Download - ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN
![Page 1: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Sworn Affidavit by Chief Investigator Michael Zullo for AZ Sheriff Arpaio's Cold Case Posse Reporting that Obama's Long Form Birth Certificate and Draft Registration Card are Forgeries
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 2: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 3: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
3
. SheriffJosephM.ArpaiobecameSheriffin1992andhasbeenreelectedtoan
unprecedentedsixthterminoffice.Hebeganhiscareerasafederalnarcotics
agentinfiltratingdrugorganizationsfromTurkeytotheMiddleEastto
Mexico,Central,andSouthAmericatocitiesaroundtheU.S.
4. Hisexpertiseandsuccessledhimtotopmanagementpositionsaroundthe
worldwiththeU.S.DrugEnforcementAdministration(DEA).Heconcluded
hisremarkablefederalcareerasheadoftheDEAforArizona.Arpaiohasover
ment.fivedecadesexperienceinlawenforce
5. TheMaricopaCountyColdCasePosse
6. UndertheArizonaConstitutionandArizonaRevisedStatutes,theelected
SheriffofMaricopaCountyhastheauthoritytorequestassistancefroma
volunteerpossetoassisttheSheriffintheexecutionofhisduties,working
underlawenforcementauthorityoftheMaricopaCountySheriff.
7. UponactivationbytheMaricopaCountySheriff,certifiedPossemembersare
empoweredtoactasiftheSheriffhimselfwerepresentwhencalleduponto
doso.PossemembersoftheMCSOaredelegatedtheirlawenforcement
authoritybytheMaricopaCountySheriff.
8. UnderthatactivationSheriffArpaiograntedfullylawenforcementauthority
oftheMaricopaCountySheriff’sOfficetoconductthisinvestigationandto
reportbacktotheSheriffourfindingsforhisultimatedispensation.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 4: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
9
4
. InOctoberof2006,SheriffArpaioorderedthecreationoftheMCSOColdCase
Posse(CCP).AthispersonalrequestIacceptedappointmentascommander
ofthisunit.Ihaveservedinthiscapacityforthelastsevenyears.
10. ThepurposeoftheCCPwastoassistMaricopaCountySheriff’sOfficein
investigationsincludingactiveandColdCaseHomicides.Sinceitsinception,
theCCPhasbeenplacedundertheguidanceandcontrolofTheGeneral
InvestigationDivision.
11. TheMCSOColdCasePosseconsistsofhandselectedindividualswithdiverse
skillsconsistingofprofessionalexperiencesinconductinginvestigations,
includingindividualswithbackgroundsinLawEnforcement,Insurance
FraudInvestigations,MilitaryService,Physicians,ComputerInformation
Systems,CorporateCEO’s,aswellasattorneyswhohaveparticipatedin
criminalandorcivillitigation.
12. SheriffArpaioreferredthecomplainttohisColdCasePosse,directingmyself
asLeadInvestigatortoreviewtheevidence,todeterminewhetherandto
whatextentthecomplainthadmerit,toinvestigatefurtherinduecourseas
necessary,andtoreportdirectlytoSheriffArpaio.
13. Afive‐memberteamofexperiencedinvestigatorswasexpresslyselected.It
includedformerpolicedetectivesandattorneys(whomhavereceived
additionalinvestigationaltrainingbyMaricopaCountySheriff’sOffice)who
workedvoluntarilyandatvirtuallynoexpensetothetaxpayer.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 5: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
InvestigationoftheComplaint
14. SheriffArpaioreferredthecomplainttohisColdCasePosse,directingmyself
asLeadInvestigatortoreviewtheevidence,andtodeterminewhetherandto
whatextentthecomplainthadmerit.Weweretoinvestigatefurtheras
necessary,andreporttoSheriffArpaio.SheriffArpaioexpressedthatitwas
hisgoaltoclearthedocumentasauthenticandmovethecountryforward.He
alsorequiredthattheinvestigationbethoroughandabsentofanypolitical
ideologies,andthatitbeperformedwiththeutmostcareanddiligence.
15. AttheSheriff’sdirection,theprincipalfocusoftheinvestigationwasthe
electronicdocumentorcomputerimageontheWhiteHousewebsitethat
PresidentObamahadpresentedasanauthenticimageofhislong‐formbirth
certificatetotheAmericanpeopleandtocitizensofMaricopaCountyata
WhiteHousepressconferenceonApril27,2011,whenhehadsaid,“We
providedadditionalinformationtodayaboutthesiteofmybirth...yes,infact,
IwasborninHawaii,August4,1961,inKapiolaniHospital.”
16. Theinvestigatorswerealsodirectedtoreviewallbackground
documentationprovidedbythepetitionersinrelationtotheircomplaint,and
toconsiderallotherinformationobtainedordevelopedduringthenormal
courseoftheinvestigation.
17. ThepetitionerssuggestedthattheSheriff’sOfficeshouldstartbycontacting
Dr.JeromeCorsi,aninvestigativejournalistwhohadwrittenabookinsearch
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 6: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
ofMr.Obama’soriginalbirthcertificatedocumentandhadamasseda
substantialbodyofevidence.Dr.JeromeCorsiwasunknowntothe
investigatorspriortothisinvestigation.Subsequently,wespent16hours
interviewingDr.Corsi,whoagreedtoturnovertousforreviewallofthe
6
informationhehadonfile.
18. AttheconclusionofDr.Corsi’sinterviewIdeterminedthatDr.Corsi’swork,
(withtheexceptionofacopyofthedownloaded.pdffilereleasedbythe
WhiteHouseonApril27,2011)wastobetreatedas“investigational
information”onlyandnottobeconsideredasevidence.
19. Thebasisforthisdecisionwasdueinparttothefactthatsomeofthe
informationpresentedbyDr.Corsiwasacompilationofresearchperformed
byotherindividuals.InadditionDr.Corsiwasincommunicationwiththese
individualspriortomeetingwithusandtheseindividualswereyetunknown
toourinvestigators.
20. TopreservetheindependenceandintegrityofourinvestigationDr.Corsi’s
informationwouldbeutilizedasinvestigativebackgroundinformationonly.
Dr.Corsiworkedcloselywithourinvestigationasaninformationalsource
untilJuly2012.
21. Dr.Corsisuggestedthatweshouldcontactanationallyrecognizedcomputer
expert,MaraZebest,whohasservedasacontributingauthorandtechnical
editorformorethan100booksonAdobeandMicrosoftsoftware.Ms.Zebest
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 7: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
wascontactedandinvitedtoparticipateinatwo‐dayinvestigationalmeeting,
towhichweinvitedfiveotherparticipants:investigators,attorneys,and
professionalsincomputerizedgraphicdesign,ITprofessionals,anda
physician.NonehadanypriorfamiliaritywiththeWhiteHousecomputer
7
imagedocument.
22. Duringthatmeeting,allaspectsofthedocumentwereexaminedwiththe
intentionofattemptingtodisprovetheallegationthatthedocumenthadbeen
fabricated.Thisincludedareviewoftheworkofanauthorbythenameof
JohnWoodman.JohnWoodman,astruggling,self‐describedcomputerexpert,
hadauthoredabookputtingforthexplanationsonhowcomputersoftware
automaticallycausedtheanomaliescontainedintheWhiteHousedocument.
Mr.Woodman’sworkhadbeencitedvigorouslybynumerousmediaoutlets
attemptingtodisqualifyallegationssuggestingthatthe.pdfdocumentoffered
byMr.Obamawasanythingbutauthentic.
23. ThetheoriessetforthinMr.Woodman'sbookwerethoroughlytestedby
investigatorsandfoundtobenothingmorethanpurespeculationand
supposition.TheinvestigatorsconcludedMr.Woodman'sworkwasnothing
morethanconjecturewithoutanyevidentiaryproofthathistheoriescouldbe
supported.
24. Wheninvestigatorsputhistheoriesintopracticalapplication,theycouldnot
successfullyreproduceanyoftheanomaliesfoundintheWhiteHouse
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 8: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
documentbyautomatedcomputerizedprocess.ThereforeMr.Woodman's
8
workwasdismissedasirrelevantandofferingzeroevidentiaryvalue.
25. Attheendofthetwo‐dayevent,allinvestigationalinformationconcerning
the.pdffilewaspresentedwasintenselytestedanddeliberated.
26. AllinattendanceagreedunanimouslythattheWhiteHousecomputerimage
.pdffilecontainedanomaliesthatwereunexplainableunlessthedocument
hadbeenfabricatedpiecemealbyhumanintervention,ratherthanbeing
copiedfromagenuinepaperdocument.Thisconclusionalsoservedto
contradicttheallegedchainofeventssurroundingtheproductionofthe
document,asputforthbytheWhiteHouseandtheHawaiiDepartmentof
Health.
27. InvestigationalfindingsthusfarwerereportedbacktoSheriffArpaio.Having
informedSheriffArpaiothatthedocumentappearedtobeafabricated
forgeryandthatviolationofArizonacriminalstatutesandfederalstatutes
mayhavetakenplace,itwouldbeessentialtocontinuetheinvestigation.
SheriffArpaioagreedandinvestigatorsbegantopursuefurtherinvestigation
ofthe.pdffileandrelatedeventssurroundingthecreationofthedocument.
28. Thisservesasanoutlineofourwork,preliminaryresults,andpreliminary
conclusionstodate.Asofthedateofthisreport,thisinvestigationremains
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 9: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
openandongoingandadditionalforensicevidencecontinuestobeuncovered
9
furthervalidatingtheoriginalinvestigationalfindings.
29. InvestigatorsstudiedMr.Obama’s“short‐form”Hawaiianbirthcertificate
thatbecamepublicin2008;the“long‐form”certificateendorsedbyMr.
ObamaataWhiteHousepressconferenceonApril27,2011,andthenposted
asanelectroniccomputerimageatwww.whitehouse.gov(nophysical
documentwasproduced);andtheselectiveserviceregistrationcardallegedly
signedbyMr.ObamaonJuly30,1980.
30. Weinterviewedseveralpersons,consultedmanyexperts,testedand
evaluatedcomputerevidenceusingrelatedsoftware.Inearlyin2012,I
informedSheriffArpaioofourpreliminaryfindings.Ireportedthatafter
extensiveexaminationoftheelectronicdocument,thecomputerimage
releasedbytheWhiteHouseonApril27,2011,andexaminationofMr.
Obama’sSelectiveServiceregistrationcard,thatwebelievedtherewas
probablecausetosuspectMr.Obama’sidentitydocumentswerein‐fact
forged.
31. TheSheriffheldapressconferenceonMarch1,2012,toannouncethe
findingsthatinvestigatorshadconcludedthatthedocumentreleasedonApril
27,2011,bytheWhiteHouseofMr.Obama’slongformbirthcertificatewasa
computergeneratedfraudcreatedexclusivelybyhumaninterventionandnot
bytheactionsofrandomcomputerization.Thepressconferenceservedto
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 10: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
attractfurtherevidence,andtogiveusanopportunitytopresentanoutlineof
10
ourreasons.
32. OnMarch1,2012,SheriffArpaioheldapressconferenceduringwhichhe
andIpresentedanoutlineofthoseaspectsoftheinvestigationthatwouldnot
compromisethesafetyofwitnessesortheintegrityandfuturecourseofthe
investigation.
33. Atthattime,weannouncedthatwehadconcludedthattherewasprobable
causethatforgeryandfraudhadbeencommittedinrespectoftwo
documents:1)thelong‐formororiginalbirthcertificatecomputerimage
presentedbyMr.,Obama,whichcontainedmultipleerrorsandanomalies,
manyofthemseriousand:2)theselective‐servicedocumentforMr.Obama,
whichcontainedatwo‐digityear‐stamp.Thiswascontrarytospecifications
issuedbyfederalregulationtotheeffectthattheyearofissueshouldbe
expressedasfourdigitsonthestamp,andalsocontrarytoanyother
selective‐serviceregistrationdocumentthatwehadbeenabletoexamine.
34. IvisitedHawaiitwiceandcontinuedourinvestigation.Afterfurtherin‐depth
computerizedtestinganddiscoveringadditionalinformation,weconcluded
inmid‐2012thatMr.Obama’sidentitydocumentswerenotonlyforged
beyondthelegalstandardofprobablecause,butduetoloopholesinthestate
ofHawaii’svitalstatisticsreportinglaws,therewasthedistinctevidence
suggestingthatHawaii’sstatutesappearedtobeinconflictwithfederal
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 11: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
immigrationlawandposedanindependentthreattothenationalsecurityof
11
theUnitedStates.
SheriffArpaio’sPressConferenceonJuly17,2012
35. Afterthreemonthsoffurtherinvestigation,theSheriffheldasecondpress
conferencetoannounce,withmysupport,thattherewasnolongeraquestion
ofmeresuspicionbutthatofprobablecause.Itwasnowdemonstrated
beyondprobablecausethatthedocumentpresentedtothepublicbyMr.
ObamaandplacedontheWhiteHousewebsitewasanutterforgery.
36. Inaddition,SheriffArpaioreportedconcernsthatHawaii’sstatutesappeared
tobeinconflictwithfederalimmigrationlawandthebirthregistrationpolicy
inHawaiiposedathreattonationalsecurity.
37. SheriffArpaiostatedatbothpressconferencesthatwearenotinaposition
toconcludeeitherthatMr.Obamahimselfhascommittedanyoffenseorthat
hewasbornoutsidetheUnitedStates,northatheisconstitutionally
ineligibletoseekorholdtheofficeofPresidentoftheUnitedStates.
38. However,thefactthatmostifnotalloftheidentitydocumentsareforged
supportsthecomplainant’sallegationthatMr.Obama,inendorsingand
postingaforgedbirthcertificateimageontheWhiteHousewebsite,has
raisedlegitimatequestionsthatshouldnowbeinvestigatedbyCongress.
39. SheriffArpaioalsoannouncedthattheinvestigationwouldcontinue,andit
hascontinuedeversince.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 12: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
TheOngoingInvestigation
40. Astheinvestigationcontinued,variousnationalandlocalmediaattemptedto
disqualifytheinvestigativefindingsbyfosteringalternativeexplanationsfor
thedocumentsirregularities.Opponentsmadenothingmorethan
superficialexplanationsallegingthattheObamadocumentsirregularities
weresimplycausedbynothingmorethantheautomationprocessesof
computersoftware.However,themediafailedtoputforthanyinvestigative
evidencetovalidatetheirtheories,whichweresoundlydefeatedbyover
ors.1,200independentcomputersoftwaretestsconductedbyinvestigat
41. Investigatorswantedtodeterminetheprobabilitythatadocument
containingtheplethoraofirregularitiesasfoundinthecomputerimage
Obamapresentedcouldstillbegenuine.
42. Takingitastepfurther,investigatorssoughtanindependentauthorityon
forensicdocumentexaminationthathadnopreviousconnectionwithour
inquiry.Investigatorscommissionedacourtcertifiedhandwritinganalyst
andforensicdocumentexaminerwithover20yearsofexperienceproviding
documentexpertisetolegalandlawenforcementcommunities,corporations,
financialinstitutionsandprivateindividualsforthistask.
43. Investigatorsrequestedanindependentreviewofourfindingsinrespectto
thelong‐formbirthcertificateimagethatfellwithinhisfieldofexpertise.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 13: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
44
13
. Upontheconclusionofourexpert’sexaminationheissuedanindependent
40pageforensicreportinwhichheverifiedourinvestigationalfindingand
validatingconclusioninfullagreementwiththefindsofinvestigators.He
concluded:
x “…basedonmyobservationsandfindings,itisclearthatCertificateofLiveBirthIexaminedisnotascanofanoriginalpaperbirthcertificate,utadigitallymanufactureddocumentedcreatedbyutilizingmaterialbfromvarioussources.”and
x “Inover20yearsofexaminingdocumentationofvarioustypes,Ihaveeverseenadocumentthatissoseriouslyquestionableinsomany
abricated.”nrespects.Inmyopinion,thebirthcertificateisentirelyf
AuthenticityofWhiteHouseReleasedBirthCertificateImage
45. Investigatorshavedeterminedbeyondprobablecausethatthecomputer
imagereleasedonApril27,2011bytheWhiteHouse,andpurportingtobea
truecomputercopyofMr.Obama’slongformbirthcertificate,isnotascanof
anoriginalhardcopydocument.Itis,infact,anundeniablecomputer
generatedforgerycreatedwiththesoleintenttodeceivethepublicby
commissionoffeloniousfraudulentacts.
46. SheriffArpaio’sinvestigatorshavedeterminedthedocument(the.pdffile
releasedbytheWhiteHouse)wascreatedentirelybyhumanintervention,
andnotbytheactionsofrandomcomputerization.Assuch,theWhitehouse
computerimagecannotberelieduponasbonafidefactualrecordofthebirth
eventthatitattemptstodepict.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 14: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
47
14
. Ourinvestigationhasalsoconcludedthatthemethodusedtofabricatethe
documentwasbymeansofhumanlogicandthedistinctmanualplacement
anddistributionofelectronicdatabetweenninedistinctcomputergenerated
“layers”.Thistypeoflayeringisentirelyuncharacteristicofapaperdocument
that,whenscanned,resultsinasimple,digitized,singlelayerphotographic
image.
48. Investigatorsinparticularfocusedontheregistrarstampbearingthe
signatureofHawaiiStatesRegistrarDr.AlvinT.Onaka.Thisstampwasfound
tobecomprisedofexternalobjectsthatwereimportedintothedocument,
createduniquelyfortheforgeryoftheObamabirthdocument,byan
intentionallydeceptivecut‐and‐pasteprocess.Thisfactaloneissufficientto
rendertheentiredocumentvoidofanyprobativevalue.
49. Ourinvestigationalfindingssoundlydefeatedtheonlytwoattempted
explanationsoftheanomaliesonthecomputergeneratedlong‐formbirth
certificateimageofferedforjustification:OCR(OpticalCharacter
Recognition)and/orOptimization(Compressionofthefilesinorderto
reducethefilesize).Investigatorsattemptedtorecreatetheanomaliesfound
inthecomputergeneratedimagebytediousimplementationofthesome
1200computerizedtests,andwereunabletorecreatetheanomalies
containedintheWhiteHouse.pdffile.Investigatorsclearlydemonstrated
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 15: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
thatneithercouldaccountforthemyriaddiscrepanciesfoundintheWhite
15
Houseimage.
50. Subsequently,thisissupportedbyanindependentexpertforensic
examinationconfirmedtheelectroniccomputerimageofBarackObama’s
longformCertificateofLiveBirth,releasedbytheWhiteHouseonApril27,
2011,isinfactaforgery,thussupportingtheinitialfindingsofour
investigation.
51. ThereforeMr.Obamahasinfactnotofferedanyverifiableauthoritative
documentofanylegalsignificanceorpossessinganyevidentiaryvalueasto
theoriginsofhispurportedbirthnarrativeorlocationofthebirthevent.
52. InadditioninvestigatorshavedeterminedthattheWhiteHouse.pdffile
displayingamanufacturedimageofMr.ObamaspurportedHawaiianbirth
certificatecouldnotsurvivejudicialscrutinyorbeofferedasdocumented
evidence,certifiedbytheStateofHawaii,asproofattestingtotheeventand
thereforecouldnotbeacceptedassuchinanyjudicialproceeding.
53. Assuch,thiscomputermanipulatedfraudulentimagecannotbedeemedas
acceptablelegalevidenceforthepurposeofvalidationorverificationof
identityorcitizenship,orserveasverificationofabirtheventbyany
SecretaryofStateintheconfinesoftheUnitedStates.
54. Mr.Obamahasnotreleasedanyevidenceotherthanamanufactured
computerforgerybyhumaninterventionanddesigninanefforttosupport
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 16: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
hisclaimofhisbirthtakingplaceatKapiolaniHospital,Honolulu,Hawaiion
16
August4,1961.
55. Additionally,HawaiiStateStatuesandHawaiiDepartmentofHealthpolicy
donotauthorizetheHawaiiDepartmentofHealthtocreateacomputer
generated.pdffileasanofficiallycertifieddocumentseveringasaverification
ofalivebirthevent.
56. Theverycreationthis.pdffilerunsindirectconflictwiththeHawaii
DepartmentofHealth’sownadmissiondeclaringtheyreleasedtwopaper
copiesofa“BirthDocument”tothePresident’sattorneyPerkinsCoiepartner
JudithCorleyonApril25,2011.
57. AccordingtocopiesoflettersreleasedbyWhiteHouseofficials,JudithCorley
initiatedtheprocessandtraveledtoHawaiitopickuptwophotocopiesof
Mr.Obama’slongformbirthcertificate,notanelectronic.pdffile.Thetwo
copiesreleasedtoJudithCorleyhaveneverbeenmadepublic.
58. Investigatorshavealsodeterminedthatthemuchtouted1961newspaper
announcementsareinfactutterlyunreliableasevidencetosupport
verificationoftheeventasdepictedinthe.pdfimageofthemanufactured
birthcertificatereleasedbytheWhiteHouseandattestedtomyMr.Obama.
Inadditiontheaforementionedannouncementscanbeofnosubstitutefora
HawaiiStateOfficialBirthCertificationandorCertificate.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 17: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
59
17
. Insummation,investigatorsbelievethatthecomputerimagepresentedby
theWhiteHouseisanunabashedforgery,andthuscouldnotsurviveeventhe
lowestlevelofjudicialscrutinyinanyjurisdictionintheUnitedStates,and
doesnotserveasevidenceorcertificationofanysuchevent.
60. Furthermore,itcannotbeusedasanauthenticatedlegaldocumentforproof
ofcitizenship,orprooftoobtainalegitimatepassport,orlegitimateSocial
SecurityIdentificationNumber.Itmostcertainlycannotberelieduponas
legitimateproofandverificationofalivebirtheventbytheresidentsof
MaricopaCounty,theStateOfArizona,orinanyjurisdictionwithintheUnited
States.
Arizona’sVerificationAttemptsThwarted
61. ArizonaSecretaryofStateKenBennettrequestedverificationofMr.Obama’s
birthrecordsfromtheStateofHawaiiDepartmentofHealth:
62. “PleaseverifythattheattachedcopyoftheCertificateofLiveBirthforMr.
Obamaisatrueandaccuraterepresentationoftheoriginalrecordinyour
files.”
63. However,HawaiiDepartmentofHealthStateRegistrarDr.AlvinT.Onakadid
notverifytheWhiteHousecomputerimageasatrueoraccurate
representationoftheoriginalbirthrecord,onlyresponding,“theinformation
inthecopy…thatyouattachedwithyourrequestmatchestheoriginalrecord
inourfile.”
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 18: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
64
18
. Hawaiiofficialscleverlyfocusedontherepresentationofinformation
depictedinthefraudulentimagedivertingattentiontothefoundationofthe
requestofSecretaryofStateBennett.“Pleaseverifythattheattachedcopyof
theCertificateofLiveBirthforMr.Obamaisatrueandaccurate
representationoftheoriginalrecordinyourfiles.”
65. “Information”isnotaverificationofthedocument(.pdffile)asawhole.
66. Afraudulentlycreateddocumentoftentimescontainsmatchinginformation
onsomelevelwhencomparedtosomeotherdocumentofrecord,however,
thefactthatsomeinformationmaymatchinafiledoesnotverifythe
legitimacyofthedocumentasawhole.
67. Inthiscasethe.pdfimagepresentedbytheWhiteHousetothepublic,isin
theappearanceofwhattheunsuspectingpublicwouldperceivedtobeatrue
copyofanofficialdocumentandthereforeacceptedonfacevalue.Thisalso
includesthefabricationandappearanceofgreensecuritypaperbackground
thatonewouldexpecttobeusedonsuchanofficialdocument.Thecreation
anduseofthisbackgroundwouldsolelybeusedtogivetheperceptionof
authenticityinanofficialcapacity.
68. Further,Hawaiihasnotacknowledgedthattheyevercreatedorreleasedan
electroniccomputercreated.pdffilecontaininganimageoftheBarack
HusseinObamaIIHawaiiCertificateofLiveBirthtotheWhiteHouseortothe
attorneyforBarackHusseinObamaII.Theyalsodidnotverifyhowand
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 19: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
wheninformationmayhavebeenaddedordeletedfortheoriginalfileandfor
19
whatpurpose.
69. ThePDFfilepostedontheWhiteHousewebsiteshowsnoevidenceofascan
ofaphotocopieddocumentevertakingplace,butdisplaysalltheevidenceof
amanufacturedfile.Anelectronicimageofthephotocopieddocumentasit
wouldhavebeeniftheoriginaldocumenthadbeengenuinewouldnothave
possessedtheirregularitiesintheWhiteHouse.pdffilethat,inourforensic
experts’opinion,demonstratethattheimagewaspiecedtogether
electronicallyfrommultiplesources.
70. OneofourmostseriousconcernsisthattheWhiteHousedocumentappears
tohavebeenfabricatedpiecemealonacomputer,constructedbydrawing
togetherdigitizeddatafromseveralunknownsources.
IsolationOfTheRegistrar’sSignatureAndDateStamps
71. Theregistrar’ssignaturestampandthedatestampadjacenttoiteachappear
independentlyonseparatelayersoftheelectronicimage.Furthermore,these
distinctlayerscontainnootherdataofanykind.Ourexpertshaveconsidered
thepossibilitythattheinkusedforthesetwostampsmighthavebeenofa
sufficientlydistinctcolortobedistinguishedfromallothercolorsonan
originalpaperdocumentandthusisolated.However,wehaveconcludedthat
noscanofanoriginaldocumentcouldproducesuchseparationof
individuallydistinctitemsintodistinctlayerswithnootherdataonthem.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 20: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
72
20
. Theregistrar’sstampappearstohavebeenimportedfromanotherunknown
sourcedocument.
73. Investigatorsintentlyfocusedonthefactthatthestampcannothavebeen
placedonthedocumentpursuanttostateandfederallawsasoneofmany
indicationsthatthedocumentisaforgeryand,therefore,thatitcannotbe
relieduponasverification,legalorotherwise,ofthedate,placeor
circumstancesofMr.Obama’sbirth.
74. Thedatestampnexttotheregistrar’ssignaturestampexhibitedasimilar
graveanomaly,allowingittobemovedaboutelectronicallywithinthe
document–whichwouldhavebeenimpossibleifthedocumentwerethe
scannedandcertifiedcopythatofficialstatementsprofessittobe.
75. Wewereparticularlydisturbedtofindthattheregistrar’sdateandsignature
stampscouldbepickedupandmovedaroundthedocumentatwill,leaving
behindadistinctwhitehaloimpressionofthetwostamps.
76. Onourtestdocument,withasinglelayerandasinglelink,anymanipulation
ofthiskindwasimpossible.
77. AcloseexaminationoftheStateregistrar’sstampontheelectronicimageof
Mr.Obama’sbirthcertificateshowstherearetwodifferentregistrarstamps
evidentontheelectronicimage:(1)thedatestamp,indicatingApril25,2011,
and(2)thetextandsignaturestampcontainingDr.AlvinOnaka’ssignature.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 21: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
78
21
. Bothregistrarstampsgivetheappearanceofbeenappliedbyarubberstamp
inkedfromapad.
79. Theregistrar’sdatestamp(left)andsignaturestamp(right)
80. However,ourexpertsdeterminedthattheregistrar’sstampsareexternal
objectsthatwereimportedintothedocument.Thestampswerenot
impressionscopiedwhole,butwerecreateduniquelyfortheObama
documentbyacut‐and‐pasteprocess.
81. Thewhiteareaaroundthedatestampindicatestheimageisnotascanofa
paperdocumentbutacomputer‐generatedfilefabricatedelectronically.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 22: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
82. Thattheregistrar’ssignatureanddatestampswerebothcreatedbylinksto
externalobjectsimportedintotheObamabirthcertificateisalsoconfirmed
byturningon“Links”inthe“Window”menuinAdobeIllustrator.
83. Notonlywastheregistrardatestampimportedfromanexternallink,itwas
scaledandthenrotatedclockwiseby90degreestobeplacedinthe
document:
22
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 23: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
84
23
. Theregistrar’sdate‐stampscaledandrotatedtobeplacedintheWhite
Houseimage
85. Likewise,thesignaturestampwasalsoanimportedobjectscaledandthen
rotated90degreesclockwisetobeplacedinthedocument:
86. TheRegistrar’ssignature‐stampanddate‐stampwerecomputer‐generated
imagesthatwereimportedintothedocument.Theywerenotelectronic
imagesofactualrubber‐stampimprintsinkedbyhandormachineontoa
paperdocument.Thiscanonlybeaccomplishedbyhumanlogicand
intervention.
WhiteHaloEffect
87. Furthermore,theWhiteHouseimagedisplaysawhite“haloeffect”around
theletters,suchthatthetextureofthepapercannotbeseenunderneaththe
ink,andtheimagenoiseisinconsistentthroughoutthedocument.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 24: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
88
24
. Asseenbelow,movingthetwostampsleavesthewhitehalovisible,
indicatingwherethetwoexternallinkshadinitiallybeenpastedintothe
document.
89. Registrar’sdateandsignaturestampsseparatelyrotatedandrepositionedon
theWhiteHouseimage.
90. Thefactthatthe.pdffilecontainsevidenceoftheimportationoftheOfficial
HawaiiRegistrarsStampandDatestampandthefactthattheStampscanbe
pickedupandmovedaboutthedocumentleavingawhitebackgroundofits
importedplacedlocationshouldbeevidenceenoughoftamperingbringing
theauthenticityofthedocumentcompletelyintoquestion.Thisfactalone
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 25: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
providessufficientevidenceforanycourtcertifieddocumentexaminerto
concludeandtestifytheentiredocumentisfatallyflawedandisvoidofany
25
legalauthority.
91. FraudulentBirthcertificatescreatedinWashingDC.
92. PresidentObama’sWhiteHousetechnologyczarVivekKundra,oversaw
technologyprojectsandbudgetsfor86D.C.governmentagenciesasheadof
theDistrict’sOfficeoftheChiefTechnologyOfficer.YusufAcar,thenacting
headsecurityofficerfortheD.C.OfficeoftheChiefTechnologyOfficerwas
arrestedandultimatelysentencedto27monthsinprisoninconnectionwith
abriberyscambyfederalauthoritiesin2009.
93. AssistantU.S.AttorneyThomasHibargertoldafederaljudgethatAcar,wasa
flightriskbecauseagentsseized$70,000incashinhishouseandbecausein
recordedconversations,heboastedthathecouldeasilyfleetohisnative
Turkey.Acaralsotoldaninformantthathecouldusecomputerstocreate
Hibargersaid.fakeD.C.birthcertificates,
94. InspectorGeneralReport
95. InSeptember2000,theOfficeoftheInspectorGeneraloftheU.S.Department
ofHealthandHumanServicespublishedareportonbirth‐certificatefraud,
showingthatbirthcertificateswerewidelyusedtoobtaincitizenship
fraudulently.Itfoundthatfewgovernmentofficialsweretrainedindetecting
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 26: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
fraudulentbirthcertificates.Yetthereisnofederallawspecifyinguniform
26
formorcontentforbirthcertificates.Thereportcited:
96. “Legitimatebirthcertificatesprovidevitalinformationabouttheperson
whosenameappearsonthecertificate.Whileoriginallyintendedforthesole
purposeofbirthregistration,birthcertificatesarenowusedextensivelyfor
employmentpurposesandtoobtainbenefitsorotherdocumentsusedfor
identification.
97. “TheOfficeofInspectorGeneralhasconductedthreeinspectionsfocused
specificallyonbirthcertificatefraudthatidentifiedanumberof
vulnerabilitiesinbirthcertificateprocesses.BecausesomanyFederaland
Stateagenciesrelyonbirthcertificatestoassistthemindetermining
eligibilityforservicesandbenefits,itisimportantthattheseagencieshave
currentinformationonthenatureandextentofbirthcertificatefraudto
assistthemintheproperassignmentandprotectionofbenefits.”
98. “Acertifiedcopyofabirthcertificateisproofonlythatabirthoccurredand
wasrecorded.Forthatpurpose,itmaybedesirablethatthepublicbeallowed
easyaccesstothem.However,theagenciesandorganizationsthatusebirth
certificatesasproofofidentificationforemploymentpurposes,toobtain
benefitsorotherdocuments(e.g.,driver’slicenses,SocialSecuritycards,and
passports),andtoassistthemindeterminingeligibilityforpublicassistance
andotherbenefits,mayhaveconcernswithhoweasilycertifiedcopiesof
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 27: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
birthcertificatescanbeobtained.Theseconflictingperspectivesareatthe
27
veryheartofthebirthcertificatecontroversy”.
irthCertificatescontinuetobeUsedas“BreederDocuments”andareEasyBtoObtain
99. VirtuallyallFederalandStateagenciesagreethatfraudulentbirth
certificatesareusedas“breederdocuments”toobtainthegenuine
documentsneededtocreatenewidentities,andthatfraudulentbirth
certificatesareeasytoobtain.Factorswhichcontributetotheiruseas
g“breederdocuments”includethefollowin
BirthCertificateFraudisHardtoDetect
100. “Manyalteredorcounterfeitbirthcertificatesandgenuinebirth
certificatesheldbyimpostersmaygoundetected.Thereasonswhythese
fraudulentbirthcertificatesarehardtodetectincludethefollowing:
• ation;over14,000differentversionsofbirthcertificatesareincircul
• nearly4millionUnitedStatesbirthswereregisteredin1999;
• securityfeaturescontainedinthepaperusedtoissuebirthcertificates,
aswellasformatsandsignatures,varyamongStatevitalrecords
officesandthemanylocalentitiesissuingthem;
• technologicaladvancesintheInternet,scanners,colorprinters,and
copiersmakeiteasiertoobtaingenuinebirthcertificatesandcreate
counterfeitones;
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 28: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
• between85and90percentofthebirthcertificatefraudencountered
bytheImmigrationandNaturalizationServicesandPassport
Servicesstaffistheresultofgenuinebirthcertificatesheldby
imposters‐‐themostdifficultfraudtodetect;andFederalandState
agencystaffreportreceivingonlylimitedtrainingfocusedonthe
es.”detectionoffraudulentbirthcertificat
StatePracticesCreateOpportunitiesforFraud
101. “ItwastheconsensusofthoseweinterviewedthatanumberofState
practicescreateopportunitiesforfraud.Thosepracticesincludethe
following:
• delayed,amended,andmidwifebirthregistrationsthatarebasedon
affidavitsofpersonalknowledge,includenodocumentaryevidence,
andarenotoftenmarkedoroverlaidaccordingly;
• delaysinmatchingdeathandbirthrecordscanmaketheidentitiesof
manydeceasedpersonseasytoassumebetweenthetimethe
persondiesandthetimethedeathandbirthrecordsarematched;
• questionablephysicalsecuritysituationsthatcreateopportunitiesfor
fraud;andlimitedoversightoflocalissuingentitiesbyStatevital
recordsoffices”.
BirthCertificatesAloneDoNotProvideConclusiveorReliableProofofIdentit y
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 29: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
10
29
2. “Manyagenciesandorganizationsrequestthatindividualsprovide
theirbirthcertificatestoreceiveabenefitorservice,ortosupportthe
issuanceofotherdocumentsoftenusedforidentitypurposes(e.g.,driver’s
license).
103. However,agencieswhorelyonbirthcertificatesasameansof
establishingidentitymustunderstandthelimitationsofacceptingabirth
certificateasproofofage,citizenship,oridentity.Forexample,genuine
documentsobtainedwithcounterfeitbirthcertificatescanbeusedtoobtain
genuinebirthcertificates.Thus,itisinherentlyillogicaltorequiresomeoneto
provetheiridentityusingpotentiallyfraudulentidentitydocumentsspawned
toobtainabirthcertificate."byfalsebirthcertificatesinorder
GovernorAbercrombieofHawaii
104. Mr.AbercrombiehaspubliclystatedthathewaspresentwhenMr.
Obamawasborn.Thereisnoevidencetosupportthisclaim.Nodoctoror
nurseorpersonswhoattendedMr.Obama’sbirthhascomeforwardtosay
so.Noonehasevercomeforwardtosayheorsherecallshavingseeneither
infant.Mr.Obamaorhisparentstogetheratanysocialeventwhenhewasan
105. Itisnotsurprising;therefore,thatGovernorAbercrombielater
recantedthatstatementthathehadseenMr.Obama’sparentswiththeir
new‐bornso.Heacknowledgedthathehadnotseenthematanyhospital,
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 30: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
althoughhesaidherememberedhavingseenMr.Obamaasachildwithhis
30
parentsatsocialevents.
106. OnceMr.AbercrombiehadbecomeGovernor,hetoldtheHonoluluStar
AdvertiseronJanuary20,2011,thathewassearchingwithintheHawaii
DepartmentofHealthtofinddefinitivevitalrecordsthatwouldproveMr.
ObamawasborninHawaii,becausehefearedthecontinuingeligibility
controversymighthurtthePresident’schancesofre‐electionin2012.
107. Mr.Abercrombie,whoisamemberofMr.Obama’spoliticalparty,said
thatthebirthcertificateissuewouldotherwisehave“politicalimplications”
forthepresidentialelection“thatwesimplycannothave.”
108. Mr.Abercrombiedidnotsubsequentlyreportthateitherheorthe
HawaiiDepartmentofHealthhadfoundMr.Obama’slong‐form,hospital‐
generatedbirthcertificate.Thegovernoronlysuggestedhisinvestigationto
datehadidentifiedanunspecifiedlistingornotationofMr.Obama’sbirththat
someonehadmadeinthestatearchives:“Itwasactuallywritten,Iamtold,
thisiswhatourinvestigationisshowing,itactuallyexistsinthearchives,
writtendown.”
109. Thisbeingthecase,thisdocumentasreportedwouldclearlybeoutof
thechainofcustodyoftheHawaiiDepartmentofHealth.Hence,the
authenticityofthatwrittenrecordandtheintegrityofthatrecordcannotbe
verifiedorsufficientlysecuredtopreventtampering.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 31: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
11
31
0. Todate,thepurportedundisclosedbirthrecordinthestatearchives
thatGovernorAbercrombiehasclaimedtohavediscoveredandhas
sneverbeenmadepublic.describedasbeing“actuallywritten”ha
NoMentionHasBeenMadeOfItSince
111. FromGovernorAbercrombie’sadmission,itislegitimatetoinferthat
thisrecord,ifitindeedexists,wasnotinthepossessionoftheHawaii
DepartmentofHealth,whichmayhavehadnorecordofthein‐countrybirth
ofMr.Obamaeitherinhardcopyform,suchasalongformbirthcertificate,
preservedinavault.Ifsuchadocumenthadexisted,Mr.Abercrombiewould
havehaditwithinminutesofhisrequest:forhehadtheright,asthesenior
fficialo oftheHawaiiadministration,toexamineitifhewishedtodoso.
112. GovernorAbercrombie’spredecessor,LindaLingle,whowasinoffice
untilJanuary2010,saidshehadaskedthethenDirectorofHealth,Dr.
ChiyomeFukino,toconfirmtheexistenceoftheoriginalpaperlong‐form
birthcertificateandtoissueastatementconfirmingthatsheandDr.Alvin
Onaka,theregistrarofbirths,hadlocatedandverifiedtheexistenceofthe
document
113. However,GovernorAbercrombie,evenafterlaunchinganexhaustive
investigation,failedtoproducethedocumentaryevidenceofMr.Obama’s
Hawaiianbirththathehadsaidhewouldproduce.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 32: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
11
32
4. Onthequestionofthelong‐formbirthcertificate,Dr.ChiyomeFukino,
formerlyDirectorofHealthforHawaiihasmadeseveralstatementsof
interest:
115. InOctober,2008,shesaidHawaiianlawforbadetheissuanceof
certifiedcopiesoforiginalbirthcertificatestopersonswithnotangible
interestintherecord,butaddedthatsheandDr.AlvinOnaka,theRegistrarof
VitalStatistics,hadpersonallyseenandverifiedtheoriginalbirthcertificate
“inaccordancewithstatepoliciesandprocedures”.
116. Tothisday,Dr.Fukinoistheonlypersonwhohassaidpubliclythatshe
haspersonallyinspectedMr.Obama’sactualbirthcertificateinaboundbook
inavaultattheDepartmentofHealth.
117. Dr.Fukino’sstatementconfirmsGovernorLingle’sownstatementthat
shedidnotpersonallyverifytheexistenceoftheoriginalbirthcertificate,but
reliedsolelyontherepresentationsofDr.Fukino,whosestatementalso
impliesthatabirthrecordofsomekindexistsandthatsheinspectedit,
thoughsheprovidedneitheradescriptionofthedocumentnoranyverifiable
informationsaidtohavebeencontainedtherein.
118. Dr.FukinosaysshewasaccompaniedbyDr.AlvinOnaka,withwhom
sheviewedthedocument.WenotedthatDr.Onakahasneverpublicly
confirmedthathehadaccompaniedDr.Fukinoorthathehadverifiedthe
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 33: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
existenceofthedocument.Dr.Onakahasremainedsuspiciouslysilentonthe
33
mattertodate.
119. Underthesecircumstances,Dr.Fukino’sstatementtotheeffectofa
verificationofanauthentic“LongFormBirthCertificate”haslittleevidential
value.
120. Dr.FukinoalsogaveaninterviewtoCNNonApril26,2011,inwhich
shestatedthatshesimplywentintothevaultandinspectedMr.Obama’s
originalbirthcertificate.Byinference,then,itshouldhavebeennomore
difficultforGovernorAbercrombietolocateitaswell.
121. InJuly,2009,Dr.Fukinosaidshehadseen“theoriginalvitalrecords
maintainedonfilebytheHawaiiStateDepartmentofHealthverifyingBarack
HusseinObamawasborninHawaiiandisanatural‐bornAmerican.”Again
thisstatementhasnoevidentialvalue.
122. AsreportedbyFoxNews,Dr.Fukinosaidthatduringhertimeas
DirectorofHealthforHawaiiDr.AlvinOnaka,StateRegistrarofHawaii,had
movedMr.Obama'sbirthcertificatefromafilevault,whereboundbooks
containingvitalrecordslinetheshelvesinhandwritten,leather‐bound
ledgersandplacedinsidethevault's5‐ft‐tallgraymetalcombinationandkey
locksafethatholdsmoneyandothervaluables.Ifso,Dr.Onakacouldvery
easilyhavealertedGovernorAbercrombietoitswhereabouts.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 34: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
12
34
3. In2008whenGovernorLinglestated,thatinanattempttoquellthe
issueshehadtheBirthCertificateinspectedbythestate’sDirectorofHealth,
r.ChiD yomeFukino:
124. Mr.OnakawastheRegisteratthattime.Presumablythedocumentwas
inthesameboundvolumeastheother499fromthattheyearsecuredinhis
vault.ThequestionbecomeswhathappenedtoitwhenGovernor
Abercrombiecamelookingforitin2011.
125. Dr.FukinosaidthatMr.Obama’slong‐formbirthcertificatewas
preservedinahard‐coveredboundvolumealongwiththeotherlong‐form
birthcertificatesofthatperiod.Thisrecord–ifithadexisted–wouldhave
beeneasilyobtainablefromtheDepartmentofHealthupontheGovernor’s
request.
126. Dr.FukinoalsosaidthatMr.Obama'soriginalCertificateofLiveBirth
wasboundinaledgercontaining499othercertificatesofpeoplebornin
Hawaiiin1961.Therewere500sheetsperbook,and35volumesof1961
birthrecords.Thelastseriesofdigitsintheregistrationnumberfoundon
Hawaiianlongformandcurrentcomputerized‐formatbirthcertificates
indicateswhichnumberedvolumecontainstheoriginaldocumentinsidethe
healthdepartment’sfirst‐floorvault.
127. Sheexplainedthateachoftheboundvolumesforthe1960s,including
theonecontainingMr.Obama'sbirthcertificate,hadbrightorangeelasticized
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 35: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
canvascoverswiththebirthyearstampedclearlyonthespine.Different
35
colorswereusedfordifferentdecades.
128. Thelastfewdigitsintheregistrationnumber,whicharecorrelated
withthecurrentcomputerizeddatabaseofinformationtakenfromthe
originalpaperrecords,serveasauniqueidentifierallowingthevolume
lt.containingtheoriginalcertificatetobefoundimmediatelyinthevau
129. Therefore,itshouldnothavebeenatalldifficultforGovernor
AbercrombietolocateMr.Obama'soriginallong‐formbirthcertificateby
simplyaskingtheDepartmentofHealthtolookupthecomputerizedrecord,
checkthecertificatenumber,andinstantlylocatetherelevantvolumeof
papercertificates.Hisfailuretolocatethedocumentraisesthepossibilitythat
Mr.Obama’sbirthrecordmaynothavebeenintherelevantorange‐bound
volumeof500sequentially‐numberedcertificates,orthat,ifitispresent,it
didnotshowhimashavingbeenbornanywhereinHawaii.
130. ItisalsopossiblethatMr.Obama'sbirthregistrationwasnotrecorded,
orthatthenumberonthatregistrationdidnotcorrelatetohisnameinthe
DepartmentofHealth’scomputerizeddatabasethathasbeeninusesince
001.2
131. WenotedthatDr.FukinohadchangedthewordingfromviewingMr.
Obama’s“originalbirthcertificate”(inherfirststatement)tohaving“seenthe
originalvitalrecords”(inhersecondstatement).
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 36: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
13
36
2. WelaterlearnedthatHawaiianlawpermitsamendmentofabirth
certificateandthecreationofadocumentfilecontainingthesealedrecordof
theoriginaldocumentandsupportingdocumentationthatauthorizeda
changetotheinformationcontainedintheoriginaldocument.Wealso
learnedthatanamendedcertificatewouldbedistinctlymarkedalertingto
efacth titwasaltered.
133. Thewordingsuggeststhatperhapstherewasafileofsometype
locatedwithintheDepartmentofHealthcontainingadditionalinformation
regardingthismatter,permissibleunderHawaiiStateStatutes.Butthefile
maynothavecontainedanoriginalbirthcertificateidenticaltotheelectronic
imageontheWhiteHousewebsite.
HawaiiStatePracticesAllowFraudulentU.S.Citizenship
134. Investigatorsfoundahighpotentialforfraudintheregistrationand
issuanceofHawaiibirthcertificationdocuments.Itwasdiscoveredtobe
evidentin:1)laxstatutoryregulationand2)throughobscureevidentiary
requirementsinestablishingfactualverificationoftheinformationrequired
inthereportingoflegitimatebirthsoccurringwithinthestateofHawaii.
135. In1982,Hawaiirevisedalongstandingstatute(§338.17.8)allowing
theissuanceofbirthcertificatestochildrenbornoutofstate.Hawaiideclares
theseforeignbornchildrentobeAmericancitizenssimplybyvirtueofan
applicationbyanyadultmakingrepresentationsonbehalfoftheparents,and
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 37: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
simplysupplyingdocumentationsubstantiatingtheparentshadresidedin
HawaiiandpaidincometaxtothestateHawaiiforoneyearpriortothebirth
ofthechild.Thus,bystatutoryprovision,Hawaiihasgranteduponitselfthe
uniquepowertoconfercitizenshiptochildrennotbornintheUnitedStates,
andtochildrennotborntoUnitedStatescitizenparents,buttochildren
37
actuallybornonforeignsoil.
[§338‐17.8]CertificatesforChildrenBornOutofState.
(a) Uponapplicationofanadultorthelegalparentsofaminorchild,theDirectorofHealthshallissueabirthcertificateforsuchadultorminor,providedthatproofhasbeensubmittedtotheDirectorofHealththatthelegalparentsofsuchindividualwhilelivingwithouttheTerritoryorStateofHawaiihaddeclaredtheTerritoryorStateofHawaiiastheirlegal
thresidenceforatleastoneyearimmediatelyprecedingthebiroradoptionofsuchchild.
(b) ProofoflegalresidencyshallbesubmittedtotheDirectorofHealthinanymannerthattheDirectorshalldeemappropriate.TheDirectorofHealthmayalsoadoptanyrulespursuanttoChapter91thatheorshemaydeemnecessaryorpropertopreventfraudulentapplicationsforbirthcertificatesandtoequireanyfurtherinformationorproofofeventsnecessaryrforcompletionofabirthcertificate.
136. Thefeeforeachapplicationforregistrationshallbeestablishedbyrule
adoptedpursuanttoChapter91.[L1982,c182,§1]
137. Theseimplicationsofthislawisevidencedbythediscoveryof
correspondencebetweentheDepartmentofHealthDirectorGeorgeYuen,in
supportofthemeasure,andStateRepresentativeHerbertA.Segawa.TheMarch1st
1982documentclearlyshowstheeffectthisproposedBillH.B.3016‐82wouldit
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 38: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
havebecomelaw.Thedocumentrecognizedthefactthatthedepartmentwould
havetoissuebirthcertificatestochildrenworldwideifthechild’sparentscould
provetheywereinfactlegalresidentsoftheTerritoryorStateofHawaii.Legal
residentsascategorizedbyHawaiitaxcode,notUntiedStatescitizens.
38
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 39: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
39
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 40: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
13
40
8. ThereisnothinginHawaiiRevisedStatute§338.17.8torequirethat
thisbirthcertificatebemarkedasthechildbeingbornoutofstate,northat
wasthechildbornwithintheUnitedStatesoritsterritories.Thereisno
requirementinthisstatutethatatleastoneparentprovideproofofUnited
Statescitizenship.
139. Thissectiononlyrequiresadeclaration(andproofwhichisnotdefined
andisbaseduponrequirementsdeemedappropriatebytheDirector)that
theparentswereresidentsofHawaii.Itdoesnotrequirethattheparents
werecitizensoftheUnitedStates.
140. BystatutoryprovisionHawaiihasgranteduponitselftheunique
powertoconfercitizenshiptochildrennotbornintheUnitedStates,andto
childrennotborntoUnitedStatescitizenparents,buttochildrenactually
bornonforeignsoil.Conceivably,theparentsandchildmayneverhaveset
footonUnitedStatessoil.Hawaiideclarestheseforeignbornchildren
Americancitizenssimplybyvirtueofanapplicationofanyadult,making
representationsonbehalfoftheparentsandsimplysupplyingdocumentation
substantiatingtheparentshadresidedinHawaiiandpaidincometaxtothe
stateHawaii,foroneyearpriortothebirthofthechild.
141. TheauthoritytonaturalizepersonsascitizensoftheUSisconferred
upontheAttorneyGeneralonly,nottheStateofHawaii.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 41: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
14
41
2. ItwouldappearthatHawaiiRevisedStatute§338.17.8isindirect
conflictwiththeImmigrationandNationalityAct,inthatUnitedStates
citizenshipmaybebeconferredtoanindividualwhoisnotentitledtosuch
citizenship.
143. SeeI.N.A.§§301,etseq.,whichcomprehensivelyregulateshowachild
bornoutoftheUnitedStatesacquiresU.S.Citizenship.Eventhiswould
requireatleastonparentbeaUnitedStatescitizenatthetimeofthebirth.
144. Thiscomprehensiveregulationwouldclearlybemeanttoexcludeany
regulationintheareabytheStates.Arizonav.UnitedStates,11‐182(June,
012).2
145. Compulsoryregistrationofbirths,authorizedbyHawaiiRevisedLaw
§57‐8requiresallbirthsofberegistered.Italsopermitstheregistrationfor
anunattendedbirthtobeacceptedontherepresentationofonlyoneofthe
parents.Nootherwitnessesarenecessaryforaclaimedunattendedbirth.
Conceivably,aparentcouldhavegivenbirthoutsideoftheU.S.,andclaimed
thatitwasanunattendedbirth(nowitnesses)inHonolulu.
146. Localregistrartopreparebirthcertificate,authorizedbyHawaii
RevisedLaw§57‐8isbristlingwiththefraudulentpotentialbycompellingthe
localregistrartoprepareabirthcertificateforanallegedunattendedbirth
basedsolelyuncorroboratedtestimonyfromanyoneclaimingtohavehad
knowledgeofthebirthtakingplace.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 42: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
14
42
7. Underthisstatute,abirthcouldexistoutsideoftheU.S.,andany
personcouldrepresentfalseinformationtothelocalregistrar.Theregistrar
iscompelledtofilethecertificate.
148. Additionally,thereisnorequirementforaparentorrelative,providing
identificationtobepresentattimeofregistration.Anyperson,arelative,
friendorstrangermayregistrarthebirthofachildwhileboththemotherand
babywereoutsideofthecountry.
149. Thereisnoverificationprocessandnowaytobecertainoftheactual
identifyoftheparents.
H.R.S§338‐6,CurrentLawasofOctober25,2009
150. Delayedoralteredcertificates,authorizedbyHawaiiRevisedLaw§57‐
18.UtilizingthisStatute,apersonmayapplyforadelayedoramended
certificatehavingoneyeartodosofromtimeofbirth.Thereisno
verificationtodeterminewhytheregistrationislate.TheStatutealsoallows
anyperson“born”intheTerritoryofHawaiitofileoramendacertificate.
151. Thiswouldincludethatanyadultcouldclaimtheirbirthwasnever
reportedadecadelater,fileforabirthcertificate.Thevalidityofthethree
typesofbirthfilingsweresoquestionablethatevenHawaiiwouldnotaccept
emath s“PrimaFaciaEvidence”.
152. ThisStatutewouldrequirethebirthcertificatebeplainlymarked,
“Delayed”,or“Altered”andtheprobativevaluewoulddeterminebythe
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 43: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
officialtowhomthecertificatewasbeingoffered.Webelieveitissafeto
concludethateventheStateofHawaiididnothaveconfidenceinthe
43
representationsonthisdocument.
153. InvestigatorshaveadvisedSheriffArpaiothatseveralpossiblecrimes
mayhavebeencommitted:
154. First,thefraudulentcreationofanofficialdocument
155. Second,theWhiteHousecharacterizingaforgeryasanofficially‐
roducp edgovernmentalbirthrecord;and
156. Third,Mr.ObamarepresentedtotheresidentsofMaricopaCountyand
theAmericanpublicthataforgerywas“proofpositive”ofhisauthentic1961
Hawaiianlong‐formbirthcertificate,therebydeceivingvotersandstate
electioncommissionsacrossthecountryintobelievinghewaseligibleto
becomePresident,havehisnameappearonPresidentialballots,thereby
garneringvotesfromthepublicunderfalsepretenses.
157. Accordingly,SheriffArpaiocontinuestorecommendthattheCongress
oftheUnitedStatesopenanimmediateinvestigation,includingthe
appointmentofaselectcommittee,asregardstotheauthenticityofMr.
Obama’sdocumentation,whetheranycrimeshavebeencommitted,andto
determineMr.Obama’seligibilityfortheofficeofPresidentoftheUnites
tates.S
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 44: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
44
Mr.Obama’sSelectiveServiceRegistrationCard
158. InvestigatorsalsoexaminedMr.Obama’sSelectiveServiceregistration
cardbearingMr.Obama’ssignature,whichdisplaysaPostOfficeDatestamp,
“July29,80,”inthelowerrightcorner.Forcomparisonpurposes,
investigatorsreviewedanumberofauthenticSelectiveServiceregistration
quests.cardsofotherindividuals,obtainedviaFreedomofInformationActre
159. Alltheauthenticregistrationcardstheinvestigatorsinspected
displayedaPostOfficestampindicatingthecalendaryeardatestampwith
fourdigits,forexample“1980”.ThiswasinsharpcontrasttoMr.Obama’s
cardwhichdisplayedatwodigitdatestampof“80”fortheyear.
160. InvestigatorsinterviewedseveralPostOfficeemployeeswhoverified
thatitwasstandardproceduretoutilizeonlyafourdigitdatestamp.
Investigatorslearnedthatthedatestampthatwouldhavebeenutilizedin
1980wasidentifiedasaPicaPostOfficestampsetthatcouldonlybe
obtainedthroughpostalsupplyhouses.
161. Investigatorslocatedthatparticularstampsetbutwereunsuccessfulin
locatingafourdigit1980datestampinsert.
162. Noticingirregularitiesinthedatestamp,namelythedate“80”onMr.
Obama'sregistrationcard,itisoffsetlowandtorightwhencomparedtothe
fullfourdigit“1980”datestampsonothercards.Investigatorsbelievedthat
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 45: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
thisanomalywascreatedbytheseveringofanintactfouryear“2008”date
”.
45
stampandinvertingtheremaining“08”invertingittocauseittodisplay“80
163. Investigatorsconcludedthatthisrepresentationof“80”thatappears
onMr.Obama'sselectiveservicecardisinfactanaltered2008picadate
stamp.
164. Investigatorsobtaineda2008PicaPostOfficedatestampandsevered
itinbetweenthetwozeros.Thenbyinvertinginvestigatorswereableto
replicateanidenticallookingstamptothatonefoundonMr.Obamaselective
servicecard.InvestigatorsconcludedthatthereisahighprobabilitythatMr.
Obama’sselectiveservicecardwasrecentlycreatedasanattempttocoverup
thefactthatMr.ObamafailedtoregisterforSelectiveServiceasrequiredby
lawin1980.
MissingImmigrationRecordsforAugust1‐7,1961
165. TherehasbeenimmensespeculationthatMr.Obamamayactually
havebeenborninKenya.Thesespeculationswerefuellednotonlybythe
refusalofMr.ObamatoproduceavalidHawaiianbirthcertificate,butby
recognitionoftheKenyagovernmentclaimingKenyaasbeingMr.Obama’s
birthplace.TherewerenumerousreportsthatStanleyAnnDunhamhad
reportedlyleftHawaiitotraveltoKenyainthesummerof1961togivebirth.
166. InanattempttoverifywhetherMr.ObamaandhismotherStanleyAnn
DunhamhadpossiblyarrivedintheUnitedStatesatoraroundthealleged
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 46: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
dateofhisbirth,wecontactedtheNationalArchivestoobtainmicrofilmsof
.
46
theimmigrationlandingrecords(I‐94document)forthecalendaryear1961
167. InvestigatorsfocusedonmicrofilmrecordsofINSpassengercardsfor
foreignflightsarrivinginHonoluluduringthetimeperiodofJuly1961
throughSeptember1961.
168. WediscoveredthatdatarecordsfortheentireweekofAugust2,1961
throughAugust7,1961,werecompletelymissingfromthemicrofilmroll.
ThisincludedtheallegeddateofMr.Obama’sbirth(August4,1961).
SelectiveServiceRegistrationCardAnalysis
169. InvestigatorsalsoexaminedMr.Obama’sSelectiveServiceregistration
cardbearingMr.Obama’ssignature.Theyconcludedthatthereisahigh
probabilitythatMr.Obama’sselectiveservicecardwasrecentlycreatedasan
attempttocoverupthefactthatMr.ObamafailedtoregisterforSelective
Serviceasrequiredbylawin1980.
170. 1961August4,7:24pm‐BarackHusseinObamaIIwasallegedlyborn
inKapiolaniHospital,Honolulu,HI,accordingtotheimageofhislong‐form
birthcertificatethatispostedontheWhiteHousewebsite.Birthcertificate
number61‐10641.
171. However,thishasbeengreatlydebateddueinparttoinitialreports
thatMr.ObamawasreportstohavebeenborninQueensMedicalCenter,in
HonoluluHawaii.InquiriesweremadeatQueensMedicalCenterand
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 47: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
authoritiestheredisclosedthattheyhadnorecordofthatevent.
Subsequently,achangewasmadeinthenarrativeallegingthebirthplaceto
nowbeKapiolaniHospital.Whilethismaybeanoversightotherdiscrepancy
surfacedaroundtheinformationvisibleonthe.pdffileimagereleasedbythe
47
WhiteHouse.
172. Theserialnumbershownontheimageofthecertificate,which
purportsonitsfacetohavebeenimposedontheformwithanautomated
sequentialnumberingstamp,is61‐10641.Investigatorslearnedatthattime,
batchesofbirthcertificateswerecollectedmonthly,orderedbydateandtime
ofbirth,andthensequentiallynumber‐stampedinaspecialroombyasingle
clerktrainedforthepurpose,tominimizenumberingerrors.
173. Thelong‐formoriginalcertificateswereinspectedtwiceforaccuracy
bytwodifferentclerksandthensignedbytheregistrar.Theywerekept
togethersecuredinacertainroomuntiltheywereallnumberedattheendof
themonth.Theywerenotallowedtobecomeoutoforderandtheywerenot
numberedincorrectly.(ItshouldbenotedthattheNordyketwinswereborn
minutesapartandtheirrespectivecertificatenumberingwasbasednotonly
bydatebutbytimeaswell.Thisindicatestheclerkscrutinizedthe
documentspriortoplacingtheminchronologicalorderforproper
numbering.)
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 48: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
17
48
4. VitalstatisticswillshowthatSusanNordykewasbornatKapiolani
Hospitalat2:12p.m.HawaiitimeonAug.5,1961,andwasgivenNo.151‐61‐
06371 ,whichwasalsofiledwiththeHawaiiregistrarAug.11,1961.
175. GretchenNordyke,twintoSusanNordyke,wasbornatKapiolani
Hospitalat2:17p.m.HawaiitimeonAug.5,1961,andwasgivenNo.151‐61‐
06381 ,whichwasalsofiledwiththeHawaiiregistrarAug.11,1961.
176. BarackHusseinObamaIIpurportedlybornatKapiolaniHospitalat
7:24p.m.Hawaii,Aug.4,1961,andwasgivenNo.151‐61‐10641,whichwas
filedwiththeHawaiiregistrarAug.8,1961.
177. VirginiaSunaharawasbornatWahiawaHospitalat9:16p.m.Hawaii
timeonAug.4,1961,andwasgivenNo.161‐1961‐011080,whichwasfiled
iireg .withtheHawa istrarAug.10,1961
n red ate#Nameofchild Dateandtimebor Registe Certific
BarackObama Aug4at7:24pm Aug8 10641
VirginiaSunaharAug4at9:16pm Aug10 11080
SusanNordyke Aug5at2:12pm Aug11 10637
retchenNordyke Aug5at2:17pm Aug11 10638G
178. 1961August4,9:16pm‐VirginiaSunaharawasborninHawaii,
accordingtohercurrentbirthrecord.Theserialnumbercurrentlyshownon
VirginiaSunaharashortformCertificateofLiveBirthasthatofherbirth
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 49: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
recordis61‐11080.Thisregistrationnumberis439numbersafterBarack
49
HusseinObamaII.
179. Some17,578birthsoccurredinHawaiiin1961–anaverageofabout
twobirthsperhour.VirginiaSunaharawasbornlessthantwohoursafter
BarackHusseinObamaIIstatedtimeofbirth,sothatthenumberthatought
tohaveappearedonheroriginalbirthcertificateshouldhavebeennotmore
thanadozeneithersideofBarackHusseinObamaII61‐10641.
180. VirginiaSunahararegistrationnumberisinexplicablyoutofsequence
by439numbers.
181. 1961August5‐DeathofVirginiaSunaharaafterbreathing
complicationsat8PM
182. Mr.Obama’sbirthcertificatewasregisteredAugust8,1961.The
Nordyketwins’birthcertificatewasregisteredAugust11,1961.Evenifthe
sequentialnumberinghadfollowedthedateofregistrationratherthanthe
dateofbirth,Mr.Obama’scertificateshouldhavebeenautomaticallyassigned
anumberlower,nothigher,thanthenumbersallocatedtothecertificatesof
theNordyketwins.AndthenumbercurrentlyassignedtoMs.Sunaharais
entirelyoutofsequence
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 50: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
50
HawaiiNewspaperBirthAnnouncements
183. Investigatorsconductedanexhaustivesearchofallbirthrecords
announcedintheHonoluluAdvertiserandtheStarBulletinforthemonthof
August1961.
184. Thefollowingconclusionswerereached:
x Therewasnoapparentconsistencyintheorderordaywithwhicheach
newspaperreportedbirthannouncements,suchthatoneortheother
ofthetwonewspaperswouldoftenleadorlagtheotherinthe
reportingofanyparticularbirth.
x spaperandnotinanother.Somebirthswereannouncedinonenew
x Somebirthswerenotannouncedatall.
x Birthstounwedmotherswereomittedfromreportingineither
newspaper,eventhoughHawaiivitalstatisticsreporttherewereover
1,000birthstounwedmothersin1961.
185. AcomparisonoftheObamabirthannouncementinthetwo
newspapersclearlydemonstratestheannouncementsareidenticalinevery
detail,includingtheorderofotherbirthannouncementsprecedingand
followingtheObamabirthannouncement.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 51: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
186. Wefoundthesequenceofreportedbirthsaroundthereportingofthe
ObamabirthwasactuallyananomalyforHawaiiannewspaperreportingin
August1961becausethesequenceofbirthsbeforeandafterObama’swas
oneofthefewbirthsequencesintheentiremonththatwereidenticalin
everydetail,includingtheorderofotherbirthannouncementsprecedingand
followingtheObamabirthannouncement.
187. WeconcludedthatbirthlistswereinfactreleasedbytheHawaii
DepartmentofHealth,notinformationvolunteeredtothenewspaperfrom
parentsorrelatives,wasthelikelysourceofinformationforthenewspaper
birthannouncementlisting,inthat:
Neithernewspaperhadaneditorthathandledbirthannouncements;
51
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 52: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
52
x Bothnewspapersmerelyprintedbirthannouncements,directlyas
received,frominformationpublishedinDepartmentofHawaiivital
statisticsannouncements;
x Hawaiianhospitalsdidnotreporttonewspapersanybirth
announcementinformation;
x Neithernewspaperindependentlycheckedthetruthfulnessor
accuracyofbirthannouncementinformationpublishedbythe
.newspapersfromHawaiiDepartmentofHealthvitalstatisticsrecords
188. Searchingoveraseveralyearperiod,variousresearchershavefound
repeatedlistingsofbirthstoJapaneseparentsasbeingreportedinthe
newspapersasHawaiianbirths,eventhoughthechildrenwerefoundtobe
borninJapan.Thesefindingstendtoreinforcewhatwelearnedonourvisits
toHawaii:thatitwasthenthewidely‐recognizedpracticeinHawaii,later
regularizedbystatute,tocertifyforeignbirthstoHawaiianparentsas
Hawaiianbirths.
189. In1961,theHawaiiDepartmentofHealthappearstohaveusedlocal
areaofficesoutsideHonoluluasreportingcenterswhereparentsandother
familymemberscouldrepresentchildrenborntothefamilyasHawaiian
births,withoutsubmittinganyproofthechildwasactuallyborninHawaii.
Thispracticewasalsostatutorilypermitted.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 53: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
19
53
0. ItisplausiblethatanoriginalbirthrecordofsometypeforMr.Obama
mayexistinHawaii.However,asnotedelsewhere,ourinvestigationhas
discoveredthatatthattimeHawaiianlawcontainedaspecificprovisionthat
permittedaHawaiianparentofachildbornanywhereintheworldorany
adultpurportingtorepresentthatparent,therighttoregisterthechildas
Hawaiian‐born.
191. Itisforthisreasonthattwoentriesinthe“Births”columnofthelocal
newspapersatthetimedonotconstituteevidencethatMr.Obamawasborn
inHawaii.Theyaremerelyevidencesuggestingthatabirthcertificateof
sometypewasissuedforhiminHawaii,andtheytellusnothingabout
whetherornothewasbornthere.Inparticulartheydonot–astheWhite
Housedocumentpurportstodo–identifythehospitalofbirth.Hawaiilaw
permitsvariousformsofregistrationandsupplementationatlaterdates,
withdifferentinformation.Themereissuanceofabirthrecorddoesnot
States.confirmthebirthtookplacewithinthestateofHawaiiorintheUnited
192. IfMr.ObamahadnotinfactbeenborninHawaii,thelong‐form
originalbirthcertificatewouldnothavestatedthathehadbeenbornina
particularhospitalataparticulartime,andwouldnothavebornethe
signaturesoftheattendingphysician.Thenewspaperentrieswouldhave
beenidenticalwhetherhehadbeenborninHawaiiorelsewhereintheworld,
butthebirthrecordswouldnothavebeenidentical.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 54: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
19
54
3. Theexistenceofthislawpermittingout‐of‐countrybirthstobe
registeredasthoughtheywereHawaiianbirthsisafurtherevidencethathe
newspaperannouncementsofMr.ObamaspurportedbirthinHawaiicannot
andshouldnotbereliedonasanyevidentiaryvalidationoftheeventtaking
placeasdepictedbythemanufactured.pdffileimagereleasedbytheWhite
House.
IrregularitiesintheParents’Address
194. BObama(Kenya)andStanleyAnnDunham,PresidentObama’salleged
parents,didnotlivetogetherasmanandwifeat6085KalanianaoleHighway
inHawaii,thebirthaddressshownontheWhiteHouseimageaswellasinthe
twobirthannouncementsforBarackObamaJr.publishedinlocalnewspapers
atthetime.
195. Bothnewspapers,theHonoluluAdvertiserandtheStarBulletin,
carriedtheannouncementthatBarackObamaJr.wasbornonAug.4,1961,to
hway.Mr.andMrs.BarackH.Obamawhoresidedat6085KalanianaoleHig
196. MadelynDunhamandherdaughterStanleyAnnlivedat6085
KalanianaoleHighway.ThereisnoevidencethatBObamaSr.livedthere.
197. StanleyAnnDunhamandBarackH.ObamaSr.livedattwodifferent
addressesaftertheirmarriage.StanleyAnnDunhamremainedintherented
6085KalanianaoleHighwayafterhermarriage.
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 55: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
19
55
8. BObamaSr,livedaloneatan11thAvenueaddress,closertothe
universitywherehewasastudent.ItisreportedthatStanleyAnnDunham
leftHawaiiinAugust1961,themonthofBarackObamaJr.’sbirth,takinghim
withherbutleavingherhusbandbehindwhenshemovedtoSeattletoenroll
attheUniversityofWashington.
199. WhetherBObamaSr.didnotestablisharesidencewithhiswifeand
soninHawaiiisunknown,thereisnolistinginthePolkdirectoriesfor1961‐
1962thatdocumentsStanleyAnnDunhamandBObama(Kenya)asever
havinglivedatthesameaddress.
200. AsearchofthePolk’sDirectoryofHonolulufor1961‐62indicatesthat
6085KalanianaoleHighwaywasbeingrentedbythegrandparents,Madelyn
L.Dunham,listedasaloaninterviewerandescrowagentattheBankof
Hawaii,andStanleyA.Dunham,listedasamanagerwithPrattFurniture.
201. Inaseparatelisting,AnnS.Obama,Mr.Obama’smother,isidentifiedas
astudentlivingatthe6085KalanianaoleHighwayaddress;BarackH.Obama,
herhusband,islistedasastudentlivingataseparateaddress,hisown
apartmentat62511thAvenue,closertotheUniversityofHawaiiatManoa:
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 56: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
56
202. Polk’sDirectoryofCityandCountyofHonolulu,Hawaii1961‐1962
203. ResearcherswereunabletodeterminethatBObama(Kenya)and
StanleyAnnDunhamObamaeverlivedtogetheratanycommonaddressin
Hawaii
204. MuchofMr.Obamasearlyliferemainsamysteryandisonlyrevealed
tothepublicthroughanunsupportedcompositenarrative.Instancesexist
wherethenarrativeofbirthorotherreportedlifetimeeventshavebeen
calledintoquestionandthenthenarrativeisalteredinanefforttoclearsup
discrepancy,butabsentofanydocumentationsupportingthechangein
questionablefacts.
205. Athoroughbackgroundinvestigationsupportedbythereleaseoflife
timedocumentationwouldbenecessarytostrengthenthebirthnarrative
shoulditexistasdepictedtothepublic.
206. However,investigatorshavebeenhamperedbytherefusalofMr.
bama heyexist.O toreleaseanyofhispastrecordsshouldt
207. Recordnotreleasedincludingthefollow:
A. Original,long‐form1961Hawaiianbirthcertificate.
B. MarriagelicensebetweenObama’sfather(BarakSr.)and
mother(StanleyAnnDunham)
toBarackHusseinObama)C. Namechange(BarrySotero
D. Obama’sadoptionrecords
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org
![Page 57: ProtectOurLiberty - REPUBLIC FOR MICHIGAN](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081503/62a20a4cc885e6261b3aeb25/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
E.
57
RecordsofObama’sandhismother’srepatriationasUS
urnfromIndonesiacitizensonreturnfromret
F. Obama’sbaptismrecords
G. NoelaniElementarySchool(Hawaii)
. cordsH PunahouSchoolfinancialaidorschoolre
drecordsI. OccidentalCollegefinancialai
ordsJ. HarvardLawSchoolrec
K. Columbiaseniorthesis
L. ColumbiaCollegerecords
M. Oba ma’srecordwithIllinoisStateBarAssociation
erasanIllinoisStateSenatorN. Obama’sfilesfromcare
O. Obama’slawclientlist
P. Obama’smedicalrecords
Q. Obama’spassportrecords
Sworntounderpenaltyofperjury.
Date MichaelZullo
Copy provided courtesy of: ProtectOurLiberty.org
ProtectOurLiberty.org