forwards response to ie bulletin 80-08, 'exam of ... › docs › ml1720 › ml17208a851.pdf ·...

14
P.O. BOX 529100, MIAMI,FL 33152 I I FLORIOA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY July 8, 1980 L-80-215 Mr. James P. O'Reilly, Director, Region II Office "of Inspection and Enforcement U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 101 Marietta Street, Suite 3100 Atl anta, Georgi a 30303 Dear fir. O'Reilly: Re RI I: JPO 50-335 If Bulletin 80-8 A reply to the subject Bulletin is attached. Very truly yours, Robert E. Uhrig Vice President Advanced Systems & Technology REU/MAS/paf Attachment cc: Director, Division of Reactor Construction Inspection Harold F. Reis, Esquire 80072503(2- PEOPLE... SERVING PEOPLE

Upload: others

Post on 03-Feb-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • P.O. BOX 529100, MIAMI,FL 33152

    II

    FLORIOA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

    July 8, 1980L-80-215

    Mr. James P. O'Reilly, Director, Region IIOffice "of Inspection and EnforcementU. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission101 Marietta Street, Suite 3100Atlanta, Georgi a 30303

    Dear fir. O'Reilly:

    Re RI I: JPO50-335If Bulletin 80-8

    A reply to the subject Bulletin is attached.

    Very truly yours,

    Robert E. UhrigVice PresidentAdvanced Systems & Technology

    REU/MAS/paf

    Attachment

    cc: Director, Division of Reactor Construction InspectionHarold F. Reis, Esquire

    80072503(2-PEOPLE... SERVING PEOPLE

  • ATTACHMENT

    Re: RII JPO50-335IKE BULLETIN 80-08

    EXAMINATION OF CONTAINii1ENT LINERPENETRATION MELDS

    The subject 18E Bulletin requested data on Non Destructive Examination (NDE)performed on full penetration butt welds made between containment penetrationassemblies and the penetration sleeve, and penetration assembly flued head toouter sleeve welds. Figures 1 and 2, attached, illustrate the types ofpenetration assemblies utilitized at St. Lucie Unit ¹l. Note that containmentboundary butt welds have been identified on Figures 1 and 2, and consist offield welds made during construction and shop welds made by the penetrationassembly fabricator, Tube Turns Division of Chemetron Corporation.

    The date of issue of the Purchase Order with Tube Turns was June 30, 1971.Fabrication of the penetration assemblies and shop welding was done inaccordance with ASNE Section III, 1971 Edition. The design specification forthe assemblies and manufacturers and fabrication drawi ngs both requiredRadiography (RT) as the method for NDE in accordance with the code. TubeTurns has been contacted and has assured that no exception was taken on anyassembly to the RT examination requirements (see Tube Turns letter dated6/2/80, attached).

    The following and Table 1, attached, are our responses to the action itemsenumerated in'he subject Bulletin and are directed to the field welds only:1. Penetration assemblies affected are as listed in Table 1 and illustrated

    in Figures 1 and 2.

    2a. Although issue of the Construction Permit allowed the use of ANSI B31.1,St. Lucie Unit ¹1 committed to compliance with ANSI B31.7, 1968 Editionwith 1969 Winter Addenda for construction. Acceptance standards for non-destructive examination (NDE) were in accordance with the draft ASHESection III, 1968 Edition with 1969 Winter, Addenda.

    2b. Type of NDE performed as per attached Table l.2c. Type of weld joints and joint details as per attached Table l.2d. Results of NDE as per attached Table l.3. Radiographic examination of full penetration circumferential butt welds in

    penetration assemblies which are part of the containment pressure boundaryis required per, code. However, when the joint detail does not permitradiographic examination such as on complex-designed mechanicalpenetrations, due to access limitations and/or geometric unsharpnessfactors, ultrasonic examination plus liquid penetrant or magneticparticulate examination may be used in lieu of radiography (reference ASNESection III, NE 5211.1). This option was exercised on approximately 50$

  • of the weld joints listed in Table 1, since ultrasonic examination is, bycode, an acceptable alternate to radiography for volumetric examination ofopen root type butt welds.

    A major concern in using ultrasonic exami nation for open root butt welds isthat if a backing ring is used during welding, it may distort the results ofthe examination in the root area. The welds listed on the attached Table andall shop welding were done without the use of backing rings or bars except inthe case of penetrations P-40, P-64, and P-33. As part of the final repairwelds to these penetrations in order to preclude additional weld-inducedresidual stresses, backing strips were used for sections of the welds and thewelds were accepted by ultrasonic examination. The welds in Penetrations P-40

    . and P-64 were examined by radiographic exami nation during a recent plantoutage and were accepted.

    Penetration P-33 is for the containment sump suction piping and is one ofthree Type IV penetration assemblies (see Figure 1). The weld in question islocated in the reactor auxiliary building pipe tunnel and would be extremelydifficult to RT without disassembling the penetration. Therefore it isimpractical to RT P-33. There is a high level of confidence in the integrityof the weld, however, based on the results of RT on P-40 and P-64. The threepenetrations were all assembled and inspected in accordance with the samecodes and procedures during plant construction. For these reasons, we areconvinced of the integrity of the weld and no radiographic examination hasbeen scheduled for P-33.

  • FIELD OP WELD

    ~ ~

    ~ ee ~ 0 Ova~ LVO «0 ~

    ~oooo reaaa «o eoo~of»~fool eoo +

    'f OOT laor

    O

    ~oov«pa a»a~I» ~ 1 ~~f~ oo ~ ~~0» ~OVP

    TICIIoolvo» «loo

    ~ 1 ~~a ~ aa'Ia»OO«O»oo

    Dv oael ~~1 ~ ~ Ioaeepv

    40»aeC ~ IOICCaco»l aevaN»1

    ~CO

    ~ aa ao

    Tc«oo»OCT cca» RI»4f00 Dlealalla

    ~» ae ~ O II0 alt»D~«4 40»401

    aooaeT ~ 5

    Roe»0 oeooopa»444

    Iaa 04tat ~ oeCIICLI

    ~ 0

    OICT»Ia 10OTftl~ I» 0000

    ~o 0 oo~cato leo OLT0 4

    0

    OA CONC ~ 0 oa)~ OL~ «aat

    OCT «CI ~ 4VCtaa

    ANCHOR RING

    ~1441.Coaro evotpt

    ~o 4I0 al

    SHOP WELD

    ao Oaara

    ~ OCIA I ~P la

    a«aataoo~»avf ~~f~ 1 ~ a

    ~ ~ L' «cavo af 1 ~ 1 ~arvev ~af \aa ~~\O aoea '

    ~ ~PA ~ aaf 0 4 ~,0

    FIELD WELD

    +0~a'ToahOV~ aat cato tall 0 la Ia«14

    FIGURE. 1: TYPE I III &- IV PENETRATIONS

  • FIELD WELD

    SHOP WELDr

    Jetet ~ ~ T,4 tvt~ ~ l

    FIELD WELD--

    ~ Ias to eh\east aNtarahlpf~tell lhp tto 4&\4v etttaeaeha'laatas ~ ll a Pret h ~apt Iaovaap ~ th ~ 4aathhtvh CS

    ~SOJOIJ~ Isea i

    Wetths fapses eh~ sl.~ catv, Itest ss

    r'/]Ke 'lea hsN ~ e ee

    ~e

    aeslo j~~fte tat10 t ~ tto ~ l ~

    Nh eN tto t\ to~tl lttt ~ evttaahoo

    JataOPJ

    e

    ffhtthhtaeh Js.ft lf J1 as. les $ )~e aah la ~ I etaathahptlaaett J

    ~s Iles~hIWtss

    gshea essf~ recta

    sq 4 setsf acts teNehsstaettss

    )Shit'I aeSOCJ lta4haS etN 1 fhstSS

    ~M4ho vavSlhfts~rf ehshttafes~ag trt o

    her I

    JJ 4~t l ~ a. ~OT t\$ tt)

    ~ x r4 %5%4 hts tf

    t~hasf vvs m

    ~seS,thah) eatt44

    Ner,'IELD

    WELD

    .'IELDWELDI~ ha\ ' tet

    fv

    rsPha elf

    (4~rt Il te

    cthe ovrfIpeaas It t~~ t ~ e ~

    /t,~

    fte~Met

    ~oahaa Neth seso~a» tpra ~

    fJ~\~tar~steat eetll 4

    ~a ~ teNets ~ I eso steal Nato ~~ tee s

    * T:

    ~ e PtsllalhTPh

    ~NtI~ Vhtahf Pv

    ~ hsh stafsat~4 Sf ffaltss ~ eel,elfsal f el 4 etttttatso

    Jaaeea J

    ' ~ thea

    A PROCESS PIPE WELDED TO PENETRATION B GUARD PIPE WELDED TO PENETRATION

    FIGURE 2: TYPE II PENETRATIONS FOUR DESIGNS

  • Tube Turns DivisioncHEhtElRON CORPOAAnc'.V

    Box 32160. Louisville. Kentucky 40232Telephone 502 774.6011

    June 2, 1980

    ECElVEJUAt 4 1980

    KBCKO ENQIMEERi%

    Ebasco Services IncorporatedSt. Lucie Plants 1 and 2P. 0. Box 1117Jensen Beach, Florida 33457

    Attention: T. A. Tarte, Project Engineer

    Tube Turns fabricated Containment Piping Penetration Assemblies forSt. Lucie Plants 1 and 2 on Purchase Order HY-422564 from EbascoServices Incorporated acting as age'nt .for Florida Power And Light.

    For this contract, all butt welds joining the containment sleevepipe to the multiple flued forging and all butt welds within thecontainment sleeve were subjected to 100% radiographic examinationand found to be satisfactory to specification requirements.

    Respectfully,

    S. D. VitatoeManager, Quality Assurance

    /gjb

  • ~~, ~ .' 'c ~ V~V ~ r ~EBA5CO 5ERV1CE5 INCORPORATED

    PKV.NO,

    PEN,TYPE

    SERVICE LHLDNG,

    ESASCO O,DMELD PROC, (IN+)

    IHICX,(IN,)

    FLORIDA POIlER & LICHT COHPANY

    tt osccv ST. LUCIE UNIT NO. 1 bhCFJITsursccv~IIUE TION C CONTAlh".CNT PENETRATION MELDS

    SACERI

    RING I~ NDE PERPORHED

    ops Ito PLO 5822 196

    cttcctcco os

    ~S- 0ossc

    RESULIS OP EXhGHATICI

    P-1 I llhIN STEAN FM IC MP-100 60,0 1,2$ REJECTED C: l'T fOR EXIKSSIVK LI:ZARDEFECTS ~ REPAIRED AND REJECT& CX L'TFOR NORE DEFECTS ~ REPAIRED h'.1D ACCEI TEIION IllIRD UT,

    P"2 HAIN STEAN PM-IC bUTT MP 100 60.0 1,25 Nh RKJECTFD Cl UI FOR I.lliEAR DEFECTS ~ RKPAIRED AND ACCEPTED Ci SKCQtD UT.

    P 3 I FEEDMAIKR FM-IC MP 100 45,0

    ~ I

    1.25

    I

    ~1

    SKVLl AREAS REJECTED C'IRST UT 3-13-75,RKPhlkKD h:RI TVO APEAS REJKCTLD C COVD UI 4 22 751 REPAIRED ASD ACCEPTEDON THlRD UT 5-I-75+

    FEED'MATER FM 1C MP-100 4$ .0' 1.251

    CS, Nh X Nh REJECTKD OH UT 3 18 7$ , REPAIRED AHibTMO AREAS kEJECTED Cl UF '-22 75 ~ REPAIRED ASD hCCEPTED Ci UT 5 1 75

    P-51

    1

    P 6

    I

    III BLOMDOMN

    III SLOMDOMN

    FM-I

    PM 1

    MP-100'

    II

    lMP 100l

    I

    I

    10,7$

    IOt75

    0,594

    I

    0.$ 94

    ~ I

    lCS "

    I

    i !

    Nh NA

    REJECTED Ci UT 7-27-75 FOR DEFECT ISROOT AT CiE POINT (APPR(N, 1" LCiC),REPAIRED AND ACCEPIED OH UI 8 24 75 ~

    RFJECTKD OH UT 7-26 7$ FOR EXCESSIVEROOT HILT IllkOUCH~ REPhlkED hiD ACCKPIIDdl UT 9 IS 7$ 1

    P-7 PRIHARY MATERSUPPLY

    FM-I BUTT MP-64 2,375t

    0.344 NA ACCEPTED,I

    A

    }M-1h SUTT MP-43 I 2.375 0.344 'SS ACCKPTED.

    IP-8 STATIOH AIR FM-1 MP»24 .

    II I

    2t375 0.344 CS:1 l

    I

    kFJKC'lED Cl RT 10 7 75 ~ REPAIREU NHIACCEPTED OH RT 10 28 7$ i

    P 9 INSTRUHENT AIR PM-1 MP-24 2,375 0.344 Nh Nh Nh . ACCEPTED.

    P-10 II

    SII0!IN

    HVAC~ 1

    48,0 1.0J CS i

    1 ~I

    NA ACCEPIKDa MELD bY HVAC CCiIRACTOR.

  • E8ASCO SERYlCES INCORPORATED a~car- 2 or 6

    cucor Fl ORIDA POMER 6 LICHT CCHPAHT~toltcr~ orc wo. FLO 5822.196 ocr r. ro.

    ~y H J DRIES otrt 5 8 80NRC BULLETIN 80 08: EXAHINATION OF COHTAINHENT PENETRATION MELDS TABLE 1 (CelZNUED) ciicciito oy otrt

    PEN,NOi

    Pl"I.TVPE

    SERVICE MELDNO,

    MELDTVPE

    EBASCOMELD PROC,

    O.D, THICK,(IH.) (IN.)

    BASEHETAL

    BACK,RING RT

    iNDE PERFOIOIED

    LPRESULTS Or mslSATICH

    P 11 IIVAC 48,0 1,00 NA Hh NA ACCEPIEO, MELD BT HVAC COSTRACTOR,

    P 14 HIIROCEHSUPPLY

    FM-1 MP 64.I

    2i37$ Oi218 IHCONEL Hh. Nh Nh ACCEPTED,

    FM-lh BUTT MP SOI 2,37S Oi344 SSI

    Hh Nh REJECTED AHD REPAIRED TACE ON RT,ACCEPTED OS THIRD RT.

    P 15 CCM FRIRI PAHCOOLER 1C

    FM 1 BUTT MP 24 8.62$ 0.322 CS, NA.l

    Nh NA ACCEPTED,

    P-16 CCM TO FAHCOOLER 1C

    FM I MP 24 iI

    Bi62$ Oi500 MELD NdIE AND ACCEPTED IEI RT 4~11~73,CUT ASD REMELLED LLE TO PIPiHiC HIEALIC:DIECT, ACCEPiED AQI i 0N R 5 25 73 ~

    P-17 CCM FRIPI FANCOOLER 1D

    MP-24 .I

    i

    8,62$ Oi 500 HhI

    Hh X ACCYI'1 LD,

    P-18

    P-19

    CCM TO FANCOOLER 1D

    CCM FROH FANCOOLER lh

    F'M 1

    FM 1

    MP-24 .I

    MP-24 .

    Bi62$ OiSOO CS

    ',62S

    O,SOO CS .

    HA

    Nh

    X9

    Nh X i ShvS AS P 16 (LXCEPZ FOR DA.ES) ~

    SA'.IE AS P-16 (EXCEPT FOR DATES) ~

    P 20 CCM TO FAHCOOLER 1A

    I

    MP-24!I

    I

    8 62S 0,500 SAIE AS P-16 (EXCEPT FOR DATES) ~~ ~

    P 21 CCM FR(PI FANCOOLER lb

    FM 1 MP 39 I Bi625 Oi500 CS Hh NA ACCEPTED,

    P 22 CCM TO FANCOOLCR 1B

    FM 1 MP 24

    I I

    Bi625I

    ~ ~

    0,500 CS .I

    XI

    HA SANE AS P 16 (EXCEPT FOR DATES) ~

    P-23 CCM TO R.C,PIDIPS

    FM 1 BVIT MP-39(

    I

    8.62S O,SOO

    i..I

    Nh. Nh ACCEPTEDi

  • - ~ ':r " I' '' ~ ~ ~ '- SESASCO SERVICES (JICORPORATEO ~ ter~'r

    ogygssr~@'f~(YIMKR~fglJ EX@PAST~IPJg JP{JJ h0~1»A RA~CKP

    ~~OJEEEELEELEE I IIA lil SP »INTA NNEIIT PBIETIIATISN NEESS ThbLE 1 (CONTINUED)

    ore wo. 0 22 I 6~ r IPRcssccsico or

    ~SS»oorc

    POI ~NO»

    FEH,TYPE

    SERVICE MKLDNO,

    MEI,DTYPE

    ebASCOMELD PROC,

    O,D.(IN.)

    THICK,(IN,)

    rbACK,RING

    RT HT LP

    NDE PERPOPHED

    VT

    RZSIILTS OP EKJA'ILNTIOS

    P PEAI CCM FROH R.C,PIMPS

    PM I MP 24A

    8.625 0»500 CS SAHE AS P 16 (EXCEPT fOR DATES) ~

    P 26 FM-I MP 100 .12 75 1 2$ NA REJECTED IXI UT 7-26~75 ~ RQ'AIRED ANNIACCEPTED OH UT 8 2$ -75,

    P 27 aIARCINC PM 1 MP-100 10 75 1.12$ CS REJECTED Ct UT 7-2S 7S» REPAIRED A ~ACCEI"JIJJ 0:l UT S-24-75 ~

    SAHP LING FM-1 MP-24 6,62S 0,432 CS 'Nh ACCEPTED,

    F29 II SAHPLIHC FM-I MP-IOOI

    6»62S 0 500 REJECTED FOUR TJHES lkl UT, REPAIRS JLIDEA:ID ACCEPTED OH FIFTH UT

    (P-So BLOMDOMH FM I MP 100,

    I6,625 0,500 CS-

    E

    REJECTED 0:I lit 7 29 7$ , REPAIPZD h:s3ACCEPTED ON UT 9 1$ 7S»

    P-SI COHTAIIZIEHTVENT IIEAMR

    PM-I DUTTE

    MP-64 2»375 0,218 IHCOHEL X ACCEPTED,

    I'2 IV LYPITAIJDEHTSIPIP SUCTION

    bUlT .I

    MP 100. 34,00

    34 00

    A

    1,500

    1,500 CS Nh

    X ACCEPTED

    S

    ACCEPTED (SHOP MELD bY CR6l) ~

    34,00 1,500 'CS NA X ACCEPTED (FIELD LKLD bY CS61) ~

    P-33 IV ODITAIIDIKNTSUMP SUCTION

    FM-II

    MP 100

    I

    34,00 1,500 ACS ;Nh Nh X T REJECTED A:ID REPAIREDI'I"E I'S IX'I

    ACCEPTED ON TE:ATH LT, FINAL REPAIRINCLUDED USE OF PARTJAJ. RAECKJ:A'0 RISC

    DUTY w ~ I 34.00 I 500 Nh ACCEPTED (SIIOP M~ bY CSLJ)~ .

    ~

    ~ ~ ~ ~

    34,00 1.500 CSI I

    E

    Nh ACCEPTED (FIELD MELD bY Cbli)~ ~

  • EBASCO SERVICES IIICORPORATEO s tc.r 4 or

    CLl ter OR DA

    e roster ST LUClK UNIT HO 1 ~ DACRFITt t 'r HRC bULl.KTIN 8 08 ~ EXAHINA ON OF COMTAIHHENT PENETRATION WELDS ThslJr. 1 (COHTINUED)

    ort wo.~r H J DRIEScl4tctto or

    ocrr. ao. ~~oart 5-8-80

    otrtPEN ~HO.

    PKN,TYPE

    SERVICE WELDNO

    WELD

    TYPEESASCO

    WELD PROC,O,D.(IN. )

    IHICK.(IN.)

    bASEHETAL

    SACK,RIND RI

    NDE

    UT

    PERPORHED

    HT

    RESULTS OF DJ'ILVAIION

    P 34h6 34b

    CONTAIHHENTSPRAY HEADER

    Cs 12/FW 1

    WP 60 10,75 0,250 INCONEL'IO SS

    HA ACCFFfED,

    CS-IS/FW I

    WP SO 12,75 0.250 Ss RUECTKD A%I REPAIRED TL'ICE, ACCEPTOV THIRD RT

    ' 35A6 3Sb

    COHTAINHEHTSPRAT HEADER

    Cs-13/FW 2

    WP 60 10.75 Or250 INCCNELTO SS

    ACCEPTEil.

    Cs 19/FW 1

    WP 50 12 '5 0.250 Ss ACCEPTED,

    P 36 SI MOP lh2 FW 1 bUTT WP 100 16,00 I 593 REJECTED el UT 7-28-75, REPAIRED AVDACCEPTED LV I.'I 8 25 75

    P 37 SI LOOP Ihl, FW-1 WP 100, 16 00 Ir593 'SI

    Nh NA REJECTED AVD REPAIRED V.: L'T INPr TL'KIFOURTH PEPAIR AND Uf ACCLPfKD,

    IP 38

    ISI LOOP Ibl FWrl I'P 100

    <16,00 1.593 , CS NA ,X Nh ACCEPTED,

    s o-39 SI LOOP lb2 WP-100 i 16.00 1,593 RUECTED OS UT 7 27 75, REPAIRED AQACCEPTED IP UI 8-24 75,

    P-40 SIIUTDOWHCOOLIHC

    FW I 'UIT ~ Il

    WP 100I

    24r00 Iron Cs I NA RUKCTKD AVD REPAIRED KIQIT TIHIS OS llACCKP1CD ON NlsfN Uf, FINIJ RK!'Alb lsCLUDEO USK OF PARTIAL AACRLVC F1SC,

    PWI III S,IrT, TEST PW 1'UTT WP-IOO I 8.625 Or 500 CSI i

    NAI

    RUECTED OV UT 7 24-75 ~ REPAIRED AVDACCEPIKO OS Ur 8-21-75.

    P 42 CONT*INN ENTSUHP PIIIPDISCNARCE

    FW 1 UP&4 . 3r50

    II

    0 300 INCCIIEL Hh

    I I

    Nh REJECTED AHD REPAIRED iÃICE OV RT, ACCKPIKD CI 1HIRD Rf, LK' CL'I AVD frLDSKDUK TO Pll'1"G HISPLIC'a M;I RK.'KCTrb A"'REPAIRED Il'aCS AND ACCKP1KU CV F1SAC E:

  • ~ ~iiil

    E8ASCO SERVICES It(CORPORATED

    ~ 4

    l~lC' .'rcvas,v FLORIDA POWER 6 LICHT CtbtPANT gQ FLO 5872 ~ 196 OCr V. ~ O. 531

    ~ IIOJCCT

    SVOJCCT

    C CEK

    VRC RULLETIH 80-08 EKAttTNATttbt OF CONTAINNENT PENETRATION WELDS TASLE 1 (CONTINUED) CHCCIECO OT DJTC

    PEH,NO,

    PEH,TYPE

    SERVICE MELDHO.

    ESASCOMELD PROC,

    OiD.(IN,)

    THICK,: RASE(IN ) ttETAL

    bhCK.RING RT

    NDE PERPORHED

    NT VT

    RESULTS OF EFJttlNATITEt

    IV REACTOR DRAINPetP SUCTION

    PM~2 ltP-76

    WP 24

    8,625

    8,625

    0.500

    Oi500

    INCOHEL'IO CS

    NA Nh

    RtJECTED tbt RT 10 9 72 ~ REPAIFLDACCEPIED ON RT 10-13 72,

    ACCEPTED,

    PQ.5 bUTT MP 24, 8.625 0.500 CS Nh NA Nh ACCEPT ED,

    PM RCP RI.EEDOFF FM I MP 100 6.625 Oi432 CS ltA REJECTED tent UT 7 29 75 ~ REPAIRED A!iDACCEPTLD Ott UT 8 24 75

    'P 45 TNSTRVHFNTTUblttC

    PM~I WPi100 2i375 0,344 CS

    I

    ltA REILCTEO TMlCE Ott LT FOR SVRt'ALE tOtOLITREPAIRED AHD ACCEPTED tbt 'DllRD L ~

    REFUELINO CAV,PURIP INLET

    FM 1 bUIT MP 68 „ 6,625 0,432 CS TOSS

    ACCEPTED,

    P-47 REFlJELINO CAV,PVRIF, OVILET

    FM-1 SUIT WP 72 ~ 5,563 0,625 INCONELTO SS

    Nh ACCEPTED,

    P-48 Et STRVNENTTV SIN 0

    FW-I MP-100 6.625 0,719 CS ACCEPTED,

    ~ P 49 SLOMDOtN FW-1 SUIT WP-100 6,625 Oi 500 CS Nh REJECTED et IJT 7i29 7S, REPAIRED h!TDACCEl'TED Ott 8T 9-15-7Si

    IP 51 FHSTRUHCttT

    IUbINGWP 24 6i625 0,500 NA Nh ACCE~ ~

    P 52

    I

    IP-53

    IHSIRVttENTTUSINC

    INSTR tbt EttTTvblltc

    Flt-1

    FM 1

    WP100'P

    100I

    12.00

    di625

    Oi500

    0,500

    Nh

    Nh.

    NA X

    ltA

    ACCEPTED

    RFJECTED TPt VT 7-25 75 ~ REPAIRED AQACCEPTED CN UT 8 24-7S.

  • EBASCO SERVICES IHCDRPCRATED

    ca,a ~ aar FLORIDA POHER & LIOlT COHPANT

    ~ aaofgor ST LUCIE UNIT NO 1 ~ BACKFITop/ ato PIO S822 196

    oy M J DRIES

    ~ aal

    okra 5-8-KO

    PEN,NO,

    PEN,TVPE

    SERVICE HELDNO.

    EBASCOHELD PROC,

    O.D.(>N.)

    ggoggor 'NRC BULLETIN 80 08'XAHINATIONOP COITAIIblENT PENETRATION HELDS

    THICK.(IN,)

    BACK,RING

    RT UT

    TABLE 1 (CONTINUED)

    PERFORHED

    caascaaco oy oar+

    RESULTS OF maLWTION

    P S6 HVAC CV 12/FM-3

    HP-24 '2,375 0 218 CSaI

    NA ACCEPTED+

    P-57 HVAC CV-2/FQ 1

    HP-24 2,375 0,218 . HAa

    NA ACCEPTED

    P-SB CV 10/FQ 1

    WP 24 2,375 0,218 'CS Nh NA HA ACCKPIED,

    P-64 SNVTDOHNCOOLING

    FH-1' MP-100 aa

    24+00I

    I

    1,00 CS '

    a

    Nh, lEJECTED AND REPAIRED FOUR TIYES a; L ~'aCCEPTED a FIYIll UI. FI!IAL PAMPA RINCLUDED USE OF PARTIAL BACKING P.I!'G

    ~ ~

    ~ ~

    l aa

    ~ I

    ~ ~

    Ia

    I !~ ~

    a

    a

    a

    a I I

    a

    .; I. Ia

    Ia

    II"

    II.

    a ~

    a

    ~ ~

    Ij

    I

    IIa

    Ia

    a

    '

    , I

    )I

    II

    ~a

    a

    tj ~

    a

    a

    I

    a

    Ia

    a

    a

    ~ ~

  • 1

    ltI

    J ~

    Jk(