final proposal2 - pennsylvania state university · !’r(")2)3)f"&8$0)n’0.&t)...
TRANSCRIPT
!!
!
!
!
!
!
"#$!%$&&'()*+&,+!-.+.$!/&,*$0',.(!
1$+).#!+&2!134+&!5$*$)674$&.!83,)2,&9!
:#0,'.67#$0!;0+<,+&,!
:6&'.03=.,6&!
!
!
"#$%&!'()*)+%&!
,-.-/0-(!123!4516!
789#+-(!!!:(%#;!,<0&-(!
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&& ,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 78-91."4-&:122$(;&
&
!"#$%&'(#)*%++,-.)
</-&'-##&:.$.-&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6&"+&=-"#6&
9)#+.(19.-0&)#&$&4-(;&."6/.&+".-&>"./&2$#;&*).-#."$%&+9/-01%-&("+?+@&A"./&$&+.()#6&
*()B-9.&9)2*%-.")#&.1(#)4-(&0$.-C&".&"+&"2*-($."4-&.)&$#$%;D-&*()=%-2$."9&$(-$+&.)&
-#+1(-&./$.&./-&*()B-9.&"+&#).&*1.&=-/"#0&+9/-01%-@&A"./&2$#;&".-2+&)#&./-&9("."9$%&
*$./&)E&./-&+9/-01%-C&./-(-&$(-&21%."*%-&$(-$+&)E&9)#9-(#&.)&/"#0-(&./-&+9/-01%-&
*()6(-++")#@&F%)#6&>"./&./-&+9/-01%-C&./-&)>#-(G+&2$B)(&9)#9-(#+&"#9%10-&H1$%".;C&
9)+.C&$#0&+$E-.;@&</-&)=B-9."4-&)E&./"+&./-+"+&*()*)+$%&"+&.)&$00(-++&./-+-&"++1-+&$#0&
E"#0&>$;+&.)&$99-%-($.-&./-&+9/-01%-&>/"%-&?--*"#6&./-&*()B-9.&1#0-(&=106-.&$#0&
2$"#.$"#&H1$%".;&./()16/&./-&"#4-+."6$.")#&)E&E)1(&$#$%;+"+&$(-$+@&&
&
</-&E"(+.&$#$%;+"+&>"%%&$00(-++&./-&"++1-&9)#9-(#"#6&./-&9)#9(-.-&+/-$(&>$%%&
+.$"(&.)>-(@&</"+&$#$%;+"+&>"%%&=-&*-(E)(2-0&.)&(-0-+"6#&+.$"(&.)>-(&F&"#.)&$&+.--%&
=($9-0&E($2-@&</"+&*()*)+-0&$#$%;+"+&>)1%0&$99-%-($.-&./-&+9/-01%-C&"2*()4-&
H1$%".;&)E&./-&*()019.C&$#0&(-019-&+$E-.;&9)#9-(#+@&</"+&0-*./&$(-$&>"%%&=-&1."%"D-0&
$+&2;&+.(19.1($%&=(-$0./&$+&=-$2&+"D"#6&>"%%&#--0&.)&=-&*-(E)(2-0@&
&
</-&+-9)#0&$#$%;+"+&>"%%&E)91+&)#&./-&9))(0"#$.")#&)E&+;+.-2&"#+.$%%$.")#&"#&
./-&$.("12@&</-&$.("12&>"%%&=-&-8.(-2-%;&9)#6-+.-0&01("#6&./-&9)#+.(19.")#&*/$+-@&I.&
>"%%&=-&"2*-($."4-&.)&$(($#6-&./-&+-H1-#9"#6&)E&./"+&$(-$&+19/&./$.&+$E-.;&$#0&
-EE"9"-#9;&9$#&=-&2$8"2"D-0@&</-&$#$%;+"+&>"%%&"#9%10-&$&J3&+9/-01%-&0-*"9.")#&$#0&
0"EE-(-#.&)*.")#+&>"%%&=-&-8*%)(-0@&A"./&$&21%."K*("2-&9)#.($9.C&./-(-&>"%%&=-&2$#;&
0"EE-(-#.&+1=9)#.($9.)(+&>)(?"#6&)#&+".-&$.&)#9-@&L))(0"#$.")#&)E&./-+-&.($0-+&>"%%&
=-&9("."9$%@&&
&
F#$%;+"+&M&>"%%&"#4-+."6$.-&*).-#."$%&)*.")#+&.)&0-$%&>"./&$&4-(;&."6/.&9-"%"#6&
+*$9-@&F&4-(;&9)2*%-8&N7'&+;+.-2&/$+&=--#&"2*%-2-#.-0&"#.)&./"+&*()B-9.@&</-&
*()*)+-0&+)%1.")#&.)&./"+&"+&$&(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12@&</"+&+;+.-2&>"%%&(-2)4-&$&%$(6-&
*"-9-&)E&019.>)(?&"#&./-&9-"%"#6C&=1.&".&>"%%&9$1+-&E)(&%$(6-(&E%))(K.)KE%))(&/-"6/.+&$#0&
(-H1"(-&$%%&2$.-("$%+&.)&=-&*%-#12&($.-0@&</"+&0-*./&>"%%&$%%)>&2-&.)&-8*%)(-&$&
2-9/$#"9$%&=(-$0./&.)&$#$%;D-&./-&L!N&(-H1"(-2-#.&)E&./-&(-.1(#&$"(&+*$9-@&&
&
</-&E"#$%&$#$%;+"+&>"%%&E)91+&)#&$%.-(#$."4-&-89$4$.")#&2-./)0+@&A/-#&./-&+)"%&
>$+&E)1#0&.)&=-&+)%"0&()9?C&./-&*()B-9.&.-$2&0-9"0-0&.)&1+-&()9?&-89$4$.")#&=%$+."#6&
.-9/#"H1-+&$+&)**)+-0&.)&./-&.($0".")#$%&()9?&/$22-("#6@&</"+&$#$%;+"+&>"%%&
9)2*$(-&./-+-&.>)&2-./)0+&)E&-89$4$.")#&$#0&0-.-(2"#-&./-&9)+.&+$4"#6+&$#0&
+9/-01%-&$99-%-($.")#@&O-+-$(9/&>"%%&$%+)&=-&*-(E)(2-0&.)&0-.-(2"#-&"E&)./-(&
2-./)0+&9)1%0&=-&1."%"D-0&.)&$99-%-($.-&./-&+9/-01%-&E1(./-(@&&
&
</-+-&$#$%;+-+&$(-&-8*-9.-0&.)&*()4"0-&*).-#."$%&+)%1.")#+&.)&./-&91((-#.&
"++1-+&)#&./-&*()B-9.&+".-@&</-&"#.-#.")#&)E&./-+-&$#$%;+-+&"+&.)&*()4-&./-&=-+.&
*)++"=%-&$99-%-($.")#&+9-#$(")+&>/"%-&2$"#.$"#"#6&9)+.&$#0&H1$%".;@&&
!"#$%&'()*)+$%& ,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 7$8%-&)9&:)#.-#.+&
&
!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&
&
7-;/#";$%&<#$%=+"+&3-+;("*.")#+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>&?&
& <#$%=+"+&?&@&A.$"(&7)B-(C<&D-0-+"6#>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>&?&
& <#$%=+"+&E&@&:))(0"#$.")#&)9&<.("12&A=+.-2+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>&F&
& <#$%=+"+&F&@&D-.1(#&<"(&'%-#12>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>&G&
& <#$%=+"+&H&@&<%.-(#$."4-&IJ;$4$.")#&K*.")#+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>&L&
<**-#0"J&<&C&5(-$0./&7)*";+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>&M&
<**-#0"J&5&@&A*("#6&A-2-+.-(&'()N-;.-0&7"2-.$8%->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>&??&
<**-#0"J&:&@&D-9-(-#;-+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>&?H&
&
&
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 7&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & 7&
!"#$%&#'()*%'(+,&,)-",#.&/0&1%,)
)
*%'(+,&,)2)3)40'&.)!15".3*)6"7",&8%)940.:#0:.'();."'70$<)&
& 8#-&)9&./-&2$:)(&*();%-2$."<&$(-$+&)#&./-&*():-<.&=$+&+.$"(&.)=-(&>?&@/"+&"+&$&
91%%&<$+.A"#A*%$<-&<)#<(-.-&+.$"(&.)=-(&./$.&"+&$<."#6&$+&$&+/-$(&=$%%&9)(&./-&+.(1<.1($%&
+.--%&+B+.-2?&@/-&"#+.$%%$.")#&)9&./"+&+.$"(&.)=-(&=$+&4-(B&.-0")1+&$#0&=$+&$&2$:)(&
+</-01%-&<)#<-(#?&C.&(-D1"(-0&+.("*&9)(2+E&./-&*%$<-2-#.&)9&(-;$(E&$#0&$&<)#<(-.-&
*12*&.(1<F&9)(&./-&<)#<(-.-&*)1(?&&8#&+".-E&".&=$+&(-D1"(-0&.)&/$4-&$&<)#<(-.-&*12*&
.(1<FE&$&<($#-E&$#0&$&GHI&%"9.&"#&)(0-(&.)&($"+-&./-&9)(2+&$#0&2$F-&./-&*)1(?&J).&)#%B&
0)-+&./"+&(-D1"(-&$&%$(6-&$2)1#.&)9&<))(0"#$.")#&)#&+".-E&;1.&$%+)&".&"+&$&2$:)(&+$9-.B&
<)#<-(#&9)(&<)#+.(1<.")#?&K/"%-&1*&)#&./-&9)(2+&"#+.$%%"#6&./-&(-;$(E&".&=$+&
"2*)(.$#.&.)&-#+1(-&./$.&./-&
*-(+)##-%&=$+&*()*-(%B&."-0&)99&
$#0&+.$#0$(0+&=-(-&2-.&9)(&
61$(0($"%&(-+.("<.")#+?&,)=-4-(E&
="./&./-&+.("*&9)(2+E&$&LMN&
61$(0($"%&(-D1"(-2-#.&<)1%0&#).&
;-&2-.&01-&.)&./-&/-"6/.&)9&./-&
+.$"(&.)=-(&9)(2+&$.&./-&
<)#<(-.-&*%$<-2-#.&/-"6/.?&@/"+&
=$+&$&2$:)(&+$9-.B&<)#<-(#&./$.&
/$0&.)&;-&2)#".)(-0&$#0&
$00".")#$%&(-+.("<.")#+&=-(-&
(-D1"(-0?&>%+)E&./-(-&"+&$%=$B+&$&
<)#<-(#&9)(&<($#-&+$9-.B&)#&+1</&
$&."6/.&+".-?&@/-&+</-01%-&"2*$<.+&
=-(-&+--#&"22-0"$.-%B&"#&./-&
9"(+.&%-4-%&<)#+.(1<.")#&)9&./-&+.$"(&.)=-(?&@/-&<)#+.(1<.")#&)9&./"+&+/-$(&=$%%&.))F&
%)#6&*-(")0+&)9&."2-?&@/"+&."2-&=$+&-+."2$.-0&.)&;-&$;)1.&7&=--F&*-(&%-4-%?&!"61(-&7&
*()4"0-+&$&4"+1$%&)9&./-&+"O-&$#0&0-.$"%&(-D1"(-0&9)(&./-&"#+.$%%$.")#&)9&./-&+.$"(&
.)=-(?&&
&
@/-&2$"#&9)<1+&)9&./-&)=#-(&)#&./"+&*():-<.&"+&./-&D1$%".B&)9&./-&;1"%0"#6&$.&
.1(#)4-(?&>9.-(&"#+.$%%$.")#&=$+&<)2*%-.-E&".&=$+&0"+<)4-(-0&./$.&./-(-&=-(-&"++1-+&
="./&./-&D1$%".B&)9&./-&.)=-(?&K/-#&+.--%&$(("4-0&)#&+".-E&$&+1(4-B&=$+&<)2*%-.-0&.)&
2$F-&+1(-&./$.&./-&+.$"(&.)=-(&=$+&"#+.$%%-0&<)((-<.%B&$#0&./$.&./-&+.--%&=)1%0&9".&"#&
*()*-(%B?&>9.-(&./-&+1(4-B&=$+&<)2*%-.-0E&".&=$+&9)1#0&./$.&./-&.)=-(&/$0&2"#"2$%&
.="+."#6&$+&".&6(-=&"#&/-"6/.?&!()2&./-&.)*&)9&./-&.)=-(&.)&./-&;)..)2E&".&=$+&)99&;B&
()16/%B&P&"#</-+?&@/"+&%-0&.)&"#<)((-<.&2$.</"#6&)9&+.--%&;-$2+?&Q)2-&*"-<-+&=-(-&
.))&+/)(.&$#0&+)2-&=-(-&.))&%)#6E&=/"</&<$1+-0&$00".")#$%&."2-&"#&./-&+</-01%-?&&
&
C#&)(0-(&.)&+)%4-&./-&<)#<-(#+&)9&+$9-.BE&+</-01%-E&$#0&D1$%".BE&C&$2&*()*)+"#6&
.)&</$#6-&./-&<)#<(-.-&+/-$(&=$%%&.)&$&+.--%&;($<-0&9($2-?&@/"+&=)1%0&(-01<-&+$9-.B&
<)#<-(#+E&$<<-%-($.-&./-&+</-01%-E&$#0&"2*()4-&D1$%".B?&R/$#6"#6&./"+&+.(1<.1($%&
Figure 1 Installation of Stair Tower A
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& M&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & M&
9-$.1(-&="%%&(-D1"(-&$#&$#$%B+"+&)9&=/$.&+"O-&;-$2+&$#0&<)%12#+&=)1%0&;-&(-D1"(-0&
.)&+1**)(.&./-&9)(<-+&9()2&./-&(-+.&)9&./-&+.(1<.1($%&+.--%&+B+.-2&$+&=-%%&$+&<(-$."#6&
$(-$+&=/-(-&./-&+.$"(+&<$#&;-&."-0&"#&.)&./-&+.(1<.1(-?&@/"+&$%.-(<$.")#&="%%&#).&6-.&("0&
)9&$%%&+$9-.B&<)#<-(#+E&$+&$&<($#-&="%%&+."%%&#--0&.)&;-&1+-0&)#&+".-?&,)=-4-(E&./-&
$2)1#.&)9&-D1"*2-#.&./$.&="%%&;-&(-D1"(-0&="%%&;-&+"6#"9"<$#.%B&2"#"2"O-0&$+&=-%%&$+&
./-&2$#*)=-(?&@/-(-&="%%&;-&+"6#"9"<$#.&+</-01%-&$04$#<-2-#.&;B&"2*%-2-#."#6&
./"+&+B+.-2?&>&<)2*$("+)#&)9&."2-&(-D1"(-2-#.+&9)(&./-&.=)&+B+.-2+&="%%&;-&
*-(9)(2-0&.)&+--&/)=&21</&."2-&".&<)1%0&+$4-&)#&./-&+</-01%-?&&>%+)E&$&<)+.&
<)2*$("+)#&<)1%0&;-&*-(9)(2-0&./$.&$#$%BO-+&./-&+.(1<.1($%&2-2;-(+&./$.&="%%&;-&
*%$<-0&<)2*$(-0&.)&./-&<)#<(-.-E&$+&=-%%&$+&-D1"*2-#.&."2-&(-D1"(-0&.)&*-(9)(2&./-&
$<."4"."-+?&&
&
@/-&$#$%B+"+&)9&./-&+.(1<.1($%&+.--%&2-2;-(+&./$.&=)1%0&;-&(-D1"(-0&.)&
+1;+.".1.-&./-&<)#<(-.-&+/-$(&=$%%&=)1%0&$<.&$+&2B&+.(1<.1($%&;(-$0./&9)(&2B&+*("#6&
./-+"+&*():-<.?&@/"+&="%%&;-&$&4-(B&</$%%-#6"#6&;(-$0./&.)&"#4-+."6$.-&$+&".&="%%&(-D1"(-&
$#&"#&0-*./&+.(1<.1($%&$#$%B+"+&9)(&./-&+.--%&9($2-?&C#&)(0-(&.)&$<<)2*%"+/&./"+&
$#$%B+"+E&./-(-&="%%&;-&21%."*%-&+)1(<-+&./$.&C&="%%&#--0&.)&<)#+1%.?&@/-&9"(+.&*-(+)#&
./$.&C&=)1%0&+--F&)1.&.)&0"+<1++&./"+&"0-$&=)1%0&;-&./-&+.(1<.1($%&-#6"#--(&)9&./-&
*():-<.?&C&=)1%0&#--0&.)&6-.&./-&+.(1<.1($%&%)$0+&./$.&$(-&;-"#6&*1.&)#&./-&<)#<(-.-&
+/-$(&=$%%&;B&./-&+.(1<.1($%&+.--%?&@/-&#-S.&*-(+)#&./$.&C&=)1%0&<)#+1%.&=)1%0&;-&$#&
"#01+.(B&2-2;-(&./$.&+*-<"$%"O-+&"#&+1;+.".1."#6&<)#<(-.-&+/-$(&=$%%+&="./&+.--%&
;($<-0&9($2-+?&@/"+&"+&+)2-)#-&./$.&C&/$4-&2-.&./()16/&#-.=)(F"#6&$#0&=)1%0&;-&
$;%-&.)&$++"+.&2-&"#&./-&+.-*A;BA+.-*&*()<-++?&H$+.%BE&".&=)1%0&;-&;-#-9"<"$%&.)&2--.&
="./&./-&6-#-($%&<)#.($<.)(&THQ!U&"#&)(0-(&.)&-+."2$.-&./-&<)#+.(1<.")#&)9&./-&
<)#<(-.-&+/-$(&=$%%&$#0&.)&0-.-(2"#-&./-&-D1"*2-#.&./$.&=$+&(-D1"(-0?&&
&
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& P&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & P&
*%'(+,&,)=)>)6"34"?:"%#&%8)1@)*0.&:A)4+,0"A,)&
& >&2$:)(&<)#+.(1<.$;"%".B&<)#<-(#&9)(&./-&*():-<.&"+&+--#&"#&./-&$.("12&)9&./-&
;1"%0"#6?&@/-&2$:)(&"++1-&"#&./"+&$(-$&"+&./-&<)#<-(#&9)(&./-&2$.-("$%&9"#"+/-+&;-"#6&
"#+.$%%-0?&C#&./-&$.("12E&./-(-&="%%&;-&$&4-(B&-%$;)($.-&+.$"(<$+-&*1.&"#&*%$<-&$+&=-%%&
$+&$#&$(</".-<.1($%&+<(--#&
=$%%?&@/-&2$.-("$%&9"#"+/-+&)9&
;)./&)9&./-+-&+B+.-2+&(-D1"(-&
9)(&$&.-2*-(-0&-#4"()#2-#.E&
=/"</&=)1%0&2-$#&./$.&./-&
;1"%0"#6&=)1%0&#--0&.)&;-&
-#."(-%B&-#<%)+-0?&@/"+&
*(-+-#.+&$#&"++1-&="./&./-&
<)#+.(1<.$;"%".B&)9&./-+-&
+B+.-2+?&C#&)(0-(&.)&
$<<-%-($.-&./-&+</-01%-E&./-&
*():-<.&.-$2&/$+&-%-<.-0&.)&
<)#+.(1<.&;)./&)9&./-+-&
+B+.-2+&$.&./-&+$2-&."2-?&>+&
+--#&;B&!"61(-&ME&./"+&="%%&;-&
$&4-(B&</$%%-#6"#6&$(-$&01-&.)&
./-&<))(0"#$.")#&./$.&="%%&;-&
(-D1"(-0&"#&+1</&$&."6/.&+*$<-?&>#)./-(&"++1-&"+&/)=&./-&=))0&*$#-%+&="%%&;-&$;%-&.)&
;-&%"9.-0&"#.)&*%$<-?&@B*"<$%%BE&$&<($#-&=)1%0&;-&;()16/.&"#&$#0&./-&*(-9$;("<$.-0&
*"-<-+&="%%&;-&($"+-0&"#.)&*)+".")#?&,)=-4-(E&"9&./-&;1"%0"#6&#--0+&.)&;-&-#<%)+-0E&$&
<($#-&="%%&#).&;-&$;%-&.)&;-&1+-0?&>&+<"++)(&%"9.&/$+&;--#&-+.$;%"+/-0&.)&;-&./-&
$%.-(#$."4-&.)&/)"+.&./-&*$#-%+&"#.)&*%$<-?&Q<$99)%0"#6&="%%&$%+)&;-&*1.&"#&*%$<-&"#&
)(0-(&.)&"#+.$%%&./-&+<(--#&=$%%&$#0&9)(&)./-(&$<."4"."-+&.)&;-&*-(9)(2-0&$.&./-&+$2-&
."2-?&R))(0"#$."#6&=/-(-&./-&+<"++)(&%"9.&<$#&;-&*%$<-0&"#&;-.=--#&./-&+<$99)%0"#6&
="%%&;-&$&</$%%-#6-?&R)#6-+.")#&"#&./"+&$(-$&="%%&;-&"#<(-$+-&=/-#&+.$"(&R&"+&;-"#6&
"#+.$%%-0?&K/-#&./-&+.$"(+&$(-&*%$<-0E&./-&+%$.-&9"#"+/&="%%&;-&)#&./-&+.$"(+&$#0&="%%&
#--0&.)&;-&*(-+-(4-0?&Q)E&".&="%%&;-&<("."<$%&./$.&./-&9"#"+/-+&$(-&*().-<.-0&9()2&$#B&
)./-(&$<."4"."-+&.$F"#6&*%$<-&$9.-(&./-&+.$"(+&$(-&"#&*%$<-?&@/-&%$+.&"++1-&(-6$(0"#6&./"+&
$<."4".B&"+&+$9-.B?&K/-#&=)(F"#6&="./&%$(6-&*(-A9$;("<$.-0&*"-<-+E&".&"+&"2*)(.$#.&.)&
-+.$;%"+/&$&+B+.-2&./$.&=)(F+&"#&$#&-99"<"-#.&2$##-(&$#0&"+&+$9-&9)(&-2*%)B--+&.)&
"#+.$%%?&@/-&+<$99)%0"#6&-D1"*2-#.&="%%&;-&$&2$:)(&+$9-.B&<)#<-(#&$+&=)(F-(+&="%%&;-&
$.&./-&.)*&)9&./-&+<$99)%0"#6&=/"%-&)./-(&=)(F&="%%&;-&6)"#6&)#&1#0-(#-$./&./-2?&
>%+)E&./-&2$#-14-("#6&)9&./-&+<"++)(&%"9.&="%%&/$4-&.)&;-&<$(-91%%B&2)#".)(-0&.)&
-#+1(-&./$.&".&0)-+&#).&0"+.1(;&./-&+<$99)%0"#6&"#&$#B&=$B?&&
&
@/-&<)#+.(1<.$;"%".B&<)#<-(#+&(-%$.-0&.)&./-&"#+.$%%$.")#&)9&./-&+<(--#&=$%%&$#0&+.$"(&
R&"+&$#&$(-$&./$.&<)1%0&;-&91(./-(&$#$%BO-0?&@/"+&=)1%0&;-&$&<)#+.(1<.")#&;(-$0./&
./$.&9)<1+-+&)#&+-D1-#<"#6&)9&$<."4"."-+&"#+"0-&./-&$.("12?&C&;-%"-4-&./$.&0"99-(-#.&
+-D1-#<"#6&)*.")#+&<$#&;-&$#$%BO-0&"#&)(0-(&.)&-+.$;%"+/&./-&+$9-+.E&2)+.&-99"<"-#.E&
2-./)0&)9&"#+.$%%$.")#?&>#&$#$%B+"+&)9&./-&+</-01%-&9)(&01($.")#+&$#0&*(-0-<-++)(+&
B&8:.")=C))D&"5)1@)*0.&:A)-:.&%8)40'&.)E)'%7)4#.""%)F'(()
G%,0'(('0&1%))
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& L&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & L&
="%%&;-&(-D1"(-0&.)&+--&/)=&%)#6&+*-<"9"<&$<."4"."-+&$(-&$#."<"*$.-0&.)&.$F-&$#0&=/"</&
$<."4"."-+&<$#&;-&)4-(%$**-0?&@/"+&$#$%B+"+&/$+&./-&*).-#."$%&9)(&5CV&<))(0"#$.")#?&C&
;-%"-4-&./$.&$&L3&2)0-%&=)1%0&;-&4-(B&/-%*91%&
"#&./-&<))(0"#$.")#&*()<-++&$#0&=)1%0&;-&$&
6))0&=$B&)9&-S*%)("#6&0"99-(-#.&)*.")#+?&@/-&
*).-#."$%&.)&0)&./-&$<."4"."-+&+-*$($.-%B&=)1%0&
$00&."2-&.)&./-&+</-01%-E&/)=-4-(&".&2$B&-$+-&
./-&"#+.$%%$.")#&*()<-++E&$+&2)(-&())2&=)1%0&
;-&*()4"0-0&9)(&./-&=)(F-(+&.)&<)2*%-.-&./-"(&
.$+F+?&@/-(-&"+&$%+)&./-&*)++";"%".B&)9&+*%".."#6&
./-&$.("12&"#.)&O)#-+&=/-(-&./-&+B+.-2+&
<)1%0&;-&+-D1-#<-0&+)&;)./&.($0-+&<)1%0&=)(F&
$.&./-&+$2-&."2-E&;1.&+-*$($.-%B?&V$#B&
)*.")#+&<$#&;-&$#$%BO-0&"#&)(0-(&.)&0-("4-&./-&
2)+.&%)6"<$%&+)%1.")#?&!"61(-&P&+/)=+&=/$.&./-&
9"#"+/-0&*()01<.&"+&.)&$**-$(?&>+&"+&+--#E&./"+&
="%%&;-&$&2$:)(&$-+./-."<&9-$.1(-&"#&./-&$.("12&
+*$<-?&C#&./-&-#0E&".&2$B&;-&9)1#0&./$.&./-&
*%$#&$+&+</-01%-0&"+&./-&2)+.&%)6"<$%&0-<"+")#E&
;1.&".&="%%&;-&"#.-(-+."#6&.)&-S*%)(-&./-&
0"99-(-#.&=$B+&)9&<))(0"#$."#6&.($0-+&.)&
2$S"2"O-&-99"<"-#<B&$#0&+$9-.B?&
&
31-&.)&./-&9$<.&./$.&./"+&"+&$&21%."*%-&*("2-&<)#.($<.E&./-(-&="%%&;-&21%."*%-&
<)#.($<.)(+&*-(9)(2"#6&./"+&=)(F?&@/"+&$00+&.)&./-&"++1-&)9&<))(0"#$.")#&./$.&="%%&
#--0&.)&;-&(-D1"(-0?&@/-&<))(0"#$.")#&)9&0"99-(-#.&.($0-+&="%%&#--0&.)&;-&*()*-(%B&
2$#$6-0&$#0&2-2;-(+&9()2&-$</&.($0-&="%%&#--0&.)&;-&<)#.$<.-0&.)&-#+1(-&./$.&
./-"(&:);+&<$#&;-&0)#-&"#&<-(.$"#&+".1$.")#+?&C#&)(0-(&9)(&./"+&.)&;-&$&+1<<-++91%&
$#$%B+"+E&"#9)(2$.")#&(-6$(0"#6&2$#*)=-(E&-D1"*2-#.E&$#0&2$.-("$%+&="%%&#--0&.)&
;-&6$./-(-0&9()2&./-&0"99-(-#.&<)#.($<.)(+?&C.&="%%&;-&"2*)(.$#.&.)&1#0-(+.$#0&./-&
2-./)0&)9&<)#+.(1<.")#&$+&*%$##-0&+)&$+&.)&-#+1(-&./$.&./-&)./-(&)*.")#+&="%%&9)%%)=&
$&+"2"%$(&*()<-++&"#&./-&-(-<.")#&+-D1-#<-?&@/-&*-(+)#&.)&<)#.$<.&9)(&./"+&
"#9)(2$.")#&=)1%0&;-&./-&5CV&<))(0"#$.)(&)9&./-&*():-<.?&@/-(-&/$4-&;--#&<)#<-(#+&
$;)1.&./"+&$(-$&)#&./-&*():-<.&$%(-$0B&$#0&./-&5CV&<))(0"#$.)(&/$+&=)(F-0&="./&./-&
<)#.($<.)(+&.)&-#+1(-&./$.&./-&-D1"*2-#.&<$#&9".&"#+"0-&./-&;1"%0"#6&$#0&./-&*"-<-+&
<)1%0&;-&-(-<.-0&*()*-(%B?&G)/#&V-+#-(&="%%&;-&$&6))0&<)#.$<.&9)(&./"+&$#$%B+"+&$+&
=-%%?&C&*%$#&.)&2--.&="./&/"2&"#&./-&'-##&Q.$.-&CR8J&%$;&.)&<(-$.-&./-&L3&+</-01%-&)9&
./-&=)(F&"#&./"+&$(-$?&&
&
)
)
)
)
)
B&8:.")H)*0.&:A)B&%&,$",)6"%7".&%8)
I;1$(&%)E+5&%,J&)K'#J,1%L)
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& W&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & W&
*%'(+,&,)H)3)6"0:.%)*&.)M("%:A)9N"#$'%&#'();."'70$<)& &
& >#)./-(&<)#<-(#&)#&./"+&;1"%0"#6&"+&./-&<)2*%-S&VX'&0-+"6#&"#&./-&<-"%"#6&
+*$<-+?&@/"+&"+&$&2$:)(&(-$+)#&=/B&5CV&=$+&"2*%-2-#.-0&9)(&<))(0"#$.")#?&!"61(-&L&
0-*"<.+&$#&$(-$&#-S.&.)&$&2-</$#"<$%&())2E&=/"</&<)#.$"#+&/-$4B&<)#6-+.")#&"#&./-&
<-"%"#6&+*$<-?&K"./&$#B&/"6/A.-</&;1"%0"#6E&./-(-&"+&$%=$B+&$&<)#<-(#&="./&9".."#6&$%%&
)9&./-&-D1"*2-#.&"#.)&./-&+*$<-&./$.&"+&$4$"%$;%-?&@/-&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&
3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6&"+&#)&0"99-(-#.?&K"./&./"+&<)2*%-S".B&)9&0-+"6#&"#&$&+2$%%&
+*$<-E&".&"+&"2*)(.$#.&.)&6-.&$%%&.($0-+&"#4)%4-0&-$(%B&"#&./-&*():-<.&$#0&9)(&./-&
-D1"*2-#.&+"O"#6&.)&;-&F#)=#&;-9)(-&"#+.$%%$.")#?&>+&*(-4")1+%B&2-#.")#-0E&./"+&"+&$&
21%."*%-&*("2-&<)#.($<.?&Q)E&./-(-&="%%&;-&21%."*%-&<)#.($<.)(+&=)(F"#6&"#&./"+&."6/.&
<-"%"#6&+*$<-&.)&2$F-&+1(-&./$.&$%%&)9&./-&2$.-("$%+&$(-&*1.&"#&*%$<-&<)((-<.%B?&@/-&
2$:)(&<)#<-(#&"#&./"+&$(-$&"+&.($0-&<))(0"#$.")#?&K"./&./"+E&<)2-+&$&*).-#."$%&
+</-01%-&0($=;$<F?&>%%&2$.-("$%+&$(("4"#6&)#&+".-&#--0&.)&;-&+"O-0&.)&./-&-S$<.&
0"2-#+")#+&$+&)#&./-&5CV&2)0-%&="./&$&4-(B&%"..%-&.)%-($#<-&.)&-#+1(-&./$.&$%%&*"-<-+&
9".?&&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
K/-#&0-$%"#6&="./&$&."6/.&<-"%"#6&+*$<-E&./-(-&$(-&2$#B&0"99-(-#.&$%.-(#$."4-+&
.)&"#<(-$+-&./-&$2)1#.&)9&+*$<-&"#&./-&<-"%"#6&*%-#12?&>+&$&2-</$#"<$%&;(-$0./E&C&$2&
*()*)+"#6&.)&(-2)4-&./-&(-.1(#&$"(&01<.=)(F&$#0&"2*%-2-#.&$&(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12?&>&
(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12&=)1%0&-%"2"#$.-&$&%$(6-&*"-<-&)9&01<.=)(F&$#0&+$4-&+*$<-&"#+"0-&
./-&<-"%"#6&.)&$%%)=&./-&<)#.($<.)(+&.)&/$4-&2)(-&())2&.)&=)(F&="./?&!"61(-&W&+/)=+&
$&<)2*$("+)#&)9&$&(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12&$#0&$&.B*"<$%&(-.1(#&$"(&*"-<-&)9&01<.=)(F?&>+&"+&
+/)=#E&./-&<-"%"#6&+*$<-&"+&21</&2)(-&)*-#&01-&.)&./-&%)++&)9&./-&(-.1(#&$"(&
01<.=)(F?&@/"+&$#$%B+"+&=)1%0&(-D1"(-&"#<(-$+"#6&./-&9%))(A.)A9%))(&/-"6/.+E&
$#$%BO"#6&./-&R!V&(-D1"(-2-#.+&9)(&./"+&+*$<-E&$#0&*%-#12&($."#6&$%%&)9&./-&
2$.-("$%+&"#&./-&<-"%"#6?&&@/"+&=)1%0&(-D1"(-&$#&-+."2$.-&9)(&./-&<)+.&"#<(-$+-&)9&./-&
$00-0&9%))(A.)A9%))(&/-"6/.?&@/"+&="%%&;-&$<<)2*%"+/-0&="./&./-&-+."2$.-+&./$.&=-(-&
<)2*%-.-0&"#&@-</#"<$%&Y-*)(.&M?&>&<)+.&*-(&+D1$(-&9)).&9)(&+.(1<.1($%&+.--%&="%%&;-&
1."%"O-0?&C#&)(0-(&9)(&$&(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12&.)&=)(F&<)((-<.%BE&$%%&2$.-("$%+&"#&./-&
B&8:.")O);GN)N17"()4$15&%8)NPM)4+,0"A)E1%8",0&1%)
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& Z&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & Z&
<-"%"#6&="%%&#--0&.)&;-&*%-#12&($.-0?&@/"+&"+&$&+2$%%&</$#6-&./$.&<)1%0&2$F-&$&/16-&
0"99-(-#<-&)#&./"+&*():-<.?&
&
& & &&T$U& & & & & & T;U&B&8:.")Q)I'L)!+/&#'()6"0:.%)*&.)-:#051.J)IRL)6"0:.%)*&.)M("%:A)-.1/)5&0$)-.1/)E"&(&%8)
& @/"+&$0:1+.2-#.&=)(F+&;-+.&"#&/$%%=$B&+*$<-+?&Q)E&+"#<-&./-&$(-$&)99&)9&./-&
2-</$#"<$%&())2&)#&./-&9"(+.&9%))(&"+&$#&-S.(-2-%B&<)#6-+.-0&$(-$E&C&="%%&%))F&.)&
1."%"O-&./-&(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12&"#&./"+&+*$<-?&@/"+&"0-$&<)1%0&;-&91(./-(&21%."*%"-0&
./()16/)1.&./-&(-+.&)9&./-&/$%%=$B&$(-$+&"#&./-&;1"%0"#6?&>#&$#$%B+"+&="%%&;-&
*-(9)(2-0&.)&0-.-(2"#-&./-&<)+.&$00".")#&)(&(-01<.")#&9()2&"2*%-2-#."#6&./"+&
+B+.-2E&$+&=-%%&$+&."2-&+$4"#6+?&C#&)(0-(&.)&*-(9)(2&./"+&$#$%B+"+E&".&="%%&;-&
"2*)(.$#.&.)&"#.-(4"-=&$&<)2*$#B&./$.&+*-<"$%"O-+&"#&(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12&+B+.-2+?&>&
<)2*$#B&%"F-&@(1%$#0&2$B&;-&$&6))0&)*.")#&.)&<)#+1%.&="./?&@/"+&$#$%B+"+&="%%&;-&
*-(9)(2-0&.)&0-.-(2"#-&<)+.&(-01<.")#&$#0[)(&+</-01%-&$<<-%-($.")#&="./&./-&
"2*%-2-#.$.")#&)9&./"+&#-=&+B+.-2?&&
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& \&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & \&
*%'(+,&,)O)3)*(0".%'0&S")PT#'S'0&1%)U/0&1%,)96","'.#$<)
)>&2$:)(&</$%%-#6-&)#&./"+&*():-<.&=$+&9)1#0&"#&./-&4-(B&-$(%B&+.$6-+&)9&./-&*():-<.?&
K/-#&./-&6-).-</#"<$%&(-*)(.&=$+&0)#-&9)(&./"+&*():-<.E&".&=$+&9)1#0&./$.&./-&+)"%&
=$+&<)2*)+-0&)9&+)%"0&()<F?&@/-#E&=/-#&"#"."$%&-S<$4$.")#&;-6$#E&".&=$+&<)#9"(2-0&
./$.&".&=)1%0&.$F-&$&%)#6&*-(")0&)9&."2-&T-+."2$.-0&P&2)#./+U&.)&/$22-(&)1.&./-&
()<F&$#0&-S<$4$.-?&K"./&./-&*/$+-&)<<1(("#6&"#&./-&+122-(&2)#./+E&".&=)1%0&/$4-&
;--#&)F$B&.)&/$4-&<)#+.$#.&/$22-("#6&$#0&#).&0"+.1(;&$#B&<%$++-+?&,)=-4-(E&./-&
"0-$&)9&()<F&-S<$4$.")#&;%$+."#6&=$+&*()*)+-0&$+&$&2-./)0&)9&(-01<"#6&+</-01%-&
."2-&$#0&0-<(-$+"#6&./-&$2)1#.&)9&#)"+-&./$.&=)1%0&)<<1(&9()2&%)#6&*-(")0+&)9&()<F&
/$22-("#6?&Y)<F&XS<$4$.")#&;%$+."#6&"+&0)#-&;B&0("%%"#6&/)%-+&()16/%B&7W&9--.&0)=#&
"#&./-&6()1#0E&9"%%"#6&./-2&="./&-S*%)+"4-+E&$#0&+-.."#6&)99&</$(6-+&.)&;(-$F&1*&./-&
()<F&$#0&$%%)=&9)(&-$+"-(&-S<$4$.")#?&@/"+&*()<-++&(-D1"(-+&$&+"6#"9"<$#.&$2)1#.&)9&
*%$##"#6&$#0&<))(0"#$.")#&)9&-4-(B)#-&)#&+".-&$+&=-%%&$+&*-)*%-&9()2&./-&
+1(()1#0"#6&;1"%0"#6+?&31("#6&./-&"#"."$%&*%$##"#6&*/$+-E&".&=$+&"2*)(.$#.&.)&$#$%BO-&
./-&-#."(-&+".-&$#0&/)=&./-&;%$+."#6&=)1%0&$99-<.&./-&+1(()1#0"#6&$(-$+?&!)(&./"+&
*():-<.E&".&=$+&-+.$;%"+/-0&./$.&$&P]]A9)).&+$9-.B&($0"1+&=)1%0&;-&#--0-0&9)(&$&
<)2*%-.-&$1.)2);"%-&$#0&*-0-+.("$#&+/1.0)=#?&@/"+&(-D1"(-+&$&/16-&-99)(.&9()2&$&
2$#$6-2-#.&+.$#0*)"#.?&C#&)(0-(&.)&-+.$;%"+/&$&+$9-.B&;$(("-(E&".&"+&"2*)(.$#.&.)&
-#+1(-&./$.&$&*()*-(&+.$99&="%%&;-&*()4"0-0?&!"61(-&Z&0-*"<.+&./-&*-("2-.-(&+$9-.B&
($0"1+&$#0&./-&*-(+)##-%&(-D1"(-0?&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&B&8:.")V);(',0&%8)M".&A"0".)4'@"0+)6'7&:,)
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& ^&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & ^&
&
& >&*()9-++")#$%&.($99"<&<)#.()%&.-$2&=$+&/"(-0&"#&)(0-(&.)&/$#0%-&$%%&$1.)2);"%-&
$#0&*-0-+.("$#&.($99"<&)#&./-&4-(B&;1+B&R)%%-6-&>4-#1-?&,"("#6&$&*()9-++")#$%&.($99"<&
<)#.()%&<)2*$#B&#).&)#%B&-#+1(-0&$&*()9-++")#$%&6()1*&)9&*-)*%-E&;1.&$%+)&/-%*-0&.)&
-+.$;%"+/&.($99"<&<)#.()%&;$+-0&)#&'XJJ38@&+.$#0$(0+?&@/-(-&=-(-&()16/%B&P]&
*-)*%-&"#4)%4-0&"#&./-&0$BA.)A0$B&$<."4"."-+&)9&./-&()<F&-S<$4$.")#&;%$+."#6?&K"./&./"+&
$2)1#.&)9&$<."4".B&$#0&./-&"0-$&)9&-S*%)+"4-+&;-"#6&1+-0E&".&"+&"2*-($."4-&.)&#)."9B&
+.10-#.+&$#0&9$<1%.B&"#&./-&+1(()1#0"#6&;1"%0"#6+?&@/"+&"+&$&%$(6-&-99)(.E&="./&2$:)(&
(-+1%.+&"#&+</-01%-&$<<-%-($.")#?&&
&
& C&/$4-&9)1#0&$&4-(B&+.()#6&"#.-(-+.&"#&./"+&2-./)0&)9&-S<$4$.")#?&C&./"#F&".&
=)1%0&;-&4-(B&"#.("61"#6&.)&<)2*$(-&./-&*()<-++&)9&()<F&-S<$4$.")#&;%$+."#6&.)&./-&
.($0".")#$%&:$<F&/$22-("#6?&>%+)E&C&*%$#&.)&(-+-$(</&$%.-(#$."4-&2-./)0+&.)&
-S<$4$."#6&+)%"0&()<F?&8#-&*$(."<1%$(&"0-$&"+&$&*"-<-&)9&2$</"#-(B&./$.&;(-$F+&1*&./-&
()<F?&@/"+&"+&<$%%-0&$&()<F&/$=6?&@/"+&.B*-&)9&2$</"#-(B&1."%"O-+&@)*&3)=#&<1.."#6&
.-</#)%)6BE&=/"</&$%%)=+&".+&.--./&.)&<1.&0)=#&"#.)&./-&()<F&$#0&;(-$F&".&1*&"#.)&
+2$%%-(&*"-<-+?&C#&)(0-(&.)&2$F-&+1(-&./$.&./"+&/-$4B&2$</"#-(B&=)1%0&<1.&./-&()<F&
./$.&=)1%0&;-&(-D1"(-0&.)&;-&<1.&)#&+".-?&>%+)E&C&=)1%0&#--0&.)&<)#.$<.&$&<)2*$#B&
=/)&)=#+&./"+&.B*-&)9&2$</"#-(B&$#0&/$+&*-(9)(2-0&./"+&=)(F&;-9)(-&+)&./$.&
-+."2$.-0&01($.")#+&<)1%0&;-&-+.$;%"+/-0?&@)&6-.&./-&2)+.&$<<1($.-&$#$%B+"+E&<)#.$<.&
="%%&#--0&.)&;-&2$0-&="./&./-&6-#-($%&<)#.($<.)(&=/)&=$+&"#"."$%%B&*%$##"#6&.)&
*-(9)(2&./-&:$<F&/$22-("#6&$#0&-S<$4$.")#?&>%+)E&".&=)1%0&;-&/-%*91%&.)&<)#.$<.&./-&
;%$+."#6&<)#.($<.)(&T3)16%$+&XS*%)+"4-+U&"#&)(0-(&.)&0-("4-&./-&+-D1-#<"#6&
"#9)(2$.")#&9)(&./-&;%$+."#6&*()<-01(-+?&@/"+&="%%&;-&$#&"#.("61"#6&(-+-$(</"#6&
)**)(.1#".B&.)&-S*%)(-&./-&0"99-(-#.&2-$#+&)9&*-(9)(2"#6&-S<$4$.")#?&&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& _&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & _&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
*//"%7&T)*)&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 7]&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & 7]&
;."'70$)!1/&#,))
40.:#0:.'();."'70$)9G%#1./1.'0"7)&%01)*%'(+,&,)2<)
)
& @/-&+.$"(&.)=-(&(-0-+"6#E&$+&0-+<(";-0&"#&>#$%B+"+&7E&*()4"0-+&$#&)**)(.1#".B&
.)&(-+-$(</&$#0&$#$%BO-&$&;(-$0./&)1.+"0-&)9&./-&<)#+.(1<.")#&2$#$6-2-#.&)*.")#?&
@/"+&$(-$&=$+&"#"."$%%B&$#$%BO-0&;-<$1+-&".&=$+&+--#&$+&$&*();%-2$."<&$(-$&)#&./-&
*():-<.?&C#&)(0-(&.)&+*--0&1*&./-&<)#+.(1<.")#&+</-01%-E&$&(-0-+"6#&)9&./"+&+.$"(&.)=-(&
="%%&;-&*-(9)(2-0?&@/-&*()*)+-0&+.--%&;($<-0&9($2-&="%%&"#<)(*)($.-&./-&1+-&)9&
+.(1<.1($%&+.--%&2-2;-(+&$+&)**)+-0&.)&./-&<)#<(-.-&+/-$(&=$%%?&>#&$#$%B+"+&)9&./-&
+.(1<.1($%&+.--%&<)##-<.")#+&.)&./-&;($<-0&9($2-&="%%&;-&(-D1"(-0&$+&=-%%&$+&."-&"#&
*)"#.+&.)&./-&+)&./$.&./-&+.$"(+&<$#&;-&*1.&"#&*%$<-?&>%+)E&$#&$#$%B+"+&<$#&;-&
*-(9)(2-0&.)&0-.-(2"#-&9"(-*())9"#6&(-D1"(-2-#.+&9)(&./-&+.--%&2-2;-(+?&@/"+&
*()*)+-0&$%.-(#$."4-&=)1%0&$<<-%-($.-&./-&+</-01%-E&=/"</&"+&<(1<"$%&;-<$1+-&./"+&
$(-$&"+&)#&./-&<("."<$%&*$./?&!()2&$&+.(1<.1($%&$#$%B+"+&+.$#0*)"#.E&./"+&="%%&;-&$&4-(B&
</$%%-#6"#6&(-0-+"6#?&&
&
N"#$'%&#'();."'70$)9G%#1./1.'0"7)&%01)*%'(+,&,)H<)
&
& @/-&."6/.&<-"%"#6&+*$<-&0)-+&#).&$%%)=&9)(&21</&.)%-($#<-&9)(&*%$<-2-#.&)9&VX'&
-D1"*2-#.&"#&2$#B&$(-$+&)9&./-&;1"%0"#6?&8#-&)9&./-&2$:)(&$(-$+&"+&./-&/$%%=$B&
)1.+"0-&)9&./-&2-</$#"<$%&())2&)#&./-&9"(+.&9%))(?&@/"+&$%%)=+&2-&.)&*-(9)(2&$&
2-</$#"<$%&;(-$0./&$#$%B+"+&$+&2-#.")#-0&"#&>#$%B+"+&P?&C#&)(0-(&.)&/$4-&$&
+1<<-++91%&(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12&"#&./"+&;1"%0"#6E&./-&9%))(A.)A9%))(&/-"6/.&="%%&#--0&.)&;-&
($"+-0?&@/-&R!V&(-D1"(-2-#.+&9)(&./-&(-.1(#&$"(&*"-<-&)9&01<.=)(F&./$.&="%%&;-&
(-2)4-0&="%%&#--0&.)&;-&$#$%BO-0&+)&./$.&$&*()*-(&*%-#12&<$#&;-&"#+.$%%-0&.)&2--.&
./)+-&(-D1"(-2-#.+?&>%+)E&"#&)(0-(&.)&/$4-&$&(-.1(#&$"(&*%-#12E&$%%&2$.-("$%+&"#&./-&
*%-#12&#--0&.)&;-&*%-#12&($.-0&$#0&./-&<-"%"#6&+*$<-&#--0+&.)&;-&+-$%-0?&C.&="%%&;-&
"#.-(-+."#6&.)&+--&./-&.B*-&)9&+</-01%-&"2*$<.&./"+&+B+.-2&="%%&/$4-&)#&./-&*():-<.?&C.&
="%%&);4")1+%B&+$4-&."2-&"9&B)1&$(-&#).&"#+.$%%"#6&$&(-.1(#&$"(&01<.E&;1.&".&="%%&.$F-&
."2-&.)&*%-#12&($.-&$%%&)9&./-&-D1"*2-#.&$#0&2$.-("$%+&"#&./-&<-"%"#6&+*$<-?&&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 77&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & 77&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
&
)
*//"%7&T);)
)
)
)
)
)
)&
&
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 7M&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & 7M&
&!'R(")2)3)F"&8$0)N'0.&T)
Description
Critical
Industry
Research
Value
Engineering
Analysis
Constructability
Review
Schedule
Reduction/
Acceleration
Total
Stairtower
Redesign 5% 5% 10% 10% 30%
Atrium
System
Coordination
5% 10% 5% 20%
Return Air
Plenum 5% 5% 10% 5% 25%
Alternative
Excavation
Methods
5% 5% 10% 5% 25%
Total 20% 15% 40% 25% 100%
)
)
)
)
)
)&
&
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 7P&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & 7P&
4/.&%8)4"A",0".)P,0&A'0"7)!&A"(&%")
)
)))
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 7L&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & 7L&
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
*//"%7&T)E))
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
!"#$%&'()*)+$%&&&&&&&&&,-$%./&$#0&,12$#&3-4-%)*2-#.&51"%0"#6& 7W&&
,,3&51"%0"#6& & 7W&
6",1:.#",)&
>%%&(-#0-("#6+&$(-&<)1(.-+B&)9&5)/%"#&RB="#+F"&G$<F+)#E&./-&$(</".-<.&)#&./-&*():-<.?&&
&
I))6%-&C2$6-&Q-$(</&
&
V$++$()&RVQ&5CV&V)0-%&
&
&
&
)&