executive summary - tinkeringchildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/junior-library-cas…  ·...

69
P J Buckley, in collaboration with Megan Daley and Jackie Child, presents the findings of the St Aidan’s Anglican Girls’ School Junior Library case study which sought answers to the following question.

Upload: dotruc

Post on 03-Feb-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

P J Buckley, in collaboration with Megan Daley and Jackie Child, presents the

findings of the St Aidan’s Anglican Girls’ School Junior Library case study

which sought answers to the following question.

Page 2: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Contents

1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY...........................................................................................................3

2. NATURE OF THE STUDY..........................................................................................................4

3. COMPLETING THE CASE STUDY...............................................................................................6

4. CRITICAL EVALUATION OF CASE STUDY DATA.........................................................................8

5. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS............................................................................13

6. REFERENCES.........................................................................................................................14

7. APPENDICES.........................................................................................................................16

A. Phone call with Jackie Child................................................................................................17

B. Meeting with Megan Daley and Jackie Child......................................................................19

C. Email to teachers requesting responses to survey..............................................................21

D. Megan and Jackie’s social media networks and recent presentations...............................22

E. Email and Twitter call requesting responses from teacher librarians.................................24

F. Summary of results from parent survey.............................................................................26

G. Parent comments...............................................................................................................30

H. Summary of student responses..........................................................................................36

I. Comments from students...................................................................................................39

J. Summary of teacher responses..........................................................................................45

K. Summary of peer responses...............................................................................................49

L. Peer comments..................................................................................................................52

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 3: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

1. Executive Summary

Little data exists on the impact of Makerspaces programs in educational settings. One

dynamic program occurs at St Aidan’s Anglican Girls’ School Junior Library where teaching

partners Megan Daley and Jackie Child blend high- and low-technology Makerspaces with

literature, producing project-based learning activities through which students rotate in their

library lessons. Four stakeholder groups were surveyed about community reach and impact

on student and teacher learning. Overall, the results were positive, indicating it stimulates and

engages students, and has support and appreciation from parents. Whereas responses from St

Aidan’s teachers were insufficient, Megan and Jackie are touted in the librarian community

as leaders in their field. It is recommended that the library program continue its current

direction, and that Megan and Jackie further exploit social media to strengthen their standing

across the school and the wider community.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 4: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

2. Nature of the Study

Megan Daley and Jackie Child have job-shared at St. Aidan’s Anglican Girls’ School Junior

Library for six years. A new library was built in 2012, and the teacher librarians reassessed

their own roles, and the role of the space in a climate of tightened budgets, fewer students,

and increased expectations of academic success in a post-GFC world.

The concept of Makerspaces is not new, but the name is. Coined in 2005 (Cavalcanti, 2013)

by the Make Group, the movement has gained momentum across the world in educational

and other settings (Educause, 2013). There are both high- (‘Hackerspaces’) and low-

technology Makerspaces, but both promote self-directed learning and collaboration,

emphasising creativity and sharing (Moorefield-Lang, 2015). Teacher librarians embraced

this movement to reinvent their spaces (Koh & Abbas, 2015), knowing hands-on programs

reflect 21st-century teaching and learning, and support classroom work. The Digital

Technologies Curriculum (DTC) (ACARA, 2016) was released in 2013 at the perfect time to

validate Megan and Jackie’s work. Even as the DTC remains in limbo (Sharwood, 2015), it

still provides a relevant framework.

While many libraries have incorporated Makerspaces, Megan and Jackie don’t only provide

the usual lunchtime activities. They created a formal library program connecting Makerspace

components to the DTC, (Child, 2015), and linked it to a literature component. Each class in

the junior school has one 45-minute lesson with either Megan or Jackie. Classes are divided

into groups which rotate through a series of activities, ensuring variety and equitable access.

Each year level’s activities are both scaffolded and developmental, catering for needs. Strong

links to classroom activities, and appropriate explicit teaching of ‘library skills’ like writing

bibliographies, critically evaluating websites for authentic information, and inquiry skills are

incorporated as needed.

To offer this wide range of activities and experiences, Megan and Jackie have updated their

skills, and transformed a personal hobby, especially in Jackie’s case (Appendix A) into

formal instruction. These competencies are often overlooked, as is the work outside school

time that enables their rich connected learning environment (Koh & Abbas, 2015). There is

little understanding how to achieve these competencies; perhaps university courses in

librarianship should address these concerns in future relevant units (Koh & Abbas, 2015).

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 5: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Of the 221 students in the Junior School, two streams are in each upper year level, and one is

in the lower classes (prep, years 1, 2 and 3). Most classes are small, although the kindergarten

is comprised its full complement of 25 girls and boys. Along with library lessons Jackie

teaches a Year 6 Geography class and takes sport, and Megan teaches Extension English to

several year levels. They have access to one library technician shared with the senior library,

equivalent to one full day over the week.

Little data exists about how this kind of library program impacts learning, and we saw this as

an opportunity. While there are descriptive articles about the Makerspace movement

(Cavalcanti, 2013; Miller, 2016), and more about how to place them in a library (Houston,

2013; Moorefield-Lang, 2015; & Stephen, 2015), there is scant record of evidence-based

practice. Along with contributing to the library community, Megan and Jackie want to

present the findings to their school to demonstrate the worth of the library.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 6: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

3. Completing the Case Study

The first interview with Megan and Jackie (Appendix B) investigated the classroom impacts

of the library program, and perception of the library from users, teachers, and parents. It was

important to discover if skills taught were demonstrated in classrooms, and assess any

improvement opportunities. We discussed who to survey and what to ask. Students and

teachers were the prime targets, and I made a case to include parents. The surveys were

designed via email, and adjusted in collaboration with study peers. They are descriptive

surveys of the kind often employed for how-and-why questions (Baxter & Jack, 2008).

The first survey designed was for parents. The final version was published through the school

newsletter, emails from Megan, and requests from classroom teachers. In two weeks there

were 28 responses, primarily from Year 4 and 6 parents, but also kindergarten and Year 1

parents.

Teachers were our priority. They are in the best position to observe and articulate skills

transfer. Their insights would identify whether and how library lessons support classroom

learning. With only ten teachers in the junior school, it seemed easy to retrieve data through

this survey which Megan emailed (Appendix C). Megan emphasised the last week of Term 3

was extremely stressful; only two teachers responded. We left this survey open until October

7, and two more teachers added comments.

Surveying the students was important to establish their perception of library lessons. We

wanted to provide some language, but also let them use their own words to describe their

understanding. The upper year levels (Years 3 to 6) were targeted. Jackie was particularly

keen to highlight the importance of learning enjoyment. We wanted to know how true that

was for the girls. During library lessons, Megan emailed a survey to students. Two full

classes, one Year 4 and one Year 6 responded, and several individuals from Year 6, but there

was only one student from Year 3. There were no responses from Year 5, possibly because

the survey was distributed by email while Year 5 communicates via Edmodo. Of the 140

students in Years 3 to 6, 48 (34%) students responded. While this figure is lower than

expected, it’s likely more data would have reinforced the positive result.

Megan and Jackie embody the characteristics of 21st-century teachers and learners,

encouraging enquiry, and sharing their journey and knowledge across social media

(Appendix D). This networking has led to invitations to present at network meetings,

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 7: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

conferences, panels, and webinars. If educators present a unique or useful experience,

conferences such EDUTech, and associations like ALIA and QSLA offer further

opportunities, which increases reach. It was hoped a survey would gauge how far this sharing

extends. This survey was developed and sent out a week after the first three. Calls for

responses went out on discussion lists and Twitter (Appendix E), and 17 colleagues

completed the short survey—almost all positive and supportive of Megan and Jackie’s

efforts.

Further interactions with the two teacher librarians occurred through email and Facebook

messenger. Most communication centred on despair at the lack of responses, and

administrative questions about class size, explanations of methodology, and requests for

documents.

In retrospect, the case study was unfortunately timed; we distributed these four separate

surveys in the last two weeks of Term 3, limiting responses. Megan and Jackie were working

full-time to replace the secondary teacher librarian who was on long-service leave for the

whole term, and Jackie was overseas for the last two weeks. Junior school staff were

inundated with marking, and unfortunately, at one point, for several days, the email system of

the school was unavailable.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 8: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

4. Critical Evaluation of Case Study Data

While the response rate was disappointingly low, the results submitted were generally

positive, so it’s likely more participants would have reinforced the chorus of respect and

encouragement. Each group will be discussed separately, but there are correlations across the

groups. With positive support from the adults, and contentment from students,

recommendations will favour continuation over improvement.

Parent Survey Analysis

Responses came from 28 parents, and overall they were positive. Distribution across year

levels was uneven. Most parents responded to most questions, although question 5 had a low

response rate. Appendix F summarises the results, and Appendix G provides all unabridged

comments. The data suggests parents who responded are those who have positive

associations with the library or the teacher librarians. Only one was negative, concerning his

or her daughter’s preference ‘to run around’ at lunch time. This was the only parent who

claimed activities ‘are only open to a certain audience… not the full school’. Everyone else

praised the programs as ‘vibrant,’ and ‘child focused’, encouraging ‘creativity and

imagination’ with a ‘holistic approach’, and the teacher librarians as ‘unbelievably

passionate’, ‘incredible’, making the girls feel ‘welcome and inspired’. This affirms Megan

and Jackie’s approach, and indicates their reach into the community.

One parent wrote with gratitude about her dyslexic daughter’s enjoyment of the ‘inclusive

and fun’ program. Another called the space ‘safe’, and others indicated their daughters loved

being there. There was evidence that parents knew about coding and robotics, however, most

of the comments related to books and reading. St Aidan’s parents value literature, and

recognise how reading benefits children. Some mentioned the opportunities for children, and

the tone was never one of privilege or expectation, rather gratitude and appreciation.

Some popular and recognisable activities, such as Earth Angels and the mother-daughter

book club, are in Megan and Jackie’s own time. Both are promoted by the school marketing

team who acknowledge the library programs attract students; however, this isn’t reflected in

the data—almost half the respondents either said they knew little about the library program,

or skipped the question, and yet all ticked at least one activity. Is this a self-promotion or

construction-of-question problem? One recommendation is to promote directly to parents,

attributing the activities to the teacher librarians to ensure acknowledgement.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 9: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Based on the responses, parents of students in the junior school are aware of the work of the

library, and are impressed and content. All of the respondents agreed the library program

benefits their daughters, so this is the best news to hear.

Student Survey Analysis

Only 35% of students responded to the survey; nonetheless, students seemed honest and

provided interesting data (Appendix H). Overwhelmingly, students said they enjoyed library

lessons—the majority chose the top two categories in the last question. These affirmations

support Megan and Jackie’s intent to offer engaging lessons. The comments (Appendix I) are

split between girls who prefer reading, and those who like to code or hands-on create,

although reading is slightly more popular. When students wrote about their enjoyment, they

mentioned ‘variety and fun’, ‘competitions’, ‘great to explore’, and ‘different’, ‘fun hands on

stuff’. Makerspaces offers learners an opportunity to investigate, collaborate, and control

their learning (EDUcause, 2013), so it’s heartening to see Megan and Jackie’s encouragement

of inquiry learning is valued by their students.

Although reading dominated the skills students believed transferred to classrooms, it’s

pleasing that designing and problem solving scored as high as bibliography creation and

searching. Megan and Jackie endeavour to build resilient individuals with multidisciplinary

skills. The more intangible skills are inherent to Makerspaces, and more difficult to teach

than content or essay structure. While students selected many skills, their articulation was

less clear. One wrote, ‘we do it in class time with the teacher’. Does that mean library doesn’t

teach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped, repeating the word

improved. A recommendation from this data is to explain how library activities align with

classroom work.

Girls are encouraged into science-related fields of study. This survey was an opportunity to

determine if Makerspaces-related coding and robotics was effective. This is split down the

middle; the data indicates there is still far to go. A recommendation is to repeat this survey in

two years to identify if increased exposure leads to increased interest.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 10: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Figure 1

Surprisingly students at St Aidan’s have opted for additional assessment, but perhaps they

have not thought it through. Narrowly, more students indicated library projects should be

marked, and many included a comment. The majority of students who chose no (Figure 1)

believe they already have enough assessment. They also believe library projects are more

about fun, and they don’t want to have to think about assessment. One astute student argued,

‘What exactly would you grade it on? There are many different things in library to do’, and

another wrote, ‘these are things we do all-out, not the neat, little things teachers expect’, an

insightful comment about how assessment has become streamlined and prescriptive.

Figure 2

The yes case can be divided into three (Figure 2). Students value library, and the idea that

important must align with assessment shows students believe teacher rhetoric. Students have

always indicated assessment as a motivator. They are aware how schools work, and apply

those understandings in their attempts to achieve, and to keep teachers happy. A

recommendation from data is that the teacher librarians hold discussions with students about

assessment, what it achieves, and why library should remain unassessed.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 11: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Overall, students’ responses reflect their upbringing. These are daughters of educated parents

who value learning and reading. They are compliant and conditioned to believe academic

success provides long-term rewards. It is affirming that they value Megan and Jackie’s

attempts to provide a variety of stimulating, self-directed experiences. Both parents and

students wrote enthusiastic comments about access to a wide variety of reading material, and

a strong recommendation is that Megan and Jackie continue to supply high quality texts to

maintain student interest in reading for pleasure.

Teacher Survey Analysis

From a possible ten there were only four responses. One objective of this survey was to

identify transferrable skills, but though all responders indicated the program benefits

students, none identified any skills. Perhaps the question should have nominated them.

Instead, teachers briefly noted their students’ interest and enjoyment of visiting the space.

Each teacher demonstrates a different degree of understanding of what the library program

can achieve. One interesting outcome is that each respondent represents a different teacher

type. Appendix J sets out the responses, and includes a table mapping teacher type to

response.

Teacher #1 represents an experienced teacher who sees the library traditionally, focusing on

books. While he or she acknowledges the library offers ‘different related activities’, there is a

desire to return ‘to the basics’, and ‘focus on pure reading’. Older teachers sometimes express

these feelings, and teacher librarians work with them to update their knowledge, skills, and

understanding of new technologies.

Teacher #2 represents someone who appears to be new and possibly young. He or she has a

better grasp of technology, and implores library staff to ‘teach me to code!’ This person

wants the library to take a leadership role by developing technology classes. Phrases like

‘excited to be in a school with an innovative library’, and ‘the staff of the junior school

library generously share their expertise’, indicate this teacher is keen to collaborate.

Teacher #3 has a strong relationship with the library, is well informed about offerings, and is

supportive and appreciative. Unfortunately no comments for questions 2 and 4 were added.

Librarians love to work with these teachers.

Teacher #4 had the least to say, and was the most negative. The survey seems an obligation.

Describing the activities offered by the library program as unique in quotation marks suggests

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 12: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

a lack of belief in the value of their uniqueness. It indicates scepticism, reinforced by the

response of no to the question whether library programs benefit the community. To go on to

comment ‘If it does I am not aware how’ suggests a disinterest in school events. Calling this

teacher independent reflects the way he or she interacts with the school community.

This data provided by teachers reinforces what Megan and Jackie already know. Their

teachers are on a spectrum of interest and skill, and need appropriate support. One

recommendation is that Megan and Jackie plan to accommodate diverse needs using this data

as a guide.

Peer Survey Analysis

Appendix K is a summary of the responses to the peer survey. Appendix L provides all

comments. Of the 17 respondents, 3 hadn’t heard of Megan and Jackie’s program. The others

responded positively. While some could name Megan and Jackie, most spoke specifically

about Makerspaces or literature, and several connected them. There were frequent references

to Megan’s blog, in which she continually shares the journey. Megan’s reach extends via

Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook (Appendix D).

Jackie’s blog is newer, but there is demand for her insights into quality Makerspaces

activities and materials. Social media has kept teacher librarians aware of many aspects of the

library program. Megan and Jackie’s confidence with these media means their message is

strong and targeted. One recommendation is for Jackie to continue to update her blog, and for

Megan to keep promoting on her own blog. Colleagues have attended webinars and

workshops led by either Megan or Jackie (Appendix D), and it is recommended that they

continue to share with their peers in these network-building communities.

Teacher librarians observe the St Aidan’s library program benefitting their community, and

make supportive comments. They also recognise the importance of what Megan and Jackie

are doing for their students. Comments which apply best include: ‘there is direction and

dedication’, ‘strong curriculum knowledge valuable to planning, teaching, and learning,’ and

‘teacher librarian is actively visible in the school’. This visibility is reflected in responses

from both parent and teacher surveys. They are seen to be engaging, and to provide a range of

student activities.

While responses to the final question reflect the various professional environments,

knowledge of the respondents’ locations would further reveal the extent of their reach. This is

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 13: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

a design flaw, and it is recommended this survey be repeated in twelve months, incorporating

a question on location.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 14: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

5. Conclusions and Recommendations

Megan Daley and Jackie Child’s library program is successful and well-known. The

stakeholder groups surveyed provided predominately positive data. Although responses from

St Aidan’s teachers were few and brief, the teacher librarian community response was

greater, and wholly supportive. Both parents and students value the extra and different

opportunities for learning, and the passion for reading and literature.

It is recommended that the library program continue unchanged, and that Megan and Jackie

continue to share via social and traditional media to strengthen their standing across the

school and the teacher communities.

Some specific recommendations are:

Keep parents informed via a short regular publication which celebrates the work in the

junior library, and informs parents of the validity of the different aspects of the program.

Keep students’ interested in reading by continuing to provide varied, high quality books.

Keep students aware of transferable skills, and explicitly outline the connection between

library work and classroom learning.

Identify increased interest in career options in science related fields by surveying students

in two years to track trends.

Keep students aware of why library projects should not be assessed, and discuss with

students the justifications and implications of formalising the library program.

Keep supporting classroom teachers’ unique needs, using the survey data as a guide.

Keep professional colleagues informed by regularly updating blogs and social media.

Determine the extent of the program’s continuing reach by repeating this survey in twelve

months, incorporating a question on location.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 15: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

6. References

7 Things you need to know about Makerspaces. (2013). Educause

Abram, S. (2015, 2015 January-February). Real makerspaces in school libraries.

Internet@Schools, 22, 10+

ACARA. (2016). Digital Technologies Curriculum. Retrieved from

http://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/technologies/digital-technologies/curriculum/f-

10?layout=1

Baxter, P. & Jack, S. (2008). Qualitative case study methodology: Study design and

implementation for novice researchers. The Qualitative Report, 13(4), 544-559. doi:

10.1.1.152.9570

Cavalcanti, G. (2013). Is it Hackerspace, Makerspace, TechShop, or FabLab? Retrieved from

http://makezine.com/2013/05/22/the-difference-between-hackerspaces-makerspaces-

techshops-and-fablabs/

Child, J. (2015). CSER MOOC. Retrieved from http://tinkeringchild.com/cser-mooc/

Daley, M. (2016) Children’s Books Daily. Retrieved from http://childrensbooksdaily.com/

Fleming, L. (2016). The power of a school library hashtag. Retrieved from

http://www.edutopia.org/article/power-of-school-library-hashtag-laura-fleming

Houston, C. (2013). Makerspaces@your school library: consider the possibilities! Paper

presented at the International Association of School Librarianship Annual Conference.

http://search.proquest.com.ezproxy.csu.edu.au/docview/1621840502?accountid=10344

Koh, K., & Abbas, J. (2015). Competencies for Information Professionals in Learning Labs

and Makerspaces. Journal of Education and Information Science, 56(2).

doi:10.12783/issn.2328-2967/56/2/3

Miller, A. (2016). What is a Makerspace? Retrieved from

https://www.makerspaces.com/what-is-a-makerspace/

Moorefield-Lang, H. (2015). Change in the Making: Makerspaces and the Ever-Changing

Landscape of Libraries. TechTrends, 59(3), 107-112. doi:10.1007/s11528-015-0860-z

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 16: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

QSLA. (2016). Brisbane sub-committee AGM and Term 1 meeting. Retrieved from

http://www.qsla.org.au/calendar/2016/3/9/brisbane-subcommittee-agm-term-1-meeting

Sharwood, S. (2015). Australia's digital technologies curriculum parked again. The Register.

Retrieved from

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/03/06/australias_digital_technologies_curriculum_p

arked_again/

Technovation. (2016). Retrieved from http://www.technovationchallenge.org/

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 17: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

7. Appendices

A. Phone call with Jackie ChildAfter sending Megan and Jackie a draft of my assignment, I spoke with Jackie on the phone

on 8 October 2016. Unfortunately, she has been overseas for the past four weeks, and prior to

leaving, just at the time I was putting together the surveys and discussing what we wanted to

achieve, she was in the middle of marking and reporting. She had a week to mark 60

assignments, so she apologised for her lack of input into the design and dissemination of the

surveys. It is my personal belief that had Jackie been in the school at this time, we would

have received a much better response rate from both teachers and students as she would have

been able to assist Megan at this busy time.

I asked Jackie about her skills update. She told me that her interest in the Makerspaces

movement started about three years when she attended a seminar on the topic. Jackie could

see how this movement would incorporate many components of the Digital Technologies

Curriculum, and from there, Jackie was driven by her passion in this area to learn as much as

she could. She completed a (free) MOOC in her own time, and other professional

development opportunities at her expense, and she does it willingly. Jackie sees young people

(particularly young women) who are scared to take risks, or to make mistakes, and she argues

that hands-on creative projects like tech makerspaces is a way to learn these types of skills.

The fact that she is part-time means she does have some time to learn these skills, and she is

amazed at how much interest (both locally and globally) there is in her journey.

She was also keen to try to explain the low numbers of respondents, and mentioned that lots

of girls are taken out of the school in the last week to travel with family. While this is a

negative for our surveys, she believes these girls are getting a lot of rewards by learning

about other cultures and opening their eyes to many aspects that schools can’t and don’t

cover. As far she’s concerned, travel is beneficial and worth the loss of school time.

Jackie is very excited about collaborating with the IT teacher from the secondary school at St

Aidan’s, Tim Kemp. Having to work in the secondary library has given her an opportunity to

develop working relationships with other teachers she has not known before. This was one

positive benefit from working full-time. She and Tim have started an Technovations group

that now meet after school on a Thursday. It brings together students from both sides of the

school campus to be part of a global challenge. It just started recently and Jackie spoke at

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 18: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

length about motivating girls to check it out by promising them fun and challenging

activities.

It’s interesting to note that Jackie’s time in the library during her two days at school is

limited. She teaches two Year 6 History/Geography classes, and take sport on Friday

afternoons. She and Megan collaboratively wrote the early programs and Megan does a lot of

the teaching of it, but now they have little time to update materials. I believe Jackie spends

some of her days off working on aspects of the program, and this is because she values the

Makerspaces program, and believes it benefits the girls in many ways.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 19: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

B. Meeting with Megan Daley and Jackie ChildI met with Megan and Jackie on 1 September 2016 and it was productive.

We discussed their aims, their achievements, and their expectations for the case study. Each

class is given one lesson a week, but the activities spill over into break times, which are

before school and lunchtime. Students can collect any material or equipment they want and

can continue to work on their project independently. The only issues Megan and Jackie have

with this, are the times when students’ leave the items without returning them to where they

got them (which is often), and when they constantly ask where items are stored, which is

frustrating for the teacher librarians.

Megan and Jackie are a genuine team and bring different skill sets to the partnership. Jackie

is the scientist, the coder, the builder. Megan is the marketer, the wordsmith, the promoter.

Their support of each other is unequivocal. It’s also clear they have taught each other these

skills. Megan is learning to code, and Jackie is blogging at a new site, where she outlines all

her accomplishments and experiences. They are both very experienced teachers and

librarians, and were building lessons based on practical skills, incorporating inquiry learning,

and developing inclusive environments for many years before this.

Jackie has a Year 6 History/Geography class and has been incorporating elements of the

library program into her lessons. She sees a huge potential for crossover into other

classrooms, and both TLs can see how these types of experiences impact on student learning.

While they do spend time planning their lessons, there is also a degree of flexibility, and

activities are modified after being taught, so they are always being improved. They spoke

highly of a text that informs their practice – Beautiful Failures by Lucy Clarke. They have a

quality list of texts that they share with the teacher librarian community. This is a positive

aspect of the partnership. They love to share and don’t expect anything in return.

Their biggest issue is time. They want to develop the program further, and believe empirical

data will support the good work they are trying to accomplish, and want to use it to back their

requests for further investment, both in time and money. They know the leadership team

supports their endeavours, but are less certain about the classroom teachers, and they secretly

seem a bit worried about what the teachers might report back.

We discussed the surveys, and the timelines, and I was given a tour of the library spaces, and

the tools and equipment they use to engage the students. They are very aware of the digital

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 20: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

technologies curriculum, and deliberately include many elements in their program. They use

literature as a jumping point, and spoke about their ‘Maker Faire’ which they ran last week, a

huge component of their Book Week celebrations. I took many photos.

They agreed to survey parents, teachers, and students. We have two weeks of school until the

September holidays, so the surveys should be disseminated next week. We discussed the type

of questions, and drafted some possible choices for me to work on.

The program has developed very organically, and they have bought items from their ordinary

budget allocation. They have never asked for or received special funding, although they don’t

discount in the future. While they believe the work they do will impact directly on classroom

learning, they also feel strongly that their engagement with students should primarily be

about enjoyment and pleasure, and not about assessment and outcomes.

I asked about unexpected outcomes, and argued they are the leading edge of this type of

library program. Megan insists Jackie is the leader, and she is being (happily) dragged along.

But it’s clear that Megan’s promotion through social media is giving them a wider audience.

Organisations and networks often approach them to talk about the program. TLs are

requesting to visit, and this is having the added bonus of drawing attention to the school in

the wider community.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 21: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

C. Email to teachers requesting responses to survey

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 22: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

D. Megan and Jackie’s social media networks and recent presentations

Jackie’s SMS Megan’s SMS

Blog

Twitter: @jackie_child

Facebook

Pinterest

Blog

Twitter: @daleyreads

Facebook

Pinterest

Instagram: @childrensbooksdaily

Megan was awarded the Qld Teacher Librarian of the Year Award in 2015 at the Futures

Library Conference 0n August 19 2015.

Presented at the QSLA Brisbane Sub-Committee AGM together March 2016

Article published in QSLA April 2016 ‘Coding in the Primary Years’ (picture from QSLA

newsletter, April 2016)

Presented together at EDUTech Conference in Brisbane June 2016

Jackie presented at the Future Schools Expo/Conference in Sydney in March 2016

Megan in June on school book clubs, and in July 2016 on literature supporting makerspaces.

Both were webinars.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 23: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Jackie presented a webinar in August 2016 on Keeping the makerspaces momentum moving

Jackie presented to the Logan Secondary Teacher Librarian Network on June 16 with Anne

Weaver, discussing STEM programs in libraries. (picture, article from QSLA newsletter Sept

2016)

Stars of the first ‘Magic Moments’ promotional video for St Aidan’s (search for ‘magic

moments episode 1’)

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 24: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

E. Email and Twitter call requesting responses from teacher librarians

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 25: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 26: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

F. Summary of results from parent survey

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 27: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 28: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 29: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

G. Parent commentsQ1. What do you know about the Junior School Library Program (24 comments 4

skipped the question)

1. That there is a coding club and a mother and daughter book club.

2. A little. I have been involved with Mother Daughter book club and also attended events in

the library around

literacy and reader events.

3. Not much

4. The program is exceptional, providing students with endless opportunities and focusing on

a love of everything to do with books.

5. Encourages the girls to read a wide variety of books

6. Regular author visits, open before/after/during school, Book week celebrations, borrowing

of all book types encouraged, lots of 'activities' running throughout the term – the library is

no longer a quiet place just for reading!

7. I know that it is a very successful program that offers lots of magnificent opportunities to

young girls

8.Very minor - my 'kindy' child visits the library every Wednesday and obtains books for

reading. I know nothing other.

9. That we have a fantastic librarian who loves her job. There are many different activities on

offer at the library for the girls. My daughter loves her library lessons and also going there in

her lunch time.

10. I know that each year group spends time in the library learning from Megan Daley and/or

Jaqui Child. They do the most amazing things with the girls and the kindy boys!

11. Not a lot at this point. My daughter is in kindy, so they go to the library once a week, and

hire out two new books.

12. Very little

13. It's about a lot more than books- libraries have transformed since I was a school student-

the librarians at St Aidans are at the pointy end of innovation-the physical library space at the

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 30: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Jr school is very inviting- when we toured the school prior to enrolling the library space as a

reflection of learning sold the deal.

14. nothing

15. Not much to be honest apart from the days that the girls change their books plus I

accompany them somedays to change books outside of usual lesson times.

16. It's a very vibrant, child focussed engaging environment in which the girls feel welcomed

and inspired.

17. not a lot. A few of the programs are really only open to a certain audience.... Not the full

school. I keep trying to ask my daughter to do coding and chess at lunch but she prefers to

run around outside! (Not a bad option either) But she does love to borrow books and enjoys

that new books are available regularly

18. I know we've got two very excellent teacher librarians who are sensitive and responsive

to our student's needs. Their passion is evident, as are their efforts at integrating the library

into the mainstream curriculum. In terms of the library 'program', I know they offer

something for nearly everyone, from Maker Space to Coding to Lego to robotics and exciting

author visits.

19. It is a learning area for girls. they have specialised teachers who help the girls to choose

books suitable to their needs and interests.

20. A wholistic approach filled wiht enthusiasm not only for books but fro other resources as

a part of the child's learning.

21. It's a lovely space which is very well utilised by the girls and at the heart of the Junior

School. I believe this is largely due to the two wonderful teachers that run the library.

22. no in-depth knowledge

23. Girls are read to in library lessons, they participate in coding activities, they borrow

books, do charity projects,

author visits, M/daughter book club, Reader Cup.

24. Very Little

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 31: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Q4. In what ways does the library program benefit your daughter(s)? (26 comments 0

skipped).

1. She benefits from participating - it's educational, social etc

2. Engaging

3. She sees herself as a successful reader. Reading is a normal part of her daily routine. She

gets excited about particular authors and genres. Sees the library as the fun place to be.

4. Get involved in the school and integrate with all year levels

5. My daughter has a love of literature and values the role of an author. It also allows my

daughter to value the skills of other students that may not be able to showcase their talents

easily. It allows my daughter to be involved !!!!

6. Both of my daughters have utilised the school library to extend the range of books they are

exposed to. Both have been involved in reader's cup. Mother-daughter book club is difficult

because of work commitments.

7. Exposure to a variety of text types Exposure to a range of authors Encouraging children to

read - it isn't a 'nerdy' thing to do

8. Overall development and literacy

9. Reading is a high priority learning outcome in my opinion. The ability to read is critical to

her learning development over many and varied aspects of her education and development.

Reading ability, in my opinion, cannot be understated.

10. Having access to the books and being able to borrow at any time is a very lucky thing.

Megan Daley is an inspirational teacher and teachers her classes in creative and different

ways. She has certainally funked up the library! Going to the library isn't daggy anymore!! :-)

11. Anything that supports her love of reading is beneficial, and she loves going to the school

library. I have also visited the library with my daughter a couple of times, and I love that it is

a non-traditional library! I love that everyone talks in normal voices (not the horrible silence

that I grew up with), that it is a place where the girls can do more than just read, and that it is

a place where the girls actually enjoy being because there's so much to do. When you read

about what the future workforce looks like, creativity (and not just in an artistic sense, but

also the ability to think outside the square or do things differently) will become an incredibly

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 32: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

important skill to have, because computers, hopefully, will never be able to replicate this, as

they inevitably will do with so many other jobs. Creativity and imagination are so inter-

twined, so I think reading is a vitally important element in opening their minds and allowing

their creative and imaginative thoughts to take hold and flourish. Apologies if I haven't

articulated that very well!

12. Borrows books on Wednesday library visits.

13. See Q1- library space in't just about books anymore.

14. She likes to spend her lunch time there. She reads alot.

15. I am a firm believer of reading to and with the girls and have been from an early age. The

school library has given the girls access to a different variety of books other than their

bookshelf's at hime

16. My youngest daughter loves to visit the library to make things with her friends at morning

tea / lunchtime. My older daughter enjoyed mother daughter book club and I experienced the

enthusiasm and passion for learning displayed by Mrs Megan Daley during this activity. Our

children are lucky to have such great resource (both human and non-human!)

17. Reading, no matter who inspires it, is a great advantage...

18. Eldest daughter lives in the library, it's her sanctuary. Librarians work with me to actively

engage her in interacting with other students (by even kicking her out sometimes).

19. My daughter has dyslexia and feel anxious about reading in class room settings but the

library is one of her favourite places at school. She has a positive association with books and

has participated in readers cup. I think this because of how the library space is organised and

that the programmes are so inclusive and fun.

20. it helps my daughters to develop their own interests and enhances there knowledge and

enjoyment of school

21. To creat a love of books and learning about many other things they offer which in turn

support classroom programs

22. Absolutely. The girls are being shown how dynamic a library space can be and this

versatility demonstrates there is something for everyone.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 33: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

13. Positive focus on reading. The skill and enjoyment of reading seems a very core principal

of the teaching staff at St Aidans and they way in which our kids are exposed has resulted in

a very health update and respect for reading

24. We are so fortunate to have unbelievably passionate Teacher Librarians in the Junior

School Library. Their genuine interest in the school the children and their roles has been so

instrumental in building a fantastic relationship between the children and the library space.

25. Wonderful literary environment with great breadth of teaching. Girls are very fortunate to

be exposed to as many fields of literature and language as they are through our incredible

librarians. Very much doubt most schools have as many top opportunities in an ongoing

manner.

26. The variety of programs & the interaction

Q5. How else can the Junior School Library promote their program to reach parents

and the wider community? (15 comments 13 skipped).

1. Invite parent helpers in.

2. Open days? Signage in community about events.

3. More information on Facebook/Instagram/ notes sent home directly to parents

4. Signs/message boards would be useful correspondence directly into the diary (ie A4 note

put into diary).

5. Sending out more communications to parents

6. Promotion of the programs available. Unfortunately, whether through lack of my

engagement in this aspect of school life, or due to non-promotion of the programs available

by the school itself, I simply don't know what is on offer apart from my daughter bringing a

book home for me to read to her. Perhaps a flyer (paper or email) could be provided.

7. Possible parent/student days/classes in the library?

8. Perhaps some communication directly from the librarians (part of the school newsletter,

separate newsletter via email, facebook page??).

9. I'd love to know if the library is open before and after school to choose books with my

child- maybe it is and I am ignorant- but I'd love an afternoon a week where it was open tip

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 34: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

430 or 5pm so I could go form work to pick up to library- maybe not to borrow but just enjoy

the space together?

10. Newsletter

11. I am not sure ...

12, No thoughts on this one. :) But you have left Prep off the list below in Q6. So tick a Prep

box for me there.

13, Continue with class/student and emails.

14. I think they do a pretty good job as it is.

15. I think possibly having the library newsletter with what our girls are doing included in the

classroom termly newsletter may not bring library 'news' to the fore sufficiently. I think most

parents reading that focus on the English/Maths/Science & other subjects and possibly don't

give the library section sufficient attention at this point at the start of term. The same info

communicated again just from the librarians perhaps would be good though perhaps some

parents don't want any more emails. Do feel parents are quite remote from whole library

experience as no p/t interviews or direct correspondence really. Librarians do a fabulous job

and I'm happy to learn more of what they offer, more often.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 35: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

H. Summary of student responses

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 36: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 37: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

I. Comments from students Q3 Pick your top three library activities (students were given an option to leave a

comment)

1. I also like making things with tinkerkad.

2. Makerspace

3. Technology

4. I enjoy going onto the computer

Q4. Tick the skills you have been using in the classroom (students were given an option

to leave a comment) 15 students did.

1. Many of these skills we already knew, but we improved them. Some where new, and all of

them really helped with assessment and learning.

2. Umm...

3. By doing these activities, I have been improving these skills.

4. By doing activities.

5. In assignments and other tests I have found these skills very useful.

6. letting us learn what to do when we get older like teaching us life skills and encouraging

people to read and learn more.

7. We read books that associate with the subject and talk about it in deeper context.

8. controlling BB8 was good for iPad navigation

9. Encouraging everyone to be evolved in Readers Cup and other occasions that encore to

reading, designing and searching skills.

10. we do it In class time with the teacher.

11. computers descusionss

12. in learning new stuff and finding new skills

13. by reading and writing you can do essays and get a high mark bskillsuse you used good

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 38: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

14. I'm an avid reader, and the library has a lot of books and I enjoy drawing and creating

very much.

15. by reading and writing reports about books.

Q5 Have you been encouraged to consider computer science and/or engineering as a

career path? (Students were given an option to leave a comment to the question, ‘in

what ways?’) 5 comments were given.

1. I am not extremely interested in robotics and coding, bot some coding I do enjoy.

2. Yes, I know that the 'in what ways' is a typo (is it?). But I chose it because I don't really

know. I have goals and things and I have a bit of a life plan going. But it hasn't not either. I

am undecided on this!

3. I want to program machines and make apps but that's all.

4. Because I am not interested in coding, more in reading.

5. I chose yes because I find in fun to code and make different things.

Q6. Should marks be assigned to library projects (then given an option to leave a

comment) 32 comments were given (the capitalised ‘NO’ & ‘YES’ has been added by

me)

1. NO Girls are already putting time into other things like studying and sport activities and do

not need another thing to worry about

2. NO Because we don't do any library projects.

3. YES I think library projects are really fun and should have marks assigned for them.

4. YES I believe that librabry should be a subject included on the report card because it is

English in reading books and you may say that it is a subject that not all people would want

to but sport is included.

5. NO because i think library is an activity that should be fun and not about grades. it should

take peoples mind of assessments and tests.

6. YES Because it pushes you to put in extra effort with your library projects!

7. NO We hardly ever finish projects, and the lessons are very short. We hardly have enough

time to read 1 picture book. None of them are really interesting, or big, and they are not

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 39: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

related to learning. If marks were assigned, we would need longer and more frequent lessons,

and more major and interactive projects, that were going to impact on our education.

8. NO What exactly would you grade it on? There are many different things in library to do.

Also, it is nice to have a lesson where you don't have to worry about your grades!

9. NO It is because I think that this should not be graded.

10. NO Library is fun to me and I don't want to be marked on it!

11. NO Because library is where we borrow books, not a subject

12. YES it is always good to see were you need to improve.

13. YES Yes because I think it would encourage me more and help me.

14. NO Because we already have a lot of marks

15. NO these are things we do all-out, not the neat, little things teachers expect.

16. NO Because library projects are a way to have fun and think about things other than

grades.

17. YES because it is a nather way to in pres your focks.

18. YES because you learn from your bad marks and try harder!!!!!!!

19. YES because you might want to know how you are doing in class

20. YES because it teaches us what we need to focus on.

21. YES Because library is an important subject that includes most subjects.

22. NO I don't think so because it is just for fun and learning and if we are getting marked on

it, it will feel like a test

23. YES Yes because the teachers need to know that we understand during the project.

24. YES To show the teachers what or how many books your pupils are reading daily,

weekly, or monthly.

25. NO no because I don't like being critised and juged about how smart I am

26. NO Because Library Isn't An Important Subject Really Subject As History or Science In

My Humble Opinion. Not To Offend Anyone, It's Just My Opinion

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 40: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

27. YES because they make us work harder

28. YES because then it will show hard work to earn a good grade

29. YES yes becauseit is a really good oppitunetty to know how your going with your library

lessons.

30. YES I chose yes because I like to know how I do in library tests and see what I can do

differently

31. YES Because students could see their teachers feedback, and what they can do better next

time.

32. YES because reading gives you answers to many things

Q7 Is library enjoyable for you? (students were given an option to leave a comment) 35

comments were given

1. I love them because of the variety and fun activities that we do in lessons. For example, the

Rio Olympics wall of competitions.

2. there books who does not love books

3. because I love to read!!!!

4. because I love to read every night ( I try to)

5. because it teaches us to read and enjoy learning and joining clubs such as coding.

6. Library has so many meanings and has a lot of areas that are great to explore and are

interesting.

7. I love library lessons because we usually do fun hands on stuff.

8. I love them because they are fun and we have really good teachers.

9. I just love to read in a corner in my own time because it calms me as well as helping my

education.

10. because some times its not fun but 99% is fun

11. I love reading!

12. because library lessons involve reading

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 41: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

13. I don't enjoy coding as I don't understand it and it doesn't interest me.

14. ii do like most lessons because they are fun but sometimes I don't like them

15. I love library lessons because they are peaceful and I can just sit down and read. I also

love it because I like the activities

16. library = book. BOOK!!!!!!

17. they are so much fun there are lots of different

18. I love library because we get to do fun and awesome activities

19. I just love library

20. I don't think we benefit from the lessons.

21. Library lessons are really fun because I love reading and craft.

22. Because they are fun and have different rotations each week that include borrowing,

literature skills and coding skills that are always interesting and teach me something new

23. i think it could be a bit more interactive with people and not just doing work on your

laptops.

24. I love most of my library lessons because they involve free silent reading and computers.

Some that i'm not so keen on involve having books read to me, or if they are slightly boring!

25. I find all all the lessons very enjoyable

26. They are too short to really get into anything. I really dislike coding, which is one of the

main things we have to do. I am not learning anything, except when we focus on something

( e.g how to write a bibliography.) and we don't usually. If we had more lessons and they

were longer, as well as it being based more on the library and books rather then computers

and coding, I would enjoy it more. I love being in the library, but the lessons just aren't as

interesting as they could be.

27. I don't think that any class in the entire world has lessons that everybody loves all the

time. I think most activities are fun and cool. I like the TinkerCad thing that we are doing at

the moment. One thing I don't really like is having books read to me usually I am either not

interested or it is kind of too young (I am reading young adult books)

28. I would prefer reading more than coding and robotics things.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 42: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

29. Sometimes I don't enjoy library lessons because we don't get to do very interesting things.

I love creating things, and also designing things too. I also think there needs to be more

variety with what we do during the time that we have in the library.

30. I enjoy reading activities but I don't enjoy doing coding activities.

31. Because we usually do fun things most of the time

32. I like some things but not others

33. I think library lessons are fun and efficient

34. Because they are good library teachers and they do fun activities.

35. some are a little boring, and i like craft, robotics and reading, not sheet work.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 43: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

J. Summary of teacher responsesComments are complete and unabridged, however, for the purposes of aligning the table to

the comments, I have added, ‘no comment left’ to the corresponding number.

Teacher

Type

Perception of

Teacher Librarians

Working relationship Example of language

used in comments

#1 The Old

School

Confined, limiting,

narrow

Minimal, distant,

professional

Literary focus. Reading is

good, back to basics

#2 The

Newbie

Enthusiastic, high

expectations, needy

Subordinate, requires

guidance and much

support

Excited. TLs are generous,

innovative, and engaging

#3 The

Genuine

Article

Positive, supportive,

informed

collaborative,

personable, willing,

open

TLs are accessible,

knowledgeable, excellent

resource

#4 The

Independent

Uninterested, self-

motivated, needs-

based only

Non-existent Not sure how TLs benefit

wider community

The above table sums up the type of teacher each of the four respondents represents. Teacher

#1 in the table corresponds to the comments on all questions numbered 1.

Q1 What is your understanding of the Junior School Library Program? (open ended

Question – all 4 left a comment)

1. Different learning related activities with a literary focus.

2. I don't know a lot about the program. I have only started here this year. I believe the library

has broadened its offerings to include maker spaces and all things technology (3D printer and

coding resources). I know they also foster a love of literature in our girls by connecting girls

with books and authors.

3. 1. Quality librarian delivering essential skills for literacy and literature development. 2.

provide resources for research and teach how to access information 3. maker space activities

(design and technology) 4. provide author study visits

4. I understand it to work in conjunction with class activities as well as providing

opportunities for teachers and students to access more 'unique' activities

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 44: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Q2. Has the junior school library altered or repositioned itself within the school

community? (option to comment 2 of the 4 made a comment).

1. I am not sure I have been here long enough. (responded NO to the question)

2. I feel excited to be in a school with an innovative library that sets the standard for other

school libraries. YES

3. YES but didn’t leave a comment

4. NO but didn’t leave a comment

Q3. Do you believe the library program benefits students in your classroom (option to

leave a comment 3 of the 4 did).

1. Reading is always good. YES

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 45: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

2. The girls are engaged in the program and speak about it very positively. I believe they are

learning valuable skills. YES

3. The students are motivated to visit the library on a weekly and on volunteer basis. The

students have amazing opportunities to do more than just read in this library - they create,

make, design, etc. The students have access to technology and print resources in the school.

YES

4. YES but didn’t leave a comment

Q4. Do you believe the junior program benefits the wider community (option to

comment which 3 or the 4 did).

1. Yes. Books are great! YES

2. The staff of the Junior School library generously share their expertise in many ways with a

broad audience. YES

3. YES but didn’t leave a comment

4. NO If it does I am not aware how it does this.

Q5. Can you suggest ways to improve the junior school library program? (comments

only question. Three teachers responded, one skipped)

1. Maybe take some things back to the basics. Focus on pure reading again.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 46: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

2. I would like to see a coding program taught in a sequential way across the school. I would

like to see the library staff lead this development by working with class teachers, as they have

the expertise and the enthusiasm to make it work.

3. The library is always up to date with latest publications and the resources we have help to

implement our ACARA units. No suggestions to improve - the librarians are leading and

assisting us in so many ways.

4. Didn’t leave a comment

Q6. Are there other ways the junior school library staff could assist you in your

classroom teaching and learning? (Comments only question. 2 teachers answered two

skipped)

1. didn’t leave a comment

2. Teach me how to teach coding please!

3. no - they are always very accessible, helpful, knowledgeable. We have an excellent

resource at our school

4. Didn’t leave a comment

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 47: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

K. Summary of peer responses.Q1 What do you know about the St Aidan’s Junior School Library Program?

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 48: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 49: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 50: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

L. Peer commentsQ1. What do you know about the St Aidan’s Junior School Library Program?

(comments only – all 17 provided a comment)

1. Well run junior primary school library with innovative teacher librarians who are

passionate about reading. Child friendly.

2. It has a renowned makerspace

3. Runs a well established MAKERSPACE.

4. I have read a great deal about their makerspace program and other activities such as Earth

Angels, involvement with Hour of Code, the way they have structured their library lessons

etc. When we started our makerspace I gave Jackie a call and she was extremely helpful and

generous with her advice.

5. NOthing

6. I have visited the school to look at it.

7. The have 2 fabulous TLs. Jackie has more the tech focus whilst Megan has the lit focus. it

is based in a school that has a high socio economic clientele so students are lucky in being

able to access a wide range of resources carefully chosen by their TLs. Both of them are

exceptional in their knowledge and skills and very dedicated. Any young lady lucky enough

to be part of their programs are VERY lucky.

8. Nothing

9. No, but would like to see and know more about it.

10. They have a huge Makerspace program and Megan Daley does many reviews for her blog

'Children's Books Daily'

11. Lots of exciting things happening, makerspaces, great team of 2 librarians

12. Maker spaces Teaching programming

13. Makerspace program. They run their library classes in groups, and some do Makerspace,

others literacy and some borrowing. Leaders in Makerspaces in Libraries. Also mini-displays

of books in boxes.

14. I follow Megan on Linked in, Twitter and Facebook.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 51: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

15. It's interesting, engaging and colourful - Makerspace, Book Week, love of literature and

enthusiasm for books

16. Make a space

17. That it is a combination of literature and makerspace (both high tech and low tech) that

supports the Aus curriculum.

Q2. How did you hear about the St Aidan’s Junior Library Program? (comments only –

all 17 provided a comment)

1. Colleagues

2. through social networking regarding the makersapce

3. Discussion forums / lists, at professional developments.

4. QSLA newsletters, conference presentations, Megan and Jackie's blogs, OZTL list.

5. through this survey

6. Teacher Librarian - Future Libraries programme

7. Through Megan's blog and twitter

8. I didn't

9. Via the grape vine, I did hear some great things happening at St Aidan's Junior Library.

Just haven't had to time to visit.

10. Being subscribed to Megan's blog and via OZTL Net and COTLIBs network meetings.

11. Children's Books Daily - Facebook

12. Through various library networks and literature

13. Megan's blog, magazine articles, Jackie's webinars

14. Social media sites.

15. Facebook

16. QSLA meeting link up chat

17. Originally through "Children's Books Daily" blog after "meeting" Megan Daley as a

fellow student in the QUT TL Masters course. Also through QSLA email about PD they held.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 52: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

Q3 Do you believe the library program benefits the role of the teacher librarian? (all 17

agreed with the statement. 14 left a comment as well)

1. The Tls give the knowledge and passion to the job that only a professional can; they run

parent programs and book club; there is direction and dedication to the role.

2. it increases the role and significance of the library and the teacher librarian in schools. Sets

an excellent role model.

3. Expert knowledge of literature, reading promotion, inquiry learning, information literacy.

A support to teachers in resource selection, implementing inquiry learning and promoting

reading. Has strong curriculum to knowledge valuable to planning, teaching and learning.

4. Absolutely. That is who we are and what we do.

4. By having such a close association with the students and being allowed to make their

'library' a true resource centre and makerspace they epitomise the role of a TL.

6. The connection is obvious

7. Having a program would see skills etc. develop sequentially and obviously beneficial when

people ask what you are doing in the library. It would also establish what you see your role as

and how you want to support classroom units. It also looks professional.

8. I think their program greatly benefits the role of the TL as it makes them well known in the

wider community, not only to other TLs but to important education stakeholders such as

parents, principals and college boards.

9. Teacher librarian is actively visible in the school to students, staff and parents

10. Advertises the role of the TL and how they are capable of contributing to the digital and

technical and computational education of students

11. Yes, it works for them in their school, and they have been wonderful advocates for

Teacher Librarianship. They have brought attention to the different activities which can be

hosted in the Library space. I don't believe that we all need to be doing the same thing. We

need to be finding the best possible way of working in our own context to promote literature,

support our teachers and students, promote enquiry and curiousity.

12. Most definitely.

P J Buckley Case Study findings

Page 53: Executive Summary - TinkeringChildtinkeringchild.com/.../uploads/2016/10/Junior-Library-Cas…  · Web viewteach any skills? However, some students indicated library lessons helped,

13. promotes and encourages inquiry learning, effective advocacy of TL role, encourages

students to 'have a go' and make mistakes

14. It gives another dimension to use literature, opens up more opportunities for students to

make and create, gives more reasons for students to be in the Library.

P J Buckley Case Study findings