elie halévy's first lectures on the history of european ... · elie hal evy’s rst lectures...

37
Elie Hal´ evy’s first lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert. Elie Hal´ evy’s first lectures on the history of European socialism. Journal of the History of Ideas, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2007, Vol. 68 (N 2), pp.329-353. <halshs-00213503> HAL Id: halshs-00213503 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00213503 Submitted on 23 Jan 2008 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ ee au d´ epˆ ot et ` a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´ es ou non, ´ emanant des ´ etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´ etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´ es.

Upload: others

Post on 13-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

Elie Halevy’s first lectures on the history of European

socialism

Ludovic Frobert

To cite this version:

Ludovic Frobert. Elie Halevy’s first lectures on the history of European socialism. Journalof the History of Ideas, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2007, Vol. 68 (N 2), pp.329-353.<halshs-00213503>

HAL Id: halshs-00213503

https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00213503

Submitted on 23 Jan 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.

Page 2: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

������������ ������������ ���������� �!#"$�%'&�(*),+.-/% 021�3�4�3�5�671#%8( 9:% 0;5#<�4=+'6=>�?��8@�"�A'BDC�E*�8"�F;�@ ��GIH�J'@ KL��M�N OQPR� SLO#TU@�G��VTR�WS�G�OX�'Y;T[Z�G�Z���O7TV�8SLM\��P���S]��^�G*J�YQO=�8�L� J8@ ��O#_a`'"8b�"'c8��d�e7c�f�c�"

�Z�G��G=PV� Y�� T=� ��G���G�SLOV����YX� OJL��J���@ J�g�@�G�J.ThZ�T�T[^Wh i i _U��O=GL" jLZ���" G]���,i @��8k'� Yml.�mSL� n�i jL����S]YWJ8@ OVi jV����SLY�J�@ o��8P�o'T=Z�GRo�Z���O7TR��S*Mpo���P�o�� ��G]J�Oqi��,��A�BLi#A'B8" ��P#S���g,G�SVT=" Z'TR_U@

ras't�uwvyx�s8z{}|D~=���:t������:��u������\��u����U���W�\u

v�t������I�|y���:r��\�Q���DuQxU���}�I��t8x�s�t����

���X�U��X�=���D���� �¡��£¢

¤¦¥¨§�©'ª�«­¬�®;¯°®�±�¥�®£©m±�¥U®£²

¤D®´³Uµ]©m®;¶·§�µ]¸=¹�³�§�º�¬�®:ºV§»¯°®�±£¥�®©�±�¥X®2¼�±�¸*®³Uµ�¸ ½�¸L¾�¿X®

À ±¹�º]®;¶�¹�©�Á§�ºL®\¼�¿�ÃD«´©¸V®�¿Q©Ä®;Å\®£µLµ=©�®�²­®£µ�¼I±�¸=®£³U±�®£²�ÆÇ¿�Á§Q¸V³�®�²

È �U��¡�É�É�¡ Ê

Ë2Ì·Í�Î8�°Í�Ï

Ð�ÑÓÒ\Ô��W���=É�Õa¡�É���Ô���¢�¡É

Ö�×�Ø�Ö�ØÙ�;ÚX��ÛÂ�£¡���¡ÝÜÙÞ�ß

�D��Ô�ÛX��¡

�­�X�à���X�=��á7�D��� Q¡���¢�âã¡�ÛXÉWÎ8äLÉ�åUáVæ��

Page 3: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

������������ ����������������W��������� ��!#"%$%&'$(")�*�,+��������-/.0$�12+3�4!65�$("�&718�:9�;�&7��$(")!#&<$=&�+��>+3��!?&�$�1���$�.

;�&@�����:&�A10�<�")��!CBD$�1E&7$F&�+)�6+)��!G&7$�1@�F$H.EBI$�-��J1K"I-)�JBL$�5�1K�5M�,��"N�O"�P)�*�"�-�Q�9�;�&R+)�S��!T���!?$NP��J")��1UA���*�

-��JV)��5�&7�J-W�!S,P�10���&#���*9)�J10��X&7+)�*"�Y���18ZR[R10��"�5J+\5�$�B�BL��"�&�J&�$�10!MQX.K10$�B^]_M��BI$�"%-a`_1b$�"a&7$c")$�d

e���5J$����!#fgM�)��1K��h�Q�+HM�)�>")$(&K��-N&�+%�jik$�"�&7��!Cl�;)�<��;)�KmO$�5�l�;��J�)���<�������>A�� ����/�n"�&7��������5�&�;)��3&K1K�-��*&7�<$�"�opZ

q0")-�����-�QH�>��� ����sr�!_V3��185���V�&7��$("�$�.2!C$)5J������<!CB�r�!g5�$("�&71UA-���5�&7$�1@�="�J&�;�18�L��!g5J$�"3!t��-���1K��-,$�"%�S$�.2+)��!

BL0uM$�1O�*"�&7�����<��5J&�;)���5�$�"�&K1b�*9�;�&K��$�")!�Z�qK"L+)��! ����5J&�;H17�6$�"SvAmE+��#��1K6$�.Rm'��10J")")����!8w�Q(+)�_5A�<A�<BL��-j&�+�M&

!x�n")5A�a!t$�5��<A����!CBcr�!,�BS93�:&@�<$�"yd6A!=&7$k�1�&0��5�;)���&7�z&7d>${BL8ux$|1L5�$("�&�1UA-)�*5J&�$|1��k&@�J"��J&7!F}~"��BL���*�

�JBL�"�5��:V�J&@�*$�"S�"�-S$�1KP�A")�<!tJ&7��$("j}I�*&0!O$�;�&05�$�BN�g5J$�;%��-j$�")�*�>9)�#5�+��$�!�M")-j&���1K�"�"�� o o ZJ��;�9)����!8+���-

��" ��������Q��>��� J����r�!�V��V���1��*"H.7�<;%�J")5J�A-�gd6+�$����_P��M"���1KJ&7��$("L$�.H[�18��"�5J+I���*9���1K���&K+)�*"�Y���10!MQ�"�$�&�J9)�*�

&7+�$�!M��5�$(")5��J1K"%��-�d>�*&K+���5J$�")$(BI��5�!MQ>!G;)5�+��!c]g��)BI$�"�-�`_10$�")Q_]g$�9)�J1K&Fi�J1�ux$H�4�n")Q_�O&0����"�")�

i�J"�&�$�;��3Zsm�1K�"%!C�<M&7�J-\�<"�&7$z�'"�P�����!8+W9���i���W�~����<�!S�")-aV�;�9)����!8+)�J-\�:"c�T�A�(�)���>������QO�*&T���!C$

+�A-S!t$|B��_�*"H.7�<;%�J"�5��T$�"j[s10����-�10��5�+j�>�����Y��*"S+3�4!Xd61b�n&7�<"�P>$�.E���)�2�T�(���I�*�j����� �������>� � �pZ

mE+)�����n9%�J10�����!?B $�.�>A�� M���Rr�!Nd>$|1KY~��!L;�"�l�;)��!?&7��$(")M93�*�WM")-¡��!,18�A�<�M���"�&6&K${+)��!,���&@�J1

&@����&7!CQ2"�$(&KM9��:�W&K+�$�!x�c$�.g+)��!LBN$�!?&gV���!x!M�:BI��!G&@��5=�|�J�10!MQE&�+)��mE+)�<1�&@����!�ZEf¢�J.0$�10�,&�+%��£_1b�JJ&T���1bQ

+%$|d¢���%��10QH�>A�� �����r�!_�"���:�)!x��!g$�.2!M$�5��<A����!?B¤d6�!_B�$�10�jV�$)!C�*&��n�|�%Z�qK&2��!¢&7�������:")PN&�+)�&�+)�Sd610$(&7�L�n"

�������3¥TvJ¦>")�n�|�J18!t�����h���-����*9���1�&��§��!\-���BL$�5�1UA5J�H¨¢�")-�;�")�n�%��10!C����:h���-�-��MBL$H5�1UA5J��Q6d6+���"§�n&=��!

����&<�J"�-���-/.K1b$�B©&n+)�jV�$����n&7��5J��ª.0�����*-N&7$=&�+)���J5�$�"�$�BI��5S$(")�AQ3��!T"�$(&�+��:")PF9�;�&G¥�!C$�5A�<A����!?BLw�o «tZ��~+��&

��"�&K��18��!G&O&�+)�6��$�;�"�PN�>��� ����%Q|&7+)�J",�!C����.0��VH10$�5��*��*BL��-I-�18����.K;)!C�18-,�"�-N1b��V�;�9)����5JM"¬�n"�&7�������J5�&�;����Q

��!¬&�+)�kV�$�&��J"�&@�n���.7$|1�!x$�5��*��SM")-yV)$����:&0�*5�A�L5�$("�&K10$)�S�*"�+��J1b��"�&=�:"§��5�$�"�$�BN�45­V�10�5J&7��5��J!MZgmX+)��!

��"�&K��18��!G&s5J�"S9��T.0$�;�")-S�:"�����H$�.)+)��!OBL8ux$�1s&7�J��&@!O$�.|&7+)� �A�������W�A�¨�¯®SV)�J1b�*$�- « Z

Page 4: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

q0&{d������\5J$�BL� A!�"%$ !G;)1KV�1b��!t� &�+)�J1b�J.0$�10��Q/&�+HM&{�¢��� �����r�!�����5�&n;H10��! $�"©�';H10$�V%�JJ"

� $�5A�<A���*!CBIQ3-��(���*����10��-,M&E&�+����5A$��������n9�10��-���! � 5A���M"�5���!#�s$)�*�n&@�*l�;���!T9)��&Kd¢�J��"��������,A"�- ��������Q

9%���1O&K+��j&71K�5J�A!_$�.2!C;�5M+�J"����%$)�:;�&K��$�"ªZ � $�BL�S$�.E&K+%�J!x�L�*��5�&�;�1b�J!_d¢��10�>V�;�9)���4!?+��A-c�:"�����®H��QR��Z��(Z

&@��"y�%��J10!cA.<&0��1��>��< J���3r�!�-���M&�+)Q 9�� !C$�BL�\$�.S+)��!N.7$H����$�d>��10!MQTd_+%$¡;�")-��J18!t5�$�1b��-~�>A�� �����r�!

+%$�!G&0�����n&�� &0$ !C$�5��<�����!GB,ZT� �*&�+3�:" &�+)�­�>��� �����`6185J+)�:�|�(!��I!?&7�����S������Q+)$�d¢���)��18Q6;�"�Y�"�$�d_"§M")-

;�"�V�;�9�����!G+)��-�Q(&�+)�#"%���13&0$(&7����4&��L$�.3&�+��_.K�<10!?&s!M�J1b���(!2$�.R���J5J&�;)10��!�$�"L!C$�5��<A����!?B -��A���n�%�J1b��-F�*" �����(�3Z

q0&R��!X&�+3�TV�;�1KV%$H!t�_$�.3&�+��<!2VHMV%��13&@$F!8+%��-j"���d ���*P�+(&s$�"j�>��� �����9��L���)V%$�!C�:")Pj&�+)�_5�$("�&��J"�&s$�.H&K+)��!

V��1�&@��5M;)�<�16!x�J18����!�$�._���J5J&�;)10��!CQE�!6���M&T;�")!8&�;)-����J-HZ�`¤5���$�!C�N10���-H��"�PW$|. &�+��<!�!C��& !?+%$�d>!jN���J1K�

-���.U.7��10��"|&�V�10�������à�M®L�>��� ����%Q�$�"%�j�*"�!M�4!?&K�*"�PS")$(&��9)�n��$("Sik�1K�Rr�!#!t��BI�:")��H10$����>�*"S;�"%-��J18!8&K�"�-��:")P

5J�V)�n&������!?B �")-�$("�&�+)�LV�18$�P�18��!C!S$�.��"W��5�$�"�$�BI��5N!U�)!8&0�JB �:"Wd6+���5�+�&�+��,�*"�.0�*;���"%5��N$�.�&71K�-����

;�"3�*$�"%!CQ65�$�$�V%�J1UM&0�*�)��!c�"%-�Q#�9�$(�)�W�����Q &K+�� � &KM&K�{d¢$(;)��-¡9%�{-��A5���!x�n�%�(Z qK"�!8+)$�1K&KQ &K+)��!c�J�1b�n�

�>A�� ����%QOBI$|10�c1b�MV�;�9)����5�M" «0o &�+�A"{���*9��J10���Q�!C;�P�P���!?&7!�&�+�J&g,V)$�!M�:&0�*���N���*�����������7� �ª9��M&Kd>���M"a&�+��

&7d>$ &7�M")��&7!�$�.�!M$�5�������<!tB } �JBL�"�5��*V�J&7��$(" M")- $�1UP��")�*h��&@��$(" �k5�$�;)��- �"�-^!8+�$�;)��- 9)�

;�")-��J1K&K�Y��J"~�*"¡B�$�-)�J1K"y�*"%-�;�!G&718�*��6!t$�5(�4�A&@�*��!NJ"%-�&�+��&6&7+)�<!,-������$�P�;��{�4!=&�+���V�1b�J10��l�;)��!C�*&��W$�.

!x$�5��<A�|M"%-jV)$����p&0��5����V�1b$�P�1b�J!x!�Z

mE+)� �A���(� �*��5�&�;�1b�J!MQN"%�Jd>�n�DV�17��!?��"�&K��- +��J1b��QN�10��&�+�;�!y$�.\5JAV)�n&�����:"�&���10��!8&W.0$�1{

1b���<"�&7�J1KV�10�J&�J&7��$("�$|.T&�+��F&�+�$�;�P�+�&g$�.6$�"���$�.#&7+)�/BL$�!8&¢�n").K��;��J")5���X[R1b��")5M+��:"�&������<��5J&�;)�� $�.#&�+��

�JA10�n�~�)�� �I5��M"�&�;�1K�)ZT` .0�<10!?&�!C��5�&7�*$�"~$|.K.0��1b!c"��Jd �*"�!x�<P�+�&K!¬�n"�&7$­&�+)�{10��V�;�9)���*5�M"��*"�&K�A���*��5C&�;�A�

9�A5JY�P�10$�;�"�-I$|.E�>A�� ����sr�!g�J�18�*�,d>$�1KYNA")-F+)��!8&7$�18��5JA�E-��C&KA����!#�9�$�;(&�+��*!_���&@�J1�!G+)��.�&�Jd>��,.K1b$�B

!x$�5��<A����!?B,Z�q0"=!?�A5�&0�*$�"L�S&�$��%Q�M"NJ&�&7�JBSV�&��*!TBF�-��¢&7$SV�1b�J!x��"�&R�>A�< M���3r�! &7$(�)�*"HPLd>�:&�+I!C$�5A�<A����!?B

&7+�18$�;�P�+c&�+)�,5�$�"�&K�M"�&T$�.T+��<! �����(�\���J5�&�;�1b�J!JZR`D.0��"���T!C��5J&7�<$�"\!?;�BLBLJ1b�<hA�J!j&�+��,1b��!?;)�:&7!S$�. &�+��

!x��10����!~$|.W���J5J&�;)10��!kVH10�A!C�J"�&0��- 9�� &7+����%$�;�"�P �>��� ���� �<" &�+)��.0��18!8&�&0��1UB $�. �������¤$("

1b���<"�&7�J1KV�10�J&�J&7��$("L$�.��>��� A���Rr�!�!8&K�")-S$("�!C$�5A�<A����!?B§�"�->����9��J10�����!tB/Z

���������������! #"%$'&)(!�#* �,+-�.&/���#�0��12* 3546��879*6:�&.�!&;"=<�>?4@���-A�(�<#�@�-B2<�&DCE���@�=FHGHI?�!&/*@�)G�&J�,K0L��.&/*�+NM

Page 5: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

®

�ÄáË­����Ë Ï È �2Ë���� È Ì°Õ Í����� È ��Í��

�R+����<$�!C$�V�+)�J1bQ{��"�&K�A������5�&�;)A�­+)��!G&7$�18�*�")Q{J"%- +)��!U&7$�18��J" $�. ��5�$(")$�BI��5 J"%- V)$����:&0��5JA�

V�10�5J&7��5J��!xQ(���<���_�>��* J���F�W�������)�W�A�����|��-��J�%$�&@�J-S����H+)��! �M"���1KP��S&7$�&�+%�6!?&�;)-(�L$�.R&�d>$�V�+%��")$�B���")

d6+)��5M+3Q2�<"W")�:"���&7�J�M"�&�+3�K5A��"�&�;�1K�a�2;�1b$(V)�AQ�!t;�V�V)$�1�&7��-�&�+��c�.K.b�*1UBLM&0��$�"kM"�-a&�+��J"W&�+���!tV�18�J�-\$�.

5��*�)�����"�-6V�$)���n&0�45�A��Q�9�;|&)A��!x$j��5�$�"�$�B���5#M")-�!?$�5A�<A�����<9%�J1K&K����!�Z

�>��� J����d6A!MQH&0$�!?&K�1@&7Q3I!M5J1U;�V�;��*$�;�!6�"HA�n�%!?&2$�.O&K+)�L5J+�M")P���!>�n"z!?$�5A�<A�E5�$�"�!M5����M")5J�I�n"

�2")P��nA"�-3Z,`#&2&�+3�j�%�J1K�,9)�JP)�*"�"��*"�P�$�.E&7+)�F5A��"�&�;�1K��QR+)�SV�;�9)�*��!?+���-N&�+)�j&�+�1b�J�����)$)�:;�BI�Sd6$�10Y� O�

���H�t�_���<�����§�9y�����)���J�������M�¢��� �)� �����M���X�)��������W�����à���W������®H� «0o o o Q>�")-§�:" ���à�¯��+)�¡9%�JP�M"§+)��!

BI$("�;�B���"�&�����L�����n�����x�#�������� �����#� ���*�)���2�9! #"��#����$��#�<�>�K���J.�&�;�").K�<")��!8+3��-��Ed>�:&�+L#+��%V�$(&�+��A!C��!xQ

+%�J"�5���.7$|1�&7+c�5��<�!M!x��5S$(")��Q o % 10���*J&7�n"�PN&7$N&�+)�S5J10;�5A�<A�O�:BSV�$�1�&K�")5��S$�.Xi��J&�+)$�-��<!?&'.K��1KBI��"�&O�*",&�+��

-��A�%����$�VHBL�M"�&s$�.3���<9)�J10��)-���BL$�5J10�5�����"j�2")P��<M"%-sZ %

�>��� ����Ld6A!MQ(�)��1��I���18�*�I$|")Q���*!C$L-�10Jd6"L&K$S&�+)�_V�+%�J"�$�B��J"�$�"N$�.3�2;�18$�V)�JM"I!C$�5(�*�����!?B,Z

e>�BI��-NV�10$�.0��!C!x$�1OJ&R&K+%�#�T������� O��&��t�j�)�'�T�)���*�J���A�(�)� ���<�7�*��� ��(�>���=� � �E�2��" �����|�S&7$F&7�J�5J+N&�+)�

���|$��*;�&0�*$�"�$�.jV)$����:&K��5J��6�*-����!,�*"¡�'"�P)�n�"�-�Q +)�\�n�;�"%5J+���-y�*"¡&�+����5��-��MBI�<5��%�J�1 �A���à�A�W�������

�")$(&�+��J1>5�$�;H10!x�,$�"a&�+)�N+��*!?&7$�1���$|.T�2;�18$�V���M"k!t$�5��������!?B,Zª���,A�n&7�J10"��&7��-a9)��&7d6���J"a&�+���!t�N&Kd6$

V�1b$�.0��!C!x��$("����-�;�&0����! .K$�1{�9)$�;|&W&�+)�*1K&<� .0�n�|� �%���1b!�ZN�>��� J���+* !�d>$�10Y�! $(" !C$�5��*�����!8B d>�J1b�

V�;�9)���*!t+���-�QS��"§9�$�$�Y§.K$�1KBIQj�.<&@�J1c+)��!W-��JJ&�+R¥#&�+�;�!\-��<-�&n+3�k5�$����*��5�&7�*$�"§��"�&0�:&0����-, .- �_�t�¡�%�/�

�'0��G�����)���'�#1��g� (���2��,)� �<�_�)�����*�������C�6�>�����*�43 ����C�t�'5 � �V�V)��J1��*" �A�����)Q|�")-S+)��!#d>$�1KY��L���A�:�)���C�

� �)�����*� �����x�6�2�5)�?����6J����7 5 � � A��!C$>V�;�9)���4!?+��A-jV�$�!?&�+�;�BL$(;)!x�n�%Q��<" �A��®)��Z

Page 6: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

mE+)��!��<M&�&���1Ld>$�10Y¡d6�!,V�;�93����!8+)�J-�9��¡&7+��k!t$�5�����&��~$�.j&�+��z[�10����")-�!�$�.j�������a�>��4 A���)Z

�R1b��!M�*-���-,$(���J129����T �����!8&0�*"Nfg$(;�P)�4 (Q�&K+)��!6$�1UP�M"3�*h�M&0�*$�"�* !_P�$���ªd6A!¢&�$NV�;�9)����!?+,&�+)�j¦6")�*�%�J18!x�n&��

5�$�;�18!t�W$("��O;)10$(V)�J�"�!C$�5��*�����!?B &�+)�&6�>��* J����+��-k")$(&6+�A-�&�+���&0�*BL��&K$�d610�n&���;�Vk+��nB�!M���<.0Z

� �J�%�J10��2.K$�10BN��1T!?&K;%-��J"�&@!6$�.X�>��� J���z5�$����<M9�$�1KJ&7��-�$("c&�+)��!>�J-��*&K��$�"E¥��M���"3�<i�J1b5��(���x��M"�")�M")���%Q

�����J1010� �2�10$�l(;%��Q¢�O&@�*�J"�"%��i�M"|&<$�;��)Q_]g$�9��J1K&Lik�1:ux$)���n")Q_9�;�&IA��!t$��.K1b���J"%-�$�.F&7+��­�>A�� M���

.0JBI���4��Q�]gJ��BI$|"%-¡`_10$�"~�@d6+%$¡d6$�;)��-kBFA"�JP%�¬&�+)��V)10$CuC�A5�&>J.�&@�J1j&7+)�{-���J&�+~$|.jf¢$�;�P)�* {�*"

����®����tZ�q0"N&�+)�j.K$�10�Jd�$�1K-)Q|`61b$�"N9�10$�;�P�+�&R;�VN&�+��>-��n.0.0��5�;)�n&��=$�.E&�+��&��!tYHZ�[���10!?&7Q|�>��� ����=���J5J&�;)10��-

.010�����n�\.018$�B^+3�4!F�9�;�")-�M"�&T"%$(&K�A!JZ � ��5�$�"�-�QO.K10$|B �A���¨�,&7$ �A�����a&�+���5�$(;�1b!t�/+�A-a;�"�-��J10P�$�")�

5M+HM"�P)��!MQ_d>�:&�+ &n+)�{+)�*!?&7$�1���$|.�VH1K�5M&0��5���!zP�1UA-�;�A���n� !?;�V�V)�*J"�&@�n"�P�&�+)�a+��*!?&�$�1���$�.I-�$�5�&K10�*"%�(!MZ

[���"�����n�%QE&K+���!?;�9Mux�J5J&T+�A-�"������J1g9����M"k�-�-�1b�J!x!C��-{.K;����:���<"kM"���$�")�=�%�J�1 %0o o o Z'mX+�;�!MQE&�+)� ���(®R�

��-H�:&@�<$�"W.K$�10!M$�$�Y,&�+)�I-��J.K��")�n&@�4�|�N$�;�&0���*"��F&�+�J&2�>��� ����¬+��-�.0$�;�")-c&�+)��&@�<BL�F&<$�-�1U�d ;�V{�*"�&�+)�

!tV�10�<"�PW$�.·�A������J"%-aV�10$�V)$�!?�A-aM"k��-��:&0��-z�%��10!M�*$�"\$(.T&K+)�,5�$�;�10!M��Qª9)�!x�J-W$�"a"%$%&7��!j&��Y��J"W9��

!x$�BN�>!G&�;%-���"�&7!_�*"I�&�&K��"�-��"�5��jM&R&�+�� � ���9��� O� &��?�6�)�'�#�)�A�<�M�)���'� ���9�<�7�<���9��(�>��"N&�+%�&�+)�<1�&@�*��! �")-

$�"k!C$�B����*��5�&�;�1b�J!Ld618�:&�&K�M"k$�;|&#�*$�"�P�+HM"%-a9��W�>��� J�(��-�J&7��"�Pa.K10$�B &7+��N&�;H1K"�$�._&�+���5���"�&�;�1K�)Z

[R;)1�&�+)��1KBL$�18�AQ'&�+%�/�;�&�+�$�1g+H�-�"�$�&�+��-c&0��BL�N&�$W-�1UMd¤;�V{=5J$�"%5��*;)!M�*$�"{.7$�1_&�+)�N5�$�;�18!x�(ZRmE+)�

��-H�:&7$�1b! 9)�A�<�����)��-�QH+%$�d6�J�%��10Q�&K+��&ª�>A�� M����Q�+)�-,�JA10������12.0$�10BF;)���&@�J-N�5�$�")5��:;)!M��$(")Q3��"N&K+��6V��V)�J1

�M"|&7�*&0�*��-��0mO+)�j� 1K=$�.gm'��10J"�"��*��!��bQªV�1b��!x��"�&@�J-/e$%�|��BL9)�J1��������cM& &�+)�j�)������6���6����?����J�����C�L�)�

�2�3�;�����M���'���*�)¥ � $�5�������*!CB +)�-FV�J�|�J-F&�+��>d6J�,.7$H1OBI$�-���1K"N&���10J"�"��*��!g�<"�!t$�.��1OA! &K+)�6&Kd>$,�*-��J�!

&7+��&�.0$�1UB &K+%�{9��!x��!�$�.I!C$�5�������*!CBIQ6��BL�"%5��*V�J&7�<$�"y�"%-�$�1KP��")�*h��&@�*$�")Q_d6�J1b�k�*1U10��5�$�"�5����<M9)���(Z

� �J�%�J10����<$�"�P�5��n&KM&0�4$�")!�.K10$|B�&�+�J&s�*��5�&�;�10�_$�.D�������jd>�J10�#&7+�;)!�10��V�10$�-(;)5A��-S�:"S&�+��_d¢$|1KYL$�.2���(®3�

A!X&�+)�_5�$(")5��*;%!M�*$�"3Z %Ko «

mE+)�#�%�J1@�������1��L�����������C�_�9>�������*�������M�6� �5��C��� 6������� /"��#����$������6MV�V)�J�10�A-�Q�M��J")�<���;)�

� A1�&K10���$���5J��-S+��*!_10�Uux��5�&@�*$�"I$|.'�n&7!_5�$�"�5��:;)!C��$�")Q3$�1OBL$�10�V�1b�J5��*!M���n�=$�.�d6+HM&0Q�+)�j.0���*&0Q�+��-F9%�J�J"

Page 7: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

.0���!C���*��5�$�"%5��*;�-���-�.K1b$�B �>��� �����¥ � � Z*Z*Z���&7$�-�A10��&7$ !C��~&�+)M&I!M$�5��������!tB � �������� ��.K10$|B &K+)��!

5�$�"�&K1K�-���5�&@�*$�")Q�$�"%�d¢$(;��*-j+)��|�#&7$�9%�#;�"��dj�1b�¢&�+��&���-���$���$�P�����!O+)��|�_6-)�n��*��5�&@�<5���H9%�J5A$�BN�*"�P)¨

�"I�A�%$��*�)�*"�PS5A$����*��5C&0�:�)�6d_+%$H�*�� K������� �g.K10$|B �n&7! 5�$("�&�1UA-)�*5J&K��$�")! $(")�*�I�*"F&�+)�6���%��!�$�.ª&�+�$�!t�6d_+)$

9%�(�������|� &�+�J&y&�+)� 5�$("�&�1UA-)�*5J&K��$�")!©�10� .�1b$�hA�J" J"%- ;�"%5�+)M"HP��J�9)��� � %�« Z\mO+)� V�+)���4$�!?$�V�+3��1

5�$�"�5��*;%-��J- &n+HM&,V�A!C!C�P��­&�+�1b$(;�P�+ 5�$("�&71U�-���5¯&@�<$�")!k��!¡�:"�+%�J1b��"�&L&K$ !t$�5��<A����!CB M")- �n&,A��$(")�

P�;H�1U�"�&7�J��!cV�1b$�P�1b��!M!/&7$�d6�10-�¡P��J"�;)�*"�� �05�$�")5J18�M&K�k���*9)�J1@&�� �tZ_q0" 5�$("�"%��5�&7��$("§d>�n&n+ � �1�&710�#* !

��"�&K��1@�|��"�&7�<$�"3Q��:&g�*!&@�nB��(�:��&0$���BSV�+)�!M��h��F&�d6$c&�+)�n"�P%!J¥R.8�*1b!G&@Qs&K+)� ����®)���J-)�:&0�*$�"\��!j�"WJ1�&@�<.K��5��<A�

5�$�")!?&�1K;�5�&b¨�!M�J5�$�"�-)Q��>A�� ���� * ! $�V��:")�*$�"I$�.R!M$�5��<A����!?B d_A!�d>�*&K+�$�;|&�g-�$�;�9�&��*��!x!�1UA-)�*5����&�+�J"S&�+)�

V%�(!t!M�*BI��!G&0��5>5J$�")5��*;)!M�*$�"I$�.��A�����Nd6$(;)�4-,�<���-S;)!�&7$L9������<�M���>J"%-N.K;�1@&�+���1KBI$�10�BLJ�=�:&0!x�(�*.O+�M���

���%V��J1b���M"�5A�J-j"�;�B��J18$�;)!��M��$)�:;�&���$("�!�Z

�U������� * !W5�$�")!U&K�"�&�-��(!8V���*1L&K�Y���!cB��­M9�A5JY)Q �Idj1b$(&0��&�+)�a[R18�M")5M+yV�+����<$�!x$(V�+)�J1N`¢�<A�<"

���2BI�<��� ��+��1�&@���J10�E&7$F['�*$|10��"�5���>��< J���,��" ������� %�«0o Z �Uq7"c&K+)��!T.K��$�$�-I$|.�+�J&7��QH.K;�1���QH�")-F�)��$����M")5��

� $�.#&7+)�=[���10!?& �~$�10��-��y�1��KQ'q>.0����� ��"�;�")-��&@�J-)QO�*$)!G&0Q�!G&�;�"�")�A- � %K«0o o Qª�>��� A���Wd>�!j&0$\5J$�"H.7��!?!S&b$

�>M������1 �X J$�"���" ���à�#��Zª���*!LJ"�A�n�%!M��!Fd6��10�cBL�1UY%��-�9|�\P�10$|d>�:")PWV���!M!C��BL��!tBNQOd_+)��5J+\d6$�;)��-

���&@�J1O9)��ut;)-(P%��-N���%5���!C!C�*�)�S�*",10��P��1b-F&�$F&�+��S-����%���*$�V�BN�M"�&�$�.O!M$�5��*�����!?BIQHA!#d>�����s�!#$�.'����9)�J1UA�

-���B�$�5J10�5��*��!MZ %K«7o o o>e>;�BL�J1b$(;)!����1b�<���J1a&7����&<! 1b���%����,�"©�;�&�+)$�1{BS;%5�+DBL$�1b��9�A�<M")5���- J"�-

M&�&@��"�&@�n�%� &@$&�+)�#�BL9)�<P�;)$(;%! ����!t!C$�")!O$|.3+)��!G&7$�1K�HZ

q8.�$�"%�¡5�J"�$�")�n��!?V���5M;����&@�¡5�$(")5���1K")�n"�Py&�+��~�n�!G&�V�+��!x�¡$�.L�>��� ���� * !�&�+)$(;�P�+�&@!c$�"

�2;)1K$�V)�J�" � $�5��*�����!?BIQ��:&R5JM"�"%$(&)9)�_!CA��-&�$j9)� &�+)�_!t�BI�_5�$(")5���1K")�*"�P6+���!��J�1b������1E!8&K�P���!�Z�q7"F.0A5A&7Q

A�<BI$�!?&6&�+%�zdg+�$�����$�.j+)��!N.0�*18!8&�!M�J18�4�(!I$�.S����5�&�;�1b�J!NP)�:���M"y�&g&�+��N� ���9��� 2��&��t�����/�N�%���������J�2�

�������K�*������2�_9)�M&Kd6���M" �M�"�;�J1K�IJ")-N`gV�10���R$|.­�������,5J�"N9%�j.K$�;�"�-,�*"N&�+���>A�� ����I`6105�+)�*�%��!JZ�mE+)�

�������|��" ���J5�&�;�1b��!c�10�k$�10P�A")�:h���-��*"(&7$y.0$�;�1,��J10P��kP�10$�;�V�!�¥�&�+)�­.0�*1b!G&@Q6$("�[s18���J-�1b��5�+ ����!?&S�")-

£6�J10BLJ"N����!8&K$�1b��5A�<!tBIQ%&7+��>!C��5�$�"�-)Q�$("Lik�1@�|��!?BIQHd6+%��5M+,5J�"N9)�>5�$�"�!M�*-��J1b��-F&�+%�V)�*�%$(&K��HV%$��*"�&

Page 8: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

$�.O&K+)�L5�$�;�18!x�N�*" �����¨�AQH&K+%��&�+)�<10-�QR$�"�J"z�������;HM&0�*$�"¬$�.Oik�1@�|��!?B^�*"�1b�����&@�<$�"�&�$/&�+��LBL$�-��J10"

V�+)��"%$|BL�M"�$�"�$�.25�MV)�*&KA�ª5A$("�5A��"�&71UM&0��$�")QH�"�-,.K��"�����n�%Qs&�+��j.7$�;H1�&�+)Q3$�"/&�+)�j&�10M"3!t.0$�1UBLM&0��$�"�!#&�+�M&

�2;)1K$�V)�J�" � $�5��*�����!?B -���!8V3�*J�%��-S�*"j&�+%��$�1��SA")-S�*"jV�10�5J&7��5J�TJ&�&K+%� &7;�1U"�$�.|&7+)�_5��M"�&�;�1@�)Z

Z f¢��.K$�1b��&�+)�yVH10��!t�J"�&�J&@�*$�" $�.c&K+%�(!t�§�*�A5�&�;�18��!MQF+%$�d6�J�%�J18QLd>��BS;)!G&=9H10���J.0�n� ���)V)����*"

�>A�� �����r�!����10�<�>9)��$�P�1U�V�+��>�")-&�+��T+)��!G&7$�18��5JA��-��¯&7�����!O$�.�&K+)�_5A$("�&7�J��&)$�.�+)��!25�$�;�10!C�(Z

��-�;�5�J&���-L�&)&�+�� �T�J�9�����6���t�_�����T�9���6��M������M��Q(�SA�� ����Ld6�! 6V�+�����$�!C$�V�+)�J1�9|��&�10A�<")�*"�PHZ

]¢��5��*V%���M"�&g$|.T&�+3�cv��P�P�1b�JP�J&7��$(")wW�:"��������)QX+)�,V�J1K&0��5��:V)�&7��-k�*"{&�+%�c1b��"%��d6A�T$|.g")�J$)���>�"�&@�n�"

10�&@��$|"�A����!?B J"%-¡.0$(;�")-��J-{&�+��,� ����������� 6��:���X� 0+�¯� ����W���#�����k���8�-�4�{��*$�"�P�d>� &�+ �>M�)���J1

�� �$�"��")- �� �$("cfg10;�")!t5M+|�|�<PHZ)����!j.7�<1b!G&2&0�*&K����&�$�9)�N$("¬9�$�$�Y�!?+%���n�%��!jd6�!jI18�J.0����5�&7�*$�"¬$�"�&�+)�

�����&@$("��*5k-��<A���J5J&7��5 %Ko % ZTq0" ��������Q#+�$�d>���|�J10Q+%�­9%�J5��BL���n"�&<��10��!U&0��-��*"y&�+��kd6$�10Y�$�. �¯��18��BF�

f¢�J"�&�+��BIQª�")-W�*"c&�+��N+)��!?&�$�1��z$�.#�2"�P�����!8+c]gA-��*5������!8BIQªd6+��<5�+�d6�!&�$�9)�F&�+)�I!?;�9Jut�A5�&�$|.�+)��!

[R1b�J")5M+,-���!?!x�J1K&��&K��$("RZ(fT�I&K+��j&�;�1K",$�.E&K+%�S5��J"�&�;�1@�%Q|����� J���,9%��P�M"�!M�*$�d>�:�N&0$I-���!8&KM")5��j+)�<BL!t���*.

.010$�BDV�;)10�V�+)���*$)!t$(V�+��IJ")-F&<$F.0�*"3-NP�18$�d>�*"�P,�:"�&���10��!b&'�*",��5�$�")$�BN�45j-�$�5A&�1b�:"��J!JZ�mE+)��!T-��<1b�J5M&0��$(")Q

;�")����V)��5�&7��-�$�.TN��$�;�"�P�[R1b�M"�5J+WV�+)����$�!t$�V�+)��10Q25JM"W9)�N�J��V)�<��:")��-a.7$|1T&�+3�,BL$�!8& V)�1@&T9��¬&Kd>$

1b���<M&0��-,�����JBL��"�&0!J¥%$�"/&�+)��$("��>+HM"%-HQH9��I&�+)�j�5M;)�n&��F$�.�+)��!_10�JV�;�9%���*5��",V�$����n&7��5J��R5�$�")!C5����M")5(��Q % %

�")-¡$�"�&�+)�W$%&�+)��1S+�J"%-�Q 9|��&�+��{-���!x!?J&7��!t.K�5J&7��$�"¡+%�a.0���*&Sd>�*&�+yd_+�J&>&�+)��BL��:"yV�1b$�P�1K��!t!M�:�)�

��"�&K�A���*��5M&�;�A�F&K1b�M"�-�!k$�.c+)��!a&0�<B���d¢��10��5�$�"(&K10��9�;�&@�n"�P &7$ 10��.7����5J&7��$(" $("�5J$�")5J1b��&7�����*9��J1K&��Rr�Q

��!tV���5A�<A���:�\5�$�")5��J1K")�*"�P\�4&@!S��5�$�"�$�BL��5/�"�-\!t$�5��<A���!8V��A5�&0!MZ�mE+)�<!L$�9�!C��1@�%�&@��$("���!j9H1K�!G+��:�\�<A��-

$�;|&��:"�+��*!1b�����*��d $�.X&�+��j9�$�$|Y,9����¯$�+�"c�$(9%!C$("�QE�����S�)�����*��� ���?��&����J� 5 5 � ¥)v�qK&���!6FV�1b$�.0$(;�")-

;�")-��J1b!G&7J"%-��n"�P $�.�V)$����:&7��5J����J5�$�"�$�Bj� &K+�M&������$�d>!�i�18ZS��$|9%!C$(" &K$D!8V����Y �9)$(;�&z!C$�5A�<A�

5�$�"�5���1�"3!2�*"F10��P�$�18$�;)! �*J"�P�;�JP%��Q(�"�-j&7$S��!C5JMV��#.�18$�B 9�$�&�+j&�+��_.0$�10BL�����!CB§$�.��>J"�&7�<M"L-�$�5�&K1b�*")�

Page 9: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

$�"��<�d§M")-F&�+3�>!t$�BL�J&7�<BL��!#�9%!?&�1UA5J&KQ�!?$�B��A&7��BL�J!_B���&7JV�+)$�10��5����Q|.7$|1KBL�����!?B¤$�.O5�$("�&7��BSV%$�1U�1@�

!x$�5���$���$�P(�|QEJ"�-a.7�<"�A���n�%QO��")!?&����-a$�.T1b��.K;�&0�*"HPz$�1_-���.K��"�-��*"�PWJ9%!G&71UA5�&T&�+)��$�1@�\$�"�&�+)�,10�<P�+|&<!S$�.

BL�"3QJ&0$>10�A�|��!t��Q�5J$�BSV)����&7��Q�$|1s�n"�!C$�BL�g!C�M"3!t��Q��(�J�D���7���<�3Z w(% %Ko o

]g$�;�P�+��4��9%�J&�d¢���M"c&�+����%���18! �A�����,M"�-��A�����)QH�>��� C���¬����V��*$�1K��-,&�+)�SBF��:"�!?&�10M")-�!_$�.

��5�$(")$�BI�*5L��-���A!JZ����S!8&�;%-H�4��-=&n+)� �T�n�!?!M�45�A�E�A5J$�"%$�BN��!8&0!_M")-N&�+)�j;�&7�����:&K�18��J")! % %0o o o QH&�+%�L!C$�5��*�����!?&

A!CV���5M&�$|.R&�+)�¢]¢��5J�18-����M"N+)�J10�*&K�P�� % %7o «0Q�&�+)�6i{A1����<!CB $�.Eik�1K�,�"�-F+��*!T�JV)��P�$�")��!MQ�ik�1UP%�n"�A�K�K!CB

��!tV���5A�<A���:����"/&�+)�S`g;)!?&�1b�*�",�)�J1b!C��$("�A-(��$�5�J&���-N9������1b�si���"HP��J12�"�-N�O;)P���",f���+�BI��f_�d6��1UY%Q

�")-�&n+)����5�$(")$�BI��5a��-��J�!,$�._&�+3� � A�*"�&0� � ��BL$("��*J")! % %K« ZXq0" ��������Q�+)�cV�;�9)����!8+)�J-kc�)��1@�~��$|"3P

�1@&@��5(����Q��0m�+%���s18�*")5��*V)����!_$�.2&�+)������!?&�18�*9�;�&@�*$�"�$�.X� �J��:&7+ �tQR�*"c&�+��_� � ��)�j��� � 6��:���'�20������9��F���

�%� �k���G������QEI!x$�1@& $�. BL�")�<.7��!G&7$W�:"Wd_+��*5J+�+)�N-��M���J��$(V%��-c+)��!>$�d_"\�J5A$("�$�BL��5N��-����!JZWq0"z&�+)�

!t�BI���%��J1bQE�*"�&�+��N!M�*P�"���-��J"�&K1��z.0$�1 �KV�$����:&0��5JA�2�J5�$�"�$�BS� �g�*"W`_")-�10 ��A�<�"�-���r�!������J�+&���:���*�M�

���A�����3���9�� �A���2�C�K�����9��§�)� �:� �O�)�J�<���x���E������QN+3�§!M�*P�")��.K��5J�"�&0�:�¤V�1b$(V�$�!t��-©&�+)� .K$����<$�d>�*"�P�¥

� � ��$)���n&@�<5�A�R��5J$�")$�BS����! � � 5��<��"�5��j+)M���:"�P,�!6�:&@!_P�$(A�ªA"c;�"�-��J1b!G&7M")-��n"�P=$�.E&K+)�jV�+%��")$�B���")

�")- �0�*.a&K+)�§"�J&�;)10� $�.a&�+3��!M��V�+��M")$�BL�M"H§��<��$�d .0$�1��n&7Q/d6+���5J+ ��!y;�"%-��J1�-��M9)�&7��Q:�{&�+��

-��A&<��1KBI��"�J&7�<$�",$�.O�*�d>!g5J$�"%5J��1K"��:"HPL&�+)�>-��*!?&K10��9�;�&0��$�",$�.Ed��JA�n&7+N�!Td6�����sA!_�:&7! V�18$�-�;�5�&@��$(",M")-

5�$�")!?;�BSV�&0�*$�")Q��n"�!t$,.KJ12�!#&7+���!x�V�+)�J"�$�BN��"�j�10�L���:"�Y���-=&7$,�*&�!_-)�*!?&�18��9�;�&@�*$�" �tZ % %�«0o �>;�1b�*"�P/&�+��

A5��-��JBI��5j�%�J�1°�A�������W��������QH+)�S9��JP�M",&7$,!C�M"3!t�j&�+�J&�L!C��"�P����Sd>$�1UY�$�"��A5J$�")$�BN��5SM"�-�!C$�5��<A�

-�$�5�&K10��"���!_d>$�;)�<-N"%$%&'-�$H¨R�*")!G&@�J�-�Q�+)�j9)1K�"�5M+)��-,$�.U.O&b$�d6�10-N&�+%�L!G&�;�-���$�.25�$�"%5�10��&7��V�10A5A&<��5���!CQ

��"SV�J1K&0�45J;)�<�18Q�$�.H&K+)$�!t�6�*"S�O"�P)�nA"�-HZ¢mX+�;�!MQ��*" �������6+���!X&�d6$S�1�&0��5����J!2$�"ji���&�+)$�-���!CB��V�V%���1b�J-�Q

V�1b�J5�;�18!t$�1b!�&7$c&�+%�c.0�*18!?&T�|$��n;�B��,$�._+��<! �L�����*�����C�N�� ������ �4���_� �-�n�)���S�9 /"���QOd_+)��5J+\d6$�;)��-

�V�V��JA1R!M�:�S�)�J�1b!����&@�J1 % %K«0o o Z

Page 10: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

mE+)� �A���¨���W�A���(� 5�$�;�10!C��d6A!{&�A;�P�+�&�-�;�18��"�P 5�1�;)5��<A�FV)��10��$�- �:" &K+%�y+)�<!8&7$�1@� $H.

� $�5A�<A���*!CBIQjBL�1UY%�J- �*"��2;�10$�V��k9���&�+)�{]¢���)��!C��$("��*!G&/5J1b�4&@��l(;��yM")- 9|� &�+��¡�R�10���JBL�J"�&7J1b�*�"

&@�JBSV�&KM&0��$�"3ZHqK"�[R1U�"�5J��Q3&�+)�S!CJBI�SV)�J1b�*$�-,d6�!A��!t$�-�$�BI�n"�M&7�J-,9��,S�)JP�;3�L-���!C��10�F.0$�1 ;�"��*$�"

9%�A&�d¢�(�M" 18�:�%��S!t$�5��<A����!?&�P�1b$(;�V)!�¨gJ&S&�+)�k�*"�&K�A�����J5M&�;�A�S���J�%�(��Q#&�+)��!�d6�!�5M+)J10�5M&K��10��h���-�9|�~�"

��BFV%$�1@&��"�&SAd6JY%�J")�*"�P¡+%��1K��<-���-¡9��%Q_.0$�1I�J���BFV��*��Q &�+)�Wl�;)��5JY¡&71KJ")!x�<M&0��$(")!MQTJ.�&7��1 ��������QT$�.

i�J1K��* !#BLA�<"N&@�4&@�*��! % %K«Ko o o�$�1E&�+)�1b�<P%$�1O$�.ª&7+)�"%��d�J"�A�n�%!M��! VH17$�V�$�!C��-F9�� �¯�JJ" �xJ;�1��A!CQ3£6��$|1bP���!

� $�10����$�1 �2;)5�����"W�>�J101 % %0o %tZ3�2BI�����Ff¢$(;�&7B��%Qª&7+)�J"W-)�n1b��5A&<$|1¢$�. &7+)�������9��� 2��&|�t�,���(�L�%�����J�)��� �

�������K�*������2�AQ(V�1b$(V�$�!t��-S&�$��>��* J���%Q|d6+%$Fd6A! �&R.0��10!?&R10���*;)5�&KM"�&@Q(&K$L-�$F65A$(;�1b!?�>$("I!t$�5�������*!CBIQ��n"

&7+�� � 5J+�$�$H�Kr�!j"��Jd��:�W.0$�1KBI��- �@�(5�$(")$�BI��5FA"�-W!C$�5��<A� �6!x�(5M&0�*$�")Q�$�V��M")�J-W�<"ã�A�����sZ�mE+%�j�T�J�9����Q

.0$�;�")-��J-k�*"{&�+��cA.<&0��1UBLM&K+�$�._&K+)�,[R1U�"�5A$��7�R10;)!t!M�*J"{���10Q A�<BI��-{M&gV�18��!C�M"|&7�*"�Pk,V�$)!C�*&��n�|��!8&

�V�V�18$��5�+N&�$,��-(;%5��&@�*$�"��:",5A$("�&7�JBSV)$�10J10�LV3$����:&K��5JA��Q)��5J$�")$�BI�<5AQ|�"%-,!C$�5��<A�3V�+���"�$�BL�J"� % % % Z�`_&

&7+��N&�;�1K"\$�. &�+��N5A��"�&�;)1���Q��n"W&�+)��!j&�1UA-H�p&0�*$�"�����*�\���<9���1K���!C5J+%$�$)��d_+%�J18��!t$�5��<A�2��5J$�")$�BI�<5A!�d6�!

9%�(��"HPk&KM;)P�+�&S9��~.K$�����$�d>�J1b!c$�.>[R18 A-� J18��5 �2�a������|Q % % %Ko k!CV%�J5��*��>�:"|&<��10�A!G&�d6�!c�5�5�$�18-��J-�&@$

d>����.K�1b� !C$�5��<A����!?B � �@!M$�5��������!?B�� -��^�<^5J+���n1b��b�0Q d6+)��5M+3Q��*" £6��1KBLJ"��%Q¡+�A- �����$�d6��-

1b���)$)�:;�&���$(")J1K� !M$�5��<A����!tB &7$�9%�y-��J.K;)!M��-3Z_�>�M"�5���QS�:&/�<!k�*"�&�+)��!aV%��10!tV)�J5J&7�n�%�¡&�+��&Lfg$�;�&7BS�

�M"|&�10;�!?&��A-a�>��� ����\d>�n&�+W&�+%�/9�;�10-��M"k$�.g�!M��18����!L$�.6�������|��"�����5�&�;�10��!JZRq0"k$�1K-)�J1_&7${!8&�;�-(�W&K+)��!

BI$�-���1U" -�$�5�&K10�*"���NV�+��J"%$�BL�J"�$�" �"�- �n" $�10-��J1c&@$�J�)$)�*-§"��&@��$("������!?&I;�"%-���1�&0$�")�J!MQL�:&�d6�!

�M"|&7�*&0�*��- �0mE+)�#�O�%$H��;|&7��$("I$�.3��5J$�"%$�BI�<5_�")- � $�5��n�� ��$�5A&�1b�*")�6�n">�2"�P��<M")-S�"�-L£_��1KBL�"����<"S&�+)�

� �A5J$�")-��>A�<.>$�._&K+)�ce��:")��&7���J"�&�+ �T�J"�&�;�1K�3Z �Sq7"y.K�5M&bQ �<")!8&K1K;)5C&0��$("�d6�!F&7${9%�zP�;)��-��A-{9��{&�+)�

�"HA�n�%!M��!2$|.H&7+)�6£6�J10BF�"LBL$�-��A��Q(A"�-�Q�!C��P�")��.0�<5�M"�&@�n�%Q(�>��� J�����!?Y%�(-S.7$|13&�+3�T+����:VL�"%-�P�;)��-��"�5��

$�. �T (�4��!G&@�n"{f¢$�;�P��� �Q�[s1K�"���$���! � �*BI�<M")-�Q J")- �O;%5����J"k�>��1K1?Z % % %Ko o mE+��W5�$�"�&7��"�&�$�.6&�+3��!,.8��1t!?&

5�$�;�18!t�,d6�!MQO�*&g!t���JBI!MQª&�+)�,.K$)����$�d>�*"�P3¥2���_q0"�&�18$�-�;%5�&7��$("3¨��)�#[R1b����-�18��5J+ �T��!?&TM")-c&�+��N")�&@�*$�"�A�

V%$H���n&@�*5���2��5�$(")$�BS�)¨O���gmE+���£_��1KBL�"c����!G&�$�10��5J�� � 5M+)$�$��K¨R®��_i\�1�����!CB �"�-c����:;)�F&�+���$�1K�3¨2���

Page 11: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

`g;)!?&�1b�<�"N����n;)�6&�+)�J$�1K�,�"�-,�:"|&<��10�A!G&R&�+)��$�1��3¨����O&�+)�6BLJ&7��10�<A����!8&'5�$(")5���V�&7��$(",$�.E+)��!G&7$�1K�3¨)���E&�+3�

i�J1K�)��!G&k&�+���$|1�� $�.k&�+�� BL��1KP)�*")P M")- 5�$("%5���"�&71UM&0��$�"^$�.~5�JV%�n&KA�@¨W��� �T$�"�5��M"�&K10�&@��$�" �*"

�P�10��5J;��:&�;�18�TM")-S�*")-(;�!?&�1K�)¨����H¦>"���$("��*!CB,¨Q����� � $�$�V���1KJ&7��$�"3¨�J"�- ����� � &�J&7� � $�5��������!?B,Z % % %0o o o

mE+)�Sd6���+)�>9)�JP��",&�+)�L5�$(;)10!C�FA���4$|d¢�J-/�>A�� ����,&7$c���*BN�*&��*"�!?&�1U;%5J&K��$�"c&7$=&�+)��!?&�;%-(�¬$�.

£6�J10BLJ"z!C$�5A�<�����!tB,¨��n"¬")�n"%�J&����M"�&�+)�05��J"�&�;�1@�¬£6��1KBL�"(�%QEL&K1b�nV����F1b�JA5�&0�*$�"¬+��-z.0$�10BI�J-��P���*")!8&

&7+��§�:")-��*�)��-(;������!?BIQL1UM&0��$�"������!tBIQF�"�- ")$�")�U�*"�&7�J1K�)�M"|&7��$("��*!?&�V�$�����5��D$�.�&�+�� �'"HP%���<!t+D���*9%�J1UA�

V%$H���n&@�*5������5J$�")$�BS�HZL¦6")-���1X&�+%�S�:"�.0��;)��")5��j$�.E����P����|A"�-F[s��5M+�&K�AQ|"�M&0��$("���<��!CB 10$�!t�6;�V,�P���*")!8&

5�$H!tBL$�V�$����:&K�"\�*"�-)�4���4-�;�����<!tBIQE��BSV)�*18��5J��!?B^d6�!�!C��&g�*"\MV�V)$�!x�n&@�*$�"�&�$W-���-�;�5J&7�n�%�/10M&0��$("������!?BIQ

�")-��*�!G&@�:�)QR�<"�&7�J1K�)�M"|&7��$(")��!CB¤V�10��!C�M"|&<��-��:&0!t���*. ��"W�n&7!6!C$�5A�<A�<��!G&2.0$�10B �K�10P�;)BL�J"�&7!.7$|1 �n&2+�M���n")P

9%����"�9�$�1K1b$�d>�J-¡.K10$�B &7+��W.K$�;�"�-���18!,$�.���5�$�"�$�BN�45{���*9)�J1UA����!CB �n"~$�10-��J1j&7$­&n;�1U"¡&n+)�JB 9��5�Y

�P����")!?&�&�+��JBL�tZ�`65�5�$�10-��*"�Pj&7$�>A���M����Q�6!x$����*-S!?&�;%-(�)Q�5��J"�&7�J1b�J-�$("S&�+��_��BLBL��"�!t� �b!C$�5�������<!?&)�")-

��"�&K��1@�|��"�&7�<$�")��!?&{10���5�&0��$�"�w�Q % % %0o « d6�!�V%$�!C!x�*9)�<�D�:"^!t$ .K�1k�!yik�1�����!?&\-�$�5�&�1b�*")��Q/9��!M��5���K�<�

!8��"�&�+)��&7��5�QHd>$�;)��-�QHJ&X$(")�SV�$��*"(&@QHv�5J1��|!G&7������*h���wS&�+��L!t$�5��<A����!8&OBI$(�)�JB��J"�&0Z/qK&2d>$�;)�4-HQH+%$|d¢���)��10Q

9%�#")��5(��!C!C�1K��Q(&7$SBI���!G;)10�#&�+��_.0��5�;�"�-)�:&���$�.3i\�1�����!CB,Q�&0$S����V�;�10P�M&0�6�*&�$�.E�:&@! �7�V)$�5JA�n��V|&7��5_M")-

;�&7$(V��*J"I�����JB���"�&7!��8Q % % %K«Ed6+%��5M+I5�$(;)��-S9��6�J��V)�<���")�J-L�! 5��:1b5J;)BL!G&7M"|&7����KZj[s$�1E�>��������|Q(i��1U���K!CB

$�.0.0�J10��-�Q�����M�)�*"�P�!C$�BL�g���)�P�P��J10�&@��$(")!�A!C��-���Q�_1b�J�����!U&0��5TV3�*5J&�;)10�_$�.3A����&K+%�_BFbut$|1�;�V�+)��J��A��!2$�.

&7+��_BL$�-��J1K"L��5J$�"%$�BN��5g!?��!8&0�JBIQ�M")->�n&��J�%�J"L����*$�d6��-j.0$�1���B�V�+��!t��!2$(" �b5��J1K&KA�n"�5�+��1K�5�&0�J1b��!G&7��5A!

$�.R&�+)�_V%$����:&0��5J��H��5�$("%$|BS�I$�.3�';H10$�V%�j�*"j&�+)�65��M"|&n;H1��S&7+��&'�*! 9%�JP)�:"�")�*"�P �xZ % % %K«0o��#�%��1�J"%-N�9)$����

�*&K!L-�$�5�&K10�*"��� !x��-���Qªik�1@�|��!tB ���!t$aA����$�d¢�J-W.0$�1#&7+)�/V�1b�J-)�*5J&7��$("\$�.#&�+)�N&0�<B��Nd6+)��"�!C$�5A�<A����!?B

�bd>�<���ª+�J�|�j&K$,!8;�9HBI�:&E&�$,P�$%�%�J10"�BL�J"�&7��R$�V�V�$�1�&�;�"3��!tB �tZ % % %K«Ko oNqK",&K+%��!#"%��d�&���V)�S$�.25J�V)�n&7����K!?B=Q

+%$|d¢���%��10Q3d>$�;)��-,��5�$("%$|BI�*5S1b�JP�;)���&@�*$�"N9)�jV�1b�*")5��*V�����*�,;�")�*"�&7��"�&7�<$�"���ªM")-N9�1b$(;�P�+�&'$(",9��N&�+)�

!tV�$("�&7�"���$�;�!�9)��$�$�BI�*"�P $�.=5($�$(V)�J10M&0�:���J!xQj$�1,d6$�;)��-§�4&�1UM&K+%��1,9%�y�:"�&7�J"�&0�*$�"�A��Q6BLJY)�*")Py�"

Page 12: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

��"�5J1b�J�!t�*"�P)�:� ��J10P��{V)���5J�{.0$�1S&K+%�{!8&KM&0�a�"�-~�n&7!/�-(BI�<")��!G&71KJ&7��$�"�� ��� �{d>�����6$�V�&S.7$|1 � &7�&@�

� $�5A�<A���*!CB��0QNdj1b$(&0���>��< J���H¨ �8�"3- d>�§d>�<���c5�$�"�!x��-���1a&�+)�&Wd¢��dS�����/+�M���§���J�1K")��-©.K1b$�B

!x$�5��<A����!?B &�+�J&�P�$(�)�J10"��:")P�&�+����J5�$�")$�BI�*5�d¢$|10��- �<!{")��5���!M!?�1�� �tZ % % %�«0o o o ` .0�*")��,l�;)��!¯&@��$�"�Q

+%$|d¢���%��10Q2-��MBFA"�-��A-a.�;�1K&K+%�J16!?&�;%-(��¥H&K$W�J��A�*;�J&7� � � Z�Z*Z �_��"{dg+�J&�}­�:")5J10���!M�:")P\�#BI�J�!?;�1b�N&�+)�

V�;�9)���*5g��5J$�"%$�BS�>BF;)!8&)BI��1KP%�_d>�:&�+>&�+)� � &KM&7�_��5�$("%$�BS� �tZ % % %0o %

��á���Ï Ë�� Ë�� � È Ì�aË È ��� �2��Ì

[R1b$�B &K+�� ����®���* !k$�"3QS�M����"�&�+%$�;�P�+ �K&�+)� -�10�JAB $�.�£6��1KBL�"§;�")�*&<� ��!W9)��5J$�BI�:")P

5����JA1 �GQ %� V)1K$�V%$("���"�&0!>$�. N")M&0�*$�"�A����5�$�"�$�BS�)Q�!?;)5M+a�!6[E10���J-�10��5�+ ����!G&@Qª�"�-��-�+���18�M"|&7!_&7$¬&n+)�

����!G&7$�18��5�A� � 5J+�$�$���Q2!?;�5�+k�!S� ���<+%���nB ]g$�!C5M+���10QXfg10;�"�$a������-��J9�1UM"%-HQ �>�18���>")����!MQX�")-{���&@�J1

£_;)!8&��� � 5M+�BL$�������10Q>-��<1b��5�&7�J-�&�+����*1�.0�n1b!G&=$�.K.0�J")!M�n�%�kJP���*"3!8&S&�+)��&7�JA5J+)�*"�P�!W$�.F&K+)�{�O")P����*!?+

�T�<A!C!x��5J�� ��5�$�"�$�B���!?&�!JZ�`65�5A$�18-��n"�PW&�$a�>��* J����Q2�n&gd6�!LJ"\$�.0.K��")!C�*�%�/&�+�J&7Q��*"k!8V��:&K��$�._¬.0�Jd

��"�&K��18��!G&@�n"�P~�MV3�*!x$�-���!xQ#.KA������-�Q#.0$�1S&K+)�WBL$�!?&>V��1@&@Q#.0$�1j&Kd¢$ 10��A!C$�"�!�¥ $�"y&�+��\$("%�a+)M"�-)Q &�+)�

£6�J10BLJ"L1b�JA5�&0�*$�"L10��BL��*"%�J-j&7$�$S5��*$�!x� &7$j&�+)�_����")��!�$�.R&�+)$(;�P�+�&�$�.��:&0!2�-(�%��10!C�1b�<�A!�¨�$�"S&�+)�_$(&�+%�J1

+��"�-�Q)�:&Ed6A!�")���%��1E�9��*�¢&7$L5�$�"�5����:���6_&�1K;��6��:&K��1U"�J&7�:�)�_&7$�&�+�� �T���!x!C��5JA�ª��5�$�"�$�BL��5�!CQ�d6+)��&�+%�J1

��"j&���1KBI!�$�.35A$�"�5��JV�&7�*$�"�$�.HgBN�J&�+)$�-�Q�$�.HT&K+)��$�1K�%Q�$|1����|��"L$�.�6-�$�5J&�1b�n"%�(Z

fT�L$�V�V%$�!M�*"�PS+)��!X&�+)�J$�1���$|.3&�+3�TV�$�d>��10! $�.3V�1b$�-�;�5M&0��$("S&7$j&�+%�¢&n+���$�1K�I$�.��J�)5M+HM"�P%�J�9)���

�%��*;)��!S�-�$(V�&7��-c9�� � BI�:&K+)Qª]�*5�J1b-�$W$�1#i���*&K+�;�!MQ ����!G&g��BSV�+��!x�*h���-z&n+��,-)�n.0.0�J10��"�5��L9)��&Kd¢�J�J"

V�;�9)���*5��aA"�-©V�1b�:�)�&7���0!C��5J&7$�1��J5�$�"�$�BL���J!MQ,�")- 9%�J&�d>���M" �")�&@�*$�"�����"%- §5�$�!?BL$�V%$����*&��"

��5�$(")$�BS�#%� opZ ����!G& * !y�A5J$�"%$(BI��5 "��&@�<$�"������!8B "���5(��!M!t�n&��&K�A- &�+%� �-�$�V�&0��$("D$�.�&�+)������!8&�$�1b��5J��

BI��&�+�$�-�Q�6B��A&n+)$�-j&�+��&'�*��->+)�<B§&K$L!t�J�%�J1UA�3.K1U;)�*&�.K;)�3-���!C5�$%�%�J1b����!JZ6qK&R18�M���J�����-j&�+)�g�J�)��!U&@��")5��6$�.

!t;)5J5���!M!C�*�%�¡!U&K�P)��!�$�.I5(�:�|�����*h�M&0�*$�")Q_d6+)��5J+ d6$�;)��-¡V)10$�BSV�&S&n+3�WV)$���� &@��5��<�"�&�$ d6$�10Y &7$�d6J10-

Page 13: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�¯�

!8&K10;�5�&�;�1b�J-I-����)���4$�V�BN�M"�&0ZNqK&OA��!M$L-��JB�$("�!G&K1K�&0��-F&�+HM&���"�-�;)!?&�18�*��R��-�;�5J�&K��$�"3Q)�J!tV���5�������4�L&7JY)�*")P

&7+��,.K$�1KB $�.TVH1K�P�BL�&@�<5,V)1K$�&���5�&@�*$�")��!8B^�-�JV�&7��-z&�$W5�$�"�5�10�J&���!M� &�;�J&7�<$�"3!xQO��!&�+)�N9%��!G& &7$�$�� .7$�1

��5�$(")$�BI�*5,P�$(�|��1�")BL��"�&bZ¡[��*")����:�)QO�*&g!?+)$�d>��-z&�+�J&�&�+)�F�2"�P����<!8+�!G;)5�5���!t!Sd6�!j&�+)�,10��!8;)�n& $|.T

�|��10�*&K�9)���_!G&71UM&0��P(��¥�&7+)�65J$�B�9)�n"�M&0��$�"L$�.R6.0�������*9��*�#&���V)�_$�.�+)��-�-��M"SV�1b$(&7�J5J&7��$("��*!CB§J"%-S65��*�J�%�J1

.010�����U�M�)5J+�M")P��_V�18$�VH�P��"�-��Q�9)$(&n+,5�$�"�!M��!8&7��"�&@�n�I�*BLV3�4��B���"�&7��-sZL`6.�&0�J1R&K+)��! d6�! �V�V)10��5����&7��-�QH�:&

�V�V��JA10��-�&7$ � �*!?&3&�+�M&�+��M")5��J.0$�1K&K+S&�+��6P)$���H$�.RV�$����:&0�45J��R��5�$�"�$�BS�Ld>$�;)��-I5J$�")!C��!8&��*" �b-��J.0�*"3�*")P

&7+��L5J$�"%-��:&0�*$�")!g$�.2�A�|��!8&0�M")5J�L.0$�1��"c�����(�)���>���M�-�;� 0c�����C�6�9�E�����<�*��� �GQ %� o o)!8V)��5���.<�)�*")P�5�$(")-��*&7�<$�"3!

V�1b$(V�� &0�4$�;)!X&7$�&�+)�g$(V�&K��BL��H10������<h�J&7��$("�Q��*"I!GV�A5���"�-L�*"S&K��BL��Q�$�.3&K+)�6�*"�&7�JP�1KM&0��$("L$�.�����HV�$�d6�J1b!

$�.2V�10$�-(;%5A&7��$("��"�-,J"��,V%$��<�:&@�<5����QH9�;�&O�9�$(�|��A����Q3�"(�,P)�A$�P�1K�V�+)��5S5�$�"�-��*&0�*$�"%!�Zcq0"¬!8+�$�1�&0Q��K&�+3�

��-��J��T��!SJ"kM;�&7$�")$�BL$(;)!S"�M&0��$(")Q2!?;�V�V�����BL��"�&���-W9��\�5�$���$("��n���-�$�BF��:"3Q2-��J�%����$(V��:")P�d>�n&�+)�*"

�*&K!x���<.N&�+��¡!?&�1b$(")P���!G&IV�$�!x!C�*9)��� �:"|&<��P�1UM&0��$�" $|.N&�+���V)$�d6�J1b!{$�.,V�1b$�-(;)5�&@�*$�"3¨6&�+��yBL�J�")!{.K$�1

1b�JA���<h��n"�P�&�+)���*-)�JA�#�4!jVH10$(&7��5J&K��$�"3��!?B,¨R&K+)�,BL��&�+�$�-�.b$�16����|�n")PW$�;�& &�+%�c��-��J��2M")-a-��A�<��BL�n&@�:")P

V�1b$(&7�J5J&7��$("I��!X&�+%�¢����!G&7$�1b��5�A��BL�J&�+)$�-H¨)!8;%5J+,�*! ����!?& * ! -�$�5�&718�*")�(Z � %� o o o Z�mE+��6.0�*18!?&�-�$�5J&�18�*"%�¢&7$L5J���J�1

�"¡;�"%-���!G&�;�1U9%��-{&K��1U1K���")Q ����!G& * !,!?;�.0.K��10��-¡.�1b$�B 5��J1K&���*"yP�JV%!/�"%-¡!8+%$|1�&@5�;�&�!JZ `¢5�5J$�1b-��*"�P{&K$

�>A�� ����%Qj+)$�d6�M�)�J1bQS�:&,d6�!W"3$�"��J&�+)������!M!{�*"�")$(�%J&7�n�%�y$�" &7d6$�V)$��*"�&@!J¥6��"�&0�J1K�%��"�&7�<$�"3��!tB �")-

+)��!G&7$�1b��5���!tB/Z � +%$�;)�<-Wd6�c�5J5��MV�&gd>�n&�+�$�;|&g10��!t��1���J&7��$("{&�+��,&�+)��!M��!N!8&KM&0�:")P�&�+��& ����!8&_d6�!�&�+)�

V�1b�J5�;�18!t$�12$�.3&Kd>$LBN$(�%��BL�M"�&7!�&�+�J&sd>$(;)�*-L9��>-�$�BI�*"��"�&RM&R&�+)�>��"%-F$�.3&K+)�_")�*"��J&��A��"�&�+I5��J"�&�;�1K�

��"N£g�J10BF�"���¥ � &KM&0�6!t$H5��<A����!CB M"�-Sd6���*.K�1b�6!C$�5�������*!CB �­[ª$�1s�>��� ����)Q�&7+)��! d6A!X�|�J1��I-��M9HM&KM9)����Q

9%��5J�;%!?��9)$(&�+ ���<!?&br�!,�J5�$�"�$�BI��5�V)!?�%5�+)$���$�P(��A"�-k+���!N1b�J.0����5�&0��$�"�!,$�"k&�+%�{�J"%-�!,$�.>V3$���� &0��5JA�

��5�$(")$�BS�=J1b�SBF;%5�+¬����Y���&n+)$�!C�S$�. � BI�*&K+,�"�-F]¢��5JA1K-�$HZ�mE+%�F��BSV�1b$(����BL�M"�&2$�.25�$�"�-��:&0�*$�")!g$�.

-���!G&718�*9�;�&@�*$�",�10�S")$(&OSV�A1�&�$�. ����!G& * !6JP%��"%-|AQR!M�:")5��F$�"3�:��P�10$�d_&�+¬�n"�V�1b$�-(;)5M&0�*$�"IVH10��$�5J5�;�V��*��!

+)��B/¨�V)1K$�P�10��!t! �*"L5M;3�:&�;�1b��Q�5��n�%���<�*h��&K��$�"3Q�J")-SBL$�1K����:&��I$�")�n��+�J�%�_BL��J")�*"�P��n"L+%��!2!G�)!8&0�JB d_+%�J"

&7+����¬�10�,!C;�9%$|10-��*"�J&<�F&K$�P�18$�d_&�+\�:"WV�$�d6�J1tZ{q0"\.��5�&bQ3�>��� J���z!?;)BSBL�10�<h��A-�Q �.����!G&�d6�"�&0!6&�+)�

Page 14: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

V%$H���n&@�*5��*J"k&7$¡d6$�10Y{&0$¡BL�Y���W18������n&�� �I$|.6&K+)�WP�1b��M& � �T$�BLBI��105(�*�� ]g�MV�;�9)����5Jw�Q�&�+%� �8����P�A�

.b��5A&7��$(" �R�*BL�P���")�J-j9�� � BI�n&�+3Z %� o «

mXAY��*"�Pj&�;�1K"3��$|.0��&�+3�A�U5���"�&�;)1��I£6��1KBL�"LV�+�����$�!?$�V�+��L�!X&7+�����1O!x$(;�1b5J��Q�M")-FBLA�*")�n�S��JP�����Q

V�1b$(V)$�"��J"�&7!L$�._+)��!G&7$�18��5���!?B -���")$�;�")5���-z&�+)��5J$�"�.K;)!x��$("k$�. *A9)!G&K10A5�&tr �"3- �5�$(")5�17�A&<�|r �"�-\$�.

��*�dLr J")- *"�$�10B�r �<"W&�+��,10�&@��$("���<��!tB $�. &K+)�NV%$H�4�n&0�45J�����5J$�")$�BS�\$�. ]6��5J�10-�$HZR`¢5(5�$�1b-��n"�P�&K$

�>A�� ����%Q�5($�B�V��J&7�n"�P¬BL�J&�+)$�-�!S$|.�10�(!x�J�105J+z$("�&�+��F&�1U;%�,�<�d>!j$�.T���|$H��;|&7��$("Wd6$�;)��-/&7JY%�F&�+)10���

!t;)5J5���!M!C�*�%� .0$�1UBI!¤5�+��10�5J&���10�<hA��- 9|� -��<.K.0��1b�J"�&�V)��18��$�-�!¤$|.�+3��!?&�$�10��5A�<!8&§1b��!C��J1b5�+�¥Wd>�n&K+

]g$�!x5�+)��18Q %� «�10��!t���1b5�+I$("IP��M"���1K��3��Jd>! .0$�1R&�+)�g-����)����$(V�BI�J"�&R$�.�"��&@��$("�!MQ�d>�*&�+F������-��M9H1K�"%-SJ"�-

�>")����!MQEIV�18$�V)$�!?���$�.TP)�J"%��1K�� �*�d>!S.K$�1#&�+3�,-����)�A�<$�V�BL�J"�& $|.T+�;�BFA"��n&��W�!�Id6+)$�����Q % «0o �"�-

.b�*"HA���:�)QTd>�:&K+ � 5M+HBL$����*��1L�"�-¡&�+��a�%$(;�"�P���1S���<!?&7$�10��5J�� � 5J+%$�$)�65����J�18�*��VH;%!?+)�:")P­&�+%�(!t�{.0�*1b!G&

�BL93�:&0��$�;�! V3�*�"�!T�!x�<-��AQH!8&�;%-�����!CQ�9)�!x�J-I$("IBL$(")$�P�1U�V�+�!TJ"%-N5�$H�����J5J&7�n�%�>�*"����J!8&0�<P��&@��$("�!MQ�$�.E&�+��

���|$��*;�&0�*$�" $�.D5A��1�&7���" P�10$�;�V�!^$�. +)�*!?&7$�10��5����V�+��J"%$�BL�J"� 5�$�")!M��-��J1b�J- �:" ��!C$����&b��$�"ªZ %� «7o o

�O�)�BI�n")�*"�P � A10�ai��M"HP��J1 * ! %� «7o o o 10�(!8V%$�"�!C� &7$ � 5�+�B�$H�*���J1 * !�A1KP�;�BN�M"�&�!MQ/�>��� ����^.7�(�:&k&7+HJ&

+)��!G&7$�1b��5���!tB +)A-¡P�1b�JJ&>BL��18�:&0QT!x�<"�5A�{�:&�!?V%��5��<.7��5J��<�*� -�������BL�n&7��- ��&K+)�W.0�<����-�$�.&7+)�a-)��-(;)5�&@�4�|�

BI��&�+�$�- �¬�*" �J5�$�")$�BI�*5�!{M"�-§.0�<������- B�J"�� �<A5�;�"���y$�.���5�$�"�$�BL��5¡-�M&K�Z %� o % �O���M"�&�+)$�;)P�+

+)��!G&7$�1b��5���!tB BI�<P�+�&6+�J�%�a9%�J��"yM9)���z&�$y!CM&0�4!C.���{")����-¡.K$�1S�BL�!M!x�<"�P~�n"�.0$�10BSJ&@��$("�Q��>A�� M���

5�$�"�5��*;%-��J-)QN+)$�d6�J�%�J1bQ=&�+)�&\�*&�! 5J$�"�&710�<9�;�&K��$�" &�$ &�+)�§.0���A�<-DM")- &7$ &n+)� �b$�1KP��"3�*h��&@�*$�"¤$�.

��5�$(")$�BI�*56Y�"�$�d>����-�P�� �Od6A!����J1@�Id>�J�Y3Z �_"L&K+��6$�"%�_+��"�-�Q)�:&RV�10$�V�$�!C��-F")���*&�+)�J1��"NA�n&���1K")�&7�

"%$|1R_V)��1K.0��5J&7��-j�%�J1b!C��$("I$�.H&K+)�#]¢��5J�18-���M"��)A�*;)�#&�+���$�1@�R¨�$�"S&�+)�_$�&�+)�J1R+��"�-)Q��n&�V)$��*"(&@�J-j&7$S18�JA�

d>�JAY("���!C!#d6+)��10��&n+)�J18��!G+)$�;)��-N+���|�j9����M"�!G&K1b�M"�P(&�+�Q|&�+HM&2��!xQª5�$(")5���1K")�:"�P��n&7!6�:"�&���1KV)10�A&�J&7��$("=$�.

���|$��*;�&0�*$�"3Z>�>��� ����I�M"�-���-F+���!T�<��5J&�;)10�6$�"�&�+%�¢����!?&�$|10��5J�� � 5�+�$�$��)9��L"�$�&7�n"�PS&�+�J&b¥�v � Z4Z<Z �E!C��BLV)�n�

&@$N-���5��*�10�&�+�J&�-��*����10!x�S�J���JBL�J"�&<!_$�.O!M$�5��<A��Q)��5�$(")$�BL��5�Q)���JP�A��Q�V%$H���n&7��5����Q|B�$�1UA��Q�J"�-N10�����<P%��$(;�!

���n.0�I�����J1�&�10��5��*V�18$�5J��EA5A&7��$("¬$("z$�"��F�")$(&�+��J1 ��!MQR�*"W!?+%$�1@&@Q�&7$c1b�J.K;)!M�S&�$c�"�A�n�%!M��QH&0$�10��.�;3!t�S&0$

Page 15: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�¯®

���%V)�<A�*",d_+�M&O��!�&K10�"�!?V)��10�<"�P3Z�qK&'�<! ")$(&s5��J1@&����",d_+)��&�+���1O�BL$(")PF&n+)�J!M�6-��:�)��18!x�.KA5J&K$�10!MQ�&�+%�J1b�j��!

$�")�&�+)�&'��!TV�10�J-�$�BI�*"�M"�&E�")-Fd6+)��5M+����)��1@&7!#�5�M;)!C��3A5�&0��$("=$("N&�+��S$(&�+%��10!JZ ����& * !g�:"���$�Y%�&�+)�

���4���*")P�$|1KP��")��!?B ��" d6+%��5M+ .�;H"%5�&0��$("%!k�J����1@&=10�(5��*V�1b$�5J��L�5�&7��$(" ;�V)$�"§$�"%� �")$(&�+��J1tZ �M;%!G&

9%��5J�;%!?�W!x$�5�����&��kV�10��!x��"�&7!N¬5���1�&KA�n"k"�;�BS9)�J1�$�.6�"���<$�P)�4�(!Ld>�:&�+�W���n�|�*"�Pk$�10P��")��!?B ��!F"%$%&7Q

+%$|d¢���%��10Q)j10��A!M$(",d_+��L&7+��>!C$�5��<A�E!t5����J"�5A��!#d¢$(;)��-F"%��5���!t!C�18���n�I+�M���&�+)�S!t�BL�jd¢�J�Y�"���!t!#�!

9)��$���$�P��)Zpw oR`_"�")$(;�")5��*"�Pa&�+���!C�Al(;���� ��"{+��<!�5�$(;�1b!C��QE+���5�$�"�&0�:"�;%�J-R¥ªvMikA1��)��!?&¢!x$�5��*����*!CB �<!L

V�+3����$�!x$(V�+��=$�.E+���!?&�$|1��L&7+��&X!C��-�;�5���-NBLM"|�IBI�*")-�!CQ)BN$�!G&X�<��Y��(�:�I9)��5J�;�!x�S�:&R&K$�$|Y=�:"�&�$N�5�5J$�;�"�&

.0�5M&0!CQOM&g���J�!G&g5�$�"�&7�JBSV)$�10J1K�\$�"���!JZk[�10$|B �n&7!S�9%!C$��*;�&��N&K1b�n;�B�V�+)QO$|1¢�4&@!S10�(�*J&7�*�����<"�.0��;)��")5���Q

+)��!G&7$�1b��5JA�_BLJ&���10�<A����!?B 5�$("�&�18�:9�;�&7��-¡BL$�1b��Q V)�J10+�MV)!CQ�&0$­&n+)�a$�1KP��"��<hAJ&7�<$�"y$�.�$�;�1S+)��!G&7$�18��5JA�

Y�")$�d>�<��-�P�� &�+HM"�-H�4-&K+%�_!C5M+�$)�*�10!?+)�*VL$�.�&K+)� ����!?&�$�1b��5��� � 5J+)$�$��<w�Z

Ø�á#� È ��� �£Í �

q0"Se�$(�)��BS9%�J1������à�AQ��>��< J���Sd61b$(&0�#&�$jfg$�;�P%�� �¥ �0e����n&7+��J1 � 5�+�B�$H�����J1bQ��~JP�")��10Q(A"��L$�.

&7+��jV�10$�.0��!M!t$�1b!#"%$|12M"|�/$�.E&K+)�>��5�����5�&@�*5&�+)�*"�Y��J1b!6�:"�&��J10��!G&@!#BL��Z/q29�����$("�P=5�$(B�V)�<�M&0���n�N&7$ �>�10�

i�J1K�\�UZ�Z*Zp�tZ{i\�1�����!CB d>�����X9%�F&�+%�,���n"%5J+�V)�*"�.0$�1TBS�\5�$�;�10!C�F&�+���!d>�*"�&7�J1 �� o o:Z)ik�1@�|��!tBNQRd6+3��5J+

.K;)!x�(!j&�+)�,-��*�%�J18!t�,�!8V)�J5M&0!S$�.g!M$�5��*�����!8BIQE1b�JVH10�A!?��"�&K��-aB�$�18�,!8V)��5���.K��5J����n��&7+����:"�&���1�����"�&@�<$�")��!G&

5�$|B�V�$(")�M"�&'$�.3&K+)�>£_��1KBL�"N10�J�5�&0��$("L&�$�&�+%�¢&7+���!t��! $(.R&K+)� �T�<�!M!C��5J��3�J5A$(")$�BI�*!?&7!�ZSqK&'-��JBL�"�-�!

P%$%�%�J10"�J"%5J��$�.#&�+3����5�$�"�$�BL��5c!8V�+%�J18��Z��>A�� ����Iut;)-(P%��-{�*&T"��A5���!C!C�1K��&0$\-���!G&@�*"�P�;3��!t+{d>�n&�+)�*"

i�J1K�)��!?B &�+)M&Ld_+)��5M+���BF�"�J&7��-¡.010$�B ]g��5J�10-��*�" �*"�.0�*;���"%5���Q#+���!/����<;��a&n+3��$�1@�%Q6.U10$�B &�+�M&

d6+)��5M+ ��BFM"��&���-¡.K1b$�B ����P��A���<M" �:"H.7�<;)�J"%5J��Q &�+)��BLM&0�J1b�*�����!G&�5A$(")5���V�&7�<$�"y$�.�+3��!?&�$�1��3Z mE+)�

��"�&K��1UV�17�A&�J&@�*$�"j&�+�J&%+)�#V�10$�V�$�!C��-S��!E&�+)�#.0$����<$�d>�:")P3¥

Page 16: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�#�

ik�1@� �-�$�V|&�!k]6��5JA10-H�*�" �)���;���&�+)��$�1K� �")- ;�!M��!¡�:&0QS&�+H10$�;�P�+© 5J$�B�93�:")M&0�*$�" $�.

-��������5A&7��5J��OM")-W�*$�P���5JA�XV�10$�5���-(;�1b��!MQs&0$,1b���)�J���5�$("�&�10�-)�*5J&7�<$�")!CQ���!8V3��5��<A���*�,&�+)�N5�$�"(&K10A-��<5M&0��$(")Q

$�1b�<P%�n"�A���:�L9)�M&Kd6���J"S;)!x���<�)A�n;)�_�"�-����)5M+��"�P��A�<�)���;���Q�9��J&�d6����"�l(;)���� &����")-Sl�;�J"�&@�4&��)Z o o o¢m�$>+)�<!

BI�<"%-�Q &�+��a&�+%�J$�1�� $�.L��J9�$(;�1b�7�%���;��{d6A!/&�+��J"%5���.K$�1�&K+��:"y"%$y5J�!t�a&�+��a&71KJ")!8V)$�!x�4&@�*$�"~$|.j&�+��

ux;�18�*-���5�.0$�1KBL;3�* �.�1b$�B �JA5J+��5J5�$�1b-��*"�P{&�$a+���!,�<M9%$�;�1Cr0¥ �8qK&6d>$�;)�<-{9%�c9��M&�&7�J16&K$k!CM�{&7+�J&6

d>$�1b��-\�n"kdg+)��5�+{�%��:;����*!FB���A!8;H10�A-a9�A!C��-{$("{&�+%��l(;)M"�&0�*&<��$�.gd>$|1KY�5�$|B�V)�<�M&K��-k��!S"%$(&_�"

���|�J1b�n�!G&0�*"�Pyd¢$�10��-�Q &�+��&��n&��*!c�&K1K�"3!x�n&7$�1��~.0$�1UB $�.L+�;�BLM" !C$�5�����&��%Q &K10J")!M�:&7$�1@� !C��"�5��k�:&L��!

;�")!G&K�9)����Q�;�")!?&KM9)���69)��5J�;�!x�S�n&'��!_5�$�"�&K1K�-���5�&7$�1��=��&K+)�S$�V�V�$�!M�:&@�<$�",$�.�;3!x�(�<�%��*;)�jM")-N�J�%5J+�M")P����

�%��*;)� ���:&0���&7��!y&�+)�§d_+)$���� &�+%��$�1�� $|.��<�9)$�;�18�<�)A�<;%�J�?Z � o « mE+)��! ��!��:" .��5�&\d6+���10� i�J1U�

-���!G&@�*"�P(;��*!t+)��!N+)�*BN!x���<.�.K18$�B +)��!,$�1�&K+�$�-�$(�y.0$�����$|d¢��1b!N�!,d>�����_A!c.K10$�B ]¢��5JA10-�$�* !,!x$�5��*�����!8&

.0$����<$�d��J10!�¥�����R$H.ª&7+)�JBD���B &7$N18��!8&7$�10�jJ"���-���A�R!M�:&�;�M&7��$�",$�.O����5M+�J"�P%�S�*",d_+)��5M+N&�+%�j.0$�10BF;)��

*&7$S�J����1@��BLJ"L�5�5�$�1K-)�:")Pj&�$6+3��!2�<M9)$�;�1Cr�d>$�;)��-j9���5�$�BN�_T1b�J����n&��|Q(d6+���10��A!'i��1��L��BSV�+��!C�*hA��!

��" &�+)�k$�V�V�$�!C�:&@�k-��<10��5�&@�*$�"y&�+���5�$("�&71K�-���5�&7$�1@� ")M&�;�18�k$�.,�M�)5J+��"�P��%ZgmE+�;)!CQ6+��k-�$���!��-�$�V�&

]¢��5J�10-���J" ����*;)����&�+)��$|1��|Q9);(&I$�"3�:� �<"�$�10-��J1N&7$�-��JBI$(")!G&71KJ&7�y�n&<!{5�$�"�&K1KA-��<5M&K$�1K��5�+��1UA5J&K��18Z

�~+)���*�¬�n&g��!�&�1K;��/&7$�-�J�%Q'&7+)�=&�+���$�1��{+��!�9)���J"�5J������J-a&7$�BL$�-��<.����*&K!M�A�<.6.K$�1_&�+3�,.�;�&7;�18�AQ��!L��!

!x�<P�"HA���4��-�QN.0$�1k�*"�!G&KM")5���QN9�� &�+%� MV�V%�J�1K�")5���$�.\�����*;)����&�+���$�1K�D���<"�Y���- &7$ &�+��§5�$H!8&¬$�.

V�1b$�-�;%5�&0��$("N&<$N�-�-�10��!x!#V%$�!C!M�:9)���>l�;���!?&���$�"3!TJ9%$�;(&R&K+%�j-)�*.U.7��10��")5����:"N&K+%�j$�10P��")��5S5�$�BSV)$�!C�n&@�*$�"

$�.�5��V)�4&7��S9%�A&�d¢�(�M"�9�10�")5�+%�(!MZ#f ;|&7Q�>��� J��� �!CY�!xQjd6+HM&=�<.Ni\�1���r�!a&7+)�J$�1��§d>�J1b�y!x�<BSV)�*�

d61b$�"�P �ymE+��*!_��! d_+)�&�&K+��#i�J10P���"������!U&0! A-(�%$H5JM&7�J-L�&�&K+��_�)��1��I��"%-F$�.R&�+3� ���(&�+=5J��"�&�;�1���d>�n&K+

"���d �����;�� &�+%��$�1�� J"�-�y"%��d -)��!?&�18�:9�;�&@�*$�"�&�+���$�1K��&@$ !x$��n�%� ��$�P���5J����n�§&�+)�­]¢��5J�10-)�*J"

V��1K�-�$(�)�A!JZ������%���*$�V�BL�M"|&ª�n"L&�+)�6d6$�1KY)! $�.3ikA1KP)�n")A����!?&7!MQ�!?;�5M+N�! � Z �����|$("�!MQ��TZ��~��*10�!MQ��"3-

�_Z�i­�J"�P���10Q « ����-N�>��� ����N&7$�!?V���5��*.@� ��&K+)�L��Jd $�.OVH10$�P�10��!x!_.0$�1��9)!8&K10�5M&OV�$����n&7��5J����J5�$�"�$�BS� �C¨

-���-Nik�1UP%�<"�A����!?B 10��.�;�&7� � $�5�������*!CB �Sv �T"��S&�+)�*"�P���!_&�10;���Z�[R18$�B¤L-�$�5M&K10�<"�A�EV�$��*"�&�$�.X�|���Jd>Q

Page 17: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

5�$�")!C�J1K��M&0�*�)�NV%$����n&7��5J����J5�$�"�$�BS�W�"�-\!t$�5��<A����!G&�V�$)�<�:&@�<5�A� ��5�$(")$�BS�\+�J�%�c���5M+��:"{&�;�1K"{9%���J"

$�")�j!8&K�MVN�+����-I$�.s&7+��6$�&�+)�J18ZSq0" ���U����Q�&�+)�.7$�����$�d6�J1b!T$�.E`6-��B � BI�*&�+IJ"%-�]¢��5J�10-�$S+�M�)�_&�+)�

;�V�V��J1T+�M")-3¥�&K+%����+HM�)�SL-�$�5�&K1b�*")��&�+)M&E&�+)� �b!C$�5��n��<��!?&7!��T-�$,"�$(&'+������Zc[R1b$�B �A�Q�A�N&�$ �A������Q

.010$�B &K+%� �6��� ���M�n����� � ��� ��$�. � ��!tBN$�")-��ª;�"|&7���3ik�1@�+* !��S�����6������� � ��Q3&�+)�N!t$�5��*�����!?&K!_&K�Y��S9��5�Y

&7+��S;�V�V%�J1 +)M")-/�"%-c5����!x������!C!x�n�¬�M"�18��5�+�&�+)���<1 5J18�*&7��l(;%�L$|.�$�1@&�+�$�-�$%��V%$����:&7��5J����J5A$("�$�BS�,d>�*&K+

"%��d �1KP�;�BI�M"|&<!JZSqK" �������HQ�5�$�"�!t��1��)M&0�:���V%$����n&7��5J��3��5�$("%$|BS�S&��Y%��! 9��5�YS&�+)�6;�V�V)�J1E+)M"�-)Q�J")-

i�J1K�)��!G&)��A�<;����<&7+���$�1���9)��5�$�BN��!2$�9�!C$�����&7�(Z w «Ko

mE+)�_i{A1KP)�n")A���*!?&7!�rR!?;%5J5A��!C!TBS;�!8&0Q�+)$�d6���|�J18Q�9��6V�;�&'�*"NV���10!tV���5�&7�*�)��¥�$�"N&�+��>$�")�_+��"�-�Q

&7+�� [s�9���J"%!#��"j�O")P��<�"�-6V�;�&��n"�&7$S�5J&7�<$�"L#"%�Jdy�����;)� &�+��J$�1K���<"�$�18-��J13&K$>9�18�*"�P�!?$�5A�<A����!?B§9��5�Y

&@${�:&0!L1K$�$(&0!M¨ «0o o $("{&�+%�c$(&�+���16+�M")-�QE&�+��Nik�1UP%�<"������!8&7!�&7+��JB�!M�J�*�)��!j;�"%-���10����"��N&�+)�,-���!G&@�:")5�&@�*$�"

9%�A&�d¢�(�M"N_&7+���$�10�J&7��5���H�"�-L6V�1UA5J&7�<5���HV�$)���n&7��5���3�A5J$�")$�B��)Z ��$H��!�&�+)�6�J1018$�"%��$(;%!T5J+��1K�5�&7�J1'$�.

&7+��_ik�1@�|��!G&R&�+��A$�1@�=$�.O��J9)$�;�18�<�)A�<;)�_"�;3�����<.<�L&7+)�j�*"�&0�MP�1b�n&��=$�.Ei{A1�� * !TBI��!C!tJP)�(¨%-�$��A!_�:&�10��")-��J1

&7+��_!?&n;)-(��$�.H&K+)�T$�&�+)�J1�5��M"�&K10���&�+���!t��!O$�.R+)��!Od>$�1UY%Q��*"�-�;%!G&718�*���BI�J1UP���10!MQ(.01K;)�n&@����!C! �a[�$�13�>��4 A���%Q

��"W$|10-���1#&7$aP%�n�%�/N�|�J10-���5C&0QO�*&g��!>"���5���!M!?�1K��&7${!?&�;)-���&K+)�N&�1U;%�/.0$�;�")-��&7��$("�$�. i�J1K�)��!?B¬¥ª+)��!

BLM&0�J1b�<A����!?&�5�$�"�5��MV�&0��$("�$�.)+3��!?&0$�1���Z

q0"I$�10-H�J13&@$j;�")-��J18!8&KM")-jik�1K��* !�+)��!8&7$�18�*5�A�|BLJ&7��10�<A����!8BNQ��:&s��! ��!t!M�M"�&K�����&0$�!GV���5��<.��Ld6+�M&

+%�j9)$�1U10$�d>!6.�1b$�B©����P�����* !#V�+)����$�!x$(V�+��,�")-F+)$�d§+%�S-���!?&7�n"�P�;��*!?+)�A!#+)�<B�!?���*.2.U10$�B¤�n&8Z «0o o oN[R18$�B

���JP%��� * !6V�+)���<$�!t$�V�+��)QHi�J1K��Y%�JV�&O&�+3�L���%$)�:;�&K��$�")�<!?&X$�18���J"�&7�&@��$("�M"%-/&�+��N��-���S&�+)�& �K&�+��S18���!t$�"

.0$�1LV�1b$�P�1b��!C!���!=&�+��WV���1�V���&�;�A���n�­5�$("�&�1UA-���5�&7$�1@��"�M&K;�1b�W$�.&7+)�<"�P�! �8Z©fg;�&@Q#!x�<"%5��zi\�1��~d6�!

��"�.0�n;)��"�5���-{9��{&�+��c&�+)�A!C��!N$�._fg1U;�")$zf¢M;)��1>M"�- �';)-�d>�<PW[���;)��1K9��5J+)Q2J"%-k!C�*"�5��,+)�cV)�*A5���-

+)��BL!t�(�*.'�n"L&K+%�P%��")��1K��35�$�"(&@����&ª$�. �U&�+��j£g�J10BF�"LV�+����<$�!C$�V�+��I$�.����*93��1@&�� �bQ%i��1��=-���!?&7�*"�P�;)��!?+%��-

+)��BL!t�(�*.�.K18$�B§���JP)����9��SV��*�5��*"�PSBL�")Q(")$(&s£6$�-�Q(J&)&�+)�_+���J1K&s$�.3+3��!X&7+���$�1K�)Z6�>��� ��H��5�$�"�&�10�!?&@!

Page 18: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

&7+��c&�d>$a-)�*�����5�&7��5��� �V�V�10$��5�+%��!,�:"{&�+)�c.0$�����$�d>�*"�PW&K��1UBI!J¥�v�q7"­&7+���d6$�10Y�!I$�._����P�����Q -)� ���:"��

&7+�$(;)P�+�&�5�$(")-��JBS")!jM"%-�J&O&�+��N!?ABL��&7�<BI�Tu8;3!U&@�n.0����!CQEA!jI.0$�1KB !8;�9�A�n&7�J10"��&7�F&7$c�*&0!t���*.0QE�����J1K�

.0$�10B $�.�9)���*"�P)Q�$�.�����.7��Q�J"�-S$�.�!M$�5�����&��R¥��:&E10��!8;)�n&@! �:"I6!?V%��5M;)�<M&0�n�|�_$�V|&7�<BI��!?BIQ��*"NgV�+)����$�!C$�V�+��

$�.RV�1K�5�&@��5J����:")-��<.K.0�J1b�J"%5(��Z#i�J1K�S&K�Y��A!�BLM" * !2V�$��*"�&)$�.H�|���JdS¨%-��<A����5�&@�<56�4!�;)!t��.�;3��&7$+)��B§J9%$(�)�

A���O9)��5J�;�!M�I�n&�-��JBL$�")!G&71KJ&7�(!6&�+)�NJ9%!?;�1b-�Qª;�"%!G&KM9��*��Qs&71K�")!C�*&7$�1@�¬5�+��1K�5M&K��1_$�.2&K+)�NV)10��!t��"�& �")-

P%�n�)��!_S10��A!C$�"c.7$|1O&�+3�L.�;�&�;H10�j�|��10!t;)!#&�+��SVH17��!?�M"�&KQR.0$�1�&�+)�SV�10��!t�J"�&E���J1b!8;�!#&7+��jV)�!?&0Z,���JP)��� * !

-��������5A&7��5_��!|ux;�!8&0�<.7��5J�&K$�1��>�")-S5�$�"�!t��1��)M&0�:���(¨Ji��1�� * !MQ�5�10�n&7��5J����"�-j10�J�)$��*;�&7��$("��1��RZ w o %

�~+�J&2"���5���!x!C�n&���BL�Y%��!j$�.2BLJ"�&K+��I-�18�*�)�*"�P�.K$�105(�L$�. +)��!8&K$�1K� �j�O1K�5�&@��5�A��Q3"%$(&T�*$�P���5JA�

"%��5���!t!M�:&��)¨'�n&g��!�A5�&@�<$�")QO�J5�$�"�$�BI��5,�5A&7��$("\d_+)��5J+�9)��5�$�BL�A!j,-�1b�n�|�<"�PW.K$�105��Nd6+��M"k�*&T5A�<�!?+%��!

d>�*&�+¤10�����Qc5�$(")5J1b�C&0��5A$("�&�10A-��<5M&0��$("%!�¥FvM&K+)��!x�§5J$�"|&�10�-)�*5J&7��$(")!?w�Q=�>��4 A��� !G&K10�A!C!C��!MQ,vJ+�J�%�

5�$�"�5J1b��&7��Q310�����Q3��5�$("%$|BI�*5S5�+��1K�5J&@�J18¨H&�+)���=J1b�L5J$�"�.0����5M&0!T$�.2�<"�&@�J18��!?&�!MQHd6+)�M&�+%�J1�$|.2��"�-��n�|��-(;����!

$�1�$|.25A�<A!M!?�A!CQ3��"�$(&�+%��1�d>$�10-�!MQ|&n+)���,�10�S+)��!G&7$�18��5JA�O!G&�1K;)P�P%����!#9)��&7d>�J�J"¬�:")-��:�)�4-�;����!_$�1�P�18$�;�V�!

$�.2�*")-)�4�|�*-�;�A��!JZ w % ik�1K��-�10Jd>!_.K10$�B &K+)��!g�n"�&7�J10V�10�J&�J&0�*$�"I$�.E+)��!G&7$�1@�L&�+��S�*��!t!C$("=$�.OjP�10$�d>�*"HP

5J�V)�n&������!G&�5�$�"�5��J"�&K1K�&K��$("�Q�d6+)��5�+=5�M"I$�"3�:�I���J�-�&<$F_&0��1UBI�*"HA�)5�10��!C��! �"�-S&K+%�j��!?&�J9)���*!?+�BL��"�&�$�.

T18A-���5J��<�*��-��<.0.K��10��"�&���5�$(")$�BI��5#�"�-S!x$�5��*���18��P��<B��(Z

�~+�J&�!8+)$(;)��-Nd6�>1K�J&KA�*")Q|�5�5�$|10-��:")PF&<$��>��� J���%Q3$�.R&K+���!_�:"�&���1�V)10�J&�J&7�<$�",$�.O+)��!G&7$�1K� � ���

��")�n&7�<A���*��18�J.K;)!x��!MQE��"�+3�4! �A���(�W5�$�;�18!t��Qs&7$�-���!x5�;)!x!&�+��FV�+3����$�!x$(V�+3�*5�A����M")-�!t5�MV)�AQªV��1�&@�<5M;)�<�1b�n�

&7+�� l(;)��!8&0�*$�" $�.,&�+��yv�10���*J&7�<$�"3!8+%�nV)!{9%�J&�d>�A��" &�+)�*"�Y%�<"�P M")- �5�&0�:"�P�w�Z %Ko ��� "�$("%�J&�+)�����J!M!

5�$�")!M�*-��J10!N&�+)�<!Nik�1K�)�<�" �:"�&���1�V)10�J&�J&7�<$�"¡V�1b$�-�;%5�&0�*�%�a$(�%��1SA����Q_�A!GV���5(�*����*�~�n"~10���<M&0�*$�"k&7$­&�+��

!8&0��10�����n&��=$�.E+)��!G&7$�1b��5���!?B�¥�v�qK&2��!#>.K�5J&7Q:wS+%�jd61b�n&7��!CQ�vJ&�+)�&'�*"F&�+)�_")�*")��&7���M"�&�+=5J��"�&�;�1K�%QH��5�$(")$�BI��5

5J�;)!C��!_�J�%�J1K&7��-NS5�$�"�!x��-���1K�9)���j��.U.7�(5M&O$�"L&�+)�;�"�.0$���-���"�PI$�.E+��<!?&<$|1��R¨��"�-F&�+�J&0Q�A!#>18��!C;)�:&7Q3.K$�1

&7+��&�V��1@&@�<5�;)�<�1 �J10AQs+%��!8&K$�1b��5���3BLJ&���10�<A����!?BD9����10!_6BL�1KY�$|.O10���*J&7�n�|�j&K1K;�&�+RZ w %Ko o,`#&�&�+)��! V�$)�:"|&

Page 19: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�A�

��"�&n+)�_5�$(;)10!C��Q�+%�#V�1b$(V�$�!x��!X&�+)M&H&7d6$j&�+)�n"�P�!�9%�_10�J&���n"%�J-S.010$|B�i��1��)��!CB,¥J&�+3�6��")-��JV%��")-���"�5J�g$�.

&7+��c&�+)��!M�*!,$�.>�*")-(;)!?&�1b�n��_5�$�"�5��J"�&K1KJ&7��$("�d>�n&�+�18�A!?V���5�&g&K${&�+)�W�n"��%�����-�J&���-{&�+)��$�1@�­$|.>��J9)$�;�10�

�%��*;)� �"%- 5JMV��:&KA����!G&�!8;)1KV3�:;)!x�7�%���;���Q,J"%-©&�+%� ��BSV�$�1�&K�")5�� $�.W&�+��§18�J��<�*&��¤$�.���5�$(")$�BL��5

5�$�"�5���"(&K1K�&K��$("RZW`#&O&�+��*!_V)$��*"�&0QH&�d>$,l�;���!?&0�*$�")!_�18�L1K���!M�J-,.0$�1T-)��!C5M;�!M!C��$�"E¥)mO$cdg+�J&2����&<�J"�&0QR�*.

&7+���&�+%��!M�*!6$�. 5�$�")5��J"�&71KJ&7�<$�"�P�1b$�d_&�+W��!_�%�J1b�n.0����-�QE-�$���!>�4& �*���-/&�$,&�+%�N-�$�dg"�.K����O$�.T5J�V3�:&KA����!?B

�")-�&�+��y�-(�%�J"�&=$�.���"�&K��P�10��I5�$����*�A5�&0�:���*!CB � mO$�d6+��&=�J��&7�M"�&���!a&�+)�J1b�y�*"�-�����-�yP��J"%�J1UA�

BI$(�)��BL��"�&�&7$�d6J1b- �)�C� �T�<� �I5�$("%5(�M"(&71UM&0��$�" �

��á �2ÏÂË�Ò � ���2�­Ë � ��� � ��Ì �:Ë�Ì ��� È � �'��Ì

q0" +3��! �������§5�$�;�10!C��Q#�>��< J����!?+)$�d¢�J-y&K+�M&S&�+��k.U������<"�P $�.S&K+)�{ik�1K�)��!8&S&K+%��$�1���$�.

5�$�"�5���"(&K1K�&K��$("=��!�&7$F9��>.0$(;�")-,��",�n&7! 10�-)�*5�����*!CBIQH�*"��:&7!#BL$�")$����:&�+���!?B,ZSq0",10������4&��%QHjBI$(�%��BL�M"�&

&@$�d6J1b- 5�$("�5J�M"|&�10�&@��$("¤��!y5J���J�10�*� �V�VH�1b��"�&@QF9�;�&¬5A$(;�"�&���10��&0�M"�-)��"%5(�4��!y���|�<!8&0QLJ")- d6+)M&W��!

1b���)��A���J-y9���5�$�"�&0�MBSV�$�1K�1K��5J�V)�*&�����<!tB ��!�{V�1b$�5���!C!�$�.I���)$)�:;�&���$("�Q_1KJ&�+)��1F&�+)J"�k1K�-���5JA�

5M+HM"�P)�g�*"L�J5�$�"�$�BI��5_��$�P%�<5�Z

mE+)� i\�1�����!?&)&�+���$�1���$|.s5�$�"�5��J"�&K1K�&K��$�"L$|d¢��!�BS;)5M+j&7$&�+)�_��"3!x�<P�+�&7!�$�. � Z � ��!CBL$�"�-)�|M")-

�_ZJ�'��5�l(;%�J;�18Z %0o o o i�J1K�I-�$���!O"�$�&3�-�$�V�&3&�+)�#&�+)��!M��!�$�.H&7+��_.0$�1KBI��10Q�d6+)��5M+N!x�J��! �J�%5J+�M")P��_M&3&�+s�

$�1b�<P%�n"�$�.H&K+)�_BL$(�|�JBL�M"|&)&7$�d6J1b-S5�$�"�5��M"�&K1K�&K��$("�Q(�"�-jV�1b�J.0�J1b!X&7$S��BSV�+��!x�nhA�#&�+��6��BSV�$�1�&K�")5J�g$�.

&7+��S.0�<1b!G&X!C;�1UV%�n;)!x�7�%��*;)�L�:"/&7+��jV)10�<BI�:&0�*�%��A5�5M;�BS;��n�&K��$�",VH10$�5���!C!MZ¬mE+H10���>V�+��!x�J!MQ3!C�"�5J&7��$("��:")P

&7+�18��� !G;%5�5��(!t!M�:�)��BN$�BL�M"�&7!k$�.,9)$�;�1KP���$H��!{�M��V)��$��n&��&K��$("�Qj+�M�)�¡V�;�"�5J&�;)�&7��- &�+����A�%$��*;�&0��$�"R¥

!x�<BSV)���S5�$�$(V%��1K�&K��$�"3Q)-��n�|�<!x��$(",$�.O�*�9)$�;�10Q)J"%-NBF�!?! V)10$�-(;%5A&7��$("3ZI`65�5����*��1KJ&7��-N5�$(")5��J"�&�1UM&0��$(")Q

5M+H�10�5J&���10��!x��-F9��L&�+��*!6�*$�P)�*5S$�.ª&7+)�j�M��V)��$��n&�J&7��$("=$�.E&K+)�jd¢$�1KY)�J1O9|�L&�+)�S5JMV��:&KA����!G&@QH��!#.7$H����$�d¢��-

9���~�n�!G&IV�+��!x��Q>$�"���$�.,5���"�&K1K��<��!?J&7��$("�Q6d6+���5M+§!t���A!z&�+)���*"�&K��")!C�<.0��5�M&0�*$�" $�.,5�$�BSV��J&7�n&7�*$�"

Page 20: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

9%�A&�d¢�(�M"�5J�V)�n&������!G&7!JZ �>��� �����$(V�V)$�1�&K;�")���n� !?V%��5��<.7�K��!MQ_vMik�1@� 5�$(V��*��! � ��!?BL$�")-��jd6$�1b-�.7$�1

d>$�1b-�QH9�;�&�9)�5�YF&7$/.K10$�"�&0Z�mE+)�jV�1b�*BL�SBL$(&7$�1 $�.E&7+)�jd6+�$)�*�SBL$�����BL�J"�&2��!g����V)��$��n&�J&7��$("�$�.O&�+)�

d>$�10Y���1>9��{&�+���5JMV��:&KA����!G&bZ�ik�!t!LV�18$�-�;�5�&@�<$�")Q�-)�:���*!M�*$�"�$|.>�*�9)$�;H10Q�BL�5M+��:")�J1K�{�10��"�$�&�+��:")P

BI$�1b�¬&n+HM"�10��.K�<")�A-{VH�1@&7!I$|._&�+��<!,�J��V)��$��n&�J&7��$("RZOmE+)�¬!?&�10;�P�P����/;�"%-���1�&K�Y)�M"k9���5J�V)�*&�����<!?&7!F&7$

-��(!8&K17$%��$�"%�#�"%$(&�+3��1R��!2!C��BSV)�n�6&7+��_���!?&)V�+��!x�T$|.�&K+)�T.0���)��1R$�.R5J�V3�:&7�����!G&)�5J5J;�B�;)�<M&0��$("3Z w %0o «

�~+�J&L�4!/&�+��W�����M"�&�;���_5�$�!?&>$�.L!C;%5J+y�V�1b$�5��A!C!CQT�5�5J$�10-H��"HP{&7$­i\�1�� � ���a10�J�%�J���!

+)��BL!t�(�*.O+)�J1b�&7$S9)�j�! V)��!C!x�<BI�*!?&7��5jA! � �*!CBL$�")-��sM")-L�!g$�V(&@�nBI��!b&@��5�! �R�A5Jl�;)��;�1��*"H�!tBS;)5�+,�!

+%�N5�$�"�!M�*-)�J1b!6�J�5M+cV�+HA!t�N$�.�&�+)�N����V��*$H�:&7�&@�<$�"c&7$/+)C�)�NLV)$�!C�n&@�:�)�N!x��-��NM")-�S")�JP�M&7�4���I!C��-���¨

v �#��� �����G�s�*���(�)w�QO!tV���5���.K����!j�>��� A���\.K$�16���%�BLV����AQEv��*�JA-H!6&K$c&�+)�,-��A!GV%$%&7��!GB $�.g5�JV)�*&KA� �*"a&�+)�

d>$�10Y�!t+�$(V�Qª9�;|& �:&TA��!t$�5J1b�JJ&���!&n+)�F��� ���J��&9� 0�Qs&�+)�L�J���;�<�����*���A�K� 0\$|.�&7+)�Nd>$�1UY%�J1b!�Z � MV)�n&7��E&�+�;�!

�M"|�|��!t�P��J!S&�+%�=�)� ��� ���*���\�0� �:� &���)�MQOd_+��*5J+k-���9)A!C��!�&7+��cd¢$�1UY%�J1bQXd6+��*5J+W1b�J-�;%5���!S+)�<B &7$a&�+)�

�����%�(�)$�.E_&7$�$��Hd>�n&�+�$�;�&��:"�&��������<P��M")5J��Z�mE+��6-)�4���4!M�*$�"L$(.���J9�$(;�1�+��!MQ�+�$�d6�����J1�_V%$�!C�n&@�:�)�6!C��-��6�n"

&7+��&X�4&ª��!G&7M93����!?+)��!MQH�*",BS�"�;).��5�&K;�10�*"�P)Q)$�1UP��"���!?J&7��$("=�<"N&�+)�6V�10$�-�;)5�&0�*$�"LV)10$�5J��!M!CQ)�5�5�$�10-��*"�PF&7$

I18�&@��$(")��O�"�-W!8�)!G&@��BLJ&7��5FV)�<M"�QE�*"\5�$�"�&K1K�!8&�&7$c&�+)�F�"H�185M+��z$�._V�10$�-(;)5J&���$�"{��"\!?$�5A�<�M&��)ZRmE+��

��"�����"�&0�*$�"=$�.EBL�5�+)�n"%��!#5�18�JM&7�J!_6"%�Jd§M")J1b5�+��|Q|9��IV)10$�P�1K��!t!M�:�)���*�N�#���*�>�*���s�n�*� �/&�+)�d¢$|1KY)��12�<"

.0��|$|;�1'$�.E&�+)�jBL��5�+)M")��5�A�H&7$�$��@¨�9�;�&'�n&�+��! J"I�-(�%J"�&��P)�S�:"L&�+�M&2�:&3�%�(� �O�����*����� ��� �g&�+%�d¢$|1KY%��10Q

P%�n�)��"�PS+��nB JP�A�*"F&�+%�V%$�!C!C�*9)���<�:&��I$�.R9)�(5�$�BI�:")PSjd6+%$����BLM"�w�Q %K«8Z%mE+)�<!T5�$("�&�10�-)�*5J&7�<$�"Ndg+3��5�+

1b�JV���M&0!T�:&7!C����.E�M���J1EBI$�1b�j��"(&0�M"�!x���n�I.K1b$�BD$(")�>5J10��!M�*!�&K$S&�+��6"��J��&�;�"�&0���|&�+��6.0�<"�A�R5JM&KA5(�:�|!?B,ZSq0"

&7+��>��V��*!C$�-��j�M"�-)�:")PS&�+%�j�J�%$��:;�&7�<$�")Q|+%$�d>�J����10Q��! �>A�� ����IV�$��*"�&7!T$(;�&KQ)vJd>�*&�+I$�"��S���!8&E�5J&7��$("��*"

&7+��{�M�)5M+�J"�P��{-�����*��5M&0�*5�Q &n+3�c")��P��&@�4���W!M�*-��W-���!?MV�V����10!c5A$�BSV)����&7���n� �*"¡&�+)��!,-��A!?&�1K;)5J&���$�" $�.

5J�V)�n&������!G&�!t$H5����M&��)¨J&7+)�#V)$�!M�:&@�4�|�_!x�<-��#1b�JBL��:"�!J¥A5�$�BLBS;�"��*!CB,Zpw %�«0o

Page 21: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�%�

��$�&�+)�¡.KA5A&7!a�)A����-��&7�­&�+)��!k��"�&K��1�VH10�J&�J&7��$(" � %�«0o o#�>A�� �����BL�Y%��!{ -���!8&7�:"35C&0�4$�"�+���1G�

9%�A&�d¢�(�M"�5�$("%5(�M"(&71UM&0��$�"L��"S�P�1b��5�;)�n&�;)10�#�"�-S5�$�"�5��J"�&71KJ&7��$("��n"��<"�-�;)!G&71��3Z

� �4&7+ 10��P�J10-©&7$ �P�18��5J;%�n&�;)10��Q/+)�§V�10$�5J����-�!�.K10$�B &�+)� -���9�J&�� 9%�A&�d¢����" �2-�$(;)J10-

f¢��1�")!?&7���*"SM"%-�&�+%�_$�1�&�+%$�-�$(�>ik�1@�|��!8&0!JZTfg�J10"�!G&7���*")Q�10���:�)�*")Pj+%�JJ�)���:�>;�V�$("�!?&��&0��!?&7�<5�!OV)�J1@&���*"��:")P

&@$a1b�J�� ��!?&�J&<�c$�d_"%�J18!t+)�:V�Q�!t+)$�d6��-�&�+��&6��"{&�+)��!LJ1b�J,&K+���18����!Lc.01K�P�BI�J"�&�J&7��$("k$�._V�10$�V)��1@&��

+%$H�*-)�:")P�!¡J"%- &�+�M&¬�J�)�M"¤�n" 5��!t��!�$�.W5�$(")5��J"�&71KJ&7��$(")QL")$ 1b�J���5�+��"�P��§�n" &�+%��BI$�-���$�.

���%V)��$��n&�J&7��$("\��!&�$c9)�N.7$�;�"�-HZRmO$c&�+���!MQ3+)��!j�-��%�J18!t�10���A!j18�MV)������-/&�+�J&�d6+��&2i\�1��W+)�-a�M�)$�Y���-

d6A!jBL$�10�NSV�+)�M")$(BI��")$�"�$�. �<"�&7��"�!C��.K��5JJ&7��$("WJ"%-c&�+��&@QE.K;�1�&K+)��1KBL$�10��Qs+%�F+�A-�!G&7�&7��-/&�+�J&2&�+)�

5J�V)�n&������!G&O10��P%�<BL�SY�"�$�d>�:")P��n�=BS���"�&���n"%�J-,S1b�JP�;3�*�1�!G�|!G&@�JB¤$�.Ov��*�d>!.7$|1O&�+3������V�M"�!t�<$�"c�")-

&7+��_-���BI�n"�;�&0��$("�w6$�.3BLUu¯$�1E1b�J��)��!?&�J&7�_V�1K$�V)�J1K&0�4�(!xQ�10�J"�-���10�<"�P>V���1KV)��&�;���)6!C�*&�;��&@�<$�"Ld6+���10�_vJ&�+)�

�|��1��/!CBL����E�<�"�-�$�d6"%��1 ��!6M"c�P�10��5M;)�n&�;�10��RVH17$�����&��10��J"�w�Z %K«0o o o �>��� ����%Q3!M�:&K;�J&7�*"�PN+��*BL!M���<.OB=$|1G�

��"�f#�J1U"%!G&7���:"Rr�! 5�JBSV)Q�V�10��!t�J"�&@!X&�+)10����10P�;�BL�J"�&7!�&7$S!?;�V�V�$�1K&7��10!T$�.3&K+%�#ik�1@�|��!8&O��"|&���1KV�1b��&KM&0��$�"R¥

.b�*18!8&0�n�|Q�&�+���.KA5A&�&�+HM&¬$(")� 5�M"�")$(&@QFd>�:&�+�$�;�&¬-���!G&7$�1K&7��$("�QN!8;%5�5J��!t!C.�;)���n� ��-��J"(&@�n.K�§&K+)� ;�1U9��"

V�1b$�����&K�18�*�"�5�$�BSV)����&@���n�Id>�n&�+,&�+)�L!?BLA���3�P�1b��5J;)�n&n;H1K��RV�18$�����&7J1b�*�"3Z,�>�Sd610�n&@�J!�¥�v ��� � �*"�;�1U9��"

��"�-(;)!8&K1��|Q%&7+)�j���|5�+��"�P��>!?�%!?&���B +)�!T5�$�BSV)����&7���*��Q�$�1E�)��1��I"3�J�1b�n�%QH��1K�-���5JM&K��-N����H&�1UA5���!T$�.E&�+)�

V�1b�����*$�;%! !?�%!G&7�JB �n"Ldg+)�<5M+LBLM"SVH17$�-(;)5���-S.0$�1R+3�*!2$�d6"SV%�J18!t$�"����;)!x�_M"�-S$�")�*�L�M��5�+�J"�P%��-&�+��

V��1�&/$|.,+���!aV)10$�-�;%5��yd_+��*5J+ �J�%5J����-)�J-�+)��!a")����-H!M¨L�*" AP�1b�<5�;)�n&�;)10��Q&�+��¡5��V��n&7�����!?&,10��P���BL�

V%��1KBL�"%��"�&7�n�=BFA�<"�&7��*"%!MQHd>�n&�+¬!?;%5J5A��!C!x�n�%�S5�10��!t��!_$�.2�J�%5���!t!_�"%-Nd6J"�&7Qs�5����!t!6$�.OBI�J",d_+���5J+

V�1b$�-�;%5J��!OA5(5�$�10-��*"�P&7$j;%!M������A�n;%�#9)�J.0$�1b�#V�1b$�-�;)5��*"�P6�5�5�$|17-��*"�P&7$S���|5�+�A"�P�������A�*;)�%Z w %Ko %

� ��5�$�"�-��*�%QX+��,5�$(")!x��-��J1b!�&�+�M&0Q2���)�M"��<.¢$("���d>��17�/&7$aA5J5��MV�&T&�+)�N+|��V%$%&�+)�A!M�*!�&�+�J&T&�+)�

BLA�<"�&7��")M"�5��L$�.2�"�M�)��1K�P��A�U!x�<hA�F1b�J��O��!?&��&K�SV)1K$�V)�J1�&��¬��!j5�$�BSV�J&7�*9)���Fd>�:&�+cik�1K�Rr�!¢&�+)��!x�<!MQR�:&

!8&0�����T18�JBL���")!F&�+HM&6B�$(�)�JBL��"�&_&7$�d6J1b-k5�$(")5��J"�&�10�&@��$("k+���10��-�$���!F"%$%&¢!x�<P�")�<.����V3$��<�18��!CM&0��$�"

Page 22: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

5�$|B�V�J10J9��*�F&7$c&�+)�,5JA!C�I$�.T�<")-�;%!G&K1K�)Z�mO+)�<10-��:�)QR+)�F"�$�&���!j�!S!M�*P�")�<.K��5J�"�&2&�+��,�*"�-���5���!x��$(")Qª&�+)�

�%�P�;%�J")��!t!MQ�"�-�&�+%�y�*-��JA!MQ6$�.�&7��"�.K�1,1b�JBI$%�%��-�.K18$�B i�J1K�)��!?BIQ>$�.F&K+%�¡BLUux$�1N�';H10$�V%�JJ"

!x$�5��<A����!G&%VH�1K&K����!Od>�n&�+S10��!8V)�J5�&)&�$&7+����*13�P�1U�1b�*�"SV%$�����5¯�>V�1b$�V)$�!?��<!MZ

q0")-�;)!G&71��)Q3.K$�12�n&7!TVH�1@&7QH��A����-��&@�J!TBI$|17�S��.K.0��5J&K�*�)���:�L&K+)�6&�+)��!M��!_$�.'5�$�"�5��M"(&K1K�&0��$("RZF����18�

&@$�$�Q +)$�d>���)��18Q �>��� �����+HA!�!?�J�%��1K��610�(!t�J1K���&K��$(")!c10��P�J1b-��*"�P¡&�+)�k�:"�&7��1�V�1b��&KM&0��$�" $�.U.7��10�(-k9��

$�1K&K+%$�-�$(�Wi\�1�����!CB/Z m�$W!?&7J1K&7Q�$�"%�cBS;�!?& "�$(&7�/&�+�����"%-�;�1U�"�5A��Q��J�%�J"W&�+%�/���:&KA���:&��%Q $�.¢!?BL����

��"�-(;)!8&K10���J!{&�+��&/-����)����$(V �*" &�+)� !t+��-�$�d $�.¬�*�1KP)�J1W��"�-(;�!G&710����!JZ6e�����&@QF�*&¬�*!��<BSV%$�1@&��"�&,&K$

1b��5�$|P�")��!C�_&�+�J&��*"%5�10���!t�6�n"LV�1b$�-�;%5�&0��$("I��!��5�5�$�BSV��")���J-I�*"FBL�"|�F5J�!C��!29|�L6P��M"3��1UA�3�*"�5�10���!x�

��"N5�$("�!8;�BSV�&K��$�"3Q��")-S"�$(&R9��L�",��"�5�10���!t�>�*"NV�$��%�J1K&��)Zj��$�d�BN��P�+�&�$�"%�j�J��V)�<A�*"F&�+��*!T.K�5J&��yq0"

5���1�&KA�<"I5JA!C��!xQ�;�"�-���18���<"%��!��>��� ����)Q�vJ&�+%�j5���"�&�1UA����!?M&0��$("I$�.'5JMV3�:&7��HBLM�S&K�Y��_V��*�5��_")$(&�$("��:�L9��

BI�J�")!c$�.�-H��!G&71U;%5�&0��$(")QT9�;�&����)�M" BL$�1b�k!?$�9��¡&�+)�aA!C!x$�5��*J&7��$("�$�.L!CBL����j5�JV)�*&���<��!U&0!J¥T���5�+

9�;)!C�*")��!t!6��!xQ3�*"N&�+)��!_!t��5�$(")-,5JA!C� � � �X"%$c��$(")P��J1 M",�93!t$��*;(&@�j�")-N-��A!?V�$�&7��5�B�$("��105J+��%Q39�;�&'

1b�JV�;�9)���*5�QH$�1O�5�$�")!?&K�:&�;�&0�4$�"���3BL$("��105�+���Q��n",d6+���5J+N&�+)�S5A�4&7��h��J"%!#�18�>S��J10P��j"�;�B�9)�J12$|.'!?BL����

!t+�J1b��+)$���-��J1b!�Z w % %�[��*")����:�)Q���5J$�")$�BI�<5>���%$)�:;|&<�<$�"N+�A!T!?�A��"L&�+%�V)1K$�P�10��!t! $�.3&K10�-)�_;�")��$(")!xQ|9%$%&7+

��"j"�;�BS9)�J13�")-��n"�$�1KP�M"3��!CM&0�*$�"3Z % %0o

�O���M"Nd>�n&n+3�:"L&�+��>���*BI�n&7! $�.��n&@!#�*").K��;)�J"�5���Q(&�+��>5�$�"�5��J"�&�1KJ&7��$�"I$|.�5JAV)�n&���3��!T-��J.0����5�&7��-�9��

5�$|B�V��M"3!tJ&�$�1��W�5J&7!MQEd_+)��5J+¬18��!t;)�n& �*"c&�+)�NP��M")��1K�� �:BLVH10$��%�JBL�J"�&�$�.Td>$�1UY%�<"�PW5�$(")-��*&���$("�!�Zkq�&

d6A! &�+�;)!�"�$�&k!t;�1UV�1b��!C�:")P &7$ �>��*�J��� &�+HM&�5�$�"�&7��BLV%$|1K�1�� !x$�5��n��<��!?&�!�+��-©;�")-���1UP�$�"��D

5�$�"��%��10!M��$�"R¥|v�q�&T��!_")$,��$(")P��J1 Ll�;%�(!U&@�*$�"�$�.OV�1b��-H�*5J&7�*"�PN&�+��L-��<��4��5�&0�45S5��&7�5��*�%!CBNQ)d6+)�<5�+,d>������Q

!x$�$(")��1g$�1g�<M&0�J1bQE-)��!G&K1b$(�z5JJV)�*&������!G&�!x$�5����J&<�|Qª�"3-�$�._����BN�*&7�n"�Pz$(")��r�!S�J.0.K$�1�&0!&7$�V)1K�JV��18�*")Pc&�+��

d>$�10Y���"�P�5��<A!C!xQ P�10$�;�V)��-��n"�&7$¡10�J�%$��*;�&7�<$�"��1��~9�$�-�����!MQ#.7$|1>&�+)�W-���5���!M�:�%�a�"�-~�:"3�M�)�:&K�9)���a-���

d6+%�J"�&�+�����5�$(")$�BI��5k5�$("�&71UA-���5�&0��$�"�!W5�10�JJ&7�J- 9�� &�+)�k5�MV)�*&KA����!G&Id6$�1b��-�d>���*�>+HM�)�{9��J5�$�BL�

Page 23: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

;�"|&���"�M93�*��Z_q�&���! .0$�1ª&�+)�JB§"�$�d gl(;���!G&0��$�"L$�.��J"��)��!CMP)�*"�Pj&�+��6MV�V)10$(V)10�<M&7�_BL�J�!8;)10��!X&�$S5�M"�5J�A�

$�1R10��-(;%5��#V�10$�.0�:&�d>�n&K+)�*"Sg!8&0������5�MV��4&7����*!?&�!C$�5����M&<�)Zpw % %0o o

Ñ�á��°Ì�� ��Ì���� ����ÒDË � È � �'�°Ë È Ì°Õ Í � È �2Ë

fT;�&>d_+�M&6�10��&�+��aB��J�!8;)10��!CQ d_+)��5J+)Q .K10$�B "�$�d^$�"3Q d>�����T�����$�d ;%!=&�$�5�$�BS9�J&6&�+)�

P�18$�d>��"�P�-���!?V�10$�V%$�1@&@�*$�"¬$|.T10��5�+)�J!jA"�-c&�$�P��:�����)A�*;��F&7$�L")�JdD!t$H5��<A����!CB � �>��* J���z-���.K�<"%��!

&7+��JB§V�10��5��*!x���n�%Q��"�")$�;�"�5J�*"�P>+���10�#&�+��#P�10$�;�V)�*"�PS$�.H&�+)�6�*�!8&3&�+)10���_����5�&�;�10��!2�*"S+)��! �����(�L5�$�;�10!C��¥

vM����10� d¢�¡+�J�|�­&�+��­d>$�1KY��J1b!JrL;�"��*$�" � � �UQ&7+�� 5�$�$�V���1UM&0�*�)��Q&�+%�¡V�;�9)���*5 !C�J1K�)��5���Q>d_+��*5J+

!x�<P�"3�*.0��5JJ"�&7�n�IBI$�-)�*.��F&�+��j-���!8&K10�<9�;|&7��$("=$�.2!C$�5(�*��310���|�J"�;%��ZFi���=$(")�6"�$(&@Q�9��L&K�Y)�n")PF&n+3�:")P�! &7$

&7+�����1L���*BI�n&7QT!8;�V�V�$�!x�z&�+)M&0QT�*.&7+���!t�a-���.U.7��10��"�&��*"%!G&0�*&�;�&K��$�"�!,-����%����$(V�V�10$|P�10��!C!x�n�%���n���")-{&K�M")-

5�$�")!M�*!?&��J"�&@�:�©&7$¤�JJ&\Jd6��D�&W&7+�� �*")!U&0�*&�;|&7��$("%! &�+��&W�10� &71K;)�n� 5J�V3�:&KA����!8&W;�"�&7�<�c&�+)�M� �1b�

5�$|B�V)�<�M&K�A�n�������*BI�*"�J&���-�QOd>�cd>$�;3�*-\�J"�-{;�Vkd>�:&�+k�5�$�������5M&K�*�)��!?B -��J18�*�)��-{.K10$|B^&K+)��5�;)1K18��"�&

5J�V)�n&������!?BIQX"%$(&T9��{BI�JM"�!L$�._1b���)$)�:;�&7�<$�")QX9�;�&T9��{BI�JM"�!L$�.6��BFV%�J1b5J�JV�&@�:9��*�c�M�)$��*;�&0�*$�"3Z�`_"

�����9�;)�<�*������� 0 ")��$��U!t$�5�������<!CB �4! &0�M"�-)�:")P &7$�d6�18- &K�Y)�*"HP &�+�� V)���5�� $�. 18����$���;|&7��$(")J1K�

i�J1K�)��!?B,Zpw % %Ko o o

ik�1K�I$(9)!t�J1K�)��-j&�+)�T1K�V)��-S����V)M")!C��$("L$�.3&�10�-��T;�")��$(")! ��"j�O")P���J"%-jJ"%-HQ�.��5A��-Sd>�4&�+j&�+)��!

V�+)��"%$|BL�M"�$�")Q�+)��! M&�&7�:&�;�-��Td6�!��BS9)�n�%�����"�&b¨�$�"j&�+��6$("%�#+)M"�-j+)�TV�1UA��!t��-j&�+%��!?�_.0��10!?&R��.U.0$�1�&@! $�.

&7+��Sd6$�10Y���"�P,5����!t!#&K$,$�1KP��"��*!M�L� &0!t���*.��")-N")$(&���-N&�+)���*1���.0.K��5�&X$�"/&n+)�S-����|����$(V�BL��"�&O$�.2.K�5�&0$�1K�

���JP���!C��J&7��$("3¨R$�",&�+��L$(&�+��J1�+�M")-�Q3$�9)!t��1�����-N�>��� ����%QH+��SvJ+��!#&7$�$/BS;%5�+¬.K��*&K+��<"¬5J�V)�n&������!CB &K$

9%�(�������|�/&�+)�&¢�n&#�<!L-���!M�*1U�93�4�c$�16V)$�!C!C�*9)���/&�$\-���!?10;�V�& &�+)�c5�$(;)10!C��$�.65JAV)�n&������!?B 9��\BI�J�")!S$�.

;�"3�*$�" $|1����JP)��!M�<M&0�:�)�~�n"�&7�J1K�)��"�&K��$�"�w�Qj�"%- .K1b$�B &K+��&,BI$�BL�M"|&=$�")Qj+%�¡9������4�A�|�J-�&�+��&I"��Jd

Page 24: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�%�

���JP���!C��J&7��$(")QOd6+���&�+���1g-��A5J18���!M�:")PW$�1¢�n"�&7�M"�!M�*.K����"�P�&�+%�/d¢$�1UY%��$��-�QEd6$�;)��-�$�")�n�¬�5�5������J10M&0�F&�+��

BI$(�)��BL��"�&>&�$|d6�1b-k5�$("�5J�M"�&�10M&0��$("3Z e���)��1�&�+����*��!t!MQ {.7��d^�����18!¬�n�&K��10Q &K+)�{!x$�5��������!G&0!,d>�J10�

$�93���<P���-F&<$N�5JY�")$�d>���J-�P%�&�+)�S�:")5J1b�JA!M�n"�PIBL$�BL�M"|&n;�BD$|.R&K10�-)�j;�")�<$�")!_�K�2�*"�£6�J1UBL�"|�%QHd6+���5J+

!t�d>Q(V)J1K&7��5M;3�*�10�*�L�.�&7��13&K+)�6�<�d�$�.R�J�)5���V�&0�*$�"L$�.D�����|�%Q�&�+)�6�*BSV)$�!C�:&0��$�"N$�.�_V�$�!C�:&0�:�)�_V%$�����5���$�.

1b�J.0$�1KB �<BLV)����B���"�&���-c9��¬J"\�<B>V)�J1b�*��XP%$%�%�J10"�BL�J"�&�5A$("�5��J1K"%�J-�d>�*&�+z-��J.K;)!C�*"�P�1b���)$���;|&7��$(")J1K�

!x$�5��<A����!?B,Z qK&�d6�!W��!x!C�M"�&0�<A���:�y�'"HP%�*J"%-HQT+�$�d6�J�%�J1bQ_d6+)��5�+�5�$�"�&0�*"�;%��-­&�+��J"y&7$¡V�1b$(V%�(�6&�+)�

BI$(�)��BL��"�&'�EvJq�&'��! �O")P��<�"�-)Q�"�$�&���-S�>��� ����|Q|d6+)��5M+FV)10$��)��-���-��';H17$�V)�d>�*&�+N&�+��65��*�!t!M�<5�A�|&���V)�

$�.D;�"��*$(" d6$�10Y��J1bQ�d6+)��5M+ &KM;)P(+�& �O;�1b$(V)� �9)$(;�& &�+�� .0$�10BI! $�. ���*93�J10A����!CBIQ�$�1 $�.

V��10���<�BI��"�&��10�<�"3�4!CB �*"/&n+)�F.��5�&0$�1K�%Q�ux;)!?&2�!>�:&O&KM;�P�+(&O�O;)10$�V��LM9)$(;�&2&�+)�S.0$�1UBI!6$�.�����9��J10�����!tB

�")-/V��1b���*�BL�M"�&K�18��J")��!8B �<"IV)$����:&0��5�!?w % %0o « ���"3-N&�+)�L�*�!G&R&7+)�<1K-�$�.E&�+��j")�*"��M&K�A�J"(&�+¬5J�J"�&n;31@�z!M�d

&7+��S-��A�%����$�VHBL�M"�&2$�.E&71K�-�����;�"3�*$�"¬!t$�5��*�����!CBLQ3$�.Od6+��*5J+ � �*-�"��J�I�"%-Ffg���&710��5��� �M9�9,d>�J1b�&�+)�

V�1b�<"%5��*V������-(�)$�5�J&7��!�Z % %K« mE+��*!ad6�!��VH1K�P�BL�&@��5y!C$�5J�������!?B �"�-��>A�� �������BLV�+�A!C��!t��-§�<&b!

;�"3�*l�;%��")�A!C!_��"N&K+����n"�&7�J10V�10��&7�&@�*$�",V�10$(�)��-��A-F9��F&�+)�_�~�J9�9�!J¥�v��*"�!G&0���-L$�.O�<")!x��!8&0�*"�P�Q3����Y��6ik�1@�|Q

;�V)$(" &�+��y1UA-)�*5���,$�V�V�$�!M�:&@�<$�" $�.z�n"�&7��10��!G&7!k9���&7d6���J" &�+)� d6$�10Y���10!¡M")- &�+�� ����NV�$�d>�J10.�;)�

�JB�V3�*$��%�J1bQª;�V�$�"c&�+��S���/�����)�:���M� $�. &�+)�L5�MV��4&7��O�*"�&�+��N.��5�&0$�1K�%Qs&7+��J��V)�*A5J�I��BSV�+��!x��!j�:"�!G&7�JA-

;�V)$("c&�+)�L��5�$�"�$�BL��5N�*")!G&7�n&n;|&7��$(")!jdg+)��5�+W�18�LV�10��!C�M"�&7�n��&K��"%-��*"�Pc&7$����<BI�:& &�+)�L$�BS")�*V�$(&7�M")5��L$�.

5J�V)�n&���g�<"{&�+���.KA5�&0$�1K�%Q ;HV%$("k&�+%�c�����6�����?�����<�¬.0�JJ&�;�10��!,$�.6BFA!M!NV�1b$�-(;)5M&0�*$�"3Z w % %K«0o � ������1U��

BI��&�+�$�-�!SJ1b�F&�+�;)!jBL$�93�����<!x��-,9|��&n+3�S&K10�-��(��;�")��$�"aB�$(����BL�M"�&8¥3BL;�&�;)�� �*"%!?;�1K�"%5���QO5�$�������5�&@�4�|�

9��1KP�A�<")�*"�P%Q�"�-��9�$��%�¡�����Q>�*��P���!C���&@�:�)�k-)�J5��*!M�*$�"%!�Z mE+)�J� �����$�d �:&L&K$��5M+��<�J�%�¡�5��J1K&KA�<"

"�;HBS9%�J1�$�.{��nBI!MQ��*" V��1@&@��5J;)�<�1{&�+)� .0�*�)�<"�P¤$�.{18;)����! M")-©BI�*")�<BL§1b�JP�J1b-��*"�PDdS$�1KY)�*"�P

5�$�"�-��*&0�*$�"%!#�")-Nd6JP%��!�Z=mX10�-)�;�")�<$�"3�4!CB &�+�;�!#10���5J+��A!_�n&7!T$(9Mu¯�J5J&7�n�%��!xQH9�;�&@Q|A!#�>A�� ����NV)$��*"�&7!

$�;|&7Q�d>�:&�+)�n"S�%��1��SV)10��5(��!x�_���*BI�n&7!xQ(.0$�1��n&s��!O")$(&)gl�;)�J!?&7��$("L.0$�13&K+%� ;�")��$�")Q�v�$�.������nBI�*"�J&7�*"�P6VH10$�.K�*&7Q

Page 25: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

��®

9�;|&�$�"c&�+��N5�$�"�&K1KA1@�|QE$�.�&K�Y���"�P��!6NP��*�%��"�&�+��N1b�J���&@��$�"�!?+)��V�9)��&Kd¢�J��"c&�+��N5�MV)�*&KA����!G&�M")-c&�+)�

!t��<�18����-��JBSV)��$(�)����Q��*"L$�1K-���1H&0$S�*BLV)1K$��)� &�+%�_5�$�"�-��n&@�*$�"�$�.H&K+)�Td6�P����0�J�1�"3��1Kw�Z

q0&¬�<!{&K+)��5J$�$�V��J10M&0�n�|�J!{&�+��&¬!M��� &�+%���<1�P%$���NA!�&7+����A���*BL�*"�J&7��$("D$�.�V�18$�.0�:&tZ mE+)�

BI$(�)��BL��"�&gd6�!S.0�*1b!?&_;�&7$�V)�<5�d>�4&�+W]g$(9)�J1K& �_d>��")QO&�+)��"�-�$�5A&710�<"�A� d>�4&�+{[s�J1b-��*"��"�- �2�!x!?�������Q

d6+%$ !8;�V�V%$|1�&@�J-^���|5��*;�!C�*�%�(�:� &7+��§VH10$�-�;�5J&7�<$�" 5�$�$(V%��1KJ&7�n�)��Z fT� ��������Q�P�;)��-���- 9�� &�+)�

5�$�"�&K10��9�;�&7��$(")!6$�. � +��10���A!6£j�*-��AQ � �)-�"%�J�,�"�-Nfg���&710��5��� �J9�9)Qs�"�-N[R10J"�h �_V�V��J"�+�����BI�(1bQ % %K«0o o

�*&>$(V�&7��-­.0$�1�5�$�"%!?;�BSV�&@�<$�"�5J$�$�V��J10M&0�n�|��!MQ�dg+)�<5M+kV)�J1KBI�n&�&7��-a&�+)��!?;�V�V)10��!C!M�*$�"�$|._&�+���5����!t!M��5

5�$�"�.0����5�&@!X9%�A&�d>���M"L5�$�"�!t;�BL��1ª�")-jV�10$�-�;�5��J1R�"%-j9��J&�d>����"I5�MV)�n&7���J"%-L�<M9)$(;�1tZ_i�JY%�n"�P>;�!?�g$�.

&7+��_5�$�$(V%��1KJ&7�n�)����;�")��$�"L5J$�BSV%���JBL��"�&�A10�n&��%Q�BN$�-���1K"L!t$�5��<A����!?B§&�+�;%!XV�1b�J-)�*5J&���-j&�+)�_vMV�1b$�P�1K��!t!M�:�)�

�")-L!GV)$�"�&KM")��$(;�!�10�������!C�&@�<$�"L$�.3&K+%�65�$����*�A5�&0�:���*!?&R1b�JP��*BI�Jw�Z % %K«Ko o o mE+%�_!?;)5�5���!M!CQ�+%$�d6�J�%�J18Q�$).E&K+��

5�$�$(V%��1K�&K�*�)�cB�$%�|��BI�J"�&_BL;%!?&T9���l�;HA���*.0���J-HZ �_9MuM��5�&7��$�")!F.K$�1>10��A!C$�"%!L$�._V)10�<")5��:V��*�cBL��\9��

BLA-���¥ �T$H$�V���1KJ&7�n�|��!tB $�.0.K��10!N")${V)10��5���!C��1K;)����!,5�$(")5���1K")�n"�P{&�+%�a!t�J&�&7�*"�PkM")-{P�1K�-�;�J&7�n"�P�$�.

!t��<�1@�F�<�J�|����!CQ��:&�-�$���!X"%$(&��*���-j&K$Sg1K�-���5J��H���<BI�*&��&K��$�"L$|.�V�18$�.0�:&bQ(A")-F�*&�$�.U.7�(10!�")$S10��A�H!x$��n;�&@�*$�"

&@$/&�+��SV)10$�9)���JB $�.218������U��!8&KM&0�I�n"%5J$�BL�(ZW`g9)$%�%�L�����QH+%$�d>���%��10QR$�"��LBN��P�+�&O+)��|��1b��!C�J1K��J&7��$(")!

�9)$(;�&2&�+���V%$(&7��"�&7�<A�O�A��V��"�!M�*$�"¬$�.T!?;)5M+�I!G�|!G&0��BNQ3d6+��*5J+\�*!j��nB���-/"%���n&�+%�J1TJ&�&�+%�F����1��¬18��5�+

"%$|1RM&3&�+)$�!x�#d6+%$��1b�_���|5��*;�-��A-S$�13���J1@��V�$�$|10Q�d6+3�45J+L��!T�:"|&<��P�1KJ&0��-j"%�(�:&�+���1��*"j&�+��65�$(;�"�&71���Q�"%$�1

&71K;3�:�I��"F&�+)�9)��PS;�1K9)M",5��M"�&K10��!xQ|�"�-L.0�<"�A���*�)Q�d6+��<5�+N10�JBL��*")! 10���!x$("��9)�n�Ld>�JAYN�*"L&K��1UBI!T$�.��n&0!

5�$�"�&K10��9�;�&7��$("j&@$&�+)�_-��J���A�<$�VHB���"�&s$�.HP)��$�9)���d>����*&�+3Z

�>��� J��� 5�$("%5(��;)-���- +)�<! ����5�&�;�10� $�" 5�$�$(V%��1KJ&7�n�%��! 9�� 10�JBL�1KY)�*"HP�¥�v � � � &�+3�

-��A�%����$�VHBL�M"�&�$�.O&K+)�F.K;�"%5J&K��$�")!j$�.O&K+)� � &7�&@�F5�$�"�!8&0�*&�;|&<�(!_"%$�d6�-����!6LBL;�5J+�BL$�10�N�<B�V�$�1K&K�"�&

+)��!G&7$�1b��5JA�#V�+��J"%$�BL�J"%$("k&�+�M"{&�+)��-��J���A�<$�VHB���"�&¢$�.�5J$�$�V���1KJ&7�n�|�(!�¥ � &�J&7��5J$�"�&710$H�2+��!F&�+�;)!N

P�18�J�&K��1S+)��!8&K$�1b��5���6��BSV�$�1K&K�"�5���&�+HM" ��$�$(V)��1UM&0�:����!CBNZpw % %0o % ¦>"�.0$�1@&�;)"�J&����:�)Q��>A�� ����~-H��-y")$%&

d61b�:&0�S$�;|&R&�+)�S�*�!8&'�<�A5�&�;�10�j$�.ª&7+)� �������,5�$�;�10!C��Q3-����)$�&0��-F&7$ � &�J&��S5�$�"|&�10$��KZ % % %�mE+)�>5�$("�&���"|&�$�.

Page 26: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

&7+)�<!>�*��5M&�;�1b�FBLM��"��J�%�J1K&�+)�A�<�A!C!_9��L-���-(;)5���-��*"�N5�$(;�V)���L$�.2d6��%!�¥)9���10��V�1b$�-(;)5A�n"�PN�>A�� M���3r�!

$�;|&7���*"%�F.K$�1g�:&0Q % % %Ko�$�1#9��¬�J�%JBI�*")�*"�Pc+)��!jd61b�:&0�*"�P�!6$�"c&�+%� � &�J&7�N!?+%$�1@&@�:���.�&@�J10d6J1b-�!CQE9%��&0d>����"

�����(�S�")- ������®3Z

�>��� J���>V�1b$(V%$H!t��-j.7$|1)&�+��_�*�!8&R����5M&�;�1b�T$�.;�����(�>&�+%�#.0$����<$�d>�:")P>$(;�&@���:")��¥

vJq0"�&718$�-(;)5�&@�*$�"R¥ &�+���!?$�5��n��<��!?&7!�M")- &�+�� � &7�&7�(Z q8Z ����.K�<�"�5J��$�.F&7+��¡.7��!M5JA� � &�J&��y�KBI�<���:&K�1@�%Q

V%$H����5J���8Z�qKqxZ)mX+%�]>�45��1b-��n�")��!?BD$�.Ei��1��'¥�+)��!TV�18�Uut;%-��<5���!#10��P�A10-��n"�PL&�+��L��-���S$�.E&7+�� � &KM&0�(Z�qKq0qtZ

mE+)�g£6�J1UBLM"L!t$�5�����)-���BL$�5J10�&@!�!x�n"%5�� �A�����HZ ���:���*��¯�����*����� �M�LZ

�_1b�nP)�*"�!§$|. � &KJ&7�^!t$�5��*����<!CB,Z��~�(�*.K�1b� !C$�5��<A����!8&0! �7fg1b��"�&7M")$�Q � 5J+�B�$����*��1K�tZ � &KM&0�

!x$�5��<A����!G&7!�¥��~�P�")��18Z ���C�0���(� �¯���2J")-j�t�������t�>���JZ

`SZ mO�J"�-��J"�5��6&@$�d6�10-)!O-�$�P�BL�&@��!CB/Z

�Z �RA1�&0�<A�#1b����")!G&KM&7�JBL�J"�&¢$�.>5��<A!C!M��5JA� V3!8�)5M+�$)�*$�P(�)Z2mO+�����5A$("�$�BL��5�BL$�&@�n�|�(Z

mE+)�T��&7�J10"�����"�-&�+��T+3�4!?&K$�10��5J���Z

93Z q0")5�$�1�V)$�1K�&K��$(" $�.,+���!?&�$|10��5J��LBFM&7�J1b�n��<��!?B �:"|&<$§5��<A!C!x��5J��S&����5�+��:")PHZ¢mE+)�

&7+���$|1���$H.�&K+)�g�J.0.K��5�&s$�.3��Jd ;�V�$�">&�+3�T��5�$("%$|BS�)Z � $�5��*���10�<P�+�&0!JZ

f>Z mE+)�#10$����T$|.H&�+�� � &7�&7�(Z

�Z mE+)�&n+�18���jV)10�<"�5��:V��*��!g$�.2$|1KP��")��!tJ&7��$("RZ�� 1b�4&@��l�;��S$�.O&�+)�jV�10�n�%�5��,V�1b�*"�5��*V)���(Z

mE+)�TP���BL���:"3�K!C� �

93Z mE+)�g�nAdy$�.3��")5J1b�J�!t�*"�PS���%V�J")!x��$("�$|. � &KM&0�T�5J&7�n�|�n&��HZ

� $("�5��n;)!M�4$�"

����!G&7$�18��5�A�ª��BSV�$�1�&K�")5��j$�.R&K+)��!g-�$�5�&710�*")�%¨%J�2BI�J"�&0�*$�"L&�+)�S�:")5J1b�JA!C�>$�. � &�J&7��.K;�")5M&0�*$�"%!�¨)9��2mE+)�

V%$H�:"�&�&7$�d6J1b-

d6+)��5�+L-�$�5�&K1b�:")��!25�$�"��)�J10P��(¨�"�M&0��$�"�����<!tBIQ(+)��!U&7$�1b�<5���!?B�Q(!M$�5A�<A�<��!?B,Z

Page 27: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�%�

`gV�VH10��5A�<M&0�*$�"�$�.25�$�BSV)�����/-�$�5�&710�<"���¥�A���-(�)�"�&K�P)��!#�"%-,-���!?A-(���"�&K�P���!_$�.OBL�!C!_V)10$�-�;%5�&7��$("3¨

9��RV�10$�-(;%5J&K��$�"

J")-L-���!G&710�*9�;�&K��$�"ª¨%5J�ª&�+%�6�n")5�10���!C�6$�.3&7+��6.K;�")5�&@�*$�")!�$�.R&�+)� � &�J&<�d6+)�*5�+L-�$S"�$�&�5�$�"�.0�<��5�&

d>�*&�+>&�+%�

-��J�%����$(V)BL�M"�&>$�.>�<"%-��n�|�<-�;����9�;3!x�n"%�J!M!t��!M¨�-|�>BS;)�n&7�*V)����5JM&0��$�"�$�._&K+���.K$�1KBN!F&7+�J& � &KM&7�

��"�&K��1@�|��"�&7�<$�"SBLJ�

&K�Y���Z

fT;�&T&�+)�E��������10��BL��*"%!J¨EBL�"3�*.0��!?&7!L�n&�!x���<.g��"z&7+��N+���!?&�$�1@�a$�.>�n")!?&@�:&�;�&7�*$�")!MQO�g��!�1b�J.0����5�&0��-{�*"W&�+)�

+)��!G&7$�1K��$|.�-�$�5A&�1b�:")��!tw�Z

���F&�+�;)!6")$(&7�J!jA!H�������E&�+)�N10��!C�L$�. NV�1b�*"35A�nV)���I$�. � &0M&0�,5�$�"(&K10$����<�*"�Y���-c&�$W��5�$(")$�BL��5

A5J&K�*�)�*&��)Z `#& &�+��,!?�B��F&0�<B���QE+)� � �t���X� �¯�(�AQE.K$�16�M�)JBLV)����QO-�;�1b�:"HP�&�+%�,5�$("�&718$(�%��10!?�W9%��&Kd>���J"

+)��BL!t�(�*.�J")-�������.�1b��-)$��J1b��&7$�Q(&�+�J&H&�+%� � &7�&7�6��!�v��A!C!C�M"�&0������:�)Q(&�+)�6�*")!G&K1K;�B���"�&R$�.�-��J.0��"�5��6$�.R����

��"�-��n�|��-(;)���!#�P���n")!8&�����3P�1b$(;�V3!8wL���>A�� ���� ������®E¥U���������tZL���jd610�n&@��!#BI$�1b�j����&<�J")!C�:�)���*�I!?&0�����H&7$

fg$�;HP%�� �Q���"ae$(�)�JBS9)��1·�������R¥RvJq>9)�����*�J�)�N&�+��&g&�+)� � &��&K�¬�<!S"%$(&_�'� �¯���s�*�*�9�D� 0{&���10J")")��5J��0¥E�*&¢��!

�(���x�J���<�:� �;� 0z&�+%�S�*")!G&K1K;�B���"�&'$�.2-��J.0�J"�5��>$�.2!M$�5�����&�����",P��M")�J1UA�ªAP�A�<"�!?&�V��1�&@��5M;���J1T!t$�5����J&����J!MQ)$�.

A���)�<"%-H�:���*-�;�A��!��P�A�n")!?&�A����P�10$(;�V)!JZ6q�&�"3$L�*$�"�P���1�5�$�1K18��!tV�$�")-�!X&7$L�:&0! ��!x!t�J"�&0�*���5J+��10�5J&7��1ªd6+%�J"

�*&O9��A5J$�BL��!_M"¬�<"%!G&K10;�BI�M"|&'-���.7��"�-��*"�P,P�1b$(;�V%!_J"%-/V�J1K&0��5�;)�<�1 !x$�5����¯&@����!JZNfg;�&7Qsd6+%��"¬�n&'.K;)��.K����!

�*&K!S.K;�"%5A&7��$("�QEd_+%�J"k�p&Td6$�1KY)!j&�$W!?&�1K;�P�P)���N�P�A�*")!?&�&�+��NV�1b��-�$�BL�:")J")5��,$�.TVH�1@&7��5�;��*�16!t$�5��*�J&7����!

�")-cP�10$�;�V�!CQH&7$N9��L����1KBI�J-N9��¬�:&0!6�5A&7��$("�QH9%��5JM;�!?�j&�+�J&2�5J&7��$(",&K�M"�-)!#&�$c1b���n"�.0$�1b5��I�4&7!x���<.2J")-

BL�Y)��! �n&7!x���<.0Q����&@�J18Q�_&@�J1K1b�<9)���6d6��JV)$�"N�*"L&�+)�_+�M")-�! $�.s&�+��J!x�P�18$�;�V)!xQ���!�&7$�P%�¯&ª5JJ;)P�+�&3;�V,�*"N

�|��5���$(;)!25���105(�4�_J"%-&7$jP��*�)� ;�Vj&�+��T$(")�n�>BI�JA"�!2�<"�$(;�1RV�$�d¢��1)&0$S-��J.0�J")-H���C���J�%���LZ�v % % %0o o

Page 28: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�%�

mE+)� � &��&��S+HA!MQH&�+)�M"�Qª��!M!t�J"�&7�<����*��Q3LV�$����:&0�*5�A�E.K;�")5�&0�4$�"c&�$cV�10��!x�J1K�)�F.K10����-�$|BD&�+�18$�;�P�+

&7+��_5�$�"�&K17$H��$�.RV%$�d>��1RM")-j&�+)�T10��P�;)���&@�<$�"L$�.3V�+%��")$�BL��"�_$�.s-�$�BN�*"�M&0��$("3Zg�>��* J���|Q(+���10�_�P���*")Q

!8&KJ&7��!L5����JJ1b�n�s¥ªv�qU&¢!C+)$(;)��-W"�$�&T9���!t��*-a&�+�J&gBL�M"kJ1b�,9�$�10"k.�1b���c�"%-k�J!?&��9)���*!t+a&�+)� � &�J&7�/&7$

��"�5J1b�J�!t�#&�+)���n1�!M��5J;�1b�4&��LM&ª&�+)�6����V)�M")!C�6$�.3&K+%���n1O.K1b����-�$�B,ZjqK&�!t+)$(;)��-S9��6!CA�<-I�*"�!G&7�J�-�&n+HM&RBL�J"

d>��!G+y&7${9��z.01b���a�"�-­&�+�J&7Qg�n")!x$�.KJ1LA!/&K+%�J��d>��!?+k&7$¡9��W.K18�A�(Q &�+)��� �J!?&��9)����!?+�&�+)� � &�J&���&K$

��"�5J1b�J�!t�,J&T$�"�5��N&�+����<1¢!t��5�;�1b�n&��W�"�-z&�+%�(��1_.K1b����-�$�BSw % % %Ko o opZ¡[R1b����-�$�B �*!j")$(& -��J.0�*")��-�9|�\&K+��

�93!t�J"%5J�I$|. 5J$�")!8&K1K��*"�&7QEI5J$�"35��JV�&2d_+)��5�+��>��� A���¬-���!t5�10�n9)�A!j�!jv�J"��105�+)�*5�Qª�"|&7��!C$�5��<A�*wF}W9�;�&

9��L&K+%�j�;�&7$("%$|B�$(;�!Tv����%��105��*!C�S$�.�18���!C$�",�"�-N.KA�n&�+��<",10��A!C$�"�w�Z��>�M&E+)$�d -�$��(! &�+��*!#.K;�")5�&@�*$�"

���|$��n�%�{d>�n&n+)�n"y&�+)�{.�1U�BI��d>$�1KY $�.Sk!M$�5A�<�M&��~d6+���10�{��5A$("�$�BI�*5WV�1UA5J&7�<5���!c-�$�BI�n"��&�� � `g18�

!x$�5��<A�ª�"�-���5�$(")$�BI��5jV�1K�5�&@�*5���!_BL$�10�S��.K.0��5�&@�n�|��&�+�M"�$�&�+)�J1b!6�*"��J"�M93���*"�PN&�+�� � &7�&@��&7$N1b�J�����!M�

�*&K!2v��J!M!t�J"%5J��w�Q�&7$�;%!C�#�>A�� �����r�!X&7��1KB �k���6$|.0.0�J1b!�+)�J1b�_J"L�BS9)�*��A����"�&3�")!?d>��10Q�9�;�&R$�")�_d_+��*5J+

��!CQ�.0$�12�:&0!�&0�*BL��Q�V�18��-�$�BI�:"HM"�&@�n��$(V�&@�<BI��!G&7��5�¥�$�"L&�+��_$�")�_+�M")-�Q��n&s!C����BN!O&�$F1b��&KA�*"S&�+)�j�4�(!t!x$("I$�.

+)��!G&7$�1b��5JA�EBL�&7�J1b�*�����!tB©�")-NA5JY�"%$�d>�<��-�P��6&�+��&O�A5�$("%$|BL��5jV�10A5A&<��5���!CQH+�M���:")PN&�+)�jV��1@&7��5�;��*�10�n&��

$�.R9)���*"�PS�9)���g5J$�"|&7�*"�;)����:�j&@$�10��5�$�"�5������65J$�"H.7����5M&3�"%-S5�$�$(V���1KJ&7��$("�Q(�18�_V�1b$�BI�<!x�*"�PS�"�-SBLM�S9��

�93�4�/&7$z&���A5J+�&�+%�c�10-�;%$(;)!L����!C!t$�"\$�._V)�*;�10�����!?B J"%-{5�$|BLBL$�"{P�$(�)�J10"�BL�M"|&0Z �#"W&�+%�c$(&�+%�J1

+��"�-�Q�+%�_-�$)��!X")$(&�-)��"��>&K+��&H&�+��6!t�BL�TV�1UA5J&K��5���!CQ���.R;�"�5M+)��5�Y���-)Q(�18�_V%$%&���"�&0�*����n��5J$�"%-(;)5��*�%�#&K$

"%��dy&���10�"H")����!JZ>q0"N+)��!���"�&�1@�I$�"Iv�!t$�5��*�����!tBFw��:"L&�+%� �%�H�M��&�9�*�%���t�j�A�C�K�*������>�A�3�<���J���)��� ���%� �*�

�E�3�;��� �¯� �'���*��Q_�>��� ���� V�$��n"�&7!�$�;�&L&7+��&L&�+���10�y���|��!?&L���10���-(� &Kd>$�-H�4!?&0�:")5�&I.7$|1KBI!{$�.,v � &KM&0�

!x$�5��<A����!?B�w�¥�FvA-���BL$�5�1UM&0��5�.7$|1KBLw�Q310��V�1b�J!t�J"�&7��-/9�� ��+H�1K&K��!?BIQH&�+)�F!t$�5(�*�����!CBD$�.=��$�;)��!#f6��M")5

��" ���A®H�W�"%-a9��\vA5J;�1U10��"�& i�J1K�)��!?BLw�QXdg+)��5M+k���BL!S.K$�1j�"��<"�&7�JP�1UA�T-��JBL$�5�1K�&K��!C�&@�*$�"\$|.T&�+3�

� &7�&@��M")-a.0$�16&K+)���JBLJ")5��:V�J&7�*$�"�$|._&�+��c�*"%-H�:���*-�;�A��QO�"�-kM"kv��10��!8&0$�5�1KJ&7��5c.K$�1KBLwadg+)��5J+{+)�

A!M!t$�5��<M&7��!Fd>�:&�+{&�+��,"��BL�A!�����P�����Q � A10�n�%����QE]¢$�-(9%�J1�&K;)!MQOM")-a���P�")��10QX�"%-ad6+%��5M+{d6�!S&�+)�

.0$�10B JV)V)���*�A-z&7$a&�+���!t$�5��*���V�$)���n&@�*5�!N$�.Tf¢��!?BL�1UY)Z§����5��<�1b�n.0����-k�:&_&�+)�J10��¥Rv � $�5��������!?BIQE&�+�;�!

Page 29: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�)�

5�$�"�5��A�n�)��-)Q�+��!N9)10$�Y��M"yA���#&@�*��!/d>�:&�+¡&�+)��`6"�P���$���[31b�J"%5J+y�*"%-H�:���*-�;�A����!?B $�.&�+��W���<P�+�&7���J"�&�+

5��J"�&�;�1@�)Z~mO+��,�*"�-��*�)��-(;)��2�J�)��!G&@!j$�")�n��&0$c�5�+)���J�)�I5J��1�&KA�<"\�*-�������"�-W��BSV)�J1b!C$("���XA�<BI!S� �1@&7Q

!x5(���M"�5��AQ(1b������P���$("L�3d6+��*5J+S�1b�_�JBS9%$�-����J-j9��>&�+)� � &�J&���ZTfT;�&0Q�V�1b�J5���!C���*�>9)��5J�;�!x� &�+��6�*"�-)�:���*-�;�A�

1b�JBI$(�)��- .�1b$�B &K+�� � &KM&K����!¡M"DM9)!8&K1K�5�&@�*$�")QFd>�*&�+ +)��!��n"%5�$�10V�$�10�&@��$("¤�:" &�+3� � &�J&7��Q�&�+)�

��"�-��n�|��-(;)��6.0�*"3-�!c+���!/&�1U;%�{10�<P�+�&�!c1b�J�����!?�A-HZ mO+)��!/v � &KM&0�k!t$�5��*�����!CBSwk5�$�"�!?&7�n&�;�&7��!c�!t$|1�&�$�.

9�;H10��M;�5�1KJ&7��5FV�J&���1K")����*!CB d_+)��18�S&�+)�N�*"�-)�:���*-�;�A��Qs&�+�1b$(;�P�+z&n+)��������J"�M&0��$("¬$�. +��<!>$�d6"�1b�<P�+�&7!CQ

.b�*"3-�!E+)��!OBFM&7��10�<A���")-jBL$�10���+��V�V��*")��!C!OP�;H�10J"�&7����-(w�Z

Ö�á�� ��Ì �:� �·Í��2��Ì

�>��� J����r�!c.K��10!?&����J5�&�;�1b�J!,$�"k�2;�10$�V���J"~!t$�5��*�����!CB 9����1j&K+%�z;�")-��M"3�*�9)���¬&71UA5���$�.>+)��!

+)��!G&7$�1b��5JA�F�"�-§5M;)�:&�;�1UA�FBI�������M;N¨6&K+)�J��18�J.0����5�&I�"�;)BS9��J1�$�.N&7+)�¡l�;)��!?&7��$(")!CQ>-���9��&@�J!MQjM")-

!x�<P�"3�*.0��5JJ"�&�5�$�"�&�1b$(�)��18!x�<�A!c$�.j&7+��{vA£j$���-���" `_P%�Jwk$�.S&�+��{mE+%�<10-­]#�JV�;�93����5k�:"y[R10J"%5��(Z�qK&���!

��BFV%$�1@&��"�& ")$�"��J&�+)������!M!&�$W��BjV�+�A!C��!&�+)�N.��5�&�����'&7+)�(!t�I�����JBI�J"(&@!jd6�J1b�N�V�V)1K$�V�1b�n�&K�A-c9|��&�+)�

�%$�;�"�P�V�+)����$�!x$(V�+)�J1b��+3�4!?&K$�10��J"W&7$zV�1b$(V%$�!t�N+)��!S$�dg"aV%��10!C$(")A��.U1KABN��d>$�1UY\.K$�165�$�"|&���BSV%�<M&0�:")P

�")-S�*"�&7��1�VH10�J&7�*"�P&�+%�_5�$�;�18!t�_$�.�&K+)�_��5�$�")$�BN�45_J"%-S!C$�5��<A�H�M�)�M"�&K!2$�.3+)��!'&7�<BI�(Z

mOd6${A!GV%��5�&7!Fd6��18��!t��P(")��.0��5��"�&8ZR[���18!8&0�:�)QO+)��!SV�$�!x�:&0�n�%���*"�&7�J10V�10�J&��&���$("k$�.#i\�1���d>$�1KYH¨

!x��5J$�"%-��n�¬+���!jM"���n�%!x��!>$�.�&K+%�N18�����&@��$("�!69)��&7d6���M"W �5�$(")$�BI��5J!>J"%-cV�$����n&7��5J!jdg+3��5J+z!G+��V���!6+���!

P%�J"��J10A�H�*"�&K�A�<���J5J&�;)A��.K18JBI�Jd>$�1KY3Z

�>�10��$�;�!W5�$(BLBI�M"�&��&�$|10!�+�J�%�k5����JA10�n��l�;������.0�<��-¡&�+��k5����!x!C��5k$(9�!x�J1K��J&7��$�"�BL�-��a9��

��$�;%�<!>`>�4&7+�;)!x!?��1 % % %0o « 10�(�*J&7��-c&7$c&�+��F&�+)�J$�1K�J&7��5J��Od>�J�Y�"��A!C!>$|.�&�+��N10��5J�MV|&7��$("z$�. i\�1��s��!MB ��"

[R10�"35��y�&L&�+��¡&�;)1K"§$�.N&7+��¡")�*"��J&��A��"�&�+ M"�-�&Kd6�M"�&7����&�+ 5���"�&�;�1b����! % % %K«tZmO$ &�+)��!{�M")-�Q�&7+)��!M�

Page 30: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�%�

5�$|BLBL�M"�&KM&7$�18!>18�����*��-�$�"�&�+)�F;�"�5�$(�%��10�<"�P¬$�.TN-)�JBSA"�-��*"�Pc"%$�")�7i\�1�����!?&�18��5��JV�&0�*$�"z$�.�ik�1@�

9��S&7+��#[�10�J"%5�+=�n"�&7�������J5�&�;����! �2;%5�����"L�>��1K1bQ�� +)�18����! `_"%-H�4��10Q�$�1O£6��$�1KP���! � $�10�(��Q�JB�$(")PL$(&�+��J1b!�Z

�����<�#��A�< M���I5��*���18�:�LV)J1K&7��5��*V�J&<�(!��:"F&�+)��!�;�")�M��V���5J&���-S10��5J�MV�&K��$�"ªZ�����! �:"�&7��1�V)10�A&�J&7��$("�Q(+%$|d¢���%��10Q

$�.R&�+)�_V%$(&7��"�&7�<A���:&7����! $|.3i�J1K�)��!?B -��<.K.0�J1b!T!C�<P�"��*.0�<5��"|&7�:�I.K18$�B &�+)�65��<A!C!x��56$(")�6�:"L[R1UM"�5��_J&3&�+)��!

&@�nBI�6VH10$�V)$�!x�J-�Q3.K$�12���%�BLV)�<�AQ|9�� � +��1b����!#`_")-����J18Z)`6"%-��<��1�d6A!_!M�M"�!M�:&0�*�%�&7$F&�+3�6V)�*;�1K�����!CB $�.

!x$�5��<A����!G&�&K1K�-��*&K��$�"�!a�"�-y&�+�;)!W5J�10��.�;��&7$ ���)�BN�*")�{&�+��aV)10$�5J��!x!W$�.F&K+%�¡-��J5A$�BSV�$�!x�n&7��$("�$�.

i�J1K�)��!G&�-�$�P�BL�Q�5J$�"%-���BS"%�J-�.0$�1g�n&@!S�J5�$�"�$�BI��5N-���.K��5A�<�M")5����J!>$�1T.0$�1_�*&0!S-���!t-���*"�.0$�1g�<�dDJ")-

� BI$�1K���� �UZSq0"¤5�$�"|&�10�!?&7QI�A�|��"¤�*.�+����*"D"�$ d6�� +3��-���!{ik�1@�sr�!k�V�V�1b$(�)�*BLJ&7��$(")!MQ��>A�� M���

5�$�")!M�*-��J10!F&�+�J&g&�+3��.�1U;)�*&K.K;)�<"%��!C!I$�._ik�1��|��!CB 18��!x��-���!,�*"~�n&�!NBLJ&7��10�<A����!?&>�*"�&7�J10V�10��&KM&0�4$�")Q�J")-

�9)$(�%�F����2�:"��*&7!6�n"����:&7�&@�<$�"c&�$c10��.0����5�&�$�"c&�+)�SV�$����*&K��5M��E10$)�<��$|.���5�$�"�$�BN�45F5A$("�.0����5�&@!JZ)mE+)��!j��!6

V%$H�:"�&gd6+���5�+{&�+��c[R1b�M"�5J+\V�+)���4$H!t$�V�+%��1jM"%-k5(�4$�!C��!?&_.010����"�-k$�._�>��� ����|Q `¢�<A�<"\93��!?&¢!G;�B�!F;�V

d6+%�J")Q65�$�BLBL�M"|&7�*"�P¡&7��" �%�J�10!W�<M&0�J1L;�V)$("��>A�� M���3r�!�.0�<10!?&S�|$��*;�BL�k$(" &�+%�{+)��!G&7$�1@� $�.�&�+��

�2")P��<��!?+\V)�J$�V3�*�W��"­&�+)��")�:"3�M&K���J"�&�+k5��M"(&�;�1K�~��VH;�9)����!8+���-��:" ���à�M���bQ�+)��d61b�4&@�J!F&7$k+)��!N.K18����"�-�Q

vJq0")-�;%!G&718�*��N9��1U9�A10��!?B ��!{&�+�����.U.7��5J&¬$�.c�V�18���|��$�;)!{9H�1U9��1b�<!CBIQS�")- BL��5M+�J")��!tJ&7�<$�" +�A!

"%$%&�+��:")Pc&7$�-�$Wd>�n&�+��n&g�T$�"a&�+��,5�$�"�&K1K�1��RZ3i­��5M+HM")��!CM&0�*$�"�+)A!MQE1KJ&�+)�J18QEBLA-��F&�+��,$)�*-W!M��&�$�.

+��9)�n&�! ;�"�9���J10�93�*��Q�9��LP)�:�|�<"�PS&K+%��B >5��*��J1'5�$(")!x5�����")5���Q�9��L1b�JV)$|1�&@�*"�P�&n+)�JBD�*"F&�+��6BI��-��<AQ�9��

BL�Y)�n")Pc&�+)��B V)10$�P�1b��!t!j.U1b$�B &�+��N�J��� �x���E&7$¬&�+)�)�X�9���� �M���KZRmE+)��!V)��5�&�;�1b�N��!jd¢$�1@&�+��z$�.�ik�1��R¨

�")-&�+)�J1b� �%$(;S+)M�)� �%$�;H13BI$�-��(��w % % %�«0o:Z

�>��� J��� V��J1b!t$�"���L.K1U�BI�Jd>$|1KY§BI�*P�+�&I9%�­"%$|d !?;�BSBI��-�;�V �*"�&�+)�¡.7$H����$�d>�*"�P§.0�Jd

d>$�1b-�!JZ��>��� J����r�! �&�&0�J"�&@�<$�"Nd6A! �9�!x$�1K9)�J-S9��S&7+)�1b��!t�>$�.EBI$�-���1�"=�<"%-(;)!G&710�<A�R!?$)5�����&7����!CQ�d>�*&K+)�*"

&7+���';�18$�V)�JJ"=!?V�+)�J18�AQ3�*"/&�+)� ���� ��5A��"�&�;�1K�HZ�[�$�1O&K+)��!T18�JA!C$�")QH�)�J1K���JA10�n��$�")Q3+��S5M+)$�!x��&<$F&�;�10"

+)��!>�n"�&@�J10��!8&�&�$,&�+%�SV�$)�<�*&0�*5�A�O�<BSV��5¯&�$�.T�A5J$�"%$�BN��5L-��J�%����$(V)BL�M"�&8Z����L$�9)!t��1�����-/&�+�M&2dS�:&�+c&�+��

-���!?AV�V)�J�1U�")5��_$�.RBI�<���n&��1K�SA")-jBI�<���n&��10��!G&0��5g!?$)5�����&7����!CQ�!C$�BL�T")�Jd��:"�&���1K�5�&0�4$�")!X�10$�!x��Q�10��!8;)�n&@�:")P

Page 31: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

.010$�B 5�$�$(V)��1KJ&7��$(" �")-¡5A$("�.0����5J&7Q#�"%- �:" 5�$�")!?&��"�&����|$��n;�&@�*$�")Q 9)��5J�B��aP��M")��1K����*h���-yJB�$(")P

V�1b$�-�;%5J��10!MQ#�;�&�+)$�10��h��*"�P¡"%��d .0$�1UBI!�$�.L5�$�"�&K17$���"�-y1b�JP�;)�*J&7�<$�"y9���&K+��\5J$)�����J5J&7�n�%��Z�q7" &�+)��!

5�$�"�&7����&s-�$�BI�*"�J&���->9��L��"�-(;�!G&71��)Q�������"I��.3+)�#")$(&7��-�&�+%�_18��!C�6$�.s5�$�$�V3�J10M&0�:�)��!2J"%-�&71K�-��A�@;�"3�*$�"%!CQ

�>A�� �����;�"%-��J1b�<�*"%��-�&7+��\�n"%���)$�10�9)�<�WP�1b$�d_&�+�$|.6&�+3� � &�J&7�aA"�-­&�+)�\�*BSV�$�1�&K�"|&>M")-{V)$�!x�n&7�:���

V%$H���n&@�*5��� 10$����cdg+)�<5M+��:&gd>$(;)��-aV)����\.K1b$�B &�+)�& V�$��:"�&¢$("�QOd>�4&�+%$�;�&g-���!?P�;)��!x�n"�PW&�+��c.��5�&T&K+�J&7Q

d>�*&�+)$�;�&218��!?&K1K��n"�&@QH&�+%�FP�10$�d_&�+¬$�.X&7+�� � &�J&��I5�$(;%��-c���!t$/9��J5�$�BL�L-�M"HP��J1b$(;)!�¥|v�qg��")-/d��:&�+�&�+)�

� &7�&@��w�Qj+)�yd610$�&�� &7$�fg$�;�P%�� ��:" BL�� �����(�)QSv��:&¬��!{"�$(&�BS� .��;)�*&�J"%- &�+�� ���*9)��1K��<!kM")-

���n9)��1@&��10��J"�!�5�J"�"�$(&)+�$���-jBI�T18��!?V%$("�!C�*9)���#.K$�1R�*&�w % % %K«0o o�Z

�>��� J����r�!y$�10�<P%�n"���<�*&�� 5�M" 9%�����%�J" BL$�10� V�1b��5���!x���:� !?&KM&0��-3¥j9�$�&�+ V�+)����$�!C$�V�+)�J10�

+)��!G&7$�1b�<�"��")-/�"W��5�$("%$|BI�*!?&7Qª+%�F10�JV�1b��!x��"�&7!CQ��*"c[R10J")5���QE$�"��I$|.O&�+3�L1K�10�N��"�&K�A���*��5C&�;���<!6$�.�+)��!

P%�J"��J10M&0��$�"j&7$j+�M�)�#&�18����-j&K$�5J10$�!t!�V�$����n&7��5J���10��.K����5J&K��$�")!�$�"j&�+)�#.0$�;�"�-��&K��$�")!�$�.H&7+��T")�Jd¡[R1b��"%5J+

]¢�JV�;�9)����5#d>�n&�+S1b�J.0����5�&0�4$�"�!2$�"j&�+)�_��5�$�"�$�BI��5#BI�J5�+�J"%��!?BI!O$�.H&�+��#"%�Jd �<"%-(;)!8&K10�<���!?$)5�����&@�*��!�Z

Page 32: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�U�

��6(�,�� 6

Å­®£²2µ=©Ä§ � §�¿�� µL§�©Ä¬�¸ ½�²\¬�� À º]¸*®2Æ §�º*« �������� ���������� �� ¹�³QµÄÃ2®£©mÁw¸V²­¬�®°ºR®°±ºR§�²�²�®�©�ÃD§�©WÁ ¸UºV®�²

ª�©�§�³X¬ ²»§�¿Qµ]®�¿Q©m²°º]¸���«£©�§�¿�����®£³aÃ2§©mµ�¸=±�¿Uº]¸=®´©»²�¿Q© º*®IíºV§�³ «�±¹�³U¹�Á ¸=¾�¿U®���§�¿ � � 4 ²¸�!�±�º*®#"%$�º�®&��¸V²�µp®

³�«�§�³QÁ¹�¸7³U²a¿Q³ µ=¹�¿ µI§�¿UµV©®:Æ §�º*« ��� �Ã2º*¿�²:©�«]í¿'��º]¸*±§�¸V³y¾�¿U®�º]¸���«£©Ä§�º(��¾�¿U®�º)��¹�³ÓÃ;®�¿ µI©�®£µ=©m¹�¿ � ®�©

¬�§ ³�²2²�®�²\±�¹�³Uµ=©�¸���¿Qµp¸*¹�³�²\§ ³Uµ]«�©¸V®�¿Q©m®£²+* ºR§-,2©m§�³�¬�®.,2¿U®©�©�®#" À ºLº=®�²2µ]«´Á¹�¸ ªà³X®£³�µ�¬�®»º=§}Ã;©�«�²�®£³X±�®

¬/� ¿Q³ §�¿ µp®�¿Q© Ã�º=¿�² ©Ä«V½�¹©�Á ¸V²�µ=®���Ã2º*¿�²·§�µLµ]®£³Uµp¸ ½y§�¿���±£¹�³U¬�¸=µ�¸V¹�³X²w±¹�³�±�©�!£µ]®£² ¬�® º=§�º=¸���®�©mµL«Ç¬�®²

¸=³�¬�¸ � ¸=¬�¿Q²­®µ�¬�®´²/Ã2®�¿mÃ�ºV®²&�Q®µ(�U¬0!£²­ºV¹�©m²1��Ã2ºL¿�²2³�¿�§�³U±�«­²�¿U©\ºV®UÃ2©m¹�2®�µ/¬/��¿Q³ ±£¹�³Uµ=©13�ºL®�Ã2¹�º=¸*µp¸V¾Q¿�®:®µ

²Ä¹�±�¸=§�º:¬�® º4� «£±¹ ³X¹Á ¸=®�"�¤D®65IÃ;©�®Á ¸V®�©87 Æ §�ºL« ��� Áw«�©Ä¸[µ]® ®9�à§Á®�³:"/;<� §=��¹ ©m¬·ÃD§�©�±® ¾�¿U® ±£®µ

§�²=Ã2®�±£µX¬�®:²m¹�³6>°¿ � ©m®�®�²�µ�§�²�²Ä®�?UÃ2®�¿ ±�¹�³X³U¿:" À ³Q²¿X¸*µ=®��U®£³ ©Ä§�¸[²m¹�³ ¬�®°²m¹ ³Ç¸V³Uµ]«£©#@£µI¸[³�µL©¸V³�²�!¾Q¿�®��

*ãºV§°½�¹�¸V²\Ã;§�© º=§y¾�¿�§Qº=¸*µ]« ¬�®´²Â®�³X¾�¿'@�µ=®�²·¥�¸*²mµ]¹©¸V¾�¿Q®�² ¾�¿A� ¸Lº2ÁB!£³�®Ç§�º*¹�©�²1�;Á§�¸*²Â§�¿Q²�²Ä¸�Ã2§�© º=§

� §QºR®¿�© ¬�®£² ©Ä«V½�º*®9��¸*¹�³�² ¾�¿C��¸]º ±�¹�³X¬�¿U¸*µ ²¿�© ºV®�² ©m®�º=§�µp¸*¹�³�² ®³àµR©�® «�±£¹�³¨¹Á ¸=®�� «£µ]¥�¸=¾�¿Q® ®µ

ÃD¹Qº=¸*µp¸V¾�¿U®�"�Å-� «�µ]¿Q¬�®·¬�®wº=§:Ã}©m®£Á ¸(!�©m®�²�«£©¸R® ¬�®ÙºL®�D¹�³U²E�}¸*³�«�¬�¸Vµ]®�²&�ಿ�©aº4� ¥�¸=²�µ=¹�¸V©�®·¬�¿ ²�¹�±¸*§�º]¸V²�Á®

®�¿�©�¹�Ã2«®�³:�:¾�¿A� ¸Lº°¬�¹�³U³X§ ®£³ ���� �F* ÅG� À ±�¹�ºV® Å­¸���©�® ¬�®´² ¼�±�¸=®£³X±�®´²IH;¹�º=¸VµL¸=¾�¿U®²1�UÃ2®´©mÁ®£µ°¬�®

� «�©�¸ ½�¸=®�©\ºV§}Ã;©m«�²�®³�±£®»¬�®:±®J5�æ©Ä®´Á ¸*®©87:ÆǧQºV« ��� "

��& ���n�8�)���

À ºL¸V®­Æ§QºV« �K� � ²­º=§�µL®©/L»¹©&M�²2¥X§ � ®­Áw§�¬Q®­¥�¸VÁ ¹�³�®:µ=¥�®�Á¹�²�µU©m®�³U¹NL­³�®£¬.O2©®�³X±Ý¥Çº=¸���®�©m§�º

µ]¥�¸*³:M�®£©�²a¹�½ µ=¥�®P� � µ]¥ ±�®�³àµ]¿�© � "Q$.L­§³Xµ}µL¹ §�©�ª�¿�®��à¥�¹=L»® � ®´©9� µ=¥I§�µ�µ]¥U®�©®�®E�¦¸V²mµ*² § ³X¹�µL¥X®£©�½�§�±£®µ

¹�½ãµL¥�®ÇÁw§�³R�[Á¹�©m® ©�®pÃ2¿'��º=¸*±§�³ µ]¥U§�³�ºL¸���®£©�§�º(��µp¹<��®2½�¹�¿U³X¬ ¸V³�¥�¸V²­Ã;©Ä® � ,2©m®�§�µBS§©­ÃD§�Ã;®£©m²&"

Page 33: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

Æǧ�º=« � � ©�® � ®§�ºV²�¥�¸VÁw²m®�º ½ §² § Á§�³ L»¸*µ]¥ ©�®V½�¹©�Á ¸V²mµ µ�®�³�¬�®�³�±¸L®�²&� ±�¹�³U±�®©�³U®¬ L»¸Vµ=¥ µ=¥I®

±¹ ³X±£©Ä®£µ]® §²=ÃD®£±�µ=²Ù¹'½»½�©®£®�¬�¹Á �/��¹�µL¥Ù½�¹�© ¸*³X¬Q¸ � ¸V¬�¿�§�º[² §�³U¬aÃ2®¹�íºV®£²&�2§�³X¬ µ=¥�®�©®V½�¹�©m®w¥�¹�ºV¬�¸V³�ª

Á¹©®Â¾�¿Q§�º=¸ ½�¸]®£¬ � ¸=® L2² ¹�³ µ=¥�®\Ã;©�¹�2�®£±µ2¹8½ §�ÃD¹�ºL¸=µ=¸L±§QºD§³X¬ ²Ä¹�±�¸=§�ºD±�¹³XµL©�¹�º}¹�½ µL¥�® ®�±£¹�³�¹�Á � "

� ¥�¸=²°¿Q³RM�³U¹=L­³ Æ §�ºR« ��� ¬�®£²�®�© � ®�²°¹�¿�©:§�µ]µ]®£³Uµ�¸R¹ ³:�U³�¹�µ�¹�³Iº � ��®£±�§�¿�²®�µ=¥�¸V²°§�²=ÃD®�±£µI¹'½w¥¨¸*²AL ¹©)M

¸=²�¥U§�©�¬�º � ® � ®Ý©°Á®£³Xµ�¸=¹�³U®�¬N� ��¿Qµ §�º*²m¹ ��®±�§�¿Q²Ä®�½�¸=©�²�µ}¸Vµ­¸V²a§�³y¸[Á\ÃD¹ ©mµL§�³Uµ\±£¹�³�µV©¸(��¿Qµ]¸=¹³ãµ]¹ µ=¥�®

¥�¸=²�µ]¹© � ¹�½ ®�±¹�³�¹Á ¸=±´²1��§�³U¬0�U²�®�±¹�³U¬N��¸*µI¸=²°§�³ ¸=³Qµp®´©Ä®´²�µ]¸*³�ª §�³¨¬ � §�ºL¿�§=��ºV®�±�¹�³�µL©Ä¸���¿�µL¸=¹�³ µ]¹wµ=¥�®

²mµ�¿�¬ � ¹�½ µL¥�® ©m®ºR§ µ=¸=¹�³ ��®�µ(L­®�®�³ ®µL¥�¸=±�²1��Ã;¹�º*¸=µ]¸*±²w§�³X¬�®±�¹�³X¹�Á¸*±²&"�� � §�³¨§�º � ²�¸=²I½Q¹�±�¿Q²m®£²·¹�³

Æǧ�º=« � � � ² ¿Q³ÄÃ2¿Q��ºL¸#²�¥U®¬�½�¸[©�²mµ:²Ä®£©¸V®£²Ç¹�½ º]®£±µ�¿Q©Ä®´²Ç¹�³ µL¥¨® ¥�¸V²�µ]¹�© � ¹'½ À ¿Q©�¹�Ã;®�§�³ ¼à¹�±�¸V§Qº=¸V²�Á �

¬�®º=¸ � ®Ý©m®�¬ ¸*³ �%� � §�µ µL¥X® À ±£¹�ºV® Å­¸���©�®�¬�®´² ¼�±¸R®Ý³X±®Ý² H2¹�ºL¸Vµ�¸R¾Q¿�®£²1�L¸V³ L­¥�¸=±£¥ µ=¥�® Á§�2�¹�©

½�®�§�µ�¿�©�®²D¹'½�µ=¥I¸V²2®�§©º � Æ §�ºV« �K� ±�§�³G��®C��®£²mµU¸R¬�®£³Uµ�¸ ½�¸=®£¬0" "

� F�����%�."HC5<�3#1 $'& <�3 K��!L9<�G�&8��� (���3H4;�)3?��*6& �21 A���* � � ���@�� �"���K� ������������������������! �"���#$�%#'&)(*���,+���� �-�����/.10����� )�! 2./0����,K3�465*798$:;7-<1= B�*6(0<H� �0+�>=� �!&/��?HK@��!A�B� ����DC�(E ���FHG1�IBJ �(2���K�%�!���L���I���MBN.O�P���*�D����#� �� $Q���*� 5 L �.& *�+JR1S=���@� *6CE�.& 1#K7-8�8�T)< M� � A �6*@�=���0���! �"#KU� 7V�W)& �21��,+ 4 "�&)� 3�3#*@�,+2�,K�*63DX�Y Z�(!�H�����H� A�(*���������*�\[;]^�%�����\�J�!��(������! �"��������_�!BH�H���`�%�DQ���M(2(!� 5 L �.&)*;+)KS'�N����*@C � & 1#K 7-8�T�a�< M� � � F�� ��K��'G,b � FH4�G#�!&D4dc < 3��,+ K`� �����5A9&)�5<H>'��"H&)�!3H3#*6�H+�R�A���*@�5�������N " �.3#1fe#& *6� 1�&)*@()� #<�3 � �!"H�Mg <�3 F<H( *���� *;+.C K��]/��(E !.`�-���^h� ���(i������ j&VkV ��K���%��"9����l�0��9 �(�A?K 7m5Kn�o�o�n�< K9p T�q�4�8 M M� r A �6*@�=�2������ �"Ks 7�� + I&J*63( * I#�,+ 1H�5���=1�* +D4@&J*6:GH4 *6<H3�1H�,+-& *�(N���,+ +!� +;t�K)@��*uv���w����B�#M�%�!.10�A��-��x����w�-�U�,��B� �(i���%�,K 7935�7-8)o�4�< R9p 3 p q p 8 pMr F��� 7�G�1H<H �* (�e#& <H:�!&J4;K�]V������yD���%#�uzAN[`@�#z.1��{����Kx����D�M�d#M"- ��� �BJ�%�I|9}�~����2|9~U|9�#K 5 7 *@������RL�&/� +)+.�,+ 1�G F��!I#4 �!3H4�& *�<H3?Kn�o�o�T)< Mr���� <H3�( �!&D3�*63'bPe&)�!3#(!� & �!IGH: �6*@(,�.3#* +DC +D��� � �;�.G#1H� B2*�( <�����4;K�X�Y�!��#9�w(*#j.`�,{)����"���� �,�����D�V(2����"M� 5 L �.&/* +�RNS ����� *6C �!&)17-8�a$n�< KB2*@(�<�����+=����3�?,�!&.K�X`�w@�#j.1��{��K�%x���� 5 L9�!&J* +MR�L?& �N+!+ � +^�=3#* ���&/+.*64 �0* & ��1���e#&)�.3?( � 7v8�8�T$< �!3�1 $%� ��* 3��'�!3 �.G�4���4

Page 34: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

F "��6 �*@��� � +DGH&)� K�� 7�� 1H* +)(!G?+ +)*6< 3 &D��I�GH:��*�( �0* 3#� 1�G ��* :?�!&.���@*;+DC�� C�<�1���&;3��� * 3 yD�_�!�� ���(�� ��� �%� ./0���� ��! 2.10,�K�.1 ����%���Kx���� K 1�*6&)M�$ M*�'�!3 �.G�4 5 L �.&/*;+�R � ���6C �!3H3 q 7 �N " 7\8�8�8$< Mr�� �,�8�0>;��&J��3( � 4 < 46�� L � � 4 <H3�* +DC < >246����N� &/��" ���N���� H"?M�A�� *�� �2� �@�� "K;X1� �K0�#� �(*����./������ ����%"9�K�-���������!�w��"-���9�U"9�9� KL �!& *�+9R!$2�@( �.3 K 7-a�8$4�< Mr�� � �)A93'b��@* + � 4�&)� 3?+ � �!4 *@<�3 K�l�0�����(2 ����%0� i&VkV0����% �� *.10��%"-���9@V������"����%�%�-B2K0>;* &/+.4#� 1H*@4 *6< 3 K 7 <�3#1H< 3 7\8�n�a M� ��� 3 46�#�@�E�!� �! �"54����H+D* +� �.31246�?� 1H��: � 4 � +�4@�#�!4 *@4 +DI?�!&ig���1K�+!���=4���8& ��(,�!3H4�+;" 3�4@���,+!*�+-*63� * (!� �N� ����M � �!4 4 + K�l�0�� �%�2���9���K�-( � 5 ���H>;<�&/1R � �;� & �!3#1H< 3=L?&/� +!+ 7M8�8 p <n R T$:,T�qzT$: pM� A-�6*�� � �0�6�� �"K�yD�%�9�% ��%(!�����w.V�!�!.`�������vQU�%���%�w��� |9~��D�!�KZ�"9���NK ?<H�;M 7 KUX�YC^�vQ�K�����9(2(����-� |v}�|�� 5 L�� & *�+�R�����(!�?�!4 4 �7-8;7!n�< M�z� A�3,b��@* + �546&)� 3?+ � ��4�*@<�3 K�lU0��1]�(E�� i&�lMA,(2�������K�!�9[���%�������*�d �� �! �"9�K����� ��B �������/�,(��HB2����� <H&Eg#K 798$4 p)F�z� � B2< 4 "���446& �.3 +D�;�!4 �012*63H4 < A93'b��@* +D��M�z� � � �'��"�C�< 3�1 $=&J<H3#K > < &J���=<�&/1 A�� *@�-� �0���N "K*yL� �-�K ��K(!�V�����! �"M�%�,�%�_�-B��V�9��(2 2./#9��� 5 L �.& * +�RvS=�N��� * C �!&/1 798�3�a$< M�z� rHA��@* ���2�0���� H" 5\7-8�3�a�< R n�8 p q�n�8): M�zr�c)���!3 q L9�!G��?F#�.&D4�&J�HK*]����K(2�9���%�9���1����(`�%�N.` ,�%�K���%x���� 5 L9�!&/*�+�R9S=���@��*@CE� &/1 798$3,8$< R 7!o�n M�zr%�)$=�;�!*63#K��V �(2(!�*��.1 ���������"9�V��u\�M" �V�K �(*�-��"�������]V���K�1yD���K#!uEA 5 L9�!&J* +^RvS=�!� ��* C �.& 1 7\8 p a�< R TO7!3 M�zr%� �!A���* ��� �N� �N " 5�7-8�8$4,< R 3,aU7 M�zr%� � � �%3 �2�)�@�� "�� + *63 I �.&D4�GH3! /G#+.4�*�>D*�� 1 I#�,+ +.*�C5* +/C �*;+ q�"9q * + A�3,bH�6*;+D� +D<�(�*;�!� * +DC K�+ �0�De&)� 3�#�<#*�+ >8��1?� & *�1���KVs A �;* �� �N���� H" ��4-��� + <H(�*��0��* +/C �E�.3b�� �N* +`t K)@J�*uv���w0,� ���� �(!�%x����,K n p 3 5*7-8$:�4�< R T$:O7\qzT�8�a�= #*�+ q�"�q �* +=�@* : �!&)� �91H�NC�<H(�& �!(�*6� + K+ ���V�%�!" C�<�3#1 $ & <�3#K�s=7V�W�&J�-1�N+ 4�" &/�!3H3#*@�,+�1N A ��*@�-�2� �@�) "Ht�K*@���u9�������VBH#��K�2./0!A'�!��x����V�9������B� �(2���K�NK 3�4 5*798�T�8�< M�z� � A��@* ���2� �@�� "K�X1�w�%0�#! �(2����.V�%���% �����"9�%�9�����V���\�1�-"����-��"���� 5 L �!&J* +$R!$2��(,�!3 7-a�8$4�< M�$� F�� ��� +5+.*jb03#* >J* ( �!3�4-�#* + GH3#1H�!&J4J� g#* 3b � 4 46�#� 4;* C � <�>84@�#�&%=&/�)" >;G?+��N>;>/�N*6& � 5 ���N���! #" 7-8�8$4 R n�o,T�q 3�o�< M�� 3 �*�+*63H <H�6 ���C �!3�4;K�+D� �(' * 3�(,�!3�4�%=G#(��@�)&D4JK;��A�� *6� �04�%��!3�*@� �����!� �� " 1�.3#+2�z $=>;>J�0*6& �%2&J��"�>;G#+*� K�* 3�X1��&M��B��K�%����yD����#*uiA|�)\��*$�i|$~���*HK�� 1�M)�=��3H& * �)4 4���S-G�" q 79<H� 5 L �!& *�+9R\e � "�!& 1 7\8�8$4�< M�$��� c < �H32$5M��%< : + <�3?Kvl'0��+�, �"9� ���9kV(2 �{��K��B,� 5 7 <�31H<H3NR!B5*�+D:#�N4 K 7-8�o;79< M�$��� � @���u9�,�I��� B�#M���2.10�A��-��x����I�9�����IBJ �(2���K�NK 7-8$o17 K �<H�;M 8 K�cDG#�6" +/GHIHI#���NC��!34 K I M 3 M � ��� & �) *6���2+-�=��&J� ������!3�<�3�"�C�< G#+0M ���#�2�.G�4@��<�& (��!3#K���< �2�! ?�)&)K+.4�* � �:�2*61��)3�4 *@>J*@� 1 *63 3HG�C5�!&/<�G?+-(,� +.�N+ � +����N� �! H"#K?+!* 3�( �=46��)&)�=*;+� ��N&/"+D46& <�3'b I�&/<0: �D:?*6��* 4�" 4@� �.48�?� 4�<�<$g I �!&)+D<H3#��� &/�,+/I#< 3#+ * :?*6��* 4 " > < &2&J�N �*����2* 3b 4���� I�GH:#�@*�( �N4�*�<H3�<H>=4���-�%< &ig�<H>2�!3A93'b��@* + �2��( < 3�<HC5* +D4DM�$��� � � A���*@�-�2��� �) �"�KMX1�'& �(2B����%�� ��H����(2�����%"9���K�%�!B��.10��%�� )�! 2./0��%x��,� 5ET �<�� M)L � &J* +$R!$2� (,�.3 7v8$o17-q*7-8)o�3�< M�$��� r A���*�� � ��� �! �"�K�l'0� �B����yw ��9Q���.v�%�w|/)!}0)-�2|9}��$~ 5 L �!&D* +9R F#<H(0*6� 4�� 3�<HGH �� �@���81H� � * :�&)�!*6& *��8��41N6�01H*�4 *6<H3 798�o�T�< M�$��r A��@*��-�2��� �� "K�s 7�� 1H<�(!4�& *63�8� ( <�3<�C�*21 G#�-1H�=F#�0* 3�4 q F�* C�<H3wt KMX1��@��*uv���`�,�/3 ��_�NK 3 R 4�3;7-q�4�:�4 K��!4 4 R T�8�q�: p5�7-8)o�a$< M�$��r���4 3 4���8(�<HGH&)+ �8< >?4����� �!" 7va 4@���!3�1�c GH3� a 4��2(�� ��+�+�C � ��4;* 3'bH+ <H> 798$o p�K0�2�!���� �" I&J��+D��3�4 � 1 46�* +91H�0>;*@3�*�4 *�<�3#K /���%�K�9���K�H���V���5�� �"���#��K# &)(!����+����%�-�V���.10��K�� ��! 2.`0��K�6� 798�o pK 7-8):,q*7-8�a M�$��r�� � A �6* ������� �) �"�K���79�-3#�0*�+)+!�!3�(,�-1 G=CE�!4@�#<H1�* +DC �8��3=$ 3,bH�@��4;�!&J&J�M�,K�@���u9���V���/k`��(*�%� K 79T KMp 7\8�q p T�8 � 3�1 a)3;7\qza)4�: M�$��r�� � � ���*��!&J&;" L���1 G�<H4 K;X/�*�O& ���_�-����(E�P���������9Q;�*�\[ �!�*�-���V�-��(D�%� Q����Z��!�����*�LB���(87$�%�!B��!���9� �`(!����"9�I|9}�}9*��2|�~|��5 L9�!&J* +VR 7 � FH"�(�<�C�<�& � 7M8�a)o�< M

Page 35: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

��®

�$��� �+� ��1H� � ��*63�� �'�!:?�)& *6<HG��?K��07 �5+ <H(�*�� � *�+DC � ��3Le&)�.3#( � 1�� 7-a):;7�"�798U7-3 �,K*63wyD�%�!�K ��K(!�JQU#���#9(E���%� �����! �"9� �,�%�_�9BH�,K �<�� M n K�1H*6&�M9c M�%=& <$? 5 L�� & * +^R!L &D�,+ +!�N+ GH3#* ?�!&.+D*@4J�!*6& �81H�^e#&)�.3�(,� 7v8�8�:�< M�$� �8F��!: ��+D4 *���3 7 �!GH& ��3�4;K9X�Y ]V"9 ��K�J�K�j{)(!�������V�-"��K�-��"����.1 ����%����x����*������|9} )9| � |9~�|v�M � �!C5<�*6&D�'1��'�E 4 3#+.4 *64�GH4�1���4@G#1H�,+I#<���* 4 * 1�G�N+�1���L �!&)*�+)K 798�8;7 M�$� �z�)A9C5*��@� � ��� "�+�+D<H3#K�>;< & ���#� C2I#�@�HM�$� �z� ��� 3 � � �@�,+ 4;*63D>8<�Gb����2�!3�1we�&/�!3 # <H*;+ F�* C�* � 31 � +-* 3�>J� G#��3�(�� K?+D�,�=� �!4 4���&)K�c.GH3�� 798$o17 K >J�!C *��6"��.&)(!�#* #��+)K�F�G�(�" q ��3 q>-&/*@�,M L?�*��6<+D<HI���!&.+ K9�!�6GHC53* <�>�4@����]�"� ��K���� �(2BJ�����5���*./#9(2�K�9��(!� K9�.3#1 C��NC2:?�!&.+ <�>�4���� 4 �N�NC <H>�4���2I�!&/*@<H1�*6(H�)�X�� C�����#9� �� �"-�K ��% 9Q;��x���� :?<�4@�#K�>8<�G'b���� �.31 F*6C *��!3�1 � �!1 �.3 ����(�� � �@�)34DgH3< �%�@��1,bH� <�> S �!& CE�!3 �0( < 3�<HC *�(��* 4 ��&)�!46G�& �HM >8<HG,bH�6� � �!1 IGH49�#* + 3#� CE�E4 < �5+DC ���@�9C�< 3�<�b�&)�.I�� �!3�4 *64;�6� 1DX1���5��"9������"9��� �� �"��������*� ���wC�������B��$Q��,� =F�*6C5* �.3#1 & �9b�G��;�.&/�6" &J�� *�������1 3#��� S8�N&;C �!3�&J� � � �,+D��+ <�3 �,(�<H3�< C�*@(,+ >;<�& 46� � ;�,(�<H3�< C�* ( +D<�(�*�<���<�b�"9%+ �0(�4 *@<�3 <H>X�� C�����#9�0�, �"M�% ,�% $Q�%x�����M �%3=7?G#(0* �!3=�2�!&D& � +�* 3> � G���3#(0�,KH+ � � 5 �2� �@�� " 7M8�8)4 R 4�8$:�< M�$� �z� � � $ & �N�N1�*63,b <�>91�*6>D>J�!&)�!3�4 �@� (�46G�&/�,+!K� 315*635I �!& 4 *@(!G#� � &�4�&)�.3 +.*64 *@<H3#��� I � + +!�9b��,+ K+ ���!CE+�4 < ( <�&D&J<H:<H&/�!4 �84@��*;+8< &)1��0& M4 3DcDG�3� 7v8$o17 K �%<�&Eg�*63,b5<�354@��� >J*@&/+D4 < GH4;��* 3?� +�<�>��?*�+8(�<HGH&)+D�HK������@�� " > G�&D4�����& CE<�&)�2�.3�3�<HGH3#(�� 1 �-I� �!35 #�N& " (,�@<�+ �4 < 4@�#* +�<�3?� 5 + � �-79�04 4��N& 4 < � MM>8<�G'b�����K�>/�!C5* ��"��.& (!�#*6 � + < M�$� �z� r�� �0���! #" � <H� ��� (04 *6< 3#KH>;<�61��!& n M 7 K9 �� �<�� G4�*@<H3�< > ��(�<H3�< C�*�(=�.3#1 + <�(�* �0��1H<(!4�&)* 3#� +-* 3 A�3,b � �!3�15�!3�1DS �)&DC �!3#" *@34����'+.� ( <�31 �#���@> < > 4@�#� 7v8 4@�2( �N3H4�G�&;" JK 7�n I �-b � +)KNI���b � 4 M�$� �zr �9{�����F �HI �9b�� 8 M�$� �zr�� �9{��K����I �9b�� 7!o M�$� �zr�� � �\{)����F �,I ��bH� 7-o M�$� �zr�� � � �9{��K��F ��I���b � 7!o M�$� �z� � �9{��K��F �HI �Mb�� 7�7 M��� e <H�@1H��& : M 3 K��e#& *��01�&/*@()�57�*�+/4 �!3�1 4��#� B��!4�*�<�3 �!��L <��6* 4 *6(H�!��A�( <�3�<HC2"9/K n�n I �9b���+)KNI �9b�� 7 M��� � e& *���1H&J* (!� 79* +/4 K � �����������K ������0�9A�������B ���9(�k/ ��%�K�j� ��"90����5.9 ��� �BH�%��jl�0����^���%�% ������+��A��!����B j&I�%0��wk1 ��%������"$���]V"9 ��� �B1A� 5*7-a)3;79< M ���)�@�! #"=G#+!��1 4����e& �)3?(!� � 1H*@4 *6< 3NR �-A��!��Z�BH�������%�� ���������� #M"- ��� �BH�%�;.1 ��K���%��x����NK 5 L �.&/* +VR � �.I ���@� �7-a p 7�< M ���!�KW) �" �N� + < &D�,�6* � 1�<�3 � M79���2* +!K+;�2* + 4 <�&/"�< >-L?&/<�4 � (�4 *�<H3�* + C /K�@J�*uv���w��� #9"� ��� �B��K�/.1 ��%���K�%x����,K 7�o 5 7-< K7-a�8$4 M��� � � �\{)����F �,I ��bH� + 7�7 �!3�1 7-n M��� � � � �-{��K��F ��I���b � 7!4 M��� � r �-{�����F �,I ��bH� n�n M��� r � ���@�� �" +!��� C +-4 <5�#�! �� I�& * 3#(�* I ���@� "EG +D� 1R��8<�+ (����!& K��H(2�����,(2�_�2������� �(*�%���!���9Q;�*����{��9(V���K�,��%�����_� ���%(-�K0���"-0��z&���F���,"*0�QN�*��"-0��K"-0����K��"�0��9(/3 �v�K0� ���� 5*7-a�3�T)< K*C����-�%"M0����M� ���9(��� �� .9������(!�K0���"-0�� &)� 5�7-a)4;7!< K :HGH4?���2�N� +D<5G?+D� 1�-A'�!���9B ����(�� �� .9������(!�K0���"-0��j&)� � �.:?<� #���!� �� <H�;M 7 K � ���-��(2������� �vQ���I���M(��^���%�� �������,.- ��� �B������ 5\7-a p 3�< M �%����� +D< & � ��* ��1 <H3$%1�<H�6I�� � �9b03#�!&6� +9( <�C CE�N3H4 �!* &)�N+!K ��(!���������2QU���vQ����9(kV ����%���%��"90��9����!.\ ��� �BH�%� 5-7\a$:�4�< M��� r%� ����� 4 �%< C �)* 3 +D< GH&/( ��+=>D<�&'�����@�! #" �=�!&/� 4���� >J<H� ��< �=*63bR'>8&;G�3�< �%*@��1H��:�&.�.31�K � �%���������% ����,� ��.- ��� �B��������9(���2Q�9� �/�,(2� ���������.9���i&)� 5*7-a�3�a)<2= �=*���1H�N:�&)� 31�K %2* � b �vbH�!3����.&D4 *�b � $=G�> bH�!:� 1H��& � * +)+.��3#+ (!� �!>;4 1��!&B��!4�*�< 3#������g�<H3�<�C *6��JK�* 3Dh���0�(2{���"�0��9()& ��(!�^�,�K�% ������ � .� ��� �B��%� �����-���%���K�%�!��� . 5*79a$4,T�<*=#" �!& � " 3*�� +�K � �%�V./ ����K���%��"�0,����.9 ��� �B��%�Vu9 ��5���%�����2.`��� .9�K�d���9(Q;�*�-"�0��%"90��K���%"90��9� 3 �9�%0� ���� 5 ����& b �!& ��1�* 4;*�<�32<�> 7\a�a�T�< M

Page 36: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

�9�

��� r%� � � �)* 3 +D< GH&/(���RS-G?+D4 � F�(!��C�<���� �!&.K9�H(2������(*�%�2�H����(dC���� Q;��B��9�K���9� �� �� .9� ����(!�_�-"�0��j&)�%�!����0�(2�,K�<�> � �?*6(�� 4 ���> *6& +.4 �<�� GHC��+�E��+�� #� * ���!:���8* 3 7\8�o;7 M��� r%� � �!�2�)& �-�2� �6�N " C �!3�4 *�<�3?+�R � �!& ��� �!3'b ��&/K G/������( �-��"�0����$Q������{���(/����� 3 �9�%0� ����V���M( �, �9� ��� �m� ���!�9�)�-"�0��z&)�j�M(-����������9(kV ����%���%�!"M0��9� � .\ ��� �B����V���)�\{)��� ������-(*� K 7\a�a�T F��� � �Ue <��61��!& : M 3 K�@�%* +.4�<H&J* ( * +DC /K n�o I �Mb��N+!K0I ��bH� 7�: M�i�-{��%��F �HI �9b�� 7-8 M� � �9{��%�,F �HI �Mb��,+ 7-8 � 31 n�o M� � � A �6* ��� �0� �) �" 5*7\8�8)4�< R T;7-T M� � � � � ���6�N "�� + :#* :��*�<�b &/�!I�� "�b�*6 ��,+ 4@��� > <����@< �2*63'bE&J�0>;��&/�!3( �,+ > < &'+D4�G1," <�> � �!& � � + #�0� G#� q 4��� <�&J"R " �.&/�9� � &$� K � ���� �!./�K�%��� 5 XO��{�(2���K(!�%�w����.d(E vQU(!Z*��e?&J��3�(�� 4�& �!3#+ � �!4;*6<H3�<H>� �<H� G�C � 4 5�7-a): p < �.3#1��.3#<�4����N& 4@&/�!3#+.� �.4;*�<�3 :�"�S8* �!&/1��.3#1>-&/*KW)& �,K �<H�6G�C�� 4 5�798$o�o�< K 4$4 5\7\8�o�o�< K�� 3�1 4�4$4 5*7v8$o17 �.31 7-8$o�n�<*= >;<�&246�?� 7-8)o�n ( <�GH&)+ � K��� G#+.��1 4@�#��S �!&JC �!3� 1H*64 *�< 3 >;< &246�#��(�< 3H4 �N3H4 + <H> #<H� GHC � 4$4�4 <2= " M9� �.&8�#K�3 � ��Zv(2�������%� .`0��K�% ��- 2.10��K�NK 3#��� �01H*�4�*@<H3 :�" S8* & �.&/1 �.3#1>-&/*KW)& � 5\7-a�8�4�<!= " M�� �!& � K��,��������(2���2.V(2� 7 �!.`(! j&)���_� 5*7\a�8�8�< M� � r�e <H��1H��& 4 M n K� � � &���*;+ C�M�'=��� G#� q 4����0<�&/"9/K n,n I?�9b��,+ K0I?�9b�� 7M8 M� r 4 354���� 7v8$o�n (�<HGH&)+D�,KH* 4 +)�0��CE+ 4��?�!4�������! #" �2��+ �.:?<� #�=�!���?* 3�4 ��&/��+ 4 �01�* 3546�#� $'G?+D4�& * � 3� ��N&/+!*�<�3 <�>?CE�!&2b�* 3?����*;+.C�M�%� G + �015� �N3,bH�!& K ��(!����������� ���J���9(��� �� .9� ���%(!�K�!"90��z&$�_�-�%�90�(!� 5\7\a$:O7-< �.3#1 A9G,bH�!3w>!�H��C q >=� �=��&Eg#K0 #<H� M n < > � �!./�K���������� � �!./�K�%��� �9���)�NK ��3H4 * 4 � ��1 k/ ��!�K�j�_uv� l�0��! �(2���I����� � �*./���K��� 5*7-a�a�8�< M 4 3 �#* + :#*6:��*@<�b0&.�!I�� "�K �#< �=�� ��&/K �#� �!�;+ <C���3H4;*@<�3#+�F�4 �.3���� " c �� �< 3#+�K�l�0,�* �(%A &fk` ,�%�K���K"9����]V"* ��� �B1A 5*7-a$:17!< �!3�1 79� < 3 � ��� &/��+ K/]V�K#-B��M���%��� � #9"� ��� �B��K�.1 ����%���Kx�����.1��(2� 5 4@��*6& 12��1�* 4 *�<�3?K 7\a�8$4�< M �%� ����+ < ( * 4;�N+ A9G,b)W)3�-L ��4 *64;K�]��%�����J"�(*�%�j�Kx����V�����/��� &�&)#�(!�����%���d�K0�#� �(*�%���d�����K�uv���K���,( 5\7-a�8�:�< M� rK� e <H��1H��& 7�7 M n K J���#�-$ G + 4@&)*��!324@��� <�&/" <H>? ?��� G?� �.312*63�4 �!& �,+D4 JK a I#�9b��,+!M� rK� � �9�=< + <�G�& (��,+ ����&J��R��`�,{��K���D]V�2�!�*A�� 5�7-a�8�8$< K ���!���! #" C �!3�4 *6<H3?+ *63�I �.&J4�*@(�G#� � &^>'�!&J3?�!&J1 F��#����� + (�<H3H4@&)*6:?G�4;* < 3 KJ���#� > ��+!* + <H>8F�<H(�* ���@*�+.C A�( <�3�< C�* (� = �!3�1EA 1H<�G �.& 1w>8��&;3?+ 4 � * 3 K �N��( �����-"�0��K"�0����������Ll�0��! �(2�������*� �, �"9� �,�K� �-B��)�5�7-8)o;7!< M� rK� � � � <�3(���&;3#* 3b 46�#��C �!4 �N&/* ����*;+ 4�*63�4��N&;I&J��4J�.4 *@<�3 <H> �#*�+.4 <�&J"�K �����@�) " � � C��!34 ��1 3�<H4 :#� * 3b �.: �6��4 < &/��>D� & 4;<X�� �!��#� ��K 9Q;�%�J�����%�9B���������M8�=�'1H*@1#K ��< �2�) �!& KH( * 4 � 4����=> <�6��<��2* 3b5+ <�GH& ( � +vR!� �!& � K��V �����(2��{������% �� � ���w"9(2���%�Kx����������K�.10����% �� *.10��%�D��� ��(2 ��K�V�,� yD�iQ;��� 5 7\a$3,T)< K 5 e& �!3#(!� 4�&/�!3#+.� �!4 *�<�3 :�" S *�� &J1 �!3�1 >8&J*�W!& � K 7-a�8 p <2= � �.&8�#K�3I����� &)�*�-����V �B�BJ�����%�!�K� 5 *63 4��#��4@&.� 3#+ �;�.4 *@<�3 I�& <0I <�+.��1 :�" � �#� &/�@�,+ $=3#1H�@��&/K 7v8$o17!<*= e&/*@��1H& *�(!� A93'b��0� +)K^yD�9(2(*� ]`�vQU���� ��0�(*� �$Q��HG1B,����� �����$Qw���9(��w�%�*�!�9����"-0��j&)� 5\7-a�:�a�< M� � � e?<���1H��& : M 7 K� �=*�+ 4 <�&/*@(,����CE� 4 ��& * �0�6* +/C JK 7 p%I���b �N+!K�I ��b��,+ a �!3�1 8 M� � �9{�����M K0I M 7!o M� �z� �-{��%�?M K I M 7!3 M1�8�vbH�!&D1�* 3'b 46�#* + K-<H3�� +/��<HG���1 3�<H4�� 4@��� ( <�34�&D<H ��!&.+D"�>;<�����< �2* 3'b S8�0<�& b�� F�<H&J�0�i�+ ���HI?<�+ � �07 �CE�!4 ��& * ���@* +.C��-��* +.4�<H&J* 1HG��M�NKM V���K���������H���V�����! �"9�%#$��#v&)(2�,��+����%�!�^���.`0����% ��2 !.10��%�,K n K 798$o�n M� �z� � �\{)����M K�I9M 7�3 M� �z� � � F�* C�<�3#1H� F* + C�< 3�1�* K �� ���u9�����V.V(2����"M� ./�\�m� Y #�"9 ��� �B����;./ ������%�Kx���� 5�7-a)n�o�<*= � <�3 + 4;� 3�4;* 3�L9��(�1�G�!G�&/K � �*�J���U���$(-�M�9���� "� �B�BH��(!"�� ��� �$Y �%�������!��(2���!����� � Y ��Q(*�%"9���K����(*� �-����� ��� "��Kuv���K�%�!���%�� �� ��� Q�9���9(E�,���! ���� � Y ���j&)��������"9� ���*��2.�.`����"����%�� ����1���d�K��u9�!.`����( 5\7-a�T�8�< M

Page 37: Elie Halévy's first lectures on the history of European ... · Elie Hal evy’s rst lectures on the history of European socialism Ludovic Frobert To cite this version: Ludovic Frobert

���

� �z� r�e?<��61��!& 7�7 M T KM�,������� �.&8��* +D44���� <�&J" <H>�(,�!I#* 4 � ��( <�3#(0��3H4�&)�!4 *6< 3,�,K 7 p I �9b���+ K0I �9b��,+ 79T � 3�1 7!3 M� �zr9�9{��K��F ��I �-b � 7!3 M� �zr%�E�-{�����F�K�I9M 7 pM� �zr%� �1�'�9b��.& 1H*63,b 4���� &)� (0��3H421��!: �.4 � + �!&J<HGH31�46�#*�+ 1�G��,+ 4 *�<�3 K-�2�0�6� H"�1 G�<�4 �,+�R " � & � " �!GH4;+ g#"�K � �%�DC�QU(!��( &�(*�vQ1�5�7-a�8�8$<!= A 1�<HG#� &J1D>8��&D3#+D4��0*63#K � �%��� �(2�����2�-��� �M���9QN���D���*�,�� �9�K���%�_�!B����������D�����dC��j&\Q��,{)�-�����M(��� ����%��������BJ �.9(!�������5�7-a�8�8$<!= A�C�*@��� '=�.3#1H�N&; #����1��,K�X`�d"� ����K�9"9�K��u9�K�!BH�V�9���MY #�u9 ��%�,�%�K ��H� �������!��(*�%�9���K� 5�7-8)o�o�< M� �zr%� � � e <H�@1H��& 7�7 M 7 K$� � �.I * 4;�!�#(�< 3�(,�!3�46&)�N4 *�<�35* 3E�9b0& * (!G#�64@GH&/�M�,K 7-n I ��bH� +)KNI �Mb�� a M� �z� � �-{�����F�KNI ��b�� a M� �$� e?<��61��!& : M n K$� � �.I*64 �!�(�<H3�(��!3�46& �.4;*�<�32*635*63�1 G#+ 4@& "��,K I �9b�� 7 p M� �$��� � ���#� (�< 3�( �!3�4�& ��4�*@<H3 < >8( �.I?* 4 �0��* +2��( (�< C2I � 3�* ��1K�*63 4@���5C�<�1���& 3 �=<H&J�@1#K�:�" �!3 *63H #�!&)+D�5C <� �� C5��3�4�4 < �E�!&)1( <�3�( �!34�&/� 4 *�< 32<H>�46�#���=<H& g#* 3'b%>J<�& ( �$� K���{��%��F�K�I?�9b�� 7!: M� �$��� � �-{��%��F K0I?�9b�� n�o M� �$��� � �2e <H�@1H��& 7 M T K9�,��&)�!1���GH3#*@<�3�* +.C ��K 7 p I ��bH� +)KNI �-b � 7 M� �$��� r��\{)����F�K0I?��bH� n M� �$��r�� ���@�� �"=C5��3H4;*�<�3?+�F "�1�3#��"�� 3�1�>%� �N46&/* (�� � ��:�:/�+��2�����)�-�K(2����� � �9B� �"9(E��"jA 5*7\a�8$:�< M� �$��rK�� �$��rK� � � � �.& ��� +�S8*@1#� K;X`�6"� � 2.`#9(2���K�% �� 5 7\8$o�o�<*= >8�,�.4�& *�(0� L <H4@4 ��& 5 � &.+NM � �):: < KVl�0���"- � 2.V�-(2�����_u\��B� �u9�$BH����������(!�����6 V(2�K�����%� 5 7\a�8�8$<!= e&.�.3�? � I�I��3H�#��*6C5��&)K � ��� ���������%���9QU� Q;�*�� ��*�!�9����"!0�� &)� ���9(E�-��"90 �9�%����( k` ��!�����Ku9�9�G/�9{��9(����%�������9Q��,�*� � �BJB������%�!B����V����(*"!0HX��)�!���vQD����� ������ ��2�-�����!"90��z&�� ��./(2 �{��%�9B��/�����H����('CVQU(2��( &�(E�vQU� 5*7-a�8$4,< =� � �.&/�@� +�$=3�1H� ��&/KU��7 �=&D<#�6�5+D<( *;�!��1H� +-(�<�<�I �!&)�.4 *6 �,+E�HK9@��\u\�������HB�#����2.`0!A��!�Kx��,���M�����B� �(2����� K a K 7-8$o�o K IHI9M 7!n17-q7-T�3 M� �$��rK� � � e�<H��1H��& 8 M 3 KM� � <H<�I#��&/� 4�* +.C �,K 7�: I �-b � +)KNI���b � 7�3 M� �$��� � �9{��K��F K0I?�9b�� 7-: M� �$� � 7 ��4 4 �!&94�< > <�Gb����HM� �$� �z� e <H�@1H��& 4 M n K^��FH4 � 4 � +.<�( *;�!� *�+DCD�HM��%� 3�<�4 � + 4��� >D<H� �@< �%* 3'b :?* :#��*6<�b0&.�.I�,";R9$ M�� �9b03�)&)K ��(!���������EQ���vQ �����k/ ��%�K�j�_�!"90��M� ���.v ��� �B��K� 5\7-a�:�4�<*= S M9FHG� ?,�!&.K � �%� � � .9��� & �/���!��� �9�%���K�%�!B���� 5-7-a�8�8$<*= �!3�1 '=�!3�1��!&J �� �@1H���+��2<�&igC���3H4;*@<�3�� 1��!:<� #��M� �$� �z� � A �6* ��� �0� �! " 5*798�8�4�< R T�n�8 M� �$� �z� � � A��@* ���2� �@�� " 5-7\8$o;7vq*7-8$o�3�< K T R n�3�T M� �$� �z� r 7 < G�* + $2�64��HG?+ +!�)&)K�kV ���( 3 ��(87 5 L �!&J* +9R�� ��+ I?�!&/< 7-8):�T�< R 7!3 M� �$� �zr %��!3�*@��� 7 * 3�1��!3�:�)&!b ��4 � � "��!& K�L-M $2K1X1��"9������yD�9(2( �1X/���! �"������K�%�!B����-�m�- ��I���*�-�K�%� 5 L9�!&J* +MR � �0� C �!3�3 q 7��� ?"7-8�:�:�<1= � �H& * + 4 <�I����L�&J<�(!� ��+!+ <�3#K�X1���V�������9�K�j��"$�%���-�_�d�9�����V�- �"9�%����� �9B�� 5 L � &J* +MR!L ��< 3 7\8�8$:�< M� �$� �zrK� $%�;��* 3 5\7\8 p a�< R 7-n�a M� �$� �zrK� � A��@* ���2� �@�� " 5\7-8�8$4�< R T$n�n M