globalization, railways, and agriculture in … · robert m. schwartz!"#$ globalization,...

Robert M. Schwartz

!"#$

GLOBALIZATION, RAILWAYS, AND AGRICULTURE IN FRANCE AND GREAT BRITAIN, 1850 TO 1914GLOBALIZAÇÃO, CAMINHOS DE FERRO E AGRICULTURA EM FRANÇA E NO REINO UNIDO, 1850 A 1914

Robert M. Schwartz (U. Vanderbilt, USA EUA)Thomas Thevenin (U. Boston, USA EUA)

Robert M. Schwartz is E. Nevius Rodman Professor of History Mount Holyoke College, South Hadley, Massachusetts. U.S.A.Thomas Thevenin (University of Boston; previously University of Burgundy and THEMA / CNRS, France) research is about transportation systems with an historical perspective.

Robert Schwartz é E. Nevius Rodman Professor de História, no Mount Holyoke College, Massachusetts, EUA. Especialista em história ambiental da Europa, desde o século XVII até agora.Thomas Thevenin (Universidade de Boston, E.U.A.; anteriormente Universidade de Burgundy e THEMA / CNRS, França) investiga sistemas de transportes numa perpsetiva historica.

Abstract ResumoPowered by steamships, railways, and telegraphy, the pace and extent of globalization grew dramatically from the 1850s to the Great Depression. This was especially true in the realm of agriculture, when a huge increase in the production and export of American wheat and beef generated a long agrarian crisis in Europe (1876-1896) as prices fell sharply, forcing farmers, landlords, and governments to adjust to intensifying competition in foodstuffs. Meanwhile, however, railways helped create commercial markets on the industrial scale, sometimes by investing in port facilities, sometimes merely by offering rapid transport to the huge consumer markets of London and Paris. GIS and spatial analysis, will help demonstrate the geography and growth of some commercial markets in Great Britain and France.

O ritmo e a dimensão da globalização cresceram dramaticamente entre 1850 e a Grande Depressão, especialmente no que respeita à agricultura, em que um enorme aumento das exportações de carne e de trigo Americanos criaram uma longa crise agraria na Europa (1876-1896). Or preços cairam e obrigaram os

Railroads in historical context: construction, costs and consequences

"#%!

lavradores e os proprietaries a ajustarem-se a uma intense competição na produção alimentar. Entretanto os caminhos de ferro ajudaram a criar mercados comerciais com escala industrial, por vezes investindo em facilidades portuárias, outras vezes pela oferta de transporter rápido para os enormes mercados de Londres e Paris. Com a ajuda de SIG e de análise especial, demonstra-se a geografua e o crescimento de alguns mercados comerciais no Reino Unido e em França

Robert M. Schwartz

!"#&

Globalization, Railways, and Agriculture in

France and Great Britain, 1850 to 1914

'()*+,!-.!/0123+,4!356!71(839!71*:*5;5!

71;9!3+,;0<*!;9!)39*6!(5!+*9*3+01!9=>>(+,*6!)?!3!@(<<3)(+3,;:*!'*9*3+01!A+35,!B+(8!,1*!C3,;(53<!D5-

6(28*5,!B(+!,1*!E=835;,;*9!F'GHI#I$$H#J#K.!L*!2(=<6!<;M*!,(!,135M!,1*!B(<<(2;5N!B(+!,1*;+!9=>>(+,!;5!

>+(6=0;5N!,1*!AO/!63,3!(5!P+;,;91!+3;<23?9!B+(8!-.!E.!@())Q9!+*83+M3)<*!3,<39!(BThe Railways of Great

Britain, a Historical Atlas, "!:(<9.!F/1*>>*+,(5R!O35!G<<35S!"##IKR!-*+;,T*<<!A3<<3+,S!-3,*=!-(+;<<39!356!

U.!-3+,;HV(8;5N=*4.!71;9!2(+M!239!>3+,!(B!3!D=+(>*35!/0;*50*!W(=563,;(5!;5;,;3,;:*!FD=+(0(+*9K!356!

,1*!>+(X*0,!2;,1;5!;,S!YL3,*+S!'(36!356!'3;<R!71*!V*:*<(>8*5,!(B!D=+(>*35!L3,*+23?9S!'(36!356!'3;<!

O5B+39,+=0,=+*9R!G!A*(N+3>1;03<! O5B(+83,;(5! /?9,*8! B(+! ,1*!E;9,(+?! (B!D=+(>*35! O5,*N+3,;(5! FZ%"IH

"##IKS!6;+*0,*6!)?!U(+6;!-3+,;!E*55*)*+NS!O5:*5,;5N!D=+(>*!N+35,!W[H##I.!71*!AO/!63,3!(5!,1*!W+*501!

+3;<!9?9,*8!13:*!)**5!0(59,+=0,*6!2;,1!,1*!1*<>!(B!-3,1;<6*![;44=,(!2;,1!B=569!(B!,1*!CDE!A+35,S!356!

\(;0!/3>*,!2;,1!N+35,!B=569!B+(8!,1*!W+*501!C3,;(53<!GN*50?!(B!'*9*3+01!FGC'!#$!@(+>!#Z&K.!-=01!(B!

,1*!63,3!B(+!P+;,3;5!2*+*!,3M*5!B+(8!,1*!A+*3,!P+;,3;5!E;9,(+;03<!AO/!FAPEAO/S!1,,>R]]222.N)1N;9.(+NKS!

356!,1*!035,(53<!)(=563+;*9!2*+*!M;56<?!9=>><;*6!)?!A.!L;<<;38!/M;55*+!(B!,1*!̂ 5;:*+9;,?!(B!@3<;B(+5;3S!

V3:;9.!/0123+,4! ,135M9! 9,=6*5,9! B(+! ,1*;+! 399;9,350*R! U30;5,3!D6*)*<;S! 356!G?<3!P*5H@13;8S!_;+9,*5!

E359*5S!356!-(+N35!L;<9(5!B(+!1*<>!;5!>+*>3+;5N!,1*!AO/!63,3!(5!V(+9*,!@(=5,?!3N+;0=<,=+*.!/>*0;3<!

,135M9!N(!,(!(=+!0(<<3)(+3,(+S!O35!A+*N(+?!356!B(+!1;9!;56;9>*59;)<*!1*<>!(:*+!,1*!?*3+9.!W(+!,1;9!>3+,!(B!

(=+!>+(X*0,S!O35!>+(:;6*6!,1*!9,3563+6;4*6!>3+;91!=5;,9!356!399(0;3,*6!>(>=<3,;(5!63,3!FZ%JZHZ&ZZK!356!

,1*!6;N;,3<!>1(,(N+3>19!1*!836*!(B!,1*!GN+;0=<,=+3<!@*59=9!'*,=+59!B(+!V(+9*,!@(=5,?!3,!,1*!C3,;(53<!

G+01;:*9S!_*2`!71(839!71*:*5;5!>+(:;6*6! ,1*!N*(+*B*+*50*6!0(88=53<!)(=563+;*9! 356! 9*,,<*8*5,!

0*5,*+9!356!9=>*+:;9*6!,1*!2(+M!(B!-3,1;<6*![;44=,(!356!\(;0!/3>*,!21(!6;N;,;4*6!,1*!+3;<! <;5*9!356!

9,3,;(59!B(+!W+350*.

\(99*9!?*3+!3B,*+!?*3+!356!;50+*39;5N!0(8>*,;,;(5!;56;03,*!,13,!,1*

!0+(>9!5(2!N+(25!3+*!5(,!9=Ba0;*5,!,(!9=>>(+,!,1*!B3+8*+.!L1*5!1*

*56*3:(=+9S!1(2*:*+S!,(!:3+?!1;9!8*,1(6!(B!0=<,=+*S!356!,(!

;5,+(6=0*!9(8*,1;5N!5*2S!1*!;9!8*,!3,!,1*!(=,9*,!)?!,2(!N+*3,

6;Ba0=<,;*9.!...!71*!a+9,!b;9c!,1*!*T,+3(+6;53+?!,;,1*!...`!,1*!9*0(56

;9!+*3<<?!*:*5!8(+*!;8>(+,35,d;,!;9!,1*!6*a0;*50?!(B!,+359;,.Z

Z! !';013+6!U*BB*+;*9S!Y/,*38!(5!@(=5,+?!'(369Se!;5!Field and Hedgerow, being the last essays of

Richard Jefferies F\(56(5R!\(5N8359S!A+**5S!356!@(.S!Z%%&KR!"f%S!"fZ!+*9>*0,;:*<?.!71;9!239!3!

>(9,1=8(=9<?!>=)<;91*6!0(<<*0,;(5!(B!1;9!*993?9!(B!,1*!Z%%#9.!U*BB*+;*9!6;*6!;5!Z%%$.!/**!D+;0!\.!

U(5*9S!Y71*!\356!,13,!';013+6!U*BB*+;*9!O51*+;,*6Se!Rural History ZJS!5(.!Z!F"##IK`![.U.![*++?S!YG5!

GN+;0=<,=+3<!U(=+53<;9,!(5!,1*!YA+*3,!V*>+*99;(5eR!';013+6!U*BB*+;*9Se!The Journal of British Studies

&S!5(.!"!FZ&$#K.


"Z#!

O,!;9!5(,!,((!8=01!,(!93?!,13,!,1+**!>3+,9!(B!D5N<356!3+*!g=;,*!39!

8=01!;5!5**6!(B!(>*5;5N!=>!39!,1*!)30M2((69!(B!G8*+;03.!L1*5!3!

5*2!+3;<+(36!,+30M!;9!>=91*6!(:*+!bG8*+;035c!>+3;+;*!356!,1+(=N1

>+;8*:3<!2((69S!9*,,<*8*5,9!9>+;5N!=>!)*9;6*!;,.!L1*5!+(36!,+3;59

b;5!P+;,3;5c!+=5!,1+(=N1!+*8(,*!138<*,9S!,1(9*!+*8(,*!138<*,9!2;<<!

323M*!,(!3!5*2!<;B*.

';013+6!U*BB*+;*9S!Y/,*38!(5!@(=5,+?!'(369Se!Z%%h

GB,*+! +*i*0,;5N! (5!G8*+;035! 3N+;0=<,=+*! 356! +3;<+(369S!';013+6! U*BB*+;*9S!

35!3N+;0=<,=+3<!X(=+53<;9,S!932!(5*!,1;5N!0<*3+<?R!P+;,3;5!8=9,!03,01!=>.!A((69!

,+3;59!;5!3N+3+;35!G8*+;035S!1*!2+(,*S!9,(>!5(,!8*+*<?!3,!9,3,;(59!)=,!:;+,=3<<?!

35?21*+*!3<(5N!,1*!<;5*!21*+*!,1*+*!239!N+3;5!356!>+(6=0*!,(!>;0M!=>.!71*!P+;,-

;91!B3+8*+S!3<39S!*5X(?9!5(!9=01!0(5:*5;*50*.!7(!N*,!0+(>9!356!>+(6=0*!,(!83+M*,!

;9!3!9,+=NN<*.!W;+9,S!1*!8=9,!03+,!,1*8!,(!3!+3;<23?!9,3,;(5d3!9<(2!X(=+5*?!(B!=>!

,(!Z#!8;<*9`! ,1*5S!3,! ,1*!9,3,;(5S!1*!B30*6!3! <(5N!23;,S!*:*5,=3<<?!9=++*56*+;5N!

Y,(!,1*!8;66<*835!,(!N*,!1;9!N((69!,(!83+M*,.e"!P+;,;91!,+3;59!2*5,!B+(8!,(25!,(!

,(25S!)=,!,1*?!5**6*6!,(!N(!,(!,1*!B3+89!356!,1*!0+(>9.

Road trains, 1*!3+N=*6S!2*+*!,1*!9(<=,;(5.!71*9*!+*6*9;N5*6!9,*38H>(2*+*6!

,+3;59!2(=<6!+=5!5(,!3<(5N!+3;<9!)=,!(5!0(=5,+?!+(369S!9,(>>;5N!3,!*301!B3+8!356!

Y<(36;5N!3,!,1*!N3,*!(B!,1*!a*<6ef!'3;<23?9S!1*!N+35,*6S!2(=<6!9,;<<!)*!*99*5,;3<!B(+!

<(5NH13=<!91;>8*5,9S!)=,!,1*!+(36!,+3;59!2(=<6!)+;5N!8=01!6*9;+*6!0135N*.!L;,1!

9>**6?!,+359;,!3,!1356S!B3+8*+9S!1*!0(5,;5=*6S!2;<<!><35,!>*+;913)<*!B+=;,9!356!

:*N*,3)<*9!(5!=5=9*6!><(,9S!,1*!+=+3<!>(>=<3,;(5!2;<<!N+(2S!356!P+;,;91!B3+8*+9!

2;<<!+*03>,=+*!+*:*5=*!5(2!N(;5N!,(!,1*!@(5,;5*5,!356!G8*+;03!B(+!;8>(+,9.!7(!

)+*3M!(>*5!+=+3<!;9(<3,;(5S!63;<?!+(36!,+3;59!B(+!>399*5N*+9!2(=<6!0(55*0,!:;<-

<3N*9!2;,1!83+M*,!,(259.!'*8(,*!138<*,9!would 9>+;5N!,(!<;B*.

@39,;5N!1;9!*?*!30+(99!,1*!@1355*<!3,!(<6!+;:3<!W+350*!239!5(!0(59(<3,;(5.!

W+350*!239!8(:;5N!31*36!(B!P+;,3;5S!,((.

L*!13:*!<3,*<?!9**5!,1*!W+*501!6*:(,*!35!*5(+8(=9!9=8!,(!,1*!<3?-

;5N!6(25!(B!+3;<9!;5!3N+;0=<,=+3<!6;9,+;0,9S!,(!,1*!83M;5N!(B!0353<9S!

356! N*5*+3<<?! ,(! ,1*! ;8>+(:*8*5,! (B! ;5,*+53<! 0(88=5;03,;(5! ;5!

>+(:;50*9!)=,!,1;5<?!>(>=<3,*6.!71*!;56=9,+;(=9!W+*501!13:*!+*0-

(N5;4*6!,13,!(<6!0(=5,+;*9S!21(9*!3+*3!;9!<;8;,*6S!035!(5<?!0(8>*,*!

2;,1!G8*+;03S!21(9*!3+*3!;9!3<8(9,!=5<;8;,*6S!)?!+*56*+;5N!,+359;,!

*39?!356!01*3>.!L*!;5!D5N<356!913<<!=<,;83,*<?!13:*!,(!3>><?!,1*!

938*!B30,.h

U*BB*+;*9Q! <38*5,! ,3M*9!=9!)30M!,(!3!>*+;(6!(B!300*<*+3,;5N!N<()3<;43,;(5!;5!

B((6!9,=BB9S!,(!0+;9;9!356!36X=9,8*5,!;5!,1*!;5,*+53,;(53<!6;:;9;(5!(B!B((6!>+(6=0-

"!IbidS!"fZ.!

f!Ibid, "fJ.

h Ibid., "f&.

Robert M. Schwartz

!"ZZ

,;(5S!356!;,!9*,9!,1*!90*5*!B(+!9(8*,1;5N!5*2R!3!0(8>3+3,;:*!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?!,13,!

)+;6N*9!,1*!N3>!)*,2**5!,2(!+*9*3+01!3+*39!,?>;03<<?!,+*3,*6!;5!;9(<3,;(5!B+(8!

(5*!35(,1*+S!(5*!(5!+3;<23?9!356!,1*!(,1*+!(5!3N+;0=<,=+*.!L13,!2*!6;90(:*+!;9!

3!)*,,*+!=56*+9,356;5N!0135N*!(:*+!9>30*!356!,;8*!)*,2**5!+3;<!,+359>(+,!356!

3N+;0=<,=+3<!>+(6=0,;(5.!G<,1(=N1!+=+3<! +3;<! 9*+:;0*!239!3!)((5! ,(! B3+8;5N!)?!

(>*5;5N! 6;9,35,! =+)35!83+M*,9S! ;,! 3<9(! >;501*6! B3+8*+9!21*+*! ;,! 1=+,S! )+;5N-

;5N!;5,*59;B?;5N!;5,*+53,;(53<!0(8>*,;,;(5!;5!B((69,=BB9!,(!,1*!B3+8!N3,*.!/,;<<S!

*:*5!39!0(8>*,;,;(5!N+*2!356!,1*!3N+3+;35!6*>+*99;(5!(B!Z%%#9!356!Z%&#9!9,+=0M!

3N+3+;35!*0(5(8;*9S!300*99;)<*!+3;<!,+359>(+,!(B,*5!1*<>*6!B3+8*+9!363>,!,(!5*2!

83+M*,!0(56;,;(59!(B!,1*!N<()3<;4;5N!2(+<6!(B!,1*!<3,*!5;5*,**5,1!0*5,=+?.!U*BB*+-

;*9!239!=53)<*!,(!9**!,1;9!*:*5!,1(=N1!1*!300=+3,*<?!6*>;0,*6!,1*!N*5*+3<!0+;9;9!

(B!0(5a6*50*!;5!D=+(>*35!B3+8;5N.

HISTORICAL GIS AND SPATIAL HISTORY

W3+8*+9!(B!,1*!>*+;(6!M5*2!:*+?!2*<<!,13,!,1*;+!B(+,=5*9!;50+*39;5N<?!6*>*56*6!

=>(5!+3;<23?9!356!,1*;+!B+*;N1,!013+N*9.!7(63?S!B*2!901(<3+9!6(=),!,13,!+3;<23?9!

356! 3N+;0=<,=+*! 2*+*! <;5M*6! 356! ;5,*+6*>*56*5,S! 356! ?*,! 1;9,(+;359! 0(50*+5!

,1*89*<:*9S!3<8(9,!*T0<=9;:*<?S!2;,1!(5*!(+!,1*!(,1*+!9=)X*0,.!'3+*!*T0*>,;(59!

,(!,1;9!(BB*+!:3<=3)<*!;59;N1,9S!21;01!2*!035!;8>+(:*!=>(5!;5!9*:*+3<!23?9.!AO/!

356!9>3,;3<!353<?9;9!83M*!;,!>(99;)<*!,(!9,=6?!<3+N*+!356!8(+*!0(8><*T!)(6;*9!

(B!*:;6*50*!3,!6;BB*+*5,!903<*9!356!(:*+!,;8*.!E*+*S!(=+!N*(H+*B*+*50*6!*:;6*50*!

0(8*9!B+(8!<3+N*!63,3)39*9!(5!+3;<23?9S!>(>=<3,;(5S!356!3N+;0=<,=+*!B(+!A+*3,!

P+;,3;5!356!W+350*!B+(8!,1*!Z%f#9!,(!Z&f#9.!G5(,1*+!;8>+(:*8*5,!;9!(=+!=9*!

(B!3!0(8>3+3,;:*!3>>+(301!,(!;5:*9,;N3,*!>3,,*+59!(B!0135N*!2;,1;5!356!)*,2**5!

9,3,*9S! ,1*! )*,,*+! ,(! ;6*5,;B?! 356! *T><3;5! )(,1! 9;8;<3+;,;*9! 356! 6;BB*+*50*9! ;5!

0(=5,+;*9!,13,!136!6;BB*+;5N!>(<;,;03<!*0(5(8;*9S!3!6;BB*+*50*!+*i*0,*6!;5!3N+;-

0=<,=+3<!>(<;0?!)?!P+;,;91!B+**!,+36*!356!W+*501!>+(,*0,;(5;98.!O5!,1;9!>*+;(6!(B!

N<()3<;4;5N!83+M*,9!0(8>3+3,;:*!1;9,(+?!;9!3<<!)=,!;56;9>*59;)<*!B(+!=56*+9,356-

;5N!,1*!>(9;,;(5!(B!35?!N*(N+3>1;03<!3+*3!356!;,9!>+(6=0*+9!;5!;,9!+*<3,;(5!,(!,1*!

91;B,;5N! ;5,*+53,;(53<! 6;:;9;(5! (B! <3)(+! H3! 5**6! =56*+90(+*6! )?! ;,9! 3)9*50*! ;5!

8=01!(B!,1*!<;,*+3,=+*!(5!,1*!3N+3+;35!6*>+*99;(5!(B!,1*!<3,*!5;5*,**5,1.I

G8(5N!1;9,(+;359!(B!P+;,;91!3N+;0=<,=+*!,1*+*!;9!3!0(59*59=9!,13,!,1*!6*>+*9-

9;(5! ;5!P+;,3;5!239! 5(,! 3! YN*5*+3<! 0+;9;9e! ;5! 3N+;0=<,=+3<! (=,>=,! )=,! (5*! ,13,!

I!71*+*!3+*!9*:*+3<!5(,3)<*!*T0*>,;(59!,13,!9>*0;a03<<?!3>><?!3!0(8>3+3,;:*!3>>+(301!;5!,1*!9,=6?!

(B!3N+;0=<,=+*!356!3N+;0=<,=+3<!>(<;0;*9.!C;*M!_(5;5NS!The failure of agrarian capitalism :

agrarian politics in the UK, Germany, the Netherlands and the USA, 1846-1919 F\(56(5R!

'(=,<*6N*S!Z&&hK`!-;013*<!7+30?S!Government and agriculture in Western Europe, 1880-1988,

f+6!*6.!FC*2!j(+M!`!\(56(5R!E3+:*9,*+!L1*3,91*3BS!Z&%&K`!_*:;5!E.!kQ'(=+M*S!Y71*!D=+(>*35!

A+3;5!O5:39;(5S!Z%$#HZ&ZfSe!The Journal of Economic History I$S!5(.!h!FZ&&$KS!356!U.!\.!:35!

l356*5!Y71*!A+(2,1!(B![+(6=0,;(5!356![+(6=0,;:;,?!;5!D=+(>*35!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%$#HZ&ZhSe!The

Economic History Review hhS!5(.!"!FZ&&ZKR!"ZIHf&.


"Z"!

:3+;*6!)?! +*N;(5!356! ,13,! 9,+=0M! ,1*!0*+*3<!N+(2;5N! +*N;(59!(B! ,1*! 9(=,1!356!

9(=,1*39,!8=01!13+6*+!,135!*<9*21*+*!;5!D5N<356!356!L3<*9.!V*)3,*!0(5,;5=*9S!

1(2*:*+S!39!,(!21*,1*+!(+!5(,!P+;,;91!3N+;0=<,=+*!YB3;<*6e!,(!8**,!,1*!013<<*5N*9!

(B!;5,*59;B?;5N!B(+*;N5!0(8>*,;,;(5.!Y[*99;8;9,9e!>(;5,!,(!,1*!6*8;9*!(B!<3+N*S!

8(+*!>+(6=0,;:*!B3+89S!3!<30M!(B!;55(:3,;(5!356!*5,+*>+*5*=+;3<!93::?S!356!,1*!

N(:*+58*5,Q9! 0(8><30*5,! 6*>*56*50*! (5! ;8>(+,9! B+(8! ,1*! )(=5,;B=<! 3N+;0=<-

,=+3<!+*9(=+0*9!(B!,1*! .̂/.!356!P+;,3;5Q9!0(<(5;*9.J!G9!8(+*!+*N;(53<!+*9*3+01!;9!

=56*+,3M*5S!Y(>,;8;9,9e!3+N=*!,13,!resilience, 5(,!B3;<=+*S!013+30,*+;4*6!D5N<;91!

B3+8;5N!;5!6;Ba0=<,!0;+0=89,350*9.$!L1*,1*+!(>,;8;9,!(+!5(,S!,1*!+(<*!(B!+=+3<!+3;<!

,+359>(+,!;5!+*9>(59*!,(!,1*!3N+3+;35!6*>+*99;(5!;9!;5!,1;9!<;,*+3,=+*!=9=3<<?!3)9*5,!

(+!8*5,;(5*6!(5<?!;5!>399;5N.%

71*!938*!;9!,+=*!;5!+*9*3+01!(5!W+*501!3N+;0=<,=+*!;5!,1*!9*0(56!13<B!(B!,1*!

Z&,1!0*5,=+?.!P?!356!<3+N*S!9,=6;*9!(B!3N+;0=<,=+3<!>*+B(+8350*!356!,1*!6*>+*9-

9;(5!;5!>3+,;0=<3+!0(50*+5!,1*89*<:*9!2;,1!,1*!53,;(53<!<*:*<!3<(5*S!356!9,=6;*9!

(B!9>*0;a0!+*N;(59!3+*!(5<?!)*N;55;5N!,(!3>>*3+.&!-*3521;<*S!6*)3,*!(:*+!W+*501!

3N+;0=<,=+*!*01(*9!,13,!(:*+!P+;,;91!B3+8;5N.!W+*501!Y>*99;8;9,9e!83+913<!*:;-

6*50*!(<6!356!5*2!,(!6*8(59,+3,*!,13,!W+*501!3N+;0=<,=+*!<3NN*6!)*1;56!P+;,3;5!

356!8(9,!(B!L*9,*+5!D=+(>*.Z#!k>,;8;9,9!+*9>(56!2;,1!5*2!63,3!356!3+N=8*5,!

J!D.!U.!7.!@(<<;59S!Y71*!A+*3,!V*>+*99;(5S!Z%$IHZ%&JSe!;5!The Agrarian History of England and Wales.

Volume VII1850-1914, *6.!D.!U.!7.!@(<<;59!F@38)+;6N*R!@38)+;6N*!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!"###KS!Zf%H

"#$`!';013+6![*++*5S!Agriculture in depression, 1870-1940, C*2!9,=6;*9!;5!*0(5(8;0!356!9(0;3<!

1;9,(+?!F@38)+;6N*R!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!Z&&IK.

$!D.E!E=5,!356!/.!U.![38S!Y[+;0*9!356!/,+=0,=+3<!'*9>(59*!;5!D5N<;91!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%$fHZ%&JSe!The

Economic History Review I#S!5(.!f!FZ&&$KR!h$$HI#I`!P*,135;*!GB,(5S!Y71*!A+*3,!GN+;0=<,=+3<!

V*>+*99;(5!(5!,1*!D5N<;91!@13<M<3569R!71*!E38>91;+*!DT>*+;*50*Se!Agricultural History Review

hhFZ&&JKR!Z&ZH"#I`!-;013*<!7=+5*+S!Yk=,>=,!356![+;0*9!;5!^_!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%J$HZ&ZhS!356!,1*!

A+*3,!GN+;0=<,=+3<!V*>+*99;(5!'*0(59;6*+*6Se!The Agricultural History Review h#S!5(.!Z!FZ&&"KR!

f%HIZ`!-;013*<!D.!7=+5*+S!YGN+;0=<,=+3<!k=,>=,S!O50(8*S!356![+(6=0,;:;,?Se!;5!The Agrarian

History of England and Wales. Volume VII1850-1914, *6.!D.!U.!7.!@(<<;59S!The Agrarian History of

England and Wales F@38)+;6N*R!@38)+;6N*!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!"###K`!:35!l356*5!Y71*!A+(2,1!(B!

[+(6=0,;(5!356![+(6=0,;:;,?!;5!D=+(>*35!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%$#HZ&Zh.e

%!/**!B(+!*T38><*!,1*!<;8;,*6!,+*3,8*5,!(B!+3;<23?9!;5!D.!U.!7.!@(<<;59S!*6.!The Agrarian History

of England and Wales. Volume VII1850-1914, 71*!GN+3+;35!E;9,(+?!(B!D5N<356!356!L3<*9!

F@38)+;6N*R!@38)+;6N*!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S"###K.!O8>(+,35,!*T0*>,;(59!;50<=6*!@1+;9,;5*!E3<<39S!

The Wensleydale Railway F@<3>138!bP*6B(+691;+*cR!V3<*9835!P((M9S!Z&%hK`!V.L.!E(2*<<S!Y71*!

;8>30,!(B!+3;<23?9!(5!3N+;0=<,=+3<!6*:*<(>8*5,!;5!5;5*,**5,1H0*5,=+?!L3<*9Se!Welsh History

Review $FZ&$hHIK`!@1+;9,;5*!E3<<39S!Y71*!/(0;3<!356!D0(5(8;0!O8>30,!(B!'=+3<!'3;<23?R!71*!

L*59<*?63<*!\;5*Se!The Agricultural History Review fhFZ&%JK`!356!V3:;6!7=+5(0MS!An historical

geography of railways in Great Britain and Ireland. G<6*+91(,S!E35,9S!D5N<356S!P+((Ma*<6S!m,R!

G91N3,*S!Z&&%.

&!@1+;9,(>1*!P(=5*3=S!Y@1*8;59!6*!B*+!*,!6*:*<(>>*8*5,!+=+3<!*5!W+350*!6*!Z%I"!3!Z&f$!R!<3!

0(5,+;)=,;(5!6*!<3!@(8>3N5;*!6=!-;6;!Y!Histoire, Economie et Societe ZFZ&&#K`!E=N1!@<(=,S!Y71*!

[3?9!6*!P+3?R!G!m3<*!(B!V3;+;*9!;5!C(+,1*+5!W+350*Se!Agricultural History Review IZS!5(.!"!F"##fK!R!

Z&&#H"#%.

Z#!U*35H[;*++*!V(+8(;9S!Y\3!n:(03,;(5!3N+;0(<*!6*!<3!W+350*Q.!\Q3N+;0=<,=+*!B+3503;9*!B30*!3!<3!

0(50=++*50*!)+;,355;g=*!3:35,!<3!N=*++*!6*!Z&ZhSe!Histoire etMesure ZZS!5(.!fHh!FZ&&JKR!f"&HJJ`!

G<)*+,!P+(6*+S!Y\3!<(5N=*!9,3N53,;(5!B+3503;9*R!>35(+383!N*5*+3<Se!;5!La Longue stagnation en

France. L’autre grande depression 1873-1897, *6.!j:*9`!P+(6*+!P+*,(5S!G<)*+`!\=,B3<<3S!-;01*<S!

*69.!F[3+;9R!D0(5(8;03S!Z&&$K`!U*35HW+350(;9!m;63<S!Depression etretour de la prosperity. Les

Robert M. Schwartz

!"Zf

,13,!,1*!W+*501!9?9,*8!(B!983<<HB3+8;5N!239!8(+*!+3,;(53<!356!>+(6=0,;:*!,135!

0(88(5<?!,1(=N1,.ZZ!L;,1;5!W+350*!;,9*<BS!3!<(5NH1*<6!N*5*+3<;43,;(5!1(<69!,13,!

;5!3N+;0=<,=+*d39!;5!;56=9,+?d,1*!0(=5,+?!239!6;:;6*6!)*,2**5!,1*!6*:*<(>*6!

5(+,1!356!,1*!<*99!6*:*<(>*6!9(=,1.!k5!,1*!;99=*!(B!+*N;(53<!6;9>3+;,;*9!5*2!(>-

>(+,=5;,;*9!B(+!0(8>3+3,;:*!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?!3)(=56S!,135M9!;5!>3+,!U*35H@<3=6*!

7(=,3;5Q9!2(+M!(5!+*N;(53<!:3+;3,;(59!;5!>+(6=0,;:;,?!N+(2,1!B+(8!Z%Z#HZ&&#.Z"!

k5*!83X(+! a56;5N!239! ,13,! 5(+,1H9(=,1! 6;9>3+;,;*9! 53++(2*6! 3B,*+! Z%J#9! 356!

,13,!N+(2,1!+3,*9!;5!,1*!,2(!+*N;(59!0(5:*+N*6!3,!,1*!*56!(B!,1*!5;5*,;*,1!356!

*3+<?!,2*5,;*,1!0*5,=+;*9S!(2;5N!;5!<3+N*!>3+,!,(!,1*!;50+*39*6!>+(6=0,;:;,?!(B!,1*!

2;5*!356!83+M*,HN3+6*5;5N!9*0,(+9! ;5!,1*!9(=,1.!7(=,3;5Q9!63,3!356!3+N=8*5,!

)+;5N!2*<0(8*!3,,*5,;(5!,(!,1*!;99=*!(B!3N+;0=<,=+3<!+*9,+=0,=+;5N!3B,*+!Z%J#!356!

+*5*29!6*)3,*.!k5*!+*0*5,!3+,;0<*S!B(+!*T38><*!3+N=*9S!+3,1*+!=5>*+9=39;:*<?S!,13,!

+*N;(53<!9>*0;3<;43,;(5!(B!,1*!M;56!,13,!6*:*<(>*6!;5!P+;,3;5!239!<3+N*<?!3)9*5,!

;5!W+350*!B+(8!Z%$#!,(!Z&Zh.Zf!O5!B30,S!,1*!;99=*!03<<9!(=,!B(+!B=+,1*+!+*9*3+01.!O5!

(=+!<3+N*+!2(+M!2*!3592*+!,1*!03<<S!91(2;5N!,13,!,1*!N*(N+3>1;0!+*9,+=0,=+;5N!(B!

W+*501!3N+;0=<,=+*!239!8=01!B30;<;,3,*6!)?!+3;<23?!*T>359;(5.!G<,1(=N1!2*!6(!

5(,!>=+9=*!,1*!)+(36*+!>3,,*+59!1*+*S!,1*!353<?9;9!)*<(2!(B!,1*!@(,*!6Qk+!V*>3+,-

8*5,!;5!P=+N=56?!;<<=9,+3,*9!(=+!3>>+(301.

L;,1!(=+!>+()<*8!;5!;,9!1;9,(+;(N+3>1;03<!B+38*S!2*!035!5(2!0(59;6*+!,((<9!

356!8*,1(69.!E(2!035!(=+!g=*9,;(59! 3)(=,! 9>3,;3<! +*<3,;(591;>9! 356!0135N*9!

(:*+!,;8*!)*!9?9,*83,;03<<?!366+*99*6o!7;8*!239!21*5!9,=6?;5N!,1*!;5i=*50*!

(B!>+(T;8;,?!;5!9(0;3<!+*<3,;(59!239!3!13+6!+(2!,(!1(*S!356!(5*!136!,(!<;8;,!*;,1*+!

,1*!9;4*!(B!,1*!9,=6?!3+*3!(+!,1*!938><*!(B!63,3.!7(63?S!AO/!356!N*(N+3>1;03<<?H

+*B*+*50*6!63,3!+*6=0*!,1*9*!>+*:;(=9!0(59,+3;5,9!356!(>*5!5*2!>(99;);<;,;*9!;5!

9>3,;3<!353<?9;9!=9;5N!:;9=3<;43,;(5S!03+,(N+3>1?S!356!9>3,;3<!9,3,;9,;09.Zh!O5!,1;9!

!"#"$% & '(") # &*+*,+*-#*.'*/0/ *&% !, *F[3+;9R!\QE3+83,,35S!"###K`!U.!\.!:35!l356*5!Y71*!

A+(2,1!(B![+(6=0,;(5!356![+(6=0,;:;,?!;5!D=+(>*35!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%$#HZ&Zh.e

ZZ!U=35!@3+8(53S!Y/13+*0+(>>;5N!356!<;:*9,(0M!9>*0;3<;43,;(5!;5!W+350*S!Z%f#HZ&f#Se!Continuity and

Change "ZF"##JKR!"fIHI&.!G56+*`!m*+<*?!/,+3=9S![3,+;0MS!Y\Q*0(5(8;*!B+3503;9*!3=!pOp*!9;*0<*.!

G53<?9*!830+(H*0(5(8;g=*S!=5*!(*=:+*!;9(<**!(=!=5*!(=:*+,=+*!:*+9!6*9!+*01*+01*9!5(:3,+;0*9!

oeS!1 2' *.34%&5"%( *.'*/0/ *&% !, *"fF"##ZKR!Zh`!m;63<S!Depression et retour de la prosperity. Les

!"#"$% & '(") # &*+*,+*-#*.'*/0/ *&% !, *`!-;013*<!E3=S!Y\3!+*9;9,350*!6*9!+*N;(59!6Q3N+;0=<,=+*!

;5,*59;:*!3=T!0+;9*9!6*!<3!a5!6=!pOp*!9;*0<*!R!\*9!039!6*!<QG<930*S!6=!m3=0<=9*!*,!6=!P39H

\35N=*6(0Se!;5!6#*&% !, *.34%&5"%( *+7(%!", *-(+#8+%& 9*:!5 &*.'*!",,"8' *. *la Societe frangaise

d’economie rurale, *6.!@13<8;5S![1;<;>>*!356!A=*9<;5S!G56+*!FD0(5(8;*!+=+3<*S!Z&%%KR!fZHhZ`!

A;;5,1*+!/018;,,S!YGN+;0=<,=+*!;5!C;5*,**5,1!@*5,=+?!W+350*!356!P+;,3;5R!G5(,1*+!DT><353,;(5!

(B!O5,*+53,;(53<!356!O5,*+9*0,(+3<![+(6=0,;:;,?!V;BB*+*50*9Se!The Journal of European Economic

History Z&S!5(.!Z!FZ&&#K.

Z"!U*35H@<3=6*!7(=,3;5S!La production agricole de la France de 1810 a 1990: Departements et

Regions. Croissance, productivity, structures, f!:(<9.S!E;9,(;+*!g=35,;,3,;:*!6*!<Q*0(5(8;*!B+3503;9*!

FA+*5()<*R!@31;*+9!6*!ZQO/-DG!bD0(5(8;*9!*,!9(0;*,*9cS!Z&&"HfK`!Y\3!@+(;99350*!;5*N3<*9!6*9!

+*N;(59!B+3503;9*9R!<Q3N+;0=<,=+*!6*!Z%Z#HZ&&#Se!1 2' *4%&5"(%8' *I&#FZ&&hKR!fZIHI&.

Zf!V(+8(;9S!Y\3!n:(03,;(5!3N+;0(<*!6*!<3!W+350*Q.!\Q3N+;0=<,=+*!B+3503;9*!B30*!3!<3!0(50=++*50*!

)+;,355;g=*!3:35,!<3!N=*++*!6*!Z&ZhSe!fI%.

Zh!G!N((6S!)+;*B!;5,+(6=0,;(5!,(!1;9,(+;03<!AO/!;9!O35!C.!A+*N(+?S!A Place in History: A Guide to Using

GIS in Historical Research FkT)(2R!kTB(+6!"##fK.!W(+!3!B=<<*+!300(=5,!9**!O35!A+*N(+?!356![3=<!

D<<S!Historical GIS: Technology, methodology and scholarship F@38)+;6N*S!D5N<356R!@38)+;6N*!

^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!"##%K.!71*!8(9,!0(5:*5;*5,!9=+:*?!(B!,1*!AO/!a*<6!;5!;,9!:3+;*,?!356!,*015;g=*9!


"Zh!

039*!*50(6;5N!,1*!N*(N+3>1;0!0((+6;53,*9!;5!*301!=5;,!(B!353<?9;9!83M*9!;,!>(9-

9;)<*! ,(! 03<0=<3,*!835?! 6;BB*+*5,! 39>*0,9! (B! 6;9,350*S! >+(T;8;,?S! 300*99;);<;,?S!

356!,+359>(+,!0(9,!21*5!X(;5*6!2;,1!AO/!63,3!(5!,1*!6*:*<(>8*5,!(B!+3;<23?9!

356! +3;<! 9,3,;(59! B+(8! ,1*! Z%f#9! ,(! Z&f#9.!^9;5N! N*(H+*B*+*50*6! ;5B(+83,;(5!

(5!3N+;0=<,=+3<!>+(6=0,;(5!356!<356!=9*!3,,301*6!,(!P+;,;91!0(=5,;*9S! +*N;9,+3-

,;(59!6;9,+;0,9S!356!>3+;91*9!356!,(!,1*!0(++*9>(56;5N!=5;,9!(B!W+*501!368;5;9-

,+3,;(5d!6*>3+,8*5,9S!035,(59S!356!0(88=5*9dN;:*9!=9!0(8>3+3)<*!63,3!3,!

,1*9*!9*:*+3<!903<*9!(B!N*(N+3>1;0!+*9(<=,;(5.

C(2!2*!,=+5!,(!9>*0;a0!g=*9,;(59.!L1;01!0(88=5;,;*9!;5!3!N;:*5!+=+3<!3+*3!

2*+*!Z#!8;<*9!(+!B=+,1*+!B+(8!3!+3;<23?!9,3,;(5S!,1*!0(56;,;(5!U*BB*+;*9!013+30,*+-

;4*6!39!<38*5,3)<*o!k:*+!,1*!?*3+9!21;01!:;<<3N*9!0(5,;5=*6!,(!B3<<!;5,(!,1*!Y6;9-

,35,e!03,*N(+?!39!(>>(9*6!,(!,1(9*!,13,S!2;,1!+3;<!*T>359;(5S!038*!,(!)*!Y5*3+e!3!

9,3,;(5S!13:;5N!a:*!8;<*9!(+!B*2*+!,(!N*,!,1*;+!0+(>9!,(!3!91;>>;5N!>(;5,o!W=+,1*+S!

1(2!239!>+(T;8;,?!,(!+3;<!,+359>(+,!+*<3,*6!,(!0135N*!;5!,1*!=9*!(B!3N+;0=<,=+3<!

<356S!,(!,1*!91;B,!B+(8!3+3)<*!B3+8;5N!,(!<;:*9,(0M!356!63;+?!B3+8;5No!71*!0(8-

);53,;(5!(B!AO/!356!9>3,;3<!353<?9;9!)+;5N!,1*!*T38;53,;(5!(B!,1*9*!0(8><*T;,;*9!

2;,1;5!+*301.ZI

BACK TO THE STORY: THE AGRARIAN DEPRESSION AND

THE RAILWAY SYSTEMS OF BRITAIN AND FRANCE

The Depression

-35?!(B!1;9!0(5,*8>(+3+;*9!3N+**6!2;,1!U*BB*+;*9Q9!0(50*+5!2;,1!,1*!;536-

*g=30;*9!(B!P+;,3;5Q9!+=+3<!+3;<!,+359>(+,!9*+:;0*9.!P+;,;91!9*+:;0*9!2*+*!2(*B=<<?!

(=,83,01*6!)?!,1(9*!;5!,1*!^5;,*6!/,3,*9!356!8;N1,!)*!(:*+,3M*5!)?!,1(9*!;5!

W+350*! 39!2*<<.! 71;9! ;59=Ba0;*50?! 9*+;(=9<?! =56*+8;5*6! ,1*!P+;,;91! B3+8*+Q9!

3);<;,?!,(!9=+:;:*!,1*!3N+;0=<,=+3<!6*>+*99;(5!356!2;,19,356!;5,*59;B?;5N!;5,*+-

53,;(53<! 0(8>*,;,;(5! ;5! B((6! 9,=BB9! B+(8!G8*+;03.ZJ 71*! 9;N59! (B! 6;Ba0=<,;*9!

;9!,1*!0(<<*0,;(5!(B!3+,;0<*9!)?!<*36;5N!9>*0;3<;9,9!;5!G.!/,*23+,!W(,1*+;5N138!356!U(15![.!L;<9(5S!

The handbook of geographic information science, P<30M2*<<!0(8>35;(59!,(!N*(N+3>1?!F-3;6*5S!

-GR!P<30M2*<<![=).S!"##%K.

ZI!71*!B(<<(2;5N!6;90=99;(5!6+329!(5!+*9*3+01!OQ:*!>+*9*5,*6!;5!>+*:;(=9!0(5B*+*50*!>3>*+9!356!

9*:*+3<!+*0*5,!3+,;0<*9S!;50<=6;5N!YC*2!7((<9!B(+!@<;(R!AO/S!'3;<23?9S!356!@135N*!(:*+!7;8*!

356!/>30*!;5!W+350*!356!A+*3,!P+;,3;5S!Z%h#HZ&ZhSe!"##$S!3!6;N;,3<!>=)<;03,;(5!F^5;:*+9;,?!(B!

C*)+39M3!356!^5;:*+9;,?!(B!O<<;5(;9![+*99K.!1,,>R]]222.8,1(<?(M*.*6=]0(=+9*9]+90123+,]+3;<23?9]`!

Y'3;<!7+359>(+,S!GN+3+;35!@+;9;9S!356!,1*!'*9,+=0,=+;5N!(B!GN+;0=<,=+*R!W+350*!356!A+*3,!P+;,3;5!

@(5B+(5,!A<()3<;43,;(5S!Z%J#HZ&##S!Social Science History fh."!F"#Z#KR!""&HII`!356!Y/>3,;3<!

E;9,(+?R!'3;<23?9S!^5*:*5!V*:*<(>8*5,S!356!3!@+;9;9!(B!A<()3<;43,;(5!;5!W+350*!356!A+*3,!

P+;,3;5Se!Journal of Interdisciplinary History F=56*+!+*:;*2KS!2;,1!0(H3=,1(+9!O35!C.!A+*N(+?!356!

71(839!71*:*5;5.

ZJ!G!)+;*B!;5,+(6=0,;(5!,(!,1*!9=)X*0,!;9![*,*+!G.!@(0<35;9S!YP30M!,(!,1*!W=,=+*R!71*!A<()3<;43,;(5!(B!

GN+;0=<,=+*!;5!E;9,(+;03<!@(5,*T,Se!SAIS Review "fS!5(.!Z!F"##fKR!$ZH%h.!W(+!P+;,3;5S!9**!@(<<;59S!

Y71*!A+*3,!V*>+*99;(5S!Z%$IHZ%&J.e!W(+!W+350*S!U*35!\1(88*S!Y\3!0+;9*!3N+;0(<*!3!<3!a5!6=!pOp*!

Robert M. Schwartz

!"ZI

*8*+N*6!;5!,1*!8;6!Z%$#9!21*5!3!9*+;*9!(B!0((<!356!+3;5?!9=88*+9!<*6!,(!)36!

13+:*9,9!356!03,,<*!6;9*39*9!,13,!+*301*6!3!0+;9;9!>(;5,!;5!Z%$&.!O5!,1*!938*!>*-

+;(6!,1*!a+9,!23:*!(B!G8*+;035!N+3;5!*T>(+,9!3++;:*6!;5!P+;,3;5!356!(,1*+!D=+(-

>*35!0(=5,;*9S!B(+0;5N!,1*!>+;0*!(B!21*3,!;5!>3+,;0=<3+!,(!<(2*+!356!<(2*+!<*:*<9!

=5,;<!3!8;<6! +*0(:*+?!)*N35! ;5! ,1*!8;6HZ%&#9.!W+(8!Z%$f! ,(!Z%%"S!G8*+;035!

*T>(+,9!(B!21*3,!+(9*!B+(8!h#!,(!ZI#!8;<<;(5!)=91*<9S!6;9><30;5N!'=99;3!39!,1*!

01;*B!*T>(+,*+!(B!0*+*3<!N+3;59!21;<*! ,1*! <3+N*9,! 913+*!038*! ,(!P+;,3;5.Z$!L*<<!

)*B(+*!,1*5!D5N<;91!;5,*+*9,!;5!G8*+;035!3N+;0=<,=+*!>+(6=0*6!35!(=,>(=+;5N!(B!

3+,;0<*9!356!+*>(+,9S!3!B3;+!5=8)*+!13:;5N!)**5!2+;,,*5!)?!3=,1(+9!21(!136!()-

9*+:*6!G8*+;035!B3+8;5N!a+9,!1356.!71*!)*9,!M5(25!(B!,1*8!239!U38*9!@3;+6S!

3!-*8)*+!(B![3+<;38*5,!356!,1*!83;5!B(+0*!)*1;56!,1*!*9,3)<;918*5,!;5!Z%JJ!(B!

,1*!355=3<!0(<<*0,;(5!(B!P+;,;91!3N+;0=<,=+3<!9,3,;9,;09.Z%!7(=+;5N!G8*+;03!;5!Z%I%S!

1*!6*90+;)*6!,1*!-;66<*!L*9,!Y39!,1*!N+*3,*9,!,+30M!(B!B*+,;<*!<356!(5!,1*!N<()*.eZ&!

O5!Z%%Z!3!'(?3<!@(88;99;(5!239!9*,!=>!,(!9,=6?!,1*!3N+;0=<,=+3<!6*>+*99;(5!;5!

D5N<356!356!L3<*9.!'*0(N5;4;5N!,1*!;8>(+,350*!(B!G8*+;035!;8>(+,9!39!(5*!(B!

,1*!03=9*9S!;,!013+N*6!(5*!(B!;,9!8*8)*+9S!U(15!@<3?S!,(!N3,1*+!*:;6*50*!;5!,1*!

^5;,*6!/,3,*9!356!+*>(+,!1;9!a56;5N9.!E;9!+*>(+,!<3=6*6!,1*!2(+M;5N9!(B!G8*+;-

035!21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5!356!G8*+;035!+3;<S!03<<;5N!;,!3,!(5*!>(;5,!Y8;+30=<(=9.e"#!

k,1*+!D=+(>*359!B+(8!W+350*S!A*+835?S!G=9,+;3HE=5N3+?S!356!'=99;3!21(!038*!

,(!9,=6?!,1*!G8*+;035!9?9,*8!3N+**6."Z

O5!W+350*!,1*!-;5;9,+?!(B!GN+;0=<,=+*Q9!;5,*+*9,!+(9*!,(!5*2!1*;N1,9!;5!Z%%&S!

21*5!,1*!3N+;0=<,=+3<!6;9><3?9!3,!,1*!̂ 5;:*+93<!DT>(9;,;(5!;5![3+;9!03=9*6!39,(5-

;918*5,!3,!,1*!>+(6;N;(=9!3N+3+;35!03>30;,;*9!(B!,1*!^5;,*6!/,3,*9!356!(,1*+!C*2!

L(+<6!0(=5,;*9.!O5!35!Z%&Z!+*>(+,S!,1*!*5:;3)<*!*Ba0;*50?!(B!,1*!G8*+;035!9?9-

,*8!239!6*90+;)*6!;5!9(8*!6*,3;<.!O5!,1*!21*3,!,+36*!N((6!?;*<69!(5!*5(+8(=9!

30+*3N*9S!01*3>!,+359>(+,S!,1*!G8*+;035!9?9,*8!(B!N+3;5!*<*:3,(+9d3<<!2(+M*6!

13+8(5;(=9<?!<;M*!3!N;N35,;0S!2*<<H6*9;N5*6!8301;5*.!71*!+3;<!9?9,*8!3<(5*!239!

39!1=N*!39!,1*!0(=5,+?S!356!;,9!N+(2,1!239!+*83+M3)<*.!L;,1!"I&S###!M;<(8*,*+9!

9;*0<*!*5!W+350*.!D993;!6Q;5,*+>+*,3,;(5!*0(5(8;g=*!*,!9(0;3<*Se!1 2' * !"#"$%8' *"ZS!5(.!h!FZ&$#KR!

I"ZHIIf.!W(+!3!0(8>3+3,;:*!>*+9>*0,;:*S!9**!_(5;5NS!The failure of agrarian capitalism; 7+30?S!

Government and agriculture in Western Europe, 1880-1988; 356!kQ'(=+M*S!Y71*!D=+(>*35!A+3;5!

O5:39;(5S!Z%$#HZ&Zf.e

Z$!-(+,(5!'(,19,*;5S!YG8*+;03!;5!,1*!O5,*+53,;(53<!';:3<+?!B(+!,1*!P+;,;91!L1*3,!-3+M*,S!Z%J#H

Z&ZhSe!The Mississippi Valley Historical Review, m(<.!h$.f!FZ&J#KR!h#ZHhZ%.!E3++?!U.!@3+835S!

YD5N<;91!m;*29!(B!-;66<*!L*9,*+5!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%I#HZ%$#Se!Agricultural History %.Z!FZ&fhKR!fHZ&.

Z%!A.D.!W=99*<S!Y71*!@(<<*0,;(5!(B!GN+;0=<,=+3<!/,3,;9,;09!;5!A+*3,!P+;,3;5R!O,9!k+;N;5!356!

D:(<=,;(5!Agricultural History, m(<.!Z%.hFZ&hhKR!ZJZHZJ$S!>.!ZJ".

Z&!q=(,*6!;5!E3++?!U.!@3+835S!YD5N<;91!m;*29!(B!-;66<*!L*9,*+5!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%I#HZ%$#Se!

Agricultural History, m(<.!%.Z!FZ&fhKR!fHZ&`!g=(,3,;(5S!>.!h.

"#!/=>><*8*5,3+?!+*>(+,!)?!-+.!U(15!@<3?S!U=5.S!(5!G8*+;035!GN+;0=<,=+*S!91(2;5N!;,9!;5i=*50*!(5!

,13,!(B!A+*3,!P+;,3;5S!>>.!$#IH$Z%S!'(?3<!@(88;99;(5!(5!GN+;0=<,=+*.!'*>(+,9!(B!,1*!G99;9,35,!

@(88;99;(5*+9.!/(=,1*+5!6;9,+;0,!(B!D5N<356.!'*>(+,!)?!-+.!\;,,<*!(5!V*:(5S!@(+523<<S!V(+9*,!

356!/(8*+9*,S!F2;,1!9=883+?!(B!>+*:;(=9!+*>(+,9.KS!Z%%".!

"Z!'(,19,*;5S!YG8*+;03!356!,1*!P+;,;91!L1*3,!-3+M*,Se!>>.hZ"HZJ.


"ZJ!

;5!(>*+3,;(5!;5!Z%&#S!Y,1*!^5;,*6!/,3,*9!139!8(+*!,135!Z&!,;8*9!39!8=01!+3;<23?!

<;5*! ,(63?!39! ;,!6;6!f#!?*3+9!3N(.e""!O5!Z%&#S! ,1*!aN=+*9! B(+! ,1*!8=01!983<<*+!

0(=5,+;*9!(B!W+350*!356!A+*3,!P+;,3;5!2*+*!3)(=,!f%S###!M;<(8*,*+9!356!f#S###!

M;<(8*,*+9S!+*9>*0,;:*<?."f

Railways and Rural Transport

P?!Z%&#S!+3;<23?!*T>359;(5!;5!D5N<356!356!L3<*9!136!>+*0*6*6!B=+,1*+!,135!

U*BB*+;*9!239!2;<<;5N!,(!368;,.!G,!,1*!*56!(B!,13,!,1*!Z%%#9!,1*+*!2*+*!B*2!+=+3<!

+*N;9,+3,;(5!6;9,+;0,9d3!83+M*,!,(25!356!9=++(=56;5N!>3+;91*9d,13,!<30M*6!3!

9,3,;(5!356! 9(8*!0(55*0,;(5S!1(2*:*+! ;56;+*0,S!2;,1! ,1*!53,;(53<! 9?9,*8.! O5-

6**6S!+3;<!9*+:;0*!)*N35!,(!+*301!,1*!0(=5,+?9;6*!;5!,1*!<3,*<%I#9!356!Z%J#9S!"#!

?*3+9!)*B(+*!U*BB*+;*9!2+(,*!Y/,*38!(5!@(=5,+?!'(369.e!̂ 9;5N!,1*!1;9,(+;03<!AO/!

(5!P+;,;91!+3;<23?9!356!>(>=<3,;(5!?;*<69!3!8(+*!>+*0;9*!6*90+;>,;(5!;5!N+3>1;03<!

356!03+,(N+3>1;03<!6;9><3?9.!GB,*+!03<0=<3,;5N!,1*!6;9,350*!FM;<(8*,*+9K!B+(8!,1*!

0*5,*+!(B!*301!>3+;91!,(!,1*!5*3+*9,!+3;<23?!9,3,;(5!3,!3!N;:*5!63,*S!3!8*35!(B!,1*!

>3+;91!90(+*9!;9!03<0=<3,*6!B(+!*301!(B!Jff!+*N;9,+3,;(5!6;9,+;0,9`!,1*5!,1*!6;9,+;0,!

8*359!B(+!*301!63,*!3+*!0<399;a*6!)?!6;BB*+*5,!<*:*<9!(B!6;9,+;0,!>(>=<3,;(5!6*5-

9;,?!356!>+*9*5,*6!;5!3!W;N=+*!ZG.!71*!aN=+*!91(29!,1*!>3,,*+5!(B!;50+*39;5N!30-

0*99;);<;,?!(:*+!,1*!6*036*9R!*T0*>,!;5!,1*!<*39,!>(>=<3,*6!6;9,+;0,9S!>+(T;8;,?!,(!3!

+3;<23?!9,3,;(5!0(5,;5=*6!,(!;50+*39*!=5,;<!,1*!,=+5!(B!,1*!"#,1!0*5,=+?S!*9>*0;3<<?!

9(!B(+!0(88=5;,;*9!(B!8(6*9,!>(>=<3,;(5!6*59;,?!F"I!,(!Z##!>*+9(59!>*+!9g=3+*!

M;<(8*,*+K.!O5,*+*9,;5N<?S!U*BB*+;*9!,((M!,1;9!1;9,(+?!9(!8=01!B(+!N+35,*6!,13,!1*!

;N5(+*6!;,!;5!1;9!2+;,;5N9.

O5!1;9!399*998*5,!(B!,1*!P+;,;91!9?9,*8S!3!83X(+!6*a0;*50?!239!,1*!<(5N!6;9-

,350*!)*,2**5!,1*!B3+8*+Q9!a*<6!356!,1*!+3;<23?!9,3,;(5S!0;,;5N!3!X(=+5*?!(B!=>!

,(!Z#!8;<*9!39!5(,!=50(88(5!)=,!+*N+*,,3)<?!;50(5:*5;*5,!356!(=,63,*6.!G8(5N!

,1*! B3+8*+9! 1*! 0(59=<,*6S! ,1*+*!2*+*S! 5(! 6(=),S! 3! N((6<?! 5=8)*+!21(! 0(8-

><3;5*6!(B! ,1;9! ;50(5:*5;*50*.!/,;<<S! 136!1*! ,+3:*<<*6! ,1+(=N1!W+*501!:;<<3N*9!

6=+;5N!,1*!938*!>*+;(6S!1*!2(=<6!<*3+5!,13,! ,1*!0(8><3;5,9!(B!P+;,;91!B3+8*+9!

2*+*!983<<!>(,3,(*9!;56**6.!O5!B30,S!3!0(8>3+3,;:*!9,=6?!(B!P+;,;91!356!W+*501!

+3;<! 5*,2(+M9! 9=NN*9,9! 3!8(+*! >(9;,;:*! 9,(+?! (B! +=+3<! +3;<23?! 6*:*<(>8*5,! ;5!

D5N<356!356!L3<*9!,135!U*BB*+;*9!2(=<6!13:*!=9!)*<;*:*.!F/**!W;N=+*!OPK

O5!+3;<23?!6*:*<(>8*5,!W+350*!239!3!6*036*!(+!8(+*!)*1;56!P+;,3;5.!G!0(=5-

,?!B(=+!,;8*9!<3+N*+!,135!D5N<356!356!L3<*9S!W+350*!136!3!N((6!6*3<!8(+*!,*++;-

,(+?!(:*+!21;01!,(!<3?!6(25!+3;<9S!,(!0(55*0,!83X(+!0;,;*9!356!>(+,9S!356!,(!+*301!

""!!-;5;9,+?!(B!GN+;0=<,=+*S!DT>(9;,;(5!=5;:*+9*<<*S![3+;9S!Z%%&.!'3>>(+,9!6=!X=+?!;5,*+53,;(53<.!

A+(=>*!mOOO.!GN+;0=<,=+*S!:;,;0=<,=+*!*,!>;90;0=<,=+*!F[3+;9R!O8>+;8*+;*!53,;(53<*S!Z%&"K!R!&&.!

71*!aN=+*!(5!G8*+;035!+3;<+(369!;5!Z%&#!9**89!,(!)*!,1*!aN=+*!B(+!Z%%IS!300(+6;5N!,(!3!<3,*+!

0(8>;<3,;(5!)?!,1*!^./.!>=)<;03,;(5.!/**!G99(0;3,;(5!(B!G8*+;035!'3;<+(369S!356!P=+*3=!(B!

'3;<23?!D0(5(8;09S!Comparative Railway Statistics of the United States, the United Kingdom,

France and Germany for 1900 and 1909 FL391;5N,(5S!V.@S!Z&ZZK.

"f!!W;N=+*9!B(+!P+;,3;5!356!W+350*!R!U30M!/;88(59S!The Railway in England and Wales, 1830-1914

F\*;0*9,*+R!\*;0*9,*+!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99!S!Z&$%KS!G>>*56;T!"`!-;5;9,*+*!6*9!7+3:3=T![=)<;0S!;5+5%&5%8' *

centrale des chemins de ferres frangais au 31 decembre 1932.

Robert M. Schwartz

!"Z$

W;N=+*!Z!H!G:*+3N*!300*99;);<;,?!(B!+3;<!,+359>(+,!;5!P+;,3;5!356!W+350*S!Z%I#!,(!Z&f&S

G.!A+*3,!P+;,3;5`!P.!W+350*

I.I

I

h.I

h

f.I

f

".I

"

Z.I

ZZ%I#! Z%J#! Z%$#! Z%%#! Z%&#! Z&##! Z&Z#! Z&"#

G.!G:*+3N*!300*99;);<;,?!;5!,1*!+*N;9,+3,;(5!6;9,+;0,9!(B!D5N<356!356!L3<*9.

V;9,350*!B+(8!V;9,+;0,!@*5,*+!,(!C*3+*9,!/,3,;(5S!Z%I#HZ&"#)?!V;9,+;0,!

[(>=<3,;(5!V*59;,?

/(=+0*9R![3+;91!)(=563+;*9!356!399(0;3,*6!>(>=<3,;(5!63,3!B+(8!O35!A+*N(+?`!+3;<!<;5*9!356!9,3,;(59!,3M*5!B+(8!-.E.!@())S!The Railways of Great Britain, a Historical Atlas.!"!:(<9.!F/1*>>*+,(5R!O35!G<<35S!"##fKS!39!6;N;,;4*6!=56*+!,1*!6;+*0,;(5!(B!U(+6;!-3+,r!E*55*)*+NS!^5;:*+9;,?!(B!\<*;63S!/>3;5.

_;<(8

*,*+

9

V*036*

fI

f#

"I

"#

ZI

Z#

I

#

Z%J#! Z%$#! Z%%#! Z%&#! Z&##! Z&Z#! Z&"#! Z&f#

P.!G:*+3N*!300*99;);<;,?!(B!+3;<!,+359>(+,!;5!,1*!035,(59!(B!W+350*S!Z%J#!,(!

Z&f#.

V;9,350*!B+(8!035,(5!0*5,*+!,(!5*3+*9,!9,3,;(5S!Z%J#!,(!Z&f#S!)?!035,(53<!

>(>=<3,;(5!6*59;,?>(>=<3,;(5!6*59;,?

/(=+0*9R![(>=<3,;(5!aN=+*9!B+(8!,1*!<',, 5%#*. &*,"%&*. *,+*1=)'>,%8' *?(+#@+%& A*Z%%$R!"#hHh%`!+3;<!<;5*9!356!+3;<23?!9,3,;(59!6;N;,;4*6!B+(8!Carte des chemins de fer ?(+#@+%&!S!/C@WS!Z&hhS!P;)<;(,1sg=*!C3,;(53<*!6*!W+350*S!A*!PP!fJ%.

_;<(8

*,*+

9

V*036*


"Z%!

0(=5,+?! ,(259!356! ,1*!9(8*!f#S###! +=+3<!0(88=5*9! ;5!21;01! ,1*!)=<M!(B! ;,9!

>(>=<3,;(5!9,;<<!<;:*6!356!2(+M*6.!@(8>3+*6!,(!L3<*9!356!,1*!D5N<;91![*55;5*9S!

,1*!=><3569!356!8(=5,3;59!(B!,1*!W+*501!9(=,1S!,1*![?+*5**9S!356!,1*!G<>9!>+*-

9*5,*6!8(+*!B(+8;63)<*!,(>(N+3>1;03<!356!a5350;3<!013<<*5N*9.!-(+*(:*+S!,1*!

W+*501!>30*!(B!;56=9,+;3<;43,;(5!239!+*<3,;:*<?!9<(2S!3N+;0=<,=+3<!>+(6=0,;:;,?!;5!

,2(!,1;+69!(B!,1*!0(=5,+?!239!<(2!)?!P+;,;91!9,3563+69S!356!,1*!53,;(5Q9!6*B*3,!

)?![+=99;3!;5!,1*!23+!(B!Z%$#H$Z!136!)**5!3!0(9,<?!1=8;<;3,;(5!,13,!9;>1(5*6!(BB!

,3T!+*:*5=*9!,(!>3?!,1*!5*2!A*+835!D8>;+*!9=)9,35,;3<!+*>3+3,;(59.

O5!Z%$%S!;5!,1*!3B,*+83,1!(B!6*B*3,!356!,1*!W+*501!9,3,*Q9!6*9;+*!,(!03,01!=>!

2;,1!G8*+;035!356!P+;,3;5S! ,1*!N(:*+58*5,!(B! ,1*!5*2!71;+6!'*>=)<;0S!8=01!

39!U*BB*+;*9!+*>(+,*6!356!>+3;9*6S!<3=501*6!3!1=N*!>+(X*0,!,(!*T>356!,1*!W+*501!

+3;<!9?9,*8!;5,(!,1*!0(=5,+?9;6*.!C38*6!3B,*+!;,9!01;*B!>+(>(5*5,S!,1*!-;5;9,*+!

(B![=)<;0!L(+M9S!@13+<*9!W+*?0;5*,S!,1*!>+(N+38S!;5!366;,;(5!,(!,1*!*T>359;(5!

(B!83;5!<;5*9S!;50<=6*6!9,3,*!9=)9;6;*9!,(!>+(8(,*!,1*!N+(2,1!(B!9*0(563+?!<;5*9!

6*9;N5*6!,(!9*+:*!+=+3<!356!3N+3+;35!0(88=5;,;*9."h!G!6*036*!<3,*+S!;5!,1*!Z%&#9S!

,1*!>+(X*0,*6!*T>359;(5!(B!Y<;5*9!(B!<(03<!;5,*+*9,e!N(,!=56*+23?S!356!,1*!>30*!

(B!0(59,+=0,;(5!g=;0M*5*6S!0=<8;53,;5N!;5!,1*!Z&"#9.!'3;<23?!300*99;);<;,?!;5!,1*!

+*<3,;:*<?!:39,!,*++;,(+?!(B!+=+3<!W+350*!<3NN*6S!300(+6;5N<?S!)*1;56!P+;,3;5S!)=,!

,1*!N3>!0(5,;5=*6!,(!53++(2!3B,*+!Z%$#.!P?!Z&##!:;<<3N*9!;5!8(6*+3,*<?!>(>=-

<3,*6!035,(59!F)*,2**5!"I!356!I#!>*+9(59!>*+!9g=3+*!M;<(8*,*+K!2*+*!(5!3:*+3N*!

2;,1;5!a:*!M;<(8*,*+9!(B!,1*!5*3+*9,!+3;<23?!9,3,;(5.!F/**!W;N=+*!OP.K

Proximity to Railway Stations in rural Britain and France: Change over

time and space

7=+5;5N!,(!9>3,;3<!353<?9;9S!a+9,!(B!P+;,3;5!356!,1*5!(B!W+350*S!2*!=9*!,1*!

AO/!63,3!(5!+3;<23?9!356!>3+;91*9!,(!83>!,1*!6;9,350*!B+(8!>3+;91!0*5,*+9!,(!,1*!

5*3+*9,!9,3,;(59!3,!,1*!*56!>(;5,9!(B!,1+**!6;BB*+*5,!6*036*9R!,1*!Z%I#9S!,1*!Z%%#9S!

"h!!W+350(;9!@3+(5S!Histoire des chemins defer en France, 1740-1883 F[3+;9R!W3?3+6S!Z&&$KS!%JS!fJZH$#.!

j39=(!A(5X(S!Y\*!n[<35!W+*?0;5*,QS!Z%$%HZ%%"R!=5!39>*0,!6*!<3!nA+356*!V*>+*99;(5Q!*0(5(8;g=*!*5!

W+350*Se!1 2' *4%&5"(%8' *"h%FZ&$"K!R!h&H%J.!

73)<*!Z.!71*!A+(2,1!(B!,1*!83;5!356!9*0(563+?!+3;<!5*,2(+M9!;5!W+350*S!Z%$#!,(!Z&f#

j*3+9 Z%$# Z%%# Z%&# Z&## Z&Z# Z&Z" Z&"% Z&f#

-3;5!<;5*9!FM8K Z$S$#$ "IS$I& fhS%$% f%S"JZ h#S"Zh h#SJ&J CG h"Sh##

\(03<!<;5*9!FM8K "&f "SZ%$ fSIZI $SJZ" ZISfh$ Z$SJIf "#S"&Z "#S"#"

/(=+0*9R!-;5;9,s+*!6*9!7+3:3=T![=)<;0S!;5+5%&5%8' *! #5(+, *. &*!4 $%#&*. *? (( &*?(+#@+%&*+'*BC*.=! $>( *CDBE9*France, voies ferrées d’intérêt local, tramways, services subventionnés d’automobiles!F[3+;9R!O8>+;8*+;*!C3,;(53<*S!Z&fIS!>.!I.K`!'(N*,![+;0*S!The Modernization of Rural France!F\(56(5R!E=,01;59(5S!Z&%fKS!>!"I!`!G99(0;3,;(5!(B!G8*+;035!'3;<+(369S!356!P=+*3=!(B!'3;<23?!D0(5(8;09S!Comparative Railway Statistics of the United States, the United Kingdom, France and Germany for 1900 and 1909!FL391;5N,(5S!V.@S!Z&ZZK.

Robert M. Schwartz

!"Z&

356!,1*!Z&##9."I!G9!91(25!;5!W;N=+*!"S!P+;,;91!B3+8*+9!136!<*99!+*39(5!,(!0(8-

><3;5!;5!,1*!Z%%#9!,135!)*B(+*S!356!)?!,1*!a+9,!6*036*!(B!,1*!,2*5,;*,1!0*5,=+?S!

*:*5!<*99!9(S!B(+!)?!,1*5!,1*+*!2*+*!(5<?!3!B*2!0<=9,*+9!(B!>3+;91*9!21*+*!,1*!

5*3+*9,!9,3,;(5!239!more ,135!-2 *F%,"$ 5 (&*Ff.Z!8;<*9K!323?!B+(8!,1*!>3+;91!

0*5,*+d3!N((6!6*3<!0<(9*+!,135!,1*!Z#!8;<*!;9(<3,;(5!>(;5,!8*5,;(5*6!)?!U*BB*+-

;*9.!O5!(,1*+!2(+69S!,1*!83X(+;,?!(B!>3+;91*9!;5!Z&##!(+!*3+<;*+!B*<<!within 213,!

(5*! B3+8*+! ,1(=N1,! 3!83T;8=8!6;9,350*R!)*?(56! ,1+**!8;<*9! B+(8!3! 9,3,;(5S!

1*!+*83+M*6S!;9!Y3N+;0=<,=+3<!6*3,1.e"J!71*!1;N1!6*N+**!(B!300*99;);<;,?!*T;9,*6!

3<9(! ;5!V*+)?91;+*!356! ,1*!8;6<3569!356! ;5! ,1*! 9(=,1!N*5*+3<<?.!C(,! 9=+>+;9-

;5N<?S!;5!9>3+9*<?!>(>=<3,*6!+*N;(59!300*99;);<;,?!239!8(+*!(B!3!>+()<*8.!O5!,1*!

>*+;>1*+;*9! (B! ,1*! 0(=5,+?d;5!V*5);N191;+*! 356! @3+6;N3591;+*! FL3<*9KS! ,1*!

9(=,12*9,*+5!0(=5,;*9!(B!V(+9*,S!V*:(5S!356!@(+523<<S!356!,1*!5(+,1*+5!0(=5,?!

(B!C(+,1=8)*+<356d,1*+*!2*+*!5=8*+(=9!>3+;91*9!21*+*!0(5:*5;*5,!300*99!,(!

+3;<!9,3,;(59!239!;5!6(=),.!G56!?*,S!*:*5!;5!L3<*9!356!,1*!9(=,12*9,S!9=01!;50(5-

:*5;*50*!39!*T;9,*6!;5!Z%I#!136!)**5!8=01!+*6=0*6!)?!,1*!*:*!(B!,1*!A+*3,!L3+.

"I!!71*!AO/!63,3)39*9!2*!=9*6!B(+!,1;9!3+,;0<*!3+*!6*90+;)*6!;5!5(,*!Z.

"J!!';6*+!E3NN3+6S!Rural England, \(56(5S!Z&""!SZS!>.!IZZS!0;,*6!)?!U.!7.!@(>>(0MS!YGN+;0=<,=+3<!

@135N*9!;5!,1*!@1;<,*+59!Z%$IHZ&##Se!Agricultural History Review Z#!FZ&JZKS!>.!ZJ.

W;N=+*!"!H![+(T;8;,?!(B!+3;<23?!9,3,;(59!;5!,1*!>3+;91*9!(B!D5N<356!356!L3<*9S

Z%I#9!,(!,1*!Z&##9.

@(=5,?!)(=563+;*9

-(+*!,135!I!_8!B+(8!9,3,;(5

Z%I#9 Z%%#9

Ck'7E^-PD'\GCV

VDCPOAE/EO'D

@G'VOAGC/EO'D

VDmkC

@k'CLG\\Vk'/D7 LO\7/EO'D

VD'Pj/EO'D

/(=+0*R!ibid.


""#!

[+(T;8;,?!,(!3!9,3,;(5S!(B!0(=+9*S!239!(5<?!(5*!39>*0,!(B!0(5:*5;*5,!91;>>;5N!

356!>399*5N*+!,+3:*<.![((+!9,3,;(5!B30;<;,;*9S!1;N1!91;>>;5N!+3,*9!356!,;0M*,!>+;0*9S!

;5B+*g=*5,!,+3;59S!6*<3?9S!;5*Ba0;*5,!0(55*0,;(59!B+(8!)+3501!,(!,+=5M!<;5*9d3<<!

>+(6=0*6!1;N1*+!0(9,9!356!8(+*!3NN+3:3,;(5!B(+!,1*!B3+8*+.!O5!,1;9!+*9>*0,S!U*B-

B*+;*9!239!(5!,1*!8(5*?.!P=,!;5!,*+89!(B!6;9,350*S!,1*!300*99;);<;,?!(B!+=+3<!+3;<!

9*+:;0*!136!;8>+(:*6!9=)9,35,;3<<?!9;50*!,1*!<3,*!Z%J#9!21*5!U*BB*+;*9Q!03+**+!39!

35!3N+;0=<,=+3<!X(=+53<;9,!239!)*N;55;5N.

O5!W+350*!;8>+(:*8*5,!(B!,1;9!M;56!038*!<3,*+!356!3,!,1*!6;BB*+*5,!903<*!(B!

8=01!<3+N*+!,*++;,(+?.!O5!,1*!Z%J#9S!21*5!Y;+(5!+(369e!2*+*!+*301;5N!B=+,1*+!;5,(!

,1*!P+;,;91! 0(=5,+?9;6*! 356!(>*5;5N! +*8(,*!8;5;5N!356!3N+;0=<,=+3<!6;9,+;0,9S!

,1*!9(=56!(B!3!21;9,<;5N!<(0(8(,;:*!239!3<8(9,!=5M5(25!;5!+=+3<!W+350*.!71*!

83X(+!3+,*+;*9!(B!,1*!53,;(53<!9?9,*8!2*+*!;5!><30*S!)=,!,1*!8(6*+5;4;5N!)*5*a,9!

(B!+3;<!,+359>(+,!;5!3N+;0=<,=+3<!+*N;(59S!9(!30,;:*!;5!,1*!8;569!(B!:;9;(53+;*9!356!

N(:*+58*5,!><355*+9S!136!?*,!,(!83,*+;3<;4*!;5!8(9,!(B!,1*!0(=5,+?.!G9!91(25!;5!

W;N=+*!fS!,1*!9;,=3,;(5!136!0135N*6!B(+!,1*!)*,,*+!)?!,1*!Z%&#9.!71;+,?!?*3+9!<3,*+!

W;N=+*!f!H![+(T;8;,?!(B!+3;<23?!9,3,;(59!;5!,1*!0(88=5*9!(B!W+350*S!Z%J#9!,(!,1*!Z&"#9.!

'3;<23?9!356!GN+;0=<,=+3<!@135N*

V*>3+,8*5,!)(=563+;*9

@*5,*+!(B!@(88=5*!8(+*!,135I!_8!,(!5*3+*9,!9,3,;(5

/(=+0*R!ibid.; 13);,3,;(53<!0*5,*+9!(B!0(88=5*9!356!6*>3+,8*5,3<!)(=563+;*9!>+(:;6*6!)?!71(839!71*:*5;5S!V*>3+,8*5,!(B!A*(N+3>1?S!^5;:*+9;,?!(B!P=+N=56?.

Z%J#9 Z%&#9

@k7DHVQk'

Z&"#

Robert M. Schwartz

!""Z

;5!,1*!Z&"#9!,1*!3;89!(B!,1*!Z%$%!W+*?0;5*,!>+(N+38!(B!+3;<23?!*T>359;(5!038*!

,(!B+=;,;(5!356!,1*!9;4*!(B!,1*!83;5!356!9*0(563+?!5*,2(+M9!+*301*6!;,9!4*5;,1.!

71*+*!2*+*!+*N;(59!;5!,1*!9(=,1*+5!=><3569!356!8(=5,3;59!9,;<<!5(,!2*<<!9*+:*6S!

)=,!;5!,2(H,1;+69!(B!+=+3<!W+350*!;,!239!5(!8(+*!,135!3!13<B!63?Q9!23<M!,(!03,01!

3!,+3;5d<*99!,135!,13,!B(+!1(+9*H6+325!23N(59!356S!;5!,1*!Z&"#9S!*:*5!<*99!B(+!

0(8)=9,;(5H*5N;5*!3=,(8();<*9!356!,+=0M9.

A3=N;5N!,1*!)*5*a,9!(B!+=+3<!+3;<23?9!B(+!3N+;0=<,=+*!;9!3!8(+*!0(8><;03,*6!

,39M.! O5!P+;,3;5! 356!W+350*S! B3+8*+9!2*+*! 39! 0(5:;50*6! 39!239! U*BB*+;*9! ,13,!

,1*;+!;50+*39;5N!<(99*9!+*9=<,*6!B+(8!,1*!;5,*59;a*6!;5,*+53,;(53<!0(8>*,;,;(5!;5!

3N+;0=<,=+3<!>+(6=0,9.!W+(8!Z%J$!,(!Z%&"S!21*3,!30+*3N*!;5!,1*!^5;,*6!/,3,*9!*T-

>356*6!,1+**!B(<6S!21;<*!;5!,1*!21(<*!(B!,1*!^5;,*6!_;5N6(8!B+(8!Z%$"!,(!Z%&IS!

;,!6*0<;5*6!)?!8(+*!,135!13<B!;5!+*9>(59*!,(!,1*!B3<<;5N!>+;0*9S!03=9*6!83;5<?!

)?!G8*+;035! ;8>(+,9! ,13,! 3++;:*6! 6=,?HB+**! ;5! (>*5!83+M*,9.! @(8>3+3,;:*<?!

9>*3M;5NS!21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5!+*83;5*6!B3;+<?!9,3)<*! ;5!W+350*!356! ;50+*39*6! ;5!

A*+835?d,2(!0(=5,+;*9!;5!21;01!,3+;BB9!+*6=0*6!B(+*;N5!0(8>*,;,;(5S!39!91(25!

;5!73)<*!"."$

G9!,1*!>+(a,3);<;,?!(B!21*3,!0=<,;:3,;(5!6*0<;5*6S!P+;,;91!356!W+*501!0*+*3<!

B3+8*+9S!;5!+*N;(59!(B!9=;,3)<*!0<;83,*!356!*0(<(N;03<!0(56;,;(59S!<((M*6!;50+*39-

;5N<?!,(!03,,<*!+3;9;5N!356!63;+?!B3+8;5N!,(!8;5;8;4*!<(99*9S!,+359B(+8;5N!0+(>-

"$!71*!aN=+*9!91(=<6!)*!,3M*5!39!*9,;83,*9!of orders of magnitude. L(+M*6!=>!B(+!>+*9*5,3,;(5!3,!,1*!

O5,*+53,;(53<!O59,;,=,*!(B!/,3,;9,;09!;5!Z%&$!)?![.!A.!@+3;N;*S!1*36!(B!,1*!/,3,;9,;03<!/*+:;0*!(B!,1*!

P+;,;91!P(3+6!(B!GN+;0=<,=+*S!,1*!aN=+*9!+*i*0,!,1*!;8>+(:*8*5,!;5!*9,;83,*9!836*!3B,*+!Z%I#S!

21;01!(00=++*6!;5!9,*>!2;,1!N+(2;5N!N<()3<!0(8>*,;,;(5S!9,3,*!;5,*+*9,!;5!3N+;0=<,=+3<!>(<;0?!

356!213,!2*!5(2!03<<!B((6!9*0=+;,?S!8(+*!300=+3,*!356!0(8>+*1*59;:*!9,3,;9,;03<!0(<<*0,;(59!)?!

;56;:;6=3<!53,;(5!9,3,*9S!356!N+*3,*+!D=+(>*35!0(<<3)(+3,;(5!;5!0(<<*0,;5N!356!913+;5N!9,3,;9,;09!

:;3!,1*!O5,*+53,;(53<!O59,;,=,*!356!(,1*+!)(6;*9.!@+3;N;*Q9!*9,;83,*9!2*+*!300*>,*6!)?!,1*!W+*501!

-;5;9,+?!(B!GN+;0=<,=+*!39!9=Ba0;*5,<?!300=+3,*!,(!>=)<;91!,1*8!;5!;,9!+*>(+,!(5!,1*!9,3,*!(B!W+*501!

3N+;0=<,=+*!;5!Z%&$.

73)<*!".!L1*3,!30+*3N*!;5!,1*!^5;,*6!_;5N6(8S!W+350*S!A*+835?S!356!,1*!^5;,*6!/,3,*9S!

Z%J$!,(!Z%&I

j*3+9

@(=5,+? Z%J$ Z%$" Z%$$ Z%%" Z%%$ Z%&" Z%&I

^_ ZShI%S### ZSIf&S### ZSffJSI## ZS"&JS### &$"S### &fZSI## J#$SI##

W+350* $S"h&SI## JS&"ISI## JS&JJS### JS&JJS### JS&JJS### $S##JSI## $S##JSI##

^/ hS&&ZSI## %ShJhSI## Z#SJIZSI## ZIS#"ISI## ZIS""%S### ZISJffS### ZfS$$#S###

A*+835? ZS%%"SI## ZS&#fSI## ZS&%hSI## ZS&hhS###

/(=+0*R!W+350*S!-;5;9,s+*!6*!<QGN+;0=<,=+*.!;5+5%&5%8' *:7(%!", *. *,+*G(+#! 9*1=&',5+5&*7=#=(+'H*. *,3 #8'I5 *décennale de 1892.![3+;9R!O8>+;8*+;*!53,;(53<*S!Z%&$R!&hH&I.!/,3,;9,;09!B+(8!-3X(+![.A.!@+3;N;*S!V;+*0,(+!(B!/,3,;9,;09!(B!,1*!P(3+6!(B!GN+;0=<,=+*!FA+*3,!P+;,3;5KS!(+;N;53,;5N!B+(8!1;9!B+(8!@(88=5;03,;(5!B3;,*!3=!@(5N+s9!6*!<QO59,;,=,*!;5,*+53,;(53<*!6*!9,3,;9,;g=*!F/3;5,![*,*+9)=+NS!f!/*>,*8)*+S!Z%&$K.


"""!

<356!,(!>39,=+*!356!+*6=0;5N!,1*;+!23N*!);<<9!;5!,1*!>+(0*99.![+(a,9!B+(8!,1*9*!

30,;:;,;*9!2*+*!8(+*!<;M*<?!;5!,1*!(Ba5N!)*03=9*!(B!,1*!+;9;5N!6*8356!B(+!8*3,S!

)=,,*+S!356!B+*91!8;<M!;5!0;,;*9d3!6*8356!*5<3+N*6!B=+,1*+!39!2(+M*+9Q!+;9;5N!

+*3<!;50(8*9!>*+8;,,*6!,1*!0(59=8>,;(5!(B!1;N1*+!>+(,*;5!B((69."%!

Britain and Dorset County

G<,1(=N1!+3;<23?9S!9,*3891;>9S!356!,*<*N+3>1?!>(2*+*6!,1*!N<()3<;43,;(5!(B!

B((69,=BB9!356!,1*!;50+*39*6!0(8>*,;,;(5!,13,!9,+=0M!0*+*3<!B3+8*+9!>3+,;0=<3+<?!

13+6S!+3;<!,+359;,!239!5(5*,1*<*99!3!0+=0;3<!B30,(+!;5!,1*!*T>359;(5!356!;5,*59;-

a03,;(5!(B!<;:*9,(0M!356!63;+?!B3+8;5N.!W(+!63;+?!B3+8*+9!;5!(=,<?;5N!0(=5,;*9!

9=01! 39!L;<,91;+*S!V(+9*,S! 356!V*+)?91;+*S! +3;<! ,+359>(+,! >*+8;,,*6! ,1*! 91;>-

8*5,!(B! B+*91!8;<M! ,(!\(56(5S!\**69S!-3501*9,*+S! 356!(,1*+!0;,;*9.!/;8;<3+<?S!

03,,<*! B3+8*+9! ;5!(=,<?;5N!0(=5,;*9! 9,((6! ,(!)*5*a,!)*03=9*! ,1*?!0(=<6! B3,,*5!

,1*;+! 9,(0M!(5!9;,*!356! ,1*5!91;>! ,1*!35;83<9! ,(!83+M*,!)?! ,+3;5S!3:(;6;5N! ,1*!

,+36;,;(53<!356!<*99!>+(a,3)<*!>+30,;0*!9*56;5N!9,(+*!03,,<*!(5!B((,!,(!N+34*+9!;5!

B3,,*5;5N!+*N;(59!(+!,(!(25*+9!(B!B**6<(,9.!W(=+!L*<91!0(=5,;*9!9(!3BB*0,*6!2*+*!

G5N<*9*?S!V*5);N191;+*S!W<;5,91;+*S!356![*8)+(M*91;+*."&!/;8;<3+!>3,,*+59!1*<6!

,+=*!B(+!W+350*.f#

OB!+3;<23?9!1*<>*6!P+;,;91!356!W+*501!B3+8*+9!363>,!,1*89*<:*9!,(!6;Ba0=<,!

0;+0=89,350*9!6=+;5N!,1*!GN+3+;35!V*>+*99;(5!(B!,1*!Z%%#9!356!Z%&#9S!,1*5!3!

+*:;*2!(B!9>*0;a0!*:;6*50*!91(=<6!1*<>!0(5a+8!(+!+*a5*!,1*!>+(>(9;,;(5.!/*<*0,-

;5N!,2(!039*9!B+(8!(=+!*T;9,;5N!63,3S!2*!,3M*!=>!,1*!@(=5,?!(B!V(+9*,!;5!D5N<356S!

356!,1*!V*>3+,8*5,!(B!@(,*H6Qk+!;5!W+350*.fZ!O5!V(+9*,!2*!=9*!AO/!63,3!3,!the

parish level B+(8!,1*!+*,=+59!(B!,1*!3N+;0=<,=+3<!0*59=9!;5!Z%$Z!356!Z&#Z!,(!83>!

,1*!6*59;,?!(B!0*+*3<!>+(6=0,;(5!356!03,,<*!3,!,1*9*!,2(!63,*9d,1*!a+9,!)*B(+*!

,1*!3N+3+;35!0+;9;9S!,1*!9*0(56S!3B,*+!;,9!3)3,*8*5,.!O5!)(,1!039*9S!,1*!6*0<;5*!(B!

"%![.!U.!G,M;59S!Y71*!A+(2,1!(B!\(56(5Q9!'3;<23?!-;<M!7+36*S!0.!Z%hIHZ&ZhSe!The Journal of

Transport History hS!5(.!h!FZ&$%KR!"#%H"J.!V.!73?<(+S!Y\(56(5Q9!-;<M!/=>><?S!Z%I#HZ&##R!G!

'*;5,*+>+*,3,;(5Se!Agricultural History hIFZ&$ZKR!ffHf%`!k<;:;*+!W35;03S!YV=!<3;,!>(=+!<3!03>;,3<*.!

\3!>+(6=0,;(5!<3;,;*+*!3=,(=+6*![3+;9!FZ$##HZ&ZhKSe!;5!:!5 '(&* 5* &)+! &*. *J , 2+7 *K/L00 M//0 *

siecle). Evolution, structuration, specialisation., *6.![1;<;>>*`!-(+;0*3=!-36*<;5*S!U*35H-3+0S!

<%>,%"54 8' *.3N%&5"%( *1'(+, *F'*55*9R![+*99*9!^5;:*+9;,3;+*9!6*!'*55*9S!"##JK`!';013+6![*++*5S!

The meat trade in Britain, 1840-1914, /,=6;*9!;5!*0(5(8;0!1;9,(+?!F\(56(5!`!P(9,(5R!'(=,<*6N*!356!

_*N35![3=<S!Z&$%K.

"&!'()*+,!-.!/0123+,4`!O35!A+*N(+?S!356!U(+6;!-3+,;HE*55*)=+NS!YE;9,(+?!356!AO/R!'3;<23?9S!

[(>=<3,;(5!@135N*S!356!GN+;0=<,=+3<!V*:*<(>8*5,!;5!<3,*!5;5*,**5,1!0*5,=+?!L3<*9Se!;5!

Geography and the Humanities, *6.!V(=N<39!';013+69(5!FL391;5N,(5S!V@R!G99(0;3,;(5!(B!

G8*+;035!A*(N+3>1*+9S!"#Z#K.

f#!W(+!3!B=<<*+!6;90=99;(5S!9**!8?!Y'3;<!7+359>(+,S!GN+3+;35!@+;9;9S!356!,1*!'*9,+=0,=+;5N!(B!

GN+;0=<,=+*R!"fhHf$`!';013+6![*++*5S!Y-3+M*,;5N!(B!GN+;0=<,=+3<![+(6=0,9Se!;5!The Agrarian

History of England and Wales. Volume VII1850-1914, *6.!D.!U.!7.!@(<<;59!F@38)+;6N*R!@38)+;6N*!

^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!"###KS!"IhHII`!V3:;6!7=+5(0MS!An historical geography of railways in Great

Britain and Ireland), "IhHII.

fZ!G<,1(=N1!*T38;5;5N!L;<,91;+*!2(=<6!,3M*!=9!,(!U*BB*+;*9Q!)30M!?3+6S!,1*!63,3!5**6*6!B(+!,13,!0(=5,?!

13:*!5(,!?*,!)**5!366*6!,(!(=+!63,3)39*.

Robert M. Schwartz

!""f

21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5!9,3569!(=,!0<*3+<?.!71*!;5,*59;a03,;(5!(B!63;+?!356!)**BH03,,<*!

B3+8;5NS!1(2*:*+S!;9!<*99!>+(5(=50*6!,135!8;N1,!)*!*T>*0,*6!21*5!,1*!+*,=+59!

B(+! ,1(9*! ,2(!63,*9! 3+*!=9*6.!C(5*,1*<*99S! ,1*!6*0<;5*! ;5!21*3,! B3+8;5N!239!

6+383,;0.!O5!,1*!>3+;91*9!(B!0*5,+3<!356!=><356!V(+9*,S!21*3,!30+*3N*!*9,;83,*6!

;5!Z%$Z!136!B3<<*5!)?!(5*!13<B!(+!8(+*!;5!Z&#ZS!2*<<!;5!<;5*!2;,1!,1*!53,;(53<!

3:*+3N*.!O5!,1*!938*!>*+;(6S!,1*!6*59;,?!(B!)**B!356!63;+?!03,,<*!+*83;5*6!9,3)<*!

(:*+3<<!356!;50+*39*6!;5!,2(!0<=9,*+9!(B!>3+;91*9!5(,*6!(5!W;N=+*!h.

O5!V(+9*,S!2*!035!6;N!6**>*+!;5,(!,1*!6*0<;5*!(B!21*3,!N+(2;5N.!71*+*!3,!,1*!

>3+;91!<*:*<S!+*9=<,9!B+(8!3!N*(N+3>1;03<<?!2*;N1,*6!+*N+*99;(5!8(6*<!?;*<6!*9,;-

83,*9!(B!,1*!6*N+**!,(!21;01!0135N*!;5!21*3,!30+*3N*S!,1*!;56*>*56*5,!:3+;3)<*S!

3+*!*T><3;5*6!)?!,1*!;5,*+30,;5N!*BB*0,9!(B!,1*!8*35!*<*:3,;(5!(B!>3+;91!,*++3;5!

356!,1*!6;9,350*!B+(8!;,9!0*5,*+!F0*5,+(;6K! ,(! ,1*!0<(9*9,!+3;<23?!9,3,;(5.f"!71*!

f"!AL'!;9!3+N=3)<?!,1*!,((<!(B!01(;0*!1*+*!356!;5!(,1*+!9;,=3,;(59!21*5!,1*!+*<3,;(591;>9!=56*+!

;5:*9,;N3,;(5!3+*!<;M*<?!,(!:3+?!30+(99!3!9,=6?!3+*3S!39!239!,+=*!(B!21*3,!N+(2;5N!;5!V(+9*,.!

W;N=+*!h!H!@135N*9!;5!@3,,<*!'3;9;5N!356!L1*3,!W3+8;5NS!V(+9*,!@(=5,?S

Z%$Z!0(8>3+*6!,(!Z&#Z

@(29!;5!Z%$#

/(=+0*9R!C3,;(53<!G+01;:*9S!_*2S!-GW!J%S!-;5;9,+?!(B!GN+;0=<,=+*S!W;91*+;*9!356!W((6!356!>+*6*0*99(+9R!/,3,;9,;09!V;:;9;(59R![3+;91!/=883+;*9!(B!GN+;0=<,=+3<!'*,=+59S!V(+9*,!@(=5,?S!Z%$Z!356!Z&#Z`![3+;91!)(=563+;*9!>+(:;6*6!)?!O35!A+*N(+?S!^5;:*+9;,?!(B!\35039,*+.!

@(29!;5!Z&#Z

7(,3<!@(29

7@(29!]![3+Z##G

#!H!I

J!H!&

Z#!H!ZJ

Z$!H!"f

"h!H!I$

7(,3<!@*+*3<9

7@*+*3<9!]![3+Z##G

#!H!f

h!H!&

Z#!H!Zh

ZI!H!"Z

""!H!"f$!

@*+*3<9!;5!Z%$# @*+*3<9!;5!Z&#Z

#! I! Z#! T! "#


""h!

+*9=<,9!91(2!,13,!JI!>*+0*5,!(B!,1*!:3+;3,;(5!;5!21*3,!30+*3N*!(:*+!,1*!6*036*!

Z%%Z!,(!Z%&Z!035!)*!300(=5,*6!B(+!)?!+3;<!300*99;);<;,?!356!8*35!*<*:3,;(5.

71*!*BB*0,!(B!>+(T;83,*!+3;<!9*+:;0*!239!:3+;*6!356!0(8><*TS!B(+!;,!03++;*6!3!

negative (+!positive ;5i=*50*!(5!0135N*9!;5!21*3,!30+*3N*S!6*>*56;5N!=>(5!<(-

03,;(5!356!,1*!3:*+3N*!*<*:3,;(5!(B!,1*!<(03,;(5.!73M;5N!9,3,;(5!>+(T;8;,?!3<(5*S!

,1*!83;5!,*56*50?!239!B(+!21*3,!30+*3N*!,(!6*0<;5*!9<;N1,<?!39!,1*!6;9,350*!(B!

,1*!5*3+*9,!9,3,;(59!;50+*39*6.!P=,!21*5!X(;5*6!2;,1!,1*!*BB*0,!(B!,*++3;5!*<*:3-

,;(5S!,13,!83;5!,*56*50?!239!;5i*0,*6.!G9!91(25!;5!W;N=+*!IS!,1*!;5i=*50*!(B!

9,3,;(5!6;9,350*!239!5*N3,;:*!;5!,1*!3+*39!91(25!;5!N+3?!356!>(9;,;:*!;5!,1(9*!

91(25!)<30M.!W+(8!Z%%Z!,(!Z%&ZS!;5!=><356!3+*39S!21*+*!21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5!136!

)**5!*T,*59;:*S!21*3,!30+*3N*!,*56*6!,(!;50+*39*!(+!+*83;5!9,3)<*!;5!parishes

W;N=+*!I!H!/>3,;3<<?!:3+?;5N!+*<3,;(591;>!)*,2**5!+3;<H9,3,;(5!>+(T;8;,?!356!0135N*!;5!

21*3,!30+*3N*S!Z%%ZHZ%&ZS!2;,1!,*++3;5!*<*:3,;(5!)*<(2.

'3;<!9,3,;(5

V;9,350*!,(!9,3,;(5

'3;<!>+(T;8;,?!t!0135N*!

;5!21*3,!30+*3N*

5*N3,;:*!H#."ZI&J!H!#.######

>(9;,;:*!u#.#####Z!H!#.#""JI$

#! f.$I! $.I! T! ZI_;<(8*,*+9

7*++3;5

-*35!*<*:3,;(5!F8*,*+9K

$!H!JZ

J"!H!%"

%f!H!Z"#

Z"Z!H!"#I

Robert M. Schwartz

!""I

farther B+(8!9,3,;(59`! ;5! ,1*! <(2<3569S! ;5!0(5,+39,S!>3+;91*9!closer ,(!3!9,3,;(5!

91(2*6!35!;50+*39*!;5!30+*3N*!0(8>3+*6!,(!<(2<356!>3+;91*9!B3+,1*+!323?.!71*!

*:;6*5,!0(8><*T;,?!2*<<!+*8;569!=9!,13,!2*!3+*!6*3<;5N!2;,1!3!0(8><;03,*6!1;9-

,(+?!(B!91(+,!356!<(5N!,*+8!6*0;9;(59!)?!B3+8*+9!(B!,1*!>*+;(6!;5!,1*!B30*!(B!91;B,-

;5N!83+M*,9S!2*3,1*+S!356!<*39;5N!0(56;,;(59.!71;9!0(8><*T;,?!03<<9!B(+!B=+,1*+!

9,=6?!356! ,1*! ;50(+>(+3,;(5!(B!(,1*+! B30,(+9S! 9=01!39! ,+3:*<!6;9,350*!(+! ,+3:*<!

,;8*!3<(5N!+(369d39!(>>(9*6!,1*!9,+3;N1,H<;5*!@3+,*9;35!6;9,350*d5=8)*+9!(B!

03,,<*!356!(,1*+!0(8>*,;5N!3N+;0=<,=+3<!30,;:;,;*9!356!0+(>9S!,1*!:3+;*6!B3+8;5N!

*0(<(N;*9!(B!,1*!0(=5,?S!,1*!B+*;N1,H1356<;5N!03>30;,?!(B!9,3,;(59S!356!9(!B(+,1.ff

L13,!3)(=,!0135N*9!;5!<;:*9,(0Mo!/(8*213,!9=+>+;9;5N<?S!(=+!353<?9*9d=9-

;5N!(+6;53+?!<*39,H9g=3+*9!+*N+*99;(5S!AL'S!356!(,1*+!9>3,;3<!9,3,;9,;09dB(=56!

5(!9;N5;a035,!*BB*0,!(B!+3;<!300*99;);<;,?!(5!0135N*9!;5!,1*!9;4*!(B!03,,<*!1*3+69!

(:*+!,1+**!6*036*9!B+(8!Z%$Z!,(!Z%&Z.!71;9!9=NN*9,9d;5!M**>;5N!2;,1!,1*!>3,-

,*+59!6;9><3?*6! B(+! 0(29! ;5!W;N=+*!hd,13,! ,1*! *T>359;(5!(B! 03,,<*! +3;9;5N! ;5!

V(+9*,!%#5 #&%- .*+3,1*+!,135!9>+*36;5N!2;6*<?!(:*+!,1*!0(=5,?.!W=+,1*+S!,1;9!;5-

,*59;a03,;(5!239!6*,*+8;5*6!)?!B30,(+9!(,1*+!,135!+3;<!>+(T;8;,?!;5!,1*!Z%$#9!356!

Z%%#9.!OB!,1*!>3+;91!+*,=+59!B(+!,1(9*!?*3+9!136!6;9,;5N=;91*6!63;+?!0(29!B+(8!

)**B!03,,<*S!2*!2(=<6!<;M*<?!a56!35!*BB*0,!(B!+3;<!300*99;);<;,?!356!63;+?!B3+8-

;5N!)*03=9*!,1*!B+*91!8;<M!,+36*!6*>*56*6!=>(5!+3;<23?9!,(!N*,!,1*;+!>+(6=0,!,(!

83X(+!=+)35!83+M*,9.

France: The Department of the Cote d-Or

O5!W+350*S!,1*!@(,*H6Qk+!V*>3+,8*5,!>+*9*5,9!9,(+?!2;,1!9;8;<3+;,;*9!356!6;B-

B*+*50*9.!71*+*S!39!;5!W+350*!N*5*+3<<?S!,1*!,3+;BB9!(5!21*3,!;5,+(6=0*6!;5!Z%%f!

91;*<6*6!0*+*3<!B3+8;5N!B+(8!;5,*+53,;(53<!0(8>*,;,;(5S!N;:;5N!0*+*3<!B3+8*+9!

3!+*>+;*:*!5(,!*5X(?*6!)?!,1*;+!P+;,;91!0(=5,*+>3+,9.!7(!*T38;5*!,1;9S!2*!83>!

,1*!>*+,;5*5,!3,,+;)=,*9R!>*+0*5,3N*!0135N*!;5!21*3,!0=<,;:3,;(5!)?!canton F0(8-

>3+3)<*!,(!,1*!P+;,;91!+*N;9,+3,;(5!6;9,+;0,K!356!,1*!6;9,350*!B+(8!,1*!0*5,*+9!(B!

communes F0(8>3+3)<*!,(!P+;,;91!>3+;91*9K.!O5!W;N=+*!J!,1*!N+3?!<;5*9!0(55*0,*6!

,(!9,3,;(5!5(6*9!+*>+*9*5,!,1*!0<(9*9,!6;9,350*!B+(8!35?!N;:*5!0(88=5*!,(!3!9,3-

,;(5.!G9!B(+!21*3,!30+*3N*!356!03,,<*!6*59;,?S!3!9,+;0,!0(8>3+;9(5!2;,1!P+;,3;5!3,!

,1*!>3+;91]0(88=5*!<*:*<!;9!5(,!B*39;)<*!)*03=9*!,1*!63,3!5**6*6!B(+!,1*!0(8-

8=5*9!(B!@(,*!6Qk+!3+*!;50(8><*,*.!k=+!63,3!>*+,3;5!,(!,1*!5*T,!1;N1*+!W+*501!

368;5;9,+3,;:*!(B!,1*!035,(5!F0(8>3+3)<*!,(!3!P+;,;91!+*N;9,+3,;(5!6;9,+;0,K.

G0+(99!,1*!035,(59!(B!,1*!@(,*H6Qk+S!*T38;5;5N!,1*!>*+0*5,3N*!0135N*!;5!0*-

+*3<!>+(6=0,;(5!)*,2**5!Z%%Z!356!Z&#I!91(29!213,!(5*!2(=<6!*T>*0,.![+(,*0,*6!

)?! ,3+;BBS!21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5! +*83;5*6! B3;+<?! 9,3)<*! B+(8! ,1*!Z%%#9! ,(! ,1*!8;6H

Z%&#9S!;.*.S!*:*5!6=+;5N!,1*!N+*3,!B3<<!;5!21*3,!>+;0*9!;5,*+53,;(53<<?.!P?!Z&#IS!

1(2*:*+S!,1*!91;B,!B+(8!21*3,!,(!03,,<*!+3;9;5N!356!,(!(,1*+!=9*9!(B!3N+;0=<,=+3<!

<356!239!83+M*6!;5!3<<!ff!035,(59!(B!,1*!V*>3+,8*5,!*T0*>,!,1(9*!(B!V;X(5!356!

ff!W(+!(=+!W+*501!AO/S!71(839!71*:*5;5!139!+*0*5,<?!0+*3,*6!*9,;83,*9!(B!+*3<!,+3:*<!0(9,9!B+(8!*301!

0(88=5*!;5!W+350*!,(!;,9!5*3+*9,!9,3,;(5S!)=,!,1*?!2*+*!5(,!3:3;<3)<*!3,!,1*!,;8*!(B!2+;,;5N.


""J!

P*3=5*!21*+*!,1*!,2(!<3+N*9,!0;,;*9!(B!,1*!6*>3+,8*5,!21*+*!<(03,*6.!@*5,*+*6!

(5!,1*!0;,;*9!(B!V;X(5!356!P*3=5*S!,1*!,2(!035,(59!932!21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5!+;9*!

;5!,13,!6*036*.!F/**!W;N=+*!J.K!E(2*:*+S!)*?(56!,1*!V;X(5!+*N;(5!356!,1*!83X(+!

:;5*!N+(2;5N!6;9,+;0,9!+=55;5N!B+(8!V;X(5!,(!P*3=5*S!35!;50+*39*!;5!>39,=+*!356!

03,,<*!5=8)*+9!3,,*9,9!,(!,1*!*T>359;(5!356!;5,*59;a03,;(5!(B!<;:*9,(0M!B3+8;5N.!

F/**!W;N=+*!$.K

L1*5! ,1;9! ;5B(+83,;(5! ;9! 0(8);5*6!2;,1!63,3!(5! +3;<23?!300*99;);<;,?S! ,1*!

+*9=<,9!9=NN*9,!,13,!+3;<!9*+:;0*!>+(T;8;,?!239!(5*!B30,(+!,13,!;5i=*50*6!0135N*9!

;5!21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5S!5(,!;5!,1*!Z%%#9S!39!239!,+=*!;5!V(+9*,S!)=,!;5!,1*!Z%&#9.!

W;N=+*!J!H![*+0*5,!0135N*!;5!21*3,!0=<,;:3,;(5!F;5!1*0,3+*9K!)?!035,(5!;5!,1*!V*>3+,8*5,!(B!

@v,*H6Qk+S!Z%&"HZ&#IS!356!>+(T;8;,?!(B!0(88=5*9!,(!,1*!5*3+*9,!+3;<23?!9,3,;(5S!

Z&##HZ&#&.

'3;<!<;5*9S!Z&##!H!Z&#&

@(88=5*!0*5,*+!,(!5*3+*9,!9,3,;(5

'3;<23?9!9,3,;(59S!Z&##!H!Z&#&

H"h!H!HZ$

ZJ!H!H!&

H%!H!#

Z!H!ZI#! Z#! "#! T! h# _;<(8*,*+9

/(=+0*9R!G+01;:*9!Vw>3+,*8*5,3<*9!6*!<3!@v,*H6Q#+S!J-!Z".!OO3fZS!OO3f$S!OO3I#S!/,3,;9;,;g=*!3N+;0(<*!6*9!0(88=5*9!*,!035,(59S!Z%%ZS!Z%&"S!Z&#I`!O+(5 *. &*!4 $%#&*. *? (*?(+#@+%&S!/C@WS!Z&hh.

Robert M. Schwartz

!""$

P?!Z&#IS!,1*!)=;<6;5N!(B!)+3501!<;5*9!356!,1*!(>*5;5N!(B!5*2!9,3,;(59!;5!=56*+-

9*+:*6!3+*39S!8=01!39!,1*!W+*?0;5*,!>+(N+38!136!>+(X*0,*6S!239!2*<<!=56*+23?.!

@(59*g=*5,<?S!8(+*! B3+8*+9! ;5! ,1*!@(,*! 6Qk+! 356! *<9*21*+*! 136! +3;<! 9*+:;0*!

0<(9*+! ,(! 1356.!7(! 6*90+;)*! ,1*! *BB*0,! (B! ;8>+(:*6! 300*99;);<;,?S! 903,,*+! ><(,9!

6*>;0,!,1*!+*<3,;(591;>9!)*,2**5!>+(T;8;,?!,(!3!9,3,;(5!356!,1*!0135N*!;5!0*+*3<!

>+(6=0,;(5!356!03,,<*!+3;9;5N.fh

71*!6*0<;5*! (B!21*3,! 0=<,;:3,;(5! 356! ,1*! >+(T;8;,?! (B! +3;<! ,+359>(+,!2*+*!

;5:*+9*<?!+*<3,*6R!B+(8!Z%&"!,(!Z&#IS!,1*!>*+0*5,3N*!6*0<;5*!;5!21*3,!F1*0,3+*9K!

239!N+*3,*+!39! ,1*!6;9,350*! ,(! ,1*!5*3+*9,! +3;<! 9,3,;(5! ;50+*39*6.fI! F/**!W;N=+*!

fh!71*!<;8;,*6!5=8)*+!(B!=5;,9!FffK!,13,!0(8>+;9*!,1*!@(,*H6Qk+!035,(53<!63,3)39*!83M*9!,1*!

3>><;03,;(5!(B!AL'!353<?9;9!=5B*39;)<*!3,!,1;9!>(;5,!;5!(=+!+*9*3+01.

fI!71*!3:*+3N*!;9!,1*!8*35!6;9,350*!B+(8!*301!0(88=5*!;5!3!035,(5!,(!,1*!5*3+*9,!9,3,;(5.!71;9!;9!3!

)*,,*+!8*39=+*!,135!,1*!6;9,350*!B+(8!,1*!0*5,*+!(+!9*3,!(B!3!035,(5!3<(5*!)*03=9*!,1*!300*99;);<;,?!

(B!(=,<?;5N!0(88=5*9!2(=<6!)*!;N5(+*6.!O,!239!3!9,3,*!>+;(+;,?!,(!(>*5!3!9,3,;(5!;5!*301!035,(53<!

9*3,!{chef-lieu).

W;N=+*!$!H![*+0*5,!0135N*!;5!5=8)*+9!(B!03,,<*!)?!035,(5!;5!,1*!V*>3+,8*5,!(B!@v,*H6Qk+S!

Z%&"HZ&#I

'3;<!<;5*9S!Z&##!H!Z&#&

'3;<23?9!9,3,;(59S!Z&##!H!Z&#&

[*+0*5,!0135N*!;5!5=8)*+!(B!03,,<*S!Z%&"HZ&#I

H"h!H!HZ$

ZJ!H!H!&

H%!H!#

Z!H!ZI #! Z#! "#! T! h# _;<(8*,*+9

/(=+0*9R!ibid.


""%!

%.K!G9!;5!>3+,9!(B!<(2<356!V(+9*,S!B3+8*+9!0<(9*+!,(!3!9,3,;(5!,*56*6!,(!+*6=0*!

21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5!,(!3!<*99*+!*T,*5,!,135!,1(9*!21(!2*+*!B3+,1*+!323?.!W3+8*+9!

3,!N+*3,*+!6;9,350*!B+(8!+3;<!,+359>(+,!8(+*!<;M*<?!>=,!,1*;+!<356!356!<3)(+!,(!=9*9!

8(+*!>+(a,3)<*!,135!N+(2;5N!8(+*!21*3,!,135!5**6*6!B(+!,1*;+!(25!0(59=8>-

,;(5.!D:*5!21*5!21*3,!>+;0*9!2*+*!>+(,*0,*6S!,1*?!2*+*!<(2!)?!*3+<;*+!9,3563+69.!

71*!366;,;(53<!0(9,!(B! ,+359>(+,;5N!21*3,!B+(8!+*8(,*!B3+89!239!6(=),<*99!3!

6;9;50*5,;:*.!k5!,1*!(,1*+!1356S!B3+8*+9!0<(9*!,(!,1*!0;,;*9!(B!V;X(5!356!P*3=5*!

*5X(?*6!3!0(8>*,;,;:*!36:35,3N*!)(,1!;5!,1*;+!>+(T;8;,?!,(!+3;<!9*+:;0*!356!,(!

,1*!<3+N*9,!+*N;(53<!83+M*,9!B(+!N+3;5!356!i(=+.!7(!8**,!,1*!<(03<!6*8356!B(+!

N+3;5!356!i(=+S!21*3,!B3+8;5N!;5!,1*!><3;59!3+(=56!,1*!,2(!0;,;*9!*T>356*6.

O5!03,,<*! +3;9;5NS!>*+0*5,3N*!0135N*9!B+(8!Z%&"! ,(!Z&#I!+35N*6!B+(8!>(9;-

,;:*! ;50+*39*9! ,(!9,**>!6*0<;5*9S!356! ,1*!+*<3,;(591;>!2;,1!8*35!6;9,350*!B+(8!

3!0(88=5*!,(!3!9,3,;(5!239!;5:*+9*.!F/**!W;N=+*!&.K!P?!356!<3+N*S! ,1*!N+*3,*+!

300*99;);<;,?!F983<<*+!6;9,350*KS! ,1*!N+*3,*+! ,1*! ;50+*39*! ;5! <;:*9,(0M!5=8)*+9`!

0(5:*+9*<?S! ,1*! <*99*+! 300*99;);<;,?! FN+*3,*+! 6;9,350*KS! ,1*! 983<<*+! ,1*! 983<<*+!

,1*!6*59;,?!(B!03,,<*!;5!Z&#I!39!0(8>3+*6!,(!Z%&Z.!71;9!>3,,*+5!239!8(+*!>+(-

5(=50*6! ;5!=><356!3+*39! ,135! ;5! ,1*!><3;59.! O5! 0(5,+39,! ,(! ,1*!><3;59!(B!V;X(5!

356!*39,*+5!P*3=5*!21*+*!21*3,!B3+8;5N!239!*T>356;5NS!;5!,1*!=><356!035,(59!

(B!@13,;<<(5H9=+H/*;5*S!G+53?H<*HV=0S! 356!G;N53?H<*HV=0! 03,,<*! B3+8;5N!239!

W;N=+*!%!H!'3;<!9,3,;(5!>+(T;8;,?!356!0135N*!;5!21*3,!0=<,;:3,;(5!;5!@v,*H6Qk+!035,(59S!

Z%&"!,(!Z&#I

"#

ZI

Z#

I

#

HI

HZ#

HZI

H"#

H"I

Hf#Z! "! f! h! I! J! $! %

[+(T;8;,?!,(!+3;<!9,3,;(5!356!0135N*!;5!21*3,!0=<,;:3,;(5!;5!@v,*HVQ(+S

Z%&"!,(!Z&#I

/(=+0*9R!ibid.

[*+

0*5,3

N*!01

35N*!;5

!1*0

,3+*

9!(B!2

1*3

,!0=

<,;:

3,;(

5

8*35!6;9,350*!B+(8!>3+;91!0*5,*+!,(!,(!9,3,;(5!;5!M;<(8*,*+9

Robert M. Schwartz

!""&

*T>356;5N!9;N5;a035,<?.!O5!Z&#I!0(8>3+*6!,(!Z%&"S!=><356!B3+8*+9!21(!2*+*!

+*<3,;:*<?!0<(9*!,(!3!9,3,;(5!Ff!,(!h!M;<(8*,*+9!323?K!2*+*!,?>;03<<?!+3;9;5N!8(+*!

9,(0M!,135!,1(9*!B3+,1*+!323?.!O5!9(!6(;5NS!,1*?!B(<<(2*6!3!53,;(53<!,+*56!356!6*-

>*56*6!=>(5!+3;<!,+359>(+,!,(!36X=9,!,1*!91;B,;5N!0(56;,;(59!(B!83+M*,9!B(+!8;<MS!

)**B!03,,<*S!356!8*3,.!O5!9=8S!;5!,1*!@(,*H6Qk+!3,! ,1*!,=+5!(B!,1*!0*5,=+?S! ,1*!

>+(T;8;,?!,(!+3;<!,+359>(+,!B30;<;,3,*6S!,(!3!:3+;*6!6*N+**S!,1*!91;B,!B+(8!21*3,!

0=<,;:3,;(5!,(!<;:*9,(0M!B3+8;5N.

71*!938*!36:35,3N*!1*<6!8(+*!(+!<*99!,+=*!;5!,1*!W+*501!6*>3+,8*5,!(B!,1*!

<;*+!356!;5!,1*!D5N<;91!0(=5,?!(B!V*+)?91;+*.fJ!O5!V(+9*,S!,1*!+(<*!(B!+3;<23?9!;5!

B3+8*+9Q!36X=9,8*5,9!,(!6;Ba0=<,!83+M*,!0(56;,;(59!239!9;N5;a035,S!;B!0(8><*TS!

;5!21*3,!>+(6=0,;(5.!L1*,1*+!,1*9*!>3,,*+59!1*<6!,+=*!;5!(,1*+!W+*501!356!P+;,-

;91!+*N;(59!356!;5!,1*!,2(!0(=5,+;*9!N*5*+3<<?!3+*!83,,*+9!5*T,!(5!(=+!3N*563.

CONCLUSION: A REFLECTION ON SPATIAL HISTORY

71;9!3+,;0<*!,+;*9!,(!;<<=9,+3,*!1(2!1;9,(+;03<!AO/S!N*(N+3>1;0!,1;5M;5NS!356!9>3-

,;3<!9,3,;9,;09S!in the good company (B!,+36;,;(53<!B(+89!(B!1;9,(+;03<!53++3,;:*!356!

fJ!/0123+,4S!Y'3;<!7+359>(+,S!GN+3+;35!@+;9;9S!356!,1*!'*9,+=0,=+;5N!(B!GN+;0=<,=+*Se!"f&HhIS!"h$HI#.

W;N=+*!&!H![+(T;8;,?!,(!+3;<!9,3,;(5!356!0135N*!;5!03,,<*!+3;9;5N!;5!@v,*H6Qk+S!Z%&"!,(!Z&#I

J#

I#

h#

f#

"#

Z#

#

HZ#

H"#

Hf#

Hh#Z! "! f! h! I! J! $! %

[+(T;8;,?!,(!+3;<!9,3,;(5!356!0135N*!;5!03,,<*!+3;9;5N!;5!@v,*HVQ(+S

Z%&"!,(!Z&#I

/(=+0*9R!ibid.

[*+

0*5,3

N*!01

35N*!;5

!03,

,<*

8*35!6;9,350*!B+(8!>3+;91!0*5,*+!,(!,(!9,3,;(5!;5!M;<(8*,*+9

@1x,;<<(5H9=+H/*;5*

G+53?H\*HV=0

G;N53?H\*HV=0

V;X(5 P*3=5*


"f#!

353<?9;9S!3+*!M*?!;5N+*6;*5,9!;5!,1*!83M;5N!(B!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?.!71*!9,(+?!>+*9*5,*6!

1*+*!(B!N<()3<;4;5N!3N+;0=<,=+3<!83+M*,9S!;5,*59;B?;5N!;5,*+53,;(53<!0(8>*,;,;(5S!

,1*!*T>359;(5!(B!+3;<!,+359>(+,3,;(5S!356!3N+;0=<,=+3<!0135N*!(BB*+9!3!9M*,01!(B!3!

B3+H+*301;5N!1;9,(+;03<!,+359B(+83,;(5.!/(8*!;8>(+,35,!B*3,=+*9S!,(!)*!9=+*S!3+*!

,1*+*!,135M9!,(!AO/!356!9>3,;3<!353<?9;9.!O5!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?S!1(2*:*+S!EAO/!F1;9-

,(+;03<!AO/K!2(+M9!)*9,!39!3!X=5;(+!>3+,5*+.!A;:*5!,1*!63,3S!;,!035!1*<>!;6*5,;B?!

>+()<*89!356!B30;<;,3,*!,1*;+!*T38;53,;(5.!P=,S!<;M*!(,1*+!,((<9!;5!,1*!1;9,(+;35Q9!

M;,S!;,!0355(,!B+38*!>+()<*89!2(+,1!;5:*9,;N3,;(5.!C(+!6(*9!;,!N*5*+3,*!;5,*+>+*-

,3,;(59!356!8*35;5N9.!O,9!0(8><*T;,;*9!03++?!3!+;9M.!P*03=9*!,1*!>+*>3+3,;(5!(B!

N*(H+*B*+*50*6!63,3!356!,1*!<*3+5;5N!(B!,1*!,*015(<(N?!035!,3M*!3!N+*3,!6*3<!(B!

,;8*S!>+30,;,;(5*+9!(B!EAO/!(B,*5!N*,!03=N1,!=>!;5!,1*!8*,1(69!356!N;:*!,((!<;,,<*!

3,,*5,;(5!;5!,1*;+!>3>*+9!356!>=)<;03,;(59!,(!9=)9,35,;:*!+*9=<,9.!L*!>+30,;,;(5*+9!

91(=<6!6(!3!)*,,*+!X()!;5,*+>+*,;5N!356!0(88=5;03,;5N!(=+!6;90(:*+;*9!,(!83M*!

0<*3+*+!21?!1;9,(+;03<!AO/!;9!2(+,1!,1*!*BB(+,.

G!+*<3,*6!;8>*+3,;:*!;9!,(!+*0(N5;4*!)(,1!,1*!<;8;,9!(B!1;9,(+;03<!AO/!356!,1*!

;8>(+,350*!(B!0(8><*8*5,3+?!9(=+0*9!356!3>>+(301*9.!OB!AO/!,*015(<(N?!2*+*!

,(!6+;:*!,1*!;5:*9,;N3,;(5S!(5*!8;N1,!*39;<?!(:*+<((M!+*0(+69!6(0=8*5,;5N!,1*!

<;:*6!*T>*+;*50*!(B!5;5*,**5,1H0*5,=+?!B3+8*+9S!,1*;+!2;:*9S!9(59S!356!63=N1-

,*+9S!,1*!()9*+:3,;(59!356!(>;5;(59!(B!X(=+53<;9,9!<;M*!U*BB*+;*9S!(+!,1*!,*9,;8(5?!

(B! B3+8*+9! )*B(+*! ,1*!P+;,;91! 356! W+*501! ;5:*9,;N3,;(59! ;5,(! 3N+;0=<,=+3<! 356!

3N+3+;35!0+;9;9.!713,!2(=<6!)*!3!<(99.!k5!,1*!>(9;,;:*!9;6*S!,1*!353<?9;9!(B!0*5-

9=9!+*0(+69!356!3N+;0=<,=+3<!9,3,;9,;09!;5!3!AO/!035!>+(:;6*!,1*!)+(36*+!>3,,*+59!

5**6*6!B(+!9;,=3,;5N!039*!9,=6;*9!356!+;01!g=3<;,3,;:*!*:;6*50*!;5!,1*;+!>+(>*+!

1;9,(+;03<!0(5,*T,.

/>3,;3<!1;9,(+?!(=N1,!,(!)*!8(+*!,135!*T38;5;5N!g=*9,;(59!3)(=,!N*(N+3>1;0!

6;9,+;)=,;(59!(:*+!,;8*S!39!21*5!2*!=9*!9136*6!,1*83,;0!83>9!,(!91(2!>*+0*5,-

3N*!0135N*!;5!21*3,!0=<,;:3,;(5!;5!V(+9*,!356!,1*!@(,*H6Qk+.!O56*5,;B?;5N!9=01!

9>3,;(H,*8>(+3<!>3,,*+9!;9!3!N((6!a+9,!9,*>.!7(!N(!B=+,1*+S!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?!91(=<6!

0(50*+5!,1*!9,=6?!(B!9>3,;3<!+*<3,;(591;>9!356!(B!9>3,;3<!;5,*+0(55*0,;:;,?!(:*+!

,;8*S!;.*.S! ,1*!6*N+**!,(!21;01!3!0135N*!;5!(5*!>3+,!(B!35!;5,*+H+*<3,*6!9?9,*8!

3<,*+9! (,1*+! >3+,9! ;5! ,=+5.! W(+! *T38><*S!21*5S!21*+*S! 356! ,(!213,! *T,*5,! 6;6!

+3;<23?!*T>359;(5!*BB*0,!3N+;0=<,=+3<!>+(6=0,;(5!356!<356!=9*o!E(2!6;6!,1*!3+-

+;:3<!(B!+3;<!,+359>(+,!;5!+*8(,*!3N+3+;35!+*N;(59!3BB*0,!>+(6=0,;(5!356!<356!=9*!

;5!,1(9*!6;9,+;0,9o!O5!6;9,+;0,9!0<(9*+!,(!83X(+!83+M*,9S!6;9,+;0,9!,13,!1*+*,(B(+*!

*5X(?*6!,1*!36:35,3N*!(B!>+(T;8;,?!,(!<3+N*!356!N+(2;5N!5=8)*+9!(B!=+)35!0(5-

9=8*+9o!k+S!39!9(!0(50*+5*6!U*BB*+;*9S!1(2!6;6!,1*!*T>359;(5!(B!+3;<!,+359>(+,!;5!

G8*+;03!3BB*0,!B3+8*+9!;5!P+;,3;5o

71*!N*(N+3>1*+Q9!0(50*>,!(B!Y903<*e!356!1;9,(+;35!-3+0!P<(01Q9!0(50*>,;(5!

(B!0(8>3+3,;:*!1;9,(+?!91(=<6!3<9(!)*!0(8>(5*5,9!(B!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?.f$!O50(+>(+3,-

f$!C*;<!P+*55*+S!YP*,2**5!W;T;,?!356!-(,;(5R!G00=8=<3,;(5S!7*++;,(+;3<!k+N35;43,;(5!356!,1*!

E;9,(+;03<!A*(N+3>1?!(B!/>3,;3<!/03<*9Se’Environment and PlanningD: Society and Space ZJFZ&&%KR!

hI&H%Z`!-3+0!P<(01S!YG!@(5,+;)=,;(5!7(23+69!3!@(8>3+3,;:*!E;9,(+?!(B!D=+(>*35!/(0;*,;*9Se!;5!

Land and Work in Medieval Europe FC*2!j(+MR!E3+>*+!t!'(2S!Z&J$KR!hhH%Z.

Robert M. Schwartz

!"fZ

;5N!8=<,;><*!903<*9!(B!N*(N+3>1;0!+*9(<=,;(5!356!,1*;+!;5,*+!+*<3,;(591;>9!)+;5N9!

(=,!,1*!;5,*+0(55*0,;:;,?!(B!0135N*d!(+!>*+9;9,*50*d3,!6;BB*+*5,!<*:*<9!(B!1=-

835!30,;:;,?!356!53,=+3<! B(+0*9.! O5! ,1*!039*!6*90+;)*6!1*+*S! ;5,*+0(55*0,;:;,?!

239! 9;N5;a035,! 3,! ,1*! N<()3<S! 53,;(53<S! 356! <(03<! <*:*<9! (B! 30,;:;,?.!G8*+;035!

B3+8*+9!13+:*9,;5N!21*3,! ;5!C*)+39M3!356!,1*!V3M(,39!2*+*!=<,;83,*<?!;5i=-

*5,;3<!;5!6*0;9;(59!3)(=,!3N+;0=<,=+3<!<356!=9*!;5!V(+9*,!@(=5,?!356!;5!,1*!V*-

>3+,8*5,!(B!@(,*H6Qk+S!X=9,!39!)36!2*3,1*+!356!>((+!13+:*9,9!;5!,1*!G8*+;035!

A+*3,![<3;59!0(=<6!+*9=<,!;5!1;N1*+!21*3,!>+;0*9!;5!\;:*+>((<.f%!O5!,1*!Z%&#9S!39!

G8*+;035!21*3,! B3+8*+9! ,1*89*<:*9! 038*! ,(! 9=BB*+! B+(8! B3<<;5N! >+;0*9S! ,1*?!

038*!,(!)*<;*:*!,13,!,1*!\;:*+>((<!83+M*,!9*,!,1*!<(2!>+;0*9!,13,!,1+*3,*5*6!,1*;+!

<;:*<;1((69.f&

G5(,1*+!,39M!;5!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?!;9!,(!,*39*!(=,!<;5M9!)*,2**5!,*8>(+3<!356!9>3-

,;3<!0135N*.h#!G<,1(=N1!(5<?!)+;*i?!,+*3,*6!1*+*S!,1*!*T>359;(5!(B!+3;<!,+359>(+,!

356!;,9!*BB*0,9!(5!3N+;0=<,=+*! ;9!3!+*:*3<;5N!*T38><*!(B!0135N*!8(:;5N!30+(99!

,*++;,(+?! 356! ,;8*.!G5(,1*+! ;8>*+3,;:*S! ,(! +*>*3,S! ;9! ,(! (>*5! ,1*! 0(5:*+93,;(5!

3)(=,!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?!,(!3!2;6*+!3=6;*50*!,135!9>*0;3<;9,9!;5!1;9,(+;03<!AO/.!71*!

(>*5;5N!(BB*+*6!1*+*S!;8>*+B*0,!39!;,!;9S!9,3+,9!)?!B+38;5N!,1*!>+()<*8!,1+(=N1!

,1*!*?*9!(B!3!0(5,*8>(+3+?!()9*+:*+!356!,1*5!0(5,;5=*9!)?!;50(+>(+3,;5N!AO/H

+*<3,*6!a56;5N9!;5,(!35!300*99;)<*!53++3,;:*!3)(=,!1;9,(+;03<!0135N*.!C3++3,;:*S!

3B,*+!3<<S!+*83;59!,1*!lingua franca (B!8(9,!(B!1;9,(+;359!356!+*36*+9!(B!1;9,(+?.

W;53<<?S!,1*+*!;9!,1*!=+N*5,!,39M!(B!;5,*+*9,;5N!1;9,(+;359!;5!9>3,;3<!+*<3,;(5-

91;>9!356!+*5*2;5N!,1*;+!+*N3+6!B(+!N*(N+3>1;03<!,1;5M;5N.!71;9!6(*9!5(,!+*g=;+*!

AO/S!356!,(!>+*9=8*!,13,!;,!6(*9!83?!)*!8(+*!1;56+350*!,135!3;6.!G!93<=,3+?!+*-

8;56*+!;5!,1;9!+*N3+6!;9!,(!+*03<<!,1*!;59;9,*5,!)*<;*B!913+*6!)?!9(8*!N*(N+3>1*+9!

356!1;9,(+;359!;5!,1*!Z&J#9!356!Z&$#9!,13,!g=35,;,3,;:*!8*,1(69!2*+*!the M*?9!

,(!,1*!M;5N6(8.

G9!0(50*+59!,1*!>+(8;9*!(B!;5,*+0(55*0,*6!9>3,;3<!1;9,(+?S!';013+6!U*BB*+;*9S!

;5!9(8*!9*59*S!91(2*6!=9!3!23?!B(+23+6.!G!M**5!()9*+:*+!(B!3N+;0=<,=+3<!0135N*!

;5!P+;,3;5!356!3)+(36S!1*!+*0(N5;4*6!)(,1!,1*!;5,*+53,;(53<!0(55*0,;(5!)*,2**5!

G8*+;035!356!P+;,;91!B3+8*+9S!356!,1*!+*N;(53<!356!<(03<!9;N5;a0350*!(B!+3>;6!

356!0(5:*5;*5,!,+359>(+,3,;(5!;5!,1*!3N*!(B!N+(2;5N!N<()3<;43,;(5.!7+=*S!39!35!

36:(03,*!B(+!P+;,;91!B3+8;5N!;5,*+*9,9!1*!239!3>,!,(!9,+*,01!,1*!,+=,1!;5!1;9!013+-

30,*+;43,;(59!(B!G8*+;035!356!W+*501!+;:3<9!356!(B!,1*!;536*g=30;*9!(B!+=+3<!+3;<!

f%!-*<35;*!W;55S!YDBB*0,9!(B!\(03<!L*3,1*+!(5!3!A<()3<!-3+M*,Se!=5>=)<;91*6!9*8;53+!>3>*+S!

F-(=5,!E(<?(M*!@(<<*N*S!/(=,1!E36<*?S!-399301=9*,,9S!V*0*8)*+!"##&KR!Z"HZhS!6*8(59,+3,*9!,1*!

<;M*<;1((6!,13,!6+(=N1,!356!>((+!21*3,!13+:*9,9!;5!C*)+39M3!;5!,1*!*3+<?!Z%$#9!<*6!,(!21*3,!>+;0*!

;50+*39*9!;5!\;:*+>((<S!D5N<356.

f&!^./.!E(=9*!(B!'*>+*9*5,3,;:*9S!V*>+*99;(5!(B!G8*+;035!GN+;0=<,=+3<!/,3><*9S!'*>(+,!Z%&&S!

,*9,;8(5?!(B!V3:;6!\=);5!356!G<*T!L*66*+)=+5S!>+*9;6*5,9!(B!,1*!9,3,*!A+35N*!399(0;3,;(59!(B!

@3<;B(+5;3!356!m;+N;5;3!+*9>*0,;:*<?S!-3+01!"S!Z%&IS!>>.!fZHffS!IhHII.

h#!A*(N+3>1;0!;5B(+83,;(5!90;*5,;9,9!3+*!0=++*5,<?!*T><(+;5N!23?9!,(!B(+83<<?!;50(+>(+3,*!,;8*!;5!

AO/.!k5!,1;9!9**!-3?!j=35S!YG66;5N!,;8*!;5,(!A*(N+3>1;0!O5B(+83,;(5!/?9,*8Se!;5!The Handbook

of Geographic Information Science, *6.!G.!/,*23+,`!L;<9(5!W(,1*+;5N138S!U(15![.S!Blackwell

Companions to Geography F-3;6*5S!-GR!P<30M2*<<!"##%KS!ZJ&H%h.


"f"!

9*+:;0*!;5!P+;,3;5d3<<!,1*!)*,,*+!,(!+3<<?!;5N*5=;,?!356!+*9(<:*!,(!+*9,(+*!P+;,;91!

3N+;0=<,=+*!,(!;,9!>+(>*+!><30*!;5!,1*!2(+<6.!G<,1(=N1!1*!(:*+9,3,*6!,1*!,+3:3;<!(B!

8(:;5N!0+(>9!B+(8!B3+8!N3,*!,(!9,3,;(5!><3,B(+8S!1*!35,;0;>3,*6!,1*!63?!21*5!

N39(<;5*!>(2*+*6!,+=0M9!356!3=,(8();<*9!2(=<6!><?!,1*!+(369!(B!+=+3<!P+;,3;5.!

G5!3+6*5,!()9*+:*+!(B!P+;,3;5Q9!3N+3+;35!2(+<6!;5!;5,*+53,;(53<!>*+9>*0,;:*S!1*!

239!3!:;9;(53+?S!,((.

Robert M. Schwartz

!"ff

REFERENCES

GB,(5S!P*,135;*.!Y71*!A+*3,!GN+;0=<,=+3<!V*>+*99;(5!(5!,1*!D5N<;91!@13<M<3569R!71*!

E38>91;+*!DT>*+;*50*.e!Agricultural History Review hh!FZ&&JKR!Z&ZH"#I.

G,M;59S![.!U.!Y71*!A+(2,1!(B!\(56(5Q9!'3;<23?!-;<M!7+36*S!0.!Z%hIHZ&Zh.e!The Journal of

Transport History hS!5(.!h!FZ&$%KR!"#%H"J.

P<(01S!-3+0.!YG!@(5,+;)=,;(5!7(23+69!3!@(8>3+3,;:*!E;9,(+?!(B!D=+(>*35!/(0;*,;*9.e!In

Land and Work in Medieval Europe hhH%Z.!C*2!j(+MR!E3+>*+!t!'(2S!Z&J$R!hhH%Z

P(=5*3=S!@1+;9,(>1*.!Y@1*8;59!6*!B*+!*,!6*:*<(>>*8*5,!+=+3<!*5!W+350*!6*!Z%I"!3!Z&f$!R!

<3!0(5,+;)=,;(5!6*!<3!@(8>3N5;*!6=!-;6;!Y!Histoire, Economie et Societe Z!FZ&&#KR!&IH

ZZ".

P+*55*+S!C*;<.!YP*,2**5!W;T;,?!356!-(,;(5R!G00=8=<3,;(5S!7*++;,(+;3<!k+N35;43,;(5!356!

,1*!E;9,(+;03<!A*(N+3>1?!(B!/>3,;3<!/03<*9.e!Environment and Planning D: Society and

Space ZJ!FZ&&%KR!hI&H%Z.!P+(6*+S!G<)*+,.!Y\3!<(5N=*!9,3N53,;(5!B+3503;9*R!>35(+383!

N*5*+3<.e!la La Longue stagnation en France. L’autre grande depression 1873-1897,

*6;,*6!)?!j:*9`!P+(6*+!P+*,(5S!G<)*+`!\=,B3<<3S!-;01*<S!*69.![3+;9R!D0(5(8;03S!Z&&$.

@3+8(53S!U=35.!Y/13+*0+(>>;5N!356!<;:*9,(0M!9>*0;3<;43,;(5!;5!W+350*S!Z%f#HZ&f#.e!

Continuity and Change "Z!F"##JKR!"fIHI&.

@3+(5S!W+350(;9.!Histoire des chemins defer en France, 1740-1883. [3+;9R!W3?3+6S!Z&&$.!

–.!Histoire des chemins defer en France, 1883-1937. [3+;9R!W3?3+6S!"##I.

@<(=,S!E=N1.!Y71*![3?9!6*!P+3?R!G!m3<*!(B!V3;+;*9!;5!C(+,1*+5!W+350*.e!Agricultural

History

Review IZS!5(.!"!F"##fKR!Z&&H"#%.!@(0<35;9S![*,*+!G.!YP30M!,(!,1*!W=,=+*R!71*!A<()3<;43,;(5!

(B!GN+;0=<,=+*!;5!E;9,(+;03<!@(5,*T,.e

SAISReview "fS!5(.!Z!F"##fKR!$ZH%h.

@(<<;59S!D.!U.!7.S!*6.!The Agrarian History of England and Wales. Volume VII1850-1914.

D6;,*6!)?!U(35!71;+9MS!71*!GN+3+;35!E;9,(+?!(B!D5N<356!356!L3<*9.!@38)+;6N*R!

@38)+;6N*!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!"###.

–.!Y71*!A+*3,!V*>+*99;(5S!Z%$IHZ%&J.e!O5!The Agrarian History of England and Wales.

Volume VII1850-1914, *6;,*6!)?!D.!U.!7.!@(<<;59S!Zf%H"#$.!@38)+;6N*R!@38)+;6N*!^5;:*+9;,?!

[+*99S!"###.


"fh!

V(+8(;9S!U*35H[;*++*.!Y\3!n:(03,;(5!3N+;0(<*!6*!<3!W+350*Q.!\Q3N+;0=<,=+*!B+3503;9*!B30*!3!<3!

0(50=++*50*!)+;,355;g=*!3:35,!<3!N=*++*!6*!Z&Zh.e!Histoire etMesure ZZS!5(.!fHh!FZ&&JKR!

f"&HJJ.

W35;03S!k<;:;*+.!YV=!<3;,!>(=+!<3!03>;,3<*.!\3!>+(6=0,;(5!<3;,;*+*!3=,(=+6*![3+;9!FZ$##H

Z&ZhK.e!O5!:!5 '(&* 5* &)+! &*. *J , 2+7 *K/L00 M//0 *;5 , P9*Q2",'5%"#A*&5('!5'(+5%"#A*

specialisation., *6;,*6!)?![1;<;>>*`!-(+;0*3=!-36*<;5*S!U*35H-3+0.!'*55*9R![+*99*9!

^5;:*+9;,3;+*9!6*!'*55*9S!"##JR!ZhZHIh

W(,1*+;5N138S!G.!/,*23+,S!356!U(15![.!L;<9(5.!The handbook of geographic information

science, P<30M2*<<!0(8>35;(59!,(!N*(N+3>1?.!-3;6*5S!-GR!P<30M2*<<![=).S!"##%.

A(5X(S!j39=(.!Y\*!n[<35!W+*?0;5*,QS!Z%$%HZ%%"R!=5!39>*0,!6*!<3!nA+356*!V*>+*99;(5Q!

*0(5(8;g=*!*5!W+350*.e!1 2' *4%&5"(%8' *"h%!FZ&$"KR!h&H%J.

A+*N(+?S!O35!C.!A Place in History: A Guide to Using GIS in Historical Research. kT)(2R!

kTB(+6!"##f.

E3<<39S!@1+;9,;5*.!Y71*!/(0;3<!356!D0(5(8;0!O8>30,!(B!'=+3<!'3;<23?R!71*!L*59<*?63<*!

\;5*.e!The Agricultural History Review fh!FZ&%JKR!"&HhI.

–.!The Wensleydale Railway. @<3>138!bP*6B(+691;+*cR!V3<*9835!P((M9S!Z&%h.

E3=S!-;013*<.!Ye\3!+*9;9,350*!6*9!+*N;(59!6Q3N+;0=<,=+*!;5,*59;:*!3=T!0+;9*9!6*!<3!a5!6=!

pOp*!9;*0<*!R!\*9!039!6*!ZQG<930*S!6=!m3=0<=9*!*,!6=!P39H\35N=*6(0e.e!O5!Un siecle

.34%&5"%( *+7(%!", *?(+#7+%& 9*:!5 &*.'*!",,"8' *. *,+*;"!% 5 *?(+#7+%& *.3 !"#"$% *('(+, A*

*6;,*6!)?![1;<;>>*!@13<8;5!356!G56+*!A=*9<;5!FD0(5(8;*!+=+3<*S!Z&%%K!R!fZHhZ

E(2*<<S!V.L.!Y71*!;8>30,!(B!+3;<23?9!(5!3N+;0=<,=+3<!6*:*<(>8*5,!;5!5;5*,**5,1H0*5,=+?!

L3<*9.e!Welsh History Review $!FZ&$hHIKR!h#HJ".

E=5,S!D.E`![38S!/.U.!Y[+;0*9!356!/,+=0,=+3<!'*9>(59*!;5!D5N<;91!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%$fHZ%&J.e!

The Economic History Review I#S!5(.!f!FZ&&$KR!h$$HI#I.

U(5*9S!D+;0!\.!Y71*!\356!,13,!';013+6!U*BB*+;*9!O51*+;,*6.e!Rural History ZJS!5(.!Z!F"##IKR!

%fH&f.

_(5;5NS!C;*M.!The failure of agrarian capitalism : agrarian politics in the UK, Germany, the

Netherlands and the USA, 1846-1919. \(56(5R!'(=,<*6N*S!Z&&h.

\1(88*S!U*35.!Y\3!0+;9*!3N+;0(<*!3!<3!a5!6=!pOp*!9;*0<*!*5!W+350*.!D993;!6Q;5,*+>+*,3,;(5!

*0(5(8;g=*!*,!9(0;3<*.e!1 2' * !"#"$%8' *"ZS!5(.!h!FZ&$#KR!I"ZHIf.

kQ'(=+M*S!_*:;5!E.!Y71*!D=+(>*35!A+3;5!O5:39;(5S!Z%$#HZ&Zf.e!The Journal of Economic

History I$S!5(.!h!FZ&&$KR!$$IH%#Z.

[*++*5S!';013+6.!Agriculture in depression, 1870-1940, C*2!9,=6;*9!;5!*0(5(8;0!356!9(0;3<!

1;9,(+?.!@38)+;6N*R!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!Z&&I.

–.!The meat trade in Britain, 1840-1914, /,=6;*9!;5!*0(5(8;0!1;9,(+?.!\(56(5!`!P(9,(5R

'(=,<*6N*!356!_*N35![3=<S!Z&$%.

Robert M. Schwartz

!"fI

[*++*5S!';013+6!Y-3+M*,;5N!(B!GN+;0=<,=+3<![+(6=0,9.e!O5!The Agrarian History of England

and Wales. Volume VII1850-1914, *6;,*6!)?!D.!U.!7.!@(<<;59S!&IfH&%.!@38)+;6N*R!

@38)+;6N*!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!"###.

[*++?S![.U.!YG5!GN+;0=<,=+3<!U(=+53<;9,!(5!,1*!YA+*3,!V*>+*99;(5eR!';013+6!U*BB*+;*9.e!The

Journal of British Studies &S!5(.!"!FZ&$#KR!Z"JHh#.

/018;,,S!A;;5,1*+.!YGN+;0=<,=+*!;5!C;5*,**5,1!@*5,=+?!W+350*!356!P+;,3;5R!G5(,1*+!

DT><353,;(5!(B!O5,*+53,;(53<!356!O5,*+9*0,(+3<![+(6=0,;:;,?!V;BB*+*50*9.e!The Journal of

European Economic History Z&S!5(.!Z!FZ&&#KR!&ZHZZf.

/0123+,4S!'()*+,!-.`!A+*N(+?S!O35`!-3+,;HE*55*)=+NS!U(+6;.!YE;9,(+?!356!AO/R!'3;<23?9S

[(>=<3,;(5!@135N*S!356!GN+;0=<,=+3<!V*:*<(>8*5,!;5!<3,*!5;5*,**5,1!0*5,=+?!L3<*9.e!O5!

Geography and the Humanities, *6;,*6!)?!V(=N<39!';013+69(5.!L391;5N,(5S!V@R!

G99(0;3,;(5!(B!G8*+;035!A*(N+3>1*+9S!"#Z#.

/,+3=9S!G56+*`!m*+<*?S![3,+;0M.!Y\Q*0(5(8;*!B+3503;9*!3=!pOp*!9;*0<*.!G53<?9*!

830+(*0(5(8;g=*S!=5*!(*=:+*!;9(<**!(=!=5*!(=:*+,=+*!:*+9!6*9!+*01*+01*9!5(:3,+;0*9o.e!

Revue .34%&5"%( *.'*/0/ *&% !, *"f!F"##ZKR!"Z#HZ%.

73?<(+S!V.!Y\(56(5Q9!-;<M!/=>><?S!Z%I#HZ&##R!A Remterpretation.” Agricultural History hI!

FZ&$ZKR!ffH%.

7(=,3;5S!U*35H@<3=6*.!Y\3!@+(;99350*!;5*N3<*9!6*9!+*N;(59!B+3503;9*9R!<Q3N+;0=<,=+*!6*!Z%Z#H

Z&&#.e!1 2' *4%&5"(%8' *I&#!FZ&&hKR!fZIHI&.

–.!La production agricole de la France de 1810 a 1990: Departements et Regions.

Croissance, productivity, structures. f!:(<9S!E;9,(;+*!g=35,;,3,;:*!6*!<Q*0(5(8;*!B+3503;9*.

A+*5()<*R!@31;*+9!6*!Z7/-DG!bD0(5(8;*9!*,!9(0;*,*9cS!Z&&"Hf.!7+30?S!-;013*<.!

Government and agriculture in Western Europe, 1880-1988. f+6!*6.!C*2!j(+M`

\(56(5R!E3+:*9,*+!L1*3,91*3BS!Z&%&.

7=+5*+S!-;013*<.!Yk=,>=,!356![+;0*9!;5!^_!GN+;0=<,=+*S!Z%J$HZ&ZhS!356!,1*!A+*3,!

GN+;0=<,=+3<!V*>+*99;(5!'*0(59;6*+*6.e!The Agricultural History Review h#S!5(.!Z!

FZ&&"KR!f%HIZ.

7=+5*+S!-;013*<!D.!YGN+;0=<,=+3<!k=,>=,S!O50(8*S!356![+(6=0,;:;,?.e!O5!The Agrarian

History of England and Wales. Volume VII1850-1914, *6;,*6!)?!D.!U.!7.!@(<<;59S!""hH

f"#.!@38)+;6N*R!@38)+;6N*!^5;:*+9;,?![+*99S!"###.

7=+5(0MS!V3:;6.!An historical geography of railways in Great Britain and Ireland. G<6*+91(,S!

E35,9S!D5N<356S!P+((Ma*<6S!m,R!G91N3,*S!Z&&%.

:35!l356*5!S!U.!\.!Y71*!A+(2,1!(B![+(6=0,;(5!356![+(6=0,;:;,?!;5!D=+(>*35!GN+;0=<,=+*S!

Z%$#HZ&Zh.e!The Economic History Review hh.!"!FZ&&ZKR!"ZIHf&.

m;63<S!U*35HW+350(;9.!R )( &&%"#* 5*( 5"'(*. *,+*)("&) (%5 9*S &* !"#"$% & '(") # &*+*,+*-#*

du /0/ *&% !, 9*[3+;9R!\QE3+83,,35S!"###.


"fJ!

j=35S!-3?.!YG66;5N!,;8*!;5,(!A*(N+3>1;0!O5B(+83,;(5!/?9,*8.e!O5!The Handbook of

Geographic Information Science, *6;,*6!)?!G.!/,*23+,`L;<9(5!W(,1*+;5N138S!U(15![.S!

ZJ&H%h.!-3;6*5S!-GR!P<30M2*<<!"##%.

globalization, railways, and agriculture in … · robert m. schwartz!"#$ globalization,...

Documents