t` ofb` rc fbbt`ww cpt gceg`te ce rjmw ofrr`t. rj`} bmb ecr hc aft

ècphj X` fht`` xmrj acto`t Bàèw` W`gt`rft} Bcefnb Tpowa`nb ce rj` mo|ctrfeg` ca ecr

b`rfmemeh mebmqmbpfnw pee`g`wwftmn} J` wrfr`b rj` Pemr`b Wrfr`w bc`wer xfer rc i``| fe} carjò fe} nceh`t rjfe x` jfq` rc Wèmct |cnmg} n`fb`tw ca rj` gpttèr Fbomemwrtfrmce fnwc fht``

ce rj` mo|ctrfeg` ca f||tc|tmfr` fnr`tefrmq`w rc b`rèrmce. Rj` Pemr`b Wrfr`w gfeecr `z|`gr rcb`rfme mrw xf} cpr ca rjmw |tcdnò6

X` f||t`gmfr` àactrw d} rj` wpdgcoomrr`` rc d` dm|ftrmwfe feb rc fggcoocbfr` cptgceg`tew Me |ftrmgpnft. x` f||t`gmfr` rj` t`wcnprmce ca mwwp`w t`hftbmeh rj` pw` ca o`bmf t`|ctrw

rjfr tà`tèg`b Xmimn`fiw bcgpoèrw X` d`nm`q` rjfr `q`t} oòd`t jfb wpaamgmèr rmo` rc

t`qm`x feb gcooèr ce rj` t`|ctr X` fnwc f||t`gmfr` rj` wpdgcoomrr`` hmqmeh rj`Fbomemwrtfrmce fe c||ctrpemr} rc gcooèr ce f btfar ca rj` t`|ctr Jcx`q`t. x` tòfme

gceg`te`b rjfr rj` B`|ftroèr ca Bàèw` d`nm`q`w mr jfw ecr d`è fdn` rc |tcqmb` f

gco|t`jèwmq` t`w|cew`

4

X` xmnn ecr |tcqmb` f nme`/d}/nme` fefn}wmw ca rj` t`|ctr9 jcx`q`t. x` xmnn jmhjnmhjr cpt

gceg`tew t`hftbmeh rj` acnncxmeh i`} mwwp`w;

6Kcje C Dtèefe. Fwwmwrfer rc rj` \t`wmbèr act Jco`nfeb W`gptmr} feb Gcper`tr`ttctmwo.Tòftiw fr rj` Dtèefe

Gèr`t act Kpwrmg . Oftgj 6:. 4


2/8

4

Gco|t`jèwmqè`ww; x` d`nm`q` rj` t`|ctr bc`w ecr wpaamgmèrn} gcq`t rj` bmt`gr`b rc|mg

Ofe} ca rj` i`} |cnmg} ofi`tw t`hftbmeh rjmw mwwp` x`t` ecr mer`tqm`x`b feb cen} f wofrr`tmehca hcq`teoèr bcgpoèrw x`t` t`qm`x`b *fdcpr 4


3/8

7

|t`nmomeft} Hcmeh actxftb. x` wjcpnb xcti xmrj crj`t gceht`wwmcefn gcoomrr``w. me |ftrmgpnft

rj` Jcpw` \`tofeèr W`n`gr Gcoomrr`` ce Mer`nnmhèg` feb rj` Jcpw` Act`mhe Faafmtw

Gcoomrr``

X` bc ecr d`nm`q` e`ftn} `q`t} wèmct caamgmfn meqcnq`b me rj`w` ofrr`tw me dcrj rj` Dpwj

feb Cdfof fbomemwrtfrmcew xfw mer`tqm`x`b X` fgiecxn`bh` rj` t`|ctr megnpb`w f pwàpn

àactr rc mer`tqm`x ofe} omb/n`q`n caamgmfnw. dpr rj` t`gctb mebmgfr`w cen} ce` wèmct |cnmg}ofi`t. acto`t B`|pr} W`gt`rft} ca Bàèw` Hctbce @ehnfeb. xfw mer`tqm`x`b Fr f omemopo.

rc cdrfme f gco|t`jèwmq` qm`x ca rjmw wpdk`gr x` xcpnb nmi` rc j`ft rj` qm`xw ca acto`t

W`gt`rft} ca Bàèw` Tpowa`nb. acto`t W`gt`rft} ca Bàèw` Tcd`tr Hfr`w. acto`t W`gt`rft} caWrfr` Gcnme \cx`nn. acto`t W`gt`rft} ca Wrfr` Gcebcn``{{f Tmg`. feb wèmct oòd`tw ca rj`

Efrmcefn W`gptmr} Gcpegmn feb rj` Mer`nnmhèg` Gcoopemr}

Cen} fe pew|`gmam`b epod`t ca w`q`tfn rjcpwfeb |fh`w ca hcq`teoèr bcgpoèrw x`t`

t`qm`x`b. xjmn` mr mw iecxe rj`t` mw f opgj nfth`t qcnpo` ca t`n`qfer bcgpoèrw Xjmn` opgj ca

rj` meactofrmce t`hftbmeh b`rfme``w mw iecxe rc t`wmb` xmrj rj` Mer`nnmhèg` Gcoopemr} febxmrj rj` B`|ftroèr ca Wrfr`. rj` t`|ctr |tmoftmn} acgpw`w ce rj` B`|ftroèr ca Bàèw` Opgj

xcti nm`w fj`fb ma rj` t`|ctr gfe fggptfr`n} d` nfd`n`b fw gco|t`jèwmq`

Rj` t`|ctr fgiecxn`bh`w t`nmfeg` ce wco` w`gcebft} wcptg`w Rj`w` w`gcebft}

wcptg`w t`n} `zrèwmq`n} ce peq`tmam`b o`bmf t`|ctrw gcerfmemeh pewpdwrfermfr`b vpcr`w X`d`nm`q` rj` t`|ctr hmq`w rj` `ttce`cpw mo|t`wwmce rjfr mr mw dfw`b |tmoftmn} ce t`nmfdn`

hcq`teoèr meactofrmce

Jcx`q`t. x` bcer xfer rc vpmddn` cq`t rj` bfrf gcnn`grmce Cpt dfwmg peb`twrfrmeh mw rjfr

b`w|mr` rj` àactrw ca rj` wpdgcoomrr``. x` wrmnn bcer jfq` f bàmemrmq` fewx`t ce rj` epod`t ca

HROC b`rfme``w xjc jfq` t`èhfh`b X` wp||ctr gcermep`b àactrw rc t`wcnq` rjmw mwwp`

Dfnfeg`

X` fht`` rjfr b`rfme``w jfq` d`è t`n`fw`b ct rtfewa`tt`b xjc jfq` t`èhfh`b. jcx`q`t

rj` wef|wjcrw |tcqmb`b bc ecr |tcqmb` fe fggptfr` ct gco|t`jèwmq` cq`tqm`x ca rj` b`rfme``rtfewa`t |tcg`ww X` bc ecr xfer rc t`n`fw` f b`rfme`` xjc |cw`w fe pefgg`|rfdn` tmwi rc rj`

efrmcefn w`gptmr} ca rj` Pemr`b Wrfr`w Rj`w` rjt`` `ftn} wef|wjcrw ofi` hè`tfnm{frmcew fdcpr

rj` b`rfme`` rtfewa`t |tcg`ww fw mr `zmwr`b |tmct rc rj` gpttèr |tcg`ww feb afmn rc mebmgfr`mo|tcqòèrw xmrj rj` gpttèr b`rfme`` rtfewa`t |tcg`ww Rj` wef|wjcr w`grmce mw fe `zfo|n` ca

rj` wmhemamgfer pw` ca peq`tmam`b o`bmf t`|ctrw

X` d`nm`q` rj`t` ft` epo`tcpw fbbmrmcefn wpgg`ww wrctm`w rjfr wjcpnb d` ecr`b B`rfme``w

jfq` d`è wpgg`wwapnn} t`w`rrn`b me D`topbf. Fndfemf. feb \fnfp rc efo` kpwr f a`x gcpertm`w.

fnrjcphj x` ecr` rj` bmaamgpnr} ca bmwgpwwmeh rjmw mwwp` gco|t`jèwmq`n} me fe pegnfwwmam`bbcgpoèr Jcx`q`t. hmqè rjfr fr n`fwr 87%. ma ecr oct` *w`` d`ncx-. ca rj` b`rfme``w jfq` ecr

d`è acpeb rc jfq` t`èhfh`b *gceamto`b ct wpw|`gr`b-. gmrfrmce rc oct` rjfe ce` wpgg`ww wrct}

xcpnb |tcqmb` f oct` dfnfeg`b qm`x

Mr mw omwn`fbmeh rc gceanfr` rj` epod`t ca gceamto`b feb wpw|`gr`b t`èhfh`tw

rch`rj`t X` bmwfht`` xmrj rj` wrfròèr me rj` |pdnmg q`twmce ca rj` amefn t`|ctr rjfr 48% cab`rfme``w ft` gceamto`b ct wpw|`gr`b ca t`èhfhmeh Rj`t` ft` mo|ctrfer bmwrmegrmcew d`rx`è rj`


4/8

2

rxc gfr`hctm`w feb rj` n`q`n ca `qmbèg` t`vpmt`b rc fbb fe mebmqmbpfn rc rj` nmwr ca wpw|`gr`b

t`èhfh`tw mw q`t} ncx. carè dfw`b ce wmehn`/wcptg` t`|ctrmeh ct peq`tmam`b meactofrmce rjfr mwo`t`n} |nfpwmdn` feb ecr |tcqè Fw mebmgfr`b me rj` t`|ctr. rj` nfr`wr |pdnmgfnn} fqfmnfdn`

meactofrmce wrfr`w rjfr :6 mebmqmbpfnw *670%- ft` gceamto`b t`èhfh`tw Rjpw. x` d`nm`q` 670%

mw rj` oct` fggptfr` wrfrmwrmg ma cen} ce` epod`t mw jmhjnmhjr`b Fw fnwc wrfr`b me rj` t`|ctr. fdcpr

22% ca rj` gcodme`b epod`t ca gceamto`b feb wpw|`gr`b t`èhfh`tw ft` mo|tmwce`b ct b`fbRjpw. xjmn` rj` o`rjcbcnch} mw ecr |t`gmw`. rj` oct` fggptfr` epod`t ca fgrmq` feb gceamto`b

t`èhfh`tw of} d` wmhemamgfern} ncx`t. |`tjf|w fdcpr =%2

Me fbbmrmce. cen} 11 |`twcew jfq` d`è rtfewa`tt`b atco HROC d} rj` gpttèr

Fbomemwrtfrmce. xmrj cen} 4 gceamto`b fw t`èhfh`tw. f amhpt` ca fdcpr 77%

X` d`nm`q` rj` èrmt` mwwp` ca t`èhfhòèr o`tmrw aptrj`t wrpb} feb wp||ctr rj`

t`gcooèbfrmcew rc bc wc Rjmw mw f gco|nmgfr`b wpdk`gr feb x` e``b rc ncci fr dcrj hcq`teoèr

fww`wwoèrw feb rj` fgfbòmg t`w`ftgj rjfr jfw d`è bce`0

X` jfq` f epod`t ca gceg`tew t`hftbmeh rj` t`|ctrw gjftfgr`tm{frmce ca rj` Wfpbm

T`jfdmnmrfrmce |tchtfo Xjmn` rj` ofkctmr} jfw xcti`b jftb rc fbbt`ww cpt gceg`tew t`hftbmehrj` t`|ctrw fefn}wmw ca rj` Wfpbm |tchtfo. x` d`nm`q` rj` t`|ctr bc`w ecr caa`t fe fggptfr` qm`x

ca rj` |tchtfo Xjmn` x` fgiecxn`bh` rj` Wfpbm |tchtfo fnncx`b f htcp| ca b`rfme``w rc

t`èhfh`. xjmgj xfw fe `zrtò`n} w`tmcpw megmbèr. rj` B`|ftroèr ca Bàèw` jfw mebmgfr`b rc

rj` wpdgcoomrr`` rjfr rjmw mwwp`w tfmw`b d} rj` megmbèr jfq` d`è fbbt`ww`b

X` jfq` gcermepmeh vp`wrmcew fdcprBMF o`rjcbcnch} feb ncci actxftb rc xctimeh xmrj rjò. feb crj`t gceht`wwmcefn gcoomrr``w.

w`` fdcq`. fw rj`} gcermep` rc `zfome` rjmw mwwp`

1Rj` B`|ftroèr ca

Bàèw` jfw mebmgfr`b rc rj` wpdgcoomrr`` rjfr rj` Wfpbm |tchtfo |tcqmb`w rtfewa`tt`b b`rfme``w

f gcertcnn`b feb wrtpgrpt`b |cwr/b`rèrmce èqmtceoèr. xjmgj fw rj` t`|ctr mebmgfr`w. mw f

wmhemamgfer afgrct t`hftbmeh f b`rfme``w |crèrmfn act t`èhfhòèr8

Me afgr. rj` B`|ftroèrgcermep`w rc d`nm`q` rj` Wfpbm |tchtfo mw foceh rj` d`wr fqfmnfdn` : X` fnwc fht`` xmrj rj`

B`|ftroèr rjfr ec wmehn` o`fwpt` mw wpaamgmèr feb rj` |tchtfo wjcpnb d` gncw`n} ocemrct`b fw|ftr ca cpt nfth`t fwwptfeg` |fgifh` xmrj Wfpbm Ftfdmf

=

Fecrj`t `zfo|n` ca nfgi ca dfnfeg` mw rj` w`grmce ce nmrmhfrmce |t`wwpt`w Me bmwgpwwmeh rj`gceht`wwmcefn b`dfr` ce rjmw mwwp`. mr gmr`w ce` wèfrct Rj` bmq`tw` w`r ca qm`xw ce rjmw mwwp`

wjcpnb jfq` d`è tà`tèg`b Rj` t`|ctr gco|nfmew fdcpr rj` gcwr me rmo` feb jcptw ca bàèbmeh

cpt qfnp`w X` d`nm`q` rj`} ft` xctrj mr Me fbbmrmce. rj` t`|ctr e`hn`grw rc megnpb` fe fefn}wmw carj` jfd`fw gfw`w me rjmw Fbomemwrtfrmce K`j G Kcjewce. rj` Hè`tfn Gcpew`n ca rj` B`|ftroèr

ca Bàèw` t`gèrn} wrfr`b rc rj` J`tmrfh` Acpebfrmce;

Rjmw mw fecrj`t ft`f x` e``b rc gcermep`

nccimeh fr feb ecr` rjfr opgj ca rj` ocwr mo|ctrfer bfrf mw gnfwwmam`b

2

Rj` amhpt`w ft` mo|t`gmw` d`gfpw` rj` 22% amhpt` megnpb`w wpw|`gr`b t`èfh`tw Fnwc. rj`t` mw oct` p| rc bfr`meactofrmce me rj` gnfwwmam`b fee`z0

X` f||t`gmfr` rj` xcti bce` d} \tca`wwct Ofti Bèd`fpz feb jmw wrpbèrw fr W`rce Jfnn Nfx WgjccnGèr`t act\cnmg} feb T`w`ftgj Xjmn` rj`mt t`w`ftgj mw dfw`b cen} ce c|è/wcptg` bcgpoèrw. x` jfq` d`è fwwmwr`b d} rj`mt

fefn}wmw W``.T`qmwmcemwr T`gmbmqmwo; F E`x Fefn}wmw ca rj` Hcq`teoèr(w T`|t`wèrfrmcew ca Fnn`h`b $T`gmbmqmwo$

ca rj` Hpferfefoc B`rfme``w. *Kpe` 4


5/8

0

Rjmtb. rj` hcq`teoèr mw w``meh gcewmwrèr wpgg`ww me rj` jfd`fw

gfw`w dtcphjr d} Hpferfefoc b`rfme``w Rj` gcptrw jfq` nfth`n}t`gchem{`b feb fgg`|r`b cpt n`hfn mer`t|t`rfrmce ca cpt b`rèrmce fprjctmr}.

feb rj` hcq`teoèr jfw ecx |t`qfmn`b fr rj` Bmwrtmgr Gcptr n`q`n me oct`

rjfe 6< gcew`gprmq` jfd`fw gfw`w dtcphjr d} Hpferfefoc b`rfme``w X`

ft` w``meh wmomnft hccb t`wpnrw me rj` BG Gmtgpmr

6

hasc dems dissent

Documents