culvert design fish - united states fish and wildlife … channel vs. hydraulic culvert design •...

34
Culvert Design for Fish Passage Gian Dodici & Carl Schwartz USFWS

Upload: vanngoc

Post on 07-Jun-2018

226 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Culvert Design for Fish Passage

Gian Dodici & Carl SchwartzUSFWS

Page 2: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 3: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 4: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

How do crossings affect a watershed?

• Alter drainage patterns and stream flows• Affect temperatures• Alter sedimentation, organic matter• Introduce contaminants

Page 5: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Effects of crossing on aquatic organisms..

• Passage barriers• Increased erosion and sedimentation• Source for pollution

Page 6: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 7: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Why is fish passage important?

• Migration for spawning• Movement for survival temperatures, flows, available food and cover

• Prevent population fragmentation• After a catastrophic event, recolonization

Page 8: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Fish Passage Criteria

• Culvert Diameter• Culvert Slope• Roughness• Velocity• Fish species/size

Page 9: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Active Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design

• Active Channel – Sized to allow natural movement of bedload and formation of a stable streambed inside the culvert 

Bankfull Width

Page 10: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 11: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 12: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Active Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design

• Hydraulic – Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species.  Some problems include:– Super critical flow– Hydraulic jumps– Highly turbulent conditions– Abrupt changes in water surface elevation at inlet and 

outlet

Page 13: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Culvert conditions that create barriers to fish

• Excess drop at culvert outlet• High velocity within culvert• Inadequate depth in culvert• Turbulence in culvert• Debris at culvert inlet

Page 14: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

What’s the problem?

• Pool Depth

Page 15: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

What’s the problem?

• Jump Height

Page 16: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 17: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

What’s the problem?

• Flow velocity

Page 18: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

What’s the problem?

• Flow depth

Page 19: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 20: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Channel IncisionLongitudinal Profile

350

351

352

353

354

355

356

357

358

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550Channel Distance

Elev

atio

n

Culvert

Page 21: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Case Study

Crossing the Town of Marcellus, Onondaga County, New York

Page 22: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Cross vanes installed to back water up into the culvert eliminating the 

vertical barrier 

Page 23: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

But was this enough?

Page 24: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

How do I know?

http://www.stream.fs.fed.us/fishxing/

Page 25: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Need some basic measurements

Page 26: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 27: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 28: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 29: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 30: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 31: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 32: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 33: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species
Page 34: Culvert Design Fish - United States Fish and Wildlife … Channel vs. Hydraulic Culvert Design • Hydraulic –Matches hydraulics of culvert with swimming abilities of target species

Questions?