exhibits, freedom of information hearing, may 18, 2016

Upload: the-valley-indy

Post on 06-Jul-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    1/11

    rffitt

    Lussier,

    Christina

    l6-)"(,?

    From:

    Sent:

    To:

    Subject:

    Attachments:

    Sent

    from my

    iPhone

    Begin

    forwarded

    message:

    Grant,

    Kelly

    Wednesday,

    January

    13,2A1,6

    5:01 PM

    Lussier,

    Christina

    Fwd:

    Ansonia

    PD

    Use

    o{

    Force

    Investigation?

    Valley

    Indy

    FOI

    Request.txt;

    ATT0000l",htm

    From :

    Ethan

    F.y

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    2/11

    On

    Wed,

    Jan

    13,2016

    at4:04

    PM,

    Grant, Keliy

    wrote:

    I

    just

    spoke

    with our

    Legal

    staff,

    you

    can

    contact

    Reporls

    and

    Records

    for

    a

    copy of

    the l'eport,

    or

    you

    can

    submit

    a

    FOIA

    request, The

    Chief

    State's

    Attorney

    Office

    also

    conducts an

    investigation

    and

    you

    can

    iontact

    them

    for

    furlher

    assistance,

    I

    will

    not

    be able

    to

    get

    you

    basic

    details

    about

    the

    reporl

    until

    tomorrow.

    After

    a

    complete

    investigation is concluded,

    the

    State's

    Attorney's

    Office

    will

    review

    the

    find.ings and determine

    whether

    or

    not the

    use

    of

    force was

    justified.

    The

    State's

    Attorney

    will

    complete

    a written

    report

    detailing

    the investigation

    and

    its

    findings

    which

    are

    public

    and

    can

    be

    viewed

    online

    at

    http://www.ct.

    From: Ethan

    Fry

    [mailto:elelandf@gmail,com]

    Sent:

    Wednesday,

    January 13,

    2016

    3:48

    PM

    To:

    Grant,

    Kelly

    Subject:

    Rel Ansonia

    PD

    Use of

    Force

    Investigation?

    Thanks

    for

    your

    call.

    Can you

    give me

    whatever basic

    infornation

    you can

    regarding the report?

    Appreciate

    it,

    Ethan

    On

    Wed,

    Jan

    13,

    2016

    at 3:40

    PM,

    Ethan

    Fry

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    3/11

    I'm

    a

    reporter

    on deadline.

    In

    the interests

    of the

    story I'm writing

    and

    have

    to

    hand

    in

    by the

    end

    of the

    day

    (5

    p.rn.),

    can

    you

    explain

    why

    members

    of

    the

    public

    have to

    wait an undetermined

    amount of time

    to find

    out

    the facts behind

    a shooting

    involving

    a

    police

    officer?

    This is the

    flrst

    time

    we've

    ever

    been

    sent

    such

    instructions

    in

    response

    to a

    request

    fol

    a

    copy

    of

    a

    public

    record.

    Thanks,

    Ethan

    On Wed,

    Jan 13, 2016

    at2:57 PM,

    Grant,

    Kelly

    wrote:

    Ethan,

    Copies of reports are obtained

    through

    Reports

    and Records.

    To

    obtain

    a

    police

    reportvisitour

    website

    at ct.gov/despp

    and click the "state

    police

    reports"

    link

    orcall 860-685-:8250,

    Thank

    you

    From:

    Ethan

    Fry

    [mailto:[email protected]]

    Sent:

    Wednesday, January 13,2016 2:43 PM

    To:

    Grant,

    Kelly

    Subject:

    Ansonia

    PD

    Use

    of Force Investigation?

    Trooper Grant,

    Ethan

    Fry here fi'om the

    Valley

    Independent

    Sentinel

    in Ansonia

    (http://www,Valleylndv.org)

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    4/11

    I'm

    writing a story about a

    plea yesterday

    in Derby

    court involving Maurice

    Beall,

    who

    was

    arrested Feb,

    2,

    2Al4

    after being

    shot

    by

    an

    Ansonia

    police

    officer

    during

    a

    physical

    confrontation.

    Mr.

    Beall's

    lawyer

    said the state

    police

    conducted

    (and

    completed)

    a

    use

    of

    force

    investigation

    into

    the

    incident.

    I was

    just

    wondering

    whether that's

    the

    case,

    and

    if

    so, could

    you

    send

    me

    a

    copy of

    the

    reporl

    via

    email

    fureferably)

    or by fax

    (g\A-qll-gq0Tl

    Thanks,

    Ethan

    2A3-446-2335

    (office)

    203-241-3516

    {cell)

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    5/11

    ('#*

    Lussier,

    Christina

    From:

    Sent:

    To:

    Subject;

    Attachments:

    Lussier,

    Christina

    Tuesday,

    March

    22,20L6

    2'.42

    ?M

    Castagliuolo,

    Stephen

    Request

    # 6-267

    2O160322L438 18453.

    pdf;

    Req

    uest

    Fo

    rm

    C

    hristina.doc

    Good

    Afternoon

    Major,

    Due to

    a

    glitch

    in Outlook,

    the

    attached

    request was

    inadvertently

    missed

    and

    our unit

    did not

    acknowledge

    the

    req

    uest. The

    requester

    has

    filed

    a complaint

    and it

    would

    be

    great

    if

    we could

    get

    the

    information

    to him

    quickly

    so

    he

    may

    withdraw.

    Thank

    you

    for

    your

    assistance,

    Christina

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    6/11

    Department

    of Emergency

    Services

    and Public

    Protection

    Office

    of

    the

    Commissioner

    To:

    Major

    Castagliuolo

    Professional

    Standards

    From :

    Christina

    Lussier, Administrative

    Assistant

    Legal

    Affairs

    Re:

    Freedom of

    Information

    Act

    Request

    Sutrpoena

    AG/Litigatio

    n

    Reques

    llLaw

    Enforcement

    lleq

    uest

    -

    Yictim Advocate

    Request

    pursuant to

    C.G.S.

    $

    46a-13b

    et

    seq.

    Date:

    March

    22,2A16

    aaltarllrlalttaaltltllllaaatalrtrrilltllarllrrttlfllllrlllrrlllllllt'tt-l

    Please

    provide

    this

    office

    with

    one copy

    of

    the

    following:

    Use of

    Force

    Report per

    attached

    request.

    In

    order

    to

    fulfiIl

    our

    obligations

    in

    this

    matter,

    this

    office

    must

    reccive

    the

    requested

    information

    by

    April

    5,

    2016.

    Failure

    to

    provide the

    information

    by this

    date

    may

    adversely

    impact

    the

    agency

    and/or may

    require

    testimony

    from

    your

    troop/unitloffice.

    Should

    you

    have any

    questions

    concerning

    this

    request,

    please contact

    the

    Legal

    Affairs

    Unit

    at

    (860)

    685-8150.

    Please

    advise

    this

    office

    if

    there

    is

    a

    pending criminal

    investigation

    or

    prosecution

    related

    to this

    matter,

    or if

    the

    matter

    has

    been concluded,

    please

    provide

    documentation

    concerning

    the

    final

    disposition.

    File

    Number;16-267

    llequester:

    Fry

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    7/11

    ,{*

    Lussier,

    Christina

    Fronr:

    Sent:

    To:

    Cc:

    Subject:

    DelGrosso,

    Jay

    Thursday,

    March24,2016

    12:I"1

    PM

    Lussier,

    Clrristina

    Castagliuolo,

    Stephen;

    Pendleton,

    Michael

    F;

    Davis, Michael;Giglio,

    Marcia

    RE: Request

    #16-261

    Ms,

    Lussier,

    The case

    referenced

    in

    your

    request

    for

    file,

    16-267

    is

    a Police involved shooting. This

    case was

    investigated

    by Trooper

    Rachael

    Van

    Ness

    #1431 and supervised by Sergeant

    Joshua

    Pattberg

    #130 both

    of Centrai District Major Crime,

    This

    case was

    investigated

    under

    1400065455

    as a Use of Force Case. Normal course

    of

    action

    in a case involving

    a Use of

    Force incident

    with

    another

    Department

    is a Use of force report is

    completed

    by that

    deparinrent. ln

    this case

    the

    Officer involved

    is

    from

    the Ansonia

    Police Department. Therefore the

    Ansonia

    Police Department Use of Force

    policy

    would

    be referenced and

    the Ansonia Police

    Department would

    complete a Use of Force report

    for

    this incident, Our

    agency would

    conduct the

    Criminal

    {nvestigation and

    submit

    the

    results of the investigation

    to the local

    States

    Attorney's office

    and

    those

    reports

    would

    be

    held

    in

    our

    Reports and

    Records

    section.

    lf our agency conducted

    a Use

    of

    Force

    report for this incident it would

    be recorded

    in

    NEXGTN and the hard

    copy

    report

    would

    be

    held

    in a

    file

    located

    at the offices

    of

    lnternal Affairs,

    I

    checked the

    NEXGEN

    records of reports

    for

    1400065455

    and no

    Use

    of

    Force

    report

    was

    created for this

    incident.

    I

    also hand

    searched

    all

    of

    the

    Use

    of Force reports

    for

    2014

    held

    at

    our office

    and

    one has

    not been filed

    for

    Maurice

    Beall.

    lf

    you

    have

    any furtherquestions

    please

    do not

    hesitate

    to contact me directly.

    Lieutenant

    J

    DelGrosso

    #045

    Connecticut State Police

    lnternal Affairs Unit

    203-630-4353 Desk

    860-558-9267

    Cell

    From :

    Castagl

    iuolo, Stephen

    Sent:

    Tuesday,

    March 27,2A762:47

    PM

    To:

    Pendleton,

    Michael

    F;

    Davis,

    Michael; DelGrosso, Jay

    Cc: Lussier, Christina;

    Giglio, Marcia

    Subjectr

    FW:

    Request

    #76-267

    Lts Davis,

    Pendleton

    &

    DelGrosso;

    Please

    see

    attached.

    Can

    you

    assist

    and

    get

    Christina the requested documents.

    Please contact

    me

    with any

    problems,

    Thank

    you.

    Major Stephen

    P.

    Castagliuolo

    COMMAND]NG OFFICER

    Bureau

    of Professional Standards

    and Compliance

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    8/11

    Connecticut

    State

    Police

    294

    Colony

    St., Building

    #6

    Meriden,

    CT 06451

    (203)

    630-43a3

    (office)

    (860)

    62s-s661

    (cell)

    ste

    phe

    n.

    ca

    stjr

    gl

    i

    uolo

    @ct.eov

    ,,The

    ultimote

    meqsure

    of

    a man

    is

    not

    where

    he

    stands

    in

    moments

    ol

    comfort and convenience,

    but where

    he

    stonds

    at

    times

    of chaltenge and

    controversy,"

    Martin

    Luther

    King,

    Jr.

    From:

    Lussier,

    Christina

    Sent: Tuesday,

    March

    77,

    2A76

    2:42

    PM

    To:

    Castagliuolo,

    Stephen

    Subject:

    Request

    #L6-267

    Good

    Afternoon Major,

    Due

    to

    a

    glitch

    in

    outlook,

    the

    attached

    request

    was

    inadvertently missed

    and

    our

    unit

    did

    not

    acknowledge

    the

    request.

    The

    requester

    has

    filed a

    complaint

    and

    it

    would

    be

    great

    if

    we

    could

    get

    the

    information

    to him

    quickly

    so

    he

    may

    withdraw,

    Thank

    you

    for

    your

    assistance,

    Ch

    ristina

    n

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    9/11

    ,-L

    (

    {rto

    /v+

    .'R

    +'id$

    I'.

    6',r

    '=-

    :- ..i

    ,J#*#k

    *.

    pl,-"gi:=

    rleirt+iJ_

    ST'ATE OF

    CONNECT'XCIJT

    DEPAITTMENT OF

    EMERGENCY SERVICES

    AN}

    PUBLIC

    PROTECTION

    LEGAL

    AFFAIRS

    UNIT

    March

    31,2016

    Ethan Fry

    Valley

    Independent Sentinel

    158

    Main

    Street,

    Suite

    305

    Ansonia,

    CT

    06401

    RE: File

    16-267

    Deal

    IvIr'.

    Fry,

    l: researching

    youl'request,

    I believe

    the

    case

    you

    are referring

    to is

    CFS#

    1400065455,

    I have

    attached a Connecticut Judiciai Branch

    printout

    to

    avoid

    any

    confusion as to

    the

    investigation

    you

    are

    seeking.

    The

    case number referenced above was

    investigated by

    the

    Connecticut

    State Police-'W.estern District Major Crime

    in

    addition

    to

    the

    Aasonia Police

    Department.

    There is

    a statutory fee

    of

    $16.00

    associated

    with

    obtaining

    investigative

    reports

    completed

    by

    the

    Connecticut State Police

    under Connecticut

    Genelal

    Statute

    $29-10b.

    Please

    courplete and

    return

    the

    attached Request

    for

    Copy

    of

    Repod Form:

    DPS-96-C, along

    with

    payment,

    for

    processing.

    I have also listed

    the Ansonia Poiice

    Department's contact information

    beiow for copies

    of

    any reports

    completed by

    their

    agency that

    you

    may require.

    Aasonia Police

    Deparlment

    2

    Elm

    Street

    Ansonia, CT

    06401

    Phone

    (203)

    735-1885

    Fax

    (203)

    734-6398

    Piease reference

    fi1916-267

    in all

    cornmunications

    and

    payments

    to

    this agency related

    to this request.

    Respectfully,

    ru;:"'";,

    cK{;??

    TFC.

    Michael Evangelisti

    #7 7

    4

    Connecticut

    State Police- Legal

    Affairs

    Unit

    I

    I I

    I

    Coun{ry,

    Clttb lloucl

    fuIi dcll

    etolt,n,

    CT

    064

    5

    7

    Plrone:

    (860)

    685-8150/Fax.

    (860)

    685-

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    10/11

    .'@\

    ?S*tr6

    W6=

    State

    of Connecticut

    DEPARTMENT OF EMERGENCY

    SERVICES

    &

    PI.IBLIC

    PROTECTION

    DryMIONOF STATEPOLICE

    Flequest

    for

    CoPY

    ol RePort

    Name

    of

    Person Requesting

    Fleport Copy:

    (First,

    Ml,

    Last)

    Mailing

    Address:

    (Street

    / P. O.

    Box)

    (Many

    accident

    reports

    may

    also be obtained

    on

    the

    internet

    at

    Docview,us,com)

    Enclose

    search fees

    (C.G.S.

    S

    29-1A\

    by check

    or money

    order

    payable

    to

    "Treasurer

    State

    of CT"

    in

    the

    proper

    amount:

    lndicate

    the

    number of uncertified

    reports

    requested:

    @$16.00

    per

    request

    lndicate

    the

    number

    of

    certified.reports requested:

    @$17.00

    per request

    TotalAmount:

    $

    E-Mail Address:

    .

    (Optionat)

    eleat

    cipt

    an

    electronlc

    response to

    your request,

    if

    applicabie.

    Incidents

    wii6n

    may

    riquire

    additiona

    review

    or

    requests

    for certified

    copies

    will NOT

    be

    transmitled

    electronically,

    and

    will

    be mailed via

    the United

    States

    Postal

    Service.

    Mail

    the

    check or money

    order in the amount

    required

    and

    this

    request

    to:

    DESPP-Reports

    &

    Records

    Unit,

    1111

    Country Club

    Road,

    Middletown,

    CT

    06457.

    Case

    Number:

    Date

    of

    Incident:

    MM

    DD

    YY

    City

    or Town of lncident:

    Name of

    Any

    Principal Party:

    Last,

    First,

    How involved

    Date

    of Birth

    ff

    available)

    License #

    (it

    availabte)

    Last,

    First,

    How involved

    Date

    of

    Birth

    (if

    available)

    License

    #

    (if

    available)

    Last,

    First,

    How

    involved

    Date

    of Birth

    (if

    available)

    P

    rovi d e

    An

    y

    Add

    iti

    o n

    al

    Av

    ai

    I

    ab

    Ie

    I

    n f

    o

    rm

    ati

    o n :

    Approximate

    timer

    Vehicle

    Plate#

    lncident

    Type

    or

    Description

    (i.e.

    Accident,

    theft,

    hit deer,

    hit

    pole,

    criminal

    incident,

    etc.):

    License

    #

    (if

    avaitabte)

    For

    DESPP

    Office

    lJse

    Qnly

    -

    Do Not

    Write Below

    This

    Line or Slgn

    Form

    Date:

    equest

    cornpleted by:

    DPS-96-C

    (Rev.

    7/1

    1)

    An

    Affirmative

    Action/Equal

    Employment

    Opportunity

    Bmployet

  • 8/17/2019 Exhibits, Freedom of Information Hearing, May 18, 2016

    11/11

    :t.Jr

    :-i+i

    r:;r_:rs:

    *i:.n-r:,

    jl:

    Page

    1

    of

    1

    Criminal/Motor

    Vehicle

    Conviction

    Case

    Detail

    Information

    is

    accurate as

    of

    t'larch

    31./ 2076

    A5:O7 AM

    .

    Defendant lnformation

    Represented

    By:

    41471 8

    EG

    CERRITELLI

    Docket lnformation

    Thursday,

    March 31,20'16

    Docket

    Search

    by

    Court Locatlon

    Thursday,

    March

    31,2016

    Docket Search

    by

    Defendant

    Pending

    Cases

    Search

    by Defendant

    Pending Cases

    Search

    by Docket

    Number

    Convictions Search

    by

    Defendant

    Convictions Search

    by Docket Number

    Attorney/Firm

    Case

    List

    Attorney/Firm

    Look-up

    Numbers

    GA Court Phone

    Numbers

    JD Gourt Phone

    Numbers

    Home

    Last, First:

    BEALL MAURICE

    Birth Year:

    '1S80

    Dock6tNor

    AosD"CR14-0149720-S

    Court:

    Derby GA

    5

    Costs:

    Origlnal Arrestin

    g

    Agency

    :

    Origlnal

    Arrest

    Date:

    Sentenced

    Date:

    LOCAL POLICE

    ANSONIA

    2t112014

    111212016

    I

    courts

    J

    Directories

    I

    Educational

    Resources

    I

    E-Serviceq

    I

    FAQ',s

    IJuror

    lnfomation

    I

    Media

    I

    Oplnions

    I

    Opportunilies

    I

    Self-Help

    |

    ggg

    Common

    LeoatTerms

    I

    Co -tact Us

    lSlte

    Map

    I

    Websle

    Folicies

    Copyright

    @ 20 16,

    Stale

    of

    ConnBcticut

    Judicial

    BrEnch

    Description

    classrvpe o""$tr"j"u

    0,",

    y:;i,ftH"]"t Fine Fee(s)

    To CommitAsslt

    Pb

    /2ol4Gulltvcuiltv 1/'l

    2/201

    f---'""-__l

    Attoroevs

    I

    Casa Look-uo

    http://wwwjud2.ct.gov/crdockets/CaseDetailDisp.aspx?source:Pending

    &Key=Zf3e31c5-a-..

    3/3U2Arc