core zebra saras the zero spacing interferometers · 2018-04-20 · ravi subrahmanyan, rri ....

33
CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers Ron Ekers, CSIRO & Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop Sydney, 19 Nov 2012

Upload: others

Post on 15-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

CORE ⇒ ZEBRA ⇒ SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers

Ron Ekers, CSIRO &

Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI

CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop Sydney, 19 Nov 2012

Page 2: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

From CoRE I to ZEBRA

CoRE I (Chippendale)

CoRE II (Virtual)

ZEBRA ⇒ SARAS

ZEBRA II

Calibratable receiver

CSI

RO

R

RI

MR

O

Page 3: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Global EoR system RRI Bangalore

Ravi Subrahmanyan

Ron Ekers

Peter Shaver

A. Raghunathan

Page 4: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Zebra – fat dipole v1

Page 5: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Zebra – receiver MkI

Page 6: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

First light 14 Sep 2010

Spectrum is the expected galactic power law.

Page 7: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Log (Freq) Tsky

fro

m c

osm

olog

ical

HI

~10mK

~ 10-100 MHz

Signal in the 50-200MHz depends on the (i) spin temperature (ii) ionization fraction during z = 26 - 6

Global EoR Signal

Page 8: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

The challenge

Global ∆T 30mK in few MHz – S/N easy – can reach a few mK in one hour

∆T/T < 10-4 to10-5

Calibrate the gain Minimize the number of unknowns that can couple to EoR Remove the additive constant

– Correlation receiver » Eliminate LNA additive noise – but still many problems

– Position switching » ∆T now very small so large antenna and long integration times » Correlation interferometer » Arrays

• Statistical detection • Direct detection

Zero spacing interferometer Zero spacing

interferometer

Page 9: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

ZEBRA– interferometer

Page 10: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

1.5m

110-170MHz 1.5m

– 0.55 to 0.85 λ 3m

– 1.1 to 1.7 λ

3m

Uniform sky visibility

Page 11: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

ZEBRA Global EoR Experiment

ZEro-spacing measurement of the Background RAdio spectrum

Partially reflecting resistive screen

Virtual zero spacing interferometer

Removes all additive errors

Modulate screen ?

Subrahmanyan, Ekers Patra

Partial reflector/transmitter

X

Page 12: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

The space beam-splitter: a resistive wire mesh

Need a space beam-splitter before the antenna A lossless screen (e.g. a conducting grid)

– transmitted & reflected waves are orthogonal Resistive wire mesh

– Thickness of wire < skin depth – Frequency independent – Re-radiated fields no longer cancel the incident field on

the far side of the wire screen

Lumped resistance on scale << λ – Practical solution instead of resistance wire

Page 13: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Building resistive screen

Page 14: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

The Resistive Screen

copper wire + lumped resistors

resistor value = free space impedance/2

3x4 metres

holes to reduce wind loading

Roll up for transport

Page 15: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Measurements of propagation Amplitude & phase through the resistive mesh For normal and oblique incidence Measurements of E and H plane fields

Page 16: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Modeling the transmission amplitude and phase for FINITE SCREEN Predictions based on WIPL-D model vs Predictions from analytic formulation of transmission thro’ a mesh plus physical optics

Page 17: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

ZEBRA – interferometer first CMB correlation 20 Jan 2011

3.4m

1.5m separation Max sky coverage at zero spacing

26% Contributions to correlated output

– Global sky signal – Screen radiating – 1.5m interferometer sky

correlation » One path through screen » Both paths miss screen

Ferrite absorber

Page 18: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

ZEBRA at Gauribidanur

Page 19: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

ZEBRA receiver schematic Raghunathan Fat dipole

– 87.5-175MHz Correlator

– 2x ACR's – 1x XCR, – 12bit, 250MHz

Correlator 100m away – Replace coax by

fibre

Page 20: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Zebra correlated output

Baseline ripple – changes with LST – Repeats each day – Multipath scattering of galaxy foreground signal – Shifted location …….

Page 21: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Try heating the screen

Page 22: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Screen Model grid 1

Page 23: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Screen Model grid 2

Page 24: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Screen Model grid 3

Page 25: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Screen Model grid 4

Page 26: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Screen Model grid 5

Page 27: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

ASKAP Phased Array Feed

Page 28: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

SARAS receiver evolution

Page 29: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Antenna Requirements for EoR measurements

Half-power beamwidth variation < ±2.5% – For a frequency range 87.5 to 175 MHz – Keeps un-modeled foreground residuals < 5mK

An electrically small antenna – No spurious high order frequency components

Return loss > 10dB and constant over band – antenna gain losses and internal reflections of the

receiver noise must be low and vary smoothly with frequency.

Page 30: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Fat Dipole Antenna Prototype II

Page 31: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Fat Dipole Antenna

A. Raghunathan, Udaya Shankar, Ravi Subrahmanyan – submitted to IEEE AP

A wide-band fat-dipole antenna – sinusoidal profile – frequency independent performance 87.5 to 175 MHz

Structure optimized using electromagnetic modelling – Adopt a sinusoidal profile

Design validated by constructing a prototype – The input return loss > 15 dB – Radiation power pattern is a frequency invariant (< 2.1% ) cosine

square over the octave bandwidth Now used in SARAS by Nipanjana Patra

Page 32: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

RRI gets some interesting visitors!

Composition by Ravi

Snake photo by Nipanjana

Page 33: CORE ZEBRA SARAS The Zero Spacing Interferometers · 2018-04-20 · Ravi Subrahmanyan, RRI . CAASTRO Global EoR Workshop . Sydney, 19 Nov 2012 . From CoRE I to ZEBRA CoRE I (Chippendale)

Pulse calibration ?

Pulse injected at Parkes vertex

Pulse reflected from Parkes focus

Inject and integrate short (ηsec) pulses Calibrated noise spectrum Understand & calibrate reflections Nipanjana Patra, Paul Roberts