effects of inadequate housing on the residents of wa township

Upload: saani-adam-sandow

Post on 06-Apr-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    1/80

    UNIVERSITY FOR DEVELOPMENT STUDIES

    FACULTY OF INTEGRATED DEVELOPMENT STUDIES

    THE EFFECTS OF INADEQUATE HOUSING ON THE RESIDENTS OF THE WA

    TOWNSHIP IN THE UPPER WEST REGION OF GHANA

    A Dissertation Presented to the Department of Planning and Land

    Management in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Bachelor of

    Arts Degree

    In Integrated Development Studies.

    SUBMITTED BY:

    AMPOMAA EVELYN

    DOGBEY DINAH JESSICA

    MAC- ABUBAKAR ABDUL- RAZAK

    SAANI ADAM SANDOW

    YAKUBU SAKINA

    JULY, 2010

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    2/80

    DECLARATION

    The research team accepts all errors and misrepresentation of information and hereby declares that no part

    of this work should be found in any document or electronic medium without prior notice of the team.

    STUDENTS ID NUMBER SIGNATURE

    AMPOMAA EVELYN IDS/ 3240/ 06 .

    DOGBEY DINAH JESSICA IDS/ 3444/ 06 .

    MAC- ABUBAKAR ABDUL- RAZAK IDS/ 3622/ 06 .

    SAANI ADAM SANDOW IDS/ 3787/ 06 .

    YAKUBU SAKINA IDS/ 3900/ 06 .

    SUPERVISOR:.

    SIGNATURE:...

    DATE:

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    3/80

    DEDICATION

    The research work is dedicated to our parents and guardians who thought it wise to support us in our

    education.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    4/80

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

    The research team wishes to show its profound gratitude first and foremost to the Almighty God for

    sustaining us through out all our years of study in this noble institution of ours.

    Mr. Agbenyo Fauster, our assiduous supervisors effort can not be over looked. We appreciate his strict

    guidance and instructions during the research period, may God replenish all the resources he unselfishly

    put into this work.

    The teams final gratitude goes to the Assistant Development Planning Officer at the Regional Co-

    ordinating Council, the Building Inspector of the Building Inspectorate at the Wa Municipal Assembly

    and the Regional Gynecologist/Obstetrician at the Upper West Regional Hospital for their immense

    Contributions with regards to information relating to their respective disciplines.

    ABSTRACT

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    5/80

    The right to decent housing is no more an issue of luxury but a necessity which every human being is

    entitled to. Housing in Ghana has mainly been characterized by inadequate facilities, no or poor drainage,

    and haphazard development. Based on the above, this study set out to assess the effects of inadequate

    housing on residents of the Wa Township. Some objectives of the study were determining the causes and

    effects of inadequate housing on the residents of the Wa Township in the areas of; Health; Social life;

    Economic life; and Government policy with proposed interventions for policy consideration.

    The research also focused on the residents of the Wa Township who the researchers believed had a fair

    knowledge of the housing situation in the area and the region at large. Questionnaire, unstructured

    interviews, focus group discussion and key informant interviewswere administered to gather information

    from various categories ofrespondents.

    The analysis revealed that the concept of housing was misplaced and misunderstood. Most households

    were without housing facilities especially the sanitary facilities and yet still paid rents above one hundred

    Ghana cedis. An increased number of room occupancy ( 5 and above) does not only create no privacy

    but also over crowding/ congestion which also lead to poor ventilation, thereby creating a healthy

    atmosphere for the spread of viral infections such as T.B and CSM. Based upon the study findings, some

    practical implications for the housing sector were discussed and suggestions made for future research.

    Table of ContentsINTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................1

    1.0 BACKGROUND........................................................................................................1

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    6/80

    1.1 PROBLEM STATEMENT.........................................................................................2

    1.2 RESEARCH QUESTIONS.........................................................................................3

    1.3 FORMULATION OF HYPOTHESIS............................................................................3

    1.4 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES........................................................................................4

    1.5 SCOPE..................................................................................................................4

    1.6.0 METHODOLOGY.................................................................................................5

    1.6.1 RESEARCH DESIGN.........................................................................................5

    1.6.2 SAMPLING DESIGN..........................................................................................5

    1.6.3 SAMPLE POPULATION.....................................................................................5

    1.6.4 SAMPLE SIZE.............................................................................................6

    1.6.5 SAMPLING TECHNIQUES.................................................................................6

    1.6.6 SOURCES OF DATA.........................................................................................6

    1.6.7 TOOLS / METHODS OF DATA COLLECTION.......................................................7

    1.7 DATA ANALYSIS AND PRESENTATION...................................................................8

    1.8 RELEVANCE OF THE STUDY..................................................................................8

    1.9 ORGANISATION OF THE REPORT...........................................................................8

    LITERATURE REVIEW.................................................................................................10

    2.0 INTRODUCTION.....................................................................................................10

    2.1 DEFINITION OF TERMS.......................................................................................10

    2.1.1 SHELTER......................................................................................................102.1.2 RESIDENCE..................................................................................................11

    2.1.3 TOWNSHIP....................................................................................................11

    2.1.4 SETTLEMENTS..............................................................................................11

    2.1.5 TOWNSHIP AND SETTLEMENT.......................................................................12

    2.1.6 HOUSE.........................................................................................................12

    2.1.7 HOUSING......................................................................................................12

    2.1.8 HOUSE AND HOUSING...................................................................................12

    2.1.9 HOME..........................................................................................................122.2 DIMENSIONS OF HOUSING..................................................................................13

    2.2.1 POLICY DIMENSION......................................................................................13

    2.2.3 SOCIAL DIMENSION......................................................................................17

    2.2.4 LEGAL DIMENSION.......................................................................................19

    2.2.5 ECONOMIC DIMENSION.................................................................................20

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    7/80

    2.2.6 HEALTH DIMENSION.....................................................................................21

    2.3 CAUSES OF INADEQUATE HOUSING....................................................................21

    2.4 EFFECTS OF INADEQUATE HOUSING...................................................................22

    2.5 THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK...............................................................................23

    2.6 CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK...............................................................................25

    3.1. 0 Physical Characteristics........................................................................................29

    3.1.1 Location and Size:..................................................................................................29

    3.1.2 Relief, Drainage, and Topography.........................................................................29

    3.1.3 Climate and Vegetation......................................................................................30

    3.1.4 Soils.............................................................................................................30

    3.2. 0 DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS..................................................................30

    3.2.1 Population Size, Growth Rate and Density..............................................................30

    3.2.2 Age/ Sex structure of the population.....................................................................30

    3.3.0 SOCIO- CULTURAL CHARACTERISTICS.............................................................31

    3.3.1 Ethnicity........................................................................................................31

    3.3.2 Religion.........................................................................................................31

    3.4.0 SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION OF THE POPULATION...................................................31

    3.4.1 Literacy Rate...................................................................................................31

    DATA ANALYSIS AND PRESENTATION........................................................................32

    4.1 SOCIO-DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS..........................................................324.1. 1 Sex Distribution.....................................................................................................32

    4.1.2 Educational Status...................................................................................................33

    4.1.3 OCCUPATIONAL STATUS.....................................................................................34

    4.2 HOUSING CONCEPTS..........................................................................................34

    4.2.1 Housing Definitions..........................................................................................34

    4.2.2 HOUSING INFRASTRUCTURE AVAILABLE.............................................................35

    4.3 DIMENSIONS OF HOUSING..................................................................................36

    4.3.1 POLICY DIMENSION......................................................................................364.3.2 SOCIAL DIMENSION......................................................................................38

    4.3.3 ECONOMIC...................................................................................................42

    4.3.3.1 Income Earned.....................................................................................................42

    4.3.3.2 SAVINGS BY RESPONDENTS..............................................................................43

    4.3.3.10 RENT PAID BY RESPONDENTS..........................................................................51

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    8/80

    4.3.4 CAUSES OF INADEQUATE HOUSING...............................................................52

    4.3.5 EFFECTS OF INADEQUATE HOUSING..............................................................53

    4.4 HYPOTHESES..................................................................................................54

    CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................................57

    5.0 INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................57

    5.1 MAJOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION................................................................57

    5.1.1 HOUSING DEFINITION...................................................................................57

    5.1.2 SOCIAL DIMENSION......................................................................................57

    5.1.3 ECONOMIC DIMENSION.................................................................................58

    5.1.4 BUILDING REGULATIONS..............................................................................58

    5.1.4 POLICY DIMENSION......................................................................................58

    5.2 RECOMMENDATIONS.........................................................................................59

    5.2.1 HOUSING DEFINITION...................................................................................59

    5.2.2 SOCIAL DIMENSION......................................................................................59

    5.2.3 ECONOMIC DIMENSION.................................................................................59

    5.2.4 BUILDING REGULATIONS..............................................................................60

    5.2.5 POLICY DIMENSION......................................................................................60

    APPENDIX

    5.2.5 POLICY DIMENSION

    Tables and Figures

    3.1.1 Location and Size:............................................................................................................ ..........30

    4.1. 1 Sex Distribution......................................................................................................................33

    4.1.2 Educational Status....................................................................................................................34

    4.1.3 OCCUPATIONAL STATUS....................................................................................................35

    4.2.2 HOUSING INFRASTRUCTURE AVAILABLE.............................................................................35

    4.3.3.1 Income Earned...............................................................................................................................364.3.3.2 SAVINGS BY RESPONDENTS...................................................................................................43

    4.3.3.3 OCCUPATION AND INCOME STATUS OF RESPONDENTS.............................................44

    4.3.3.4 INCOME AND AFFORDABILITY OF BUILDING MATERIALS........................ ..... ..... ....45

    4.3.3.5 COST OF BUILDING MATERIALS AND AFFORDABILITY..............................................46

    4.3.3.6 HOUSING INFRASTRUCTURE AND INCOME STATUS OF RESPONDENTS.................47

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    9/80

    4.3.3.7 RENT AND INCOME STATUS OF RESPONDENTS............................................................48

    4.3.3.8 RENT AND INCOME STATUS OF RESPONDENT..............................................................49

    4.3.3.9 RENT AND INCOME STATUS OF RESPONDENT..............................................................51

    4.3.3.10 RENT PAID BY RESPONDENTS........................................................................................ .....52

    4.3.4 CAUSES OF INADEQUATE HOUSING....................................................................................53

    4.3.5 EFFECTS OF INADEQUATE HOUSING..................................................................................54

    Wilcoxon Signed Ranks Test.................................................................................................................56

    LIST OF ACRONYMS

    P. PAGE

    V. VOLUME

    W.M.A WA MUNICIPAL ASSEMBLY

    R.C.C REGIONAL CO-ORDINATING COUNCIL

    S.P.S.S STATISTICAL PACKAGE FOR SOCIAL SCIENTISTS

    ENVTAL ENVIRONMENTAL

    MDGS MILLENIUM DEVELOPMENT GOALS

    PRSPs POVERTY REDUCTION STRATEGY PAPERS

    DEVT DEVELOPMENT

    PHC POPULATION AND HOUSING CENSUS

    No. NUMBER

    FIG FIGURE

    Abs ABSOLUTE

    DONT DO NOT

    ASYMPT. ASYMPTOTIC

    SIG SIGNIFICANT

    KVIP KUMASI VENTILATED IMPROVED PIT

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    10/80

    TB TUBERCULOSIS

    CSM CEREBRO- SPINAL MENINGITIS

    CHAPTER ONE

    INTRODUCTION

    1.0 BACKGROUND

    The right to decent housing is no more an issue of luxury but a necessity which every human being is

    entitled to. Housing came to the fore fronts of debates during the 1950s and 1960s by the war

    welfarist foundations after the Second World War. Over the years, however, there have been calls for the

    provision of adequate housing and not just a roof over ones head. This call came strongly from the

    Human Rights Education Associates who in their view see housing as a right regardless of ones social

    status. This right to adequate housing is codified as human right in the Universal Declaration Of HumanRights: Every one has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself

    and his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the

    right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of

    livelihood in circumstances beyond his control (hrea.org,(article 25(1)).

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    11/80

    This universal human right to housing has become a privilege to a minority rich in society, due to

    increasing demand for land, rural urban migration, increasing population growth and insufficient financial

    and natural resources. These have resulted in widespread homelessness and habitation in inadequate

    housing with its attendant problems such as health and environmental sanitation hazards such as

    tuberculosis, cholera, typhoid, and guinea worm infections, poor academic performance, low productivity,

    rural urban migration and increase in social vices.

    Governments all over the world including African countries have made several attempts at solving the

    problem. There is an instance where in 1997,

    South Africa built more than 200 low cost housing units with environmentally friendly features

    such as dual flash toilets and passive solar energy design to minimize the energy needed for heating and

    cooling. These units initially accommodated athletes to the all African games but were later allocated to

    residents ofAlexandria, one of Johannesburgs worst slums (Everett, 1999 cited in Bashir, 2002 Vol. 92

    No. 5).

    Housing in Ghana has mainly been characterized by inadequate facilities, no or poor drainage, and

    haphazard development. Poor housing delivery remains a national headache. Only 8% of Ghanaians can

    afford to buy a property without a mortgage and yet only 15% of the population can access mortgages.

    The Building and Road Research Institute of the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research(CSIR)

    establishes that out of the total housing supply of 40,000 in 2004, supply from private individuals

    amounted to 38,200, which accounted for 95.5% . At a recently held African Union for Housing Finance

    Conference in Ghana, the Minister of State for Water Resources, Works and Housing Mrs. CeciliaDapaah is reported to have blamed real estate developers for the housing problem in Ghana. She thinks

    the developers pay too much attention to providing for the upper class at the expense of low- cost housing

    for the average income earner( Ghana Web. com, Housing in Ghana ) ( accessed 28 December 2009 ).

    However, governments over the years together with some stakeholders such as the Home Finance

    Company (H.F.C) and Regimanuel Gray Estates are trying to provide adequate housing to Ghanaians to

    solve the problem of the housing inadequacy

    1.1 PROBLEM STATEMENT

    The housing sector in Ghana has attracted attention with respect to the adequacy of housing in recent

    times. This is quite surprising given the numerous bye- laws and zoning regulations together with housing

    policies which have been enforced in the country. Three broad issues directed this research problem.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    12/80

    Firstly, there has been an increase in the population resident in the Wa Township which has put pressure

    on available housing facilities. The Upper West Region has a population size of 576,583 and 80,559

    households with a total of 51,898 houses, with dwelling units which are in the form of compound houses

    whose qualities are generally poor.

    Secondly, it has been realized that, some necessary facilities which make up an adequate housing unit are

    absent in the majority of houses in the Wa Township. About 58.2% of households have access to

    potable water while 11.55% have access to toilet facilities inside the houses with 24.1% accessing public

    toilet facilities (Ghana Statistical Service, 2005: V2).

    Finally, a number of previous studies have examined the housing stock deficit in the country. Ossegge

    (2008, p.3), it is estimated that there is a deficit of about 600,000 housing units in Ghana. However,

    there has been a lack of studies that sets out to investigate the effects of inadequate housing on residents

    in the Wa Township, specifically.

    To this end, this study, set out to assess the effects of inadequate housing on residents of the Wa

    Township with some proposed recommendations, which can be described as timely and most appropriate.

    1.2 RESEARCH QUESTIONS

    Given the above state of affairs in the housing sub-sector in Wa, the following questions keep boggling

    the minds of the researchers who are poised to seek relevant and appropriate answers to them.

    MAIN QUESTION: What are the effects of inadequate housing in Wa?

    SPECIFIC QUESTIONS:

    1. What are the residents views on their housing conditions in the township?

    2. Why is there a problem of inadequate housing in Wa?

    3. What are some of the effects of inadequate housing on the residents in Wa in the areas of;

    (i) Health;(ii) Social life;

    (iii) Economic life; and

    (iv) Government policy.

    1. How do residents manage to reduce the effects of inadequate housing?

    2. Are there any recommended interventions to the problem of the current housing situation in Wa?

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    13/80

    1.3 FORMULATION OF HYPOTHESIS

    As a means of carrying out the research effectively, the following hypotheses have been formulated to

    guide in the collection and analysis of the data.

    GENERAL HYPOTHESIS:

    Null (Ho): There is inadequate housing in the Wa Township.

    Alternative (H1): There is no inadequate housing in the Wa Township

    SPECIFIC HYPOTHESES:

    1. Ho: There exists a relationship between residents income status and the type of housing units in

    which they reside.H1: There is no relationship between residents income status and the type of housing units they

    reside in.

    2. Ho: The income status of a resident determines the housing facilities available in his or her

    residence.

    H1: The presence of housing facilities is not determined by the income status of a resident.

    3. Ho: There exists a relationship between a residents income earned and the rent paid.

    H1: There is no relationship between a residents income earned and the rent paid.

    1.4 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES.

    MAIN OBJECTIVE:

    The main objective of the study is determining the effects of inadequate housing on the residents of Wa

    Township and to propose interventions for policy consideration.

    SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES:

    1. To find out what the residents of Wa understood by inadequate housing and if they consider the

    current housing and its facilities as inadequate.

    2. To dwell on objective (1) to find the causes of the problem of inadequate housing in Wa.

    3. To Endeavour to explore some effects of inadequate housing in the areas of ;

    (i) Health;

    (ii) Social life;

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    14/80

    (iii) Economic life; and

    (iv) Government policy.

    1. To find out how residents manage to reduce the effects of inadequate housing.

    2. To make some suggestions that may help to reduce the effects of inadequate housing.

    1.5 SCOPE.

    This research will concentrate on the effects of inadequate housing on the residents of the Wa Township.

    Inadequate housing goes beyond the provision of poor shelter to the provision of poor or lack of amenities

    such as potable water and good sanitation for the people.

    This study covered a period of four years September 2006 to July, 2010 and was within the Wa

    Township in the Upper West Region of Ghana.

    The research also focused on the residents of the Wa Township who the researchers believed had a fair

    knowledge of the housing situation in the area and the region at large.

    1.6.0 METHODOLOGY.

    For accurate and valid research output, some sampling techniques, data collection methods and tools of

    data analysis were employed.

    1.6.1 RESEARCH DESIGN.

    A research design is a procedural plan that is adopted by the researcher to answer questions with

    validity, objectivity, accuracy and economy. According to Jahoda et al, a research designis the

    arrangement of conditions for the collection and analysis of data in a manner that aims to combine

    relevance to the research purpose with economy in procedure ( Jahoda et al 1962;50cited in Kumar

    1999 p.74).

    Based on this, both qualitative and quantitative researches were conducted using the survey design. A

    survey design is a method which relies upon the questioning of a selected group (sample) of a population

    and analyzing the data to answer a set of hypotheses or describe a set of characteristics. A survey design

    may either be descriptive or analytical where a study seeks to describe a situation, or explain the situation

    and study the determinative process respectively.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    15/80

    The survey design was used because it is believed that respondents may be more willing to answer

    questions than take part in experimental research. It is helpful in obtaining retrospect information- why

    inadequate housing in the Township. This method also helps in the collection of large amounts of data,

    quickly and cheaply and data gathered can easily be generalized to the population.

    1.6.2 SAMPLING DESIGN.

    The sampling design determines the procedure through which the researcher can arrive at his or her

    respondents or units of analysis from whom data can be collected for a particular study. It comprises the

    sample population, sample size and sampling techniques.

    1.6.3 SAMPLE POPULATION

    This is the overall number of people in the study area from which the researcher selects a few for the

    study. The sample population for this study is 66,644 (Republic of Ghana 2005).

    1.6.4 SAMPLE SIZE.

    This is the number of sampling units which would be used for the study. A sample size of a hundred and

    sixteen (116) respondents was used. This was done using the formula;

    n= N Z2 * 0.25

    {d2 * (N-1)} + [Z2 * 0.25]

    See appendix one for further details.

    1.6.5 SAMPLING TECHNIQUES.

    For the purpose of this study, simple random sampling and purposive sampling techniques were used.

    SIMPLE RANDOM SAMPLING; This technique was used to select respondents at random in such a way

    that, all members of the total population stood an equal and non- zero chance of being selected. This was

    used in the case of the residents who the researchers administered questionnaires to and this was done

    using a table of random numbers where people in the sample population were randomly picked according

    to the sample size for data collection.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    16/80

    PURPOSIVE SAMPLING; This was where respondents were selected because they had fair or enough

    information on or knowledge of the subject under investigation. The respondents were selected on

    purpose as they satisfied certain criteria set by the researchers.

    This technique was employed to interview some planners from the Regional Coordinating Council and

    the Building Inspectorate Unit of the Wa Municipal Assembly for their views on the inadequate housing

    situation in Wa.

    1.6.6 SOURCES OF DATA.

    Both primary and secondary sources of data were used.

    PRIMARY SOURCES OF DATA; These are data which were gathered by the group based on the

    observation, responses to questionnaires and interviews. They are primary because they are first hand and

    gathered directly from the field.

    1.6.7 TOOLS / METHODS OF DATA COLLECTION.

    PARTICIPANT OBSERVATION; Where the researcher takes part in the activities of the respondents with

    or without the respondents knowledge. Since the group had been in Wa for over three (3) academic

    years, it was considered as part of the residents and so used its experiences and observations in recording

    information. This can be termed both as retrospective current and introspective participant observation.

    There is a high tendency of biases and exaggerations in the information to be gathered since the

    researchers are to serve as respondents. These were easily overcome and brought to a minimal level

    where the group scrutinized every data generated from members.

    QUESTIONNAIRE; A scientific tool or instrument for data collection which consists of a written list of

    questions where respondents read and provide answers. This was administered to respondents who were

    both literates and illiterates, and had proper understanding of the issues, interpret these issues and record

    their own responses accordingly.

    UNSTRUCTURED INTERVIEWS; This is known as an in-depth interview where the researcher developsa framework called an interview guide within which the interviewer formulates questions spontaneously

    during an interview. This was used by the group to respondents who were illiterates and also to those who

    were targeted using purposive sampling.

    FOCUS GROUP DISCUSSION; This is a data collection method where people with similar backgrounds

    come together to form small groups of between six (6) and twelve (12) or at most fifteen (15) to discuss

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    17/80

    issues surrounding the subject. These groups included men, women, children/youth, residents and

    landlords.

    KEY INFORMANT INTERVIEWS; These are qualitative in-depth interviews with people whoknow what

    is going on in the community. The purpose of these interviews was to collect information from a wide

    range of people including community leaders, professionals, or residents-who have first hand knowledge

    of the community. These community experts with their knowledge and understanding can provide insight

    on the nature of problems and give recommendations for solutions. The researchers conducted face-to-

    face interviews with the Building Inspector at the WMA and the Assistant Development Planning Officer

    at the Upper West R.C.C.

    SECONDARY SOURCE OF DATA; These were data which were gathered from the Ghana Statistical

    Service, internet and books written by authors relating to the subject of housing. These data (information)

    were adapted to suit the specific needs of this particular study.

    1.7 DATA ANALYSIS AND PRESENTATION.

    In the analysis of data, two computer programmes (SPSS and Excel) were employed. Content analysis

    was used to discuss relationships between and among variables qualitatively while statistically quantified

    data were presented using tables and charts.

    1.8 RELEVANCE OF THE STUDY

    This study will help the government as well as other stakeholders in the housing sector in their bid to

    achieve Target eleven(11) To achieve a significant improvement in the lives of at least 100million

    dwellers by the year 2020of the Goal seven(7) Ensure environmental sustainabilityof the

    Millennium Development Goals.

    The out come of the study will also serve as a basis for further research by other housing agents and

    institutions interested in the subject. The study would serve as additional source of information to the

    District Assembly and the Town and Country Planning Department during the formulation of bye-laws

    and zoning regulations for the District. Landlords can use this information to determine the standard

    housing units to supply to tenants while tenants would also be informed as to what to expect.

    1.9 ORGANISATION OF THE REPORT

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    18/80

    This report consists of five (5) chapters. Chapter one had to do with the introduction which contained the

    background to the study, problem statement, research questions, hypothesis, research objectives, and

    scope of research, methodology, relevance of the study, limitations to the study and organization of the

    report.

    Chapter two was on the literature review of works of authors who have written on the subject matter. This

    consisted of definition of terms, dimensions of housing, causes of inadequate housing, effects of

    inadequate housing, theoretical framework, and conceptual framework.

    Chapter three focused on the profile of our target community which included demographic characteristics

    of the community such as the population size as well as the resource base of the community such as the

    geology, vegetation, relief, drainage, climate, economic activities among others.

    Chapter four consisted of data analysis and presentation where data were analysed using SPSS and Excel

    computer programmes which were presented using content analysis and tables and charts.

    Finally, chapter five included discussions on major findings, conclusions and recommendations on the

    socio-demographic characteristics, housing concepts, social, economic, policy, regulations and health

    dimensions of housing as well as the constraints and effects of housing.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    19/80

    CHAPTER TWO

    LITERATURE REVIEW

    2.0 INTRODUCTION

    This chapter provides conceptual definitions of terms relating to housing as have been provided by

    various authors, and other sources. It also looks at the policy, social, health, legal and economic

    dimensions of housing in order to understand the subject matter of housing leading to its inadequacy, the

    causes and effects of inadequate housing as have been written by various authors and suggestions of

    possible ways and means of curbing the problems of inadequate housing. The chapter concludes with

    theoretical and conceptual frameworks.

    2.1 DEFINITION OF TERMS

    As this study is focused on the discussions of the effects of inadequate housing on the residents of the

    Wa Township, we present an operational definition for each of these key terms as used in the study;

    Shelter, Residence, Township, Settlements, House and Housing.

    2.1.1 SHELTER

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    20/80

    As defined in the Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English (1987) , shelter is a building or roofed

    enclosure that gives cover or protection

    The Commission on Human Settlements` Global Strategy for Shelter to the year 2000 (1998) as cited in

    (Duncan, n.d.)Adequate shelter meansadequate privacy, adequate space, adequate security, adequate

    lightening and ventilation, adequate basic infrastructure and adequate location with regard to work and

    basic facilities all at a reasonable cost.

    The Commission highlights almost all the basic facilities that have to be attached to a building or

    structure which the dictionary failed to acknowledge. However, it fails to explain the term adequate - is

    it adequate in terms of numbers or quality. It also fails to include the sanitation facilities which are key

    for the well-being of man but it defines shelter in the terms of housing and not just the physical structure.

    Shelter is operationally defined in this research as a structure that is put up in a legally permitted

    environment with the required, durable and affordable materials used in construction, and the ability of itto allow for the provision of basic facilities in it.

    2.1.2 RESIDENCE

    This is the place where one lives, a house especially a large important one (Longman Dictionary of

    Contemporary English 1987).

    In the analysis of the above, what kind of a place is it that one lives? Is the house just a shelter, a building

    or a structure? There was no mention of the availability of housing facilities for occupants.

    2.1.3 TOWNSHIP.

    A geographical division of the county , established in land surveys and usually made up of 36 sections,

    each with roughly an area of 1 sq mi(2.6 sq km)( The Columbian encyclopedia).

    In Canada and the U.S; A town, or town and the area around it, that has certain powers of local

    government(Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English, 1987 ). In Ghana, every settlement with a

    population of 5000 and over is officially regarded as a town (Dickson and Benneh, 2004).

    Based on this, a township is conceptually defined as an urban settlement with a population of 5000 and

    over with political and legal boundaries.

    From the above definitions, Township is viewed differently at different places. It is realized that the land

    mass of an area in question is considered. However, it fails to analyze it in terms of its components. What

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    21/80

    constitutes a town is as important as its land mass. Features of a township are viewed as: heterogeneous

    settlements, industrial, commercial and residential activities, mutual correlation among all these in terms

    of accessibility, location and distance and the provision of communal facilities such as parks and gardens

    and recreational centers. All must be backed by proper zoning regulations and building bye-laws.

    2.1.4 SETTLEMENTS

    It is a purposely grouped and organized cluster of houses and non residential buildings. The smallest of

    such clusters are known as hamlets which may contain about a dozen of such buildings whiles the largest

    are the worlds greatest cities (De Blij, 1993).

    2.1.5 TOWNSHIP AND SETTLEMENT

    A Township can be described as an administrative division of a district or region within a local

    government authority. Settlements on the other hand can be described as a community of people whichcan be a town, village, cottage or even hamlet. Comparing the two, Townships are usually formed out of

    settlements. Geographical or administrative divisions of districts or regions are based on a number of

    settlements.

    2.1.6 HOUSE

    A house is a home, shelter, building or structure that is a dwelling or place for habitation by human

    beings. The term includes many kinds of dwellings ranging from rudimentary huts of nomadic tribes to

    free standing individual structures (Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia). It must however be noted that not

    all houses are homes but all homes are necessarily houses.

    2.1.7 HOUSING

    Tibaijuka (2009) indicates that conceptually, housing is a set of durable assets, in addition to being a

    bundle of services and an array of economic, sociological and psychological phenomena. Apart from

    providing shelter, a key basic need, it is also believed to be one of the key elements that link tangible

    economic and social aspects of any settlements.

    However, sustainable housing has been defined in the following perspective by the European Union as:

    Construction (e.g. quality of construction), social and economic factors (e.g. affordability and

    psychological impacts) and eco-efficiency (efficient use of non-renewable resources) (VROM, 2005 cited

    in Abu Bakar et al (http//eprints.usm.my//6076/1/1cc109-14 aidah awang pdf (accessed, 24 Feb. 2010).

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    22/80

    2.1.8 HOUSE AND HOUSING

    The terms house and housing have been misunderstood by so many people. Most at times, a house is

    misconceived to be housing which in actual sense is not the same. A house is a structure that has been

    constructed just for one to lay down his head whereas housing is seen to be a house constructed with

    quality materials which meets the economic, sociological and psychological needs of occupants.

    2.1.9 HOME

    In housing terms, a home is no longer just about a roof over our heads. It is also, or sometimes only, an

    asset, an investment, a pension, an income, sometimes a liability, an office, a business (The Smith

    Institute 2006).

    They considered a home in the economic context living out the social and health aspects. It also saw a

    home in the light of housing terms. In actual facts, a home may not necessarily be a housing unit with all

    the facilities.

    2.2 DIMENSIONS OF HOUSING

    2.2.1 POLICY DIMENSION

    In Ghana economic policies have always influenced the way housing is viewed within the development

    process. During the early post war period, the government saw its mandates as that of providing basic

    social services to build the social infrastructure necessary for development. Housing and related health

    projects were the earliest to be funded and retained a high profile in the countrys first post war

    development phase (1946 1956). Average annual budgetary allocations to the housing sector stood at

    seven to nine percent during this period. In terms of its role, however, housing was classified as a social

    service, and while its improvement was considered important, the government played down its economic

    impact. As a government development plan at the time stated, (housing) does not normally make a direct

    contribution to the economy, important as their indirect contribution may be their development must be

    dictated by the economic prosperity of the country, with the exception of few projects, the overwhelmingmajority of housing programs were designed not so much to stimulate economic growth as to address

    social needs and deliver welfare.

    Inadequate housing is a visible manifestation of poverty. Since the late 1990`s, the IMF and World Bank

    have required low-income countries seeking debt relief and financial support to prepare Poverty

    Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs). The objective of these papers vary across countries but have

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    23/80

    centered mostly on devising strategies to promote macro economic stability, increase productivity and

    national employment, enhance human resource development and expand social programs to vulnerable

    people, among other things. Housing policies should be linked to broader poverty reduction goals and

    objectives, which may include, for example, creating employment, mobilizing local financial resources or

    building physically the capital stock of communities. In addition, long term effects on factors such as

    health, labour productivity, and economic growth of local and regional communities may be sighed - out.

    That is, the specific ways by which housing can influence poverty reduction and vice-versa should be

    spelt out and promoted(Tibaijuka, 2009).

    Tibaijuka in her work connects housing policy to broader poverty reduction strategies. She highlights all

    the areas from the economic to health and how poverty results in the provision of inadequate housing.

    This clearly indicates that a country`s financial status determines the kind of policies put in place and the

    housing environment of its people.

    . Not only does government exert an indirect influence generally on housing markets through tax

    policies, but it also exerts, in particular, a direct influence through construction of public houses and

    subsidization of housing cost. The rationale for government intervention in the housing market, as can be

    gleaned from policy documents, revolves around the goal of providing all Ghanaians with a decent house

    in a suitable living environment(Institute of Economic Affairs, May, 1993).

    The article although brought out the policies regarding housing in Ghana and the way forward, especially

    government`s intention of providing a decent housing in a suitable environment, in a way fell short of the

    other vital aspects of the dimensions of housing. Issues such as affordability of these decent houses andthe brackets of people this policy will target are essential aspects of housing policies. Also, provision of

    decent housing in a suitable environment is not clearly defined. How suitable is that environment will it

    entail all the basic and necessary facilities needed around a housing unit for even the low income earner

    to afford? Is this environment to be a socially peaceful one, economically vibrant or viable one,

    physically sustainable one or culturally acceptable one?

    The Ghana National Housing Policy and Action Plan of 1987 -1990, states that Our housing problem is

    one of a national development crisis with a current annual need of 70,000 units and an accumulated

    delivery deficit of 250,000 units needed to be decrowd urban units from 10-61 to a household occupying

    rates of 7. An annual delivery of 133,000 units will be needed to provide adequate housing within the next

    twenty years as against the current annual delivery of 28,000 units which yield a performance rate of

    21%.

    What actions must Ghana take to solve this housing crisis and to overcome the persistent deficit in

    housing delivery? Certainly, the solution to this problem is within the bailiwick of Ghanas seat of

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    24/80

    Government. Government must pursue sound economic policies in order to redress or redirect the inept

    economic practices of past regimes.

    There is a need to rethink our national housing strategies. Lack of adequate housing to shelter the

    populace and to prevent homelessness is the essence of poverty reduction. The common theme running

    through the High Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative is SHELTER. The problem of escalating

    costs of building materials and the ancillary problem of the high import content of building materials used

    in the country was examined three decades ago. The Bank of Ghana, the monetary manager of Ghana,

    established that the country could save considerable foreign exchange if the money spent on clinker

    imports, including rising freight costs, could be reduced by exploiting local resources as substitutes for

    imported building materials. Indeed, the former Governor of the Bank of Ghana, Dr. Amon Nikoi,

    commented a decade ago:

    A Central Bank in a developing country cannot remain indifferent to development issues particularly

    in a country like Ghana where the bulk of the foreign exchange which it is the Banks main function tomanage, is produced by cocoa (sooner cassava and cashew) farmers and where approximately 70% of

    the population lives in the rural areas in sub-standard housing.

    Housing policies ultimately depend on political ideologies and practices. Political systems and

    institutions in developing countries have been characterized by greater instability than those of more

    developed countries. The lack of political stability is recognized as one of the major problems of

    development. Because of the absolute necessity for a long-term commitment to specific housing

    objectives and policies, the process of formulating and implementing housing programmes is critically

    affected by unstable political institutions. Thus, it could be asserted that, political instability may be animportant contributor to Ghana`s current housing and infrastructure problems (Agyemang, 2000).

    In the light of the above, political instability and political ideologies have a heavy impact on the housing

    policies in most countries especially developing countries. Different governments usually have different

    ideologies and hence would have different policies pertaining to housing. Although most have very good

    policies which is usually not the problem, the problem is the continuation of those policies in case there is

    a change in government. . Coup dtats have also put a halt to most government policies thereby creating

    a huge gap in the provision of vital social services such as housing.

    The (PNDC) government introduced numerous reforms into the housing sector based on neo-liberal

    ideas from 1983 onwards. On a broader scale, the changes were rooted in liberal ideologies that had

    swept through many economies in the 1980s and 1990s.The most important initiatives during this reform

    phase included:

    *State withdrawal from direct housing production and financing;

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    25/80

    *Stimulating the growth of the real estate sector, that is the indigenous private sector;

    *Liberalization of the landmarks and the building material industry;

    *Encouraging rental housing; and

    *Creating new housing institutional reforms, notably the Home Finance Company (HFC) (Tibaijuka,

    2009 p.111).

    The reforms on housing under the PNDC government paved way for more private investors into the

    sector and a reduced involvement of the state in direct production and financing. These reforms though

    were necessary for the economy, aggravated the sufferings of the poor who could not afford the houses

    provided by the private sector since their main motive was profit maximization.

    Good social housing policies heavily rely on sound and efficient economic systems. In addition,

    economic policies related to housing should have a strong component of housing affordability and

    accessibility for all income groups. Social housing policies enhance the quality of urban life, as they help

    in reducing and preventing slum formation. Shelter improvements are often associated with

    improvements in health and have a direct impact on the reduction of different forms of social and

    economic exclusion (Tibaijuka, 2009, 165).

    The stated objective of housing policies in most Gulf States is to ensure that all segments of societies,

    particularly the lower income population, have greater access to adequate and affordable housing and

    related support facilities. However, reality is different as the objective goes beyond credits, finance,

    monthly installments or giving greater access to an affordable house where the main concerns should be

    the quality of life and the socio-economic impact of housing developments (Salama, 2007, VI).

    The ultimate goal of shelter policy is to provide adequate and affordable stock of housing with the

    requisite infrastructure and basic services to satisfy the basic needs of the people. Growth and Poverty

    Reduction Strategy II treats the provision of housing as a strategic area for stimulating economic growth

    which at the same time improving the living conditions of Ghanaians. The very activity of providing

    housing contributes to economic growth through its multiplier effect on job creation and the local

    building material industry.

    Lack of sufficient housing units in the urban areas has contributed to over crowding, development of

    illegal structures, children and young people living in the streets and undue pressure on the already

    limited water and sanitation facilities.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    26/80

    Government (NPP) is in process of reviewing the National Shelter Policy, with the ultimate goal of

    providing adequate and affordable housing with requisite infrastructure and basic services to satisfy the

    needs of the people (National Development Planning Commission, 2005).

    The GPRS II has adequately provided the causes of inadequate housing in Ghana particularly in the

    urban areas. But in order to stop this problem of overcrowding and pressure on the already existing few

    facilities, the government of Ghana is in process of reviewing the National Shelter Policy document

    which will at its best solve more than half of the housing problems in the country of which Wa township

    is no exception.

    What is really intriguing in this policy document is the idea of improved housing leading to jobs creation

    and the growth of local building material industry such as sand winning, carpentry, sawmilling, and

    masonry.

    The standard of living of people can be improved if their state of housing is improved. This directly

    explains the job creation aspect of the GPRS II. If jobs are created, standard of living would definitely

    improve in a way.

    2.2.3 SOCIAL DIMENSION

    The loss of rural population to urban centres is often bemoaned for its implied adverse effects on rural

    development. The empirical data have revealed that migration is generally selective of the young,

    versatile and /or better educated members of the community (Ritchey, 1976; Boowniy and Feindt, 1969).This creates a form of brain drain on the rural population. At the points of destination, the deleterious

    consequences of rural urban migration have been noted. With demand for urban socio-economic

    amenities exceeding their supply, the urban areas often become spectacles of multifarious problems such

    as over crowding, congestion, inadequate housing, high rates of unemployment and under employment,

    crime and other forms of delinquency ( Ankra Twumasi, 1995). This calls for increased efforts towards

    providing decent housing units in urban areas (Ossege, 2008).

    The various authors look at how rural-urban migration goes a long way to affect housing. As Ankrah -

    Twumasi clearly stated, over crowding, congestion and inadequate housing would be the end product if

    services and job opportunities are unevenly distributed. This brings about the idea of rural - urban

    migration as an effect of inadequate housing.

    Housing design affects people in countless ways, particularly in terms of social well being. Housing is

    not only about the physical form of the dwelling, but also about the places that housing creates, the

    interrelations of form, space and social dynamics. The sustainable housing concept also recognizes

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    27/80

    social aspects as a key dimension and social interaction as an important indicator of social

    sustainability. The design of housing should therefore not only approach aesthetic quality and/ or the

    environmental perspective but it should also aim at encouraging social interaction that will result in

    social sustainability Sutida Sattayakorn (n. d) as cited in the proceedings at the Rotterdam Conference

    25-28 June.

    This school of thought concerning housing is far different from what have been reviewed so far. We duly

    support their argument to some extent. The social structure of a place should be carefully studied before

    any project can be sustainable. The people must be cordial to one another to have a peaceful coexistence

    in a residential pattern. For example, the provision of public facilities such as toilets, urinals and

    recreational facilities among others that entails housing in a community which is lacking that social

    interaction among one another might not lead to the sustainability of such facilities leading to

    deterioration and hence inadequacy. As has been stated by the literature, the design of housing should not

    only look at aesthetic quality but it should also aim at the social sustainability of the setting in which it is

    being provided.

    Most households in Ghana (79%) live either in rooms in compound houses or other types of rooms.

    About 45% (26% in urban areas and 59% in rural areas) of households in Ghana own the houses they

    live in. About 73% of urban households have access to pipe borne water compared to only 14% of rural

    households. Almost four fifth (79%) of households in urban areas use electricity for lighting as against

    27% of households in rural areas. Charcoal is the most popular source of cooking fuel for urban

    households (52-6%), where as firewood is the main source of cooking for rural households (80.2%).

    Only one out of every ten households in Ghana (22.2% in urban and 1.1 in rural) have access to flush

    toilets (Republic of Ghana, 2008).

    Social housing operates within the context of a society and economy whose purpose is to provide among

    other things a standard of living for all households (Mc Share, 2002). This is active through a variety of

    social and economic processes, including those undertaken by government. This standard of living

    includes many different components, one of which is housing. A range of standards of living operates

    within a society, but the goals of social and economic progress is to ensure that all households enjoy an

    equitable standard of living including adequate and appropriate housing(MC Nelis, 20-22 June, 2007).

    One basic necessity of life of the human population is shelter. The type and quality of housing facility a

    household uses constitute a basis for assessing the standard of living of a household(Republic of Ghana,

    2005).

    The various authors buttress the fact that to have a good standard of living would mean to have adequate

    housing where all the facilities and services that are supposed to be in a house and near the house are

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    28/80

    available. This literature brings out the importance of these facilities. That is why the Ghana Living

    Standards Survey Report 5 compiled a comprehensive report on housing to unearth the challenges with

    regards to the inadequacy of these houses especially in the rural areas which have little to boast of in

    terms of adequate housing.

    2.2.4 LEGAL DIMENSION

    Article 18(1) and (2) of the 1992 Constitution states every person has the right to own property either

    alone or in associations with others while no person shall be subjected to interference with the privacy of

    his home, property, correspondence or communication except in accordance with law and as may be

    necessary in a free and democratic society for public safety or economic well-being of the country, for

    production of health or morals, for the prevention of disorder or crime or for production of rights of

    freedoms of others.

    Universal Declaration Of Human Rights: Every one has the right to a standard of living adequate for the

    health and well-being of himself and his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and

    necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability,

    widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control(Human Rights

    Education Associates, article 25(1)).

    The 1992 Constitution of Ghana indicates the right to own property and the security of the individual

    owning such property. That is a plus for the drafters of the Constitution of Ghana which serves as a guide

    to all citizens of Ghana. Since the issue of housing as right has been provided for in the 1992

    Constitution of Ghana, the supreme legal document of the land, it goes to suggest that failure on the part

    of a government to honour its promises in this regard can attract court action for redress.

    However, the provisions on housing in the constitution are not strictly followed to the letter by the

    previous governments due to lack of political will and political interference.

    The provisions of the Fundamental Human Rights and Freedoms are entrenched in Chapter 5, Articles 12-

    33 of the 1992 constitution of Ghana. The rights, duties, declarations and guarantees relating to the

    fundamental human rights and freedoms specifically mentioned in this Chapter shall not be regarded as

    excluding others not specifically mentioned which are considered to be inherent in a democracy and

    intended to secure the freedom and dignity of man. The Constitution of Ghana does not expressly protect

    the right to adequate housing. It nevertheless provides for the right to own property alone or in association

    with others, the right of non-interference with the privacy of ones home as well as protection from the

    deprivation of ones property, all of which can be found in Chapter 5 of the Constitution.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    29/80

    2.2.5 ECONOMIC DIMENSION

    Income disparities and social inequity in Latin America have increased over the past two decades

    (Habitat II summary 1996). This skewed income and wealth distribution prevents increases in gross

    economic production, when they do occur, from translating into improved economic conditions for poorpeople. According to one report, Reducing inequality as the key to attacking poverty in Latin America

    and the Caribbean has been underscored in a number of recent studies and reports by international

    institutions such as the Inter-American Development Bank, the World Bank, the International Monetary

    Fund and the Economic Commission for Latin America the Caribbean (Canadian Foundation for the

    Americas 2001: 6).

    Income disparities have worsened in economies of rapid development and liberalization, such as Chile

    and Mexico, over the last decade (www. aciamericas. coop). Other sources, however, fault market

    impediments, such as protectionism and failure of the markets to open more completely to foreign

    investment and competition, for increased poverty.

    Governmental policies contributing to entrenched poverty in the Latin America and Caribbean area may

    include austerity-based macroeconomic policy choices (following recommendations by the International

    Finance Corporation, the Inter-American Development Bank and the World Bank), weak state institutions

    to support the poor, and a low investment in social capital such as education and health care (International

    Fund for Agricultural Development 2002: 6, Ward 2001: 5).

    Poor Housing Delivery Remains a National Headache Only 8% of Ghanaians can afford to buy a

    property without mortgage ... and yet only 15% of the population can access mortgages. At a recently

    held African Union for Housing Finance Conference, the Minister of State for Water Resources, Works

    and Housing Mrs. Cecilia Dapaah is reported to have blamed Real Estate Developers for the housing

    problem in the country. She thinks the developers pay too much attention to providing for the upper class

    at the expense of low cost housing for the average income earner( Ghana web .com, Housing in Ghana)

    (accessed 28 December 2009)

    The general price levels of housing in Ghana depend on the house type and this informs an individuals

    affordability. The house types and prices in Ghana range between GHC2, 100 and GHC6, 295. A house

    with more than four bedrooms as at 2008 costs between 2,100- 6,295, 1,260 2,100 and some couldexceed100, 000 and 300, 000 Ghana cedis. A two or three bedroom house was priced as 840- 1,260, 525-

    840, 40,000 - 60,000 and 25,000 40,000 Ghana cedis while a single or two bedroom house was also up

    to 840, 525, 40,000 and 25,000 Ghana cedis ( Ossege, 2008).

    2.2.6 HEALTH DIMENSION

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    30/80

    Working in concert to address multiple issues at once is becoming a top priority as more communities

    face health crises of epidemic proportions in areas directly related to sub standard housing. Cleveland,

    Ohio, found itself dealing with a double dose of trouble when studies showed that prevalence of asthma,

    the most common chronic childhood disease, had increased by more than 100% in 20years. Additionally,

    childhood lead poisoning had become a crisis among Clevelands children. In 1998, 34% of children in

    Cleveland were found to have elevated blood lead levels, compared with 5% nationally (Bashir ,V 92

    No. 5).

    It is not only with the United States of America that the effects of substandard housing go beyond social,

    policy, economic to health implication. The provision of sub standard housing means inadequate facilities

    available in these houses. Imagine in a community where most of the Housing units are crowded without

    good drainage facilities, toilet facilities and many others, it would increase the rate of airborne and

    communicable diseases that would result from bad sanitary situations.

    2.3 CAUSES OF INADEQUATE HOUSING

    Most literature on inadequate housing in Latin America and the Caribbean attributes it to at least in part

    to an underlying state of poverty, low household income and unemployment(Calderon Cockburn 2001, in

    Ward 2001: 2,5).

    According to empirical data collected in the 1990`s, poverty or the lack of ability to pay is strongly

    associated with poverty housing (Angel 2000; 112, Canadian Foundation for America 2000; 8, Gilbert

    1996).

    It is not surprising that most literature on inadequate housing in Latin America and Caribbean attributes it

    to poverty, low household income and unemployment. The standard of living of the people in an

    environment determines the quality of housing unit they find themselves. Those with low incomes and

    unemployment always struggle to make ends meet thereby using part of their meager incomes to cater for

    other issues rather than housing. So far as they find themselves a roof to cover themselves, they become

    content with it to the neglect of other vital facilities. On the other hand, those with high incomes and fully

    employed have enough to cater for housing and other social pressing needs for their families. They tend

    to provide all the necessary facilities needed in a house.

    The property market is shrouded in secrecy in the sense that majority finds it difficult in selling and

    buying of lands unless one has perfect knowledge about this sector. Acquiring land for any development

    purpose takes a lot of time. The prices of land keep increasing in most developing countries and the

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    31/80

    ability to borrow becomes very difficult as a result of the high interest rates in the financial institutions in

    most developing countries.

    Accelerated urbanization in most Latin and Caribbean countries has led to concentration of the poor in

    urban centers and has resulted in an unbalanced national and regional human settlement network

    (Habitat II summary, 1996).

    One of the initial arguments against housing was that, its investment exerts pressure on the balance of

    payments because of the high import content of building components. Indeed, the proportion of imported

    materials used in the building and construction of industries in most developing countries is high, (about

    60% in Africa) (Tibaijuka, 2009, p. 215).

    In most developing countries governments still have stringent building code and regulations in place that

    prohibit the use of certain traditional building materials in urban centres notably sun dried bricks and

    wood, low or no access to credit facilities, (Ward, 2001:93) forces families to make do with inadequate

    resources, to live and work in multi-functional spaces combining make shift shacks, partly finished

    rooms, and temporary partitions for walls.

    2.4 EFFECTS OF INADEQUATE HOUSING

    People living in informal settlements often endure high crime rates, drug trafficking and organized

    crime activities.

    People in inadequate housing units suffer from disease and sometimes death.

    Researchers have found that the cost of purchasing services such as water and electricity outside of the

    formal sector is significantly higher than in the formal sector, and so further increases poverty in

    settlements areas (Coit 2001:2, Salazar Cruz 2002: 5-6, Rojas 1995: 2).

    It is a supported fact that, the standard or quality of a housing unit, in which an individual lives is an

    indicator for the measurement of his or her standard of living. This is evident in the fact that the rich or

    wealthy often dwell in better housing and are able to meet their basic needs and therefore live comfortable

    lives. The poor on the other hand often inhabit low standard environments finding it difficult to meet their

    daily bread or support their families. This prompts people in such settlements to result in indecent acts

    and high crime activities such as prostitution, drug trafficking and armed robbery among others.

    2.5 THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    32/80

    This aspect of the research would look at two key theories or models of housing: Housing First and

    Healthy Housing.

    Housing First is an approach that centers on providing homeless people with housing quickly and then

    providing services as needed. What differentiates a Housing First approach from other strategies is that

    there is an immediate and primary focus on helping individuals and families quickly access and sustain

    permanent housing. This approach has the benefit of being consistent with what most people experiencing

    homelessness want and seek help to achieve. Housing First programs share critical elements:

    There is a focus on helping individuals and families access and sustain rental housing as quickly as

    possible and the housing is not time-limited;

    A variety of services are delivered primarily followinga housing placement to promote housing stability

    and individual well-being;

    Such services are time-limited or long-term depending upon individual need; and

    Housing is not contingent on compliance with services instead, participants must comply with a

    standard lease agreement and are provided with the services and supports that are necessary to help them

    do so successfully.

    A Housing First approach rests on the belief that helping people access and sustain permanent, affordable

    housing should be the central goal of our work with people experiencing homelessness. By providing

    housing assistance, case management and supportive services responsive to individual or family needs

    (time-limited or long-term) after an individual or family is housed, communities can significantly reduce

    the time people experience homelessness and prevent its further episodes. A central tenet of the Housing

    First approach is that social services to enhance individual and family well-being can be more effective

    when people are in their own home.

    While there are a wide variety of program models, Housing First programs all typically include:

    Assessment-based targeting of Housing First services

    Assistance locating rental housing, relationship development with private market landlords, and lease

    negotiation

    Housing assistance ranging from security deposit and one months rent to provision of a long-term

    housing subsidy.

    Healthy Housing is a broad theory and WHO takes a holistic and interdisciplinary approach. There is no

    universally agreed definition of healthy housing, but it does not mean a specially designed visionary

    house; it simply means a home that provides an environment that is safe, comfortable and hygienic.

    Healthy housing is mostly a question of applying existing evidence, knowledge and proven principles:

    over the centuries, housing standards and good practice have been developed to provide this. But these

    are often ignored. The following physical, social and mental factors all come in to play. For most people

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    33/80

    home is a refuge from the outside world, part of our sense of identity as an individual or as a part of a

    family. It is as our space to be ourselves if external stressors or other factors noise, cold, pest, damp,

    lack of security interfere with this, they limit this feeling of safety, intimacy and control over our own

    lives.

    Health effects can be directly triggered by inadequate housing conditions. For example;

    Mould growth

    Indoor air pollution

    Chemical emissions from building materials

    Infestations- rats , pest

    Inefficient heating systems and insulation

    Lack of hygiene and sanitation amenities.

    Added to this, the physical quality and the design of housing is central. It can mean that you are unsafe, or

    isolated, or subject to increased noise or it can limit the lives of those who have less mobility or physical

    handicapped. A large number of studies provided evidence that the social cohesion of a community and

    its sense of trust and collective efficacy to some extent depends on the quality of the neighborhood, and

    this is closely allied to the provision of diverse public places and facilities for social life if you can easily

    meet the neighbors, while retaining independence and privacy, your life is enriched and you are healthier.

    The quality of urban design affects health. Poorly planned or neglected residential areas, often lacking

    public services, greenery, parks, play grounds and walking areas, have been associated with a lack of

    physical exercise, increased prevalence of obesity, cognitive problems in children, and a loss of the abilityto socialize. Residents can see the signs of decline: litter, pollution, graffiti, segregation, loitering and

    increased insecurity. This is made worse by an increased dependence on individual transport, triggering

    increased pollution and noise exposure and endangering or isolating the most vulnerable population

    groups such as children, elderly or disabled people.

    There are different approaches to housing, but that of Housing First approach and the World Health

    Organizations approach to housing and health are of paramount importance to our research. Inadequate

    housing in our system is as a result of several people who are homeless and are struggling to make ends

    meet. As a result of their predicaments, they tend to put up structures that are sub standard and very

    harmful to their health. This is what Housing First seeks to achieve; that is providing housing for the

    homeless people who are out there on the streets. This would go a long way to curb the problems of

    emerging slums and squatter settlements. Not only does the Housing First approach take in to

    consideration the provision of housing for the homeless, it also emphasizes the need for individuals and

    families to access rents at affordable prices and as quickly as possible so they can be sustainable.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    34/80

    This approach also recognizes the fact that services should be delivered to most housing stability and

    individual wellbeing. If these services are provided there would not be any need to create temporal

    structures that are used as housing facilities which most at times endanger individuals wellbeing.

    In order for residents not to be exploited, this approach challenges tenants to always insist on a standard

    lease agreement and comply strictly with it and they are provided with services and supports that are

    necessary to help them do so successfully.

    Finally, a Housing First approach believes in assisting the vulnerable to access affordable housing and

    the necessary available facilities that would go a long way to curb homelessness. These help individuals

    and families to improve their wellbeing and increase productivity at their work places.

    Regarding the World Health Organizations approach to Healthy Housing, it views housing in a more

    attractive and encouraging sense. The environment in which the house is found should be serene,

    comfortable and safe. In providing a housing unit, the health of the people must be critically looked at so

    as not to endanger the people with indoor pollution, mould growth, infestations of pest and rats and so

    many others. All these are as a result of inadequate housing conditions.

    2.6 CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK

    The conceptual framework which underlies this study consists of concepts and the kind of relationships

    that exist between and among them.

    Housing is a very important concept that everybody must appreciate. The demand for housing in most

    parts of the world is increasing day in day out. This as a result has called for the establishment of slums,squatter settlements among others in most developing countries. In other to curb this menace, there should

    be housing policies that are good enough to drive the housing sector to a more positive direction.

    These policies should be implemented for actions to be taken. In the process and after the implementation

    of these policies, the natural or environmental characteristics for the provision of housing materials

    should be considered and taken critical look at. The materials that would be used for the provision of

    housing are very important because, natural or environmental characteristics across the country vary and

    so the appropriate and most conducive materials that suit a particular environment or weather conditions

    should be used. The social and demographic characteristics of the people where housing is to be provided

    are very important. What are the peoples values, beliefs, norms, interests and perceptions? Does the

    provision of certain facilities in a house go against their beliefs and values? If so, what kind of a facility

    can be a substitute to suit them or what do they prefer instead of what was to be provided initially. If all

    these are not considered, the provision of adequate housing would forever be a problem in Ghana and in

    most developing countries.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    35/80

    Furthermore, there should be laws and several legislations that emphasize the need for the provision of

    adequate housing. Failure to do this by unscrupulous landlords would be liable to prosecution under the

    laws of the nation. One most important issue in the provision of housing is our economic systems and

    institutions. In Ghana, our economic systems and institutions are not vibrant and encouraging in such a

    way that, there is no heavy investment in the housing sector. The few are usually not affordable by the

    poor. The interest rates in the banks are so high that, it deters a lot of people to go in for loans in order to

    invest in this sector. Macroeconomic indicators such as inflation are not stable thereby discouraging a lot

    of people from going into this sector.

    More so, the health and sanitation sector of the economy should also be looked at critically. Facilities in

    most houses when provided should take into consideration the health related effects of it, how compact

    are the rooms and how near are they to the rooms in the case of a compound house. The provision of

    liquid and solid drainage facilities in our housing systems in the country is so appalling. This increases

    our health risks. To build a more vibrant housing sector, health and sanitation is key. What kind or style

    of housing is being adopted in a particular area or community? It would be realized in some part of the

    country, there are different styles to which their houses are built. This is usually based on their cultural

    setting and they build to suit it.

    The nature and level of the development of the private sector is also very important. The development of

    the private sector would assist government in the provision of decent housing that the average Ghanaian

    can afford. If all these indicators are seen to be effective, it would help boost the national economy and

    thereby have these direct positive effects on the lives of many Ghanaians. Promotion of local building

    materials would create jobs for those who would be engaged in the provision of these materials. If these

    jobs are created, definitely incomes would increase thereby encouraging savings. The effect of increased

    savings would be investment. The health conditions of the people would be improved which would

    finally lead to increase in labour productivity.

    Taking a look at the objectives of the Ghana Vision 2020, the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers and the

    Millennium Development Goals, it can be realized that, to effectively achieve development, government

    policies, economic structures and the socio- demographic characteristics must be geared towards

    providing and improving adequate housing for the citizens. Housing is very important and has a lot of

    benefits if appropriately taken care of. But it can also have serious repercussions on the lives of many

    Ghanaians if much attention is not given to the sector. Rural- urban migration, over crowding, poor health

    conditions, low productivity and poverty are some of the negative effects of poor housing.

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    36/80

    A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK ON HOUSING AND ITS DEVELOPMENTAL IMPLICATIONS.

    Housing demand Direct Positive Effects

    1. Promotion of local

    building materials

    2. Job creation

    3. Income

    4. Savings

    5. Investment

    6. improved health

    conditions.

    7. Labour productivity

    Housing policies

    Natural/ envtal

    characteristics for the

    provision of housing

    materials

    Social and

    demographic

    characteristics

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    37/80

    SOURCE: Authors Construct 2010

    CHAPTER THREE

    3.0 PROFILE OF THE WA MUNICIPALITY

    Legal Environment of

    HousingNation

    alHOUSI

    Indirect Positive Effects

    1. MDG`s

    2. PRSPs

    3. Vision 2020

    Economic systems and

    institutions

    Health and sanitation

    Negative Effects

    1. Rural- urban

    migration

    2. Over crowding

    3. Poor healthconditions

    4. Low productivity

    5. poverty

    Cultural environment

    of housing

    Nature/Level of Devt

    of the private sector

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    38/80

    3.1. 0 Physical Characteristics

    3.1.1 Location and Size:

    Figure 3.1a Figure 3.1b

    Fig.3.1a and b: Maps of Ghana and Upper West Region showing research study area-Wa.

    The Wa Municipal Assembly in the Upper West Region is bordered to the North by the Nadowli District,

    to the East by Wa East District, to the West by Wa West District and to the South by both Wa East and

    West Districts. It lies within latitudes 140N to 245N and longitudes 932 to 1020W with a landmass

    of approximately 23,474(sq km), which is about 6.4% of the region.

    3.1.2 Relief, Drainage, and Topography

    The Municipality lies in the Savanna high plains, which generally, is gently undulating with an average

    height between 160 m and 300m above sea level. The municipality has two main drainage systems, Sing-

    Bakpong and its tributaries to the South and Billi and its tributaries to the North. The main types of rock

    which underlie the Municipality are predominantly Pre-Cambrian, granite and metamorphic rocks.

    3.1.3 Climate and Vegetation

    The vegetation is of the Guinea Savanna grassland type, made up of short trees and shrubs of varying

    heights and luxuriance, with grass ground cover in the wet season. Commonly occurring trees are Shea

  • 8/3/2019 Effects of Inadequate Housing on the Residents of Wa Township

    39/80

    trees Dawadawa, Kapok and Baobab. Generally, the Municipality has two marked seasons namely, the

    wet and dry seasons. The South-Western Monsoon winds bring rains between May and September,

    whilst the North-Eastern Trade winds bring the long dry season between October and April. The mean

    annual rainfall varies between 840mm and 1400mm within June and September, and is generally for the

    cultivation of crops such as millet.

    3.1.4 Soils

    The most extensive soil type is the laterite soil. The second type is the Savanna orchrosols found along

    the Black Volta.

    3.2. 0 DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS

    3.2.1 Population Size, Growth Rate and Density

    According to the 2000 Population and Housing Census (PHC), the Wa Municipality has a total population

    of 98,675 (Ghana Statistical Service). Wa Town has a population size of 66,644. The growth rate of the

    Municipality varies between the rural (2.7%) and the urban (4%). By implication, there is a high density

    of population in Wa and consequently pressure on land and socio-economic infrastructure.

    3.2.2 Age/ Sex structure of the population

    From past population records, the population structure has revealed a preponderance of the youth over the

    aged and females over males. The former characteristic is mainly attributed to the cultural values