cosmic awe, self-esteem, and materialism

1
Overview: IV: Self-Diminishing Sense of Awe DV: Endorsement of Materialism Format: Online Survey Participants: MacEwan Undergraduate Students Cosmic Awe, Self-Esteem, and Materialism The effects of awe and self-esteem on materialist values and beliefs Emmett McCurdy, David C. Watson Ph.D., MacEwan University Materialism: Materialism is a worldview in which material possessions hold central importance. People high in materialism tend to view acquiring possessions as centrally important to their lives, pursue happiness through the acquisition of material goods, and judge others and expect to be judged on the basis of their material possessions. Awe: Awe is an emotional reaction which involves a self-transcendent shift in one’s frame of reference or perspective and a sudden fascination with a particular stimulus. Experiences which elicit awe tend to expand or contradict individuals’ understanding of the world, and can involve art, nature, and new information or concepts, among other sources. Past research has shown that experiencing awe can reduce materialist motivations and increase prosociality. Other research has shown that experiencing self-diminishing awe has different effects on people with low or high self-esteem, such that self-esteem acts as a buffer against the existential threat presented. The Present Research: It is hypothesized that experiencing self- diminishing awe will reduce materialist values and beliefs more than neutral awe or the control condition, and that this effect will be greater for individuals with higher self-esteem than individuals with low self-esteem. Expected Results Discussion Methods Introduction Procedure: Participants will be randomly assigned to one of three conditions, then asked to complete a demographics survey including a measure of self-esteem. Participants will then complete one half of a materialism scale and of an awe scale, either be shown a video conveying the scale of the universe, a compilation of videos of natural phenomena including plants and animals, or no video, and just the same music as was included in either of the awe condition videos. Following the manipulation, participants will complete the second half of the materialism and awe measures, and then be debriefed. Cosmic Awe Condition Neutral Awe Condition Control Condition Scale of the universe video Video of natural phenomena No video; listen to music Survey 2-b: -Materialism Scale-B -Awe Scale-B -Manipulation check Survey 1: -Demographic info -Self-Esteem Debrief Cosmic Awe Neutral Awe Control Materialism Score Expected Scores After Manipulation: High SE Low Se The present research is intended to investigate the effects of self-diminishing awe on endorsement of materialist values and beliefs. Previous research has shown that awe can reduce selfish motivations and increase one’s tendency towards generosity and helping behaviours, as well as shifting people’s values and goals from material to social matters, and from extrinsic motivations to intrinsic motivations. If this study shows the expected results, then we will have demonstrated that experiencing this kind of awe can expand people’s frame of reference and concern away from the self and their immediate lives enough to reduce materialist values. These results would also demonstrate the difference between experiences of awe which are self-diminishing and awe which does not involve the self in creating this effect on materialism. Survey 2-a: -Materialism Scale-A -Awe Scale-A

Upload: others

Post on 23-Feb-2022

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Cosmic Awe, Self-Esteem, and Materialism

Overview:• IV: Self-Diminishing Sense of Awe• DV: Endorsement of Materialism• Format: Online Survey• Participants: MacEwan

Undergraduate Students

Cosmic Awe, Self-Esteem, and MaterialismThe effects of awe and self-esteem on materialist values and beliefsEmmett McCurdy, David C. Watson Ph.D., MacEwan University

Materialism:Materialism is a worldview in which

material possessions hold central

importance. People high in materialism

tend to view acquiring possessions as

centrally important to their lives, pursue

happiness through the acquisition of

material goods, and judge others and

expect to be judged on the basis of their

material possessions.

Awe:Awe is an emotional reaction which

involves a self-transcendent shift in

one’s frame of reference or perspective

and a sudden fascination with a

particular stimulus. Experiences which

elicit awe tend to expand or contradict

individuals’ understanding of the world,

and can involve art, nature, and new

information or concepts, among other

sources. Past research has shown that

experiencing awe can reduce materialist

motivations and increase prosociality.

Other research has shown that

experiencing self-diminishing awe has

different effects on people with low or

high self-esteem, such that self-esteem

acts as a buffer against the existential

threat presented.

The Present Research:

It is hypothesized that experiencing self-

diminishing awe will reduce materialist

values and beliefs more than neutral

awe or the control condition, and that

this effect will be greater for individuals

with higher self-esteem than individuals

with low self-esteem.

Expected Results Discussion

MethodsIntroduction

Procedure:

Participants will be randomly assigned to one of three conditions, then asked to complete a demographics survey including a measure of self-esteem. Participants will then complete one half of a materialism scale and of an awe scale, either be shown a video conveying the scale of the universe, a compilation of videos of natural phenomena including plants and animals, or no video, and just the same music as was included in either of the awe condition videos. Following the manipulation, participants will complete the second half of the materialism and awe measures, and then be debriefed.

Cosmic Awe Condition

Neutral Awe Condition

Control Condition

Scale of the universe video

Video of natural phenomena

No video; listen to music

Survey 2-b:-Materialism

Scale-B-Awe Scale-B

-Manipulation check

Survey 1:-Demographic

info-Self-Esteem

Debrief

Cosmic Awe Neutral Awe Control

Mat

eria

lism

Sco

re

Expected Scores After Manipulation:

High SE Low Se

The present research is intended to investigate the

effects of self-diminishing awe on endorsement of

materialist values and beliefs. Previous research

has shown that awe can reduce selfish motivations

and increase one’s tendency towards generosity

and helping behaviours, as well as shifting people’s

values and goals from material to social matters,

and from extrinsic motivations to intrinsic

motivations. If this study shows the expected

results, then we will have demonstrated that

experiencing this kind of awe can expand people’s

frame of reference and concern away from the self

and their immediate lives enough to reduce

materialist values. These results would also

demonstrate the difference between experiences of

awe which are self-diminishing and awe which

does not involve the self in creating this effect on

materialism.

Survey 2-a:-Materialism

Scale-A-Awe Scale-A