do wti oil price movements follow a markov...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page1
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
DOWTI OIL PRICEMOVEMENTSFOLLOWAMARKOVCHAIN?
ByRichardR.ConnCMA,MBA,CPA,ABV,ERP
Thispaperisthefirstinatwo‐partserieswhichis,ultimately,dedicatedtooutliningamethodologyforpredictingfutureoilpricesusingMarkovproperties.Farfrombeinguniqueorinnovative,therehavebeenmanyexcellentacademicworksonthissubjectalreadywritten(seeReferences).However,thedifficultywithacademicpapersisthattheyaretypicallywrittenfortheacademiccommunityandnottheaveragepractitioner.Thispaperissquarelyaimedatprovidingthetypicalfinancialanalyst(whoalreadyhasarudimentaryunderstandingofmatrixalgebraandthebasicqualitiesofMarkovprobabilities)withanoverviewofcreatingaWTI(WestTexasIntermediate)MonteCarlo‐styledoilpricepredictionmodel.
Theprimarydifferencebetweentheapproachtakenherecomparedwiththeacademicpapersisthatthefocusofthisserieswillbeuponforecastingthefuturestatesoftheoutcomes(i.e.directionallythestepsinvolvedingettingfromthecurrentWTIleveltosomefuturepredictionofWTI)comparedwithestimatingthefuturepricelevelofWTI.Mostoftheacademicpapersareintentuponestimatingwhetherfutureoilpricewillbehigherorlowerthancurrentpricesand,ifso,buthowmuch.We,instead,willbeinterestedinpredictingtherandomwalkthatWTIislikelytotakebetweennowandthelong‐termforeseeablefutureratherthanuponattemptingtoestimatethesizeofeachofthosesteps(i.e.themagnitudeofthepricechangeateachpointintime).Onlyafterwehavedevisedapaththatfutureoilpricemovementsarelikelytofollowwillweturnourattentiontothequestionofestimatinghowlargeeachofthosepricechangesreasonablycanbeexpectedtobe.Thepracticalityofthisapproachwillbecomeevidentasthemethodologyisunveiled.
ANOVERVIEWOFTHEMECHANICS
Whiletheexplanationwillbetedious,thedetailsofwhattheMarkovpropertiesareandwhytheyareimportanttothemovementsofoilpricesisunavoidable.Atthesametime,aslittlespaceaspossiblewillbededicatedtowardstheunderlyingtheory–thisseriesisdedicatedtowardscomingupwithapracticalandworkingmodel.
MarkovChainsareprobabilisticmodels/observationsaboutmovementswithinastatespace.Consideringthemovementofoilprices(andweshallonlyconcernourselveswiththemovementofWTI)thereareonlythreestates.Attheendofanygivenday,forexample,theWTIpricecouldhavemovedup,moveddownorstayedthesame,relativetotheclosingpriceofthepreviousday.Thislatterstatewouldbedescribedasa‘loop’–thepriceloopedbacktowhereitwassuchthatthenew‘state’isthesameastheold.
![Page 2: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page2
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
Suchanobservationshouldleadtheanalyticallycurioustothequestion:‘WithwhatfrequencyhaveWTIpricesincreasedinthepastrelativetohowoftentheyhavedeclinedorremainedthesame?’BeingabletoanswerthisquestionmayleadtobeingabletomakebetterpredictionsaboutthefuturepathofWTIprices.IfweabbreviatesuchmovementsasD,S,UforDown,Same,Uprespectively,thenwehaveashorthandmeansofquicklysymbolizinglongstringsorchainsofpricemovements.If,forexample,wearedescribingasequenceofpricechangesoversixdays(i.e.fivemovements)asDDSUD,then,thatmeanstheSeconddayendingpricewasDownfromthefirst;theThirdwasDownfromthesecond;theFourthwastheSameastheThird;theFifthwasUpfromtheFourth;andfinallytheSixwasDownfromtheFifth.
TheprimarycharacteristicofMarkovianmovementsbetweenthevariousstatesisthatonlythecurrentpositionwithinthestatespaceisinanywayrelevanttothenextmovement.Intheexampleabove,ifweareattemptingtopredictwhereWTIwillbeattheendofDaySeven(eitherD,S,orUrelativetoDaySix),theonlyinformationthatisusefulinmakingthatpredictionisthatDaySixendedasa“D”day.ThefactthatthepreviousfourmovementspriortoDaySixwereDDSUinnowayimprovesourstatisticalchancesofcorrectlyestimatinghowDaySevenwillend.AnotherwaytosaythisisthatXXXXDD(whereDaySevenendsasa‘Down’Day,forexample)hasjustasmuchprobabilityofoccurringasDDSUDDorUUUUDDorUSDSDDoranypermutationwhereXXXXrepresentsanyrandomstringof“D”,”S”,”U”(andthemathematicallyastutewillrecognizethatthereare3^4=81permutationspossiblehere).InotherwordsthehistoryorpaththatWTIpricestookbeforearrivingattheDofDaySixhasnobearinguponthedirectionthatpriceswilltakeonDaySeven.AnotherwayofsayingthisisthatthepricemovementonDaySeveniscompletelyindependentofthedirectionofthepricemovementsatanytimepriortoDaySix.
WhyshouldwecareifWTIpricesexhibitMarkoviancharacteristics?Because,ifWTIpricesareindependentofthepathupontheytooktogettothecurrentstateANDwecanidentifyordetermineaprobabilityforwhichstatetheymightnextmoveto,thenthiswillquiteeasilyallowustobuildasimpleprobabilisticmodelforpredictingwhereWTIpricesmaybegoing.Conversely,if
CurrentWTIPrice
FIGURE1
NewHigherPrice(U)
NewLowerPrice(D)
PriceStaysSame(S)
![Page 3: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page3
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
WTIpricesarepathdependent,thenthelevelofcomplexityinvolvedincalculatingwheretheycannextbeexpectedtomovetoincreasesexponentially.Imagine,forexample,thatitisnowDaySixwhichhasendedasaDDayandtheprobabilityofwherepricemayendtomorrowisdependentuponthepathpricestookinthepreviousfivedays(i.e.thefourpricemovementspriortothe“D”ofDaySix).Thatwouldmeanthateachofthepossible81differentpricepathsthatmayhaveoccurredinthelastfivedayscouldhaveitsownuniqueprobabilityindeterminingwherepricemovestoonDaySeven.Andnowimaginehowcomplexitmaybetopredictpricemovementsiftomorrow’spricewereinsomewaydependentuponwhichpricepathhadbeentakenovertheprior50or100or1,000tradingdays?Thatwouldbe3^49or3^99or3^999possiblepermutationsrespectively–numberstoolargetocomprehend,muchlessassignprobabilitiesto.
SowewantWTIpricemovementstopossessMarkoviancharacteristics,butwecannotsimplyassumethattheydo.SomeformaltestprocedureneedstobeappliedtoempiricalWTIhistoricdatainordertoassessifthosemovementshavefollowedaMarkovchain(i.e.arepathindependent)
ANINTUITIVEAPPROACH
EvenbeforeconsideringamorerigorousapproachthatinvolvestheuseofmatrixalgebraandtheChi‐squaretest,thereisanintuitiveapproachthatshouldallowustosetalower‐boundaryabouttheprice‐pathdependencyofhistoricWTIpricemovements.WhilethisinformalmethodwillnotallowustoabsolutelyconcludethatWTIpricemovementsdofollowaMarkovchain,itwillalertusintheeventthattheyclearlydonot.
IfWTIpricemovementsareMarkovianandprice‐pathindependent,thenitisonlythecurrentstatethathasanybearinguponwherepricewillmovenext.Thismeansthat,selectingasub‐sampleof,sayDD,pricemovementsfromaverylargesampleofWTIpricehistorywewouldexpecttofindthesamerelativefrequencyofDDpricechainsastheoccurrenceofXDDpricechains.Thatis,giventhattheprobabilityforpricestodeclinetwiceinsuccession(whichnecessarilywouldrequirea3dayobservationperiod),wewouldexpecttofindthesameprobabilityforanXDDpricechaintooccuroverafourdayobservationperiod(wherethe“X”couldrepresenteitheraUp,DownorSamemovement).Ifthiswerenotthecase,thenonemightbegintosuspectthatprice‐pathhadsomebearinguponwhatcoursethethirdpricemovementtook.
Expandingthislogic,ifposthocWTIpricemovementsareprice‐pathindependent,wewouldexpectXXDDtooccurwiththesamerelativefrequenciesasDDchains.And,similarly,XXXXXXXDDtendayobservationsshouldoccurwiththesamefrequencyandsoshouldone‐hundred‐daychainsendinginDDoccurinjustthesamefrequency.1
1Thecaveathereisthatwearespeakingaboutrelativefrequency.If,forexample,oursubsampleis1,001dayslong,thereare1,000chainsoflengthtwopossible.Thisisbecause,onthefirstday,thereisnomovement,soittakestwodaysuponwhichtoobservethefirstmovement.Sequentially,then1,000two‐periodchainscouldbeobservedovera1,001daysubsample.Ifnisthenumberofdaysinthesubsample,andkisthelengthofthechain,then,n‐(k‐1)=numberofchainspossible.Therefore,1,001–(2–1)=1,000.Similarly,ifwewanttoobservethefrequencyoflengththreechains,nowtherewouldonlybe1,001–(3–1)=999chainspossible.InthatcasewemaybemeasuringtheratioofXDDchainsthatoccurover999possible
![Page 4: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page4
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
EIAEMPIRICALEVIDENCE:TheU.S.EnergyInformationAdministration(EIA)maintainsalargedatabaseofhistoricalWTIprices(spotprices,measuredatCushing,OK)andmakesthatavailableforeasydownloadineither,daily,weeklyormonth‐endform.ThatdatabasebeginsonJan.2,1986andthereforeincludesapproximately7,100tradingdayobservationsuptopresentday(thispaperwaswritteninearlyMay,2014).Bydrawingourconclusionsfroma28yearsample,weareimplicitlyconditioningourresultstobelong‐termedinnature.Anysingle‐eventWTIpriceshockthathasoccurredsinceJanuary1986will,tosomeextent,bereflectedinthedata–buttemperedbythelong‐termstatusquo.Similarly,anyshortormid‐termcyclesthattheWTIhasexhibitedwillbesomewhatmitigatedinourresults.Hadwewantedtoconstructamid‐termestimatorofWTIprices,wewouldhavebeenfacedwiththedifficultyofdecidingwhichportionofthehistoricdatabestreflectedtheexpectedcharacteristicsoftheforthcomingmid‐term.Wewill,however,examinethedataforshortandlong‐termvolatility,withtheintentofidentifyinganypermanenttransitionsthatmayhaveoccurredovertime.Butwewillnotdosountilafterourobservationsaboutfrequencyhasbeenpresented.
outcomes.Similarly,achainoflength100(i.e.wouldrequire101observationdays)couldonlypossiblyoccur1,001–(100–1)=902inthissubsampleandthereforeitwouldbefrequencyofthenumberlength100chainsendinginDDrelativetothe902possibleoutcomesofachainthislengththatwouldprovidetheimportantstatisticinthiscase.
![Page 5: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page5
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
TABLE1:FREQUENCYOF‘XX’ENDINGCHAINSINEIADATA
Two Day Chains:
Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n + 1) Observation
D 22.11% 0.71% 24.63%
S 0.83% 0.07% 0.84%
U 24.50% 0.95% 25.37%
Ten Day Chains:
Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n + 1) Observation
D 22.10% 0.71% 24.63%
S 0.83% 0.07% 0.84%
U 24.50% 0.95% 25.37%
One-Hundred Day Chains:
Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n + 1) Observation
D 22.03% 0.71% 24.67%
S 0.82% 0.07% 0.84%
U 24.54% 0.95% 25.37%
One-Thousand Day Chains:
Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n + 1) Observation
D 22.49% 0.60% 24.67%
S 0.65% 0.08% 0.72%
U 24.61% 0.76% 25.42%
Lookingfirstatthe2DayChaindata,attheintersectionofDD,thistellsusgivenallthepossible2daychainsthatcouldhavebeenobservedintheEIAdata(therewere7,143)22.11%ofthetimeaDownmovementonDaynwasfollowedbyasubsequentDownmovement(i.e.DD)onDayn+1.Similarly,25.37%ofthetimeanUpmovementwasfollowed,onthenextday,byanotherUpmovement(i.e.UU).Movingtothedatarepresentingthe1,000daychainswefindthat,ofallthepossible1,000daychainsthatcouldhavebeenobservedinthatdata(ofwhichtherewere7,144–(1000–1)=6,145uniqueobservations),weseeverysimilarstatisticsasthein2Dayobservations.Thereisroughlya22.5%chanceofobservinga1,000daychainthatendsinDD.Thereisonlyasixth‐tenthsofone‐percentchanceofobservinga1,000daychainthatendsinSD.And,thereisapproximatelya25.4%chanceofa1,000daychainendinginUU.Theseareverysimilarnumberstotheobservationsinthe2daychainswhichare,inturn,veryclosetothosestatisticsobservedwiththe10daychains
![Page 6: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page6
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
andthe100daychains.Hadweobservedadramaticallychangingstatisticasthechainsgotlonger,wemighthavebeguntosuspectthattheWTImovesinaprice‐pathdependentmanner.Butthedailyoutcomes2haveremainedremarkablyconsistentregardlessofthelengthofthechain,thereforeitisappropriatetodosomemoreformaltesting.
MARKOVPROBABILITIESINMATRIXFORM
ItisconvenienttopresentMarkovsingle‐stagedatainMatrixform.Foreaseofexposition,wewillspeakofthedailypricemovementswhenexplainingthemethodology,butlatertheweeklyobservationswillalsobepresentedandcomparedtothedaily.Therearetwopresentationalternativespossible(oneisthetranspositionoftheother)andafewwordsonMatrixprotocolareprobablyinorder.
FIGURE2
Day n Observations
Down Same Up
Day (n +1) Observations
Down DD SD UD
Same DS SS US
Up DU SU UU
100% 100% 100%
Day (n + 1) Observations Down Same Up
Day n Observations
Down DD DS DU 100% Same SD SS SU 100%
Up UD US UU 100% Thedifferencebetweenthetwopresentationsabovedealswithwhetherweareidentifyingthe‘Dayn’observationsasrowsandthe‘Dayn+1’observationsascolumns,ortheotherwayaround.Theconventionusuallyistheformer,‘Dayn’arerows,‘Dayn+1’arecolumnsand,asaresult,thetotalofeachrowsumsto100%.Thedifferencebetweenthetwoisamatterofpersonalpreference,butitisimportanttokeepinmindthatthestatisticweareinterestedinisthatgiventhatweareatcurrentstateXasat‘Dayn’,wewishtoknowtheprobabilityofmovingtostateXon‘Dayn+1’.Forexample,giventhatwehaveobserveda‘DState’on‘Dayn’weareinterestedinlearningthe
2ForreasonsofspacetheweeklystatisticswillnotbepresentedherebyreservedforAppendix1.Similartothedailystats,thereisagooddealofconsistencymovingbetweenthelengthsofchains.OnenotabledistinctionbetweentheDailyandWeeklyobservationswasthatitwasnoticeablymorelikelyforatwo‐weekchaintofinishonaUU(about30%ofthetime),thanitwasforatwo‐daychaintodoso(onlyabout25%ofthetime).
![Page 7: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page7
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
frequencywithwhichthistransitionstoa‘DU’chain,forexample,onDayn+1.Therefore,thesumofallthe‘DX’chainsinthatsubsampletotal100%(which,bydefinition,theymust).Itwouldbeamistaketoobtaintheteststatisticinthewrongorder.Forexample,todeterminethefrequencyof‘XD’.Inwordsthiswouldbeakintoaskingourselves,giventhefactthat‘Dayn’hasendedinthe‘DState’whatistheprobabilityofobservingthe‘XState’on‘Dayn–1’?SuchanobservationwouldnotbeinaccordancewithMarkoviancharacteristics.Forreasonsofpersonalpreference,thispaperwillusetheunconventionalDaynObservationsascolumns(ergo,theColumnswillsumto100%),andapologizesareofferedtothosereadersmoreaccustomedtothemorefrequentformwheretherowssumto100%.
MARKOVPROBABILITIESOBSERVEDINWTIPRICEMOVEMENTSSINCE1986
ThefollowingtableshowstheprobabilityofobservinganXpricemovementonDayn+1giventheoccurrenceofanXmovementontheprecedingday:
![Page 8: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page8
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
TABLE2:MARKOVPROBABILITIESINWTI
2 Day Chain3 Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 46.61% 41.13% 48.44% S 1.74% 4.03% 1.65% U 51.65% 54.84% 49.90%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
10 Day Chain Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 46.60% 41.13% 48.44% S 1.74% 4.03% 1.65% U 51.66% 54.84% 49.90%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
100 Day Chain Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 46.48% 40.98% 48.49% S 1.74% 4.10% 1.65% U 51.78% 54.92% 49.86%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
1000 Day Chain Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 47.10% 41.57% 48.56% S 1.36% 5.62% 1.41% U 51.53% 52.81% 50.03%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
3Somelicenceistakenwiththenamingconventionhere.Recognizethatanobservationoftwoperiods(e.g.SU)requiresthreeseparatedaysbecauseitcanonlybeknownwhatthe‘n’daymovementisattheendofthesecondday.Similarly,then+1dayobservationcanonlybecompletedatendofdaythree.Therefore,whenwespeakofaTwoDayChain,wereallymeanthreedayshaveelapsed.Further,forthe10‐DayChain,Day‘n’istheobservationtakenonDay10(the9thpricemovement)andDay(n+1)istheobservationtakenonDay11.Usingposthocdatalookingbackwards,wearealwaysinterestedintheXXmovementsattheendofthechain.ThiswillnotbethecasewhenweuseMarkovprobabilitiestopredictfuturepricemovements.
![Page 9: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page9
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
Similartoourobservationsregardingthesimplefrequenciestable,wenotethattheMarkovprobabilitiesalsodisplayasurprisingconsistencyregardlessofhowlongthepricemovementchainis.Itisnotasintuitivelyobvious,inthiscasewhetherthisconsistencyisagoodthingornot.However,thestatisticalinterpretationofoutcomesissimilar.Lookingatthe2DayChaindata,forexample,ofalltheoccasionswhereanoccurrenceofDXwasobserved,46.60%ofthosetimesresultedinaDDobservation,1.74%ofthetimeaDSwasobservedand51.65%ofthetimesaDUeventhadoccurred.BeforeproceedingonwithamoreindepthdescriptionofMarkovprobabilitiesandhowtheymightbetested,itwillbeusefultodigresstoacomparisonoftheDailyvs.WeeklyMarkovMatricesasthisinformationwillbecomerelevantlaterinthediscussion.ThefollowingissimplyarepeatofTable2asabove,exceptnowtheweek‐endclosingpricedatahasbeenjuxtaposed(ontheright)alongsidethedailydata:
![Page 10: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page10
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
TABLE3:DAILYVSWEEKLYMARKOVPROBABILITIES
Daily WTI Price Chain Data Weekly (i.e. week-ending) WTI Price Chain Data 2 Day Chain 2 Week Chain
Day n Observation Weekly n Observation
D S U D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 46.61% 41.13% 48.44% Weekly (n +1) Observations
D 51.66% 50.00% 42.51%
S 1.74% 4.03% 1.65% S 0.58% 0.00% 0.26%
U 51.65% 54.84% 49.90% U 47.76% 50.00% 57.23%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
10 Day Chain 10 Week Chain Day n Observation Weekly n Observation
D S U D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 46.60% 41.13% 48.44% Weekly (n +1) Observations
D 51.17% 50.00% 42.44%
S 1.74% 4.03% 1.65% S 0.59% 0.00% 0.26%
U 51.66% 54.84% 49.90% U 48.25% 50.00% 57.31%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
100 Day Chain 100 Week Chain Day n Observation Weekly n Observation
D S U D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 46.48% 40.98% 48.49% Weekly (n +1) Observations
D 51.55% 50.00% 42.47%
S 1.74% 4.10% 1.65% S 0.62% 0.00% 0.27%
U 51.78% 54.92% 49.86% U 47.83% 50.00% 57.26%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
1000 Day Chain 1000 Week Chain Day n Observation Weekly n Observation
D S U D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 47.10% 41.57% 48.56% Weekly (n +1) Observations
D 51.14% 0.00% 41.54%
S 1.36% 5.62% 1.41% S 0.46% 0.00% 0.00%
U 51.53% 52.81% 50.03% U 48.40% 100.00% 58.46%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
Salientobservationsincomparingthedailyvs.weeklyprobabilitiesare:
1. GiventhataparticularweekhasendedinaUstate,itisabout8%morelikelythatitwillbefollowedbyanotherUweek‐endthanisitthecasethataUUoccurrencewouldbeobservedinthedailydata.
2. Thecorollaryisthat,giventhataweekhasendedinaDstate,itismarginallylesslikelythatitwillbefollowedbyaU(DU’sonlyoccurapproximately48%ofthetimeintheweekly
![Page 11: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page11
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
data)thanwouldbethecaseinthedaily(whereDU’soccurapproximately52%ofthetime).
TheotherreadilyapparentobservationwecanmakeabouttheWeeklyData,isthatthismuchlessstabilityintheoccurrenceoftheSXchains.Thisstandstoreasonbecausethenumberofoccasionsuponwhichthefirstweekwillendatexactlythesamepriceasthestartingobservationwillbequiterare.
THEMARKOVTRANSITIONMATRIX
Ifweacceptthatonlythecurrentstateisanindicatorofwherethenextstateislikelytobe(and,therefore,allthepreviouspricemovementspriortothecurrentstatehavenobearinginthematter),thenthereisasinglematrixthatwillencapsulateallthatcanbeknownaboutprobablepricemovements.ThisiscalledtheTransitionMatrixand,inthecaseofthedailyWTIpricedataisrepresentedby:
TABLE4:MARKOVTRANSITIONMATRIX
2 Day Chain Day n Observation
D S U
Day (n +1) Observations
D 46.61% 41.13% 48.44% S 1.74% 4.03% 1.65% U 51.65% 54.84% 49.90%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
Thistellsusthat,giventhatwehavealreadyobservedaDmovementtoday(onDayn),thereisa46.61%probabilityofanotherDmovementhappeningtomorrow(onDay(n+1)).Butdoesitgiveusanypredictiveinsightintowhatislikelytohappenthedayaftertomorrow(onDay(n+2))?Forexample,giventhattodayaDmovementhasalreadyoccurred,whatistheprobabilitythatanotherDmovementwilloccurtomorrowfollowedbyanotherDmovementthedayafterthat?Well,todayweknowthereisa46.61%probabilitythatasubsequentDwilloccuronDay(n+1)andthentomorrow,giventhataDmovementhadalreadyhappenedonthatday,theprobabilityofanotherD(onDay(n+2))is46.61%again.So,theprobabilityofaDDDis46.61%^2=21.7249%ButwhatifwewereattemptingtopredictthemorerelevantinstancewhereweknowtodayhasendedwithaDmovement(forexample),butwewishtopredictifDay(n+2)wouldendwithaDmovement?Symbolically,thiscanberepresentedbythechainDXD.TheprobabilityofobservingaDonDay(n+2)giventhataDhasoccurredonDaynmustbethesumoftheprobabilities:DDD+DSD+DUD.ThesearetheonlythreepathsbeginningwiththecurrentstateofDthatwillallowustofinishwithaDonDay(n+2).Usingthe2DayprobabilitiesfromtheTransitionMatrix,wecancalculatethisprobabilityas:
![Page 12: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page12
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
DDD=(DD)x(DD) =46.61%x46.61% =21.7249% DSD= (DS)x(SD) =1.74%x41.13% =0.7157% DUD=(DU)x(UD) =51.65%x48.44% =25.0193% PROBABILITYOFDXD =47.46%4Markovchainshavethissomewhatcounter‐intuitiveandironicquality:pastmovementshavenopredictivepower–knowingthepricepathuponwhichtoday’sstatecameintobeingisofnopracticalassistanceinestimatingwhattomorrow’spricemovementwillbe–onlytoday’sstatehasanybearingupontomorrow.Andyet,whenestimatingfurtherforward,saytothedayaftertomorrow,thenthepricepathdoesbecomerelevant.Thisisbecausetomorrow’sstateisdependentuponwhatstateweareattodayandsotoowillbethestateonDay(n+2)becauseweareattemptingtopredictitpriortoknowingwithabsolutecertaintyhowtomorrowwillend.Thisisthe‘chain‐like’featureofMarkovchains.WhilewecouldcontinuetocalculateallthepossiblepathsremainingaswedidaboveforDXD,namely:DXS,DXU,SXD,SXS,SXU,UXD,UXSandUXU,itwillbeeasieratthispointjusttonotethat,becauseofthemarvelsofmatrixalgebra,alltheseoutcomeswillbeprovidedsimplybyraisingtheTransitionMatrixtothepoweroftwo:FIGURE3:TRANSITIONMATRIXRAISEDTO2NDPOWER
Matrix A Matrix A2 D S U D S U
D 46.61% 41.13% 48.44% ^2 47.46% 47.39% 47.43%S 1.74% 4.03% 1.65% = 1.73% 1.78% 1.73%U 51.65% 54.84% 49.90% 50.81% 50.82% 50.83%Therefore,if,onDaynweareinStateS,andweareattemptingtoestimatewhattheprobabilityisthatDay(n+2)willendalsoinStateS,MatrixA2tellsusthereisa1.78%chanceofthatoccurring.And,itshouldbereadilyapparentthatestimatingtheoutcomeonDay(n+3)isrepresentedinMatrixA3andthattheprobableoutcomesonDay(n+100)arecapturedinMatrixA100,etc.Therefore,ifwewishtoknowwhattheprobabilityisthatWTIwillcloseeitherinanD,SorUstate1,000dayshence,weonlyneedaninexpensivematrixcalculatortokeyinMatrixAasaboveandraisethistothepowerof1,000.Couldanyapproachbesimpler?Inthiscase,theanswerisYES,because,aswewillnextdiscuss,theprocessveryquicklyapproachesasteadystate.
STEADYSTATELIMITVALUEOFTRANSITIONMATRIX
Ignoringallthereasoningastowhythisistrue5,itturnsoutthat,iftheTransitionMatrixis‘regular’(meaningallitselementsarepositive–and,ofcourse,thecolumnsallsumto1),thenraisingthe
4ThosewithagreaterfamiliarityofMatrixAlgebrawillrecognizethisasthedotproductofthefirstcolumnandthetranspositionofthefirstrow.
![Page 13: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page13
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
matrixtoincreasinglylargerpowerswilleventuallybringittoa‘steadystate’whereinalltheelementsapproachalimitingvalue(referredtoasanasymptoticquality).Asithappens,theWTItransitionmatrixreachesitslimitveryquickly(inlessthan5days),ascanbeseenbelow:
5Thesteady‐statevectorcanbefoundbyfirstfindingtheeigenvectorresultingfromtheeigenvalue+1.Thiseigenvectorwillbeamultipleofthesteady‐statevectorwhichcanbefoundbyscalingitscomponentssuchthattheysumto1.
![Page 14: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page14
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
TABLE5:TRANISITIONMATRIXRAISEDTOINCREASINGPOWERS
Matrix A
D S U
D 46.61% 41.13% 48.44%
S 1.74% 4.03% 1.65%
U 51.65% 54.84% 49.90%
Matrix A2
D S U
D 47.46% 47.39% 47.43%
S 1.73% 1.78% 1.73%
U 50.81% 50.82% 50.83%
Matrix A3
D S U
D 47.44% 47.44% 47.45%
S 1.74% 1.74% 1.74%
U 50.82% 50.82% 50.82%
Matrix A4
D S U
D 47.44% 47.44% 47.44%
S 1.74% 1.74% 1.74%
U 50.82% 50.82% 50.82%
Matrix A10
D S U
D 47.44% 47.44% 47.44%
S 1.74% 1.74% 1.74%
U 50.82% 50.82% 50.82%
Matrix A100
D S U
D 47.44% 47.44% 47.44%
S 1.74% 1.74% 1.74%
U 50.82% 50.82% 50.82%
Matrix A1000
D S U
D 47.44% 47.44% 47.44%
S 1.74% 1.74% 1.74%
U 50.82% 50.82% 50.82%
![Page 15: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page15
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
ItcanbeseenintheabovethattheWTIsteadystateisachievedbyDay(n+4)–theprobabilitiesinMatrixAraisedtothe4thpowerareexactlythesamewhenraisedtothe10th,100thor1,000thpower.Noteaswellthattheprobabilitiesineachofthecolumnsduplicateeachother–thismeansthat,bythefourthday,itdoesnotmatterwhattheinitialstatewas–theoutcomeprobabilitiesarethesameregardlessofwhereonestarted.Therefore,forlong‐termestimation,oneneednottakeintoaccountthestartingstate,theprobabilityofexperiencingaD,SorUonanygivendayinthefutureremainsstatic,namely;D=47.44%,S=1.74%,andU=50.82%6Similarly,fortheWeeklyData,theTransitionMatrixcanbeseeninTable3above(theTwo‐Weekmatrix)andthismatrixisalsoquicklyasymptotic,reachingasteady‐stateafterbeingraisedtothepowerofseven.TABLE6:WEEKLYSTEADYSTATEPROBABILITIES
Weekly Data - Steady State
D S U
D 46.827% 46.827% 46.827%
S 0.406% 0.406% 0.406%
U 52.767% 52.767% 52.767%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
CHI‐SQUARETESTS
Atlastwehavesufficientbackgroundtoattendtotheinitialquestion:“DoWTIoilpricemovementsfollowaMarkovChain?”TheChi‐Squarestatisticisagoodness‐of‐fittestthatwecanusetoaskthequestion;‘Howlikelyisit,baseduponrandomvariationalone,thattheobservedWTIoutcomeswoulddifferasmuchastheydofromtheexpectedoutcomes–assumingthatWTIpricedoesmoveinaMarkovchain?’TheChi‐squarestatisticis:
² ∑
However,onecannotuse‘scaled’orproportionateinputsforthechi‐squarecalculation–thepercentagedatathathasbeensoconvenienttouseinmatrixformuptothispointwillgive
6Somemaypointoutthatthesesteady‐stateprobabilitiesderivedfromtheTransitionMatrixaresimplythesumoftherowsintheveryfirst2‐dayfrequencystatisticsfromTable1.D=47.45%=(22.11%+0.71%+24.63%);S=1.74%=(0.83%+0.07%+0.84%);U=50.82%=(24.50%+0.95%+25.37%).Thisisoftenthecasewithmoresophisticatedmeasurementfunctions–theyonlyservetoconfirmwhatweintuitivelywouldhavesuspectedtobethetruthbutwithoutstatisticalproof.Withonlytherelativefrequencies,forexample,wedidnotknowthattheMarkovprobabilitieswouldconvergetoasteady‐statelimitorhowquicklythismayhappen.
![Page 16: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page16
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
erroneouschi‐squarestatistics.7Wemustactuallyusethecountdata,which,forexample,forthetenday‐chain,was:TABLE7
10 Day-Chain Observations
D S U
D 1,577 51 1,757
S 59 5 60
U 1,748 68 1,810
3,384 124 3,627
Theten‐dayexpectedmatrixdataisafunctionoftheA10matrixinTable5–thatis,iftheWTIpricesdofollowaMarkovchain,wewouldexpectthepossibilityofaDstateonday10tobe47.44%(regardlessofthestartingstate),anSoutcomewouldoccur1.74%ofthetimeand,finallyanUoutcomehastheprobabilityof50.82%.Thisinformation,combinedwiththefactthatweknowtherewere7,13510‐daychainsinthehistoricdata(simplythesumofthecolumntotalsfromTable6)leadsustotheconclusionthatthe10‐DayExpectedMatrixwouldbe:TABLE8
10-Day Expected Outcome
D S U
D 1,606 59 1,721
S 59 2 63
U 1,720 63 1,843
3,385 124 3,627
Theresultingchi‐squarestatisticfromthecomparisonofthesetwomatricesis8.44.Applicable‘DegreesofFreedom‘forthistestis8.8Wewillassumea.05or5%alphasignificance.OurnullhypothesisisthattheWTIpricesdofollowaMarkovchainandthereforeanyvariancewefindbetweentheactualobservedcountsandthehypotheticallyexpectedarejusttheresultofrandomvariation(i.e.chance).Thechi‐squarestatisticcalculateshowprobableitwouldbetoencounterthecalculatedvariancejustbaseduponrandomchancealone.Ifwefindthatthereislessthana5%chancethatsuchachi‐squareoutcomecouldbeobservedasaresultofrandomchance,thenwemustrejectthenullhypothesisandconcludethatWTIpricesdonotfollowaMarkovchain.ConsultingaChi‐squaretablequicklyshowsthat,at8dfandχ2=8.44thestatisticiswellabovethe25%probabilitymark(anyreliablestatisticssoftwarepackagewillreportthattheactualprobabilityis39.1%).Therefore,baseduponthe10‐daychainalone,wewouldnotrejecttheconclusionthatWTIpricesfollowaMarkovchain.
7Specifically,alltheexpectedcountsmustbe>thanone–andbydefinitionaprobability%willnotqualify.8ThereisoftenconsiderableconfusionaboutDegreesofFreedom(df)forthechi‐squaretests.Theissuedependsuponwhetherasingle‐sampletestofindependenceisbeingperformed(inwhichcase,therelevantdfwouldbe(rows–1)(columns–1)andwouldamountto4fortheabove.However,agoodness‐of‐fittestisacomparisonbetweentwosamples:theactualobservedandthehypotheticallyexpected,thereforethedfis(k–1)wherekisthenumberofcellsinthetwo‐waytable.
![Page 17: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page17
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
Similarly,theχ2wascalculatedforallthe10‐Day,100‐Dayand1,000‐Dayand10‐Week,100‐Weekand1,000‐Weekchains.Innocasewastherereasontorejectthenullhypothesis.WhilewecanreasonablyconcludethatWTIpricesdofollowaMarkovchain9,wearemoreinterestedintheresultsofthelonger1,000‐periodchainsasweareattemptingtomodellong‐term,ratherthanshorttermWTIprices.
9Tobeprecise,wehavenoevidencetorejecttheassumptionthatWTIfollowsaMarkovchain.ThisisdecidedlydifferentthanhavingproofpositivethatWTIdoesfollowaMarkovchain.
![Page 18: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page18
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
TABLE9:CHI‐SQUARESTATISTICS
Chi-square results (8 df) CHAIN LENGTH χ2 α Prob. Reject Ho?
10-Day Chains 8.45 39.1% No
100-Day Chains 8.89 35.2% No
1000-Day Chains 11.00 20.2% No
10-Week Chains 12.68 12.3% No
100-Week Chains 12.90 11.5% No
1000-Week Chains 6.78 56.1% No
TIMEHOMOGENEITY
OneoftherequirementsofMarkovprobabilitiesistheassumptionoftimehomogeneity.Thatis,theprobabilityofmovingfromagivenstatetothenextstateisassumedtoremainconstantovertime.InthecaseofWTIpricemovements,wecanspeculatethatthisisarequirementthatisnotstrictlyadheredto.Weknowforcertain,forexample,thatWTIpricesexhibitsperiodsofgreaterandlesservolatility(seeFigure4).TheseperiodsmayalsobeassociatedwithvaryingprobabilitiesbetweenD,S,andUstates.Wemightalsospeculatethat,duringtimesofeconomicboon,thefrequencyofUmovementsincreasesand,correspondingly,theDfrequencymayincreaseduringperiodsofeconomicrecession.Thepertinentquestionbecomes:‘HowmightthisinfractionofthetimehomogeneityrequirementimpairourabilitytouseaMarkovprobabilitymodeltopredictfuturepricesteps?
Theanswertothisquestionisbeyondthescopeofthispaperandiscertainlydeservingofapaperallonitsown.Sufficeittosaythat,onayear‐over‐yearbasis,thereisconsiderablevariationamongstthestatespaceprobabilities.Completedetailsofall28individualyearsareprovidedinAppendix2.Tohighlightthedailyextremes,however,insomeyearstheDDchainrepresentedasmuchas54.5%ofallDXmovementswhereasinothersitdroppedtoonly36.8%.InpeakyearstheUUchainoccurred61.7%ofallUXmovementsandthisdroppedtoaslowas38.8%inotheryears.
Inspiteofdemonstratingloweroverallpricevolatility,theweeklychaindatademonstratedanevengreatervariance.InsomeyearstheDDchainrepresented71%ofallpossibleDXoutcomeswhereasinothersitdroppedto23.5%.Attheotherextreme,UUchainsrangedbetweenahighof71%ofallUXoutcomestoalowof36.8%.
Iftherelevantperioduponwhichtomeasuretimehomogeneityisone‐yearinlength,thenwecandefinitelyconcludethattheWTIpricemovementsarecompromisedinthischaracteristic.WTIpricemovementsdonotadheretoahomogenousprobabilitymatrixthroughtime.
![Page 19: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page19
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
FIGURE410
CONCLUSIONS
ThispaperhasdiscussedtheprimarycharacteristicsofMarkovchainsandhowtheymayapplytothemovementofWTIpricesbetweenprice“states”(Down,SameandUp).ThemostimportantMarkovpropertyisthatonlythecurrentstatehasanypredictivebearinguponthenextstate–allpreviouspricemovementsbeforethecurrentstateareirrelevantinthepredictionofwhereWTIpricemaygonext.WetestedfortheexistenceofaMarkovchainusingsimplestatisticsaswellasviaaformalChi‐squareapproachandfound,inallcases,thattheWTIpricemovementsdostronglyexhibitthisqualityofaMarkovchain.Further,weidentifiedthetransitionmatrixforboththedailyandweeklyMarkovprobabilitiesandfoundthat,inbothcases,theasymptoticlimitsarequicklyachievedandasteadystateisrealizedonlyafterafewfutureperiods.Aconfoundingcomplexity,however,isthattheposthocWTIhistoricaldatadoesnotdemonstratetimehomogeneity.Infact,thereisconsiderablevariationinthesingleyearMarkovprobabilitiesovertimeanditremainstobeseenjusthowsuchadefectwillimpairourabilitytoreasonablypredictfutureWTIstates.
10Theweeklyvolatilityparallelstheebbsandflowsofdailydata,butisexpectedlylessineachyear.Thisisbecausethedailyfluctuationsadds‘noise’tothevolatilitycalculation.
0.00%
10.00%
20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00%
60.00%
70.00%
80.00%1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
Annual WTI Price Volatility: Daily vs. Weekly Data
Daily Data: Annualized Single‐Year WTI Volatility
Weekly Data: Annualized Single‐Year WTI Volatility
![Page 20: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page20
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
Wehavenotyetbeguntoconsiderhowlargethesizeofeachstepbetweenthevariousstatesshouldbe(i.e.thedollaramountofaUorDmove).Thistopicislefttobeinvestigatedinthefollowingpaper.
WehavediscussedtheconceptualissuessurroundingMarkovprobabilitiesandmatrixalgebrasufficientlythatweshouldnowbeabletoapplythesteady‐stateprobabilitiesinanactualMonteCarlomodeldesignedtopredictfuturestatesoftheWTIpricemovements.Thiswillbethesubjectofthenextandconcludingpaperinthisseries.
![Page 21: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page21
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
APPENDIX1
WEEKLY DATA: Frequency of 'XX' Ending Chains in EIA Data
Two-Week Chains Week n Observation
D S U
Week (n + 1) Observation
D 24.15% 0.20% 22.46%S 0.27% 0.00% 0.14%U 22.33% 0.20% 30.24%
100% *
Ten-Week Chains Week n Observation
D S U
Week (n + 1) Observation
D 23.81% 0.20% 22.52%S 0.27% 0.00% 0.14%U 22.45% 0.20% 30.41%
100% *
Ten-Week Chains Week n Observation
D S U
Week (n + 1) Observation
D 24.06% 0.22% 22.46%S 0.29% 0.00% 0.14%U 22.32% 0.22% 30.29%
100% *
Ten-Week Chains Week n Observation
D S U
Week (n + 1) Observation
D 23.33% 0.00% 22.50%S 0.21% 0.00% 0.00%U 22.08% 0.21% 31.67%
100% * * The sum of all 9 observations total 100% as expected
![Page 22: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page22
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
APPENDIX2
APPENDIX 2: ANNUAL MARKOV PROBABILITIES 1986 THROUGH 2013 DAILY DATA WEEKLY DATA
YEAR YEAR
1986 D S U 1986 D S U
D 49.57% 33.33% 45.16% D 56.00% 0.00% 42.31%
S 3.42% 0.00% 4.03% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 47.01% 66.67% 50.81% U 44.00% 0.00% 57.69%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1987 D S U 1987 D S U
D 50.00% 50.00% 44.26% D 53.85% 0.00% 46.15%
S 5.00% 0.00% 4.92% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 45.00% 50.00% 50.82% U 46.15% 0.00% 53.85%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1988 D S U 1988 D S U
D 36.84% 50.00% 50.37% D 45.83% 0.00% 44.83%
S 4.39% 0.00% 0.73% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 58.77% 50.00% 48.91% U 54.17% 0.00% 55.17%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1989 D S U 1989 D S U
D 38.26% 25.00% 51.49% D 42.86% 0.00% 38.71%
S 3.48% 0.00% 2.99% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 58.26% 75.00% 45.52% U 57.14% 0.00% 61.29%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1990 D S U 1990 D S U
D 50.39% 40.00% 51.22% D 46.15% 0.00% 57.69%
S 2.33% 0.00% 1.63% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 47.29% 60.00% 47.15% U 53.85% 0.00% 42.31%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1991 D S U 1991 D S U
D 43.44% 50.00% 50.78% D 53.85% 0.00% 42.31%
S 3.28% 0.00% 1.56% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 53.28% 50.00% 47.66% U 46.15% 0.00% 57.69%
![Page 23: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page23
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
APPENDIX 2: ANNUAL MARKOV PROBABILITIES 1986 THROUGH 2013 DAILY DATA WEEKLY DATA
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1992 D S U 1992 D S U
D 45.24% 54.55% 53.33% D 52.17% 50.00% 40.74%
S 2.38% 0.00% 6.67% S 4.35% 0.00% 3.70%
U 52.38% 45.46% 40.00% U 43.48% 50.00% 55.56%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
1993 D S U 1993 D S U
D 50.00% 14.29% 61.68% D 61.77% 0.00% 63.16%
S 2.94% 14.29% 1.87% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 47.06% 71.43% 36.45% U 38.24% 0.00% 36.84%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1994 D S U 1994 D S U
D 51.24% 0.00% 46.51% D 31.58% 0.00% 42.42%
S 0.83% 0.00% 0.78% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 47.93% 100.00% 52.71% U 68.42% 0.00% 57.58%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1995 D S U 1995 D S U
D 44.14% 33.33% 44.03% D 45.83% 0.00% 42.86%
S 1.80% 0.00% 2.99% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 54.05% 66.67% 52.99% U 54.17% 0.00% 57.14%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1996 D S U 1996 D S U
D 42.59% 33.33% 43.57% D 42.86% 0.00% 38.71%
S 1.85% 16.67% 2.14% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 55.56% 50.00% 54.29% U 57.14% 0.00% 61.29%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1997 D S U 1997 D S U
D 51.88% 46.15% 54.72% D 70.97% 50.00% 47.37%
S 3.76% 15.39% 5.66% S 6.45% 0.00% 0.00%
U 44.36% 38.46% 39.62% U 22.58% 50.00% 52.63%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
![Page 24: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page24
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
APPENDIX 2: ANNUAL MARKOV PROBABILITIES 1986 THROUGH 2013 DAILY DATA WEEKLY DATA
1998 D S U 1998 D S U
D 54.48% 66.67% 50.88% D 67.65% 0.00% 55.56%
S 1.49% 0.00% 0.88% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 44.03% 33.33% 48.25% U 32.35% 0.00% 44.44%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
1999 D S U 1999 D S U
D 47.66% 60.00% 38.85% D 36.84% 0.00% 38.24%
S 0.94% 0.00% 2.88% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 51.40% 40.00% 58.27% U 63.16% 0.00% 61.77%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2000 D S U 2000 D S U
D 44.14% 50.00% 43.80% D 45.46% 0.00% 36.67%
S 0.00% 0.00% 1.46% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 55.86% 50.00% 54.75% U 54.55% 0.00% 63.33%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2001 D S U 2001 D S U
D 53.49% 0.00% 50.85% D 53.57% 0.00% 58.33%
S 1.55% 0.00% 0.85% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 44.96% 100.00% 48.31% U 46.43% 0.00% 41.67%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2002 D S U 2002 D S U
D 44.44% 14.29% 43.70% D 45.46% 0.00% 40.00%
S 2.78% 14.29% 2.22% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 52.78% 71.43% 54.07% U 54.55% 0.00% 60.00%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2003 D S U 2003 D S U
D 41.38% 50.00% 50.76% D 47.83% 100.00% 35.71%
S 1.72% 0.00% 0.00% S 0.00% 0.00% 3.57%
U 56.90% 50.00% 49.24% U 52.17% 0.00% 60.71%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
2004 D S U 2004 D S U
![Page 25: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page25
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
APPENDIX 2: ANNUAL MARKOV PROBABILITIES 1986 THROUGH 2013 DAILY DATA WEEKLY DATA
D 41.18% 0.00% 55.04% D 59.09% 0.00% 29.03%
S 0.00% 0.00% 0.78% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 58.82% 100.00% 44.19% U 40.91% 0.00% 70.97%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2005 D S U 2005 D S U
D 40.74% 75.00% 43.17% D 54.17% 0.00% 39.29%
S 2.78% 0.00% 0.72% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 56.48% 25.00% 56.12% U 45.83% 0.00% 60.71%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2006 D S U 2006 D S U
D 46.28% 0.00% 51.56% D 45.83% 0.00% 50.00%
S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 53.72% 0.00% 48.44% U 54.17% 0.00% 50.00%
100.00% 0.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2007 D S U 2007 D S U
D 43.70% 66.67% 49.23% D 33.33% 0.00% 32.35%
S 1.68% 0.00% 0.77% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 54.62% 33.33% 50.00% U 66.67% 0.00% 67.65%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2008 D S U 2008 D S U
D 53.49% 0.00% 48.78% D 68.75% 0.00% 50.00%
S 0.00% 0.00% 0.81% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 46.51% 100.00% 50.41% U 31.25% 0.00% 50.00%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2009 D S U 2009 D S U
D 50.41% 0.00% 45.80% D 23.53% 0.00% 37.14%
S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 49.59% 0.00% 54.20% U 76.47% 0.00% 62.86%
100.00% 0.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2010 D S U 2010 D S U
D 52.42% 100.00% 45.67% D 47.62% 0.00% 37.50%
S 0.00% 0.00% 0.79% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
![Page 26: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page26
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
APPENDIX 2: ANNUAL MARKOV PROBABILITIES 1986 THROUGH 2013 DAILY DATA WEEKLY DATA
U 47.58% 0.00% 53.54% U 52.38% 0.00% 62.50%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2011 D S U 2011 D S U
D 42.02% 0.00% 51.88% D 41.67% 0.00% 46.43%
S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 57.98% 0.00% 48.12% U 58.33% 0.00% 53.57%
100.00% 0.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
2012 D S U 2012 D S U
D 47.86% 100.00% 44.78% D 65.52% 0.00% 45.46%
S 0.86% 0.00% 0.00% S 3.45% 0.00% 0.00%
U 51.28% 0.00% 55.22% U 31.03% 100.00% 54.55%
100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
2013 D S U 2013 D S U
D 45.38% 0.00% 49.62% D 60.00% 0.00% 40.74%
S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% S 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
U 54.62% 0.00% 50.38% U 40.00% 0.00% 59.26%
100.00% 0.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 100.00%
![Page 27: DO WTI OIL PRICE MOVEMENTS FOLLOW A MARKOV CHAINconnvaluation.com/caseStudies/WTI_Oil_Prices_by_Markov_Chain.pdf · qualities of Markov ... Why should we care if WTI prices exhibit](https://reader031.vdocuments.us/reader031/viewer/2022013014/5af4d2b57f8b9a74448d5988/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Copyright2014ConnValuationServicesLtd.Allrightsreserved,nopartofthisworkmaybereproducedwithouttheowner’sexpresswrittenpermission. Page27
CONN VALUATION SERVICES LTD.
REFERENCES
Xu,H.,Zhang,Z.X.,ATrendDeductionModelofFluctuationOilPrices,(revised2011),InstituteofInternationalStudies,FudanUniversity,Shanghai
Mostafaei,H.etal.,ModellingthefluctuationsofBrentoilpricesbyaprobabilisticMarkovchain,(2011),JournalofComputations&Modelling,vol.1,no.2,17–26
Abazi,A.,StochasticVolatilityintheCrudeOilPrices:AMarkovChainMonteCarloApproach,(2003),unpublishedthesis
Sirdari,M.Z.etal.,AsationaritytestonMarkovchainmodelsbasedonmarginaldistribution,SchoolofMathematicalSciences,UniversitiSainsMalaysia