evidence-based design thesis_paulramoie_2014

38
Dynamic Design: How Evidence-Based Design Creates a Happy, Healthy You Paul A. Ramoie, Student ASID The Illinois Institute of Art- Chicago

Upload: paul-ramoie

Post on 16-Feb-2017

1.426 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Dynamic Design:

How Evidence-Based DesignCreates a Happy, Healthy You

Paul A. Ramoie, Student ASIDThe Illinois Institute of Art-

Chicago

Page 2: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Table of Contents

Artists Philosophy 3Thesis Paper 4wORKS CITED 19ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY 23PORTFOLIO PRESENTATION 26

Page 3: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Table of Contents

Artists Philosphy Since I was a young child, I have been fascinated with the world of design and architecture. It started out with endless hours of play-ing with Legos, connecting them together to build homes, buildings, cities, castles, cars, and other things. From there, it progressed into watching Bob Villa on TLC and other various construction and design shows. It eventually evolved into architectural and design programs for my computer, and I would draft out floor plans and build inte-riors. It was a no brainer that I would choose Interior Design as my life’s work. Now that I am studying and working in the interior design field, I’ve realized the impact that interiors and structures have on our ev-eryday lives. My designs have the ability to shape the places we live, work, shop, learn, play and heal. My portfolio of work is very modern and structural. I love in-corporating nature, texture, curvilinear and organic shapes into some of my designs while contrasting them with clean, rectilinear spaces, pops of color, and strong concepts. Each design has a unique focal point to draw your attention. I believe that design transforms lives and that interior design and architecture should be for everyone, and that all people should have access to healthy, healing, positive spac-es as a democratic right. It is my goal to use my skills to give back to local communities through non-profit design work for the vulnerable and those in need, including veterans and homeless people. I see this as a social responsibility and why I am passionate about designing inte-rior spaces. It not only humbles me, but brings gratitude and perspec-tive to what I do. As an interior designer, what sets me apart from the average decorator is my education and my unique knowledge of industry re-search, such as evidence-based design, well-being and sustainability, social responsibility and the ways this knowledge impacts design and its outcome for clients. This helps to showcase the positive impact of design on the human experience and the value interior designers pro-vide. This is why implementing evidence-based design research into my work is essential in setting me apart from the typical designer or decorator. The built environment can have a tremendous impact on the physical and psychological life experience of those that occupy the space. Evidence-based design takes hard facts, research, and results of previous designs into account when creating a new, fully functional, aesthetically pleasing space. Every detail, every color and every ob-ject has a specific purpose to improve the lives of the client, whether that is a therapeutic approach, a sustainability approach, or a barrier-free environment approach. Evidence-based design is used to aid and assist in your design application. My designs bring healing and dignity to my clients. Interior design is a natural choice for me. It allows a hands-on experience in a flexible, ever-evolving industry while remaining consis-tent and challenging. The best part for me is creating functional living spaces that people will be enjoying for years to come and walking away feeling fulfilled. Little pieces of your heart, mind, and soul are left behind everywhere you go. Who wouldn’t want a creative, rewarding ca-reer like this?

Page 4: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 1

Research has become a vital, essential, and expected component of the design

process in the field of professional interior design. Research results in better design

solutions, and end-user satisfaction. As the profession has evolved and designers are faced

with new issues and challenges, the rise of the internet and DIY clients and TV shows, it has

become necessary to qualify design solutions with facts and evidence that results in safe,

healthy, and healing environments that pure aesthetics and decorating alone cannot

provide. In steps Evidence-Based Design (or, EBD), a revolutionary and innovative tool that

is both practical and philosophical.

Evidence-Based Design originated in the healthcare industry due to the importance

of evidence-based medicine culture. Its implementation of research and hard data focuses

on improving patient and staff outcomes, well-being, patient healing, safety, stress

reduction, environments, and psychology. Due to its phenomenal success with patient

outcomes in the healthcare design industry, evidence-based design is becoming a necessary

standard in residential and hospitality applications. Interior designers use EBD to collect

the best quality of research to apply to design problems for successful outcomes, to add

credibility and innovation to their designs, increase their worth and value to clients and

employers, and enhance the bottom line. Design decisions are directly based on

quantitative and qualitative research and knowledge and then applied as solutions.

(Nussbaumer).

So, what is evidence-based design? EBD is defined as “a process for the

conscientious, explicit, and judicious use of current best evidence from research and

practice in making critical decisions, together with an informed client, about the design of

each individual unique project.” (Nussbaumer). And “Evidence-based design is the process

Page 5: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 2

of basing decisions about the built environment on credible research to achieve the best

possible outcomes.” (EDAC/TCH). EBD links research to your design, helps to support the

decisions you ultimately make, and leads to innovative results that can be further studied

along with new discoveries.

Let’s learn about how EBD has evolved over the years. Evidence-based Design as a

concept originated in the 1970’s with basic research methods. In 1978, the Planetree model

was established. Planetree is a non-profit organization that aims to demystify the

healthcare experience and create a more personalized, humanized environment that

focuses on healing and nurturing the mind, body, and spirit. (Planetree). Planetree

Designation is the only program of its kind emphasizing patient-person-centered care

based on evidence and standards that is putting the needs of the individual first.

(Planetree). Patient-centered care has a direct relationship between the built environment,

its materials, and the physical well-being of the individuals in healthcare facilities. (Zengul,

et. al.).

Planetree’s Designation Program assists in making the patient-centered care

concept practicable, attainable, and measurable with clear guidelines and definitions of

what it means to be patient-centered. Patient-centered care is about safety, accessibility,

and high-quality environments that have a holistic feel to enhance and improve healing,

health, and well-being for all. (Planetree).

During the 1980’s Roger S. Ulrich, Ph.D., EDAC paved the way for innovative

research on healthcare facilities and healing environments. Dr. Ulrich’s study in 1984

revealed that surgical patients who had exposure to nature had fewer complications,

required less pain medication, and healed faster than in traditional hospital settings with

Page 6: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 3

no nature views. Other studies of his showed the psychological effects of lighting and noise

on care patients. (Ulrich, et. al.). Dr. Ulrich’s most recent studies address the effects of a

single bed vs. multi-bed patient room on infection transmission rates, the negative effects

of noise levels on patients and staff, and the benefit of nature and artwork. (The Center for

Health Design). These studies provide a direct link of the environment to the improvement

of patients and staff on duty, their wellness and happiness.

In 1993, The Center for Health Design was formed by a small group of pioneering

healthcare and design professionals. CHD leads the way in improving the qualities of

healthcare through the design of the built environment (healthdesign.org). CHD’s mission

is to transform healthcare environments for healthy aging, and a healthier, safer world

through design research, education, and advocacy. (The Center for Health Design).

By 2000, The Center for Health Design had a vision for a guide that the healthcare

industry, interior designers and architects could follow. The result of that vision was The

Pebble Project. The Pebble Project seeks to direct, teach and assist healthcare providers,

architecture and design firms, and industry partners to use an evidence-based design

process in their healthcare environment projects. (The Center for Health Design).

“As a Pebble Project Partner, the commitment to perform research on the effectiveness of the

design on clinical outcomes, patient and staff satisfaction has resulted in evidence that will

guide future design decisions as we strive to create the most healing environments.” ~ Sue Ann

BartonPrincipal, ZGF Architects, LLP (The Center for Health Design).

Research is focused in areas of quality of care, patient safety, staff safety, and

environmental safety. Evidence-based design features are used to improve outcomes such

as patient and staff satisfaction, fewer infections and injuries, better work flow and

Page 7: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 4

circulation, reduced noise and medical errors, and other areas of concern. (The Center for

Health Design).

In 2003, evidence-based design was officially “defined” and given standards by D.

Kirk Hamilton, FAIA, FACHA, EDAC. As of 2008, TCH has completed over 1200 post-

occupant studies that provide evidence for projects. Between 2004 and 2008, 650 rigorous

studies on staff and patient safety issues, the impact of the environment on stress, and

clinical quality outcomes were completed and followed by scholarly, peer-reviewed

journals and hundreds of citations. (Hamilton). Since 2008, healthcare designers can now

become certified via EDAC, Evidence-based Design Accreditation and Certification, created

by The Center for Health Design.

EBD is used from the beginning of a project to the end, from pre-design, design,

construction, and post-occupancy. (EDAC/TCH). EBD starts with the Design Process that is

divided into phases: programming, schematic development (concept), design development,

contract documentation and contract administration. EBD must be integrated throughout

the process of design and building. It requires a collaborative effort comprising of

architects, interior designers, health care professionals, and patients. EBD infuses

“principles, goals and expected outcomes throughout all steps of planning, designing and

operating buildings.” (Health Facilities Scotland).

The collaborating team should always ask themselves: “How will the proposed

project incorporate all relevant and proven evidence-based design innovations to optimize

patient safety, quality and satisfaction, as well as work-force safety, satisfaction,

productivity and energy efficiency?” (Health Facilities Scotland).

EBD’s Foundation: The Design Process

Page 8: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 5

“An evidence-based designer, together with an informed client, makes decisions based on the

best available information from research and project evaluations.” (Hamilton).

“Evidence-based practice stands in contrast to approaches that are based on tradition,

convention, belief, or anecdotal evidence.” (National Registry of Evidence-based Programs

and Practices).

The first phase of EBD is programming. The programming phase is the most

significant part of the design process. This is where you’re problem seeking, setting goals

and objectives. During the programming phase you collect the relevant information needed

for the project, you identify the problem at hand, and you interview the client to confirm

their wants and needs. The programming phase is purely about gathering and analyzing

evidence. These data, facts and evidence, are collected and analyzed to assist in the design

process. Evidence comes from researching journals, periodicals, articles, and trade

publications and other publications as well as interviews, surveys, questionnaires and

observations. Facts are derived from current information or data, whereas research “seeks

to produce new knowledge in recognizable ways that can usually be applied regardless of

locale.”(Nussbaumer). There are two common types of research in EBD. Quantitative

research is a numerical measurement of observations, and qualitative research is

nonnumeric observations that describe meaning and patterns. (Nussbaumer). Variables are

also taken into consideration depending on the person. What works for one situation or

person may not work in another, and what does work may not work elsewhere. Once

you’ve collected all your information; you analyze the facts and organize them into a

program development. (Nussbaumer).

Page 9: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 6

The next step is the schematic development phase, where you use the data to inform

your design process, brainstorm ideas, and create sketches, plans and details. Next is the

design development stage, where the best possible solution is refined and final drawings,

details, sections, and elevations are produced. During the contract document phase, the

project is implemented. Construction drawings and specifications are made, tying in the

structural, architectural, mechanical and electrical aspects of the design including the

fixtures, finishes, and equipment (FF&E).This is for the general contractor to follow.

(Nussbaumer).

And lastly, the project implementation is completed in the contract administration

phase. Contractors, and sub-contractors are hired and construction occurs. Shortly after

move-in, a post-occupancy evaluation (or POE) is completed. A POE is defined as a means

to help “identify problem areas in existing buildings, to test new building prototypes and to

develop design guidance and criteria for future facilities.” POE’s help to improve current

and future projects. (Nussbaumer).

Evidence-based design research within the programming phase has 12 key areas.

You have the user needs, structural and context needs, sustainability needs (LEED,

environment), human factors (including physiological, anthropometrics, ergonomics,

psychological, and sociological needs), economics, functional needs, FF&E (furniture,

fixtures, and equipment), design types, diversity in design, historical precedents in design,

and finally develop program requirements and analyze various design theories.

(Nussbaumer). These research steps determine the effect of your design layout, the effect

of site and structure on your design, evidence on codes, social responsibility, indoor air

Page 10: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 7

quality, health concerns, socioeconomics, ergonomics, universal design, and more.

(Nussbaumer).

EBD in Healthcare Settings

“Your design decisions are memorialized in concrete and steel and effect patient outcomes,

how care is provided by nurses, physicians, and other healthcare professionals, and the

survivability of healthcare organizations who often must add additional resources to fix design

mistakes.” ~ Jaynelle F. Stichler (Stichler).

Hospitals have changed dramatically over the years, easing up on the institutional

look and feel by transforming into a warmer, welcoming place reminiscent of a hotel or

your own home. The use of EBD, however, goes far beyond pleasing aesthetics. Rather, the

focus of evidence-based design is to create hospitals that actually help patients recover and

be safer, and help staff do their jobs better. EBD is a process that provides a setting for a

caring, effective, safe, patient-centered environment. (Ulrich, et. al.).

Figure 1 (Children's Hospital Colorado). Figure 2 (Johnstone-Yellin).

Let’s explore the implementation of evidence-based design and the many ways it

has impacted and aided in the healing of patients.

The Effectiveness of Single-Bed Rooms

“The problem is not so much what we don’t know; it’s what we think we know that just ain’t

so.” (Attributed to Mark Twain).

Page 11: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 8

Scientific studies and peer reviewed journals have proven and stressed the

importance of single-bed rooms in all hospitals. Single-bed rooms greatly reduce the risk of

hospital-induced nosocomial infections, such as MRSA, diarrhea and gastroenteritis or

SARS. Single-bed rooms help to limit person-to-person and person-surface-person spread

of infection because they are far easier to decontaminate after patient discharge than

multibed rooms. Incorporating sinks and alcohol-gel dispensers into each room

encourages staff and patients to wash hands regularly. (Ulrich, et. al.).

Figure 3 (CBRE Healthcare). Figure 4 (Kotzer).

A single-bed room also reduces room transfers and medical errors, reduces noise

levels, improves patient confidentiality and privacy, facilitates social support by families,

improves staff communication to patients, and increase patients’ overall satisfaction with

health care. (Ulrich, et. al.).

Single-bed rooms combined with good air quality significantly reduce infections and

mortality amongst patients and staff, therefore making them far safer in single rooms than

in multibed spaces. (Ulrich, et. al.).

Research and evidence show that hospitals designed with portable high-efficiency

particulate air (HEPA) filters have lower rates of airborne infections amongst patients and

Page 12: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 9

immunocompromised patients compared to hospitals that didn’t implement HEPA. HEPA

filters are especially effective in operating-rooms and rooms that need to be ultra clean to

house immunocompromised patient populations. (Ulrich, et. al.). Proper ventilation and

airflow is also important. It is critical to combine HEPA filters with enhanced cleaning and

decontamination methods such as hydrogen peroxide vapor (HPV), the sealing of windows,

and barriers between patient-care areas and other areas. (Health Facilities Scotland). Also,

furniture and material choices play an important role. They should be easy to clean and

reduce the ability of holding contaminates.

What’s That Noise?

Hospitals are typically very noisy, caused from numerous sources such as alarms,

beds, bedrails, telephones, voices and the interior materials like floors, walls, and ceilings

that reflect sound rather than absorb it. These sounds travel down corridors, linger into

patient rooms and often create loud echoes. This creates an uncomfortable acoustic

atmosphere. (Ulrich, et. al.).

Installing high-performance sound absorbing ceiling tiles and providing single-bed

rooms are shown to be more effective in eliminating noise sounds compared to adopting

quiet hours or educating staff. Peer-reviewed studies have proven that noise levels are

much lower in single-bed than multi-bed rooms. Eliminating double-occupancy in rooms

reduces distractions and noise significantly from staff, medical equipment, and family

visiting. (Ulrich, et. al.).

The results of these findings came from a study in 2003, in which survey data from

2,122,439 patients in 1,462 healthcare facilities was collected. Surveys showed universally

patients were very satisfied with “noise levels in and around your room”, 11.2 percent

Page 13: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 10

higher nationally compared with patients in multi-bed rooms. Noise-level measurement

studies also support this data. (Ulrich, et. al.).

Reducing and eliminating unnecessary noises has a positive impact on infants in

ICU’s, particularly eliminating the common need for oxygen support therapy as a result of

oxygen loss, prevention of high blood pressure, increased heart and respiration rate, and

poor sleep. Noise also causes stress, high blood pressure, increased heart rate and poor

sleep in adults and children. By implementing these effective design changes we can

directly impact healthcare patients and staff in positive ways. (Ulrich, et. al.).

The Internal Impact of Lighting.

Figure 5 (Children's Hospital Colorado). Figure 6 (Kotzer).

Lighting design has a direct link to reducing clinical depression in patients. Patients

exposed to bright natural and artificial light, predominantly in the morning, had reduced

depression, agitation and improved sleep and circadian rhythms. Studies strongly show

improved lighting conditions have a greater impact on dementia patients, patients with

seasonal affective disorders (SAD) and bipolar disorder. Improved lighting conditions

reduce the length of stay for patients compared to poorly lit rooms by an average of 3 days.

Intense sunlight in hospital rooms significantly decreases stress, pain and the need for pain

medication by 20-22 percent. This is an important consideration to take into account when

Page 14: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 11

designing hospital layouts. Optimize sunlight exposure in patient rooms by using an east-

facing orientation. (Ulrich, et. al.).

A Growing Need for Nature.

Figure 7 (Oudeman). Figure 8 ( Mastorakos: SmithGroupJJR).

Figure 10 (Rendering courtesy CO Architects).

Figure 9 (Fouts, et. al.).

Furthermore, scientific studies have consistently shown that exposure to natural or

simulated nature settings have positive emotional and physiological effects. Negative

emotions such as stress are quickly replaced with positive feelings. Views of nature can

also positively influence heart rate and blood pressure, compared to increase stress and

heart rate for those who aren’t exposed to nature artwork or natural views. Patients

Page 15: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 12

exposed to landscape scenes experienced less stress, anxiety and required lower dosages of

pain medication when compared to those who viewed no paintings, abstract art or faced

buildings or parking lots. These encounters, regardless of how brief, make a world of

difference in all people, regardless of setting. (Ulrich, et. al.).

Figure 11 (Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago). Figure 12 (Sheffield Children's Hospital).

Therapy gardens in hospitals, both indoors and outdoors, are one way to expose

patients and staff to a serene environment. Therapy gardens allow for calmness, a place of

escape and recuperation from stress, and uplifting moods for healthcare staff thus leading

to better patient satisfaction of care. We can foster health by incorporating simulated

nature views in hospital settings to reduce stress, and provide distractions from pain.

(Ulrich, et. al.).

Case Study: The Children’s Hospital of Denver, Colorado.

Page 16: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 13

“We envision a world where every hospital, health clinic, treatment center, doctor’s office, and

residential care facility is designed to improve both the quality of care and outcomes for

patients, residents, and staff.” (The Center for Health Design).

Photo Credit: (EDAC/TCH).

Photo Credit: (Kotzer).

Page 17: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 14

The Children’s Hospital, located in Denver Colorado, was collaborative project

between TCH and two architectural design firms, Zimmer Gunsul Frasca Architects and

H+L Architecture. Work on the project began in 2003, and construction was completed in

September 2007. The hospital spans an impressive 1.44 million square feet over multiple

stories, with capacity of 240 beds, includes 4 trauma rooms, 14 operating rooms, and a

helipad on the rooftop. TCH also became a Pebble Project member as a research

collaborative to enhance the design of children’s hospitals across the country and is a key

instrument in improving research data for evidence-based design. (Kotzer). TCH is ranked

as one of the Top 10 children's hospitals in the country. (Zacharakis).

The designers on the project wanted to emphasis the “experience” of the space as a

theme, enhancing the hospital with use of artwork, nature, light, color, touch, sound, and

scale to positively influence health and care amongst patients and staff. (Zacharakis). To

gain insight and to better solidify a design concept for the new TCH, the design teams

visited over twelve hospitals, including Texas Children's Hospital in Houston; Doernbecher

Children's Hospital in Portland, Oregon; Children's Hospital Central California in Madera;

Vancouver General Hospital in Vancouver, British Columbia; Good Samaritan Hospital in

Cincinnati; Vanderbilt Medical Center in Nashville; Parker Adventist Hospital in Parker,

Colorado; and Children's Hospital of Omaha. (Zacharakis).

These visits provided a first-person experience on how other health care facilities

were designed and used and or lacked evidence-based design. They studied important

areas and key environmental elements, such as finish materials used, amenities for patients

and staff, location of nurses stations, circulation and flow, patient room layouts, and

operating rooms. (Zacharakis).

Page 18: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 15

The design team was dedicated to thinking like a child would and how children

would react, perceive and experience the environment. Seven designers from Zimmer

Gunsul Frasca Architects spent several diligent weeks shadowing and investigating

patients, staff, and families across all healthcare departments in the current TCH. This

shadow and interview period gave the designers a view of the daily conditions of the

hospital that staff and patients endure. Some of the results were simply awful. Excessive

noise, congested circulation and poor patient room layouts were quick design observations

needing addressing. (Zacharakis).

Patient rooms lacked storage space, were crowded and provided no

accommodations for parents. In the surgery department, overlapping and crowded waiting

areas with lack of privacy were all issues. The emergency department was inconvenient,

loud, overcrowded, stressful, uncomfortable and evoked feelings of chaos. Each of these

observations were documented and compared to the other health care facilities and

evidence-based design literature and research literature that existed at the time to create

satisfying design solutions. (Zacharakis).

These issues were addressed and made manifest in the new design of the hospital.

The new hospital designates three individual “zones”; patient, family, and staff.

(Zacharakis). The private, single-bed rooms provide a toilet, and various hospitality

amenities such as internet service and room service. Storage was implemented to provide

supplies at the bedside and includes patient care equipment in each room. Private rooms

include custom-designed sofa sleepers, gliders, recliners, and sleep chairs. Each inpatient

and critical care floor provides a “family zone” Family Center featuring private sleeping

rooms, kitchen, laundry areas and lounge space for parents and siblings of all ages.

Page 19: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 16

(Zacharakis). Each floor provides access to nature and “healing” gardens. These new design

changes give the patient and parent a sense of control and calmness. (Kotzer).

The hospital also features a young adult safe-space for teens that includes a movie

theater, pool table, arcades, basketball quart, music and reading areas, a kitchen, cell phone

areas and a computer lab. Child Life and Creative Play areas offer parents a break from

kids. A 24-hour cafeteria connects to outdoor seating, with a gelato and espresso bar

adjacent to a sun-lit atrium. (Zacharakis).

Hospital staff was not neglected. Personal lounge areas, private showers, workout

and gym facilities, bike racks, conference rooms and staff-only patio terraces allows staff to

recuperate from stress and fatigue. (Zacharakis).

Decentralized nursing stations were implemented while still maintaining a

centralized “hub” area for staff to communicate and consult privately, complete

administrative tasks and accommodate visitors. Decentralized stations improve efficiency,

contact with patient and reduces distraction. (Zacharakis). The goal was to increase

patient-nurse interaction by 70%. (Kotzer). The new surgery rooms improved circulation,

reduced walking distances and fatigue, and includes a skylit interior with nature and

artwork integrated into the waiting space for pre-operative and post-operative patients

and families. (Zacharakis).

Emergency rooms were designed to have south-facing views that attach to outdoor

gardens, sunlight, and clean fresh air. The space provides a safe, secure entry with easy

check-in. Additionally, food services are accessible 24-hours a day. This reduces stress and

chaos by providing a calm, relaxing, and therapeutic environment. (Zacharakis).

Page 20: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 17

Color has a strong psychological and subliminal effect on human behavior and

emotions. Color theory and scientific research was used to consider the amount, intensity,

and value of colors used throughout the hospital. (Zacharakis). From this research, the

designers composed five color palettes to use throughout the hospital; Community, Social,

Spirited, Tranquil, and Work. (Zacharakis). Each of the color palettes were inspired by

Colorado’s geography and natural scenery, with specific colors chosen for their therapeutic

and healing qualities and used in areas most helpful to the patient and staff.

Active areas, such as the cafeteria, express the Social Palette with vibrant, rich reds,

oranges, greens, and yellows complimented with images of Colorado. In contrast, the

Tranquil Palette creates a tranquilizing environment, consisting of a variety of pastel colors

like sky blue, mint green, butter yellow, and lavender, strategically used in the chapel,

intensive care units (ICU), and some waiting areas. Adventurous and daring colors such as

turquoise, magenta, apple green, and sunflower yellow comprise the Spirited Palette

located in clinic spaces and on inpatient floors. Lastly, the circulation areas and the atrium

have fun splashes of color contrasting with neutral undertones that make up the

Community Palette. (Zacharakis).

In light of the research available at the time, the designers designed an interior

court-yard and six-story atrium to take advantage of the sunlight’s ability to reduce pain,

depression, agitation and improve sleeping patterns. Lots of windows and various interior

light fixtures illuminate patient rooms, corridors, offices, and staff areas. (Zacharakis).

Final analysis and case study results show a significant decrease in noise levels and

satisfying results on lighting perceived by patients and staff compared to the previous

location. Staff retention rates have dramatically increased.

Page 21: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Ramoie 18

As one of The Center for Health Design's Pebble Projects, The Children's Hospital is

a part of an ongoing research study to determine if the new designs meet objectives for

healing, reduced infection rates, staff recruiting and retention rates, and reduction in

operating costs and how these changes can be implemented in other hospitals across the

country. (Zacharakis).

In conclusion, we have learned about the significant impact that design and the

many components that make up our environment has on our health, mind, and well-being.

We’ve reviewed what evidence-based design is, how it’s evolved over the years, and its

implementation in healthcare settings. We’ve also learned the importance of evidence-

based design and the research designers should consider during the design process.

Evidence-based design doesn’t just end in healthcare. Recently, the American

Society of Interior Designers published a research study, “Researching Home: Evidence-

based Residential Design”, that implements EBD in residential interiors in practical,

meaningful ways, creating healing, therapeutic environments right in our own homes!

Welcome to the innovative, dynamic design of the future!

Page 22: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Works Cited

Australian Interior Design Awards, . 2012 Australian Interior Design Awards. 2012. JPEG file.

australian interior design awards Web. 20 Mar 2014.

<http://gallery.australianinteriordesignawards.com/year:2012/16/130>.

Cardon Children's Medical Center, . N.d. Photograph. Banner Health Web. 20 Mar 2014.

<http://www.bannerhealth.com/Locations/Arizona/Cardon Childrens Medical Center/_Cardon

Childrens Medical Center home page.htm

CBRE Healthcare. Children’s Medical Center in Dallas. 2013. Photograph. Building Design &

Construction. JPEG File. 18 Mar 2014. <http://www.bdcnetwork.com/pediatric-hospitals-improve-

care-flexible-age-sensitive-design>.

Children's Hospital Colorado. “About Our Hospital on Anschutz Medical Campus.” 2014. JPEG File.

Children's Hospital Colorado Web. 18 Mar 2014. <http://www.childrenscolorado.org/about/our-

hospital>.

Children's Hospital Colorado. Lobby area. 2014. Photograph. Children's Hospital Colorado. JPEG

File. 18 Mar 2014. <http://www.childrenscolorado.org/about>.

Children's Rehabilitation Center, Children's Rehabilitation Center. N.d. Photograph. The Pediatric

Center Web. 20 Mar 2014. <http://www.setonpediatric.org/>.

CO Architects. Nature Nurtures. 2012. Photograph. Continuing Education Center. Web. 18 Mar

2014. <http://continuingeducation.construction.com/article.php?L=5&C=917&P=4>.

Cornell University, . Teaching design that follows the evidence. N.d. Photograph. evidence based

livingWeb. 20 Mar 2014. <http://evidencebasedliving.human.cornell.edu/2011/03/02/video-

feature-teaching-design-that-follows-the-evidence/>.

EDAC/The Center for Health Design. "Evidence-Based Design Accreditation and Certification

(EDAC) Examination Preparation." EDAC. (2008): n. page. PDF file.

Fouts, et. al., "Healing Through Evidence-Based Design." Oncology Issues. (2008): n. page. PDF file.

Hamilton. "Research Informed Design Supports Evidence-Based ICU Medicine." Health

Environments Research & Design Journal. (2013): page 2-3. PDF file. 18 Mar. 2014.

Health Facilities Scotland. Research Report Evidence-based design. PDF file.

Johnstone-Yellin. Say What!?. 2010. JPEG File. 18 Mar 2014.

<http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_8g8U9C3mo8M/S-

PLa99TO5I/AAAAAAAAAL4/WSSjgf5P6tE/s1600/york-hospital-womens-ward-1901.jpg>.

Kotzer. Using Evidence-Based Design to Improve the Healthcare Environment for Patients, Families

and Staff. 2008. PDF/JPEG File. The Children’s Hospital and H+ L Architecture. 18 Mar 2014.

Page 23: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Legacy Health, . Randall Children's Hospital at Legacy Emanuel. N.d. Photograph. Legacy

HealthWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago. Crown Sky Garden. 2014. Photograph. Evidence-Based

Hospital Design. Web. 18 Mar 2014. < https://www.luriechildrens.org/en-us/our-

home/Pages/evidence-based-hospital-design.aspx>.

Maple Wood Crafts, . INTERIOR DESIGN PROCESS. N.d. Photograph. Maple Wood CraftsWeb. 20 Mar

2014. <http://www.maplewoodcraft.in/service/interior-design-process/>.

Marberry, . Emerging vs. Strong Research to Support Evidence-Based Design. 2014. Photograph.

Sara Marberry LLCWeb. 20 Mar 2014. <http://www.saramarberry.com/emerging-vs-strong-

research-evidence-based-design/>.

Mastorakos: SmithGroupJJR. Holy Cross Hospital in Silver Spring, Maryland. 2014. Photograph.

Continuing Education Center. JPEG File. 18 Mar 2014.

<http://continuingeducation.construction.com/crs.php?L=222&C=928>.

Melina, . Rates of Hospital Infections Dropped in 2010. 2011. Photograph. Live ScienceWeb. 20 Mar

2014. <http://www.livescience.com/16717-health-care-infections-drop.html>.

Nussbaumer, Linda. Evidence-Based Design for Interior Designers. New York : Fairchild Books ,

2009. Print.

Oudeman. Massachusetts General Hospital’s Lunder Building. 2012. Photograph. Continuing

Education Center. JPEG File. 18 Mar 2014.

<http://continuingeducation.construction.com/article.php?L=5&C=917>.

Planetree, Planetree: Global Leader in Advancing Patient-Centered Care Solutions. N.p., 2014. Web.

18 Mar 2014. <http://planetree.org>.

SCHUMACHER, . Interior Design Process. 2012. Photograph. andrea schumacher interiorsWeb. 20

Mar 2014. <http://www.andreaschumacherinteriors.com/423/interior-design-process/>.

Sheffield Children's Hospital. Oncology garden, Sheffield Children's Hospital. 2014. Photograph.

Sheffield Children's, Western Bank, Sheffield, UK. Web. 18 Mar 2014.

<http://www.sheffieldchildrens.nhs.uk/>.

Stichler. "Applying Different Processes for Evidence-Based Design." HEALTH ENVIRONMENTS

RESEARCH & DESIGN JOURNAL. 7.1 (2013): n. page. PDF file. 18 Mar. 2014.

The Center for Health Design. "Roger S. Ulrich, Ph.D., EDAC." The Center for Health Design: Moving

healthcare forward.. N.p., 2014. Web. 18 Mar 2014.

<http://www.healthdesign.org/chd/about/board-directors/roger-s-ulrich-phd-edac>.

The Center for Health Design. "A View Of Who We Are." The Center for Health Design: Moving

healthcare forward. . N.p., 2014. Web. 18 Mar 2014.

<http://www.healthdesign.org/chd/about/view-who-we-are>.

Page 24: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

The Center for Health Design. "The Pebble Project for Architecture & Design Firms: Learn. Research.

Share." (2014): page 1-3. PDF file.

<http://www.healthdesign.org/sites/default/files/pebblebrochure_archdes_v9final_single1.pdf>.

The Royal Children's Hospital, . The Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne. N.d. JPEG file. RCHWeb.

20 Mar 2014.

Ulrich, et. al., "Nature Artwork Preferred by Children in Pediatric Settings." InformeDesign. N.p.,

2008. Web. 18 Mar 2014. <http://www.informedesign.org/Rs_detail.aspx?rsId=3403>.

Ulrich, et. al., "The Role of the Physical Environment in the Hospital of the 21st Century: A Once-in-

a-Lifetime Opportunity." (2004): n. page. PDF file. 18 Mar. 2014.

University of Minnesota, . Amplatz Children's Hospital. 2014. Photograph. University of Minnesota

JPEG file. 20 Mar 2014. <http://www.uofmchildrenshospital.org/>.

Zacharakis, . "Designing an evidence-based research project: The Children's Hospital collaborative

approach." . N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Mar 2014.

<http://www.healthcaredesignmagazine.com/article/process-design-informing-building-healing-

environment-childrens-hospital-denver-colorado>.

Zacharakis, . "The process of design: Informing the building of a ‘healing environment’ at The

Children's Hospital in Denver, Colorado." . N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Mar 2014.

<http://www.healthcaredesignmagazine.com/article/process-design-informing-building-healing-

environment-childrens-hospital-denver-colorado>.

Zengul, et. al. A Review of Evidence Based Design in Healthcare from Resource-Based Perspective.

Diss. University of Alabama at Birmingham, Journal of Management Policy and Practice, 2013. PDF

file.

ZGF Architects LLP, . The Children’s Hospital, Denver, Colorado. 2007. PDF file. n.p. Web. 20 Mar

2014.

Page 25: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Dynamic Design:

How Evidence-Based DesignCreates a Happy, Healthy You

Paul A. Ramoie, Student ASIDThe Illinois Institute of Art-

Chicago

Page 26: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

What is evidence-based design?

“Evidence-based design is the process of bas-ing decisions about the built environment on

credible research to achieve the best possible outcomes.”

“An evidence-based designer, together withan informed client, makes decisions based on

the best available informationfrom research and project evaluations.”

Page 27: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

The Evolution of evidence-based design

Page 28: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

EBD in Healthcare Settings

Page 29: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

ebd’S Foundation: The Design Process

“How will the proposed project incorporate all relevant and proven evidence-based design innovations to optimize patient safety, quality and satisfaction, as well as work-force safety, satisfaction, productivity and energy efficiency?”

Page 30: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Single-Bed Rooms

“Your design decisions are memorialized in

concrete and steel and effect patient

outcomes, how care is provided by nurses,

physicians, and other health-care

professionals,and the survivability of healthcare

organizations who often must add additional

resources to fix design mis-takes.”

Page 31: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Single-Bed Rooms

“The subliminal effect of your environment can influence your

emotions and thoughts.”

Page 32: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

The Internal Impact of Lighting

Page 33: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

The Internal Impact of Lighting

A Growing Need for Nature

Page 34: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

A Growing Need for Nature

Page 35: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Modern Hospital Interiors

“Architecture and interior design is not just a job. It is a responsiblecommitment in community service; a responsibility to the enduring andcreative advancement of humankind and environmental preservation.”

Page 36: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Case Study: The Children’s Hospital of Denver, Colorado

“We envision a world where every hospital, health clinic, treatment center, doctor’s office, and residential care facility is designed to improve both the quality of care and outcomes for patients, residents, and staff.”

Page 37: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Works Cited

EDAC/The Center for Health Design. “Evidence-Based Design Accreditation and Certification (EDAC) Examina-tion Preparation.” EDAC. (2008): n. page. PDF file.

Stichler. “Applying Different Processes for Evidence-Based Design.” HEALTH ENVIRONMENTS RESEARCH & DESIGN JOURNAL. 7.1 (2013): n. page. PDF file. 18 Mar. 2014.Carol Way Cisco, Allied ASID - LEED AP ID C, . Mission Recovery Impact of Interior Design on Disabled Veterans. 2014. quote. n.p. PDF file. 20 Mar 2014.

Hamilton. "Research Informed Design Supports Evidence-Based ICU Medicine." Health Environments Re-search & Design Journal. (2013): page 2-3. PDF file. 18 Mar. 2014.Children's Hospital Colorado. “About Our Hospital on Anschutz Medical Campus.” 2014. JPEG File. Children's Hospital Colorado Web. 18 Mar 2014. Johnstone-Yellin. Say What!?. 2010. JPEG File. 18 Mar 2014. CBRE Healthcare. Children’s Medical Center in Dallas. 2013. Photograph. Building Design & Construction. JPEG File. 18 Mar 2014.

Oudeman. Massachusetts General Hospital’s Lunder Building. 2012. Photograph. Continuing Education Center. JPEG File. 18 Mar 2014.

Mastorakos: SmithGroupJJR. Holy Cross Hospital in Silver Spring, Maryland. 2014. Photograph. Continuing Education Center. JPEG File. 18 Mar 2014. CO Architects. Nature Nurtures. 2012. Photograph. Continuing Education Center. Web. 18 Mar 2014.

Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago. Crown Sky Garden. 2014. Photograph. Evidence-Based Hospital Design. Web. 18 Mar 2014. Sheffield Children's Hospital. Oncology garden, Sheffield Children's Hospital. 2014. Photograph. Sheffield Children's, Western Bank, Sheffield, UK. Web. 18 Mar 2014.University of Minnesota, . Amplatz Children's Hospital. 2014. Photograph. University of Minnesota JPEG file.

Page 38: Evidence-Based Design Thesis_PaulRamoie_2014

Works Cited

Stichler. “Applying Different Processes for Evidence-Based Design.” HEALTH ENVIRONMENTS RESEARCH & DESIGN JOURNAL. 7.1 (2013): n. page. PDF file. 18 Mar. 2014.

ZGF Architects LLP, . The Children’s Hospital, Denver, Colorado. 2007. Photograph. n.p. Web. 20 Mar 2014.

Health Facilities Scotland. Research Report Evidence-based design. PDF file.

Australian Interior Design Awards, . 2012 Australian Interior Design Awards. 2012. Photograph. australian interior design award-sWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Legacy Health, . Randall Children's Hospital at Legacy Emanuel. N.d. Photograph. Legacy HealthWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Children's Rehabilitation Center, . Children's Rehabilitation Center. N.d. Photograph. The Pediatric CenterWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Cardon Children's Medical Center, . N.d. Photograph. Banner Health Web. 20 Mar 2014.

Marberry, . Emerging vs. Strong Research to Support Evidence-Based Design. 2014. Photograph. Sara Marberry LLCWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Melina, . Rates of Hospital Infections Dropped in 2010. 2011. Photograph. Live ScienceWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Cornell University, . Teaching design that follows the evidence. N.d. Photograph. evidence based livingWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Maple Wood Crafts, . INTERIOR DESIGN PROCESS. N.d. Photograph. Maple Wood CraftsWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

SCHUMACHER, . Interior Design Process. 2012. Photograph. andrea schumacher interiorsWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Renown Health, . Renown Children's Hospital. 2014. Photograph. RenownWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

The Royal Children's Hospital, . The Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne. N.d. Photograph. RCHWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Australian Interior Design Awards, . 2012 Australian Interior Design Awards. 2012. Photograph. australian interior design award-sWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Legacy Health, . Randall Children's Hospital at Legacy Emanuel. N.d. Photograph. Legacy HealthWeb. 20 Mar 2014.

Children's Rehabilitation Center, . Children's Rehabilitation Center. N.d. Photograph. The Pediatric CenterWeb. 20 Mar 2014.