chomsky - the creative aspect of language use and nonbiological nativism

26
!"#$%&#'()*#$+,-#. ($/0$1'234'3#$5, #$'26$7/28)/ 9/3).'9$7'()*), :$ $ ;'&<$%=$>'<#&$ ?4(3#&,$52)*#&,)(@$ $ !"##$%&'()*+&,(%# $ !"#$%/32)()*#$A.)#2.#$#&'$.'2$8#$ 6)*)6#6$)2(/$(B/$6),()2.($ -#&)/6,$B)("$&#,-#.($(/ $("#$ (/-).$/0$)22'(#2#,,C$'($9#', ($0&/:$("#$*)#B-/) 2($/0$("#$9)234),(=$$! "#$0)&,($-#&)/6C$B")."$  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 -&'.().#$8@$6#*#9/-)23$("#$("#/&@$)2$("),$B'@=$ S2$0'.(C$S$8#9)#*#$("#$.4&& #2($,('(#$/0$(")23,$)2$9) 234),().,$,"/B,$(" '($("#$0)&,($ 3#2#&'()/2J,$&#().#2.#$/2$("#,#$: '((#&,$B',$B'&&'2(#6= $$!"#$8',).$2/()/2$("'($:'2@$/0$("#$ 0426':#2('9$-&)2.)-9#,$/0$P ,'@R$,@2('L$'&#$)2 2'(#$)2$"4:'2,$),$'$ -/B#&049$'26$4,#049$)6#'C$ '26$("#&#$),$/..',)/2$0/&$ ("#$-&'.().)23$9)234),($(/$:'<#$4,#$/0$)($/2$'2$/2V3/)23C $:/2("$  8@$:/2("$8',), =$$W4#,()/2,$/0$B"#("#&$,4."$'26$,4."$'$, @2('.().$-"#2/:#2/2$,"/496$8#$ '((&)84(#6$(/$("#$)22'(#$#26/B: #2($/&$2/(C$'26$)0$,/$ )2$B"'($0/&:C$ '&),#$&#349'&9@$'26$  -&/*/<#$)2(#&#,()23$'26$-&/0 )('89#$6),.4,,)/2=$$S2$ ./2(&',(C$("#$'66)()/2'9$',,4:-()/2$("'($ ("),$)22'(#$<2/B9#63#$),$ '$3#2#().'99@$#2./6#6$#*/9*#6$'6'-('()/2C$(/$ 8#$426#&,(//6$B)("$ ("#$(//9,$/0$#*/94()/2'&@$ -,@."/9/3@$"',$2/($ 8##2$-/B#&049$/&$-&/64.()*#C$ '26$/&6)2'&@$ 9)234),(,$2##6$2/($'--#'9$(/$ )($/2$'$&#349'&$8',),=$ S($"',$2/($9#6$(/$'2@$ ,48,('2()*#$2#B$ 6),./*#&)#,$("'($S$':$'B'&#$/0C$2/&$"', $)($3)*#2$6##-#&$#L-9'2'()/2,$0/&$ -&#*)/4,9@$<2/B2$  84($:@,(#&)/4, $6#(')9,$'8/4($("#$9'234'3#$0'.49(@=$ $A/:#():#,$)( $:)3"($6/$,/:#$6':'3#C$  8@$:'<)23$&#,#'&."#& ,$42649@$./2,#&*'()*#$'8/4($-/, )()23$'$")3"9@$,(&4.(4& #6$)22'(#$ #26/B:#2(C$)2$: @$/B2$-#&,/2'9$*)#B=$$A/$'($8#,(C$)($"', $8##2$'2$)2#&($"@-/("#,),C$ '99#3#69@$./2(&)84()23$(/$("#$ 0/426'()/2,$/0$("#$0)#96$'($'$ 9#*#9$B")."$),$)2*),)89#$(/ $:/,($  -&'.().)23$9)234),(,=$$+($B/&,($)($"',$& '),#6$:@,(#&)#,$'8/4($"/B$("#$0)#96,$./22#.($("'($)($ 6/#,$2/($,/9*#=$ X)00#&#2($-#/-9#$&#'.($(/$("),$-#&.#)*#6$6),./22#.($8#(B##2$P/2#$<)26$/0R$ 9)234),().,$'26$8)/9/3@$ )2$6)00#&#2($B'@,= $$A/:#$9//<$'($8)/9/3@ $'26$)20#&$("'($52)*#&,'9$ Y&'::'&$./496$ 2/($8#$',$("#$%"/:, <)'2$9)234),(,$,'@$)( $),=$$Z("#&,$./2.#2(& '(#$/2$("#$ '((#,(#6$9)234),().$6'('$'26$)32/& #$("#$8)/9/3@$',$8#)23$(/ /$.&46#C$8&4(),"C$'26$, -#.49'()*#$

Upload: jamie-robertson

Post on 09-Apr-2018

224 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 1/26

!"#$%&#'()*#$+,-#.($/0$1'234'3#$5,#$'26$7/28)/9/3).'9$7'()*),:$$

;'&<$%=$>'<#&$

?4(3#&,$52)*#&,)(@$

$!"##$%&'()*+&,(%#$

!"#$%/32)()*#$A.)#2.#$#&'$.'2$8#$6)*)6#6$)2(/$(B/$6),()2.($-#&)/6,$B)("$&#,-#.($(/$("#$(/-).$/0$)22'(#2#,,C$'($9#',($0&/:$("#$*)#B-/)2($/0$("#$9)234),(=$$!"#$0)&,($-#&)/6C$B")."$

 8#3'2$)2$("#$9'(#$DEFG,$'26$B',$."'&'.(#&)H#6$8@$("#$B/&<$/0$-#/-9#$9)<#$%"/:,<@$'26$I/6/&C$'&34#6$0/&$&#*)*)23$'$2'()*),($-/,)()/2C$)2$B")."$'$,48,('2()'9$':/42($/0$-#/-9#J,$

<2/B9#63#$/0$9'234'3#$B',$)22'(#$&'("#&$("'2$9#'&2#6$8@$',,/.)'()/2$/&$)264.()/2$/&$

'2'9/3@=$$!"),$./2,()(4(#6$'$8&#'<$B)("$("#$#:-)&).),(K8#"'*)/&),(K,(&4.(4&'9),($(&'6)()/2$("'($"'6$6/:)2'(#6$("#$0)#96$8#0/&#$("'(=$

!"#$,#./26C$:/&#$&#.#2($-#&)/6$'66#6$(/$("#$0)&,($-#&)/6J,$.9'):$/0$)22'(#2#,,$("#$

#L-9).)($.9'):$("'($("#$)22'(#$<2/B9#63#$)2$M4#,()/2$),$(/$8#$426#&,(//6$#2()&#9@$B)(")2$'2$

#*/94()/2'&@$8)/9/3).'9$0&':#B/&<=$$I/&$#L':-9#C$("#$)22'(#$<2/B9#63#$),$('<#2$(/$8#$./6#6$)2$("#$3#2#,$'26$(/$"'*#$'&),#2$',$'2$#*/94()/2'&@$'6'-('()/2=$$N)(")2$9)234),().,$

'2@B'@C$("),$,#./26$-#&)/6$8#3'2$&'("#&$,"'&-9@$)2$DEEG$B)("$("#$-489).'()/2$/0$O)2<#&$

'26$>9//:$PO)2<#&$Q$>9//:C$DEEGR=$$>#0/&#$("'($B/&<C$6),.4,,)/2,$/0$("#$#*/94()/2$/0$9'234'3#$B#&#$&#9'()*#9@$&'&#$'26$-#&)-"#&'9$(/$("#$0)#96C$B"#&#',$("#@$"'*#$2/B$8#./:#$

./::/2-9'.#=$$S($),$2/($("'($%"/:,<@C$I/6/&C$'26$/("#&$T0)&,($3#2#&'()/2U$./32)()*#$

,.)#2(),(,$#*#&$6#2)#6$("'($("#$)22'(#$<2/B9#63#$/0$9'234'3#$B',$8)/9/3).'9$)2$("),$,#2,#=$$

>4($("#@$B#&#$2/($*#&@$)2(#&#,(#6$)2$("),$',-#.($'26$("/43"($("#&#$B',$9)((9#$(/$3')2$)2$ -&'.().#$8@$6#*#9/-)23$("#$("#/&@$)2$("),$B'@=$

S2$0'.(C$S$8#9)#*#$("#$.4&&#2($,('(#$/0$(")23,$)2$9)234),().,$,"/B,$("'($("#$0)&,($

3#2#&'()/2J,$&#().#2.#$/2$("#,#$:'((#&,$B',$B'&&'2(#6=$$!"#$8',).$2/()/2$("'($:'2@$/0$("#$

0426':#2('9$-&)2.)-9#,$/0$P,'@R$,@2('L$'&#$)22'(#$)2$"4:'2,$),$'$-/B#&049$'26$4,#049$)6#'C$'26$("#&#$),$/..',)/2$0/&$("#$-&'.().)23$9)234),($(/$:'<#$4,#$/0$)($/2$'2$/2V3/)23C$:/2("$

 8@$:/2("$8',),=$$W4#,()/2,$/0$B"#("#&$,4."$'26$,4."$'$,@2('.().$-"#2/:#2/2$,"/496$8#$'((&)84(#6$(/$("#$)22'(#$#26/B:#2($/&$2/(C$'26$)0$,/$)2$B"'($0/&:C$'&),#$&#349'&9@$'26$

 -&/*/<#$)2(#&#,()23$'26$-&/0)('89#$6),.4,,)/2=$$S2$./2(&',(C$("#$'66)()/2'9$',,4:-()/2$("'($

("),$)22'(#$<2/B9#63#$),$'$3#2#().'99@$#2./6#6$#*/9*#6$'6'-('()/2C$(/$8#$426#&,(//6$B)("$

("#$(//9,$/0$#*/94()/2'&@$-,@."/9/3@$"',$2/($8##2$-/B#&049$/&$-&/64.()*#C$'26$/&6)2'&@$9)234),(,$2##6$2/($'--#'9$(/$)($/2$'$&#349'&$8',),=$S($"',$2/($9#6$(/$'2@$,48,('2()*#$2#B$

6),./*#&)#,$("'($S$':$'B'&#$/0C$2/&$"',$)($3)*#2$6##-#&$#L-9'2'()/2,$0/&$-&#*)/4,9@$<2/B2$

 84($:@,(#&)/4,$6#(')9,$'8/4($("#$9'234'3#$0'.49(@=$$A/:#():#,$)($:)3"($6/$,/:#$6':'3#C$ 8@$:'<)23$&#,#'&."#&,$42649@$./2,#&*'()*#$'8/4($-/,)()23$'$")3"9@$,(&4.(4&#6$)22'(#$

#26/B:#2(C$)2$:@$/B2$-#&,/2'9$*)#B=$$A/$'($8#,(C$)($"',$8##2$'2$)2#&($"@-/("#,),C$

'99#3#69@$./2(&)84()23$(/$("#$0/426'()/2,$/0$("#$0)#96$'($'$9#*#9$B")."$),$)2*),)89#$(/$:/,($ -&'.().)23$9)234),(,=$$+($B/&,($)($"',$&'),#6$:@,(#&)#,$'8/4($"/B$("#$0)#96,$./22#.($("'($)($

6/#,$2/($,/9*#=$

X)00#&#2($-#/-9#$&#'.($(/$("),$-#&.#)*#6$6),./22#.($8#(B##2$P/2#$<)26$/0R$

9)234),().,$'26$8)/9/3@$)2$6)00#&#2($B'@,=$$A/:#$9//<$'($8)/9/3@$'26$)20#&$("'($52)*#&,'9$Y&'::'&$./496$2/($8#$',$("#$%"/:,<)'2$9)234),(,$,'@$)($),=$$Z("#&,$./2.#2(&'(#$/2$("#$

'((#,(#6$9)234),().$6'('$'26$)32/&#$("#$8)/9/3@$',$8#)23$(//$.&46#C$8&4(),"C$'26$,-#.49'()*#$

Page 2: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 2/26

!"#$%&'#%()#*+%,!-,%.#/'%+-(0#"(#!$'-+#.-(01-2!-,#!$'"+-'23#4!-..#"!$'+2#5'()#!$%!#!$'+'#-2#%()#2'+-"12#!'(2-"(#%!#!$-2#2!%0'#"6#"1+#7("8.'50'98$-,$#1(5'(-%/.)#$%2#:%()#.%+0'#0%*2#-(#

-!3##;$')#:-0$!#$"*'#!$%!#!$'#-(!'+6%,'#/'!8''(#.-(01-2!-,2#%(5#/-"."0)#8-..#/',":'#%#

 *+%,!-,%.#%(5#:'%(-(061.#"('#%2#8"+7#,"(!-(1'2#!"#*+"0+'22#-(#/"!$#0'('+%!-&'#.-(01-2!-,2#

%(5#'&".1!-"(%+)#*2),$"."0)3#

<(#!$-2#*%*'+=#<#8%(!#!"#'>*."+'#%("!$'+#*"22-/.'#+'%,!-"(#!"#!$-2#*+%,!-,%.#5-2,"((',!-"(9(%:'.)=#!$'#-5'%#!$%!#!$'+'#,"1.5#/'#2":'#-((%!'#-5'%2#%(5?"+#*+",'22'2#

!$%!#%+'#("!#2!+-,!.)#/-"."0-,%.#-(#(%!1+'3##;$'#121%.#%+01:'(!#-(#6%&"+#"6#!$'#'&".1!-"(%+)# *2),$"."0)#%**+"%,$#!"#-((%!'#2!+1,!1+'#-(#.%(01%0'#-2#!$'#@-!A2#!$'#"(.)#0%:'#-(#!"8(B#

%+01:'(!3##C-(7'+#%(5#D."":#EFGGHI=#6"+#'>%:*.'=#':*$%2-J'#!$%!#%5%*!-&'#'&".1!-"(#-2#

!$'#"(.)#2,-'(!-6-,#'>*.%(%!-"(#6"+#61(,!-"(%.#,":*.'>-!)3##4-:-.%+.)=#-(#%#:"+'#0'('+%.#,"(!'>!=#K%++1!$'+2#EK%++1!$'+2=#FGGLI#("!'2#!$%!#!$'#%!!+%,!-"(#"6#'&".1!-"(%+)#

 *2),$"."0)#-2#!$%!#-!#*+"&-5'2#%#8%)#"6#(%!1+%.-J-(0#(%!-&-2:3##C'+$%*2#2"=#/1!#!$-2#2"+!#"6#

%+01:'(!#-(#%#5":%-(#8$'+'#'>*.%(%!"+)#21,,'22#-2#.-:-!'5#"6!'(#2"1(52#!"#:'#.-7'#%(#

%+01:'(!#6+":#!$'#*"&'+!)#"6#-:%0-(%!-"(3##;$'+'#-2=#"6#,"1+2'=#("#!"#$%&! #'(!%-.:'(!#6+":#(%!-&-2:#!"#/-"."0-,%.#(%!-&-2:3##;$'#$-2!"+-,%.#*+""6#"6#!$-2#-2#!$%!#(%!-&-2:#-2#".5'+#

!$%(#/-"."0)#%2#%#!$'"+'!-,%.#6+%:'8"+73###;$'#"+-0-(%.=#FM!$

#,'(!1+)#/+%(5#"6#(%!-&-2:#'2*"12'5#/)#N'2,%+!'2=#O'-/(-J=#%(5#"!$'+2#."(0#*+'5%!'2#!$'#:%-(#+'21.!2#"6#:"5'+(# /-"."0)#8-!$#8$-,$#(%!-&-2:#-2#("8#%22",-%!'5#-(#8$%!#P"5"+#EP"5"+=#LHHHI#,%..2#!$'#

@('8#2)(!$'2-2B3F##4"#!$'#-5'%#!$%!#!$'+'#:-0$!#/'#-((%!'#2!+1,!1+'#!"#!$'#E$1:%(I#:-(5#

!$%!#-2#("!#'>*.%-('5#/)#,1++'(!#/-"."0)#-2#%#."0-,%.#*"22-/-.-!)=#!"#/'#5',-5'5#6"+#"+#%0%-(2!#/)#!$'#8'-0$!#"6#':*-+-,%.#'&-5'(,'3##;$-2#-2#!$'#6"1(5%!-"(%.#Q1'2!-"(#<#*+"*"2'#

!"#,"(2-5'+#-(#!$-2#*%*'+3##R"+'#2*',-6-,%..)=#<#8-..#%+01'#!$%!#!$'+'#-2#("#'&-5'(,'#-(#6%&"+#

"6#!$'#%55-!-"(%.#/-"."0-,%.#%221:*!-"(#%(5#%#.-!!.'#'&-5'(,'#%0%-(2!#-!#8$'(#-!#,":'2#!"#

"1+#1(5'+2!%(5-(0#"6#%!#.'%2!#"('#-:*"+!%(!#%2*',!#"6#!$'#$1:%(#,%*%,-!)#6"+#.%(01%0'3#R)#5-2,122-"(#8-..#1(6".5#-(#!$'#6".."8-(0#2!%0'23##<(#2',!-"(#L=#<#+'&-'8#

K$":27)A2#*%+%5-0:S5'6-(-(0#,.%-:#!$%!#!$'#$1:%(#,%*%,-!)#6"+#.%(01%0'#-(&".&'2#("!#"(.)#"6#!$'#8'..S2!15-'5#,":*"('(!2#"6#%#&",%/1.%+)#%(5#%#0+%::%+=#/1!#%.2"#8$%!#$'#

,%..2#T!$'#K+'%!-&'#U2*',!#"6#O%(01%0'#V2'A#EKUOVI3##<(#2',!-"(#W=#<#*+'2'(!#8$%!#%+'=#%2#

6%+#%2#<#7("8=#!$'#6-+2!#'>*.-,-!#%+01:'(!2#!$%!#!$-2#!$-+5#,":*"('(!#-2#E.-7'#2)(!%>I#21/2!%(!-%..)#-((%!'#-(#$1:%(23##4',!-"(#X#!$'(#%272#8$'!$'+#!$'#7-(52#"6#'&-5'(,'#!$%!#

$%&'#2":'!-:'2#/''(#12'5#!"#%+01'#!$%!#2)(!%>#-2#*%+!#"6#2!%(5%+5#/-"."0)#%+'#+'*.-,%!'5#

6"+#!$'#KUOV=#,.%-:-(0#!$%!#!$')#%+'#("!3##<(#*%+!-,1.%+=#<#.""7#/+-'6.)#%!#'&-5'(,'#6+":#

('1+".-(01-2!-,#2!15-'2#"6#%*$%2-%=#%!#0'('!-,#2)(5+":'2#!$%!#!%+0'!#.%(01%0'=#%(5#%!#,":*%+-2"(2#8-!$#"!$'+#*+-:%!'23##4',!-"(#Y#%+01'2#!$%!#-!#2$"1.5#("!#/'#%#21+*+-2'#!$%!#!$'#

KUOV#$%2#("!#/''(#'>*.%-('5#/-"."0-,%..)=#2-(,'#-!#,%(("!#'&'(#/'#,$%+%,!'+-J'5#

,":*1!%!-"(%..)Z#-!#-2#%(#-(!+-(2-,%..)#%/51,!-&'#,%*%,-!)#%(5#!$'#,":*1!%!-"(%.#!$'"+)#"6#:-(5#5"'2#("!#%,,"1(!#6"+#!+1'#%/51,!-&'#*+",'22'23##<(#!$-2=#<#5+%8#%#.-(7#/'!8''(#

K$":27)A2#,"(,'+(2#%/"1!#!$'#KUOV#%(5#P"5"+A2#,"(,'+(2#%/"1!#%/51,!-"(#%2#2$"8-(0#

!$'#.-:-!2#"6#!$'#,1++'(!#,"0(-!-&'#2,-'(,'#*%+%5-0:3##

!"#$#%&'()*+,-#).#(/0#1&,-2&-0#%&'23(4#

#

#################################################FU(5#-(5''5#!$'#(%!-&-2!#!+%5-!-"(#-2#'&'(#:1,$#".5'+#!$%(#!$-2=#-(,.15-(0#C.%!"#%(5#:%()#*+'S:"5'+(#K$+-2!-%(#!$-(7'+23#

Page 3: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 3/26

!"#$%&#'(%)*#)$#+%,-+.&#+%)$#'/+0/#1(.)*#$"#(#0$213&4#1/&%$2&%$%#5#63(%7-(7&8#(.&#)$#9&#()).+9-)&:#)$#)/&$.;#<#6*(;#&=$3-)+$%(.;#9+$3$7;8#(%:#'/+0/#1(.)*#(.&#%$)>#+)#+*#/&31"-3#)$#

/(=&#*$2&#+:&(#$"#'/()#)/&#2(?$.#1(.)*#$"#5#(.&#+%#)/&#"+.*)#13(0&@##A/()#)/&%#2+7/)#9&#

)/&#1(.)*#$"#)/&#/-2(%#3(%7-(7&#"(0-3);B#

# !%#"(0)>#C/$2*D;#1.$1$*&:#(#"+.*)#1(**#(%*'&.#)$#)/+*#,-&*)+$%#9(0D#()#)/&#*)(.)#$"#

)/&#0$7%+)+=&#.&=$3-)+$%>#+%#)/&#EFGHI*#6C/$2*D;>#EFGJ>#EFGF8@###K33#$"#)/&#*-00&**&*#+%#2$:&.%#7&%&.()+=&#3+%7-+*)+0*#*+%0&#)/()#)+2&#(.7-(93;#:&1&%:#$%#/+*#(%*'&.>#'/&)/&.#)/+*#

+*#.&(3+L&:#$.#%$)@##M(*+0(33;>#C/$2*D;#"(0)$.&:#3(%7-(7&#+%)$#)/.&&#0$21$%&%)*#6&(0/#$"#'/+0/#0$-3:>#$"#0$-.*&>#/(=&#7.&()#+%)&.%(3#0$213&4+);8N#)/&#3&4+0$%>#)/&#7.(22(.#6*;%)(4#

+%#)/&#9.$(:#*&%*&O8>#(%:#'/()#/&#0(2&#)$#0(33#)/&#PC.&()+=&#K*1&0)#$"#Q(%7-(7&#R*&I>#$.#

CKQR#6C/$2*D;>#EFSS8@##!%#:+=+:+%7#-1#3(%7-(7&#+%#)/+*#'(;>#/&#'(*#2(D+%7#(#1.(0)+0(3#(%:#2&)/$:$3$7+0(3#:&0+*+$%T#/&#'(*#).;+%7#)$#:+*)+%7-+*/#)/$*&#,-&*)+$%*#)/()#'&.&#$1&%#

)$#2&(%+%7"-3#+%,-+.;#7+=&%#)/&#0-..&%)#*)()&#$"#D%$'3&:7&>#(%:#)/$*&#)/()#'&.&#%$)@##U+*#

03(+2#'(*#)/()#*;%)(4#0$-3:#9&#+%=&*)+7()&:>#9-)#)/&#CKQR#0$-3:#%$)#"$.#)/&#"$.&*&&(93&#

"-)-.&#6C/$2*D;>#EFGF8@##6Q()&.>#9;#EFJG>#/&#9&7(%#)$#&%)&.)(+%#)/&#+:&(#)/()#'&#'+33#%&=&.#-%:&.*)(%:#)/&#CKQR#0$21$%&%)>#9&0(-*&#+)#"(33*#$-)*+:&#)/&#:$2(+%#$"#'/()#$-.#

0$7%+)+$%#0(%#/(%:3&>#2-0/#(*#)/&#%$)+$%#$"#(#1.+2&#%-29&.#"(33*#$-)*+:&#)/&#:$2(+%#$"#.()#0$7%+)+$%#6C/$2*D;>#EFJG8@8##V/&#1.$?&0)>#)/&%>#+*#)$#&413(+%#'/()#*&%)&%0&*#3+D&#WC$3$.3&**#7.&&%#+:&(*#*3&&1#"-.+$-*3;X#(%:#WU(.23&**#3+))3&#:$7*#9(.D#,-+&)3;X#/(=&#+%#

0$22$%Y)/&#1.$1&.);# !"#$$#%&'#(  Y(%:#%$)#)$#).;#)$#&413(+%#'/;#$.#+%#'/()#

0+.0-2*)(%0&*#(#1&.*$%#'$-3:#9&#2$.&#3+D&3;#)$#*(;#$%&#.()/&.#)/(%#)/&#$)/&.#6C/$2*D;>#EFGJ8@##V$#-*&#(%#(%(3$7;#".$2#)/&#0$%*).-0)+$%#+%:-*).;>#)/&#3&4+0$%#+*#3+D&#)/&#9.+0D*>#

2$.)(.>#(%:#$)/&.#9-+3:+%7#2()&.+(3*>#'/+3&#)/&#7.(22(.#+*#3+D&#)/&#9-+3:+%7#0$:&*>#'/+0/#

*1&0+";#'(;*#+%#'/+0/#)/&*&#2()&.+(3*#0(%#9&#0$29+%&:#)$#2(D&#3(.7&.#-%+)*>#*-0/#(*#

'(33*>#.$$"*>#.$$2*>#(%:#-3)+2()&3;#/$-*&*@##V/&*&#)'$#"(0&)*#$"#)/&#3(%7-(7&#"(0-3);#'&#/(=&#(#.&(*$%(93&#/$1&#$"#-%0$=&.+%7#(%:#-%:&.*)(%:+%7>#(00$.:+%7#)$#C/$2*D;@##M-)#)/&#

0$%*).-0)+$%#+%:-*).;#'$-3:#%$)#7&)#=&.;#"(.#'+)/#?-*)#.('#2()&.+(3*#(%:#9-+3:+%7#0$:&*@##!)#(3*$#%&&:*#(.0/+)&0)*#)$#:&0+:&#'/&.&#)/&#'(33*#*/$-3:#7$#+%#1(.)+0-3(.#0(*&*#)$#(0/+&=&#

(#:&*+.&:#&""&0)>#(%:#0$%).(0)$.*#)$#(0)-(33;#(**&293&#)/&#.('#2()&.+(3*#+%)$#'(33*#+%#'(;*#

0$%*+*)&%)#'+)/#9-)#%$)#-%+,-&3;#:&)&.2+%&:#9;#)/&#*).+0)-.&*#$"#)/&#9-+3:+%7#0$:&*@##!%#)/&#*(2&#'(;>#)/&#/-2(%#0(1(0+);#"$.#3(%7-(7&#2-*)#0$%*+*)#$"#2$.&#)/(%#(#3&4+0$%#(%:#(#

7.(22(.T#+)#(3*$#0$%)(+%*#)/&#1$'&.#)$#(**&293&#)/&#'$.:*#+%#(00$.:(%0&#'+)/#)/&#

7.(22(.#)$#2(D&#(0)-(3#*&%)&%0&*@##!)#+*#)/+*#0(1(0+);#)/()#C/$2*D;#0(33*#)/&#CKQR>#

+:&%)+";+%7#+)#"$.#)/&#1-.1$*&*#$"#:+*)+%7-+*/+%7#+)#".$2#7.(22(.#(%:#1-))+%7#+)#(*+:&>#()#3&(*)#+%#)/&#9-3D#$"#/+*#)&0/%+0(3#'$.D@#

# V/+*#:+*)+%0)+$%#+*#*$#2-0/#1(.)#$"#)/&#0$22$%#7.$-%:>#()#3&(*)#"$.#7&%&.()+=&#

3+%7-+*)*>#)/()#+)#+*#&(*;#)$#2+**#/$'#+21$.)(%)#+)#+*@##M-)#)/&#1.&ZC/$2*D+(%#9&/(=+$.+*)#).(:+)+$%#0.-0+(33;#:+:#%$)#"(0)$.#3(%7-(7&#+%#)/+*#'(;@##[$.#)/&2>#)/&#1.$?&0)#'(*#)$#

 1.&:+0)#6(%:#0$%).$38#'/()#(#1&.*$%#'$-3:#*(;#'/&%#1.&*&%)&:#'+)/#(#1(.)+0-3(.#*)+2-3-*>#

(*#(#.&*-3)#$"#)/&#1&.*$%I*#/+*)$.;#$"#0$%:+)+$%+%7#6\D+%%&.>#EFGJ8@##M;#".(2+%7#)/&#1.$?&0)#

#################################################O#V/&#9.$(:#*&%*&#$"#*;%)(4#)/()#C/$2*D;#-*&:#()#)/()#)+2&#+%03-:&:#(3*$#)/&#1/$%$3$7;#(%:#(*1&0)*#$"#'/()#'$-3:#%$'#9&#0(33&:#*&2(%)+0*Y(33#$"#3(%7-(7&#)/()#+*#.-3&Z9(*&:#(%:#0$21$*+)+$%(3@##!%#)/+*#1(1&.>#!I33#-*&#7.(22(.#(%:#*;%)(4#2$.&#$.#3&**#+%)&.0/(%7&(93;@##[$.#)/&#9.$(:#0$%*).-(3#$"#*;%)(4>#)/+*#+*#(00-.()&T#"$.#)/&#%(..$'&.#*&%*&#$"#*;%)(4#6/$'#'$.:*#(.&#0$29+%&:#)$#2(D&#*&%)&%0&*8#+)#+*#%$)#(00-.()&>#

 9-)#/(.23&**@##](..$'#*;%)(4#+*#%$)#+:&%)+0(3#)$#7.(22(.>#9-)#+)#+*#(%#+21$.)(%)#(%:#.&1.&*&%)()+=&#*-91(.)#$"#7.(22(.@#

Page 4: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 4/26

!"#$%!&#'()*#$%+)#'+,+#($$+-.$!"/#$0#+1.2(!"#$%+#30,-#("4#$%+#50"$+"$#03#(#&+"$+"5+#(22#($#$%+#&(-+#$!-+*#("4#!"#$%+#&(-+#$+,-&6###70,#+1(-.2+*#(#5+,$(!"#8!&9(2#&$!-929&#'0924#

$,!//+,#(#.(,$!592(,#&+$#03#'0,4&#:)#(&&05!($!0"*#$%0&+#'0,4&#'0924#$,!//+,#(44!$!0"(2#

'0,4&#:)#(&&05!($!0"*#("4#3!"(22)#$%+#5022+5$!0"#03#'0,4&#&0#(5$!8($+4#-!/%$#$,!//+,#(#

&!-.2+#&)"$(5$!5#3,(-+#!"$0#'%!5%#(22#$%0&+#'0,4&#50924#:+#&20$$+4*#(/(!"#:)#(&&05!($!0"6##

;%9&*#200<!"/#($#(#=+-:,("4$#5("8(&#-!/%$#$,!//+,#$%+#'0,4#>?9$5%@*#("4#$%+#5("8(&#("4A0,#$%+#'0,4#?9$5%#!$&+23#-!/%$#$,!//+,#>/,+($@#("4#>.(!"$+,@6##;%+"#$%+&+#$%,++#50"$+"$#

'0,4&#$0/+$%+,#-!/%$#$,!//+,#$%+#3,(-+#>;%+#BBB#'+,+#BBB##BBB&@#,+&92$!"/#!"#$%+#9$$+,("5+#>;%+#?9$5%#'+,+#/,+($#.(!"$+,&6@##C%($#!&#:+!"/#&(!4#("4#$%+#&$,95$9,(2#

50"4!$!0"&#0"#!$#50-+#(:09$#:)#+&&+"$!(22)#$%+#&(-+#$%+0,+$!5(2#4+8!5+&6##D"4#$%($#'()#03#

200<!"/#($#$%+#.,0:2+-&#03#2("/9(/+#.,08+4#+-.$)#("4#&$+,!2+*#(&#E%0-&<)#4+-0"&$,($+4#'!$%#30,5+6##F0#>8+,:(2#:+%(8!0,@#,+-(!"+4#(#'+(<#.0!"$#30,#G+%(8!0,!&-#:+5(9&+#!$#4!4#

"0$#4!&$!"/9!&%#$%+#EDHI#3,0-#/,(--(,#("4#2+1!50"6##J"#50"$,(&$*#2("/9(/+#:+5(-+#(#

40-(!"#03#/,+($#(550-.2!&%-+"$#("4#5,+4!:!2!$)#30,#50/"!$!8+#&5!+"5+#:+5(9&+#E%0-&<)#

4!4#-(<+#$%!&#4!&$!"5$!0"6## E%0-&<)@&#3922+&$#.0&!$!8+#5%(,(5$+,!K($!0"#03#'%($#$%+#EDHI#!&#!"#E%0-&<)#

LE%0-&<)*#MNOOP*#'%+,+#%+#4!&59&&+&#'!$%#(..,08(2#?+&5(,$+&@#0:&+,8($!0"&#(:09$#%9-("#2("/9(/+#+1.,+&&+4#!"#Q(,$#R#03# !"#$%&'()%*"'+",*-.'/ 6##;%+#E,+($!8+#D&.+5$#03#H("/9(/+#I&+*#E%0-&<)#&()&*#!&#$%+#%9-("#(:!2!$)#$0#9&+#2!"/9!&$!5#,+&09,5+&#

L805(:92(,)#!$+-&#("4#&)"$(5$!5#,92+&P#!"#(#'()#$%($#%(&#$%,++#.,0.+,$!+&#&!-92$("+09&2)S#

!$#!&#L!P#9":09"4+4*#L!!P#&$!-929&T3,++*#("4#L!!!P#(..,0.,!($+#$0#&!$9($!0"&6##?+&5(,$+&#'(&#!"$+,+&$+4#!"#$%!&#50"&$+22($!0"#03#.,0.+,$!+&#:+5(9&+#%+#:+2!+8+4#$%($#!$#50924#"0$#:+#

+1.2(!"+4#!"#.9,+2)#-+5%("!5(2#$+,-&*#'!$%!"#(#$%+0,)#03#50"$(5$#.%)&!5&6##?+&5(,$+&#

0:&+,8+4#$%($#"0#("!-(2#%(4#50--9"!5($!8+#:+%(8!0,#L0,#(")#0$%+,#:+%(8!0,P#$%($#%(4#

$%+&+#.,0.+,$!+&*#"0,#4!4#(")#(9$0-($0"*#+1!&$!"/#0,#!-(/!"(,)6##U+#',0$+S##

# V3#$%+&+#$%+#3!,&$#W$+&$X#!&#$%($#$%+)#W-(5%!"+&X#50924#"+8+,#9&+#'0,4&#0,#0$%+,#&!/"&#(,,("/+4#!"#&95%#(#-(""+,#(&#!&#50-.+$+"$#$0#9&#!"#0,4+,#$0#4+52(,+#09,#$%09/%$&#$0#

0$%+,&S#30,#'+#-()#+(&!2)#50"5+!8+#(#-(5%!"+#$0#:+#&0#50"&$,95$+4#$%($#!$#+-!$&#805(:2+&*#

("4#+8+"#$%($#!$#+-!$&#&0-+#50,,+&.0"4+"$#$0#$%+#(5$!0"#9.0"#!$#03#+1$+,"(2#0:Y+5$&#'%!5%#5(9&+#(#5%("/+#!"#!$&#0,/("&Z#30,#+1(-.2+*#!3#$095%+4#!"#(#.(,$!592(,#.2(5+#!$#-()#4+-("4#

'%($#'+#'!&%#$0#&()#$0#!$Z#!3#!"#("0$%+,#!$#-()#5,)#09$#$%($#!$#!&#%9,$*#("4#&95%#2!<+Z#:9$#"0$#

$%($#!$#&%0924#(,,("/+#$%+-#8(,!09&2)#&0#(&#(..0&!$+2)#$0#,+.2)#$0#'%($#!&#&(!4#!"#!$&#

 .,+&+"5+*#(&#-+"#03#$%+#20'+&$#/,(4+#03#!"$+22+5$#5("#406#[#70,#!$#!&#%!/%2)#4+&+,8!"/#03#,+-(,<*#$%($#$%+,+#(,+#"0#-+"#&0#4922#("4#&$9.!4*#"0$#+8+"#!4!0$&*#(&#$0#:+#!"5(.(:2+#03#

 Y0!"!"/#$0/+$%+,#4!33+,+"$#'0,4&*#("4#$%+,+:)#50"&$,95$!"/#(#4+52(,($!0"#:)#'%!5%#$0#-(<+#

$%+!,#$%09/%$&#9"4+,&$0046##

?+&5(,$+&#L("4#E%0-&<)P#0:&+,8+&#$%($#!$#!&#+(&)#$0#!-(/!"+#-(5%!"+&#$%($#9$$+,#(#2!-!$+4#

"9-:+,#03#'0,4&#0,#&+$#.%,(&+&6##;%+&+#'0,4&#0,#.%,(&+&#50924#:+#9$$+,+4#4+$+,-!"!&$!5(22)*#'%+"+8+,#(#5+,$(!"#&$!-929&#!&#+1.+,!+"5+4*#0,#$%+)#50924#:+#9$$+,+4#

,("40-2)*#'!$%#"0#50""+5$!0"#$0#$%+#+"8!,0"-+"$6##C%($#!&#&.+5!(2#(:09$#%9-("#2("/9(/+#

 :+%(8!0,#!&#$%($#'+#\(,,("/+#W'0,4&X#8(,!09&2)]#L!6+6#!"#("#9":09"4+4#'()P*#"0$#!"#(#

,+32+1T2!<+#'()#4+$+,-!"+4#:)#&$!-929&*#("4#)+$#(2&0#"0$#,("40-2)#:9$#,($%+,#\&0#(&#(..0&!$+2)#$0#,+.2)#$0#'%($#!&#&(!4#!"#W09,X#.,+&+"5+]#("4#\50"&$,95$#(#4+52(,($!0"#:)#

'%!5%#$0#-(<+#W09,X#$%09/%$&#9"4+,&$004]#L!6+6#!"#'()&#$%($#(,+#(..,0.,!($+P6##;%($#09,#

Page 5: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 5/26

!"#$%"$&'%(&')('%#*+%#,&,')('#+-'&#+%$.'-+'/"0&')-'12&"-)3&4')-'5+%!,'#+-'*&'12&"-)3&'-+'2&6&"-'*"10'%#1."#$&,'"#')#7)#)-&'3"2)&-8'+7'(&#-&#1&('-."-'5&'.&"2')#'+%2'62&(&#1&9'':."-'

+%2'!"#$%"$&'%(&')('(-)/%!%(;72&&')('#+-'&#+%$.'-+'/"0&')-'12&"-)3&4')-')('#+-'12&"-)3&'-+'

(6&"0'5+2,('2"#,+/!89''<#,')-')('#+-'&#+%$.'-."-')-'*&'"662+62)"-&4')-'5+%!,'#+-'*&'

12&"-)3&'-+'62+,%1&'-.&'-.2&&'%--&2"#1&('=>"#$&24'(#"0&?@'=>"#$&24'&"$!&?'"#,'=>"#$&24'

!&+6"2,?')#'-.&'1+22&1-'1)21%/(-"#1&(9A''B%-'*&."3)+2'-."-')('()/%!-"#&+%(!8'%#*+%#,&,@'#+-',&-&2/)#&,'*8'(-)/%!)@'"#,'C#+-'2"#,+/'*%-D'"662+62)"-&')('(6&1)"!9'':."-')('5."-'

>&(1"2-&('-++0'"('*&)#$'(%77)1)&#-'&3),&#1&'-."-'"'12&"-%2&'."('"'/)#,@'"#,'5."-'E.+/(08'("),'/%(-'*&'6%-'"(),&')7'+#&'5"('-+'/"0&'62+$2&(('+#'%#,&2(-"#,)#$'+-.&2'

"(6&1-('+7'!"#$%"$&')#'$&#&2"-)3&@'1+/6%-"-)+#"!'-&2/(9'

' F+5',+&('E.+/(08G('-"1-)1"!',&1)()+#'-+'7"1-+2'-.&'62+*!&/('+7'!"#$%"$&')#-+'3+1"*%!"28@'(8#-"H@'"#,'-.&'E<IJ'!++0'KL'8&"2('!"-&2M'':.&'"#(5&2')('-."-')-'(-)!!'!++0('

$++,9''E.+/(08'5"('2)$.-'-."-'$2"//"2N(8#-"H'1+%!,'*&'2)6&'7+2')#3&(-)$"-)+#')#'-&2/('+7'

-.&#;#&5'7+2/"!'#+-)+#('!)0&'2&1%2()3&'2%!&(@'"#,'!)#$%)(-('."3&'7%!!'*++0(.&!3&('-+'62+3&'

)-9'':.)('."('!&,'-+'&#+2/+%('#&5',)(1+3&2)&('"*+%-'-.&'(-2%1-%2&'+7'O#$!)(.'"#,'.%#,2&,('+7'+-.&2'!"#$%"$&(9''P#'1+#-2"(-@'-.&2&'."('*&&#'&((&#-)"!!8'#+'62+$2&(('+#'-.&'E<IJ@'"#,'

-.&'*%!0'+7'!)#$%)(-('."3&'7+!!+5&,'.)('",3)1&'#+-'-+'6%2(%&')-Q&3&#'-+'-.&'6+)#-'+7'#&"2!8'7+2$&--)#$'-."-')-')('-.&2&9''<#,'8&-'#+'2&"(+#('."3&'1+/&'-+'!)$.-'-+',&#8'-."-'-.&'E<IJ'&H)(-(9''R&'0#+5'"'!+-'/+2&'"*+%-'-.&'*%)!,)#$'1+,&('7+2'(&#-&#1&('-."#'5&',),Q"#,'"'

 *)-'/+2&'"*+%-'-.&'*%)!,)#$'/"-&2)"!('-.&/(&!3&(Q*%-'#+-'()$#)7)1"#-!8'/+2&'"*+%-'-.&'

"21.)-&1-('"#,'1+#-2"1-+2(9''S&-'5&'/%(-'(-)!!'"((%/&'-."-'-.&'"21.)-&1-('"#,'1+#-2"1-+2('&H)(-@'()/6!8'*&1"%(&'-.&2&'"2&'"1-%"!'(&#-&#1&('"2+%#,'%('5.)1.',+'/+2&'+2'!&(('1+/6!8'

5)-.'+%2'*%)!,)#$'1+,&('*%-'5.)1.'+%2'*%)!,)#$'1+,&('1"##+-'"11+%#-'7+2'-.&'&H)(-&#1&'+7'

+2'"(6&1-('+7'-.&'#"-%2&'+79''R&'1"#'("8'5.8'-.&'+*T&1-'7+!!+5('-.&'3&2*')#'"'6"2-)1%!"2'

(&#-&#1&@'T%(-'"('5&'1"#'("8'5.8'-.&'5"!!'7+2/('"'2)$.-'"#$!&'5)-.'-.&'7!++29''B%-'+%2'$2"//"2'1"##+-'("8'5.8'-."-'6"2-)1%!"2'+*T&1-'5"('%(&,'5)-.'-."-'3&2*'+#'-."-'+11"()+#@'

 T%(-'"('+%2'*%)!,)#$'1+,&'1"##+-'("8'5.8'-."-'5"!!')('&H"1-!8'-.&2&')#'-."-'6"2-)1%!"2'.+%(&9'

' P7'5&'"11&6-'-.)(',)3)()+#'+7'-.&'!"#$%"$&'7"1%!-8')#-+'C"-'!&"(-D'-.&'3+1"*%!"28@'-.&'

$2"//"2@'"#,'-.&'E<IJ@'5&'1"#'-.&#'$+'+#'-+'"(0'7+2'5.)1.'+7'-.&(&')('-.&2&'&3),&#1&'-."-')-')(')##"-&9'':.&#'5&'1"#'"(0'7+2'5.)1.'+7'-.&(&')('-.&2&'&3),&#1&'-."-')-')('*)+!+$)1"!'

)#'-.&'%(%"!'(&#(&9''<#,'7)#"!!8'5&'1"#'"(0'5.&-.&2'-.&'"#(5&2('-+'-.&(&'-5+'"#(5&2('

/"-1.9'

B&7+2&'62+1&&,)#$'-+'-."-@'.+5&3&2@'!&-'/&'6"%(&'-+'1+//&#-'+#'5.8')-')('&"(8'7+2'1+$#)-)3&'(1)&#1&@'&3+!%-)+#"28'6(81.+!+$8@'"#,'2&!"-&,'-.&+2)&('-+'+3&2(-"-&'-.&)2'

2&(%!-(9''P-'1+%!,'*&'-."-'-.&'7)&!,')('*"(&,'+#'1&2-")#',&1)()+#('"*+%-'.+5'-+',&!)/)-'-.&'

,+/")#'+7')#U%)28'-."-'."3&'*&1+/&'(+'/%1.'6"2-'+7'+%2'."*)-('-."-'5&'7+2$&-'"*+%-'-.&/9''

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A'V&&'E.&#&8'"#,'V&87"2-.'CE.&#&8'W'V&87"2-.@'XYYLD'1.9'Z@'K'7+2',&-")!&,',)(1%(()+#'+7'3+1"!'

1+//%#)1"-)+#'"/+#$'3&23&-'/+#0&8(9'':.&8'(.+5'-."-'-.&'"!"2/'1"!!('+7'-.&'3&23&-('"2&'#+-'+#!8'"662+62)"-&'*%-'/"8'"!(+'*&'(-)/%!%('72&&9''<-'!&"(-'-.&8'"2&'#+-'2&7!&H;!)0&@'*&1"%(&'-.&'1"!!('"2&'#+-'"%-+/"-)1"!!8'-2)$$&2&,'*8'-.&'(&&)#$'+7'"'1&2-")#'62&,"-+2['-.&8'1"#'*&'(%662&((&,')7'"#'"#)/"!')('"!+#&'+2'

)#'-.&'62&(&#1&'+7'2)3"!('2"-.&2'-."#'0)#N"!!)&(9'':.&8'6&2."6('1"#'"!(+'*&'7"!()7)&,')#'+2,&2'-+',)(-2"1-'+2'(1"2&'+77'"'2)3"!'*"#,'+7'/+#0&8(9''B%-'&3&#')7'-.&8'"2&'%(&,')#'-.&(&'\12&"-)3&G'5"8(@'-.&2&')('#+',+%*-'-."-'-.&'3&23&-'1+//%#)1"-)+#'(8(-&/')('(-2)1-!8'*+%#,&,@'1+#()(-)#$'+7'!&(('-."#'XL',)(-)#1-'3+1"!)]"-)+#('"#,'#+'(8(-&/'7+2'1+/*)#)#$'-.&/'1+/6+()-)+#"!!89'':.)(')('"#+-.&2')!!%(-2"-)+#'+7'-.&'6+)#-'-."-'"!!'-.2&&'

E<IJ'1."2"1-&2)(-)1('"2&'#&&,&,'-+'U%"!)78'"('-2%&'E"2-&()"#'12&"-)3)-89''CP'-."#0'V-&3&'I"52&#1&'7+2' 6+)#-)#$'+%-'-.)('2&7&2&#1&'-+'/&9D'

Page 6: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 6/26

!"#$%#$%&$'&(#)**+%,&-',#./%0"&.%123%,"&13#&$%)$'#3&%,1%(1-'*&,&.&$$%)*1./%1.&%4#-&.$#1.5%%613%&7)-'*&8%#,%-#/",%.1,%9&%$1%:)3%:31-%,32&%,"),%#:%+12%/#;&%-&%).+%<./*#$"%

$&.,&.(&%=%().%')3$&%#,$%'"3)$&%$,32(,23&%(1-'*&,&*+8%#4&.,#:+%#,$%.1.*1()*%4&'&.4&.(#&$8%

).4%$1%1.5%%>2''1$&%,"&.%,"),%=%")4%)%(1-'*&,&%/3)--)3%:13%<./*#$"5%%=%(12*4%#.%)%$&.$&%

*&/#,#-),&*+%93)/%,"),%-+%(1/.#,#;&%$(#&.(&%().%/#;&%-&%)%(1-'*&,&%,"&13+%1:%<./*#$"5%%

?2,%,"),%41&$%.1,%-&).%,"),%=%");&%-)4&%,"&%$*#/",&$,%'31/3&$$%1.%,"&%@2&$,#1.%,"),%>A#..&3%,"12/",%0)$%#-'13,).,B%"10%,1%'3&4#(,%C).4%(1.,31*D%0"),%')3,#(2*)3%<./*#$"%

$'&)A&3$%012*4%$)+%0"&.%'3&$&.,&4%0#,"%)%$,#-2*2$5%%E12*4%,"&+%$)+%FG)3-*&$$%*#,,*&%41/$%9)3A%$1:,*+H%13%FI1*13*&$$%/3&&.%#4&)$%$*&&'%:23#12$*+HJ$&.,&.(&$%,"),%)3&%&.,#3&*+%

,"&%$)-&%)$%:)3%)$%-+%$1K()**&4%F(1-'*&,&H%,"&13+%#$%(1.(&3.&45%%!"&3&%(12*4%9&%).1,"&3%

0"1*&%4#-&.$#1.%,1%,"&%'"&.1-&.1.8%0"#("%=%)-%'31.&%,1%#/.13&5L%

%

!"#$%#&'(#)*+,#$--.&(/#

%

M&,H$%,"&.%013A%0#,"%,"#$%#4&)%,"),%,"&%"2-).%*)./2)/&%()')(#,+%(1.$#$,$%1:%,"3&&%'1$$#9*+%(1-'*&7%:)(,13$B%;1()92*)3+8%/3)--)38%).4%,"&%INMO5%%!"&.%0&%().%)$A%0"#("%1:%,"&$&%

)3&%#..),&5%%=%)((&',%,"&%:)-#*#)3%I"1-$A#).%)3/2-&.,$%,"),%/3)--)3%#$%*)3/&*+%#..),&8%)')3,%:31-%)%*#-#,&4%.2-9&3%1:%')3)-&,&3$%,"),%)3&%:#7&4%9+%&7'&3#&.(&%C$&&%?)A&3%PQQR%:13%$1-&%3&;#&0%).4%4#$(2$$#1.D5%%=%0#**%.1,%(1.$#4&3%,"&%;1()92*)3+%),%)**8%)*,"12/"%=%.1,&%

,"),%#,$%1;&3)**%$,32(,23&%-#/",%;&3+%0&**%9&%#..),&%,118%&;&.%,"12/"%,"&%')3,#(2*)3%$12.4K

-&).#./%')#3$%(&3,)#.*+%)3&%.1,5%%C>&&8%:13%&7)-'*&8%?)A&3%C?)A&38%PQQSD%:13%)3/2-&.,$%,"),%,"&%$)-&%,"3&&K0)+%4#$,#.(,#1.%9&,0&&.%.12.$8%;&39$8%).4%)4T&(,#;&$%#$%:12.4%#.%)**%

*)./2)/&$8%)*,"12/"%)%')3,#(2*)3%.1,#1.%$2("%)$%F,)**H%-#/",%9&%&7'3&$$&4%)$%)%.12.%#.%1.&%

*)./2)/&%CFU1".%")$%,)**V.&$$WHD%13%)%;&39%CFU1".%,)**$HD%13%).%)4T&(,#;&%CFU1".%#$%,)**HD5%%=%

:1(2$%#.$,&)4%1.%,"&%*#,,*&K4#$(2$$&4%INMO8%).4%)$A%0"&,"&3%,"&%$)-&%A#.4$%1:%)3/2-&.,$%,"),%$"10%,"),%/3)--)3%#$%#..),&%().%9&%(1.$,32(,&4%)*$1%:13%#,5%

% X.&%A#.4%1:%&;#4&.(&%,"),%$+.,)7%#$%*)3/&*+%#..),&%(1-&$%:31-%,"&%:)(,%,"),%#,%#$%2.#;&3$)*%#.%,"&%"2-).%$'&(#&$5%%613%&7)-'*&8%#,%#$%,"12/",%,"),%&;&3+%*)./2)/&%#.%,"&%

013*4%4#$,#./2#$"&$%/3)--),#()*%$29T&(,$%:31-%19T&(,$8%).4%(1.,)#.$%9)$#(%$,32(,23&$%#.%

0"#("%,"&%19T&(,%#$%-13&%(*1$&*+%/312'&4%0#,"%,"&%;&39%,").%,"&%$29T&(,%#$%C?)A&38%RYZZD5%%=$%,"&%INMO%$#-#*)3*+%2.#;&3$)*[%%!"&%).$0&3%#$8%1:%(123$&8%+&$5%%<;&3+%$1(#&,+%2$&$%#,$%

*)./2)/&%#.%,"&%:3&&%&7'3&$$#1.%1:%,"12/",5%%=.%&;&3+%$1(#&,+%'&1'*&%$'1.,).&12$*+%-)A&%

2'%.&0%$&.,&.(&$%#.%)%0)+%,"),%#$%.1,%(1.,31**&4%9+%,"&#3%&.;#31.-&.,%13%).+%$#-'*&%

(")3)(,&3#\),#1.%1:%,"&#3%#.,&3.)*%$,),&$8%92,%,"),%#$%$&&.%)$%)''31'3#),&%).4%'23'1$&:2*%#.%,"&%$#,2),#1.5%%E&%A.10%1:%41**$%).4%$,2::&4%,1+$%,"),%/#;&%)%:#7&4%3)./&%1:%$&,%3&$'1.$&$%

#.%)%-&(").#()*%13%3).41-%:)$"#1.8%92,%0&%41.H,%A.10%).+%'&1'*&%/312'$%,"),%)3&%*#A&%

,"#$5%%!"#$%)''*#&$%,1%,"&%*1./K#$1*),&4%,3#9&$-).%1:%'*)(&$%*#A&%!)$-).#)%).4%,"&%]&0%^2#.&)%"#/"*).4$%)$%-2("%)$%,1%).+%1,"&3%/312'5%%=%A.10%1:%.1%(1.,31;&3$+%1.%,"#$%'1#.,%

0"),$1&;&35%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%L%E"&.%=%$)+%,"),%,"&%*)./2)/&%:)(2*,+%#$%:)(,13&4%#.,1%,"&%*&7#(1.8%,"&%/3)--)38%).4%,"&%INMO8%=%41.H,%.&(&$$)3#*+%-&).%,"),%).+%1:%,"&$&%)3&%$'&(#:#(%,1%*)./2)/&5%%!"&+%(12*4%9&%-13&%/&.&3)*%-&.,)*%()')(#,#&$%

,"),%().%9&%)''*#&4%,1%*)./2)/&5%%613%&7)-'*&8%,"&%*&7#(1.%#$%'319)9*+%),%*&)$,%4&&'*+%(1..&(,&4%,1%)%-13&%/&.&3)*%(1.(&',2)*%$+$,&-%0"#("%().%)*$1%9&%4&'*1+&4%#.%1,"&3%0)+$%C$)+8%#.%.1.;&39)*%3&)$1.#./8%9&*10%,"&%*&;&*%1:%(1.$(#12$.&$$D5%%>#-#*)3*+8%,"&%INMO%-)+%9&%.1,"#./%-13&%,").%,"&%"2-).%F:3&&%0#**H%C0"),&;&3%,"),%#$D%9&#./%&7&3(#$&4%#.%,"&%41-)#.%1:%*)./2)/&5%%=%#.,&.4%,1%*&);&%,"#$%&.,#3&*+%1'&.5%%=.%).+%

()$&8%*)./2)/&%#$%#.,&3&$,#./%9&()2$&%#,%3&;&)*$%123%:3&&%0#**%-1$,%:2**+%).4%3#("*+8%)$%2.4&3$,114%9+%_&$()3,&$8%)$%0&**%)$%!23#./%C!23#./8%RY`QD%).4%1,"&3$5%

Page 7: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 7/26

! "!#$%&'(!)*'(!&+!$,*($'%$!-./-!#0'-/1!*#!2/34$20!*''/-$!%&5$#!+3&5!-.$!+/%-!-./-!*-!$5$34$#!#&!$/3206!7$+&3$!%.*2(3$'!./,$!2$/3'$(!5/'0!&-.$3!-.*'4#!-./-!#$$5!#*582$!-&!9#:!!

;-!./#!7$$'!#.&<'!-./-!-.$!,$30!+*3#-!-<&=<&3(!9--$3/'%$#!&+!%.*2(3$'6!<.*%.!/88$/3!

 7$+&3$!-.$!/4$!>6!/23$/(0!#.&<!$,*($'%$!&+!#0'-/%-*%!#-39%-93$:!!?'42*#.!%.*2(3$'!#/0!

@</'-!%&&)*$A!<.$3$/#!B/8/'$#$!%.*2(3$'!#/0!@%&&)*$!</'-A6!#.&<*'4!-.$!8/3-*%92/3!)*'(!

&+!+*1$(!<&3(!&3($3!-./-!-.$!+922!2/'49/4$!-.$0!/3$!2$/3'*'4!#8$%*+*$#!CD2&&56!EFGHI!D3&<'6!EFGJI!K2&7*'6!EFLMN:!!?,$'!5&3$!#8$%-/%92/3206!O3$'%.!%.*2(3$'!%&'#*#-$'-20!89-!

+*'*-$!,$37#!7$+&3$!'$4/-*&'!/'(!'&'+*'*-$!,$37#!/+-$3!'$4/-*&'P$,$'!-.&94.!-.$0!(&'A-!0$-!9#$!'&'+*'*-$!,$37#!*'!-.$!%&33$%-6!/(92-=2*)$!</0!CQ$83$R!S!T*$3%$6!EFFJN:!!U.*#!

/3495$'-!/2#&!/882*$#!-&!-.$!V"WXY!%.*2(3$'A#!$/320!9--$3/'%$#!/3$!/2#&!#-*5929#=+3$$!/'(!

 8938&#$+92:!!U.$0!/3$!'&-6!&+!%&93#$6!9'7&9'($(!/-!-.$!-<&!<&3(!#-/4$6!70!($+*'*-*&':!!D9-!-.$3$!*#!59%.!3$/#&'!-&!-.*')!-./-!-.$!-<&=<&3(!9--$3/'%$#!/3$!/773$,*/-*&'#!&+!2/34$3!

#-39%-93$#!-./-!-.$!%.*2(!./#!*'!5*'(!79-!%/''&-!9--$3!0$-!CD2&&56!EFGHN:!!U.$3$!*#!/!+/*3!

/5&9'-!&+!,/3*$-0!$,$'!*'!-<&!<&3(!9--$3/'%$#6!/#!%.*2(3$'!5/)$!(*++$3$'-!%.&*%$#!/7&9-!

<.*%.!&+!/!3/'4$!&+!#$5/'-*%!3$2/-*&'#.*8#!-&!$183$##!&'!/!4*,$'!&%%/#*&':!!"'(6!5&3$!#*4'*+*%/'-206!-.$3$!*#!'&[email protected]$$!<&3(!#-/4$A:!!"+-$3!/!+$<!5&'-.#6!2/'49/4$!9#$!$182&($#!

*'!/'!9'7&9'($(!+/#.*&'!#&!-./-!*-!*#!'&!2&'4$3!8&##*72$!-&!$'95$3/-$!-.$!#-39%-93/2!%&57*'/-*&'#!-.$!%.*2(!9#$#:!!V.*2(3$'A#!9--$3/'%$#!/2#&!5/0!'&-!7$!/883&83*/-$!*'!-.$!/(92-A#!#$'#$I!-.$0!/3$!&+-$'!-/%-2$##!/'(!/7398-6!+&3!$1/582$:!!D9-!-./-!*#!'&-!-.$!#$'#$!&+!

/883&3*/-$'$##!*#!/-!*##9$!*'!-.$!V"WXI!3/-.$36!-.$!8&*'-!*#!-./-!-.$!%.*2(3$'A#!9--$3/'%$#!

/3$!'&-!3/'(&5!#-3*'4#!&+!<&3(#!-./-!/3*#$!70!+3$$!/##&%*/-*&':!!"'(!*'!/'0!%/#$6!*-!*#!%2$/3!-./-!V"WX!7$./,*&3!*#!+9220!*'!82/%$!2&'4!7$+&3$!%.*2(3$'!#-/3-!)*'($34/3-$':!

! D0!+/3!-.$!5&#-!*58&3-/'-!/3495$'-!+&3!*''/-$'$##!*#!-.$!8&,$3-0!&+!#-*5929#!

/3495$'-6!<.*%.!./#!#$,$3/2!+2/,&3#:!!K*'%$!-.*#!*#!-.$!5&#-!*58&3-/'-!%&'#*($3/-*&'6!/'(!

#*'%$!*-!%&92(!7$!%&'-3&,$3#*/26!;!<*22!2*'4$3!&,$3!*-!/!7*-:!!U.$'!;!<*22!5$'-*&'!-<&!,/3*/'-#!&+!-.*#!/3495$'-!-./-!./,$!7$$'!9#$(!*'!-.$!%/#$!&+!#0'-/16!<.*%.!#$$5!/2#&!/8820!-&!-.$!

V"WX:!! U.$!7/#*%!*($/!&+!8&,$3-0!&+!#-*5929#!/3495$'-#!*#!-./-!-.$3$!*#!3*%.'$##!/'(!

#-39%-93$!*'!-.$!%&4'*-*,$!#-/-$!/33*,$(!/-!70!-.$!%.*2(!-./-!*#!'&-!83$#$'-!*'!-.$!%.*2(A#!

$',*3&'5$'-P&3!/-!2$/#-!'&-!*'!-.$!(/-/!/,/*2/72$!-&!-.$!%.*2(:!!CK$$6!+&3!$1/582$6!V3/*'!/'(!T*$-3&#)*!CV3/*'!S!T*$-3&#)*6!>HHEN!+&3!/!3$%$'-!3$,*$<!/'(!(*#%9##*&':N!!U08*%/2206!

-.*#!/3*#$#!<.$'!-.$!(/-/!*#!/57*49&9#!*'!/!%$3-/*'!</0Y!$*-.$3!43/55/3!"!&3!43/55/3!D!

%&92(!%3$/-$!-.$!&7#$3,$(!#$'-$'%$#6!/'(!%.*2(3$'!'$,$3!.$/3!/!%39%*/2!$1/582$!-./-!&'$!

43/55/3!%/'!/%%&9'-!+&3!/'(!-.$!&-.$3!%/''&-6!79-!0$-!&'$!%/'!#.&<!-./-!-.$!%.*2(3$'!/22!$'(!98!<*-.!43/55/3!D:!!U.$!%&'%29#*&'!*#!-./-!-.$0!59#-!./,$!./(!#&5$!)*'(!&+!*''/-$!

 7*/#!-&</3(!43/55/3!D!3/-.$3!-./'!43/55/3!":!!"#!/!2*'49*#-!/%-*,$20!*',&2,$(!*'!

+*$2(<&3)6!;!%/'!/--$#-!-./-!-.*#!#&3-!&+!#*-9/-*&'!!"#$%$&!''&()%&(#*%:!!;!%&'#-/'-20!+/%$!-.$!+/%-!-./-!$,$'!*+!;!./,$!7$$'!<&3)*'4!./3(!&'!/!2/'49/4$!+&3!0$/3#6!#&5$!#-39%-93$!%&5$#!

98!#9%.!-./-!'&-.*'4!;!)'&<!-$22#!5$!<.$-.$3!*-!*#!8&##*72$!&3!'&-:!!;!'$$(!-&!3$#&2,$!-.$!

5/--$3!70!%&/1*'4!/!'/-*,$!#8$/)$3!*'-&!Z9(4*'4!#&5$!%/3$+9220!$'4*'$$3$(!#$'-$'%$6!79-!%.*2(3$'!#&5$.&<!3$#&2,$!-.$!/57*49*-0!<*-.&9-!-./-!&88&3-9'*-0:!

! U.$3$!/3$!#$,$3/2!</0#!&'$!5*4.-!-30!/8820*'4!8&,$3-0!&+!#-*5929#!3$/#&'*'4!-&!

-.$!V"WX:!!K988&#$!-./-!-.$!V"WX!<$3$!'&-!*''/-$:!!U./-!<&92(!5$/'!-./-!-.$!%.*2(!

#&5$.&<!8*%)#!*-!98!+3&5!*-#!$',*3&'5$'-:!!"'(!-.$3$!/3$!,/3*&9#!-.*'4#!-&!2$/3':!!U.$!#*582$#-!5*4.-!7$Y!@[0!8/3$'-#!/3$!'&-!/9-&5/-/:A!!U.$0!/3$!9#*'4!-.$*3!,&%/792/30!/'(!

43/55/3!-&!5/)$!#$'-$'%$#!*'!/!</0!-./-!*#!'$*-.$3!#-*5929#=7&9'(!'&3!3/'(&56!79-!

Page 8: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 8/26

!"#$%!&'(&"&)"*&#$"#&'+&",,!-,!'"#%&"(.&,/!,-+%0/12&&3$%&+%4-(.&#$'(5&#-&1%"!(6&)$'4$&7"*&4-7%&0!-7&#$"#&'+&89&+$-/1.&(-#&:%&"(&"/#-7"#";&9&#--&7"*&7"<%&+%(#%(4%+&#$"#&"!%&

/(:-/(.%.&"(.&+#'7/1/+&0!%%6&*%#&",,!-,!'"#%&#-&#$%&+'#/"#'-(&"(.&7*&5-"1+2=&&3$%&#$'!.&

"(.&7-+#&'7,-!#"(#&#$'(5&#-&1%"!(&)-/1.&:%&!"#&(-#&#-&:%&"(&"/#-7"#-(>$-)&#-&.%?%1-,&

#$%&4","4'#*&#-&/+%&#$%&1"(5/"5%&'(&#$'+&)"*2&

& 3$%&1"+#&"(.&7-+#&'7,-!#"(#&?%!+'-(&-0&#$'+&@/%+#'-(&9&#$'(<&)%&4"((-#&%?%(&0!"7%&"#&#$'+&,-'(#2&&A%&$"?%&(-&#$%-!*6&4-7,/#"#'-("1&-!&-#$%!)'+%6&-0&$-)&<(-)1%.5%&-0&

?-4":/1"!*&"(.&5!"77"!&4"(&:%&/+%.&#-&7"<%&"(&'(0'('#%&?"!'%#*&-0&+%(#%(4%+&'(&"&)"*&#$"#&'+&(%'#$%!&.%#%!7'(%.&(-!&!"(.-72&B9&.'+4/++&#$'+&"#&7-!%&1%(5#$&'(&+%4#'-(&C2D&&E(.&

+'(4%&)%&$"?%&(-&,!%4'+%&)"*&#-&+,%4'0*&#$%&<(-)1%.5%&#$"#&#$'+&4","4'#*&.%,%(.+&-(&-!&

#$%&,!-4%++&#$"#&'#&'(?-1?%+6&)%&4"((-#&%+#'7"#%&#$%&"7-/(#&-0&'(0-!7"#'-(&#$"#&'+&'(?-1?%.2&&90&)%&$".&0!%%F+,%%4$&,!-5!"7+6&)%&7'5$#&:%&":1%&#-&4-/(#&#$%&:'#+&'(&#$%&

+'7,1%+#&+/4$&,!-5!"7+2&&3$%(&)%&4-/1.&4-7,"!%&#$"#&#-&#$%&'(0-!7"#'-(&#$"#&'+&

!%"1'+#'4"11*&"44%++':1%&#-&4$'1.!%(&'(&#$%'!&%(?'!-(7%(#6&"(.&+%%&)$%#$%!&'#&'+&

4-77%(+/!"#%2&&G/#&)%&$"?%&(-&+/4$&,!-5!"7+6&+-&)%&$"?%&(-&+/4$&7%"+/!%2&&H'(4%&)%&.-(=#&<(-)&)$"#&#$%&IEJK&'+&)'#$&"(*&,!%4'+'-(6&)%&4"((-#&<(-)&)$"#&)-/1.&:%&

!%@/'!%.&#-&1%"!(&'#2&&3$%!%0-!%&)%&"1+-&4"((-#&<(-)&)$%#$%!&#$%&'(0-!7"#'-(&#$"#&'+&(%%.%.&'+&"44%++':1%&'(&#$%&%(?'!-(7%(#&-0&#$%&4$'1.2&& 9&#$%!%0-!%&!%#!%"#&#-&)$"#&7'5$#&:%&#$%&+'7,1%+#&'(&#$'+&41/+#%!&-0&'.%"+L&#$%&

@/%+#'-(&-0&)$%#$%!&7*&,"!%(#+&"!%&"/#-7"#"&-!&(-#2&&H/!%1*&7"#/!%&,%-,1%&<(-)&#$"#&

#$%*&"!%&(-#6&"(.&'#&$"+&5!%"#&+'5('0'4"(4%&'(&$-)&#$%*&1'?%>'(&,"!#'4/1"!&$-)&#$%*&#"1<&#-&-#$%!+2&&A%&.-&(-#&#"1<&'(&"&0!%%6&/(:-/(.%.&)"*&#-&#$'(5+&#$"#&)%&:%1'%?%&"!%&"/#-7"#"6&

+/4$&"+&.-11+&"(.&?-'4%F7%(/&+*+#%7+&-(&#$%&,$-(%2&&H-&,"!#&-0&#$%&IEJK&'+&<(-)'(5&

)$-&#-&/+%&'#&)'#$>("7%1*&#$-+%&#$"#&$"?%&#$%&IEJK&4","4'#*&#$%7+%1?%+2&&M-)&%'#$%!&

#$%&(-#'-(&#$"#&7*&,"!%(#+&"!%&IEJK&/+%!+6&(-#&"/#-7"#"6&'+&'(("#%6&-!&'#&'+&1%"!(%.2&&H/,,-+%&'#&'+&1%"!(%.2&&N-)&4-/1.&'#&:%O&&A$"#&<'(.&-0&%P,%!'%(4%+&)-/1.&#$%&4$'1.&$"?%&

)'#$&-#$%!&,%-,1%&#$"#&)-/1.&4-(?'(4%&$'7&#$"#&#$%*&"!%&(-#&"/#-7"#"OC&&E!%&#$-+%&<'(.&

-0&&%P,%!'%(4%+&"?"'1":1%&#-&#$%&4$'1.O&&90&(-#6&"(.&'0&4$'1.!%(&.-&!%5/1"!1*&"4@/'!%&#$'+&

 :%1'%06&#$%(&)%&$"?%&"&,-?%!#*&-0&+#'7/1/+&"!5/7%(#&#$"#&",,1'%+&#-&"#&1%"+#&#$'+&'7,-!#"(#&

 ,"!#&-0&#$%&IEJK2&&E(.&9&"++/7%&#$"#&'0&,-?%!#*&-0&+#'7/1/+&"!5/7%(#+&",,1*&#-&#$'+&#$%&+'7,1%+#&4-7,-(%(#&-0&#$%&IEJK6&#$%(&"&0-!#'-!'&#$%*&,!-:":1*&",,1*&#-&#$%&-#$%!6&7-!%&

4-7,1%P&"(.&7*+#%!'-/+&"+,%4#+&-0&#$%&IEJK&"+&)%112&

& A%&4"(&5%#&+-7%&$'(#+&#$"#&,-?%!#*&-0&#$%&+#'7/1/+&7'5$#&",,1*&0!-7&#$%&0"4#&#$"#&

B/(1'<%&4$'1.!%(OD&+-7%&'(#%11%4#/"1+&$"?%&#$-/5$#&#$"#&,%-,1%&"!%&"/#-7"#"&'(&#$%&!%1%?"(#&+%(+%2&&H<'((%!&"(.&#$%&:%$"?'-!'+#+6&0-!&%P"7,1%6&#$-/5$#&#$"#&,%-,1%=+&?%!:"1&

 :%$"?'-!&)"+&(-#&+#'7/1/+F0!%%2&&&Q%+4"!#%+&/+%.&#$%&IEJK&"+&$'+&#%+#&0-!&-#$%!&7'(.+6&

 :/#&7"(*&-0&$'+&4-(#%7,-!"!'%+&)%!%&(-#&,"!#'4/1"!1*&'7,!%++%.&)'#$&#$'+&#%+#6&"(.&4-(+'.%!%.&'#&"&)%"<&,-'(#&'(&#$%&I"!#%+'"(&0!"7%)-!<2&&3/!'(56&)$-&.'.&+-&7/4$&#-&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&C&3$'+&@/%+#'-(&'+&+'7'1"!&#-&"(.&7"*&:%&!%1"#%.&#-&#$%&@/%+#'-(&-0&$-)&"&4$'1.&"4@/'!%+&"&R3$%-!*&-0&S'(.T6&"+&+#/.'%.&:*&E1"(&J%+1'%&BJ%+1'%6&UVVWD&"(.&-#$%!+2&&G/#&'#&'+&(-#&'.%(#'4"1&#-&'#2&&E&4$'1.&4"(&.%4'.%&#$"#&"(-#$%!&4!%"#/!%&$"+&:%1'%0+&$%&<(-)+&#-&:%&0"1+%&)'#$-/#&%P,1'4'#1*&/+'(5&1"(5/"5%6&0-!&%P"7,1%2&&X(%&4"(&

"1+-&?%!*&)%11&'7"5'(%&"(-#$%!&4!%"#/!%&$"+&:%1'%0+&"(.&'(#%(#'-(+&)$'1%&+#'11&(-#&+$-)'(5&I"!#%+'"(&4!%"#'?'#*&'(&1"(5/"5%&/+%2&&I$%((*&"(.&H%*0"!#$&BUVVYD&#%(#"#'?%1*&:%1'%?%&#$'+&":-/#&?%!?%#&7-(<%*+6&0-!&%P"7,1%2&&H-&#$%&IEJK&@/%+#'-(&"(.&#$%&#$%-!*&-0&7'(.&'++/%&"!%&,"!#1*&'(.%,%(.%(#2&&BX(&#$%&-#$%!&$"(.6&'#&+%%7+&?%!*&/(1'<%1*&#$"#&"&4!%"#/!%&4-/1.&+$-)&I"!#%+'"(&4!%"#'?'#*&'(&1"(5/"5%&/+%&:/#&(-#&$"?%&:%1'%0+&

"(.&'(#%(#'-(+&#$"#&"!%&7"('0%+#%.&:*&#$%'!&1"(5/"5%&/+%2&&3$"#&'+&7-!%&-!&1%++&#$%&,-'(#&-0&Q%+4"!#%+=&#%+#&0-!&-#$%!&7'(.+&"(.&3/!'(5=+&#%+#&0-!&'(#%11'5%(4%&'(&7"4$'(%+2&&H-&#$%&#)-&'++/%+&"!%&(-#&/(!%1"#%.2D&

Page 9: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 9/26

!"#$%&'()*+,)*-"+'"-*"!*."$/0+%+'"-1*+,"02,+*+,%+*'+*3"0&4*5)*/"66'5&)*!"#*%*."$/0+%+'"-%&*4)7'.)*+"*06)*&%-20%2)*'-*%*3%8*+,%+*3"0&4*5)*'-4'6+'-20'6,%5&)*!#"$*,"3*

 /)"/&)*06)*'+*58*+,)*8)%#*9:::*;<0#'-21*=>?:@A**<,'6*6022)6+6*+,%+1*'!*'+*'6*+#0)*+,%+*/)"/&)*

06)*&%-20%2)*'-*%*3%8*+,%+*.%--"+*5)*.,%#%.+)#'()4*%6*)'+,)#*4)+)#$'-'6+'.*"#*#%-4"$1*+,)*

)7'4)-.)*!"#*+,'6*'6*605+&)*%-4*-"+*)%6'&8*"56)#7%5&)A*

* B)*.%-*2)+*%*$"#)*."-.#)+)*,%-4&)*"-*+,'6*58*#).%&&'-2*+,)*4'6%2#))$)-+*5)+3))-*C,"$6D8*%-4*+,)*5),%7'"#'6+6A***<,)*5),%7'"#'6+6*5)&')7)4*+,%+*/)"/&)E6*0++)#%-.)6*;%6*

3)&&*%6*+,)'#*"+,)#*5),%7'"#@*3%6*4)+)#$'-)4*58*+,)*6+'$0&'*+,%+*'$/'-2)4*"-*+,)$*/&06*6"$)*;7)#8*'$/"7)#'6,)4@*6)-6)*"!*+,)'#*'-+)#-%&*6+%+)F*C,"$6D8*4'4*-"+*5)&')7)*+,'6A**

G"3*4'4*C,"$6D8*%#20)*%2%'-6+*+,)*5),%7'"#'6+61*%-4*'6*+,)*)7'4)-.)*,)*06)4*"56)#7%5&)*

+"*%*.,'&4H**C,"$6D8*;C,"$6D81*=>?>@*6+%#+)4*!#"$*%-*)I%$/&)*"!*JD'--)#E6*'-*3,'.,*6"$)"-)*&""D6*%+*%*/%'-+'-2*%-4*JD'--)#*6%86*K"-)*."0&4*7)#8*3)&&*6%8*LM0+.,ENA**

C,"$6D8*%2#))61*50+*%446*+,%+*"-)*."0&4*O06+*%6*3)&&*6%8*%-8*7%#')+8*"!*"+,)#*+,'-26*%6*

3)&&1*'-.&04'-2*L.&%6,)6*3'+,*+,)*3%&&/%/)#E1*LP*+,"02,+*8"0*&'D)4*%56+#%.+*3"#DE1*LQ)7)#*

6%3*'+*5)!"#)E1*L<'&+)4E1*LG%-2'-2*+""*&"3E1*L5)%0+'!0&E1*L,'4)"06E1*L#)$)$5)#*"0#*.%$/'-2*+#'/*&%6+*60$$)#ER*"#*3,%+)7)#*)&6)*$'2,+*."$)*+"*"0#*$'-46*3,)-*&""D'-2*%+*

%*/'.+0#)A**J"*3)*.%-*,%7)*%-*0-5"0-4)4*-0$5)#*"!*#)6/"-6)6*+"*+,)*6%$)*6+'$0&'1*$%-8*"!*3,'.,*."0&4*."0-+*%6*%//#"/#'%+)*+"*+,)*6'+0%+'"-*;%-4*,)-.)*-"+*#%-4"$@A**J0//"6)*+,%+*3)*%2#))*+,%+*C,"$6D8E6*%#20$)-+*'6*."##).+*%-4*."$/)&&'-2A**<,)*S0)6+'"-*'61*'6*+,)*

.#0.'%&*!%.+*'+*,'-2)6*"-*"56)#7%5&)H**P6*'+*+,)*6"#+*"!*+,'-2*"-)*.%-*6))*'-*%-"+,)#1*%-4*

,)-.)*."-.&04)*+,%+*,)*'6*-"+*%-*%0+"$%+"-H**P*+,'-D*+,)*%-63)#*'6*LQ"E1*"#*%+*&)%6+*LQ"+*)%6'&8EA**J0//"6)*+,%+*C,"$6D8E6*.,'&4*,%4*%*.,%-.)*+"*"56)#7)*C,"$6D8*'-*!#"-+*"!*

JD'--)#E6*/%'-+'-2A**G)*.%--"+*"56)#7)*+,)*$%-8*+,'-26*+,%+*C,"$6D8*D-"36*,)*$'2,+*

,%7)*6%'4F*,)*.%-*"-&8*"56)#7)*+,)*"-)*+,'-2*+,%+*C,"$6D8*4'4*'-*!%.+*6%8*"-*+,'6*

 /%#+'.0&%#*"..%6'"-A**<,%+*"56)#7%+'"-*'6*/)#!).+&8*."-6'6+)-+*3'+,*+,)*7')3*+,%+*C,"$6D8E6*#)6/"-6)*'6*4)+)#$'-)4*58*+,)*6+'$0&06F*$%85)*,)*%&3%86*6%86*O06+*+,%+*3,)-*

,)*'6*."-!#"-+)4*3'+,*60.,*%*/'.+0#)*'-*60.,*%*6'+0%+'"-A**J'-.)*,'6*.,'&4*,%6*-)7)#*6))-*C,"$6D8*'-*!"#$%&'*+,%+*6'+0%+'"-*5)!"#)1*+,)#)*'6*-"*)7'4)-.)*%2%'-6+*+,)*%0+"$%+"-*

+,)"#8A**T)#,%/6*+,)*.,'&4*."0&4*."$/%#)*C,"$6D8E6*#)6/"-6)6*+"*6'$'&%#*6'+0%+'"-6*"7)#*

+'$)1*50+*+,%+*3"0&4*-"+*5)*)%68F*"-)*3"0&4*,%7)*+"*4).'4)*3,%+*6'+0%+'"-6*."0-+)4*%6*6'$'&%#*'-*+,)*#)&)7%-+*3%86*%-4*D))/*+#%.D*"!*%*/"+)-+'%&&8*0-5"0-4)4*%$"0-+*"!*4%+%*+"*

#)6"&7)*+,)*S0)6+'"-*'-*+,'6*3%8A**C,"$6D8E6*%#20$)-+*'6*."$/)&&'-2*3,)-*3)*/0+*

"0#6)&7)6*'-*+,%+*/"6'+'"-U*3)*,%7)*%-*'--)#*6)-6)*"!*!#))4"$*+,%+*6%86*KV)61*P*."0&4*'-*

!%.+*6%8*%-8*"!*+,"6)*+,'-26AN**W0+*3)*.%--"+*"56)#7)*6"$)"-)*)&6)E6*6)-6)*"!*!#))4"$*'-*+,'6*3%8F*3)*.%-*"-&8*'-4'#).+&8*)7%&0%+)*3,)+,)#*+,)8*6%8*%*6022)6+'7)*6056)+*"!*+,)*

+,'-26*+,%+*3)*3"0&4*6%8*'-*)I)#.'6'-2*"0#*!#))4"$A**<,)#)!"#)1*+,)#)*'6*%*/"7)#+8*"!*

6+'$0&06*%#20$)-+*,)#)A**P!*"+,)#*/)"/&)*%#)*6+'$0&06X!#))*'-*+,)'#*&%-20%2)*06)*%-4*'!*3)*%&&*."$)*+"*D-"3*+,'61*'+*'6*-"+*"-*+,)*5%6'6*"!*#)%4'&8*"56)#7%5&)*4%+%A**<,061*+,'6*5)&')!*'6*

&'D)&8*+"*5)*'--%+)A*

* Q"3*."-6'4)#*+,)*"+,)#*3%8*+,%+*+,)*CYZ[*."0&4*!%'&*+"*,"&4U*7)#5%&*5),%7'"#*."0&4*5)*6+'$0&06X!#))1*50+*-"+*%//#"/#'%+)A**P-*+,%+*.%6)1*'+*."0&4*5)*$"4)&)4*-"+*%6*%*

4)+)#$'-'6+'.*."$/0+%+'"-1*50+*#%+,)#*%6*"-)*+,%+*,%6*6"$)*D'-4*"!*#%-4"$*."$/"-)-+A**

C,"$6D8*;C,"$6D81*=>?\@*%#20)4*%2%'-6+*+,'6*D'-4*"!*7')31*%-4*%2%'-*,)*06)4*

0-"56)#7%5&)*4%+%*+"*4"*6"A**G)*."-6'4)#)4*%*!%$'&8*"!*7')36*+,%+*%660$)4*+,%+*+,)*-+,*3"#4*"-)*0++)#6*'6*6"$)*D'-4*"!*/#"5%5'&'6+'.*!0-.+'"-*"!*+,)*/#)7'"06*-X=*3"#46A**<"*

%#20)*%2%'-6+*+,'61*,)*%6D)4*+,)*#)%4)#*+"*'$%2'-)*+,)*6)S0)-.)*LP*6%3*%*!#%2'&)*XXAE**G)*

Page 10: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 10/26

!"##$!%!&%'(%&)*$&'(!&*$+$,&'$(,-&%'$&.),-&/.'(0$1&2)00).3*#&%'3!&!$4"$*5$&)2&.),-!6&*),&'(!&)*$&$+$,&'$(,-&%'$&.),-&/)21&%'$,$7&&8)&9)%'&.),-!&'(+$&:,)9(9303%;&<7<&(!&

5)*%3*"(%3)*!&)2&%'$&!$*%$*5$7&&=*-&;$%&.$&'(+$&+$,;&-322$,$*%&,$(5%3)*!&%)&%'$&%.)&

!$4"$*5$!>&/?&!(.&(&2,(#30$&.'(0$@1&3!&#,(AA(%35(06&.'$,$(!&/?&!(.&(&2,(#30$&)2&@1&3!&

*)%7&&B')A!C;&5)*50"-$!&%'(%&#,(AA(%35(03%;&3!&*)%&(&A(%%$,&)2&!%(%3!%35!&),&!%(%3!%35(0&

(::,)D3A(%3)*7&&/?&!(.&(&2,(#30$&.'(0$1&3!&#,(AA(%35(0&9"%&*)%&"!$-&9$5("!$&3%&3!&E(0A)!%&(0.(;!F&3*(::,):,3(%$6&.'$,$(!&/?&!(.&(&2,(#30$&)21&3!&"*#,(AA(%35(07&&B)*%,(!%!&03C$&%'3!&

!').&%'(%&0(*#"(#$&"!$&3!&*)%&(&!%)5'(!%35&:,)5$!!6&%'(%&.$&'(+$&C*).0$-#$&)2&0(*#"(#$&%'(%&#)$!&.(;&9$;)*-&%'$&5)*-3%3)*(0&:,)9(9303%3$!&)2&)*$&.),-&(::$(,3*#&3*&%'$&5)*%$D%&

)2&)%'$,&.),-!7&&G"%&*)%35$&%'(%&)*5$&(#(3*&%'$&-(%(&%'3!&(,#"A$*%&-$:$*-!&)*&3!&*)%&

,$(-30;&)9!$,+(90$7&&?A(#3*$&%'(%&(&5'30-&3!&$*%$,%(3*3*#&%'$&';:)%'$!3!&%'(%&'3!&:(,$*%&3!&(&,(*-)A&.),-&#$*$,(%),7&&H$&.300&*)%&9$&(90$&%)&,$!)0+$&%'$&4"$!%3)*&3*&%'$&!(A$&.(;&%'(%&

B')A!C;&-3-6&!3*5$&9;&';:)%'$!3!&'$&*$+$,&)9!$,+$!&%'$&:(,$*%&!(;3*#&$3%'$,&/?&!(.&(&

2,(#30$&.'(0$1&),&/?&!(.&(&2,(#30$&)217&&I'$&,$0$+(*%&2(5%&3!&%'(%&%'$&:(,$*%&!"#$% &E3*&!)A$&

,$!:$5%!F&!(;&%'$&2),A$,&9"%&*)%&%'$&0(%%$,J9"%&.'(%&%'$&:(,$*%&5)"0-&-)&9"%&*$+$,&-)$!&3!&*)%&)9!$,+(90$7&&=#(3*&.$&'(+$&(&:)+$,%;&)2&!%3A"0"!&3!!"$7&&?2&:$):0$&(,$&*)%&,(*-)A&

.),-&#$*$,(%),!6&(*-&32&.$&5)A$&%)&C*).&%'(%&%'3!&3!&!)6&%'$*&3%&!$$A!&%'(%&%'3!&5(**)%&9$& 9$5("!$&.$&,$03(90;&'(+$&-3,$5%&(55$!!&%)&"*(A93#")"!&5,"53(0&$+3-$*5$7&&K(%'$,6&%'$&3-$(&3!&:,)9(90;&3**(%$7&

& ?&'(+$6&)2&5)",!$6&)*0;&5)*!3-$,$-&%.)&$D%,$A$&:)!3%3)*!>&%'(%&A;&:(,$*%!1&+$,9(0&

 9$'(+3),&3!&5)A:0$%$0;&-$%$,A3*$-6&),&%'(%&3!&5)A:0$%$0;&,(*-)A7&&L)%!&)2&)%'$,6&';9,3-&5)A93*(%3)*!&(,$&:)!!390$6&.'35'&3*50"-$&9)%'&-$%$,A3*3!%35&(*-&,(*-)A&$0$A$*%!6&9"%&

(,$&!%300&5)A:(%390$&.3%'&A;&:(,$*%!&9$3*#&("%)A(%(7&&M),&$D(A:0$6&!"::)!$&%'(%&(2%$,&

'$(,3*#&/?&!(.&(&2,(#30$&N&/&3%&3!&-$%$,A3*$-&%'(%&%'$&*$D%&.),-&.300&9$&(&*)"*6&9"%&,(*-)A&

.'(%&:(,%35"0(,&*)"*&3%&.300&9$7&&I'(%&.)"0-&(55)"*%&2),&%'$&/.'(0$1&+!7&/)21&3*%"3%3)*&

.3%')"%&:)!3%3*#&(&A;!%$,3)"!&B=LO&2(5"0%;7&&=*-&?&!"::)!$&%'(%&A"!%&9$&.'(%&%'$&2"00;&

5)AA3%%$-&5)A:"%(%3)*(03!%&.')&-)$!*1%&9$03$+$&3*&A;!%$,3$!&A"!%&9$03$+$7&&?1A&*)%&,$(00;&%,;3*#&%)&:,$!!&%'(%&:)3*%&'$,$7&&G"%&3%&-)$!&,$$A:'(!3P$&%'$&:)+$,%;&)2&!%3A"0"!&

 :)3*%7&&?2&0(*#"(#$&"!$,!&-)&3*&#$*$,(0&'(+$&%'$&E:)!!390;&%(53%F&9$03$2&%'(%&)%'$,&:$):0$&

"!$&0(*#"(#$&3*&(&.(;&%'(%&3!&*$3%'$,&-$%$,A3*$-&9;&%'$3,&!3%"(%3)*&*),&,(*-)A6&9"%&,(%'$,&(55)A:03!'$!&5)AA"*35(%3+$&#)(0!&,$0(%$-&%)&%'$&2,$$&$D:,$!!3)*&)2&%')"#'%6&%'$*&%'$;&

-3-&*)%&(,,3+$&(%&%'$&9$03$2&9;&,(.&)9!$,+(%3)*7&&?%&3!&+$,;&03C$0;&%)&9$&(*&3**(%$&9$03$27&&&

=*-&!3*5$&%'3!&3!&,$0(%$-&%)&%'$&B=LO&A),$&#$*$,(00;&E%$003*#&"!&.')&.$&!')"0-&$A:0);&

%'$&B=LO&.3%'F6&%'$&B=LO&5)A:0$D&(!&(&.')0$&3!&:,)9(90;&(0!)&3**(%$7&& ?*&%'$&-)A(3*&)2&!;*%(D6&%'$,$&(,$&)%'$,&!"9Q+(,3$%3$!&)2&%'$&:)+$,%;&)2&!%3A"0"!&

(,#"A$*%&%'(%&)*$&A3#'%&%,;&%)&(::0;&%)&%'$&B=LO&(!&.$007&&M),&$D(A:0$6&3%&'(!&9$$*&

50(3A$-&%'(%&5'30-,$*&0$(,*3*#&!;*%(D&*$+$,&A(C$&5$,%(3*&C3*-!&)2&$,,),!7&&&R),$& :,$53!$0;6&%'$;&A(C$&$,,),!&%'(%&!').&%'(%&%'$;&-)&*)%&C*).&%'$&3-3)!;*5,(%35&-$%(30!&)2&

%'$&0(*#"(#$&%'$;&(,$&0$(,*3*#&E(!&;)"1-&$D:$5%F&9"%&*)%&$,,),!&%'(%&+3)0(%$&O*3+$,!(0&

S,(AA(,7&&I'$;&A(C$&A3!%(C$!&.3%'&%'$&:(,(A$%$,&!$%%3*#!6&9"%&*)%&.3%'&%'$&3*+(,3(*%& :,3*53:0$!7&&I'3!&!"##$!%!&%'(%&%'$;&(,$&%$!%3*#&';:)%'$!$!&.'$*&3%&5)A$!&%)&%'$&

 :(,(A$%$,!6&9"%&%'$;&(,$&%(C3*#&%'$&:,3*53:0$!&2),&#,(*%$-&E!$$6&2),&$D(A:0$6&.),C&9;&

8%$:'$*&B,(3*6&K)!(03*-&I'),*%)*6&$%57F7&&I'$&:(,(00$0&4"$!%3)*&.)"0-&9$&.'$%'$,&

5'30-,$*&$+$,&A(C$&A3!%(C$!&.3%'&%'$&B=LO7&&T)&%'$;&#)&%',)"#'&(&:$,3)-&.'$,$&%'$;&!$$A&%)&9$&3*%$,:,$%3*#&%')!$&(,)"*-&%'$A&(!&("%)A(%(6&.')!$&.),-!&(,$&!)A$&

5)A93*(%3)*&)2&-$%$,A3*$-&(*-&,(*-)A6&,(%'$,&%'(*&:",:)!$2"0&(*-&!$02Q$D:,$!!3*#U&&T)&

Page 11: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 11/26

!"#$%&'%!"(')&"%*%+#(,'-%,.%/",0"%!"#$%!"#12#34#2%*0!%!",2%/*$5%%67%2'8%!"*!%/')3-%2"'/%!"*!%!"#$%*(#%!($,.&%')!%!"#%"$+'!"#2,2%!"*!%+#'+3#%"*4#%*%4'0*9)3*($%*.-%*%&(*11*(8%9)!%

.'%:;<=>%%?)!%2)(#3$%!"#$%-'%.'!%-'%!",2>%%67%!"#(#%,2%*.$%2!*&#%,.%/",0"%0",3-(#.%*0!%*.-%

,.!#(+(#!%'!"#(2%*2%*)!'1*!*8%,!%1)2!%9#%9#7'(#%!"#%3*.&)*&#%#@+3'2,'.%,.%!"#%!",(-%$#*(%'7%

3,7#A*.-%9#7'(#%!",2%!"#(#%,2%.'!%1)0"%#4,-#.0#%7('1%3*.&)*&#%)2#%*!%*338%'.#%/*$%'(%!"#%

'!"#(>%% ;%7,.*3%4*(,#!$%'7%!"#%+'4#(!$%'7%2!,1)3)2%*(&)1#.!%!"*!%"*2%9##.%*++3,#-%!'%2$.!*@%

,2%!'%3''B%*!%3*.&)*&#%-#4#3'+1#.!%,.%*9.'(1*38%).)2)*33$%,1+'4#(,2"#-%#.4,('.1#.!2>%%67%!"#%#@+#(,#.0#%*4*,3*93#%,.%2)0"%*.%#.4,('.1#.!%,2%03#*(3$%(#-)0#-8%9)!%!"#(#%,2%3,!!3#%

-,20#(.*93#%,1+*0!%'.%!"#%B.'/3#-&#%*!!*,.#-8%!"*!%,2%!*B#.%*2%#4,-#.0#%!"*!%!"#%

B.'/3#-&#%,.%C)#2!,'.%"*2%*%3*(&#%,..*!#%0'1+'.#.!>%%D.#%03*22,0%3,.&),2!,0%#@*1+3#%,2%0(#'3,E*!,'.8%/"#.8%*2%*%(#2)3!%'7%!"#%9()!*3,!,#2%'7%!"#%23*4#%!(*-#%0",3-(#.%-,-%.'!%&#!%*.%

*-#C)*!#%2*1+3#%'7%*.$%'.#%.*!,4#%3*.&)*&#%!'%*0C),(#%,!%+('+#(3$>%%F"*!%2##12%!'%

"*++#.%,2%!"*!%!"#$%0(#*!#%*%.#/%3*.&)*&#%7('1%!"#%*4*,3*93#%+*(!2%!"*!%"*2%,!2%'/.%=GH

'9#$,.&%(#&)3*(,!,#28%.'!%*!!(,9)!*93#%!'%!"#%1,2"1*2"%'7%+,-&,.,E#-%1*!#(,*3%2+'B#.%*(').-%!"#1%I?,0B#(!'.8%JKLJM>%%;.'!"#(%03*22,0%#@*1+3#%,2%0'.&#.,!*33$%-#*7%0",3-(#.%'7%

"#*(,.&%+*(#.!28%/"'%*(#%,2'3*!#-%7('1%2+'B#.%3*.&)*&#%9$%!"#,(%3*0B%'7%"#*(,.&%*.-%/"'%*(#%,2'3*!#-%7('1%2,&.%3*.&)*&#%9$%*00,-#.!%'(%-#2,&.>%%6.%!"#2#%2,!)*!,'.28%-#*7%0",3-(#.%,.%,.!#(*0!,'.%/,!"%!"#,(%0*(#H&,4#(2%1*B#%)+%*%2,&.%3*.&)*&#%-#%.'4'8%*.-%!"#2#%N"'1#%

2,&.2O%*(#%03*,1#-%!'%"*4#%1*.$%'7%!"#%0"*(*0!#(,2!,02%'7%1'(#%'(-,.*($%")1*.%3*.&)*&#2%

IP>%G'3-,.HQ#*-'/%R%Q$3*.-#(8%JKLSM>%%T"#%C)*3,!$%'7%!"#%7*0!2%,.%!"#2#%*(#*2%,2%0'.!('4#(2,*38%9)!%*33%*&(##%!"*!%"'/%!"#$%!)(.%')!%"*2%9#*(,.&%'.%,22)#2%'7%,..*!#.#22>%

T"#%C)#2!,'.%.'/%,2%/"#!"#(%2,1,3*(%*(&)1#.!2%0')3-%9#%0'.2!()0!#-%!"*!%/')3-%

 9#*(%'.%!"#%,..*!#.#22%'7%!"#%:;<=%0'1+'.#.!%'7%3*.&)*&#>%%T"#%*.2/#(%2##12%!'%9#%

$#2>%%U('9*93$%.'%0",3-%"*2%9##.%#@+'2#-%!'%*%(,0"%4'0*9)3*($%*.-%*%7)33H73#-&#-%&(*11*(%/"'%"*2%.'!%*32'%9##.%#@+'2#-%!'%3*.&)*&#%)2#%!"*!%,2%).9').-#-8%2!,1)3)2%7(##8%*.-%

*++('+(,*!#V%!"#%:;<=%/*2%+(#2)1*93$%1'-#3#-%,.%!"#%+,-&,.%)!!#(*.0#2%'.%!"#%2)&*(% +3*.!*!,'.28%#4#.%,7%&(*11*(%/*2%.'!8%7'(%#@*1+3#>%%?)!%!"#%0*2#%'7%-#*7%0",3-(#.%.'!%

#@+'2#-%!'%2!*.-*(-%2,&.%3*.&)*&#2%,2%(#3#4*.!8%2,.0#%!"#$%"*4#%#22#.!,*33$%.'%

,.-#+#.-#.!%1'-#3%'7%3*.&)*&#%)2#%*!%*33>%%W#4#(!"#3#228%!"#%"'1#%2,&.2%!"#$%-#4#3'+%2##1%.'!%!'%9#%)2#-%!"#%.'!%1#0"*.,2!,0*33$8%9)!%7'(%!"#%7(##%#@+(#22,'.%'7%!"')&"!>%%

6.-##-8%,!%,2%+(#2)1*93$%,.%+*(!%!"#%-##+%")1*.%.##-%!'%,.!#(*0!%,.%!",2%/*$%!"*!%+)2"#2%

!"#1%!'%0(#*!#%!"#,(%'/.%.#/%4'0*9)3*($%*.-%&(*11*(%,.%!"#%7,(2!%+3*0#>%%P)0"%0*2#2%/#(#%

*++*(#.!3$%B.'/.%*3(#*-$%!'%X#20*(!#28%/"'%/(,!#2Y%%

% 6.%+3*0#%'7%/",0"%1#.%9'(.%-#*7%*.-%-)198%*.-%!")2%.'!%3#228%9)!%(*!"#(%1'(#%!"*.%

!"#%9()!#28%-#2!,!)!#%'7%!"#%'(&*.2%/,!"%'!"#(2%)2#%,.%2+#*B,.&8%*(#%,.%!"#%"*9,!%'7%2+'.!*.#')23$%,.4#.!,.&%0#(!*,.%2,&.2%9$%/",0"%!"#$%-,20'4#(%!"#,(%!"')&"!2%!'%!"'2#%/"'8%

 9#,.&%)2)*33$%,.%!"#,(%0'1+*.$8%"*4#%3#,2)(#%!'%3#*(.%!"#,(%3*.&)*&#>%I+>%Z[M%

%Q'-#(.%/'(B%'.%"'1#%2,&.%2$2!#12%9$%P)2*.%G'3-,.HQ#*-'/%*.-%"#(%0'33#*&)#2%9#*(2%

')!%X#20*(!#2O%'92#(4*!,'.>%%T"#(#%2##12%!'%9#%.'%-')9!%!"*!%0",3-(#.%)2#%!"#,(%&#2!)(#2%,.%

/*$2%!"*!%*(#%*++('+(,*!#%,.%!"#%X#20*(!#\:"'12B$%2#.2#%'7%.'!%(*.-'1%*.-%#@+(#22,4#%

'7%!"#,(%!"')&"!>%%]'1#%2,&.2%*(#%+#("*+2%1'(#%9').-%!'%!"#%,11#-,*!#%2,!)*!,'.%'7%)!!#(*.0#%!"*.%0'.4#.!,'.*3%3*.&)*&#2%*(#8%9#0*)2#%!"#$%!#.-%!'%3*0B%I*%(,0"%2#!%'7%.').2M%

*.-%(#3$%'.%+',.!,.&%!'%(#7#(%!'%!",.&2>%%?)!%!",2%-'#2%.'!%1#*.%!"*!%!"#$%*(#%.'!%2!,1)3)2H

Page 12: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 12/26

!"##$%&'%&(%)*'%+'%+,,%'-#%.+(#%'-+'%.-&,/"#)%0''#"%'-#%(+1#%(&2)%(#)'#).#(%1#.-+)&.+,,3%4-#)%'-#3%+"#%50'%&)%'-#%(+1#%(&'0+'&*)(6%%7-#%8&22#('%.*).#")%1&2-'%8#%4-#'-#"%'-#%-*1#%(&2)%

(3('#1(%+"#%0)8*0)/#/6%%9*1#%(&2)%(#)'#).#(%'#)/%'*%8#%(-*"':%4&'-%+%1#+)%,#)2'-%*!%

0''#"+).#%*!%*),3%;6<%*"%;6=%(&2)(%5#"%0''#"+).#%>?6%@*,/&)AB#+/*4%C%B3,+)/#":%;DE=F:%

.*15+"#/%'*%BGH(%*!%.,*(#%'*%=%!*"%(5#+I&)2%.-&,/"#)%*!%.*15+"+8,#%+2#(6%%J0'%&'%&(%

-+"/,3%(0"5"&(&)2%'-+'%'-#"#%&(%(*1#%/#K#,*51#)'+,%/#,+3:%2&K#)%'-#%#L'"#1#%#15*K#"&(-1#)'%*!%'-#%&)50'%+)/%'-#%,&1&'#/%'&1#%4&)/*4%!*"%/#K#,*5&)2%'-#%-*1#%(&2)%

>M%+((01#%'-+'%(**)#"%*"%,+'#"%+,,%'-#(#%.-&,/"#)%#)/%05%2#''&)2%#L5*(#/%'*%(*1#%.*)K#)'&*)+,%,+)20+2#%*"%*'-#"F6%%@*,/&)AB#+/*4%+)/%B3,+)/#"%/*%5*&)'%*0'%'-+'%'-#%

1+L&1+,%,#)2'-%*!%0''#"+).#%>+(%*55*(#/%'*%'-#%1#+)F%!*"%1*('%*!%-#"%(08N#.'(%4+(%

 8#'4##)%!&K#%+)/%)&)#%(&2)(:%4-&.-%&(%)*'%(&2)&!&.+)',3%,#((%'-+)%'-+'%*!%.-&,/"#)%4&'-%.*)K#)'&*)+,%&)50'6%%7-#3%-+K#%+,(*%+"20#/%&)%/#'+&,%'-+'%#K#"3%.-&,/O(%-*1#%(&2)%&(%

"#.0"(&K#:%+,,*4&)2%*)#%5"*5*(&'&*)%'*%8#%#18#//#/%&)(&/#%+)*'-#"%>?0(+)%@*,/&)A

B#+/*4:%;DE<:%;DEPF6%%M)/##/%'-#(#%#18#//&)2%('"0.'0"#(%+55#+"%&)%-*1#%(&2)(%+'%+8*0'%

'-#%(+1#%+2#%><6=%3#+"(F%'-+'%'-#3%+55#+"%&)%'-#%5"*/0.'&*)(%*!%-#+"&)2%.-&,/"#)6%%?*%'-&(%,+)20+2#%0(#%/*#(%.*0)'%+(%0)8*0)/#/6%%?*%#K#)%'-#(#%.-&,/"#):%4&'-%K#"3%,&1&'#/%*0'(&/#%

&)50':%/#K#,*5%'-#%QRGH%.+5+.&'3%1*"#%*"%,#((%*)%(.-#/0,#6%%B*"#*K#":%@*,/&)AB#+/*4%+)/%B3,+)/#"%.*15+"#/%-#"%.-&,/"#)O(%0(#%*!%-*1#%(&2)%4&'-%'-+'%*!%'-#&"%1*'-#"(6%%?-#%/&(.*K#"#/%'-+'%#K#)%'-*02-%1*'-#"(%1+/#%1+)3%&)/&K&/0+,%(&2)(:%'-#3%4#"#%(&2)&!&.+)',3%

,#((%,&I#,3%'*%.*18&)#%'-*(#%(&2)(%&)'*%('"0.'0"#/%(#)'#).#(%.*)(&('&)2%*!%1*"#%'-+)%*)#%

(&2)%'-+)%'-#%.-&,/"#)%4#"#6%%R55"*L&1+'#,3%;ST%*!%1*'-#"(O%0''#"+).#(%.*)(&('#/%*!%1*"#%'-+)%*)#%(&2):%.*15+"#/%'*%=UT%*!%.-&,/"#)O(%0''#"+).#(:%+)/%"#.0"(&*)%+55#+"(%

#+",&#"%&)%'-#%.-&,/O(%(&2)&)2%'-+)%&)%'-#%1*'-#"O(%&)%+,1*('%#K#"3%&)('+).#6%%7-0(:%'-#"#%&(%

)*%#K&/#).#%'-+'%'-#%.-&,/"#)%+"#%5&.I&)2%05%QRGH%.+5+.&'3%!"*1%'-#&"%1*'-#"($%"+'-#"%&'%

(##1(%'*%8#%#1#"2&)2%(5*)'+)#*0(,3%!"*1%4&'-&)%'-#1:%+(%*)#%4*0,/%#L5#.'%&!%'-#%QRGH%&(%&))+'#6%

V0''&)2%'-&(%'*2#'-#"%4&'-%'-#%*'-#"%+"201#)'(%&)%'-&(%(#.'&*):%M%.*).,0/#%'-+'%*)#%.+)%5"*8+8,3%.*)('"0.'%+%.+(#%!*"%'-#%QRGH%8#&)2%'*%+%,+"2#%#L'#)'%&))+'#%&)%-01+)(%'-+'%

&(%+(%('"*)2%*"%('"*)2#"%'-+)%'-#%!+1&,&+"%.+(#%!*"%(3)'+L%8#&)2%'*%+%,+"2#%#L'#)'%&))+'#6%

%

!"#$%#&'(#)*+,#-./001234#56131768/39:#

%

7-#%)#L'%W0#('&*)%&(%4-#'-#"%'-#"#%&(%#K&/#).#%'-+'%'-#%QRGH%&(%8&*,*2&.+,6%%X!%.*0"(#:%

'-#%+)(4#"%/#5#)/(%*)%-*4%*)#%0)/#"('+)/(%'-#%'#"1(6%%M!%8&*,*23%&(%(&15,3%'-#%('0/3%*!%,&!#:%'-#)%2&K#)%'-+'%'-#%QRGH%&(%+%5"*5#"'3%*!%(*1#%'-&)2(%'-+'%+"#%+,&K#%>-01+)(:%

+)34+3F%&'%&(%'+0'*,*2&.+,%'-+'%'-#%QRGH%&(%+%8&*,*2&.+,%5-#)*1#)*)6%%J0'%&)%/&(.0((&)2%

'-&(%W0#('&*)%M%+1%&)'#"#('#/%&)%8&*,*23%&)%+%)+""*4#"%(#)(#Y%/*#(%'-#%QRGH%!&'%.*1!*"'+8,3%&)%'-#%!"+1#4*"I%*!%.*)'#15*"+"3%8&*,*23:%(0.-%'-+'%&'%(-*4(%(&1&,+"%

 5"*5#"'&#(%'*%'-&)2(%I)*4)%'*%8#%8&*,*2&.+,%+)/%(*1#%*!%&'(%5"*5#"'&#(%+"#%#,0.&/+'#/%83%

'-#%8+(&.%'-#*"&#(%&)%8&*,*236%%B*"#%(5#.&!&.+,,3:%&(%'-#"#%#K&/#).#%'-+'%'-#%QRGH%&(%#18*/&#/%)#0"*,*2&.+,,3:%'-+'%'-#%"#,#K+)'%)#0"+,%('"0.'0"#(%+"#%.*/#/%!*"%&)%2#)*1#:%+)/%

'-+'%'-#(#%2#)#(%+"*(#%'-"*02-%#K*,0'&*)+"3%1#.-+)&(1(6%%M!%'-#%+)(4#"(%'*%'-#(#%

W0#('&*)(%+"#%3#(:%'-#)%'-#%Z)#4%(3)'-#(&([%5+"+/&21%*!%#K*,0'&*)+"3%5(3.-*,*23%1+3%8#%

+/#W0+'#%!*"%+,,%&)('+).#(%*!%&))+'#)#((6%%J0'%M%4&,,%.,+&1%'-+'%'-#%+)(4#"%&(%)*:%+)/%-#).#%'-+'%'-#"#%1+3%8#%+%/&('&).'%.+'#2*"3%*!%)*)8&*,*2&.+,%&))+'#)#((6%%R2+&)%&'%4&,,%8#%0(#!0,%

&)%(*1#%.+(#(%'*%.*15+"#%'-#%QRGH%4&'-%(3)'+L:%4-&.-%-+(%8##)%1*"#%('0/&#/6%

Page 13: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 13/26

Page 14: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 14/26

!"#$%&'%(%)&**+,+'-&(.%/(01%23%/+%(,+%-+45-+)%-3%2(0%-6(-%-6+%!"#$%7&,78&-%6(2%9++'%:'37:+)%38-%/6&.+%3-6+,2%6(;+%9++'%25(,+)<%

% "-%*&,2-1%-6+%('2/+,%2++42%-3%9+%0+2<%%=6+%6(..4(,:%3*%!"#$%&2%.('>8(>+%82+%-6(-%

&2%8'938')+)1%2-&48.82?*,++1%(')%(55,35,&(-+<%%@+,'&7:+A2%(56(2&(%B-6+%2+73')%:&')%-3%9+%

)&273;+,+)C%2++42%-3%9+%76(,(7-+,&D+)%90%.('>8(>+%5,3)87-&3'%-6(-%.(7:2%-6+%

E(55,35,&(-+'+22A%*+(-8,+<%%F+,+%&2%(%2(45.+G%%

F&2%/&*+%2(/%-6+%/3'-&'>%-3%/3*&'%-3%(%6382+%/&-6%-6+%849.+.3,<%%=6+'%6+%.+*-%-6+%/3')&'>%-6+'%6+%-33%-3%-6+%/34&'%(')%-3%-6+%849+..(%85%2-(&,2<%%F&2%/&*+%7(,,0%&-%

852-(&,2<%%=6+'%-6+%6382+%)&)%'3-%>3%*(2-+,%-6+,'%(')%-+..%>3%&'%-6+%/&-638-%/&-6&'%5(&'%

/6+,+%&-%&2%/6&,+%&'%-6+%6+,7+%&'%2-37:<%%BBH33)>.(22%I%J(5.('1%KLMNC%OLC%%

=6&2%25++76%&2%7.+(,.0%8'938')+)%(')%2-&48.82%*,++1%98-%&-%&2%'3-%/6(-%/+%/38.)%73'2&)+,%

(55,35,&(-+<%%=6+%25++76%3*%-6&2%:&')%3*%5(-&+'-%&2%76(,(7-+,&D+)%(2%*.8+'-%(')%6(2%'3,4(.%

&'-3'(-&3'%(')%*,++%82+%3*%>,(44(-&7(.%+.+4+'-21%98-%&-%&2%,(49.&'>1%)&23,>('&D+)1%'++).+22.0%7345.+P1%(')%*8..%3*%4(.(5,35&2421%563'3.3>&7(.%+,,3,21%(')%'3'/3,)2<%%=6+%

&45,+22&3'%-6(-%/+%(,+%/&-'+22&'>%(%,(')34%2-,&'>%3*%/3,)2%B(')%/3,)?.&:+%+.+4+'-2C%7('% 9+%5,+--0%2-,3'><%%=6&2%738.)%9+%(%5358.(-&3'%-6(-%,+(..0%)3+2%2(0%E!3.3,.+22%>,++'%&)+(2%2.++5%*8,&382.0A%3,%('0%3-6+,%>,(9%9(>%3*%/3,)2%-6(-%3778,2%-3%-6+4<%

% Q8-%@+,'&7:+A2%(56(2&(%7(''3-%9+%R82-%(%)&2,85-&3'%3*%-6+%!"#$%7(5(7&-0<%%=6&2%&2%

2++'%*,34%-6+%*(7-%-6(-%@+,'&7:+A2%5(-&+'-2%(.23%6(;+%.('>8(>+%)&2,85-&3'2%-6(-%6(;+%'3-6&'>%-3%)3%/&-6%-6+%!"#$<%%S'%5(,-&78.(,1%-6+0%6(;+%2+,&382%5,39.+42%8')+,2-(')&'>%

/3,)2%5,+2+'-+)%&'%&23.(-&3'<%%=/3%5,34&'+'-%7.&'&7&('2%/,&-+%(938-%-6&2%20'),34+%-6(-%

T=6+%&45(&,4+'-%3*%(8)&-3,0%7345,+6+'2&3'%&2%+;&)+'-%+;+'%(-%-6+%3'+?/3,)%.+;+.<%%=6+%

 5(-&+'-%4(0%,+5+(-%-6+%+P(4&'+,A2%/3,)2%8'7345,+6+')&'>.01%3,%/&-6%5(,(56,(2&7%)&2-3,-&3'2<%%"-%2+;+,+%.+;+.21%(8)&-3,0%7345,+6+'2&3'%4(0%9+%D+,3UV%BH33)>.(22%I%

J(5.('1%KLMNC<%%=6&2%)+*&7&-%&2%-682%'3-%(%5,39.+4%/&-6%58--&'>%/3,)2%-3>+-6+,W%&-%&2%(% 5,39.+4%/&-6%-6+%/3,)2%-6+42+.;+2<%%@+,'&7:+A2%(56(2&(%482-%9+%(%)&2,85-&3'%3*%-6+%

;37(98.(,0%73453'+'-%3*%.('>8(>+%(')%'3-%BR82-C%(%)&2,85-&3'%3*%-6+%!"#$%73453'+'-<%%

S')++)1%-6+%7.(22&7(.%8')+,2-(')&'>%3*%@+,'&7:+A2%(56(2&(%&2%-6(-%-6+%238')?4+('&'>%(2237&(-&3'%&';3.;+)%&'%/3,)2%&2%)&2,85-+)X(%;&+/%-6(-%*&-2%/+..%/&-6%-6+%*(7-%-6(-%

@+,'&7:+A2%(56(2&(%&2%7(82+)%90%.+2&3'2%&'%-6+%T(2237&(-&3'%73,-+PV<%%Y3/%>&;+'%-6(-%/+%

:'3/%-6(-%-6+%;37(98.(,0%&2%(**+7-+)%&'%@+,'&7:+A2%(56(2&(1%73'2&)+,(-&3'2%3*%5(,2&43'0%

.+()%82%-3%(2:%/6+-6+,%-6&2%)+*&7&-%&2%+'38>6%-3%+P5.(&'%-6+%76(,(7-+,&2-&7%25++76% 5,3)87-&3'%3*%-6+2+%5(-&+'-21%3,%/6+-6+,%/+%482-%(2284+%-6(-%-6+%!"#$%&2%(**+7-+)%-33<%%

S'%*(7-1%-6+%;37(98.(,0%)+*&7&-%&2%28**&7&+'-<%%Z'+%7('%/+..%&4(>&'+%-6(-%@+,'&7:+A2%

(56(2&72%6(;+%,+(23'(9.+%2+'-+'7+2%&'%4&')%(-%234+%.+;+.1%98-%-6+0%3*-+'%(7-&;(-+%-6+%/,3'>%5,3'8'7&(-&3'2%*3,%-6+%4+('&'>2%-6(-%-6+0%&'-+')<%%=6(-%90%&-2+.*%/38.)%9+%

 5+,*+7-.0%28**&7&+'-%-3%7,+(-+%-6+%+**+7-%3*%,(')34?2++4&'>%2-,&'>2%3*%/3,)2<%%"')%&'%*(7-1%

(%;(>8+%5.3-.&'+%7('%9+%)&27+,'+)%8')+,'+(-6%@+,'&7:+%(56(2&7%25++76%3'7+%3'+%*(7-3,2%38-%-6+%4(.(5,35&242<%%F+,+%&2%63/%(%@+,'&7:+A2%(56(2&7%)+27,&9+2%(%5&7-8,+%3*%-/3%9302%

2-+(.&'>%*,34%(%733:&+%R(,%/6&.+%-6+&,%43-6+,%&2%9820%/(26&'>%)&26+2%&'%('%3;+,*.3/&'>%

2&':G%

%@+..%-6&2%&2%U%43-6+,%&2%(/(0%6+,+%/3,:&'>%6+,%/3,:%38-%3A%6+,+%-3%>+-%6+,%9+--+,1%98-%

/6+'%26+A2%.33:&'>1%-6+%-/3%9302%.33:&'>%&'%-6+%3-6+,%5(,-<%%Z'+%-6+&,%24(..%-&.+%&'-3%

Page 15: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 15/26

!"#$%&'"$!"#"($$$)!"*+$,-#.&/0$1/-%!"#$%&'"$2"314+"$+!"*+$0"%%&/05$%--($$)-$%!"$%,-$ 2-6+$,-#.$%-0"%!"#$1/$-/"$&+$+/"1.&/*$1#-4/7$!"#"5$'1.&/0$!&+$8$,-#.$1/*$!&+$

94#%!"#$94//1+$!&+$%&'"$!"$!17($$:"$1/*$%!"$-%!"#$9";;-,$,"#"$#4//&/0$1#-4/7$%!"$,-#.$

!"#"5$,!&;"$'-%!"#$1/-%!"#$%&'"$+!"$,1+$7-&/0$%!1%$,&%!-4%$"<"#6%!&/0$,#-/0$!"#"($$=%$

&+/*%$#&0!%5$2"314+"$+!"*+$'1.&/0$1$%&'"$!"#"$-9$,-#.$%&'"$!"#"5$;"%%&/0$'-%!"#$0"%%&/0$

1;;$,"%$!"#"$12-4%$+-'"%!&/0($$>!"$.&7+$1#"/*%$#&0!%$!"#"$2"314+"$%!"6$7-/*%$?4+%$+16$-/"$!"#"$1/7$-/"$!"#"@%!1%*+$1;;$#&0!%5$1;%!-40!$%!"$9";;-,$!"#"$&+$2#"1.&/*$2"%,""/$

%!"$%,-$-9$%!"'5$%!"6*#"$3-'&/*$1#-4/7$%--($AB--70;1++$C$D1E;1/5$FGHIJ$$

K;%!-40!$&%$,1/7"#+$1/7$&+$94;;$-9$,#-/0$,-#7+5$%!"#"$&+$1$<104"$+"/+"$-9$,!1%$&+$0-&/0$

-/$!"#"(L$$)-$%!&+$%6E"$-9$1E!1+&1$+!-,+$4+$3;"1#;6$%!1%$1+E"3%+$-9$%!"$<-3124;1#6$

3-'E-/"/%$1#"$7"E"/7"/%$-/$2#1&/$%&++4"5$24%$/-%$%!1%$%!"$MKNO$&+($$)&'&;1#$#"'1#.+$!-;7$

9-#$%!"$-%!"#$+-P31;;"7$Q9;4"/%$1E!1+&1+*5$"+E"3&1;;6$%!"$#1%!"#$#1#"$>#1/+3-#7&31;$)"/+-#6$

KE!1+&1($$>!"+"$E1%&"/%+$%--$E#-743"$#1/7-'5$E4#E-+";"++$+-4/7&/0$+E""3!5$&/3;47&/0$

+"/%"/3"+$;&."$Q:"$;--.+$;&."$!"*+$4E$;&<"$,-#.$8$:"$;--.+$;&."$!"*+$7-&/0$?13.$-9&/1#6+$8$:"$;6&/0$,!"1%;6(*$$R4%$%!"&#$7"9&3&%$+!-,+$4E$3;"1#;6$"<"/$,!"/$%!"6$1#"$0&<&/0$-/"P

,-#7$/1'"+$%-$&%"'+$AAB--70;1++$C$D1E;1/5$FGHIJ$E($HSJ($$$ T-#$1$3#-++U$QR#1V&;&1/$3;-%!"+210*$

$ T-#$1$%!4'2U$QK#0"/%&/"$#&9;"*$

$ T-#$1$'"%1;$1+!%#16U$Q2""#P31/$%!&/0*$$ T-#$1$/"3.%&"U$Q%-"/1&;$8$#4+%6$/1&;*$

$

>!"#"$&+$-2<&-4+;6$1$+"<"#"$E#-2;"'$,&%!$%!"$<-3124;1#6$!"#"5$1/7$%!1%$&+$+499&3&"/%$%-$

"WE;1&/$1;;$%!"$-%!"#$E#-2;"'+($$A>!"$'1?-#$7&99"#"/3"$2"%,""/$>#1/+3-#%&31;$+"/+-#6$KE!1+&1$1/7$X"#/&3."*+$1E!1+&1$&+$%!1%$>)K$E1%&"/%+$31/$#"E"1%$+"/%"/3"+$%!1%$%!"6$!"1#$

'43!$2"%%"#$%!1/$X"#/&3."*+$E1%&"/%+$31/($$>!&+$!1+$/-$2"1#&/0$-/$MKNO$&++4"+5$2"314+"$MKNO$&+$/-%$/"3"++1#&;6$&/<-;<"7$&/$%!"$31E13&%6$%-$#"E"1%$1$+"/%"/3"$,-#7$9-#$,-#7Y$%!1%$

&+$/-%$1$Q+%&'4;4+$9#""*$2"!1<&-#(HJ$

$ K$<"#6$7&99"#"/%P+""'&/0$E-++&2;"$;-++$-9$%!"$MKNO$&+$9-4/7$&/$R#-31*+$1E!1+&3+($$:"#"$%!"$E#-2;"'$&+$/-%$,&%!$%!"$1EE#-E#&1%"/"++5$24%$#1%!"#$,&%!$%!"$2-4/7"7/"++$-9$%!"$

;&/04&+%&3$-4%E4%($$=/$'-#"$+"<"#"$31+"+5$E1%&"/%+$+E"1.$-/;6$-/"$,-#7$1%$1$%&'"($$:"#"$&+$1$

+1'E;"$3-/<"#+1%&-/$AB--70;1++$C$D1E;1/5$FGHIJU$

$$ =/%"#<&","#U$X!1%$7&7$6-4$7-$2"9-#"$6-4$,"/%$%-$Z&"%/1'[$\1%&"/%U$T-#3"+$

$ =/%"#<&","#U$]-4$,"#"$&/$%!"$1#'6[$ \1%&"/%U$)E"3&1;$9-#3"+($

$ =/%"#<&","#U$X!1%$7&7$6-4$7-[$ \1%&"/%U$R--'^$$ =/%"#<&","#U$=$7-/*%$4/7"#+%1/7($$ \1%&"/%U$Q+E;-+&-/+($

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$L$=%$!1+$2""/$+400"+%"7$%!1%$%!"$,1/7"#&/0$/1%4#"$-9$X"#/&3."*+$1E!1+&1$+E""3!$&+$1$+&7"$"99"3%$-9$%!"$ E1%&"/%$/-%$4/7"#+%1/7&/0$!&+$-,/$+E""3!5$2"314+"$-9$!&+$+"<"#"$E#-2;"'+$,&%!$;"W&31;$133"++($$>!"#"9-#"5$!"$31//-%$"99"3%&<";6$'-/&%-#$!&+$-,/$+E""3!5$1/7$7-"+$/-%$0"%$1/6$9""7213.$12-4%$,!"/$!"$!1+$

+433"++94;;6$3-''4/&31%"7$1/$&7"1($$>!&+$'1."+$!&'$E#-/"$%-$#"E"%&%&-/$1/7$,1/7"#&/0$-/$1$%!"'"($H$>,-$-%!"#$+6/7#-'"+$&/$%!"$9;4"/%$1E!1+&1$91'&;6$1#"$1/-'&1$1/7$3-/743%&-/$1E!1+&1($$K/-'&1$&+$1/-%!"#$ E#-2;"'$,&%!$%!"$;"W&3-/Y$&%$&+$!1#7$%-$133"++$3-/%"/%$,-#7+5$'1.&/0$%!"$1E!1+&3*+$+E""3!$94;;$-9$<104"$,-#7+$;&."$Q%!&/0*5$QE;13"*5$7"&3%&3$,-#7+5$1/7$3&#34';-34%&-/+($$M-/743%&-/$1E!1&+&3+$!1<"$+E"3&1;$

7&99&34;%6$&/$#"E"1%&/0$+"/%"/3"+5$24%$%!"&#$9#""$+E""3!$1/7$3-'E#"!"/+&-/$&+$/-%$+-$217($$=/$2-%!$31+"+5$&%$&+$3;"1#$%!1%$%!"$MKNO$&+$&/%13%($

Page 16: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 16/26

! "#$%&!'(&)*+$,)-! ./*+&,*0!1&!22!$,&!3(4!! 5,*&%6+&7&%0!!8&%&!4$(!/9$,&!7:&,!4$(!7&%&!+,;(%&<=!!!./*+&,*0!>&?$,@!)?$(*!

! 5,*&%6+&7&%0!8:/*!:/AA&,&<B!7:4!/%&!4$(!:&%&=! ! ./*+&,*0!CA&&?:!

! 5,*&%6+&7&%0!8:/*!:/AA&,&<=!! ./*+&,*0!#$%*/%!

!

D&%&!+)!/!E%$?/F)!/A:/)+?!<&)?%+A*+$,!$G!*:&!?$$H+&!*:&G*!A+?*(%&0!!

! I$$H+&!;/%!@!G/99!$6&%!@!?:/+%!@!7/*&%!@!&1A*4!@!$6!@!$6@!"&J/1+,&%0!!$6&%G9$7=-!K&/:2!!!"L$$<39/))!M!N/A9/,O!PQRS-!A2!TU!

!

V,&!1+3:*!7&99!*:+,H!$G!*:+)!/)!/!<&G+?+*!$G!*:&!/W+9+*4!*$!A(*!7$%<)!*$3&*:&%!+,*$!)&,*&,?&)2!!E(*!/3/+,O!*:+)!+)!,$*!*:&!$,94!A%$W9&1!*:/*!/!*4A+?/9!E%$?/F)!/A:/+)+?!:/)2!!

X:&4!/9)$!:/6&!)&6&%&!/%*+?(9/*+$,!A%$W9&1)O!*:&!A%$)$<4!$G!*:&+%!)A&&?:!+)!/GG&?*&<O!/,<!

*:&+%!)A&&?:!+)!)9$7!/,<!&GG$%*G(9O!&6&,!7:&,!*:&4!/%&!)/4+,3!$,94!$,&!7$%<2!!X:&%&!/%&!

/9)$!)4,*/?*+?!A%$W9&1)!"/3%/11/*+)1-O!7:&%&!+,G9&?*+$,)!/%&!9$)*!/,<!$,94!*:&!1$)*! A%+1+*+6&!?$,)*%(?*+$,)!/%&!()&<2!!Y8:+9&!:&!Z*:&!E%$?/F)!/A:/)+?[!1/4!*%4!*$!G$%1!

?$1A9&*&!)&,*&,?&)O!:&!:/)!()(/994!9$)*!*:&!/W+9+*4!*$!&6$H&!)4,*/?*+?!A/**&%,)O!/,<!&6&,!/!)&,*&,?&!%&A&*+*+$,!*/)H!1/4!A%$6&!+1A$))+W9&!G%$1!*:&!3%/11/*+?/9!A$+,*!$G!6+&72\!""L$$<39/))!M!N/A9/,O!PQRS-!A2!TT-!!!C$!*:&!E%$?/F)!/A:/)+?!?&%*/+,94!:/)!A%$W9&1)!7+*:!

/%*+?(9/*+$,!/,<!3%/11/%!*:/*!<$!,$*!<+%&?*94!?$,?&%,!*:&!I]^_O!W&?/()&!*:&4!/GG&?*!

&6&,!$,&!7$%<!(**&%/,?&)!/,<!%&A&/*&<!)&,*&,?&)2!!]%&!*:&)&!<&G+?+*)!&,$(3:!*$!&JA9/+,!*:&+%!W&:/6+$%!7+*:$(*!*:&!I]^_!+*)&9G!W&+,3!/GG&?*&<=!!]AA/%&,*94!4&)0!+G!)/4+,3!7$%<)!

+)!)$!&GG$%*G(9!/,<!)4,*/J!+)!,$*!/(*$1/*+?O!+*!+)!A9/()+W9&!*$!*:+,H!*:/*!E%$?/F)!A/*+&,*)!

:/6&!?$1A9&*&!)&,*&,?&)!+,!1+,<!W(*!*:&)&!3&*!%&<(?&<!<$7,!*$!$,&!$%!*7$!7$%<!

(**&%/,?&)!W&?/()&!$G!*:&!<+GG+?(9*4!$G!A%$<(?+,3!*:&!)&,*&,?&2!!X:+)!+)!?$,)+)*&,*!7+*:!*:&!G/?*!*:/*!*:&+%!/W+9+*4!*$!+,*&%A%&*!,&7!)&,*&,?&)!+)!%&9/*+6&94!+,*/?*`/,!/W+9+*4!*:/*!

 A%&)(1/W94!/9)$!<%/7)!$,!*:&!I]^_2!!])!/!%&)(9*O!*:&+%!$,&!7$%<!%&)A$,)&)!/%&!/AA%$A%+/*&!+G!,$*!(,W$(,<&<2!!#$%&$6&%O!*:&4!<$!,$*!)&&1!*$!W&!)*+1(9()!W$(,<0!,$*&!

*:/*!*:&!A/*+&,*!%&)A$,<)!*$!*:&!6&%4!6/3(&!'(&)*+$,!a8:/*!:/AA&,&<=F!7+*:!*:&!

)*/*+)*+?/994!(,9+H&94!W(*!/AA%$A%+/*&!+,!?$,*&J*!/,)7&%!a1$%*/%F2!!L$$<39/))!/,<!N/A9/,!/9)$!$W)&%6&!*:/*!*:&!A/*+&,*!1/4!*%4!*$!G$%1!/!)&,*&,?&`&6&,!*:$(3:!*:&4!G/+9!G$%!1$%&!

 A&%+A:&%/9!%&/)$,)2!!C$!:&%&!7&!)&&!*:/*!3%/11/%!?/,!W&!/GG&?*&<!W4!W%/+,!</1/3&!"/)!

7&99!/)!/%*+?(9/*+$,-O!W(*!/3/+,!*:&%&!+)!,$!?9&/%!&6+<&,?&!*:/*!*:&!I]^_!+)!/GG&?*&<2!

! 8:/*!7$(9<!/!*%(&!I]^_!/A:/)+/!W&!9+H&=!!./*+&,*)!7+*:!*:+)!/A:/)+/!7$(9<!:/6&!3$$<!$W;&?*!,/1+,3!/,<!7$%<!%&?$3,+*+$,O!):$7+,3!*:/*!*:&!9&J+?$,!+)!+,*/?*2!!X:&!)A&&?:!

7$(9<!W&!G9(&,*!/,<!G%&&!G%$1!3%/11/*+?/9!&%%$%)O!7:&,!")/4-!*:&4!/%&!%&A&/*+,3!/!

)&,*&,?&!$%!%&?+*+,3!/!H,$7,!A+&?&!9+H&!/!)$,3!$%!*:&!^$%<F)!.%/4&%2!!X:/*!7$(9<!)(33&)*!*:/*!*:&!3%/11/%!+)!+,*/?*2!!E(*!*:&!)A&/H&%!7$(9<!G/+9!*$!A(*!*$3&*:&%!7$%<)!

)A$,*/,&$()94!+,*$!A:%/)&)O!/,<b$%!:&!7$(9<!A(*!*:&1!*$3&*:&%!+,!/!)&&1+,394!%/,<$1O!

 A(%A$)&9&))!G/):+$,2!!]99!*:&)&!)41A*$1)!&J+)*`W(*!*:+)!A/%*+?(9/%!?$1W+,/*+$,!$G!*:&!)41A*$1)!+,*$!/!)4,<%$1&!<$&)!,$*!)&&1!*$!W&!/**&)*&<2!!C$!A&%:/A)!+*!+)!,$*!*%(&!*:/*!

 W%/+,!</1/3&!?/,!<+)%(A*!/,4!1&,*/9!G(,?*+$,!$,&!?/,!+1/3+,&B!+*!<$&)!,$*!<+)%(A*!*:&!

I]^_!+*)&9G2c!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!c!X%/,)?$%*+?/9!#$*$%!]A:/)+/!"/9)$!?/99&<!d4,/1+?!]A:/)+/!"#/%()e&7)H+O!PQRT-!AA2!PPPfPT-!:/)!*:&!

?$1W+,/*+$,!$G!)41A*$1)!*:/*!+)!1$)*!9+H&!*:&!1+))+,3!A%$G+9&2!!5*!+)!3%$(A&<!7+*:!E%$?/F)!/A:/)+/!/)!/!,$,G9(&,*!G$%1!$G!/A:/)+/2!!D$7&6&%O!*:&%&!1/4!,$*!W&!)(?:!$W6+$()!A%$W9&1)!7+*:!/%*+?(9/*+$,O!/,<!

Page 17: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 17/26

! "#$%!&'(&)*%$'(!+$,,',%!-!&)-%%$&-)!.$/0!$(!(/*,')$(1*$%2$&%3!!4$&#2#/$+!5667! 8,'8'%/9!-!+'9/)!':!2#/!)-(1*-1/!:-&*)2;!2#-2!:/-2*,/9!2#,//!9$%2$(&2!<&/(2/,%=>!+'2',!

?8,'9*&2$'(@A!-*9$2',;!?8/,&/82$'(@A!-(9!&'(&/82*-)!?B-8)-(A!5C6D@3!!"#/%/!&/(2/,%!0/,/!

&'((/&2/9!2'!/-&#!'2#/,!E;!(/*,-)!8-2#0-;%A!-(9!2#/!+'2',!-(9!-*9$2',;!&/(2/,%!0/,/!

&'((/&2/9!2'!2#/!'*2%$9/!0',)9!$(!2#/!'E.$'*%!0-;3!!4$&#2#/$+!/F8)-$(/9!2#/!,-(1/!':!

G('0(!-8#-%$-%!E;!8,'8'%$(1!2#-2!-(;!&/(2/,!',!8-2#0-;!&'*)9!E/!9$%,*82/9!E;!E,-$(!$(H*,;I0$2#!2#/!%2,$G$(1!/F&/82$'(!':!2#/!<&'(&/82!&/(2/,=3!!J(9A!-%!-),/-9;!+/(2$'(/9A!

2#/!&)-%%$:$&-2$'(!':!-8#-%$-%!#-%!/+/,1/%!:,'+!2#$%!.$/0!#-%!%2''9!2#/!2/%2!':!2$+/A!-(9!$%!%2$))!2#/!E-%$%!':!+'%2!&)$($&-)!9$-1('%$%!+',/!2#-(!5KK!;/-,%!)-2/,3!!"#/!-('+-);!2#-2!#$%!

%;%2/+!#-9!'(/!&,*&$-)!$(1,/9$/(2!2#-2!0-%!('2!8,'(/!2'!9$%,*82$'(!E;!$(H*,;!$%!2,/-2/9!-%!-!

&'(&/82*-)!:)-0!E;!%*E%/L*/(2!(/*,')'1$%2%!?%*&#!-%!B-8)-(@IE*2!2#/;!#-./!('2!9$%&'./,/9!2#/!+$%%$(1!%;(9,'+/!',!8,'8'%/9!-!0-;!':!,/-,,-(1$(1!2#/!-22/%2/9!

%;(9,'+/%!%'!2#-2!2#/!1-8!9'/%!('2!-88/-,3!!4$&#2#/$+M%!<&'(&/82!&/(2/,=!$%!2#-2!-%8/&2!':!

2#/!)-(1*-1/!:-&*)2;!2#-2!$%!2#/!)-%2!%2/8!$(!&'+8,/#/(%$'(A!2#/!:$,%2!%2/8!$(!8,'9*&2$'(A!

-(9!?$(!&'(2,-%2!2'!8/,&/82$'(!-(9!-,2$&*)-2$'(@!$%!('2!$(.')./9!$(!%$+8)/!,/8/2$2$'(3!!"#*%!$2!$%!8)-*%$E);!2#/!%-+/!:-&*)2;!-%!0#-2!N!#-./!E//(!&-))$(1!2#/!BJ4O3!!P'!2#/!,/%*)2!':!

5QKR!;/-,%!':!(/*,')'1$&-)!,/%/-,&#!%//+%!2'!E/!2#-2!2#/,/!$%!('!,/-)!/.$9/(&/!2#-2!2#/!BJ4O!9/8/(9%!'(!9/9$&-2/9!&$,&*$2,;!$(!2#/!E,-$(!2$%%*/3

C!

! S'0!)/2!*%!2*,(!:,'+!(/*,')'1;!2'!1/(/2$&%>!0#-2!/.$9/(&/!$%!2#/,/!2#-2!2#/!BJ4O!

$%!1/(/2$&-));!/(&'9/9T!N%!2#/,/!-!BJ4O!1/(/A!',!%/2!':!BJ4O!1/(/%A!%'+/0#/,/!$(!2#/!

#*+-(!1/('+/T!!!N:!%'A!2#/(!'(/!+$1#2!/F8/&2!2'!:$(9!9/./)'8+/(2-)!9$%',9/,%!2#-2!-::/&2!2#/!BJ4O!$(!-!9$::/,/(2$-)!0-;I9$%',9/,%!2#-2!+$1#2!*)2$+-2/);!E/!2,-&/9!2'!1/(/2$&!

-E(',+-)$2$/%3!!J,/!2#/,/!%*&#!9$%',9/,%T!!!"#/!&)-%%$:$&-2$'(!':!P8/&$:$&!4-(1*-1/!

N+8-$,+/(2%!?P4N@!9'/%!('2!#-./!-%!,$&#!-(9!%2-E)/!-!#$%2',;!-%!2#/!&)-%%$:$&-2$'(!':!

-8#-%$-%!#-%A!E*2!$2!#-%!E//(!2#/!%*EH/&2!':!$(2/(%$./!,/%/-,&#!$(!2#/!)-%2!UK!;/-,%!',!%'3!!P2-(9-,9!&)-%%$:$&-2$'(%!&'+/!:,'+!V$%#'8!?V$%#'8A!UKKQ@!-(9!W-8$(!-(9!J))/(!?W-8$(!X!

J))/(A!5C6Y@3!!V$%#'8!?UKKQ@!2/(2-2$./);!$9/(2$:$/%!:'*,!2;8/%!':!P4N>!2;8$&-)!P4NA!%/./,/!,/&/82$./!)-(1*-1/!9$%',9/,A!9/./)'8+/(2-)!./,E-)!9;%8,-F$-A!-(9!8,-1+-2$&!)-(1*-1/!

$+8-$,+/(23!!"#/!:$,%2!2#,//!-,/!,-2#/,!&)/-,);!$,,/)/.-(2!2'!2#/!BJ4O>!2;8$&-)!P4N!-::/&2%!

2#/!1,-++-,!&'+8'(/(2!?*($L*/);!',!-)'(1!0$2#!'2#/,!:/-2*,/%!':!)-(1*-1/@Z!%/./,/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!,/8/2$2$'(!':!%/(2/(&/%!$%!L*$2/!1''9A!:,//!:,'+!1,-++-2$&-)!/,,',%3!![',!%'+/!,/-%'(A!2#$%!-8#-%$-!$%!('2!

9$%&*%%/9!$(!-%!+*&#!9/82#!$(!+;!%'*,&/%3!!\''91)-%%!-(9!]-8)-(!?\''91)-%%!X!]-8)-(A!5CDU@!!#-./!'();!'(/!%#',2!8-,-1,-8#A!-(9!(/$2#/,!2#/;!(',!]/,2/%^!?]/,2/%^A!5CDC@!1$./!-(!$))*%2,-2$./!&-%/!%2*9;3!!"#/!+-$(!%;+82'+!2#-2!2#/%/!8-2$/(2%!#-./A!-88-,/(2);A!$%!-!:-$)*,/!2'!$($2$-2/!%8//&#!-2!-))3!_-,*% /̂0%G$!9/%&,$E/%!$2!

2#*%>!<"#/%/!8-2$/(2%!)-&G!-(!-&2$./!-22$2*9/!-(9!9'!('2!$($2$-2/!%8//&#Z!2#/;!1/(/,-));!&'+8)-$(!':!</+82$(/%%!$(!2#/!#/-9=!-(9!$(-E$)$2;!2'!8#,-%/!$(!0',9%!2#/!$(:',+-2$'(!2#/;!0-(2!2'!/F8,/%%3=!!`/!&$2/%!4*,$-M%!.$/0!2#-2!<"#$%!0-%!2#'*1#2!2'!E/!-!G$(9!':!9$%',9/,!':!./,E-)!2#$(G$(1!$(.').$(1!2#/!)'%%!':!2#/!-E$)$2;!2'!8,'1,-++/!-!2/F2!%8'(2-(/'*%);!$(!2#/!+$(93=!!"#$%!0'*)9!%//+!2'!E/!-!9$%,*82$'(!':!2#/!BJ4OA!$:!-(;2#$(1!$%3!!`'0/./,A!'(/!8,'E-E)/!$(9$&-2$'(!2#-2!2#/!BJ4O!$%!$(2-&2!E*2!('2!/-%;!2'!/F8,/%%!$%!2#-2!

2#/%/!8-2$/(2M%!-E$)$2;!2'!*(9/,%2-(9!('./)!%/(2/(&/%!$%!-88-,/(2);!L*$2/!1''9A!-(9!2#/!&-8-&$2;!2'!$(2/,8,/2!('./)!%/(2/(&/%!8,/%*+-E);!9,-0%!'(!2#/!BJ4O!2''3!!!J)%'A!2#/%/!8-2$/(2%!2/(9!('2!2'!$($2$-2/!/./(!'(/!0',9!*22/,-(&/%A!-(9!%*&#!*22/,-(&/%!0'*)9!('2!,/L*$,/!2#/!BJ4OZ!2#$%!%*11/%2%!2#-2!2#/!8,'E)/+!$%!'(/!':!

-&2$.$2-2$(1!%8//&#3!![*,2#/,+',/A!]/,2/%^!?5CDC@!+/(2$'(%!2#-2!+'%2!8-2$/(2%!0$2#!",-(%&',2$&-)!_'2',!J8#-%$-!-,/!&-8-E)/!':!E*,%2%!':!?':2/(!-1,-++-2$&@!%8//&#!-2!2$+/%A!-(9!_-,*%^/0%G$!?83!55Y@!+/(2$'(%!/F-+8)/%!0#/,/!2#/!8-2$/(2%!:',+!./,;!1''9!%/(2/(&/%!0#/(!2#/;!#-./!-!&/,2-$(!G$(9%!':!.$%*-)!8,'8%!2'!#/)8!2#/+!:'&*%3!!"#$%!%#'*)9!('2!E/!8'%%$E)/!$:!2#/!BJ4O!&$,&*$2!0/,/!2,*);!1'(/3!C4$&#2#/$+M%!'0(!.$/0!0-%!2#-2!2#/!&'(&/82!&/(2/,!0-%!%8,/-9!9$::*%/);!2#,'*1#!'*2!2#/!E,-$(A!0#$&#!+/-(%!2#-2!$2!$%!('2!-::/&2/9!E;!)'&-)$^/9!)/%$'(%3!!"#-2!$%A!':!&'*,%/A!-('2#/,!)/1$2$+-2/!8'%%$E$)$2;3!

Page 18: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 18/26

!"#"$%&'"()*+,-*,"(.&/0!."!(&/(*($!01)"2(3&%4(*-.&%0!5($!0#"//&+,6(."'")0$2"+%*)('"!1*)(.5/$!*7&*(&/(*($!01)"2(3&%4(*!%&#-)*%&0+(0!($"!4*$/(3&%4(20!"(*1/%!*#%($40+0)0,&#*)(

!"$!"/"+%*%&0+8((94&).!"+(3&%4(/5+.!02"/(0:(%4"(:&!/%(*+.(%4&!.(%5$"/(*!"(*$$*!"+%)5(

#*$*1)"(0:(/$""#4(%4*%(&/(-+10-+.".;(/%&2-)-/<:!""(*+.(*$$!0$!&*%"=&%(&/(>-/%(

,!*22*%&#*))5(:)*3".(*+.?0!($40+0)0,&#*))5(."'&*+%8((@4"(0+)5(%5$"(0:(ABC(%4*%(2&,4%(1"(

!")"'*+%;(%4"+;(&/(D!*,2*%&#(B*+,-*,"(C2$*&!2"+%(EF*$&+(*+.(G))"+H/(A"2*+%&#<D!*,2*%&#(I&/0!."!J8((@4&/(&/(."/#!&1".(*/(:0))03/K(L@4"(#4&).(3&%4("*!)5()*+,-*,"(.")*5(

,0"/(0+(%0(2*M"(!*$&.($!0,!"//(&+(2*/%"!&+,($40+0)0,5(*+.(,!*22*!(*+.(/%*!%/(%0(/$"*M(&+()0+,(*+.(#02$)"7(/"+%"+#"/;(1-%(-/"/(-%%"!*+#"/(&+*$$!0$!&*%")58((A-#4(#4&).!"+(2*5(

0::"!(%*+,"+%&*)(*+/3"!/(%0(N-"/%&0+/;()*#M(#04"!"+#"(&+(#0+'"!/*%&0+(0!(+*!!*%&'"(/$""#4;(

*+.(*$$"*!(0'"!)&%"!*)(&+(%4"&!(#02$!"4"+/&0+8O(EP&/40$;(QRRSK(TQUJ8((F*$&+(*+.(G))"+H/(EUVWTK(UXSJ(."/#!&$%&0+(&/(*/(:0))03/K(

(

C+(,"+"!*);(%4"(-%%"!*+#"/(%4"5($!0.-#"(*!"(/5+%*#&%&#*))5(3"))<:0!2".;($40+0)0,&#*))5(

&+%*#%;(*+.;(0+(%4"(/-!:*#";(L,00.()*+,-*,"O8((Y+(#)0/"!("7*2&+*%&0+;(403"'"!;(0+"(.&/#0'"!/(%4*%(%4"()*+,-*,"(&/(0:%"+(+0%(!"*))5(#022-+&#*%&'"8((@4*%(&/;(%4"!"(&/(*(

/"'"!"(&2$*&!2"+%(&+(%4"(*1&)&%5(%0("+#0."(2"*+&+,(!")"'*+%(%0(%4"(#0+'"!/*%&0+*)(/&%-*%&0+;(*+.(*(/%!&M&+,(&+*1&)&%5(%0("+,*,"(&+(#022-+&#*%&'"(.&/#0-!/"8(902$!"4"+/&0+(0:(%4"(#0++"#%".(.&/#0-!/"(0:(%4"(#0+'"!/*%&0+*)($*!%+"!(*)/0(*$$"*!/(

%0(1"(&2$*&!".;(*)%40-,4(/40!%($4!*/"/(*+.(&+.&'&.-*)(30!./(*!"(#02$!"4"+.".8(

(@4&/(2&,4%(1"(/""+(*/(*(9GBZ(.":&#&%K(%4"&!(/$""#4(&/(-+10-+.".;(/%&2-)-/(:!"";(1-%(+0%(

*$$!0$!&*%"8(([03"'"!;(&%(/""2/()&M"(/02"%4&+,(.&::"!"+%(&/(1"&+,(2"*+%(15(\*$$!0$!&*%"H(

4"!"8((C+(#4*!*#%"!&]&+,(%4"(9GBZ;(9402/M5(*+.(I"/#*!%"/(-/"(\*$$!0$!&*%"H(&+(

0$$0/&%&0+(%0(\!*+.02HK(&%(&/(%4"(#4*!*#%"!&/%&#(0:(/$""#4(%4*%(!"/$0+./(%0(*(/&%-*%&0+(&+(*(3*5(%4*%(&/(+"&%4"!(."%"!2&+&/%&#(+0!($!01*1)&/%&#8((G+.(#4&).!"+(3&%4(D!*,2*%&#(B*+,-*,"(

C2$*&!2"+%(*!"(#*$*1)"(0:(/$""#4(%4*%(&/(*$$!0$!&*%"(&+(%4&/(/"+/"8((^4*%(P&/40$(*+.(F*$&+(_(G))"+(/""2(%0(1"(,"%%&+,(*%(&+(%4"&!(."/#!&$%&0+/(&/(/02"%4&+,(20!"(*)0+,(%4"(

)&+"/(0:(/$""#4(%4*%(&/(0+(&%/(03+(3*'")"+,%48((C%(2&,4%(1"($-!$0/":-);(1-%(%4"($-!$0/"/(.0(

+0%(2"/4($!0$"!)5(3&%4(%40/"(0:(%4"&!(#0+'"!/*%&0+*)($*!%+"!/8UR((F*$&+(*+.(G))"+H/(

"7*2$)"(&/(&+/%!-#%&'"(&+(%4&/(!"/$"#%6(%4"5(!"$0!%(E$8(UX`JK(

(

a0!("7*2$)";(%4"(N-"/%&0+(L34"!"(.0(50-(,0(%0(/#400)bO(3*/(*+/3"!".(15(0+"(0:(0-!(

#4&).!"+(3&%4(L@0225(,0"/(%0(25(/#400)(1"#*-/"(C(/""(4&2(&+(%4"(4*))("'"!5.*5;(1-%(3"(4*'"(.&::"!"+%(%"*#4"!/;(*+.(C()&M"(*!&%42"%&#(1-%(@0225()&M"/(!"*.&+,8O(

(

@4"(#4&).H/(!"/$0+/"(&/(&+*$$!0$!&*%"(&+(%4*%(4"(#)"*!)5(.&.(+0%(*+/3"!(%4"(N-"/%&0+8((P-%(&%(&/($"!:"#%)5(#04"!"+%(*+.(2"*+&+,:-)(34"+(%*M"+(&+(&%/(03+(%"!2/8((["(2*5(1"(2&//&+,(

/02"%4&+,(*10-%(/0#&*)(/"+/&%&'&%5;(1-%(4"(&/(+0%(2&//&+,(4&/(9GBZ(&+(9402/M5H/(/"+/"8((

Y'"!*));(%4"+;(34&)"(%4"!"(2*5(E0!(2*5(+0%J(1"("'&."+#"(&+(%4"()&%"!*%-!"(0+(."'")0$2"+%*)(.&/0!."!/(:0!(*(\,!*22*!(,"+"H(.":"#%/(&+(34&#4($!0.-#"(@5$&#*)(ABC;(

%4"!"(&/(+0(#0!!"/$0+.&+,("'&."+#"(:0!(*(\9GBZ(,"+"H8(

( a&+*))5;(#0+/&."!(%4"($!0/$"#%/(:0!("7$)*&+&+,(%4"(0!&,&+(0:(%4"(9GBZ(&+(4-2*+/(

&+(%"!2/(0:("'0)-%&0+8((C(/-$$0/"(%4*%(&:(3"(.0(+0%(M+03(403(%4"(9GBZ(&/("210.&".(&+(%4"(+"-!*)(4*!.3*!";(+0!(403(&%(&/(/$"#&:&".(&+(%4"(,"+"%&#(#0.";(%4"(#4*+#"/(0:(

(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((UR(C+."".;(10%4(/0-!#"/(#0+>"#%-!"(%4*%(%4&/(/5+.!02"(&/(!")*%".(%0(*-%&/28(

Page 19: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 19/26

!"#$%&'!%(#)*+*,-%+(.-,*-/".'%("#+&0*+!!"'#%*+&-*$.(1*%"*#"#-2**345*!"'&$-*(%*($*-+$0*%"*%-..*$%"&(-$*+6"'%*780*8+/(#)*%8-*!+9+!(%0*%"*5&--.0*-:9&-$$*%8"')8%*(#*+*7+0*%8+%*($*

+99&"9&(+%-*%"*6'%*#"%*,-%-&1(#-,*60*$(%'+%("#$*($*+,/+#%+)-"'$*%"*$'&/(/+.*+#,*

&-9&",'!%("#2**;8-*-/".'%("#+&0*9+&+,()1*!+#*6-*+99.(-,*%"*%8-*<=>?*+%*%8+%*.-/-.2**@'%*A*

%+B-*,($!'$$("#$*%8+%*-:($%*"#.0*+%*%8+%*.-/-.*"5*)-#-&+.(%0*%"*6-*"5*.(1(%-,*(#%-&-$%C 

(#,--,D*%"*6-*+.1"$%*%+'%".")(!+.2E**@'%*%8($*)(/-$*1-*10*!8+#!-*%"*!"11-#%*"#*+*#"%"&("'$*($$'-*"5*78-%8-&*+9-$*+&-*!+9+6.-*"5*.+#)'+)-*78-#*%8-0*+&-*&+($-,*(#*%8-*&()8%*

-#/(&"#1-#%2**A#*"&,-&*%"*1+B-*9&")&-$$*"#*%8($*-#,.-$$.0*!"#%-#%("'$*F'-$%("#D*"#-*1'$%*8+/-*+*!.-+&.0*+)&--,G"#*#"%("#*"5*78+%*($*-$$-#%(+.*%"*.+#)'+)-2*;8-*/+)'-#-$$*+#,*

 9".0$-10*"5*%8-*7"&,*H.+#)'+)-I*8+$*+99+&-#%.0*!+'$-,*1'!8*1($'#,-&$%+#,(#)*+#,*8'&%*

5--.(#)$*(#*%8($*&-)+&,2**@'%*&+%8-&*%8+#*)-%%(#)*-16&"(.-,*(#*%8($*(#*+*78".-$+.-*7+0D*A* 9&"9"$-*%"*$%+0*5"!'$-,*"#*%8-*5+!%"&(#)*"5*%8-*.+#)'+)-*!+9+!(%0*(#%"*3+%*.-+$%E*

/"!+6'.+&0D*)&+11+&D*+#,*%8-*<=>?2**<+#*+9-$*+!F'(&-*+*/"!+6'.+&0J**=99+&-#%.0*0-$K*

+9-$*&+($-,*60*8'1+#$*8+/-*6--#*$8"7#*%"*1+$%-&*+*#'16-&*"5*+&6(%&+&0*$()#$*(#*%8-*

LMM$2**<+#*+9-$*+!F'(&-*+*)&+11+&J**N+06-2**;8($*8+$*6--#*%+B-#*%"*6-*%8-*!&'!(+.*F'-$%("#*(#*1'!8*"5*%8-*.(%-&+%'&-2**O+/+)-GP'16+')8*3O+/+)-GP'16+')8D*LQQRE*+#,*8-&*

!"..-+)'-$*8+/-*+&)'-,*%8+%*%8-*6"1"#"*!8(19+#S--*T+#S(*!+#*'#,-&$%+#,*)&+11+%(!+..0*!"19.-:*$-#%-#!-$*(#*U#).($8D*+#,*$8"7$*%8&--*$(19.-*$0#%+!%(!*&-)'.+&(%(-$*(#*8($*"7#*9&",'!%("#$C(#!.',(#)*$0$%-1+%(!*"&,-&(#)*"5*/-&6*6-5"&-*"6V-!%D*

+$*(#*U#).($82**3;8-(&*%-$%$*,"*#"%*+99&"+!8*%8-*.-/-.*"5*$"98($%(!+%("#*"5*%8"$-*%8+%*

!.(#(!(+#$*'$-*%"*9&"6-*%8-*!+9+!(%(-$*"5*+)&+11+%(!*+98+$(!$D*8"7-/-&2E**@'%*5"&*10* 9'&9"$-$*8-&-D*%8-*!&'!(+.*F'-$%("#*($*78-%8-&*+9-$*!+#*+!F'(&-*%8-*<=>?*!+9+!(%02**W-&-*

%8-*+#$7-&*$--1$*%"*6-*+#*'#-F'(/+!+6.-*#"2**U/-#*T+#S(D*$'99"$-,.0*%8-*1"$%*9&"5(!(-#%*

"5*%8-*+9-$D*8+,*+*1-+#*'%%-&+#!-*.-#)%8*"5*V'$%*"/-&*"#-2**O+/+)-GP+')8*3O+/+)-G

P'16+')8D*LQQRE*&-9"&%$*%8+%*"#.0*+6"'%*LMX*"5*8($*'%%-&+#!-$*!"#$($%-,*"5*1"&-*%8+#*"#-*$()#D*+#,*(%*7+$*/-&0*&+&-*5"&*8(1*%"*'$-*1"&-*%8+#*%7"*"&*%8&--*$()#$*(#*"#-*

'%%-&+#!-2**;8($*.+#)'+)-*6-8+/("&*5+..$*$8"&%*"5*%8-*<=>?*"#*%8-*'#6"'#,-,#-$$*%-$%2**T+#S(*!"19+&-$*'#5+/"&+6.0*(#*%8($*&-$9-!%*-/-#*7(%8*%8-*8"1-G$()#G'$(#)*!8(.,&-#*"5*

Y".,(#GN-+,"7*+#,*N0.+#,-&D*78"*8+/-*+*1-+#*'%%-&+#!-*.-#)%8*"5*L2Z[D*'$-*1'.%(9.-*

$()#*$-#%-#!-$*\MX*"5*%8-*%(1-D*+#,*8+/-*+*1+:(1'1*$-#%-#!-*.-#)%8*"5*[GQ*$()#$2*O+/+)-GP+')8*3O+/+)-GP'16+')8D*LQQRE*)"-$*%"*$"1-*9+(#$*%"*-:9.+(#*%8+%*%8($*

 6"'#,-,#-$$*"5*"'%9'%*($*#"%*T+#S(I$*5+'.%2**W($*/"!+.*%&+!%*($*#"%*7-..G!"#5()'&-,*%"*

$9-+B*$-#%-#!-$*."#)-&*%8+#*%8+%2**W($*8+#,$*,"*#"%*8+/-*5(#-*-#"')8*!"#%&".*%"*$()#*

$-#%-#!-$*."#)-&*%8+#*%8+%D*8+/(#)*6--#*%"')8-#-,*60*7+.B(#)*"#*%8-12**W($*6-$%*1-%8",*"5*!"11'#(!+%("#*($*9"(#%(#)*%"*$()#$*9&(#%-,*"#*+*B-06"+&,2**@'%*(#*%8($*1",+.(%0*8+$*+#*

(#8-&-#%*.(1(%+%("#]*"#!-*8($*/"!+6'.+&0*)-%$*.+&)-*-#"')8*%"*$+0*+#*(#%-&-$%(#)*&+#)-*"5*

%8(#)$D*(%*%+B-$*%""*."#)*%"*5(#,*%8-*$016".$*8-*7+#%$*7(%8(#*%8-*'#7(-.,0*1+%&(:*"5*$016".$2*O"*%8-&-*($*+*!"16(#+%("#*"5*5+!%"&$*%8+%*%")-%8-&*8+/-*%8-*-55-!%*%8+%*(%*($*#"%*

5+(&*%"*-:9-!%*+#*+9-*%"*9&",'!-*'#6"'#,-,*$9--!8*(#*&-+.*%(1-D*+!!"&,(#)*%"*O+/+)-G

P+')82**N+06-*$"D*6'%*%8($*$"'#,$*&+%8-&*.(B-*+*!"#$9(&+!02**=*$(19.-&*+#,*1"&-*'#(5(-,*-:9.+#+%("#*!"#$($%-#%*7(%8*%8-*5+!%$*($*%8+%*%8-*<=>?*($*.+!B(#)*(#*%8-*+9-2**4/-&+..*%8-#D*

^-$!+&%-$*7+$*!"&&-!%*%8+%*%8-&-*($*#"%8(#)*.(B-*%8-*<=>?*+%%-$%-,*(#*%8-*+#(1+.*B(#),"1*

+9+&%*5&"1*8'1+#*B(#,*3$--*+.$"*<8-##-0*+#,*O-05+&%8*3<8-#-0*_*O-05+&%8D*LQQME*"#*%8-*

$!"9-*"5*9&(1+%-*!"11'#(!+%("#*(#*%8-*7(.,E2**;8'$D*%8-&-*($*.(%%.-*-:9.+#+%"&0*+,/+#%+)-*%"*)+(#*60*$+0(#)*%8+%*%8-*<=>?*,-/-."9-,*-/".'%("#+&(.0D*60*%8-*)&+,'+.*(19&"/-1-#%*

Page 20: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 20/26

!"#$%#&'(")*#!"#+'*#,-"&+!$"#$,#(#.%**/!0+!")#&(.(&!+1#+'%$-)'#+'*#2*&'("!02#$,#"(+-%(3#0*3*&+!$"455#

# 6$#$7*%(33#8*#'(7*#0**"#+'(+9#3!:*#)%(22(%9#+'*%*#!0#)$$;#%*(0$"#+$#<*3!*7*#+'(+#

+'*#=>?@#!0#!""(+*9#)!7*"#!+0#-"!7*%0(3!+1#!"#'-2("0#(";#.$7*%+1#$,#0+!2-3-0#

&$"0!;*%(+!$"0#$,#7(%!$-0#:!";04##A$8*7*%9#+'*%*#!0#"$#)$$;#*7!;*"&*#,%$2#(.'(0!(#+'(+#!+#

!0#"*-%$3$)!&(331#*2<$;!*;9#"$#)$$;#*7!;*"&*#,%$2#;*7*3$.2*"+(3#;!0$%;*%0#+'(+#!+#!0#)*"*+!&(331#*"&$;*;9#(";#"$#)$$;#&$2.(%(+!7*#*7!;*"&*#+'(+#!+#*7$37*;#,%$2#0$2*+'!")#

+'(+#8*#'(7*#!"#&$22$"#8!+'#&3$0*31#%*3(+*;#.%!2(+*04##B'*#=>?@#0**20#+$#&$"+%(0+#!"#+'!0#%*0.*&+#8!+'#)%(22(%9#(+#3*(0+#0$2*#(0.*&+0#$,#8'!&'#;$#0**2#+$#<*#(,,*&+*;#!"#8*33#

*0+(<3!0'*;#"*-%$3$)!&(3#01";%$2*09#!"#(#.(%+!&-3(%#;*7*3$.2*"+(3#;!0$%;*%9#(";#8'!&'#

'(0#<**"#*/'!<!+*;#C!+#!0#&3(!2*;D#<1#(+#3*(0+#$"*#(.*4##6$#+'*%*#!0#%*(0$"#+$#+'!":#+'(+#+'*%*#!0#(#+1.*#$,#!""(+*"*00#+'(+#!0#"$+#"(%%$831#<!$3$)!&(34#

#

!"#$%&'()*)+%,-#*./(0)+%,-#*,/#)12#$345#

#A(7!")#&$2.(%*;#"$%2(3#'-2("#3(")-()*#&(.(&!+!*0#+$#+'$0*#$,#;(2()*;#'-2("09#

&'!3;%*"9#(";#(.*09#8*#&("#(30$#&$2.(%*#+'*2#8!+'#+'*#3(")-()*#&(.(&!+!*0#$,#2("E2(;*#&$2.-+(+!$"(3#;*7!&*04##B'!0#!0#%*3*7("+#<*&(-0*#&$)"!+!7*#+'*$%!*0#(%*#&$2.-+(+!$"(3#+'*$%!*09#2$%*#$%#3*00#<1#;*,!"!+!$"4##>";#8*#'(7*#(#.%*++1#)$$;#!;*(#$,#'$8#+'*#<%(!"#&("#

;$#&$2.-+(+!$"04##6$#+'*%*,$%*9#!+#0**20#.3(-0!<3*#+'(+#("1+'!")#+'(+#&("#<*#0.*&!,!*;#

&$2.-+(+!$"(331#&$-3;#,!+#!"+$#(#"(%%$831#<!$3$)!&(3#.(%(;!)29#(+#3*(0+#!"#.%!"&!.3*4##F*#:"$8#+'(+#&$2.-+*%0#&("#;$#(#3$+#)!7*"#*"$-)'#&$2.-+(+!$"(3#%*0$-%&*0#C+!2*9#2*2$%19#

=G@D9#(";#8*#:"$8#+'(+#+'*#<%(!"#'(0#3$+0#$,#%*0$-%&*09#)!7*"#+'*#'-)*#&$2.3*/!+1#$,#!+0#

"*-%$"0#(";#+'*!%#7(%!$-0#!"+*%&$""*&+!$"04##6$#+'*%*,$%*#!+#2!)'+#0**2#+'(+#+'*%*#!0#

"$+'!")#2*"+(3#+'(+#&$-3;#"$+#<*#-";*%0+$$;#8!+'!"#+'*#<!$3$)!&(3#.(%(;!)24##H"#&$"+%(0+9#!,#8*#3*(%"#+'(+#+'*#=>?@#&(""$+#<*#2$;*3*;#&$2.-+(+!$"(3319#,$%#)$$;#%*(0$"09#+'(+#!+#!0#

 .*%'(.0#"$+#0$#0-%.%!0!")#+'(+#!+#(30$#&(""$+#<*#*/.3(!"*;#<1#+'*#-0-(3#+$$30#$,#<!$3$)14## I-%#&$",!;*"&*#+'(+#+'*#&$2.-+(+!$"(3#+'*$%1#$,#2!";#&("#<*#(#&$2.3*+*#+'*$%1#$,#

2!";#&$-3;#<*#("$+'*%#!"0+("&*#$,#+'*#<3!";"*00#+'(+#&$2*0#,%$2#-";*%0+(";!")#

*7*%1+'!")#(3$")#$"*#;!2*"0!$"#2(:!")#$"*#,$%)*+#+'(+#+'*%*#!0#("$+'*%#;!2*"0!$"#+$#&$"0!;*%4##J$;$%#CJ$;$%9#KLLLD#2(:*0#+'!0#&(0*#!"#0$2*#;*+(!39#(%)-!")#+'(+#&$2.-+(+!$"(3#

 .01&'$3$)1#'(0#0*%!$-031#$7*%0+(+*;#!+0#0-&&*00*04##H"#.(%+!&-3(%9#'*#.%*00*0#+'*#.$!"+#+'(+#

+'*#&$2.-+(+!$"(3#.(%(;!)2#'(0#"$#(&&$-"+#,$%#+'*#.'*"$2*"$"#$,#(<;-&+!7*#

%*(0$"!")M!4*49#!",*%*"&*#+$#+'*#<*0+#$7*%(33#*/.3("(+!$"9#8'*"#+'*%*#!0#"$#8(1#$,#

#################################################55#>.*#3(")-()*#%*0*(%&'*%0#$,+*"#&'(,*#(+#8'(+#+'*1#0**#(0#(#;$-<3*#0+(";(%;4##F'1#(2#H#0$#%*(;1#+$#

(++%!<-+*#=>?@#+$#+'*#54NO#1*(%#$3;#&'!3;#(";#+'*#P%$&(Q0#(.'(0!&#(";#0$#03$8#+$#(++%!<-+*#!+#+$#+'*#(.*9#8'*"#+'*!%#3!")-!0+!&#$-+.-+0#(%*#0!2!3(%9#(+#3*(0+#(+#!"(02-&'#(0#+'*1#&$"0!0+#2$0+31#$,#$"*#8$%;#-++*%("&*0#(";#"*7*%#2$%*#+'("#+8$#$%#+'%**#8$%;04##H#&("#-";*%0+(";#8'1#+'*1#,**3#+'(+#8(14##P-+#&$"0!;*%(+!$"0#$,# .(%0!2$"1#&-+#;!,,*%*"+#8(10#!"#+'*#;!,,*%*"+#&(0*04##B'*#P%$&(Q0#(.'(0!&#&3*(%31#'(;#+'*#=>?@#<*,$%*#'!0#

0+%$:*9#0$#+'*#R-*0+!$"#!0#8'*+'*%#'*#0+!33#'(0#!+4##G(%0!2$"1#3*(;0#$"*#+$#,(7$%#(#1*0#("08*%#!,#$+'*%#:"$8"#;!,,!&-3+!*0#(%*#*"$-)'#+$#*/.3(!"#+'*#<*'(7!$%#$<0*%7*;4##B'*#1$-")#&'!3;#&3*(%31#8!33#'(7*#+'*#=>?@#!"#("$+'*%#0!/#2$"+'09#0$#+'*#R-*0+!$"#!0#;$*0#0'*#(3%*(;1#'(7*#!+4##G(%0!2$"1#&("#3*(;#$"*#+$#,(7$%#(#1*0#

("08*%9#!,#$+'*%#:"$8"#;*7*3$.2*"+(3#&'(")*0#(%*#*"$-)'#+$#*/.3(!"#+'*#&'(")*#!"#<*'(7!$%4##P-+#+'*#(.*#"*7*%#2("!,*0+0#+'*#=>?@4##6$#'*%*#.(%0!2$"1#3*(;0#$"*#+$#,(7$%#+'*#"$#("08*%9#0!"&*#+'*%*#!0#"$#*7!;*"&*#+$#+'*#&$"+%(%14##>,+*%#(339#+'*#=>?@#!0#(#7*%1#0.*&!(3#&(.(&!+1#+'(+#$"31#(#+!"1#.*%&*"+()*#$,#+'!")0#!"#+'*#8$%3;#'(7*S#0-%*31#(#'*(71#<-%;*"#$,#.%$$,#,(330#$"#0$2*$"*#8'$#&3(!20#+'(+#(#"*8#:!";#$,#+'!")#'(0#+'!0#

&(.(&!+14##

Page 21: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 21/26

!"#$%"&'%"'()*("+,'$-(.'/(+.0'$%11'2,'3,1,*(".4''5,'6#%".0'#7.'.-(.'.-,'.3("0/#38(.%#"0'.-(.'('+#867.,3'+("')#'#"'("'%"67.9$-(.'$,'+(11':%"/#38(.%#"'63#+,00%"&;9870.'#"1<'

),6,")'#"'.-,'0<".(+.%+'63#6,3.%,0'#/'.-(.'%"67.='#"'-#$'%.'%0'67.'.#&,.-,34''>.'+(""#.'

),6,")'#"'.-,'0,8(".%+'63#6,3.%,0'#/'.-,'%"67.='07+-'(0'$-(.'.-,'*(3%#70'0<82#10'3,/,3'.#4''

?-%0'%0'"#.'0#8,'(++%),".(1'1%8%.(.%#"'0.,88%"&'/3#8'-#$'+#867.,3'0+%,".%0.0'-(66,"'.#'

$3%.,'63#&3(80@'3(.-,3='%.'%0',82,)),)'%"'?73%"&A0'),/%"%.%#"'#/'$-(.'+#867.(.%#"'%04''?-70='+#867.,30'(3,'$#"),3/71'(.'3,(0#"%"&'),)7+.%*,1<'B$-,"'$,11C63#&3(88,)D@'.-,<'

+("'.,11'$-(.'+#"+170%#"0'/#11#$'2,+(70,'#/'.-,'/#38'#/'.-,'63,8%0,0'2,..,3'.-("'-78("0'+("4''E7.'.-,<'+(""#.'3,(0#"'(2)7+.%*,1<='.,11%"&'70'$-(.'+#"+170%#"0'/#11#$'2,+(70,'#/'

.-,'+#".,".'#/'.-,'63,8%0,04''F#'$-,3,(0'.-,'.-,#3<'#/'+#867.(.%#"'+("'&%*,'70'('

$#"),3/71'(++#7".'#/'#",'.<6,'#/'3(.%#"(1%.<'%"'.,380'#/'"#"3(.%#"(1='6-<0%+(1'63#+,00,0='%.'+(""#.'&%*,'70'("'(++#7".'#/'("#.-,3'.<6,='(18#0.'2<'),/%"%.%#"4''F#'G#)#3'%),".%/%,0'.-,'

H7,0.%#"'#/'-#$'%0'(2)7+.%#"'6#00%21,'(0'.-,'&3,(.'8<0.,3<'.-(.'-#*,30'#*,3'+#&"%.%*,'

0+%,"+,4'

' I",'#2*%#70'$(<'.#'3,06#")'.#'G#)#3A0'(3&78,".'%0'.#'),"<'.-(.'.-,'-78("'8%")'3,(11<')#,0'$#3!'(2)7+.%*,1<4''J,3-(60'$,'#"1<'-(*,'.-,'%1170%#"'.-(.'$,'3,(0#"'

(2)7+.%*,1<='$-,3,(0'.-,'.37.-'#/'.-,'8(..,3'%0'$,'(3,'3,(0#"%"&'%"'('),.,38%"%0.%+'(")'8#)71(3'$(<4''G#)#3A0'63%8(3<',K(861,'#/'(2)7+.%*,'3,(0#"%"&'%0'0+%,".%/%+'.-,#3<'+#"0.37+.%#"='$-%+-'-,'.(!,0'.#'2,'('0#8,$-(.'673%/%,)'(")'(861%/%,)'*,30%#"'#/'-#$'#73'

8%")0'"#38(11<'$#3!4'E7.'-%0'+3%.%+0'+("'3,06#")'.-(.'.-,'0.3%!%"&'.-%"&'(2#7.'0+%,".%/%+'

.-,#3<'+#"0.37+.%#"'%0'.-(.'-78("'2,%"&0'(3,'"#.='2<'"(.73,='*,3<'&##)'(.'%.4''I"1<'.-,'8#0.'%".,11%&,".'6,#61,')#'%.='(")',*,"'.-,<'8(!,'8("<'8%0.(!,0'.-(.'",,)'.#'2,'+#33,+.,)'

 2<'+#887"%.%,0'#/'6,,30'#*,3'-%0.#3%+(1'.%8,4''?-,3,/#3,='.-,'),*,1#68,".'#/'0+%,"+,'%0'

)72%#70'(0'("'%1170.3(.%#"'#/'-#$'-78("'+#&"%.%#"'"#38(11<'$#3!0'B0,,='/#3',K(861,'

F6,32,3'BF6,32,3='.#'(66,(3D'"#.,'LD4'' 5,3,'.-,'/(+.#3%"&'#/'.-,'1("&7(&,'+(6(+%.<'%".#'*#+(271(3<='&3(88(3='(")'.-,'

MNOP'%0'3,1,*(".'(&(%"4''Q3(88(3'B0<".(KD'+("'2,'-(")1,)'2<'+1(00%+(1'+#867.(.%#"(1'(3+-%.,+.73,0@'.-(.'%0'"#'07363%0,='0%"+,'+#867.(.%#"'37"0'#"'0<".(K4''E7.'.-,'MNOP'

+(6(+%.<'%0'("'(2)7+.%*,'63#+,00'6(3',K+,11,"+,4''>'.-%"!'.-,3,'%0',*,3<'3,(0#"'.#'2,1%,*,'

.-(.'"#"C8#)71(3='"#"C0<".(+.%+'%"/,3,"+,'.#'.-,'2,0.',K61("(.%#"'%0'3(86(".'%"'#73',*,3<')(<='#3)%"(3<'(2%1%.<'.#'+#"0.37+.'(")'%".,363,.'",$'0,".,"+,0'.-(.'(3,'(663#63%(.,4''?-(.'%0'

-#$'$,'+#86,"0(.,'/#3'.-,'*(&7,",00='(82%&7%.<='(")'%"),.,38%"(+<'.-(.'"(.73(1'

1("&7(&,'%0'/711'#/='707(11<'$%.-#7.',*,"'!"#$%"&'%.4''>'$%11'$(1!'.-3#7&-'('0%861,'

,K(861,'.-(.'+#"+,3"0'.-,'%".,363,.(.%#"'#/'63#"#7"0'%"')%0+#730,4''M#"0%),3'.-,'/#11#$%"&'0,".,"+,0R'

'

BSD!T#-"'$(0"A.'/,,1%"&'$,11='0#'-,'$,".'.#'-%0')#+.#3'<,0.,3)(<4'BUD!5,',K(8%",)'-%8'/#3'("'-#73='27.'+#71)'/%")'"#.-%"&'0,3%#701<'$3#"&4'

'

J3#2(21<'<#7'7"),30.##)'.-,'V-,A'%"'0,".,"+,'BUD'(0'3,/,33%"&'.#'.-,')#+.#3'8,".%#",)'%"'BSD='(")'V-%8A'(0'3,/,33%"&'.#'T#-"4''I"'$-(.')#,0'.-%0'%".,363,.(.%#"'),6,")W''M,3.(%"1<'%.'

)#,0'"#.'),6,")'X70.'#"'.-,'0<".(K'#/'BSD'(")'BUD4''BYD'-(0'.-,'0(8,'0<".(K'(0'BUD='27.'"#$'

V-,A'%0'"(.73(11<'%".,363,.,)'(0'T#-"'(")'V-%8A'(0'.-,')#+.#34'

'BYD'5,'H7,0.%#",)'-%8'/#3'("'-#73'(2#7.'$-(.'-%0'0<86.#80'+#71)'8,("'B27.'$(0"A.'

0(.%0/%,)'2<'.-,'("0$,30D4'

Page 22: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 22/26

!"#!$%!&'$(%!%)'!*+%',-,'%$%*#+!.'-'+.(!#+!%)'!&'/*0$&!('1$+%*0(!#2!%)'!3',4!*+!%)'!('0#+.!

('+%'+0'5!$(!6'&&!$(!%)'!(7+%$/!#2!%)'!%6#!3',4(8!!9#6!%)'!1'$+*+:!#2!%)'!2*,(%!3',4!%;,+(!

#;%!%#!4'!,'&'3$+%!%##8!!"#!0#+(*.',<!

!

=>?!@#)+!6$(+A%!2''&*+:!6'&&5!(#!)*(!.#0%#,!($6!)*1!#+!()#,%!+#%*0'8!=B?!C'!'/$1*+'.!)*1!2#,!$+!)#;,5!4;%!0#;&.!2*+.!+#%)*+:!(',*#;(&7!6,#+:8!

!D+!=B?!=6)*0)!*(!*.'+%*0$&!%#!=E??5!F)'A!,'2',(!%#!%)'!(;4G'0%!#2!=>?!=%)'!.#0%#,?!$+.!F)*1A!

,'2',(!%#!%)'!#4G'0%!#2!=>?!=@#)+?8!!"7+%$0%*0$&&7!(-'$H*+:5!%)*(!*(!%)'!#--#(*%'!#2!=E?5!6)','!

F)'A!,'2',(!%#!%)'!#4G'0%!#2!=I?!$+.!F)*1A!,'2',(!%#!%)'!(;4G'0%8!!J%!%)*(!-#*+%5!#+'!1*:)%!%)*+H!%)$%!%)'!&'/*0$&!('1$+%*0(!#2!%)'!3',4(!*(!%)'!H'7!%#!%)'!(%#,75!4;%!#%)',!'/$1-&'(!

()#6!%)$%!(7+%$/!-&$7(!$!,#&'!%##8!!K#,!'/$1-&'5!=E?!0$++#%!)$3'!%)'!(#L0$&&'.!,'2&'/*3'!

*+%',-,'%$%*#+(!*+!6)*0)!%)'!.#0%#,!'/$1*+'(!%)'!.#0%#,!2#,!$+!)#;,!#,!*+!6)*0)!@#)+!

'/$1*+'(!@#)+8!!C#6'3',5!=M?5!6)*0)!)$(!$!.*22','+%!2#,1!#2!%)'!#4G'0%!-,#+#;+5!1$7!$+.!1;(%!)$3'!#+'!#2!%)'('!*+%',-,'%$%*#+(<!

!=N?!@#)+!6$(+A%!2''&*+:!6'&&5!(#!)'!6'+%!%#!)*(!.#0%#,!7'(%',.$78!=M?!C'!'/$1*+'.!)*1('&2!2#,!$+!)#;,O8!

!

J+#%)',!1*+#,!0)$+:'!*+!%)'!(7+%$/!*+!=P?!$+.!=IQ?5!$+.!+#6!%)'!-,#+#;+(!F)'A!$+.!F)*(A!0$+!=4;%!+''.!+#%?!,'2',!%#!%)'!($1'!-',(#+5!'*%)',!@#)+!#,!%)'!.#0%#,8!!=P?!*(!4*$('.!

%#6$,.!%)'!,'2','+%!4'*+:!@#)+R!=IQ?!%#6$,.!%)'!,'2','+%!4'*+:!%)'!.#0%#,8!

!

=S?!@#)+!6$(+A%!2''&*+:!6'&&5!(#!)'!6'+%!%#!)*(!.#0%#,!7'(%',.$78!=P?!C'!'/$1*+'.!)*(!*+2'0%'.!%#'+$*&!2#,!$+!)#;,!=6)*&'!(*%%*+:!*+!%)'!6$*%*+:!,##1?8!

=IQ?!C'!'/$1*+'.!)*(!0)$,%(!2#,!$+!)#;,!=4'2#,'!'+%',*+:!%)'!'/$1!,##1?8!!

K*+$&&75!0#+(*.',!=II?!$+.!=IE?8!!T)'('!$,'!*.'+%*0$&!%#!=I?!$+.!=E?5!'/0'-%!%)$%!%)'!

2'1*+*+'!-,#+#;+!F)',A!*(!;('.!*+(%'$.!#2!%)'!1$(0;&*+'!-,#+#;+!F)*1A8!!

=II?! @#)+!6$(+A%!2''&*+:!6'&&5!(#!)'!6'+%!%#!)*(!.#0%#,!7'(%',.$78!

=IE?! C'!'/$1*+'.!)',!2#,!$+!)#;,5!4;%!0#;&.!2*+.!+#%)*+:!(',*#;(&7!6,#+:8!

! 9#6!%)'!0#1-'%'+%!(-'$H',!*(!*+0&*+'.!%#!*+%',-,'%!%)'!(;4G'0%!-,#+#;+!F)'A!$(!,'2',,*+:!

%#!@#)+5!+#%!%#!%)'!.#0%#,!$(!*+!=E?8!!T)'!,'$(#+!*(!$(!2#&&#6(<!!FC',A!1;(%!,'2',!%#!

(#1'#+'!%)$%!%)'!(-'$H',!%)*+H(!D!H+#6!$4#;%8!!J&&!D!H+#6!$4#;%!*(!@#)+!$+.!)*(!.#0%#,8!!@#)+!0',%$*+&7!,'2',(!%#!$!1$&'!=0#+2*,1'.!47!%)'!;('!#2!F)'A!%#!,'2',!%#!@#)+!*+%',+$&!%#!

=II??8!!U#0%#,(!0$+!4'!2'1$&'!G;(%!$(!6'&&!$(!1$&'5!(#!F)',A!1;(%!,'2',!%#!%)'!.#0%#,8!!

T)','2#,'5!F)'A!0$++#%!,'2',!%#!%)'!.#0%#,!*+!%)*(!0$('!='3'+!%)#;:)!.#0%#,(!;(;$&&7!.#!%)'!'/$1*+*+:?8!!@#)+!*(!%)'!#+&7!#%)',!#+'!D!H+#6!$4#;%5!(#!F)'A!1;(%!,'2',!%#!@#)+8!!T)*(!*(!

$!0#1-&'/!0)$*+!#2!,'$(#+*+:5!4$('.!#+!4#%)!(7+%$0%*0!'&'1'+%(!$+.!,'$&!6#,&.!

H+#6&'.:'V'8:8!%)'!2$0%!%)$%!.#0%#,(!0$+!4'!6#1'+!4;%!-'#-&'!+$1'.!@#)+!+'3',!$,'8!

D!%)*+H!*%!*(!0&'$,!%)$%!%)','!*(!$4.;0%*3'!,'$(#+*+:!=*+2','+0'!%#!%)'!4'(%!#3',$&&!'/-&$+$%*#+?!:#*+:!#+!%#!1$H'!('+('!#2!%)'('!-',2'0%&7!#,.*+$,7!'/$1-&'(8!!W&'$,&75!%)'!

0#+0&;(*#+(!.#!+#%!G;(%!,'(%!#+!%)'!(7+%$/8!!X+'!0#;&.!*1$:*+'!'+,*0)*+:!%)'!(7+%$/!*+!

Page 23: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 23/26

!"#$%&'()"*'+((,%#(-."/01-2(%3-(/$456(/%7-1(65-(7$88-#-39-(:-6)--3(;<=("37(;>=(:*('"*$34(65"6(65-(!-#:(?-."/$3-@($'("&6%/"6$9"11*(#-01"9-7(:*(%3-(A$37(%8('*36"96$9(

'6#&96&#-($3(65-(9%&#'-(%8(0#%9-''$342("37(65-(!-#:(?B&-'6$%3@($'(#-01"9-7(:*("3%65-#(A$37+((

C5-3(65-#-()%&17(:-(5%0-(%8(#&33$34(65-(0#%3%&3($36-#0#-6"6$%3(%88(%8(65-(-3#$95-7(

'*36".($3("(7-6-#/$3$'6$9()"*+((;D$34&$'6'(5"!-(-.0-#$/-36-7()$65('&95(E1-.$9"1(

7-9%/0%'$6$%3F(65-%#$-'($3(65-(0"'62(:&6(65-*("#-(3%)(0%0&1"#(%31*($3("(1$/$6-7(7%/"$3G "37(9-#6"$31*(65-*("#-(3%6(&'-7(6%(-.01"$3(65-($36-#0#-6"6$%3(%8(0#%3%&3'+=((H%('%/-(

8"96%#'(65"6(7%3@6(1%%A(/%7&1"#("37('*36"96$9(%3(65-(8"9-(%8($6(9%&17(:-(6&#3-7($36%(8"96%#'(65"6("#-('*36"96$9+((C5"6()%&17(:-(6-/06$34($8(65-(0#%0-#6$-'(%8(65-(!-#:()-#-(65-(%31*(

3%3'*36"96$9(/"66-#(65"6(0#%3%&3($36-#0#-6"6$%3(7-0-37-7(%3+((I&6($6(7-8$3$6-1*($'(3%6J(65-(

$36-#0#-6"6$%3("1'%(7-0-37'(%3(65-(/-"3$34(%8(65-(!-#:($3(65-(8$#'6('-36-39-2(%3(65-(A$37'(%8("7!-#:$"1(/%7$8$-#'(65"6("#-($391&7-7G"37(-!-3(%3(%&#(A3%)1-74-(%8(%&#(9&16&#-@'(

3"/$34(0#"96$9-'("37()5$95(0#%8-''$%3'("#-(0#"96$9-7(:*()%/-3+((K37--72($6('--/'(65"6(

"1/%'6("3*65$34()-(A3%)(9"3($381&-39-(5%)()-($36-#0#-6(0#%3%&3'+((L11(%8(65$'($'(8#%/(

65-(0%$36(%8(!$-)(%8(65-(1"34&"4-(0-#9-$!-#2(:&6(65-('"/-(9%3'$7-#"6$%3'("001*(6%(65-(1"34&"4-(0#%7&9-#2()5%(9%3'6#&96'('-36-39-'(1$A-(;M=N;M<=($3()"*'(65"6(7-0-37(%3()5"6(

5-(;6"9$61*=(65$3A'(65-(5-"#-#()$11(:-(/"3"4-(6%(&37-#'6"37(":7&96$!-1*+((;O8(9%&#'-2(65$'()%3@6("1)"*'()%#A(0-#8-961*P(65-#-()$11(:-(%99"'$%3"1(/$'9%//&3$9"6$%3'+((I&6(65-*("#-(#-1"6$!-1*(#"#-2("37(7%3@6(7-6#"96(8#%/(65-(%!-#"11(3"6&#-(%8()5"6($'(4%$34(%3+=((H%(65-#-($'(

4%%7(#-"'%3(6%(65$3A(65"6(":7&96$%3($'("1$!-("37()-11($3(65-(5&/"3(/$372("37(%3-(%8($6'(

3"/-'($'(65-(QLDR+M<

(( S%)(K(8$37("(!-#*($36-#-'6$34(9%3!-#4-39-(5-#-+((D%%A("6(65-('6"6-(%8(65-("#6($3(

1"34&"4-(0#%9-''$34(:*(9%/0&6-#'+((C5-#-($'(3%(0#%:1-/(4$!$34(9%/0&6-#'("(!%9":&1"#*+((

T$!$34(65-/(4#"//"6$9"1(A3%)1-74-($'(5"#7-#2(:&6(3%6($/0%''$:1-P('*'6-/'(-.$'6(65"6(9"3(

 0"#'-(3"6&#"11*(%99&##$34('-36-39-'(6%("(#-"'%3":1-(7-4#--(%8("99&#"9*2("37()-(5"!-(8"11$:1-(:&6(3%6(;B&$6-=(&'-1-''(4#"//"#(95-9A-#'(%3(%&#(9%/0&6-#'+((I&6(9%/0&6-#'("#-(

'6$11('0-96"9&1"#(8"$1&#-'("6('0%36"3-%&'1*(0#%7&9$34(9%5-#-36('0--95("37("6($36-#0#-6$34('&95('0--95(%&6'$7-(%8(!-#*(1$/$6-7(7%/"$3'+((C&#$34@'(;C&#$342(MUVW=(8"/%&'(6-'6($'(*-6(

6%(:-(0"''-7(:*("(/"95$3-2()-11("86-#(65-(VW(*-"#'(5-(0#-7$96-7+((K37--72(65-(QLDR(0"#6(

%8(1"34&"4-($'(91-"#1*(65-(1%9&'(%8(65-(/%'6('6#$A$34(8"$1&#-+((C5&'(H5$-:-#(;H5$-:-#2(MUUX=(%:'-#!-'($3(9%33-96$%3()$65(#-9-36("66-/06'(6%(#&3('%/-65$34(1$A-(65-(C&#3$34(C-'6($3(

9%33-96$%3()$65(65-(D%-:3-#(0#$Y-2(65"6(65-(0#%4#"/'(65"6(0-%01-("#-()$11$34(6%(#"6-("'(

/%'6(?5&/"3N1$A-@(6%(7"6-('&99--7("1/%'6(-36$#-1*(:-9"&'-(65-*(8$37()"*'(6%("!%$7(65-(

-.0-96"6$%3(65"6(9%3!-#'"6$%3('5%&17(:-("00#%0#$"6-($3(65-(QLDR('-3'-+M>

((C5-('-/$N'&99-''8&1(0#%4#"/'(95%%'-(6%(0%'-("'("(0'*95%"3"1*'62(%#("'("(0"#"3%$7('95$Y%05#-3$92(%#(

(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((M<(H0-#:-#(;H0-#:-#2(6%("00-"#=("1'%(5%17'(65"6(;'%/-65$34(1$A-=(":7&96$!-(#-"'%3$34(7%-'(5"00-3($3(65-(5&/"3(/$372+((S%#(7%-'(5-(7-3*(,%7%#@'("#4&/-36(65"6(":7&96$!-(#-"'%3$34(9"33%6(:-(-.01"$3-7(9%/0&6"6$%3"11*+((Z%)-!-#2(5-(5%17'(%&6(65-(5%0-(65"6(65-(:#"$3(7%-'(":7&96$%3(65#%&45(3%39%/0&6"6$%3"1( 0#%9-''-'2('&44-'6$34(65"6(65-(/"3*(7$88-#-36('&:0#%9-''%#'($3(65-(:#"$3(9%/0-6-(8%#(-3-#4*(#-'%&#9-'(

7-0-37$34(%3(5%)("96$!-(65-*("#-2(5%)(/"3*($38-#-39-'(65-*("#-(4-3-#"6$342("37('%(%3+((H0-#:-#(4$!-'("('-3'-(%8(5%)(65$'(9%&17(:-(:*(7-!-1%0$34("3("3"1%4*()$65(/&'91-(8"6$4&-+((I&6(-!-3($8(65$'(0#%9-''($'(3%6(9%/0&6"6$%3"1($3(65-('-3'-(%8($38%#/"6$%3(0#%9-''$34(7-8$3-7(%!-#("3(-.01$9$6(#-0#-'-36"6$%3"1(7"6"(

'6#&96&#-2(K(7%3@6('--(5%)($6("!%$7'(,%7%#@'("#4&/-36+((Q-#6"$31*(8$37$34(65-(/".$/&/(3&/:-#(8#%/("('-62(%#("11(65%'-(3&/:-#'(65"6("#-(4#-"6-#(65"3("(9-#6"$3(65#-'5%17($'(;%#(9"3(:-(/%7-1-7(:*=("(9%/0&6"6$%3"1( 0#%9-''G$37--72("(6#$!$"1(%3-+((K(9"3('--(5%)("3("#95$6-96&#-(%8(65-(A$37(H0-#:-#('&44-'6'(9%&17("'(7&/:(%#(7&/:-#(65"3("(91"''$9"1(9%/0&6"6$%3"1('*'6-/2(:&6(K(7%(3%6('--(5%)($6(9%&17(:-('/"#6-#2(0-#/$66$34(6#&-(

":7&96$!-($38-#-39-+(M>(K(65"3A(["!$7(\$11$"/'%3(8%#(0%$36$34(65$'(%&6(6%(/-+(

Page 24: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 24/26

!"#!#$%&'"&(!)#(*+,-."!/&*+!)&"/0#*.#!"#!#"-,-+12-!.#*)3#(%&)34!))#5-*5)-#6*.#$%&(%#$-#!.-#$&))&+7#/*#"8"5-+3#/*#"*'-#3-7.--#*8.#+*.'!)#-95-(/!/&*+"#(*+(-.+&+7#(*%-.-+/#!+3#

.!/&*+!)#3&"(*8."-:##;%-#"/!/-#*6#/%-#!./#&+#<=#&"#,-.2#6!.#!$!2#6.*'#"2"/-'"#/%!/#(!+#

'!+&6-"/#/%-#><?@0#'!2A-#%*5-)-"")2#6!.#!$!2#B"--#!)"*#999C:##;%&"#"%*8)3#+*/#A-#!#

"8.5.&"-#A2#+*$:##;%-#5.*7.!'"#6!&)#!/#)-!"/#&+#5!./#A-(!8"-#/%-#><?@#&"#!+#&+/.&+"&(!))2#

!A38(/&,-#(!5!(&/20#!+3#A-(!8"-#/%-#!A38(/&,-#(!++*/#A-#.-38(-3#/*#/%-#(*'58/!/&*+!):##D*#6!.#&/#"--'"#/%!/#E-"(!./-"F#&+/8&/&*+#$!"#'*.-#!((8.!/-#/%!+#;8.&+7F"G#/%!/#5.*38(&+7#

"5--(%#/%!/#&"#8+A*8+3-30#+*/#(*+3&/&*+-3#A2#"/&'8)8"0#A8/#!55.*5.&!/-#/*#"&/8!/&*+"#3*-"#7*#A-2*+3#/%-#A*8+3"#*6#'-(%!+&(!)#-95)!+!/&*+#!"#$-#H+*$#&/:##D*#/%-#><?@#&"#$%!/#

$-#3*+F/#H+*$#%*$#/*#"5-(&62#*.#&'5)-'-+/#&+#(*'58/!/&*+!)#/-.'"0#!+3#&/#&"#!)"*#/%-#

 5!./#*6#/%-#%8'!+#)!+78!7-#(!5!(&/2#/%!/#"--'"#&++!/-#A8/#+*/#+!..*$)2#A&*)*7&(!)#A!"-3#*+#+-8.*)&+78&"/&(0#3-,-)*5'-+/!)0#!+3#(*'5!.!/&,-#"/83&-":###

#

!"#$%&'("###=+#/%&"#5!5-.0#=#%!,-#"*87%/#/*#.-'&+3#5-*5)-#/%!/#/%-#><?@#&"#!+#&'5*./!+/#!"5-(/#*6#/%-#

%8'!+#)!+78!7-#6!(8)/2:##=#%!,-#7*+-#*+#/*#!.78-#/%!/#/%-#><?@#(!5!(&/2#&"#&++!/-#&+#%8'!+"I#&+3--3#!+!)*7"#*6#!))#/%-#"/!+3!.3#!.78'-+/"#/%!/#"2+/!9#&"#&++!/-#(!+#A-#6*8+3#/*#"%*$#/%!/#/%-#><?@#&"#!)"*#&++!/-:##J*$-,-.0#/%-#!.78'-+/"#/%!/#"%*$#/%!/#"2+/!9#&"#

-'A*3&-3#&+#"5-(&6&(#+-8.!)#(&.(8&/"0#/%!/#&/#&"#7-+-/&(!))2#-+(*3-30#!+3#/%!/#&/#-,*),-3#

6.*'#"&'&)!.#(!5!(&/&-"#/%!/#$-.-#"%!.-3#$&/%#*/%-.#5.&'!/-"#3*#+*/#7*#/%.*87%:##;%-#()!&'#/%!/#/%-#&++!/-#"/.8(/8.-#*6#/%-#%8'!+#'&+3#&"#B-+/&.-)2C#A&*)*7&(!)#&+#/%&"#"-+"-#/%8"#

%!"#)&//)-#*.#+*#-,&3-+(-#&+#&/"#6!,*.0#!+3#!33"#+*/%&+7#/*#*8.#"8A"/!+/&,-#8+3-."/!+3&+7#*6#

/%-#><?@:##=#(*+()83-#/%!/#/%-.-#&"#.-!"*+#/*#-+/-./!&+#!#/25-#*6#+!/&,&"'#/%!/#"8A"(.&A-"#

/*#/%-#-9&"/-+(-#*6#&++!/-+-""#A8/#/%!/#3*-"#+*/#/.2#/*#(!"%#*8/#/%!/#&++!/-+-""#!"#A&*)*72#&+#/%-#'!++-.#(%!.!(/-.&"/&(#*6#-,*)8/&*+!.2#5"2(%*)*72:#

##

)*+*,*#$*'-

#K!H-.0#L:#BMNOOC:# !"#$%&$%'()$"*+'+(,-$%.+$/+0%'11'()#'2+/3"#()$"+#,'"0)"0 :#>%&(!7*G#

@+&,-."&/2#*6#>%&(!7*#P.-"":#

K!H-.0#L:#BQRRSC:# 4-5)#'2+#'(-0$%)-6*+7-%869+:$3"69+'";+<;=-#()>-6:#>!'A.&37-G#

>!'A.&37-#@+&,-."&/2#P.-"":#K&(H-./*+0#E:#BMNOMC:# ?$$(6+$/+2'"03'0-:#<++#<.A*.0#L&(%:G#T!.*'!#P8A)&"%-.":#

K&"%*50#E:#BQRRUC:#D5-(&6&(#)!+78!7-#&'5!&.'-+/G#3&!7+*"/&(#3&)-''!":#=+#?:#V-.%*-,-+#

W#J:#,:#K!)H*'#BX3":C0#@2'66)/)#'()$"+$/+;->-2$&1-"('2+2'"03'0-+;)6$%;-%6*+

(,-$%-()#'2+)663-6+'";+#2)")#'2+)1&2)#'()$"6#B55:#SRN1SQYC:#L!%$!%0#Z[G#?!$.-+(-#

X.)A!8'#<""*(&!/-":#

K)**'0#?:#BMN\RC:# 4'"03'0-+;->-2$&1-"(*+/$%1+'";+/3"#()$"+)"+-1-%0)"0+0%'11'%6:#>!'A.&37-0#L!"":G#L=;#P.-"":#

K.*$+0#]:#BMN\SC:# <+/)%6(+2'"03'0-*+(,-+-'%2.+6('0-6:#>!'A.&37-0#L!"":G#J!.,!.3#

@+&,-."&/2#P.-"":#

>!5)!+0#E:#BMNO\C:# :-3%$2)"03)6()#6+'";+2)"03)6()#+'&,'6)$2$0.:#>!'A.&37-G#>!'A.&37-#@+&,-."&/2#P.-"":#

Page 25: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 25/26

!"##$%&'#()*+,*-.//01,* !"#$%&'%()*+,-+&$%,&."#$%&%$/"0+,*2345#67*2345#6*89:;'#(:%<*+#'((,*

!&'9'<)*=,)*>*?'<4"#%&)*@,*-.//A1,* !()&#(%'+12&2++&/.+&)(0*, ,*!&:B"C57*89:;'#(:%<*54*

!&:B"C5*+#'((,*

!&5D(E<)*F,*-./GH1,*31%/$4/54&2/0"4/"0+2,*I&'*J"C$'7*K5$%59,*

!&5D(E<)*F,*-./G/1,*@';:'L*54*?E:99'#)*M'#N"O*P'&";:5#,* 6$%-"$-+7&89-.1)*0QRGS,*!&5D(E<)*F,*-./QQ1,*:$0/+25$%&*5%-"52/542,*F'L*T5#E7*J"#U'#*"96*@5L,*

!&5D(E<)*F,*-./HG1,* ;+<*+4/5(%2&(%&*$%-"$-+,*F'L*T5#E7*+"9%&'59,*!#":9)*?,)*>*+:'%#5(E:)*+,*-0AA.1,*F"%$#')*9$#%$#')*"96*89:;'#("O*V#"DD"#,* 65%-"52/542&

$%,&=.5*(2(>.17&?@)*.W/R.SQ,*

='U#'X)*M,)*>*+:'#B')*Y,*-.//W1,*F'C"%:59*"96*4$9B%:59"O*U#5Z'B%:59(*:9*'"#O<*B&:O6*C#"DD"#,* 65%-"52/54&A%B"5017&?@)*0GRQS,*

[565#)*\,*-0AAA1,*C.+&#5%,&,(+2%D/&)(0'&/.$/&)$1,*!"DN#:6C')*K"((,7*K]I*+#'((,*

V5O6:9RK'"65L)*?,*-./S01,*I&'*#'(:O:'9B'*54*#'B$#(:597*"*(%$6<*54*"*B5DD$9:B"%:59*

(<(%'D*6';'O5U'6*L:%&5$%*"*B59;'9%:59"O*O"9C$"C'*D56'O,*]9*^,*_"99'#*>*̀ ,*VO':%D"9*-^6(,1)* 6$%-"$-+&$4B"525/5(%E&/.+&2/$/+&(<&/.+&$0/ *-UU,*G.RHH1,*

!"DN#:6C'7*!"DN#:6C'*89:;'#(:%<*+#'((,*V5O6:9RK'"65L)*?,*-./SH1,*896'#O<:9C*#'6$96"9B<*"96*:%(*#'6$B%:59*:9*"*O"9C$"C'*

6';'O5U'6*L:%&5$%*"*O"9C$"C'*D56'O,*]9*P,*`$(%*-^6,1)*3/",5+2&5%&/.+&$4B"525/5(%&

(<&$%$>.(0$*-M5O,*0)*UU,*.AGR.Wa1,*=5#6#'B&%7*@':6'O,*

V5O6:9RK'"65L)*?,)*>*K<O"96'#)*!,*-./SW1,*V'(%$#"O*B5DD$9:B"%:59*:9*6'"4*B&:O6#'97*959'44'B%*54*U"#'9%"O*:9U$%*59*O"9C$"C'*6';'O5UD'9%,*345+%4+7&??F-aQAS1)*WH0R

WHa,*

V556CO"(()*J,)*>*b"UO"9)*^,*-./H01,*C.+&$22+22#+%/&(<&$>.$25$&$%,&0+*$/+,&,52(0,+02,*

+&:O"6'OU:"7*`'"*>*['N:C'#,*b'#%'(X)*Y,*-./H/1,* G>.$25$&$%,&$22(45$/+,&,52(0,+02E&/$H(%(#17&*(4$*5I$/5(%7&$%,&

0+4(J+01,*F'L*T5#E7*V#$9'*>*?%#"%%59,*`'(O:')*Y,*K,*-.//a1,*+#'%'96:9C*"96*N'O:';:9C7*:(($'(*:9*%&'*%&'5#<*54*I5KK,*:(-%5/5(%7&

9K-.RW1)*0..R0WS,*

K"#$(X'L(E:)*K,*-./HG1,* 6$%-"$-+7&4(##"%54$/5(%&$%,&/.+&L0$5%,*I&'*J"C$'7*K5$%59,*+:9E'#)*?,*-0AA01,*C.+&L*$%'&2*$/+E&/.+&#(,+0%&,+%5$*&(<&."#$%&%$/"0+,*F'L*T5#E7*

M:E:9C,*

+:9E'#)*?,)*>*PO55D)*+,*-.//A1,*F"%$#"O*O"9C$"C'*"96*9"%$#"O*('O'B%:59,* M+.$J5(0$*&$%,&

 M0$5%&345+%4+27&F8)*HAHRHSa,*@"U:9)*],)*>*YOO'9)*=,*-./SW1,*=';'O5UD'9%"O*O"9C$"C'*6:(5#6'#(7*95(5O5C:B*

B59(:6'#"%:59(,*]9*8,*b:#E*-^6,1)* N+"0(>214.(*(-1&(<&*$%-"$-+7&0+$,5%-7&$%,& 2>+**5%- *-UU,*.GGR.Sa1,*F'L*T5#E7*YB"6'D:B*+#'((,*

?";"C'R@$DN"$C&)*?,*-.//a1,* O$%I5E&/.+&$>+&$/&/.+&L05%'&(<&/.+&."#$%&#5%, ,*F'L*T5#E7*

_:O'<,*

?&:'N'#)*?,*-.//a1,*̀ '((59(*45#D*"*#'(%#:B%'6*I$#:9C*%'(%,*:(##"%54$/5(%2&(<&/.+& G22(45$/5(%&<(0&:(#>"/5%-&P$4.5%+017&8Q -Q1,*

?E:99'#)*P,*[,*-./GH1,*R+0L$*&L+.$J5(0 ,*F'L*T5#E7*YUUO'%59R!'9%$#<R!#54%(,*

?O5N:9)*=,*-^6,1,*-./SG1,*C.+&:0(22*5%-"52/54&2/",1&(<&*$%-"$-+&$4B"525/5(%,*J:OO(6"O')*

 F,\,7*`,*^#ON"$D*Y((5B:"%'(,*

Page 26: Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

8/7/2019 Chomsky - The Creative Aspect of Language Use and Nonbiological Nativism

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chomsky-the-creative-aspect-of-language-use-and-nonbiological-nativism 26/26

!"#$%#$&'()'*+,'-""#-$.)'/,012-$3+4'-50'$#2#6-57#8'9,:'7-5'-';-<<36#24';,012-$';350' %#'=2#>3%2#'-50'7,5+#>+?<#5<3+36#@'A5'B)'C-$$1+D#$<&'!)'E-1$#57#'F'!)'!+37D'*G0<).&'

!"#$%&&'(#$)%&*+$,(-./(.-#$'&*$/0&(#&( )'

H1$35I&'J)'/)'*KLMN.)'C,;"1+35I';-7D35#$4'-50'35+#223I#57#)'1%&*2$34*OPQ.&'RPP?RQN)'

'