employees provident fund organisation · pdf fileno. epf/mp/ind/lc/t-1/panel advocate/ date:...

12
- mm mcl5R" cf>l~fct~, iJ{£?.BJ~~T mr~ 3-Jqc;f 1, ~l-1Qill1 m, - 452003, Employees Provident Fund Organisation Mi nistry of Lab our, Govt.of Ind ia Regional Office - Madhya Pra des h Pr adhikaran Bh awan, 7, Race Cou rse Road Indore - 4520 03 ~N>cfR of. Phone/Fax No- 0731- 2531923, 2537100, 2543768 No. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELME NT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO), on behalf of the Central Boa rd, Employees' Provident Funds, a statutory body of the Ministry of Labour & Employment, Government of India, proposes to engage Panel Counsel(s) to res present the Central Board, EPF before High Court of Madhya Pradesh Bench at Indore and Central Govern ment Industrial Tribunal, Jabalpur. The practicing advocates who are registered with Bar Cou ncil of I ndia/ State Bar Council are eligible for empanelment. The qualification, experience, schedule of fees, other terms and conditions and the application format in which the application has to be made, have been prescribed. Th e Advocates who are on the existing panel of EPFO shall cea se to be on the pan el of EPFO after new panel is finalized against this notice. Th erefor e, they may also apply afresh in response to this notice. Eligible practicing advocate must submit application in the format prescribed in Annexure "A" and Annexure "B" enclosed herewith, along with all supporting document s in a sealed en velope to :- (Asper list enclosed) The envelope should be superscribed as following :- "Application for Empanelment of Advocate for High Court of M.P. Bench at Indor e/ Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Jabalpur" The last date of receiving Applications in the prescribed format alongwith supporting documents is 10th Feb., 2018 till 16.00 hours. Application for empanelment at EPFO does not confer any right/ assurance whatsoever, to an applicant that he/ she wi ll be empanelled on the pan el of EPFO. Letters to advocates confirming their empanelment will be issued by EPFO separately. Letto.:r

Upload: ngotuyen

Post on 11-Feb-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

~ ~ - mm mcl5R"

~ cf>l~fct~, iJ{£?.BJ~~T

mr~ 3-Jqc;f 1 , ~l-1Qill1 m, ~ - 452003,

Employees Provident Fund Organisation

Ministry of Labour, Govt.of India

Regional Office - Madhya Pradesh

Pradhikaran Bhawan, 7, Race Cou rse Road

Indore - 452003

~N>cfR of. Phone/Fax No- 0731- 2531923, 2537100, 2543768

No. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/ 0 1/2018

NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES

Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO), on behalf of the Centra l Board, Employees' Provident Funds, a statutory body of the Ministry of Labour & Employment, Government of India, proposes to engage Panel Counsel(s) to respresent the Central Board, EPF before High Court of Madhya Pradesh Bench at Indore and Central Government I ndustrial Tribunal, Jabalpur.

The practicing advocates who are registered with Bar Council of I ndia/State Bar Council are eligible for empanelment. The qualification, experience, schedule of fees, other terms and conditions and the application format in which the application has to be made, have been prescribed.

The Advocates who are on the existing panel of EPFO shall cease to be on the panel of EPFO after new panel is finalized against this notice. Therefore, they may also apply afresh in response to this notice.

Eligible practicing advocate must submit application in the format prescribed in Annexure "A" and Annexure "B" enclosed herewith, along with all supporting documents in a sealed envelope to :-

(Asper list enclosed)

The envelope should be superscribed as following :-

"Application for Empanelment of Advocate for High Court of M.P. Bench at Indore/ Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Jabalpur"

The last date of receiving Applications in the prescribed format alongwith supporting documents is 10th Feb., 2018 till 16.00 hours.

Application for empanelment at EPFO does not confer any right/assurance whatsoever, to an applicant that he/she will be empanelled on the panel of EPFO. Letters to advocates confirming their empanelment will be issued by EPFO separately.

Letto.:r

Page 2: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

1. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner - I Regional Office Employees' Provident Fund Organisation LO.A. Building 7, Race Course Road, Indore 452003 Telephone 0731 2541603

2. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner - II Regional Office 7, Bharatpuri Administrative Area Dewas Road, Ujjc:1in, M.P. Telephone 0731 2517730

3. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner - I Regional Office Bhavishya Nidhi Bhawan 59 Arera Hills Bhopal, M.P. 462011

4. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner - I Regional Office Scheme No. 5, Krishi Upaj Mandi Area Vijaynagar, Jabalpur, M.P. 482002 Telephone 0731 2640601

5. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner - II Regional Office Second Floor, Sanjay Complex, Jayendraganj Lashkar, Gwalior, fv".P. 474009 Telephone 0731 2638700

6. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner - II Regional Office 10, Civil Line Sagar, M.P. 470001 Telephone 07582 226738

Lener

Page 3: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

Jr •• ,, ... ,i . . ~ - ~-

... ~ " f

• I

I

-.,.. .... ... .,,.

- - ---- - ----

Application for empanelment at EPFO does not confer any ,vtrt/assurance whatsoever, to an applicant that he/she will be empanelled on the panel of EPfO. Letters to advocates confirming their empanetment will be issued by EPFO sepamely.

GUIDELINES FOR EMPANELMENT OF AQVOCATES

Following guidelines are designed to provide and regulate the manner· and procedure fOf empanelling the advocates to represent end assist EPFO -before var.ious courts and for regulating the referrals of the cases and payment o,f ·fee'remuneration. These guidelines shall supersede all existing instructions In this regard. if any, and is suqect to change wtthout aaalgnlng any reason. ·

1. Eltalbllltv of Empanelment

Before filling the application form, the candidates are advised to carefully read and follow the

eligibility criteria, instructions and terms & conditions for ernpanelment of Advocates In EPFO mentioned herein below :-

For designation of an advocate to handle the cases before the Hon'ble Court:-

1} Be enrolled/ registered as an advocate wtth 1he Bar Cou."ldl d ffidia / tt,e State 8ar Councii

ii) Be enrolled / registered and currently practising .as an Advocate-on Record,

iii) Have a minimum, relevant experience of Ttn years of h~ Civil, Criminal, Service,

Labour matters, Arbitration matters and other cases before Hott"ble Court of India with a fair knowledge of labour laws with spec_iaj reference to ~es· Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (E.P.F. and M.P. Act. 1952).

2. Tenure or Empaoelment

The iriifial empanelment will be for the period of two year, Le. for the period 01 .04.2017 to 31.03.2019, Performance of empanelled advocates shall be re'fiewed at regular interval for continuance in the panel of Advocate. i..

3. Payment of Fee and Other Conditions

(1) T_he fee payable to the Advocates shall be governed by the guideines Issued from the Head

Office, New Delhi and as amer,ded from time to time. However. at present there is no seperate fee defined for the panel advocate of EPFO, Who are designated as Senior Advocate by the Hon'ble Court.

2) The Competent Authority shall have the right in exceptional cases to approve the payment of a higher fee than the fee mantioned in the annexed shcedule keeping i!'I view the importance of the matter and the efforts put in by the advocate in a particular case.

3) No retainer fee shall be paid to any panel Advocate merely because such advocate has been empanelled.

4. Procedure for Empanelment

Page 4: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

·,•

• ... . .. ...... .. , ·:,·· ~ ·· ·

..

-- ---- .... ----~ .. --... -·- .. -

a. Th• appl!Gant advocate must apply on the format preacrtbed by the EPFO OAly. No other forJT1at WIii be entertained.

b. An applicant advocate wlllti,g to be emperieli.d for mor. than one forum (I.e. High Court. CAT. SCORF. OCDRF, .Lo\Ner Court as well ae dlffel'9nt Judicial fora) may apply separately tor each forum In Hparate envelope superscrt>ed aa mentioned ear11er.

c. Any •pplicatio!" rec:alved after the last date preac::rlt;,ed In the advertlsemerit shall not be

entertained.

d. No applicant advocate shall be called for intervi4,w/lnteractJon unless he/she H tisfies the eliglbiflfy condltlont and .. ahortltated for the ume.

9. Depending upon the requirement and !'!Umber of application, .recei ... ed, EPFO re1ervea the right to shortllat the candidates to be called for Interview/interaction and to be empanelled

f. Merely fulfllHng the eligibility criteria will not confer any right on an appllicant advocate to be called for Interview/interaction and to be selected. .

g.The decision of the competent authority regarding short listing and selection of !he candidates shall be final. ·

h. Canvassing in any form thall ~ treated as a diequallflcatlon. The candidature of such applicants shall be forthwith.

L Shortlisted applicant advocates with the date, time aiid venue of Interview will be informed indivlduallv.

J. The applllcant advocate shall bring original document, at the time of Interview.

k.Letter to applicant advoetes confirming their empanelment will be issued by EPFO separately.

!5. Dutt,. of tb• Empanelled Advocate• :

a. The Advocate 1h11l not advise any p•rty or- accept any case against the EPFO in which he/she has appeared or Is likely to be called upon to appear for or advise. which Is likely to afftict or lead to litigation agai1nt the EPFO .

b. Timely appearance of the Counsel to contest the eases for EPFO in the Court is a must. His/her absence in the Court. wit~ut any reasonalble ground and notice In advance, will not be accepted.

c. EPFO ahall only engage empanelled Senior Advocate In a case (as and when required) by providing him an advocate for assistance from the approved penel.

c. EPFO aend1 the Information to the panel advocatu through email regarding entrustment of a case and after receiving the e-mail, it is duty of the panel Advocate,, to collect the brief/copy of petition along with assignment letter from the concerned office of EPFO at the ear11est

Pace 3 of 11

Page 5: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

: . . ,---, -· ,

· ' Q - ~ ~ - •

--- --- -·- __ ,, ______________________ ..,,_

d. EPffO 1, free to enga~ any adwooate or 1t1 own oholoe •n<I an •mpaneflad AdvQOllte •hall make no clalm that he/1he ah:,ne ahould be entrusted wllh EPFo·s legal m•twr(1).

e. RefUeal by any advocate to accept any worx without :any ,,aeonab'le cause (e.g. on grounds of conflict· of lntel'J'tl) may ent,ajl removal of eucb advocata from the 'panel. fot11'1wtth without waiting for the empanelment period to expire.

f. The advocate,. a.hall accept Ule terms and oonditions -of the empanelment as determined by the EPFO from time to time.

g. In order to ensure that there la effective check on t'he cases being conducted, the Advocates on the panel must report the status of-the cases after eaGh date of hearing. Failure to submit status report wlll be a ground for remova1 ot the ,,--ame·of 1tMt lawyer ooncemed from the

panel.

h. In cases where on th.e request of the Union of India, Ministry of Labour & Employment have also to be represented, no extra fee shall be pajd to the tdvocate to wa1oh and safeguard the interests of Union of India, Ministry of Labour & Employment.

I. If required, render all assi&tfflce to Special or SenlQr CooJ1Jfl engaged -in a pearticular caaas before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. H\gh Court sod other judicial bodies.

J. Keep EPFO Informed and updated on all-importa'tlt ,developments in the designated cases. dates of hearing, order of the court on the date of lts pronouncement, supplying copy of

orders/judgment etc.

k. Furnish monthly statement about the cases_rep,-ented by himfher before the High Court,

CAT, SCDRF, DCDRF, Lower Court or any other authority and their outcomes.

I. When any case attended by him/her is decided against the Organisation, th.e Advocate concerned must give considered opnlon :-egarding the r.ea&ons for such adverse order and thtnKMsability of filing an appeal from s·uch a decision nQt taler than 5 working daye of the

order (kuc~ha copy). However. reason 'for suctefl may .also be forwarded along with final order. ...

m. 30% of the feea payable to the counsel shall be de.duded, if ·the, certified copy of the judgment 11 not handed over to the LegaJ cen of EPfO·wtthfn three days (excluding the time

taken by the- Court In preparation of the cop~) from the date of judgement. . ·

s. Remoyal from Panel

· EPFO reserves the right to terminate the empanelment of a Coun&el with one month's notice in

writing without aaalgning any reason. The counsel may also resign from the Organi&atlon by serving one month's notice.

Empanelrnent shall be liable to be cancelled due to occurring of any of ,the following disablements on the part of the Advocate.

a. Giving false Information ln the application for empanelment.

Page 6: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

I '

:·~ · . ..;.· .. · .. '

b.

c: .

d.

••

f.

g.

h.

Falling to ,ttend the hearing of the case without 1ny &uffldent reaaon ancs / or prior Information.

Not 11Ctln9 u per EPFO'e lnltructlona or going agalfl&t 1pedflc ln1tructlons;

Thf9atenlng, Intimidating or abusing any of the EPFO's employeea, office~ . or ntpnasentattvN :

Pualng on lnformaUon relating to EPFO's cue on to the oppgelte partleti or their advQc;•ta• or 1r,y tHlrd p•rty whlcf\ la llltely to cauee any dam"• to the &PFO'a lnternt9 ;

OMng fll .. or mlt1eaC0r,0 lnfarmat!on to the EPFQ ,..attno to. !he prooMdlnge of the c:aea ; and

Seaklng frequent adjoumments or not objecting the adjoulnment moved by other pany wtthout·sufflclent reason. :

Frequent abaence from the court proceedings even if 'pan over' or 'proxy' ia obtained by an advocate.

.. ...

- -- ·-- ----Regional P.F. Commissioner

EPFO, Regional Office, Muzaffarpur Sihar

Pa•t S of 11 ·

Page 7: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

r-·--

,; :

. APPLICATION NO. ----(To be fllled by EPFO)

APPUCATIQN PQRM FOR CMPANCLNC::NI IN EPfo

(TO BE FILLED IN BY ALL APPLICANT ADVOCATES)

--·- ····---· - - - - -- ----To,

Regional Provident Fund Commissioner Employees' Provident Fund OrganleatJon, (Mlnlatry of Labour & Employment, Govt. Of India) Regional Office, Muzaffarpur 1 .. floor, Surya Complex, 8rahmpu11.PO- MIT Dlat- Muzaff arpur- 842003(B1har) Telephone:- 0621-2263965

Name ( in Block letter) Father'• name Court for which

. BDDlied

List of documents attached (please ..J )

- ·

CHECKUST

Copy of all Certificates & mark - sheets (X th onwards) Experience Certlflcat.e Duly flied Annexure- A&B Othe~ (Please specify) : 1.

. 2 .

-

... ...

.

--

~FULL

PERSONAL DETAILS (IN Block letters)

2. Father's/ Husband's Name

3. Date of Birth . .

4. Age on ( last Date of receipt of application)

5. Nationality

Is. I Marital Statua I

'

ANNEXURE A

I

I I

~

Page 8: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

_;

j

' J ' i

.J ,.f - ,;.

'!,

., .. . . ~ 'f//: I

' .

.

7. ~reae for corre1pao.ndance with PIN and phone

'8. Permanent Addrne with PIN and Phone

9. Addre88 of offlce/ci,ambe.r, tr any, with P~~ -and Phone

10 .. MQblle Number(s) I

11. EmalllO: t

.

12 . Are you related to any EPFO employees ? If so, .J»ea5e ghle detail& (viz. Nam~. Designation, place of wciik & relationship with the applicant :

1:2. Details of Educational qualiflcatlon (C-ommencing with the Matriculation or equivalent examination)

E>camtnatlona Name of the Class Of % of Marks Suijact1 Year of Paned Boara/U nlver1lty division I Pasting 1otnl

I

MatFtculation --_,

12th/ - .. ln~m,~c,<tiate '

Graqvc1tion LLS/law GradUJte o.gree . Pott Grflld1,1atlon Other Professional Quallficatione ,,

1

I I .

·-

:

Page 7 of 11

Page 9: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

---·- -- - ---·--·' --- - - ·-· ... .. - . - ___ .. .

'f i l t

:J. .:t . t 1

l t . ~ . .. .

: ... .:·, 1t' ' ·.• ;. -~·· ~ ·· · ' { ·."'

.

f ;

. •. ~

13. Whether the applicant 11 cum,ntty on . the Panel of .any other a ·overnment Oe~t/PSU/Statutory Bt,Qy/Autonomoua BCJd¥'&; Ind if yes. the d.i&il, baJow (Self . - --CQpy of the Office. Orct.rlletJ• d •~may be-attached) ;-

N..-Qftha Fr-om To O.,:artnwfttf P8U/8 . ._t\ltory . Body/AutGnaT\OU&'·Body .

..

1.

2. .

14. ~r-\he·ei>.Pllcan~ hf!' w.orud _as L~I R•e~ {LR) attached to any Court/Judge ? If v.-, ti\& ,detallf. and the supportfng documanta :-

N•rn•of'Qourtl.Judge Period of Res~ I Suppdrur:,g ~oouments

1.

2.

15. lf-one:or .more advocates are asaociated as junlora of the applicant. their details be provided

below: ....

SI.No. Name of th• adv'ocate Enrolment no. with date

- -... .. ..

i 18, lnfrutn.tctur•I faolllflee·avallabJa with the :appJIJoant (Pl8aM tick If ·ava/labte) be provided

below :

I ._S_I._N_o_.~~~ ..... I-Offi~·ce~•p_ace ___ ~__._]O~ffi-ce_c_l8"1<~~--"l~Sten9hyp_j_st-~~I-Su-pport~ -- •ta_ff _ ___,

17. No. of Cun relating to·EPF and MP Ad 1952, lfhatldfedie,rlier :-

1 SI. No. : I Tltlo of cue(Oocumontary proofrmwtbultaohed)

Page 10: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

?

18. Whotner the applicant ha been engaged (through Vwlatname} as counNl in any landmartt or mottler c..ae ? If ye1, th• partlcularw Qf the cue with copy or the judgment

. wherein hie/her name 18 recorded aa advocate for-0ne of the partJes (Copy of order/Judgement be attached as proof) ;-

Name "1h• Court Caae title Nature of Judgment

19. Whether Income Tax return Is being ffled for last ffve yeaR:? Yes/No (If yes, please attach copies or ITRs.)

-

20. Details or Bank Aceount/Aadhar Number be provided below :-

Bank Account Oetalla (Bank, PAN number Aadhar Number Account Number, Ad.drea of . the branch and If SC code)

. . - .

21. Whether any proceeding has ever been commenced or is continuing before the Dtaciplinary Committee of the Bar Council for alleged professional misconduct :-

SI. No. Details of allegations and proceedings Finding made by"the Disciplinary Committee.

·------~-

I . .. . ...

22. Whether any criminal complail'tt has ev.r been filed or FIR regislPred or any criminal proceltdlng ha.1 ever commenced against the applicant advocate :-

SL No. Detalls of alieg111tlons and proceedjngs Finding·mad• by the Court .

. -

Page 11: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

• . >~ ~ ~ .,.,:·~., .. ·· ·

.·~ / .

. J' ------------------------------- - - - --~m

• .. .. · ·~~ ..t I

23. Any addltk>nal prof8"40nal qualification (S), which wJU further the candlature, Including . membership Qf profeaek>nal eoclata. awardl. and honours etc. may be llated In tt,e box below, {Documentary proofa may be attacllad) :

UNDERTAKING

1) I herebyco.nflrm and declare that the informatiQn fumiehed in the applicaUon and.in the attached,Certift~te te truelco,-,..ct and complete. to the belt of my knowledge and belief. I have not concealed any relevant lnfonmtion. I am Mty .aware·that If any of the lnfonnatlon furniehed by me la found to be falaelincorract. my candid,atuie f.or the emp1nefment will be treated as cancelled and matter wm be refer~ to the appl'09'fate authority.

2) I ateo uodeftake to maintain abaolute aecrecy about the cases of the EPFO aa required under the Act. Rutes an<f Regulations therevnder.

3) I also undertake to return all case nles and records to the EPFO as and when required by EPFO,

4) I ag,_ wtlh the fee Schedule notifted by EPFO.

' .

Signature of Advocate Enrolment Number

Moblle Number :,·. ~ ·.--·

I

.. Place and Date :• ..

! \ I j , .,

Page 12: Employees Provident Fund Organisation · PDF fileNo. EPF/MP/IND/LC/T-1/Panel Advocate/ Date: ?-?/01/2018 NOTICE INVITING APPLICATIONS FOR EMPANELMENT OF ADVOCATES Employees' Provident

. ... ' .. , . •. • c '

,,_

ANNEXURE-,8 APPLICATION NO. -----(To be filled by EPFO)

ADDITIONAL INFORMATiON S.HEET (To be filled In by exlatlng Panel advocatn, •pplylng fo·r fresh empanelment)

1. Name of the Panel Advocate ;

2. Empanelled for Supreme Court/High Court/ EPf AT NtM Delhi ................. .

3. Duration In the Panel : .. . ... ... ... ..... . .... ................. ......... : .. .. . .. ... ....... . ,. .•.

"· Total No. of cases allotted : ..

5. No. of caee1 Decided :-

In favour cue title f

2.

Against Remanded back

5. No. of caaes pending ~- ........ .. ....... .. .. .... ~ .. ...................... .... " ...... ... . ""' ........ ..

7. Det,111 of oldest pending with the advocate ... .... .. ............ . .. ............ . .. . ..

8, Special ldlJe:vementa. If any:• ............. , ..... . ~ ................................... · .... .. . ,

9. Remartts of appllcant advocate, If any

-

I ~ • • ' ••

·~~ ' ~· ' ..

. • ..... (Signature and name of th• appllcant) Place:-Date :-

Pa1e 11 of 11