Designing Women (and Men, and Everyone in Between)

Why Studying Gender Matters

What is Gender?

• 1950s: biological attributes, sexual characteristics and social roles that characterize a person as male or female.

• 1960s: social movements begin to locate identity in systems of power; feminism centers ideas of oppression in sex itself

• “Women’s studies” and its various permutations give way to gender studies, recognizing role of the social, performance and art itself in producing gendered bodies.

Simone de Beauvoir, The Second Sex (1948)• Men are human, women are “not

men;” they represent sex itself.• Women have no common past or

history, and thus no identity: it becomes the task of feminism to imagine all of these things.

• Men argue that women’s subordination is natural: but isn’t the status of this truth a self-justifying one? Relativism.

• Men and women are united in their mutual and unequal dependence: “To decline to be the Other, to refuse to be a party to the deal – this would be for women to renounce all the advantages conferred upon them by their alliance with the superior caste.”

• Men profit from inequality, and from controlling the terms of inequality

Does visual art have a gender?

Women artists Male artist

Laura Mulvey, “Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema,” (1975), film and media studies, Birkbeck College, University of London• Psychoanalysis as a critical tool.• Scopophiia as a source of erotic pleasure that is

structured by gender.• Phallocentric society scripts women as the

passive, gazed-upon figure; men as active lookers. Because of how cinema is structured, the viewer always looks from a male perspective

• In modern film, there is a division of labor in which men act and women inspire action.

• Cinema structures the way women can be looked at.

• Three different ways of looking: the camera, the audience, and the way the characters look at each other within the frame.

• Women’s images have been “stolen” by traditional film, and only by destroying traditional conventions can women regain filmic agency.

Janet Leigh as Marion Crane in “Psycho” (Alfred Hitchcock, 1960• A woman• Naked• Terror• What is she looking at?• Where is she looking?• Her open mouth

Christian Dior’s “New Look” Vogue, March 15 1947

Case Study: Judy Chicago

• B. Judith Sylvia Cohen, 1939• Rejected from Chicago Art Institute

in 1956; attends UCLA• 1970: begins teaching “feminist

art” at Fresno State, changes her name to Judy Chicago

• 1971: goes to Cal Arts, establishes Feminist Art Program.

• With Miriam Schapiro, launches Womanhouse as a women’s living and studio space.

• January 1972: Womanhouse opens to the public

• 1974-1979: Creation of The Dinner Party; tours 1979-1981

• Empowering: makes feminism popular

• Essentialist view of art that doesn’t take on questions of power

The Dinner Party: Eleanor of Aquitaine

The Dinner Party: Emily Dickinson

Judith Butler: Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity (1990)• Sex is not prior to or

independent of gender: sex and gender depend on each other.

• No gender can exist without cultural acts that make it visible

• Gender is unstable and performed

• Bodies have no identity without the scripts, rehearsals, performances and acts of interpretation that confer it.

Why does gender matter to you, and what you study?

• Because space is gendered and gendering

Why does gender matter to you, and what you study?

• Because everyone is understood through gender and the relationships of power gender signifies – and it’s complicated!

Why does gender matter to you, and what you study?

• Because gender is a way to understand who and what is being looked at – and who is doing the looking.

What can you do about it?There is a Gender Studies Course Book

• Foundations of Gender Studies• Performativity and Powerlessness• History of American Advertising• Design/History/Revolution• And many courses taught in Parsons as well

that are listed here!