EmDe

merginemand

ng Mard Resp

A

rkets &onse (

nnual

& Tech(DR) P

Repor

nologyrojects

rt: 2011

y s

1

3

EDATII

3/30/2012

Emerging MDemand ResAnnual RepoTable of ConI.  SummaII.  Projects

A.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  R4.  N

B.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  R4.  N

C.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  S4.  N

D.  DRon CEC w

1.  O2.  C3.  S4.  N

E.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  S4.  N

F.  DR10DR10SCE

1.  O2.  C3.  R4.  N

G.  DRDR10SCE

1.  O2.  C

Markets & Tesponse (DR) ort: 2011 .....ntents ..........ary ...............s Completed

R09.09 OfficeOverview ....CollaborationResults ........Next Steps ...R10.02 OfficeOverview ....CollaborationResults ........Next Steps ...R10.03 OpenAOverview ....CollaborationStatus ..........Next Steps ...R10.06 PCT Lwebsite) .......Overview ....CollaborationStatus ..........Next Steps ...R10.07 One-COverview ....CollaborationStatus ..........Next Steps ...0.09 DemandE1.09.03) ....Overview ....CollaborationResults ........Next Steps ...R10.11 DRRCE1.11.03) ....Overview ....Collaboration

chnology ...Projects .....

...................

...................

...................d in 2011 .....e of the Futu...................n .......................................................e of the Futu...................n .......................................................ADR Standa...................n .......................................................Language in......................................n .......................................................Cycle Contro...................n .......................................................d Response R......................................n .......................................................C - Mainstre......................................n .................

Table ........................................................................................................................

ure (OTF) – ................................................................................

ure – GO4 (P................................................................................ards Develop................................................................................

n Codes and ....................................................................................................ol M&V ......................................................................................Research Ce....................................................................................................

eaming Auto............................................................

EmergDeman

of Conte........................................................................................................................Federal Buil................................................................................Posted on ET................................................................................pment ..........................................................................................Standards (C........................................................................................................................................................................................................

enter (DRRC....................................................................................................

o-DR (Tasks ............................................................

ging Markend Respons

Annu

ents ........................................................................................................................lding (Poste................................................................................TCC as DR1....................................................................................................................................................................................CASE study ........................................................................................................................................................................................................

C) – DR Too....................................................................................................1 & 2) (Pos

....................

....................

....................

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................d on ETCC ................................................................................

10SCE1.02) .....................................................................................................................................................................................and 45-day

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................ls (Task 2) (....................................................................................................sted on ETCC............................................................

ology ojects 2011

1

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................as DR09SCE........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................language av

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................(Posted on E....................................................................................................C as ............................................................

............ 1 

............ 1 

............ 1 

............ 1 

............ 4 

............ 6 E1.09) 6 ............ 6 ............ 6 ............ 6 ............ 7 ............ 7 ............ 7 ............ 7 ............ 7 ............ 8 ............ 8 ............ 8 ............ 9 ............ 9 ............ 9 vailable ............ 9 ............ 9 .......... 10 .......... 10 .......... 10 .......... 10 .......... 10 .......... 11 .......... 11 .......... 11 

ETCC as .......... 11 .......... 11 .......... 12 .......... 12 .......... 12 

.......... 12 

.......... 12 

.......... 13 

3

II

3/30/2012

3.  R4.  N

H.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  R4.  N

I.  DR101.  O2.  C3.  R4.  N

J.  DR111.  O2.  R3.  N

K.  DRDR11SCE

1.  O2.  C3.  R4.  N

L.  DRET10SCE

1.  O2.  C3.  R4.  N

III.  ProjecIV.  Projec

A.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  S4.  N

B.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  S4.  N

C.  DR1.  O2.  S3.  N

Results ........Next Steps ...R10.12 DRRCOverview ....CollaborationResults ........Next Steps ...0.13 DRRC -Overview ....CollaborationResults ........Next Steps ...

.04 DR OppOverview ....Results ........Next Steps ...R11.05 DR OE1.05.02) ....Overview ....CollaborationResults ........Next Steps ...R11.11 Future

4.07.0) .......Overview ....CollaborationResults ........Next Steps ...cts initiated icts continued

R09.02 HomeOverview ....CollaborationStatus ..........Next Steps ...R09.08 ExpanOverview ....CollaborationStatus ..........Next Steps ...R10.05 Auto-Overview ....Status ..........Next Steps ...

...................

...................C – DR Cod...................n .......................................................- Industrial D...................n .......................................................

portunities in.........................................................

Opportunities......................................n .......................................................e Outlook fo......................................n .......................................................in 2011 ......d in 2011 ....e Battery Pil...................n .......................................................nding Reside...................n .......................................................-DR PCT .............................................................

....................

....................des and Stand................................................................................DR (Posted o................................................................................n Residential............................................................s in Corridor....................................................................................................or Residentia............................................................................................................................................ot (HBP) .....................................................................................ential DR in ................................................................................................................................................................

EmergDeman

....................

....................dards (Posted................................................................................on ETCC as ................................................................................l Lighting (P............................................................r Lighting (P....................................................................................................al Energy M................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................the Irvine S

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

ging Markend Respons

Annu

....................

....................d on ETCC ................................................................................DR10SCE1

....................

....................

....................

....................Posted on ET............................................................

Posted on ET....................................................................................................

Management (................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

Smart Grid D................................................................................................................................................................

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

....................

....................as DR10SCE................................................................................1.13) ............................................................................................TCC as DR1............................................................

TCC as DR1....................................................................................................(Posted on E................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

Demonstratio................................................................................................................................................................

ology ojects 2011

2

....................

....................E1.12) .............................................................................................................................................................................................11SCE1.04.0............................................................1SCE1.05.0....................................................................................................

ETCC as ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................on (ISGD) pr................................................................................................................................................................

.......... 13 

.......... 13 

.......... 13 

.......... 13 

.......... 14 

.......... 14 

.......... 14 

.......... 14 

.......... 14 

.......... 15 

.......... 15 

.......... 16 01) ..... 16 .......... 16 .......... 16 .......... 16 

01 and .......... 17 .......... 17 .......... 17 .......... 17 .......... 18 

.......... 18 

.......... 18 

.......... 19 

.......... 19 

.......... 19 

.......... 20 

.......... 21 

.......... 21 

.......... 21 

.......... 21 

.......... 21 

.......... 21 roject 22 .......... 22 .......... 22 .......... 22 .......... 22 .......... 23 .......... 23 .......... 23 .......... 23 

3

V

3/30/2012

D.  DR1.  O2.  S3.  N

E.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  S4.  N

F.  DR101.  O2.  C3.  S4.  N

G.  DR1.  O2.  C3.  S4.  N

H.  DR1.  O2.  S3.  N

V.  Budget

R10.08 DR PoOverview ....Status ..........Next Steps ...R10.09 DRRCOverview ....CollaborationStatus ..........Next Steps ...0.11 DRRC –Overview ....CollaborationStatus ..........Next Steps ...R10.16 SmartOverview ....CollaborationStatus ..........Next Steps ...R11.01 AncilOverview ....Status ..........Next Steps ......................

ool Pumps...........................................................C – DR Tool...................n .......................................................– Mainstream...................n .......................................................t Appliances...................n .......................................................lary Service............................................................................

....................

....................

....................

....................ls (Task 1) ..................................................................................ming Auto-D................................................................................s ...................................................................................................s Pumping E................................................................................

EmergDeman

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................DR (Task 3) .....................................................................................................................................................................................Equipment ...................................................................................

ging Markend Respons

Annu

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

ology ojects 2011

3

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

....................

.......... 23 

.......... 23 

.......... 24 

.......... 24 

.......... 24 

.......... 24 

.......... 24 

.......... 24 

.......... 25 

.......... 25 

.......... 25 

.......... 25 

.......... 25 

.......... 25 

.......... 25 

.......... 25 

.......... 26 

.......... 26 

.......... 26 

.......... 26 

.......... 26 

.......... 26 

.......... 26 

.......... 27 

3

IA(20Ttsdu Svitrw

1

fh12

h

3/30/2012

I. SummAs described(SCE) Amen2009-2011 (A0272 AdoptinTechnology technologiesstandards to directed in Oundertaken th

SCE is workvision for DRnteroperabil

to coordinateresearch effowith other st

Calif Dema Univ

SCE Emer Calif Organ Open Offic

EnergCompand S

Elect Open Cons U.S. North

Amended Tes

for Approval ofhttp://www3.sc11+DR+Amend Decision Ado

http://docs.cpuc

mary d in Section Vnded ApplicaA.08-06-001ng DR Activ(EM&T) pro, understandenable custo

Ordering Parahrough the E

king closely wR, identify telity of DR tee, collaborateorts to instituatewide agen

fornia Energyand Responsersity of Cais on the Te

rging Technofornia Lightinnization for

n Smart Gridce of the Futugy (DOE), Spany (PG&ESeattle City Ltric Power Rn Automatedumer ElectroGreen Buildh American

stimony in Supf Demand Respce.com/sscc/lawded+App_SCE

opting Demandc.ca.gov/word_

VIII of the Aation for App11) and authovities and Buogram execud customer pomer participagraph 14 ofEM&T progr

with industryechnologies echnologies. e and share r

utionalize anncies and othy Commissiose Research alifornia Berkchnical Advologies Coorng Technolothe Advance

d (OpenSG) aure (OTF) C

Sacramento ME), Sempra ULight

Research Instd Demand Reonics Assoc

ding CouncilEnergy Stan

pport of Southeponse Programw/dis/dbattach1E-01+Amendedd Response Act_pdf/FINAL_D

Amended Teproval of Deorized in Caludgets for 20utes projects references apation in SCf D. 09-08-0ram.

y groups, acthat can be lThe Californresults from

nd expand DRher parties inon (CEC) PuCenter (DRRkeley’s DR

visory Councrdinating Coogy Center (Cement of Strat UCA Inte

Consortium inMunicipal UUtilities, Nat

titute (EPRI)esponse (Opiation l (USGBC) ndards Board

ern California Ems, Goals, and B1e.nsf/0/F89EFd+Testimony+tivities and BudDECISION/106

EmergDeman

estimony in Semand Respolifornia Publ009 through

to explore iand market p

CE’s DR prog027 to provid

ademic instileveraged fonia Investor each IOUs p

R in Californnterested in ublic InteresRC) at LawrEnabling Te

cil ouncil (ETCCCLTC) ructured Infoernational Usncluding Ne

Utility Districtional Grid, B

) penADR) All

d (NAESB)

Edison CompanBudgets for 20F6F12FE7C562Vol.+I.pdf [as dgets for 2009 6008.pdf [as of

ging Markend Respons

Annu

Support of Sonse (DR) Plic Utilities C2011, SCE E

innovative anpotential andgrams. This de an annual

itutions, andor DR and esr Owned Utilportfolio of nia, SCE intDR, such as

st Energy Rerence Berkelechnology D

C)

ormation Stasers Group (ew Buildingsct (SMUD), BC Hydro, N

liance

ny’s Amended009-2011: 2882574C900of March 29, 2 through 2011:f March 29, 20

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

Southern CalPrograms, GoCommissionEmerging Mnd cost effec

d provide inpreport is bei report on th

d other utilitistablish standlities (IOUs)EM&T proj

tends to conts: esearch (PIERley National

Development

andards (OA(UCAIUG) s Institute (NPacific Gas NSTAR, Co

d Application

70BEA6/$FIL2012]. : 012].

ology ojects 2011

4

lifornia Edisoals, and Bun (CPUC) D

Markets & ctive DR put on DR coing submittehe projects

es to develodards for ) meet everyects. In the otinue collabo

R) programl Laboratoryt Project for

ASIS)

NBI), Departand Electricnsolidated E

LE/A.08-06-001

son’s udgets for . 09-08-

odes and ed as

p a

y month ongoing orations

which

tment of c Edison,

1+2009-

3

Tac(a

I

Ttw

3/30/2012

The positive and other stacommunicati(BCD) Accoadopt DR tec

Custoassoc

Integcollaborganexecu

Quartof EMAdvoIrwin

DR Fdistintopic

In adEM&ca.coCEC,emeroutlin

In 2011, SCE Estab Deve Resea Conti Enab

--

This report sto each projeweb site.

results fromakeholders. Aing DR adva

ount Managechnologies aomer Informciated with Dgrated Demanboration betwnization, as wute EM&T pterly Techno

M&T DR anocacy, and Cndale, CA. Forum to helnguished gros to stakehol

ddition to the&T projects aom). ETCC c, and the CPging technolned in the Ca

E chartered Eblishing DR elopment of Darch into theinuation of tling future I OTF proje Exploring

Smart Gri

ummarizes tect are listed

m EM&T advAs detailed inances across rs who can t

and strategiesmation SheetsDR technolognd Side Manween EM&Twell as partnprojects utilizology Briefind D&ES Em

Codes and Sta

p communicoup of industlders from a

e EM&T annare also avaicoordinates aUC to facilitlogies that walifornia Lon

EM&T projecapabilities DR standarde DR potentithe Home BaIDSM policyect collaborag Home Areaid Demonstr

the results anand these ca

vance DR onn following SCE to inte

then educates. Specific as to aid Accogies and stranagement (IDT and the Cunering with Bzing the engngs for BCD

merging Techandards prog

cate and cootry speakers cross the com

nual reports plable to the pamong its metate the asse

will benefit Cng Term Ene

ects in the foin standard c

ds for buildinial of consumattery Pilot (y objectives tation with Ca Network (Hration (ISGD

nd status foran be used to

EmergDeman

nly if those rbullets, SCE

ernal stakehoe and influenapproaches foount Manageategies develDSM) explorustomer EnerBCD’s Desigineering staf

D representathnologies, Hgram project

rdinate DR iwho have ompany. provided to tpublic throuembers inclu

essment of prCalifornia cuergy Efficien

ollowing areacommercial ngs, appliancmer applianc(HBP) projecthrough

CEES HAN) capab

D) project

r individual po locate spec

ging Markend Respons

Annu

results are coE has implemolders like thnce customerfor disseminaers in commloped by EMration througrgy Efficiengn & Engineff within D&tives by D&E

HVAC Technts at the Ene

information ffered varied

the CPUC, fugh the ETCCuding Califoromising En

ustomers andncy Strategic

as: product offe

ces and mesces and new ct

bilities for D

projects. Thecific project

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

ommunicatedmented severhe Business Crs to enroll inating inform

municating thM&T

gh coordinatncy & Solar (eering Servic&ES. ES to commnology and Sergy Educati

across SCE d perspectiv

full reports oC web site (hornia's IOUs,nergy Efficied respond to c Plan (LTE

ferings saging protoconstruction

DR by partici

e DR projectdocumentat

ology ojects 2011

5

d to our custral approachCustomer Dn DR progra

mation includhe opportunit

tion and (CEES) ces (D&ES)

municate the System Diagon Center (E

by hosting aes on DR-re

on the complhttp://www., the SMUD

ency (EE) anthe initiative

EESP).

ocols n building co

ipating in the

t numbers astion on the E

tomers hes for ivision’s ams and de: ties

to

results gnostics EEC) in

a elated

leted etcc-, the

nd DR es

odes

e Irvine

ssigned ETCC

3

I

3/30/2012

II. Projec

A. DETC

cts Com

DR09.09 CC as DR

1. Over

The purposolution (evaluateddevelopedLos Ange

Determfrom S

Quantand

Provid

2. CollaThis projespecificalprojects h

3. ResuThe new ldimming electrical baseline fhours oveto a 1-minthe lightincommissibaseline Dto demandfollowing

DR tebusinedemandesireactual

ThereALCS

mpleted i

Office of R09SCE1

rview

ose of this pr25% better t

d the DR capd by Encelliueles Federal B

mine whetheSCE, or busitify demand

de measured

aboration ect collaborally PG&E anhave been sh

ults lighting systballasts thatinput for ge

for DR testiner three separnute intervalng level to fioned level.

DR level. A d during the

g findings:

esting for theess managemnd reductioned reduction l DR reducti was a reduc

S and the new

in 2011

f the Futu.09)

roject was tothan 2008 Tiabilities of aum SystemsBuilding. Th

er the ALCSiness managreductions t

d and technic

ated with othnd San Diegohared during

tem includedt were commneral lightin

ng. DR testinrate days. Tol during the tive different Each settingnon-test daythree test da

e ALCS confment participn was not prois needed, thon rather thaction in overw lighting fi

EmergDeman

ure (OTF)

o evaluate anitle 24) for tyan Advanced. The systemhe primary g

S allows for rgement as pathat are achie

cal data in su

her memberso Gas & Elescheduled m

d LEDs for tmissioned at ang. This newng was succeo increase datest periods. settings: 10

g lasted for oy was also reays. The proj

firmed that lpating in a Doportionate the controls san relying onrhead lightinxtures. The

ging Markend Respons

Annu

– Federa

n in situ demypical large d Lighting Cm was installgoals of this

reliable contart of a DR Pevable with

upport of the

s of the OTFctric Compa

monthly conf

ask lighting a setting of 8

w commissionessfully condata accuracy The testing

0%, 15%, 20%one hour, aftecorded by thoject achieve

lighting loadDR Program.to the reductshould be tesn the system

ng load dema DR reductio

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

al Buildin

monstration ooffice space

Control Systeled on half oproject inclu

trol of facilitProgram, a well-desig

e OTF initiat

F consortiumany (SDG&Eference calls

and downlig80% of the lning level wducted on thy, recording gg procedure i%, 25%, andter which it rhe data logged the stated

ds may be rel With this tetion in all setsted and cali

m setting. and after theon for lightin

ology ojects 2011

6

ng (Poste

of the OTF 2es. This projem (ALCS) of the 12th flouded:

ty lighting lo

gned lighting

tive.

m identified eE). Results os.

ghts with flulighting’s rat

was designatehe same busingranularity wincluded chad 30% belowreturned to ters as a comobjectives w

liably managechnology, thtting levels. ibrated to de

installation ng was 0.58

d on

25% ect

oor of the

oads

g system,

earlier; of these

uorescent ted ed as the ness was set anging w the the

mparison with the

ged by he If a

etermine

of the kW, or

33/30/2012

B. DDR

0.073 approxachiev

4. NextAlthough pursue othprogram o

DR10.02 R10SCE1.

1. Over

The purposolution (consisted building oenabled Wfourth flo

Determa DR

Examsystem

Provid

2. CollaThis projespecificalscheduled

3. ResuThe new lfluorescendown by 2the preferoccupancyarrives at unoccupiethree sepaintervals. settings: 1lasted for

Watts per sqximately 17%ved from tun

t Steps this project

her advancedofferings.

Office of 02)

rview

ose of this pr25% better tof the Execu

occupied by Wiremold ALor of the GO

mine whetheProgram,

mine demand m, and de measured

aboration ect collaborally PG&E and monthly co

ults lighting systnt lights for 20% of its torences and ney sensor thatthe desk and

ed. DR testinarate days. D The testing

10%, 15%, 2one hour, af

quare foot (W% assuming

ning the syst

has been cod lighting an

f the Futu

roject was tothan 2008 Tiutive Suites SCE. As par

LCS were evO4 Building.

er the ALCS

reductions t

d and technic

ated with othnd SDG&E.onference ca

tem consistegeneral lightotal electricaeeds of the ot brings lighd reduces ligng was succe

During the teg procedure i20%, 25%, after which it

EmergDeman

W/sf) at the g a baseline oem to 80% o

ompleted, SCnd controls p

ure – GO4

o evaluate anitle 24) for tyon the fourtrt of this stuvaluated. Th The primar

S allows for r

that can be a

cal data in su

her membersResults of th

alls.

d of LEDs foting. The ne

al input. All occupant. Ehts to the occghting levelsessfully cond

est periods reincluded chaand 30% belot returned to

ging Markend Respons

Annu

30% DR levof 3.4 kW. Tof full capac

CE will contiprojects that

4 (Posted

n in situ demypical large th floor of thudy the DR chis ALCS wary goals of th

reliable cont

achieved with

upport of the

s of the OTFhese projects

for task lightew lighting sopen office ach worksta

cupant’s prefs to 15% powducted on thecording inteanging the ligow the commthe baseline

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

vel. The percThis is in addcity.

inue to monimay influen

d on ETCC

monstration ooffice space

he General Ocapabilities oas installed inhis project in

trol of facilit

h a well-des

e OTF initiat

F consortiums have been

ting and dowystem was uworkstation

ation was equferred light lwer when thehe same busiervals were rghting level missioned lee DR level o

ology ojects 2011

7

centage redudition to the

itor OTF effnce future DR

C as

of the OTF 2es. This proj

Office 4 (GOof the Convian the offices

ncluded:

ty lighting as

signed lightin

tive.

m identified eshared durin

wnlights withuniversally tuns were tuneduipped with level when se space is iness hours oreduced to 1to five diffevel. Each sef 0%. A non

uction is savings

forts and R

25% ect 4) a-s on the

s part of

ng

earlier; ng

h uned d to meet an omeone

over -minute

erent etting

n-test day

33/30/2012

C. D

was also rdays. The DR te

part ovariatsough

ThereALCS0.072

This pinitiat

4. NextAlthough pursue othprogram oproject in

DR10.03

1. Over

The EnergInstitute ocoordinatinformatiosystems…establisheachieve Sthrough PGrid InterOpenADRcommerciInternet. Ainfrastrucprocess ofexpand thproducts fthan propproducts bare based intuitive uinformatiosignals, an

recorded by e following oesting for thef a DR Progions brought

ht, or even th was a reduc

S and new ligW/sf at the

project provitive.

t Steps this project

her advancedofferings. Th general mov

OpenADR

rview

gy Independof Standards e developmeon managem

…" which resed Priority ASmart Grid InPAP 09. Oneroperability R, which defial/industrialAdopting anture (AMI), f developing

he marketplafor customerrietary or “Cbeing develoon developi

user interfacon about thend will also

the data logobjectives wee ALCS confgram. Howevt upon by oc

he pattern, wction in overghting fixtur30% DR lev

ides valuable

has been cod lighting anhe lessons leving forward

R Standa

dence and Seand Techno

ent of a framment to achiesulted in the

Action Plans nteroperabilie of the two NStandards Frfines messagl customers

n open standaand DR has

g, finalizing ace to includers enabled byCalifornia-onoped by consing productses. These pr

eir energy usempower th

EmergDeman

gers as a comere achievedfirmed that lver, due to iccupancy sch

were not realirhead lightinres. The DRvel. e data, and le

ompleted, SCnd controls pearned can bed.

ards Deve

ecurity Act (Eology (NIST)mework that ieve interoperSmart Grid (PAPs) to foity, includingNIST recognramework th

ges exchangefor price-resards approacs resulted in and adoptinge the domesty a variety only” solutionsumer electrs to engage croducts will bsage, helpinghe marketpla

ging Markend Respons

Annu

mparison to d as a result lighting loadssues in isolhedules, the ized. ng load demaR reduction f

essons learn

CE will contiprojects that e applied to

elopment

EISA) of 20) with the "pincludes prorability of smInteroperabi

ocus on a vag “Standard nized standarhat are directed between usponsive andch for Smart some delaysg standards. tic US mark

of interoperans for DR. Thronics manufcustomers wibe capable og customers race to innova

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

demand durof this proje

ds may be rellating lightinpercent pow

and after thefor lighting w

ned which ca

inue to monimay influenany OTF eff

t

007, appointeprimary respotocols and mmart grid devility Standar

ariety of the cDemand Re

ards for inclutly applicablutilities and d direct load Grid, advan

s in deploym However, th

ket and will oable commerhere are manfacturers whith meaningfof providing respond to p

ate and differ

ology ojects 2011

8

ring the threeect: liably managng loads and wer reduction

installation was 0.85 kW

an support th

itor OTF effnce future DRffort or lighti

ed the Nationponsibility tomodel standavices and rds Project. components esponse Signusion in the Sle for DR is

control overnced meter ment due to th

he end resuloffer a robusrcial devices ny commerc

hose businessful informaticustomers w

price or DR erentiate prod

e test

ged as

ns

of W, or

he OTF

forts and R ing

nal o ards for

NIST to

nals” Smart

r the

he slow t should

st set of rather

cial s models ion and

with event duct

33/30/2012

D. D45-

offerings project waby OASIS

2. CollaIn this proNAESB, and the O

3. Statu

Phase onerequiremeincorporaNovembeby reviewDR. In adof OASISWeb Servreviewed work wasscheduledwill be ba

4. Next

Although continue tcertificati

DR10.06 -day lang

1. Over

The purpopotential cCommuni(USTs) inthat requisignals ancustom se

while targetas to drive aS and incorp

aboration oject, SCE cSmart Grid I

OpenADR Al

us

e of this projents specificated into the er 2010. Phaswing securityddition to enhS to get threevices Calendby the SGIP

s completed wd to completeased on elem

t Steps

the OpenADto participateion process f

PCT Lanuage ava

rview

ose of this prcode languaicating Thern the study, tre a building

nd adjust theettings progr

ting a varietyan expedited poration as a

ollaborated wInteroperabilliance.

ject was comations and swork complse two of thi

y and adding hanced capae specificatiodar (WS-CaleP, and addedwith eMIX ae this proces

ments of these

DR standarde in the Opefor products

guage in ailable on

roject was toge for Califo

rmostats (PCto be installeg permit. Thrmostat temp

rammed by th

EmergDeman

y of customedevelopmenreleased Sm

with UCAIUility Panel (S

mpleted in 20ervice definileted by OASis project furspecificatio

abilities, Phaons: 1) Energendar), and 3

d to the Smarand WS-Calss in the firste three OAS

ds developmenADR Alliautilizing the

Codes an CEC we

o evaluate feornia Title 2

CTs), referreded in all newe PCTs wouperature set he customer

ging Markend Respons

Annu

er price poinnt of the Ope

mart Grid inte

UG’s OpenSSGIP), consu

010 with the itions. TheseSIS and relerther enhanc

ons for quickase 2 monitorgy Market In3) Energy InrtGrid Catalolendar addedt quarter of 2

SIS standards

ent work hasance to devele OpenADR

and Standebsite)

easibility of, 4 which woud to as Upgr

w constructiould be able to

points basedr.

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

nts. The primenADR staneroperability

SG OpenADRultants from

creation of e documents

eased for pubced the capabk response inred and enconformation Enteroperabiliog of Standa

d to the CoS 2012. The Os.

s been complop and enhastandard.

dards (CA

and if appliuld mandate

radeable Setbon and HVACo receive prid upon defau

ology ojects 2011

9

mary objectivndard for ratiy standard by

R task forceXtensible S

the system s were then blic commenbilities of Opnteractions oouraged the Exchange (ety (EI) finali

ards (CoS). Tin 2011 and

OpenADR 2.0

pleted, SCE wance a testin

ASE stud

cable, devele Programmaback ThermoC retrofit proice and DR eult factory se

ve of this ification y NIST.

, OASIS, olutions,

nt in penADR

or “fast” efforts MIX), 2) ized, This d EI 0 profile

will ng and

dy and

op able ostats ojects event ettings or

33/30/2012

E. D

2. CollaIn collaboproposed Several phagreemenSCE also possible precommen

3. Statu

Meetings IOU’s andreleased oQ2 of 201

4. NextThe CEC proposed with stake15-day lan

DR10.07

1. Over

The purpopeak load(OCC). Ofor this prSCE serviEvaluatioincluded:

En In Pr

sit As Ut

sto Va

aboration oration with that would ahone calls an

nt on the langhosted a me

provisions fondations to C

us

with CEC sd CEC agreeon February 12.

t Steps has releasedlanguage. D

eholders to rnguage and

One-Cyc

rview

ose of this prd reduction pOCC was awaroject and coice territory.n and Energ

nsure complinform vendorrovide OCC tes ssist in devetilize the Enorage alidate the re

the statewidalign with nand meetings guage regardeeting to engor PCTs withCEC.

taff and comed on the lan24, 2012, w

d the 45-dayDepending onresolve outstadopted cod

cle Contro

roject was toproject utiliziarded a PIERontacted SCE. This projec

gy Conversio

iance with Sr and customwith the for

eloping the mergy Conver

esults of the

EmergDeman

de IOU Codeational Smarwere also w

ding PCTs thgage supplierhin Title 24 w

mmissioners nguage to be

with 15-day la

y language ann the nature tanding issuede.

ol M&V

o provide Meing battery sR Emerging E for assistanct included cons & Storag

SCE Rules &mers of potenms necessar

measures to trsions & Sto

pilot sites

ging Markend Respons

Annu

es and Standrt Grid stand

with the CEChat should bers and industwhich furthe

continued d proposed. Tanguage and

nd is awaitinand volume es, and deve

easurement storage techn

Technologynce because

collaborationge groups. Th

& Tariffs ntial safety iry to request

track during orage group a

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

dards team codards currentC in an efforte included intry professioer informed

during 2011 aThe 45-day ld adoption ex

ng any comm of commenlop revised r

and Verificanology from y Demonstra the propose

n with SCE’she scope of

ssues or codinterval met

the pilots as technolog

ology ojects 2011

10

ode languagetly being devt to come to n the 2013 Tonals and to the IOUs

and eventuallanguage waxpected to o

ments on the nts, SCE willrequirement

ation (M&VOne-Cycle

ation Grant (ed pilot sites s Program work for thi

de violationster data for t

gy experts fo

e was veloped. an

Title 24. discuss

lly the as ccur in

l work s for the

) for a Control ETDG) are in

is project

the pilot

or battery

33/30/2012

F. D(Ta

2. CollaThis was played strproduct.

3. StatuSeveral mof their Peoffices wecompleted

4. Next

Although with OCC

DR10.09 ask 2) (Po

1. Over

The purpopotential idevelopindeliverablTask 1 is report:

a)A web-batheir respobuilding sfrom Auto Buildi

mass, Intern

schedu HVAC

the co Auto-

during

aboration a collaborati

rictly an adv

us meetings and eak Load Reere the pilot d and provid

t Steps

the M&V pC to perform

Demand osted on E

rview

ose of this prin commerci

ng a statewidles. Task 2 wongoing and

) Task 2 - Sased databaseonse to Opensize and systo-DR eventsing Informatbuilding siz

nal Informatiules of theseC System: syooling and heDR Field Teg the test or

ion project wisory role, p

demonstratieduction (PLsite for initi

ded a letter o

portion of them additional l

ResponsETCC as

roject was toial buildings

de DR databawas completed is included

Statewide e will be set nADR signatems informas. The informtion: addressze, etc. ion: number e internal loaystem type, oeating seasonest InformatiDR period.

EmergDeman

with OCC inproviding me

ions were heLR) battery sial testing. Sof support for

e project is cab testing an

se ResearDR10SC

o improve ths by evaluatiase. The projed and is inc

d in Section I

DR Databaup to collec

als. The dataation, DR co

mation collecs, type, build

of occupancads, vertical operating scns, capacity ion: Field te

ging Markend Respons

Annu

n support of teasurement a

eld with OCCstorage devicCE reviewedr the M&V p

complete, SCnd a field tes

rch CentCE1.09.03)

he software ting existing tojects two macluded in thiIV (Projects

ase ct and store iabase will incontrol strategcted will be ding envelop

cy, lighting ptransportatio

chedules, zonof plant, etcsted control

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

the PIER ETand validatio

C to gain a bce and its capd the resultsprocesses ut

CE plans to cst at another

ter (DRRC3)

tools availabtools in a scoajor tasks hais section of continued in

information clude fields gies, measuras follows:

pe, building l

power, plug on (elevator)ne temperatuc. strategies, i

ology ojects 2011

11

TDG programon for a proto

better underspabilities. O from the testilized.

continue worfacility.

C) – DR T

ble for estimaoping study

ad separate the report wn 2011) of th

on facilities for collectin

red demand s

layout, therm

and misc po), etc. ure set points

dentify any

m. SCE otype

standing OCC’s sts

rking

Tools

ating DR and

while he

and ng the savings

mal

ower,

s during

problem

33/30/2012

G. DETC

2. Colla

This projeto enhancat comme

3. Resu

The DRRand will cfrom sitesto be a painformatioprograms

4. Next

Begin utilmore accuother info

DR10.11 CC as DR

1. Over

The purpoin new comaterials,and shed and 2 werongoing a

a)Develop sretro-comcustomersstrategies

b)Assemblefeatures aproducts twill also scan suppo

aboration

ect was comce the tools aercial sites.

ults

RC collaboratcoordinate ths that have wart of this daton from the .

t Steps

lizing the staurately deterormation.

DRRC - MR10SCE1

rview

ose of this pronstruction a, assessing syattenuation. re completedand is includ

) Task 1 - segment spe

mmissioning s. This task aand value st

) Task 2 - Ae a DR guideand functionathat support survey majoort Auto-DR

mpleted in colavailable for

ted with the he data colleworked withtabase, a cenbuilding fac

atewide DR rmine DR po

Mainstrea.11.03)

roject was toand in existinystem capabThe project

d and are incded in Sectio

Develop edcific educatiagents, accoalso includedtreams from

Assessmeeline that outality for AutAuto-DR anr controls co

R strategies a

EmergDeman

llaboration wunderstandi

three IOUs ction of newthe DRRC i

ntral web-bascility manage

database witotential base

aming Au

o facilitate anng buildingsbilities of cons three majo

cluded in thisn IV (Projec

ducation aion and trainount executivd the develo

m DR.

ent of contrtlines minimto-DR and crnd comply wompanies to nd comply w

ging Markend Respons

Annu

with the DRRing and furth

to collect inw customers.in the past. Fsed survey wers as their b

th new potend on buildin

uto-DR (T

nd acceleratby developi

ntrols, and eor tasks had ss section of tcts continued

and trainingning materialves, etc. for copment of ca

rols systemmum energy mreate an onli

with OpenADcollect infor

with OpenAD

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

RC and othehering the ad

nformation on Initial data

For any new will be develbuildings sig

ntial Auto-Dng types, bus

Tasks 1 &

te the adoptioing educationevaluating loseparate delithe report, wd in 2011) of

g materialsls for controcommercial

ase studies th

m capabilitmanagemenine database DR specificarmation on lDR specifica

ology ojects 2011

12

er Californiadoption of A

n existing cuwill be acqusite that wou

loped to collgn up on Aut

DR customersiness segme

& 2) (Poste

on of Auto-Dn and trainin

oad shape chiverables. Ta

while Task 3f the report:

s ols vendors, a

and industrihat will outli

ties nt and contro

of companiations. The Dlegacy systemations as we

a IOU’s Auto-DR

ustomers uired uld like lect this to-DR

rs to ents, and

ed on

DR both ng anges asks 1 is

auditors, ial ne DR

l system es with

DRRC ms that

ell as

33/30/2012

H. DDR

legacy syinclude quvendors a

2. Colla

This projeto improv

3. Resu

CustomerGrid in thconcepts ainstalling customerswell-defindecision spossible astep DR eof DR fietechnologexplore hostep, the eintegrated

4. Next

Determinsystems.

DR10.12 R10SCE1.

1. Over

The originand stand(LEED) cthe LEEDimplemenDR creditmarket stu

stems that aruestions to u

and develop m

aboration

ect was comve the unders

ults

r adoption ofhe U.S. One oand technolothe equipme

s to respond ned, streamlisupport toolsand more comenablement pld tests and i

gies. Althougow these tooenablement pd with operat

t Steps

e the best str

DRRC – D12)

rview

nal scope of dards to a foccertification. D credits a bunting DR. Tht, in order toudy was con

re not upgradunderstand thmethods for

mpleted in colstanding and

f concepts anof the key deogies with thent and lettinto price or r

ined processs that are targmmon. A resprocess, deciinteraction wgh this projeols can be usprocess shoutional EE pr

rategy to util

DR Code

f this project cus on USGB

The DRRC uilding can rhe DRRC als gain a bette

nducted throu

EmergDeman

dable to suphe maintenanlong-term m

llaboration wd adoption of

nd technologemand-side he customersng it respondreliability vas. This procegeted towardsult of this pision supporwith customect concentra

sed for integruld be followocesses.

lize training

es and Sta

evolved fromBC’s Leaderdeveloped a

receive with so performeder understandugh interview

ging Markend Respons

Annu

pport Auto-Dnce contractmaintenance

with the DRRf Auto-DR in

gies is the kemanagemens is DR. Recd to DR evenariations of thess will requds key playe

project was trt concepts, aers while depated on DR prating opera

wed up by an

g materials an

andards

m an effort trship in Enera strategy gua focus on t

d a small scading of the vws with buil

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

DR strategiests between th of Auto-DR

RC and othen the market

ey to the sucnt activities tcent work hants is not sufhe electricity

uire training, ers, to make the developmand tools devploying auto

process and tational EE ann evaluation

nd the assess

(Posted o

to influence rgy and Envuide to be usthe new credale market stviability of thlding industr

ology ojects 2011

13

s. The surveyhe customersR strategies.

er Californiat.

ccess of the Sthat link Smaas shown thafficient. Engy grid requireducation, aDR particip

ment of a steveloped oveomated DR tools, it doesnd DR. As a process whi

sment of con

on ETCC

California cironmental D

sed in maximdit available tudy of the Lhe DR creditry stakehold

y will s and

a IOU’s

Smart art Grid

at simply gaging res a and ation p-by-

er years

s not next

ich is

ntrol

as

codes Design

mizing for

LEED t. The

ders.

3

3/30/2012

I. D

2. Colla

This was worked w

3. ResuThe mark

a)

LE EE Lo LE DR Re

b)

Pr Po In Gr Pr M

A guide ain DR andcredit was

4. Next

In 2012, Swith the U

Enhan Devel Track Devel

DR10.13

1. OverAs part ofimprove t

aboration

a collaboratiwith USGBC

ults ket study con

) Findings

EED points oE is not consoad shed threEED points oR strategy detro-active p

) Recomm

rovide more oints awardencentivize earant points orovide option

Make credit av

aimed at provd Auto-DR ps also develo

t Steps

SCE plans toUSGBC, the

nce the LEEDlop an under

k and improvlop peak dem

DRRC - I

rview f California’the ability of

ion project w in developi

nducted resul

s:

offer additiosidered in loesholds mayoffered are nevelopment

point acquisit

mendations

resources toed should be arly design ofon proportionn for ‘retrofivailable und

viding informprograms andoped as a res

o participate DRRC, and

D DR creditrstanding of ve the persistmand and DR

Industrial

s LTEESP, tf industry to

EmergDeman

with the DRRng the DR L

lted in the fo

onal incentivad shed requ

y be too highnot equitableeffort must tion is not av

s:

o learn aboutscaled basedf DR enablenate scale toit’ points der LEED CI

mation and ad assist thessult of this pr

in the Demad Environme

t language economic antence and repR benchmark

l DR (Pos

there are sevbetter mana

ging Markend Respons

Annu

RC and otheLEED credit

ollowing find

ves for adoptuirements h for small/me for cost andbe started eavailable

t DR opportud on energy

ement o load shed

I

assistance foe projects toroject.

and Responsental Defense

nd environmpeatability oking

sted on E

veral activitiage both peak

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

er Californiacriteria.

dings and re

tion of DR

medium commd effort requarly in the de

unities in onperformanc

or LEED proo achieve the

se Partnershie Fund (EDF

mental benefiof DR

ETCC as D

ies either plak and on-go

ology ojects 2011

14

a IOU’s. The

ecommendat

mercial builuired esign proces

ne’s area e

ojects to parte LEED DR

ip Program eF) to:

its of DR

DR10SCE

anned or unding electrica

e DRRC

ions:

ldings

ss

ticipate pilot

effort

E1.13)

derway to al energy

3

3

3/30/2012

http://www.su

use. One by the DOfacilities fmanagemThe purpothe adoptiof these fasites whicdemonstraconductinmanual), the indust

2. CollaThis projefunding p

3. ResuEnergy mtechnical capabilitiefor DR. Tinstallatiorelevant oorganizatibetween Dmeters thachanges cin DR. Ancontrol ovby utilitiematerial schanges, aother induin severalfindings fand equipeither eneseparate bmandate tmanagem

uperiorenergyp

synergistic OE and a numfor EE.3 A c

ment standardose of this prion of sophis

facilities to imch had been ation progra

ng a study at load managetrial site in im

aboration ect was com

portions of th

ults management s

and operatioes and increa

The technicalon of variabloperational cion of DR opDR implemeat Bentley Pcould be madn increase inver facility des would morstorage withias well as thustrial facilitl ways. Morefrom this stupment are exergy managebut promote that the orga

ment systems

performance.ne

activity is thmber of otheore element

d, initially ANroject was tosticated contmplement thselected for

am to developthese sites t

ement, contrmplementing

mpleted in parhe project be

systems weronal changesased personnl changes moe frequency

changes werepportunities entation and rince Street de which won the control demand, and re closely min the proces

he ones whicties. The nexe comprehen

udy truly apptremely variment or DRboth through

anizations thainto their op

et [as of March

EmergDeman

he Superior Eer public andof this initiaNSI MSE 20o understandtrols in parti

he energy mathe Californp this understo examine throls capabilitg the energy

rtnership witeing undertak

re incorporats. These channel awarenesost relevant drives (VFD

e those that iand proceduenergy manreceived as

ould increasecapabilities an expansio

match utility nss will enhanh were alrea

xus of energynsive studiesply to other inied. Utility acan offer co

h coordinateat they contrperations wh

h 29, 2012].

ging Markend Respons

Annu

Energy Perfod private secative is the a000:2008, red the relationicipating indanagement stnia Superior standing. Thhe relationshties, and the

y managemen

th the DRRCken in their s

ted into the onges, througss, have resuto DR were

Ds) on proceincreased awures. Additio

nagement cappart of their

e the ability oof both faci

on in the porneeds with fnce the flexibady implemey managemes could be unndustrial fac

and market pombined proed marketingract with muherever appli

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

ormance inittor partners

adoption andeplaced by ISnship betweedustrial facilitandard. ThiEnergy Perf

he scope of whip between level of suc

nt standard.

C. Other Calservice territ

organizationgh increased ulted in additthe installat

ess equipmenwareness throonally, therepabilities, asr Auto-DR syof these faciilities wouldrtfolio of DRfacility resoubility of ene

ented, are likent and DR cndertaken to cilities, as inprograms offograms or keg. Governmeust incorporaicable. Furth

ology ojects 2011

15

tiative put foto certify in

d use of an enSO 50001 inen DR as a dities and the is project levformance work includeDR (automa

ccess experie

lifornia IOUtories.

n, which led technical tional capab

tion or plannnt, while theoughout the

e seems to bes shown by thystem. Severilities to part

d allow moreR programs ources. An incergy usage. Tkely to applycould be encvalidate tha

ndustrial procfering incenteep programsental agencieate energy her experienc

orward dustrial nergy n 2011. driver for

capacity veraged

ed ated and enced by

Us are

to

bilities ned e most

e a link he sub ral other ticipate

e granular offered crease in These y to many couraged at the cesses tives for s es could

ce with

3

3/30/2012

J. DETC

standardsancillary b

4. NextAlthough managem

DR11.04 CC as DR

1. Over

This studycoincide wacceptancthrough thstudies cuinformatio

2. Resu

How consdecades. Omore enerthe resideSCE residlighting, a1999, peafrom 2006

The projecurrent inhighlight program presidentiaresidentia

3. Next

Based on could be ilighting (Utime of usload growresult of t

-based energbenefits.

t Steps this project

ment, control

DR OppoR11SCE1

rview

y evaluated awith projectece of load redhe review ofurrently avaion on reside

ults

sumers use eOver this perrgy-consumi

ential sector, dential territoand another ak lighting lo6, peak plug

ected potentincentives for

the tremendparticipational DR prograal customers

t Steps

the literaturinitiated, penUpstream Lise data on re

wth will lead the analysis o

gy managem

has been cocapabilities,

ortunities.04.01)

available liteed peak demduction durinf news publiclable. This r

ential DR for

energy in theriod, U.S. hoing devices senergy cons

ory today, a 52% to plug

oad occurs atg load occurs

al demand slighting and

dous potentian found throuams. The lite

to introduce

re review connding the anighting Progesidential lig

to peak demof this forthc

EmergDeman

ment systems

ompleted, SC, and overall

s in Resid

erature to demand, and to

ng peak demcations, reseresearch helpr lighting and

eir homes haomes on avesuch as homsumption hatypical hous

g loads, or mt 8 PM, withs at 8 PM.

avings fromd 447 MW foal for savingsugh the literaerature reviewe them to sm

nducted in thalysis of a fo

gram Evaluathting, which

mand coincidcoming CPU

ging Markend Respons

Annu

s will yield a

CE will contil energy man

dential Lig

etermine if redetermine th

mand. Extensearch documped to underd plug load a

as changed suerage have be

me electronicas steadily insehold attrib

miscellaneoush a secondary

m EE in the refor miscellans. The projecature revieww also indic

mart grid tech

his study, a sorthcoming tion report).h can help deding or exceeUC data show

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

additional ins

inue efforts tnagement at

ghting (P

esidential lighe potential sive research

ments, surveyrstand and evapplications

ubstantially ecome larges. Per capita

ncreased natibutes 27% ofs loads. Basey peak at 7 A

esidential seneous from 2cted increase

w underscoreates the need

hnologies an

second phaseCPUC reporThe CPUC

etermine if aeding SCE gws a peak de

ology ojects 2011

16

sight into the

to improve lindustrial fa

Posted on

ghting and pfor customeh was condu

ys, and DR cvaluate curre.

over the paser, and most a, and specifiionally. Withf its energy ued on data frAM. Based o

ctor, 481 MW2004 to 2016e in customes the opportud to further e

nd DR progra

e of the projrt on residenreport will p

and when thegeneration. Iemand impac

eir

load acilities.

n

lug loads er ucted ase ent

st three contain

fically in hin the use to rom on data

W under 6, er DR unity for engage ams.

ect ntial provide e lighting f the ct, then

3

3/30/2012

K. Das

Phase 2 oresidentia

DR11.05 DR11SCE

1. Over

a)This projeThis ALCBeach, Ca

b)The purpoRedwoodSciences

The objec Exam

loads Exam

contro

2. CollaThis projeUCI, and

3. Resu

a)Installatio2011. TheCommisselectrical DR testinconductedinvolved creductionwhich it rloggers aswere achi

f the projectal customer s

DR OppoE1.05.01

rview

) Landmarect evaluated

CS was instalalifornia.

) Universitose of this pr

d Systems. In1 building at

ctives of thismine the ALC

from businemine demand

ol system

aboration ect was comthe CLTC.

ults

) Landmaron of the lighe new lightinioning reducinput. This ng performedd during the changing thes with respe

returned to ths a comparisieved as a re

t consisting osurvey could

ortunitiesand DR1

rk Squared the DR caplled on the 1

ty of Califoroject was to

nstallation oft the UCI.

s project at bCS features thess managemreductions t

mpleted in col

rk Squarehting systemng system coced the ballanew commis

d at the Landsame businee DR level toct to the comhe baseline Dson to demansult of this p

EmergDeman

of the analysd be pursued

s in Corrid1SCE1.05

pabilities of 10th floor of t

ornia, Irvino evaluate thf this ALCS

both locationhat allowed

ment as part othat can be a

llaboration w

m and controlonsisted of flast dimming ssioned levedmark Squaress hours ovo five differe

mmissioned lDR level. A nd during theproject:

ging Markend Respons

Annu

sis of the exid.

dor Light5.02)

an ALCS dethe Landmar

e (UCI) he DR capab

occurred on

ns were: for reliable of a DR Progachieved with

with SCE’s D

l hardware wfluorescent la

settings to 6l is also desi

re building. Tver three sepaent settings: level. Each snon-test daye three test d

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

isting infrast

ting (Pos

eveloped by rk Square bu

bilities of an n the ground

control of cgram h a well-des

D&ES group

was completeamps and the65% of the liignated as thTesting was arate days. P 10%, 15%, setting lastedy was also redays. The fol

ology ojects 2011

17

tructure and

ted on ET

Lutron Elecuilding in Lo

ALCS develfloor of the

corridor light

signed, smart

p, Landmark

ed in Septeme Lutron ALighting’s ratehe baseline fsuccessfully

Part of the te20%, 25%,

d for one hoecorded by thllowing obje

a

TCC

ctronics. ong

loped by Natural

ting

t lighting

k Square,

mber LCS. ed

for the y esting and 30% ur after he data ectives

33/30/2012

L. D(Po

DR teProgra

Thereof the7.4 Wapproxdown

b)

InstallatioThe new lCommissThis new testing watest periodchanging below thethe baselicompariso as

DR tebusinecontro

ThereALCS0.031 This i

4. Next

Although lighting a

DR11.11 osted on E

1. Over

To better products aand servicSCE condresidentiamakers an

esting for theam could rel was a reduc ALCS and t

W/fixture, or 0ximately 17%the lamps.

) UCI

on of the lighlighting systioning reduccommission

as conductedds recordingthe lighting

e commissionne DR levelon to deman a result of t

esting for theess managemoller. was a reduc

S and the newW/sf at the s in addition

t Steps

this project and controls p

Future OETCC as

rview

understand rand servicesces from theducted a twoal customers nd thought-le

e ALCS confliably managction in overthe new ligh0.092 W/sf a%. This is in

hting systemtem consisteced the light ned level is ad for the samg granularity

level to fivened level. Ea. A non-test

nd during thethis project:

e ALCS confment as part

ction in overw lighting fi30% DR lev

n to the light

has been coprojects that

Outlook foET10SCE

residential cs and to unde perspective

o- pronged reand, twelve eaders.

EmergDeman

firmed that bge lighting lorhead corridohting fixturesat the 30% Dn addition to

m and controld of LED lamoutput settin

also designatme business h

was set at 1e different seach setting lday was als

e three test d

firmed that lof a DR Pro

rhead lightinxtures. The

vel. The percing savings

ompleted, SCt may influen

or ResideE4.07.0)

customer inteerstand the oes of manufasearch studyin-depth tel

ging Markend Respons

Annu

business manoads. or lighting los. The DR re

DR level. Tho the lighting

l hardware wmps and Redngs to 85% oted as the bahours over th-minute. Th

ettings: 10%asted for one

so recorded bdays. The fol

lighting loadogram, but re

ng load demaDR reductiocentage reduassociated w

CE will contince future D

ential Ene

erest in a numopportunitiesacturers and my including; lephone inter

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

nagement as

oad demand eduction for

he percentageg savings ass

was completedwood Systeof the lightinaseline for thhree separate

he testing pro%, 15%, 20%

e hour, afterby the data lolowing obje

ds can be reliequires local

and after theon for lightinuction was apwith tuning d

inue to pursuDR program o

ergy Mana

mber of smas/barriers formembers of a web surverviews amon

ology ojects 2011

18

s part of a DR

after the inslighting ave

e reduction wsociated with

ed in Octobeems ALCS.ng’s rated ouhe DR testinge days. Duriocedure inclu, 25%, and 3r which it retoggers as a ctives were

iably managl connection

installation ng averaged pproximatelydown the lam

ue other advofferings.

agement

art grid-relatr smart grid pf the supply cy among SCng industry d

R

stallation eraged was h tuning

er 2011.

utput. g. DR ng the uded 30% turned to

achieved

ged by to the

of the 62W, or y 43%.

mps.

vanced

t

ted products chain,

CE decision

33/30/2012

2. Colla

This projeSCE residTechnoloAdditionaBuilding A

3. Resu

A web surin-depth ivendors, afollowing

a)

The m Aware

and ed Many Use o

b)

Two po o

Addit Soluti

servic

4. Next

Results of re

aboration

ect was comdential custogies and HVally, this projAssociation’

ults

rvey of 606 interviews wand supply c

g key finding

) Resident

main motivateness of eneducation on

y customers hf effective, b

) Industry

primary barrLack of opConsumer

ional innovaions that requces are neede

t Steps

f this study wsidential pro

mpleted in colomers and indVAC Techno

ject piggy b’s national st

residential cwere conductchain distribugs resulted fr

tial Survey

tion for savinrgy related pspecific conhave alreadybut high cost

Leader Int

riers to adoptpen and unifr lack of undation is needuire little effed

will be used ojects that ev

EmergDeman

llaboration wdustry leade

ology and Syacked off thtudy of the s

customers wated with induutors for smarom these su

ys

ng energy is products, ser

ncepts such ay taken easy t energy sav

terviews

tion of smartform standarderstanding rded to solve efort by consu

to determinevaluate emer

ging Markend Respons

Annu

with SCE’s Ders. It was alsystem Diagnoe efforts of tsame name.

as conductedustry leadersart grid prod

urveys and in

to lower elervices, and uas DR is needand less exp

ving solution

rt grid produrds and protoregarding eneenergy relateumers or bun

e where to forging market

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

D&ES groupso co-fundedostic Advocthe Continen

d in SCE sers who represducts and sernterviews:

ectricity billsutility prograded

pensive stepsns has low pe

cts and serviocols ergy ed problemsndle energy

focus resourcts and techno

ology ojects 2011

19

p with input d with the Emacy programntal Automat

rvice territorent manufacrvices. The

s ams varies w

s to conserveenetration

ices:

solutions wi

ces on futureologies.

from merging

ms. ted

ry and 12 cturers,

widely

e

ith other

e

3

I

3/30/2012

III. Projec All n2012

cts initia

ew projects were started

ated in 2

initiated in 2d earlier in th

2011

2011 were cohe 2009-201

EmergDeman

ompleted by11 funding cy

ging Markend Respons

Annu

y year end. Tycle.

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

The only proj

ology ojects 2011

20

jects continuuing into

3

I

4

h1

3/30/2012

IV. Pro

A. D

DR applicatio

http://www3.sc11+DR+Amend

ojects co

DR09.02

1. Over

The primaautomotivStorage Uduring DRstill allevican be fou001).

2. Colla

The HBP (EVTC) i

3. Statu

LG Chemreceived i2011, twofunctionaunits wenspecialistsUnfortunathe need tE was app

4. NextNecessary2012. Oncproceed. Ainformatioand any abe includehomes in

on (A.08-06-00ce.com/sscc/lawded+App_SCE

ontinued

Home Ba

rview

ary objectiveve grade advUnit (RESU)R events or liating demanund in Appe

aboration

project is a n Pomona, C

us

m. was selectin Decembero pre-produclity and seve

nt through thes have workately, UL ceto continue fproved, allow

t Steps y design chace the RESUAt the concluon regarding

additional leaed as part ofthe ZNE and

01) Appendicesw/dis/dbattach1E-04++Append

d in 2011

attery Pilo

e of this projvanced lithiu. The goal islocalized disnd on the poendix K4 of S

collaborativCalifornia le

ed as the venr of 2010 andction units aneral other ime complete sed with LG rtification hafunding this wing the con

anges have bU’s have UL usion of fiel

g the feasibilarning gainef the ISGD pd RESU blo

s A through M1e.nsf/0/DBCAdices+A-M.pdf

EmergDeman

1

ot (HBP)

ject, which bum-ion batters to evaluate stribution conwer grid. A

SCE’s amend

ve effort withveraging the

ndor to provd extensive lnd fourteen a

mprovementsseries of RESengineers toas been delaproject into

ntinuation of

een made ancertification

ld testing, a flity of using d as a result

project and wcks.

: A190DAE972Cf [as of March 2

ging Markend Respons

Annu

began in 200ry modules f the potentianstraints to dmore detaileded testimon

h SCE’s Eleceir expertise

vide the RESlab testing hadditional uns, including wSU tests and

o resolve issuayed leading

the next funf this project

nd UL certifin, the field tefinal report wthese types

t of this projewill receive a

CEB882574C929, 2012].

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

09, is to evalfor use as a Ral of using indecrease cused explanatiny DR applic

ctric Vehiclewith lithium

SU. A prototyhas been perfnits were recweb control.d SCE’s enerues discoverto a delay in

nding cycle. t into the new

fication is anesting phasewill be writtof batteries ect. Additionadditional te

90070C520/$FI

ology ojects 2011

21

luate and tesResidential En-home battestomer impaon of this prcation (A.08

e Test Centem-ion batteri

ype device wformed. Durceived with i. These prodrgy storage red during ten field testinAdvice lettew funding cy

nticipated by e of the projeten to providas a DR resonal RESU’s sting in seve

ILE/A.08-06-0

st Energy eries ct, while roject 8-06-

er ies.

was ring increased

duction

esting. ng and er 2685-ycle.

late-ect will de ource will also

eral

001+2009-

3

5

h

3/30/2012

B. DDem

Department o

http://www.ene

DR09.08 monstrat

1. Over

SCE has bHAN depdistribute“matchingReinvestmDOE5. ThZero Net homes wiCommuniof this pro

2. CollaThis proje(TDBU) Acollaborat

3. Statu

The contrdevelopedto be signproducts pearly fieldmeters, intests sendcontinue ito continu

4. NextAdditionadrop durinincluding tested, an

f Energy Reco

ergy.gov/recov

Expandintion (ISGD

rview

been exploriployment to fd energy resg funds” alloment Act (ARhe ISGD projEnergy (ZN

ill receive diity Energy Soject are the

aboration ect is a collaAdvanced Ttes with the

us

ract with DOd, several chned with homprocured andd test was con-home displding simulateinto the nextue activities

t Steps al testing wilng several Dan EMS, sm

d installed in

overy Act Stateery/documents

ng ResideD) projec

ing how to cfurther enablsources. To fowing SCE tRRA) in SCject will dem

NE) homes infferent treatm

Storage, and DR potentia

aborative effoechnology ODOE in supp

OE was signehanges in selme owners pad installed inonducted whlays (IHDs),ed DR eventt funding cycand funding

ll be compleDR events dirmart appliancn anticipatio

e Memos: s/Recovery_Ac

EmergDeman

ential DRct

apitalize on le residentiafurther this gto leverage f

CE’s proposamonstrate pon step with Cments includa group utili

al of residen

ort with SCEOrganizationport of their

ed in Decemected vendoarticipating in the particip

hich involved and PCTs ins to these decle. Due to d

g was granted

eted during thrected at theces, plug loa

on of the prim

ct_Memo_Cali

ging Markend Respons

Annu

R in the Ir

the Edison Sal DR in coorgoal, EM&Tfunding fromal for the ISGotential EE aCalifornia’s Lding a ZNE izing individ

ntial HAN de

E’s Transmisn and BCD Dr larger, Sma

mber of 2010.rs were madin the projecpating homed the installan some of thevices were sdelays assocd in the appr

he summer oe installed PCad monitors,mary testing

ifornia.pdf [as

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

rvine Sma

SmartConnerdination wi

T provided som the AmericGD project aand DR apprLTEESP. Segroup, a grodual RESU. evices and th

ssion and DiD&ES. This art Grid dem

. As detailedde and customct leading to s. However,

ation of projehe homes. Insuccessful. Aiated with throval of Adv

of 2012 to obCTs. Additioand RESUsphase of the

of March 29, 2

ology ojects 2011

22

art Grid

ectTM meterinith EE and ome of the can Recoverawarded by thoaches to en

everal groupsoup utilizing The two maj

he HBP.

istribution Uproject also

monstration ef

d plans were mer agreemedelays in ge

, during 201ect SmartCo

nitial commuAdditional tehis project, avice letter 26

bserve actuaonal HAN des will be proce project in 2

2012].

ng and

ry & he

nable s of

ajor areas

Unit

fforts.

ents had etting 1 an

onnectTM unication ests will a request 685-E.

al load evices cured, 2013.

3

6

r

3/30/2012

C. D

D. D

Pool Pump De

response-poten

DR10.05 A

1. Over

The purpothrough thwithout a offer a socommercievents by

2. Statu

An OpenAwas compactual DRneed to imcustomer software. was decidcontractinphase is supdates nfunding fo

3. Next

Finalize sselected sreport on

DR10.08

1. OverThe purpoavailable of pool puto prior stresource:

Po In

emand Respon

ntial [as of Mar

Auto-DR

rview

ose of this prhe OpenADRbuilding or lution that pial and indus enabling tem

us

ADR compapleted in earlR events thromprove the pwas identifiDuring 201

ded to move ng process wcheduled foreeded to theor this projec

t Steps

selection of csites. Monitothe results o

DR Pool

rview ose of this prpool pumps

ump loads intudies that es

ool Pump Dentegration of

nse Potential: hch 29, 2012].

PCT

roject is to dR specificatienergy man

provides somstrial custommperature se

atible PCT wly 2011. The

oughout the sprovisioning ied that requ1 an additionforward wit

was completer the summe

e original venct was grant

customer siteor PCT functof the field tr

Pumps

roject is to pand pool pu

n response tostimated the

emand RespDR into Tit

http://www.etcc

EmergDeman

demonstrate ion. This sol

nagement sysme automatedmers during Cetbacks, with

was identifiedese devices wsummer of 2of the PCT ired an updanal vendor cth a field tested for both soer of 2012. Dndor’s equipted in the app

es to participtionality duririal.

perform laboump controllo DR event spotential fo

onse Potentile 20 for Re

c-ca.com/comp

ging Markend Respons

Annu

the capabilitlution is intestem (BMS/Ed air-conditioCritical Peakhout the exp

d during 201were tested i2011. The PCallowing it t

ate to the equcontacted SCt of both soluolutions dur

Due to the adpment, a requproval of Ad

pate in the fiing summer

oratory and flers that are dsignals or prior residential

ial6 sidential Poo

ponent/content/

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

ty of a PCT ended for comEMS). The poning load rk Pricing (CPpense of a ful

10 and procuin a lab settinCTs worked to be uniqueuipment and

CE with a simutions. The p

ring 2011 anddition of a suest to contindvice letter 2

ield trial. InsDR events.

field tests of designed to icing signalsl pool pumps

ol Pumps7

t/article/29/242

ology ojects 2011

23

using Auto-mmercial cuproject goal reduction forPP), or otherll BMS/EMS

urement of thng during seas anticipate

ely tied to a sd the associatmilar solutioprocurementd the field tesecond vendnue activitie2685-E.

stall PCT’s aPrepare a fi

commercialenable curtas. This is a fos to act as a D

20-pool-pump-

DR ustomers

is to r r DR, S.

he device everal ed, but a specific ted

on and it t and esting or and

es and

at nal

lly ailment follow up DR

demand-

3

7

c2

3/30/2012

E. D

Integration of

ca.com/compon29, 2012].

This projewell as re

2. Statu

After initipump witencounterin 2012. Aapproval o

3. NextCompletesolutions

DR10.09

1. Over

The purpopotential ideliverablearlier, as

a)This projedevelopmvariety ofparameterconsumpt

2. Colla

This projeenhance tcommerci

3. StatuThis projefor this pr

f DR into Title nent/content/ar

ect will inclutrofit solutio

us

ial implemenh integrated red have beeA request to of Advice le

t Steps e field trial oduring 2012

DRRC – D

rview

ose of this prin commerciles. Task 1 is it has been

) Task 1 - Sect includes

ment and the f users. This rs that allowtion.

aboration

ect is a collathe tools avaial sites.

us ect will be coroject was gr

20 for Residen

rticle/29/2938-

ude field triaons that wou

ntation planscommunica

en overcomecontinue act

etter 2685-E.

f integrated 2.

DR Tools

roject is to imial buildingss included incompleted:

Scoping Sa review ofcreation of awill include

w facility man

aborative effoailable for un

ompleted byranted in the

ntial Pool Pumpintegration-of-

EmergDeman

als of a pool uld add DR c

s were createation experie and plans ativities and f.

solution acc

s (Task 1)

mprove the ss. The projecn this section

tudy the literature

a frameworke a summary nagers to bet

ort with the nderstanding

y mid-2012. e approval of

ps - Phase 1: h-dr-into-title-20

ging Markend Respons

Annu

pump with icapabilities t

ed, the selecenced some dare moving fofunding for t

cording to pl

)

software tooct includes twn of the repo

e on existingk to evaluate y of metrics atter understa

DRRC and og and furtheri

A request tof Advice lett

http://www.etcc0-for-residentia

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

integrated Dto existing po

cted vendor ddelays. The

forward to cothis project w

lans; select a

ols available wo major tasort, Task 2 w

g DR tools btools and ca

and buildingand their bui

other Califoring the adop

o continue acter 2685-E.

c-al-pool-pumps

ology ojects 2011

24

DR capabilitiool pumps.

designing theobstacles

omplete the pwas granted

and test retro

for estimatisks with sep

was reported

being used orategorize theg characterizalding’s ener

rnia IOUs toption of Auto

ctivities and

s-phase-1 [as of

es, as

e pool

project in the

ofit

ng DR arate on

r under em for a ation gy

o o-DR at

funding

f March

3

3/30/2012

F. D

G. D

4. NextContinue

DR10.11

1. Over

The purponew constseparate dhave been

a)Demand rover timeby variouthe initialover time

2. CollaThis projeimprove t

3. Statu

Delays infrom beincontinue aletter 268

4. NextContinue

DR10.16

1. Over

This projemanufactureceipt ofwill proviDR eventcapable ap

t Steps monitoring

DRRC – M

rview

ose of this prtruction and deliverables.n completed,

) Task 3 - reductions v. The DRRC

us engineerin estimation i.

aboration ect is a collathe understan

us

securing theng finalized iactivities and5-E.

t Steps monitoring

Smart Ap

rview

ect will perfourers to quanf a pricing sigide an oppor signals. Adppliance effo

Task 1 to en

Mainstrea

roject is to fain existing b Task 3 is in, and are inc

Evaluationary with eac

C will go throng firms and in order to e

aborative effonding and ad

e data needein 2011.Thisd funding fo

Task 1 to en

ppliances

orm laboratontify the DRgnal. These rtunity to seeditionally, th

forts underwa

EmergDeman

nsure comple

aming Au

facilitate andbuildings. Th

ncluded in thluded in the

n of load shch event and ough a seleccompare pevaluate how

ort with the doption of A

ed by the DRs project willor this projec

nsure comple

s

ory testing oR potential fo

tests will bee first hand hhe results of ay (e.g. Ener

ging Markend Respons

Annu

etion on sche

uto-DR (T

d accelerate the project in

his section ofearlier secti

hape chansometimes

cted number rformance o

w demand red

DRRC and oAuto-DR in th

RRC to compl be complet

ct was grante

etion on sche

f “smart appor curtailing e done in a cohow “smart af this study crgy Star con

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

edule.

Task 3)

the adoptionncluded threef the report sions:

ges/shed ademand reduof audits an

of the buildinduction perfo

other Califorhe market.

plete this proted by mid-2ed in the app

edule.

pliances” froload during ontrolled labappliances”

can be used tnnected appli

ology ojects 2011

25

n of Auto-DRe major tasksince Tasks

attenuatiouctions decr

nd estimationngs over timformance cha

rnia IOUs to

oject prevent2012. A requproval of Ad

om several DR events o

b environmereact to pric

to inform variance effort)

R both in ks with 1 and 2

n rease ns done

me with anges

o

ted it uest to dvice

or upon nt and

ce and rious DR ).

33/30/2012

H. D

2. Colla

This projeDR poten

3. Statu

Initial testadditionalleast threetrends, a fcollected

4. NextDelays wimanufactuto create aTesting ofprocure sm

DR11.01 A

1. OverThe purpoequipmenproject beparticipatcompletedServices Dcomplemeresult of tresource. Pumping

2. StatuThe planncustomer durationscapabilitieselected, p

3. NextSelect thetrials to b

aboration

ect is a collantial of smart

us

ting of a “sml appliances e different mfinal report wfrom all the

t Steps ith getting courers, acquirappropriate tf appliances mart applian

Ancillary

rview ose of this prnt to participegan in 2010e in a prograd by Global DR programentary progrtransitioningInitial projecustomers c

us ning for this willingness . During 201es of each poplans will be

t Steps e equipment e completed

aborative effot appliances

mart” clothesincluding cl

manufacturerwill be creattests.

ontracts andring equipmetest cases resby several m

nces from ad

y Services

roject is to eate in an An

0 and includeam with shorEnergy Part

m for pumpinram to the exg AP-I to a Cctions are th

could be part

project begato participat

11 several pootential solue made for fi

to be used ad during the s

EmergDeman

ort with seveutilizing SC

s washer waslothes washers are schedued at the con

d Non-Discloent for testinsulted in themanufacture

dditional ven

s Pumpin

evaluate the pncillary Servied market rert notificatiotners recommng customersxisting AP-I

CAISO Reliahat by 2014 aticipating in

an in 2010 ante in a DR protential techn

ution were evield trials du

and the custosummer of 2

ging Markend Respons

Annu

eral major apCE’s D&ES l

s performed ers, refrigerauled for 2012nclusion of t

osure Agreemng and workie need to coners is schedulndors for incl

ng Equipm

potential of ices DR pro

esearch to deon and short mended that s as a potentiDR program

ability Demaapproximatean Ancillary

nd included rogram withnology vendvaluated. Onuring the sum

omer sites fo2012.

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

ppliance malab facilities

during 2011ators, and dis2. In an effortesting which

ments (NDAing with spe

ntinue this prled and efforlusion in this

ment

customers wgram. The p

etermine custdurations. MSCE pursue

ial replacemm that now hand Responseely 6% of Agy Services pr

market reseh short notifidors were idence a technolmmer of 201

or the Ancilla

ology ojects 2011

26

anufacturers s and staff.

1. Testing ofshwashers frrt to determih utilizes dat

As) in place wecific manufaroject duringrts are beings project.

with pumpingplanning for tomer willin

Market researe an Ancillar

ment or has a MW cae Program (Rgricultural anrogram.

earch to deterication and sentified and logy partner 2.

ary Services

to test

f rom at ine ta

with facturers g 2012. g made to

g this

ngness to rch ry

ap as a RDRP) nd

rmine short the is

field

3

V

L

Tf

Ua2wl

8

PCab

3/30/2012

V. Budge

Line. No. Exp

1 Labor2 Non-L3 Total

The 2009-20for the follow

DR09 DR09 DR10 DR10 DR10 DR10 EPRI

Under Orderauthorization2009-2011 fuwas approvelisted above

8 D.09-08-027,Project funded California Edisadvice letter deby including a r

et

Emergin

pense Type r Labor

011 EM&T Rwing project

9.02 HBP 9.08 Expand0.05 Auto-D0.08 DR Poo0.09 DRRC 0.11 DRRC I Technology

ring Paragrapn to carry ovunding cycled effective Jto be spent i

, Ordering Parathrough the 20

son Company, escribing specifrequest to cont

ng Markets a

2009 $396,449 $404,515 $800,964

Recorded Exs:

ding ResidenDR PCT ol Pumps – DR Tools – Mainstreay Testing Co

ph 16 of D.0ver the unspee into the 20January 1, 20in the new fu

agraph 16. “To009-2011 budgand San Diegofic projects andtinue these proj

nd Technolo

201 $516,7

$896,2 $1,412,9

xpenses do n

ntial DR in IS

(Scoping Staming Auto-Dollaboration

09-08-027,8 Sent committe12-2014 fun012, allowinunding cycle

o continue beyogets adopted in o Gas & Electrid the reason fojects in their ne

EmergDeman

ogy Recorded

0 734 $214 $1,948 $2,

not include co

SGD

tudy) DR (Load Sh

SCE filed aned portion ofnding cycle.ng the remaine.

ond December this decision, Pic Company shr the project toext demand res

ging Markend Respons

Annu

d Expense –

2011 $981,835

862,709 844,544

ontractually

hape/Shed A

n advice lettef the EM&T On March 1

ning $4.2 mi

31, 2011, an EPacific Gas an

hall each requeo continue beyosponse funding

ts & Technse (DR) Proual Report:

– 2009-2011 (

2009-2011 Totals

$1,895,018 $3,163,438 $5,058,456

committed

Attenuation)

er in 2011 reauthorized f

15, 2012, Adillion commi

Emerging Marknd Electric Comest permission eond the end of g application.”

ology ojects 2011

27

($) 2009-2Author

Fund $9,244,4

and budgete

equesting funding from

dvice Letter 2itted to the p

kets and Technmpany, Southereither through

f the funding pe

2011 rized ing

405

ed funds

m the 2685-E projects

nology rn a Tier 2

eriod, or