evaluation of an experiential learning and simulation based …kappatau/images/2015orals/9...
TRANSCRIPT
The heart and science of medicine.
UVMHealth.org/CVPH
Evaluation of an Experiential Learning and Simulation Based Clinical Orientation at UVMHN-CVPH Tracy Coleman, RN, BS, BSN, Stephanie Drown, RN, BS, BSN, Med, CMSRN, Carlyn Haag, RN, BSN, CCRN, Rachael Hite, RN, BA, OCN, CHPN, CMSRN, Cathy Patnode, RN, BSN, CCRN, Karen Phillips, RN, BSN, MSN, CMSRN
Objectives
• Discuss the development of an experiential and
simulation based orientation.
• Discuss how increased Clinical Education Manager time
on clinical units strengthens orientation for registered
nurses.
2
Purpose of Study
• To strengthen the orientation for all Registered Nurses
(RN’s) hired at UVHN-CVPH through the utilization of
experiential learning, simulated clinical orientation
experiences and increased Clinical Education Manager
time on the units.
Rationale and Significance
• JumpStart Program
– Jason Zigmont, PhD, CHSE-A
– 2 years of work in development of program
– First pilot included 153 RN’s
• New and experienced RN’s had over a 3 1/2 week reduction in
orientation time.
• Gross savings of $702,270.
Zigmont, J. J.; Wade, A., Edwards, T., Hayes, K., Mitchell, J., Oocumma, N. (2015). Utilization of Experiential
Learning, The Learning Outcomes Model Reduces RN Orientation Time by More than 35%. Clinical Simulation in
Nursing, 11, 79-94. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ecns.2014.11.001
6
Blooms Taxonomy
7 Diagram retrieved from www.laerdal.com/.../13/indianapolis/zigmont_objectives_outcomes.ppt on October 25, 2015
Learning Outcomes Model
Zigmont, J. J., Kappus, L., Sudikoff, S. N., (2011a). Theoretical foundations of learning through simulation. Seminars in Perinatology, 35(2), 47-51. Diagram retrieved from www.laerdal.com/.../13/indianapolis/zigmont_objectives_outcomes.ppt on October 25, 2015
8
•Well-Tuned Learning
Orientation
•Mental Models
•Analogical
Reasoning
Experiences
•Challenging
•Emotionally Charged
•Mistakes or Errors
Environment
•Skilled Mentors
•Evidence Based Medicine
•Products and Protocols
Improved
Patient
Outcomes
Learning Outcomes Model
Zigmont, J. J., Kappus, L., Sudikoff, S. N., (2011a). Theoretical foundations of learning through simulation. Seminars in Perinatology, 35(2), 47-51. Diagram retrieved from www.laerdal.com/.../13/indianapolis/zigmont_objectives_outcomes.ppt on October 25, 2015
9
•Individualized online
competency based
orientation, electronic
CBO
•Experiential
Learning/MBTI
Experiences
•Five days of skills and
scenarios
•Focus on the what
and how
•Critical Care Course
Environment
•Preceptor Class
•Policies and Protocols
•Unit Based Changes
Improved
Patient
Outcomes
JumpStart/UVHN CVPH Orientation
• Experienced and new graduate nurses
• Small groups (maximum of 7 students to 1 facilitator) – UVHN-CVPH – maximum of 4-5 students to 1 facilitator, ideal is
2-3 students.
• Experiential Learning Based Program
• Individual assessed at mid-point and end of their orientation – UVHN-CVPH – consistent regular weekly meetings with
• Shared Mental Model
• Use of 3D Model of Defusing, Discovering, Deepening for Debriefing – UVHN-CVPH – mixture of + Delta, Good Judgement, 3D
10
What did we want to accomplish?
• Provide a smoother transition into the workplace
– Improve graduate nurses' work ready skills and attributes
– Focus on teamwork and communication skills
– Clinical competence
– Relationship building
11
• JumpStart – Rhythm Recognition – Oxygen Therapy – Waive test – Clinical Applications – IV Pumps – Peripheral IV – Med Administration – Blood Administration – Safe Patient Handling – Restraints – Defibrillation – Central Line Dressings/Blood Draw
• UVHN-CVPH – Peripheral IV Therapy – Oxygen Therapy – Waive Test – Clinical Applications – IV Pumps – MAK – Blood Administration – Safe Patient Handling – Central Line Blood Draw/TPA
Administration – Pain Identification – Pressure Ulcer Prevention – Ostomy/Wound Care – Sepsis – Fall Equipment – Hypoglycemia Treatments – Foley Care – Central Line Care and Maintenance
Essential Practice Elements
12
Zigmont, J., Cavalieri, A., Edwards, T., Rees, T., Wade, A. (2015). Create a Simulation-enhanced RN Orientation Program. 4 hour Pre-conference course at the International Meeting for Simulation in Healthcare, New
Orleans, Louisiana, January 11, 2015.
• JumpStart – CHF
– Find the Wound
– STEMI
– IDDM
– Fall
– Pre-op Preparation/Sepsis
– End of Life
– Stroke
– Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment
– Central Line
• UVHN-CVPH – Hourly Rounding
– Hypoglycemia
– Falls
– Sepsis
– Pain and PUPS
Zigmont, J., Cavalieri, A., Edwards, T., Rees, T., Wade, A. (2015). Create a Simulation-enhanced RN Orientation Program. 4 hour Pre-conference course at the International Meeting for Simulation in Healthcare, New
Orleans, Louisiana, January 11, 2015.
Simulations
13
UVHN-CVPH 2015 Clinical Orientation June – December 2015
General Orientation
Day 2
Clinical Orientation
Day 1
Clinical Orientation Day
2
Clinical Orientation
Day 3
Clinical Orientation
Day 4
Clinical Orientation
Day 5
CPR & Waive Test
Competencies
12-2pm
Clinical &
Non-Clinical Staff
8-1pm
Welcome
Patient Advocate
Program
Patient Centered
Care/AIDET
Communication –
Team STEPPS
Infection Control
The Perception
Experience
1230-1pm
Lunch
1-430
Safe Patient Handling
& Mobility Program
Clinical Staff
8-1pm
Striving for Excellence
Dietary Presentation
Who Am I? Tips for
Being a Successful
Preceptee
PUPS/Wound Ostomy
Hourly Rounding &
Simulation
HR Check-In
1-230pm
RN/CA Documentation
230-430pm
CA’s EKG
Class/Phlebotomy
230-430pm
MAK/Order Entry
Clinical Staff
8-1230
RN Documentation/Care
Plan/Order Entry
1230-1630
Skill Sessions &
Simulations
Clinical Staff
8-1630
Pharmacy
Presentation
Skill Sessions &
Simulations
Transfusion Education
Code 99/Rapid
Response
Policy Review
HealthStream
Clinical Staff
8-1630
Peripheral IV Therapy
Central Line Blood
Draws
TPA Competency
14
Staff Satisfaction
• Descriptive evaluations were distributed to participants on the simulations days to get immediate feedback. – Take extra care in checking the events when the patient fell.
– Follow protocol for different fall levels. Make sure Star is up for high risk.
– I will advocate for my patients and stop the pain! And follow protocol.
– I will look for signs of sepsis and use the protocol.
– Ensure SBAR model is followed.
– Rely more on protocols and keep them with me.
– I found the protocols very helpful, and it’s great to know I can pull them up as a reference. I will always remember to look down to the next step to see if it applies to the situation.
15
Staff Satisfaction
• Descriptive evaluations were given after orientation was complete.
– Thirteen evaluations were distributed, nice were completed and
returned from the first group.
– Favorable emphasis on learning Pain, Pressure Ulcer Prevention, Falls, Sepsis and Hypoglycemia Protocols, assessment, document standards, and equipment.
– An average overall score of 4.2 (1-5 Likert scale) demonstrated how participants felt the simulations/skills helped them care for patients.
16
Lessons Learned
• Orientation binders with policies were a huge success.
• With large groups it is okay to have simulations before skills sessions.
• Schedule more time between the skills sessions and simulations for instructor debriefing and setting up for next group.
• Coordinate distribution of the Clinical Simulation Evaluations prior to the end of their orientation.
17
The heart and science of medicine.
UVMHealth.org/CVPH
How increased Clinical Education Manager time on clinical units strengthens orientation for registered nurses.
18
2015 New Graduate Nurses
• 16 Med/Surg
– 10 night shift
– 6 evening shift
– 10 resource pool
– 2 R5
– 2 R6
– 2 R7
• 14 Critical Care
– 6 night shift
– 7 evening shift
– 1 day shift
– 8 progressive care
– 6 short stay unit
. 20
What did we know?
• Graduate nurses experience significant stress:
– professional role adjustment and adaptation
– difficulty managing the social and work environment
– role conflict…..student vs registered nurse
– perceptions of a lack of clinical competence
(Ramritu and Barnard, 2001)
21
What did we do?
• Preceptor workshop
• Critical Care Course
• Electronic Clinical Based Orientation (CBO) document
• Schedules
• Unit presence of Clinical Education Managers
22
Preceptor Workshop
• Began in 2015 for all disciplines
– Focuses on:
• Sustaining Safe Practice
• Engaging Communication & Diversity
• Developing Performance & Critical Thinking
• Experiences in Precepting: Coaching & Conflict Management
23
Critical Care Course
• 5 days, total of forty hours
• Scheduled during the middle to end of orientation
• Days divided by topics/systems – Topics Covered
• Cardiac (MI, Post-PCI care, HF), Respiratory (COPD, ARF, etc), Multisystem (Severe Sepsis), Endocrine (DKA, Hyperglycemia), Renal (Renal Failure, Dialysis), Gastrointestinal (Pancreatitis, Cirrhosis), ETOH withdrawal, Neurologic(Stroke Recognition and Intervention), Patient Safety/TeamSTEPPS
– Included a total of 6 simulations • Chest Pain/Heart Failure exacerbation
• Respiratory Distress/Chest Tube troubleshooting
• Sepsis Recognition/Sepsis Intervention with transfer to HLOC
– Included skills testing and case scenarios • Arterial Puncture (ABG Collection)
• Chest Tube Set-up/Troubleshooting
• Groin Management (Femostop/TR-Band)
• Insulin Drip Management Case Scenarios
• CIWA Scoring Case Scenarios
– Staff content experts guest lectured during each topic • Diabetic Educator, Respiratory Therapist, Pharmacist, Progressive Care RN, ICU RN, Dialysis
RN
24
Electronic CBO Document
• Historically, paper document was 18 pages long (front
and back).
• Required preceptors to fill out and sign before end of
orientation.
• Electronic version
– Flipped the focus from preceptor ownership to orient ownership.
– Working document.
25
Schedules
• 2013/2014 Nurse Residency survey results.
– Orientations begin on hired shifts
• Limited “off the unit” classes.
• Telemetry class scheduled once off orientation.
– Exception: Critical Care orients received 3 day telemetry class
prior to coming off orientation.
• Resource pool orienting with resource pool preceptors.
26
Educators Presence on Clinical Units
• Weekly schedule of clinical time for orients
• Shoulder-to-shoulder support
• Real-time learning opportunities
• Frequent preceptor/orient meetings
• Build relationships
27
Lessons Learned
• Preceptor guidance and education
– Expanding instructional time between CEMs and preceptors
prior to the new GN’s orientation.
– Formalize a system for preceptor knowledge of new GN’s
education and work history.
• Resource pool preceptors and scheduling
– Scheduling new Resource Pool GNs with a Resource Pool
preceptor and following their schedule.
• Increasing our preceptor pool to decrease burnout
• Preparing unit staff for the influx of new nurses during
the prime GN season (June-Aug)
– Looking at knowledge gaps and competency completion
28
• 2013
– 15 Med/Surg Nurses • Average 7.18 Weeks
– 15 Critical Care Nurses • Average 10.05 Weeks
• 2014
– 1 Med/Surg Nurse • Average 8.12 Weeks
– 4 Critical Care Nurses • Average 11.74 Weeks
2013-2014 New Graduate Nurses
30
7.18 8.12 10.05
11.75
0
5
10
15
2013 2014
Med/Surg
Critical Care
2015 New Graduate Nurses
• 2015
– 16 Med/Surg Nurses
• Average 5.46 Weeks
– 14 Critical Care Nurses
• Average 8.75 Weeks
31 .
7.18 8.12 5.46
10.05 11.74
8.75
0
5
10
15
2013 2014 2015
Med/Surg
Critical Care
Estimated Cost Savings
• 2013 Cost for Orientation
– 15 Med/Surg RN’s at 7.18 weeks = 287.2 hours
– 15 Critical Care RN’s at 10.5 weeks = 420 hours
• 2014 Cost for Orientation
– 1 Med/Surg RN at 8.12 weeks = 324.8 hours
– 4 Critical Care RN’s at 11.74 weeks = 469.6 hours
• 2015 Cost for Orientation
– 15 Med/Surg RN’s at 5.46 weeks at 218.4 hours
– 13 Critical Care RN’s at 8.75 weeks at 350 hours
32
Orientation Cost in $$
7812
9010
6178
11424
13027
9901
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
2013 2014 2015
Med/Surg
Critical Care
33
Outcome
• The utilization of:
– Preceptor classes
– Feedback from previous Nurse Residency Classes
– Experiential learning, skills training, and simulations
– Increased educator time on the units
Has helped to strengthened the orientation of graduate nurses and decrease overall orientation time at UVHN-CVPH.
34
Retention
• As of October 29, 2015, all Graduate Nurses hired are
currently still employed at UVHN-CVPH.
35
References
• Ramritu, P., & Barnard, A. (2001). New nurse graduates' understanding of competence. International Nursing Review, 48, 47–57.
• Zigmont, J., Cavalieri, A., Edwards, T., Rees, T., Wade, A. (2015). Create a Simulation-enhanced RN Orientation Program. 4 hour Pre-conference course at the International Meeting for Simulation in Healthcare, New Orleans, Louisiana, January 11, 2015.
• Zigmont, J. J.; Wade, A., Edwards, T., Hayes, K., Mitchell, J., Oocumma, N. (2015). Utilization of Experiential Learning, The Learning Outcomes Model Reduces RN Orientation Time by More than 35%. Clinical Simulation in Nursing, 11, 79-94.
• Zigmont, J. J., Kappus, L., Sudikoff, S. N., (2011b). The 3D model of debriefing: Defusing, discovering, and deepening. Seminars in Perinatology, 35(2), 52-58.
• Zigmont, J. J., Kappus, L., Sudikoff, S. N., (2011a). Theoretical foundations of learning through simulation. Seminars in Perinatology, 35(2), 47-5.
37