geological marvels - welcome to the olli at uci bloggrand canyon: later hypotheses •at least 8...
TRANSCRIPT
GEOLOGICAL MARVELS: The Colorado Plateau and the Grand Canyon
SC 204 January 16, 2013
Gil Brenner
John Bush
Gary Oberts
THE HUALAPAI OVERLOOK
GLOBAL CHANGES OF SEA LEVEL
FORMATION OF THE THE GRAND CANYON
A YOUNG CANYON
OR
AN ANCIENT ONE ?
CLARENCE E DUTTON JOHN WESLEY POWELL
THE PHYSICAL GEOLOGY OF THE GRAND CANYON DISTRICT 1882
THE EXPLORATION OF THE COLORADO RIVER AND ITS CANYONS 1875
Antecedent Rivers “The Great Denudation”
SAN JUAN RIVER GOOSENECKS NEAR BLUFF UTAH
GRAND CANYON: LATER HYPOTHESES
• At least 8 major theories with minor variations
• New techniques, new evidence and new concepts were responsible
• The newer hypotheses had to incorporate validated evidence of the prior theories
James Lawrence Powell, Grand Canyon: Solving
Earth’s Grandest Puzzle Pi Press 2005
THE YOUNG CANYON HYPOTHESIS
• Grand Canyon was cut in the last 6 million years
• It was cut by the Colorado River
• This is the consensus position
THE 2010 CONSENSUS
VIDEO
“HOW THE EARTH WAS MADE—GRAND CANYON”
A YOUNG CANYON-- SUMMARY
• Calcium content of garnets
• Presence of marine fossils
• Alignment of pebbles in Hindu Canyon
• Muddy Creek formation
• Lake Bidahochi- fossils and green rocks
• Rapid down-cutting at Lee’s Ferry
• Rapids focus energy of the river
• Canyon widening processes
• Volcanoes yield lava flows into the Canyon
AN ANCIENT CANYON
• Western Grand Canyon was cut close to its present depth by 60-70 Ma
• The Colorado River did not create Grand Canyon
Brian Wernecke The California River and its role in carving Grand Canyon Geological Society of America Bulletin 123 1288-1316, 2011
SUPPORTERS OF THE ANCIENT CANYON THEORY
• Rebecca Flowers—U Colorado
• Kenneth A Farley– CalTech
R. M. Flowers and K. A. Farley Apatite 4He/3He
and (U-Th)/He Evidence for an Ancient
Grand Canyon Science, 338 1616 2012
ADVOCATES OF THE YOUNG CANYON HYPOTHESIS
• Karl E Karlstrom University of New Mexico
• Richard A Young State University of New York Geneseo
• Joel Pederson Utah State University
• Many other geologists
W.R. Dickinson & G.E. Gehrels American Journal of Science 2008
Location of the Kaibab Uplift in the west-central
Colorado Plateau, near the margin of the Sevier thrust
belt.
Tindall S et al. Lithosphere 2 221-231 2010
SOUTHWESTERN COLORADO PLATEAU
LATE CRETACEOUS—75 Ma
CRETACEOUS AMERICAN SOUTHWEST 80 MA
UNROOFING, INCISION, AND UPLIFT HISTORY OF THE SOUTHWESTERN COLORADO PLATEAU FROM APATITE (U-Th)/He THERMOCHRONOMETRY RM Flowers, BP Wernecke, and KA Farley Geological Society of America
Bulletin 120 571 (2008)
• Thermochronometry
– Based on decay of uranium and thorium to helium
– Retention of helium depends on the thermal history of the mineral (apatite) which traps it
– Helium ages record time since cooling
• Results and interpretation
Wayne Ranney Arizona Geology Magazine Fall/Winter 2012
Wayne Ranney Arizona Geology magazine Fall/Winter 2012
WHAT THEY CONCLUDED
Wayne Ranney Arizona Geology Magazine Fall/Winter 2012
LOCATION OF CROSSSECTION FLOWERS ET AL 2008
Reconstructed cross sections through the study area at (A) 80 Ma, (B) 50–35 Ma, (C) 28 Ma,
(D) 16 Ma, and (E) present day.
Based on Apatite (U-Th)He Thermochronometry
Flowers R et al. Geological Society of America Bulletin 120
571 2008
©2008 by Geological Society of America
Reconstructed sedimentary thicknesses at the selected times depicted in the cross sections
in Figure 9, relative to the horizontal Kaibab limestone datum.
Flowers R et al. Geological Society of America Bulletin
2008;120:571-587
©2008 by Geological Society of America
ARGUMENT FOR AN ANCIENT CANYON-A SYNTHESIS
The California River and its role in Carving Grand Canyon B. Werneke Geological Society Of America Bulletin 123 1288 2011
TECTONIC BACKGROUND
• 180-140 Ma Nevadan Orogeny—Sierran Arc forms
• 140- 40 Ma Sevier and Laramide (80-40 Ma) Orogenies
________________________________________
• 50-30 Ma Foundering of the Nevadaplano—beginning of the Basin and Range
• 16-6 Ma Foundering of the Mogollon Highlands, disruption of drainage
• 5-6 Ma Opening of Gulf of California, activation of the southern San Andreas Fault
CRETACEOUS AMERICAN SOUTHWEST 80 MA
EVOLUTION OF THE GRAND CANYON-1 BRIAN WERNICKE 2011
TECTONIC BACKGROUND
• 180-140 Ma Nevadan Orogeny—Sierran Arc forms
• 140- 40 Ma Sevier and Laramide (80-40 Ma) Orogenies
• 50-30 Ma Foundering of the Nevadaplano—beginning of the Basin and Range
_________________________________________
• 16-6 Ma Foundering of the Mogollon Highlands, disruption of drainage
• 5-6 Ma Opening of Gulf of California, activation of the southern San Andreas Fault
EOCENE AMERICAN SOUTHWEST 55MA
SEDIMENTS FROM THE “ARIZONA” RIVER J.L. Howard Geology 24 783-786 1996
BOLIVIAN ALTIPLANO
TECTONIC BACKGROUND
• 180-140 Ma Nevadan Orogeny—Sierran Arc forms
• 140- 40 Ma Sevier and Laramide (80-40 Ma)
orogenies
• 50-30 Ma Foundering of the Nevadaplano—beginning of the Basin and Range
• 16-6 Ma Foundering of the Mogollon Highlands, disruption of drainage
___________________________________________
• 5-6 Ma Opening of Gulf of California, activation of the southern San Andreas Fault
EVOLUTION OF THE GRAND CANYON-2 BRIAN WERNICKE 2011
TECTONIC BACKGROUND
• 180-140 Ma Nevadan Orogeny—Sierran Arc forms
• 140- 40 Ma Sevier and Laramide (80-40 Ma)
orogenies
• 50-30 Ma Foundering of the Nevadaplano—beginning of the Basin and Range
• 16-6 Ma Foundering of the Mogollon Highlands, disruption of drainage
• 5-6 Ma Opening of Gulf of California, activation of the southern San Andreas Fault
__________________________________________
EVOLUTION OF THE GRAND CANYON-3 BRIAN WERNICKE 2011
UPLIFT OF THE COLORADO PLATEAU MODEL 1:YOUNG GRAND CANYON
MODEL 2: ANCIENT GRAND CANYON
THE NEW EVIDENCE
• Employed 4He/3He thermochronometry to establish cooling history
• Eastern Grand Canyon
– Verified cooling/incision history
– Two step incision: pre 60 Ma & post 20 Ma
• Western Grand Canyon
– Reached 70-80% of its present depth by 70 Ma
– Data inconsistent with post 6 Ma incision
LOCATIONS OF SAMPLES
THE NEW EVIDENCE EASTERN GRAND CANYON WESTERN GRAND CANYON
THE LAST WORD (?)
“This history supports a model …[that]…has profound implications for the evolution of
topography, landscape, hydrology, and tectonism in the North American Cordillera”
R. M. Flowers and K. A. Farley Apatite 4He/3He and (U-Th)/He Evidence
for an Ancient Grand Canyon Science, 338 1616 2012
BUT THE BATTLE ISN’T OVER • Karl Karlstrom
– “The new data are interesting but they don’t change the big picture.”
– “It is simply ludicrous”
• Richard Young
– “Their calculation is really measuring the fact that the surface is being eroded backward”
– “Why do you have to say it’s the Grand Canyon?”
• Joel Pederson: “It is 6 million years old”
• Brian Wernicke: “Science is a succession of funerals for ideas that have been proven wrong.”
Mantle-driven dynamic uplift of the Rocky Mountains and Colorado Plateau and its surface
response: Toward a unified hypothesis
• Karl E Karlstrom
• Twenty three co-authors
• CREST Working Group
Lithosphere 4 3-22 2012