drink tank fifth element

Upload: rev-dr-christopher-j-garcia

Post on 04-Apr-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    1/14

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    2/14

    Episode Three The Tipping Point

    In the 604,800 seconds between the last column and the one I am writing today, I came to several crucial

    profound and inescapable conclusions.

    MyrstrevelationcamelatelastweekwhenImetwithseveralfriends,someofwhomhadattendedChicon7andotherswhohadgonetoDragonConoverthesameLaborDayweekend.(LettherecordshowthatIwasatChicon7,albeitworkingnearlyallthattimeintheWorldconsPressRelationsofce.Becausesomeone

    hadtohaverelationswiththepressandIdrewtheoddlot.Well,onward)The couple who went to Chicon 7 stated that while they had a good time and the con was well run, they

    weresurprisedthattherewasntahigherturnout(estimatesonattendancewerearound5000-5500)andwereshockedatthederogatorycommentsmadeduringtheraticationdebateoftheGraphicStoryHugoandthe

    equally rude behavior as the Young Adult award proposal was debated.

    ThefriendwhowenttoDragonConatlystatedthatshewenttoAtlantabecausesheusedtoattendWorldconsonaregularbasisbutstoppedbecauseofwhatshedescribedas,thebadattitudeoftheprogrammersandfansrunningit.Shesaidthatshefeltthattherewasapalatablebiasagainstfanslikeher,wholikeawide

    range of activities beyond reading.

    Thephenomenonshedescribedwasnotnewtome;sincelate1990s,Ihavenoticedagrowingschisminsffandombetweenthosewhoprimarilyreadgenrectionandthosewhoenjoywiderinterests,suchasmovies,

    television,cos-play,videogamesandgraphicstories. ThedividebetweenthevariousfangroupsandWorldconattendeeshasgrownwiderthaneveroverthe

    past decade. The numbers of fans who attend Comicon and Dragoncon have grown exponentially in the thou -sandswhiletheattendanceatWorldconshasstagnated.ThosefansthatdogototheotherconventionseitherdontknowaboutWorldconsorseefanswhoattendthemaselitistandremote,ordontcareabouttheHugosorWorldcon,atall.

    Ive alsowitnessedthereverseattitudeinaction aswell; fanswho attend traditionalconventions, owhich,onanaverage,mostlyskewtobeolder,arenotverywelcomingtofanswithotherorwiderinterests.nowbelievethatasaresultofthis,Worldconsareasmarginalizedastheyhaveeverbeen. In1999,IbeganproposingchangesintheHugoAwards.Myprimarymotivefordoingsowastodemon-

    Yet Another Rather Annoying Column of Commentaryby Chris M. Barkley

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    3/14

    stratethatthesegmentoffandomthatIhavebeencloselyassociatedwith(foroverthirtyyears)wascapableof

    change. Change that would then attract more support from media oriented fans. I was also hoping these changes

    wouldcombatvotercomplacencyandensurethattheHugoswouldremainrelevantandengaginginthe21st

    century.

    AlookatthestatisticsshowthatmembersofWorldconwhovotefortheHugoshaveincreasedslightlyoverthepastdecadeandtheyhavestoppedrubberstampingHugowinsforseveraloftheusualsuspectsintheArtist,Fanzine,Semi-ProzineandtheEditorcategories.However,thedownsideisthatthenumberofnomina-

    tionsneededthegetonthenominationballotremainsabysmallylow,DoctorWhoseemstobeentrenchedin

    theBestDramaticPresentationwinnercirclefortheforeseeablefutureandtheHugos,despiteeveryonesbestefforts,remainalowproleawardtothegeneralpublicatlarge. Asthispastweekendwounddown,Icametotheratherdisturbingconclusionthatallofthatworkwasfornaught.IwaswronginthinkingthatmerelychangingtheHugoswouldbeenoughtoaffectthechangessoughtinfandom.Thisrealization,inturn,leddirectlytomysecondrevelation. Inhis2000book,TheTippingPoint:HowLittleThingsCanMakeaBigDifference,authorMalcolmGladweldenesitasathemomentofcriticalmass,thethreshold,theboilingpoint. AfterwitnessingtheharshcriticalreactionandtheaccompanyingrudebehaviorattheChicon7Business

    Meeting,Inowfeelquitecertainthatsffandom,oratleasttheportionthatrunstheannualWorldScienceFictionandadministerstotheHugoAwards,hasdenitelyreachedatippingpoint.

    This branch of fandom cannot sustain itself into the next decade if it maintains this rather insular, sullenattitudetowardstherestofthefannishworld.AndifthesituationdoesnotbodewellforWorldcon,youcanimaginewhatthatmeansfortheHugoAwards. Afterthinkingallthisthrough,IrealizedthatIhavetoreassessmypositionontheYoungAdultHugo.decidedthatIwillproceedwithintroducingtheproposalatLoneStarCon3,asIpromised.Ifitpasses,IwillbemorethanhappytoseetheprocessthroughtoLoncon3.

    Butifitfails,IwillnolongerpursueitspassageatanyfutureWSFSBusinessMeeting.Infact,IwillnolongproposeANYmorechangestoeithertheHugoAwardcategoriesortotheWorldScienceFictionSocietys

    Constitution again.

    IvegoneasfarasIcanforaslongasIcan.Now,Ithink,myworkhascometoanend.Toparaphrasetheoldlightbulbjoke;Howmanyfansdoesittaketochangefandom?Morethanonetobesure,butfandomhasto

    REALLYwanttochange. Nextweek,wellsavetheWorldconandtheHugosbutpissalotofpeopleoffatthesametime.ItshouldbeaLOToffun,sostaytuned

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    4/14

    I Like Storiesby Christopher J Garcia

    Nottoolongago,Iwaslookingforimagesinmyever-expandingcollectionofsciencectionmagsofthepast.ThistimeIwaslookingfor

    imagesofcomputers.TherearequiteafewouttherethatIveseen,butitturnedoutthatIdonthaveanyoftheminmycollection. ThatistosayIvegotatotalofone. Thatoneisaclassic:EmEmshwillerscoverfortheOctober1957editionofAstounding.Itsagreatimage,especaillywhenyouno-

    ticethatthetapedriveshavethreereels!Thatsnutty!Ihadseenthe

    image, included it in a number of areas of the museum, including our

    exhibitonComputerChess.Theblown-upimagewehadin thatone

    now sits behind my chair at the museum, so anytime anyone comes to

    mydesk,theyaresaringattheeyesoftheunfortunateoperatorofthatcolossal machine.

    Ihadseenthatimage,butIcantthinkofatimewhenIactaully

    read it.

    Lookignatit,therewasonepartIcertainlywouldntbereading.

    ITwasCitizenoftheGalaxy,aportionofitanyways,bythatRobertaHeinlein.ItriedtoreaditwhenIwasyounger,nevergotmorethana

    coupleofpagesinandgaveup.IdonotunderstandhowamanwhoseprosefeelslikeitwascopiedoffaPostOfcepackigninstructionssheetcouldbecomethemostbelovedmaninthegenre.ThereweretwopiecesfromauthorswhowereeasilyHeinleinsbetteratthetime,soI thoughtaboutstartingthere.TherewasaRandal

    Garrettstory,andIloveRandallGarrett(thoughnotnearlyasmuchasIlovestoriesaboutRandallGarrett,likethetimePhilFarmerchasedanakedRandallthroughaconventionhotellobby),butthisone,Gentlemen:Please

    Note,wasoneIdreadnottoolongago.Theotherone,byanauthorIsayistheBESTauthorfothe1940sand50s:MurrayLeinster. Now,IvebeenreadingafairbitofLeinsterlately,largelystuffthattiesinwithALogicNamedJoe,whichImworkingonapieceforthemuseumabout.Ihadntreadthisone,TheGrandfathersWar,soIgaveitatry. Thethingisoneofthosestoriesthatwashardformetocotton,butIcouldntdenythatLeinsterwassogoodatwhathedidthatitkeptmereading.Itsapieceofpost-WWIIwritingthatfeelslikeitwaswrittenatatimewheneveryoneexpectedWWIIItohappenwithinthehour.IdontknowifIdcallitSpaceOpera,thoughtherewassomegoodSpace-faringoinon,butIwouldntcallitpacistSFeither.Ivereadenoughofthatfromthe1950stolastmealifetime.FocusingonaMedShipwasanicetouch.Thewritingfeltstrong,withprosethat

    didntmakemewanttoputmystthroughthetombstonethatholdsdownthecorpseofHeilein. InowamCOMPLETELYinagreementwithStevenHSilveraboutthefactthatLeinsterhastobeintheScienceFictionHallofFame. TheotherstorywasCompensationbyChristopherAnvil.AnvilisanauthorIveenjoyed,andherehes

    doing a story that plays wonderfully with almost nothing but dialogue. It tells a story about a society based on

    telepathy,whichwasathemeofseveralstories(andanovelortwo,thoughoneofthemmighthavebeenanextensionofthisstory!) So,Ienjoyedit,whichremindsmeofsomethignIvebeenmeaningtodo,whichisreadmore...

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    5/14

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    6/14

    Inmid-September,therewasaconsiderablebrouhahaoveralmcalledInnocenceofMuslimsthatpur-portedtobeadocumentary.TheresapossibilitythemovieitselfmaynotevenexistonlytrailersforitweretobefoundonYouTube.ThecreditslistsomeonenamedSamBacileasthelm-maker,butthatalsowasonly

    ahalf-truthatbest.Infact,SamappearstobeNakoulaBasseleyNakoula,anEgyptianCopticChristianlivinginCalifornia.GodknowsthatasaChristianminorityinanIslamicnationtheCoptshavebeentreatedliketheN-wordforcenturies,andhavereasonenoughtodespisetheiroppressors.Justwhatendthislmandthe

    deception serves, however, is far from clear.

    ThelmdepictsahighlyuncomplimentaryhistoricalMohammedthatisnoteasilyrecognizedasThe

    ProphetreverredbyIslam.Predictably,manyoftheFaithfulwentballistic,andshowedadegreeofenlightenmentthatcontinuestospeakpoorlyofthatpartoftheworld.Whenwasthelasttimeyouweredriventomasdemonstrations,wantondestructionandmurderbecauseyourchoiceofKingJamesorLatinVulgatewascriti

    cized?Thatsthesortofover-the-top,dial-right-to-elevenresponseyouwouldexpectofDutchShultzorEdwardTeach,notofapeoplewhoaresupposedlyleavingtheMiddleAgesbehindforanArabSpring. Nevertheless,therecentoutburstofreligiousparanoiaremindedofanotherexampleofwacky,goodnatured,anti-IslamichumouracomicbookIboughtonlineafewyearsago,calledMohammedsBelieveitorElse.TheauthorandillustratorwasnamedAbdullahAziz...orsoitsaysonthecover.ThepublisherwasabiblecollegeinLasVegas,leavingroomfordoubtwhetherornotthereeverwassuchapersonasAbdullahAzizWhoeverthewriterandartistwas,hisillustrationswerelaughing-out-loudfunny.HisstylewasalotlikeJack

    DavisoneofthebestcartoonistsfromtheoldMadMagazine. Mostofthetextfollowsasimpleformula:AziztakesaquotefromtheQuranortheHadithswhich

    areMohammedsleft-oversayingsandanecdotesandaddscartoonstoshowthemasthepatentlyridiculousorsuperstitiousnonsensetheyare.Theapproachisalittlerepetitive,butmakesforrichreadingthelevelo

    absurdity is sometimes so far off the scale that you need you need to go around the dial twice. Typical gems

    includeatribesofJewsturnedintoratsbecausetheyhadbecomelostinthedesert.Didyouevernoticethatratsdrinksheepmilkbutnotcamelmilk?Jewsdontherdcamels,yousee,theyherdsheep.Thatprovesit!Stilonthesubjectoftransformations,AllahonceturnedthepeopleofavillagethatlivedbytheseaintomonkeysbecausetheywereimpiousenoughtobehungryontheSabbathandcaughtsh.Alsomentionedisawarningtopraywithyoureyesloweredlestangelspluckoutyoureyeballs!

    SomethingelseMohammedwarnsustowatchoutforisfallingasleepduringprayer.Ifyoudo,Satanwil

    peeinyourear.Hewillalsocrawlupyournoseatnightforanap,so,forheavenssake,dontforgettoblowwhenyougetupinthemorning!AndifyoueatgarlicoronionbeforeprayingAllahwillnothearyou.Hellispopulatedmainlybywomen,nottoosurprisingly,anditisokaytodrinkwaterwithadeadyinit,becauseonlyonewingcarriesdiseasewhiletheotherwingcarriestheantidote.Ikiddeththeenot,unfaithfulone! Iboughttencopiesformydealerstable,guringthemassure-resalesandwasntdisappointed.Thecomic books themselveswerentexpensive; unfortunately theshipping andhandlingweremurderwhichbringsusbacktotopic. OffensivetoMuslimsastherecentlmis,toanunbelieversuchasI,however,itisnoblasphemy.Asan

    atheist,itismyunshakeablebeliefthatthereisnoAllah,noJehovah,noGodtohavedivinelyinspiredtheprophetMohammedwhoistomenomoretomethanasuccessfulArabwarlord,similarintypetoCaesarorNapo

    All Hell to Payby Taral Wayne

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    7/14

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    8/14

    52 Weeks to Science Fiction Film Literacy - The Fif th Element

    TheultimatemessageofTheFifthElementistheworldwillgetweirderbeforeitwillgetmorenormalWHileotherSFlmsreliedonspecialeffectstodevelopaworldwhichseemedlikeitwouldbeentirelydifferent

    inTheFifthElement,itwastheartdirection,andespeciallythecostumes,thatdidtheheavylifting.Thisisalmthatunderstandswhatlmcando. Thatsaid,theresalotofgreateffectsstufftoo,butletsnotgettieddownthere,shallwe? TheFifthElementisaverybasicstory.IcallittheMustCollectemAlltypeofstory.Therearealotothem,mostnotablylmslikeG.I.JoetheMovie.Thebasicconceptisthattheressomesetofthingsthathavetobefound,keptandinstalledbeforesomethingbadhappens.Itsasmartstory,aclassic,andeventhemostrecentIndianaJonesmoviecanruinit.Itsalotofintensestuffthatcanhappeninthesekindoflms,soitsagoodstructuretogowithifyouremakingamovie.

    ThelmstartswiththeMondoshawans,anawesomealienrace,comingtocollectasetofstoneswhichistheonlythingthatcanstoptheGreatEvilwhichcomesbyeveryvethousandyears.Theresapriestwhoisthekeeperofthesecret,andtheresasarcophagusthatholdsTheFifthElement! See,simplehuh? Thenwegoforwardtothe23rdCenturywhereweseethearrivaloftheGreatEvilasitdestroyanEarthshipoutinspace.ThePriestwhokeepstheMondoshawanwaysalivegoestothePresidentandtellshimthestory.TheMondoshawanreturnbutanotheralienrace,theMangalores,arehiredbytheevilindustrialistJean-BaptisteEmanuelZorgtoblowemup.TheonlythingthatsurvivesisthehandoftheFifthElement.TheycloneitandthisleadstothecreationofLeeloo.Shefreaksoutandjumpsoffthebuildingtheycreatedherinandland

    in the taxicab of one Korben Dallas.

    KorbenDallasisexactlywhatwevebeentaughtmakesforagreatheroinasciencectionstory.Hes

    fallenfromformergloryasamemberoftheSpecialForces,andhasendedupassomethingofahuskofhisfor-merselfasayingcabdriver.BruceWIllisisgoodintherole,ashewassortainatroughinhiscareer.HehadbeenthroughtheDieHards,hehadbeenthroughhisrstwaveofhalf-decentdramalms,buthewasntthestahewaseventhreeyearsbefore.Inafewyears,hewouldmakehisbiggeststringofhitsstartingwithTheSixthSense.HestillhasthatActionHerothinggoingon,buthealsohasthatfeelingthathehasseenbetterdays.And

    he had.

    KorbentakesLeelootothePriestCornelius,whoexplainsthatthestonesarewithTheDiva,asingerwhoisonaSpaceLinercruise.ThisleadsDallasformercommandingofcertoconvincehimtogoundercover

    and get on to the cruise, which he does, though he brings Leeloo with him. That leads to a great performance

    scenefromTheDiva,whoisthenkilled,thoughDallasguresoutthattheelementstonesareINSIDEtheDiva.

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    9/14

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    10/14

    weredesignedbythelegendaryfashiondesignerJean-PaulGaultier.AsIlearnedwhenIvisitedhisexhibitatthedeYoungMuseumthisyear,Gaultierhaslongbeeninuencedbythesciencectionofthe1960sand70s.Whilehehaddoneafewlms,hehadneverhadtheamountofinuenceovertheentiretyofthelookofalmashehadwithTheFifthElement.Hecreatednearlyonethousandcostumesforthetim,andtheyreallysetthestageInfact,asinglecostumemighttellasmuchofastoryasthescript.Theresascenewhereourheroesyanden-counterfutureightattendants.Theyareinshortskirts,croppedtopswithcentralcutoutsandbustiersexposedunderneath.Theyalsohavethesewonderfulhats,sortofacombinationofpill-boxandastove-pipe.Thedesigns

    sayalotaboutwhattravelmeansinthetimethatsbeingportrayed.Theyarehyper-sexualized,Iwouldargue,as

    theseouttsaredesignedtotittilate.Ifyoulookatthewaysinwhichthestewardessoutthasevolved,itsbeengoingintheoppositewaythatGaultierhastakenit. Andnoonemakesanymentionofit.Itsjusthowitgoes.Itsastatement. Thecostumesofeverycharacteraredeeplyconsidered,astheyareineverylm,butheretheygiveustheweirdbetterthaninanyotherlmIcanthinkof.TheiconicimagesofLeelooinherbirthingoutt,composedofaseriesofwhitestripsofplastic,iswhatdenesherasacharacter.ThelookthatGaultierchosemadeusseethe23rdCenturyasdisjointed,unrealattimes.Wethinkthatthefuturewillbemorestreamlined,morefunctionalThatsnotwhatGaultiergaveus.HegaveusBaroque,strange,undecipherable.Itsstyleoverfunction,whichisn

    somethingwereusedtoanymorefromourvisionsofthefuture.ItsnotTheJetsonsanymore. TheFifthElementisoneofthosemoviesthatyoumightnotcottontoatrst,buttheresalotthereto

    takeinsoasecondviewingisalwaysuseful.Once,justtakeintheimagery,especiallythemattepaintings,manyofwhicharedigitallyenhanced.Secondviewing,focusonthecostumes.Then,ifyoucanstandtowatchitagainlookattheacting.

    After that, the world is your oyster.

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    11/14

    Let us start with the legenday Warren Buff!!!!! GoodtoseeyougotaroundtoJurassicPark.Thatwasabigmovieforme,asmyfolkshadactuallybeen

    ratherstrictaboutenforcingthePG-13rating,anditwastherstlmIreallywantedtoseewithoneonceIwasoldenoughfortheirstandards.IthelpedthatIwasadinosaurfanaticasakid.Iveactuallybeenafraidtorewatchit,asitwassogoodinmychildhood,andIdontwanttorisklosingallthoseimpressionsofit.Afterreadingyouanalysisofitasalm,Imayactuallybetemptedtodoso.ItsoundslikeenoughwouldappealtotheadultinmethatIwouldntrisklosingthegloryfrommyyouth.

    The funny story about Jurassic Park and me was that my graduation gift from high school,

    while my other friends were getting cars and, in one case, an apartment, was a Jurassic Park

    T-Shirt. Well, and college, but thats neither here nor there. It did help that the movie did open

    the day of my graduation. Four years later, the second Jurassic Park movie came out, also re-leased the day I graduated from college. My gift then? A Jurassic Park t-shirt! Oh, and a party

    the likes of which GOD has never seen!

    Iwouldliketopointout,inresponsetoChrisBarkleyspiece,thatseventeenvotesintheWSFSBusiness

    Meeting is not particularly close. The total number of voters rarely surpasses, say, a hundred and twenty, even in

    instancesofhighattendance.IdidntndthegroansthatmetDr.Kloorsspeechtobedeplorable--itfeltlikehewasmakingacheapemotionalappealratherthanarguingthemeritsofthemotion,andtheBusinessMeetingislongenoughthatwithouttheout-of-ordercommentary,itwouldbecomeunbearable.Twoparticularinstancesofsuchcommentsthisyearparticularlyliftedmyspirits--CrystalHuffsquestiontoKentBloomduringthe

    GraphicStorydebate(Pointofinformation:Doyoueven*read*comics?)andStephenBouchersremarkwhenGlennGlazeraskedEemeliAroifhethoughtthehighcostoftravellingtoEuropetwoyearsrunningwouldbe

    prohibitivetoAmericanfans(Oh,crymeariver.--forthosewhodontknow,Mr.BoucherisfromAustralia).knowsomeofthestrictproceduralistsfrownonthesesortsofoutbursts,buttheyreallyaretheonlythingthatmakesthemeetingsbearable.Atmyrstsuchmeeting,Iwastoldthattheywereaboutasfunasgougingyoueyesoutwithaspoon.Idisagree,butwithouttheout-of-orderremarks,thatobjectionmightfade.

    That Kloor statement did feel like pandering, though it did still shock me a little. I didnt re-

    alise that it was Crystal who called out about the Graphic Story thing to Kent. That was a bit

    brutal. I think that the cost issue with US folks will be a big deal for the Helsinki bid. I get it,

    there are folks who have to travel to North America seemingly ever year for WorldCon, and I

    think we should have about every other year outside NA, but two in a row for the majority of

    voters I think will play a role in deciding who gets the WorldCon.

    Letter Graded Mailsent to [email protected]

    by my gentle readers

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    12/14

    IwouldfurtherliketostressmyobjectionstoaddingaHugoAwardforsomethingthatamountstolittlemorethanamarketingcategory.Wecurrently(andalwayshave)dividewrittenctionpurelybyitslength.Thereisanassumptionthatwedontneedtodenesciencectionandfantasy,becausethebaseofvotersarealreadyfans,andasufcientnumberofthemneedtoagreethatsomethingbelongsinthegenreforittogetnominated.Ibelievethistobecorrect,andthus,theonlydetaileddenitionwehaveinourwrittenctioncategoriesisthenumberofwords--andeventhen,wehaveaprovisionbywhichaworknearthebordercanswitchcategoriesifitisnominatedmoreinonewhichwouldbeinappropriatebasedsolelyonlength.Ourotherctionalcategories

    --dramaticpresentationandgraphicstory--differsufcientlyinmediumthattheyarereadilydistinguishable

    fromnovels,shortstories,andtheintermediateworks.IdonotbelievethatitispossibletodrawabrightlinearoundYoungAdultctionsuchthatmostreaderswillplacemostofthesameborderlineworksinandoutothecategory.Furthermore,Idisagreewiththenotionofdividingupavorsofsciencectionandfantasy.Wedont,forinstance,divideupsciencectionandfantasyfromeachother.Iftherewereasingledivisioninstyletomake,thatwouldbeit!

    Knowing what I know about other awards, specically the Oscars, Emmys and, though I hate

    to admit it, the Grammys, having something eligible in more than one category tends to be the

    norm. In the Oscars, Best Animated and Best Documnetary are not barred from Best Picture. I

    know there are a lot of folks who complain that the Hugos are Science Fictions Highest Honor

    given to Fantasy works. I dont see the problem with it.

    Butwedont--wehavechosen,asacommunity,nottocreatesuchdifcultdivisionswithinoureldAfterall,whichsortofstoryareLordofLight,Dune,andthePernnovels?Areyousure?Doyouthinkmostfanswouldsplittheminthesamewayyoudid(andno,Idontcareiftheyrefoolsnotto)?Instead,wehonorworks,dividedonlybyasimpleobjectivecriterion,whentheycanriseabovethegrandmeleeofallworksosimilarlengthwhichfallwithinoureld.TheargumentsforaYAHugoseemtocomedowntotheideathatthemethodoftellingaYAstoryissomehowsufcientlydifferentfromtellinganadultstorythatitdeservesto

    berecognizedseparately,andthatthetargettingoftheseworkstoadifferentsegmentofthepopulationjustiessuchanawardasameansofdrawinginthatpopulationtoourcommunity.Butifthatargumentholdssufcientmerit,whynotsplitsciencectionandfantasy?Thereisclearlyadifferentstyletothestorytellingineach(oristhere?--seethoseborderexamplesabove!),andtheyarealsoclearlymarketeddifferently(andifyoudontthinksciencectionandfantasyaremarketeddifferently,yourefoolingyourself).Butagain,asIvesaid,wehavealready

    chosenasacommunitynottofocusonthosedivisions.Isnowthetimetostart?Im not sure it would work, and could be a monster to administer, which is one of the reasons I

    favor a test through teh discretionary Hugo process. We know that the Best Video Game didnt

    work because we tried and it failed. I am really starting to think that we should keep that go-

    ing.

    ThisisntthatImopposedtorecognizingexcellenceinYAction.IminterestedinseeingifanawardonthemodeloftheCampbellcanbeestablishedforit.ButmakingitaHugowouldrequireabandoningalong-heldprincipleofunicationwithinourcommunity,andthatssomethingIcantstandfor.

    This is where we are in TOTAL AGREEMENT! Well, at least on the Campbell-stylee.

    AstoWorldconbidding,IthinksomeattentionoughttobegiventoNASFiCbidding.Phoenixhasbeenpre-biddingforthe2014NASFiCsincelastyear,andhavenowbeenjoinedintheracebyDetroit.ThatvotewillbetakingplaceinSanAntonioalongsidethevoteforthe2015Worldcon,whichshouldmeanweseevediffer-

    entbidspullingoutthestopsontheirbidparties!ImexpectingthistobeafunWorldcon,especiallyleadinguptothosevotes.Thereisalsoapotentialinuenceonthe2015WorldconracefromtherealmofNASFiC,asTimMillerhasstatedhisintentiontobidHoustonforthe2015NASFiCshouldHelsinkiwintheWorldconIwouldntdiscountthepotentialofthattoinuenceTexanvotersintheWorldconrace(thoughIalsohavendoneacarefulstudyofwhethertheirattitudesruntowardorawayfromhavinganotherNASFiC--byallac-countstheirlastonewasgrand).

    Really glad weve got Detroit in the mix! Ive seen their facilities and they seem really cool

    Plus, its a state where I wouldnt be berated by my family for entering like Arizona!

    -Warren

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    13/14

    And now... Lloyd Penney!!!!!

    DearChris:

    Afast,fastloconissues324and325ofTheDrinkTank.Notalotoftime,andwhoknowswhatImighthavetosay

    A fast LoC on two issues! A bold manuever!

    324HarryHarrisonandRayBradbury,twoSFgiantswhohaveleftus.Moreandmore,theresnosurprise,manyofthebignamesinSFIgrewupwitharegone.IthinkJoeKubertwasaguestatAdAstrayearsago,when

    AdAstrawouldalsohaveaseparatecomicsconvention.AnexcellentarticlebyStevenSilveraslongastheirbooksareonourshelves,andwereadthemorremembertheirwordsfondly,theyreallyarentdead.Theywil

    be with us a long time.

    You know, I dont think Ive read enough of either of em. I have to x that.

    IhaventbeenontheFancy3pageinsometime.Isanyonekeepingitupdatedandaddingmoreentriesorhasitbeendormant?IamhavingalookatitIhavetoaskMarkOlsonandtheLosconfolkstospellourlast

    name correctly.

    Loscon got it wrong! FOOLS!!!!! (runs off to check the spelling on his SFCOntatio page)

    Terminator2:JudgmentDay.IcantsayIvereallylikedanyofArnoldsmovies,butIdidseethersttwoTerminatormovies.Hesbecomeaparodyofhimself;recentlysawthetrailerforhisnewestautobiography,and

    evenhecallshimselfTheGovernator.TheeffectoftheT-1000wereneat,buttherewasntmuchelse.And in a way, Arnold parodying himself is more entertaining than the genuine thing! I point tothe highly under-rated The Last Action Hero, which when compared to the decent True Lies, is

    a masterpiece!

    325Andhere,IsawtheJPandJP2.Ifthereweremoreineitherseries,Imnotawareofthem.Good point!

    WishweddoneChicon,butnomoneyforit,andstillsavingforLondon.TheresarenfaireintheChicagoarea?ItsoundsmoreliketheArthurianjoustingshownearExhibitionPlacehere,MedievalTimes.Isawitonceandfounditrathercorny,butthecrowdsseemtoloveit,anditsstillgoingafter15yearsorso.

    We all missed ya! I just went by our Medieval Times in So Cal last week. I REALLY wanted to see

    it again, but it doesnt show on weekdays!

    Iamnotsomuchbored,butrealizingthatImightneedachangeofpace.Fandomisstillfun,butnewerinterestsinsteampunkandnowMurdochMysterieshasallowedusnewactivitiesandnewfriends.Youvegottokeepyourselfbusy,andifyoudontuseyourmind,youllloseit.

    I wish that was true! What I wouldnt give for a lost mind these days!

    JurassicParkgreateffects,nastysaurians,notmuchelseIcansayaboutit.Well,Ididgetaninterestingfontoutofit

    Yeah, the materials promotion JP were great! One thing I should write up someday is the evolu-

    tion of the Movie Opening Process. I especially loved the posters!

    ATorontoThanksgivingWorldconbid?Thatisindeednewstome.ServesmerightfordroppingoutotheloopwhenitcomestoWorldcons.Montrealisstillbidding,butthereisconfusionastowhatyeartheywant.Im kinda shocked you havent heard about it seeign as youre the co-Chair!

    And,Iamdone.Iamwaitingforane-mailfromanagencywhomightgetmeatwo-dayassignmentinthedowntownareaonMondayandTuesday,andthenonWednesday,Imightndoutif Igetafull-timeemployee-stylejobwithapublishingcompanyjustnorthofToronto.HurryupandwaitIhatethat,butIadmitImused

    to it.

    SeeyouatSFContario,comingupinsixorsevenweeks?Wehaventgottenalotoffeedbackfromthe

    conventionaboutwhattheydlikeustodoforyou,butonceweallgureitout,wellgetitdone.

    Yours,LloydPenney.Always good to hear from ya, Lloyd! To think, well see each other TWICE in November!

  • 7/31/2019 Drink Tank Fifth Element

    14/14