RUSSIA 1855 - 1914
How effectively did the reforms of Alexander II solve the internal problems of Russia?
The reforms of Alexander II
Timespan 1855 (death of Nikolas I) - 1881 (assassination of A II)
REFORMS:· The abolition of serfdom - not immediate, the peasants still dependent of the
commune. Econommically the serfs were worse off.· Local government reform - some powers distributed to the local community.
· Reform of the judicial system - Russia one small step towards a state governed by
law.· Economic and financial reforms
· Education reforms
· Reforms of the armed forces
· The nationalities - liberalism towards the finns, russification of the poles.
Titel: nov 10-13:41 (Sida 1 av 65)
Internal problems of Russia 1855-81:
Titel: nov 11-13:41 (Sida 2 av 65)
How well were the problems solved:
Titel: nov 11-13:41 (Sida 3 av 65)
The Crimean War made Alexander II realize that Russia was no longer a great
military power. His advisers argued that Russia's serf-based economy could no
longer compete with industrialized nations such as Britain and France.
"It is better to abolish serfdom from above than to wait for the time when it
will begin to abolish itself from below.
In 1861 Alexander issued his Emancipation Manifesto that proposed 17
legislative acts that would free the serfs in Russia. Alexander announced that
personal serfdom would be abolished and all peasants would be able to buy
land from their landlords. The State would advance the money to the
landlords and would recover it from the peasants in 49 annual sums known as
redemption payments.
Titel: nov 10-19:14 (Sida 4 av 65)
How far is it true to say that Russia was transformed into a modern country between 1855 and 1900?
Problems: the definition of modern. Transformation has to be discussed as it took place. In a conclusion the student has to decide if the result was a modern country.
Timespan; The rule of Alexander II, Alexander III and start of Nicholas II.
Titel: dec 2-20:24 (Sida 5 av 65)
Background: The humiliating defeat in the Crimean War. The war thought Russia a lesson. West European efficiency and industrialisation
defeated the stagnated and old fashioned Russian Empire. This alarmed the Russian government and the new ruler. Russia had to be
reformed in order to compete with the west.Social reform was also inevitable to prevent revolution by the
peasantry.
Titel: nov 11-13:50 (Sida 6 av 65)
By the end of the 16th century the Russian peasant came
under the complete control of the landowner and during
the middle of the 17th century serfdom became
hereditary. Their situation became comparable to that of
slaves and they could be sold to another landowner in
families or singly.
By the 19th century it was estimated that about 50 per
cent of the 40,000,000 Russian peasants were serfs. Most
of these were the property of the nobility but large
numbers were owned by the Tsar and religious
foundations.
Russian serfdom
Titel: nov 7-17:21 (Sida 7 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-21:10 (Sida 8 av 65)
Rural Russia: Land tenure in Feudal Russia was arranged by cherespolositsa, where land on each fief was divided into long narrow
strips. Serfs tended two strips side by side: one for the landlord, the other for themselves.
After serfdom was abolished in 1861, the land serfs had once cultivated for themselves became owned by a peasant commune, the Obshchina ,
formed from those peasants on the same fief. The landlords retained the lands that were not used for maintaining the life of the serfs (eg. they kept the majority of the land), still in strips side to side with the
communal land. The landlords also retained all of the forested and pastoral land.
While the serfs had once been able to graze their animals (commonly a cow and horse) on pastoral land, now their animals had no where to
graze. The newly "emancipated" peasants were also stranded from the most prized commodity of Russia throughout most of the year:
firewood.
Titel: nov 8-1:36 PM (Sida 9 av 65)
From this relationship between landowner and peasant was born the kulak ,
who imposed on the peasantry a tax to use their pasture. The communes
responded by lying fallow some of their land and turning it into pasture. Their
remained, however, the strips of the landlord's land throughout their community.
The kulak here established a system of tolls for each animal that crossed over
their land (areas now called vavilony – "babylons"). In order to have wood for
winter, peasants had little choice but to work the kulak's land in return for a
payment fee that would allow them to cut timber from the kulak's forest.
The hated Kulaks as seen in Stalin's propaganda.
Titel: nov 8-1:45 PM (Sida 10 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-21:11 (Sida 11 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-21:12 (Sida 12 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-18:20 (Sida 13 av 65)
Distressed by the suffering of the serfs and the selfishness of the
nobles Alexander II forbad landowners to move serfs to poor lands
or to dispose of them by giving them to the army.
The serfs on royal estates were liberated in 1858 and in 1861
Alexander II signed the EMANCIPATION ACT.
http://www.shsu.edu/~his_ncp/Eman.html
Here you can read the whole declaration
Titel: nov 7-17:50 (Sida 14 av 65)
· No intention of introducing a modern system of money relationship
into the countryside or a class of capitalist farmers.
· No equality before the law
· No real economic freedom to develop individual lands.
· The nobles remained priviliged increasing their share of the wealth
from 1861-1914.
Titel: nov 7-17:52 (Sida 15 av 65)
· 1864 - next major reform; the creation of the Zemstvos - elected
local governments.
· 3 categories of voters for councils chosen for 3 years.
· Local assemblies
· Provincial assemblies
· Urban councils
· Regional and provincial nobles of the highest rank chaired the
rural assemblies. The wealthy and the titled had more voting power
· Those who paid a higher tax had a greater representation
· The councils main purpose were to make improvements.
Zemstvo building
Titel: nov 7-17:53 (Sida 16 av 65)
· Army- and financial reforms;
· Universal conscription 1874 - increase of the army, six years
service with a vast reserve replaced the old serf army based on a
25-year service.
· The Prussian army acted as a model for the new Russian army.
· Economic reforms attempted to stabilise the currency and
encourage foreign investments.
· The Russo-Turkish war of 1877-78 revealed the limitations of the
new armies and caused a financial crisis and a loss of foreign
confidence.
Titel: nov 7-17:56 (Sida 17 av 65)
REFORMPOLICYAlexander II assembled the diet in 1863 which resulted inn a period of
development and reforms.· The Dietreform of 1869
-The diet had to assemble every 5, later every 3 year.
-Expanded representation-Expanded powers
REFORMS IN FINLAND
Titel: nov 9-19:29 (Sida 18 av 65)
THE INDUSTRIALIZATION OF FINLAND.Background;
· the industrial revolution, late 18:th century (Britain, Belgium, Sweden)
· liberalism of AlexanderII
Titel: nov 9-19:31 (Sida 19 av 65)
The industrial breakthrough didn't take place before the 1860's. The transition was quite slow and concerned almost
only the woodworking industry.
FORESTRY· Watermills (16:th century)· Tarproduction, the most important
product of export· Steampower, restricted until 1857
due to fear of efficiency· Paperproduction, 1842 (Frenckell)· Saima channel (1856)· Industrial towns, Kemi, Kotka· Government of forestry 1859· Worldexhibitions from 1867,
exhibition of industry and art in Helsinki 1876
The Finnish pavillion in Paris 1900. Gesellius, Lindgren and
Saarinen.
Titel: nov 9-19:34 (Sida 20 av 65)
THE RAILWAY· Helsinki-Hämeenlinna 1862· Riihimäki-St:Petersburg 1870· Trackwidth-russian
Titel: nov 9-19:35 (Sida 21 av 65)
ECONOMIC REFORMS· Right to take initiative in legislative
matters 1886· Decentrilisation, the cities and
municipilities received most of the clerical duties (education, healthcare, infra structure) but also the right of
taxation· The language reform(1863) -
Finnish an official language within 20 years.
· Stock companies (1864)· Law of free enterprice - the right to
buy/sell everywhere (1879)· Law of banks (1864)
-made it possible to start bankingactivity. Necessary to
acumulate investments.· The Finnish National Bank
-National currency 1860
Suomen Pankki (The central Bank) headquarters,
built 1882.
Titel: nov 9-19:36 (Sida 22 av 65)
Lev Bronstein, or Trotskij before the founding the
socialist party, when he was considered a Narodnik.
Titel: nov 7-18:00 (Sida 23 av 65)
Birth of Revolution: From this conflict in rural society, Russia's
first revolutionary organisation formed in the 1860s: the
Narodniks . These groups were mostly made up of students
without a clear direction, save to overthrow the monarchy and
landlords, and distribute land among the peasantry. In the spring
of 1874, the conflict between the kulaks and peasantry brought
turbulence to Russia's urban centres, and the Narodniks left the
cities for the villages, going "among the people" (hence their
name), attempting to "teach" the peasantry to revolt under their
guidance. They found almost no support.
The policefile of Stalin
Titel: nov 8-1:41 PM (Sida 24 av 65)
The Tsarist police (Okhrana) responded to the movement with steeled
repression: political action was not an option for the "emancipated"
peasantry. Revolutionaries and peasant sympathisers were beaten,
imprisoned or exiled to Siberia. As peasants were arrest and exiled or
imprisoned, kulaks gained their land, putting the peasant communes under
increasingly heavy burdens. In 1877, the Narodniks came to their height
with thousands of revolutionaries and peasants in support. The movement
was again brutally crushed.
Responding to brutal repression of the open, spontaneous forms of
organisation thereto taken, Russia's first organised revolutionary party
formed: People's Will ( Narodnaia Volia ), with a new revolutionary
programme: terrorism.
[...] Terrorism would be incorporated into the tactics of the Socialist-
Revolutionary Party after the People's Will was dissolved in the early 1880s,
and used throughout the following 40 years against the Monarchy and later
the Soviet government
Titel: nov 8-1:41 PM (Sida 25 av 65)
Opposition against Alexander II
THE DIVISION OF OPPOSITION
· The division probably preserved the autocracy until
1905.
· The only uniting element was the opposition against
the regime.
· Socially, geografically, economically divided.
· 'Divide and rule'.
Titel: nov 7-18:02 (Sida 26 av 65)
Execution of terrorists after the assassination
of Alexander II.
Titel: nov 7-18:03 (Sida 27 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-18:04 (Sida 28 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-18:07 (Sida 29 av 65)
· Serfdom vanished but the Russian agricultural traditions remained.
· The Mir (commune) based on collective farming and common
desicions.
· The payments restricted the individual enterprise of the peasants.
· Productivity and investment were low, famines a constant threat.
The situation of the Russian liberated serfs was very
much like the liberated american slaves in the USA
after the civil war.
Titel: nov 7-18:11 (Sida 30 av 65)
PROBLEMS· The former Serfs bound by high taxes, low incomes and the annual payments to the former
owners.· This hindered investments which would have been needed to modernize the farming.· The peasants were also hindered by the MIR (villagecommunity);· No chance to decide waht, when and how to farm (collective decisions). The Mir a collection of
households, not individuals.· Movement restricted by a passport system. This stopped the industrial development as it
hindered migration and therefore urbanisation.
Titel: nov 7-18:21 (Sida 31 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-18:26 (Sida 32 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-18:27 (Sida 33 av 65)
Titel: nov 7-18:28 (Sida 34 av 65)
1877
The Russo-Turkish War of 1877-78 brought an economic recession which
inflated the roubles and strengthened the central control of Russia's
economy.
Titel: nov 7-19:14 (Sida 35 av 65)
THE SITUATION FACING ALEXANDER III IN 1881
DEVELOPMENT SINCE 1855· Serfdom abolished· The Zemstvos offered consultation
and political experience.· Financial reforms and a Public budget· Judicial independence and trial by jury
indtroduced· Military reforms, conscription
NO CHANGES SINCE 1855
· Autocracy dominated
· The powers of the traditional
institutions like nobility and church
as strong as ever.
· Vaste estates dominated the
agricultural sector.
· The rich got richer and the poor
poorer
· Tradition and conservatism
dominated, liberalism weak.
Titel: nov 10-19:19 (Sida 36 av 65)
Titel: nov 10-19:21 (Sida 37 av 65)
Alexander's dilemma:
· Wanted a traditional Russia; no opposition, strict
control over peasant communities, no democracy BUT· No return back to a pre-industrial past. Russia needed to be a great
power. Towns, industries and communications had to grow AND· With growth came dangers as new ideas, which easily spread with
efficient means of communication.
The Borki train disaster occurred on October 29
[O.S. October 17] 1888 when the imperial train
carrying Tsar Alexander III of Russia and his
family from Crimea to Saint Petersburg derailed
at high speed. Twenty-one people died at the
scene and two later. According to the official
version of events, Alexander held the collapsed
roof of the royal car on his shoulders while his
family escaped the crash site uninjured.
Alexander's death 1894 has partly been blamed
on the injuries he received in the accident.
Titel: nov 10-19:21 (Sida 38 av 65)
SIMILARITIES OF THE REIGNS OF ALEXANDER II AND ALEXANDER III
· Both believed in autocracy but had different strategies to preserve it; A II
by moderate reform, A III by repression.
· Neither was consistent; The reforms of II were restricted while A III
didn't entirely abandon concession and reform.
· Both keen imperialists and expanded the Empire.
· Both encouraged economic and military development and neither really
came to terms with the possible concequences.
Titel: nov 10-19:22 (Sida 39 av 65)
IMPROVEMENTS OF ALEXANDER III· Peasant payments to the State were reduced.· A peasant land bank was established, capital for improving
investements.· Some taxes abolished· Working conditions for women and children regulated (the idea
from Bismarck's Germany).· The first collection of Russian art founded.
The State Tretyakov Gallery is the national treasury of Russian fine art and one of the greatest museums in the world. The Gallery's collection consists entirely of Russian art and
artists who have made а contribution to the history of Russian art or been closely
connected with it. The collection contains more than 150 000 works of painting, sculpture and graphics, created throughout the centuries by successive generations of Russian
artists.
Titel: nov 10-19:23 (Sida 40 av 65)
SETBACKS· Anti-semitism ('Let us never forget that it was the Jews who crucified
Jesus.' Banned from education and harrassed - emigration.· Russification - ethnic minorities threatened and rights restricted.· Press-cencorship· Control of the peasants increased by the appointments of land
captains and giving the landlords more powers.· Increase of closed trials for political offences (terrorism)· The powers of the Zemstvos reduced· Religious tolerance reduced· Universities under stricter control.
Titel: nov 10-19:24 (Sida 41 av 65)
Titel: nov 10-19:25 (Sida 42 av 65)
OPPOSITION, 1881 - 1905
· Marxist ideas resulted in the establishment of different socialis
groups; Thr Socialist Revolutionary Party 1900, Mensheviks and
Bolsheviks.
· The political oppositional groups often quite small, led from abroad
and divided on matters as use of violence.
· Russification resulted in growing nationalism and opposition.
· Industrialisation awoke urban opposition in the industrial centres
E Schauman and Bobrikoff
Lenin
Titel: nov 10-19:28 (Sida 43 av 65)
Titel: nov 10-19:32 (Sida 44 av 65)
Titel: nov 10-19:32 (Sida 45 av 65)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvTRh9C2GxY&feature=related
Rasputin, pt 2/3http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxAUQnh8-4o&feature=related
Rasputin pt 3/3
Russian cartoon, showing how
Rasputin dominated the
Russian court in 1916.
Titel: nov 10-19:33 (Sida 46 av 65)
CHANGE OF RUSSIAN POLICY · 'The armed peace'· Growing German threat (1890)· Imperialism· Balkan-'the powder keg of Europe'· Russian nationalism· Growing opposition in Russia
Titel: nov 14-21:09 (Sida 47 av 65)
THE FIRST RUSSIFICATION PERIOD
The intention was to weed out the elements of "Finnish separatism" by
depriving the country of its special status and absorbing it into the Empire.
· Nikolaj II appointed the passionately pro-Russian General Nikolay
Bobrikov as Governor-General of Finland in 1898.
· Bobrikov's first move was to merg the Finnish military with the Russian
army.
· When this run into problems the russification started (The February
Manifesto 1899)
· Adoption of the Russian languaga for use in the senate, government
offices and schools, the opening of all official posts in Finland to Russian
citizens, and extension of the legal code of the Russian Empire to the
Grand Duchy.
Titel: nov 14-21:10 (Sida 48 av 65)
The Tsar issued a decree on the 15th February 1899 which the Finns saw as an
attempt to seize power from the Diet.
With the Febrarymanifesto the Russian Tsar and Duma gained the powers to the
legislation of so called nation-wide laws and it was the Tsar who had the powers
to decide which laws were to be interpreted as nation wide ones.
The Februarymanifesto gave rise to a vast outcry. At the beginning majority of
the Finns thought that the Grand Dutch had been fooled and the Finns raised a
Great Petition (with more than ½ million names of a population on 2 million). The
petition was submitted to the Tsar but he refused to accept accept it. The same
happened to the Cultural petition.
Titel: nov 14-21:15 (Sida 49 av 65)
THE DIVISION OF
THE POPULATION
THE 'CONCILIATION LINE'· Advocated tactical collaboration with
Russia and wished of returned autonomy as a reward of good
behaviour
THE CONSTITUTIONALISTS· Urged resistance (legal) to
Russification measures· The 'Kagaal'· Boycott of conscription call-ups
ACTIVISM· As russification became harsher with
Bobrikovs dictatorial powers 1903 and Cossack riots in Helsinki 1902 a group
of radicals advocating violent resistance emerged (Nationalists and
socialists)
Titel: nov 14-21:15 (Sida 50 av 65)
1900 - Through a postmanifesto Finland lost its own national stamps.
A languagemanifesto introduced Russian as administrative language in
higher offices and the teachinglessons in Russian in the schools increased.
Censorship was tightened and newspapers and magazines were forced to
close.
1901 - Through the conscriptionlaw the Finnish army was dissolved and
military service in the Russian army became compulsory (passive
resistance and increased emigration).
1903 - Bobrikov received dictatorial powers.
Titel: nov 14-21:16 (Sida 51 av 65)
1904 - Bobrikov assassinated by Eugen Schauman.
1904-05 - The Russo-Japanese war.
The Russian defeat in the War resulted in the first revolutionary attempt in
Russia. After the Bloody Sunday a general strike spread throughout Russia
and to Finland were it became a protestmovement against the oppressive
policies.
During the year of 1904 the political situation changed drastically in
Finland. The unrest and opposition increased. Russia dragged itself into a
war with Japan and Bobrikov was assassinated by Schauman.
Titel: nov 14-21:16 (Sida 52 av 65)
The Parliamentary reform 1906
This represented a major step towards democratization of the Finnish
society. ● The outdated concept of the four estates was replaced with a unicameral Parliament
with 200 members elected for 3 years.
● Suffrage was universal and equal and the minimum voting age was set at 24 years.
● The elections were secret and proportional (d'Hondt's principles)
The outcome of this reform was that Finland developed a modern style partysystem in
which the existing parties were joined by the Swedish People's Party and the Agrarian
Party.
Titel: nov 14-21:18 (Sida 53 av 65)
REPRESSION· Extension of police powers
· Censorship
· Limitation of peasant freedom
· Modification of the freedom of the zemstvos and municipal dumas-the power of
the wealthier classes increased.· Russification
Titel: dec 2-20:25 (Sida 54 av 65)
INDUSTRIAL EXPANSION· Between 1893-1900 the industrial output doubled
· Foreign investments (France after 1890)
· S Witte increased state investments in industrial projects.
· Railway expansion of astronomous dimensions
PROBLEMS· Agricultural stagnation and poverty
· Industrial proletariat living in appalling conditions
· A population growth (74-133, 1860-1900)
Titel: dec 2-20:26 (Sida 55 av 65)
'Repression and reaction were the particular marks of the rule of
the last Tsar, Nicholas II'. Discuss the validity of this verdict on his
reign to 1914.
Titel: nov 17-17:12 (Sida 56 av 65)
To what extent the system caused its own downfall.Nicholas II was in favour of preserving the Tsarist state intact as he had inherited it, he
was prepared to repress any attempt to undermine the autocracyThe role of his advisers
The family tragedy with Michael (hemophelia), the Tsarina and Rasputin.Nicholas wasn't prepared to take over as a ruler when he had to.
The Russo-Japanese war 1904-05The Bloody Sunday, the greatest act of repressive stateterrorism on the own
people.
Titel: nov 18-14:20 (Sida 57 av 65)
But at least after 1905 one can easily find arguments against the statement as well:The democratic reforms which Nicholas was forced to carry out after the revolution of 1905 -
universal male suffrage, the elected Dumas, the returned rights of the ethnic minoroties.The reform policy of Witte and Stolypin - boosted the economic development.
The impact of the Great War
Titel: nov 18-14:25 (Sida 58 av 65)
If Russia wouldn’t have been pulled in to the Great War would the system
have survived. It wasn’t the strength and unity of the opposition which
brought the downfall it was the defeats in the war and the unpopularity of
the imperial house. Without a war there would probably not have been any
revolution.
Titel: nov 18-14:28 (Sida 59 av 65)
How extensive and how effective in promoting change was the
opposition to the Tsarist system in Russia from c. 1881 to 1914?
Titel: nov 17-17:12 (Sida 60 av 65)
Define ‘opposition’The opposition which brought the downfall wasn’t organised, united or planned. The Russo-Japanese war 1904-05 had already clearly warned the rulers that a major conflict with defeat
could shake the existing powerstructure of Russia.Opposition to the Tsar:
a. Political groupsSocialists - divided in
- Social Revolutionaries- Mensjeviks- Bolsjeviks- Anarchists
- Liberals
- Cadets
Titel: nov 18-14:34 (Sida 61 av 65)
b. Non-political groups -The farmers
-The industrial workers -The Bourgeois
-The landless peasants -The poor Nobility -The poor priests
-The ethnic minorities
Titel: nov 18-14:43 (Sida 62 av 65)
Most groups divided and unorganised. The political parties often small and with
minimal resources to premote any change in practice. The secret police
controlled most of the political groups. E.g. the socialists party which was
founded in London and of which most leaders were forced to imprisonment or
or activity in exile.
The non-political groups were only united by their opposition towards the
existing order or part of the rule carried out e.g. the russification policy.
Titel: nov 18-14:48 (Sida 63 av 65)
THE EVENTS 1904-1905The Russo-Japanese war and the Bloody Sunday had an enormous impact as these proved that the Empire could tremble. The events resulted in spontaneous protests so big that they paralysed the regime. The successes of the opposition weren’t longlasting
as the oppositional groups were so divided but e.g. the events in Finland were revolutionary. All oppositional elements had been given a proof of possible change but this needed a major crises in which Russia was part of. When the First World War started this was the signal many of the oppositional elements had been waiting for.
Titel: nov 18-14:52 (Sida 64 av 65)
Conclusion: Most of the oppositional groups were unsuccessful in promoting lasting change in Russia but those who aimed in replacing the old powerstructure with a new one would be successful. In the struggle againt the russification policy the successes of 1905-06 showed the non-russian elements that unity existed and change was possible.The only political groups which promoted change from within were the quite conservative
cadets and ‘Octobrists’. These parties had minor successes in reforming e.g. the economic legislation of Russia (wexsternisation).
Titel: nov 18-14:56 (Sida 65 av 65)