english literature department adab and humanities …
TRANSCRIPT
ANALYSIS OF POLITENESS STRATEGIES USED BY THE MAIN
CHARACTER IN HOME ALONE 1
THESIS
Submitted to the Board of Examination in Partial Fullfillment
of the Requirement for Literature Degree
at English Literature Department
by
RAMADYA ABITZA
NIM : 403170904
ENGLISH LITERATURE DEPARTMENT
ADAB AND HUMANITIES FACULTY
STATE ISLAMIC UNIVERSITY
SULTHAN THAHA SAIFUDDIN JAMBI
2021
ii
iii
iv
v
vi
MOTTO
They plan, Allah too plans, and Allah is the best of planners – Qur’an Surah
Ali – Imran Verse 54
”Mereka berencana, Allah-pun berencana, dan Allah adalah sebaik-baiknya
pembuat rencana”
“It’s not about how hard you hit. It’s about how hard you can get hit and keep
moving forward”
Bukan tentang seberapa kuat kau memukul tapi tentang seberapa kuat kau dapat
menahan pukulan dan tetap terus maju.
-Rocky Balboa-
vii
DEDICATION
“In the name of Allah, The most Beneficial, The most Merciful”
The Last and Final Messenger of Allah, Muhammad (pbuh) a good role model
and the leader of human kind.
I dedicated this thesis to:
Myself who never give up no matter what happen.
To both of my parents who always give me the best prayers, supports, and love.
To my family and friends who are always there for me in any circumstances.
And finally, for everyone who have helped me in writing this thesis.
Allow me to deliver my gratitude.
viii
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Bismillahirahmanirahim…
All praises to Allah SWT, God the owner of the universe who wills over
everything who has given me ease in completing this thesis with the title An
Analysis Politeness Strategies Used by the Main Character in Home Alone 1 Film
the requirement of the degree of Sarjana (S1) of English Literatre of Adab and
Humanity Faculty of State Islamic University Sultan ThahaSaifuddin Jambi.
Let’s deliver our blessing and salutation to the last and final messenger of
Allah, Muhammad pbuh who has brought us from the darkness to the brightness
such as we feel today.
I also would like to deliver my best appreciation to those who have helped
me in writing this thesis. My sincere gratitude goes to:
1. The Rector of State Islamic University Sultan ThahaSaifuddin Jambi,
Prof. Dr. H. Suaidi, M.A, Ph.D, the first vice rector, Dr. Rofiqoh
Ferawati, SE., M.EI the second vice rector, Dr. As’ad Isma, M.Pd, the
third vice rector, Dr. Bahrul Ulum, M.A who allowed to study in this
University.
2. The dean of Adab and Humanities faculty, Dr. Halimah Dja’far,
S.Ag.,M.Fil.I, the first deputy dean Dr. Ali Muzakir, M.Ag, the second
deputy dean Dr. Alfian, S.Pd, M.Ed, the third deputy dean Dr.
Raudhoh, S.Ag., SS., M.Pd.I, the head of English Literature
Department, Dian Mukhlisa, M.A, and the secretary of English
Literature Department, Chandri Febri Santi, M.Pd and to all the
lecturers who have shared their knowledge.
3. I would like particularly to thank Dr. Alfian, S.Pd, M.Ed and Yenti,
M.Pd for the many insights they provided me for writing this thesis.
Discussions with them have also proven most helpful.
ix
4. All of the lecturers and staffs of Adab and Humanity faculty for
became the place where I study until undergraduate in this university.
5. My father, Andrio Maijon who always reminds me of Allah, who
always told me to be patient and accept what happen for those are
Allah’s teachings and plans. For my mother, Susi Mediyawati, S.Pd
who always gives me the best she could possibly give, for always there
when I need her. For my siblings and my grandmother for being the
best family I could ever have.
6. For all of my classmates for sharing all the moments during 3 years
pass.
7. Last but not least, I want to thank me for believing in me, I want to
thank me for doing all of this hard work, I want to thank me for having
no days off, I want to thank me for never quitting, I want to thank me
for never giving up on me.
This thesis is still far from perfection, the writer humbly request some
critiques and suggestions in order to make it better in the future time. Finally, the
researcher wishes that this thesis could extend useful contribution to the readers,
especially for the students of English Literature Department of Adab and
Humanities Faculty.
Jambi, 17 Februari 2021
Ramadya Abitza
403170904
x
ABSTRACT
Abitza, Ramadya, 2021 : Analysis Politeness Strategies Used by the Main
Character in Home Alone Film. English Literature
Department, Adab and Humanities Faculty, University of
Islamic Sulthan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi.
Supervisor I : Dr. Alfian, M.Ed
Supervisor II : Yenti, M.Pd
This thesis discusses the politeness strategies in Home Alone 1 movie.
Home Alone 1 told the story of a child named Kevin who tried to keep his house
from burglars. Kevin used politeness strategies to launch his ambitions. The
purposes of this study were as follows: (1) to know kinds of politeness
strategy used by the main character in the home alone 1 movie, (2) to know
how the main character used the politeness strategies.
This thesis used a pragmatic approach from Eva Alcon Soler and
Aricia Martinez Flor (2008), and politeness from Brown and Levinson theory
(1978). The method used qualitative research and descriptive method to analyze
the data, the researcher used the documentation to collect the data, source of the
data was taken from the dialogues and the scene in Home Alone 1 movie.
The finding in this thesis showed that Kevin used politeness strategies to
keep his house from burglars and communicated with other characters. (1) there
were four types of politeness strategies used by Kevin were bald on record,
positive politeness, negative politeness, and off record, (2) the ways Kevin used
the politeness strategy there were direct communicating and indirect
communicating.
Keywords : home alone, politeness strategy, film.
xi
ABSTRAK
Abitza, Ramadya, 2021 : Analysis Politeness Strategies Used by the Main
Character in Home Alone Film. English Literature
Department, Adab and Humanities Faculty, University of
Islamic Sulthan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi.
Pembimbing I : Dr. Alfian, S.Pd., M.Ed.
Pembimbing II : Yenti, M.Pd
Skripsi ini membahas tentang strategi kesantunan dalam film Home Alone
1. Home Alone 1 bercerita tentang seorang anak bernama Kevin yang berusaha
menjaga rumahnya dari pencuri. Kevin menggunakan strategi kesopanan untuk
meluncurkan ambisinya. Tujuan dari penelitian ini adalah sebagai berikut: (1)
untuk mengetahui macam-macam strategi kesantunan yang digunakan oleh
pemeran utama dalam film Home Alone 1, (2) untuk mengetahui bagaimana
pemeran utama menggunakan strategi kesantunan.
Skripsi ini menggunakan pendekatan pragmatis dari Eva Alcon Soler dan
Aricia Martinez Flor (2008), dan kesantunan dari teori Brown dan Levinson
(1978). Metode yang digunakan adalah penelitian kualitatif dan metode deskriptif
untuk menganalisis data, peneliti menggunakan dokumentasi untuk
mengumpulkan data, sumber data diambil dari dialog dan adegan dalam film
Home Alone 1.
Temuan dalam tesis ini menunjukkan bahwa Kevin menggunakan strategi
kesopanan untuk menjaga rumahnya dari pencuri dan berbicara dengan karakter
lain. (1) Ada empat jenis strategi kesantunan yang digunakan Kevin yaitu
berbicara langsung, kesantunan positif, kesopanan negatif, dan berbicara tidak
langsung, (2) cara Kevin menggunakan strategi kesantunan yaitu komunikasi
langsung dan komunikasi tidak langsung.
Kata Kunci : home alone, strategi kesopanan, film.
xii
TABLE OF CONTENT
APPROVAL ............................................................................................................. ii
NOTA DINAS ........................................................................................................... iii
LETTER OF RATIFICATION .............................................................................. iv
ORIGINAL THESIS STATEMENT ..................................................................... v
MOTTO .................................................................................................................... vi
DEDICATION .......................................................................................................... vii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ....................................................................................... viii
ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................. x
ABSTRAK ................................................................................................................ xi
TABLE OF CONTENT ........................................................................................... xii
CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION
A. Background of Research ................................................................................ 1
B. Formulation of Problem ................................................................................. 5
C. Limitation of the Research ............................................................................. 5
D. Purpose of the Research ................................................................................. 5
E. Significance of the Research .......................................................................... 6
CHAPTER II: THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
A. Pragmatic........................................................................................................ 7
B. Politeness Strategies ....................................................................................... 8
1. Kinds of Politeness Strategies .................................................................. 10
a. Bald on Record ................................................................................... 11
b. Possitive Politeness ............................................................................ 13
c. Negative Politeness ............................................................................ 18
d. Off Record .......................................................................................... 20
2. The Politeness Strategy Uses ................................................................... 24
a. Direct Communicating ........................................................................ 24
b. Indirectly Communicating ................................................................... 24
C. Review on Previous Research ........................................................................ 25
xiii
CHAPTER III: METHOD OF THE RESEARCH
A. Design of Research ........................................................................................ 29
B. Source of Data ................................................................................................ 30
C. Technique of Data Collection ........................................................................ 30
D. Technique of Data Analysis ........................................................................... 31
CHAPTER IV: FINDING AND ANALYSIS
A. Finding .......................................................................................................... 33
B. Analysis .......................................................................................................... 33
1. Kinds of Politeness Strategies ................................................................... 33
a. Bald On Record ................................................................................... 33
b. Positive Politeness ............................................................................... 37
c. Negative Politeness ............................................................................... 40
d. Off Record ............................................................................................ 43
2. The Main Character’s Ways of Using Politeness Strategies ..................... 46
a. Direct Communicating .......................................................................... 46
b. Indirect Communicating ....................................................................... 49
CHAPTER V: CONCLUSION
A. Conclusion .................................................................................................... 52
B. Suggestion ..................................................................................................... 53
REFERENCES
APPENDIXES
1
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
A. Background of the Research
One of the basic needs of human beings in this universe was language, so
language was used to communicate and engage each other. We expressed our
feelings as we used words, as well as the cultural values and traditions of the
cultures that we are members of: our families, social networks and other
organizations.. According to Bloch and Trager, Language is a set of signs that
functions and communicates randomly with an internal system. In general, it can
be said that language is a means of conveying knowledge, emotions, concepts or
feelings.1 Language is a way of transporting something, in other words. Language
analysis is called linguistics. According to Lyons, Linguists typically describe
linguistics as a scholarly study of language.2 Saussure regards Language as a
standardized sign system. He describes linguistics as the study of language and
the study of the manifestations of human speech.3
Linguistics had some parts. First, Semantic was a linguistic branch that
studies the meaning or meaning contained in a language, code, or other types of
representation. Second, Morphology was the science of language that studies
word formation. Third, Syntax was the science of the Strategies and rules for
making sentences in natural language. Fourth, Phonology was the science of the
vocabulary of the phonemes of a language and their distribution. Fifth, Pragmatic
was a branch of linguistics that studies the relationship between context and
meaning.
1Bloch, Bernard; & Trager, George L. Outline of linguistic analysis. Special
publications of the Linguistic Society of America. Baltimore: Linguistic Society of America,
1942. 2Lyons, John.. Language and Linguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
1981. 3Saussure, Ferdinand de. Course in General Linguistics. Edited by Charles Bally and
Albert Sechehave, in collaboration with Albert Riedliner. Translate by Wade Baskin. New York :
McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1966.
2
Pragmatic was a linguistic subdiscipline. According to Leech, The
pragmatics were the study of meaning in reference to speaking situations.4 While
Levinson state, Pragmatics is the study of language-context relation, which
describes the foundation of language comprehension.5 One of the aspects included
in pragmatics was politeness. According to Brown and Levinson, politeness is
how people behave in a way that attempts in considering of the feelings of
their addressee.6 Politeness also means that being polite was not simply way
like saying, “thank you” or “please” in the right place. It was the matter of how
people used their language appropriately toward their addressee. It means
that politeness was an important point to maintain a good relationship with
other people.
The reason for choosing the topic politeness strategies was based on the
researcher curiosity in analyzing on four types of politeness strategies of one of
the characters in the film Home Alone 1 . The topic of politeness strategies in the
film Home Alone 1 was interesting for the researcher because he thought that by
making an interaction, people can describe or show that they want to make a
request, apology, refusal, and thank. So, other people understand what is
meant and the interaction occured naturally. The researcher also knew that
politeness strategies were very needed for people to speak politely with other
people.
When we disscussed about politeness, we had to know what the standard
of politeness in every different culture in this world, based on the title that the
researcher wanted to disscuss, Home Alone 1 was the film where the scene took in
America, Edward stated in western (American) culture, when a man went outside
for drinks, but he said goodbye to his family, he went outside for fresh air at night.
Even though everyone knew he had gone out for drinks, they all acted as if he had
4Leech, Geoffrey. The Principle of Pragmatics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
1983 5Levinson, Stephen C.. Pragmatics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1983
6 Brown and Levinson i n Pater Longscope, “The Universalit of Face in Brown and
Levinson Politness Theory: A Japanese Perspective,” Journal University of Pennsylvania
graduate school of education, 1978, p. 70.
3
indeed gone for some fresh air. Even when he came home drunk, they behaved
with no regard for it. By understanding the polite fiction that applies to the
community, it is hoped that it can help predict what actions will be taken in the
new situation7.
There are several ethical manners that are considered "good manners" in
America. These ethical patterns of courtesy include: (a) We're all equals. When
Americans meet and shake hands, the two of them say “Hi” to each other, One
person will say "How are you?" and the other will answer "Fine, and you?" This
symbolizes that there is no distance between them, no matter who started the
conversation, no status difference. (b) When an American talks to other people, he
will always pay attention to the other person by looking the other person's eyes.
(c) Relax! When an American visits a friend's house, the host always asked the
guest to be able to act as if they were at home. This means that the host fully
entrusts the guest to serve himself as in his own house. (d) You and I are close
friends (or at least: I like you). If an American has just met someone who hasn't
known before, or doesn't even like someone, he will still be friendly. For
Americans, being formal is considered cold. (e) You and I are independent. It is
polite for Americans not to ask others for help with the problems they face.8
In this thesis, the researcher interested to analyse Home Alone 1 based on
their standard of politeness culture. According to Villarejo stated that film is
structured like a language and it is telling stories.9 It means that film offers us of
seeing and feeling and it is inspire product of creative team and might well
stimulate person fantasies. The researcher interested in choosing this politeness
strategies for some reasons :
First, The researcher has chosen politeness strategies as a topic in this
study because politeness is an important subject in communication.
Politeness was related to the research of how people use a language as they
7 Hall, Edward T. 1992. Beyond Culture. New York : Doubleday.
8 http://www.culture-at-work.com/politefiction.html. Accessed 15 April 2021
9 Villarejo, Amy. Film Studies the Basic, (New York : Library of Congress, 2007), Third
Edition, p.12
4
are living or talking. On the other hand, the researcher chose this movie
because this movie was acted by a child and this movie also played every
years, especially when Christmas day. As stated by Holmes, being
linguistically polite mechanism speaking to people appropriately in the light of
their relationship.10
Second, the researcher has decided to observe and evaluate the use of
politeness strategies. The researcher tried to prove that a film could be a good
medium to learn politeness. The purpose of this analysis is to observe and
evaluate the usage of politeness techniques in a film entitled Home Alone 1. The
researcher selected Home Alone 1 movie because it incorporates the formal and
casual vocabulary used in everyday communication. For instance, formal
conversation was like when student learnt in classroom with the teacher, on the
other side, informal or casual communication was like we communicated by
using telephone or communicated with friends. It reveals a lot of phrases that the
main character uses politeness strategies. Through a regular dialog, the
researcher interpreted the primary character's comments so that study questions
could be resolved. Thus, this film also offers explanations of how politeness
strategies are used in the social sense. Specifically, Home Alone 1 told the story
of a kid named Kevin and the burglars named Harry and Marv. Home Alone 1
film tells the story of a boy who is accidentally left behind by his family as the
holiday season occurs. This incident held him up alone at home, and in the
night, the robbers came to his house.
The researchers discussed the politeness strategies applied by the main
characters in the Home Alone 1 movie although a film can be a good medium to
distinguish things languages and cultures. Through the use of a film, people
would learn about the traditions of the places and the people where the movie
takes place. In addition, it can help English learners especially as the English
Literature Department students who study sociolinguistics and pragmatics,
especially politeness strategies. Moreover, the researcher found out about all the
10
Holmes, J. (1996). Women, men, and politeness. London: Longman. p. 296
5
politeness strategies and how the politeness strategies used in this film. The
research accomplished by classifying the strategies of politeness as seen by the
main character in the Home Alone 1 film and the ways of using the strategies of
politeness that affect the main character in applying the strategies of politeness
in their conversation. Based on the description above, the researcher interested in
conducting research on politeness strategies with the title: “ANALYSIS OF
POLITENESS STRATEGIES USED BY MAIN CHARACTER IN HOME
ALONE FILM”.
B. Formulation of the Research
Based on the background of the problem above, the formulations of the
problems are formulated as follows :
1. What kinds of politeness strategies were used by the main character in
Home Alone film?
2. How politeness strategies were used by the main character in Home Alone
film?
C. Limitation of the Research
This research was taken from Home Alone 1 as an object. It focused the
technique of politeness used mostly by Kevin. It based on the terms of Kevin's
directive: commands, requests, and suggestions. There had been two underlying
analyzes in this report. The first focused on what sort of politeness strategies he
put out. The second based on the study of Kevin's use of the ways of using
politeness in his directive. To do so, the other characters were included in this
analysis, since they were necessary to determine Kevin's directive and the kind of
politeness strategies used by Kevin even when they were having conversations.
D. Purpose of the Research
The purposes of this research were :
1. To find out what kinds of politeness strategies were used by the main character in
Home Alone film.
2. To find out how politeness strategies were used by the main character in Home
Alone film.
6
E. Significance of the Research
There were two practical concerns for the execution of the study. This
research was important due to its theoretical and functional functions:
Theoretically, this research was aimed at enriching the theoretical bases of
literary studies, in particular those relevant to the study of the politeness of the
main character. Practically, the principle of politeness upheld in this study gave
some teachings about politeness in regular interactions, particularly in
commanding, requesting, and suggesting. We used different strategies in separate
situations whether we were going to be required to be polite or not. Therefore, we
have also been more vigilant about selecting such strategies in order to preserve
effective relations with others and to accomplish our goal through such a
communication. Reference and alternate knowledge is also supposed to be the
outcome of this research. This study was meant to be helpful for other researchers
conducting related research, such as an investigation of the politeness of the main
character as seen in the Home Alone film.
7
CHAPTER II
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
A. Pragmatic
Pragmatic is one of those terms that gives the appearance that something
very precise and technical is being addressed although, in fact, it often has little
precise understanding and focuses primarily on the analysis of speech acts.11. In
the other hand, the pragmatics concentrate on the interaction between linguistics
and the speakers of certain forms. Pragmatics consider human in observation, in
real life people did not always speak openly to express what they desired in
order to be respectful and appreciate others. In certain special circumstances,
people would prefer to communicate implicitly rather than directly. For
example, while the robber was come to Kevin’s house and Kevin says, it can be
seen in the statement below:
Down here, you big horse's ass!12
The sentence above does not mean that he simply makes a point about
the horse’s ass, but it was an indirect order for the robber to take look for him
and chase him. Kevin could directly say down here and get me! but here he was
attempting to be more polite, so he used an indirect request. Furthermore,
context of language plays an important part in the perception of meaning. In a
single statement, various contexts will give rise to different interpretations. Just
as in this sentence. The interpretation of the comments should be understood on
the basis of the situation or the context. The study of language that emphasizes
on the interpretation of the speaker and the meaning of the context is called
pragmatic.13
. This statement is supported by some linguists such as, Istvan
Kecskes and Laurance state pragmatics as the study of meaning in the relation
11
Eva Alcon Soler and Aricia Martinez Flor, Investigating Pragmatics in Foreign
Language Learning, Teaching and Testing, (New York: Cromwell Press, 2008), p. 3. 12
Duration 00.27.23 -> 01.27.27 13
Michael, L. Scott, Programing Language Pragmatics, p. 4.
to a speech situation.14
Similarly, Evala Alcon Soler and Alicia Martinez Flor
also state that The pragmatic study of the meaning and contextual meaning of
the speaker emphasizes on the use of human language in communication,
which is affected by the state of culture.15
From the descriptions above, it can be assumed that it clarified
pragmatically how people create and comprehend ordinary utterances.
Pragmatics are very similar to the context and circumstance of the speaker and
audience in which the conversations took place.
B. Politeness Strategies
One of the facets of pragmatism was politeness. Politeness was not only in
form and in words, but also in the social role and context assumed. If the speaker
said that there was a more humble form than the meaning demanded, the speech
partner would assume that there was a secret intent. Grice figures out, that the
participants in the dialogue should still consider the decency strategies. He said
the role of politeness in society was very important and appropriate.16
According
to Holmes, the formality factor can also be polite. In formal contexts, the best way
to communicate to your siblings will depend on your role in communicating.17
Politeness was really important to human beings. According to Arthur
Martine, being pleasant in speaking to the right people is really necessary for a
stable social interaction with others18
. It means that politeness has been
translated as a willingness to be more pleasing to others and to inspire them to
build a harmonious relationship. People have sought to stop dissension and to
disappoint polite and more appealing gestures to some.
14
Istvan Kecskes and Laurance, Exploration In Pragmatics Linguistics, Cognitive
and Intercultural Aspects, (Germany: 2007), p. 9. 15
Evala Alcon Soler and Alicia Martinez Flor, Investigating Pragmatics in Foreign
Language Learning, Teaching and Testing, (Canada: UTP, 5201 Dufferin Street, North York,
Ontario M3H 5T8, 2008), p. 3. 16
Grice, H.P. (1975). "Logic and Conversation," Syntax and Semantics, vol.3 edited by
P. Cole and J. Morgan, Academic Press. 17
Holmes, J. (1992). An Introduction to Sociolinguistic. London and New York: Longman 18
Arthur Martine, Martine Hand’s Book Ettiquete and Guide To
True Politeness, (London: Forgotten Books, 2013), p. 5.
Buyer: Are there any apples?
Shopkeeper: There are just oranges and pineapples, sir.
The communication above was between a shopkeeper and a shopper. The
shopkeeper sought to please the customer by avoiding saying things that left the
buyer unhappy that there was no apple in it. However, the buyer in the
aforementioned discussion expresses tacit apology by giving the other fruits.
Thomas insists that politeness manifested by general social conduct. In
comparison, Arthur Martine claims that there is politeness when it comes to
interference between linguistics, social and cognitive.19
Politeness present
through language and as the result of a person is cognitive assessment in of the
social context. For example to request, apologize, and criticize does not only
involve the performance of a directive, commissure, and assertive. But also
performances of action with clear implication for the identities of the speaker.
People must consider various factors related to social distance and
intimacy when understanding what is said in an interaction. Zeydan K. Omar
and Sura Abdul Wahid states that people typically involve the relative
status of the participants based on social values such as power and age.20
For
example, speakers who have lower status in English speaking context tend to
mark social distance between themselves and higher status speaking by using
address forms that include a title and last name, but not the first name, for
example: Mrs. Clinton, Mr. Adams, or Dr Dang. While the goal of politeness
is to make all of the parties relaxed and comfortable with one another, these
culturally defined standards at times may be manipulated to inflict shame on a
designated party. Therefore, we need to know more about politeness strategies to
build the harmony of our communication.
19
Arthur Martine, Martine Hand’s Book Ettiquete and Guide To True Politeness, p. 7. 20
Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic Analysis of Impoliteness in
Some of Harold Pinter's Plays,” Journal College of Education for Humanities Anbar University,
Number 8 -Year 3 (2010), p. 119.
According to Brown and Levinson, a politeness strategy was developed
to save the "face" of the audience. Face-saving refers to personal respect for
oneself and maintaining "self-esteem" in public or private situations. In some
cases, we should avoid embarrassing the other person or making them
uncomfortable. Threat-to-face behaviors (FTA’s) are behaviors in which hearing
offenders maintain their self-esteem and are respected. The main purpose of
developing a politeness strategy was to deal with these free trade agreements. In
addition, Brown and Levinson proposed four types of politeness strategies,
which summarize human "polite" behaviors: bald on record, negative politeness,
positive politeness, and non-record indirect strategies. The use of each strategy
varies from situation to situation.
Bald on Record was a condition that someone wanted to perform FTA
(Facial Threat Behavior) with maximum efficiency, not to satisfy the audience's
expression, even to any degree. This means that the speaker expresses his needs
directly and usually in imperative form. For example, when a student forgets to
bring a book, and he wants the person sitting next to him to lend him a book, the
student can say “please give me a book”. Positive politeness was the behavior
directed at the positive faces of the audience, that is, the audience's positive self-
image of them. It's well-known for making friends, wanting and personality
traits. Negative politeness was a behavior directed at the negative faces of the
audience. When we talked to people who don’t know them, we use negative
politeness. Off Record was a suggested action for the audience. When we tried
to suggest a good thing to our friends or siblings, we used Off Record strategy.
1. Kinds of Politeness Strategies
Brown and Levinson also introduces two terms in their theory:
“face wants” as the expectations of people is public self-image, and FTA
concept as “the acts that threat another individual is face wants”.21
21
Brown and Levinson in Pater Longscope, “The Universalit of Face in Brown and
Levinson Politness Theory: A Japanese Perspective,” Journal University of Pennsylvania
graduate school of education, 1978, p. 70.
Politeness strategies are developed for the main purpose of dealing
with the FTAs in order to save the hearers‟ face and usually it is used to
avoid embarrassing the others. There are four strategies for doing FTA is
Brown and Levinson:22
a. Bald on record
Speaking in direct, clear, unambiguous and concise way in circumstances
where face is not irrelevant or minimized. This strategy is performed in
the most direct, clear, unambiguous and concise way as possible. It is the
most effective way for the speaker to get his message through to the hearer
but the speaker ignores the hearer is face and its wants. Here, the utterance
is maximally efficient with regards to Anne is conversational maxims.
According to Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “we do not follow
these maxims in conversations but they motivate the speakers to pay
attention to the face wants and avoid conflict”.23
1) Great Urgency or Desperation
This strategy is used when the speaker is needing the attention very
soon, especially before anything else because of its important. In cases
of great urgency or desperation, a compensation would actually
decrease the communicated urgency.
For examples : (1) “Help!”
(2) “Watch out!”
From the example above, with an exclamation point showed that there
is no other choice in that situation. From the example (1) the speaker
needed help for the hearer than in the example (2) the speaker used
to warn the hearer of danger or an accident that might be happen.
22
Brown and Levinson in Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic
Analysis of Impoliteness in Some of Harold Pinter's Plays”, p. 120. 23
Brown and Levinson in Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic
Analysis of Impoliteness in Some of Harold Pinter's Plays”, p. 121.
2) Speaking as if great efficiency is necessary in attention-getters
This strategy is used where the speaker speaks as if maximum
efficiency were very important, he or she provides metaphorical
urgency for emphasis.
For examples : (1) Look, the point is this...
(2) Listen, I’ve got an idea.
The example in (1) and (2) are used in order to get the attention from
the hearer. In example (1) the word “look” is a verb which used by
the speaker to direct the hearer‟s eyes in order to see in another point.
In example (2) the word “listen” is a verb which used to give attention
to the hearer in order to hear what the speaker said.
3) Task-oriented/ Paradigmatic Form of Instruction
This strategy is used when the speaker gives a task to the hearer in order
to get the desire results. Face redness may be felt to irrelevant when
the focus interaction is task-oriented. The example of this strategy is
“Give me the nails.” From the example, the speaker gave the hearer a
task to give the nails to the speaker.
4) Sympathetic Advice or Warnings
Brown and Levinson state that in doing an FTA, the speaker conveys
that he or she does care about the hearer (and therefore about the hearer’s
positive face), so that no redness is required. Sympathetic advice or
warning may be bald on record.
For examples: (1) Careful! He‟s a dangerous man.
(2) Your slip is showing!
In the example (1) the speaker wants to warn the hearer to be careful
because he is a dangerous man. The word “careful” was used to give an
attention to what the hearer was doing so that he or she did not have a
damage from that man. In the example (2) the speaker gave
sympathetic expression that the hearer is slip was showing.
5) Granting Permission for Something
This strategy is used when the speaker gives or allows the hearer to
do something so that the hearer is allowed to do it. The example of
granting for something is “Yes, you may go.” From the example, it
showed that the speaker allowed the hearer to move to another place.
6) Invitations
This strategy is used when the speaker requested a hearer to do
something. “Come in” or “Enter” are the examples of this strategy. It
implied that the speaker asked the hearer to move towards the speaker in
a room or bulding.
7) Welcoming
Welcoming (or post-greeting) is used when the speaker insisted that the
hearer may impose on his or her negative face. The example of
welcoming is the utterance by the speaker to a person who comes to his
or her house as in “Oh you come. Come in.”
8) Greetings and Farewells
The greeting strategy is used when the speaker welcomes the hearer to
show her or his friendliness or politeness. Meanwhile, the farewell
strategy is used when the speaker says goodbye or takes his or her
leave to the hearer. The examples of this strategy are “come”, “go”,
“sit down”, or “good bye”.
b. Positive politeness
Positive politeness strategy is redressive directed to the addressee's positive
face: his desire that his wants should be thought of as desirable. This
strategy is used to promote high involvement and solidarity. Positive
politeness is not necessarily redressive of the particular face want infringed
by the FTA but a kind of social accelerator such as joking.24
1) Claiming Common Ground
This type involves the speaker to claim the hearer in the common
ground by indicating the speaker and hearer being to a particular group.
This particular group is sharing specific desires or wants which includes
goals and values.
(a) Noticing hearer’s interests, wants, needs, and good
This strategy suggests that the speaker should pay attention or
notice to aspect of hearer's condition. It can be in the form of
sympathy, care or even compliment.
For example: “We ate too many beans tonight, didn’t we?”
The example above shows that the speaker is paid attention to the
hearer. It indicates that the speaker notices the hearer is condition.
(b) Exaggerating interest, approval, and sympathy with the hearer
This strategy can be done by saying something in a way that is
higher than its actual status using exaggerating adjective.
For example: “What a fantastic house you have!”
The example above shows that the speaker exaggerated her
or his compliment about the hearer is house. The word “fantastic”
implied that the hearer have a great house.
(c) Intensifying interest to hearer, making good story, draw hearer
as a participant into the conversation.
This strategy is used for the speaker to the hearer that she or he
wants intensify the interest of speaker is by making a good story.
24
Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic Analysis of Impoliteness in
Some of Harold Pinter's Plays,” Journal College of Education for Humanities Anbar University,
Number 8 -Year 3 (2010), p. 192.
For example: “I come down the stairs, and what do you think I see?
A huge mess all over the place, the phone is off the hook and clothes
are scattered all over.”
(d) Using in-group identity markers
This strategy is done by using in-group identity markers are address
form, language dialect, jargon, and slang to indicate that speaker
and hearer belong to some of persons who share specific wants.
For example: “Come here, guys!”
The example above shows that the speaker used in-group identity
markers by saying “guys” intended to the hearer.
(e) Seeking agreement
This strategy is to seek for hearer‟s agreement by raising “safe
topic‟ that the hearer will agree with.
For example: “Isn‟t your new car has a beautiful color?”
The example above showed that the speaker says a comment
to a neighbor‟s new car. The speaker raises the topic which is safer
instead of stating the unsafe topic.
(f) Avoiding disagreement
This strategy showed that avoiding disagreement by stating false
agreement, indirect agreement, white lies, and hedging.
For example:
A : That’s where you live, California?
B : That’s where I was born.
The speaker asked for information to the hearer whether she lived
there or not. Instead of claiming what the speaker says as a mistake,
the speaker states that she was born there. The hearer answered by
avoiding disagreement.
(g) Presupposing to raise and assert common ground
This strategy explains that presupposing is the act of believing
something is true before it is proven.
For example: “ I had a really hard time learning to drive, didn‟t I? ”
(h) Joking
This strategy is a basic positive politeness technique used to
minimize the face threatening acts (FTA). Therefore, it is the form of
claiming common ground. For example: “How about lending me this
heap of junk?”
(i) Presupposing speaker’s knowledge of and concern for the
hearer’s want
This strategy aims to presuppose what the hearer’s desire according
to the speaker’s knowledge toward what hearer’s want.
For example: “I know you love roses but the florist didn’t have
anymore, so I brought you geranium instead.”
(j) Promise
This strategy means that when the speaker makes a promise to the
hearer, the speaker has the intention to fulfill the hearer’s want.
For example: “I will treat you next week.”
The speaker promises to the hearer that she or he would treat next
week.
(k) Being optimistic
In this strategy, the speaker becomes optimistic regarding the
willingness of the hearer to fulfill or wants to do something for the
speaker. For example: “You‟ll lend me your car, right?”
The example above shows that the speaker was optimistic that
hearer would lend her or him a car.
(l) Including both speaker and hearer in an activity
This strategy aims to make the speaker and hearer involve both of
them in the activity and eventually become cooperators. This
strategy uses an inclusive “we” form, when the speaker really means
“you” or “me”.
For example: “Let‟s have a coffee, then.”
The example above shows that actually the speaker wants the hearer
to have a coffee. The speaker’s request used inclusive “we” form
“let’s”. The request will be more polite because it indicates the
cooperation between the speaker and the hearer.
(m) Giving and asking for reason
This strategy shows that the speaker and hearer are cooperators
through the act of asking and giving reason.
For example: “Why don’t we go to the market?”
(n) Assuming or asserting reciprocity
This strategy can be done by creating mutual advantages among
the speaker and the hearer.
For example: “I‟ll lend you dictionary if you lend me your book.”
A reciprocity is a behavior in which two people give each other
help or advantages. In the example above, the speaker wants to
lend the hearer her or his dictionary if the hearer lends the speaker a
book.
(o) Giving gifts to hearer can be in the form of goods,
sympathy, understanding and cooperation.
This strategy shows that the speaker can satisfy hearer‟s positive
face by actually satisfying some of the hearer’s wants. For example:
“I just know that your dog died yesterday. I’m sorry to hear that.”
The speaker gave a gift to the hearer by giving sympathy
and understanding.25
c. Negative politeness
Satisfying person’s negative face by recognizing and respecting the
addressee is negative face wants and negative politeness also making a
request less infringing, such as “If you don‟t mind...” or “If it isn't too
much trouble...” respects a person’s right to act freely. In others word
deference. There is a greater use of indirect speech acts.
1) Be direct
This strategy includes indirect speech acts that contain of indirect
request. When a speaker produces an utterance in accordance with the
negative politeness, it means that speaker wants to achieve what they
want through the FTA but also wants to redress it.
For example, “Can you please pass the salt?”
2) Do not presume /assume hearer
This strategy is done by not presuming and assuming that the FTA is
desired or accepted by the hearer. This strategy namely question and
hedge. Hedge may be functioned to soften command and turn it into a
polite suggestion.For example, “Won’t you open the door?”
3) Being pessimistic
Do not coerce hearer means that the speaker does not persuade hearer to
do something forcefully. This can be done by stating an option for the
hearer that may not do the act. This also can be done by assuming that
hearer does not want to do the act.
For example, “Could you jump over that five-foot fence?”
25
Brown, P., & Levinson, S. C. (1987). Politeness: Some universals in language usage.
(2nd
ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
4) Minimizing the imposition
This strategy is used to minimize the imposition or the threat toward the
negative face of the hearer. The minimization can be done by
choosing some words which shows the minimum state of a matter.
For example, “Could I borrow your pen just for a minute”.
5) Giving difference
This strategy explained that giving difference is the act of humbling
oneself and fulfill hearer‟s want of respect. This can be done by using
particular addressing form for someone that is superior.
For example, “Excuse me sir, would you mind if I close the window?”
6) Apologizing
By apologizing the speaker can show the unwillingness to threat the
face of the hearer or to impinge on hearer.
For example, “I am sorry to bother you, but please tell him to call me
tonight.”
7) Impersonalizing the speaker and hearer in a conversation
This strategy deals with avoiding the pronouns “I‟ and “U‟.
For example, “Do this for me.”
8) Stating the FTA as an instance of general rule
This strategy shows that the speaker does not want to impinge the hearer.
The speaker omits the fact that impinge the hearer by
emphasizes a notion that the act is a general rule.
For example, “I am sorry, but late-comers cannot be seated till next
interval.”
9) Nominalizing
Nominalizing is the act of changing a verb into a noun in a sentence. By
doing this strategy, the speaker can add more distance and formality.
The more formal utterance is, the more visible that the speaker does not
want to impinge the hearer. For example, “It is our regret that we
cannot..”
10) Going on record as incurring a debt or as not indebting hearer
This strategy is done by claiming speaker’s indebtedness to hearer or by
disclaiming any indebtedness of hearer.
Hence, the speaker can redress the FTA. For example, “I’d be eternally
grateful if you would..”26
d. Off Record
Delivering the intention indirectly, it means that the off-record strategy is
used by the speaker to achieve a communicative intention indirectly. In
other words, the speaker is trying to avoid the responsibility of doing an
FAT. In these strategies, the hearer decides how to interpret the speaker
is utterance (FTA). The FTA is performed 'off-record' typically through
the use of anindirect illocutionary act which has more than one
interpretation27
.
For example, “The door is not open.” which mean the speaker wants the
hearer to open door. The meaning of the statement is not directly stated
by the speaker. According to Brown and Levinson, there are fifteen
strategis of Off Record strategy, they are as follows :
1) Giving hints
This strategy explains that giving hints is an act if saying something
which is not relevant and inviting the hearer to search for an
interpretation of the possible relevance. The speaker invites the hearer
to search for an interpretation of the possible relevance.
For example, “This soup is a bit bland.” As asking the hearer to pass the
salt.
26
Brown, P., & Levinson, S. C. (1987). Politeness: Some universals in language usage.
(2nd
ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 27
Brown and Levinson in Pater Longscope, “The Universalit of Face in Brown and
Levinson Politness Theory: A Japanese Perspective,” p. 70.
2) Give association clues
The speaker gives a related kind of implication triggered by relevance
violations that is provided by mentioning something associated with
the act of a hearer, either by precedent in the speaker-hearer‟s
experience or by mutual knowledge irrespective of their interactional
experience.
For example, “My house is not very far away... There is the path that
leads to my house.” The speaker gives a clue to the hearer to come visit
him or her.
3) Presupposing prior event
This strategy is done by forcing the hearer to search for the relevance of
a prior event. For example, “I washed the car again today.”
As said to convey a criticism to the hearer and to ask the hearer to do it.
4) Understating
The speaker understates what he or she actually wants to say. This is the
act of saying less that what is required. By doing this strategy, the
speaker invites the hearer to search for an interpretation. In the case of
criticism, the speaker avoids the upper points.
For example, “He’s all right.”
That is an understatement which implicates that the person the speaker
is talking about is awful or fabulous.
5) Overstating
The speaker exaggerates or chooses a point on a scale which is higher
than the actual state of affairs. This strategy is saying more than what is
required. For example, “You never do your assignments.”
6) Use tautologies
By uttering a tautology, a speaker encourages hearer to look for an
interpretation from non-informative utterance. For example, “Your
clothes belong to where your clothes belong, my clothes belong where
my clothes belong.” As said to the hearer as a citicism for placing his
belonging in speaker‟s room.
7) Use contradictions
By stating two things that contradict each other, the speaker makes it
appear that he or she cannot be telling the truth.
For example, “I am happy and I am not happy about that.”
8) Being ironic
A speaker can indirectly convey his or her intended meaning by saying
the opposite of what he or she means, if there are clues that his or
her intended meaning is being conveyed indirectly.
For example, “John’s a real genius.” As said after the third person has
just done something stupid.
9) Use metaphors
By using a metaphor the speaker hedges his utterance and he invites
the hearer to interpret the meaning of his hedged utterance.
For example, “Tom is a real fish.” As said to convey that Tom swims like
a fish or swims well.
10) Use rhetorical questions
By using rhetorical question, the speaker asks a question with no
intention of getting the answer. The speaker also invites the hearer to
interpret what he really means. For example, “How many times do I
have to tell you?” As said by the speaker as a criticism to the hearer‟s
action.
11) Being Ambiguous
The speaker makes purposeful ambiguity which may be achieved
through metaphor and lets the hearer to guess what he or she meant.
For example, “Dani’s a pretty sharp cookie.” This could be either a
compliment or an insult, depending on the speaker‟s intention of stating
the connotation sharp.
12) Being vague
The speaker may go off record with an FTA by being vague who the
object of the FTA is, or what the offense is.
For example, “I’m going down the road for a bit.” As said to the local
pub.
13) Over-generalizing
This strategy is about a conveying general rule that hearer then has to
choose whether the general rule applies to him.
For example, “Mature people sometimes help to wash dishes.” As
said by the speaker to convey an order or request.
14) Displacing the hearer
The speaker may go off record as to whose target for his FTA is. He may
pretend to address to FTA to someone whom it would not threaten and
hope that the real target of the FTA will be able to realize that the FTA is
addressed to him.
For example, one secretary in the office asks another secretary in
negative politeness to pass the stapler in the circumstances where the
professor is much nearer than the other secretary. The face of the
professor is not threatened and the professor can choose to help as a
bonus for the secretary.
15) Being incomplete
The speaker does not purposefully finish his or her utterances. It can
leave the implication of “hanging in the air”, just like rhetorical question.
For example, “Oh sir, a headache...” It was used by a child to ask her
father for an aspirin. This gave him the option of telling her to go and
lie down instead of dispensing a precious pill.28
From explanation above, the researcher uses kinds of politeness
strategies by Brown and Levinson to find out the politeness Strategies that used
by Kevin in his life to keep his house from burglars, the researcher found that
the dominant between four kinds of politeness strategies to express Kevin ways
to keep his house is negative politeness because Kevin Satisfying person’s
negative face by recognizing and respecting the addressee is negative face
wants and negative politeness also making a request less infringing to a pair of
burglars and the other characters. The researcher used this theory to find kinds of
politeness strategies were used by the main character in the Home Alone 1 film.
2. The Main Character’s Ways of Using Politeness Strategies
Kierkegaard states that the use of politeness strategies could be with the
direct communicating and indirect communicating.29
a. Direct Communicating
Direct communication happens when a speaker is true intentions are
communicated in his/her verbal message. It expresses the
speaker’s/sender’s need and desires explicitly. When a direct
communicator wants or needs something, he/she will “come right out and
say it”. Direct communicators take the other speaker is words at face
value: they will not analyze the message for underlying meaning. They
value the effectiveness of short, direct answers, and expect and respect
honesty and frankness.
b. Indirect Communicating
Indirect communication happens when a speaker is true intentions are
hidden. Indirect speakers will not make a direct statement or directly
answer a question that might cause tension or result in an uncomfortable
28
Brown, P., & Levinson, S. C. (1987). Politeness: Some universals in language usage.
(2nd
ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 29
George Pattison. “The Theory and Practice of Language and Communication in
Kierkegaard is Upbuilding Discourses” p. 85-87
situation. They are more likely to say “maybe” or “possibly‟ when the true
answer is “no”. Indirect communicators believe that being polite is more
important than giving a true response; this belief is related to the concept
of “saving face” to avoid hurting another person is self-esteem. Indirect
communication is acting out rather than directly saying what a person is
thinking or feeling using facial expressions, tone of voice, and or gestures.
Based on the explanations above, it can be concluded that there are two
ways to use the language function for communicating the message they are direct
communicating and indirect communicating. The researcher will use this theory
to find out the use politeness Strategies used by Kevin by the way keep his
house from a pair of burglars in Home Alone 1 film.
C. Review on Previous Research
There have been relevant previous researchers investigated about
Politeness, their research support on this research paper as follow :
Firstly, This thesis was written by Resi Novira in 2010, entitled
Negative Politeness Strategies As found in Rachael Ray Show30
. The purpose of
this research is to know which strategy that mostly used in Rachael Ray Show and
She used politeness strategy theory by Brown and Levinson (1987), and
negative politeness strategy as her specific analysis. She used quantitative
method in this reseacrh because she wants to know which strategy that mostly
used in the data. The results of this study are speakers of applying a negative
politeness strategies were found in 31 utterances. Strategy 1. Be conventionally
indirect there are two utterances (6.45%), strategy 2. Question, Hedge there are
nine utterances (29,03%), strategy 3. Be pessimistic there are four utterances
(12,90%), strategy 4. Minimize the imposition, Rx there are 3 utterances (9,68%),
strategy 5. Give deference there are four utterances (12,09%), strategy 6.
Apologize there are 1 utterance (3,23%), strategy 7. Impersonalize S and H
30
Resi Novira. Negative Politeness Strategies as Found in Rachel
Ray Show. (Padang: Universitas Andalas, 2010)
there are three utterances (9,68%), strategy 8. State FTA as a general rule there
are 3 utterances (9,68%), strategy 9 and 10 there are only one utterance (3,23%).
Secondly, the student of Muhammadiyah University of Surakarta.
School of Teacher Training and Education named Ahlam Veryya Afnani , by
thesis entitled “Politeness in Love Expression Used in the Last Promise
Novel”31. This research aims to describe the politeness strategy of love
expression used in the last promise novel, he used theory by Brown and
Levinson (1987) and the type of this research is descriptive qualitative research
which the writer uses documentation and observation method as the method of
collecting data. The result of the research shows the politeness patterns of love
expression are bald on 10%, positive politeness strategy 77,5% and negative
politeness strategy 12,5%.
Thirdly, the student of Arts Yogyakarta State University English Language
And Literature Study Program English Education Department Faculty of
Languages named Mifta Hasmi, by thesis entitled “A Pragmatic Analysis
Of Politeness Strategies Reflected In Nanny Mcphee Movie.”32
This research
aims to identify the types of politeness strategies employed by the main
characters in Nanny McPhee movie and (2) to describe the way politeness
strategies are realized in the utterances employed by the main characters in
Nanny McPhee movie. This research used theory by Brown and Levinson
(1987) and this research used descriptive qualitative. The results of the
research show two important points. First, there are four types of politeness
strategies employed by the main characters in Nanny McPhee movie when
having conversation with the children: Bald-on record strategy (31 out of 104),
Positive politeness strategy (46), Negative politeness strategy (15), and Off
record strategy (12). Positive politeness strategy has the highest frequency
among other strategies since the dialogues are among family members who
31
Ahlam Veryya Afnani, “Politeness in Love Expression Used in the Last Promise
Novel,” Muhammadiyah University of Surakarta. School of Teacher Training and Education,
2013, p. 5 32
Mifta Hasmi, “A Pragmatic Analysis Of Politeness Strategies Reflected In Nanny
Mcphee Movie,” Arts Yogyakarta State University English Language And Literature Study
Program English Education Department Faculty of Languagesm 2013, p. 5.
have a close relationship and know each other very well. Second, in realizing
those politeness strategies, the main characters utilize their own sub-strategies.
Fourthly, the student of Faculty of Humanities Dian Nuswantoro
University named Eva Indriani, by thesis entitled “Positive Politeness Strategies
Used By Grace And Meg In Monte Carlo Movie”.33 This research aims to
describe the types of politeness strategies produced by Grace and Meg in
“Monte Carlo” movie. This research used politeness strategy theory by
Brown and Levinson (1987), and positive politeness strategy as his specific
analysis. The researcher used a qualitative research since the data engaged are
displayed in the form of strings of words.. The unit of analysis of this research is
focused on the utterances produced by the main character Grace and her step
sister Meg in Monte Carlo movie. Meanwhile, it is found that strategy 4: Use in
group identity markers and strategy 12: Include both S and H become the
highest number of strategy made by both characters in their utterances with 4 in
total. Then it is followed by strategy 1: Notice, Attend to hearer is wants and
strategy 5: seek agreement with 3 numbers. After that, strategy 2:
Exaggerate Interest and Strategy 3: Intensity interest to Hearer is in the third
place with 2. The least number of positive politeness strategies is Strategy 8:
Joke with only 1 found in the utterances produced by Grace and Meg. The result
shows that Grace as the main character produced the highest number of positive
politeness in her utterances compared to Meg.
Fifth, this thesis was written by Yuliana Prameswari in 2012, entitled
Negative Politeness Strategy in Diplomacy Meeting at UN Security Council
Summit on Nuclear Non-Proliferation and Nuclear Disarmament.34
The
aims of this research was to know the impact of negative politeness strategy
in diplomacy meeting and she used qualitative method and several theories to
analyzed the unit analysis, the theories are Brown and Levinson is negative
33
Eva Indriani,“ Positive Politeness Strategies Used By Grace And Meg In Monte
Carlo Movie,” Faculty of Humanities Dian Nuswantoro University, 2014, 5. 34
Yuliana Prameswari. NegativePoliteness Strategy in Diplomacy Meeting at UN
Security Council Summit on Nuclear Non Proliferation Disarmament. (Jakarta: UIN Syarif
Hidayatullah, 2012)
politeness strategy, supported by other theories such as John Searle is indirect
speech act, Grice is co-operative principle dimensions-non-spuriousness,
relevance, and perspicuosness, Leech is tact maxim, Agha is honorification,
Ross is degrees of nouniness and Scollon is politeness system. From this
research, the writer found the fact that by applying the theories, the researcher
knows that negative politeness strategy regularly implies in spokesman is
utterances to not infringe the hearer is negative face and to maintain the
harmonized atmosphere among them. The results, negative politeness as the
heart of respect behavior has greatly contribution to the success of
international diplomacy, with negative politeness strategies, diplomats from
different states can represent their own policy and resolution without
infringement to territory of hearer is freedom.
From the preview related research above, it can be seen that this research
had difference and similiarity from them. From the five previous researchers, this
research had different in choosing object from the second reserachers above, and
also using the different theory in four and five researchers above. The similiarity
can be seen in the first, third, becuase the researchers choosing film as their
object, but still had different in the selection of problems of this research question
about how the main character delivered politeness strategy, then this research had
similiarities with the first until four researchers in selection of descriptive
qualitative.
29
CHAPTER III
METHOD OF RESEARCH
A. Design of Research
In writing this thesis, the researcher used qualitative research and
descriptive method that was suitable with the aim of this research. Qualitative
research might be in descriptive form. The data collected in the form of words
as a descriptive explanation than a number. The result of the research contained
quotation from the data to illustrate and substantive the presentation. Descriptive
method is a research which aims to describe a phenomenon accurately based
on the characteristic of research.35
In this thesis, the researcher used
qualitative research, where the data analyzed through interpreting, not statistical
analysis. Nyoman Kutha Ratna stated: “Qualitative research provides attention to
natural data, data in relation to the context of its existence. These are the ways
in which qualitative research was perceived as multi-research because research
in turn involves a large number of relevant social phenomena. In the study of
literary works, for example, will be the author, the social environment in which
the author is located, including cultural elements.”36
According to Creswell in
his book: “Qualitative research is a means for exploring and understanding the
meaning individuals or groups ascribe to a social or human problem. The process
of research involves emerging questions and procedures. Data typically collected
in partcipant’s setting. Data analysis inductively building from particulars to
general themes, and the researcher making interpretations of the meaning of the
data. The final written report has flexible structure. Those who engage in this form
of inquiry support a way meaning, and the importance of rendering the complexity
of a situation’.37
35
John W. Creswell, Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design, (United States of America:
California 1997), p. 15. 36
Nyoman Kutha Ratna, Teori, Metode dan Teknik Penelitian Sastra. Cet. Ke-III edisi
revisi, (Yogyakarta: Pustaka Pelajar, 2011), p. 47. 37
John. W. Creswell, Research Design Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Ways
Approaches, (United States of America: SAGE Publications, 2009), p. 4
Based on the quotation above, the qualitative research used in this
research due to the qualitative method did not only involve the intrinsic aspect
in literary work. But, it related with the extrinsic aspect in the literary itself. So,
that is why, the qualitative method also said as multi method. Because, the
relating of the intrinsic aspect and extrinsic aspect in the literary itself. In this
theory, qualitative research in research procedures which produce descriptive
data as spoken words of the person or behaviour be research. It easier for
researcher to get the right data. It means that qualitative method analyzed about
descriptive data that were used documentation in this research, by using this
qualitative method, the researcher felt easy to analyze the film.
Based on those statements, it concluded that qualitative research
analyzed about descriptive data that collected in the form of the situation of the
natural object. Where descriptive data such as writer or spoken, by using
qualitative research the researcher had a nice answer about the questions in
analyzing the problem in Home Alone 1 film.
B. Sources of Data
The data for this thesis was taken from Home Alone 1 film. The
researcher used the script, dialogues, and picture on screen. Thus, The data of
the research was some dialogues among main character and another characters
which is contain politeness strategies. The researcher download the film from
http://d21.asia/home-alone-1990/ and the researcher download the script from
https://subscene.icu/subtitles/english-text/.
C. Technique of Data Collection
In an effort to get the data and fact, in this Thesis, the researcher used
qualitative research. The researcher used documentation, documentation was
the provision of footnotes, appendices, or addenda referring to or containing
documentary evidence. Scott regards the movie script was the document that
needed as the material of qualitative research38
. A document was an artefact
which has as its central feature an inscribed text. Miles and Huberman
38
Scott, J. (1990). A matter of record, documentary sources in social research.
Cambridge: Polity Press
explained that documents could be public records, textbook, letters, films, tapes,
diaries, themes, reports and so on.39
The researcher had some steps to collect the
data for this thesis :
1. Watching the film repeatedly, after getting all important sources, the
researcher watched it to make sure that the data was correlated to the
research.
2. Collecting the data and all information, then making a note od data.
After watched the sources carefully, the researcher marked any kinds
of politeness strategies to help the researcher in analyzing process.
3. Identifying and classifying the data, after finding all the data
completely, the researcher made a good arrangement for the thesis
proposal as the last step in finalizing research.
D. Technique of Data Analysis
After collecting the data, the researcher analyzed the data. In qualitative
research, technique analysis data uses to answer the formulation of the problem
in analysis data; the researcher uses a technique of data analysis. The researcher
have several techniques from the data analysis, in order to make this research
more specific. According to Susan Stainback, “Data analysis is critical to the
qualitative research process. It is to recognition, study, and understanding of
interrelationship and concept in your data that hypotheses and assertions can be
developed and evaluated”.40
Nyoman Kutha Ratna stated: “Sesuai dengan
namanya analisis isi terutama berhubungan dengan isi komunikasi baik secara
verbal maupun nonverbal.41
In line with this statement, the researcher uses the
descriptive. In this thesis, there were some activities that the researcher have to do
to be able to analyze the data correctly :
1. Identifying
The researcher identified the data and made assumptions or finds the politness
strategy that appeared from Kevin’s utterances and the other characters.
39
Miles, M. B., & Huberman, A.M. (1994). Qualitative data analysis: An expanded
sourcebook (2nd
ed.). Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications. 40
Sugiyono, Metode Penelitian Kuantitatif Kualitatif dan R & D, p. 244. 41
Nyoman Kutha Ratna, Teori, Metode dan Teknik Penelitian Sastra, p. 48.
2. Classifying the data
The researcher classified the data which has taken into several parts of
classification of data that will answer the formulaton of the problem.
3. Analyzing, describing, explaining
The researcher analyzed, described and explained the data about politeness
strategy in Home Alone 1 film.
4. Making the conclusion
After all the data have been analyzed, described and explained in this research,
the researcher made the conclusion of the research.
33
CHAPTER IV
FINDING AND ANALYSIS
A. Finding
In this chapter, the results of the research presented in detail on the
findings and discussion section. The results answer the objectives the research to
identify and to describe the kinds of politeness strategies by Brown and Levinson
theory, and how politeness strategies used by the main character by using
Kierkegaard theory in the Home Alone 1 film. In the finding, the frequencies of
the types politeness strategies, and how politeness strategies used by the main
character presented in the analysis section.
The findings of this research based on the first research question the
researcher found four kinds of politeness strategies experienced by Kevin, they
are bald on record, positive politeness, negative politeness, off record. As for the
aspect of linguistics that effected, there are two ways of using politeness
strategies, those are direct communcating and indirect communicating. The
researcher found three types of direct communicating and two of indirect
communicating.
B. Analysis
1. Kinds of Politeness Strategies Used by the Main Character
In this part, the researcher explained about types of politeness strategies
used by the main character, they are bald on record, positive politeness,
negative politeness, off record. It can be seen below:
a. Bald on Record Strategy
According to Brown and Levinson: “bald on record strategy is speaking
in direct, clear, unambiguous and concise way in circumstances where face
is not irrelevant or minimized”42
. This strategy was performed in the
most direct, clear, unambiguous and concise way as possible. Based on the
42
Brown and Levinson in Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic
Analysis of Impoliteness in Some of Harold Pinter's Plays”, p. 121.
data, the researcher found about bald on record, there were four data found.
It can be seen in the discoure below:
Datum 1
Context :
In the night of Christmas eve, Kevin went to church and sat on chair with
Marley, they both undeliberately met in there because they had bad feeling
about theirself, and they talked each other about their problems. Whereas
Kevin had problem about his family, and Marley had problem with his
son, then Kevin spoke direct and clear to Marley. It can be seen in the
dialogs below:
Marley : What's your point?
Kevin : My point is, you should call your son.
Marley : What if he won't talk to me?
Kevin : At least you'll know. Then you could stop worrying about it.
Then you won't have to be afraid anymore. I don't care how
mad I was, I'd talk to my dad ad. Especially around the
holidays.43
Analysis :
Based on the statement of Kevin in the dialogues, Kevin gave suggestion
to Marley, he tried to convey Marley that he should not be afraid to talk
again with his son, they met in the church at evening while they saw a
singging group sang Christmas song in front of them, on the other side,
the researcher identified that Kevin used bald on record strategy because
Kevin spoke to Marley directly, clear and unambiguous, “My point is, you
should call your son.” it mean that Kevin had fulfill the requirements from
the bald on record strategy.
43
Duration 01.11.37 -> 01.11.54
Datum 2
Context :
In the afternoon Kevin went to grocery to bought groceries, Kevin met
Kelly the grocery storekeeper, at the time he had to pay the stuff, Kelly
asked him about his mother. It can be seen in dialogs below:
Kelly : Where's your mom?
Kevin : My mom's in the car44
Analysis :
Based on dialogs above, Kevin went to groceries at afternoon, Kelly
asked to Kevin, it was very rare the child went to the store without his
mother or his father, so Kelly wondered why Kevin went to grocery
store alone, so she asked him about where his mother was. From the
quotations above the researcher identified that Kevin used bald on
record strategy because Kevin spoke directly to Kelly, “My mom's in
the car.” from the conversation was expressed by Kevin to Kelly, it mean
that Kevin had used the bald on record strategy because Kevin made it
clear.
Datum 3
Context :
In the night of Christmas eve, Jeff ordered Pizza, but Buzz ate all the
pizza and Kevin did not eat the pizza, he disappointed to Buzz and
attacked Buzz, but Kevin’s mother got angry because Kevin acted
excessive. Then Kevin got punishment from his mother, he got pissed up
and he said terrible words to his mother. It can be seen in dialogs below:
44
Duration 00.53.28 -> 00.53.30
Kevin : I don't want to see you again for the rest of my whole life.
And I don't want to see anybody else either.
Kate : I hope you don't mean that. You'd feel pretty sad if you woke up
tomorrow morning and you didn't have a family.45
Analysis :
Show on the dialogue above, Kevin argued his mother at night, they got
problem because of Kevin’s attitude then Kevin disappointed to his family
that treated him like a scum and then Kate punished Kevin to sleep in
rooftop. Based on the quotations above, the researcher identified that
Kevin used bald on record strategy because Kevin spoke directly to Kate
because he disappointed to his family, “I don't want to see you again for the
rest of my whole life. And I don't want to see anybody else either” seen
from the conversation, Kevin said with clear and unambiguous. It mean
that Kevin had fulfill the requirements of bald on record strategy.
Datum 4
Context :
At the evening of christmas day, everybody in Kevin’s house was busy,,
they pack up their own stuff while Kevin still did not know what should he
does. Linnie asked Kevin to sleep with Fuller but Kevin was disappointed. It
can be seen in dialog below :
Linnie: You have to sleep on the hide-a-bed with Fuller. If he has
something to drink, he's going to wet the bed.
Kevin: This house is so full of people. It makes me sick! When I grow
up and get married, I'm living alone! Did you hear me? I'm
living alone! I'm living alone!46
45
Duration 00.12.14 -> 00.12.25 46
Duration 00.04.38 –> 00.04.57
Analysis :
Show on dialogue above, Kevin mad with Linnie who made him
disappointed with his family and Kevin scream in his house, the researcher
identified that Kevin used bald on record strategy because Kevin spoke
directly to Linnie and everybody in his house, “This house is so full of
people. It makes me sick! When I grow up and get married, I'm living alone!
Did you hear me? I'm living alone! I'm living alone!” seen from the
conversation, Kevin said with clear and unambiguous. It mean that
Kevin had fulfill the requirements of bald on record strategy.
From the explanations above, there were four bald on record strategy
used by the main character, according to limited of research in this part the
researcher found only one suggestion that main character used, and Kevin said it
to Marley in the church at evening.
b. Positive Politeness Strategy
According to Brown and Levinson, positive politeness strategy is directed
to the addressee’s positive face. This strategy is used to promote high
involvement and solidarity. Considering the positive face of person by
indicating that in some respects and also positive politeness seeks to
establish a positive relationship between parties; respects a person's need
to be liked and understood.47
Based on the data that the researcher found,
in positive politenesss the researcher only found three of the data. It can
be seen in the discourse below:
Datum 1
Context :
In the Christmas eve, Kevin went to the store and he saw an Elf woman, he
gave compliment to her about her shoes and then asked whereabouts Santa,
because he needed to talk with Santa and made wish that he wanted his
family to come back. It can be seen in dialogs below :
47
Brown and Levinson in Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic
Analysis of Impoliteness in Some of Harold Pinter's Plays”, p. 121.
Kevin : Hey, nice shoes.
Elf : Oh, thanks.
Kevin : Is he still here? It's really important that I see him.
Elf : Well, he's getting in his car. If you hurry, you can catch him.48
Analysis :
Show on the dialogues above, the researcher identified that Elf used the
positive politeness strategy because Elf put a positive face to Kevin.
She appreciated that Kevin complimented her about her shoes. Elf
throwed a smile at Kevin, it mean that Elf used positive politeness
because in the theory it shows that the smile or positive face is a part of
the theory, and Elf used this theory to appreciate Kevin’s complimented.
Datum 2
Context :
After Kevin finished to talk to Elf, Kevin came over to meet Santa in his
car and told Santa about Kevin’s wish. It can be seen in dialogs below :
Kevin : Okay, this is extremely important. Would you please tell Him
that instead of presents this year, I just want my family back.
No toys. Nothing but Peter, Kate, Buzz, Megan, Linnie and
Jeff. And my aunt and my cousins. And if he has time, my
Uncle Frank. Okay?
Santa : Okay. I'll see what I can do.49
Analysis :
Based on the dialogues above, Kevin requested to Santa to made his wish
came true, the researcher identified that Santa used the positive politeness
strategy because he appreciated Kevin is wish, he just wanted his family
48
Duration 01.03.46 -> 01.03.58 49
Duration 01.04.38 -> 01.04.59
back because he missed them so much. Even Kevin disappointed to his
family but deep inside his heart he missed them so much, Santa used the
positive politeness, because in this strategy explained that smile or positive
face is a condition of the theory. Santa had fulfill these requirements.
Datum 3
Context :
In the night of Christmas day, Kevin went to the church to pray to God,
then he met Marley at Church, then Marley advised Kevin to go home
because it was already late night and Kevin agreed with Marley. It can be
seen in dialogs below :
Marley : You better run along home where you belong. Think about
what I said. All right?
Kevin : Okay.
Marley : It's nice talking to you.
Kevin : Nice talking to you.50
Analysis :
Based on the dialogue above, Kevin and Marley respected each other, they
involuntary met in the church at night, because they got problem in their
life and they gave advice to each other, the researcher identified that Kevin
and Marley used the positive politeness strategy because they said the
same sentenses at the end of dialog. Kevin and Marley used the positive
politeness, because in this strategy explains that smile or positive face is a
condition of the theory. They both had fulfill these requirements.
From the explanations above, there were three positive politeness
strategy used by the main character and also based on the limited of research, in
this part the researcher only found one of requested that the main character used in
dialog, it can be seen in second example that Kevin made his wish to Santa.
50
Duration 01.12.28 -> 01.12.38
c. Negative Politeness Strategy
According to Brown and Levinson, negative politeness strategy is
satisfying person is negative face by recognizing and respecting the
addressee is negative face wants and negative politeness also making a
request less infringing.51
According to the data, the researcher found five of
data that included into negative politeness. It can be seen in the discourse
below:
Datum 1
Context :
When Kevin asked Jeff about what should he packs up his stuff, but he
did not know what he should does, because the child like Kevin still
younger, as we knew the child should not pack up his own stuff by
himself. It can be seen in dialog below:
Kevin : Do you know what I should pack?
Jeff : Buzz told you, cheek-face. Toilet paper and water.52
Analysis :
Show on the dialogue above, Kevin asked Jeff at night when they were
busy at their own stuff, the researcher identified that Kevin used the
negative politeness strategy because Kevin put a negative face on Jeff,
Kevin used that strategy because he did not know what should he does, on
the other hand, because he was still a kid, and he did not know how to
pack up his stuff.
51
Brown and Levinson in Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic
Analysis of Impoliteness in Some of Harold Pinter's Plays”, p. 121 52
Duration 00.04.17 -> 00.04.20
Datum 2
Context :
Kevin went to store at afternoon to bought toothbrush, Kevin asked the
cashier about the toothbrush licence, because he needed to know the
toothbrush approved or not. It can be seen in this dialogs below :
Cashier : How may I help you?
Kevin : Is this toothbrush approved by the American Dental
Association?
Cashier : Well, I don't know. It doesn't say, hon.53
Analysis :
Show on the dialogues above, the researcher identified that Cashier used
the negative politeness strategy because Cashier put a negative face on
Kevin, Cashier used that strategy because she did not about Kevin and she
treated Kevin like other costumers of her store.
Datum 3
Context :
At the same time, Kevin asked again the cashier about the toothbrush
licence, he wanted to find out about that toothbrush. It can be seen in this
dialogs below :
Kevin : Can you please find out?
Cashier : Herb.
Herb : Yeah?
Cashier : I've got a question here about a toothbrush. Do you know,
is this brush approved by the American Dental
Association?
Herb : I don't know.54
53
Duration 00.38.50 -> 00.39.00 54
Duration 00.39.01 -> 00.39.22
Analysis :
Show on the dialogues above, Kevin requested the Cashier to find out
about the toothbrush, the researcher identified that Kevin also used the
negative politeness strategy because Kevin needed to find out about the
toothbrush approved or not approved by the American Dental
Association, the Cashier called her husband and asked about the
toothbrush, but her husband also did not know the answer.
Datum 4
Context :
Kevin entered Buzz’s room, after he scream out that he wanted to living
alone when he grew up, Kevin asked buzz can he sleep with Buzz in his
room, because Kevin did not want to sleep with Fuller. It can be seen in
dialog below :
Kevin : Can I sleep in your room? I don't want to sleep in the hide-a-
bed with Fuller. If he has something to drink, he'll wet the bed.
Buzz : I wouldn't let you sleep in my room if you were growing on my
ass. 55
Analysis :
Show on the dialogues above, Kevin asked Buzz that he wanted to sleep
with him, Kevin did not want to sleep with Fuller becuase he will wet the
bed, the researcher identified that Kevin also used the negative politeness
strategy because in this situation Kevin using “can” it mean that Kevin
asking his older brother for help, but Buzz did not want to help him.
Datum 5
Context :
In the night of christmas day, Buzz ordered pizza for dinner the the pizza
boy came over, everybody went to kitchen for eat their pizza, but Kevin
55
Duration 00.05.29 –> 00.05.40
was late comers so he asked his family about his pizza. It can be seen in
dialog below :
Kevin : Did anyone order me a plain cheese?
Buzz : Oh, yeah, we did. But if you want any, somebody's gonna
have to barf it up, because it's gone.56
Analysis :
Show on dialogues above, Kevin asked his family about his pizza, but the
pizza has been gone because he was late comers to kitchen where
everybody was eaten the pizza, researcher identified that Kevin also used
the negative politeness strategy because in this situation Kevin using
“did” it mean that Kevin tried to be polite because in kitchen there was
adults eat the pizza too.
From the explanations above, there were five negatve politeness strategy
used by the main character and also based on limited of research, the researcher
found two of request statement that the main character used, and Kevin used it
to the Cashier as we saw in third example and Kevin used it to Buzz as we saw
in fourth example.
d. Off Record Strategy
According to Brown and Levinson, off record strategy is delivering the
intention indirectly; it means that the off-record strategy is used by the
speaker to achieve a communicative intention indirectly.57
Based on the
data, only three of data that the researcher found in this part. It can be
seen in the discourse below :
56
Duration 00.09.19 –> 00.09.27 57
Brown and Levinson in Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic
Analysis of Impoliteness in Some of Harold Pinter's Plays”, p. 121
Datum 1
Context :
At the night when Kevin at home and thieves came to get him, Kevin
told Marv about where he was and asked Marv to get him before Kevin
called the police department. It can be seen in dialogs below:
Kevin : Down here, you big horse's ass! Come and get me before I
call the police.
Marv : Let's get him!58
Analysis :
Show on the dialogs above, Kevin commanded to Marv to get him before
he called police department, the researcher identified that Kevin used the
Off-Record Strategy because Kevin spoke indirectly to Marv seen from
the first sentence “Down here, you big horse's ass! Come and get me before
I call the police” it mean that Kevin actually wanted to say Harv was
criminal, but he used indirectly so that Kevin tried to make Harv angry and
asked Harv to chase him before he called the police. By talked like that,
Kevin hoped that Harv would understand his wishes, it mean that Kevin
used Off Record strategy.
Datum 2
Context :
At night of christmas, after Kevin finished to talk to Jeff, Kevin went to
Buzz’s without knock on the door before and then he called him. It can be
seen in this dialogs below :
Kevin : Buzz?
Buzz : Don't you know how to knock, phlegm-wad?59
58
Duration 00.27.23 -> 01.27.27 59
Duration 00.05.24 -> 00.05.28
Analysis :
Show on the dialogs above, the researcher identified that Buzz used the
Off-Record Strategy because Buzz spoke indirectly to Kevin seen from
the second conversations Buzz said “you know how to knock, phlegm-
wad?” it mean that Buzz actually wanted to say to Kevin that he was
helpless, but Buzz used indirectly to Kevin. By talked like that, Buzz
hoped that Kevin understand his wish, it mean that Buzz used Off Records
because in the theory explains that off record is talking indirectly and
Buzz spoke indirectly to Kevin.
Datum 3
Context :
Thus, at night of christmas where everybody was busy at their own
business to pack up their own stuff, Kevin spoke to Jeff and Megan, Kevin
disappointed about Megan’s statement and Jeff agreed with Megan, Kevin
replied the statement to Jeff. It can be seen in dialogs below:
Kevin : I'm not an idiot!
Megan : Oh, really? You're completely helpless! Everyone has to
do everything for you.
Jeff : She's right, Kev.
Kevin : Excuse me, puke-breath. I'm a lot smaller than you. I
don't know how to pack a suitcase.60
Analysis :
Show on the dialogs above, the researcher identified that Kevin used the
Off-Record Strategy because Kevin spoke indirectly to Jeff, seen from the
fourth conversations Kevin said “Excuse me, puke-breath. I'm a lot smaller
than you. I don't know how to pack a suitcase.” It mean that Kevin wanted
to say to Jeff that he was suck but Kevin used indirectly to Jeff. By talked
60
Duration 00.04.02 -> 00.04.12
like that, Kevin hope that Jeff understand his wish, it mean that Kevin
used Off Record because in the theory explains that off record is talking
indirectly and Kevin spoke indirectly to Jeff. According to limited of
research, the researcher found requested statement that the main character
used in this part, as we saw in the first example.
Based on Brown and Levinson theory, from the explanations above it
can be concluded there were four kinds of politeness strategies are used by the
main character in Home Alone 1, they are bald on record, positive politeness,
negative politeness, off record strategy. Referring to the question number one
about types of politeness strategies, it was found that there are four types about
politeness strategis used by the main character, they are bald on record, positive
politeness, negative politeness, off record, this finding was similiar with Resi
Novira. The researcher found negative politeness was mostly dominant in this
film, while Resi Novira thesis found the same, that mostly dominant about
negative politeness.
2. The Ways of Using Politeness Strategies
In this part, the researcher explained about how the main character’s ways
of using politeness strategies, there are two ways of it, direct communicating
and indirect communicating. It can be seen below:
a. Direct Communicating
According to Kierkegaard, direct communication happens when a speaker’s
true intentions are communicated in his/her verbal message. It
expresses the speaker’s/sender’s needs and desires explicitly.61
According
to the data that the researcher found, only four of the dta but the reseaarher
only put two example of direct comunicating. It can be seen in the
quotation below :
61 George Pattison. “The Theory and Practice of Language and Communication in
Kierkegaard’s Upbuilding Discourses” p. 85-87.
Datum 1
Context :
In the night of Christmas eve, Kevin went to church and sat on chair with
Marley, they both involuntary met in there because they had bad feeling
about their self, and they talked each other about their problems. Whereas
Kevinn had problem about his family, and Marley had problem with his
son, then Kevin spoke direct and clear to Marley. It can be seen in the
dialogs below:
Marley : What's your point?
Kevin : My point is, you should call your son.
Marley : What if he won't talk to me?
Kevin : At least you'll know. Then you could stop worrying about it.
Then you won't have to be afraid anymore. I don't care how
mad I was, I'd talk to my dad ad. Especially around the
holidays.62
Analysis :
According to statement of Kevin in the dialogues, the researcher
identified that Kevin used direct comunicating strategy because Kevin
spoke to Marley directly, clear and unambiguous, “My point is, you
should call your son.” it mean that Kevin had fulfill the requirements from
the directly comunicating strategy.
Datum 2
Context :
Kate gave Kevin punishment because Kevin’s attitude at the night, Kate
asked Kevin to sleep in rooftop all along, and Kevin disappointed because
his family treated him like a scum. It can be seen in dialogs below:
62
Duration 01.11.37 -> 01.11.54
Kevin : I don't want to see you again for the rest of my whole life.
And I don't want to see anybody else either.
Kate : I hope you don't mean that. You'd feel pretty sad if you woke up
tomorrow morning and you didn't have a family.63
Analysis :
Based on the dialogues above, when Kevin disappointed that how his
family treat him like a scum and then Kate punished Kevin to sleep at
night in rooftop. Show on the dialogues, it can be known that Kevin in the
Home Alone film, the first conversation when Kevin talked to Marley, then
Kevin Gave him an advised to call his son, then the second conversations
when Kevin talked with Kate that Kevin disappointed to his family and he
did not want to see them anymore, in this situation Kevin spoke directly
and clear to Marley and Kate. Based on the quotation above the researcher
identified that Kevin used the direct communicating to speak to Marley and
Kate about his wishes.
Datum 3
Context :
At the evening of christmas day, everybody in Kevin’s house was busy,,
they pack up their own stuff while Kevin still did not know what should he
does. Linnie asked Kevin to sleep with Fuller but Kevin was disappointed. It
can be seen in dialog below :
Linnie: You have to sleep on the hide-a-bed with Fuller. If he has
something to drink, he's going to wet the bed.
Kevin: This house is so full of people. It makes me sick! When I grow
up and get married, I'm living alone! Did you hear me? I'm
living alone! I'm living alone!64
63
Duration 00.12.14 -> 00.12.25 64
Duration -> 04.38 – 04.57
Analysis :
Show on dialogue above, Kevin mad with Linnie who made him
disappointed with his family and Kevin scream in his house, the researcher
identified that Kevin used direct communicating because Kevin spoke
directly to Linnie and everybody in his house, “This house is so full of
people. It makes me sick! When I grow up and get married, I'm living alone!
Did you hear me? I'm living alone! I'm living alone!” seen from the
conversation, Kevin said with clear and unambiguous. It mean that
Kevin had fulfill the requirements of indirect communicating. From the
explanations above, there are three direct communicating used by the
main character.
b. Indirect Communicating
According to Kierkegaard, indirect communication happens when a
speaker’s true intentions are hidden. Indirect speakers will not make a
direct statement or directly answer a question that might cause tension or
result in an uncomfortable situation.65
According to the data that the
researcher found, only three of the data in this part but the researcher only
put two example of indirect comunicating in here. It can be seen in the
quotation below:
Datum 1
Context :
In the night of christmas eve, Kevin was Home Alone and the thieves
came to his house and Kevin told Marv about where he was and asked
Marv to get him before Kevin called the police department. It can be
seen in dialogs below:
65
George Pattison. “The Theory and Practice of Language and Communication in
Kierkegaard’s Upbuilding Discourses” p. 85-87.
Kevin : Down here, you big horse's ass! Come and get me before I
call the police.
Marv : Let's get him!66
Analysis :
Show on the dialogs above, the researcher identified that Kevin used the
indirect comunicating Strategy because Kevin spoke indirectly to Marv
seen from the first sentence “Down here, you big horse's ass! Come and get
me before I call the police” it mean that Kevin wanted to say criminal to
Harv but he used indirectly so that Kevin tried to make Harv mad and
asked Harv to chase him before he called the police. By talked like that,
Kevin hope that Harv understand his wish, it mean that Kevin used
indirect communicating.
Datum 2
Context :
Thus, at night of christmas where everybody was busy at their own
business to pack up their own stuff, Kevin spoke to Jeff and Megan, Kevin
disappointed about Megan’s statement and Jeff agreed with Megan, Kevin
replied the statement to Jeff. It can be seen in dialogs below:
Megan : You're completely helpless! Everyone has to
do everything for you.
Jeff : She's right, Kev.
Kevin : Excuse me, puke-breath. I'm a lot smaller than you.67
Analysis :
Show on the dialogs above, the researcher identified that Kevin used the
indirect comunicating Strategy because Kevin spoke indirectly to Jeff,
seen from the fourth conversations Kevin said “Excuse me, puke-breath.
66
Duration 00.27.23 -> 01.27.27 67
Duration 00.04.02 -> 00.04.12
I'm a lot smaller than you. I don't know how to pack a suitcase.” It means
that Kevin actually wanted to say to Jeff that he was helpless but Kevin
used indirectly to Jeff. By talked like that, Kevin hoped that Jeff
understand his wish, it mean that Kevin used indirect communicating.
Based on the quotation above the researcher identified that Kevin used
the indirect communicating, first conversation when he talked with Harv
and, the second conversations when he talked with Jeff. There are two
indirect communicating of the ways to being politeness strategies by the
main character.
From the explanations above it can be concluded there were two the
Main Character’s Ways of Using Politeness Strategies in Home Alone film. First,
Direct Communicating: where Kevin spoke directly to Marley and Kate.
Second, indirect Communicating: where Kevin spoke indirectly to Marv and
Jeff. This finding matched with theory by Kiekegaard, saying that two ways of
how using politeness strategy, but the differences from other research findings,
the researcher focussed on Kevin’s utterances and the other characters are being
involved while they were in conversation while Mifta Hasmi from Arts
Yogyakarta State University only discussed about types and realized in the
utterances employed. The researcher found Direct Communicating mostly
dominant in this film.
52
CHAPTER V
CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION
This chapter consists of conclusion and suggestion. The researcher
concluded base on the finding and discussion, also gave some suggestion to the
reader. There are two parts of conclusion, which is summary and concluding
remark.
A. Conclusion
1. There four types of politeness strategies in Home Alone 1 film consist of : Bald
on record, Positive politeness, Negative politeness, and last Off record. The
types of politeness strategies found Bald on Record as four data, Positive
Politeness three data, Negative Politeness five data, and Off Record three data.
In Bald on Record, the researcher found suggestion statement that the main
character used in the conversation, in Positive Politeness and Negative
Politeness, the researcher found request statement that the main character used
in conversation, thus, in Off Record, the researcher found command statement
that the main character used in the conversation. In conclusion, Negative
Politeness mostly dominant used in this movie, because it more polite and in
this film the main character often talked to stranger.
2. The Main Character’s Ways of Using Politeness Strategies in Home Alone 1 ,
they are direct communicating, the researcher found three data and indirect
communicating the researcher found two data. In conclusion, direct
communicating mostly dominant used in this film, because the main character
often talked direct, clear, and unambiguous.
In conclusion, the findings in this research showed that the main
character’s used Negative Politeness mostly dominant in this movie, because it
more polite and in this film the main character often talked to strangers. This
research also showed that the main character used direct communicating more
than he used indirect communicating. This research was important because
politeness was part of human life.
B. Suggestion
The researcher states several point that could be used as suggestion and
recommendation for the readers who interested in studying the politeness strategy
because there are a lot of things that can be discussed about linguistic especially
about politeness strategy in the different discussion and point of view.
Meanwhile, for the student who are learning the politeness strategy, this
research can be alternative reference, because this research present the politeness
strategy in Home Alone film that involving the study of context, speech act,
speech event, and so on.
In addition, it also recommended for the next researchers who are
interested in doing further research in the same area to use these findings as a
starting point in conducting the research. Moreover, by using the theory Brown
and Levinson, it is suggested to use other sources of data such as from the book or
journal, advertisement or even in spoken language like speech and so on. Overall,
this research hopes to be useful for all the readers, especially who are interested in
the same field because politeness is interesting topic to discuss.
REFERENCES
Afnani, Ahlam Veryya. (2013). “Politeness in Love Expression Used in the
Last Promise Novel,” Muhammadiyah University of Surakarta. School of
Teacher Training and Education.
Arthur, Martine. (2013). Martine Hand’s Book Ettiquete and Guide To True
Politeness. London: Forgotten Books.
Bloch, Bernard; & Trager, George L. (1942). Outline of linguistic analysis.
Special publications of the Linguistic Society of America. Baltimore:
Linguistic Society of America.
Brown and Levinson in Pater Longscope. (1978). “The Universalit of Face in
Brown and Levinson Politeness Theory: A Japanese Perspective,” Journal
University of Pennsylvania graduate school of education.
Brown and Levinson in Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid, “A Pragmatic
Analysis of Impoliteness in Some of Harold Pinter's Plays”.
Brown, P., & Levinson, S. C. (1987). Politeness: Some universals in language
usage. (2nd
ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Chaer, Abdul. (1994). Linguistik umum, Jakarta: Rineka Cipta.
Eva Alcon Soler and Aricia Martinez Flor. (2008). Investigating Pragmatics in
Foreign Language Learning, Teaching and Testing. New York: Cromwell
Press.
George Pattison. “The Theory and Practice of Language and Communication
in Kierkegaard is Upbuilding Discourses”.
George Yule. (1988). The Study of Language. New York: Cambridge University
Press.
Grice, H.P. (1975). "Logic and Conversation," Syntax and Semantics, vol.3
edited by P. Cole and J. Morgan, Academic Press.
Hall, Edward T. 1992. Beyond Culture. New York : Doubleday.
Hasmi, Mifta. (2013). “A Pragmatic Analysis Of Politeness Strategies Reflected
In Nanny Mcphee Movie,” Arts Yogyakarta State University English
Language And Literature Study Program English Education Department
Faculty of Languagesm.
Holmes, J. (1992). An Introduction to Sociolinguistic. London and New York:
Longman.
Holmes, J. (1996). Women, men, and politeness. London: Longman.
Indriani, Eva. (2014). “Positive Politeness Strategies Used By Grace And
Meg In Monte Carlo Movie,” Faculty of Humanities Dian Nuswantoro
University.
Istvan Kecskes and Laurance. (2007). Exploration In Pragmatics Linguistics,
Cognitive and Intercultural Aspects. Germany.
John, W. Creswell (1997). Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design. United
States of America: California.
John. W. Creswell, (2009) Research Design Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed
Ways Approaches, (United States of America: SAGE Publications, 2009)
Leech, Geoffrey. (1983). The Principle of Pragmatics. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Levinson, Stephen C. (1983). Pragmatics. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press,.
Lyons, John. (1981). Language and Linguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Michael, L. Scott. (2006). Programing Language Pragmatics. United States of
America, Denise Penrose Press.
Miflin, Houghton, http://www.thefreedictionary.com/politeness, (accessed
November 26, 2014, at 08.12 pm)
Miles, M. B., & Huberman, A.M. (1994). Qualitative data analysis: An expanded
sourcebook (2nd
ed.). Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
Novira, Resi. (2010). Negative Politeness Strategies as Found in Rachel Ray
Show. Padang: Universitas Andalas)
Polite Fiction, retrivied from http://www.culture-at-work.com/politefiction.html.
Accessed 15 April 2021
Prameswari, Yuliana. (2012) Negative Politeness Strategy in Diplomacy
Meeting at UN Security Council Summit on Nuclear Non Proliferation
Disarmament. Jakarta: UIN Syarif Hidayatullah
Ratna, Nyoman Kutha. (2011). Teori, Metode dan Teknik Penelitian Sastra,
Yogyakarta: Pustaka Pelajar.
Saussure, Ferdinand de. (1966) Course in General Linguistics. Edited by
Charles Bally and Albert Sechehave, in collaboration with Albert Riedliner.
Translate by Wade Baskin. New York : McGraw-Hill Book Company.
Scott, J. (1990). A matter of record, documentary sources in social research.
Cambridge: Polity Press
Sugiyono. (2009). Metode Penelitian Kuantitatif Kualitatif dan R & D. (Bandung): Alfabeta.
Thomas in Liisa Vilkki. (2011). “Politeness, Face and Facework: Current
Issues,” Journal Festschrift in Honour of Fred Karlsson.
Vilarejo, Amy. (2006). Film Studies the Basic. New York : Library of Congress,
Third Edition.
Zeydan K. Omar and Sura Abdul Wahid. (2010). “A Pragmatic Analysis of
Impoliteness in Some of Harold Pinter's Plays,” Journal College of
Education for Humanities Anbar University, Number 8 -Year 3.
1990. Home Alone Film. Retrivied from Http://d21.asia/home-alone-1990/,
(accessed Januari 3, 2021, at 05.32 pm)
1990. Home Alone Script. Retrivied from https://subscene.icu/subtitles/english-
text/-IcumAqtrD43-pMcBba5yEFBaR_xAUPTU5qeF-
0emfKwPSVpPxGGaarox2g35q2sMEvTeVmNy1AMsxK96pfDfRfKqEcrC4Iav
_vJ04D4e7Sfq0uKj1xTKiTAGAgFsOt30
1990. Home Alone Synopsis. Retrivied from
https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0099785/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_0#review-teaser
APPENDIX I
A. Kinds of Politeness Strategies Used by the Main Character.
1. Bald on Record Strategy
No Dialogue/Pictures Description Duration
1
2
Marley : What's your point?
Kevin : My point is, you
should call your son.
Marley : What if he won't
talk to me?
Kevin : At least you'll
know. Then you could stop
worrying about it. Then you
won't have to be afraid
anymore. I don't care how
mad I was, I'd talk to my dad.
Especially around the
holidays.
Kelly : Where's your mom?
Kevin : My mom's in the
car.
Kevin spoke
directly, clear,
and unambiguous
to Marley, that he
should not be
afraid to talk
again with his
son.
Kevin spoke
directly, clear,
and unambiguous
to Kelly, because
Kelly wondered
where Kevin’s
mother was.
01.11.37 -> 01.11.54
00.53.28 -> 00.53.30
3
4.
Kevin : I don't want to see
you again for the rest of my
whole life. And I don't want
to see anybody else either.
Kate : I hope you don't
mean that. You'd feel pretty
sad if you woke up tomorrow
morning and you didn't have
a family.
Linnie: You have to sleep on
the hide-a-bed with Fuller. If
he has something to drink, he's
going to wet the bed.
Kevin: This house is so full of
people. It makes me sick!
When I grow up and get
married, I'm living alone!
Did you hear me? I'm living
alone! I'm living alone!
Kevin spoke
direcly, clear, and
unambigous to
his mother, that
he disappointed
with his family.
Kevin spoke
directly, clear to
Linnie that he
wanted to live
alone when he
grew up
00.12.14 -> 00.12.25
00.04.38 – 00.04.57
There were four Bald on Record strategies used by the main character.
2. Positive Politeness Strategy
No Dialogue/Pictures Description Duration
1
2
Kevin : Hey, nice shoes.
Elf : Oh, thanks.
Kevin : Is he still here? It's
really important that I see him.
Elf : Well, he's getting in his
car. If you hurry, you can
catch him.
Kevin : Okay, this is
extremely important. Would
you please tell Him that
instead of presents this year, I
just want my family back. No
toys. Nothing but Peter, Kate,
Buzz, Megan, Linnie and Jeff.
And my aunt and my cousins.
And if he has time, my Uncle
Frank. Okay?
Santa : Okay. I'll see what
I can do
Elf put positive
face to Kevin
because she
appreciated Kevin
complimented.
Santa put positive
face to Kevin,
because he
appreciated
Kevin’s wish to
have his family
back.
01.03.46 -> 01.03.58
01.04.38 -> 01.04.59
3
Marley : You better run along
home where you belong.
Think about what I said. All
right?
Kevin : Okay.
Marley : It's nice talking to
you.
Kevin : Nice talking to you.
Kevin and
Marley, they
discussed their
problem together
in the church and
in the end of
conversation they
put positive face
together.
01.12.28 -> 01.12.38
There were three Positive Strategies used by the main character.
3. Negative Politeness Starategy
No Dialogue Description Duration
1
Kevin : Do you know what I
should pack?
Jeff : Buzz told you, cheek-
face. Toilet paper and water.
At the night of
christmas,
everybody was
busy with their
own stuff, while
kevin did not
know what
should he does.
So Kevin asked
Jeff, and Kevin
put negative face
to Jeff.
00.04.17 -> 00.04.20
2
3
Cashier : How may I help
you?
Kevin : Is this toothbrush
approved by the American
Dental Association?
Cashier : Well, I don't know. It
doesn't say, hon.
Kevin : Can you please find
out?
Cashier : Herb.
Herb : Yeah?
Cashier : I've got a question
here about a toothbrush. Do
you know, is this brush
approved by the American
At afternoon,
Kevin went to
grocery to buy
toothbrush, and
then he came to
the cashier and
the cashier asked
him. The cashier
put negative face
to Kevin because
she did not know
Kevin and treated
Kevin as other
customers.
At the same time,
Kevin asked the
cashier to find out
about that
toothbrush, so the
cashier called her
husband and
asked him, but
her husband did
not know about
that toothbrush
approved or not
by American
Dental
Association.
00.38.50 -> 00.39.00
00.39.01 -> 00.39.22
4.
5.
Dental Association?
Herb : I don't know.
Kevin : Can I sleep in your
room? I don't want to sleep in
the hide-a-bed with Fuller. If he
has something to drink, he'll wet
the bed.
Buzz : I wouldn't let you sleep in
my room if you were growing on
my ass.
Kevin : Did anyone order me a
plain cheese?
Buzz : Oh, yeah, we did. But if
you want any, somebody's gonna
have to barf it up, because it's
gone.
Kevin asked
Buzz that he
wanted to sleep
with him, but
Buzz rejected
Kevin’s wish.
Kevin asked his
family about his
pizza, but Buzz
ate kevin’s pizza,
then Kevin
fought with Buzz
until he got
punishment from
his mother
00.05.29 –> 00.05.40
00.09.19 –> 00.09.27
There were five Negative Politeness Strategies used by the main character.
4. Off Record
No Dialogue Description Duration
1
2
3
Kevin : Down here, you big
horse's ass! Come and get
me before I call the police.
Marv : Let's get him!
Kevin : Buzz?
Buzz : Don't you know how
to knock, phlegm-wad?
Kevin : I'm not an idiot!
Megan : Oh, really? You're
completely helpless!
Everyone has to do
everything for you.
At the night of
christmas, the
thieves came
over to Kevin’s
house, Kevin
spoke
Indirectly to
Marv, he tried to
provocateur
Marv to get him
before he called
the police.
At the night of
christmas, after
Kevin asked his
cousin in his
house, Kevin
went to Buzz’s
room, but when
he entered
Buzz’s room he
forgot to know
the door, so Buzz
asked him with
indirectly
statement.
At the night of
christmas, Kevid
talked with
Megan and Jeff,
whereas Kevin
used indirectly
statement to Jeff
that he did not
know what
should he packed
up.
01.27.23 -> 01.27.27
00.05.24 -> 00.05.28
00.04.02 -> 00.04.12
Jeff : She's right, Kev.
Kevin : Excuse me, puke-
breath. I'm a lot smaller than
you. I don't know how to
pack a suitcase.
There were three Off Record Strategies used by the main character.
B. The Main Character’s Ways of Using Politeness Strategies
1. Direct Communicating
No Dialogue Description Duration
1
Marley : What's your point?
Kevin : My point is, you
should call your son.
Marley : What if he won't talk
to me?
Kevin : At least you'll know.
Then you could stop worrying
about it. Then you won't have
to be afraid anymore. I don't
care how mad I was, I'd talk
to my dad. Especially around
the holidays.
Kevin used direct
communicating to
Marley, that he
should not be
afraid to talk
again with his
son.
01.11.37 -> 01.11.54
2
3.
Kevin : I don't want to see
you again for the rest of my
whole life. And I don't want
to see anybody else either.
Kate : I hope you don't mean
that. You'd feel pretty sad if
you woke up tomorrow
morning and you didn't have a
family.
Linnie: You have to sleep on
the hide-a-bed with Fuller. If he
has something to drink, he's
going to wet the bed.
Kevin: This house is so full of
people. It makes me sick! When I
grow up and get married, I'm
living alone! Did you hear me?
I'm living alone! I'm living alone!
Kevin used direct
communicating to
his mother, that
he disappointed
with his family.
Kevin spoke
directly, clear to
Linnie that he
wanted to live
alone when he
grew up
00.12.14 -> 00.12.25
00.04.38 – 00.04.57
There were three Direct Communicating used by the main character.
2. Indirect Communicating
No Dialogue Description Duration
1
2
Kevin : Down here, you big
horse's ass! Come and get
me before I call the police.
Marv : Let's get him!
Kevin : I'm not an idiot!
Megan : Oh, really? You're
completely helpless!
Everyone has to do
everything for you.
Jeff : She's right, Kev.
Kevin : Excuse me, puke-
breath. I'm a lot smaller than
you. I don't know how to
pack a suitcase.
Kevin used
indirect
communicating to
provocateur Marv
Kevin used
indirect
communicating to
Jeff, because he
tried to defence
his respect
00.27.23 -> 01.27.27
00.04.02 -> 00.04.12
There were two Indirect Communicating used by the main character.
APPENDIX 2
The McCallister family is preparing to spend Christmas in Paris, gathering
at Peter and Kate's home in a Chicago suburb on the night before their departure.
Peter and Kate's youngest son, Kevin, is the subject of ridicule by his older
siblings. Later, Kevin accidentally ruins the family dinner and their flight tickets
to Paris after a scuffle with his older brother Buzz, resulting in him getting sent to
the attic of the house as a punishment, where he berates Kate and wishes that his
family would disappear. During the night, heavy winds damage the power lines,
which causes a power outage and resets the alarm clocks, causing the family to
oversleep. In the confusion and rush to get to the airport, Kevin is accidentally left
behind.
Kevin wakes to find the house empty and, thinking that his wish has come
true, is overjoyed with his newfound freedom. However, he soon becomes
frightened by his next door neighbor, Old Man Marley, who is rumored to be
a serial killer who murdered his own family, as well as the "Wet Bandits", Harry
and Marv, a pair of burglars who have been breaking into other vacant houses in
the neighborhood and have targeted the McCallisters' house. Kevin tricks them
into thinking that his family is still home, forcing them to put their plans on hold.
Kate realizes mid-flight that Kevin was left behind, and upon arrival in
Paris, the family discovers that all flights for the next two days are booked. Peter
and the rest of the family stay in his brother's apartment in Paris, while Kate
manages to get a flight back to the United States, but only gets as far as Scranton,
Pennsylvania. She attempts to book a flight to Chicago, but again, everything is
booked. Unable to accept this, Kate is overheard by Gus Polinski, the lead
member of a traveling polka band, who offers to let her travel with them
to Chicago on their way to Milwaukee in a moving van, which she gratefully
accepts.
Meanwhile, Harry and Marv finally realize that Kevin is home alone, and
on Christmas Eve, Kevin overhears them discussing plans to break into his house
that night. Kevin starts to miss his family and asks the local Santa
Claus impersonator if he could bring his family back for Christmas. He goes to
church and watches a choir perform, then meets Old Man Marley, who dispels the
rumors about him. He points out his granddaughter in the choir, whom he never
gets to meet, as he and his son are estranged; Kevin suggests that he should
reconcile with his son.
Kevin returns home and rigs the house with booby traps to take on the
burglars. Harry and Marv break in, spring the traps, and suffer various injuries.
While the duo pursues Kevin around the house, he calls the police and flees, then
lures Harry and Marv into a neighboring home which they previously broke into.
They ambush him and prepare to get their revenge, but Marley intervenes and
knocks them unconscious with his snow shovel. The police arrive and arrest Harry
and Marv, having identified all the houses that they broke into due to Marv's
destructive characteristic of flooding them.
On Christmas Day, Kevin is disappointed to find that his family is still
gone. He then hears Kate enter the house and call for him; they reconcile and are
soon joined by Peter, Buzz, Jeff, Megan, and Linnie, who waited in Paris until
they could obtain a direct flight to Chicago. Kevin keeps silent about his
encounter with Harry and Marv, although Peter finds Harry's knocked-out gold
tooth. Kevin then observes Marley reuniting with his son, daughter-in-law, and
granddaughter. Marley notices Kevin, and the pair wave to each other.