course 30/6 guy baeten
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
CITY PLANNING AS AN ARENA OF SOCIO-ENVIRONMENTAL CONFLICT
IN NEOLIBERAL TIMESThe case of Malmö, Sweden
GUY BAETENDepartment of Human Geography
University of Lund
BARCELONA, SUMMER SCHOOL ON ENVIRONMENTAL CONFLICTJune-July 2010
• Try to bring together social, environmental, economic and sustainability issues in city building under the heading of ’neoliberal contradictions’
• The case fo the Hyllie UDP in one of most ’sustainable’ cities of the world: Malmö
• Socio-environmental issues as reworking urban politics• Contradictions make common categories always have an
unfulfilled character, blurred, incomplete, messy
Hegemonic neoliberalism...
• ”Neoliberalism is the most successful ideology in world history” (Anderson, 2000)
• ”Neoliberalism has swallowed up the world in its clutches” (Said, 2000)
• ”Neoliberalism is a utopia of unlimited exploitation” (Bourdieu, 1998)
• ”Neoliberalism is not simply an economic structure, it is a philosophy” (Treanor, 2005)
’Neoliberal city planning’ as an usual combination
• Contradiction in terms, or ’giving up’• Yet: neoliberalism has a decidedly
urban history
”To mobilise city space as an arena both for market-oriented economic growth and for elite consumption practices” (Brenner and Theodore, 2002, 368)
• Coming to terms with ’actually existing neoliberal planning’ as an uneasy co-habitation, planning in an anti-planning ideology
Reading neoliberal planning as a set of contradictions
• Contradictions create eternal tension, linger on, suppressed, explode, thought away but always present, haunting specter
CONTRADICTORY URBANITIES• The plan: short term profits, long term problems
– PROFIT MAXIMISATION V DURABLE BUILT ENVIRONMENT• The people: reworking the Malmö demographic fabric against the odds:
desired immigrants and real immigrants– CREATIVE CLASS V REAL PEOPLE
• The builders: men in black, beyond democracy– AUTHORITARIAN STATE TO IMPLEMENT ’FREEDOM’ V DEMOCRATIC
PLANNING• The place: disjointed landscapes and scales of super- and subplaces
– POLARISATION V INTEGRATION• The history: Building away history, take II
– OVERCOMING SOCIAL DEMOCRACY• The environment: building a car city in the most ’sustainable’ city in the
world– NATURE V PROVEN PROFIT EXTRACTION
6
Malmö reinvented
Sustainability as core city planning idea
• 1980s: Planning in crisis– Chicago School and Milton
Friedman promoting anti-state theoryand free market absolutism
– Planning as part of the problem– Planning as the opposite of ’freedom’, ’market’– Seek new legitimacy– ’Sustainability’ discourse perfect match for planning as a
discipline and a profession• Planning had long tradition of bringing together social, economic
and environmental issues in making land use decisions• Sustainability is what planning is all about• Popularity of ’sustainability’ could revitalise planning
Eco-branding as core regeneration strategy
• 4th most ecological city (GRIST, 2010) after Reykjavik, Portland, Curitiba
• One of the 12 ’Fast Cities’ 2009• First Fairtrade City• Seeking world-leading ecological
identity after deindustrialisation
HYLLIE, THE PROJECT• new city district in southern Malmö • 7 000 dwellings, 15 000 inhabitants• new railway (21 km, 6 km tunnel, ready 2011)• new railway station (5 min to centre, 15 min to Kastrup,
25 min to Copenhagen)• ice hockey stadium (15 000)• shopping centre (75 000 m²)• hotel (600 rooms)• offices• Point Hyllie (95m)• parks and parking
(3 500)(1 300)
10
THE PLAN
11
IMMIGRATION IN MALMÖ BY REGION OF ORIGIN (2007), AND MIGRATION SALDO (2006)
0
5 000
10 000
15 000
20 000
25 000
30 000
amount 2007 27 227 21 797 10 619 4 979 3 366 2 947 1 002 195
’Eastern’ Europe
Asia NordenRest of Europe
AfricaSouth
AmericaNorth
AmericaOceania
-2 000
-1 000
0
1 000
2 000
3 000
saldo -1 610 -32 703 2 400
South West
Rest of Skåne
Rest of Sweden
Abroad
12
Saldo
Origin
REWORKING THE DEMOGRAPHIC FABRIC: WWW
• Looking west for imagined immigrants while real immigration flows come from the east
– Not building for people who do come while building for people who may not come
– “For groups, like the homeless who already have difficulties on the housing market, a acute housing shortage is in the making. There is not one apartment for rent for those who are poorly embedded in the housing market like people on low income, or youngsters” (Olle Sundh, Real Estate Office Malmö, 31-10-07)
13
THE BUILDINGS
14
Point Hyllie
45,000 sqm
PEAB
2/3 bostadsrätt
300 flats
1/3 kontor hyresrätt
CITY BUILDERS STEER MALMÖ’S FUTURE
– VISIONARY”Malmö will be the new Scandinavian powerhouse in 20-30 years
time” (Artur Buchardt, hotel developer)
– POWERFUL”Percy Nilsson took a detailed plan with a hotel, shopping mall, a
new tower and ice hockey stadium to the town hall” (E24 business magazine)
– AMERICAN”In Malmö people spend 20 pct of their consumption budget in
shopping malls. In the US that is up to 35-40 pct. People in Malmö could and should shop more in shopping malls” (Peter Warming, Emporia shopping mall)
– PERSONAL”I want this stadium to symbolise my entrepreneurship for the next
five hundred years” (Percy Nilsson, Sydsvenskan)
15
NEO-LIBERALSPATIAL DUALITIES
• New landscapes of wealth
– Cashing in on bridge, outer ring roadand opening up of nearby land:the production of space
– “Ambient power” through design and architecture (J Allen, 2006)
– Very strict idea of what the end-state of Hyllie centre should be: well-off suburb with top-quality services (transport, shopping, entertainment) and prime office market
16
• New scale of wealth– Network of ”Öreplaces”,
connected with excellent transport means rising above the ordinary urban skyline
– Superplaces• Elite consumption and housing, prime office markets,
tunnels, in control of glocal mobilities • Aestethic• Upscaled city feeding off the existing city but in denial
of it
17
Bara new golf
courses
DavidshallSlotsstaden
Rörsjostaden
Copenhagen
Örestad
Kastrup
Ideon
Dockan
Unversitets-holmen
Nyhamnen
Västra Hamnen
Hyllie
18
NEO-LIBERAL FALL-OUT
– New landscapes of deprivation
• Overcrowding (Olle Sundh, Fastighetskontoret)• Moving to cheaper places in town or away from
Malmö• Overspending on housing• Growing need for transit housing• Increasing homelessness
19
– Homelessness in Malmö
Increasing most: women, youth, non-addicts
0
200
400
600
800
1000
amount 313 413 480 521 638 801 531 563 694 849
1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
20
• New scale of deprivation– Places not connected to Öreplaces and
Örenetwork become in-between places, unnoticed, disconnected from the Örespectacle and its monies and possibilities
– places of burden, of cost, of socialbidrag– subplaces– downscaled city, depending on the Örescale but
unable to connect
21
BUILDING AWAYHISTORY TAKE II
• Unbridled believe in economic growth and progressleaving history behind, long-term futurism
• Unmatched desire to build a new city• Large-scale, industrial, impatient development• Modern architectural language• A-historical modern man overcomes social divides: difference with
the other becomes redundant through modern progress
• Progress for the few, not the masses• Building away the other take II:
– industrial, social-democratic Malmö, – growing ethnic presence
22
FUCK THE CONTEXT
23
Elitist and individualistic urban living with the city as decorum
’In’ the city but not ’of’ the city
CONCLUSION 1: neoliberal city planning as a set of contradictions
• Malmö neo-liberal variant steers away from, yet embedded in past planning– Echoes Million Program’s belief in progress and modernity, copying Million Program
forms– Building away history
• Disjointed, fragmented urban landscape of superplaces and subplaces• Reworking the demographic fabric of Malmö through the built environment: white,
western and wealthy• In the city but not of the city• Building an unsustainable city under the heading of sustainability: solving sustainability
issues elsewhere, or afterwards
24
CONCLUSION 2: neoliberal city planning as the reworking of politics and justice
• CITY MARKETING : image of the city as engaged with nature, liveability• Attract and/or keep MIDDLE CLASS POPULATIONS• DEPOLITICISING POLITICS : green roof politics – marginalising hard politics of
justice• MORALISING POLITICS : sustainable projects as ”good” for the city –
marginalising justice• JUSTIFYING INJUSTICE : elitist but green• Supporting the very development of ecological INDUSTRIES (eco-clusters)• ENGAGING WITH ’GRAND’ VISIONS for the city, rallying broad support, while
maintaining existing power relations
The blurring of concepts
• Neoliberal planning, tempered by and embedded in social-democratic past
• Socio-ecological concern, tempered by the race for profit