comparisons of the solutions of common ffs standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr...

16
Procedia Engineering 130 (2015) 1327 – 1342 Available online at www.sciencedirect.com 1877-7058 © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of ICPVT-14 doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2015.12.303 ScienceDirect a School of Materials, The University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, UK b School of Mechanical, Aerospace & Civil Engineering, The University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, UK Keywords: E-mail address: © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of ICPVT-14

Upload: others

Post on 03-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

1877-7058 © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of ICPVT-14doi: 10.1016/j.proeng.2015.12.303

ScienceDirect

aSchool of Materials, The University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, UK bSchool of Mechanical, Aerospace & Civil Engineering, The University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, UK

Keywords:

E-mail address:

© 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).Peer-review under responsibility of the organizing committee of ICPVT-14

Page 2: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1328 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Page 3: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1329 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

2a B 2c E F L

KI PIK SIK matK

Kr PrK SrK

Lr

rL

P PL Qm

Qb

ri

rm

ro

ref

f

ysr

Kr, Lr

Page 4: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1330 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Crackwise®

3.1. Case study 1

o P psig

a c

ro in B in ri in

B/ro m b

Page 5: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1331 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

im

P r ksiB

o

o

bi i i i

P r B B B ksir r r r r

m b

m

r r ry Rys r ys ys ys

refrys ys

fy

rysy

y Rr

Rr

ys ksi ys ref f

ys

rm/Brm/B

Lr a/B

Lr

Page 6: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1332 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

a/B

Page 7: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1333 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Lr

Kr

KrP

KrS

ys

KrS/Kr

P

yr/

KrS/Kr

Pyr/

KrP

KrS

KrS/Kr

P

yr/

Kr

Lr

Page 8: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1334 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Deepest point Lr Kr Lr Kr

Surface point Lr Kr

R6

Deepest point Lr Kr

R6

Surface point Lr Kr

oo

Kr

KrS/Kr

P yr/

Page 9: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1335 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

o o

P rm/B

rm/B rm/BP Lr

Kr rm/B

Triangles: API 579, 2007 (Red: RS field as in R6-BS7910)

Squares: BS 7910, 2013 (Global Plate solution - SIF Cylinder)(Green: Thick cylinder soltuion)Stars: R6, 2014 (Blue: VM yield criterion)

Solid: =90o, residual stressesHollow: =0o, residual stressesCrossed: =90o, no residual stressesSemi-Solid: =0o, no residual stresses

Page 10: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1336 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Lr Kr

Lr

L

L

Page 11: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1337 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

3.2. Case study 2

ro B

E

E

ys

Kmat .

rm/B

Page 12: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1338 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

a

Qm

Qb

Page 13: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1339 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

SrK

Page 14: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1340 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Lr Kr

Kr

Crack

Page 15: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1341 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Kr

Krs Kr

Kr

SrK

Lr

Prm/B

Page 16: Comparisons of the Solutions of Common FFS Standard ... · ksi b v o 03d o b ii i i pr bb b ksi rrr r r v ªº§· §· «»¨¸ ¨¸ «»¬¼©¹©¹ 'xh wr lwv vpdoo ydoxh lq frpsdulvrq

1342 N.O. Larrosa and R.A. Ainsworth / Procedia Engineering 130 ( 2015 ) 1327 – 1342

Lr

Kr

SIF