exeter great dam removal - northeastern transportation … · 2018-09-20 · –great dam does not...

21
Exeter Great Dam Removal Managing Aging Infrastructure to Improve Resiliency and Aquatic Habitat Presented by Jake San Antonio, PE NETWC Lightning Session | September 12, 2018

Upload: others

Post on 12-Apr-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Exeter Great Dam RemovalManaging Aging Infrastructure to

Improve Resiliency and Aquatic Habitat

Presented by

Jake San Antonio, PE

NETWC Lightning Session | September 12, 2018

Page 2: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Great Dam Impoundment

NH 108/Court

Street Bridge

Railroad Bridge

Gilman Park

Page 3: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Great Dam Structural Features

Exeter Library

Page 4: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Great Dam Site

Level 1 bullet

– Level 2 bullet 3. Great Dam

4. Fish Ladder

Kimball

Island

4. Fish Weir

1. Headworks

Exeter Library

2. Low Level Outlet

Page 5: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Mother’s Day Flood, May 2006

Page 6: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Decision Making – A Long Story

1981 • Town Takes Ownership of the Dam

2000 • NHDES Dam Bureau Issues Letter of Deficiency

2007 • Phase 1 (Dam Modification) Final Report for the Town of Exeter (Wright-Pierce)

2008 • Riverbank Scour/Design Impacts to Water Quality (Wright-Pierce)

2009 • Geomorphic Assessment (Bear Creek Environmental/Fitzgerald)

2010 • Water Supply Alternatives Study – Final Report (Weston & Sampson)

2013 • Great Dam Removal Feasibility and Impact Study (VHB)

2014 • Town Warrant Article No. 8 Passes – Authorizes Funding for Removal

2015 • Design and Permitting

2016 • Dam Removal and River Restoration

Page 7: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Feasibility Study - Benefits of Removal

Flood Resiliency – lower flood elevations upstream

Avoid flood damage costs ($1.7M-$3.4M over 10 years)

Public Safety – eliminate unsafe dam structure

– Class A Dam (Low hazard)

– Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard

– Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Avoid dam maintenance costs ($180-620k over 30 years)

Fish Passage – barrier removed, anadromous fish restoration

Water quality (thermal stratification, dissolved oxygen)

Restore 21 miles of river to free-flowing condition

Page 8: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Design Considerations

Stabilize channel and banks for the 100-year design event

Accommodate fish passage

Maintain water intake functionality

Accommodate sediment transport

Prevent channel head cut (High Street bridge scour)

Mitigate historic impacts

2017

GOLD

AWARD

Page 9: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Design Consideration – Flood Resiliency

Page 10: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Design Consideration – Flood Resiliency

Page 11: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Design Consideration - Fish Passage

Target Species:

– Alewife (Alosa pseudoharengus), anadromous

– Blueback herring (A. aestivalis), anadromous

– American eel (Anguilla rostrata), catadromous

Channel Geometry – slope, drop heights, boulder placement,

turbulence

Iterative design, ongoing research (NOAA/NHF&G)

Page 12: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Fish Weir

Existing GroundGreat Dam

Page 13: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Existing Ground

Pool Bottom

(El. 11.25)

Page 14: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Design Consideration - Fish Passage

Page 15: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Construction (2016)

Page 16: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria
Page 17: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria
Page 18: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria
Page 19: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria
Page 20: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Post-Construction Monitoring

Funding/Permit requirement

Annual Report (for 5 years)

Photo Documentation

Cross-Section Surveys - Channel Depth & Slope

Vegetation recovery – 75% in 3 years (met!)

Fish Counts - Alewife Presence (NH Fish & Game)

Spring Migration Survey – Channel micro-revisions

Page 21: Exeter Great Dam Removal - NORTHEASTERN TRANSPORTATION … · 2018-09-20 · –Great Dam does not pass the 50-year flow with 1 ft freeboard –Great Dam does not meet stability criteria

Jake San Antonio | [email protected] | 617.607.2710

ww

w.v

hb

.co

m

Offices located throughout the east coast