csr and the great recession
TRANSCRIPT
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne [email protected]
CSR and the Global Financial Crisis
Wayne VisserDirector, CSR International
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Shape of the Financial Crisis
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Size of the Financial Crisis
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Impact of the Financial Crisis
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Causes: Irresponsible Banking?
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Causes: Irresponsible Financial Markets?
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Warning: The Casino Economy
"Speculators may do no harm as bubbles on a steady stream of enterprise. But the position is serious when enterprise becomes the bubble on a whirlpool of speculation. When the capital development of a country becomes a by-product of the activities of a casino, the job is likely to be ill-done.”
John Maynard Keynes
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Causes: Irresponsible Executives?
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Causes: Irresponsible Corporations?
“The corporation has a legally defined mandate to relentlessly pursue—without exception—its own self-interest regardless of the often harmful consequences it might cause to others. Lying, stealing, killing are not rare aberrations but the duty of the corporation when it serves the interests of its shareholders to do so.” – Joel Bakan
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Causes: Irresponsible Capitalism?
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Policy Response: Financial Sector Reforms
Increased oversight of mortgage lenders
Increased risk retention & disclosure throughout the securitization process
New requirements for credit rating agencies
Regulation of derivatives markets for the first time
Increased flexibility in accounting rules (mark-to-market)
Increased bank capital requirements Addressing the systemic risk problem
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Green Jobs & Fiscal Stimulus Packages
Ban Ki-Moon called for a Green New Deal at the UNFCCC in Poznan in December 2008
And G20 governments have earmarked some $400 billion of their $2.6 trillion in stimulus funds for clean tech and sustainability programs.
Obama aims to double renewables in 3 yrs, retrofit 75% of all government buildings, weather-proof 2 million homes & create nearly half a million jobs
A report by HSBC (Feb 2009) showed that Obama's 2009 stimulus package delivers about 12% on 'green' initiatives, the Asia Pacific region led by China achieves 23%, France and Germany average 15%, and the UK 7% (later up to 15%)
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
UK Green Stimulus Package (April 2009)
£435 million to develop energy efficiency measures for homes, businesses and public buildings
£525 million over the next two years for offshore wind, funded through the renewables obligation;
£4 billion of capital from the European Investment Bank for renewable & other energy projects
A new funding mechanism to finance at least two, and up to 4 Carbon Capture and Storage projects
£405 million of new funding to encourage low-carbon energy and advanced green manufacturing
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Industry Response: UN PRI?
1. We will incorporate ESG issues into investment analysis and decision-making processes.
2. We will be active owners and incorporate ESG issues into our ownership policies and practices.
3. We will seek appropriate disclosure on ESG issues by the entities in which we invest.
4. We will promote acceptance and implementation of the Principles within the investment industry.
5. We will work together to enhance our effectiveness in implementing the Principles.
6. We will each report on our activities and progress towards implementing the Principles.
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Impacts on CSR
How will the financial crisis affect CSR?
CSR International Blog Poll (October 2008)
26%
22%
8%
44% Strengthen
Weaken
Change
No Effect
Source: www.csrinternational.blogspot.com
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
CSR Importance During the Recession
60% of senior business executives say CSR is more important to businesses now than a year ago (IBM, 2009)
UK CSR executive remuneration went up 10% in 2009 (Acre Resources, Acona & Ethical Performance, 2010)
54% of US companies say CSR activities are even more important in economic hard times. 38% reported a decline in giving, but R&D for new sustainable products was up 15% (BCCCC, 2009)
75% of US consumers say CSR remains important despite the recession (Penn Schoen Berland, 2010)
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Impacts of the Recession on CSR
40% of US companies expect green & other CSR initiatives to significantly slow due to the downturn, esp in transportation & energy sectors (Booz & Co, Dec 2008)
72% of UK charities have seen demand increase and CSR funding decrease during the recession (CAF)
41% of UK charities received less funding in the last quarter & 50% are expecting a continuing decline over the next 12 months (CAF, 2009)
Only 40% of US employees believe their company is responsible, which (Kenexa, 2010)
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
BITC survey in the UK (2010)
67% of BITC UK member companies believe that a more responsible economy is likely to emerge from the recession
97% believe that individual business leaders must be seen to act to restore confidence lost due to the financial crisis
63% said that the most important role for responsible leaders is to incorporate social and environmental considerations into their core business models
In Northern Ireland, 64% expect their focus on CSR to grow in the next 12 months, while 33% expected their focus to remain the same.
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
CSR Recessionary Priority #1: Workplace
Redeployment Over 50% are willing to retrain or take a different job
at the same level, 40% are willing to work temporarily for another employer, 60% are willing to work in another country (Career Innovation Survey)
Reduction of hours Thousands of workers at JCB voted to accept a pay
cut of £50 per week for 13 weeks to save 350 jobs. They worked a 4-day week to ride out the recession
Sabbaticals GM UK has offered workers at its plant at Ellesmere
Port in Merseyside the option of taking up to eight months leave between 1 January and 1 September 2009, on 30 per cent pay
BITC, The Responsible Workplace, 2009
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
CSR Recessionary Advantage?
Triodos Bank, which only finances sustainable projects & businesses, grew by 25% in 2008.
CAF Bank’s had 49% growth in new accounts from April 2008-2009
During the Great Recesssion, SRI grew “at higher rates than ever” to $2.7 trillion (Time)
Clean tech (biofuels, wind, solar) grew 50% in 2008 to $115 billion and are expected to reach $325 billion within the decade (Clean Edge)
Companies committed to corporate sustainability achieved “above average” performance in 2008, averaging $50 million in incremental market value per company (AT Kearney)
More consumers “systematically” purchased green products in 2008 than in 2007 (Boston Consulting Group)
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Implications for Philanthropic CSR
Philanthropic CSR will be worst hit
Philanthropy
Ethical conduct
Legal compliance
Economic contribution
Carroll (1991)
CSR Pyramid
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Implications for Strategic CSR
Strategic CSR will be less affected
Example: Coca Cola & Water
Source: Strategy and Society: The Link Between Competitive Advantage and Corporate Social Responsibility, by Michael E. Porter & Mark R. Kramer
Copyright 2010 - CSR International / Wayne Visser
Implications for Radical CSR
Radical CSR – which changes to roots, or DNA, of business - will be the least affected
“CSR can only be resilient if it is part of the DNA of an organisation, i.e. CSR will only survive the vagaries of fickle markets, fluctuating profits, financial crises and leadership whims if it is totally embedded in the corporate culture, strategy and governance systems”
– Wayne Visser, 2008
Copyright CSR International / Wayne Visser 2010
Environmental Integrity
Societal Contribution
Good Governance
ValueCreation
CSR 2.0