flexibility of nucleic acid structures investigated by ... · structure and flexibility of nucleic...

37
Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by Pulsed EPR Biophysik Ringvorlesung 2017 Thomas Prisner

Upload: others

Post on 08-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures

Investigated by Pulsed EPR

Biophysik Ringvorlesung 2017

Thomas Prisner

Page 2: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Structural Characterizations ofMembrane Proteins

Conformational flexibility of NA

Hyperpolarized NMR Spectroscopy

New Methods for EPR spectrocopy

CRC 807 CRC 902

SPP 1601, DFG/ANR

EU, DIP, DFG

BMRZ

DFG

DNP for MRI

Page 3: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Structural Characterizations ofMembrane Proteins

Conformational flexibility of NA

Hyperpolarized NMR Spectroscopy

New Methods for EPR spectrocopy

CRC 807 CRC 902

SPP 1601, DFG/ANR

EU, DIP, DFG

BMRZ

DFG

DNP for MRI

Conformational flexibility of NA

Page 4: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids

Page 5: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids

Nature Protocol (2007)

NAR (2007)Angewandte (2009)

Phys. Rev. E (2009)

Joachim Engels

(Uni Frankfurt) Snorri Sigurdsson

(Uni Iceland)

Page 6: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Magnetic Dipol-Dipol Interaction between spin-labels

B0

2 2

3 31 3cos ( ) 1 3cos ( )

eff eff

s I s Idip

SI SI

g g

r r

dip

Page 7: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

B0

B0

Magnetic dipole-dipole interaction between two spin labels

Page 8: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

B0

B0

Magnetic dipole-dipole interaction between two spin labels

Page 9: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

B0

B0

Magnetic dipole-dipole interaction between two spin labels

Page 10: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

B0

B0

Magnetic dipole-dipole interaction between two spin labels

Page 11: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Dipolar PakePattern

Width < MHz

Frozen Sample with random orientation of molecules

Page 12: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Randomly oriented powder sample

Page 13: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

N

Ox

y

z

B0

B0

0.3 T

6.4 T

Hyperfine

dominated

G-Tensor

dominated

EPR linewidth of nitroxide spin labels

Page 14: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Select only small g value

Page 15: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Select only large g-value

Page 16: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

t0

t1

t1

t2

t2

t3

t3

time

mic

row

ave

ECHOFID

t0

Pulsed EPRHahn Echo sequence

Refocusing technique eliminates inhomogeneous linewidth

Page 17: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Pulsed EPRHahn Echo sequence

Refocusing technique eliminates inhomogeneous linewidth

Page 18: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Pulsed EPRHahn Echo sequence

Pulse on coupled spin brakesthe symmetry – less refocusing!

Page 19: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

PELDOR Time Trace oscillates with dipolar frequency

B (Pump Spin)

A (Probe Spin)

rAB

B0

0 1000 2000 3000 4000 50000.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

1 2 3 4 5 6Distance [nm]

No

rma

lize

d E

ch

o A

mp

litu

de

t [ns]

1

3

2cos31~

cos)cos(~)(

AB

dip

dip

r

dttS

/2 A

B

t

Page 20: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

/2 A

B

t

2 Dimensional Experimental Procedure

2D Dataset

JMR 2016

Page 21: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Unique pattern for a given distance / geometry

Page 22: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

PELDOR Database

PCCP 2013

Simulated Multi-Frequency / Multi-Field Datasets for each orientation and distance (conformer)

Page 23: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

PCCP 2013

Unique solution found with single conformerDistance & Orientation

Test of method with rigid planar biradical

Page 24: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

2D SIFTER experiment using broadband pulses

4 pulse PELDOR/DEERwith several probe frequencies

Broadband SIFTER with FT of Echo signal

Page 25: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

11 samples with variable distance between both spinlabelshave been synthesized and measured

Investigation of dynamics of dsDNA

Page 26: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Stretching

Bending

Twisting

Dx2 ~ L

Simple modes of dynamics of dsDNA

Page 27: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Bending Twisting Stretching (Δα) Δr Δh

Models for conformational dynamics of dsDNA

Page 28: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

2D-PELDOR datasets and best model fits at 0.3 T

Page 29: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Single molecule fluoreszenz

Gore et al. Nature (2006)

SAXSI

Mathew-Fenn et al. Science (2008)

Modeling

Becker et al. Science (2009)

Models for conformational dynamics of dsDNA

The radius changing modefits best our experimental data but with a 10 timessofter streching module

JACS 2011

Page 30: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Comparison with MD simulations of dsDNA

Established Force Field parmbsc0

New Force Fields Parmbsc1 and OL15

Collaboration withG. Hummer(MPI Biophysics, Frankfurt)

JACS 2017

Page 31: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Microinjection Spin label concentration: 2 mM Sample size for EPR: 50 oocytes

Collaboration with Volker Dötsch (Uni Frankfurt)Angewandte 2011

Stacking of dsDNA in cells observed

In-cell application is possible

Page 32: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

PELDOR Experiments at Room Temperature

40 K experiment

MD ‚powder‘

MD ‚averaged‘

RT PELDOR data

Page 33: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

NMR structure from NOE‘sDornberger et al. Biochem. 38, 12860 (1999)

Investigation of DNA with A-buldge

Page 34: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Investigation of DNA with A-buldge

Page 35: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Investigation of DNA with A-buldge

PCCP 2017

Page 36: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Investigation of cocaine binding aptamer

cocaine binding

PCCP 2015

Page 37: Flexibility of Nucleic Acid Structures Investigated by ... · Structure and Flexibility of Nucleic Acids Nature Protocol (2007) NAR (2007) Angewandte (2009) Phys. Rev. E (2009) Joachim

Burkhard Endeward, Vasyl Denysenkov, Andriy Marko, Claudia Grytz, Nicole Erlenbach, Markus Gränz, Thilo Hetzke

Dominik Margraf , Ivan Krstic, Olav Schiemann

Snorry Sigurdsson (Iceland)Lukas Stelzl, Gerhard Hummer (MPI Biophysik, Frankfurt)Beatrice Suess (Darmstadt)Peter Günthert (Biophysical Chemistry, Frankfurt)

Acknowledgements / Coworkers

FCI

SFB902