everline gesare nyabwari, a097 683 208 (bia sept. 26, 2013)
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
1/25
Equnazi, Mac q.Schin & Eqnaz L1465 Daa Pakay, Su 23Dalla, TX 75254
S D
Ext w
B It ApOjc Ck
5 J 07 Leesburg Pik. St 2000F Chu Vg :41
OHSICE ic o Chif Conl - A25 E Joh Carpnt Fw St 500vng X 7562-232
Nam: NYABWAR EVERLNE GESARE A 97-68328
at o th noic 926/23
Enlosd is a copy of Bord's eision a or n th bove-rrc s.
ou
P M:Guendelsberge, JohMae, EiseAdks-Blac Chales K
Sirl,
D CwDo arCf k
usees Docket
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
2/25
,
Exective Oce Imaton Review
Dso f e Brd o Imto Apel
Falls Churh, Vg 4
File: A097 683 208 - Dals,
n e: EVERN GSAR NYBW
RMOV PROCENGS
APPEA N MOTON
ate:
N BHALF OF RESPONDENT Mc squeni squire
ON BEHALF OF HS aita J Wison GimesAssisnt Chief Counsel
APPCAON Contince; emand
EP 2 6 013
The epondent a native nd citizen of Kenya appeals the mmiation Judge's decisiondd Jne 23 2011 The espondent contests he mmigaton udges deteminationhat she issbject to emoval nd son 23a)(3)(D) o he Act She aso ges a e InaonJudge ee in denyng he uest a coninuance to appy adusment of Dung ependency of this appeal he espondent led a motion to emd and suppoing dumentonindicatng tat he pending peiion on he behalf by he United Stes ciien sposen anuy 200, w appoved on Septembe 201 The epment of Homeland Secuiy"HS) led a moion sy amce of he mmiaion Jdges decision nd aespone opposing the espondents motion to emd. The espondents appeal will b
sustined i pa and dismiss in p d he motion to emd wil be den
We eiew ion Judges ndings of fact cle eo but questions of awdiscetion nd udent nd al othe issues in appeas de novo. 8 CFR 1003d))i),ii).
The iniial issue is whethe he HS met its buden of poof show by cle and convcingevidence at e espondent is sbect to removal unde secion 23a)3)D) of he Act havg sly epesented heself to be a nited States citizen y uose o benet nde
he Act he miaon udge eviewed the evidence of ecod incuding a Fo 9 daeduly 25, 2002 and othe Fo 9 daed Je 3 2008 Boh ms indicate hat he espondent
epesented to a pospecive empoye that she was a Unted Sttes citen o natona. Howevehe espondent tes hat she did not mk tat box and indicates ha he employe mak itT at 5464). The migation udge deemned at his estimony in light of thedocumentay evidence w not cedible (. at 1215)
The esondent contends that she did not check he box hat she wa a ciizen o nationa ofhe United ates in eihe Fo 9 at issue, indicaing hat the iing pesonne ll n the boxae she had sied the m T. at 5960 60 The espondent e gues hat helguage in hese Fom 9s is "disncive hat he box at issue noes a ciizen o national ofe nied States She esied at she ndestood she not a citizen of he United Satesbut ta she did not know he meng of a "national T at 63)
Cite as: Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
3/25
A097 683 208
The migration Judge d some aspects of te respondent's testimony not credible. Inpcl he und uconvincng the esondents testimony hat he emploers mked e"citizen o natonal box on the Form -9s aer she sied the rms d provided her divesicense d social secuity card to her employes As to e te national, however, te
mmigation udge accepted te respondents eplation that she did not now e meaning oftat te IJ Decision a 0 Even accepting te mmiation Judge's paial adverse credibiliydeermaon given e disjuctive citizen or naonal language in the Fom 9s d thepossibilit tat te respondent may not have ndd the meaning or scope of te teational we do not nd that e OHS met its bden to show by cler nd convincng evidencetat he respondent lsely repesnted heself to b a ciizen of the United States r a net orpupose unde the Act Te Immiation dge easoned tat it may be inerred om terespondents iten statement of yes se is egaly eligible r empoyent n the UtStates tat she was atempting to repesent hersef a ctize of te Uited States to gainemploymnt n te Unted States U Dision at 16 However more a reonableference om the evidence is uired to demonsate emovability de he cle and
convincin evidence stdad Terere we nd that te respondent has not been shown to besubect to removal uder section 237(a)(3)(D) of e Act and tis poron of her appeal will besustained to buden of proof
The rspondent nevereless remans detale bsed on o ote grounds consising ofoverstaying her student v wthout auorition psat to section 237(a)(l )(B) of te Actand failin maintain her egal imigraton sas pursuant to secon 237(aX)(C)(i)
We now to te quesion of the espondents elibility r adusent of atus ad herrequest a continuance in order to see tat of relief Te aon Judge nd at
heespondent failed to establish good cause to rher coninue her case bause even sg
tat the Fo I130 vsa petition would be appoved e respondent would be ineligible radustment of sats under secion 24(a) in tat she s inadmissible nder section 212(a)(6)(C)(i)of the At Secion 212(a)(6)(C)(i)() of te Act povdes that [a]ny alien who falseyrepresents or falsely repesented mself or herself to be a citzen of te Uited States rny purpose or benet de is Act (including section 274A) or ny oher Feal or State laws inadmissible
e miation Judge deied te respondent's motion r a conuce based on tepending visa petition ndng tat she w not pi ce eligible to adst he stats desection 24(a) of te Act becaus she was inadmissbe de section 212(a)(6)(C)(ii)() of eAct r aving falsely represented herself to e a ned States citizen. Altog tis
deteminaion nvolves te same issue as e 237(a)(3)(D) od r emoval te burden ofpoof sis to te respondent show that she is not nadmissible under section22(a)(6)(C)(ii)() of the Act n te contet of demonsating eigibility r lief om emoval seto 240(c)(4)(A) of e At 8 USC. 229a(c)(4)(A)
The repondent h not shown tat she qualies r te eception to ndmissibilty r faseepresenaion of citizenship contained in suae () of stion 22(a)(6)(C)(ii)() Nor doesshe uali r te waive under section 22(i) of te Act wich pertains to admission ofmmiants inadmssibe r aud or will msrepresentation under section 212(a)(6)(C)()
2
Cite as: Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
4/25
A097 683 208
Fally, he dtherig provisios of sio 245() do no provide exceptio to the b toiadmissibility uder seco 212(a)(6(C)(ii.
The miatio Judge correctl ded at the repodet w ruestig o rms orelie bere te mmiatio Court othe tha a oppory to apply r adjstmet o staus
through a motio r a cotace The OHS opposed a cotiuace d he Immiatio udgecorectly deied it
The ct her dstiguished om those i Maer of Hhm, 2 I&N Dec 785 (BA2009) I that case, the Board held that a alie's uopposed motio to cotiue ogoigremoval proeedigs o await the adjudicatio o a dig amily-based visa pettio shouldgeerally be ted i appova o the visa petitio would reder m or he prima acie eliibler adustmet o status the ct case the OHS oppos the motio r a cotiuce adtere was isuciet evidece that eve i a amilybased visa peitio were approved therespodet ould be prima cie elible r adjuset o sats
For te ame esos the Board deies he respodets motio to remad bed o theapproval o the visa petitio dig the pedecy o this appea A remd is o waated the respodet is ot prima cie eligible r aduset o status The OHS corectly gues ioppositio t he motio to remad that the respodet is bed om seekng adjset osaus a mater o law We d o error i the Immiato udges resa to grat acotiuace The decisio o grt or dey a cotice is th the discretio o theImmiatio udge i good cause is shon See 8 CFR 100329; see alo Maer of F21 &N Dec 503 (BIA 1996 Maer of Sva-Rodrguez 20 I&N Dec 48 (BA 992 MaerofSbrun 8 I&N Dec 35 (B 1983
Accordgly the lowig orders will be eter
ODER: The respodets moio to remand is deied
FURTHR ORDER e respodets appeal is sustaed isoar as she is ot deportablender sectio 237(a(3(D) o he Act however, her appeal is dismissed as she is deporabeder sectos 237(a((B ad 237(a)()(C)(i o the Act ad she has ot demostatedeligibility r relie om remova
3
Cite as: Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
5/25
U.S eparment of JusticeExecutive Oice for Immigration Review
Board of mmigratio Appeals, Oce o the CekP.O. Box 8530
5107 Leesbrg Pike Ste 2000Fas Chch Vrgia 22041
CORRCTON MMORANDUM TO TH FLE
Name: NYABWAR, EVERLN GSAR
A#:097-683208
Date Setember 27 2013
PLASE NOT:
O The mmigration Judge's decisio in ths case s compete; however it sincorrectlypaginated. xp lanatio
0 The mmigratio Judge's I DDs vsa decisio this case is missig a pageExplaation:he A# umber o page (s) of the Immigratio Judges decison is icorrecthe correct A# s 97683-28
O The ame of the benefciay reected i he first paragraph of the DDs Visa
decson dated_
s icorrec. The corec ame s__
0 he espodets ame as reected in the mmgaton Jdges decso scorect. The core ame is
0 The date o the mmigatio Judges decisio shod be correcty refeced as
O The date i the footer of the mmigratio Jdges decisio is icorrect Thecorrect date is0 The ndated mmgraion Jdges decisio was redered o_
O ther
Q J l4amea Atkiso Supeisory Case Maageme SpecastDocket eam
R 206 3 paa
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
6/25
NITED TATE DEPATMENT O JTCEEXECTIVE OCE O MMIGRATON EVE
NITED TATE IMMIGATON COTDaas Texas
e N : A 09 68 201 Jue 2 20
I e Maer f
EVEINE GEAE NYAA IN EMOVA POCEEDNG
CHAGE
espdent
et 2 (a ( f te Ian andNatay
A e A as ameded ta
afer adss as a mra de en0 a 15 f te A y ae remaned n ened aes fr a ler tme a permted nvan f s At r any er a f tened aes
e 2 a f e ra andNataly At, as ameded at aeadmss as a mra uder en01a 5 f e At, y faled maa rmply t dtns f e nmra stats
under y ere admed.en 2 a D f te mra andNanaty At as amended n ta y ae aaen as fasey represeted ysef t be aten f e ned tates fr any prpse rbeneft under te A nudn et 24a r a fedea r stae a
APPICATON eqes fr nnuane fr adudat f an -0 petn
ON BEHAL O EPONDENT
Mark Esana Esqre65 Daas Paray ute 12Dallas Teas 525
1
ON BEHAL O H
Danta J. Grmes EsqueAsssant Cef CunseDaas Texas
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
7/25
I
OAL DECSON OF THE IMMIGRAON UDGE
Responden is a native and ciizen of Kenya. She was
admtted o h Unied Sates a Dallas, Texas, on o abo
August 2000, as a nonmigan F1 sden o atend Texas
Southen Univesiy n ouston, eas He F-1 sden visa
exped on May 9, 2005, and se emained in he Uned Staes
beyond ha dae wiho authoizaion fom e epament of
Homeland Sey, heeafe efeed to as e U. S. Govenmen
On uly 2, 2002, espondent was employed fo wags o ote
compensaon a asy Mar soes wthout aoizaon fom he
Govenmen
On Jne 3, 2008, e esponden was empoyed fo wages o
oe compensaon at echco 411 (Chevon) 920 No Cons
Stee, Alingon, Teas, who ahozation fom te
Govenmen.
May 2, 200 the Govenment ssed o he esponden a
Noce to Appe chagng e wih emovabiy pusuant o
Secon 27a) 1) B) of he Iigaon and Naonat Act
(Ac), as amened, and that afe admission as a nonigan in
Secion a)5) of he Act, se emaned in he Uned Saes
fo a onge tme han pemted, in violaion of ths Act o any
othe aw of e Unied States; Secon 237 (a) (1)C)) of e
Ac, as amende, in ha he pemission as a nongant nde
Secon 10 a) ) of he Act se failed o mainan o compy
wi condon of he nonigant stas nde whch she was
A 09 683 208 2 ne 2 201
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
8/25
amed and Setn 25 (a) )) te c, as amended, n
at se s an aen w asey eesented esel t be a
cten e ted Sates any use bene nde te
c ncldn Secn 27a edea state aw . See
Ebt N
t a Maste aenda ceedn n ay 6, 20, te
esnden aeaed bee te Ct w cunse, and ed,
amtted e llwn actal aleans and cae.
esnden, va nsel, atted tat se s n a cten
nana te ned Staes; tat se s a natve and cten
Kenya ta se was admtted te ned Staes at allas,
eas, n abt s , 20, as a nnan stdent
t attend Teas uten nvesty n Hstn, Teas; ta se
emaned n e nted Sates beynd te eatn e F1
stden vsa n ay 9, 2005, w atzatn te
man and auaatn Sevce, s sccess, te
eatmen Heand Secty; tat se was emyed waes
te cmensn n Jly 2, 2002, a EZ Mat Stes and
many wtu tzatn m te Ian and
Naazan Svce, ts success, te eament
meland Se ta se was emyed waes tecmensan n une , 2008, at ecc; and, 011 Cevn, 92
N Clee, ntn, Teas, wu atzan e
Deatment eand Secy.
Te esndn, va cnsel, amttd t te cae
09 68 208 June 2, 20
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
9/25
emova psuat to ecton 27(a ( (B of e Ac n a ae
amsson as a nonman ne econ ll(a ( of e Ac
se emane te ne ates o a one me an
pemtte oaon o ts Act o any oe a o e ne
aes espoent a counsel also amte o e cae o
eoval psua o ecton 2 (a ( ( ( o e Ac as
amene n tt ae amsson as a nonman une
0(a 15 o e Ac se fae o manan o comply w e
conons o e nonman sats ne wc e was
ame
Base on e esponents assons o acal aeaons
an e concessons o te wo caes of emova ne econ
2 (a ( (B o e Ac an econ 2 (a (1 ( ( o e Ac
e ot nds at ovl as een esase by cea an
convncn evence on ese wo caes. ee econ
20(c ( (A o e Ac see also 8 econ 240 8(a
Te esponen ene acal aeaon 6 n a on o
abot uly 25 2002 se epesene esel o be a ctzen o
e ne taes by alsely makn empoymen eby
vefcaon om I9 o ncae a se s a ne aes
cen fo pupose of secun naoze employmen a EZMa toes an ompany An esponent v consel ene
aleaton ne 9 at on or abo June 2008 se
epesene ese to be a czen o e ne aes by
alsely makn emplome ely vecaon om I-9 o
A 097 68 208 4 une 2 201
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
10/25
idae ha she s a ed Staes tie o uroses o
seri auhored emomet at eho esode ia
ose lso deied he orresodi hare sua o Seio
23 a) 3) D) o he A
he de is o the Goermet to esabsh he
esodes remoa ursat o Setio 23(a)(3)) o he A
as ell a aeaos 6 ad b lear ad oi eidee
See Se 24 (3)(A) o he A ad 8 FR Seio
1 8 (a)
A a heai o e 23, 2, aer hear he
esodes emo ad he ea armets reseted by he
esode hroh ousel ad the Goemet the or
osdee heher he resode heher the resode s
sbe remoa usa o Seo 23a) 3) ) o he A
he ou odes he esode is remoabe de Seo
237 (a) (3)) o he A or he reasos saed hee
Docm ary ideexhi he Noie o Aea
xhi 2, he Goermes sbmisso o emome
eriato o he Form ora ersio or he
resodes emoe a eho 411 (he Goeme moed oadm he oria Fom I- io he eod iho obeio
rom resde he o admed he oriial Form -9 io
he reor as xhi No 2 )
xhi 3 he Goermes submissio o emloe
A 7 683 28 5 Je 23, 20
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
11/25
eiaon o he o ) o o orina eson o the
resondes emoen a Maret Sores.
esonden was a soe wess at odas hean.
At the hea on e 3 the oerne aed the
resode o test eoe he or. e ollown s a
sa o her eson
re xaiaton
esondent has a Kenan assot She ae o e Ued
Staes as a oee stden . esondet s ared e
hsad led an 3 eo o he eha i aa
h nied Sates zen and maon Sere heeater
reerred o as S)
eein o xhi 3 the Asssta he onse ased
hih seon o he doe onaed he esoes
esode stated hat the seon one onans he rt
ee te box hat sas ten o naoal o h ied
States.
esonden aied or eoen a ar Soes d se
worked wth Ma Soes When she ied o e Fo
se dd no destad ha the rose o he or s o show
elil o wor in the Uned Staes Whe asked wht sheeees the ose o the o is se saed h o
eaaon as en to her b he eoer
esondet reads ad wries sh. She read e or
eore she oeed seon oe ad eore se sined te or
A 07 683 8 6 ne 23 2011
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
12/25
I. Se e tat he For I9 pertaed to er epoet to
Z Mart Se e se eeded to r her drers lese ad
Soa Seurt ard to oplete the For We ased, reerr
to xh 3 i se sees that a perso et te For 9
or erted that te epoee is eiie to or te
ited States, respode sad es
espodet had ee e ited States or o ears at
e tie ta se opeted e or er oee sdes he
ied Staes ere "eera sdes espode reads ad
res ish, ha ee ae to read ad rite e is
aae se she etered ad old let read ad re
the ls aae e se sed he or. Se as eer ad
eploet athorizato te ted States e respodet
stated tat se sied te or. We ased i se read pror to
s te or te seto tat states "I attest der peat
o perjr ta I a a tze or aoa o the ited States,
te respodet staed tat se ores hether se read tat
seto espodet testiied tat soeoe eed te "tize
or atoal ox ater se sed e doet. espodet
stated tat se aded er epoer opes o er driers
liese ad Soia Sert ard to opete te For 9espodet stated tat se as o the presee o er
epoer e er epoer opeted te or e respodet
stated tat se read that seto se eeded to si espodet
testied tat se sa te setio aoe re se as reired
A 97 683 208 7 e 23 21
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
13/25
o gn cion ing m cc on o oowng):
cn o nion o n S wu mnn
n n n uoi o wok n k o knw
o o on o o ing o on momn
Z So coc? S in know w
nonl mn
n k ic o o mo n
o cc onn o ox
nk n k w o mo o ow w
g o wo no nng o o
o mo n k w cun m
igi o moymn onn w no u
w i o momn S knw
w no o o wok wn ou om n
ow wo o wo onn
u wn o. " n w
n o ing ' cn n Soc Scu
c mo u o o ing o
n
wong Z M wo o on
onn u cn n Soc Scu co wok on onn gnu
incu n xii 2 n gnun S
ou ng xc o onn o
no mm w coo nk u o om om
0 683 208 8 un 23 2011
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
14/25
Reode wa eeed wit e oigia eio o a om I-
a icded ib 2 ad e oted a ectio oe wc
e comeed wa cometed wt be ik Reodet taed
tat e emade o e om comeed i bac
cdig e emoye ame Se tated at e cite o
atoa bo cometed wt be Se etied tat e
e te be e o e abe ad tat e e dd ot
ceck tat bo.
Reode dd o ae emoye atoao we e
woed o Ma o Ceo ad e wa ot a aw emaet
edet te o ow. Reode i ot a citie o e Ued
Sae ad e doe ot ow wa a aioa o e ied Sae
i. Se a ee eeeted ta e a atioa o e
Uied Stae Reodet dd ot om e maage a e i
a ce o Keya ad e did ot iom e ta e
oeayed e tde a om te Uied Sate Se did o
wat o otee at oato ad e did ot otee te
omaio Reode aed ta e ew i e ad
oeeed a iomao e wod ae bee abe to wo
Reode ew e wa o oed o wok i e ed
State
Reode ig-aded Reode wa aed o ee
o emoyet aoiao acato cded i ibi
Reodet comeed te eie aicao ad i wo age o
e ow e ow adwiig aide om te adwiig o e
68 28 e 23 2
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
15/25
sid pags
sband a Und Sas ctn d an 3
ptitn n h bal w t USC Rspndnt nws wha a
ctn s In wn wds b a citin av t b
a can amn tm Y av t il paps
bcm a ctzn. And i w bn Rspndnt
ndstands tat i a psn clams b a ctn th Und
tats ha psn can w n t Und Stats aw
Rspndn dd nt nw what a natnal th nd Stats is.
Sh sad at sh ds n nw w bing a atnal wud
bnt in banng w. h stad a sh nws hat
bng a cn Untd Sats wld allw smn t w
n t Untd Sats w a pbm.
T spndn sd tat whn sh sgnd bt Fm -
9s sctn n was n cmpltd Rspndn sad tat s
ad a ptn sctn n Fm I9 b sh sgnd
th dcmn bt that s dd n ad t n ntt
scn n.
Css-xanan
Wn d h m 9 cnaind n xhb 3
spndn dnd sgnatu Rspndnt stad tha mp a Ma asd h ll h mpmnt ms
wch sh dd b hat sh and mp nv viwd t
mpymnt ms gh. Rspndnt sad hat s was nl
ld b th mp sgn h ms. Rspndn dd n ad
A 9 683 28 1 Jn 23 1
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
16/25
h Fom thoougl Th spondnt dos no now wha a
naonal s spondn nod on om ndd n
hb 3 a ognaly t dat sh ntd nx o h
sgna was bth dat bt t was od o ndat
t day sh sgnd h om
Whn d o ht sh was asd to dny h
olos o n usd o ompt th Fom S sad ha
bl n s n t op poon and bla n s n boom
poton Sh statd ha sh was asd o av h dv's
lns and Soal Sy ad o on op o h papwo and
hn h mploy asd h o pom som ds aond h
sto anng n Wn th spondn am ba sh saw
tha th mpoy had tan paps and had t h dvs
lns and Soal Sty ad ot on th ds Sh and wo
mo mploys w all anng ogt
spondn not ntly wong and hsband s th
pmay badwnn o h houshold
Rd xamnaon
Rspondn sd tha sh was not tmnad om
Mat
CediblitUnd Ston 24 (4 o h A a dlty
dmnaton by an gaon Jdg onnng h appaon
o l o moval s basd on h ollowng ta
Consdng th oaty o mstan and a vant
A 7 683 28 11 n 11
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
17/25
actos th igato ug may bas a cdbity
dtmiaton o t dmano cao o sosvss o th
appcant o witnss ht plausbiity o t apcant o
witnss's accot t cosistcy btw t appcants o
wtsss witt a oal statmnts (whth mad ad wth
o not und oat and osng th cicumstancs un whch
th statmnts w ma t tal cosstcs o ach such
statmt t osstncs o sc statmt wth oth
vnc o cod (nun t ots on t atmts
sa county codto an ay accuacs o ashoods any
suc statmnts wtout gad to wt a iaccuacy
consstcy o ashood gos to th at o th appicants
cam o ay ot vant acto s o smpton o
cbty Howv no advs cdibity dtmato s
spccally mad t apicat wits sa ha a
psmto o bty o appa
At cosdng th spodt's tstmony ad a t
vnc incu n t cod th Cot s u t
totaity o cicumstancs spot d ot tstiy cdiby
bo th Cout. st sodt tstd that s was not
ta om moymt at Z at owv tocmts sbmttd by th ovmt ad incudd xhbt
ndcat tat th sodnt was tmnat om h mpoymnt
at Z Mat bcaus o pobms wt omanc namy
multp pocy nactions cg paticatig a
A 7 683 2 2 2 211
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
18/25
alecaon wh anohe employee and fasfyng he me shees.
esonden also esfed ha she knew she was no suposed
o wok n he Uned Saes ecause of he mmgaon saus.
She saed she dd no nfom he emoy tha she s a enyan
czen and oesayed he sden sa ecause she waned a o
e manage dd no ask ao he gaon sas and ha she
dd no want o olnee that nfomaon Notay aso when
he esnden was asked wha she od he emoye o show she
was egle fo emloyen she sad she dd no say anyhng of
the so to he emloye owee aeas he esonden was
asked y he manage a EZ Ma egadng he ay o awfuly
wok n he ned Sates n he apcaton fo emomen
ncludng xh whch esonden esfed hat she
comleed enely on he own and n he own handwng he
esonden was asked whehe she s egally ege fo
employen n he Uned Staes esponden woe yes e
esmony decly conadcs wh he ohe evdence ncluded
n he ecod
uhemoe esonden dd n adeael ean h
accodng to he esmony, she compleed secon one of oth
Foms he eney u left he ten o naonalsecon lak espondent saed ha she cold ead and we
n ngsh when she compleed oh he oms . esonden
esfed a she comeed secon one of oh he os -
asde fom he a ncuded n secon one askng he emloyee
A 68 28 1 Jne 2 2
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
19/25
ee e i zen o non o e nied Se.
eponden eed u e opeed o
eion of o eed o e opeed nd ned e
epoee e e epoen en" eep e poon
nded edi eeen ee e ned nd ee e
povided e deopi noon eponden even
eiied edn e o 9 ndn ii e
e eion kn e o nde ee e iizen
o nion o e ned Se e n. Wen ed
epn e ovon n evn e pe n oeve
eponden on ed e dd no kno nion
en i nen
Tu nde e o o ne e Co
onude e eponden no ede ine
Seen o L
Te ovenen o oo nd onvnn evidene
n en o een ded o e ned Se
eove. See Seon 24() () o e A. Addon no
deon on depoi e vd ne ed on
eone ujeve nd poive evdene. See Seon
) () o e A ee e ovenen o e ndonvinn evdene eponden fe epeened ee
ien o e ned Se o n ppoe o ene
nde e A (indin Seon 27() o ede o e
) en e je o eov unde Seon 2 () () )
A 6 ne 2 2
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
20/25
o e A
An an ay ony ajst e sts o a o awl
panen sn s is assl Se Seon 245a) o
A. Son 22 a) (6) ( o law pos any an
wo alsy epsns o as asy epesn esl o e a
n o ny pp o en ne A (nlng
Seton 24a) o ny oe ea o sa lw s
nassil. s, i he o ins esponen lsly
pesente sel as a iien o nt Sts o any
ppos o ne ne At o any o al o sa
law no only wo se o on Seon 23(a)3) D o te
A se wol prima fae nelgle o ajs ss
ne Seton 245(a) o e At y t o e nassiy
n Son 22a6i. o wol o o
pe ppliaon o asten o sas o
ma ae nligly o t ee
Analss, onlsons o LawT o ns ae onseng all sioy an
onay ene inl in e eo, te Gonn as
shown y la n onnng ene a sponnt alsly
pesn se as a in o nte Stas o enet o ppos n e At, an s s se to eoal
n Sion 23(a) (3) D o A
s, ase e o as on a esponn las
eiily i anno y on e siony a s i o
A 0 683 28 Jn 23 2
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
21/25
I
compee the "cizen or nton" porton of Form 9 n
tht she i not indcte on the Form 9 tht she s czen
or nion of the Unie Sttes
urhermor te eidence sggests ht she dd ndicte she
ws citizen of the Uned Stes on the orms I- espondent
testife ht she understns wht czen s "o be
ctzen yo he to be ere for certn moun of me yo
he to file ppers to become citizen nd if yo were born
here " Respondent tesifed czens of the Unted Sttes my
wfy wor in the nted Ses wthot ny hinrnces
Responent testife tht she does not know wh nton of
he Unite Ses s Responden hs testfed tht she neer
eceed any wor thorizon from the Goernment n tht she
neer h ny wf permnen resident stus in he Unte
Ses Ths, t my be nferred from the responent's wrtten
sement of yes, she s leglly eigbe for empoyment in the
ne Sttes to her Z Mrt employer ht she ws tempng to
represen hersef s ctzen of the Unted Ses o gn
empoyment in the Unte Sttes.
n ddton the Cort s not persued by he responents
rgment tht her empoyer went n o the responens Form 9
using fferen coored pen ef on he tble by he responent
to complee the "ctizen or ntonl box, especilly consderng
responen's ck of cnor to the Cour See Ehb 2.
Becuse te Cour hs foun the responent s removble
A 97 683 20 16 June 23 21
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
22/25
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
23/25
s ndmissle nde 1 )(6) () ) o e A nd se
de lse l o Uned Ses ensp. A e
eve o e A lso indes e esonden is no eligile
o ny ive o s povsion. n oe ods, ese ee
s no ve of ndmissiily psn o Seon
() (6) ) o e A, ese ee is no ive o s
gound o indmssly e o inds onnune in
s se is no ned ese even ssumng e 0
peon s ppoved, esponden ll e nelgle o
dsmen o ss n se s ndmisse nde Seon
1()(6) i) o e A nd ee is no ve o s
gond o indssiiy
eeoe, e ou nds e esponden s iled o
eslis good se o ue onnue is se
Responden is seeng no oe ee om emovl.
Aodgy, e oloing odes sold e eneed.
ORR
S HR ORR espondens eqes o onnune
e dened.
S RHR ORR esponde sll e emoved nd
depoed om e Uned Ses o eny sed on e ges
A 683 08 18 Jne 3
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
24/25
-
8/13/2019 Everline Gesare Nyabwari, A097 683 208 (BIA Sept. 26, 2013)
25/25
'EFCAE AE
hby cey tha he attach pocein beo
EC J. SS n mat o:
EVENE GESE NYABWA
A 83 8
aas as
an accate vbam anscip o he con as povi by
Excv Ofic o miaton viw an ha s s he
oinal anscip ho o he e o he Ecve Oce
aon evw.
'/AAnn E Wallac ansc F Sae epoi nc
Augus 3 (compleon a
i/'
sbmsson o hs CFCAE AE the Conaco csha a Sony BEC/-4 channe tanscb o euivaen anoCD as scb in Scon c, paaaph C. 3 3 o h conacwas us o anscib h co o ocen shown in he above
paaaph