Download - 5. 50 k1 bcn_eea_&_seap_mt_partenaires
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs
2ND Centralized training session
The European Energy Award + SEAP
theory and practice
Barcelona, 1st october 2014
Michaël TOMA, director
MT Partenaires Enginnering,
Bordeaux, France
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 2
SO MANY DIFFERENT CONCEPTS
Commitment
Financing
Covenant of Mayors
SEAP EEA
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 3
HOW DO THEY ALL FIT TOGETHER ?
SEAP ISO 50001
EEA
Global policies
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 4
A PARTICULAR EU NOTION :
CROSS - FERTILISATION
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 5
HOW DO THEY ALL FIT TOGETHER ?
Global policies
Agenda 21
SEAP
Evaluation & management
• Social
• Environmental
• Climate
• Energy
• ISO 50001
• EEA
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 6
Presentation plan
1. Theory : EEA
2. Theory : SEAPs
3. Comparison : EEA and ISO 50001
4. Practice
5. Q & A
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 7
Presentation plan
1. Theory : EEA
2. Theory : SEAPs
3. Comparison : EEA and ISO 50001
4. Practice
5. Q & A
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 8
European Energy Awards
What is EEA ?
The European Energy Award® (eea) is a quality
management and certification system for
municipalities and LA committed to sustainable
municipal energy, climate and transport policies.
EEA organisation
• International : Organisation and Forum
• National EEA Organisations
• Advisors / Auditors / International auditors
• Municipalities / Local Authorities
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 9
EEA
Overview
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 10
EEA IN EUROPE /
WORLDWIDE
FR : ADEME
(Cit'ergie)
DE : EEA
AT :
5e
IT :
SPES
IRE Liguria
CH :
Energiestadt
Participating
countries
DE, AT, CH,
FR, IT, LU,
MC, LI
Pilot countries
HU, RO, UR,
MO, CI
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 11
EEA (Cit'ergie)
Harmonised procedure
EMT Tool
Energy
team
Climate-energy policy
Actions and monitoring
EE Award : every 4 years
Assessment Comittment
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 12
EEA
6 areas
Click to edit Master text styles
• Second level
• Third level
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 13
Planning
strategies
84 pts Municipal bldgs
& facilities
76 pts
Energy, water,
sanitation, waste
104 pts
Mobility
96 pts
Communication
and co-operation
104 pts
Internal
organisation
44 pts
79 Actions
Max. 508 pts
Potential and scoring
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 14
YES / NO / Prove it No proof – no points
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 15
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 16
WEIGHT
Potential
Action complete
Action programmed
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 17
European Energy Awards
Levels
35 - 50% (Cap Cit'ergie)
51 - 75% EEA (Cit'ergie)
>75 % EEA GOLD
(subsidised by ADEME)
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 18
EEA PORTFOLIO IN EUROPE
EEA Level DE FR IT LU AT CH MC Total
35 – 50% (Cap Cit'ergie) 151 12 87 25 5 1 281
51 – 75% (EEA - Cit'ergie) 134 19 4 5 69 319 550
e5 < 50% (applicable in
Austria ) 16 16
>75% (EEA Gold) 20 2 8 21 51
NC 29 42 174 245
TOTAL 334 75 4 92 118 519 1 1143
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 19
Presentation plan
1. Theory : EEA
2. Theory : SEAPs
3. Comparison : EEA and ISO 50001
4. Practice
5. Q & A
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 20
SEAPs
SEAPs introduction and process
Covenant of Mayors :
• 6001 voluntary cities & LA : 3x20 : 192M pop.
• All covenant signatories commit to submit a SEAP
SEAP process
• Commitment : signature & administrative structures
• Baseline inventory
• SEAP submittal & approval
• Follow-up
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 21
SEAPs in Europe (early 2014)
Country
(selection)
COM
Signatories
SEAP
submitted
Approved Late
France 116 70 21 30
Germany 53 53 28 14
Italy 2 677 1 847 922 458
Spain 1 456 1 002 753 99
Poland 30 14 16
Greece 86 36 32
Bulgaria 38 11 4
Romania 65 20 23
Latvia 19 14 5
TOTAL 5 206 3 565 2 022 854
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 22
SEAPs vs. PCET
The French example
All 21 regions have an air – climate – energy regional scheme …
supposed to cover the territory
Climate – Energy action plans :
• Are compulsory by law for cities and conurbations > 50 000 inhabitants
• They consist of a territory vulnerability study, a GHG baseline and an
action plan (city / LA assets only)
• They are close to SEAPs but not identical
• And based on EEA assesments where applicable
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 23
Presentation plan
1. Theory : EEA
2. Theory : SEAPs
3. Comparison : EEA and ISO 50001
4. Practice
5. Q & A
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 24
ISO 50001 vs. EEA
ADEME has done the comparison between the two
Basically similar with some remarcable differences
ISO 50001 EEA
Holistic approach – progress PDCA Detailed assessment / scoreboard
Internal / external auditing 3 years External advisor - 4 years
No legal check ; no documentary
tracking ; no non-conformity
improvement and no baseline
Doubles white certificates Award
"Free" perimeter Assessment tools / complete perimeter
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 25
Presentation plan
1. Theory : EEA
2. Theory : SEAPs
3. Comparison : EEA and ISO 50001
4. Practice
5. Q & A
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 26
EEA & SEAPs in practice
EEA – the tool for SEAP implementation (DG Energy of the EC)
EEA used as assessment tools for SEAPs / Climate plans
• IT : ex. Moneglia
• FR : all EEA candidates and awardees : cities and conurbations
(e.g. Bordeaux, Lyon, Niort, Lille, …)
• Most EEA cities when they do SEAPs
EEA action plan merged with SEAP
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 27
Timelines Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 …
SEAP
Comittment
Baseline
SEAP submittal
Implementation
Follow up
ISO 50001 Comittment
Audit
Actions
Re-audit
EEA Comittment
Assessment
Award
Implementation
New period
Climate
plans (FR)
Free Assesment
Vulnerability
Action plans
GHG emissions
Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with
Energy management Systems According to ISO 500001 www.500001seaps.eu
@500001SEAPs 28
Presentation plan
1. Theory : EEA
2. Theory : SEAPs
3. Comparison : EEA and ISO 50001
4. Practice
5. Q & A