digital concrete: opportunities and challenges...physical chemistry of building materials eth zurich...

39
Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges

Upload: others

Post on 27-Mar-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich

Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges

Page 2: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

2Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Digital Concrete: Opportunities and Challenges

Page 3: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

3Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

National Centre of Competence in Research: Digital Fabrication in Architecture

Interdisciplinary initiative to foster the innovation capacity of architecture and constructionLaunch: June 2014

Duration: 3 x 4 year phases = 12 years

Composition: 13 Professors, (+3 associated) 8 Postdocs 24 PhD researchers (+17 associated) MAS teaching program Industry collaboration programme

Robotic Fabrication Lab, Institute for Technology in Architecture, ETH Zurich

Page 4: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

4Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Profs. M. Kohler and F. Gramazio(ETH Zürich)

Page 5: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

5Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Digital Concrete: Opportunities and Challenges

The Economist, April 2012 The Economist, April 2014

Page 6: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

6Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Page 7: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

7Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Concrete 29 % Formwork

53 %

Steel 18 %

Source: E. Lloret

Page 8: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Smart Dynamic Casting

Page 9: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

9Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

RetardedSelf Compacting Mortar

Robot and Formwork

Offline measurement

Process setup Chemical AdmixturesAccelerator

Control system

Page 10: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

10Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

RetardedSelf Compacting Mortar

Automation: activation and feeding

Robot and Formwork

Inline measurement

ControlSynchronise: acceleration, filling, slipping, shaping.

Process setup Chemical AdmixturesAccelerator

Page 11: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

11Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Page 12: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

12Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Fabrication

Includes standardReinforcement !

Page 13: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Digital ConcreteProcessing

Mesh Mould Smart Dynamic Casting

ContourCrafting

3D Printing(Moulds/direct)

13

Digital concrete processing: Rheology and Hydration control

Rheology control Rheology & Hydrationcontrol

Page 14: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Layered based printingConcrete / mortar / paste extrusion

14

Page 15: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

15Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

15

Page 16: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich 16

Page 17: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

17Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Basic consideration on layered extrusion

h

𝜏"," = 𝜌𝑔 ℎ 3�⁄

Roussel and Coussot (2005), Shahab et al, (2013), Perrot et al (2015)

Page 18: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

18Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Basic consideration on layered extrusion

𝐴 > 𝜏","/𝑡/

h

𝑉 < 3� 𝐿 𝐴 𝜌𝑔ℎ⁄𝑡/ = 𝐿 𝑉⁄𝜏"," = 𝜌𝑔 ℎ 3�⁄

Roussel and Coussot (2005), Shahab et al, (2013), Perrot et al (2015)

Page 19: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

19Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Basic consideration on layered extrusion

h

𝑉 >𝜌𝑔ℎ4

4𝜇7𝑡89:; <𝜌𝑔ℎ 4

12 + 2𝜇7𝑉ℎ

4�

𝐴Roussel and Cussigh, CCR, 2008

Page 20: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

20Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Operating windowThere is an upper and a lower bound for the production rate• Too low rates give cold joints• Too high rates collapse under their own weight

Important factors are• Thixotropic build up• Contour length• Layer height• Linear rate

Contour length is a crucial factor when discussing whether or not cold joints form

Page 21: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

21Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

What about reinforcement?Do not bother us with that question …Traditional• Place after and infill• Consider printed material as a lost formwork• Limited (probably insufficient) amounts of steel

Fiber reinforcement• Limited interconnection between layers• Gets worse at high speeds that avoid cold joints

Mats• Place ad hoc during production• Efficiency ???

Page 22: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

22Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Mesh Mould:Robotically produced Meshes as formwork AND reinforcement

Formwork + Reinforcement Formwork = Reinforcement

Page 23: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

23Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Mesh Mould: Key advance and resulting material challenge

Steel à Adequate quantity for ductile behaviord

D Rate limiting step: weld points

Increase d à decrease weld points àincrease D

Special mix design needed:Self compacting concrete that stays in the mesh

timesavingfactor ∝𝑑4𝑑N

O

Page 24: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Gramazio Kohler Research ETH Zurich

Page 25: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

25Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

What about the environment?

Page 26: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

26Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Enrico DiniD-Shape

3D Printing – Powder beds 26

Page 27: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

27Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

27

Page 28: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

28Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH ZurichDigital Building TechnologiesETH Zurich28 Imprimer le Monde, Centre

Pompidou, 2017

Page 29: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

29Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Imprimer le Monde, Centre Pompidou, 2017Digital Building Technologies

ETH Zurich29

Digital Grotesque II

Imprimer le Monde, Centre Pompidou, 2017

Page 30: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

dfab house: EMPA NEST

30

Page 31: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

31Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

NEST – dfab house •Robotically fabricated timber units

•Smart Slab (3D Printed)

• SDC facade mullions

•Mesh Mould wall

•Unit backbone

•Base

Page 32: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich 32

Page 33: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich 33

Page 34: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich 34

Page 35: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

35Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

1st RILEM International Conference on Concrete and Digital Fabrication

http://digitalconcrete2018.ethz.ch/

Extended abstractDeadline:

15 October 2017

Page 36: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

36Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

RobIArch 2018Robotic Fabrication in Architecture, Art, and Design

10th–15th SEPTEMBER 2018, ETH ZURICH

Page 37: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

37Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

ConclusionsExciting new field with a lot of challenges and opportunities

Value will come when added functionality can be delivered

Tue interdisciplinarity is crucial• Architecture, civil engineering, robotics, materials science,

chemistry and processing

New area for material science and chemistry of concrete

Science and technology of concrete admixtures are esential !

Page 38: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

38Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

Acknowledgements

Digital ConcreteProcessing

Mesh Mould

3D Printing Extrusion

Smart Dynamic Casting

Page 39: Digital concrete: Opportunities and challenges...Physical Chemistry of Building Materials ETH Zurich Robert J. Flatt, Institute for Building Materials, ETH Zurich Digital concrete:

Physical Chemistry of Building MaterialsETH Zurich

image is by AndrewRae.org.uk

Thank you for your attention